Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / CIRCLE Up: Strategic Mediation Tips for Complex Litigation with Jill M. Manning
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Circle Up, Strategic Mediation Tips
- 0:07for Complex Litigation. I'm Alapoli Castro, CLE
- 0:11advisor for Beverly Hills Bar Association. And
- 0:13today I'm delighted to introduce our speaker,
- 0:16Jill Manning. Jill Manning is the founder of
- 0:19the Manning Law Firm. She is a mediator, trial
- 0:21attorney, and skilled litigator. Ms. Manning
- 0:24has represented clients in class action and complex
- 0:27litigation matters in state and federal court
- 0:29in a wide variety of fields, including antitrust
- 0:32and competition, consumer protection, privacy,
- 0:35health care, mass torts, sports, and securities
- 0:38law. In 2025, Ms. Manning joined Jams as a mediator,
- 0:43arbitrator, special master, neutral evaluator,
- 0:45and discovery referee. She is also a mediator
- 0:48for numerous court -based ADR programs in courts
- 0:51across California. We can't wait to hear what
- 0:54she has to share with us today. So let's get
- 0:56started. Great. Thank you so much for that kind
- 1:00introduction. I really appreciate it. And I am
- 1:04delighted to be here today. Thank you so much
- 1:08to the Beverly Hills Bar Association for inviting
- 1:11me to speak on this topic. And thank you to everyone
- 1:14in the audience for joining me today for this
- 1:17presentation on unlocking success, six tips for
- 1:22complex case mediation. Now, like all the litigators
- 1:28in the room today, most of my cases settled prior
- 1:32to trial, and most settled using a private mediator.
- 1:37Some mediators were helpful, others were not.
- 1:40And I often found myself wishing for a mediator
- 1:44who did the hard work to truly understand the
- 1:48case, who listened carefully, not just to speak,
- 1:52but to understand. A mediator who treated everyone
- 1:56with respect, even in the most high stakes adversarial
- 2:00settings. A mediator who was skilled at productive
- 2:04dialogue and facilitating productive dialogue.
- 2:08someone who was thoughtful about creating creative
- 2:12solutions, and someone who stayed committed to
- 2:15helping the parties reach agreement, even in
- 2:17the most difficult cases. So I became that mediator.
- 2:22And now I approach each matter with the same
- 2:25intensity, preparation, and strategic thinking
- 2:28that I brought to my cases as an advocate, but
- 2:32with a neutrals perspective. This dual experience
- 2:36as both advocate and neutral has taught me what
- 2:39really works in mediation and what doesn't. So
- 2:43today I'm sharing those insights with you so
- 2:46you can get the most out of every mediation.
- 2:50The circle method we will explore today comes
- 2:53directly from these real world experiences on
- 2:56both sides of the table. So today's goal is to
- 3:01learn tips for preparing for mediation strategically
- 3:05and learning how to set yourself up for a successful
- 3:09outcome. Statistics show that between 95 to 98
- 3:14percent of all civil cases settle before trial,
- 3:18and that certainly resonates with my experience.
- 3:23During my 30 -year career as a litigator, I had
- 3:27only two cases go to trial. That means if you're
- 3:32in litigation, there's only a two to five percent
- 3:35chance you'll actually take your case all the
- 3:38way to trial. Given those odds, it makes a lot
- 3:42of sense to take the time and approach mediation
- 3:46strategically. So court -ordered mediation presents
- 3:49a powerful strategic opportunity. Imagine this
- 3:54scenario. You're representing a client. in a
- 4:00complex case where the judge orders the parties
- 4:03to mediation. It may not feel like welcome news,
- 4:07but it prevents a tremendous opportunity. First,
- 4:12mediation allows your client to explore resolution
- 4:16without signaling any weakness. Your client did
- 4:19not initiate the process, the judge did. Second,
- 4:23by approaching the session strategically, you
- 4:26will leave in a stronger position than when you
- 4:28started. Whether or not settlement is reached,
- 4:32you will gain valuable insights into the opposing
- 4:34party's strategy, a fresh perspective from a
- 4:38neutral, and a clearer path forward. Most importantly,
- 4:45mediation gives you the opportunity to shape
- 4:47the outcome rather than leaving it in the hands
- 4:50of a judge or a jury. So circle is a helpful
- 4:57acronym where each letter represents one of the
- 5:01six topics we are going to discuss today. So
- 5:04the first topic we're going to discuss is choosing
- 5:07your mediator wisely using the C in circle. Choosing
- 5:14your mediator wisely. Identifying strengths and
- 5:18weaknesses. Developing a range of settlement
- 5:21options. Staying calm and curious. learning through
- 5:25joint sessions, and evaluating settlement options
- 5:28carefully. So let's dive right in with choosing
- 5:32your mediator wisely. Selecting the mediator
- 5:35is one of the most important decisions you will
- 5:39make in the entire process. A successful mediation
- 5:43often hinges on the mediator's neutrality, experience,
- 5:48subject matter, and style. Take the time to evaluate
- 5:53each candidate's background and approach in light
- 5:56of the specific dynamics of your case, your client's
- 6:00priorities, and your strategic goals. A well
- 6:04-matched mediator can build trust, manage conflict
- 6:08effectively, and significantly increase the chances
- 6:12of reaching a meaningful resolution of your case.
- 6:16Don't treat this as just checking a box. Invest
- 6:19the time to find the right fit because it will
- 6:21pay dividends throughout the process. So we're
- 6:24going to discuss four key factors in choosing
- 6:27your mediator wisely. The first one is neutrality,
- 6:31and this is non -negotiable. Neutrality means
- 6:34the mediator has no stake in the outcome, holds
- 6:38no predetermined opinions, and demonstrates no
- 6:41favoritism toward either party. Carefully vet
- 6:45proposed mediators. by asking targeted questions.
- 6:50Have you ever worked with opposing counsel? Have
- 6:54you had any professional relationships with the
- 6:56parties or attorneys? What's your initial reaction
- 7:00to this type of case? Do you have any industry
- 7:05connection that might create conflicts? These
- 7:09questions help identify potential biases before
- 7:13they become problems. Even the appearance of
- 7:16bias can undermine the entire process. If one
- 7:20party suspects favoritism, they'll question every
- 7:23suggestion the mediator makes. A truly neutral
- 7:28mediator creates a safe space where both sides
- 7:31feel heard and respected, which is essential
- 7:35for productive negotiations. Remember, you want
- 7:39a mediator who can challenge both sides equally?
