Latest / Behind the Bastards / It Could Happen Here Weekly 90
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Hey everybody. Robert Evans here, and I wanted to let
- 0:02Speaker 1: you know this is a compilation episode, So every episode
- 0:06Speaker 1: of the week that just happened is here in one
- 0:09Speaker 1: convenient and with somewhat less ads package for you to
- 0:13Speaker 1: listen to in a long stretch if you want. If
- 0:15Speaker 1: you've been listening to the episodes every day this week,
- 0:17Speaker 1: there's going to be nothing new here for you, but
- 0:19Speaker 1: you can make your own decisions.
- 0:26Speaker 2: Hello everyone, and welcome to it could Happen Here podcast,
- 0:29Speaker 2: which I'm recording at eight in the morning and best
- 0:31Speaker 2: without any of my colleagues, and I'm joined today to
- 0:35Speaker 2: discuss the technological aspects of the border regime by Austin
- 0:41Speaker 2: Coca of Syracuse University and by Jake Quiener of the
- 0:45Speaker 2: Electronic Privacy Information Center. Hi guys, good morning.
- 0:49Speaker 3: How are you doing.
- 0:49Speaker 2: James good, I'm very excited to talk more border stuff.
- 0:53Speaker 2: I like covering this, even though it's sometimes terrible. So
- 0:57Speaker 2: what I wanted to start off with is I think
- 0:59Speaker 2: our listen as be familiar with CBP one, right, the
- 1:02Speaker 2: most cursed cell phone up of all time, and both
- 1:06Speaker 2: of you have written a lot and very insightfully about
- 1:10Speaker 2: CBP one so I thought we could kind of do
- 1:13Speaker 2: a little bit of a breakdown of a the issues
- 1:16Speaker 2: with it and be like with the issues with it
- 1:18Speaker 2: as an app, and then the fact that we're using
- 1:20Speaker 2: an app being a problem inherently. So perhaps we could
- 1:24Speaker 2: start with I know, Jake, you mentioned you wanted to
- 1:27Speaker 2: talk a little bit about the design of the app.
- 1:29Speaker 2: So in the process of sort of commissioning it and
- 1:32Speaker 2: making it, should we start there?
- 1:33Speaker 4: Yeah, And I think this story is pretty interesting and
- 1:36Speaker 4: unique because CBP one was built in house by a
- 1:41Speaker 4: small team at the Office of Field Operations. Wow CBP Yeah,
- 1:47Speaker 4: which is it is unique? Like, yeah, there's one other
- 1:52Speaker 4: app that they built, and I don't really know of
- 1:56Speaker 4: other mobile apps that have been rolled out with anything
- 1:59Speaker 4: close to the size of CBP one that have been
- 2:02Speaker 4: designed by a government agency.
- 2:04Speaker 2: Yeah, that's kind of an odd choice.
- 2:07Speaker 3: You know.
- 2:07Speaker 4: Conceptually, it's not something I'm critical of, Like, I think,
- 2:11Speaker 4: if we're going to have a government that's providing services,
- 2:14Speaker 4: it's good for them to do things in house. It
- 2:17Speaker 4: means you're not relying on third parties who are able
- 2:22Speaker 4: to like use information from the app and benefit off
- 2:26Speaker 4: of it. But it doesn't mean you need the institutional
- 2:28Speaker 4: competency to be able to design an app and so
- 2:34Speaker 4: to just like provide a quick history. Basically, a CBP
- 2:39Speaker 4: one app was built off of the framework of an
- 2:41Speaker 4: older app called CBP Rome. That app was used just
- 2:46Speaker 4: for people boating on the Great Lakes because technically, if
- 2:50Speaker 4: you go like voting on Lake Michigan, you will leave
- 2:52Speaker 4: the United States if you chase a fish over the
- 2:55Speaker 4: boundary to Canada. Yeah, and CBP felt that it was
- 2:59Speaker 4: very important the people who did that reported leaving and
- 3:02Speaker 4: coming back into the United States. Yeah, right, questionable, but
- 3:08Speaker 4: they built an app to let people do that, and
- 3:12Speaker 4: the framework for that app used a GPS ping to
- 3:15Speaker 4: verify when you're back in the US.
- 3:17Speaker 2: Okay, this is a small app, you know.
- 3:20Speaker 4: I don't think they encountered too many problems with it
- 3:22Speaker 4: because you're maybe a couple hundred visitors a day. And
- 3:27Speaker 4: on that framework they built out CBP one to do
- 3:31Speaker 4: a couple of things. It's used for folks like customs folks.
- 3:36Speaker 4: So if you're importing goods into the country, you can
- 3:39Speaker 4: do some of that reporting through CBP one and also
- 3:42Speaker 4: use it to apply for the and obtain the I
- 3:44Speaker 4: ninety four Travel form, which is the forum that like
- 3:47Speaker 4: most folks coming to the United States are going to
- 3:49Speaker 4: need and then critically for our uses, is that if
- 3:53Speaker 4: you are applying for asylum, you can use it to
- 3:56Speaker 4: schedule an appointment.
- 3:58Speaker 2: Yeah, that's been the of my reporting on it, is
- 4:01Speaker 2: that the bulk of its use I think so, yeah, okay,
- 4:05Speaker 2: and so I'm still blown away with the fact they
- 4:08Speaker 2: designed in house. It's crazy. Did you ever find that
- 4:11Speaker 2: job did job posting? So people who designed it or
- 4:13Speaker 2: did they just like get some people who were good
- 4:15Speaker 2: to it to kind of take a swing at it.
- 4:18Speaker 4: So, as far as I know from you know, I've
- 4:20Speaker 4: talked to one of the people involved in the creation.
- 4:23Speaker 4: I think Austin has as well. My understanding is that
- 4:26Speaker 4: it was like an in house team that already existed. Okay,
- 4:29Speaker 4: but Austin, you may be able to clarify that.
- 4:31Speaker 3: Yeah, that's my understanding too. I think they have a
- 4:34Speaker 3: technology team within the agency that was using technology in
- 4:39Speaker 3: various ways. I don't think we have a full understanding
- 4:42Speaker 3: of the scope of their responsibilities and the work that
- 4:45Speaker 3: they've done. I think, to Jake's point, it is quite
- 4:48Speaker 3: interesting that they produce something for the public It's not unusual,
- 4:52Speaker 3: of course for large agencies to have teams in house
- 4:56Speaker 3: that deal with all of the general technology call challenges
- 5:00Speaker 3: that that every agency in twenty twenty three faces, you know, databases,
- 5:06Speaker 3: you know, keeping government cell phones working and secure and
- 5:09Speaker 3: all of that, all of that kind of thing. But
- 5:11Speaker 3: a lot of the things that are public facing from
- 5:13Speaker 3: federal agencies tend to be contracted out to a private
- 5:17Speaker 3: vendor in some way. So this is it's quite unique,
- 5:20Speaker 3: and but I don't think we have a false scope
- 5:23Speaker 3: of what they what they are aren't producing in house.
- 5:27Speaker 2: Yeah, they that's interesting because they heavily rely on outside
- 5:30Speaker 2: contractors for so much of it. Like there's a whole
- 5:32Speaker 2: industry that you know, starts here in San Diego and
- 5:35Speaker 2: goes over to Tucson and are probably further into New
- 5:38Speaker 2: Mexico of people providing surveillance technology to border patrol and
- 5:43Speaker 2: then you know, it goes over to the West Bank too.
- 5:46Speaker 2: Lots of lots of it can be seen. Having talked
- 5:48Speaker 2: about they sort of unique approach to design, it's probably
- 5:52Speaker 2: a good idea to then talk about the implementation of
- 5:54Speaker 2: zapp and it's kind of lacklusters and understandment it just
- 5:57Speaker 2: fucking sucks. It's terrible. So like, in what many ways
- 6:04Speaker 2: has it been unfit for the purpose that it's supposed
- 6:07Speaker 2: to do. So I guess first we can talk about
- 6:09Speaker 2: technological and inadequacies, and then more broadly about why this
- 6:13Speaker 2: isn't a problem you can really solve with an app
- 6:15Speaker 2: on a telephone that needs to broadband and Wi Fi.
- 6:18Speaker 4: Yeah, so I'll start by saying that I think a
- 6:20Speaker 4: lot of what's happening with the problem the CPP one
- 6:24Speaker 4: app is institutional blindness. So the people who design the app,
- 6:29Speaker 4: I genuinely think want it to work well, and I
- 6:33Speaker 4: think they're simply not asking the questions that you need
- 6:37Speaker 4: to be asking. And when you design app like this,
- 6:39Speaker 4: which is who's really going to be using it? What
- 6:42Speaker 4: are their needs? What technology? What wireless services today? What
- 6:47Speaker 4: phones are they using? Basically like, if you're someone on
- 6:52Speaker 4: the southern border with very little money and probably an
- 6:55Speaker 4: outdated phone, yes, are you going to be able to
- 6:58Speaker 4: use this app?
- 6:58Speaker 3: Not a great camera?
- 7:01Speaker 4: And so I think the first place to start with
- 7:04Speaker 4: that is simply the fact that the app requires a
- 7:06Speaker 4: strong Wi Fi or sale signal to use, which is
- 7:10Speaker 4: not always present. And I think Austin has some good
- 7:14Speaker 4: insight into the problems with insufficient Wi Fi.
- 7:19Speaker 3: Yeah, definitely, you know, I think some of what's interesting
- 7:23Speaker 3: here is the way not only that the app relies
- 7:25Speaker 3: on Wi Fi, but then the kind of real world
- 7:29Speaker 3: social consequences here for how people then try to cope
- 7:32Speaker 3: with these problems. I want to take one step back,
- 7:34Speaker 3: just really quickly and discuss the world that CBP was
- 7:38Speaker 3: dropped into, because there's some important context here. So as
- 7:43Speaker 3: I know you've already covered James. You know, over the
- 7:46Speaker 3: past three years, the dominant border control policy was titled
- 7:51Speaker 3: forty two, a COVID era policy that was purportedly motivated
- 7:59Speaker 3: by concerns about public health. This is where title forty
- 8:02Speaker 3: two comes from. Title forty two of the US Code
- 8:04Speaker 3: pertains to issues of questions of public health. It's not
- 8:08Speaker 3: an immigration policy. It was a public health policy, although
- 8:11Speaker 3: detailed reporting has I think pretty well established that it
- 8:16Speaker 3: was more of a political moment of political opportunism rather
- 8:20Speaker 3: than a legitimate public health concern. But regardless, that policy
- 8:25Speaker 3: allowed Customs and Border Protection to effectively turn back anyone
- 8:30Speaker 3: who arrived at the border, whether they attempted to cross
- 8:32Speaker 3: unlawfully or not, and the primary human rights concern here
- 8:36Speaker 3: was people who were seeking asylum, which is their right
- 8:39Speaker 3: to do. One of the aspects of Title forty two
- 8:44Speaker 3: was that there was a rare exemption clause built in
- 8:47Speaker 3: that allowed people who were particularly vulnerable a.
- 8:50Speaker 5: Particular humanitarian concern.
- 8:54Speaker 3: To attempt to effectively apply for this kind of exemption.
- 8:59Speaker 3: Until Anuary of this year, that process was run by
- 9:01Speaker 3: nonprofit organizations. CBP had this sort of informal outsourced system
- 9:07Speaker 3: where NGOs on the Mexican side of the border would
- 9:10Speaker 3: effectively conduct massive amounts of intake and prioritization and triaging
- 9:16Speaker 3: of these cases and then submit you know, names to
- 9:20Speaker 3: CBP to a lot of people to come through ports
- 9:22Speaker 3: of entry. CBP one effectively replaced that system in January,
- 9:29Speaker 3: which meant that instead of migrants going through the NGOs,
- 9:33Speaker 3: they would have to download this app, fill out the
- 9:35Speaker 3: information and send it in. This is really important to
- 9:37Speaker 3: mention because the groundwork was actually laid by a tremendous
- 9:41Speaker 3: amount of effectively unpaid labor on the backs of NGOs
- 9:45Speaker 3: on the southern side of the border. And you know,
- 9:49Speaker 3: is it is fair and accurate to say that this
- 9:51Speaker 3: was an extremely imperfect system and that there were absolutely,
- 9:55Speaker 3: you know, significant issues with this. But one of the
- 9:59Speaker 3: interesting things is that the role that NGO's played meant
- 10:03Speaker 3: that people coming and seeking asylum would then in some
- 10:08Speaker 3: ways be potentially connected with a broader network of NGOs
- 10:13Speaker 3: support services, advocacy and so forth. So the introduction of
- 10:17Speaker 3: CBP one purportedly bypassed the work of NGOs in screening
- 10:22Speaker 3: people for the exemption process. However, NGOs still ended up
- 10:27Speaker 3: performing all this kind of invisible labor because they're the
- 10:29Speaker 3: ones who effectively were working with migrants to make Wi
- 10:33Speaker 3: Fi available. And it's not just Wi Fi, it's actually
- 10:37Speaker 3: charging your phone. When I visited shelters and camps on
- 10:40Speaker 3: the southern side of the border at the end of
- 10:42Speaker 3: twenty twenty two, a big part of their having camps
- 10:48Speaker 3: and shelters was actually providing electricity, you know, when I
- 10:51Speaker 3: was there, and I know others have reported on this, James,
- 10:54Speaker 3: I'm sure you've seen this too. You know, people would
- 10:57Speaker 3: be huddled around the outlets because they needed to charge
- 11:01Speaker 3: their phone, if their phone didn't work, if their phone
- 11:03Speaker 3: wasn't charged, they didn't have access. Prior to CBP one,
- 11:07Speaker 3: this was already a challenge because the primary form of
- 11:10Speaker 3: communication with CBP was phone calls. They would individuals would
- 11:14Speaker 3: get phone calls. In fact, I interviewed the Russian family
- 11:17Speaker 3: on the Mexican side of the border and Matamotos in
- 11:21Speaker 3: last November and a family now they and many of
- 11:26Speaker 3: the other migrants I spoke with, and this was also
- 11:28Speaker 3: true for many migrants. By the way, the families, typically
- 11:32Speaker 3: the wife and children, if there were a family unit,
- 11:35Speaker 3: would stay either in a hotel or a shelter or
- 11:37Speaker 3: someplace that was more safe, and then the men would
- 11:40Speaker 3: effectively have the nights on the street where they could
- 11:44Speaker 3: actually get cell phone coverage and things like that. So
- 11:48Speaker 3: CBP one introduced all of these kind of technological demands.
- 11:51Speaker 3: It's not that they weren't there before, but I think
- 11:54Speaker 3: it's a different matter when you go from interacting with
- 11:58Speaker 3: a network of NGOs to say saying, now you're actually
- 12:01Speaker 3: interacting with the US government and this is the only
- 12:04Speaker 3: way that you're going to be able to enter the country.
- 12:07Speaker 3: I think those demands were quite high. They've clearly had
- 12:11Speaker 3: some tremendously negative impacts from migrants trying.
- 12:13Speaker 5: To come through that way.
- 12:15Speaker 2: Yeah, definitely, I know have one here. But we've bought
- 12:19Speaker 2: so many of these, like solar powered charging brick things
- 12:23Speaker 2: and distributed those. But I have so many photos of
- 12:27Speaker 2: people's hands reaching through the wall and people trying to
- 12:31Speaker 2: charge to their phone on the other side of the wall,
- 12:33Speaker 2: you know, And it's been a big demand for a while.
- 12:35Speaker 2: But it's certainly when CBP were detaining people in places
- 12:38Speaker 2: where you didn't have power and then expecting them to
- 12:40Speaker 2: also communicate using their telephones, that became a particularly sort
- 12:44Speaker 2: of ridiculous issue, very upsetting to see it like done
- 12:49Speaker 2: like that. So, yeah, this app really isn't a solution
- 12:55Speaker 2: for the problem we're facing, which is, as you said,
- 12:57Speaker 2: like a three year backlug on people who have legitimate
- 12:59Speaker 2: sign claims being able to make those asylum claims. And
- 13:04Speaker 2: I guess can we talk about who it favors in,
- 13:09Speaker 2: you know, implementing this system as a catchule, right, not
- 13:12Speaker 2: an option, but the option Who does that favor and
- 13:14Speaker 2: who does it not?
- 13:18Speaker 4: Yeah, before we get there, I think it might be
- 13:20Speaker 4: helpful to just run through, like what it is like
- 13:22Speaker 4: to use CVP one. Oh, yeah, let's talk. You have
- 13:24Speaker 4: to go through because it is a yeah, and that's
- 13:28Speaker 4: when you're thinking about that, think that every step is
- 13:30Speaker 4: a potential failure. Point right, every step you could have
- 13:34Speaker 4: a glitch, And anytime you have a glitch happen, it's
- 13:36Speaker 4: going to kick you out of the app and.
- 13:38Speaker 3: You have to restart.
- 13:40Speaker 4: So, if you're on a southern border you to apply
- 13:44Speaker 4: for asylum, you've been walking for months from Venezuela, Guatemala,
- 13:50Speaker 4: et cetera.
- 13:51Speaker 2: You got your phone.
- 13:53Speaker 4: The first thing you have to do is log into
- 13:55Speaker 4: the app through login dot gov. That's the single sign
- 13:58Speaker 4: on service that many government agencies use. H works fairly well,
- 14:02Speaker 4: but you got you need, so you register yourself a profile.
- 14:06Speaker 4: Then you're going to navigate over. Hopefully you speak one
- 14:09Speaker 4: of the languages that CPP one is available in. As
- 14:13Speaker 4: of now, I believe that's English, Spanish, and Haitian Creole,
- 14:17Speaker 4: although they may have added a new language recently. You
- 14:24Speaker 4: find the right place on the app, not always super clear,
- 14:28Speaker 4: to submit your asylum application and try and schedule an appointment.
- 14:34Speaker 4: And then you're going to have to fill out a
- 14:35Speaker 4: ton of information. You're giving CBP, your name, addresses, people
- 14:41Speaker 4: you know in the US, big form to fill out,
- 14:44Speaker 4: including often information on like how vulnerable you are, so
- 14:49Speaker 4: like are you pregnant, are you disabled? Have you been
- 14:51Speaker 4: threatened in Mexico? Information that they want to use to
- 14:55Speaker 4: prioritize you hopefully, and then you're going to need to
- 14:59Speaker 4: take a facial photo that's going to go into CBP
- 15:03Speaker 4: and Department Homeland Securities databases. It will be run against
- 15:06Speaker 4: facial recognition searches that they populate with, like this massive
- 15:12Speaker 4: facial recognition system, the Traveler Verification Service that can flag
- 15:17Speaker 4: people who are on CBP's target list TSA's target list.
- 15:24Speaker 3: You could be wrongfully flagged.
- 15:25Speaker 4: By that because facial recognition is not a perfect technology.
- 15:29Speaker 4: You're also going to take a facial liveness scan. It's
- 15:32Speaker 4: related to facial recognition, but it is different. It's a
- 15:35Speaker 4: different technology and it is untested. There's been no government
- 15:41Speaker 4: agency that has evaluated facial liveness for bias, and that
- 15:46Speaker 4: basically is trying to figure out are you a real
- 15:48Speaker 4: person or are you like a picture of James that
- 15:51Speaker 4: you're holding up because you're trying to get James an
- 15:56Speaker 4: appointment and then sell it to them later or something.
- 16:00Speaker 4: Do the facial liveness scan. That's been the sticking point
- 16:03Speaker 4: where folks with darker skin and indigenous folks have not
- 16:06Speaker 4: been able to get through it. We can talk about
- 16:08Speaker 4: that a little later. Yeah, you're also going to do
- 16:10Speaker 4: a GPS pain so your phone, pulling from both cell
- 16:13Speaker 4: towers and GPS data, is going to try and establish
- 16:16Speaker 4: your location and send it to CBP. That can create
- 16:19Speaker 4: problems if you're pinging off a US cell tower, Suddenly
- 16:22Speaker 4: it's less reliable, might look like you're in the US.
