Latest / Two Talking Fools Podcast / Wrong About Alvin Part 1: Unraveling the Mystery of Alvin Ridley
Transcript
- 0:00Music.
- 0:10Day, Shabs. I'm good, buddy. How are you? Oh, you know, I'm excited.
- 0:13I know. You know, I know. I know you're excited. I'm excited and we'll all be excited together.
- 0:19Welcome back. We welcome back to the two talking fools.
- 0:23We are the two talking fools, just two average and I mean, average girls taking
- 0:29their phone calls to the podcast.
- 0:32So you guys, you guys, we brought so many interviews recently. We have so many in store.
- 0:40This one that we're doing today, I'm like shaking.
- 0:45It's wild. You guys asked and we will deliver for you. Well, you know what it is?
- 0:52Why in the true crime, crime has taken, back in the day, what was that show
- 0:57we had? We had Unsolved Mysteries.
- 0:59You remember that? And there are other shows. I think that was the start,
- 1:03the love for true crime and crime, you know,
- 1:07series and shows and stories you and like
- 1:09all that stuff all that stuff and today you crazies
- 1:13out there who love it you love these stories and I I mean that I mean that with
- 1:19love and sincere real stories though yeah the real ones like the real ones the
- 1:23real ones we have a we have a goodie for you today our friend we have a goodie
- 1:27for you today we promoted this a little bit.
- 1:31You guys are aware that we're doing this. Here we are.
- 1:35Alvin, the Alvin Ridley case. Do a shubs. Wild.
- 1:42On the show today, we have McCracken Poston Jr.
- 1:46Do I have that right, McCracken? You got it. Okay.
- 1:50And I did, we did, we did talk about earlier about making sure we say this right
- 1:56because you are, you're in the South and we're in the North and we can get names mixed up.
- 2:00Shout out to our friends in Georgia, by the way.
- 2:04You don't have a monopoly on that.
- 2:09All right. So welcome, welcome, welcome to the podcast.
- 2:14You guys, I just want to introduce you.
- 2:17McCracken Poston Jr. is on the podcast. American criminal defense attorney.
- 2:23He gained national attention for several notable cases, which were featured
- 2:28on TV series, such as CNN Presents, Dateline NBC, A&E, American Justice, Forensic Files.
- 2:36Poston, you were elected and
- 2:38served as state representative in the Georgia House of Representatives.
- 2:42Your account in 2024, your account and representation of Alvin Ridley in the
- 2:481999 murder trial where Ridley was accused of imprisoning his wife for decades
- 2:54before killing her, was published in,
- 2:58titled Zenith Man, Death, Love, and Redemption in a Georgia Courtroom. No exceptions.
- 3:09That's not part of the title. No exceptions. And that's not part of the title.
- 3:13And we have McCracken on today. Thank you for having me. This is a great honor.
- 3:20Your reputation precedes you. I've listened to some of your episodes and was
- 3:26very excited at the invitation.
- 3:28Thank you very much. Thank you.
- 3:31The story of Alvin, and we're going to get into that and we're going to dive
- 3:35deep, but what intrigued me about this story was the evolution of Alvin.
- 3:41Off air, we did talk. Every town, and I feel like every small town,
- 3:47even though you're down in Georgia, we're here in Connecticut, we have small towns.
- 3:51We have Alvin's here too. Oh, absolutely.
- 3:54And then when you think about it, the Alvins that you speak of,
- 3:57everybody already has their idea
- 4:00of their thoughts based off of their interaction with said individual.
- 4:05It could be somebody who, you know, maybe socially awkward to some or somebody
- 4:10who doesn't really talk to many people or, you know, but you always,
- 4:14like you said, every town has that Alvin Ridley.
- 4:17And sadly, because we've become more insular, I believe,
- 4:24over the last couple of generations, that these individuals used to be tolerated a lot better.
- 4:33And, you know, in a small town, you generally know their names or they've been given a nickname.
- 4:41And in bigger cities, they just kind of blend in with usually economically disadvantaged.
- 4:52And they're just kind of lumped together.
- 4:55But every town, all of us have an Alvin in our lives.
- 5:00Oh, absolutely. We do. We do. And I think that's why this particular story is going to,
- 5:08for some of you it's going to enlighten you for some
- 5:11of you it's going to make it's going to make you think for some of you it might
- 5:14it might change the way you conduct in simple interactions with the albans in
- 5:19your you know and the stories is is it's just an incredible one so and to remember
- 5:25that people are innocent until they are proven guilty beyond a reason thank you,
- 5:30Okay. Well, you know, Shabba, I mean, I have to say this. You have always wanted to be a lawyer.
