Latest / Jewish History Uncensored / 25 | Rabbinic Letters
Transcript
- 0:06Speaker 1: Welcome to Jewish History Uncensored with Mark Shapiro. This is
- 0:09Speaker 1: season sixteenth, episode twenty five.
- 0:30Speaker 2: This is the two hundred and fiftieth class, and it
- 0:33Speaker 2: happens to be the twenty fifth class as well, twenty
- 0:35Speaker 2: fifth class of this series. Okay, just a few things
- 0:40Speaker 2: before we begin. Remember I mentioned that my sack said
- 0:44Speaker 2: to me, I should write for the Wall Street Journal,
- 0:46Speaker 2: and I said, well, that's for you know, it's not
- 0:49Speaker 2: my thing, mayor Salvation, that's his thing to do. And
- 0:53Speaker 2: he has written and this week, those who get the
- 0:55Speaker 2: Journal Friday, November thirteenth, mayor salientas can learn from word Sacks.
- 1:03Speaker 2: So I had no idea that that was going to
- 1:05Speaker 2: come out, but it's just it's the very point I made,
- 1:08Speaker 2: and especially I was almost a prophet when I said
- 1:11Speaker 2: that Salivachik has succeeded succeeded Sachs in terms of he
- 1:15Speaker 2: followed in his footsteps, and uh, here you go. One
- 1:20Speaker 2: of you emailed me, and I want to get a
- 1:24Speaker 2: picture here for a second. So one of you emailed
- 1:29Speaker 2: me that he asked me a question about Aton Hankin.
- 1:34Speaker 2: There's Hanken unfortunately murdered and his wife and I gave
- 1:39Speaker 2: this person the information. But I have to point out
- 1:42Speaker 2: the name is not aton Ah. Now this name Aton,
- 1:48Speaker 2: by the way, it's It's mentioned a number of times
- 1:50Speaker 2: in Tanah Ethan. That's where the name Ethan comes from.
- 1:54Speaker 2: It mentions the wise people in the Book of Kings
- 1:57Speaker 2: It comparing Schuman. It mentions one of the wise people Ethan,
- 2:03Speaker 2: the Ezraheiit and also Aton has mentioned other places as well. Furthermore,
- 2:08Speaker 2: if you were called the the tamauld understands the word
- 2:12Speaker 2: aton to refer to Avraham. We even say it in
- 2:16Speaker 2: Young Kipper, don't we uskanas Asan and the rumbam here?
- 2:22Speaker 2: Where's the rumbumb? I found it here? In what peric
- 2:27Speaker 2: is this? Hold on? Hold on? Was I gonna tell you?
- 2:29Speaker 2: Periclus avodazara pere Gimmo in describing Avraham's coming to knowledge
- 2:36Speaker 2: of God Kavon sh Enigma ason Zen after this mighty
- 2:42Speaker 2: man was weaned, and that's Uh refers to Avraham. And
- 2:47Speaker 2: the word aton. Also Asan also appears in other places.
- 2:50Speaker 2: But Hankin's name is Ah A few tough men a tom.
- 2:56Speaker 2: So where does that come from? Well, if you look in,
- 3:00Speaker 2: I found it here to hear him. Yeah, nineteen four
- 3:05Speaker 2: where it says ad no, no, no sorry fourteen Yeah,
- 3:12Speaker 2: it's a famous chapter killer. We all know this one.
- 3:15Speaker 2: Am I'm a supperrom Kovoto made magiakia. At the end
- 3:18Speaker 2: it says, al u shluzi, so hold on, he close up.
- 3:23Speaker 2: It says, I'll use your shluz that they may not
- 3:26Speaker 2: have dominion over me as a sum, then I shall
- 3:31Speaker 2: be faultless. That's the translation. If you look in Rashi,
- 3:34Speaker 2: Rashi explains what is a sam or Tom? Yeah? Tell
- 3:38Speaker 2: me so faultless. I don't know. Maybe David Eisen is
- 3:42Speaker 2: with us, can tell us if there's other people in
- 3:44Speaker 2: Israel who have the name a Tom. I don't know.
- 3:48Speaker 2: He's the only one, and I knew him personally through emails,
- 3:52Speaker 2: But he's the only one I've ever come across with
- 3:55Speaker 2: the first name. I know that there's some last names
- 3:57Speaker 2: I believe fightn right, but he's the only one I know.
- 4:01Speaker 2: So the name is a Tom, not a Ton. And
- 4:04Speaker 2: I don't know, like I said, if any other Israelis
- 4:07Speaker 2: have that name. Last week I mentioned we're talking about
- 4:14Speaker 2: Revdovid Feinstein, and I mentioned this new book that came
- 4:17Speaker 2: out Yeshiva days Learning on the Lower East Side by
- 4:19Speaker 2: Jonathan Byarn, which is his experience as a cultural anthropologist
- 4:25Speaker 2: of being in learning on MTJ on the Lower east Side,
- 4:30Speaker 2: and the publisher writes an intimate and moving portrait of
- 4:34Speaker 2: daily life in New York's oldest institution of traditional rabbinic learning.
- 4:38Speaker 2: And I commented that it's not the oldest, obviously it's not.
- 4:41Speaker 2: Youzhnan goes back to the nineteenth century. And then I
- 4:45Speaker 2: mentioned Arvadas. Really, I could have also mentioned hein Berlin.
- 4:49Speaker 2: Heim Berlin was established in nineteen oh four, and then
- 4:52Speaker 2: a few years later when Rafie Berlin died, he was
- 4:55Speaker 2: living in Jerusalem. Before that he'd been in Revn Moscow.
- 4:58Speaker 2: He was a son of the Missive. They changed the name.
- 5:01Speaker 2: But I also I said Carravadas Terravdash. When was Tarvados founded? Well, interestingly,
- 5:11Speaker 2: if hold on, let me stop sharing for a second,
- 5:14Speaker 2: show you the big book. If you look at the
- 5:16Speaker 2: big book here instantly, if you're seeing all lots of
- 5:20Speaker 2: people's screens, you can change it so you just see
- 5:23Speaker 2: the speaker, if that's what or if you prefer you
- 5:25Speaker 2: can watch everyone. Those who don't know you go to
- 5:27Speaker 2: the upper right hand corner. So here you have America'siva
- 5:32Speaker 2: Beautiful book, and it says right here you can see
- 5:35Speaker 2: it nineteen nineteen twenty nineteen. Say it there, nineteen nineteen
- 5:41Speaker 2: to twenty nineteen. Teff is iron tent, tough shin I
- 5:48Speaker 2: in tent. However, if you look at the inside of
- 5:51Speaker 2: the book, you see it's not nineteen nineteen. It's actually
- 5:53Speaker 2: October of nineteen eighteen. So it's the Jewish year of Tumphrey.
- 6:01Speaker 2: I don't know why. Yeah, but it's a falsehood. It's
- 6:03Speaker 2: not nineteen nineteen any event. MPTJ. So after I said that,
- 6:09Speaker 2: I wanted to be one hundred percent sure because these
- 6:10Speaker 2: ashivas often, you know, they have predecessors. The best I
- 6:14Speaker 2: could find is online that MTJ is founded in the
- 6:20Speaker 2: nineteen uh oh seven. But it's a talmatoa, so that's
- 6:24Speaker 2: not a yeshiv. That's a talmotoa. I'm not sure when
- 6:27Speaker 2: it became a day school and even a high school.
- 6:31Speaker 2: There's Wikipedia gives a date, but I have another source
- 6:34Speaker 2: that gives a different date. But I don't think that
- 6:37Speaker 2: Talma Tora qualifies as a yeshiva. So we still have
- 6:42Speaker 2: to say. I think that Urvadus and obviously Heimberlin and
- 6:48Speaker 2: hundred s. There's a hunt actually joined together. It's Higen,
- 6:52Speaker 2: which was a predecessor that was the earliest one. One
- 6:58Speaker 2: more thing I want to show you, oh two more.
- 7:01Speaker 2: I we spoke last week about that very interesting case
- 7:05Speaker 2: of someone he has the donkey milk and his father
- 7:11Speaker 2: has to drink this to save his life, and he
- 7:13Speaker 2: won't unless the sun drinks it. And I told you
- 7:15Speaker 2: about the respond Therabbi Melo Day from Hong Kong. He
- 7:19Speaker 2: cites this The Preates Him, which is the Torah journal
- 7:23Speaker 2: that came out of the Yeshiva in Amsterdam where the
- 7:25Speaker 2: rough says you can't do it now. I over shambas,
- 7:28Speaker 2: I looked more carefully, actually went back to the original response,
- 7:31Speaker 2: and we have the dying who's listening with us. He
- 7:34Speaker 2: also examined it, and he spoke to people in his
- 7:36Speaker 2: show in Brooklyn and he says, everyone disagrees with this,
- 7:41Speaker 2: and everyone assumes that you would be able to drink
- 7:43Speaker 2: the donkey's milk if that's what you can do to
- 7:45Speaker 2: get your father to drink it and save his life.
- 7:49Speaker 2: Interestingly enough, if you look in the original the Preates
- 7:54Speaker 2: High in everything I told you is correct. There's one
- 7:57Speaker 2: extra point, and what he says would apply in our
- 7:59Speaker 2: society in his opinion that if the person wouldn't drink
- 8:02Speaker 2: the milk, unless you would drink it to show that
- 8:05Speaker 2: it's not kosher, you can't drink it. However, he says
- 8:08Speaker 2: something else which is applicable to Amsterdam from two undred
- 8:11Speaker 2: years ago. He's which Robamel Dad didn't quote, so it's
- 8:14Speaker 2: good I went back. He says that if the father
- 8:16Speaker 2: refuses to drink the donkey milk, you have to force
- 8:19Speaker 2: him kofinos, so you force him to drink the donkey milk,
- 8:24Speaker 2: so that he says, first you have to try to
- 8:28Speaker 2: convince him, but if he doesn't listen, then you force them.
- 8:35Speaker 2: So if you're in a situation where you can't force him.
- 8:37Speaker 2: In America you can't force someone, then his position is
- 8:40Speaker 2: you can drink it. And Eli Turko sends me that
- 8:45Speaker 2: Rabbi Zuberstein has a number of questions dealing with suicide,
- 8:50Speaker 2: and he always assumes that you can't. We don't listen
- 8:53Speaker 2: to them. If a wife threatens to him as suicide,
- 8:55Speaker 2: if they don't allow an abortion, we don't listen. So
- 8:57Speaker 2: this would appear to be a big dispute between their
- 9:00Speaker 2: abby and the last thing I want to do before
- 9:02Speaker 2: we begin this takes me back a few weeks. Remember
- 9:08Speaker 2: we spoke about the issue of could you drive, could
- 9:10Speaker 2: you invite someone to your to your house for a
- 9:12Speaker 2: shavis and meal? And or is it leaf Naiva placing
- 9:15Speaker 2: a stumbling block? And I mentioned the dispute and have
- 9:18Speaker 2: the Mosha Stembach's position that in opposition to Ramosha that
- 9:23Speaker 2: since you're trying to do a positive thing, bring the
- 9:26Speaker 2: person close to Judaism. There's never an issue of leaf Niver.