- 16:25Speaker 3: And once you get.
- 16:26Speaker 4: Through all these steps, then you're able to submit your
- 16:29Speaker 4: information and you're in a lottery or whether or not
- 16:33Speaker 4: you get an appointment.
- 16:36Speaker 2: Great. Yeah, let's the photo thing. I think has been
- 16:39Speaker 2: covered maybe I but we've been covered extensively because this
- 16:42Speaker 2: is what I do. But I think maybe some people
- 16:44Speaker 2: aren't aware of the complete inadequacy of those facial liveness scans.
- 16:49Speaker 2: And I know some nonprofit since you want to have
- 16:51Speaker 2: light booths which can help with that, but it's not
- 16:53Speaker 2: you know, it's again like that money could be doing
- 16:57Speaker 2: something more useful, right and then making like a like
- 16:59Speaker 2: a Instagram booth for people who just want to use
- 17:03Speaker 2: the exercise I llegal right to claim asylum. So let's
- 17:05Speaker 2: talk about that that technology and how it's not working.
- 17:10Speaker 3: Yeah, I think one really important factor here, and the
- 17:12Speaker 3: reason I wanted to paint some of the contexts was
- 17:16Speaker 3: and partly selfish because as a geographer, I'm always very
- 17:19Speaker 3: you know, eager to evangelize about the importance of understanding
- 17:23Speaker 3: social geography for thinking about questions of you know, human
- 17:27Speaker 3: rights and asylum and immigration, so the facial life. This
- 17:30Speaker 3: test is a great example of that. So you know,
- 17:34Speaker 3: it's hard to see this unless you've been on the
- 17:36Speaker 3: ground in some of these places. But you know, again,
- 17:40Speaker 3: just a historical thing I think will be pretty non controversial.
- 17:44Speaker 3: Anti black racism is something that's existed for a very
- 17:48Speaker 3: long time. It's not just in the United States. It's
- 17:50Speaker 3: around the world obviously, yeah, not everywhere, but but you know,
- 17:54Speaker 3: obviously through colonialism, through settler colonialism, and so forth. It's
- 17:58Speaker 3: really shaped not just anti black racism, but anti black
- 18:02Speaker 3: racism itself has produced many of the geographies that we have,
- 18:07Speaker 3: from redlining, segregation, educational acts, all kinds of things. The
- 18:11Speaker 3: way that the social world looks today is already shaped
- 18:15Speaker 3: by these issues of racism. What that then means is
- 18:18Speaker 3: questions like who has access to cell phone towers and
- 18:24Speaker 3: fast Wi Fi, and who can afford up to date
- 18:28Speaker 3: smartphones that can meet all of the threshold of require
- 18:33Speaker 3: the technological requirements to this to use this apvenues of
- 18:38Speaker 3: software is already distributed and fractured by questions of race
- 18:44Speaker 3: and identity. What that means is, even if the facial
- 18:47Speaker 3: liveness test worked perfectly and there were no issues with
- 18:54Speaker 3: the software, which is not true, but let's even just
- 18:56Speaker 3: assume that it is still true that acts to that
- 19:00Speaker 3: technology and software is already structured by race. So one
- 19:04Speaker 3: of the things I noticed, you know, having spent time
- 19:06Speaker 3: along the border, was just how much even in some
- 19:09Speaker 3: of the shelters and where black and African migrants had
- 19:14Speaker 3: access to shelter, was itself much tended to be more
- 19:17Speaker 3: pushed to the out outside of the where you're less
- 19:21Speaker 3: likely to get good cell phone coverage, less likely to
- 19:24Speaker 3: have electricity, much more likely that the roads even where
- 19:28Speaker 3: I visited, were not paved. And I was there when
- 19:30Speaker 3: it was raining in Reynosa one day, and you know,
- 19:36Speaker 3: some of the places where African migrants and African families
- 19:40Speaker 3: were staying, and black migrants, by the way from Latin America.
- 19:43Speaker 3: Let's just remind everyone that there are black Latinos living
- 19:47Speaker 3: in Latin America, right, were also pushed you know, more
- 19:51Speaker 3: to the outskirts, and as a result of that, those
- 19:54Speaker 3: factors contributed to access. So it wasn't just issues with
- 19:59Speaker 3: theware itself, which may be there. It's hard for me
- 20:02Speaker 3: to evaluate. It's not, you know, because it's not like
- 20:04Speaker 3: we've done our own evaluation of that. But it's also
- 20:07Speaker 3: all of those contextual factors. And I just want to
- 20:09Speaker 3: make a fine point on this. We know that already.
- 20:12Speaker 3: CBP should understand that already and understand the various social
- 20:17Speaker 3: factors that impact access. So simply saying, for instance, if
- 20:21Speaker 3: one wanted to take a defensive position and say, well, look,
- 20:24Speaker 3: we ran the test, the software works as intended, there's
- 20:27Speaker 3: no racial bias in the software. That doesn't get CBP
- 20:31Speaker 3: out of the responsibility of saying yes, but you absolutely
- 20:34Speaker 3: had all the information and a reasonable person should have
- 20:37Speaker 3: known that this access to this app or had these
- 20:40Speaker 3: kind of technological requirements and that access was not evenly distributed.
- 20:45Speaker 2: Yeah, I think it's really important you said that, actually
- 20:47Speaker 2: because a lot of reporters it does get reporters on.
- 20:50Speaker 2: There are people doing great work, but like sometimes it
- 20:52Speaker 2: gets missed because African migrants might not speak Spanish Black
- 20:55Speaker 2: African migrants and a lot of reporters don't have the
- 21:01Speaker 2: language skills to talk to people in I worked with
- 21:04Speaker 2: a fixer who spoke a Romo and to Grayan and
- 21:09Speaker 2: a lot of other, like five or six other languages,
- 21:11Speaker 2: and that helped to get me an insight into the
- 21:13Speaker 2: very difficult situation that lots of African people face. And
- 21:17Speaker 2: you know that their isolation and the relative lack of
- 21:20Speaker 2: resources even in what's a pretty resource spar setting for everyone,
- 21:24Speaker 2: and Haitian people, I've spoken to a lot of Haitian people.
- 21:28Speaker 2: Plus then you add that, like if I think about
- 21:31Speaker 2: last month, the languages which I was able with through friends,
- 21:36Speaker 2: through translation to speak to people with you know, Vietnamese
- 21:39Speaker 2: command you is a dialect of Kurdish, French, right, Swahili, Spanish,
- 21:45Speaker 2: evidently Dutch aside from Spanish, those are not covered. Maybe
- 21:50Speaker 2: if you're French you can, I think it would be
- 21:53Speaker 2: still hard to work in Haitian creole of you if
- 21:55Speaker 2: you spoke sort of more mainland French, those are not
- 21:59Speaker 2: covered by that, right, so you have to find a
- 22:02Speaker 2: way to access that with via translation, And then it's
- 22:05Speaker 2: very the information makes you incredibly vulnerable to whomever of
- 22:09Speaker 2: you if you're asking someone to share. Right, It's imperfect.
- 22:13Speaker 2: It's not a sufficient way to describe it, but it
- 22:16Speaker 2: extremely flawed system.
- 22:19Speaker 3: To Jake's point, like, I'm also like kind of open
- 22:22Speaker 3: minded about, you know, about using an app like this.
- 22:27Speaker 3: I mean, there's I mean Jake's right, I mean, if
- 22:30Speaker 3: you're going to have a government in twenty twenty three,
- 22:32Speaker 3: like having some reasonably up to date ways to do
- 22:36Speaker 3: things is not an unreasonable expectation.
- 22:39Speaker 5: But there's just so many blatantly.
- 22:41Speaker 3: Obvious sort of shortcomings that are not difficult to identify
- 22:49Speaker 3: in preparing this app and understanding what people are likely
- 22:52Speaker 3: to need, so to have those gaps, and then also
- 22:55Speaker 3: to roll out the app at a time when the
- 23:00Speaker 3: same policy announcement that rolls out this app is also
- 23:03Speaker 3: a policy announcement that says this is the only way
- 23:06Speaker 3: to do it. I mean, imagine if like your new
- 23:08Speaker 3: policy for like healthcare for some you know, particular healthcare
- 23:13Speaker 3: you know, thing was like, we have to go through
- 23:15Speaker 3: this route, and we know that eighty percent of people
- 23:17Speaker 3: aren't going to be able to use this, but now
- 23:19Speaker 3: this is the only treatment you have an.
- 23:20Speaker 5: Option for I mean that would be that it's just strange.
- 23:24Speaker 3: I think I think one thing to just think about
- 23:27Speaker 3: creatively here is I can imagine a phase rollout of
- 23:31Speaker 3: this where they did improve it over time, that they
- 23:33Speaker 3: were adequate, you know, outlets for people who didn't fit
- 23:37Speaker 3: into the categories that they had built into the app.
- 23:41Speaker 3: And I think I think that would be a more
- 23:42Speaker 3: complex and more nuanced than maybe a more more interesting
- 23:46Speaker 3: way to do it. I just don't think I don't
- 23:48Speaker 3: think it was rolled out responsibly in that way.
- 23:51Speaker 4: Yeah, yeah, I think we should be honest that beta
- 23:53Speaker 4: testing an app on hundreds of thousands of the most
- 23:56Speaker 4: vulnerable people in the world is incredibly responsible.
- 24:01Speaker 2: Yeah. Yeah, it's just cruel. It's not in any way appropriate.
- 24:06Speaker 2: So I guess we've talked a lot about this app.
- 24:10Speaker 2: Let's talk about let's say you're fortunate enough to get
- 24:13Speaker 2: an a sign of appointment here to enter the US.
- 24:16Speaker 2: You would then, in most cases enter something which is
- 24:18Speaker 2: called CBP's Alternatives to Detention Systems. Icis, sorry, Yeah, you're right.
- 24:24Speaker 2: Let's explain a little bit like why it's an alternative
- 24:26Speaker 2: to detention? Why would one be detained if you haven't
- 24:29Speaker 2: in theory, done anything wrong, well, in many people's perspective,
- 24:33Speaker 2: have done anything wrong, I guess. And then what does
- 24:36Speaker 2: ATD mean? And then we can get into some of
- 24:39Speaker 2: the privacy issues and the way that it affects not
- 24:43Speaker 2: just migrants but also everyone.
- 24:46Speaker 4: Yeah, one thing before we go there, I think would
- 24:47Speaker 4: be great, just closing the loop on the racial bias discussion.
- 24:54Speaker 4: This is like an element of my advocacy that I
- 24:56Speaker 4: talk about all the time in different areas of like
- 24:59Speaker 4: how fish recognition is used when it's using the criminal
- 25:02Speaker 4: justice system, is that there absolutely is bias in most
- 25:07Speaker 4: facial recognition systems. They work really well for white men
- 25:12Speaker 4: and increase increasingly less well basically as you run down
- 25:15Speaker 4: the privileged spectrum. That's an element of how these systems
- 25:19Speaker 4: are designed, right, It's they get fed a lot of
- 25:22Speaker 4: images of white men and fewer images of other folks.
- 25:27Speaker 4: That's fixable, right, like you can provide a training database
- 25:32Speaker 4: that is a whole, you know, a good spread of people.
- 25:37Speaker 4: It seems to not necessarily have been done with the
- 25:40Speaker 4: facial liveness for CBP one, in part because the British
- 25:45Speaker 4: company that designed it probably did not have access to
- 25:49Speaker 4: a lot of images of the type of people who
- 25:51Speaker 4: would be on the southern border. You're talking about like
- 25:53Speaker 4: Indigenous Mexican folks v. Shield folks, just a very large
- 25:59Speaker 4: number of different ethnicities. But any bias like that is,
- 26:04Speaker 4: as Austin said, sitting on top of a series of
- 26:08Speaker 4: other biases, right of structural biases. And so the result
- 26:13Speaker 4: we see with a lot of facial recognition systems, and
- 26:15Speaker 4: this facial ibness system is ceb going is no different.
- 26:18Speaker 4: Is that a little bit of even to a little
- 26:20Speaker 4: bit of bias in how the facial recognition works gets amplified,
- 26:25Speaker 4: and it's amplified by social biases. It's amplified by the
- 26:29Speaker 4: biases of people who run the system and people who
- 26:32Speaker 4: interact with it every day, and then it's amplified by
- 26:36Speaker 4: institutional blindness as well, failure to recognize a problem. We
- 26:41Speaker 4: had facial recognition systems rolled out since on some levels
- 26:45Speaker 4: since like the early to mid two thousands, and we
- 26:48Speaker 4: didn't even know that facial that bias was a problem
- 26:51Speaker 4: in any facial recognition system until twenty eighteen. So when
- 26:56Speaker 4: you're thinking about and you're hearing about like bias testing
- 26:58Speaker 4: and the fact that it's been bias tested. Those tests
- 27:01Speaker 4: are never incredibly reliable because they're not done in the
- 27:04Speaker 4: real world, they're not done with the people actually using
- 27:08Speaker 4: the technology.
- 27:08Speaker 3: They're done in a.
- 27:09Speaker 4: Controlled setting, and they're not done by people who have
- 27:13Speaker 4: a nuanced understanding of how the technology impacts people. Yeah,
- 27:19Speaker 4: I think it's very important to remember that. Yeah, there's
- 27:21Speaker 4: layers upon layers of bias, and they stack to make
- 27:23Speaker 4: it harder and harder for certain people coming to the
- 27:26Speaker 4: United States to get Again, what's that right? Often to
- 27:32Speaker 4: just be safe, right, like some people, especially the less
- 27:34Speaker 4: advantage you are sort of on a global scale, the
- 27:39Speaker 4: likely the less safe you are waiting in Mexico to
- 27:42Speaker 4: make an appointment for your asylum. Right, Like, if you
- 27:45Speaker 4: can't get into a shelter, or you're from a group
- 27:47Speaker 4: where you don't have community to look out for you, you're
- 27:49Speaker 4: just that bit more likely to be taken advantage of
- 27:52Speaker 4: or have something bad happen to you or your family. So, yeah,
- 27:55Speaker 4: it'll stacks up, I guess, to make for a very
- 27:58Speaker 4: unfortunate situation for people. Yeah, which means the consequence of
- 28:03Speaker 4: having a glitch happen is way higher.
- 28:05Speaker 2: Yes, I've personally known people who have had terrible consequences
- 28:09Speaker 2: from what should have been a very very straightforward asylum
- 28:12Speaker 2: application and very easy to process very rapidly. Yeah, it's
- 28:17Speaker 2: it's it's a whole it's a whole mess. And I
- 28:19Speaker 2: know I'm trying to speak more to some of the
- 28:22Speaker 2: folks who work with African migrants because I think that often, yeah,
- 28:27Speaker 2: their stories just don't get told, especially at our southern border,
- 28:31Speaker 2: where like I think obviously there's this like a lot
- 28:35Speaker 2: of people like to report on the border but not
- 28:37Speaker 2: leave New York or DC or wherever they have their
- 28:41Speaker 2: studio or newspaper or what have you. And I think
- 28:43Speaker 2: it's easy to miss that if you haven't, like Gosud said,
- 28:47Speaker 2: been around a lot and seen all these things to
- 28:50Speaker 2: stack up on top of one another. But yeah, it's
- 28:52Speaker 2: an important topic that we don't especially as like I know,
- 28:56Speaker 2: it doesn't get reported on because everyone likes to report
- 28:58Speaker 2: on Ukraine and only Ukraine, Like there's more wars in
- 29:01Speaker 2: Africa or wars in you know, certain people from Myanmar,
- 29:06Speaker 2: it's very hard for them to get to the southern border.
- 29:08Speaker 2: Actually from hearing from thousands maybe different cases where people
- 29:14Speaker 2: can't leave Thailand. But again, the system you know, when
- 29:18Speaker 2: you have a whole other alphabet that you're trying to
- 29:20Speaker 2: access the system in and it doesn't work for you
- 29:22Speaker 2: then and that makes it incredibly difficult for those people.
- 29:25Speaker 2: And that, ladies and gentlemen, is what we call a
- 29:26Speaker 2: cliffhanger in the podcasting industry. Because we will be back
- 29:29Speaker 2: tomorrow with more on how ICE tracks migrants and how
- 29:33Speaker 2: that tracking of migrants can impact other people, people who
- 29:35Speaker 2: live with them, people in their communities. I hope you're
- 29:37Speaker 2: joined us then, thanks by hi everyone to James, and
- 29:56Speaker 2: I am back with Austin and Jake to discuss ICE's
- 29:58Speaker 2: Alternatives to two tent program today. If you didn't listened
- 30:01Speaker 2: to yesterday's episode on CBP one and a little bit
- 30:05Speaker 2: of at D, then I suggest starting there because there's
- 30:07Speaker 2: a lot of context that you might be missing in
- 30:10Speaker 2: today's episode. Let's talk about alternatives to detention a bit
- 30:14Speaker 2: that's this is a this is a once inside the
- 30:17Speaker 2: US system, right, so it's a little different. It's people
- 30:20Speaker 2: who've managed to get through the significant hurdles post by
- 30:24Speaker 2: CBP one. What happened to them? Then?
- 30:29Speaker 3: Yeah, so you know ICE has the option of detaining
- 30:32Speaker 3: people at immigrant Detention facilities. This includes people who are
- 30:38Speaker 3: facing deportation. Most people who are facing deportation.
- 30:41Speaker 2: Can you explain that the Title eight thing, because people
- 30:45Speaker 2: might not be for I've tried to explain that before,
- 30:47Speaker 2: but I'd love you to explain that again, just so
- 30:48Speaker 2: people are clear regarding detention, well regarding like finding a
- 30:52Speaker 2: defensive asylum application and why people might be doing that,
- 30:58Speaker 2: like post like the post Title forty two sort of
- 31:01Speaker 2: paradigm for processing asylum.
- 31:05Speaker 3: Yeah, sure, Okay, So Title forty two, which we talked
- 31:07Speaker 3: about earlier, has gone away, which means now Title eight
- 31:12Speaker 3: is not like Title forty two. It's the part of
- 31:15Speaker 3: the US law which is about immigration. Title eight never
- 31:18Speaker 3: went away, but it is now the dominant section of
- 31:24Speaker 3: code that is shaping border enforcement and immigration processing. When
- 31:28Speaker 3: someone comes through CBP one and they get an appointment,
- 31:33Speaker 3: they go to their interview for the entry. Then they
- 31:36Speaker 3: come into the United States. They have not made an
- 31:38Speaker 3: asylum application yet, so they still have to do that.
- 31:43Speaker 3: And the United States has two options at this point.
- 31:46Speaker 3: There's two agencies that can make decisions, can receive asylum
- 31:51Speaker 3: applications and make decisions. USCIS, which is historically the primary
- 31:56Speaker 3: one US Citizenship and Immigration Services. They have what are
- 32:00Speaker 3: called asylum officers whose job it is to adjudicate assylum applications,
- 32:05Speaker 3: interview people and so forth. Or people the United States
- 32:10Speaker 3: can file removal proceedings deportation cases effectively against these individuals
- 32:15Speaker 3: and put them into immigration court, where an immigration judge
- 32:19Speaker 3: can accept an assiled application and adjudicate the assigled application.
- 32:25Speaker 3: The major difference here is that in the court room
- 32:29Speaker 3: in the immigration court system, that individual is going in
- 32:32Speaker 3: front of a judge and has an ICE officer, an
- 32:35Speaker 3: enforcement related kind of attorney effectively arguing against them in court. Technically,
- 32:43Speaker 3: they're not supposed to be arguing against them per se.
- 32:45Speaker 3: They're supposed to be finding the right outcome, but effectively
- 32:48Speaker 3: they're arguing against them, almost like they're, you know, trying
- 32:52Speaker 3: to apply for asylum and immigration court or in like
- 32:54Speaker 3: a criminal court setting. Almost not really, but almost right.