- 5:36So this is true.
- 5:41Never too late. So let's start at the beginning.
- 5:46I would love for you to just paint us a picture of the town.
- 5:51Paint us a picture of just set the stage.
- 5:56Where are we at here? Well, we would love to have you visit Ringgold, Georgia.
- 6:00It is up in the northwest corner of Georgia, just below Chattanooga, Tennessee.
- 6:08As a matter of fact, Catoosa County abuts the state line and the Chattanooga, Tennessee city limits.
- 6:15So we have grown to be a kind of an extension of Chattanooga in the last couple
- 6:23of decades, especially.
- 6:25But it's always been, because of its geographic position, very close to northeast
- 6:32Alabama, abutting Chattanooga, Tennessee.
- 6:36Pretty close to the western extension of North Carolina.
- 6:42And because Tennessee is not a very tall state. We're a short drive from Virginia and Kentucky.
- 6:50And with Georgia's somewhat one-stop shopping marriage laws,
- 6:56we became the marriage capital of the South.
- 7:01You've heard of six degrees of separation.
- 7:04You're probably closer than six degrees to somebody who got married in Ringgold,
- 7:11Georgia over the last several decades.
- 7:14So much that Dolly Parton slipped down from Nashville with her recently lost husband, Carl Dean.
- 7:24That's right. And they married in May of 1966.
- 7:29About three weeks later, another couple went and got their marriage license.
- 7:35A young soldier about to get out of his army obligation named Alvin Ridley and
- 7:44his fiancee from nearby town Rossville, Georgia,
- 7:49whose name was Virginia Hickey.
- 7:51They got their license three weeks after Dolly and Carl.
- 7:56They waited a few more weeks before getting married.
- 8:00But by the time George Jones and Tammy Wynette came to Ringgold,
- 8:06Georgia, to get married, Virginia was missing.
- 8:09There was an article in the local paper that her parents put in with her photo
- 8:16saying that their daughter was missing, last seen with her husband, Alvin Ridley.
- 8:22Well, this was a huge insult to the young couple because they had already fended
- 8:29off her parents who were very religious.
- 8:33This was a dry county back in the day and even when I was growing up.
- 8:39But we had the cheat of a state line.
- 8:43It was very wet above it, so we could go get our booze across the line.
- 8:50And that allowed us to remain pious and pure in North Georgia,
- 8:55according to what the officials wanted.
- 8:57So it became, it made it last a lot longer than it should have, probably.
- 9:03We lost a lot of tax revenue, in other words, to Tennessee.
- 9:07Yes. So in any event, Virginia's parents staged a raid looking for beer in the
- 9:14young couple's apartment. And that really made them upset.
- 9:23I knew Alvin from most of my childhood because he had a Zenith TV dealership in town.
- 9:34My father loved doing business, preferred doing business with outsider types.
- 9:43So Alvin's shop did not look like your classic TV shop with the very well-designed living room scenes.
- 9:55It was a concrete-floored place with new TVs in boxes and stacked on top of
- 10:03boxes and old disemboweled TVs on a table that he was working on.
- 10:11And he was an odd character.
- 10:15McCracken, I want to stop you there. What did the town—I believe you said that—so
- 10:22you said your dad was fond of Alvin.
- 10:25He had no problems with him. But what was the town like? What would some people say about Alvin?
- 10:32Well, Alvin—my sister went to high school with him. And my sister said,
- 10:37well, he's odd. He's weird.
- 10:40But you know it was I was quite young so
- 10:43I don't even remember the time that they were in high school together
- 10:46but I do remember him being an unusual tv repairman my sisters and I we wore
- 10:54out the tuner knob going from channel 3 to channel 9 to channel 12 the three
- 10:59channels we could get out of Chattanooga and because of the mountains we're
- 11:02in the southern Appalachians we couldn't get the Atlanta signals.
- 11:06So we just wore out 3912, 3912. The knob literally wore off.
- 11:12And my father contacted Alvin and my mother apparently out working in the garden
- 11:19or something just waved him on in the house.
- 11:22And I was watching live wrestling as a kid about 12 or 13 and,
- 11:27you know, beating up the couch cushions.
- 11:31And suddenly I realized there's a strange man behind me.
- 11:35And it was Alvin Ridley. Now,
- 11:39I didn't remember this until the representation of Alvin, because I represented
- 11:45him for his charge of murder later in life and charged with murdering his wife.
