Latest / Common Sense Rankings Podcast / CSR Podcast #1: Introduction to the Common Sense Rankings
Transcript
- 0:18Hello and welcome to the very first episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 0:23My name is Michael.
- 0:24I am the creator of the CSR, and I will be your host for this podcast Today I will start with the current process behind the AP polls and the selection committees.
- 0:36I'll talk about the reasoning for the CSR and how the CSR differs from traditional polls.
- 0:42I will talk a little bit about the Common Sense Rankings methodology as well.
- 0:45And throughout, I will bring examples from recent college football and college basketball seasons that prove that the CSR is the best way to evaluate teams Starting with the AP poll, voters are, quote,"urged to base their votes on performance, not reputation or preseason speculation, to avoid regional bias for or against, to pay attention to head-to-head results, and to make significant changes if desired," end quote.
- 1:11A portion of that read,"Not reputation or preseason speculation." So let's hold the AP voters accountable, shall we?
- 1:19Going back to the 2025 college football season, looking at just one week of games, so in the week two poll, almost half of the top 25 teams, 11 of them, either beat an FCS team or lost their first game.
- 1:3411 of the top 25 teams they are claiming are the best in the country, even though they beat a team from a lower division or have not beaten anyone.
- 1:45The AP poll voters said unequivocally those are 11 of the best teams in the country.
- 1:49On the flip side, there are teams like Tulane, who beat Northwestern, a team from the Big Ten, widely regarded as one of, if not the best conference in the country, who did not get ranked.
- 2:02Why?
- 2:03Why did a team that beat Northwestern not get ranked, but teams that either lost their first game or beat an FCS team were voted unequivocally better than Tulane?
- 2:14It doesn't make sense.
- 2:15Moving on to the College Football Playoff Committee's criteria, they are tasked with, quote,"ranking the schools based on the members' evaluation of their performances on the field using strength of schedule, head-to-head results, and comparison of results against common opponents," end quote.
- 2:32So let's hold them accountable.
- 2:33Looking back at the 2025 college football season, the College Football Playoff Committee released six rankings, so 150 teams total.
- 2:42Of those 150 ranked teams, just nine of them came from outside the Power Five conferences.
- 2:48Looking at their first release, they said, unequivocally, that nine SEC teams were better than every non-power conference team in the country.
- 2:58That doesn't seem to add up when those SEC teams have not just multiple losses, but have lost a third, if not more of their games.
- 3:08The college basketball selection committee criteria is less clear.
- 3:11It is not defined anywhere.
- 3:13However, they have given us several things that they look at when selecting the teams that go into the NCAA basketball tournaments.
- 3:19They look at things like the NET rankings, quality of play, strength of schedule, wins above bubble, overall record, and the observable component.
- 3:28We all know it as the eye test Now, each of these ranking systems, whether it be the AP poll or the various selection committees, have one goal in mind, to determine who the best teams are.
- 3:41However, they have skewed so far in the direction of the power conferences that I think that they've lost the plot a little bit.
- 3:48I know that a lot of the good teams are congregating in these, quote-unquote,"mega conferences." However, it is difficult for me to see how any teams outside of those have to meet a higher standard of success to be considered among one of the best in the country So what I think is happening in the voters' minds, whether consciously or subconsciously, is they want to provide reassurance to the conferences who own the most power, namely the power conferences.
- 4:15So the power conferences are able to say,"Look at the AP poll this week.
- 4:20We have nine teams in the top 25." And through the conferences, their TV partners are able to say,"We have two top 10 match-ups on our networks this week." Regardless, the rankings do not properly reflect what has happened on the field, and the CSR is here to change that So the first thing I had to ask myself when creating a new ranking system was whether I wanted the CSR to be strictly backward-facing or have it be forward-facing as well.
- 4:49Since by the voters and the committee members' own standards, the goal is to look at resumes of teams up to that point, the CSR reflects the same goal: to determine the best teams based on all games played.
- 5:04So how will the CSR differ from the human polls and the other computer polls that are already out there?
- 5:11The CSR is only going to include in its rankings wins and losses, both direct wins and losses, the teams that you play specifically, as well as the wins and losses from those teams.
- 5:23That differs from other computer polls especially because those other computer polls contain statistics like offensive and defensive efficiency, margin of victory, they include information on injuries, and they also have those immeasurable luck ratings where you should have won this game but you didn't.
- 5:42Let me tell you why the CSR is only going to include wins and losses in its calculations.
- 5:47It's because the people playing the game and the people coaching the game and the people evaluating the games, that's all they care about.
- 5:54Coaches want to win the game.
- 5:55They prep all week for the opponent with the intent to score more points than that team.
- 6:01At the end of the season, coaches are evaluated based on the results of their games, the wins and the losses.
- 6:07Some of that may be you did not win enough games.
- 6:10Other times that may be you didn't beat the correct opponent.
- 6:14Think Ryan Day at Ohio State a few years ago, he just could not beat Michigan, then he went on to the national championship, so he's still there.