- 32:58Speaker 3: So here's the two main differences when those individuals. You know, historically,
- 33:04Speaker 3: when people have been put into the immigration court system,
- 33:07Speaker 3: ICE does have the option of detaining them, or at
- 33:09Speaker 3: least detaining them for an early part of that process
- 33:14Speaker 3: until they meet some certain tolds. The Biden administration has
- 33:18Speaker 3: decided largely at this point not to go that route.
- 33:22Speaker 3: That has not been true in the past. The Trump
- 33:24Speaker 3: administration's detention numbers were up well over sixty thousand people
- 33:28Speaker 3: detained the day at one point. Right now, it's about
- 33:30Speaker 3: half that it's up from the beginning of the year.
- 33:33Speaker 3: But it's about almost thirty thousand people are in detention now,
- 33:36Speaker 3: and people seem to be moving through even when they
- 33:39Speaker 3: are detained, relatively quickly. This is where alternatives to detention
- 33:44Speaker 3: come in. We should not think of alternatives to detention
- 33:48Speaker 3: as alternatives detention. In fact, ICE itself has said on
- 33:52Speaker 3: their website and in testimony before Congress, alternatives to detention
- 33:57Speaker 3: is not an alternative to detention. It is an alternative
- 34:01Speaker 3: to unsupervised release. So it's what it really is is
- 34:06Speaker 3: an electronic monitoring program that allows the agency to effectively
- 34:11Speaker 3: keep track of everyone that they want to keep track of. Now,
- 34:14Speaker 3: the number of people in this alternatives to detention program
- 34:18Speaker 3: is an extremely small fraction of the number of asylum
- 34:21Speaker 3: systems in court. It is nowhere near, you know, saturating
- 34:25Speaker 3: the total number of people that they could be. One
- 34:28Speaker 3: wonders whether they consider five percent monitoring some kind of
- 34:33Speaker 3: massive success when you know, when most people are actually
- 34:36Speaker 3: not monitored. But one major change has happened, which is
- 34:40Speaker 3: in addition to the smartphone app that migrants use to
- 34:43Speaker 3: even try to seek asylum, now migrants also have to
- 34:47Speaker 3: download an app called smart Link. That is now this
- 34:52Speaker 3: one is not built in house. This is contracted out
- 34:54Speaker 3: from an organization called BI that effectively mostly contracts with
- 34:59Speaker 3: the fminal Justice system, but they also contract with ICE.
- 35:03Speaker 3: So they have to download an app on their phone
- 35:05Speaker 3: and they have to check in regularly using a similar
- 35:10Speaker 3: but different kind of facial technology. They can communicate with
- 35:15Speaker 3: deportation officers, they can get alerts about their immigration court here,
- 35:19Speaker 3: all this stuff, but the crucial part of that is
- 35:22Speaker 3: under threat of detention or redetention, redetaining migrants have to
- 35:27Speaker 3: check in on their smartphone. So it means that that
- 35:30Speaker 3: same phone that one you know, struggled with on the
- 35:33Speaker 3: periphery of Vernosa trying to just even get into the
- 35:36Speaker 3: United States to pursue what is their legal right to
- 35:38Speaker 3: pursue asylum, now they're glued to their smartphone, worried that
- 35:42Speaker 3: if they don't respond to, you know, a text message
- 35:45Speaker 3: or an alert or a ping on their phone, they
- 35:47Speaker 3: could be redetained and you know, potentially deported in some way.
- 35:51Speaker 3: So that that's currently how the system. So it's not
- 35:54Speaker 3: for everyone. It's not as if everyone follows this exact
- 35:57Speaker 3: same path, but it is true, and I think this
- 36:00Speaker 3: is the big takeaway. It is true that asylum seekers
- 36:03Speaker 3: today will start interacting with the US government, may start
- 36:07Speaker 3: interacting with the US government on their smartphone as far
- 36:10Speaker 3: south as Mexico City, and then continue to have their
- 36:14Speaker 3: primary contact and interaction with the US government on their
- 36:19Speaker 3: smartphone all the way through the border and to Columbus, Ohio,
- 36:23Speaker 3: New York City, Seattle, Washington. So the smartphone has become
- 36:27Speaker 3: effectively this kind of what I am trying to think
- 36:30Speaker 3: of and conceptualize as a kind of mobile border. They
- 36:33Speaker 3: never where, migrants never really arrive, and they never really leave.
- 36:37Speaker 2: Yeah, it's kind of not to get too sort of
- 36:40Speaker 2: I guess not conspiratory, it's their own word. But like
- 36:43Speaker 2: since two thousand and one, the border has come to
- 36:45Speaker 2: you more and more and more, right, and you don't
- 36:48Speaker 2: have to go to the border for the border to
- 36:49Speaker 2: surveil you. And we can see this in hundreds of ways.
- 36:52Speaker 2: Can we backtrack a little bit, just because our listeners
- 36:55Speaker 2: will be familiar with some of the human stories that
- 36:58Speaker 2: surrounded the end of Title forty two. Some of those people,
- 37:02Speaker 2: to my understanding, entered the United States. I'm doing heavy
- 37:05Speaker 2: air quotes between ports of entry under Title forty two,
- 37:11Speaker 2: but then were detained. That it is fairly obvious they
- 37:17Speaker 2: thought they were being detained. It looked very much like
- 37:19Speaker 2: they were being detained. They weren't allowed to leave. CBP
- 37:22Speaker 2: apparently would argue that they were not detained because the
- 37:26Speaker 2: conditions were wofully inadequate by their own detention policies, which
- 37:31Speaker 2: don't exactly provide for luxurious conditions to begin with, And
- 37:34Speaker 2: so what would the situation be for those people because
- 37:38Speaker 2: they haven't They were trying, at least some people I
- 37:42Speaker 2: spoke to to make CBP one appointments from a place
- 37:45Speaker 2: of detention, which I don't think one can do. Maybe
- 37:49Speaker 2: one can if one's not on a list or something,
- 37:51Speaker 2: but you still have to get there right and you
- 37:54Speaker 2: can't leave south or north to access.
- 37:57Speaker 3: You have to be in Mexico to schedule and appointment
- 38:00Speaker 3: on CBP one.
- 38:01Speaker 2: Okay, Yeah, these guys were in between the border walls.
- 38:05Speaker 5: As Jake knows better than I do.
- 38:07Speaker 3: I mean the issue with being along the border, and James,
- 38:10Speaker 3: you know this because I mean you're there, which cell
- 38:13Speaker 3: tower you're on if you're close to the border.
- 38:16Speaker 5: Oh yeah, tricky, isn't it.
- 38:18Speaker 2: I got so I use T mobile. That's a free
- 38:22Speaker 2: buzz marketing. But they I have roam free roaming on
- 38:26Speaker 2: my phone, right, very useful in the work I do.
- 38:28Speaker 2: But I remember in twenty eighteen, I was in Mexico
- 38:33Speaker 2: a lot, and then I was obviously also just riding
- 38:35Speaker 2: my bike a lot in places along the border, and
- 38:37Speaker 2: they were like, you've been in Mexico every day this month.
- 38:40Speaker 2: You don't live in America. We're going to cancel your
- 38:42Speaker 2: phone contract. I had been in Mexico like some days,
- 38:46Speaker 2: but they had all just think, oh, you're pinging Mexican celtoer.
- 38:49Speaker 2: Yeah what I was on a bike ride, like in
- 38:50Speaker 2: East County, San Diego. I wasn't in Mexico, but my
- 38:53Speaker 2: phone thought, I was, so, yeah, the same thing can
- 38:56Speaker 2: happen in reverse, right, You're your phone can pink American
- 38:59Speaker 2: cell towers when you're in Mexico. So those people might
- 39:02Speaker 2: appear to be in the US when they're not. But
- 39:04Speaker 2: in that situation, they couldn't make a cbp U apployment.
- 39:07Speaker 2: So I guess they're assumed to have. It's the same
- 39:10Speaker 2: as if they crossed the fence somewhere else and been
- 39:13Speaker 2: detained ten miles inside the United States, right, what would
- 39:17Speaker 2: their process be?
- 39:21Speaker 4: Yeah, So I think if we're talking about right now,
- 39:23Speaker 4: this is actually really important. Is that the new rule
- 39:26Speaker 4: called Circumvention of Lawful Pathways that replaced Title forty two
- 39:31Speaker 4: supposed to happen like three years ago. Yeah, and it
- 39:35Speaker 4: finally got passed. Basically, there were a number of court
- 39:39Speaker 4: challenges in which Red States tried to keep Title forty
- 39:44Speaker 4: two in place. The same states, mind you, who were
- 39:49Speaker 4: very critical of COVID protections, were extremely worried about lifting
- 39:54Speaker 4: the ban on people in the southern border coming in
- 39:57Speaker 4: because of COVID concerns. Part of what that rulemaking did
- 40:03Speaker 4: was it worked a fundamental change in the way that
- 40:06Speaker 4: asylum seevers work and so like just context asylum claiming
- 40:12Speaker 4: asylum is a human right, is a right guaranteed by
- 40:15Speaker 4: international law, is the right guaranteed by US law that
- 40:19Speaker 4: you can show up and say, hey, I am not
- 40:21Speaker 4: safe in the country that I'm coming from and I
- 40:24Speaker 4: need asylum in the States, and you have a right
- 40:27Speaker 4: to do that, and for the US or whatever country
- 40:29Speaker 4: you arrive in to process your claim and decide if
- 40:32Speaker 4: it's valid or not. So one of the changes in
- 40:36Speaker 4: this rule making was that they are applying what's called
- 40:40Speaker 4: the government is applying a presumption of ineligibility to people
- 40:44Speaker 4: seeking asylum, which means that if you did not show
- 40:48Speaker 4: up in the proper manner the United States. That means
- 40:51Speaker 4: if you did not use the CBP one app to
- 40:54Speaker 4: claim asylum before you got to the border, and if
- 40:57Speaker 4: you did not apply for asylum in every country that
- 41:00Speaker 4: you traveled through along the way. If you traveled from
- 41:05Speaker 4: Guatemala and you did not pay for apply for asylum
- 41:08Speaker 4: in Mexico before you got to the border, you are
- 41:11Speaker 4: automatically deemed ineligible and your asylum claim will be denied
- 41:15Speaker 4: with no hearing, with no opportunity to say, hi, I'm
- 41:20Speaker 4: here because like my husband is a police officer somewhere
- 41:25Speaker 4: in Guatemala and he's trying to kill me, and I
- 41:28Speaker 4: can't stay in the country, right And so that is
- 41:32Speaker 4: a fundamental change in the way the law works. And
- 41:36Speaker 4: that's the starting point of someone who has frost illegally
- 41:40Speaker 4: not used CBP one and then is picked up's and
- 41:43Speaker 4: that's new in the law in twenty twenty three.
- 41:45Speaker 2: Yeah, and so they would immediately be filing like a
- 41:49Speaker 2: defensive asylum application to prevent that removal.
- 41:53Speaker 4: Yes, And basically at that point you're trying to argue
- 41:57Speaker 4: for one of a tiny subset of exemptions, yes, which
- 42:01Speaker 4: there is virtually no guidance on how to implement those exemptions, right. Like,
- 42:06Speaker 4: one thing you can claim is that you cross without
- 42:10Speaker 4: a CVP one appointment because you couldn't use the app
- 42:15Speaker 4: The idea of trying to prove to someone at the
- 42:18Speaker 4: Customs of Border Protection that you were technologically enabled to
- 42:23Speaker 4: use an app seems basically impossible, given that the only
- 42:27Speaker 4: proof that you have is that you didn't get the appointment, right,
- 42:31Speaker 4: that you weren't able to submit it. That's not a
- 42:33Speaker 4: strong record that a lawyer would like to argue on,
- 42:36Speaker 4: I will tell you.
- 42:36Speaker 2: As a lawyer.
- 42:40Speaker 4: And so the result is basically that people who have
- 42:44Speaker 4: certainly legitimate asylum claims are likely to be turned away
- 42:48Speaker 4: because they didn't comply with the proper process.
- 42:50Speaker 2: Yeah. Even people we heard dabig. I can't remember where
- 42:54Speaker 2: it was now where Customs officials in Mexico have been
- 42:59Speaker 2: threatening to do people for longer than it so they
- 43:03Speaker 2: couldn't make it in time for their CBP one appointment,
- 43:05Speaker 2: right that they had already made. They're gone through that
- 43:08Speaker 2: arduous and bias process, made the appointment, and then people
- 43:11Speaker 2: were being detained unless they paid a bribe. And then
- 43:14Speaker 2: then if those people had crossed like legally in between
- 43:18Speaker 2: ports of entry, that would be very harder than to
- 43:20Speaker 2: prove that they could that that had happened at all, right,
- 43:23Speaker 2: like what had caused him to do that? So those
- 43:25Speaker 2: people are in an even more difficult scenario. If people then,
- 43:30Speaker 2: through any of these processes, find themselves in a ATD
- 43:34Speaker 2: alternative to detention, there are numerous ways it could be surveyed.
- 43:39Speaker 2: Alston mentioned that the phone app which I think is
- 43:42Speaker 2: the perhaps the most recent and most common one. Another
- 43:47Speaker 2: one is ankor monitors. Right, you can get like a
- 43:50Speaker 2: parole kind of ank style of ankor monitor And I
- 43:53Speaker 2: know that, Jake, you've written a little bit about some
- 43:56Speaker 2: of the consequences of those. Do you want to talk
- 43:59Speaker 2: about that?
- 44:00Speaker 4: Yeah, So, first of all, an overview of the ATV
- 44:03Speaker 4: program is that there are different levels of monitoring and
- 44:08Speaker 4: all of them are I think should functionally be viewed
- 44:11Speaker 4: as incarceration, which is to say that you are not
- 44:15Speaker 4: You've not been released from custody, just the location of
- 44:18Speaker 4: your custody has been moved from a prison to somewhere
- 44:23Speaker 4: out in the world where you're being surveilled and your
- 44:26Speaker 4: movements are potentially tracked. But you are still in many
- 44:30Speaker 4: ways as vulnerable as you would be if you're actually
- 44:34Speaker 4: in a jail or a prison, and so ICE has
- 44:39Speaker 4: the option to decide at their discretion which level of
- 44:42Speaker 4: monitoring you get. The levels of monitoring, the highest level
- 44:47Speaker 4: is an ankle bracelet or an ankle shackle, that is
- 44:51Speaker 4: a GPS device that is battery power, has potentially only
- 44:57Speaker 4: a few hours of charge on it, you might get
- 44:59Speaker 4: a day of charge off of it, and is constantly
- 45:01Speaker 4: monitoring your location and sending that location back to both
- 45:06Speaker 4: ICE and to the contracting staff of BI Industries. This
- 45:12Speaker 4: prison technology company, who ICE has hired as case managers,
- 45:18Speaker 4: basically people who are providing support for ICE on keeping
- 45:23Speaker 4: track of the usually eight to ten thousand people who
- 45:28Speaker 4: are on the ankle monitor system.
- 45:32Speaker 3: If you don't get quite that.
- 45:33Speaker 4: High level, or if you get de escalated over time,
- 45:35Speaker 4: you applied ICE and you say, hey, I've been on
- 45:38Speaker 4: my ankle bracelet for like three months, I've not straight
- 45:41Speaker 4: outside the area I'm supposed to go. I've always responded
- 45:44Speaker 4: to check ins. Then they might bump you down to
- 45:47Speaker 4: the smart Link app, also provided by BI Industries on
- 45:50Speaker 4: an extremely lucrative contract. Their last contract was like two
- 45:53Speaker 4: point two billion dollars. And that smart link app is
- 45:59Speaker 4: either going to be loaded on your smartphone if you
- 46:01Speaker 4: have a smartphone that can handle it, or you'll be
- 46:03Speaker 4: given a smartphone buy ICE and told to use that
- 46:07Speaker 4: smartphone to check in. You will be required to check
- 46:11Speaker 4: in on a sort of regular schedule. I don't have
- 46:16Speaker 4: a strong sense for how often that is. Could be daily,
- 46:21Speaker 4: could be less. To check in, you're going to open
- 46:25Speaker 4: the app up, it's going to ping your GPS location,
- 46:27Speaker 4: send a dice, and then you're going to take official
- 46:30Speaker 4: recognition photograph. That photograph will be compared to make sure
- 46:34Speaker 4: that you're actually you. That photograph is also potentially capturing
- 46:38Speaker 4: your surroundings, the people you live with, whoever's like in
- 46:41Speaker 4: the frame, and then you can communicate with your case manager.
- 46:45Speaker 4: On the app, you can potentially find information on when
- 46:49Speaker 4: your immigration court hearings are.
- 46:50Speaker 3: That type of thing.
- 46:52Speaker 4: It's the middle level of monitoring. The lowest level of
- 46:54Speaker 4: monitoring is voice print based. So basically, every once in
- 46:59Speaker 4: a while, whatever or your dedicated check in time is,
- 47:02Speaker 4: you're going to call into ICE on your phone. You're
- 47:05Speaker 4: gonna say Hi, I'm Jake Wiener, I'm checking in, and
- 47:10Speaker 4: ICE will run a voice print analysis and make sure
- 47:13Speaker 4: that you are the person who say you are and
- 47:15Speaker 4: confirm your location.
- 47:18Speaker 3: At any point, if.
- 47:19Speaker 4: That system screws up, you are potentially you're then in
- 47:25Speaker 4: violation of the terms of your release. And at any
- 47:28Speaker 4: point ICE, if you've there's been an error, an ICE
- 47:32Speaker 4: officer can show up and take you right back to jail.
- 47:36Speaker 2: Let's talk a little bit about that you've mentioned BI. Right,
- 47:39Speaker 2: you've both mentioned BI. This is not a government agency,
- 47:42Speaker 2: this is a contractor. But potentially they have access to
- 47:46Speaker 2: your photograph, details of your asylum case and were we
- 47:53Speaker 2: very clear on like certainly with the ICE issued phones,
- 47:56Speaker 2: people seem to have concerns like what is being monitored
- 47:58Speaker 2: and what isn't being monitored on the phone, right like,
- 48:00Speaker 2: is it only when they have the app open? Is
- 48:03Speaker 2: everything on their phone now subject to a review by
- 48:07Speaker 2: ICE and potentially also by this third party contractor? Right? So,
- 48:11Speaker 2: how are those contractors vetting their person now? How are
- 48:14Speaker 2: they're making sure that these this very sensitive information is
- 48:18Speaker 2: secure in private like it should be.
- 48:20Speaker 4: Yeah, I have no idea how they're vetting their staff.
- 48:23Speaker 4: They're not exactly forthcoming. One aspect of the surveillance that
- 48:29Speaker 4: I think is worth noting is that both ICE and
- 48:33Speaker 4: BI don't just have your whether you're on the smartphone
- 48:38Speaker 4: or if you're on the ankle monitor. They don't just
- 48:41Speaker 4: have your last GPS ping. They have your historical movements,
- 48:45Speaker 4: which means if you're on an ankle monitor, they have
- 48:46Speaker 4: a record of every single place you went for the
- 48:49Speaker 4: entirety of the time since you've been on an ankle monitor,
- 48:51Speaker 4: and they also know where you are right now a
- 48:54Speaker 4: little more limited on a smartphone, but that's information that's
- 48:57Speaker 4: highly sensitive. You're location and especially your historical location information
- 49:03Speaker 4: and tell you all kinds of things like what church
- 49:05Speaker 4: this person goes to, have they been to Planned parenthood
- 49:07Speaker 4: or recently?
- 49:09Speaker 3: Who do they associate with?
- 49:10Speaker 4: Like what houses are they visited, and for ICE, that
- 49:12Speaker 4: information is very valuable because most migrants don't live alone.
