Latest / None of Your Business Podcast / The Trauma No One Talks About: Soldiers Reveal the Reality of War in Gaza
Transcript
- 0:00The Israeli army, specifically a soldier, I don't care to what
- 0:03capacity. You are my hero and you are
- 0:05incredible people. When the war happened, I went to
- 0:08Israel to fight. I came back and I felt in a way
- 0:12that I did something so meaningful fighting for Israel.
- 0:16Impossible to go to Gaza and come back to see in person but
- 0:18no one talks about it because no one wants to be the guy asking
- 0:21for help but it's OK to ask for battery.
- 0:22The fact is that in this land, whatever it is, there's millions
- 0:26of Jews that are residing here and they have a life here in
- 0:29this communities. And we're we're actively being
- 0:32attacked from all sides. And at the end of the day, you
- 0:34can't sit idly by. Even if you're.
- 0:40Business Oshi. None of your business, Michael.
- 0:43It's the None of Your Business podcast hosted by Michael and
- 0:46Oshi. Welcome back everybody to
- 0:48another incredible episode of the None of Your Business
- 0:51podcast. I'm your host, Michael
- 0:52Greenfield joined with my Co host Oshi Schwartz.
- 0:54We are produced and sponsored by the Prime Source family.
- 0:58Thank you again to everyone behind the scenes for always
- 1:01doing an amazing job putting this together.
- 1:03Oshi, I saved the word incredible for this podcast.
- 1:06I've never used it before. From what I understand, it's
- 1:09worthy that you saved it for this moment, yes.
- 1:11So I'm anticipating this to be an incredible.
- 1:14Well, it is, and it's because I'm here with two incredible
- 1:16people, and we're going to introduce you in a moment, Haim
- 1:20and Akiva. But before I do, I just want to
- 1:22mention, and I've said this before, anyone who teaches me
- 1:25something, I call them a rabbi. People say, hey, don't call me a
- 1:27rabbi. You taught me something.
- 1:29You're a rabbi to me, someone serving in the Israeli army,
- 1:32specifically a soldier. I don't care to what capacity.
- 1:35You are my hero and you are incredible people.
- 1:38Thank you so much for joining us.
- 1:39We are joined by Chi and Misels and Akiba Shapiro, if you guys
- 1:43don't mind. Let's get straight into it.
- 1:45Just give us a quick introduction.
- 1:46I'm curious about your history, your background.
- 1:49I know a lot of people already heard your story, but some of
- 1:51our listeners have not. Some people know your story, but
- 1:55maybe not as well. But I would like to know, take
- 1:58us to the beginning of who you are as a person and what brought
- 2:01you to the Israeli army. Like that's what I want to know.
- 2:03Like that's. Yeah, I don't even ask those on
- 2:05interviews anymore. Like tell me about yourself.
- 2:08Sorry, that's why I'm saying I'm not.
- 2:09I'm specifically saying I that's why I pinpointed it for a
- 2:12reason. I said take me to the point
- 2:14where you're like, I'm going to the Israeli army and a little
- 2:16bit about your background, who you are, but let's straight to
- 2:19like, I can't even go for it. Because I went first.
- 2:22You go, you go. I went to Yeshiva Nordavid, 60
- 2:28guys, two guys without visas. Somebody did come knocking
- 2:32saying who are the two guys without visas, join or go home.
- 2:36So I went home. Now I'm like maybe I should go
- 2:40to. Got back on a plane the next
- 2:42year, went right to the drafting office which got a goose went
- 2:47in. Wow, that's all because you
- 2:50didn't have a visa. It's all because I didn't have a
- 2:51visa. Now I was born in Ariti Straw,
- 2:54so I'm Israeli by birth and figured if at any point I wanted
- 2:59to go back and live there, get it out of the way now.
- 3:03Wow, I'm done. I don't understand.
- 3:05So you were born Israel, but you lived here pretty much your
- 3:08whole. Life My mother made aliyah when
- 3:09she was 16. My father graduated undergrad,
- 3:14was travelling Europe and decided to go through Israel.
- 3:16On his way, my parents locked eyes.
- 3:19Somewhere here I am, but they were in Israel at the time, so I
- 3:23was born. There, right?
- 3:24So the minute you're born in Israel.
- 3:25Yeah, but he's you're an American citizen.
- 3:27We're also. Dual citizen.
- 3:28Yeah, dual citizen, right. So you didn't have a visa.
- 3:31What does that mean? You didn't have a visa.
- 3:32Because I have an Israeli passport, so I can go in and out
- 3:34of Israel with my Israeli passport.
- 3:36You don't need a student visa. So when you were there for
- 3:39Yeshiva? Easiest calculation, 58 guys
- 3:42with, two guys without. There is no sorting.
- 3:44You know exactly you're going to.
- 3:46The other guy didn't want to go. He hired somebody.
- 3:49I think he doused himself in alcohol, urine, this that and
- 3:52they wouldn't take him. Oh, is that a move?
- 3:54Apparently it was a move. Pay attention Khareti people in
- 3:57Israel just doused yourself. You weren't allowed to leave the
- 4:01country. You couldn't leave Israel.
- 4:02I wasn't. They didn't want me to stay if I
- 4:06didn't go join the army as a citizen.
- 4:08Every citizen joins the army. Interesting.
- 4:11Wow, you mean every citizen should join the army?
- 4:14Woo brings us to. Chime here by opinion.
- 4:17We should take away the citizenship.
- 4:19No, no. So Chime, tell us a little bit
- 4:21about your background now then. OK, I'm Chime.
- 4:25I grew up in Williamsburg Hasidis that my family so it
- 4:30started I was fascinated about the Holocaust.
- 4:32I was everything Holocaust related spoke to me a lot.
- 4:36I was very interested in speaking to my grandfather about
- 4:38it or whoever else was willing to talk about it.
- 4:41I was like, tell me more. So back and forth.
- 4:45In a way, I kind of, I wasn't the Holocaust denier, but it
- 4:47just seems so far away from reality that I was like, tell me
- 4:51more like, so I want to understand what's going on here.
- 4:54And then when I went to Israel the first time, I was like, this
- 4:58is amazing. Like you have, you had a
- 5:00Holocaust and now we have our own country, our own state, and
- 5:04we can fight as Jews, we can be Jewish and have a land and
- 5:07protect and kind of try to prevent another Holocaust.
- 5:11How old were you when you went to Israel first time?
- 5:14That I remember 1011, I was there once when I was very
- 5:17little that I don't remember or no decisions were made.
- 5:20But since then it started like start to think about it more and
- 5:23more. And as I grew older I was like
- 5:25back and forth thinking does it make sense?
- 5:27Does it not? And then I had a hard time just
- 5:32where I was going in life in terms of Satmar.
- 5:35So I was like, if I'm not as Satmar anyway, maybe I should
- 5:39just do that and then continue my life on.
- 5:42And that's what happened. So I went to Israel.
- 5:46My initial plan was to join the IDF for 18 months.
- 5:49I didn't know that I'm going to be good at it or I had no
- 5:52background, no one really to tell me how it's going to be.
- 5:55So I joined for 18 months initially and that became close
- 6:00to six years. Wow, 18 months is a program for
- 6:04those that don't understand. Yeah.
- 6:05So I actually, well, I'll, I'll say that I ultimately thought I
- 6:07was going for 18 months because I looked into nothing.
- 6:11I had three or four friends that went, we're having a great time,
- 6:13a little bit older than me. When I was going in, they were
- 6:15getting out. I also thought I was going to
- 6:17what's called Maha, the volunteer service, and I guess
- 6:23getting close towards the end of the 18 months and I went to the
- 6:25guy, I'm like, so am I getting out?
- 6:28He's like, no, you still have another like 18 months left.
- 6:32I was like, what are you talking about?
- 6:35IDF tricked me. Wow, they tricked you to combat?
- 6:40You had a you had a citizenship in Israel.
- 6:42I know I didn't really. I didn't really think about it
- 6:45before. There's a lot more.
- 6:48Organizations today that will guide you where to go, what they
- 6:52do, how long, how to get this back then.
- 6:57Not that I would have taken advantage of it, because you
- 7:00ought to be smart to do that, but yeah, not in any way.
- 7:03Can I, can I answer something? You mentioned you joined the IDF
- 7:08voluntarily and you're from Sotmer.
- 7:10I mean, I think we we got to call this out there.
- 7:13There certainly is a lot of conflict between between the
- 7:17two. So what was that transition
- 7:19like? Like how did your family take
- 7:21it? That's a big jump.
- 7:23You know, growing up in summer background and going to Israel
- 7:26and then going into the army is a stark contrast.
- 7:30So like what was like? How did that develop?
- 7:33So there's a few separate parts in this.
- 7:35So one part that I wasn't Southerner anymore means I was.
- 7:39I still like a lot of Southerner people.
- 7:41I have a lot of friends in Southerner and I have a
- 7:43tremendous amount of respect for them just the way that I see
- 7:47Israel. And in that aspect, I wasn't, I
- 7:50was kind of openly saying I think Israel should be a state
- 7:53and then whatever it is. So it wasn't such a surprise in
- 7:57that aspect. And I, I had my struggle with
- 8:02religion for, for a little bit at that time.
- 8:05So it was kind of wasn't such a big deal.
- 8:07I think people took it as a big deal in the beginning, but then
- 8:10as time went on, I was explaining I have nothing
- 8:13against anyone. I'm, you know, I'm not here to
- 8:15poke anyone's eyes or in any way.
- 8:17I'm just here because I think this is what I should do.
- 8:20This is the right thing for me at the time and that's why I did
- 8:23it. I'm still till today, I don't
- 8:25think I ever bashed that matter. I have nothing against anyone.
- 8:28Like I understand where they're coming from.
- 8:30I understand what I believe. I think is the right thing at
- 8:33it. Like now.
- 8:36Yeah, I think that the communities have softened their
- 8:40stance when it comes to Israel and Israel as a state ever
- 8:44since. You know, lots of things have
- 8:46been happening in the last four or five years.
- 8:49I think it's changed a little bit.
- 8:50I think it's shifted. I don't think it's as it once
- 8:54was. Would you agree?
- 8:56So I don't think here's the thing, the fight between Satmar
- 9:01or the Orthodox communities with Zionism as a whole didn't start
- 9:06when Israel was created, right? It started early 1800s, right
- 9:11when the whole Zionist movement started when, when that old
- 9:13thing. And that was their main issue.
- 9:15And I think they didn't believe that Israel will ever become a
- 9:18state. And with time, as Israel became
- 9:20a state, they said, hey, there is no way that's a state and
- 9:23we're going to fight the state of Israel because there's no way
- 9:25that's going to actually continue.
- 9:28Like they didn't believe that Israel will stay a state and now
- 9:31that it was a fact. And there is millions of Jews we
- 9:34have to protect, right? There's a couple million Jews in
- 9:36Israel that they're there. They're Jewish people that our
- 9:40people, We need to fight and take care of them.