- 7:42and maintain credibility with all parties throughout
- 7:44the process. So ensure that the mediator that
- 7:47you select is neutral. The next factor that you
- 7:55should consider in choosing your mediator is
- 7:57subject matter expertise. Consider whether you
- 8:01need a mediator with experience in the area of
- 8:04law or industry that is at issue in the case.
- 8:08Complex cases have nuanced legal and practical
- 8:11issues. Let's talk about a few examples. In antitrust
- 8:16cases, a mediator needs an understanding of market
- 8:19dynamics and econometric analysis. Damages in
- 8:24antitrust cases turn on expert opinions, often
- 8:27using complex regression analysis. Having a mediator
- 8:31who can understand those damages theories is
- 8:36going to be quite helpful in your case. In intellectual
- 8:39property cases, a mediator requires technical
- 8:43knowledge. Employment matters benefit from a
- 8:47mediator with familiarity with workplace dynamics.
- 8:51So don't assume all mediators are equal. Specialized
- 8:55knowledge can make the difference between settlement
- 8:57and impasse. So consider whether having a mediator
- 9:00with subject matter expertise would be helpful
- 9:03in your case. The next factor that you should
- 9:07think about in selecting a mediator is whether
- 9:10they have experience in complex cases. High stakes
- 9:14or multi -party cases require mediators with
- 9:17proven experience managing complex disputes.
- 9:22Look for a track record with high stakes disputes
- 9:24and multi -party experience. In your pre -vetting
- 9:29process, ask, what's the most complex case you've
- 9:32ever mediated? you need someone who can manage
- 9:36multiple moving parts and navigate the legal,
- 9:40logistical, and interpersonal challenges these
- 9:42cases present. Complex cases often involve competing
- 9:47interests among multiple parties, substantial
- 9:50financial exposure, and intricate legal issues
- 9:54that require carefully sequencing of discussions.
- 9:58An experienced mediator knows how to structure
- 10:01the day. when to use joint sessions versus separate
- 10:05caucuses, and how to keep momentum going when
- 10:08negotiations get bogged down in details. They
- 10:12also understand the unique pressure that comes
- 10:15with high stakes disputes and can help the parties
- 10:19maintain perspective when emotions run high.
- 10:24I'm going to pause here and see if we have any
- 10:26questions from the audience. I'm happy to take
- 10:32questions whenever they come up. So if I'm talking
- 10:36about a topic that raises a question with you,
- 10:39please feel free to put it into the chat and
- 10:43I will do my best to remember to check carefully.
- 10:49Okay. All right. Now the fourth factor that you
- 10:56want to think about in choosing your mediator
- 10:58is a style match. Different mediators employ
- 11:02varying styles. Facilitative mediators help parties
- 11:08communicate and find their own solutions. Evaluative
- 11:13mediators, on the other hand, provide assessments
- 11:16of case strengths and weaknesses. Transformative
- 11:20mediators focus on improving relationships. So
- 11:25choose a mediator whose approach aligns with
- 11:27your case dynamics and client needs. A well -matched
- 11:32mediator builds trust, manages conflict effectively,
- 11:37and significantly increases the chances of a
- 11:40meaningful resolution. So to sum up our first
- 11:45topic, which is choosing your mediator wisely,
- 11:49remember that the right mediator is your strategic
- 11:51partner. Invest time and selection because it's
- 11:55one of the most important decisions in the entire
- 11:58process. Okay, now we are moving on to I, identify
- 12:04strengths and weaknesses. All right, you've done
- 12:09the hard work and you've selected your mediator.
- 12:12Now you need to begin preparing your case thoughtfully
- 12:15for mediation. A clear understanding of both
- 12:18the strengths and weaknesses allow you to set
- 12:22realistic expectations and negotiate strategically.
- 12:27This balanced perspective helps you avoid overconfidence
- 12:31or unnecessary pessimism. So let's talk a little
- 12:37bit about leveraging your strengths effectively.
- 12:41Knowing your strongest points allows you to present
- 12:44them effectively in your written statements and
- 12:47if you have a joint session during opening statements
- 12:50to influence the other party's risk assessment.
- 12:55Lead with your most compelling arguments and
- 12:58use supporting evidence strategically to build
- 13:01confidence. This approach helps shift the opposing
- 13:06party's perception of their litigation risk.
- 13:09When you articulate your strengths clearly and
- 13:12persuasively, you're not just advocating for
- 13:16your client. You are providing valuable information
- 13:20directly to the other side to help them make
- 13:24informed decisions about settlement. A well -presented
- 13:28strength can be the turning point that moves
- 13:31negotiation from posturing to serious discussion.
- 13:36However, resist the temptation to oversell or
- 13:39exaggerate. Credibility is your most important
- 13:43asset in mediation, and once it's lost, it is
- 13:46very difficult to regain. We also need to address
- 13:52our weaknesses proactively. Understanding your
- 13:57case's vulnerabilities helps you prepare responses
- 14:00rather than being caught off guard. Anticipate
- 14:03what opposing counsel will attack and how you
- 14:06will respond without being defensive. One mantra
- 14:09that I find very helpful is, if you can't fix
- 14:12it, feature it. Every case has weaknesses. Rather
- 14:18than hiding behind them and waiting for the other
- 14:21side to point them out, address it proactively.
- 14:24Acknowledge it openly. That helps you maintain
- 14:27credibility and helps reduce the sting of having
- 14:30your opposing counsel address it in the first
- 14:33instance. If you can't fix it, feature it. And
- 14:38also distinguish core issues that are non -negotiable
- 14:41from flexible areas where you can give ground
- 14:44strategically. Now let's talk about the strategic
- 14:50benefits. of identifying the strengths and weaknesses
- 14:53of your case. This honest analysis enables strategic
- 14:59negotiation from a well -informed position. You
- 15:02can make targeted compromises while protecting
- 15:06essential interests, giving ground on less critical
- 15:10points to create momentum toward resolution.