- 9:29Speaker 2: You can do all these things. What we've seen, I've become,
- 9:33Speaker 2: it's become apparent to me in recent times is there's
- 9:36Speaker 2: been enormous changes in the Kadi world. What's happened in
- 9:40Speaker 2: the Hiaidi world is that there's a huge well maybe
- 9:43Speaker 2: huge as a not the right word. There's a large
- 9:45Speaker 2: population of Karadi young people that are leaving Karadi Judaism,
- 9:50Speaker 2: often leaving Orthodoxy completely. It used to be if you
- 9:54Speaker 2: had a kid who is non religious in your house,
- 9:56Speaker 2: you would they would throw them out literally. I one
- 9:59Speaker 2: of the emotion events that took place in Toronto about
- 10:02Speaker 2: ten years ago, I was there speaking. It was one
- 10:05Speaker 2: of the big events where they have like four speakers.
- 10:07Speaker 2: They have this big thing, and there was a guy
- 10:09Speaker 2: there that looked very unusual. For one, he had a tattoo,
- 10:14Speaker 2: not the sort of thing usually, So I'm starting speaking
- 10:17Speaker 2: to him. He drove all the way up from Rochester.
- 10:19Speaker 2: I'm not going to mention his last name, but anyone
- 10:21Speaker 2: who knows the Yeshiva world will know the name. He's
- 10:23Speaker 2: the son of a leading rabbi and liquid. And he
- 10:26Speaker 2: told me his whole story and he would listen. He
- 10:29Speaker 2: might be listening now he's been nigs, but he was
- 10:32Speaker 2: listening to the tower in motions talks and he wanted
- 10:35Speaker 2: to come. Hear me there, and we spoke and he
- 10:38Speaker 2: told me his whole story. And then he told me
- 10:40Speaker 2: that his mother doesn't let him in the house. And
- 10:42Speaker 2: I said to him, I was totally frank. I said, well,
- 10:44Speaker 2: you know, look, you have a tattoo and it's not
- 10:47Speaker 2: the but okay, So we had a whole story. Now
- 10:49Speaker 2: fast forward, this is probably more than ten years. You
- 10:52Speaker 2: have a whole population. I'm want to show you a
- 10:54Speaker 2: couple of things here. You have a whole population well
- 10:59Speaker 2: all over Lakewood. Also, there's even a there's a there's
- 11:04Speaker 2: a group, I mean an organization. It's like NCSY for
- 11:07Speaker 2: these guys. Minyon Shallan just for the off the Dera.
- 11:12Speaker 2: And when I say off the Dera, I mean druggies,
- 11:15Speaker 2: all sorts of everything from druggies or just the people
- 11:17Speaker 2: who want to wear jeans. All that it was founded.
- 11:20Speaker 2: We spoke at Rabaia Body the number of times. This
- 11:23Speaker 2: is his son, Rabeah him a body and he is
- 11:26Speaker 2: the he runs this organization. It's a wonderful organization. But
- 11:29Speaker 2: you can go online and you can see, uh, you
- 11:32Speaker 2: can see the videos. So like, uh, let me just
- 11:34Speaker 2: get you to say, they take the kids on a trip.
- 11:36Speaker 2: You look at the kids. You see these kids are
- 11:39Speaker 2: far from from Lakewood. And if you go to their website,
- 11:44Speaker 2: they describe where it came from.
- 11:47Speaker 3: Uh.
- 11:47Speaker 2: Minyon Shallana was born in response to Lakewood's growing community
- 11:50Speaker 2: of disenchanted and troubled teenagers. After dropping out of school,
- 11:53Speaker 2: many would deteriorate socially, emotionally and spiritually, engaging in negative
- 11:57Speaker 2: behaviors such as systems, substance of use, from scurity and crime,
- 12:01Speaker 2: juvenile attention, et cetera, et cetera. And you can read
- 12:05Speaker 2: all about it. Can go online, watch the videos. There's
- 12:07Speaker 2: a picture. You even have a video here of a guy.
- 12:10Speaker 2: I couldn't believe that men and Chawannaho even put it
- 12:12Speaker 2: on their website. I don't think it's cushy will put
- 12:15Speaker 2: something like this on their website. He does a rap
- 12:17Speaker 2: so explaining how it began the only place do you
- 12:36Speaker 2: want to? Okay, So obviously it's uh, things are changing
- 12:42Speaker 2: in the Farraidi world. So now there's a new phenomenon.
- 12:46Speaker 2: I'm gonna show you some things.
- 12:47Speaker 4: Now.
- 12:47Speaker 2: I'm glad you're sitting down because you're gonna find this,
- 12:49Speaker 2: I think astounding what they are now saying the leadership
- 12:53Speaker 2: in the Haadi world. And it goes back to this idea. Well,
- 12:57Speaker 2: let me first show it to you. And they're not
- 12:59Speaker 2: explaining you why. It's really into the Halati principle we
- 13:01Speaker 2: spoke about. Well, first of the example here is Rabbi
- 13:06Speaker 2: Gershon Adelstein. Rabih Adelstein is together for him, Kanievski is
- 13:11Speaker 2: the He's ahead upon a vision. He's the leader of
- 13:14Speaker 2: the mainstream Lithuanian community. And I'm gonna I'll just play
- 13:18Speaker 2: it for you. Those who read Hebrew are understand Yiddish
- 13:20Speaker 2: and then I'll say what he says and you'll be astounded.
- 13:23Speaker 2: But then you won't. This is nothing compared to what
- 13:26Speaker 2: I'm gonna play you after this. It's all this this,
- 13:28Speaker 2: this this guy named Fishoff who's very interested in this
- 13:32Speaker 2: kids off the Derrek, and he tried to create a
- 13:35Speaker 2: new approach in the Karadi world. So I went through Beatolstein.
- 13:38Speaker 2: I can't you can get the whole transcript of what
- 13:40Speaker 2: he says, but I'll just play you one couple of
- 13:42Speaker 2: things here.
- 13:44Speaker 5: I mentioned most is about bridle of the noise.
- 13:49Speaker 2: Okay, so he's I'll explain as we go. Well, he
- 13:51Speaker 2: was talking about all the things that about Anterstein was saying,
- 13:53Speaker 2: you can never throw a kid out if he's not
- 13:55Speaker 2: sel Machabs doesn't worry, y' I'm not that you always
- 13:57Speaker 2: have to keep the kids. And he says urgent rations
- 14:00Speaker 2: on the previous generations. So then he says, well, let's
- 14:02Speaker 2: say your son brings his girlfriend home. Can you imagine
- 14:06Speaker 2: what this means in the Haredi house? And I talk
- 14:08Speaker 2: to sleep over and so they want their own room
- 14:12Speaker 2: in the Haredie the house? Are you allowed to What
- 14:15Speaker 2: should you do? Now?
- 14:16Speaker 3: Uh?
- 14:17Speaker 2: Most people say, well, of course you don't put them
- 14:19Speaker 2: in the room together. How could you do that even
- 14:21Speaker 2: in a modern Orthodox But look what Ra says, he
- 14:28Speaker 2: came home as I had in the ice. Rabagho says, no,
- 14:34Speaker 2: they you can get him in the room. And he says, well,
- 14:36Speaker 2: what about they're in your house the sin et cetera.
- 14:39Speaker 2: Look what he says mentioned okay, Soos says, it goes
- 14:58Speaker 2: so far as you even give the son and his
- 15:01Speaker 2: girlfriend a room in the house. Now that isn't gonna,
- 15:05Speaker 2: you know, show you that there's been an enormous change,
- 15:07Speaker 2: and it's obviously a response to what's going on in
- 15:10Speaker 2: the Fadi world. I want to now show you and
- 15:12Speaker 2: this is an English and wine with this Rabbi Moshah
- 15:16Speaker 2: hill Hirst, who's the rosav of Sobotka. He actually comes
- 15:19Speaker 2: from America. He was it from wake Wood. He married
- 15:21Speaker 2: into the family. Listen to what he says, and all
- 15:25Speaker 2: I can say is I'm astounded.
- 15:27Speaker 5: Nothing happens to them, and then they feel like I
- 15:30Speaker 5: I'm homeless. I'm an orphan. Everybody looked down at me
- 15:33Speaker 5: and I can't breathe. And that's why they do drugs.
- 15:36Speaker 5: We say, I understand, you're not from I respect you
- 15:40Speaker 5: one hundred percent, be not from You're still my child.
- 15:43Speaker 5: We're going shopping. I'm buying you. So this is one
- 15:46Speaker 5: of the silence today is the vershi if you have
- 15:48Speaker 5: a girl and you don't buy the clothing that she wants,
- 15:50Speaker 5: so you're not a parent, So can you buy her
- 15:53Speaker 5: and not see as the good clothing that she wants
- 15:54Speaker 5: today that we should be that she's my daughter.
- 16:01Speaker 2: So first he says, you could buy, but you haven't
- 16:04Speaker 2: seen anything yet.
- 16:09Speaker 5: And then and an iPhone, everything, most of everything, anything
- 16:12Speaker 5: which can bring them back. That's the idea. It's not
- 16:17Speaker 5: either because they would buy that that would be and
- 16:20Speaker 5: that's not answer either.
- 16:21Speaker 4: But they said even if, of course see because they
- 16:25Speaker 4: begin a mixtual, but it's not a cheal is built
- 16:27Speaker 4: me bringing them back?
- 16:29Speaker 5: Since we're doing it to bring them back, that's the
- 16:31Speaker 5: that's the head.
- 16:32Speaker 4: If you have to bring him back, there's no obviously
- 16:35Speaker 4: catch take me away to visual. The medicine is is
- 16:41Speaker 4: counterintuitively and that's what grows people are Okay, you have
- 16:48Speaker 4: you had a sort of advisor. Once happened that they
- 16:51Speaker 4: went to a bowl game. Dater said, my money so
- 16:58Speaker 4: what I was told, I'm excuse that she was okay
- 17:00Speaker 4: that you gave them money to buy it wasn't a
- 17:02Speaker 4: problem at all. Buy whatever she wants without the court professionally,
- 17:06Speaker 4: just in order to make their feel comfortable.
- 17:08Speaker 5: Is that okay? If it tough seems to get it back,
- 17:11Speaker 5: probably it's okay. That's the point, the point of it
- 17:15Speaker 5: all the creator, Yeah, sure to get it that back
- 17:19Speaker 5: to stay buying it itself.
- 17:23Speaker 4: I don't see it.
- 17:24Speaker 2: That's the me.
- 17:26Speaker 5: It's in other words, anything anything else, create a cashier
- 17:31Speaker 5: with things in that and makes them comfortable that all
- 17:33Speaker 5: of a sudden becomes beautiful.
- 17:35Speaker 4: That really is not a.
- 17:35Speaker 2: Mixture, okay. He says that if I find astounding, not
- 17:43Speaker 2: only obviously you can give it for a kid the money,
- 17:44Speaker 2: the mo kid can buy whatever they want, but you
- 17:46Speaker 2: can buy the hot It's like, can you imagine you're
- 17:49Speaker 2: at a ball game and you're you're with your nephew
- 17:52Speaker 2: or your son, your daughter, they're not religious anymore, and
- 17:55Speaker 2: they want a hot dog and you go buy the
- 17:56Speaker 2: non coasure hot dog for them. I find that asound,
- 18:00Speaker 2: and I can't imagine other postgame agreeing with that. But
- 18:04Speaker 2: it just see how far it's gone because he's saying
- 18:07Speaker 2: that you show the kid that you love the kid
- 18:09Speaker 2: and you're not judging the kid, and you can bring
- 18:11Speaker 2: them closer. If a modern Orthodox or Abbi would have
- 18:14Speaker 2: said that you can buy a non cloture hot oil
- 18:16Speaker 2: for your irreligious hitting a ballgame, they would put him
- 18:19Speaker 2: in sarem and say that this is this is far
- 18:22Speaker 2: from Orthodoxy. So but and it all goes back to
- 18:26Speaker 2: the principle we spoke about that it's not leaf naiva
- 18:30Speaker 2: because you intend it's intended to bring them closer. So
- 18:35Speaker 2: I just find out a basing. Okay, everyone, we are
- 18:38Speaker 2: now picking up where we left both. We are in
- 18:45Speaker 2: Simon Saudi Zion, page two sixteen. And if you recall
- 18:51Speaker 2: we were dealing with, well, let me first summarize it
- 18:54Speaker 2: again because this letter we're looking at from Rafshoma Avinaire
- 18:57Speaker 2: had a great influence on me, maybe mistaken read I.