- 9:42At this point it's defense. It's literally self-defense.
- 9:44That's what it is like. I look at, I look at the IDF in
- 9:47a way like a shamram patrol of Israel.
- 9:51Interesting. Like it's people who are Jewish,
- 9:54people from every community, and they are out there to protect
- 9:58their community. It's not like we're going to
- 10:01somewhere else to fight, right? We have our community, we're
- 10:04there. We grew up there.
- 10:06We speak the language now we got to fight for it.
- 10:08That's the way I see it. Yeah, yeah, that makes a lot of
- 10:11sense. Yeah, I actually like the way
- 10:12you're looking at it. To be honest, I never heard it
- 10:14that way. It's only.
- 10:15Take that word state out of the. Equity for a minute.
- 10:18The fact is that in this land, whatever it is, there's millions
- 10:22of Jews that are residing here and they have a life here and
- 10:25there's communities here and we're we're actively being
- 10:28attacked from all sides. And at the end of the day, you
- 10:30can't sit idly by. You got to do something about
- 10:33it. And there are, there are people
- 10:34like you do and, and, and, and thousands and thousands of
- 10:37soldiers that are, that are out there putting their lives at
- 10:39risk to protect their brothers and sisters.
- 10:41That's a very simple way to really look at it without all
- 10:44the politics. Right.
- 10:46And if you speak to our enemies, they're not saying they're
- 10:50against Israel or particular parts of Israel.
- 10:54They're saying very clear that they're against all the Jews,
- 10:57right? And we know, for example, in
- 10:591937, there was the massacre in Chevron where they killed a holy
- 11:03Shiva of boys was way before there was a state of Israel.
- 11:06So they're out there to kill you.
- 11:08Doesn't matter what you do, how you do.
- 11:10They call a settler not just someone who lives in Judea and
- 11:14Samaria. The guy in Tel Aviv to them is a
- 11:17settler as well. So they're out there to kill
- 11:19you. They're out there to fight you.
- 11:21And we need to protect ourselves.
- 11:22That's why it's the Israeli Defense Force.
- 11:25We're there to protect, to fight you.
- 11:29You mentioned the words. Sorry.
- 11:30Go ahead. No, it's true because you could
- 11:32be walking in. I mean, you be in College in in
- 11:34in Colombia if you're Jewish, not.
- 11:37To get you right. Nothing to do with Israel.
- 11:38Yeah, not even you're. Not even there.
- 11:40Don't even. They don't even know if you've
- 11:41ever been. Could be that you're even
- 11:44against it, right? Could be your sattner.
- 11:47Like real sattner. I feel like they're using the
- 11:49word Zionism in general. And that's what I wanted to ask
- 11:52you because you mentioned Off the Air before that there's
- 11:54something going on with in your world and maybe you could talk
- 11:57about it for a second. But to try to explain to me at
- 12:00least better and to any of the listeners, how the word Zionism
- 12:03is being used and how it's being abused, perhaps, And I'll just
- 12:06try to understand that better. So Zionism we're jumping.
- 12:12Fast. Zionism was created right by an
- 12:16idea almost 200 years ago, right?
- 12:19The first Zionist Congress happened in 1897 in back in
- 12:23Europe, that's in America started things.
- 12:25So Zionism was created in order to take Jews together and have
- 12:31our own establishment. Because until then Jews were all
- 12:34over the world, right? And we didn't have even it like
- 12:37in the beginning, if you go down there weren't even talking so
- 12:40much about Israel. It was just let's get a Jewish
- 12:42identity and have us together because they had all those
- 12:44things against the Jews right now when they create, we're
- 12:49going to go a different pat and then we'll come back.
- 12:53So when they created Zionism, they created in a way, a big
- 12:56bubble, I would say. So there's a bunch of agencies
- 12:59that were being created, like the World Zionists Organization,
- 13:03the Jewish Agency, Jewish Federation, the Kakal, which is
- 13:08Kanakam. At least they bought a bunch of
- 13:10kind of agencies that were starting to fight for the Jews
- 13:13and for it to be a state. Now, the plan was once Israel
- 13:18becomes a state, this is going to be the government, the
- 13:21government of Israel and government agencies.
- 13:23Now, for a lot of different political reasons, it didn't
- 13:26happen that way. What happened was the Knesset
- 13:28open. You know, the founders of
- 13:31Israel, I'm talking in Israel, didn't go with the Zionist
- 13:34Congress, open their own thing. Now the Zionist Congress still
- 13:38has a big power. They own 30 to 40% of land in
- 13:41Israel. They still own and big budget, a
- 13:44lot of big influences. Now how what, Because they
- 13:49control so much money. How is it divided now?
- 13:52There is 500 delegate seats in the Zionist Congress.
- 13:56It's divided by thirds. 1/3 is Havrek Ness, it's from Israel
- 14:00have a say. 1/3 is Jews just from America, and a third is
- 14:05Jews all over the world. They get together once in five
- 14:08years through elections and they kind of form committees and
- 14:13subcommittees and those committees are in charge of the
- 14:16money and to represent the Jews around the world.
- 14:19Now, because it's Zionism, most Hasidic Jews or Orthodox, not
- 14:25even Hasidic didn't want to be affiliated with it because we
- 14:27know in the beginning Zionism wasn't so pro religion.
- 14:31Now what happened was a lot of the Reform and conservative
- 14:33communities took over the Zionist Congress.
- 14:36And what I mean by taking over is, for example, the the lawsuit
- 14:41in Israel against kosher cell phones was funded by WZO money.
- 14:46Woman of the Wall are being funded by WZO money.
- 14:49There's a lot of other different agencies that are being funded
- 14:52by money that belongs to everyone and should fight for
- 14:56Jews, and they're being used against a certain part.
- 14:59Of it sounds like they need Elon Musk over there.
- 15:01They really. Do.
- 15:03They really do. And they, and there's a lot of
- 15:04other bad things they're doing for the Jews saying, for
- 15:08example, there's fighting and saying we represent the Jews of
- 15:11America and we want a 2 state solution.
- 15:13I know I don't want a 2 state solution.
- 15:15I believe you guys also don't want a 2 state solution.
- 15:17But there are others saying they represent you, which they don't.
- 15:21So elections are coming up now and I'm running with Erik
- 15:24Sarkoi. This is just one of the Kareti
- 15:26parties. And what we're going to try to
- 15:28fight it. We're going to get in.
- 15:29We're going to be able hopefully to get a lot of votes and stand
- 15:33up there and say, no, you don't represent us.
- 15:35We represent the Jews. We're get we have the vote of
- 15:38the Jewish people from America and from around the world.
- 15:41And we're going to say this is what's important to the Jews,
- 15:44especially after October 7th. You have to be LED at least by
- 15:49people who are pro Israel. If you go until 1980, most of
- 15:52the Reformed rabbis were against Israel like in their idea.
- 15:56And this figure they took out everything about Israel, they
- 16:00added back on later. So we're going to fight for that
- 16:03and we're we're going to represent the Jews, God willing,
- 16:06we're going to win and we'll be able to change.
- 16:08We're talking about a close to $2 billion budget a year.
- 16:13It's a big. Number, I'm sorry, I know
- 16:14nothing about this, but I've never heard this in my life.
- 16:16This is to me complete news to me.
- 16:18I don't know. I'm I'm happy We sidetracked a
- 16:20little bit because again, I heard the word Zionism.
- 16:22And you know, I I, I have a friend of mine that I met once a
- 16:26while ago and his family is from Iran and he tells me that we
- 16:30love Jews and Iran. And I was just like, I was mind
- 16:34boggled by how he was telling it to me.
- 16:35Yeah, we protect, I think Mordechai, right, who was buried
- 16:38there for years. And and and then he said, but
- 16:41Zionism, that's a whole different world.
- 16:43And I was like, you know, I don't have the head for this
- 16:44right now. Just, you know, get me my car.
- 16:46You know, he was like an Uber driver and turned friend.
- 16:49Obviously happens to me. So that's why I was so, so
- 16:52curious about it. So you're saying that Zionism,
- 16:54from your perspective of what is, you know, this organization
- 16:57can be a good thing for us in terms of the community being
- 17:00aware that we should put our weight behind it.
- 17:04Right. So because they're out there
- 17:05saying they represent you, right?
- 17:07I don't think they do because I don't.
- 17:08I don't. So you saying you can't ignore
- 17:10it anymore? No, right.
- 17:11That's what you're saying. We have to get involved.
- 17:12So how does this election process work?
- 17:14Well, if I wanted to vote for someone, how do I OK?
- 17:16So the election process work, you got a it's an online voting
- 17:18cards on March 10 goes until May four or five everyone because
- 17:27it's been led by the forms. So everyone who checks over the
- 17:30box that they identify the Jew is eligible to vote.
- 17:33So if you just say yes, identify the Jew and pro Zionist
- 17:36movement, I can vote. Even if you're not Jewish but
- 17:39you check that box, you can vote.
- 17:41You're not supposed to, but if you identify that if your
- 17:43father's Jewish or your mother doesn't matter, you identify the
- 17:46Jew. You identify the Jew, you're
- 17:48eligible to vote. And by the way, I have a lot of
- 17:49non Jewish friends that use Chabad schools and they love
- 17:52being Shabbat dinners. They identify as Jews.
- 17:55Where's the money coming from for the WTO?
- 17:57Who's funding a? Lot of it.
- 17:58So it's a lot of, a lot of it's like like, you know, no money
- 18:01went from the government. It's mainly properties from.
- 18:04You're saying 30% to 40%? Of Israel belongs to them.
- 18:08Wow, so people. Think you can?
- 18:09Pay rent for that. It's it's there's a big income.
- 18:13It didn't you back in the day. No one cared about it.
- 18:15And even still today they're trying not to talk about it.
- 18:18So you don't know what's going. On Mind me asking, I'm
- 18:20clarifying. I walk the streets of Jerusalem
- 18:21a lot and I look up and I see beautiful churches and, and
- 18:25communities owned by Ethiopians and, and the Russians and Polish
- 18:29and, and, and, and then I, I realized several years ago that
- 18:33Israel has property that's owned by many, many different walks of
- 18:36life. Where's the property that's
- 18:38owned here? You're saying 30?
- 18:40Percent everything cacaal Karen came literally you see a lot of
- 18:42times in Israel public parks public.
- 18:44Property. That's all.
- 18:46All under them. There's a lot of like soap.
- 18:50That we don't really know about. That you don't know and they
- 18:52don't want us to know about that control, that money so.
- 18:55You're going to stand behind this now, you're going to
- 18:56campaign for it. You're going to go out there,
- 18:58you're going to spread the message, go out there and vote.
- 19:00Get us part of this organization.
- 19:02Let's make an impact because it's only every five years.
- 19:05And I guess this is something that you've been thinking about
- 19:07for a while now. So in a way, about a year ago, I
- 19:11was reached out by one of the parties that I don't really
- 19:15align with to come vote with them, to come like run with
- 19:19them. So I went down for a meeting.