- 15:15The key is conducting this analysis honestly,
- 15:18often with outside counsel. who can provide objective
- 15:21perspectives. Self -deception about case strength
- 15:26is one of the most common barriers to successful
- 15:29outcomes. I've seen cases where parties had unrealistic
- 15:33views, plaintiffs thinking cases were too strong,
- 15:37or defendants being overconfident. When this
- 15:41happens, the mediator must work harder to provide
- 15:43reality testing and get the parties moving. Address
- 15:47this on initially. address your strengths and
- 15:52weaknesses of your case, because knowing the
- 15:55case's true strengths and weaknesses through
- 15:58honest self -assessment, this is your negotiation
- 16:01compass through the mediation process. Okay,
- 16:09it looks like we have questions. Okay, I'm going
- 16:14to jump. The first question from Sally is, when
- 16:16do you use joint sessions? I use joint sessions
- 16:20in most of my mediations. Before the mediation
- 16:26session, I schedule a call with all council,
- 16:29a joint call to talk about the process. And one
- 16:33of the issues that we discuss is whether it would
- 16:36be appropriate to have a joint session in the
- 16:38case. It is always my recommendation that we
- 16:41start with a joint session and we'll talk about
- 16:46that a little bit more. But I find it's very
- 16:49helpful to use joint sessions. And unless there's
- 16:52a reason not to do it, and sometimes there is,
- 16:55I will have joint sessions. Okay, what is the
- 16:59balance between parties wanting the mediator
- 17:01to understand and experience in the law and industry
- 17:05related to the case and being fully unbiased?
- 17:10I certainly think that they can go together.
- 17:13Having an understanding of the law and industry
- 17:15doesn't make the mediator biased. but it can
- 17:18provide them with really important information
- 17:21regarding the case. Okay. I hope those were helpful.
- 17:35And just another example regarding having industry
- 17:40or legal knowledge was the example that I gave
- 17:42regarding antitrust cases. And this applies to
- 17:46any highly technical area of law. Having that
- 17:49understanding from the mediator is going to help
- 17:52reality test the party's position. So when you
- 17:55get into an impasse situation, having a mediator
- 17:59who can push back and say, you know, look at,
- 18:02for example, look at the party's expert report
- 18:04and pressure test some of the conclusions can
- 18:07help the attorneys assess their risk in litigation.
- 18:12Okay, great questions. Thank you so much. Okay,
- 18:17we are now going to move on to the next slide.
- 18:24Okay, we're now moving on to our range of settlement
- 18:29options. Develop multiple solutions that could
- 18:34meet both your client's needs and those of the
- 18:36opposing party. Consider creative and non -monetary
- 18:40terms based on your assessment of the case's
- 18:42strengths and weaknesses. Expand thinking beyond
- 18:47dollars. Payment plans and structured settlements
- 18:51can ease financial burden. Policy changes and
- 18:55procedural modifications can address systemic
- 18:58issues. Confidentiality and non -disparagement
- 19:02clauses protect reputations. Future business
- 19:05arrangements can create ongoing value. I've seen
- 19:09business disputes resolved with licensing agreements
- 19:12instead of damages, creating win -win outcomes
- 19:15that preserve relationships. Let's talk about
- 19:18client preparation. This is essential for your
- 19:24successful mediation. So before your mediation
- 19:28session, have honest discussions with your client
- 19:31about three key questions. The first, What do
- 19:35you want? Identify your client's ideal outcome
- 19:39and assess if it's realistic, given the case
- 19:44circumstances. Second question, what is available?
- 19:49Establish minimum acceptable terms, your client's
- 19:52bottom line and walk away point, and make sure
- 19:55you include any non -negotiable elements. The
- 19:59third question, what happens if the case does
- 20:02not settle? We all know not every case is going
- 20:05to settle during mediation. But in order to develop
- 20:09a range of settlement options, it's important
- 20:11for your client to understand and think about
- 20:14what is going to happen if the case does not
- 20:17settle. Discuss the risks of continued litigation,
- 20:21timeline considerations, and cost implications.
- 20:25Address emotional versus practical considerations
- 20:28to set realistic expectations. These conversations
- 20:32are often difficult, but absolutely essential.
- 20:37Clients who have not thought through these questions
- 20:40beforehand can make poor decisions under the
- 20:43pressure of the moment. For example, if a client
- 20:46has not carefully considered what will happen
- 20:49if the case does not settle, they might quickly
- 20:52reject a settlement offer when it might be in
- 20:56their best interest. Make sure your client understands
- 21:00that their best alternative to a negotiated agreement
- 21:04becomes their measuring stick for evaluating
- 21:07any settlement offer. Without this framework,
- 21:11you'll find yourself in the uncomfortable position
- 21:13of trying to counsel a client who's hearing these
- 21:16realities for the first time during high stakes
- 21:19negotiation. Decision making authority is very
- 21:24important. Ensure that all decision makers are
- 21:28present or at a minimum available for the mediation.
- 21:33If you have a case that involves an insurance
- 21:36policy that could contribute to a potential settlement,
- 21:40it's important that a representative of that
- 21:43insurance company with settlement authority is
- 21:45present or available at the mediation. If this
- 21:49is a business dispute, make sure that there is
- 21:52a corporate representative present or available.
- 21:55who has a settlement authority. If it's an individual
- 21:58case, that's easy. Make sure your client is present
- 22:01and prepared. If it's a class action case, make
- 22:04sure that you have a class representative either
- 22:07present or available who understands the case
- 22:11and can discuss settlement with you. It's important
- 22:15before the mediation to confirm authority to
- 22:19approve terms and understand the approval process.
- 22:23The last thing you want to do at your mediation
- 22:26is spend all day negotiating a settlement, get
- 22:30close to a settlement agreement, and then realize
- 22:33that the right people are not in the room. That
- 22:35is one of the worst possible outcomes. Preparation
- 22:39prevents frustration. Have multiple settlement
- 22:42options ready and ensure decision makers have
- 22:45full authority to negotiate. All right, that
- 22:50concludes our discussion about range of options.
- 22:53I'm going to check and it looks like we have
- 22:55a question. Okay, the next question is about
- 22:59joint sessions. So I'm going to actually discuss
- 23:03joint sessions a little bit more coming up. So
- 23:08that was a good preview. So thank you for that
- 23:10question. Okay, our next, we now have our second
- 23:26C, which is calm. Stay focused and curious. If
- 23:31I had to pick the most important of the six topics
- 23:34that we are discussing today, staying calm would
- 23:37be the one. I have seen so many mediations derail
- 23:42when one party gets mad and leaves. If you leave
- 23:45mediation early, there is a 100 % chance, 100
- 23:50% chance that the case will not settle. If you
- 23:54stay, there's a greater than 0 % chance that
- 23:57the case will settle and an even greater chance
- 23:59that you will actually learn something valuable.
- 24:02I tell clients, don't give me paid time off.