- 49:18Speaker 4: They live in community with other people. Some of those
- 49:20Speaker 4: people may be undocumented. And so as a migrant, you
- 49:24Speaker 4: are now worrying every time you check in. Am I
- 49:28Speaker 4: exposing someone who's undocumented to ICE surveillance? Am I exposing myself,
- 49:34Speaker 4: you know, to just like tagging somewhere that ICE doesn't
- 49:38Speaker 4: want me to be and maybe an officer is going
- 49:40Speaker 4: to show up for a check Because of that, it
- 49:42Speaker 4: is creating a ton of insecurity and a system that
- 49:45Speaker 4: is already very insecure, and the like psychological harms of
- 49:50Speaker 4: that are manifest. You know, there's good studies like internationally
- 49:56Speaker 4: that your risk of suicide and depression goes way up
- 50:00Speaker 4: you're on electronic monitoring, that your access to jobs goes
- 50:04Speaker 4: wait out. You you know, there's stigma with wearing an
- 50:09Speaker 4: ankle brace also concerns that if you take a job
- 50:14Speaker 4: you won't be able to check in at your home
- 50:17Speaker 4: at the appropriate time. It looks like you're absconding, right,
- 50:20Speaker 4: So this level of monitoring is messing with people's lives
- 50:24Speaker 4: and really fundamental and deeply cruel ways.
- 50:27Speaker 2: Yeah, definitely, and these like like you talked about sort
- 50:31Speaker 2: of how how your phone can make you a snitch. Like,
- 50:33Speaker 2: mixed status families are very common, right, and it's fifty
- 50:37Speaker 2: in migrant diaspora is so like it could be someone
- 50:40Speaker 2: in your family who have a different immigration status from you,
- 50:42Speaker 2: and to do what you need to do, you might
- 50:45Speaker 2: be putting that person at risks. And it's a very
- 50:48Speaker 2: scary thing to have that that tag on you at
- 50:52Speaker 2: all times. And like you said, it's not just where
- 50:54Speaker 2: you where you are, but where you've been and ice
- 50:57Speaker 2: if I'm right, like they they they keep that data, right,
- 51:01Speaker 2: That data isn't anonymized or sort of like destroyed. They
- 51:06Speaker 2: can keep that data forever if they want to.
- 51:08Speaker 3: Yes, it's inputed into their systems.
- 51:11Speaker 4: And that hangs around for I think the retention period
- 51:15Speaker 4: of seventy five years. Okay, yeah, great, depends a little bit.
- 51:19Speaker 2: Yeah. This technology that goes into these right, that's facial recognition.
- 51:23Speaker 2: I know they also have a number plate license plate
- 51:26Speaker 2: in America recognition. They have.
- 51:31Speaker 3: That.
- 51:31Speaker 2: I'm trying to think which are other technologies they have,
- 51:34Speaker 2: cell phone site simulation. A lot of that can also
- 51:37Speaker 2: be transferred to local police agencies right through some of
- 51:41Speaker 2: these like, they're not tech transfer programs, that's the wrong word.
- 51:44Speaker 2: But some of these grants and programs that ICE and
- 51:48Speaker 2: DHS more broadly has. Does that mean that local police
- 51:53Speaker 2: agencies could also have access to some of this data?
- 51:56Speaker 4: Yeah, So I think there's two different types of programs
- 51:59Speaker 4: and it's worth breaking them apart. There are grant programs
- 52:03Speaker 4: that are providing state and local police with the technology itself. Right,
- 52:08Speaker 4: that's like money to buy a license plate reader and
- 52:10Speaker 4: pop it out in your community. There are is also
- 52:14Speaker 4: the overlap between beteral and special Department of Homeland Security
- 52:19Speaker 4: ices databases the systems that they house all of this
- 52:24Speaker 4: information in, and state and local police they have their
- 52:27Speaker 4: own databases. Those databases are very often linked or accessible,
- 52:32Speaker 4: which means that monitoring. You know, your local police department
- 52:37Speaker 4: has a log of everyone and they arrest very often
- 52:40Speaker 4: that log is sent to ICE and vice versa.
- 52:43Speaker 3: Right.
- 52:44Speaker 4: So it's one of the main ways that this has
- 52:48Speaker 4: done is through fusion centers, which is basically a federally
- 52:52Speaker 4: funded state run technology center embedded in state or local
- 52:55Speaker 4: police departments where you have the Department of Homeland Security
- 52:59Speaker 4: agents who have access to their set of databases and
- 53:03Speaker 4: state and local police department officers who have access to
- 53:06Speaker 4: their set of databases sitting right next to each other,
- 53:08Speaker 4: and those people can then talk and be like, yo,
- 53:10Speaker 4: I need you to run this search into your system,
- 53:13Speaker 4: which is theoretically only for federal use, but suddenly it's
- 53:16Speaker 4: getting used for state law enforcement and vice versa. One
- 53:19Speaker 4: of the biggest problems with this is that cities that
- 53:22Speaker 4: want to be sanctuary cities that don't want their police
- 53:26Speaker 4: departments reporting and handing people over to ICE when they
- 53:30Speaker 4: arrest undocumented folks, city government is unable to control their
- 53:35Speaker 4: local police departments and the information that is sent to ICE.
- 53:38Speaker 4: So even a sensible sanctuary cities where the city says
- 53:41Speaker 4: we're not going to report this information, the way that
- 53:45Speaker 4: these databases are tied together, especially license plate reader databases,
- 53:50Speaker 4: but as well as arrest databases, all sorts of stuff
- 53:53Speaker 4: means that the city government functionally cannot create a sanctuary city.
- 53:57Speaker 2: Right which, just in if we talk about my situation,
- 54:01Speaker 2: I'm in San Diego, are mayor is terrible and want
- 54:06Speaker 2: to turn all our street lights into spies? Right like,
- 54:09Speaker 2: put put little put little cameras on them so that
- 54:12Speaker 2: they can watch what we're doing, and like this information
- 54:15Speaker 2: feeds into we know exactly where the future center is actually,
- 54:18Speaker 2: Like I wrote about this in twenty twenty when the
- 54:20Speaker 2: cops took someone's phone and used gray key to crack
- 54:23Speaker 2: it open. So like the Yeah, the exposure for people
- 54:26Speaker 2: who in the US who are not citizens of the
- 54:29Speaker 2: US is very high with these things. The last thing
- 54:34Speaker 2: about these databases I wanted to talk about was those
- 54:37Speaker 2: aren't the only databases that ICE has access to, right,
- 54:42Speaker 2: can you explain how they've they've managed to acquire some
- 54:44Speaker 2: data about other people and whether or not that is
- 54:47Speaker 2: strictly speaking legal.
- 54:49Speaker 4: Yeah, So we have a massive problem in America with
- 54:53Speaker 4: data broker in which is yes, companies the biggest, the
- 54:57Speaker 4: worst are Lexus and Nexus and Tops and Writers West Law.
- 55:01Speaker 4: But there are hundreds and hundreds of data brokers who
- 55:06Speaker 4: vacuum up all of the information that they can off
- 55:09Speaker 4: the Internet, off of utility records, off of publicly available information,
- 55:14Speaker 4: and basically make massive databases that are tracking to the
- 55:19Speaker 4: best that they can at every aspect of people's lives.
- 55:21Speaker 4: Credit reporting agencies, the people who like give you your
- 55:24Speaker 4: credit score, are also data brokers. They're pulling in all
- 55:27Speaker 4: this information so that they can assign you your credit
- 55:31Speaker 4: which is like where your credit cards are, how much
- 55:33Speaker 4: money you have. All this information is super valuable, right,
- 55:36Speaker 4: and it's valuable to advertisers. It's valuable, yeah, like for marketing,
- 55:43Speaker 4: but it's also really valuable for law enforcement because you
- 55:48Speaker 4: have everything from like addresses where people are spending money.
- 55:54Speaker 4: Often you can pull from advertising like phone advertising data,
- 55:57Speaker 4: people's GPS location, and a number of these services have
- 56:03Speaker 4: sold access to ICE, both like Thompson, Ridge Is Clear
- 56:08Speaker 4: Lexis Nexus has several products that they sell to ICE,
- 56:13Speaker 4: as well as locate x which is now Babble Street,
- 56:16Speaker 4: which is specifically a GPS location company. And ICE has
- 56:22Speaker 4: basically managed to obtain through contracts information that they could
- 56:27Speaker 4: not legally obtain through a warrant, right, which is to
- 56:31Speaker 4: say that if you a police officer and ICE officer
- 56:35Speaker 4: want to get information on a single person, you know
- 56:38Speaker 4: you want their GPS location off their phone, you need
- 56:41Speaker 4: to go to a court and say, hey, I'm looking
- 56:45Speaker 4: for James Stout and I think that he committed a
- 56:47Speaker 4: crime or an immigration he brook immigration law. Here's my evidence.
- 56:51Speaker 4: I need a warrant. You cannot get a warrant for
- 56:55Speaker 4: mass monitoring. That's like a fundamental part of how the
- 56:59Speaker 4: Fourth Amendment US Constitution works is that it has to
- 57:01Speaker 4: be individualized or very close to individualized. But there is
- 57:07Speaker 4: currently no law that says that ICE can't just go
- 57:12Speaker 4: buy the information on the open market and completely evade
- 57:14Speaker 4: the warrant requirement. So that's what's going on with Lexus
- 57:18Speaker 4: and Nexus, with locate Acts as well as some social
- 57:22Speaker 4: media surveillance companies.
- 57:24Speaker 2: Right, yeah, are the same database is that I as
- 57:26Speaker 2: a journalist use when I'm you know, wondering if this
- 57:30Speaker 2: Nazi is still living in this place, or you know,
- 57:34Speaker 2: finding the sense of Confederate veterans to check if they
- 57:37Speaker 2: still work at the Citadel University. So I think a
- 57:40Speaker 2: good way to finish this up will be to talk
- 57:42Speaker 2: about once you're in, you've gone through this process, right,
- 57:46Speaker 2: you've CVP one, you've at d'd, and you enter into
- 57:50Speaker 2: sort of the asylum hearing or you have your your
- 57:54Speaker 2: various different asylum processes. Can Austin, can you give us
- 57:58Speaker 2: a very broad overview of like the likelihood of success
- 58:03Speaker 2: and maybe a couple of I know you're very good
- 58:05Speaker 2: at monitoring the factors that determine the likelihood of success
- 58:09Speaker 2: in an asylum application through TRACK. This is a great
- 58:12Speaker 2: place to plug track if you want to. Can you
- 58:15Speaker 2: talk about like how likely folks are to be successful
- 58:19Speaker 2: in that asylum application process?
- 58:22Speaker 3: Yeah, So we monitor this federal data related to immigration
- 58:26Speaker 3: other areas through TRACK Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse at Syracuse
- 58:31Speaker 3: University where I'm at.
- 58:32Speaker 5: I'm also a research fellow at American University.
- 58:34Speaker 3: So we have a kind of a fun partnership right
- 58:36Speaker 3: now looking at different angles of connecting data to research
- 58:43Speaker 3: on Latin American Latino migrants. And so we keep really
- 58:47Speaker 3: close track of what's happening with the immigration courts. We
- 58:50Speaker 3: don't get data. Remember earlier I described as two tracks
- 58:54Speaker 3: of seeking asylum. We don't currently get data on that
- 58:58Speaker 3: first track where people go through asylum. Officers at USCIS
- 59:03Speaker 3: were interested in it, but they actually publish not comprehensive,
- 59:07Speaker 3: but they published decent amount of data. We would certainly
- 59:11Speaker 3: like to get more, but it's the immigration courts that
- 59:13Speaker 3: we have focused very heavily on for the last decade,
- 59:16Speaker 3: I would say. And so we get very detailed, granular
- 59:19Speaker 3: data from the immigration courts on a monthly basis that
- 59:21Speaker 3: allows us to see exactly what's happening. I would say
- 59:25Speaker 3: currently the success rate denial rate, however you want to
- 59:29Speaker 3: put it in immigration court for asylum seekers is about
- 59:33Speaker 3: fifty two or fifty three percent get denied, about forty
- 59:37Speaker 3: seven to forty eight percent are granted asylum, but that
- 59:42Speaker 3: varies widely by immigration court and by nationality. So migrants
- 59:47Speaker 3: from Central America, El Salvadorjundara, Squatemala tend to have much
- 59:51Speaker 3: higher denial rates seventy eighty percent, ninety percent, where as
- 59:55Speaker 3: nationals from let's say Ukraine, China, some other countries, Cuba
- 1:00:04Speaker 3: have very high success rates. Haiti actually is a good
- 1:00:07Speaker 3: example of a country that has very low grant rates,
- 1:00:09Speaker 3: very high denial rates, even though much like northern Mexico,
- 1:00:15Speaker 3: where we actually send people that we deport very often,
- 1:00:18Speaker 3: there are all kinds of travel warnings.
- 1:00:20Speaker 5: You know, the United States government does not.
- 1:00:22Speaker 3: Want people going to Haiti because it's too dangerous, but
- 1:00:24Speaker 3: we don't even have a problem deporting people back there
- 1:00:27Speaker 3: who are seeking asylum, right and so that's what we've
- 1:00:30Speaker 3: seen in recent years. The denial rate was as high
- 1:00:32Speaker 3: as seventy percent during the Trump administration, and so it's
- 1:00:36Speaker 3: certainly much better under the Biden administration. I do want
- 1:00:39Speaker 3: to say though, that in addition to sort of policy
- 1:00:44Speaker 3: related issues that may drive this factor, geographic concerns, people
- 1:00:51Speaker 3: are much more successful in New York City than say
- 1:00:53Speaker 3: Houston or Atlanta, Georgia.
- 1:00:57Speaker 5: But one of the really.
- 1:00:59Speaker 3: Important factors here is, in addition to all of that,
- 1:01:02Speaker 3: there's a threshold question, which is a lot of people,
- 1:01:06Speaker 3: including a lot of people who are recently arriving to
- 1:01:08Speaker 3: the United States, if they can't get an attorney, it's
- 1:01:13Speaker 3: very unlikely that they will even be able to file
- 1:01:16Speaker 3: in the sylum application in the first place. So that's
- 1:01:18Speaker 3: fifty you know, that forty eight percent rant rate is
- 1:01:22Speaker 3: for people who file in the sylum application. We're not seeing,
- 1:01:27Speaker 3: you know, the people who don't even who aren't even
- 1:01:29Speaker 3: able to file in the silum application in the first place.
- 1:01:32Speaker 3: And one of the most concerning things recent developments is
- 1:01:36Speaker 3: that the Biden administration, I think not for no reason
- 1:01:40Speaker 3: at all. I mean, there's two point two million pending
- 1:01:42Speaker 3: cases in the immigration course right now. The Biden administration
- 1:01:45Speaker 3: is trying to push cases too faster. This is something
- 1:01:48Speaker 3: the Obama Innistry administration tried Trump administration tried it, Biden
- 1:01:52Speaker 3: administration tried it, and every single time the cases get accelerated,
- 1:01:56Speaker 3: including a large number of family cases. Unfortunately, they simply
- 1:02:00Speaker 3: don't have time to get an attorney and file a
- 1:02:03Speaker 3: good stylent application. So what we're seeing as an addition
- 1:02:07Speaker 3: to like geography, nationality, does someone get an attorney. It's
- 1:02:10Speaker 3: also speed, just how fast the cases go through. And
- 1:02:14Speaker 3: the reality is if you try to force an asylum
- 1:02:17Speaker 3: case through the immigration courts or frankly even through USAIS
- 1:02:21Speaker 3: in a matter of weeks, people are just not going
- 1:02:25Speaker 3: to win. You can't speed things up and maintain a
- 1:02:29Speaker 3: fair system.
- 1:02:29Speaker 5: You just can't.
- 1:02:30Speaker 3: It's also not great for people to wait, you know, five, six, seven,
- 1:02:34Speaker 3: eight years for a hearing or for a conclusion.
- 1:02:36Speaker 5: So that's not ideal either.
- 1:02:38Speaker 3: But you know, trying to force cases through and you
- 1:02:41Speaker 3: know two or three months is just doesn't work.
- 1:02:45Speaker 2: Yeah, I've spoken to Peeve. I spoke to a friend
- 1:02:47Speaker 2: a couple of weeks ago who was saying that now
- 1:02:49Speaker 2: he's seeing people newly. Right, he's been in the United
- 1:02:52Speaker 2: States for a few years. I've gone through the process,
- 1:02:55Speaker 2: but he's seeing people come in and the amount to
- 1:02:57Speaker 2: pay for a lawyer if they want to get a
- 1:02:58Speaker 2: private lawyer is going up, and like if people only
- 1:03:02Speaker 2: have a few months or don't have the right to work,
- 1:03:04Speaker 2: there's just no way for them to obtain that much money.
- 1:03:09Speaker 2: And then the people who are doing it sort of
- 1:03:12Speaker 2: I guess sort of in for nonprofits are just overwhelmed
- 1:03:16Speaker 2: by the amount of demand. So yeah, those people are
- 1:03:19Speaker 2: in a really tough situation.
- 1:03:21Speaker 4: Yeah, I think we should talk a little bit about
- 1:03:23Speaker 4: the fundamental unfairness of this system.
- 1:03:26Speaker 3: Yep.
- 1:03:27Speaker 4: So, like immigration judges are administrative law judges. They are
- 1:03:33Speaker 4: not like real judges approved by Congress. They are hired
- 1:03:38Speaker 4: by an administrative agency, which effectively means that there are
- 1:03:41Speaker 4: much lower bars to who can be an administrative law judge.
- 1:03:46Speaker 4: You also, as an immigrant, do not have a right
- 1:03:49Speaker 4: to an attorney sitting in front of an administrative law judge.
- 1:03:53Speaker 4: And one of the things that the data throws out
- 1:03:55Speaker 4: is that in every aspect of the system, having an
- 1:03:59Speaker 4: attorney is the strongest indicator of a good result. So
- 1:04:04Speaker 4: that's like how likely peopot people are to know about
- 1:04:07Speaker 4: their appointments. It's actually extremely hard if you are someone
- 1:04:11Speaker 4: who does not speak English and has limited money and
- 1:04:15Speaker 4: limited access to the system. And frankly does not understand
- 1:04:20Speaker 4: how the American immigration law system works, which is reasonable
- 1:04:24Speaker 4: because virtually no one understands how it works. It's really
- 1:04:28Speaker 4: difficult to know, Like when you have a court take
- 1:04:31Speaker 4: much less to show up and to understand what kind
- 1:04:33Speaker 4: of information that you need to collect and present to
- 1:04:37Speaker 4: a judge that will be convincing to this person, who
- 1:04:40Speaker 4: again is not an Article three judge that's been appointed
- 1:04:43Speaker 4: by Congress, not the type of judges that you or
- 1:04:45Speaker 4: I would have our cases heard by if we were
- 1:04:48Speaker 4: arrested or if we just like file the lawsuit. And
- 1:04:53Speaker 4: so access to a judge is like the number one
- 1:04:56Speaker 4: best indicator for whether your asylum claim is going to
- 1:04:59Speaker 4: be be successful or not, or any kind of claim
- 1:05:02Speaker 4: and the immigration system, frankly, and we do not provide
- 1:05:05Speaker 4: that to people who don't have the money to hire
- 1:05:08Speaker 4: a lawyer.
- 1:05:09Speaker 2: Yeah, which is fundamentally unjust right.
- 1:05:12Speaker 4: We also there's like not a guarantee that you will
- 1:05:15Speaker 4: have a quality translator. Yes see, you will be able
- 1:05:18Speaker 4: to show up to court and at all understand what
- 1:05:21Speaker 4: is happening in your legal case, which is a huge
- 1:05:25Speaker 4: barrier to be able to get a good results to
- 1:05:27Speaker 4: be able to communicate who you are and why you
- 1:05:32Speaker 4: will not be safe if you are deported from the country.
- 1:05:34Speaker 2: Right, Yeah, we heard that in May where they were
- 1:05:37Speaker 2: like they were basically asking if anyone could come and
- 1:05:40Speaker 2: help trans migrant advocacy groups. You know, does someone speak Comanagi,
- 1:05:44Speaker 2: does someone speak Turkish? You know, just does someone speak Vietnamese?