- 11:53I didn't remember this event until during the representation,
- 11:59Alvin just dropped a bomb in conversation that he had met Andre the Giant, the wrestler. Yeah.
- 12:08And that Andre the Giant ate, as Alvin said it, two dozen eggs and a loaf of bread for breakfast.
- 12:18And it triggered a memory of the conversation I had with the TV repairman because
- 12:26he was speaking my language now.
- 12:28He was telling me something that I went to school to tell everybody I knew somebody
- 12:33who knew Andre the Giant.
- 12:34Right. And so when he told it to me again, it kind of endeared me to Alvin.
- 12:40I realized I've got a history with this guy. Yeah.
- 12:44But the problem was Alvin was extremely difficult.
- 12:50The way he first approached me when we heard that, well, by the way,
- 12:56Alvin shuttered his business inexplicably in 1984.
- 13:03And he used to post these missives on the inside of the glass that were typed
- 13:08out on this old typewriter with,
- 13:11you know, it looked like a serial killer's typewriter with all the hanging letters
- 13:16and, you know, it was a forensic scientist, you know,
- 13:21real, real hit.
- 13:23But he would rattle on about that the county, and I'm using air quotes here,
- 13:31illegal seized, because he would turn illegally and seized into one word, illegal seized.
- 13:38That they illegal seized his van in 1984.
- 13:44Well, the more I realized, this reminded me that Alvin was well known as a frivolous
- 13:54litigant in a lot of civil litigation that always got dismissed.
- 13:58And somebody did a counterclaim, thought they had a judgment,
- 14:04and had the county seize an asset, which was a 1977 Chevy van,
- 14:12which in 1984 wasn't that old, and it was seized.
- 14:18And Alvin just went just off the wall about this seizure, and it became the
- 14:25focus for the rest of his life, really,
- 14:28of government interference with his business, government destruction of his
- 14:34business, and it was an obsession.
- 14:38And so when I started representing him as he began to be questioned about his
- 14:44wife, because nobody had seen her since the parents put that article,
- 14:50that's what I thought, that nobody had seen her since they ran that article in 1968.
- 14:56And here it was 1997, 29 years later. Yeah, see, that's the thing.
- 15:02That's the thing, though. How does that happen? How does somebody at not.
- 15:07Right, Shabba? I mean, you were saying like. Yeah, I was saying because I was
- 15:11watching something on YouTube where the sister who was it, Trixie,
- 15:15I think her name was, who had said that they hadn't seen her in 30 something years.
- 15:19And to me, that's a hard pill to swallow because and by no means am I saying
- 15:25anything negatively about the family. I'm just saying what I've viewed.
- 15:29That is very interesting that they could say they haven't seen
- 15:32somebody in 30 something years and you accuse you know
- 15:35somebody of you know you accuse a spouse of keeping their
- 15:38wife away from their family but the only effort that
- 15:41was made was an article that was put out saying that
- 15:44she was missing that doesn't i don't understand how people just automatically
- 15:47believed that alvin did something to her i don't know oh that was not the only
- 15:52effort that was made but but all of their efforts were deeply resented by both
- 15:59Alvin and Virginia, I later learned.
- 16:03And I have five sisters. I grew up with five sisters.
- 16:10If any of them had married a guy who behaved strangely and then they disappeared,
- 16:15I understand. I think I would have been on top of trying to flush her out.
- 16:23And the Hickeys were doing the same thing So, you know, I think everybody was
- 16:29acting On what they thought was, you know.
- 16:34Everyone's best interest And even the prosecutors Do you think it's just blushing
- 16:39him out Or was it out of concern for her, though?
- 16:42Well, I think it was, you know There was some resentment For some reason,
- 16:49they really blamed Alvin um,
- 16:52When, you know, late, late in the case, I realized that Virginia would seem
- 16:57to be the one in charge of their relationship.
- 17:00But that's that gets to the end of the story.
- 17:03Alvin, Alvin was just odd, but he was a hell of a TV repairman.
- 17:12And he seemed to be just gifted at TV repair.
- 17:19And it was amazing how good he was, and that's the thing my dad admired.
- 17:30He had one Better Business Bureau complaint, which was later withdrawn.
- 17:37He told a lady that you live too close to this mountain.
- 17:41Channel 3 is always going to have this shadow on it. She filed a complaint against
- 17:45him. she had two more TV people out there trying to fix it. They told her the same thing.
- 17:51So she withdrew her complaint. That made Alvin very proud that he had such a good reputation.
- 17:57And that's one way that I could get a normally hard to focus client to focus.
- 18:05For example, Alvin just sees me on the street.