- 24:06You most likely have paid your mediator for a
- 24:09full day. Take advantage of that full day. You
- 24:13never know what might happen. But if you leave,
- 24:16you know what will happen. The case will not
- 24:18resolve. Now, mediation can be emotionally charged.
- 24:22That is a fact. Especially when disputes involve
- 24:26personal animosities or very high stakes. A natural
- 24:31response can sometimes be anger, frustration,
- 24:34and defensiveness. But these emotions are the
- 24:37enemy of resolution. Prepare yourself and your
- 24:41client mentally for this challenge. Discuss ahead
- 24:45of time how you will handle provocative statements
- 24:48or unreasonable positions. Remember that the
- 24:51other side may be testing your resolve or trying
- 24:54to gauge your true bottom line through their
- 24:56behavior. Now, if you only remember one thing
- 25:00from this presentation, I hope you'll remember
- 25:03this. When tensions flare, don't get furious,
- 25:07get curious. Ask the mediator these strategic
- 25:11W questions. Why is the person acting this way?
- 25:17What Are they really trying to say? What is underneath
- 25:21their position or emotion? Who is driving this
- 25:24process? By asking these questions, you are going
- 25:29to learn information that can help move the process
- 25:32along. Let's break it down. Why is this person
- 25:36acting this way? Consider a situation where the
- 25:39other party keeps making unreasonable demands
- 25:42and seems unwilling to compromise, right? We've
- 25:44all been there. Rather than labeling them as
- 25:47stubborn or getting frustrated, exploring why
- 25:51might uncover that they're facing pressure from
- 25:54stakeholders that you can't see, operating under
- 25:57different assumptions about market conditions,
- 26:01or trying to save face after a previous failed
- 26:03negotiation. This insight can help you craft
- 26:08proposals that address these hidden constraints
- 26:11while still meeting your needs. So by asking
- 26:14why this person is acting that way, you may uncover
- 26:18information that will help you understand their
- 26:21position and help you create a path forward.
- 26:26The second question, what are they really trying
- 26:27to say? Let's consider an example. When a party
- 26:31says, I want X dollars or nothing, they might
- 26:35really be saying, I need to feel that the harm
- 26:38I suffered is being taken seriously. Understanding
- 26:41this allows you to explore non -monetary ways
- 26:45to acknowledge the impact, perhaps through an
- 26:48apology, a policy change, or a public recognition
- 26:52that could satisfy their core need for validation
- 26:56while reducing the financial burden. Or my favorite,
- 27:01when a party says, this is my last best and final
- 27:04offer. I've heard this so many times. Ask the
- 27:08mediator, what are they really trying to say?
- 27:11They might be trying to say they're exhausted,
- 27:15they're tired, they're frustrated. Ask the mediator,
- 27:19do you really think this is their last best and
- 27:21final offer? It's a very overused phrase. Sometimes
- 27:24it's true. But ask, is that what they're really
- 27:28trying to say or is there something else going
- 27:30on? The next question, what is underneath their
- 27:34position or emotion? This is really important.
- 27:37Let's consider a few examples. An employee demands
- 27:41reinstatement to their former position, which
- 27:43the employer flatly refuses. Underneath this
- 27:47position, the employee might need financial security,
- 27:52professional reputation repair, or validation
- 27:55that they weren't terminated unfairly. Understanding
- 28:00what's underneath their position opens alternatives
- 28:03like enhanced severance with positive references.
- 28:07consulting arrangements that preserve income
- 28:09flow without creating an employer relationship,
- 28:13or a neutral statement about the departure that
- 28:15protects their reputation without admitting wrongdoing.
- 28:19Let's consider this in the context of an intellectual
- 28:22property dispute. A company demands cessation
- 28:26of all use of allegedly infringing technology
- 28:30while the accused party claims the right to continue.
- 28:35The underlying interests might be market protection
- 28:39and licensing revenue for the first party and
- 28:44avoiding costly redesign while maintaining a
- 28:47competitive position for the second. This could
- 28:51lead to licensing agreements, field of use restrictions,
- 28:55or collaborative development arrangements that
- 28:58benefit both parties. Let's talk about this in
- 29:03a personal injury case as an example. A plaintiff
- 29:06demands a specific monetary amount while the
- 29:09defendant offers much less. Underneath, the plaintiff
- 29:13might need ongoing medical care, lost income
- 29:17replacement. They might need assurance that their
- 29:20family is protected. While the defendant might
- 29:23need to manage insurance implications and policy
- 29:26limits. and the defendant might want to avoid
- 29:29a precedent -setting settlement. So in this case,
- 29:33solutions could include a structured settlement,
- 29:37medical payment arrangements, or agreements that
- 29:40meet the plaintiff's needs while fitting the
- 29:42defendant's risk management parameters. So the
- 29:46key insight in asking what is underneath their
- 29:49position or emotion is that positions are often
- 29:53just the first solution someone thinks of. to
- 29:56meet their underlying needs. But when you understand
- 30:00what they're really trying to achieve or protect,
- 30:04then you can often find multiple pathways to
- 30:07satisfy those interests while also meeting your
- 30:10own needs. This transforms zero -sum thinking
- 30:14into collaborative problem solving. I see that
- 30:22we have a question. I'm going to address this
- 30:23last question, and then I will answer the question
- 30:27that's in the chat. So the last W question that
- 30:30you want to ask your mediator, and obviously
- 30:33feel free to add additional. These are just some
- 30:36ideas that I have for you. And this is also a
- 30:39critical one, is who is driving the process?
- 30:43Asking the mediator to tell you who is driving
- 30:46the process reveals the actual decision -making
- 30:50dynamics, which is crucial for effective mediation
- 30:53strategy. and realistic expectations. And this
- 30:56comes up a lot in mediations. So let's use a
- 30:59few examples. In a business dispute, a corporate
- 31:03representative may participate actively but lack
- 31:07settlement authority, where the real decisions
- 31:09are being made by an absent CEO, a board, or
- 31:14an insurance carrier. Recognizing this, recognizing
- 31:20the, excuse me, Recognizing who the real decision
- 31:28maker is prevents wasting time negotiating with
- 31:31someone who can't actually agree to terms. It
- 31:34might require bringing decision makers into the
- 31:37process or structuring agreements that account
- 31:39for approval requirements. Now, we always want
- 31:42to avoid this from happening, and we talked about
- 31:44that earlier, about making sure that we have
- 31:47the right people in the room before the mediation
- 31:50begins, that we have the people who have decision
- 31:53-making authority. If you get to a point where
- 31:56that didn't happen, it's important to recognize
- 31:58it and figure out how to move forward. Note that
- 32:02there also can be institutional constraints.