- 1:05:49Speaker 2: Could they come down and help this person with their
- 1:05:50Speaker 2: initial interview? Which it's just not a not a just
- 1:05:55Speaker 2: or refrom reasonable way to do these things. But yes,
- 1:05:59Speaker 2: that's where it's out right now. I guess I think
- 1:06:01Speaker 2: most people probably aren't aware of much of that, so
- 1:06:03Speaker 2: it's good to explain how fundamentally and jest it is.
- 1:06:07Speaker 2: So if people want to learn more about this, if
- 1:06:10Speaker 2: people want to follow along, I know you both do
- 1:06:12Speaker 2: some writing online. Where can they find you and where
- 1:06:14Speaker 2: can they find more of your writing about this?
- 1:06:17Speaker 3: Yeah, so you.
- 1:06:18Speaker 4: Can find my writing on the Electronic Privacy Information Center
- 1:06:22Speaker 4: EPICS website that is EPIC dot org. You can find
- 1:06:25Speaker 4: me and my one hundred and fifty followers on Twitter
- 1:06:28Speaker 4: at at real Jake Wiener that's w I E n
- 1:06:31Speaker 4: e R. And hopefully in the near future you'll be
- 1:06:37Speaker 4: able to find some scholarship for me as well.
- 1:06:39Speaker 2: Oh cool, Yeah, using the Donald Trump Twitter format. Great.
- 1:06:44Speaker 2: How about you, Austin, where can people find you? You
- 1:06:46Speaker 2: have many more followers on Twitter dot com.
- 1:06:49Speaker 3: Yeah, so it's Austin Cooper. Last name is koc h
- 1:06:53Speaker 3: e er. Peculiarity of that name is in my favorite
- 1:06:56Speaker 3: because you know, pretty easy to search. But actually this
- 1:07:00Speaker 3: is great timing. I just had an article published this week,
- 1:07:03Speaker 3: detailed one on CBP one. It's called Glitches and the
- 1:07:06Speaker 3: Digitization of Asylum. It's an academic article, but it is
- 1:07:11Speaker 3: open access, so there's no paywall there. Glitches and the
- 1:07:14Speaker 3: Digitization of Asylum. It's also up on my Twitter page.
- 1:07:17Speaker 3: I'm on Twitter at ac Coker, so a c k
- 1:07:21Speaker 3: O c h e R. And I also write pretty
- 1:07:23Speaker 3: regularly on substack, and that's like a weird thing to say.
- 1:07:27Speaker 3: I'm slightly embarrassed to mention it, except that I'm not
- 1:07:30Speaker 3: because this academic article emerged actually out of stuff that
- 1:07:35Speaker 3: I was initially exploring on substack. So I really loved
- 1:07:39Speaker 3: that format for writing because it's given me a chance
- 1:07:42Speaker 3: to work out concepts and ideas before they even go
- 1:07:46Speaker 3: into like pure ifew print. So if people want to
- 1:07:49Speaker 3: get ahead of the curve on what I'm thinking, go
- 1:07:51Speaker 3: check that out too. Nice and don't forget to visit
- 1:07:54Speaker 3: track t R A C dot, s y R dot
- 1:07:58Speaker 3: ed U to get all kinds of data on immigration courts,
- 1:08:02Speaker 3: alternatives to detention, detention statistics and so forth.
- 1:08:05Speaker 2: Yeah, I like try this Telegram channel as well. Right,
- 1:08:07Speaker 2: it's like the only time I can go on Telegram,
- 1:08:10Speaker 2: I don't see dead people, So I appreciate it for that.
- 1:08:12Speaker 3: That's right. We put stuff out on Telegram and WhatsApp too,
- 1:08:16Speaker 3: So if you don't want to have to be on Twitter,
- 1:08:18Speaker 3: if you don't want to have to get an email
- 1:08:20Speaker 3: on something like that, you just want to get a
- 1:08:22Speaker 3: little if you like some of those other messaging platforms.
- 1:08:25Speaker 3: We have announcement threads on there. You can't interact, you
- 1:08:29Speaker 3: just you just get the little notification. But we try
- 1:08:32Speaker 3: that we try to diversify as much as possible, especially
- 1:08:35Speaker 3: with the muscification of Twitter.
- 1:08:37Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, I think that's pretty a good move. Thank
- 1:08:40Speaker 2: you very much for your time both to you. I
- 1:08:41Speaker 2: really appreciate it. That was very insightful. Thank you, James. Hello,
- 1:09:01Speaker 2: welcome to the podcast. It could happen here. It's me
- 1:09:05Speaker 2: James and Scharene today. Hi Serene, Hi James, Hi Sarene. Yeah,
- 1:09:10Speaker 2: it's it's lovely to have you. Thanks for introducing yourself.
- 1:09:14Speaker 2: A little confused, but he always talking to you.
- 1:09:18Speaker 6: I've done podcasts for a long time and I never
- 1:09:20Speaker 6: actually know how to introduce myself. But I'm really happy
- 1:09:23Speaker 6: to be doing this episode with you because you're a
- 1:09:25Speaker 6: very good episode partner.
- 1:09:27Speaker 2: Thank you, Sreen. I am also happy to beating this
- 1:09:29Speaker 2: episode with you. I think you're an excellent episode partner.
- 1:09:31Speaker 6: What are we talking about that just because I said it?
- 1:09:33Speaker 2: No, I like him. It's good, it's good. Do we
- 1:09:38Speaker 2: help people learn things?
- 1:09:40Speaker 6: Well, today you're going to learn some more things about Palestine.
- 1:09:44Speaker 6: It's been a minute since we had an update, and
- 1:09:47Speaker 6: I mean, surprise, surprise, things aren't good. So we're going
- 1:09:50Speaker 6: to talk about some recent stuff that's been happening. There's
- 1:09:54Speaker 6: we mentioned some stuff that we've mentioned before in other episodes,
- 1:09:57Speaker 6: like the Nekaba or just the ethnic cleansing that happened
- 1:10:01Speaker 6: in nineteen forty eight. Also some politics stuff. So if
- 1:10:04Speaker 6: you are interested in getting more detail and you haven't
- 1:10:07Speaker 6: listened to those, I would recommend listening to those just
- 1:10:09Speaker 6: for more context if you desire.
- 1:10:12Speaker 2: But yeah, yeah, I think you're diving in probably at
- 1:10:14Speaker 2: the deep end if if you start here. But we're
- 1:10:17Speaker 2: going to dive in at the deep end. So earlier
- 1:10:19Speaker 2: this month, Omar Katten twenty seven, a father of two
- 1:10:23Speaker 2: children who worked as an electrician for the local municipality,
- 1:10:26Speaker 2: was killed when about four hundred Israeli settlers marched down
- 1:10:30Speaker 2: thaumas Aya's main road, selling cars, homes, crops and trees
- 1:10:34Speaker 2: ablaze as they went. It's not clear if you're shot
- 1:10:37Speaker 2: by IDF troops or settlers of both stormed the village
- 1:10:40Speaker 2: carrying weapons. Under international law, Israeli settlement to illegal, however,
- 1:10:46Speaker 2: it's really Prime Minister of Benjamin net and Yahoo announced
- 1:10:48Speaker 2: plans to build a thousand new housing units in the
- 1:10:50Speaker 2: settlement of Eli in response to the deadly shooting of
- 1:10:53Speaker 2: for Israelis by two Palestinian gunmen on Tuesday, the twentieth
- 1:10:57Speaker 2: of June. The suspected assailants were late killed. One of
- 1:11:00Speaker 2: them was quote unquote neutralized by civilian the other by
- 1:11:04Speaker 2: the IDEF. But it appears the plan is to place
- 1:11:08Speaker 2: the whole nation again. Our auntwer to terror is, to
- 1:11:11Speaker 2: strike it hard and to build our country. Net Yeah,
- 1:11:13Speaker 2: who said his right wing government is dominated by settler
- 1:11:16Speaker 2: leaders and supporters. But his statements came just days after
- 1:11:19Speaker 2: the government gave far right finance minister there's a little
- 1:11:22Speaker 2: smotorridge sweeping powers to exploit the construction of legal settlements
- 1:11:26Speaker 2: by passing masses that have been in place for almost
- 1:11:28Speaker 2: twenty seven years. The violence in thaumas ayah Am I
- 1:11:32Speaker 2: saying that, right.
- 1:11:33Speaker 6: I just looked it up. Yeah, totumos Aya is it's
- 1:11:37Speaker 6: a town in the West Bank for context people that
- 1:11:40Speaker 6: don't know, so, yeah, it's it's in the Ramola and
- 1:11:45Speaker 6: LB the governor in the West Bank.
- 1:11:47Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm going to get a little bit more into
- 1:11:48Speaker 2: it of why this is all happening. We just wanted
- 1:11:51Speaker 2: to kind of paint the picture for you first of
- 1:11:54Speaker 2: all of the big events that have happened. I guess.
- 1:11:57Speaker 2: So this violence against the people of this town and
- 1:12:01Speaker 2: the shooting of Forestraelis followed an incursion by the IDF
- 1:12:04Speaker 2: and Israeli border forces into the Genine refugee camp. It
- 1:12:08Speaker 2: was an operational scale not seen for decades. So did
- 1:12:11Speaker 2: you tear gus s Dun grenades and an attack helicopter.
- 1:12:14Speaker 2: Seven Palestinians were killed, nearly one hundred were wounded.
- 1:12:18Speaker 6: And I feel like this is not the first time.
- 1:12:20Speaker 6: If you've been following any Palestinian news that you've heard
- 1:12:22Speaker 6: of Janine the refugee camp, or that it's being attacked,
- 1:12:27Speaker 6: it might sound familiar. I'll get into it more later,
- 1:12:29Speaker 6: but Sharene abou Ocle was actually killed while reporting there.
- 1:12:34Speaker 6: So I want to get into just why exactly Israel
- 1:12:37Speaker 6: keeps raiding the Janine refugee camp in particular, and I
- 1:12:40Speaker 6: want to talk about the camp's history, why it's getting targeted,
- 1:12:44Speaker 6: and why the latest raid was different than the ones
- 1:12:47Speaker 6: before it. Janine is slowly becoming a symbol of Palestinian resistance.
- 1:12:51Speaker 6: It was originally established in nineteen fifty three to house
- 1:12:55Speaker 6: Palestinians who were ethnically cleansed during the Nekaba of nineteen
- 1:12:58Speaker 6: forty eight, which force seven hundred and fifty thousand people
- 1:13:01Speaker 6: from their homes in order to make way for the
- 1:13:04Speaker 6: establishment of Israel. And again we've talked about this in
- 1:13:07Speaker 6: other episode. You want to revisit those but essentially he
- 1:13:09Speaker 6: was just a very perfect example of ethnic cleansing and massacres,
- 1:13:13Speaker 6: in genocide and displacement. So the camp has seen much
- 1:13:18Speaker 6: unrest over the decades, and it was nearly destroyed in
- 1:13:21Speaker 6: two thousand and two when Israeli soldiers ambushed it during
- 1:13:24Speaker 6: the Second Antifada. According to a Human Rights Watch investigation,
- 1:13:29Speaker 6: at least fifty two Palestinians, including women and children, were
- 1:13:32Speaker 6: killed during this period of time. In two thousand and two,
- 1:13:36Speaker 6: during the Second Anthi Fada, there were also at least
- 1:13:38Speaker 6: twenty three Israeli soldiers killed and several others injured that
- 1:13:42Speaker 6: were reported. And since then, Janine has recently seen intensifying
- 1:13:47Speaker 6: attacks by Israeli forces, especially since twenty twenty one, and
- 1:13:51Speaker 6: it has slowly, along with Gaza, become a major symbol
- 1:13:55Speaker 6: of Palestinian resistance. At this point, Palestinians are really fed
- 1:13:59Speaker 6: up up with the enaction of the Palestinian Authority the PA,
- 1:14:03Speaker 6: which is the government entity meant to oversee and quote
- 1:14:07Speaker 6: unquote protect the Palestinians within its governance. The Palistine Authority
- 1:14:12Speaker 6: was formed in nineteen ninety four following the Gaza Jericho
- 1:14:15Speaker 6: Agreement between the PLO and the Government of Israel, and
- 1:14:18Speaker 6: it was only intended to be a five year interim body.
- 1:14:22Speaker 6: Further negotiations were then meant to take place between the
- 1:14:25Speaker 6: two parties regarding its final status. According to the Oslo Accords,
- 1:14:29Speaker 6: the Palestinian Authority was designated to have exclusive control over
- 1:14:33Speaker 6: both security related and civilian issues in the Palestinian urban areas,
- 1:14:38Speaker 6: which are referred to as Area A, and only Palestinian
- 1:14:41Speaker 6: control over Palestinian rural areas, which is called Area B.
- 1:14:47Speaker 6: The remainder of the territories, including Israeli settlement, the Jordan
- 1:14:50Speaker 6: Valley region and bypass roads between Palestinian communities, were to
- 1:14:55Speaker 6: remain under Israeli control aka Area C. East Jerusalem was
- 1:15:00Speaker 6: excluded from the accords. Negotiations with several Israeli governments had
- 1:15:05Speaker 6: resulted in the Authority gaining further control in some areas,
- 1:15:08Speaker 6: but that control was then lost in some areas when
- 1:15:11Speaker 6: Israel retook several strategic positions during the Second Antifaba. At
- 1:15:15Speaker 6: this point, the Palestine Authority is an authoritarian regime that
- 1:15:20Speaker 6: has not held elections in over fifteen years, and it
- 1:15:23Speaker 6: doesn't really stand in the way of the Israeli government
- 1:15:26Speaker 6: and the crimes they commit. So what concerns Israel is
- 1:15:31Speaker 6: that in Janine and elsewhere. Young Palestinians are increasingly taking
- 1:15:35Speaker 6: up arms because they see no other way out of
- 1:15:38Speaker 6: the pressure of occupation, and they're very disillusioned with the
- 1:15:42Speaker 6: ineffectiveness of the Palestinian authority.
- 1:15:45Speaker 2: Yeah, I think that's a really important way too. Like
- 1:15:49Speaker 2: when we talk about like especially Palestinian people taking up arms,
- 1:15:52Speaker 2: right or expecting these new groups which have come in
- 1:15:55Speaker 2: the last couple of years, Right, there's that Lions Day group.
- 1:15:59Speaker 2: I think they're more like nobles. Janine Brigades is another one.
- 1:16:04Speaker 2: It's in the context of like government failure or state
- 1:16:07Speaker 2: failure in I guess when we look at like the
- 1:16:11Speaker 2: formation of states, right, when there's the it's called social contracts,
- 1:16:16Speaker 2: the area, right, the idea that when we go and consent,
- 1:16:19Speaker 2: which we don't do, but we don't ever, like we
- 1:16:22Speaker 2: don't have a chance to consent to being in a state, right,
- 1:16:24Speaker 2: like very obviously if you're from Palestine, you're aware of this,
- 1:16:28Speaker 2: Like we were supposed to give up some of our
- 1:16:30Speaker 2: freedom and get some security, but the Palestinian authority has
- 1:16:34Speaker 2: repeatedly failed to protect people in Geneine right and in
- 1:16:38Speaker 2: lots of other places too, and so like this response,
- 1:16:43Speaker 2: like this response is taking up aren't is in the
- 1:16:46Speaker 2: context of state failure, right, Like people are trying to
- 1:16:48Speaker 2: protect their own communities when there's been a complete failure
- 1:16:51Speaker 2: by the people who are supposed to protect them, the
- 1:16:53Speaker 2: people who is and that's both the PA and then
- 1:16:57Speaker 2: like the broader the international community is kind of a
- 1:17:00Speaker 2: pointless phrase. It doesn't really mean anything. But like international
- 1:17:04Speaker 2: law is also a pointless phrase. It doesn't really mean anything,
- 1:17:08Speaker 2: which I'm getting too far afield here, but like the
- 1:17:13Speaker 2: amount of times people in my replies on Twitter will
- 1:17:15Speaker 2: be like, this is against international law, and like are
- 1:17:18Speaker 2: you going to go and fucking enforce it? Then? Good?
- 1:17:21Speaker 6: Like guess if that matter is at that point, Yeah,
- 1:17:23Speaker 6: it's just so good.
- 1:17:24Speaker 2: It doesn't matter, like what we know it's bad. I
- 1:17:27Speaker 2: don't like, that's not what's up for debate? That what's
- 1:17:29Speaker 2: for debates? What the fuck are you going to do
- 1:17:31Speaker 2: about it? How are you going to stop it? And
- 1:17:32Speaker 2: like these people have decided that the way they're going
- 1:17:34Speaker 2: to stop it is by taking up arms, and like,
- 1:17:37Speaker 2: evidently Israel sees them as terrorists. Evidently there are some
- 1:17:43Speaker 2: groups inside Palestine who have killed civilians and done shit,
- 1:17:46Speaker 2: which is is you know, like, it's not very nice. Also,
- 1:17:51Speaker 2: the idea of killed civilians all the time, right, one
- 1:17:55Speaker 2: of them is funded and armed by your taxes, and
- 1:18:01Speaker 2: so like, yeah, it's it's an understandable response. And the
- 1:18:07Speaker 2: response of the IDF is to sort of paint the
- 1:18:09Speaker 2: whole of Janine as harboring quote unquoite terrorists, right, which
- 1:18:14Speaker 2: which is, and then to do these attacks which often
- 1:18:18Speaker 2: cause civilian casualties, which is not that distinct from suggesting
- 1:18:23Speaker 2: that Israel is a terrorist state, right, and then attacking Israel,
- 1:18:28Speaker 2: which like, but one of these things is more broadly
- 1:18:30Speaker 2: condemned is terrorism, and one is not as broadly condemned
- 1:18:34Speaker 2: as terrorism. When then they're not, to my eye, that
- 1:18:37Speaker 2: morally different. I guess, yeah, that makes sense.
- 1:18:41Speaker 6: I agree, and I also think, no, it makes a
- 1:18:43Speaker 6: lot of sense. I think remembering the imbalance that it
- 1:18:47Speaker 6: starts at is so important because Palestine has no army,
- 1:18:52Speaker 6: it's not backed by any rich ass nation, it's not
- 1:18:55Speaker 6: trained by anything, and it's an extremely unbalanced unquote battle.
- 1:19:01Speaker 2: No one's deploying an Apache helicopter when when the idea
- 1:19:05Speaker 2: of killers journalist right.
- 1:19:06Speaker 6: Like exactly, and yeah, like sharenaut Oarckley was a US citizen.
- 1:19:10Speaker 6: Not that it matters, but it should matter just in
- 1:19:13Speaker 6: the idea of what the US can do or like
- 1:19:15Speaker 6: the outrage it can have, but it doesn't.
- 1:19:17Speaker 2: Do anything as a journalist who goes to dangerous places
- 1:19:22Speaker 2: and is a US citizen. Now, like it's fucking infuriating
- 1:19:28Speaker 2: and obviously like and particularly thing that like you know,
- 1:19:32Speaker 2: like daddy government is coming to save me. I'm not
- 1:19:35Speaker 2: like you know, if you if you're laboring under that illusion,
- 1:19:37Speaker 2: you're probably a little bit naive. But it is just
- 1:19:41Speaker 2: incredibly frustrating to see the value of some quote unquote
- 1:19:47Speaker 2: American lives, like it's it's it's always wrong to shoot journalists,
- 1:19:52Speaker 2: of course, but like it's just in the US basically
- 1:19:55Speaker 2: condoning that. It's yes, as again, this isn't first if
- 1:20:00Speaker 2: I can get like Arab journalist that the US who
- 1:20:05Speaker 2: is a US citizen who has been killed by an
- 1:20:07Speaker 2: authoritarian regime, that the US had done fuck all about.