- 19:20I was, you know, going back and forth and I said, I don't align
- 19:25with you guys. It's like, like, as much as you
- 19:26want me and you want my vote, you want me to help you vote, I
- 19:28don't, I don't align. So then I was starting to look
- 19:31around, who do I align with? And you know, how can I actually
- 19:35make a change? And then I found Edith Taco
- 19:38this, which is official the orthodox party running.
- 19:41I had conversations with them back and forth, you know, made
- 19:45kind of a deal what I can stand for and what I can stand for.
- 19:48And when I figured that we're actually standing in most of the
- 19:51things on the same, we agree on most of the subjects.
- 19:54I was like, OK, we're going. To work right, you don't have to
- 19:56agree with everything when it comes to this kind of stuff.
- 19:57How many people are representing this organization do you know?
- 20:00So in the WCO, you have about about 150 seats from the United
- 20:05States. It's a Kurdish 1.
- 20:07Five years ago, 25 delegates. We're hoping this year to get 80
- 20:11delegates. Wow.
- 20:12The number, but I think it's I think it's I.
- 20:15Really believe the total. 500. Right.
- 20:19So very, very interesting. I learned something new today
- 20:21and I appreciate the education. Interesting.
- 20:23And it's not something that I ever thought of and or ever
- 20:26knew. And it's good to know that we as
- 20:28American Jews can have a voice in Israel.
- 20:32It's one of the things that I've been dying to ask you guys
- 20:34together. And I have to tell you my own
- 20:37personal experiences. And I can sit here for hours and
- 20:39tell you, you know things, people that I've met and
- 20:43perfect. I told my wife I was coming to
- 20:44do this. She looks at me, the kid last
- 20:47night, dead in the face. She's like, no, you're not.
- 20:50She's like, I have to remind you to talk to people at the Shabbos
- 20:54table. She's like, you go sit and talk
- 20:55on a podcast. He's still wearing bringing
- 20:56time. I'm going to drop keywords and
- 21:01he'll just go. I don't have to say.
- 21:03Anything well, so far you're doing great and I'm I'm, I'm
- 21:05going to ask you this question simply because.
- 21:08In my mouth. I think that's something that
- 21:10people don't, you know, first, so we get a background real
- 21:13quick. You're in the healthcare
- 21:14industry, right? So that's something that they
- 21:16say, yeah. So that's something that under.
- 21:18Your business. I had one place to drop it.
- 21:20There we go. So you're in our industry, and
- 21:24it's fascinating to me that you know, someone in our industry
- 21:27like that just pauses his life and goes, Haim, what do you do
- 21:30when you're not fighting our. Battles.
- 21:32So at the moment I helped Rendezvous, which is an
- 21:37organization for former lone soldiers.
- 21:40Basically, I did a bunch of other stuff before the war.
- 21:44When the war happened, I went to Israel to fight.
- 21:46I came back and I felt in a way that I did something so
- 21:51meaningful fighting for Israel. The war is still going on old I
- 21:54have to be here now for a little bit.
- 21:56I, you know, I still have to continue doing for the
- 21:58community. And then there's a couple
- 22:01stories that happened. One of them, one of the guys
- 22:03that was fighting under my command in Gaza, fighting
- 22:06together, good guy. Is that why Haim is a relatively
- 22:10important person? He's a captain.
- 22:12You'll drink. Oh wow.
- 22:13Not just a soldier. Yeah, you just mentioned under
- 22:15your command. I picked up on that, believe me.
- 22:17Yeah. And so there was an earthquake
- 22:21in April of the 24 beginning of April 24.
- 22:25He calls me, he said. Haim, I know I am in a building
- 22:28in Manhattan. I know everything should be OK
- 22:32around me, but this small shake now took me back to Gaza.
- 22:36When we got hit in Gaza and one guy passed away, it was a big
- 22:40situation over there and my brain thinks I'm still in Gaza.
- 22:45I'm now sitting in Manhattan. How do I function and what do I
- 22:49need to do to be able to get back to work?
- 22:53Like he's like, I'm now stuck. Like my brain is back there.
- 22:55How do I get back into life? That was one story.
- 22:58There was another guy in the same week or maybe a week later
- 23:02that his family were called me up that he just tried to commit
- 23:05suicide and was in the hospital in Connecticut.
- 23:08Former soldier, if I can help with anything.
- 23:10I always knew about Nivo that was involved a little bit, but
- 23:12not as doing, you know, being busy every day with that.
- 23:16And I reached out to Nivo and it was like, hey, we have so many
- 23:18soldiers now that are coming back and struggling and a lot of
- 23:21them are reaching out to you anyway.
- 23:22How about for the time being, as long as the war is going on, you
- 23:25come join us and you help those soldiers.
- 23:28We could obviously talk about it probably for hours, but I think
- 23:32in the beginning of the war, anybody who wasn't putting on a
- 23:35uniform of fighting guys were asking, I need flashlight, I
- 23:38need boots, my unit needs new helmets, right?
- 23:40All the things that people weren't embarrassed to ask for.
- 23:44Bottom line, guys, you go to Gaza, you see, just experience a
- 23:49destruction. It's not stuff that you should
- 23:51see. Bodies in the streets, inside
- 23:55out, bodies that got run over, bite that whatever it is that
- 23:57you shouldn't see. Impossible to go to Gaza and
- 24:00come back the same person, but no one talks about it because no
- 24:04one wants to be the guy asking for help.
- 24:06But it's OK to ask for batteries.
- 24:07It's not an it's not an embarrassing thing.
- 24:08It's not my fault the IDF doesn't have it.
- 24:11Probably do have it, but guys wanted better stuff.
- 24:14Whatever it is, guys don't ask for the help.
- 24:16There's how many guys that came back that are can't get back on
- 24:20their feet because they can't get past a small earthquake
- 24:23because their mind takes them back to this devastation.
- 24:27PTSD. It's a real thing.
- 24:28People don't talk about it. There's not enough.
- 24:31You see the picture where you follow IDF Instagram, right?
- 24:33You see the beautiful faces of these girls and these guys with
- 24:36the face paint, you know, finishing their, what's it
- 24:39called? It's all awesome, indestructible
- 24:40IDF. It's not true.
- 24:44No, the IDF. Is indestructible, I know, but
- 24:46some guy correct. But emotionally, you don't think
- 24:49that there's this type of damage that people are going to live
- 24:52with for the rest of their life. OK, but this is what I wanted to
- 24:55ask and this is, you know, I'm happy you went back to this full
- 24:57circle because as I was traveling Israel after October
- 25:017th and, you know, being inspiring myself, right?
- 25:05You know, people say I went to inspire others.
- 25:07No, I went to inspire myself and it was an amazing experience.
- 25:10What's a question that I as a civilian, let's call it for what
- 25:15it is, should not ask you as a soldier that I see you on the
- 25:20street and I go over to you and I say, what should I not be
- 25:23asking you, Akiva? Probably how many people you've
- 25:26killed. No, I don't know.
- 25:29Just probably There's there's. I'll tell you what you should
- 25:31do. You should do not what you
- 25:33shouldn't do. What you shouldn't do, you know,
- 25:35can go give you a list of billion things.
- 25:37What you shouldn't do, you know, I rather don't tell people what
- 25:39they should do. What they should do is tell
- 25:40them, hey, I'm here to help. Let me know what I can help you
- 25:43with. If you want to talk, if you want
- 25:45something I like, I think the idea of because I know myself
- 25:49what I do now in Baslow and everyday you want to offer
- 25:53someone help and say, Hey, this is what I can do for you and not
- 25:56this is what I can do for you. Or or because when you tell
- 25:59someone, Hey, this is the offer I have for you, they can say yes
- 26:02or no when you put them in a corner and like, Hey, you're,
- 26:06you know, you're struggling. I need to help you.
- 26:08It 1 is going to be a way tougher for them to open up two
- 26:15you putting him in a very bad position sometimes.
- 26:17You know there's the the Galatiano joke, right?
- 26:19Do I love jokes? There's the guy who was
- 26:22drowning, very wealthy guy, and he's always, you know, giving
- 26:26people stuff. And he's drowning.
- 26:29And someone said, hey, give me your hand, I want to take you
- 26:32out. And the guy doesn't give his
- 26:33hand. And they see his drowning, like,
- 26:36give me your hand, I want to take you out.
- 26:38And then a smart guy's like, hey, take my hand.
- 26:40And then the guy take it and he came out.
- 26:43So that's going to take tell them how to give.
- 26:45How many loan soldiers were back?
- 26:49Approximately so. Approximately, it's a very
- 26:53complicated subject because no one knows the exact numbers.
- 26:57I can tell you and you vote how many guys were involved with
- 27:00were involved with about the numbers go between how much we
- 27:06actually help on a day-to-day basis and how much we have in
- 27:08our database. So we have a close to I would
- 27:13say 7000 soldiers. We just know out of people we
- 27:16help on a weekly basis about 300 guys like I'm talking that we
- 27:22follow up case, we pay therapy for retreats, whatever.
- 27:26And then I would say on let's say Mr. Monas present or just in
- 27:32our database couple 1000. I, I have to ask you something
- 27:36that I know that I always think about.
- 27:38Why is the government not taking care of these type of things?
- 27:40And what are they doing and what, why is there a need for
- 27:43an, a vote? That's kind of getting me
- 27:44frustrated as I'm hearing you say this.
- 27:46Oh, is it organization that you're helping therapists?
- 27:48Almost like when you see homeless people and they're all
- 27:50vets in America and it drives you nuts, you know, So, you
- 27:53know, people blame drug and alcohol and then they just walk
- 27:55away. What's happening here?
- 27:58So it goes to to a few separate things #1 the government in
- 28:02Israel is saying, hey, if you're in America, it's not our
- 28:06problem, Come to Israel, we'll try to help you because you're
- 28:09in America. We don't need to help you or we
- 28:12we don't have anything going in America.
- 28:13Oh, so this organization is only for sold?
- 28:16Only for sold in America. Not just America, we have Canada
- 28:20and London as well. Anyone in the world not Israel.
- 28:22Anyone not in Israel, we. Don't have.
- 28:24We're trying. Hopefully we're going to get
- 28:25there. At the moment we're mainly
- 28:26America and where people reached out to get help and we have. 300
- 28:31people a week. You guys are busy.
- 28:32You're good. You're you're.
- 28:34Wow, we're very busy. So that's one Israel is saying.
- 28:38If you're not in Israel, we can't help you.
- 28:40Why that is wrong. OK, I'll give you an example.
- 28:42I had a guy in Muncie, not far that lives not far from us
- 28:45actually. His mother called me up and said
- 28:48my boy hasn't come out of bed for three weeks since he came
- 28:51back from Israel. He's stuck in bed.
- 28:53I don't know what to do. How do I help him?
- 28:55You know, I said, you know, give me his number.
- 28:58I text the guy. He never responds.
- 29:01So one night I went over to his house and said, hey, I'm here
- 29:04hanging out with his parents. And then he came out of his
- 29:07room. I can say it's now a few months
- 29:10later, the guy's already in college and has a normal life.