- 32:04For example, a school district representative
- 32:07might want to settle, but their position is being
- 32:09driven by the school board or an insurance company
- 32:13with different risk tolerance and priorities.
- 32:15This can also sometimes happen in government
- 32:17cases where a representative of the government
- 32:19doesn't have final settlement authority and has
- 32:23to get it from superiors. So it's really important
- 32:27to understand who's really calling the shots.
- 32:31This is going to help frame proposals in terms
- 32:34that will appeal to those ultimate decision makers
- 32:36and their specific concerns about precedent,
- 32:40budget, insurance, or policy implications. We
- 32:45also know that sometimes the attorney is driving
- 32:46the process more than the client. perhaps due
- 32:49to fee arrangements, personal relationships,
- 32:52or professional reputational concerns. Conversely,
- 32:57sometimes clients may be overruling sound legal
- 32:59advice due to emotional factors. Asking the mediator
- 33:02who's driving the process can help the mediator
- 33:05also frame their discussions with the other side
- 33:08to understand who they need to talk to to get
- 33:11to a point where there can be a real discussion
- 33:15about settlement. So when you understand who's
- 33:19really driving the process, you can direct your
- 33:22most persuasive arguments to the actual decision
- 33:25-makers. You can address the real concerns and
- 33:29motivations behind stated positions. You can
- 33:33anticipate which proposals are likely to gain
- 33:35traction. You can identify if necessary when
- 33:39additional stakeholders need to be included in
- 33:41the process. And you can adjust your expectations
- 33:44based on the approval process if there's a timeline
- 33:47that needs to occur. Okay, let's now go to, I
- 33:55think we have a question here. Oh, this is the
- 34:01same question that we're going to address. All
- 34:03right. Okay, continuing on our discussion about
- 34:12staying focused and curious, let's talk about
- 34:14a comparison between anger and curiosity. When
- 34:18anger takes over, it shuts down communication.
- 34:22It derails the productive discussions. It creates
- 34:26an adversarial environment, and sometimes people
- 34:30leave early. When curiosity leads, it opens communication.
- 34:36It uncovers hidden interests. It reveals opportunities
- 34:41for compromise and maintains a collaborative
- 34:46environment. In the context of mediation, anger
- 34:54shuts down communication, but curiosity opens
- 34:57it up. When attorneys get curious, they're more
- 35:00likely to uncover hidden interests, misunderstandings,
- 35:04and opportunities for compromise. So maintain
- 35:08a solution -focused mindset, not an emotional
- 35:12one. The key takeaway from our discussion about
- 35:16staying calm and focused is when tensions flare,
- 35:19don't get furious, get curious. Ask W questions
- 35:23to transform conflict into opportunity. Okay,
- 35:30now we're going to talk a little bit more about
- 35:31joint sessions. I know we've had a few discussions,
- 35:35excuse me, a few questions about joint sessions.
- 35:38And frankly, this is one of my favorite parts
- 35:41of the presentation because I truly believe that
- 35:46joint sessions are underutilized in mediations.
- 35:49So now we are at L, learning through joint sessions.
- 35:55Consider asking the mediator to start the mediation
- 35:57with a joint session. While joint sessions have
- 36:01become less common and some attorneys are adamantly
- 36:04opposed to joint sessions, in my experience,
- 36:08joint sessions provide tremendously valuable
- 36:11learning opportunities. Think of it as free discovery.
- 36:15You get to see and hear from opposing counsel
- 36:18outside the courtroom, outside of the meet and
- 36:21confer process. You will hear how they view the
- 36:24case. You will hear what evidence they think
- 36:28is important. Joint sessions offer insights you
- 36:32simply cannot get from depositions or court filings
- 36:36or court appearances because you're observing
- 36:39the attorney in their presentation, almost akin
- 36:44to what an opening statement might look like
- 36:46at trial. You'll see how opposing counsel handles
- 36:51their statement, whether they're truly confident
- 36:54in their position, and how they prioritize their
- 36:58arguments. You learn just as much from what they
- 37:02say as what they don't say. This intelligence
- 37:06becomes invaluable whether you settle that day
- 37:10or proceed to trial months later. Even in cases
- 37:14where joint sessions seem risky, and I'll talk
- 37:16a little bit at the end about, I'll provide two
- 37:19examples of where a joint session went very well
- 37:23and one where it did not go well. But even in
- 37:26cases where joint sessions seem risky, Discuss
- 37:29the possibility with your mediator. That can
- 37:32reveal a creative way to structure them safely
- 37:34and will help you decide whether or not it's
- 37:37appropriate to have a joint session in your case.
- 37:42Okay, what to observe and evaluate during joint
- 37:45sessions. Watch opposing counsel's effectiveness
- 37:51and persuasiveness. How compelling are their
- 37:54arguments? This is critical. Will they connect
- 37:58with a jury? Do they know the case well? Are
- 38:03they confident or nervous? Do they come across
- 38:07as trustworthy or arrogant? You may also hear
- 38:11from the client. What an incredible opportunity
- 38:13because you may never have met the client before
- 38:17or your interactions may have been limited to
- 38:20a deposition. So hearing from the client during
- 38:23a joint session can provide a lot of very useful
- 38:26information. Are they likable and sympathetic?
- 38:31What is their emotional state? Do they appear
- 38:35credible? These insights would be impossible
- 38:39to gain without a joint session. Pay attention
- 38:43to body language and nonverbal cues that reveal
- 38:48true confidence levels or underlying concerns.
- 38:52Notice which points they emphasize and which
- 38:55they gloss over, this tells you what they view
- 38:58as their strongest and weakest arguments. Watch
- 39:03how they interact with their own client during
- 39:05the session, as this can reveal the dynamics
- 39:09of their attorney -client relationship and who's
- 39:13driving the case strategy. We just talked about
- 39:15that. Who's the decision maker? Watching the
- 39:19interaction during a joint session can help you
- 39:22identify that information. And all of the information
- 39:26that you learn during joint session can help
- 39:29you calibrate your negotiation approach and anticipate
- 39:33how the case might play out a trial if it doesn't
- 39:37settle. Let's talk about the strategic benefits
- 39:43of a joint session. So joint sessions offer a
- 39:48preview of what opening statements might look
- 39:51like at trial. What themes will they emphasize?
- 39:55What's their strongest evidence? How might a
- 39:59jury view their case? What are they not addressing?