- 1:20:10Speaker 6: Yeah, No, I think it's just a slap in the
- 1:20:13Speaker 6: face for her family and just the entire community of
- 1:20:16Speaker 6: like both Arabs and journalists and that crossover there. But
- 1:20:20Speaker 6: I did want to mention just the terrorism. Acts on
- 1:20:24Speaker 6: both sides are obviously terrible. I just think you have
- 1:20:28Speaker 6: to remember where they started and the imbalance that is there,
- 1:20:32Speaker 6: especially if the entity that is supposed to protect the
- 1:20:35Speaker 6: Palestinians isn't doing shit and the only way Palestinians can
- 1:20:41Speaker 6: fight back or defend themselves is with violence.
- 1:20:45Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, I don't know.
- 1:20:47Speaker 6: It's just frustrating when people point out the violence on
- 1:20:51Speaker 6: just the Palestinian side, and we'll get into the news
- 1:20:56Speaker 6: version of what that means and then biases of what
- 1:20:58Speaker 6: that means it a little bit, but yeah, I just's
- 1:21:00Speaker 6: explaining exactly why these groups have risen.
- 1:21:03Speaker 2: Yeah, there's just to be an absolute fuckingd weep for
- 1:21:08Speaker 2: a second. The introduction to Wretched of the Earth that
- 1:21:11Speaker 2: John Paul starts Were wrote, it's a France fan on
- 1:21:13Speaker 2: book is fantastic when talking about violence and violence in
- 1:21:16Speaker 2: the decolonial process, and like how it's very nice that
- 1:21:21Speaker 2: these colonial states, apartheid states like Israel speak in the
- 1:21:25Speaker 2: language of rights. Yeah, and they encourage to colonize people
- 1:21:28Speaker 2: to make their claims in the language of rights. But
- 1:21:30Speaker 2: every time they fucking do, they get met with violence, right,
- 1:21:34Speaker 2: And it is entirely understandable that when the state speaks
- 1:21:38Speaker 2: you only in violence, you will reply using the same
- 1:21:41Speaker 2: language that is spoken to you with right, Like that
- 1:21:45Speaker 2: that is how decolonial struggles have been, right from Algeria
- 1:21:51Speaker 2: to Vietnam to Palestine. And like this isn't a particularly
- 1:21:56Speaker 2: like under theorized concept. It's there and Pano in the
- 1:21:59Speaker 2: nineteen sixty that's always something I like to suggest people read.
- 1:22:03Speaker 2: I think it's a very good kind of distillation of
- 1:22:06Speaker 2: what's occurring.
- 1:22:07Speaker 6: Yeah, No, I like that you mentioned that because it
- 1:22:10Speaker 6: does seem like that this is like a Palestinian problem
- 1:22:16Speaker 6: that they have, that they are violent and that they
- 1:22:18Speaker 6: hate the other side, and it is just another good
- 1:22:21Speaker 6: example of the effects of colonialism, and like that's the
- 1:22:26Speaker 6: occupied people and their only choice of like retaliation. Anyway,
- 1:22:31Speaker 6: I don't want to get into that too much, but
- 1:22:33Speaker 6: I do want to emphasize why exactly that they were disillusioned,
- 1:22:38Speaker 6: the Palestinian youth, especially during this time, because the IDEF
- 1:22:43Speaker 6: has been extremely violent and the PA still is really
- 1:22:46Speaker 6: inactive and doesn't do anything. So that's kind of the
- 1:22:52Speaker 6: reason why there.
- 1:22:53Speaker 2: Yeah, yeah, we have a little more on Shury neverorrectly
- 1:22:57Speaker 2: if you want.
- 1:22:57Speaker 6: To oh yeah, we have an episode about her, I believe,
- 1:23:02Speaker 6: and I'm going to mention her a little bit here.
- 1:23:05Speaker 6: The gen and refugee camp houses armed fighters and they
- 1:23:09Speaker 6: are from several factions, but this means Israeli's They consider
- 1:23:12Speaker 6: it a hub for what they call terrorist activity rather
- 1:23:15Speaker 6: than resistance, so the entire camp is then dubbed a
- 1:23:19Speaker 6: terrorist site. But most of the people what the IDEF
- 1:23:23Speaker 6: has killed are not engaging in any sort of violent activity,
- 1:23:26Speaker 6: and in some cases they are clearly marked as press
- 1:23:30Speaker 6: wearing a bulletproof vest and a helmet, like El Jazeera
- 1:23:33Speaker 6: journalist Sharina bu Akle, for one, she was shot dead
- 1:23:36Speaker 6: by an Israeli sniper in May twenty twenty two, and
- 1:23:39Speaker 6: in her case, the IDF said they were aiming at
- 1:23:42Speaker 6: armed Palestinians who were shooting at them and responding with fire,
- 1:23:47Speaker 6: and after I don't know a lot of inconclusive proof
- 1:23:50Speaker 6: in the IDF sticking to that story. A ballistics analysis
- 1:23:54Speaker 6: proved that that story wasn't true and there was no
- 1:23:57Speaker 6: fire coming from the other side. Regardless, no one cares
- 1:24:01Speaker 6: about that, and this happened all in Janine. So I
- 1:24:05Speaker 6: think it's very clear why this camp has become a
- 1:24:08Speaker 6: symbol of resistance simply because the atrocities that have happened
- 1:24:13Speaker 6: there are tremendous and they keep fighting back. And I
- 1:24:16Speaker 6: think it's an example of how exactly a Palestinian symbol
- 1:24:22Speaker 6: comes to be, like Gaza, like this, whatever it is.
- 1:24:25Speaker 2: I wanted to include a coat from the Israeli military
- 1:24:28Speaker 2: spokesman Ran Kouchov. He told Army Radio, which I guess
- 1:24:33Speaker 2: is not exactly a kind of neutral arbit to here,
- 1:24:36Speaker 2: that she was filming and working for a media outlet
- 1:24:39Speaker 2: amidst arm Palestinians. They were armed with cameras, if you
- 1:24:43Speaker 2: will permit me to say so, which like no, like
- 1:24:46Speaker 2: we should not not fucking permit someone because like you know,
- 1:24:51Speaker 2: I'll go to all kinds of dangerous spots with a camera.
- 1:24:55Speaker 2: Like I've never fucking shot someone with a camera, because
- 1:24:57Speaker 2: it's a fucking camera, right, Like it doesn't it And
- 1:25:00Speaker 2: that's not what cameras do. They take videos.
- 1:25:03Speaker 6: It's the most like I can't believe that's an actual
- 1:25:06Speaker 6: quote that's someone said and got away with.
- 1:25:10Speaker 2: Yeah, what the fuck is wrong? Like what it's just
- 1:25:12Speaker 2: incorrect operation of the human brain to use the fucking
- 1:25:15Speaker 2: phrase arm with camera like what is wrong with you?
- 1:25:19Speaker 2: It's I know, people get really people got really mad
- 1:25:22Speaker 2: briefly when Russians were shooting journalists in Ukraine in the
- 1:25:25Speaker 2: star of the conflict, and like I guess they were
- 1:25:30Speaker 2: kind of as we mask off about this, but like, yeah,
- 1:25:32Speaker 2: it's a fucking camera. If if your security is threatened
- 1:25:35Speaker 2: by someone filming the ship that you do, it's because
- 1:25:39Speaker 2: you shouldn't be doing it, and you know you shouldn't
- 1:25:41Speaker 2: be doing it right, like and again, like I've experienced that,
- 1:25:46Speaker 2: like people people you know, doing stuff they don't want
- 1:25:48Speaker 2: to be filmed and getting mad that I'm filming it.
- 1:25:50Speaker 2: But like maybe if you're not prepared to defend what
- 1:25:52Speaker 2: you're doing, you shouldn't be doing it. You don't, you know,
- 1:25:56Speaker 2: you don't suggest that the camera is the camera is
- 1:25:59Speaker 2: it's a new straw object here. It's not the camera
- 1:26:02Speaker 2: that shot a woman in the head.
- 1:26:04Speaker 6: Yeah, I mean that sentence is infuriating the fact that
- 1:26:09Speaker 6: literally it says they were amidst armed Palestinians and then
- 1:26:15Speaker 6: you couldn't you could stop there and people can just
- 1:26:17Speaker 6: like click out and read and like move on their
- 1:26:19Speaker 6: day thinking that they had fucking guns. And the next
- 1:26:21Speaker 6: sentence is literally they're armed with cameras, Like are you
- 1:26:24Speaker 6: I don't know. That's just so infuriating to me that
- 1:26:26Speaker 6: that's like a real thing that was said and accepted.
- 1:26:29Speaker 2: It seems to be like almost deliberately insulting or I
- 1:26:32Speaker 2: don't know, like it's definitely an attack on Like I
- 1:26:34Speaker 2: don't know. If you're a journalist and you don't see
- 1:26:37Speaker 2: that of an attack on all of us, then you know,
- 1:26:39Speaker 2: made me examine your biases, I guess. Yeah.
- 1:26:42Speaker 6: And then the ballistics analysis that I mentioned earlier where
- 1:26:46Speaker 6: she was it showed that where she was shot there
- 1:26:48Speaker 6: were several targeted shots, one of which hit her head
- 1:26:51Speaker 6: because there were shots in the tree that was behind her,
- 1:26:54Speaker 6: so she was clearly targeted.
- 1:26:56Speaker 2: Yeah, because she was shot by a sniper at the
- 1:26:59Speaker 2: back of one of very PCs. Right, they have a
- 1:27:01Speaker 2: little little like murder hole, and she was shot from
- 1:27:05Speaker 2: two hundred meters to which is not very far with
- 1:27:07Speaker 2: a magnified sign and like, yeah, you don't just it
- 1:27:11Speaker 2: wouldn't look like that, I guess, Like three little holes
- 1:27:14Speaker 2: behind where her head was suggested that someone fired like
- 1:27:16Speaker 2: a single shirts targeted, not just like spraying it sprain
- 1:27:20Speaker 2: bullets around. Yeah.
- 1:27:22Speaker 6: I don't want to talk about it too much because
- 1:27:23Speaker 6: there it is, that's on the topic of this episode.
- 1:27:26Speaker 6: But I do want to just say that I think
- 1:27:28Speaker 6: it's so ironic that the idea is supposed to be
- 1:27:31Speaker 6: this most advanced military body, this highly trained thing, and
- 1:27:35Speaker 6: then at the same breath their defenses sometimes they made
- 1:27:38Speaker 6: a mistake. Oops, you know what I mean, Like they
- 1:27:40Speaker 6: made this grave mistake. They thought she was carrying a
- 1:27:42Speaker 6: gun or she was around people with guns. I just
- 1:27:45Speaker 6: think that's a very silly I don't know.
- 1:27:50Speaker 2: Yeah, I'm being shure. It's true, I suppose, and you can.
- 1:27:53Speaker 2: You can make mistakes. But if you make mistakes, you
- 1:27:56Speaker 2: own them. You could still be like, oh, yeah, we
- 1:27:58Speaker 2: we one hundred percent fucked up, and like we need
- 1:28:01Speaker 2: to examine how we fucked up.
- 1:28:02Speaker 6: You know, that's just their defense. So many times it
- 1:28:05Speaker 6: gets really fucking old. But Okay, before we continue and
- 1:28:08Speaker 6: talk about the recent attack in Janine, let's take our
- 1:28:10Speaker 6: first break and we'll be right back. And we're back.
- 1:28:14Speaker 6: Let's go back to talk about the latest raid on
- 1:28:17Speaker 6: the Janine refugee camp. The Israeli Army launched its latest
- 1:28:22Speaker 6: raid on the Janine refugee camp in the early hours
- 1:28:25Speaker 6: of Monday, June nineteenth. Five people, including a fifteen year old,
- 1:28:29Speaker 6: were dead by the time it withdrew its forces in
- 1:28:32Speaker 6: the afternoon. Others died the following day because of their injuries.
- 1:28:37Speaker 6: Several journalists were shot at and they were surrounded and
- 1:28:40Speaker 6: one was injured. This raid ironically took place near the
- 1:28:44Speaker 6: location where Sharin A Blockley was killed. Several ambulances were
- 1:28:48Speaker 6: also fired upon with live ammunition, and at first they
- 1:28:52Speaker 6: were denied access to the injured, which is nothing new
- 1:28:54Speaker 6: to the IDF. They do this consistently with the block
- 1:28:58Speaker 6: medical aid to reach the people that are injured. The
- 1:29:02Speaker 6: Israeli armies said the raid was to arrest two suspects,
- 1:29:05Speaker 6: one of whom was a former Palestinian prisoner, Asim Abu
- 1:29:09Speaker 6: ad Haija, who was the son of an imprisoned Hamas leader.
- 1:29:14Speaker 6: I just want a quick reminder of refresh. I know
- 1:29:15Speaker 6: I say this in most of the episodes about Palestine,
- 1:29:18Speaker 6: especially the ones I've done in the beginning of this year,
- 1:29:21Speaker 6: but in twenty twenty two, Israeli forces killed more than
- 1:29:25Speaker 6: one hundred and seventy Palestinians, including at least thirty children
- 1:29:29Speaker 6: in occupied East Jerusalem and in the West Bank, and
- 1:29:32Speaker 6: this is described as the deadliest year for Palestinians and
- 1:29:35Speaker 6: those living in those areas since two thousand and six.
- 1:29:38Speaker 6: Since the start of twenty twenty three, Israeli forces have
- 1:29:41Speaker 6: killed at least one hundred and sixty Palestinians, including twenty
- 1:29:45Speaker 6: six children, and it's June. The death toll includes thirty
- 1:29:50Speaker 6: six Palestinians killed by the Israeli army during a four
- 1:29:53Speaker 6: day assault on the besieged Gaza strip between May ninth
- 1:29:56Speaker 6: and May thirteenth of this year. I just want to
- 1:29:58Speaker 6: put that into contexts because if twenty twenty two was
- 1:30:01Speaker 6: the deadliest year for Palestinians in the last twenty years
- 1:30:08Speaker 6: and we're essentially already there by six months into this
- 1:30:11Speaker 6: new year, it's just it's really disturbing and it's really
- 1:30:14Speaker 6: heartbreaking that it's truly there's no slowing down. And this
- 1:30:19Speaker 6: raid is a great example of them just like upping
- 1:30:21Speaker 6: the ante. And what was different about this raid. Israeli
- 1:30:25Speaker 6: offences into Janine are nothing new, but it appeared that
- 1:30:28Speaker 6: the raiding soldiers were caught off guard this time. Shortly
- 1:30:32Speaker 6: after the raid began, videos showed an Israeli military panther
- 1:30:36Speaker 6: APC being hit with a roadside improvise explosive device, and
- 1:30:42Speaker 6: there is a video of this. I haven't seen it
- 1:30:44Speaker 6: because I just personally don't want to, but I said
- 1:30:47Speaker 6: there if you choose to see it. Military helicopters then
- 1:30:50Speaker 6: began shooting and launching rockets and flares while surveillance aircraft
- 1:30:54Speaker 6: hovered above. It was the first time in twenty years
- 1:30:57Speaker 6: that Israel deployed helicopter gunshow in the West Bank. By
- 1:31:01Speaker 6: the end of the raid, reports suggested that at least
- 1:31:04Speaker 6: five Israeli military vehicles had been damaged by explosive devices
- 1:31:08Speaker 6: and bullets deployed by armed Palestinians. This was the first
- 1:31:12Speaker 6: time the IDF was met with this understandable degree of
- 1:31:16Speaker 6: resistance and defense Enginine, and their response was overwhelming. In return.
- 1:31:21Speaker 2: Hi everyone, it's James and Train again and we're here
- 1:31:25Speaker 2: today for a little update. It's the third of July
- 1:31:28Speaker 2: as we're recording this. Just because there's been a significantly
- 1:31:31Speaker 2: larger IDF incursion into the Genine refugee camp, and because
- 1:31:35Speaker 2: we know this is coming out at the end of
- 1:31:36Speaker 2: the week, we wanted to make sure you had a
- 1:31:37Speaker 2: little bit more update to date information, so as best
- 1:31:42Speaker 2: I can kind of bes together what happened is that
- 1:31:44Speaker 2: some It'sraeli military vehicles were hit with an ID bomb,
- 1:31:49Speaker 2: right roadside bomb and explosive device, and Israel responded by
- 1:31:55Speaker 2: going fully ham on a scale that we haven't really
- 1:31:58Speaker 2: seen since the second to fighter. So there's air attacks,
- 1:32:03Speaker 2: droned helicopters, armored vehicles. I saw them using like an
- 1:32:08Speaker 2: anti tank missile against a house. Saw videos of armored
- 1:32:13Speaker 2: bulldozers tearing up roads in the camp, and preps sreen
- 1:32:19Speaker 2: you could kind of give a scale of what this
- 1:32:21Speaker 2: has done, not just to roads obviously, but to the
- 1:32:23Speaker 2: people who live there.
- 1:32:24Speaker 6: Yeah, like James was saying, they're continuing to attack with
- 1:32:27Speaker 6: drones and rockets, and the Janine refugee camp is very
- 1:32:32Speaker 6: densely populated. It has about twenty thousand people, and they
- 1:32:35Speaker 6: are targeting infrastructure like homes and roads and the mirror
- 1:32:39Speaker 6: of Jane Nidhal Obaidi, he said the attack was a
- 1:32:43Speaker 6: real massacre and an attempt to wipe out all aspects
- 1:32:46Speaker 6: of life inside the city and the camp. Those being
- 1:32:49Speaker 6: targeted now are not just the resistance fighters, but civilians
- 1:32:52Speaker 6: are being killed and wounded as well, and water and
- 1:32:57Speaker 6: electricity services have also been cut off from the camp.
- 1:33:00Speaker 6: Since the attack has started. In the Palestine, RECRESCENTCE said
- 1:33:04Speaker 6: that at least three thousand people were evacuated from the camp.
- 1:33:10Speaker 2: Yeah, and then as far as like at time of recording,
- 1:33:14Speaker 2: which is Monday afternoon, eight people have been killed. One
- 1:33:18Speaker 2: more person was called in Romala. The two youngest victims
- 1:33:22Speaker 2: were identified as Nordine Hassam Yusuf Marshud who is fifteen,
- 1:33:27Speaker 2: and seventeen year old Majdi Joannis surd Ararawi. So both
- 1:33:32Speaker 2: of them under eighteen, but the oldest person was twenty three,
- 1:33:35Speaker 2: So these are all very young people sally dead now.
- 1:33:41Speaker 2: And then they estimate that Palestinia Request estimates that three
- 1:33:44Speaker 2: thousand people have left the camp, which I think paints
- 1:33:49Speaker 2: a picture of like emptying or cleaning or whatever colonial
- 1:33:54Speaker 2: sort of word you want to use to make it
- 1:33:56Speaker 2: seem less brutal than it is, but like emptying the
- 1:33:59Speaker 2: space of human being so that it can be colonized
- 1:34:02Speaker 2: or that other folks can move there, right.
- 1:34:03Speaker 6: Yeah, yeah. In addition to some places are saying eight
- 1:34:09Speaker 6: have died, some people some places are saying nine but regardless,
- 1:34:13Speaker 6: there are over one hundred people that are injured, and
- 1:34:16Speaker 6: so I don't know, the fact that the oldest person
- 1:34:19Speaker 6: was only twenty three years old should really paint the
- 1:34:21Speaker 6: picture of like who exactly is being targeted and killed,
- 1:34:24Speaker 6: because there's no way their defense of targeting terrorists can
- 1:34:29Speaker 6: play here, even though it probably does in the long run.
- 1:34:33Speaker 6: But I just I think it's really fucked up and unfair.
- 1:34:36Speaker 6: The White House meanwhile, so the United States quote supports
- 1:34:40Speaker 6: Israel's security and right to defend its people against Hamas,
- 1:34:44Speaker 6: Palestinian Islamic jihad and other terrorist groups, and they also
- 1:34:48Speaker 6: highlighted the need to protect non combatants, which hasn't happened,
- 1:34:53Speaker 6: and none of those people are actually being targeted or no,
- 1:34:58Speaker 6: there's nothing to defend at this point. I really don't.