- 29:12What what it took was just to take him into our community,
- 29:16just show, hey, there's a few hundred other guys like you who
- 29:19came back and had a hard time explaining for people what it is
- 29:23so distance in Israel. But a guy like that, you can't
- 29:26send them back to Israel. I can't say, hey, get on a
- 29:28flight to Israel. They can help you over there
- 29:30because his mother is here, his father is here.
- 29:31You know, he has community over here.
- 29:33So we need to help him. Over here, you have to
- 29:36reintegrate into the system, right?
- 29:38And it's much easier to do when they stick to guys like you who
- 29:42get them, who understand that. But backwards, it's a little bit
- 29:45twisted because think about how many lone soldiers leave
- 29:50Teaneck, NJ, to go to Israel to volunteer for two years, year
- 29:53and a half, three years. Israel's hat and I guess happy
- 29:56to take them. These are really motivated guys.
- 29:59They're leaving their families, their comforts, their sports,
- 30:02their whatever it is that they have going on.
- 30:04Putting out a uniform, sweating, it hurts.
- 30:07The training hurts sometimes, but then when he goes back home,
- 30:11comes back to serve in war, like, it kind of like doesn't
- 30:15complete the full picture. And there's like a missing
- 30:18puzzle piece. And Kaya Minari, who run the
- 30:22boot, are trying to fix that missing puzzle piece.
- 30:26Is there, I'm just curious, is there anything that we and I
- 30:29like the way you said that before, by the way, and I'm
- 30:31going to repeat it because I want to make sure I got this.
- 30:33So when you go over to a soldier or someone that you know that's
- 30:36served, you tell them what you're capable of doing to help
- 30:39and you just put it out there in their world and if they accept
- 30:42it, that great. If not, you did your thing
- 30:44right, which is, which is great and.
- 30:46Sometimes you maybe have to show the show to them again so they
- 30:48actually understand what you can.
- 30:49Help So, so I'll tell you I, I, I do this a lot when people come
- 30:52to me for help in organizations. I can't tell you how many times
- 30:55I've done this and it it takes me on a journey that I don't
- 30:58even know where it's going to go, but it's always an amazing
- 31:00journey for me. I always tell people I have
- 31:03time. I don't have the money to give
- 31:05you as much as you want, right? Because people come for money
- 31:07all the time from organizations. What can I do if I have time, if
- 31:10I wanted a debt? And people always say, yeah, you
- 31:12have 5 minutes a day, go to the gym, you know, dive in three
- 31:15times. It just takes 5 minutes or
- 31:16everything just takes 5 minutes, right?
- 31:19If I really though wanted to dedicate 5 minutes of my life
- 31:22towards an organization like Nevut or to help lone soldiers,
- 31:26what can I actually do? So it gets a little complicated
- 31:30and I'm going to explain why I understand where I'm coming
- 31:32from. So in the beginning, I'm talking
- 31:34half a year ago, a year ago, I had a lot of therapists, like
- 31:37professional therapists who said hey, I want to start giving
- 31:40therapy to some of your guys. What happened was after 2-3
- 31:45months when it's not exciting anymore and they don't get paid.
- 31:48Then here I made a connection between a guy and a therapist
- 31:53and now the therapist is not getting paid.
- 31:54So he has no patience for the guy anymore.
- 31:56So I kind of have a little bit of hard time on the day-to-day
- 31:59things to relay on volunteers, not because I know it's not, I
- 32:03know it's important to them, but I need to have in a way
- 32:06something that I can kind of hold them accountable to make
- 32:09sure that actually happens because I had unfortunately some
- 32:11experiences. But I need to make sure things,
- 32:13you know, I'm business the same thing.
- 32:14You got to make sure it's in for both.
- 32:16Where you could help is you can make a barbecue in your house
- 32:20and I can have some soldiers that want to come out.
- 32:23You know, we can arrange something.
- 32:24I know now for perm, right? I'm doing in Lakewood by one guy
- 32:28inviting the community to come. I'm going to do it.
- 32:31Same in LA, some guy, you know, offered Muncie.
- 32:33I'm still trying to figure out where it's going to be now.
- 32:36Pause. What do you mean?
- 32:37Muncie is still trying to figure out where you can be.
- 32:39I mean, we're we're from Muncie. What What?
- 32:41What do you? If you guys have something, we
- 32:42can arrange something. Right, you're saying to to have
- 32:44like a pseudo or have like a pseudo meal.
- 32:46Come out and hang out now. I can't promise you now how many
- 32:50guys are going to come. I can ensure you that I'm going
- 32:52to invite 50-60 guys because the thing for me is at least I don't
- 32:56want to. I don't want my guys that that
- 32:58we're trying to help. I'm not putting a pressure on
- 33:00them. Hey, you must come perform like
- 33:02I'm not. I don't want to use them as
- 33:04like, Hey, come to this shul. I want to show the whole shul
- 33:07what big of a scan you are, because then I'm counter
- 33:09producting, you know, like I'm counter doing what I want to do.
- 33:13So what I do is I make events for them and I say, hey, if you
- 33:16having a rough day or even if you're having a good day, come
- 33:18out, let's meet other people. Let's get this community going.
- 33:22So in the end, we're there from each other.
- 33:23They make connections for whatever it is in life for Shadi
- 33:27come for jobs, for community, for whatever it is.
- 33:29So I like when people make events for them, sometimes for
- 33:32money, sometimes for not, not for money.
- 33:35It's just it builds the community of people getting
- 33:38together and helping each other and making I.
- 33:39Love that Akiva, you mentioned to me earlier before we started
- 33:42that you travel with some lone soldiers, but you've offered it.
- 33:46That's a nice thing. I'm doesn't trust me.
- 33:49By the way, the synergies between you are amazing.
- 33:50How did you guys meet? Can I can I say it on my side?
- 33:54And then you say yours? What do you think?
- 33:56My side? Someone tells me, hey, there's a
- 33:57guy not far from you. Who?
- 34:00His name is Akiva. He's a lone soldier.
- 34:03Good guy. Reach out to him.
- 34:06I call him up. Akiva's like, listen, I hate
- 34:08organizations. I never want to be part of this
- 34:13organization. I'd rather suffer alone than be
- 34:16part of an organization. Whatever you want, if I can help
- 34:19you, let me know. But I don't want to know you
- 34:21basically. And I said Akiva, so how about
- 34:24you help me help other guys? And that's how we got them on
- 34:28board. Smart, smart move.
- 34:30What's your side? It's.
- 34:31True, I did say those things, but I, I, I feel like I may have
- 34:36reached out to one or two people.
- 34:39I have unique opportunity to help guys, right?
- 34:44Somebody needs a change of scenery.
- 34:45I do travel for work a lot. I have a place they can stay
- 34:48with me. Especially guys who are
- 34:50struggling that can't like aren't ready to be like left
- 34:53alone or would do better with somebody.
- 34:55And so I feel like I reached out to offer that.
- 34:59But yeah, definitely probably said a lot of those things hate
- 35:01organizations. But this is one that you can
- 35:04connect with. Let me so, so let me explain
- 35:06what I but I think on a personal level I could tell you what I'd
- 35:10benefit from from Navood and I'm sure there is guys, what's it
- 35:12called? So like I said, you cannot go to
- 35:14Gaza as strong and as powerful as as you may think you are and
- 35:18not come back different. I can tell you I'm not the same
- 35:23person I was before I went just the decision making process
- 35:29alone to pack a bag and go off to Gaza where, you know,
- 35:33everything is booby trapped. You're always looking over your
- 35:35shoulder. I mean, I guess I can go back to
- 35:41October 7th and like kind of explain the difference between
- 35:45guys who have actually experienced fighting with Hamas
- 35:49before October 7th and guys who just heard the news and didn't
- 35:52really even know what Hamas was. Because there's definitely, I
- 35:55feel a group of people who like, OK, but Gush Khatif happens.
- 35:59So orange is a special color to Jews and it's run by Hamas.
- 36:03And every once in a while they shoot rockets over and like, but
- 36:05who really knows what they are, how bad, like, what they look
- 36:09like, what they feel like, what do they wear?
- 36:11What do they smell like? But when I was making the
- 36:15decision to go, I went through some crazy stuff I had in my
- 36:21head, what happens if I go and I come back to my kids.
- 36:26So I'm a father of four kids and my face doesn't look the same.
- 36:30I took shrapnel to the face. I lost an eye, an arm, a leg.
- 36:34I went through all these different things, deciding in my
- 36:37head like, would I rather come back to my kids this way?
- 36:40Would I rather die in the field? And that being said, I will say
- 36:45that I believed so much in this war and our right to defend
- 36:49ourselves and not only in Gaza and Israel, but here too, that I
- 36:54did make the decision to put my life on the line because Gaza is
- 36:58not playground, just not. And you probably what you see in
- 37:03the news is maybe 1/4 of what's actually happening there.
- 37:07Oh my God, you know, just hearing you talk.
- 37:09Akiva, Look, I'm you're a soldier, I'm the opposite of
- 37:12that. I'm a civilian.
- 37:13I'm the person that needs to be protected and just him when
- 37:16you're talking like I feel like I need to join you.
- 37:18I'm traumatized, like I need to join the vote now, you know, and
- 37:21dramatic decision like just to hear his how he's talking.
- 37:24I can only imagine the people themselves that are there on the
- 37:27front lines and it's been it's so traumatic.
- 37:29You have to think about that. I want to tell you, do I want to
- 37:31stay and die in the field or potentially be deformed to come
- 37:34back to my kids? Which ones better just to ever
- 37:36have to be in a position to have such a thought?
- 37:39I was thinking the same, your mind?
- 37:40Yeah, leaves a star on you. Oh so.
- 37:42That's my. That's one.
- 37:43SEC because that's my point. The loudest sound that I ever
- 37:46heard in my life was closing the door of my house.
- 37:50I don't even remember if I said goodbye to all of my kids like
- 37:53in a special way, because I think it's just probably easier
- 37:55just to walk out. But when I heard like my my next
- 37:57door neighbor was driving the airport, just clicking that door
- 37:59behind is the loudest sound I ever heard of my life because
- 38:01that means done decision made everything that you just but
- 38:04it's a traumatic decision. You have kids, you have kids,
- 38:09you go away. How long is the longest you've
- 38:10gone away from home? A.
- 38:11Week, Yeah. Did you think you could
- 38:13potentially die or come back looking?
- 38:15It's it's, it's, it's, it's. But now I know that I could sit
- 38:19in a room with these guys. I don't have to talk.
- 38:21Consider the corner. Every single one of these guys
- 38:24made the same decision. And so they know what I'm
- 38:27thinking and what I went through when I did that.
- 38:28That's what I benefit from it now.
- 38:31Ari, the guy who founded it, I I raised a lot of money for RCCS.
- 38:34Not plugging them here today at all, but Ari called me after.
- 38:38I went another organization you hate.