- 6:21Also, you did not win games the right time of the season.
- 6:24So a team that consistently makes the playoff but does not advance very far may fire their coach because they are not winning the right games.
- 6:31It's not about losing close.
- 6:33It's not about offensive metrics.
- 6:35It's not about defensive metrics.
- 6:36It is about did you win the game?
- 6:39So that is the only statistic that the CSR includes.
- 6:44Before I get into the nitty-gritty, if you're a numbers person like I am, I know that might be what you're looking forward to, I want to discuss a little bit about the methodology and a few things that I want to clarify before getting into the numbers.
- 6:56First, only wins and losses are gonna matter, as we discussed previously.
- 7:00So that means margin of victory or defeat, location of the game, when the game happens in the season, all of that is irrelevant.
- 7:07Did you win the game is what the CSR is concerned with.
- 7:11No previous rankings are used to determine a new week's order.
- 7:15Each week is created from scratch based on all of the results of all the teams involved up to that point in the season.
- 7:22What that means is a team that has played more games will likely have an advantage if they've won all their games compared to a team that has played fewer games.
- 7:31So if a team has an early season bye or doesn't play as many games early in the college basketball season, they will likely be lower than a team that has played more games and had success in those games because we're not using averages.
- 7:44We want all of the data, and a team with more data is going to have more opportunities to be evaluated.
- 7:51Lastly, I think we can all agree that the college football playoff and the March Madness tournaments are a great way of crowning a season-long champion.
- 8:00I'm not going to worry about doing a CSR at the end of those tournaments because a national champion has already been crowned.
- 8:06What I'm more worried about is who gets into those tournaments.
- 8:10How are those teams determined?
- 8:11So the CSR will always end with the date of the selection committee's decision.
- 8:17We will not go into the postseason with the CSR Having clarified all those points, let's dive more into the methodology.
- 8:25The starting point for the CSR is conference strength based solely on non-conference games that have happened to that point in the season.
- 8:33And we're not talking about overall out-of-conference winning percentage.
- 8:37For example, if the Big Ten played and won all of their non-conference games against the MAC, they didn't play any other conference, then all that proves is the Big Ten is better than the MAC.
- 8:48It provides no proof the Big Ten is better than the Pac-12 or the SEC or the Sun Belt or any other conference.
- 8:54The CSR will look at conference's record against each specific conference in that sport While each conference we know is going to have a 500 winning percentage against itself, how we determine the value of those wins and losses in conference will be based on how teams have performed against all of the other conferences So let's look at an example to further prove this point.
- 9:21Let's look at the rankings after week one of the 2025 college football season.
- 9:26After week one, the Big Ten and the SEC both had winning records against five of the other eight conferences.
- 9:33That was the most of any conference in college football through week one.
- 9:38So a win against a team from the SEC or the Big Ten is going to net you most points compared to wins against other conferences.
- 9:46It will also lose you the fewest points.
- 9:49Additionally, the MAC and Conference USA both had winning records against zero conferences, so a win against a team from one of those conferences will get you the fewest positive points, and a loss to a team from those conferences will lose you the most points.
- 10:04Moving on to week three, the SEC now had winning records against six conferences, while the Big Ten still had five.
- 10:11That puts a win against the SEC at a slightly higher level compared to a win against the Big Ten.
- 10:17Additionally, on the other end, the MAC now had a winning record against one conference, as did the Sun Belt.
- 10:24So both a win against the MAC and the Sun Belt will net you the fewest points and will lose you the most points if you lose to a team from those conferences.
- 10:34That proves that conference strength is going to adjust based on games played up to that point.
- 10:44So there are two natural questions that arise after these conference strength rankings are calculated.
- 10:50The first is how to handle independents.
- 10:53Let's use Notre Dame as an example.
- 10:55They are the accumulation of all of the teams they have played up to that point.
- 10:59They are the average of all of the different values from the conferences against which they have played.
- 11:04So in week one of college football last year, they played Miami.
- 11:08So through week one, they are the same as an ACC team.
- 11:13After a bye in week two, they played an SEC team in week three.
- 11:17So through two games, Notre Dame is the average of an ACC and an SEC school.
- 11:23That total will continue to be adjusted based on who they play each week.
- 11:27So at the end of the season, they will be an accumulation of all of the different conferences that they have played in their 12 games.
- 11:34Another question that arises is how to handle games against teams from a lower division.
- 11:39For college football, that's FBS teams against FCS, and in college basketball, that's D1 teams against D2 or D3 teams.
- 11:47Wins against a team from a lower division, given that they have less budget, less access to scholarships and how they can distribute those scholarships, a win against those teams is going to net you zero points, while a loss is going to hurt you more than a loss to any of the other FBS teams based on the same factors that I mentioned previously.
- 12:09So with nearly all FBS teams playing an FCS team each season trying to get that cupcake win, that win is not going to net you any points in the CSR.
- 12:19All it will do is lose you significant points if you were to lose These direct wins and losses will account for about half of a team's common sense rating by the end of the season.