- 19:01Speaker 3: I I.
- 19:03Speaker 2: Was writing an article and doing research on the Rambam's
- 19:06Speaker 2: approach to superstition, demons on the like, and I was
- 19:09Speaker 2: convinced that there is a passage in the in his
- 19:13Speaker 2: commentary in the missiona in Masasa Vota Zaara, chapter four,
- 19:17Speaker 2: Mission desion in which he explicitly denies the existence of demons.
- 19:21Speaker 2: The problem is that none of the people who wrote
- 19:23Speaker 2: about the Rambam cite this passage. Even Rabbi Kafa, the
- 19:27Speaker 2: Great Rabbi Kafa, doesn't cite this as being a proof
- 19:32Speaker 2: that the Rambam deny demons. They cite other passages and things.
- 19:36Speaker 2: And I wrote to Rabba Avin their because it's for
- 19:41Speaker 2: you to cook. Despite what seems to be a parent
- 19:43Speaker 2: he wanted to argue that the Ramam really did believe
- 19:46Speaker 2: the demons. I said, what about this passage and a voterasara?
- 19:48Speaker 2: And he wrote back to me and this is the
- 19:50Speaker 2: first part of the tchuva, that this is not referring
- 19:53Speaker 2: to The language is ambiguous, but he said, it's not
- 19:55Speaker 2: referring to the existence of demons. It's referring to having
- 19:59Speaker 2: a conc connect demons, asking them for things, so some
- 20:02Speaker 2: involvement with them. That's what he said refers to and
- 20:07Speaker 2: uh and that's the letter. And based on that, I
- 20:12Speaker 2: wrote an article on the the Rambam and superstition, and
- 20:16Speaker 2: I cited this opinion that the admission on a voter
- 20:20Speaker 2: azara doesn't it's not really denial of these, this is
- 20:22Speaker 2: the demons. It's only a denial that you can you know,
- 20:26Speaker 2: you can use demons, you can ask them things, et cetera.
- 20:29Speaker 2: No one corrected me at all. No one said a word.
- 20:32Speaker 2: All the people and they said, said, KFA doesn't mention
- 20:34Speaker 2: this as a site. It's ambiguous. So whether he what
- 20:37Speaker 2: it means, if it means demons per se or demons
- 20:40Speaker 2: to use them for a key schuff and things like that.
- 20:43Speaker 2: And then I published a book and uh, no one
- 20:46Speaker 2: makes a comment, No one corrects me. Big scholars looked
- 20:49Speaker 2: at it, including Gerald Blitstein Hearn who just passed away.
- 20:54Speaker 2: He wrote a review of the book. Reversing said that
- 20:57Speaker 2: Gerald Blitstein was the Roughs tops student. I mean Reviron
- 21:02Speaker 2: couldn't say about himself. I think Jerry Woodston would say
- 21:05Speaker 2: there Revarron was the top student, so he's the second
- 21:07Speaker 2: top student. He didn't make No one made a comment,
- 21:10Speaker 2: so I thought it was obvious it was correct. That
- 21:14Speaker 2: doesn't mean that reb Steed, who are correct of the Rumbum,
- 21:17Speaker 2: obviously denied demons. But this passage can't be seen. And
- 21:20Speaker 2: in the book, I say the Rumbum nowhere explicitly denies demons,
- 21:24Speaker 2: and then and then something. A new edition of the
- 21:31Speaker 2: Rumbum's Uh commentary on the Mishnah came out of Malaya Dumin,
- 21:37Speaker 2: the Great Yeshiva of Malaya Dumin and Uh by where
- 21:42Speaker 2: is he?
- 21:43Speaker 1: Uh?
- 21:45Speaker 2: Translated by this man genius of geniuses, He'll be upset
- 21:50Speaker 2: if I said that, So don't tell them. If any
- 21:52Speaker 2: of you know him, I've been corresponding with him for
- 21:55Speaker 2: many years, Drawer Fixer. He's an award winning physicist in
- 21:59Speaker 2: Israelim in the scientific world. They know him for physics. Well,
- 22:07Speaker 2: and behold if for all these us of corresponding with them.
- 22:09Speaker 2: Three years ago, two and a half years ago, I'm
- 22:13Speaker 2: in Beijing, I go Friday night to Kabban, I sit
- 22:15Speaker 2: down lo and behold who's sitting right next to me?
- 22:17Speaker 2: Jord Fixler. Because he runs his whole program with China,
- 22:21Speaker 2: and the Chinese students come to Barriolan to study, he
- 22:24Speaker 2: goes there. Well, he's also a musmach, he's a Rabbi,
- 22:26Speaker 2: he's Tom and Muffak of Rmhamer Benovich. He's the one
- 22:29Speaker 2: who's explained many of his views. And he's an Ashkenazi.
- 22:32Speaker 2: But he told himself Arabic and he has begun to translate,
- 22:37Speaker 2: in addition to many many Torror articles, translate a new
- 22:41Speaker 2: works of the rambamb from Arabic. So I'm holding in
- 22:44Speaker 2: my hands here from two thousand and two his commentary
- 22:47Speaker 2: and A Voters are retranslated and based on this and
- 22:50Speaker 2: the way he wrote it, I wrote to fix Sler
- 22:52Speaker 2: just to clarify this matter, and Fixler, who was also
- 22:55Speaker 2: an expert in the Arabic, says, there's no question at
- 22:57Speaker 2: all that Masakos Asari Rama's commentary chapter four seven is
- 23:04Speaker 2: a denial of demons, not just as I was led
- 23:10Speaker 2: to believe demons. That's together with Tischeff and Nihos and
- 23:15Speaker 2: all these sorts of things. So you can all investigate
- 23:18Speaker 2: it further, but for now I'm going with Professor Rabbi
- 23:23Speaker 2: doctor Fixler that the Ramam does explicitly deny demons in
- 23:28Speaker 2: his commentary on in the Mission, but I'm not one
- 23:31Speaker 2: hundred percent sure.
- 23:32Speaker 1: Now.
- 23:34Speaker 2: The second part of my letter here to Revavinair was
- 23:38Speaker 2: I had wrote to Revavinaer because during the withdrawal from
- 23:41Speaker 2: Gaza we saw some interesting things. It broke down in
- 23:44Speaker 2: the right wing road to scientists world between what they
- 23:46Speaker 2: call the CoV which Revalvin Air is part of, and
- 23:49Speaker 2: the non CoV. What do you do that is do
- 23:53Speaker 2: you protest? Do you do you fight the soldiers who
- 23:56Speaker 2: are dragging you away? Or do you uh the soldiers
- 24:00Speaker 2: and say, we understand you have no choice in what
- 24:03Speaker 2: you're doing. We're leaving. Uh it's unfortunate, but we're not
- 24:07Speaker 2: going to go up against the uh the soldiers. Now
- 24:11Speaker 2: the the CoV who view there those that group who
- 24:15Speaker 2: view really the army is how we and uh the
- 24:19Speaker 2: Mamacht is ho we the whole thing. Uh, They're they're
- 24:25Speaker 2: they're not like the marcause that's why Marcross Arrov she
- 24:28Speaker 2: was squit Merricross Arrov is the mainstream, I guess you
- 24:31Speaker 2: would say, or I don't know if it's mainstream. It's
- 24:34Speaker 2: the old fashioned man from the markas Arrov perspective. If
- 24:37Speaker 2: the government is forcing uh, their rooting of settlements, then
- 24:40Speaker 2: this is not a hole we government. This is a government.
- 24:42Speaker 2: We need to protest, have them drag us out, but
- 24:45Speaker 2: they they refuse to do that. In the other segment,
- 24:47Speaker 2: so I wrote to Revolving there for some explanation on this,
- 24:51Speaker 2: because your cook was very firm in opposing all withdrawals,
- 24:56Speaker 2: and he says, he replies to me, and this is
- 24:58Speaker 2: really a good understanding of the approach of what they
- 25:02Speaker 2: call the CoV that that segment of the right wing
- 25:06Speaker 2: religious scientist world, that the government can really do no
- 25:10Speaker 2: wrong in an ultimate sense. In that that you saw
- 25:15Speaker 2: by the way you saw among some of these right
- 25:18Speaker 2: wing religious Zionists after the expulsion from Gaza, with the withdrawal,
- 25:22Speaker 2: some of them really were no longer even interested in Zionism.
- 25:25Speaker 2: What was important to that Reftal was one of them.
- 25:28Speaker 2: It was interesting, it really was a focus on the
- 25:30Speaker 2: land and that they had really lost all all respect
- 25:37Speaker 2: for the government as a as a force, you know,
- 25:40Speaker 2: as a as a representative of the kingship of Israel.
- 25:45Speaker 2: Marcas didn't go that far, but they they had no
- 25:48Speaker 2: difficulty speaking very strongly and encouraging protests et cetera. For
- 25:53Speaker 2: Revoellows that would see you who'd have taught us that
- 25:57Speaker 2: we have to have Nephish uh give ourselves for Ersi
- 26:01Speaker 2: Strow and everyone in Israel, and every person in the
- 26:04Speaker 2: army has to do what he can or he she
- 26:07Speaker 2: also to prevent any withdrawal from territories. He also said
- 26:11Speaker 2: and this was my question that any order to uproot
- 26:14Speaker 2: a settlement is in illegal order. But Taylor and we
- 26:18Speaker 2: will tell it that has no effect. So my question was,
- 26:23Speaker 2: then why did you Revolvin Air went down there and
- 26:26Speaker 2: told them we should all, you know, kiss the soldiers
- 26:28Speaker 2: as we leave, but don't protest, et cetera. Says, in
- 26:33Speaker 2: these matters we need to distinguish within halaja and hajalamasa.
- 26:38Speaker 2: That is, what's the law Jewish law, and what's the
- 26:40Speaker 2: Jewish law in practice? And he writes that uh he
- 26:43Speaker 2: gives an example where in one settlement, uh the uh
- 26:48Speaker 2: not settlement they set up like this illegal uh mini
- 26:51Speaker 2: settlement or see who was there's a famous story. And
- 26:54Speaker 2: they came and they told him that he has to leave,
- 26:56Speaker 2: that they're gonna tear it down there these tents down
- 26:59Speaker 2: hear and see who said, I'm not leaving and even
- 27:02Speaker 2: if you want to bring a gun here, I'm not leaving.
- 27:05Speaker 2: But then when a higher officer came to him and
- 27:07Speaker 2: explain to him that you know, you really can't stay here,
- 27:11Speaker 2: he agreed. And he left the idea being that when
- 27:14Speaker 2: it really is, it really is going to come to
- 27:16Speaker 2: a civil war or fighting or raising a hand against
- 27:19Speaker 2: a soldier for the kav the army is holy, it's
- 27:23Speaker 2: a representative of Mahuk Israel, and it's to raise a
- 27:26Speaker 2: hand to a soldier or policeman to try to withstand
- 27:30Speaker 2: what they're doing. Even passive resistance, that can't be done.