- 18:10I had just had my ass whipped in a race for the United States Congress.
- 18:17I actually saw him the night that I got my ass wept.
- 18:21I said goodbye to everybody. I called my opponent and conceded defeat.
- 18:28And I had been winning my district in the Georgia State House by margins of like 70 percent.
- 18:36And then what happened was I was a Democrat.
- 18:41And the red tide of change was happening in Georgia and it washed up to the
- 18:49corner that election cycle and the state pretty much flipped completely.
- 18:57And so I was, of course, taking it all too personally, like it was about me,
- 19:04but you can't, but you can't help to do that.
- 19:07But I was very resentful that I didn't even win my home county that I had served
- 19:17and I felt bled for trying to do the right things.
- 19:24I passed Georgia's first lobbyist registration and reporting law where they
- 19:30had to report the gifts they gave legislators.
- 19:33That made me such a popular guy under the Gold Dome, but it was extremely popular
- 19:40outside of the Gold Dome of the Georgia Capitol. Right. And so...
- 19:45So I really felt like I had done everything right to get such an insulting,
- 19:50overwhelming defeat was just, I couldn't understand it.
- 19:56So I was a little sore.
- 19:59And when I saw everybody jumping, Alvin, who I remembered was,
- 20:04you know, my dad's TV man and my sister's classmate.
- 20:10I accepted when he kind of stalked me on the street and we started up a conversation.
- 20:18The problem was he could never remain on the right conversation because he wanted
- 20:24to talk about the government illegal seizing his ban 15 years before.
- 20:30And to him, that was the downfall of everything.
- 20:34And that after that, his father died,
- 20:40his mother died, and then his wife died, that they were all worried to death
- 20:45by the way the county had done Alvin and ruined his business by taking his van.
- 20:51So it just was not making any sense to me.
- 20:54And I found out and decided early on, And, well, if I am going to represent
- 20:59this guy, and when I try to right now to get him to talk about his wife,
- 21:05and he turns it into a conversation about a 1977 Chevy van,
- 21:11I do not think this is the kind of guy I would want to put on the stand.
- 21:16And so it was kind of understood that, you know, people would not understand
- 21:22how he could be so unwilling to talk about his wife.
- 21:30And so he kind of accepted it when I said it.
- 21:33But the problem was I was getting frustrated that he kept talking about the van.
- 21:39Well, first, he did not want to make an appointment.
- 21:43And my dad gave him my home number.
- 21:48And so I would get calls in the middle of the night.
- 21:52I'd also gone through a divorce. I was trying to start dating again.
- 21:57And, you know, I would have, you know, someone over and I would get these screaming
- 22:02calls from Alvin Ridley that you could hear outside of the phone handset.
- 22:09And he was always seemed like on the side of a road screaming into a payphone,
- 22:16and so I realized he didn't have a phone anymore in his home and this was,
- 22:24You know, the cell phones were around, but not a lot of people had them.
- 22:30So it was just, it was very frustrating to me.
- 22:34And so I made a compromise with him then and there, which was my first compromise.
- 22:40And I said, Alvin, or I think I called him Mr. Ridley at the time.
- 22:44I said, Mr. Ridley, you don't have to make an appointment.
- 22:48He didn't like people knowing where he was going to be at any given time. Okay.
- 22:53So I said, I said, you don't have to make an appointment. Just drop by my office
- 22:57anytime you see my car there and I'll stop what I'm doing and I'll talk to you.
- 23:02But please quit calling me at home unless it's the most dire emergency.
- 23:06So he agreed, and I premised it by saying, you and your wife were very private
- 23:12people, and I just kind of am as well.
- 23:17And I think that was the way to approach Alvin, was to acknowledge him and then say, okay, me too.
- 23:26So let's be a large utilizing the policy and showing up at my office.
- 23:33And we would end up yelling at each other because he would always bring up the
- 23:391977 Chevy van, illegal C's.
- 23:44And at one point in my office, I just...
- 23:49I heard the word van, and I went, the van, oh, Lord.
- 23:54Well, Alvin went silent, and I looked up, and he had his eyes closed tight and
- 24:00his hands clasped together.
- 24:02He obviously thought I was praying, and he assumed the prayer position.
- 24:09And I thought, I can work with this.
- 24:13And so I continued. I said, dear Lord, please help Alvin understand that we
- 24:19really don't need to talk about the van right now.
- 24:22We need to talk about Virginia.
- 24:25And, you know, please help him understand, oh Lord.
- 24:28And from then on, as a part of every one of our meetings, we had a prayer where
- 24:35I could, he would just sit and listen while I actually gave his legal advice.