- 40:05Take close attention to these dynamics and take
- 40:09detailed notes. Use these observations to refine
- 40:13your negotiation strategy and develop more informed
- 40:17settlement offers. Okay, so a couple examples.
- 40:23Joint sessions are not appropriate for every
- 40:25case, but I think the problem with most mediations
- 40:29today is there is just an assumption going into
- 40:32the mediation that there will be no joint session,
- 40:36that you'll automatically start with separate
- 40:38caucuses. So let me provide you with two examples.
- 40:43In one case, I mediated a sexual harassment case
- 40:47where a student sued a for -profit college. for
- 40:52conduct by one of the professors at that college.
- 40:56Now, in a case like that, I might not recommend
- 41:00a joint session because of the high tension and
- 41:04emotional involvement of the case. However, when
- 41:08I talked to the parties in a pre -session conference,
- 41:13they both wanted to have a joint session. And
- 41:16in particular, the plaintiff strongly advocated
- 41:19for having a joint session. And I quickly realized
- 41:24why. During that joint session, the plaintiff
- 41:28was able to speak directly to the professor.
- 41:33She was able to speak directly to the owners
- 41:36of the college and tell them in her own words
- 41:39what had happened to her from her perspective.
- 41:43She was able to tell the owners of the college
- 41:45what the professor had done. and what words he
- 41:48had used. And I could tell just watching the
- 41:54body language of the defendants that they listened
- 41:57and they heard what she was saying. It was quite
- 42:00powerful. Now, after the joint session, we proceeded
- 42:05to separate caucuses and the case actually settled
- 42:09pretty quickly. I think there were three offers
- 42:12and counter offers. And I was actually quite
- 42:15surprised at the number that the case settled
- 42:18for. I thought it was lower than what the plaintiff
- 42:22likely could have gotten, but the reason was
- 42:25her interest wasn't just dollars. Her interest
- 42:29was telling her story and being heard, and that
- 42:33was frankly more important to her. So she got
- 42:37an amount of money that was acceptable to her,
- 42:39but she got what she needed most, and that was
- 42:42the opportunity to tell her story and be heard.
- 42:45And that's an example of a case where I don't
- 42:49think it would have gone that well if there hadn't
- 42:51been a joint session. I don't think it would
- 42:54have settled for the amount that it settled for.
- 42:58It may not have settled at all. And I view that
- 43:01settlement as a win -win because the defendant
- 43:05understood that they needed to settle the case
- 43:08and settled, I believe, for less than they had
- 43:13budgeted. And the plaintiff got an amount of
- 43:16money that was acceptable to her and got to tell
- 43:19her story. So whenever people, I hear this quite
- 43:23often, people say, you know, a mediation is successful
- 43:25when both parties leave unhappy. I could not
- 43:29disagree with that more. I've had many cases
- 43:32where both parties left feeling like it was a
- 43:35fair settlement. And that is one example. So
- 43:38that's an example of where a joint session went
- 43:40quite well. Now, in fairness, I need to provide
- 43:43an example of a joint session that did not go
- 43:46well. Now this case was an employment class action
- 43:50case, which was a wage and hour case. So it didn't
- 43:55seem like there would be high emotions or any
- 43:58kind of red flags that would caution against
- 44:00a joint session. So I recommended that we would
- 44:03start with a joint session and the parties agreed.
- 44:06And I talked about my priorities for joint sessions.
- 44:11When I give the plaintiff the first opportunity
- 44:14to give an opening statement, I typically don't
- 44:17provide time limits. And I suggest sticking to
- 44:22the facts and the law and that each the other
- 44:25side needs to not be quiet during the other side's
- 44:30presentation and save any questions for after
- 44:33the presentation has concluded. So the plaintiff
- 44:36started making his opening statement. And instead
- 44:41of focusing on the facts and the law and the
- 44:43case from his perspective, he took the opportunity
- 44:46to disparage the defendant in ways that were
- 44:52very frustrating to the other side. And unfortunately,
- 44:57the in -house counsel for the defendant started
- 44:59yelling at the plaintiff attorney, which then
- 45:03caused the plaintiff attorney to yell back. Yelling
- 45:09ensued and we were on zoom. So I was like time
- 45:11out time out. Let's you know, everybody calm
- 45:14down Well, they didn't calm down. Luckily. I
- 45:17had the opportunity to mute them. So I put them
- 45:20on mute and re Reshared my rules for joint sessions
- 45:28about being you know, letting the other side
- 45:31speak and being calm and Unfortunately, when
- 45:36we broke into separate caucuses after the joint
- 45:39session, the in -house council was so mad and
- 45:44frustrated that the case, he was not able to
- 45:48engage in any serious settlement discussions.
- 45:51He didn't get curious, he just got furious and
- 45:55did not ask W questions. Unfortunately, the damage
- 45:59was done. Definitely approach joint sessions
- 46:03with a degree of caution. Identify any potential
- 46:08red flags that you see. If there is a pre -existing
- 46:12relationship between the attorneys that could
- 46:14be a problem, if it's a highly emotional case,
- 46:19if there are family dynamics, address those issues
- 46:23with your mediator. But don't, my point, I think
- 46:26my key takeaway is don't assume that you shouldn't
- 46:29have a joint session. For all of the reasons
- 46:32that we've discussed, joint sessions can be incredibly
- 46:35valuable. They are essentially free discovery.
- 46:38If you have them, use them to gather intelligence
- 46:41about opposing counsel, their client, and then
- 46:44preview trial dynamics. I think you're going
- 46:48to find that there are more upsides to joint
- 46:50sessions than downsides, but as we've discussed,
- 46:55approach them with some caution in certain cases.
- 46:59Okay, that is our discussion about learning through
- 47:02joint sessions, and now we're going to move on
- 47:06to evaluating settlement offers. This is the
- 47:12E, the final letter that we are going to discuss.
- 47:15Okay, it is critical to evaluate settlement offers
- 47:20carefully. So now we've had the joint session.
- 47:25and the parties are now proceeding to separate
- 47:28caucuses with the mediator. And the mediator
- 47:31at this point is going to be speaking with the
- 47:33parties separately and will be shuttling back
- 47:35and forth with information and offers. Now, this
- 47:39is your time to be candid with the mediator.