- 27:34Speaker 2: So Rabbae Alfiner says that sort's see who he left
- 27:39Speaker 2: when he was asked. He says, obviously it's it's more
- 27:42Speaker 2: of a crime to force the people to leave than
- 27:46Speaker 2: to agree to leave. But he says, these are the
- 27:49Speaker 2: sorts of questions, and you have to know the situation,
- 27:52Speaker 2: and the basic principle is that no person in Israel
- 27:58Speaker 2: can do anything to assist removing of settlements. Nevertheless, halahalama sah.
- 28:05Speaker 2: Once it's already being done and the government has made
- 28:09Speaker 2: the incorrect, unfortunate decision, I'm saying incorrect, unfortunate from the
- 28:12Speaker 2: standpoint of revolving. There are obviously people on the liberal
- 28:16Speaker 2: Reli designsm of soul, nature or little thing. They have
- 28:19Speaker 2: a different perspective on this, he says. But once the
- 28:21Speaker 2: government has decided to do this mistaken path, then you
- 28:25Speaker 2: have to look at each case on its own, just
- 28:26Speaker 2: like every other Halia. There's many the situation changes, but
- 28:30Speaker 2: the corone the principle stands that it's forbidden to remove
- 28:34Speaker 2: any settlement and everyone must do what they can to
- 28:37Speaker 2: prevent that. The question is what happens when the government
- 28:39Speaker 2: decides to do the wrong thing. And Revaviner's position is
- 28:43Speaker 2: that this is a position of the cob that we're sad,
- 28:47Speaker 2: but we will not stand up and protest against and
- 28:50Speaker 2: we can protest in a square, but when the soldiers come,
- 28:53Speaker 2: we don't raise our hands to them. We don't resist
- 28:56Speaker 2: in any way. And the truth is that you who
- 29:01Speaker 2: he wasn't one hundred percent consistent when it came to
- 29:03Speaker 2: the Sinai and the people went down there to protest
- 29:06Speaker 2: about leaving the Sinai. I was I came shortly after
- 29:10Speaker 2: that to BMT and the Madri Hima BMT were among
- 29:14Speaker 2: the people who snuck into Sinai and the protested. See
- 29:17Speaker 2: who'd have said, though at that time, there's no need
- 29:20Speaker 2: to protest because the people are not with us. You
- 29:23Speaker 2: can't have a protest that the people are not with you.
- 29:25Speaker 2: But he had other times when he said, when it
- 29:27Speaker 2: comes to you, don chomons, because that's really biblical Israel,
- 29:30Speaker 2: the Sinai is not. He said that. He did say
- 29:34Speaker 2: it'll lead to civil war if they tried to give
- 29:37Speaker 2: it back. Now does that mean that there should be
- 29:39Speaker 2: civil wars? He just speaking rhetorically that that's the issue.
- 29:44Speaker 2: And okay, that's number ninety seven. Number ninety eight is
- 29:52Speaker 2: also addressed to revolving there and here. Let me His
- 29:56Speaker 2: answers are just like three words and five words. Question
- 30:00Speaker 2: is of interest. Though he has a book, he has
- 30:03Speaker 2: many books. It comes out with like five years. It's
- 30:05Speaker 2: called Botsanella, and it deals with women's issues, and it's
- 30:11Speaker 2: very conservative with a small thing, even more conservative than
- 30:15Speaker 2: you'll find in parts of the Haredi world. A lot
- 30:17Speaker 2: of people don't realize this that the right wing religious
- 30:20Speaker 2: Zionists are in many ways more conservative on women's issues
- 30:26Speaker 2: in the Haradi world. Even in the Haadi world itself.
- 30:31Speaker 2: It's you'll find different opinions. One part of the Hiadi world,
- 30:35Speaker 2: the more modern part of the Fraida world, makes a
- 30:37Speaker 2: big deal about the fact that there's a Hasienic woman
- 30:39Speaker 2: judge and they But on the other hand, that goes
- 30:42Speaker 2: against the all Haradi philosophy. But in terms of the Rabbins,
- 30:47Speaker 2: very conservative, even more conservative perhaps than the Haredi world.
- 30:51Speaker 2: And you know the women don't they wear these long skirts,
- 30:53Speaker 2: and they don't put wear makeup, and they whenever dream
- 30:55Speaker 2: of wearing a shado, and their rhetoric is basically the
- 30:59Speaker 2: same as the most conservative Karatei circles. So Revolvinir says
- 31:04Speaker 2: on page two twenty six, the majority, the overwhelming majority,
- 31:08Speaker 2: rum shall Godoli forbid women's involvement in voting, with the
- 31:16Speaker 2: exception of Kamabo Dadim A few exceptions, Shaohayuba Madre got
- 31:20Speaker 2: godolioam and they're not to be regarded as Godoli. This
- 31:25Speaker 2: goes back to the old dispute when there were elections
- 31:28Speaker 2: in Palestine for the the Vadelumi, which was the governing
- 31:34Speaker 2: authority of Palestine for the Jewish community, and everyone was
- 31:40Speaker 2: trying to get their votes in because this would determined,
- 31:43Speaker 2: you know, how it's run. And the Orthodox, of course,
- 31:46Speaker 2: we're encouraging it. Roff Cook comes out with a statement
- 31:49Speaker 2: and the Garadi rabbis later also he actually made the
- 31:53Speaker 2: Karadi rabbis even before. But Roff Cook was a big
- 31:56Speaker 2: surprise that women are forbidden to vote. And uh, when
- 32:01Speaker 2: you look back, I mean, it's it's quaint almost to
- 32:03Speaker 2: the waiver of cook. He doesn't argue alockically. He argues
- 32:05Speaker 2: that almost Victorian sentiments that a woman's woman is supposed
- 32:10Speaker 2: to be at the home. She's the the man goes
- 32:13Speaker 2: out and struggles outside, and the woman is at home
- 32:16Speaker 2: making sure Torah values are in the home. And if
- 32:20Speaker 2: the woman, we need to keep the woman from the
- 32:22Speaker 2: rough and tumble of the outside world. And will and behold,
- 32:26Speaker 2: if the women get into of politics and the woman
- 32:28Speaker 2: has an opinion on this and it's different than her husband's,
- 32:31Speaker 2: this will lead to the breakdown of show Bays. You know,
- 32:34Speaker 2: the wife is going to vote for Biden and the
- 32:35Speaker 2: husband's voting for Trump or vice versa. It's going to
- 32:38Speaker 2: break down Sean Bays and all these sorts of the
- 32:41Speaker 2: fact that he doesn't argue he's important because even some
- 32:43Speaker 2: of the followers are of Cooks say that it's not
- 32:46Speaker 2: a how argument. So we'll change with the times. But
- 32:48Speaker 2: in those days, this is not long after the in
- 32:51Speaker 2: America women got the right to vote. I mean in
- 32:53Speaker 2: Switzerland there are cantons that waited decades. So it's really
- 32:58Speaker 2: a period piece when you read it today, it's strange.
- 33:01Speaker 2: Even in a Haredi world, all the women vote today,
- 33:04Speaker 2: everyone votes. What you're going to give up half your
- 33:07Speaker 2: population in terms of voting. But so Revavinir is not
- 33:11Speaker 2: saying that the women should vote, but he's talking like
- 33:13Speaker 2: in some theoretical world, even the messianic world, that really
- 33:16Speaker 2: it would be better if we didn't have voting. And
- 33:17Speaker 2: he goes to forest to say that. Look in my
- 33:21Speaker 2: in my synagogue in West Orange, New Jersey, women didn't
- 33:25Speaker 2: weren't didn't have the right to vote until in the
- 33:30Speaker 2: nineteen eighties they gave them the right to vote. And
- 33:34Speaker 2: I mean, it's very strange, but uh, and I'm sure
- 33:36Speaker 2: there's places still today. But Revaviner says that only a
- 33:40Speaker 2: few rabbis permitted. And he's talking about it at the
- 33:44Speaker 2: beginning when they had the dispute. Today as an emergency measure,
- 33:48Speaker 2: of course, the women have to vote, and he says
- 33:50Speaker 2: they were not God. So I wrote to him, how
- 33:52Speaker 2: could you say this? Ravuziel first started chief Rabbi Veritrol
- 33:58Speaker 2: of the State of Israel. He was one of the
- 34:00Speaker 2: Godoe what about Rew C. Hoffman, what about Reelok of Weinberg?
- 34:05Speaker 2: They have no problem with voting. He has no problem
- 34:08Speaker 2: with voting or being elected. REVUSI all rights. He doesn't
- 34:13Speaker 2: understand this. They said it's not sneels men and women
- 34:16Speaker 2: to be mixing at the in parliament. He says, they
- 34:19Speaker 2: go to the supermarket, they mix. So so I said that,
- 34:24Speaker 2: in my opinion, the way you frame this is pigia
- 34:28Speaker 2: dom that this is really degrading to these great rabbis.
- 34:31Speaker 2: You say that, No, great rabbis, when they had the
- 34:35Speaker 2: discussions of this, said that women should be allowed to vote. Obviously,
- 34:38Speaker 2: I'm talking about Godolie and I could consider solve ah.
- 34:41Speaker 2: I could have said any numbers, but these are the
- 34:42Speaker 2: ones who wrote about it during the disputes. And what
- 34:46Speaker 2: is he write back? And you have to give him
- 34:48Speaker 2: credit for this because a great tom of Hauffem, but
- 34:51Speaker 2: authentic Tomahaffam is not afraid to acknowledge and not embarrassed
- 34:55Speaker 2: to acknowledge when they spoke improperly, he writes. So Dave
- 34:58Speaker 2: Yes says, you are correct. In other words, I misspoken.
- 35:02Speaker 2: I shouldn't ever use that language. And then I write
- 35:07Speaker 2: to him a second thing in the same book. He writes, well,
- 35:12Speaker 2: this is mine was one letter he's speaking and you
- 35:15Speaker 2: find us. Often he speaks about the idea that how
- 35:18Speaker 2: Jews punished and he says in its Lamo bates soar,
- 35:22Speaker 2: we do not have Jews do not have prisons, and
- 35:26Speaker 2: then he so that's often used. People use that as
- 35:29Speaker 2: an argument that the idea that we send people to jail.
- 35:33Speaker 2: It's you know, it doesn't make sense. Jews never send
- 35:36Speaker 2: people to jail. We should follow the Jewish approaches. It's
- 35:40Speaker 2: true that there is in masakasan Hedrin, they speak about
- 35:44Speaker 2: putting someone in that keepo if you lash him and
- 35:48Speaker 2: he still continues to do the crime, or if he
- 35:50Speaker 2: commits a murder, let's say, and you can't convict him,
- 35:52Speaker 2: but you know he did it, but you can't have
- 35:54Speaker 2: convict him with the witnesses. The witnesses maybe you have
- 35:58Speaker 2: ten witnesses, but all of them are passu or something.
- 36:01Speaker 2: It says, you throw them at a keepa and you
- 36:03Speaker 2: feed them certain things, you force feed him and then
- 36:05Speaker 2: that causes his death. That's the way that Hazal were
- 36:09Speaker 2: able to keep order through extra legal means. But that's
- 36:13Speaker 2: not prison. Prison is we keep people for a long term.