- 1:35:02Speaker 2: I don't know. It's it's also weird that I don't know,
- 1:35:06Speaker 2: Like it just seems such a knee jerk response. Maybe
- 1:35:09Speaker 2: this is just me being being a dweeb or whatever,
- 1:35:11Speaker 2: but like, at least one of the IDs was was
- 1:35:16Speaker 2: like claimed by Janine Brigades, I think the one earlier
- 1:35:19Speaker 2: last week to call out groups by name like and
- 1:35:22Speaker 2: then not call out the group who are claiming responsibility
- 1:35:25Speaker 2: for at least one of these attacks. It just seems
- 1:35:27Speaker 2: so like okay, like press play on the tape.
- 1:35:30Speaker 6: Yeah, they're also naming things that people are probably more
- 1:35:32Speaker 6: familiar with, like almost to like justify or like entice
- 1:35:37Speaker 6: fear of being like, oh my god, yeah Hammas attack
- 1:35:40Speaker 6: Hamas or whatever they think will happen with that response
- 1:35:45Speaker 6: in the international response. Yeah, the international response has also
- 1:35:49Speaker 6: been dog shit, surprise, surprise, because it will always just
- 1:35:52Speaker 6: talk and nothing really happens. Turkey's Foreign Ministry voice is
- 1:35:56Speaker 6: deep concern over the attack. They warned that it can
- 1:35:59Speaker 6: trigger a new spiral of violence it already has, and
- 1:36:03Speaker 6: they called the Israeli encouragion a heinous crime. Cut Her
- 1:36:07Speaker 6: stress that the need for international community to move urgently
- 1:36:10Speaker 6: to protect the Palestinian people was very necessary. And then
- 1:36:13Speaker 6: Jordan condemned the escalation as a violation of international humanitarian law,
- 1:36:19Speaker 6: which Israel has been breaking for years. So nothing has happened.
- 1:36:24Speaker 6: And then Egypt, on the other hand, it warned of
- 1:36:27Speaker 6: serious repercussions and it called on other international people to intervene.
- 1:36:34Speaker 6: And then the UN said the situation is very dangerous,
- 1:36:38Speaker 6: like all these things I think have already been said
- 1:36:41Speaker 6: every time. That's why. I just think it's so empty
- 1:36:43Speaker 6: and I don't know, I nothing if it's just words
- 1:36:48Speaker 6: and no actions, Like, how are we supposed to even
- 1:36:50Speaker 6: take anything seriously? I guess I don't know.
- 1:36:53Speaker 2: Yeah, it's the the thoughts and prayers of the yeah, exactly,
- 1:36:56Speaker 2: national like the UN is always deeply concerned that it
- 1:37:00Speaker 2: never does fuck all right, So yeah, I guess to
- 1:37:04Speaker 2: wrap up, we should talk about what this means for
- 1:37:09Speaker 2: Janine as a place, like as a community.
- 1:37:14Speaker 6: Yeah, we mentioned this in our previous recording last week.
- 1:37:18Speaker 6: But Israel's attacks on Janine are part of an effort
- 1:37:21Speaker 6: to crush resistance with the young Palestinians that are increasingly
- 1:37:24Speaker 6: taking up arms because their disillusioned with the PA, and
- 1:37:28Speaker 6: according to analysts, Israel's hard right government is likely to
- 1:37:31Speaker 6: continue with heavy handed approach toward Palestinians in the West Bank.
- 1:37:35Speaker 6: Palestinian lawyer and analyst Diana Buttu said Israel wants to
- 1:37:39Speaker 6: do whatever it can to crush Janine in any other
- 1:37:42Speaker 6: form of resistance. Israel has made it clear that there
- 1:37:45Speaker 6: are three options available for Palestinians. Option one is to leave.
- 1:37:49Speaker 6: Option two is to remain as residents, but not as
- 1:37:52Speaker 6: citizens of any state. And option three is if you resist,
- 1:37:56Speaker 6: we are going to crush you. This is what they
- 1:37:59Speaker 6: are implementing. Yeah, yeah, I think that's well said. Yeah.
- 1:38:04Speaker 6: Hassan Ayub, who is a Palestinian political science professor at
- 1:38:08Speaker 6: n Nija National University in Nablus, he agreed with the
- 1:38:12Speaker 6: lawyer's statement, and he said, the end game is to
- 1:38:15Speaker 6: make Palestinians give up any hope of achieving self determination
- 1:38:18Speaker 6: or being recognized as a people. Janine has a long
- 1:38:22Speaker 6: history of resistance. It is a model for the masses
- 1:38:25Speaker 6: that Israel wants to eliminate. But for Palestinians, the question
- 1:38:28Speaker 6: is a matter of principle, and their endgame is to
- 1:38:31Speaker 6: end this occupation. And essentially Israel intends to crush what
- 1:38:36Speaker 6: I you refer to as quote the Janine phenomenon or
- 1:38:40Speaker 6: any form of Palestinian resistance. Yeah, the Israeli aggression it
- 1:38:45Speaker 6: raised fears of an escalation that continues to happen in
- 1:38:49Speaker 6: areas such as the Kaza Strip because that's another symbolic
- 1:38:52Speaker 6: place of resistance for Palestinians. And yeah, that's where we
- 1:38:57Speaker 6: are now.
- 1:39:00Speaker 2: Pretty much. It will I reach out to some people
- 1:39:03Speaker 2: I know, but people generally don't like to be on
- 1:39:06Speaker 2: their phones when this stuff is happening. So maybe I'll
- 1:39:09Speaker 2: update you with some more information.
- 1:39:12Speaker 6: Yeah, hopefully. I mean updates like this are always kind
- 1:39:15Speaker 6: of like unfortunate because I don't think we want to
- 1:39:20Speaker 6: update that more shitty things are happening, But especially with
- 1:39:24Speaker 6: stuff like this, it doesn't seem like Israel is going
- 1:39:28Speaker 6: to back down anytime soon. So yeah, that's that's the update.
- 1:39:34Speaker 2: Okay. Yeah, so I wanted to talk about some of
- 1:39:37Speaker 2: the people who were killed. One of the people who
- 1:39:39Speaker 2: was killed was I'm dadf al Jas. He was forty eight.
- 1:39:45Speaker 2: His son, aged twenty two, was killed in the Guinane
- 1:39:48Speaker 2: massacare that occurred in January this year, so kind of
- 1:39:51Speaker 2: gives you a sense of like the risk that I
- 1:39:53Speaker 2: guess one incurs unwillingly by existing in what is a
- 1:39:57Speaker 2: fucking refugee camp. His son wasn't the only young person killed.
- 1:40:02Speaker 2: Another person who's killed was a Sadil Natcha Nachia. She
- 1:40:07Speaker 2: was fifteen, and a few days later her classmates attended
- 1:40:12Speaker 2: her funeral, all in their school uniforms. It's pretty sad.
- 1:40:16Speaker 2: There are obviously images of it if you want to
- 1:40:18Speaker 2: go look them up. But you can see lots of
- 1:40:19Speaker 2: little school girls burying their friend in a town which
- 1:40:23Speaker 2: is covered in burned detritus. No one should have to
- 1:40:30Speaker 2: bury their kids. It's a torrible kid shouldn't have to
- 1:40:32Speaker 2: deal with this shit. But there are plenty of pictures
- 1:40:35Speaker 2: of little school girls standing by her grave. It's it's awful,
- 1:40:41Speaker 2: so horrible. Yeah. The other victims were identified as Ahmed
- 1:40:45Speaker 2: Saka Ahmed Da Rachma, Colored Dawish custom Pais Labusilia. They
- 1:40:54Speaker 2: were fifteen, nineteen, twenty one, nineteen, and twenty nine respectively.
- 1:41:00Speaker 2: They after this occurred, the aforementioned attack on settlers in
- 1:41:03Speaker 2: Eli took place. Two gunman shown to a gas station
- 1:41:06Speaker 2: or restaurant. One was killed on the scene and one
- 1:41:09Speaker 2: was killed later. It was a response to the master
- 1:41:11Speaker 2: attack on Tulmasya that occurred a few days before. And
- 1:41:15Speaker 2: I want to highlight how the NYT covered this because
- 1:41:19Speaker 2: I think it's important to dissect how Palestine is covered
- 1:41:23Speaker 2: by the US right because obviously the US is one
- 1:41:26Speaker 2: of the biggest state supporters of Israel, and specifically one
- 1:41:30Speaker 2: of the people who continues to equip the IDF to
- 1:41:33Speaker 2: do this stuff, so I'm quoting here directly. Last week,
- 1:41:39Speaker 2: two Palestinians called for Israelis and injured four others near
- 1:41:42Speaker 2: the Eli Settlement, escalating month long violence between Palestinians and
- 1:41:46Speaker 2: Israelis in the West Bank. The next day, some four
- 1:41:49Speaker 2: hundred settlers descended on several Palestinian villages, including tulmas Aya,
- 1:41:54Speaker 2: a prosperous town near Romala, where reportedly they torched cars
- 1:41:59Speaker 2: and homes. I want to I want to stop right there,
- 1:42:02Speaker 2: because it is not reportedly right, Like we do not
- 1:42:07Speaker 2: have to qualify this with like maybe or like we've
- 1:42:10Speaker 2: just seen this on Twitter dot com. Like you could
- 1:42:13Speaker 2: probably see this shit on Google maps, right, Like they
- 1:42:16Speaker 2: torched a town. There's there's massive damage done. Even the
- 1:42:20Speaker 2: New York Times itself didn't qualify it as a reported
- 1:42:25Speaker 2: incident in its own reporting, and that this isn't we
- 1:42:31Speaker 2: don't hear the same thing with the two Palestinian gunmen, right.
- 1:42:36Speaker 2: Just to read the first opening sentence again, last week,
- 1:42:39Speaker 2: two Palestinian carriers killed for Israelis. It's just stated as
- 1:42:43Speaker 2: a fact, right, And these just within those couple of sentences,
- 1:42:49Speaker 2: you can see so much of the bias in the
- 1:42:52Speaker 2: way this is reported so much of the different perspectives
- 1:42:57Speaker 2: through which state violence I would encourage you people not
- 1:43:00Speaker 2: to use terrorism. I would encourage them to see things,
- 1:43:03Speaker 2: especially in this context, in terms of political violence. Right,
- 1:43:07Speaker 2: there is political violence done by both sides. One of
- 1:43:09Speaker 2: those sides is a state actor, the other side is
- 1:43:12Speaker 2: a non state actor. But qualifying one and making it
- 1:43:15Speaker 2: distinct from the other, I think is shoddy journalism, and
- 1:43:20Speaker 2: I don't think it really helps us understand this situation.
- 1:43:24Speaker 2: So what happened, right Like, fifteen homes were burned, sixty
- 1:43:28Speaker 2: vehicles were burned, and the writer's sort of quote unquote,
- 1:43:32Speaker 2: sort of saying this is reportedly. It's not true. It's
- 1:43:35Speaker 2: a thing that really happened. Another kind of phrasing that
- 1:43:38Speaker 2: I've found really objectionable in this instance is clashes, right
- 1:43:43Speaker 2: Like often you'll see clashes in Janine, and like that
- 1:43:49Speaker 2: casts a lens of parity, or it looks at these
- 1:43:52Speaker 2: things through a lens of parity, which I don't think
- 1:43:54Speaker 2: is real on the ground. Like, it's not a clash
- 1:43:57Speaker 2: when a helicopter is firing rockets, even if it's varying
- 1:44:01Speaker 2: rockets at people with kalashnikovs, Right Like, that it's not
- 1:44:05Speaker 2: a clash. There's not really a parody there, right, Like,
- 1:44:09Speaker 2: and it's it also kind of downplaced the violence of
- 1:44:13Speaker 2: what's happening, right, it's an attack, it's an assault. I
- 1:44:16Speaker 2: think the constant use of clashes, right, it's nearly always.
- 1:44:20Speaker 2: You don't really see it used anywhere else. If you
- 1:44:23Speaker 2: if you do, it's for it's for much less severe violence,
- 1:44:26Speaker 2: like like clashes between an arrival football fans, not that
- 1:44:29Speaker 2: that can't be very violent, care, but you don't really
- 1:44:33Speaker 2: see this word used to characterize like state violence on
- 1:44:37Speaker 2: this scale anywhere else. And so I would really encourage
- 1:44:42Speaker 2: people when they're reading, especially coverage of this, right, which
- 1:44:45Speaker 2: is an issue that the US cannot get its head
- 1:44:48Speaker 2: out of its ass about, uh, to look for this
- 1:44:51Speaker 2: bias language. And if you're reading coverage or anything else, right,
- 1:44:55Speaker 2: if you're if you're reading coverage something, and you start
- 1:44:57Speaker 2: to notice that, like I would perhaps question where you're
- 1:44:59Speaker 2: getting your coverage from. And I know you had some
- 1:45:02Speaker 2: shit to say about the New York Times sharing.
- 1:45:04Speaker 6: I mean, yeah, I one really liked what you said
- 1:45:07Speaker 6: about referring to it as state violence versus terrorism, because
- 1:45:11Speaker 6: I think that's a huge point that I also want
- 1:45:14Speaker 6: to adopt because I didn't even really transfer that over
- 1:45:17Speaker 6: until just now when you said it, and I think
- 1:45:19Speaker 6: it's a really important distinction, So thank you for that.
- 1:45:21Speaker 6: But yeah, the New York Times, as well as many,
- 1:45:25Speaker 6: if not most news organizations, they're incredibly biased when it
- 1:45:28Speaker 6: comes to Palestine. Is real reporting, and The New York
- 1:45:31Speaker 6: Times in particular has been absolute dog shit and their
- 1:45:35Speaker 6: coverage of Palestine for quite a while now. There has
- 1:45:38Speaker 6: been a persistent pattern of bias when it comes to
- 1:45:40Speaker 6: Israel and Palestine. I'm going to go in chronological order,
- 1:45:44Speaker 6: and then James will jump back in with the recent
- 1:45:47Speaker 6: article about the New York Times and this terrible thing
- 1:45:50Speaker 6: that it has within it that I'm not going to
- 1:45:51Speaker 6: give away right now. But let's go back in time
- 1:45:54Speaker 6: to February twenty eleven, when The New York Times published
- 1:45:57Speaker 6: a piece on JVP activism in the Bay Area. JVP
- 1:46:01Speaker 6: stands for Jewish Voices for Peace, and this article said,
- 1:46:05Speaker 6: the activists say they are not working against Israel, but
- 1:46:08Speaker 6: against the Israeli government policies they believe are a discriminatory
- 1:46:12Speaker 6: which is yes correct, But in the editor's note, the
- 1:46:16Speaker 6: Times later wrote that one of the articles two authors
- 1:46:19Speaker 6: was a pro Palestinian advocate and that he should not
- 1:46:22Speaker 6: have written the article and should not have been allowed
- 1:46:25Speaker 6: to write it. So it initially seems like good reporting
- 1:46:29Speaker 6: because it's true you're protesting against the Israeli government. But
- 1:46:34Speaker 6: then to say that a Palestinian advocate can't write it
- 1:46:38Speaker 6: is ridiculous, So fuck you New York Times. And then
- 1:46:41Speaker 6: in twenty fifteen, a study was done analyzing the New
- 1:46:45Speaker 6: York Times publications during the period of September tenth and
- 1:46:48Speaker 6: October fourteenth and twenty fifteen. At the time of the
- 1:46:52Speaker 6: study in twenty fifteen, two thousand Palestinians had been injured
- 1:46:56Speaker 6: while eighty three Israelis were injured, just for context of
- 1:47:01Speaker 6: what the reporting was about, and the study analyzed thirty
- 1:47:05Speaker 6: six articles. In these articles, the New York Times talked
- 1:47:08Speaker 6: about Palestinian quote unquote violence thirty six times and Israeli
- 1:47:12Speaker 6: violence two times. The word attack was used to describe
- 1:47:16Speaker 6: Palestinian actions one hundred and ten times, in Israeli actions
- 1:47:21Speaker 6: seventeen times. They use the word terrorist forty two times
- 1:47:25Speaker 6: to refer to Palestinian violence and one time one time
- 1:47:29Speaker 6: to refer to Israeli violence. More than half of the
- 1:47:33Speaker 6: New York Times headlines during that whole year depicted Palestinians
- 1:47:37Speaker 6: as the instigators of violence. Zero headlines depicted Israelis as aggressors.
- 1:47:43Speaker 6: None and nothing has changed. I know that's from a
- 1:47:46Speaker 6: period in twenty fifteen, but that's basically consistent, if not
- 1:47:50Speaker 6: more so prevalent.
- 1:47:51Speaker 3: Now.
- 1:47:52Speaker 6: It just seems like the New York Times editorial board
- 1:47:54Speaker 6: refuses to incorporate Palestinian perspective into its editorials, even though
- 1:47:59Speaker 6: there have been many calls to do so, and this
- 1:48:02Speaker 6: leads it to fundamentally misread the reality on the ground
- 1:48:05Speaker 6: in Palestine. And it clearly shows the newspaper's bias when
- 1:48:08Speaker 6: it comes to what it chooses to include about Palestine
- 1:48:11Speaker 6: and from whom. Of the two thy four hundred and
- 1:48:15Speaker 6: ninety opinion pieces about Palestinians with The New York Times
- 1:48:18Speaker 6: published between nineteen seventy in twenty nineteen, only forty six
- 1:48:24Speaker 6: written by actual Palestinians, which is an average of less
- 1:48:27Speaker 6: than two percent. With the lack of Palestinian and Arab
- 1:48:31Speaker 6: columnists that are even employed by New York Times, a
- 1:48:34Speaker 6: kind of group think has inevitably emerged there, and this
- 1:48:38Speaker 6: group think consistently places Israel, Israeli framings and Israeli perspectives
- 1:48:43Speaker 6: above those of Palestinians. A keyword search of the Times
- 1:48:47Speaker 6: editorials that discuss Palestinians is like this. Between nineteen seventy
- 1:48:52Speaker 6: and twenty nineteen, the word piece appeared one thousand and
- 1:48:56Speaker 6: one hundred and twelve times, but justice only appeared eighty
- 1:48:59Speaker 6: six times. Terror was mentioned six hundred and forty nine times,
- 1:49:03Speaker 6: but occupation was only mentioned two hundred and nineteen times,
- 1:49:07Speaker 6: two hundred and nineteen times. I want to also remind
- 1:49:09Speaker 6: you this is from starting from nineteen seventy. Israel's security
- 1:49:14Speaker 6: quote unquote was written ninety times, but Palestinian freedom was
- 1:49:18Speaker 6: mentioned just three times. While keyboard searches alone do not
- 1:49:24Speaker 6: tell the whole story, they do help us get a
- 1:49:26Speaker 6: sense of the overall tenor of the Times coverage, and
- 1:49:30Speaker 6: over the last five decades, Israel has been unquestioningly presented
- 1:49:34Speaker 6: by Times editors as a close ally, while the Palestinians
- 1:49:37Speaker 6: have been consistently framed as a problem.
- 1:49:41Speaker 2: So I want to talk about this. There was an
- 1:49:43Speaker 2: excellent piece that came out in Study Hall. I believe
- 1:49:46Speaker 2: it's based on some reporting in a Canadian outlet called
- 1:49:48Speaker 2: Passage and Study Hall is a freelance journalists like group
- 1:49:56Speaker 2: Localists serve, but they also do some editorial work. It's
- 1:50:00Speaker 2: talking about this this Israeli nonprofit or it's really funded
- 1:50:03Speaker 2: nonprofits based in the US and also in Israel called
- 1:50:07Speaker 2: Honest Reporting. What it is is a five oh one c.