- 47:42During joint session, you were advocating for
- 47:44your client, you were putting on your best case,
- 47:48you were positioning yourself strongly in this
- 47:52negotiation process by showing your opposing
- 47:54counsel that you know the facts and the law,
- 48:00that you are a strong advocate, and that if they
- 48:02take this case to trial, you are going to do
- 48:04very well in front of the jury. Now you get to
- 48:08be candid. Everything that you talk about with
- 48:12the mediator is going to be held in confidence.
- 48:15You've signed a confidentiality agreement prior
- 48:17to your mediation, so the mediator will not be
- 48:19sharing any information with the judge. And make
- 48:22sure that if you tell the mediator something
- 48:25that you don't want the other side to know, be
- 48:27sure that you're clear about that. But this is
- 48:29the time to share your concerns about the case.
- 48:32Every case has weakness. We all know that. No
- 48:35case is perfect. Share those concerns. Share
- 48:39your priorities. And of course, share ... I say
- 48:45share your settlement parameters. Not every lawyer
- 48:47feels comfortable doing that. But from the plaintiff's
- 48:50side, you need to make an opening demand. So
- 48:52you need to share that with with your mediator
- 48:55and then, of course, the defense, the same thing,
- 48:58a response. If you feel comfortable sharing your
- 49:01settlement parameters confidentially, you can
- 49:04do that. That can sometimes be helpful, especially
- 49:07when a mediator potentially is crafting a mediator
- 49:10proposal at the end of the session if requested
- 49:15by the parties. And just to emphasize again,
- 49:18let the mediator know what they can share and
- 49:20what must stay confidential. But this is your
- 49:23time to really help the mediator understand your
- 49:26client's perspective by explaining your client's
- 49:29motivations, the pressures, and any non -monetary
- 49:33issues. Share key facts or documents that support
- 49:36your case, and share key facts and case law that
- 49:40doesn't support your case. Use the mediator as
- 49:43your reality testing partner. Be open to hearing
- 49:47the risks and weaknesses in your position. Ask
- 49:50the mediator to pressure test your opponent's
- 49:52likely response. And stay flexible. Explore creative
- 49:57solutions. Is there injunctive relief that could
- 50:00be quite useful in a case like this? Even if
- 50:04it differs from your initial demands, be prepared
- 50:08to adjust in light of new information that you've
- 50:10learned from the other side. And manage your
- 50:13time wisely. Use caucus time to refine proposals,
- 50:17not just to wait for the other side. And keep
- 50:19your client engaged and informed between sessions.
- 50:22I know that there can often a lot of downtime
- 50:25during mediation sessions, so use that time to
- 50:28talk to your client about what did they think
- 50:32about the joint session? What are their settlement
- 50:35parameters? I'm sure you've talked about a lot
- 50:38of this before the session, but when you get
- 50:40there, continue the discussion. And when your
- 50:44client receives a settlement offer, evaluate
- 50:46it carefully. Consider if the proposed outcome
- 50:49is better than what the client is likely to achieve
- 50:52at trial by analyzing case strength, likelihood
- 50:56of success, and potential costs of litigation.
- 51:01A common mistake is focusing solely on monetary
- 51:05terms. This often misses underlying interests
- 51:09that actually drive disputes. as I explained
- 51:12using the example of the sexual harassment case
- 51:14where one of the underlying issues was really
- 51:16to be heard. Many parties have non -financial
- 51:21needs, preserving relationships, protecting reputation,
- 51:24having their voice heard, ensuring future opportunity,
- 51:28or receiving acknowledgement. When mediations
- 51:31become purely transactional negotiation over
- 51:34dollars, they often ignore creative solutions.
- 51:38And those creative solutions might provide greater
- 51:41value, such as an ongoing business relationship
- 51:44or a policy change that could cost little but
- 51:46deliver significant benefit. Additionally, an
- 51:50exclusive focus just on money can escalate emotions
- 51:53and entrench positions, as parties may interpret
- 51:56financial offers as statements about the worth
- 51:59or validity of their claims rather than the practical
- 52:04problem -solving tools. I've seen cases where
- 52:09a sincere apology was worth more to a plaintiff
- 52:13than additional settlement dollars. I've seen
- 52:16situations where a defendant agreed to change
- 52:18a business practice, which provided the vindication
- 52:21that a plaintiff was really seeking. The key
- 52:25is to listen carefully to what the parties say
- 52:28they want and then explore what they actually
- 52:32need. Again, we're going back to understanding,
- 52:35asking our W questions about what What are they
- 52:37really saying? What is underneath their position?
- 52:42And you also need to compare a settlement to
- 52:47trial prospects. Conduct a realistic litigation
- 52:51risk assessment. What are the strengths of your
- 52:55case and the likelihood of success? This is hard
- 52:58to do, but think of it this way. Because I know
- 53:04plaintiffs don't Plaintiffs don't always have
- 53:06a realistic version of their case, and defendants
- 53:08sometimes don't either. So ask yourself this
- 53:11question. If the case goes to trial 10 times,
- 53:15how many times will your client win? This isn't
- 53:18about being optimistic or pessimistic. It's about
- 53:21being brutally honest with yourself and your
- 53:25client. And use your mediator as your partner
- 53:28in this process. If you have an evaluative mediator,
- 53:32or even if you don't, ask the mediator, can they...
- 53:35give their neutral assessment of your case. If
- 53:40there are particular important issues that need
- 53:44to be resolved, ask them what they think about
- 53:46it. It might be helpful. Think about what hurdles
- 53:50you have to surpass. Depending on where you are
- 53:54in your litigation, there might be a motion to
- 53:56dismiss coming up, class certification, summary
- 53:59judgment. Each of these procedural barriers represents
- 54:03not just a legal challenge, but also months or
- 54:07years of additional expenses and uncertainty.
- 54:12Remember, when you settle your case during mediation,
- 54:15you have 100 % control over what the agreement
- 54:19is. When you go to trial, you have very little
- 54:24control. It's in the hands of the judge and the
- 54:26jury. So consider the uncertainty. that you will
- 54:30be facing if the case does not settle. Consider
- 54:33the potential costs of continued litigation.
- 54:36We're talking about attorney's fees, expert costs,
- 54:40time delays, appeals, business disruption. These
- 54:44costs can quickly spiral beyond their initial
- 54:47estimates, especially in complex cases where
- 54:50discovery disputes and motion practice consume
- 54:53significant resources. For plaintiffs, They often
- 54:58think justice delayed is justice denied. A settlement
- 55:02today may be worth more than a larger verdict
- 55:05years from now. A settlement has finality. Even
- 55:09a trial verdict is subject to appeal and retrial.