- 36:17Speaker 2: But what are the options if you don't have prison,
- 36:20Speaker 2: what are you supposed to do? They didn't, so in Spain,
- 36:22Speaker 2: for instance, if they had prison, they couldn't done some
- 36:24Speaker 2: of the ro barracks stuff they did. They chopped up
- 36:26Speaker 2: people's an, they chopped up people's tongues, and did all
- 36:30Speaker 2: sorts of things that today we regard his torture because
- 36:33Speaker 2: they didn't have prisons. In any event, I write to
- 36:35Speaker 2: him and say, I don't understand this argument of him
- 36:38Speaker 2: that you know, arguing against the idea of prison. I say,
- 36:42Speaker 2: if the government wants to put a prisoner, a violator
- 36:46Speaker 2: in prison, it has authority to do though the taro
- 36:49Speaker 2: grants him the rabbi's great authority to that. Also, it
- 36:52Speaker 2: has the authority to give macOS, blashes and even mesa.
- 36:56Speaker 2: Even the government can put people to death if they want.
- 37:00Speaker 2: It might not be a smarting, might not be a
- 37:01Speaker 2: good thing, but the tar gives them the authority. I said,
- 37:06Speaker 2: you should look at Simhasoff's book. Shud Simhasov the great
- 37:12Speaker 2: Supreme Court justice, but before he was Supreme Court justice,
- 37:15Speaker 2: he was an eloy from Tells and huge tom Hacham.
- 37:18Speaker 2: He has a whole book showing how courts throughout the
- 37:21Speaker 2: generations punished people because when you have an autonomous community,
- 37:27Speaker 2: you have to punish because you have the authority. They
- 37:29Speaker 2: had jails. For instance, I already spoke in previous classes
- 37:33Speaker 2: how the shire Fray frama Cohen from Buddha from pesh
- 37:36Speaker 2: speaks not to you need a mosusa on the jail.
- 37:38Speaker 2: The Jewish community had its own jail in Prague. They
- 37:42Speaker 2: had a jail. We even think that when you go
- 37:45Speaker 2: into the Altinois show. People have been with me. I've
- 37:48Speaker 2: showed them where they have the the little room there
- 37:50Speaker 2: with the bars that that could have been in the
- 37:52Speaker 2: prison where they'd kept people. They could only put a couple,
- 37:55Speaker 2: one or two in a time. But we know Jewish
- 37:57Speaker 2: communities had jails. And I say to him, from your language,
- 38:01Speaker 2: it appears that the idea of having a prison a
- 38:03Speaker 2: jail is against tora. And that's not ain't orna Hong Kong.
- 38:08Speaker 2: That's not correct at all. There is permission for judges
- 38:12Speaker 2: in every generation to do what is correct in their mind.
- 38:16Speaker 2: But that came at all one to uh to fix
- 38:20Speaker 2: the world and protect the population. The rom Bump speaks
- 38:23Speaker 2: about it, Theron speaks about it. The rabbis, the base
- 38:27Speaker 2: didn't have the authority. Even if the Torah doesn't speak
- 38:30Speaker 2: about a prison, well, they have the authority to develop
- 38:35Speaker 2: any system they want, and Jews have and that's in
- 38:37Speaker 2: line with the Jewish tradition that the hope based in
- 38:41Speaker 2: when it has authority, can do what it wants. So,
- 38:44Speaker 2: for instance, in Israel today, if a guy won't give
- 38:46Speaker 2: his wife a get they throw him in jail. And
- 38:50Speaker 2: that usually does the trick. Not always. There was one
- 38:52Speaker 2: guy who for decades it didn't do the trick, but
- 38:54Speaker 2: that does the trick. Really, uh didn't didn't think this
- 38:59Speaker 2: was helpful. He thought we should go back to the room. Bum.
- 39:02Speaker 2: The rerum mom says, for these people don't give their
- 39:04Speaker 2: wife forget the rum has a simple solution. You beat
- 39:07Speaker 2: him until he gives the guests. You can't do that
- 39:09Speaker 2: in America, but you could do that in the Jewish state.
- 39:12Speaker 2: And then the question is the raal Bum asked the
- 39:14Speaker 2: question and answers it, Well, doesn't the gut have to
- 39:15Speaker 2: be given willingly? When you beat him, then he's willingly
- 39:18Speaker 2: because he wants to give it. Now, the rob mom says,
- 39:22Speaker 2: because really, every Jew wants to deep down wants to
- 39:25Speaker 2: do the right thing. But at the end of the day,
- 39:26Speaker 2: you're making him see the light. And what is real
- 39:30Speaker 2: gonna say to my strong criticism of him, a criticism
- 39:33Speaker 2: that you often hear people people all they know is
- 39:36Speaker 2: the tomorrow and the hummish, and they know that you
- 39:38Speaker 2: if someone if there's not two male witnesses who warned
- 39:41Speaker 2: someone at a time, you can't punish them, which means
- 39:43Speaker 2: I can kill everyone who when when's the last time
- 39:45Speaker 2: a murderer murdered or or rob before two people who
- 39:49Speaker 2: gave them a hustura warning ahead of time. You can
- 39:52Speaker 2: never enforce any law. You can't do because that's that's
- 39:56Speaker 2: the biblical like almost theoretical law. If you look at
- 39:58Speaker 2: how courts throughout history you have done it. The Gamarra
- 40:01Speaker 2: speaks about how they killed all these witches or shim'n shattach,
- 40:05Speaker 2: and they speak about how they killed a guy who
- 40:07Speaker 2: was riding a horse on sharvis. So that's that's not
- 40:09Speaker 2: even a tour law. How do he kills someone to
- 40:11Speaker 2: riding horse on sharps And they explain because in order
- 40:15Speaker 2: to to establish the law to person, there's no breakdown
- 40:19Speaker 2: in society. The sages, the bait diden can do anything
- 40:22Speaker 2: they feel necessary in order to in order to keep
- 40:28Speaker 2: to keep order, as as emergency measures and not just
- 40:31Speaker 2: as emergency measures. The run we spoke, you can go
- 40:34Speaker 2: back to my classes on our Hertzog, where he deals
- 40:37Speaker 2: with the view of the rabinonissima Girona, because when they
- 40:40Speaker 2: were trying to create thinking about creating a constitution, when
- 40:43Speaker 2: he was running a constitution for the future state, how
- 40:45Speaker 2: would a feature state function? How what are you gonna
- 40:48Speaker 2: do in terms of courts, et cetera. So what is
- 40:50Speaker 2: your reavery they ever applied to me? He says, this
- 40:53Speaker 2: was my intention, but I only I was too short. Again,
- 40:59Speaker 2: thank you, you are correct. This is important that the
- 41:02Speaker 2: rabbis great rabbis much greater than me, are able to
- 41:06Speaker 2: acknowledge when they misspoke or they were incorrect. And so
- 41:11Speaker 2: even if it's only a few word answer, I give
- 41:14Speaker 2: him a lot of credit for that. Now we go
- 41:19Speaker 2: to Simon ninety nine, and this is actually the last
- 41:22Speaker 2: Simon in the section, which is known as dot Umadina.
- 41:29Speaker 2: Usually people you see him here in Hebrew dot du
- 41:31Speaker 2: medina of religion and state, they think of Israel. But
- 41:34Speaker 2: as we saw already, the questions were not just about Israel.
- 41:36Speaker 2: They are out America. This word dot. Incidentally, let me
- 41:41Speaker 2: show you something here, dot as religion. Well, where do
- 41:48Speaker 2: we get this from? Here? From? If you look in Well,
- 41:58Speaker 2: first of all, all the scholars today will tell you
- 42:01Speaker 2: that the word dot is a Persian word. It only
- 42:05Speaker 2: appears in the later books of the Bible, except we
- 42:10Speaker 2: have it in Devari chapter thirty three, where we have
- 42:13Speaker 2: this word that's written as one word has read to
- 42:18Speaker 2: Astadt and the sages and you hope and uncle is
- 42:22Speaker 2: also read this as a stadt, namely a fiery law.
- 42:26Speaker 2: But if you look at it from an academic perspective,
- 42:30Speaker 2: and then I'm holding in my hands, for instance, an
- 42:33Speaker 2: article from the Journal of Biblical Literature by Richard Steiner
- 42:38Speaker 2: in which he talks about this, it's hard that this
- 42:41Speaker 2: to say this is a scientific translation, because we know
- 42:44Speaker 2: that dot comes from it's a Persian word, so it
- 42:48Speaker 2: wouldn't be in Devari. Now, yes, the has A'll do
- 42:52Speaker 2: give understand it that way, but has I'll give lots
- 42:54Speaker 2: of derivations that are not scientific but are moralistic or heermneutical.
- 43:01Speaker 2: The even explained to Tiberius, why is it called Tiberius?
- 43:04Speaker 2: They give a reason, a madrasia reason. They give madrasha
- 43:07Speaker 2: reasons for Esther's name, Tiberius is from the emperor, the
- 43:10Speaker 2: Roman emperor. So when Hazal see a word and they
- 43:14Speaker 2: explain it, that doesn't mean that that's the scientific etymological meaning.
- 43:18Speaker 2: That's they're offering a madrashic meaning. If you look in
- 43:25Speaker 2: Steiner's article, he wants to claim that it's really dotted.
- 43:29Speaker 2: Here is a the oliph has dropped out. It's an
- 43:34Speaker 2: irregular spelling of the verb of a verb dollard olive hey,
- 43:38Speaker 2: which means like to fly or to or to fire flu.
- 43:48Speaker 2: That's how he translates it. That from his right hand
- 43:51Speaker 2: fire flu into them. That's how he translates it. And
- 43:55Speaker 2: he from the word dolla olive hay, which means like
- 43:59Speaker 2: the why or travel or something like that. It's a
- 44:02Speaker 2: rare words. Professor Steiner Pfessor Steiner, for those who don't know,
- 44:07Speaker 2: was many years professor at Yeshiva University, an expert not
- 44:12Speaker 2: just in Hebrew, but in ancient Semitic languages. So getting
- 44:18Speaker 2: back to what we're doing now, this is the last
- 44:23Speaker 2: simon in this section, and it's written by a figure
- 44:29Speaker 2: we've seen a number of times there. He is Rabbi
- 44:32Speaker 2: high Am Rappaport from London. He knew Rabbi Sachs obviously
- 44:40Speaker 2: quite well. Also he could talk to you about him,
- 44:45Speaker 2: he writes to me in twenty twelve, responding to a
- 44:51Speaker 2: blog post I wrote about certain issues with the Haredim
- 44:55Speaker 2: in Israel. I've got a certain a Soutner author name
- 45:00Speaker 2: you throw all harfness. He's written a number of very
- 45:04Speaker 2: good sporry, but within the Sari, which are good, there's
- 45:09Speaker 2: all sorts of nonsensical things. When I say nonsensical, I
- 45:12Speaker 2: just mean like, well, we'll see an example that rapp
- 45:15Speaker 2: Art gives. Some people are so blinded by their hatred
- 45:19Speaker 2: from the state of Israel that they come up with
- 45:22Speaker 2: some of the most outrageous things. So I mentioned a
- 45:26Speaker 2: bit of that, and Rebbi Ropport writes me as follows,
- 45:30Speaker 2: and he says, in my blog post I mentioned Chito
- 45:35Speaker 2: Tav Studio Tav, the positions, the nonsense. He does a
- 45:40Speaker 2: maliita plan words of Rabbie Harfiness, and he says, I'm
- 45:43Speaker 2: going to give you another example of one of his
- 45:46Speaker 2: books that show you really how And he's a sotomore
- 45:49Speaker 2: author that how just really out of it they are.