- 38:39Another organization that I cannot stand.
- 38:44They do good stuff, I think, I hope.
- 38:47But this guy, Ari, who who founded Navood called me, he's
- 38:50like, I see year after year you raise a tremendous amount of
- 38:53money. He's like, for us, funds and
- 38:56fundraising is a tough thing. How do you do it?
- 39:00I said let's get together and I'll, I'll walk you through kind
- 39:02of things. Now whether that conversation
- 39:03did or did not happen yet, I don't know, I don't remember,
- 39:08but still happy to have it. But that's kind of how it is.
- 39:11But then at the same time, when I heard what they did, I said
- 39:13I'm not interested in benefiting from you guys cuz maybe I'm too
- 39:18damaged to know that I really need it.
- 39:20But I have an opportunity to help some of your guys.
- 39:24And that was the phone call client where and now we're
- 39:27making that full circle here. But I said.
- 39:29You need to help me. I offered.
- 39:33Yeah. You know, Michael in the shul, I
- 39:36think it's a great example. You always have the people that
- 39:39ask on him in the shul, right? The active people that are doing
- 39:41things and they get recognition for it and they they get an
- 39:44award at the shul level, Mark or whatever.
- 39:47Then you have some of the people who do all The Dirty work when
- 39:51nobody's really watching and the, the uncool things, for
- 39:53example, after the kid is, or after shots, they're cleaning up
- 39:56and, and they do it every week and they're making sure, you
- 39:59know, they come back at night after hours.
- 40:01Much helps to sweep up the those people like, you know, and, and
- 40:04they don't take center stage, but they're doing important
- 40:07work, one could say the most important work because they're
- 40:11keeping the system running. They're keeping and and
- 40:13everybody else is having a good time and doing the glamorous
- 40:16things. That we all love to do.
- 40:18Everybody steps up for that moment.
- 40:20But guys like you are picking up the pieces.
- 40:23You know, these are young people not talking about veterans
- 40:27coming back from where they're 56 years old.
- 40:29These are teenagers. In a lot of cases, their whole
- 40:31life is ahead of them. They have the, the runways in
- 40:35front of them and they've already been damaged.
- 40:37They've already been through so much that people haven't
- 40:39experienced in a lifetime. Going into war.
- 40:42It's that's the, that's when your life is over.
- 40:45Nothing is ever the same again. And guys like you, you step up
- 40:48and instead of going back to your life and going into the
- 40:50business world and seeing how you can make more money now and
- 40:52how you can make a better life for yourself, you're choosing to
- 40:56help other people and sacrifice from your own life, which is
- 41:00which is really amazing. I commend you.
- 41:02I'm inspired by you. I think what you're doing is
- 41:05unbelievable. And you're not just doing it on
- 41:08a small scale. You're trying to see how you can
- 41:09make it bigger and help more and more and more people on the six,
- 41:12700 people on a weekly basis that you're helping.
- 41:16I'm just like blown away by this.
- 41:17And thank God that there are people like this amongst us.
- 41:19And I think this is what makes the Jewish nation so great, and
- 41:23This is why it's worth defending, is because of the
- 41:25love and devotion that we have for one another.
- 41:27These are people that you never met, people you don't know, and
- 41:30that's all. Reasons why people hate us.
- 41:32Exactly. Explain that.
- 41:34What do you mean yes? There's a jealousy to our
- 41:37connection to one another, whether we have been friends
- 41:40forever or not. When we walk down the street, we
- 41:45in an airport, right? You guys travel a lot?
- 41:48Yeah, you don't feel more connected to people walking by.
- 41:51Sure, look at the other people walking by each other.
- 41:53Don't even look at each other. Right.
- 41:56It's true. It's so true.
- 41:57You walk in an airport and you see another you.
- 42:00You lock eyes for a second and you give a little nod to each
- 42:04other like. You know, I almost could know
- 42:06you. I I.
- 42:06Probably do know if we went to a room together for 5 minutes and
- 42:09talked. We're probably related also.
- 42:11Yeah, yeah. It's a jealousy thing.
- 42:13Yeah. And that's that's a big reason
- 42:15why the rest of the world hates us.
- 42:16It is a big, it is a certainly big part is the jealousy.
- 42:20But you know, I'm going to be a little controversial for a
- 42:22moment. Sometimes we also, you know,
- 42:25sometimes we get a little bit too out there and people, people
- 42:28don't like that, you know, in in Germany when you know, before,
- 42:32before everything happened, the Jews were very, very successful,
- 42:36very successful. Like they own the banking
- 42:38industry. Like today we're in healthcare
- 42:39and real estate. Like back then, the financial
- 42:41district was run by by the Jews and the non Jews looked at that
- 42:46and they're like, how did this happen?
- 42:47Like what's going on over here? Are we being outsmarted?
- 42:50Like, you know, and and they hate the hatred and suit.
- 42:52And that's when real lot of problems began.
- 42:54So we have to be careful. We can't just, you know, flaunt
- 42:57everything. You know, we.
- 42:58I like the. I like the.
- 42:59Balance. We have to be very careful.
- 43:00To live a life thinking that the people around me are inspired
- 43:03and they are enjoyable. It doesn't always have that.
- 43:06I got it. I got it.
- 43:07Yeah. And and you know, it's an
- 43:08age-old question that we discussed also before we started
- 43:12here is do we ignore the hate? Do we fight the hate?
- 43:16How do we fight the hate? I'm curious what your opinion
- 43:18is. Crime.
- 43:20OK, so I think when it comes to hate, depending what type of
- 43:24hate, and that's how we're going to confront it.
- 43:26OK, If someone says not going to mention his name, but let's say
- 43:29this famous singer that's going around now with the swastika and
- 43:32whatever he does, right? This guy's nonsense, right?
- 43:35Yeah. Anything he says, it's just out
- 43:37of his mind. Right.
- 43:38He's extreme. Extreme.
- 43:39Everybody knows he. Does not.
- 43:40He does not need a response from anyone exactly, however.
- 43:44However, there's a guy who sees a picture of a dead baby on the
- 43:49Internet and says this is what the IDF does.
- 43:52This guy does need a respond sometimes because 1.
- 43:54He doesn't know that the picture from the baby is well taken from
- 43:57Syria from 2014 when Assad killed his people.
- 44:01That's number one. Number two, he doesn't
- 44:03understand that even according to Hamas, right?
- 44:07I'm talking according to Hamas, the IDF killed about 50,000
- 44:13people. Now if you go 50,000 people and
- 44:17they don't differentiate between a terrorist and a civilian and
- 44:21they also say they lost 30,000 Hamas soldiers.
- 44:25So right away you have 60% or most of the people that were
- 44:29killed even according to them are Hamas soldiers.
- 44:33Now take those numbers and divide the war where there is 2
- 44:38million people and terrorists with in between them and you got
- 44:42to fight 1 by 1. You have the ratio of death from
- 44:46civilians in Gaza is nothing like literally nothing according
- 44:50to the amount of people who just die something, sometimes from
- 44:52car accidents. Yeah, the lowest in the history,
- 44:55the lowest in. History like never.
- 44:56The ratio of combatants to civilian is the best ratio that
- 45:02ever happened, that ever happened in war, right?
- 45:04And we need to say that because people don't know that enough.
- 45:06Like I know that we had an incident in in Gaza that we had
- 45:11one time. It's complicated story, but we
- 45:15saw civilians that we said there might be civilians, might not.
- 45:18We looked after them and they were in a place they were not
- 45:21supposed to be. And we had reason to believe
- 45:24that they are terrorists. But they don't wear Hamas
- 45:27uniform, right? I asked for permission to open
- 45:31fire on them because we had a reason, you know, real reason to
- 45:34believe that they're they're bad people.
- 45:36Got denied. The day later we walk by there
- 45:39and a guy gets killed. His name was Michael Gal.
- 45:42Now, I can't tell you that those people for sure put an ID over
- 45:47there, but the chances are close to, I would say 95% of those are
- 45:51the people who did it and we couldn't do anything.
- 45:53And then ours all just get killed for that.
- 45:55That's I think that's how. Careful.
- 45:57We're being and we're being accused of the very opposite.
- 46:00The very opposite then. Like, where else did you hear?
- 46:03Like the hostages, right? Yeah.
- 46:05You have people who went to a festival.
- 46:07Yeah. You're not talking about someone
- 46:08who was a spy or like, and arrested with the case or
- 46:12something. You have people who literally
- 46:13went to a festival to dance. Yeah.
- 46:15And he took them hostages and you exchange them, one guy for
- 46:20200 terrorists, like people who actually kill people and show
- 46:24pictures and say he's going to get out.
- 46:26It's not prison. They aren't like they're
- 46:28terrorists. They're not prisoners.
- 46:29They're not prisoners. They're terrorists.
- 46:31They're people who are proud to kill.
- 46:32They say I'm going to go out and I'm going to kill again.
- 46:35They're going back to Gaza. They're joining Hamas again,
- 46:37right? Yes.
- 46:38In what? Right.
- 46:39The guy that was the leader of Hamas got out by prisoner
- 46:43exchange like that, right? It's beyond like you're taking a
- 46:47civilian, taking him hostage, taking, for example, the Bibas
- 46:50family, right? We gave back 600 live terrorists
- 46:55for the bodies of Jewish kids. That's insane.
- 46:58Not Jewish kids, Jewish babies, Jewish babies.
- 47:00Huge difference. Now we have to fight for that
- 47:03and we have to explain that we're not fighting because we
- 47:05chose this war. They chose.
- 47:08They chose to attack us. And when they're attacking us,
- 47:10they're not just attacking the border of Gaza.
- 47:13They're saying we're going to get to Tel Aviv, we're going to
- 47:15get everywhere. We're going to kill the Jews all
- 47:16around the world, right? We saw what happened in
- 47:18Amsterdam, right? Where they try to kill Jews in
- 47:21the streets of Amsterdam. We see what's happening in
- 47:23Colombia now and all the other universities where they're not
- 47:26just saying, hey, here's what we're protesting.
- 47:29They're saying we're going to kill the Jews, right?
- 47:31And, and they're saying it very clearly.
- 47:34We found Mine mine camp, right? Hitler's book against the Jews.
- 47:37And quite a few of the houses in Gaza, we found them.
- 47:39I saw them, so we got to fight back for that and that's where I
- 47:43think we do have to respond more.
- 47:46Yeah. What language is mine comfort?
- 47:49So it's written in German, but they.
- 47:51Could they could. Read it.
- 47:51No, they have it in Arabic. They actually have it.
- 47:54They have it translated in Arabic.
- 47:56And there's so much I want to get to, but my heart is racing
- 47:58right now. I'll be honest with you, because
- 47:59I'm still picturing myself. It's very, very difficult for
- 48:01me. But like, I've watched movies,
- 48:03right? You know, So you're like, you're
- 48:05you're scoping out the enemy and you have a question of whether
- 48:09you should proceed or not and you're asking for permission and
- 48:13then you're denied that permission.