- 55:13For defendants, ongoing cases distract from business
- 55:17operations, right? The employees have to appear
- 55:20for a deposition. They may have to testify at
- 55:22trial. Ongoing cases create uncertainty that
- 55:26affects strategic planning and stakeholder confidence.
- 55:30Assess the quality of your evidence in key witnesses.
- 55:34What evidence will hold up at trial? Is that
- 55:37evidence admissible at trial? Are witnesses credible
- 55:40and available? Are they within the court's subpoena
- 55:42power? Is your evidence compelling and understandable
- 55:46to the average juror? This is so important to
- 55:49think about in complex cases. where damages analysis
- 55:53often turns on expert opinions. You need to think
- 55:57about the quality of your expert testifying at
- 56:00trial and whether the average juror, not you,
- 56:03who knows your case back and forth, up and down,
- 56:06whether the average juror is able to understand
- 56:09the expert testimony and the damages theory in
- 56:12your case. The documentary evidence that seems
- 56:17ironclad to you might appear confusing. or irrelevant
- 56:21to jurors who lack your legal training and your
- 56:23case knowledge. Remember, you've been working
- 56:25on this case perhaps for years. Jurors are hearing
- 56:29all of this information for the first time. Consider
- 56:33procedural factors, judge's tendencies, venue
- 56:37advantages, jury pool characteristics. Maybe
- 56:40you've done a focus group or a mock trial. That's
- 56:43going to help you inform an it will help you
- 56:48evaluate settlement offers carefully. And remember,
- 56:52when you're hearing settlement offers, we need
- 56:55to remember to stay calm. As we discussed in
- 56:57the prior slide, stay calm when you're evaluating
- 57:01settlement proposals. You may be furious with
- 57:03the offer. It is either way too high or way too
- 57:06low and you're offended. Remember to get curious,
- 57:09not furious. Use your W questions. And sometimes
- 57:13the best option simply is to take a break. I
- 57:16do this quite often when I can see people getting
- 57:18frustrated or tired. I say, if you can go outside
- 57:23and take a walk. Sometimes have a snack. If you
- 57:26have a pet nearby, go and spend some time with
- 57:28your pet. This can offer a reset when tempers
- 57:32flare. Let's talk about broader client goals.
- 57:41Consider multiple objectives beyond financial
- 57:44recovery. How important is confidentiality? What's
- 57:47the value of speed and closure versus vindication?
- 57:51Are there emotional considerations like an apology
- 57:53or acknowledgement? Are there precedent concerns
- 57:58about future cases? Take the time to understand
- 58:02your client as a whole person or organization,
- 58:05not just as a legal position because the best
- 58:08settlements address human needs. not just legal
- 58:10claims. And leverage the mediator's insight.
- 58:14Ask the mediator's neutral perspective on offers
- 58:17and their assessment of trial prospects. This
- 58:20may provide insight into how the offer compares
- 58:22to similar cases or suggest creative options
- 58:25for bridging gaps. The mediator can sometimes
- 58:28craft solutions that neither party would have
- 58:31proposed themselves, but that both parties can
- 58:34accept because it comes from a neutral source.
- 58:37If you get to a stalemate, consider asking for
- 58:40a mediator proposal. So your key takeaway from
- 58:44evaluating settlement offers is look beyond the
- 58:46dollars, evaluate offers against your client's
- 58:50broader goal and realistic trials prospects,
- 58:53not just the monetary amount. All right, our
- 58:58key takeaways. Choose your mediator wisely considering
- 59:02neutrality, subject matter expertise, experience
- 59:06in complex cases, and style match. Identify your
- 59:10case's strengths and weaknesses honestly to negotiate
- 59:13strategically. Develop a range of settlement
- 59:17options, including creative non -monetary terms.
- 59:21Stay calm and curious when tensions flare, ask
- 59:24W questions to understand underlying interests.
- 59:28Learn through joint sessions when appropriate
- 59:30to gather intelligence and preview trial dynamics.
- 59:34Evaluate settlement offers carefully. comparing
- 59:37them to realistic trial prospects and your clients
- 59:40broader goals. Mediation gives you the opportunity
- 59:46to shape the outcome rather than leaving it in
- 59:50the hands of a judge or a jury. My information
- 59:56is attached on this slide. I hope you enjoyed
- 1:00:00hearing from me and feel free to reach out if
- 1:00:03I can be of assistance in any of your cases and
- 1:00:09I want to thank you for your intention and engagement
- 1:00:12and a big thank you to the Beverly Hills Bar
- 1:00:15Association for this opportunity to connect with
- 1:00:18all of you. I appreciate the opportunity to share
- 1:00:20these insights with you and hope the circle method
- 1:00:23will help you approach your next mediation more
- 1:00:25strategically. I invite you to connect with me
- 1:00:28when you need a mediator and I'm happy to discuss
- 1:00:31any specific challenges you may be facing. And
- 1:00:34now I'm happy to take questions. And I think
- 1:00:37I see a few. Oh, thank you. Thank you, Lan. I
- 1:00:43appreciate that. Oh, can I review the method
- 1:00:47to ensure neutrality? Absolutely. Let me try
- 1:00:54to go back to choosing our mediator wisely. So
- 1:01:01these are the four factors that we discussed
- 1:01:03with neutrality, making sure that the mediator
- 1:01:06doesn't have any stake in the outcome, that they
- 1:01:09have no predetermined opinions about the case,
- 1:01:12that they have no favoritism toward any party,
- 1:01:14and that you carefully vet them with targeted
- 1:01:17questions. So my advice is when you're considering
- 1:01:20a mediator that you haven't used before, set
- 1:01:23up a meeting with them. I regularly have meetings
- 1:01:26with potential new clients and I'm happy to answer
- 1:01:30any questions. And often it's the mediator's
- 1:01:32reaction that's just as important as their answer.
- 1:01:35If they get defensive about a question, then
- 1:01:39that's potentially something for you to think
- 1:01:41about. But it's important to ensure that your
- 1:01:44mediator is neutral in this process. It's one
- 1:01:47of the key factors for you to consider. OK. I
- 1:01:56don't see any more questions. And it looks like
- 1:01:59our time is up. So again, I want to thank you
- 1:02:01all so much. I really appreciate your time today.
- 1:02:05It was an absolute pleasure. And I hope that
- 1:02:08you learned some helpful tips for unlocking success
- 1:02:11in your next complex case mediation using the
- 1:02:14circle method. Thank you very much. Have a great
- 1:02:17rest of your day.