- 45:54Speaker 2: This is what Robbie Harfiness says in his book. He
- 45:57Speaker 2: wrote a book on Holstonia, and he's speaking about the
- 46:00Speaker 2: idea you're supposed to place the minorah outside coming up
- 46:04Speaker 2: to Hanak assume. But in Europe they didn't place it outside.
- 46:07Speaker 2: There was they're afraid of the non Jews, and it
- 46:09Speaker 2: became the custom, the practice to put it inside. But
- 46:12Speaker 2: if you live in Israel, of course you want to
- 46:14Speaker 2: put it outside. They build these things into the walls
- 46:16Speaker 2: and you put it out there. What does Robber Harfin say? However,
- 46:20Speaker 2: on our day in the land of Israel, the practice
- 46:24Speaker 2: of many people is to light it outside, which is
- 46:28Speaker 2: the simple understanding of the takhana of Krazo. And this
- 46:33Speaker 2: was what the Perusium did, the Pruceium, the followers of
- 46:35Speaker 2: Vinego who went in Aliyah. He says, however, and he says,
- 46:40Speaker 2: in our day in the land of Israel, most of
- 46:43Speaker 2: the Harassi team light on the inside of the house,
- 46:47Speaker 2: like they used to do in Houssarts. In any sense,
- 46:50Speaker 2: even today in the land of Israel, there's a shash.
- 46:53Speaker 2: There's a worry that the wicked ones of Israel the
- 46:58Speaker 2: riche all the boomery as that they're gonna turn out,
- 47:02Speaker 2: They're gonna mess up, mess around with your candles, turn
- 47:05Speaker 2: out the lights. And then you know these people who
- 47:07Speaker 2: are found in Israel. And he says, Umasi Maholom, say
- 47:10Speaker 2: Hudi Haredim solely Metsionim, Seamersheim your co. He says, it's
- 47:15Speaker 2: every day we their stories that the the the Haredi
- 47:18Speaker 2: Jews in Israel suffer from the Zionists, the wicked Zionists
- 47:22Speaker 2: mean the names of the wicked be bought it out,
- 47:25Speaker 2: Uh through attacks and Redifa hadat that there's persecution of
- 47:30Speaker 2: of Judaism in the state of Israel, and they break
- 47:33Speaker 2: into synagogues and Buddy mid rush and they tramp on
- 47:37Speaker 2: all that's holy. I don't know. I need the news
- 47:40Speaker 2: every day. I haven't heard much in the way of that, Uh.
- 47:43Speaker 2: And then he goes on that he says that he
- 47:47Speaker 2: quotes from a book that a year after the the Medina,
- 47:52Speaker 2: that is the the the zion Est state. They don't
- 47:55Speaker 2: they can't call it the state the zion Estate. When
- 47:59Speaker 2: the Haznish went to bake Matsa's He says that it's
- 48:03Speaker 2: a year after the state was proclaimed, and we could
- 48:06Speaker 2: still make bake Matsa. This is you know hostaschem, this
- 48:09Speaker 2: is you know, the mercy of God. Because there was
- 48:12Speaker 2: a fear. You had many people who were afraid that
- 48:15Speaker 2: when the labor rights who were in control, that they
- 48:18Speaker 2: would institute restrictions and all sorts of things about require
- 48:23Speaker 2: everyone to go to secular schools. None of this came
- 48:25Speaker 2: to be. It was all based on these false ideas
- 48:28Speaker 2: that the the secular Zionists would insist on in doctrinating everyone.
- 48:33Speaker 2: They did some indoctrination with the El de Tehran and
- 48:36Speaker 2: as Farda kids, but the idea that they would take,
- 48:38Speaker 2: let say, Hasidic children from their homes and and put
- 48:42Speaker 2: them somewhere in the secular environment never happened. And then
- 48:46Speaker 2: so the Cosina was surprised. And then he says the
- 48:49Speaker 2: Sutmar ran Amni Sutmar said that he's afraid that there
- 48:53Speaker 2: will come a time when we're not going to be
- 48:56Speaker 2: able to observe Torah and mitzvos in the land of
- 48:58Speaker 2: Israel because of the persecution of the Okay, so that's
- 49:01Speaker 2: now and now by Harfiness is writing this like in
- 49:04Speaker 2: in recent years, in the least ten years, and everybody
- 49:08Speaker 2: outports as as follows. Apparently these people live in a
- 49:13Speaker 2: world of the of imagination, and what we can see
- 49:18Speaker 2: with our with our eyes, with our hush, they don't see.
- 49:22Speaker 2: In other words, it's like the people who who just
- 49:24Speaker 2: don't believe what's what's out there. They'll they'll deny, uh,
- 49:28Speaker 2: they'll deny that vaccines work, and they'll deny they'll deny
- 49:31Speaker 2: the moon landing and all these things. They just don't
- 49:33Speaker 2: they don't see because obviously if you go to Israel,
- 49:36Speaker 2: i don't care how right when you are you see
- 49:38Speaker 2: that tonra is driving and it's never been better. And
- 49:41Speaker 2: to speak about the secularists bursting into shoals and all
- 49:44Speaker 2: this sort of stuff, that's crazy. And then he says, uh.
- 49:49Speaker 2: In addition that there's in Schachner, there's no basis for
- 49:53Speaker 2: what Robert Harfin says, and it's actually the opposite, is
- 49:58Speaker 2: correct that if it wasn't for the money awarded, the
- 50:05Speaker 2: monetary will help of the Israeli government for the tore institutions,
- 50:09Speaker 2: you want to have the cools and the Achievas. The
- 50:13Speaker 2: greatest supporter of Torah in history is the Israeli government.
- 50:18Speaker 2: The Israeli government gives more every single year than all
- 50:23Speaker 2: the donors in America have given to Torah in the
- 50:25Speaker 2: last fifty years. It's it's really unbelievable how much money
- 50:30Speaker 2: is given now. To their credits, I guess you could
- 50:33Speaker 2: say that, I think to their credit. St. Mart they're
- 50:37Speaker 2: anti Zionists and they won't take money from the government
- 50:39Speaker 2: for their issivas. So I guess there's some honesty and
- 50:43Speaker 2: consistency there. It annoys me to no end when anti
- 50:48Speaker 2: Zionists take the money. But for St. Mart to say
- 50:51Speaker 2: they don't take any money from the government is not
- 50:53Speaker 2: really correct. First of all, they use the police when
- 50:55Speaker 2: they need it, they use the roads, they use the
- 50:58Speaker 2: health insurance and all these things. But at least they
- 51:00Speaker 2: don't take money for the issues. But rubber rapports point is,
- 51:04Speaker 2: you're going to say that the State of Israel is
- 51:06Speaker 2: the big enemy and is going to destroy Torah. If
- 51:08Speaker 2: it wasn't for the State of Israel, you wouldn't have
- 51:10Speaker 2: all these all these achievers. They support them, including he says,
- 51:16Speaker 2: the call of the husband, the they get money from
- 51:20Speaker 2: the government, and then it says he says, a certain
- 51:27Speaker 2: wise man once said that we live in an era
- 51:31Speaker 2: that legend is history and history is a legend. Legend
- 51:39Speaker 2: is history, history is legend. So the true history, the
- 51:42Speaker 2: true things that you don't believe, but the legends you believe. Now,
- 51:46Speaker 2: one of the people is on with us right now.
- 51:50Speaker 2: He shared the following with me, which I didn't even know.
- 51:54Speaker 2: But this is famous apparently from the the movie The
- 52:00Speaker 2: Man who shot Liberty Valvelence. It's almost Ruther Rapport was saying,
- 52:03Speaker 2: I don't think he knew it.
- 52:04Speaker 3: But listen, you're not going to use the story god, no, sir,
- 52:16Speaker 3: this is the West, Sir. The legend becomes back in
- 52:20Speaker 3: the legend. He's right.
- 52:25Speaker 2: So it's the same thing by Rappitport pointing out that
- 52:29Speaker 2: among these there are some people who are just so
- 52:31Speaker 2: blinded that they didn't know what to do. When the
- 52:35Speaker 2: Sathreby's grandson, well, the two something Ready's nephew, I think
- 52:41Speaker 2: he's the great grandson of the previous summer. Ready joined
- 52:44Speaker 2: the Israeli army and he's not a secularist here to
- 52:47Speaker 2: keep us through gun But uh so that's so that's
- 52:51Speaker 2: with that, we ended the section dot Umadina. When we
- 52:55Speaker 2: pick up next week. We have all sorts of interesting things,
- 52:58Speaker 2: and as I said, a new care of rabbis for
- 53:01Speaker 2: the most part new issues. It's the sections called Tikuo
- 53:04Speaker 2: and Sofa, and we're going to pick up with the idea.
- 53:06Speaker 2: Although that the focus of my letters to Rabbi Ka
- 53:09Speaker 2: the Great kaf. I'll tell you all about it and
- 53:11Speaker 2: Rabi's Lot. If you haven't heard of him, take my
- 53:14Speaker 2: word for it. He's had. He is someone who they
- 53:17Speaker 2: will be reading in five hundred years or at least
- 53:20Speaker 2: two hundred years. What he achieved is uh is is
- 53:24Speaker 2: really incredible, and I'll explain to you who he is.
- 53:27Speaker 2: And if you haven't heard of him, you'd be quite
- 53:28Speaker 2: surprised that you haven't heard of she Lots, because every
- 53:32Speaker 2: single scholar of the rambamb and other works has has
- 53:35Speaker 2: his writings. The question is going to be uh. But
- 53:39Speaker 2: it's a start just as a translation question, but get
- 53:41Speaker 2: into a basic philosophical question. Is there a belief a
- 53:44Speaker 2: commandment to believe in God? How can you have a
- 53:47Speaker 2: commandment to believe in God? If you who's who's doing
- 53:49Speaker 2: the command it? What do we say about Anhi, the
- 53:52Speaker 2: very first commandment? And what about what does the Rambam
- 53:54Speaker 2: mean when the Rambamb includes it. So we'll have to
- 53:57Speaker 2: get your Arabic ready and our medieval Hebrew dreads, and
- 54:01Speaker 2: we'll move on all sorts of interesting things. What is
- 54:07Speaker 2: a don't think about? What is a Dona Lumby, eternal
- 54:12Speaker 2: lord or lord of the universe? All sorts of interesting stuff.
- 54:15Speaker 2: If you're interested in Dick Dook, if you're interested insider
- 54:18Speaker 2: in translation, and so add Reb Mazus. We're going to
- 54:24Speaker 2: really go and get into Rev. Mazoo's and his things.
- 54:27Speaker 2: So we are we're starting next class. We'll start at
- 54:32Speaker 2: page two twenty three, so we're more than halfway done
- 54:36Speaker 2: the book. Let's get to the questions covered a lot today.
- 54:41Speaker 2: Let us see what some of the learned questions. I
- 54:43Speaker 2: hear so much from these questions and comments. Someone mentions
- 54:48Speaker 2: privately that a biography or climosa just came out. Yes,
- 54:51Speaker 2: I actually put my order in for it. That's my
- 54:53Speaker 2: Reduvla Komeneski, Schmol Komenski's son. He's a great, great scholar
- 54:58Speaker 2: of the Lithuanian to the world. He also works for
- 55:01Speaker 2: one of the auction houses. That'll be something nell, says
- 55:08Speaker 2: Yakov tom Yo shave all the question. The word tom
- 55:15Speaker 2: is a it's what does it mean? Though? Now? Because
- 55:21Speaker 2: tom we read it on when we say tom could
- 55:23Speaker 2: mean a positive thing, or it could mean like a simpleton.