- 48:16What goes on in your head then? Like, how do you react
- 48:18afterwards? Like what happens in the unit?
- 48:20Like can you take us down that lane for a moment?
- 48:23So I know that it like what you said, I keep a minute before
- 48:26that like, oh, you know, you can't, you're a different
- 48:28person. But I'm going to admit what else
- 48:31she was saying. We're the civilians.
- 48:33We're thanking you. It's just I'm, you're saying a
- 48:36story here and it's my heart's still racing.
- 48:38I'm just being honest with you and you could say it's none of
- 48:40our business, but I'm. No, it is our business because
- 48:42as Jewish people we have to fight together as people who
- 48:45like Israel, as people who want to defend the Jews.
- 48:47The reason why I chose now to go into politics a little bit is
- 48:50just because I realized until now I was fighting in the battle
- 48:53and I was doing a very good job and I was representing, you
- 48:56know, and fighting for you. But I feel there is a battle now
- 49:00in public ideas and policies that I'm really hoping to be
- 49:04able to change. So if you would have told me a
- 49:06couple years ago, I'm going to be back in the idea four months
- 49:09after my wedding for a month at a time and I'm going to be
- 49:12involved in a vote and maybe I'm going to run for design as
- 49:15strong as I would say, man, you're out of your mind.
- 49:16Like, dude, it's crazy. It's absolutely like I'm so far
- 49:19of this line. I was not interested in politics
- 49:22until like couple months ago or anything in this.
- 49:26I wasn't. But then by the more I'm now at
- 49:28the stage in my life that I see we can actually make such a big
- 49:31difference. Like, whatever we say, it's not
- 49:34just we're saying something. Our voices have an impact on
- 49:38actual policies, on actual where money goes, what gets defended.
- 49:42So that's why I chose this path a little now to to see what I
- 49:45can do, hopefully just to make a change and get back to normal
- 49:48life. Yeah.
- 49:49Just to run off that, I thought the next time I was going to go
- 49:51to Israel, take my kids, go visit my mom who lives there,
- 49:57No. Right.
- 49:59Amazing. How do you combat what Michael
- 50:02was saying before the digital online, You know, because that's
- 50:06at the end of the day where people get information from and
- 50:10it's it's you have to win that war to win that public
- 50:14perception. And you know your image gets
- 50:16tarnished when do. You think you could win that
- 50:18war? That's that's the challenge.
- 50:19You could win that war because I I don't know all the time that
- 50:22you could win that war. What do you think?
- 50:24Bottom I'll explain bottom line is there's an underdog in this
- 50:27story, no matter who entered whose country and took whose
- 50:30babies or, or, or did all the stuff that they did.
- 50:33I don't know what you want me to say on here.
- 50:35It's it's they look like the underdog because their buildings
- 50:40are getting toppled, They're wearing sandals in the winter,
- 50:43their tents are flooding. And we have We're a superpower,
- 50:48so we're always going to be on top.
- 50:51We're in the public perception. Yeah.
- 50:53How do you win that underdog story?
- 50:55It's such a difficult. OK, answer.
- 50:58So one, what means winning? Well in in in business and life,
- 51:03what means winning? If you win an argument with your
- 51:05wife, did you win or lose? I think you lost right?
- 51:11That's the old winner of the battle.
- 51:12You don't want to win because then you you lose.
- 51:14Yeah, Yeah. So you got to figure out a way.
- 51:16How do I let her win and I still get to win?
- 51:19And you get what you want. Exactly.
- 51:20Yeah, yeah. So what does that look like
- 51:22here? What does that concept look like
- 51:24here? That concept looks like here?
- 51:26Who cares what they put out there?
- 51:28We got our people back and Hamas is destroyed.
- 51:30But you could still look bad at the end that even though you
- 51:32accomplish your goals. That's what I'm asking.
- 51:34Right, So the way I look at it is, at least for now, there is
- 51:38something called winning the battle and winning the war,
- 51:40meaning to say we have a fight with terrorists in, let's say,
- 51:44Han Yunus, right? The neighborhood in Gaza.
- 51:46I need to win this battle that I'm fighting now, Terry,
- 51:49terrorists against me. I'm 20, guys.
- 51:51How am I going to win that battle?
- 51:53And then there is winning the war as a whole, right, As taking
- 51:56over, taking out Hamas and bringing back the hostages.
- 52:00So that's like a war. What we need to win is not just
- 52:03the battle with one argument. We need to win the battle as an
- 52:06whole. One, that Israel has the right
- 52:08to exist and to have a state and we got to defend our people.
- 52:11And two, what they did is wrong. And even though, yes, maybe we
- 52:15have a stronger military, that's not because we wanted a lot.
- 52:20We got a stronger military. We worked hard for it, right?
- 52:22If Hamas when they got back Gaza in 2005, right, if they would
- 52:26have focused their money on building buildings instead of
- 52:29300 kilometers of tunnels, they would have had the way better
- 52:32life. So we need to explain that.
- 52:34That's why we're doing this podcast.
- 52:36That's why we're talking about this story.
- 52:38That's why we're going to take videos out of this or other
- 52:41stuff we're going to do and keep on talking to our friends,
- 52:44employees, Co workers, whatever there is and trying to tell
- 52:49anyone who listens this is really what's going on.
- 52:52What you see here is just one picture of a story, right?
- 52:56It's about art, right? And art, especially modern art,
- 52:58right? When you see a a painting,
- 53:00sometimes you want to get into the what's behind it.
- 53:02Who was this artist? Why did he write it right?
- 53:04Why did he paint it? So what we're going to try to
- 53:07explain is what's really going on?
- 53:09What are we fighting about? They don't want when when
- 53:13they're saying from the river to the sea, right?
- 53:15They're not asking here for a Palestinian state.
- 53:18They're asking to eliminate all the Jews.
- 53:20And that has to be answered. And if we don't answer that,
- 53:23people are not going to know. So that's really my point.
- 53:26We got to. Find that I heard somebody else
- 53:28on a podcast recently say, I forget whose name was, it's a
- 53:31popular podcast. And he said, you have to ask the
- 53:34question, how did Hamas know in advance before they actually did
- 53:40that attack that they were going to be able to do it and that
- 53:43they were going to have the Western media that were still
- 53:46going to back them and the rest of the world, how did Hamas know
- 53:50this? They knew that the academic, the
- 53:52academia world, they knew, they knew that somehow they were
- 53:56going to be able to still get away with it and potentially
- 53:58even get support, that they did the right thing.
- 54:02They knew this in advance. Otherwise they wouldn't have
- 54:04gotten the cavalry going the way they did if they thought that
- 54:06this was just going to the rest of the world was going to say,
- 54:08oh, these guys were terrorists, but they knew the world weren't
- 54:11going to say that. Like, how did they know?
- 54:12What coordination do they have with who that they're able to
- 54:16get away with stuff like this, right?
- 54:17Which which means that there's an Internet battle going on and
- 54:22Hamas and whoever the, you know, their proxies are and all the
- 54:25different partners that they have, they're doing a really
- 54:29good job at it. They're actually getting their
- 54:31messaging out, as warped as it is, as twisted as it is, and
- 54:35they're turning it around. And the perception that people
- 54:37are getting is actually pretty positive.
- 54:39And like you said, they're looked at as the underdog.
- 54:42That's how they're looked at. And they're playing the victim
- 54:44card beautifully. They're they're playing in a lot
- 54:47of ways, like, like, like a fiddle.
- 54:48They're really playing it well. How are they doing this?
- 54:51How are they so good at this? I.
- 54:52Don't know that it's so hard to make the assumption that they
- 54:56would be. I mean, if I was them, I, I
- 54:57would, I would be very confident that I could look at the rest of
- 55:00the world, look at look at what's happening here, the Kyle
- 55:04Rittenhouse trial, all these different organizations that
- 55:08just have this stronghold. It's not so hard to see that
- 55:11America before this past election was heading in a in a
- 55:15certain direction. Like we said, we were talking
- 55:18before about transgenders. There's a very small percentage
- 55:20of population. It's a very loud voice.
- 55:24Yeah. So what do we do?
- 55:26How do we get better at this? Because it matters what the rest
- 55:30of the world is. Unfortunately, it does matter
- 55:32because it perpetuates our problems.
- 55:34If everybody is out there thinking that we're the bad
- 55:36guys, it just makes it much harder for us to actually live
- 55:39life. If I simplify it by saying that
- 55:42the whole concept of a Kiddush Hashem, it's even more important
- 55:46because I don't know that you could.
- 55:47I still not convinced that you could win that Internet battle,
- 55:50I think. But every interaction that you
- 55:53have with your Yamaha on with somebody who isn't Jewish,
- 55:56that's a +1 maybe. They one person at a time.
- 56:00Is that what you're saying? I'm not saying one person at a
- 56:02time give me a room of 30 people, but the point is, is
- 56:05that every Jew wearing a Yamaha has a positive interaction,
- 56:08treats people with respect the way that we're taught to do,
- 56:13right? So it's not one interaction at a
- 56:14time for you, it's one interaction.
- 56:16But there's millions of interactions, maybe a day
- 56:19between Jews and non Jews and they can look at you as
- 56:22respectful as a respectful nation.
- 56:25I like that approach. I'll be honest with you, Heim is
- 56:27not such a big fan because he's saying that we could win the
- 56:30battle on social media. I'm actually on your side on
- 56:33this. I don't think it's meaning to
- 56:34me. It's like just ignore.
- 56:36But yeah, of course, strategically to also get
- 56:39involved. We have to.
- 56:40I think everyone who cares has to get involved.
- 56:43Yeah. And everyone on their level.
- 56:45So for you guys, let's say it's in the nursing home industry,
- 56:48you gotta make sure that the people around you, your program
- 56:52coordinators, whatever it's called, the people in your.
- 56:54Administrators. Directors of nursing.
- 56:56They know, they know. Like you have to give them a DEI
- 57:00class once a year. Not anymore.
- 57:03Do you not anymore? Whatever it works, right?
- 57:06Give them as as, as an employee. You know I'm.
- 57:09Going to throw it back to Akiva then how is how is the war and
- 57:12your efforts that you've done and you being the hero that you
- 57:15are, and I'm saying that and I mean it, how has that affected
- 57:19your change in your operation and how do you bring that back
- 57:22to your world? First of all, I'm not sure how
- 57:25many people how many people know.
- 57:29You're saying within your organization?
- 57:31Interesting how? Many people know exactly what
- 57:33was happening. Do you try to hide it?
- 57:36I definitely didn't publicize it.
- 57:39A. Few reasons.
- 57:42One, there's high risks if right, right.
- 57:48And like I said in the beginning, I, I really don't
- 57:51publicize the decision that I made.
- 57:53Maybe I should, maybe it'll be more helpful for me.
- 57:56Really it's because after meeting him and Ari, I see how
- 57:59many people need help. And I think that a lot of people
- 58:01don't know the second-half of the story.