- 1:50:10Speaker 2: Three And essentially what they've done is is what Sharene
- 1:50:15Speaker 2: describes right where they've they've found not I believe, mostly
- 1:50:20Speaker 2: Palestinian reporters, perhaps also non Palastinian reporters who are reporting
- 1:50:25Speaker 2: from this. I guess from what I would described as
- 1:50:29Speaker 2: the facts based approach to this, which is describing what's
- 1:50:32Speaker 2: happening as an apartheid and they've dived into these people's background,
- 1:50:39Speaker 2: their previous tweets, their previous writing, their other work to
- 1:50:44Speaker 2: describe them as biased and get their articles taken down.
- 1:50:48Speaker 2: They've done this to some very like this has happened
- 1:50:51Speaker 2: at the time, and this is at a time, like
- 1:50:54Speaker 2: I know Sharen mentioned something that happened in twenty eleven,
- 1:50:57Speaker 2: but I know that in twenty ten the Jerusalem bureau
- 1:51:01Speaker 2: chief of the Times had a child serving in the
- 1:51:02Speaker 2: IDF Right. So like you know, if if I had
- 1:51:08Speaker 2: a you know, if I was a journalist, and I said, yeah,
- 1:51:12Speaker 2: you know, I actually have a son who's in the
- 1:51:13Speaker 2: Aleaxa Martyrs Brigade. Like then they're not going to not
- 1:51:16Speaker 2: going to commission my piece. But they've for instance, Hosam Salem.
- 1:51:23Speaker 2: Have you seen Sam's work?
- 1:51:25Speaker 3: I don't know.
- 1:51:26Speaker 6: My brain doesn't create.
- 1:51:28Speaker 2: I've worked with a sum before. It's a friend of mine.
- 1:51:30Speaker 2: He's an incredibly gifted photojournalist. People should follow him on
- 1:51:33Speaker 2: the places where they see photographs. He's blacklisted by The
- 1:51:37Speaker 2: Times based on an honest reporting probe into his quote
- 1:51:40Speaker 2: unquote bias, which his photos of Gaza are some of
- 1:51:46Speaker 2: the most emotive photographs of Gaza I've ever seen. And
- 1:51:50Speaker 2: I work with him on a piece that will one
- 1:51:52Speaker 2: day become a podcast about Parkour in the Gaza Strip.
- 1:51:56Speaker 2: But yeah, Hossam is a fantastic photo journal Listen absolutely
- 1:52:01Speaker 2: like it is. It's utterly ridiculous to have like have
- 1:52:05Speaker 2: him blacklisted by a major news organization, which, like, whether
- 1:52:08Speaker 2: we like it or not, that is where a lot
- 1:52:11Speaker 2: of Americans get their news. In one instance, this organization
- 1:52:15Speaker 2: managed to get the Toronto Start to scrub all uses
- 1:52:18Speaker 2: of Palestine from their stories to include shit like yeah,
- 1:52:24Speaker 2: like the like they were profiling a DJ who was
- 1:52:26Speaker 2: Palestinian and wow, which I think is like incredibly illustrative,
- 1:52:33Speaker 2: right that, Like this is organization presents itself as fighting
- 1:52:37Speaker 2: anti Israeli bias, which I'm sure that is a thing
- 1:52:40Speaker 2: that exists. It fucking does not exist in the US media.
- 1:52:44Speaker 2: Like I'm I'm not a Palestinian person, by speak as
- 1:52:48Speaker 2: a person who has pitched articles about conflict in various
- 1:52:52Speaker 2: parts of the world, and they can tell you that
- 1:52:53Speaker 2: that that is not a bias that I have come across,
- 1:52:55Speaker 2: having worked with almost every big outlet that it is
- 1:52:59Speaker 2: possible to work for in the US. And it's not
- 1:53:03Speaker 2: doing that. It's trying to raise Palestine and Palestinian people
- 1:53:07Speaker 2: not only their perspectives but their whole existence. Right, And
- 1:53:11Speaker 2: this is something that I hop on a lot, But like,
- 1:53:13Speaker 2: I think we should do more conflict reporting that's about people,
- 1:53:16Speaker 2: unless it is about numbers and battles and such like.
- 1:53:18Speaker 2: That's why I want to write about little girls who's
- 1:53:21Speaker 2: surfing Gaza and young men who do parkour, because like
- 1:53:25Speaker 2: when Israel bombs Gaza, it doesn't just bomb people who
- 1:53:31Speaker 2: are part of fatal or humas or whatever they want
- 1:53:35Speaker 2: to say. They're targeting, right, like the lions den or genymbrias,
- 1:53:41Speaker 2: whatever they're When they're bombing these places, they're also bombing children.
- 1:53:44Speaker 2: They're also bombing places where little kids want to go
- 1:53:47Speaker 2: and play football. They're bombing towns where little boys want
- 1:53:51Speaker 2: to I mean the hospitals and schools, and yeah, like
- 1:53:55Speaker 2: the this is where people just like you live. It's
- 1:53:57Speaker 2: not like it's a very clear desire to kind of
- 1:54:02Speaker 2: erase Palestinian civilians, I guess from my narrative, and it's
- 1:54:05Speaker 2: really important that we as journalists and as people don't
- 1:54:08Speaker 2: allow that to happen. I guess you can. We'll link
- 1:54:10Speaker 2: to this in our sources at the end of the month,
- 1:54:12Speaker 2: but I think it's an excellent piece. It's worth reading.
- 1:54:15Speaker 6: Thank you parentialing that before we continue with some really
- 1:54:21Speaker 6: excellent new things. Let's take our second break and we'll
- 1:54:24Speaker 6: be right back.
- 1:54:25Speaker 2: Yes, way back, And I want to talk a little
- 1:54:30Speaker 2: bit more about h the I guess the Israeli political
- 1:54:34Speaker 2: context behind the increasing aggression towards Janina and Palestini in general.
- 1:54:39Speaker 2: So of the one hundred and sixty five Palestinian deaths.
- 1:54:42Speaker 2: About eighty six are in the North and West Bank,
- 1:54:44Speaker 2: mostly in the areas of Janine and Nublists, which cannot
- 1:54:48Speaker 2: come incidainly are the areas where we're seeing new armed
- 1:54:49Speaker 2: groups emerging. Despite this, Israel it's ready to massively step
- 1:54:53Speaker 2: up settlement in the West Bank. Earlier in June, Prime
- 1:54:56Speaker 2: Minister Benjamin then Yahoo ratified a policy allowing pro settler
- 1:55:00Speaker 2: finance Minister that's Aleel Smotridge to bypass the six days
- 1:55:05Speaker 2: process for building settlements, effectively giving him the ability to
- 1:55:08Speaker 2: make settlement decisions on its own. In recent years, Israeli
- 1:55:11Speaker 2: politicians as settlers have become more and more open about
- 1:55:14Speaker 2: their goals annexing most, if not all, of the West Bank.
- 1:55:18Speaker 2: So March of this year, Smartridge claimed that Palestinian people
- 1:55:22Speaker 2: were an invention of the last century. It's probably worth
- 1:55:27Speaker 2: taking a moment to point out that all national identities
- 1:55:29Speaker 2: are inherently constructed. If humanity did not come to earth
- 1:55:32Speaker 2: with flags, those are things that came to exist in
- 1:55:36Speaker 2: the nineteenth and twentieth century. Like, so is Israel right,
- 1:55:42Speaker 2: we can kind of put a date on that one.
- 1:55:44Speaker 3: So that's just so that's.
- 1:55:45Speaker 6: Like literally projecting an invention of the last century is
- 1:55:49Speaker 6: literally Israel whatever, Yes, the state of Israel.
- 1:55:52Speaker 2: Yeah, I mean nations calling other nations constructed. Is the
- 1:55:55Speaker 2: kind of the popcorn in the cow blackleg. Yeah, but
- 1:55:59Speaker 2: in some much as if we're going to do that,
- 1:56:02Speaker 2: I think is rarely throwing stones from a glasshouse.
- 1:56:05Speaker 6: Yeah exactly.
- 1:56:07Speaker 2: It's like it doesn't really fucking matter either, right, Like
- 1:56:10Speaker 2: it doesn't matter how long the one group of people
- 1:56:12Speaker 2: has had one flag, you still shouldn't fucking kill children,
- 1:56:18Speaker 2: which applies to anyone involved in the killing of children.
- 1:56:21Speaker 2: Smatrich said that there was no such thing as a
- 1:56:24Speaker 2: Palestinian because there is no such thing as a Palestinian people.
- 1:56:28Speaker 2: In a speech in Paris and a memorial for Jack Koppa,
- 1:56:30Speaker 2: an Activisty's else right wing LIQUD party. Do you know
- 1:56:34Speaker 2: who are the Palestinians? He said, I'm a Palestinian, going
- 1:56:39Speaker 2: on to describe his late grandfather, who he said was
- 1:56:42Speaker 2: a thirteenth generation Jerusalem might as a true Palestinian, which
- 1:56:48Speaker 2: is somewhat Look, these people are supposed to be contradictory,
- 1:56:51Speaker 2: Like it's not really worth sucking pointing this out, but
- 1:56:53Speaker 2: like you can't simultaneously say there aren't a Palestinians. Palestine
- 1:56:56Speaker 2: doesn't exist. Also, I'm a Palestinian, right, it is again
- 1:57:01Speaker 2: not the point. I guess he was a resident. He
- 1:57:04Speaker 2: is a resident one of the settlements himself. He's an
- 1:57:07Speaker 2: advocate for theocratic law, the segregation of maternity wards. So
- 1:57:11Speaker 2: he doesn't want Arab and Israeli women to give birth
- 1:57:15Speaker 2: in the same ridiculous Yeah, it's his justification for it
- 1:57:19Speaker 2: is like even worse, but I won't bother with that.
- 1:57:22Speaker 2: He's also openly homophobic, and he supports the conspiracy theory
- 1:57:27Speaker 2: that Jitzach Rabin was killed by Israel security agencies. All around.
- 1:57:32Speaker 2: Top guy Benjamin and Yahoo's party likes to use names
- 1:57:37Speaker 2: for the West Bank that you might find in the Bible,
- 1:57:39Speaker 2: and it's made accelerating a legal settlement there a priority.
- 1:57:42Speaker 2: Since it took office that Yahoos coalition has approved seven
- 1:57:45Speaker 2: thousand new housing units, many in the occupied West Bank.
- 1:57:49Speaker 2: The government also amended law to clear the way for
- 1:57:51Speaker 2: settlers to return to four settlements that have previously been evacuated.
- 1:57:56Speaker 2: Within a week of having power to make these decisions,
- 1:57:58Speaker 2: smart Rich approved five thousand new units. We this is
- 1:58:05Speaker 2: a great time to draw attention to one of the
- 1:58:07Speaker 2: most fucking infuriating paragraphs that has ever been written, which
- 1:58:12Speaker 2: I found in a New York Times article that.
- 1:58:16Speaker 6: I can't believe this is real. James said it to
- 1:58:18Speaker 6: me before this, and it is crazy.
- 1:58:22Speaker 2: I like the century and stuff I know will make
- 1:58:24Speaker 2: her angry. Of course, not all West Bank settlers are
- 1:58:28Speaker 2: alter nationalists who believe that living in the land of
- 1:58:30Speaker 2: the Bible is a religious edict. Most settlers, in fact,
- 1:58:33Speaker 2: including hundreds of thousands of Altra Orthodox News, move there
- 1:58:36Speaker 2: seeking a portable housing. I am fucking like I cannot
- 1:58:41Speaker 2: real lost it when.
- 1:58:42Speaker 6: I got here. Yeah, I checked out mentally. I catapopled
- 1:58:46Speaker 6: myself into outer space. I don't want to be here anymore.
- 1:58:49Speaker 6: That is ridiculous.
- 1:58:50Speaker 2: I have decided to curl up into a ball and
- 1:58:52Speaker 2: no longer exist. Like this is from the newspaper as well,
- 1:58:55Speaker 2: that like went so fucking ham on people in twenty twenty,
- 1:58:59Speaker 2: like taking milk from a target, you know, like when
- 1:59:04Speaker 2: you like seeking affordable dairy products. I guess could have
- 1:59:07Speaker 2: been an alternative frameing of that that they didn't. They
- 1:59:09Speaker 2: didn't go for it. It just fucking unbelievable, like the
- 1:59:12Speaker 2: like the shit that free economics has done to people's brains.
- 1:59:16Speaker 2: Is it's really next level. But more people listen to
- 1:59:20Speaker 2: our podcasts in their podcast because we're winning in the
- 1:59:22Speaker 2: marketplace of ideas and so all in seven hundred and
- 1:59:27Speaker 2: fifty thousand people live in these settlements. But being a
- 1:59:31Speaker 2: legal under international law doesn't really mean anything unless that
- 1:59:34Speaker 2: law is enforced. And it really is. We spoke earlier
- 1:59:37Speaker 2: this before, right, just like the US, which frequently violates
- 1:59:40Speaker 2: Domexican international law on its own border, Israel is simply
- 1:59:42Speaker 2: not held to account for its crimes. United Nations Special
- 1:59:45Speaker 2: Reporteur and Palestine Francisco Albernesi told Al Jazeera international law
- 1:59:50Speaker 2: has a quote unquote problem of enforcement. There is a
- 1:59:54Speaker 2: problem of double standards because clearly when it comes to Palestine,
- 1:59:57Speaker 2: there is a cognitive dissonance, especially among West countries and
- 2:00:00Speaker 2: reticents in applying these coercive measures and all the prohibitions
- 2:00:03Speaker 2: international law of thoughts are Benici said.
- 2:00:06Speaker 6: Yeah, we already mentioned how just even the phrase international law,
- 2:00:11Speaker 6: it's just make believe like you always hear about Israel,
- 2:00:17Speaker 6: even like committing crimes against humanity, None of that even
- 2:00:20Speaker 6: seems to matter when it comes to Israel. Because there's
- 2:00:23Speaker 6: never a repercussion.
- 2:00:25Speaker 2: Yeah, it doesn't matter anywhere that there's no direct interest
- 2:00:28Speaker 2: to capital to enforcing that law. Right, it doesn't matter
- 2:00:31Speaker 2: when young women in mem are get raped by soldiers.
- 2:00:34Speaker 2: It doesn't matter when villages get burned down there, It
- 2:00:37Speaker 2: doesn't matter in to grie in Ethiopia and Eritrea because
- 2:00:41Speaker 2: there's no interest to finance capital of solving that problem.
- 2:00:45Speaker 2: It's not just a Palestine thing. It's the thing all
- 2:00:50Speaker 2: over the world. And laws are fundamentally backed up by violence. Right,
- 2:00:56Speaker 2: Like in America, if you get a parking ticket and
- 2:00:58Speaker 2: you don't pay your parking ticket and you go to court,
- 2:01:00Speaker 2: and you don't go to court, eventually someone with a
- 2:01:02Speaker 2: gun will come and kick down your door. And like
- 2:01:05Speaker 2: all laws are based in violence. And there ain't no
- 2:01:09Speaker 2: one kicking down Israel's door, right, and no one will.
- 2:01:13Speaker 2: And so it doesn't matter. International law doesn't matter. It's
- 2:01:17Speaker 2: it's nice and it's there. We can point to it
- 2:01:18Speaker 2: and say, look, we've all agreed this is bad, but
- 2:01:20Speaker 2: we all know it's bad. That we don't really need
- 2:01:22Speaker 2: a bunch of like old men suits to tell us
- 2:01:25Speaker 2: it's bad. We knew it was bad. What we needed
- 2:01:26Speaker 2: to fucking make it stop, and that's not happening.
- 2:01:30Speaker 6: Yeah. I think it's also interesting to mention that internationally,
- 2:01:35Speaker 6: even when you get better quote unquote reporting about Palestine,
- 2:01:38Speaker 6: it still is not enough because it's usually about peace
- 2:01:42Speaker 6: and both sides or a conflict or whatever. So I
- 2:01:45Speaker 6: just think, I mean that also goes back to news
- 2:01:48Speaker 6: and how it's reported. But this stubborn insistence on blaming
- 2:01:53Speaker 6: both sides is reflective of a deeply flawed quote unquote
- 2:01:57Speaker 6: peace framework, and it has dominated the international under standing
- 2:02:00Speaker 6: of the Israel Palestine quote unquote conflict for decades. The
- 2:02:04Speaker 6: framework of peace centers on identity politics and ignores the
- 2:02:08Speaker 6: structural violence that the state perpetuates against oppressed groups and
- 2:02:13Speaker 6: instead focuses on acts of spectacular violence committed by those
- 2:02:17Speaker 6: groups in response to the oppression they face. And it
- 2:02:20Speaker 6: also blames them for escalating conflict and then uses it
- 2:02:24Speaker 6: to justify the repressive violence by the more powerful forces.
- 2:02:30Speaker 6: To go back to New York Times briefly, many of
- 2:02:32Speaker 6: the Time's editorials over the last thirty years since the
- 2:02:35Speaker 6: advent of the Oslo Accords have been steeped in the
- 2:02:39Speaker 6: peace framework. They treat israelis a Palestinians as having equal
- 2:02:44Speaker 6: power when they clearly don't. They praise Israel for minor
- 2:02:48Speaker 6: adjustments to its daily structural violence against Palestinians, but in
- 2:02:52Speaker 6: the same breath they scold Palestinian leaders and society for
- 2:02:56Speaker 6: acts of violence done in turn. And the word is
- 2:03:00Speaker 6: also problematic in and of itself, because Palestine isn't some
- 2:03:04Speaker 6: conflict or problem for Israel to sort out. It's a
- 2:03:07Speaker 6: cause for everyone to fight for. Since nineteen forty eight,
- 2:03:10Speaker 6: the Israeli state has prevented Palestinians from living in their
- 2:03:14Speaker 6: homeland with freedom and dignity, whether it's by banning refugees
- 2:03:18Speaker 6: from returning to their homes, or discriminating against Palestinian citizens
- 2:03:22Speaker 6: inside Israel, or keeping millions of Palestinians under military occupation.
- 2:03:27Speaker 6: If there is a problem to be solved, that problem
- 2:03:30Speaker 6: is the regime itself. But this fact of bias and
- 2:03:37Speaker 6: shitty reporting, and the fact that the truth is not
- 2:03:41Speaker 6: out of there, that fact seems to have eluded the
- 2:03:43Speaker 6: Times editorial board because, rather than recognize the systemic violence, discrimination,
- 2:03:49Speaker 6: and colonization perpetuated by Israel against Palestinians, the board blames
- 2:03:54Speaker 6: quote unquote both sides for a vastly asymmetric situation. This
- 2:03:59Speaker 6: both sides may give the appearance of balance, but it
- 2:04:03Speaker 6: does not reflect the reality in which Israel holds almost
- 2:04:06Speaker 6: total political, economic, and military power over the lives of
- 2:04:11Speaker 6: every Palestinian in a system that growing numbers of scholars,
- 2:04:15Speaker 6: human rights groups, and legal experts are defining as apartheid.
- 2:04:20Speaker 6: But I do hope some of this was at least helpful,
- 2:04:24Speaker 6: and I mean probably be back to do the same
- 2:04:28Speaker 6: kind of thing soon because Israel is relentless and stupid
- 2:04:31Speaker 6: and I hate it. So until then, fuck the IDF
- 2:04:36Speaker 6: and have a nice day.
- 2:04:40Speaker 1: Hey, We'll be back Monday with more episodes every week
- 2:04:44Speaker 1: from now until the heat death of the universe.
- 2:04:46Speaker 6: It Could Happen here as a production of cool Zone Media.
- 2:04:49Speaker 6: For more podcasts from cool Zone Media, visit our website
- 2:04:51Speaker 6: coolzonemedia dot com, or check us out on the iHeartRadio app,
- 2:04:55Speaker 6: Apple Podcasts, or wherever you listen to podcasts. You can
- 2:04:58Speaker 6: find sources for It Could Happen Here updates and monthly
- 2:05:00Speaker 6: at coolzonemedia dot com slash sources. Thanks for listening.