- 55:27Speaker 2: We read it on Theesa. It's not a positive thing.
- 55:30Speaker 2: It's sort of like he's a simpleton. And the same
- 55:33Speaker 2: thing is the word tell me what does tom me mean?
- 55:36Speaker 2: Tomim is it's used often in a very positive way
- 55:40Speaker 2: as someone is pure, it's not affected by the outside
- 55:44Speaker 2: worlds holy and and I use that as well. When
- 55:47Speaker 2: I post an article on the Stipeworg which was based
- 55:50Speaker 2: on these my classes, my term motion classes, it was
- 55:53Speaker 2: translated to Hebrew and it appeared in that big thick book, Pagadoli.
- 55:57Speaker 2: Let me get you the book. Stay right there. Here's
- 56:07Speaker 2: the book, big book, it's called Hagdoli. We had a
- 56:09Speaker 2: conference in Israel. It's people who created the face of
- 56:13Speaker 2: the Kardi Judaism in Israel. You can see it online,
- 56:18Speaker 2: the different talks. So I wrote my paper and they
- 56:21Speaker 2: translated to Hebrew. And this the title that Benny Brown,
- 56:25Speaker 2: the Great Benny Brown gave it was toral Konewski Stipewer,
- 56:32Speaker 2: and I agree with that. It's a good because if
- 56:34Speaker 2: Kanieesku was not interested in machcar and research, very like
- 56:37Speaker 2: simple belief in opposition to philosophical belief. And that's what
- 56:41Speaker 2: Tommy means. And Rabbad called himself to Tamim. If you
- 56:44Speaker 2: study at Krabadiyshivas, you'd be known as the Tommim. But
- 56:48Speaker 2: I was criticized. I was attacked by one of the
- 56:50Speaker 2: Karadi websites because I insulted the stiper. I'm calling him
- 56:54Speaker 2: a simpleton. So the word there's like two meanings for
- 56:57Speaker 2: the word tomue. David Eisen says he knows at least
- 57:01Speaker 2: one other a Tom a tom, but it's indeed a
- 57:04Speaker 2: rare name. Someone asking privately, is this Boarin related to
- 57:09Speaker 2: the Hasidic rebbe in Heilman's book Who will lead Us?
- 57:12Speaker 1: No?
- 57:13Speaker 2: No, there's no Hassidic Grebby named boar In in Heilman's book,
- 57:18Speaker 2: he speaks about beyond the beyond a Rebby. Beyond is
- 57:21Speaker 2: the Hasidic dynasty. Uh Beyonna Rebby is Breyer. He's the
- 57:26Speaker 2: son actually a professor Breyer from Yeshiva University's interesting story.
- 57:30Speaker 2: A guy that the hai the Beyona Rebby went to
- 57:34Speaker 2: poplish or mta forget one of the which one? But
- 57:37Speaker 2: now he's a rebbe. But the boar is related to
- 57:40Speaker 2: someone else who I won't speak too much about. He
- 57:43Speaker 2: has a brilliant, brilliant brother who's a professor in California,
- 57:47Speaker 2: Daniel Boyarn, but Daniel Barron, who walks north of the
- 57:50Speaker 2: big Yamaica Tom and mofok of Sean Weeberman a big,
- 57:54Speaker 2: big Tamahafam is uh. Well, he's been accused of being
- 57:59Speaker 2: an anti Semi. I'm not gonna call him an anti Semite,
- 58:01Speaker 2: but he is about as vicious anti Israel as you
- 58:03Speaker 2: can get. He's pro bds, he hates the State of Israel.
- 58:07Speaker 2: He's a Terrey Karta. When the New York Times did
- 58:10Speaker 2: a thing about five years ago about Orthodox Jews who
- 58:13Speaker 2: hate the State of Israel, he featured. He supports the boycott.
- 58:18Speaker 2: That's so it's a big issue because he's a he's
- 58:20Speaker 2: a leading academic scholar and academic conferences and everything. You know.
- 58:25Speaker 2: We we don't believe in people's views, borrowing them or
- 58:29Speaker 2: anything like that, but it's it's quite strange to have
- 58:32Speaker 2: an ant when I see an anti Zionist. I don't
- 58:35Speaker 2: mean like a brisker antiziist. I mean someone who fights
- 58:37Speaker 2: against the State of Israel. Who is when you give
- 58:40Speaker 2: the definition of an when you say, as we're always told,
- 58:44Speaker 2: you know, anti Zionism is anti Semitism. Well it runs
- 58:48Speaker 2: into some problems because or BDS is antisemitism. Because Daniel
- 58:52Speaker 2: Boiarn he had to leave his show, he said, because
- 58:57Speaker 2: it became too uncomfortable. Some guy told him, you know,
- 58:59Speaker 2: you should go back to the go to the Arabs
- 59:01Speaker 2: or something like that. But that's so Jonathan Boyarn. His
- 59:05Speaker 2: brother is Daniel Boyarron. I have no idea what Jonathan
- 59:08Speaker 2: Byarn's politics are. And uh, look, at the end of
- 59:12Speaker 2: the day, Daniel Boyaren has written some interesting things, and
- 59:14Speaker 2: I think you got to separate the politics from He's
- 59:18Speaker 2: also written some very radical progressive type new a new
- 59:23Speaker 2: I don't know the these like cutting edge type of
- 59:25Speaker 2: scholarship that Professor Torsky hated. And I'm not into it
- 59:28Speaker 2: at all. Feminist even even hetero, you know, gay type
- 59:35Speaker 2: of ways of looking at things, uh, which is not
- 59:39Speaker 2: my cup of tea. But he's a he's a top
- 59:41Speaker 2: he's a big name, Daniel Barn, And uh, you try
- 59:44Speaker 2: to avoid the politics. Unfortunately, in the academic world, from
- 59:46Speaker 2: my perspective, at least, you run into lots of people
- 59:49Speaker 2: not as extreme as barn but uh centrist. Even to
- 59:54Speaker 2: find a centrist in the academic world is often hard.
- 1:00:00Speaker 2: Uh tells us that the early name of Cimberlin was
- 1:00:02Speaker 2: the Ferris Bahuri. Yes, that's true. Then they changed to Climberlin.
- 1:00:08Speaker 2: So the tea, he says, the mt Jsentennio book, which
- 1:00:11Speaker 2: I don't have, has more info and I have to
- 1:00:14Speaker 2: look at that. The Bara says, the Haredi Spring, the
- 1:00:20Speaker 2: Lakewood Spring.
- 1:00:22Speaker 3: Uh.
- 1:00:22Speaker 2: Someone asking privately, is the ot D phenomenon in Lakewood
- 1:00:24Speaker 2: primarily male? I'm not in Lakewood, but I think it is.
- 1:00:31Speaker 2: From what I've been told by people, it's mostly male.
- 1:00:34Speaker 2: There's there's females also footsteps. Is that organization? You have
- 1:00:38Speaker 2: plenty of women as well, but Uh, I'm told it's
- 1:00:41Speaker 2: more male. I don't know.
- 1:00:43Speaker 3: Uh.
- 1:00:45Speaker 2: B n CSY I wouldn't do that. I don't think
- 1:00:47Speaker 2: n CSY would post My kids all went on n CSY.
- 1:00:51Speaker 2: They went machach and everything, and they would never post
- 1:00:53Speaker 2: videos of the n CSY kids without yamagas or doing
- 1:00:58Speaker 2: things like that. They would they have let me take
- 1:01:00Speaker 2: that back and cy too. They have the public school
- 1:01:03Speaker 2: one and they have the regular one. For the public
- 1:01:05Speaker 2: school one, they they're not religious at all. They don't
- 1:01:08Speaker 2: make them yama but for the religious one they would
- 1:01:12Speaker 2: never post it. So I guess you could say, Minachelano,
- 1:01:14Speaker 2: these people are not necessarily religious. So it's still a
- 1:01:18Speaker 2: little strange from a Lakewood group that they because they
- 1:01:21Speaker 2: choose what it's look. I understand they're not going to
- 1:01:23Speaker 2: make the kids wear yamaka's or anything like that, but
- 1:01:25Speaker 2: these are videos that they post. But okay, I see it.
- 1:01:28Speaker 2: You want to show the If every video there shows them,
- 1:01:32Speaker 2: you know, at the Kumsit Saturday night and shows them
- 1:01:34Speaker 2: with the yamaica's, then the typical off the Derek kid
- 1:01:36Speaker 2: in Lakewood is not going to step foot into me
- 1:01:39Speaker 2: and shallanu because he doesn't want that. If you will
- 1:01:42Speaker 2: watch the videos that these guys came like I don't
- 1:01:44Speaker 2: know how many months they came to Night Sator, like
- 1:01:46Speaker 2: every week they came to Night Sator. So the reward
- 1:01:49Speaker 2: is the the big trip. The point is that even
- 1:01:52Speaker 2: in Lakewood, the heart of the Toro Judaism, the ear
- 1:01:55Speaker 2: to of Lakewood. It doesn't work for everyone. And perhaps
- 1:02:00Speaker 2: if they had an option, like a more modern Orthodox option, maybe,
- 1:02:03Speaker 2: but it's it's it's tough. So you got to give
- 1:02:05Speaker 2: rabbi a body enormous amount of credit. There was another
- 1:02:09Speaker 2: rabbi very involved, or by Gissinger, who passed away recently.
- 1:02:12Speaker 2: I just saw an Arts Arts was coming out with
- 1:02:14Speaker 2: a book about him. Of Gissinger was very involved, it
- 1:02:18Speaker 2: seems because he gave sheer him in things. Talks to
- 1:02:21Speaker 2: this minion, minion Shahana. I get some shows. Probably wouldn't
- 1:02:25Speaker 2: want these kids in it, you know the way they look.
- 1:02:28Speaker 2: But as Rabbi rav gershow and Natolstein says, it's a
- 1:02:33Speaker 2: different generation. And I would agree with the soul spots
- 1:02:37Speaker 2: that this is the pure of movement. Addapted to the
- 1:02:39Speaker 2: twenty twenties. These kids come from the Haradi world, one
- 1:02:42Speaker 2: hundred percent. These are all from the Haradi world. These
- 1:02:44Speaker 2: are all from Lakewd type families. No, no, bar, he said,
- 1:02:52Speaker 2: this has been around so long. The professor just saw
- 1:02:53Speaker 2: it now. No no, I didn't just see it now.
- 1:02:55Speaker 2: I saw the aidostein thing a long time ago. But
- 1:02:58Speaker 2: I was speaking to someone and he pointed out. The
- 1:03:01Speaker 2: other one the the the Rushia of Subuka or by
- 1:03:06Speaker 2: hersh and since her by Herst specifically mentions the idea
- 1:03:10Speaker 2: of lifting either the interpretation of Emosha Stirnbach, That's why
- 1:03:15Speaker 2: I thought I would mention it, and Ragarhosak was not no.
- 1:03:23Speaker 3: No.