- 12:32The other half is going to come from how its opponents perform throughout the season.
- 12:36So we're not only using direct results, but also we're judging teams based on the successes and failures of the teams that they have played.
- 12:44For example, a team will gain additional positive points if a team they have defeated continues to win games.
- 12:51On the flip side, a team that loses will continue to incur losses when those teams lose games.
- 12:58So we reward teams whose victories continue to gain value, but we also penalize teams if losses look worse and worse as the season progresses.
- 13:08When I say that direct results and indirect results each account for half of a team's total, that will be at the end of the season.
- 13:15Direct results are going to have more impact at the beginning of the season because that's the only context we have.
- 13:20As we develop more context, the indirect results are going to have a bigger say in a team's CSR So let's look at a practical example.
- 13:31We're gonna go back to the beginning of the 2025 season, and we're gonna look at the week two polls.
- 13:36That includes all games that have occurred through week one.
- 13:40The Big Ten and the SEC reign supreme with winning records against five of the other conferences.
- 13:46The ACC and the Mountain West are tied with three conferences against which they have winning records.
- 13:52The Big 12 and American each have two, the Sun Belt has one, and Conference USA and MAC both have zero.
- 13:59So that is the pecking order for conferences through the week one games.
- 14:03There were four teams with wins against either a Big Ten or an SEC school.
- 14:08Those should be the top four teams based on the quality of the on-the-field results.
- 14:13Those teams are Ohio State, Florida State, Utah, and Tulane.
- 14:19Now, Utah was ranked 25th.
- 14:21They were thrown a bone.
- 14:22Tulane went unranked.
- 14:24Ahead of those two teams are 11 teams who either lost their first game or beat an FCS school.
- 14:31So what the AP poll voters are trying to tell us is that a win over an FCS school or a loss to anybody is more impressive than a win over a Big Ten team.
- 14:44That doesn't make any sense.
- 14:47Additionally, the AP poll only ranked 14 of the actual top teams based on on-the-field results.
- 14:55This goes back to the dichotomy that we're seeing between it matters not who you've beaten, but it matters more what conference you are a part of So looking at the trends across the previous seasons of the CSR, how is that going to differ from the AP poll and the selection committee?
- 15:13So what I've seen is the teams at the top, or those that are considered locks for each postseason tournament, are going to be the same between the CSR and many of the other computer rankings as well as human polls.
- 15:25What's going to change a little bit, however, is when we get down into that ninth SEC, tenth SEC, eleventh Big Ten team in college basketball and how they compare to those thirty-and-three mid-major conference teams who did not win their conference tournament.
- 15:40The CSR is going to look at that and say,"Well, thirty-and-three is a lot more impressive com- than seventeen-and-fifteen with an eight-and-ten record in the SEC." So what I've seen more as the trend is, especially in basketball, the SEC is not getting fourteen teams in, the ACC is not getting ten.
- 15:58Those conferences will get more like eight or nine, and we'll see a few more of those traditional one-bid conferences get multiple teams in.
- 16:05In college football, it's going to be similar.
- 16:08The top handful of teams, those that are receiving the byes in the college football playoff, are probably going to look very similar between the CSR and what actually happens.
- 16:16It's how the rest of the bracket is filled out that, in which the CSR is going to differ.
- 16:21It's going to boost teams that are in underrated conferences, and it's going to also give the mid-major teams, the teams from outside the Power Four, a real look at a comparison between them and the sixth-best team from a Power Four conference.
- 16:39And that is where I will end the first episode of the Common Sense Rankings podcast.
- 16:44If you're looking for more information about the CSR, you can go to the website commonsenserankings.com.
- 16:50You can also check us out on the socials at@comsenseranking.
- 16:55Right now on the website are the most recent five college football seasons, as well as the most recent three men's and women's college basketball seasons.
- 17:03Each of those has a weekly update that shows how each team ranks in the CSR in comparison with the AP poll or the CFP committee poll.
- 17:13The plan for future episodes, my next episode will be a look back at the twenty twenty-five college football season in depth.
- 17:19I will then look ahead to the twenty twenty-six season with the plan being to release a podcast about each of the individual conferences, how the teams ranked at the end of twenty twenty-five, and how the twenty twenty-six outlook looks for each of those teams based on incoming recruits and transfers.
- 17:35Throughout the college football season, my aim is to release a weekly podcast, probably on Sunday nights, taking a look at how the CSR ranked teams in comparison to the most recent polls.
- 17:45As college basketball season rolls around, I will also be releasing a weekly podcast looking at the college basketball rankings, comparing the CSR to AP poll as well.
- 17:55On each of these podcasts, the goal is to maybe call out some of the members of the AP who are doing a horrible job in evaluating their teams while also giving props to those that are evaluating teams fairly.
- 18:06I hope to get some of those members of the AP poll onto the podcast so they can defend what they are putting out there into the ether.
- 18:14So that is the end of episode one of the CSR.
- 18:18So as you go about your day today, please use some common sense