- 58:04They know the beginning. They know the guys that got on
- 58:05the flight LL reimbursed. They took each guy took 4 bags
- 58:10of gear that we worked so hard to.
- 58:12And by the way, it wasn't even usable because it was the wrong
- 58:14color. But doesn't matter because they
- 58:15put this effort into supporting the beginning part.
- 58:19Nobody focuses on the back end. And I think it's super important
- 58:22to start spreading the message that there are a lot of people
- 58:24coming back very damaged, and they should.
- 58:28Be rightfully so. Because war shouldn't be
- 58:32normalized to a point where, OK, like you went, you saw
- 58:37conquered, Yeah, came back. That's why.
- 58:38Everybody should try to avoid war at all costs.
- 58:40Look at the carnage on both sides.
- 58:43It's just all over. It's just that there's no happy
- 58:45ending here. But we are living in the reality
- 58:47though. Well, there is a happy ending.
- 58:49Happy ending is that we're going to fight it out and our kids are
- 58:51not going to have to fight. But if we don't fight it out.
- 58:54You think that there is an ending?
- 58:55Yes, yes. You think that this is not
- 58:56something that is going to continue.
- 58:59I mean, it's been going on for thousands of years.
- 59:00I think it's. Not the first time the American
- 59:02Civil War stopped at one point. Yeah, but we're we're.
- 59:05I think we're going. To but we're not actively
- 59:08killing each other. Not killing each other, I think.
- 59:10I guess you're right. Fight and stand up now strong on
- 59:15what we want and we say this is what has to happen.
- 59:19Then we can win If we say now let's let's make another hostage
- 59:22deal. So now you gave them a reason to
- 59:24do not to take hostages in five years again and then make
- 59:27another deal. So we're basically the way we're
- 59:30we're fighting the war now is in a way that we're giving them all
- 59:33the right to say, hey, let's do it again.
- 59:34It's going to work. So Haim and I went to hear one
- 59:36of our heroes, Ophir Winter, who was a brigade commander back in
- 59:41the day. He's retired IDF, he's general,
- 59:44I think, right, a retired IDF general.
- 59:46And somebody in the crowd asked him at the end, they were he was
- 59:49taking questions. Why is this taking the question
- 59:52was something on why is this taking so long?
- 59:55What do you think we went wrong? We think we're winning.
- 59:57Are we winning? And he he said, the issue is
- 1:00:02that you have a conversation today about what the day after
- 1:00:05looks like for Gaza. He said the second you ask
- 1:00:08yourself what the day after looks for Gaza.
- 1:00:11You've lost, you're losing because your whole mentality is
- 1:00:14you're thinking about their future and you haven't even
- 1:00:17secured your own hostages future yet.
- 1:00:19He's like, you should be stepping on your enemies
- 1:00:22throats, right? He said, he said at the end of
- 1:00:24time, right? What do you think?
- 1:00:25He said the mission or something says that at the end of time
- 1:00:27there'll be peace, there'll be sheep and lions together, he
- 1:00:30said. Who said the Jew has to be the
- 1:00:32sheep? Let there be peace, But you
- 1:00:34could be the lion. You should step on your enemies
- 1:00:39throats and you should not let up until you get what you want
- 1:00:41to know. It's extremely controversial.
- 1:00:44You want to get your your kids back, the babies back, the
- 1:00:47women, the soul. You want everybody to come back.
- 1:00:49I don't know that that's the right mentality to have when
- 1:00:53there's so much at stake because your kids could be doing this
- 1:00:56again in 20 years if we don't do this correctly now.
- 1:00:59And it sucks that it happened and it's heartbreaking and it's
- 1:01:02sad. I cried, I walked to the gym
- 1:01:05every morning. I think there was a period of
- 1:01:08time for months at a time. I cried every single morning.
- 1:01:11And it's, it's really sad for me that it took this for me to
- 1:01:15realize how important Claudius Straw was to myself, as well as
- 1:01:19what Ericius Straw meant to me. Every year.
- 1:01:21You have tissue bubble, right? And that's the whole point of it
- 1:01:23and never connected. But it's, it's, I don't, let's
- 1:01:29put it this way, I'm happy I'm not the one making the decisions
- 1:01:32because it's a tough decision to make.
- 1:01:34But I do believe that you have to go hard and strong.
- 1:01:39And I think you have to have tears of, of of what's a
- 1:01:42priority. And hostages shouldn't my
- 1:01:45opinion shouldn't be #1 because it clouds your ability to finish
- 1:01:49the job. Can I?
- 1:01:51Can I? Do your thing, Captain.
- 1:01:53So. One the hostages in a way is a
- 1:01:56priority because they're my people.
- 1:01:58As I, I said it before, not over here, but I said if I'm a
- 1:02:01hostage, I wouldn't want you to Take Me Out for prisoners or or
- 1:02:07terrorists. But if my kid or my wife is a
- 1:02:11hostage, I would do anything possible to bring them back like
- 1:02:15100%. And so now there's hostages that
- 1:02:17I know their families and I cared about them a lot, right?
- 1:02:20There's Eden Alexander from New Jersey, a local New Jersey kid
- 1:02:22that's still hostage and we know is alive.
- 1:02:25There is a kid who was also in the IDF that we know he's
- 1:02:28unfortunately not alive, also from Long Island that I want to
- 1:02:31bring him back. However, back back to your
- 1:02:35point, when we go into a box, let's say you ever guys did
- 1:02:37boxing before or watched MMA games?
- 1:02:39We watched. OK, So when I, when someone goes
- 1:02:41into a boxing ring, right, what is he thinking about how his
- 1:02:45opponent is going to feel in his rehabilitation after the fight
- 1:02:51or he's thinking, now how do I make sure that I'm the winner
- 1:02:54and I knock him out? What is he thinking?
- 1:02:56How am I sure that I'm going to be the winner and I'm going to
- 1:02:58knock him out? So when we go into Gaza, what we
- 1:03:01have to think is how do we bring the hostages back?
- 1:03:05How do we eliminate Hamas? When this is done, we'll be able
- 1:03:08to figure out what else we want to do.
- 1:03:10Now you have people who say all we want to do is to kill you.
- 1:03:13We're going to stand up. We're going to kill every Jew.
- 1:03:15We're going to make sure you guys are eliminated.
- 1:03:17So we have to fight that idea. Fight as much as we can and as
- 1:03:20strong as we can to make sure they're out.
- 1:03:22I agree with you. When this is done, we'll figure
- 1:03:23out that I agree with you. But in my priority, I wouldn't
- 1:03:27say how do we bring the hostages back and then how do we
- 1:03:29eliminate Hamas? It's together, I know, but I
- 1:03:31don't think that it can be. I think it has to be first, how
- 1:03:34do you eliminate Hamas and then bring the hostages back.
- 1:03:39And it might be more bodies than live people than you would have
- 1:03:43thought. But I think that that that's, I
- 1:03:45think it's a mentality on how you go about it.
- 1:03:48Because I don't think that you can go as hard as possible if
- 1:03:50your goal is look at him. It's it's a fact.
- 1:03:53It's a fact on the ground. There were areas that we knew
- 1:03:55there were bad people that we didn't bomb because we also
- 1:03:57thought there might be hostages. Right.
- 1:03:59And that's why I believe in special forces nations that we
- 1:04:02could do a lot more than we did. Again, I can't say on air a lot
- 1:04:06of things, but. Again, we know of how you go in
- 1:04:09and what the mission is, correct?
- 1:04:11There's about 5 to 7 hostages that Israel took out by military
- 1:04:15missions and not by deals, right?
- 1:04:17There's the three guys. And there's a couple cases where
- 1:04:20we actually did it and we're not retiring it a lot.
- 1:04:24We should do more of those, a lot more of those.
- 1:04:27That's what it means to me. I think I need to be able to say
- 1:04:30by winning, it's not just killing Hamas.
- 1:04:33Part of the war is to win the whole war as a whole.
- 1:04:36I have other other visions as well, not just about the
- 1:04:38hostages. How about we make sure that in
- 1:04:40Judea and Samaria that there's no terrorists coming out from
- 1:04:44there to Israel? That's also a separate war we're
- 1:04:46fighting now, right? How do we fight the Lebanon war?
- 1:04:48I think now if we're in fighting mode, you just go all the way.
- 1:04:51You got to figure everything out, fight whoever you need to
- 1:04:54fight politically and on the battlefield, and make sure that
- 1:04:59whenever this is done, we're getting to a normal life and not
- 1:05:03we're doing this now and in two years we're going to do another
- 1:05:05fight over there and then we're going to do something.
- 1:05:06I have. To tell you guys something, your
- 1:05:09conversation that you had three minutes ago, I was getting
- 1:05:12uncomfortable and I want to mention why and I want to
- 1:05:14mention why it's important for me to mention.
- 1:05:16This is because organizations like Nevut and other
- 1:05:20organizations that help lone soldiers and people that are at
- 1:05:23how important this conversation is for you guys to have.
- 1:05:27And only you 2 understand each other.
- 1:05:30Only you two were on the battle lines, you know, asking the
- 1:05:33question, can I take someone out, getting the answer no.
- 1:05:37And then having to deal with the repercussion afterwards of
- 1:05:39saying I could have saved that life and I didn't.
- 1:05:41That's something that we're hearing.
- 1:05:43We're listening here as civilians, right?
- 1:05:45And you, you were having an uncomfortable argument here a
- 1:05:48minute ago. And I'm thinking to myself,
- 1:05:49Akiva, I applaud you for coming on here today.
- 1:05:52I really. Do I'm an introvert?
- 1:05:54Not only, no, honestly, because you, we said it before, you're,
- 1:05:58you're in a, in a very, you know, tough position in terms of
- 1:06:04you're out there operating facilities and you're, you're,
- 1:06:06you're dealing with people on a daily basis, so much of which
- 1:06:10don't know who you are and what you're going through.
- 1:06:12And you're coming here and exposing that in a way.
- 1:06:15And I hate to break it to you, but we have thousands of
- 1:06:18listeners. Good.
- 1:06:21We don't have hundreds, we have thousands.
- 1:06:22But it's OK, we don't have millions of listeners, no.
- 1:06:25We don't. And you know what?
- 1:06:26Look, you know, we have a good quality group of people that are
- 1:06:28committed to what our cause is in our journey and the people
- 1:06:31that are along with us in our journey and.
- 1:06:33I always tell Michael about my journey is I learn more and more
- 1:06:36how awful of a person I am every time we bring on people like you
- 1:06:40on, on on the show. And I just hear stories of what
- 1:06:42people are really accomplishing, like real life things that are
- 1:06:45important. And you know, I just got back
- 1:06:47from vacation for, for, for a week.
- 1:06:50I just feel lousy about myself. I'm going into Shabbos and I'm
- 1:06:53like, I, I have to do some real soul searching and I keep saying
- 1:06:56I'm going to try to be a better person, but then we keep getting
- 1:06:58more guests on the show like this.
- 1:07:00And I'm like, like, who am I? Like what about where do I stay?