- 1:03:23Speaker 2: But the question is the question there is if they
- 1:03:26Speaker 2: come to the house and they bring the girlfriend and
- 1:03:28Speaker 2: they're gonna go, he's gonna go in his room with
- 1:03:29Speaker 2: his girlfriend. You don't throw them out? Do you let
- 1:03:31Speaker 2: them stay there? Did I find astounding? And what non
- 1:03:36Speaker 2: steeos means? Obviously there's different levels, but you could You
- 1:03:40Speaker 2: could take the daughter and buy the clothes she wants
- 1:03:42Speaker 2: to buy, even if it's not acceptable in your community.
- 1:03:44Speaker 2: The idea that you would have in a Haredi community,
- 1:03:47Speaker 2: your daughter walking in still living in your house and
- 1:03:50Speaker 2: walking in and out wearing Nonseniat clothing. This is a
- 1:03:53Speaker 2: new phenomenon. This never would have happened twenty years ago
- 1:03:57Speaker 2: that it would be so. I'm told from people in
- 1:04:01Speaker 2: the Haredi world. I don't live in Lake Woid, but
- 1:04:03Speaker 2: they tell me this Shoff gives edited snippets you say
- 1:04:09Speaker 2: terror to promote his approach. If you ask already Postkin,
- 1:04:12Speaker 2: they might say each question require Asia could be okay,
- 1:04:15Speaker 2: I don't know. Regarding my point about women voting, yell
- 1:04:19Speaker 2: and tells us. The Supreme Coordinator seventy two held that
- 1:04:23Speaker 2: an Illinois law forbidding women from practicing law was constitutional.
- 1:04:27Speaker 2: The majority opinion stated that God designed the sexist occupy
- 1:04:30Speaker 2: different spheres of action, and it belonged to men to make,
- 1:04:34Speaker 2: apply and execute the laws. Was regarded as almost axiomatic truth. Yes,
- 1:04:38Speaker 2: and uh, that's why when you look at rough Cook
- 1:04:41Speaker 2: and he's not arguing possibly, I think it's significant. He's
- 1:04:44Speaker 2: arguing from this sentiment that women and man have different roles.
- 1:04:48Speaker 2: It's the man's place to be out there. Everybody ifiak
- 1:04:50Speaker 2: of Weinberg has a very different formulation. He was asked
- 1:04:53Speaker 2: this about shoals like having women be voting and electing,
- 1:04:56Speaker 2: and he said that this is not do with haka.
- 1:04:58Speaker 2: It has to do with conception of modesty. In certain
- 1:05:02Speaker 2: Hiarati communities, for a woman to you know, be involved
- 1:05:05Speaker 2: in the running of a show, that's sort of that
- 1:05:07Speaker 2: doesn't work. But in the modern world that's no issue.
- 1:05:11Speaker 2: And Rabbi Weinberg says Yadia Osmanna. He says time will
- 1:05:17Speaker 2: tell what this means, that each community work out their
- 1:05:20Speaker 2: their own approach. Now from we're standing in twenty twenty,
- 1:05:22Speaker 2: the idea that the woman shouldn't have any involvement in
- 1:05:25Speaker 2: the modern word, I'm saying in the show and be
- 1:05:27Speaker 2: involved with it that strikes most people are strange. Even
- 1:05:30Speaker 2: though in many orthodoxials a woman can still can't be president.
- 1:05:36Speaker 2: Rebi Helman says, the first Shachter said that the rough
- 1:05:38Speaker 2: and tumble of talmmutica debate is not appropriate to women.
- 1:05:41Speaker 2: We spoke about the issue of women as witnesses. It's. Uh.
- 1:05:46Speaker 2: The thing is, though, I think the women would say,
- 1:05:47Speaker 2: if you ask the women to Mike bell O's or
- 1:05:50Speaker 2: winden down, they would say, you're right. Perhaps the rough
- 1:05:53Speaker 2: and tumble of talmutic debate has practiced by men is
- 1:05:55Speaker 2: not appropriate to women. But if the women were learning,
- 1:05:58Speaker 2: maybe they'd have a more feminine approach. Instead of fighting
- 1:06:01Speaker 2: with each other, they're trying to find resolutions and things
- 1:06:04Speaker 2: like that. So, uh, it's like when they say that
- 1:06:07Speaker 2: politics is not for women because there's there's you know,
- 1:06:11Speaker 2: there's wars and there's all these things. Well, you know,
- 1:06:13Speaker 2: maybe if women were running the world, there wuldn't be
- 1:06:15Speaker 2: so many wars and there won't be so much disputes.
- 1:06:18Speaker 2: I mean, it's it's you can look at it differently.
- 1:06:21Speaker 2: We do not know how Talmud will be studied when
- 1:06:24Speaker 2: women are involved with it inten intensively and seriously, because
- 1:06:28Speaker 2: women have never been so we look at Toalmwood and
- 1:06:31Speaker 2: halahah as as one approach when women are involved with
- 1:06:36Speaker 2: it seriously, and this is going to take decades, it
- 1:06:40Speaker 2: could be that there's a completely new way of looking
- 1:06:42Speaker 2: at it that. Uh, let's because we assume men and
- 1:06:45Speaker 2: women are not the same. If men were more the same,
- 1:06:47Speaker 2: then it wouldn't be a problem for women studying it,
- 1:06:49Speaker 2: even for for anyone. The fact that women are different,
- 1:06:52Speaker 2: then why should we assume that we're not going to
- 1:06:55Speaker 2: get new insights, feminist insights, et cetera, et cetera. I
- 1:07:00Speaker 2: have no doubt that that's going to come. What year
- 1:07:04Speaker 2: was it written in? Hardness was written in? I think
- 1:07:07Speaker 2: it's in the nineties, But no, no, we know what happened,
- 1:07:10Speaker 2: but there's no difference. You can't compare bar what happened
- 1:07:13Speaker 2: in the forties and the fifties. It's right now today
- 1:07:17Speaker 2: in the in the in the state of Israel, the government,
- 1:07:23Speaker 2: as I said, is the is the biggest supporter of Torah.
- 1:07:26Speaker 2: No one can deny that. I'm just trying to look online.
- 1:07:29Speaker 2: If I see, I'll tell you exactly what the year, Yeah,
- 1:07:37Speaker 2: Mick dushy Thrall, the book called we're speaking about is
- 1:07:39Speaker 2: two thousand and seven. So I can say without any
- 1:07:42Speaker 2: fear of being contradicted bar rough then the year two
- 1:07:44Speaker 2: thousand and seven, the state of Israel was very good
- 1:07:47Speaker 2: to the Hiadi War. And of course there's disputes, and
- 1:07:49Speaker 2: there's fights, and there's issues, but to make it seem
- 1:07:53Speaker 2: as if you're living in the worst times of the
- 1:07:56Speaker 2: Soviet Union, when they're going to shut you down and
- 1:07:59Speaker 2: you can't leave them a Noah outside because the Rasheli
- 1:08:01Speaker 2: are going to come around. David says. The best explanation
- 1:08:05Speaker 2: you heard from a Hasidic source as to why these
- 1:08:07Speaker 2: days the Honnic Relay should be lit indoors as opposed
- 1:08:09Speaker 2: to the original decree is due to the fact that
- 1:08:12Speaker 2: during the ear of the hussman Ai, the enemy of
- 1:08:14Speaker 2: the Jewish people was external, while today the enemy is
- 1:08:16Speaker 2: from within the Jewish people. Okay, they can all this
- 1:08:20Speaker 2: is justification for doing what was done in Europe. And
- 1:08:24Speaker 2: you can make the argument that today pursuing anissa's in
- 1:08:27Speaker 2: the house and we don't need to change the practice
- 1:08:30Speaker 2: to But a lot of these things, like why does
- 1:08:33Speaker 2: lots of people won't sleep in the soka on Israel
- 1:08:35Speaker 2: even though there shouldn't be any reason. These things have
- 1:08:38Speaker 2: their own their own inertia. And finally Gershon asked if
- 1:08:45Speaker 2: gearshoon can be Gershom, a ton can be eight ton? Yes, okay,
- 1:08:50Speaker 2: very good. And as we saw already with the raal Bog,
- 1:08:54Speaker 2: even though the name is Leavy being Geershom in many
- 1:08:57Speaker 2: early sources, he's already referred to as leave he been
- 1:09:00Speaker 2: gear shown. And we'll have to ask our post game
- 1:09:03Speaker 2: and the dying we have with us, what about a get?
- 1:09:06Speaker 2: If the get is written and it has gear shown,
- 1:09:09Speaker 2: not gear shown, and we can't get a new get,
- 1:09:11Speaker 2: can we keep the get or not? And for my
- 1:09:15Speaker 2: last question, last thing, yes, that one says, hey tell
- 1:09:19Speaker 2: me him's not an insult. If wat obovagers keep driving
- 1:09:22Speaker 2: Minora's year round at the Harabad houses, I noticed that recently.
- 1:09:27Speaker 2: I just thought it was too complicated to take it
- 1:09:29Speaker 2: down and put it up each year. But I don't know. Listen,
- 1:09:33Speaker 2: I don't want to gainst them and minora's. Here we
- 1:09:35Speaker 2: have the man who is me, who brought it to
- 1:09:39Speaker 2: the Supreme Court. He's with us right now, who is
- 1:09:42Speaker 2: responsible for Raabad with the menorah's and it was an
- 1:09:46Speaker 2: important constitutional issue that went before. So far be it
- 1:09:51Speaker 2: from me to even mention a word about Kabad and
- 1:09:53Speaker 2: the minora's when the great matt Lewin is with us.
- 1:09:56Speaker 2: But with that I will. I don't know if he's
- 1:09:59Speaker 2: ever given a tall I know he spoke for the
- 1:10:01Speaker 2: habbad now just recently about the anniversary. I think it
- 1:10:05Speaker 2: was the anniversary of this, But I don't know if
- 1:10:07Speaker 2: you've ever maybe a tord motion talk about the case
- 1:10:12Speaker 2: and the constitutional issues it was raised. Why is a
- 1:10:15Speaker 2: minora like a Christmas tree but not like a crash?
- 1:10:20Speaker 2: The Haredim oham on the way they attacked Rabbad for
- 1:10:24Speaker 2: claiming that it's a cultural symbol and trying to remove
- 1:10:28Speaker 2: it from only religion. These are all, these are all fascinating.
- 1:10:32Speaker 2: He was part of it was part of the Neebrock
- 1:10:34Speaker 2: attack against Rabbad. But they wanted to put Manoa's in
- 1:10:38Speaker 2: the public square and see it as not just religious
- 1:10:41Speaker 2: but nationalistic, cultural, et cetera, et cetera. But that's that's
- 1:10:45Speaker 2: for another time, and I leave that to and Bark.
- 1:10:49Speaker 2: You know already I will never say anything negative about Habbad.
- 1:10:52Speaker 2: We're going to see soon the Lebavic Rebbe's letter to me.
- 1:10:55Speaker 2: I had to read us with the Rebbe when no
- 1:10:57Speaker 2: one else could get in after his stroke. We'll talk
- 1:11:00Speaker 2: about the Lebavat Rebi, so we'll have to agree to
- 1:11:02Speaker 2: disagree on howban.
- 1:11:09Speaker 1: This series was originally recorded in twenty twenty and twenty
- 1:11:12Speaker 1: twenty one as part of an ongoing lecture series. To
- 1:11:15Speaker 1: sign up to attend the lecture on zoom, please visit
- 1:11:17Speaker 1: toronmotion dot org. Please rate and review us in your
- 1:11:20Speaker 1: favorite podcast app, or even better, tell a friend to
- 1:11:22Speaker 1: give the podcast to listen