- 24:41If I tried to do it outside of a prayer, he would interrupt me and scream at me. So beautiful.
- 24:48That was a wonderful compromise that we were able to do.
- 24:54Meanwhile, I'm kind of getting ridiculed from the town, you know,
- 24:59having fallen from the political sky.
- 25:05Suddenly, then I'm associating with this guy. one of our lower judges commented
- 25:10that with concern, he said, folks are saying you two deserve each other.
- 25:16And I just took that as a, you know, if this town doesn't like this guy and
- 25:22this town obviously doesn't like me, I'm going to help this guy.
- 25:26And still, that was hard. It was so hard.
- 25:30And the way that finally got me in,
- 25:35completely locked in to helping Alvin Ridley, no matter what,
- 25:39was when my secretary stuck her head in the door with a phone slip and said,
- 25:46Congressman Deal called and wants to talk to you.
- 25:50Well, that's the guy that less than two years before had just whipped my ass
- 25:54in this congressional race.
- 25:57He had gotten elected as a Democrat. I had helped him.
- 26:01He switched parties after telling everybody he would never do such a thing.
- 26:07And he beat me badly. So he read the tea leaves.
- 26:11I mean, if you're thinking it from purely self-interest, he read the tea leaves
- 26:16and he did the right thing for him.
- 26:18Um, I, you know,
- 26:21grew up as a Southern Democrat and I just felt like switching was very self-serving
- 26:29that you should do it before you offer for a reelection and not after you've
- 26:34just gotten reelected. Fair.
- 26:36So after the 1986, uh, no, 94, 90, 1994 election, Newt Gingrich from Georgia was.
- 26:48Became speaker and was putting the heavy pressure because that was an adjacent
- 26:53district and Nathan deal switched.
- 26:58And so then, then he whipped my ass and now, and now I'm getting a call from him.
- 27:06Well, Alvin's across the table and he just kind of straightens up.
- 27:10Like he's impressed. And I'm thinking, he even thinks this is about him.
- 27:16And I just thought, because Alvin and later I learned Virginia had this for
- 27:23every, they were paranoid about all the local and state governments.
- 27:28But for every ounce of paranoia and distrust they had about those governments,
- 27:35they had pounds of hope from the federal government.
- 27:40And that reared its head many times in this representation where Alvin would
- 27:47do something and run to the feds for help.
- 27:50And while I haplessly tried to chase him down and, you know,
- 27:57get him to cooperate with me.
- 28:01So Alvin said, well, ain't you going to call the congressman back?
- 28:05And I thought, yes, you know, at the end of our prayer, I said, yeah, why not?
- 28:13And as I wrote in the book, I thought maybe he wants to get my opinion on something.
- 28:18And maybe it's a nice, you know, peace offering.
- 28:22Maybe he's going to put me on a committee or something. Sure.
- 28:25And then I thought, hell no. You know, once you get beat in Georgia politics,
- 28:29it's pretty long lasting.
- 28:32And you have no power. Nobody wants to put you on any committees.
- 28:37So I called him back. And thank God I didn't put him on speakerphone.
- 28:42Because when I got through the operator, the familiar voice of Nathan Deal comes on the phone.
- 28:49I hadn't talked to him since I conceded defeat.
- 28:52And he said, I need you to keep Alvin Ridley away from my congressional offices.
- 29:00So it was about Alvin. And I'm sitting there awkwardly thinking,
- 29:06and I said, well, Congressman, good to hear from you.
- 29:08I will pass it on. And then Deal added, he's scaring the ladies there.
- 29:15Well, Alvin was petitioning his government for help, and so he was very strong
- 29:22about his right to do that, and now suddenly he's getting cut off from that
- 29:27right. So I hung up the phone.
- 29:30I asked Alvin to walk outside with me.
- 29:34For one, I didn't want to be overheard in the office saying this,
- 29:38but I had to think really fast. How am I going to break this to him?
- 29:44I'm already realizing how much hope he puts in the federal government.
- 29:48Now here's a whole branch of the federal government that is saying,
- 29:52I'm going to have you arrested if you come to my office again.
- 29:57And that's why Deal called me. He's giving the guy's lawyer notice.
- 30:01And once he gets that notice, the next time he shows up, he's subject to arrest for trespassing.
- 30:09That concludes this episode from this mini-series, Wrong About Alvin,
- 30:14our exclusive interview with McCracken Poston Jr.
- 30:18Thank you for listening. Thank you for your support and stay tuned.
- 30:21Another episode's coming.