- 1:07:03I think. One of the things that I might
- 1:07:05understand that other people wouldn't, I think I called my
- 1:07:07family. I think I had like I, I, we came
- 1:07:09out for like a few hours and I called my family and my wife
- 1:07:12answers the phone. I hands it directly to the kids.
- 1:07:14And after I talk to my kids, I'm like, can I talk to mommy?
- 1:07:17Mommy said she'll talk to you when you get back.
- 1:07:20Wow, wow, that's. Crazy.
- 1:07:23Wow. So yeah.
- 1:07:25I want to point on that like people don't or people do but
- 1:07:29undervalue the amount of sacrifice takes from his spouse.
- 1:07:34Yes. I think in a way, myself, at
- 1:07:36least I was in Gaza fighting with my guys.
- 1:07:39I know what's going on. I know how things are happening.
- 1:07:42My wife had no idea I didn't have my phone for a big amount
- 1:07:45of the time. Wow.
- 1:07:45She knows I'm out there. She sees pictures of people
- 1:07:48coming out on body bags. She knows that I'm not in the
- 1:07:51best place, and she knows that she's at home and none of her
- 1:07:54friends understand even what it means that her husband is away
- 1:07:57fighting a. War the anxiety must be through
- 1:07:59the. Roof and they're like, you know,
- 1:08:00tell him to come back and he's going for sure going to come
- 1:08:02back. So on that .2 things number one,
- 1:08:04I'm going to sit and tell a story that happened actually
- 1:08:06local when I'm back already. My wife calls me up one day.
- 1:08:11No, I wasn't back. I was still there, but I had my
- 1:08:13phone and you know this and this guy, I'm like, I know about him,
- 1:08:17like what's going on? We need to reach his wife,
- 1:08:20right? Like we need to reach him right
- 1:08:21now. Something big is happening.
- 1:08:23And then other people start calling me because as an
- 1:08:26officer, maybe I'll be able to figure out what's going on.
- 1:08:29After like a couple of hours, we're able to track him down.
- 1:08:31What happened? This guy was in Lebanon and he
- 1:08:35had his phone with him and they were in a battle and he packet
- 1:08:40called his wife. So she hears a phone call that
- 1:08:47gunshots, screaming and gets hung up.
- 1:08:51After a few minutes she is 100% sure that her husband got
- 1:08:55kidnapped. She's sure she has.
- 1:08:57Like she's sitting at home, she can't talk to him, he's not
- 1:09:00answering again, she just heard gunshots and screaming.
- 1:09:04She is for sure her husband got kidnapped.
- 1:09:07Now she's reaching out everyone she knows to be able to track
- 1:09:10down her husband to figure out where he was.
- 1:09:12We got through his head. Commanders were able to track
- 1:09:14him down and say hey dude, you package called your wife.
- 1:09:18But imagine the trauma, the 10 hours this took until we're able
- 1:09:22to to track him, what she and her family were going through.
- 1:09:24She has a scar for the rest of her.
- 1:09:26Life, not just she, not a. Visual scar everyone internal
- 1:09:29scar for the rest of her life it's it's.
- 1:09:31It's mind blowing. And then you see other people
- 1:09:33that like I know, I know people who weren't able to go back
- 1:09:37because their wife didn't let them.
- 1:09:38And then they're saying, my friend there was one of our
- 1:09:41friends. He was with his unit.
- 1:09:43He came back because his wife needed him for a couple days.
- 1:09:46When he came back, his team went into an ambush and six of his
- 1:09:49best friends died and four other got injured.
- 1:09:53Now imagine how is he living now at home in Muncie, knowing that
- 1:09:58he wasn't there when his friends died.
- 1:10:00Maybe he was going to die. Maybe he wasn't, you know,
- 1:10:02unknowing. And then and then his wife is
- 1:10:05like taking the blame for not being able to help, like,
- 1:10:08because not like, you know, maybe if I wasn't there, I was
- 1:10:10going to be able to do a better shot and save those guys.
- 1:10:13Those traumas stay with you forever.
- 1:10:16And it it it has a direct impact on your family.
- 1:10:18There are those those memes that you see like how does a woman
- 1:10:21want to die? It's peaceful music in bed and
- 1:10:23somebody's massaging their feet. And then how does a guy want to
- 1:10:25die? And it's like rock music and
- 1:10:27he's running to a firefight and like it's just, there's a
- 1:10:30different mentality. But there are that's a real
- 1:10:32injury. I don't know what you want to
- 1:10:34call it, a morale injury. Guys who had the ability to put
- 1:10:38on the uniform because they're in the system, but either job,
- 1:10:42wife, family, or for whatever reason they couldn't go back
- 1:10:46messes with you maybe even more than some of the other stuff.
- 1:10:49It's like this deep regret that you wanted to do something so
- 1:10:52badly and things held you back. Right.
- 1:10:56And it would we help those guys as well like.
- 1:10:57We read there's a lot of guys like that.
- 1:10:59I even feel more bad for them than some of the other other
- 1:11:02people. I have to go back to finish that
- 1:11:05question. I was telling you before, Akiva,
- 1:11:07especially now after hearing all this, so.
- 1:11:08Wait a minute, I got once want. To tell you, oh, go ahead, sure.
- 1:11:11When I was in the army in 2009, there was some sort of situation
- 1:11:16in Gaza. Now how does the the IDF works
- 1:11:19in an interesting way. If you're, you do these really
- 1:11:22intense trainings twice a year, everything gets packed up.
- 1:11:25You're in the field for like 2 weeks at a time.
- 1:11:28So if a battalion is packed up and mobile and something's
- 1:11:33happening, very often you are the quickest option to go and
- 1:11:39take care of something. And we were in the middle of the
- 1:11:41trading. They sent us back to base to get
- 1:11:43some stuff. You guys are going to Gaza?
- 1:11:46I called my parents, I could tell something was different
- 1:11:49about like what was happening and I'm like you guys, so you're
- 1:11:52going to guys. I love you click.
- 1:11:55I didn't realize at the time because I was a schmuck what I
- 1:11:58did to my parents. So when I went back now I fought
- 1:12:02it out with my wife a little bit.
- 1:12:05She she's truly amazing in the fact that as difficult of a
- 1:12:11decision. I explained that I went through
- 1:12:13how I will come back if I got hurt.
- 1:12:15This that she probably had the same process and maybe slightly
- 1:12:19different. I didn't tell my parents that I
- 1:12:21was going. Whoa.
- 1:12:23My father found out the the last day that I was there the day
- 1:12:29before I was coming home. He's like I heard.
- 1:12:32Well, he called me. He's like, where are you?
- 1:12:34And I'm like hanging out. I'm around, you know, whatever
- 1:12:38he says, where are like he pressed and pressed and pressed.
- 1:12:41And I finally told him because it's like, what's there to lose?
- 1:12:43We'll fight it out now. I'm already out.
- 1:12:48Wow. We have we haven't put a special
- 1:12:51parent support group, so we have psychiatrist meetings sometimes
- 1:12:55in person, sometimes over Zoom where we try to help parents of
- 1:12:57soldiers just understand what the kids are going through, how
- 1:13:00to support how not like not support.
- 1:13:03The struggle of parents is a real struggle that.
- 1:13:05Yeah, family members in general, brothers, sisters, parents and.
- 1:13:08And there are a lot of organizations that focus on
- 1:13:10those elements and I'm happy that you guys are doing that as.
- 1:13:12Well, but this or Nevote is doing it mostly.
- 1:13:14For soldiers. When you when you go.
- 1:13:16When you go into Gaza and Haim will relate, it's autopilot,
- 1:13:20man. Your head's on a swivel.
- 1:13:22You know, you understand you see you're you're making these split
- 1:13:25decisions, but that type of adrenaline fast pace and it's
- 1:13:29not happening here. So parents, spouses, kids who
- 1:13:32understand they have like all this time to like calculate all
- 1:13:35these horrible things. Wow out in the field.
- 1:13:39If you're going to go, you just want to go quick.
- 1:13:40I'm. Just going to give a number.
- 1:13:42Since October 7 until today, as far as we know, we don't know.
- 1:13:46This might be one or two missing.
- 1:13:48That is 43 lone soldiers who were killed 43 that's that
- 1:13:53that's a very big number. And if you go and break it down,
- 1:13:56you have about 5 were who who passed away by suicide because
- 1:13:59they came back and and couldn't deal with it.
- 1:14:01One by Kodaks and the other one is in battle.
- 1:14:03I like it's it's it's the amount people don't under. 43 people
- 1:14:06I'm sorry were killed. 43 lone soldiers, Yeah, talking people
- 1:14:09who are not in Israel, American, French who went to Israel to
- 1:14:13fight after October seven. Yeah. 43 lone soldiers who
- 1:14:17passed away. From.
- 1:14:20From what cause? From.
- 1:14:20Battle or suicide? OK.
- 1:14:23That's a terrible number, by the way.
- 1:14:25Very big number. The number of suicide also,
- 1:14:27which is so terrible, I don't know.
- 1:14:30We speak about what we can do. Again, I'm going to take your
- 1:14:34guys advice and what you said and, and always offer what we
- 1:14:37can do and then let the person take what they can from it.
- 1:14:42Suicide is definitely a thing that's happening and it's it's
- 1:14:47it's very scary to hear. Every time we hear it, we sort
- 1:14:49of shut off our brains and we're like, OK, that's not happening
- 1:14:51to anyone We know until you do know, until you do know exactly.
- 1:14:56I wanted to actually wrap this up and asking a very important
- 1:14:59question, which is, you know, what do you take back?
- 1:15:02I am from, you know, everything that you've learned.
- 1:15:04How do you apply it to your world?
- 1:15:06You know what you said a minute ago, then you're answered a
- 1:15:08little bit of it is your, your adrenaline is rushing and
- 1:15:11you're, you're on a swivel. You know, when you're there, are
- 1:15:14there are there things that are practically speaking that you
- 1:15:17learn from your experiences that you can teach us or something
- 1:15:21that you've applied to your own life that you thought about and
- 1:15:24you said, OK, this is what I learned how to do.
- 1:15:26This is something that you know, I I changed the way I look at
- 1:15:29things or I do things and in your life and.
- 1:15:34It's a very big question, you know that.
- 1:15:36Yeah. No, I know, I know.
- 1:15:38By the way, when I said I want to wrap it up, I didn't mean
- 1:15:40this minute. I mean, in the next few hours,
- 1:15:44OK. Number one that I learned, I
- 1:15:46think, and it's the biggest idea that that was new to me is
- 1:15:51understanding people from different backgrounds, because
- 1:15:55in my unit I have a guy with pears and I have a guy who
- 1:16:00officially not like, you know, in his family, they eat non
- 1:16:02culture every day. And understanding how this can
- 1:16:05work together and how they work together.
- 1:16:07Different different communities, different people, different
- 1:16:10communication, I think was the biggest deal for me to
- 1:16:12understand until I was able to figure that out.
- 1:16:14So now I can, you know, understand how to speak to you
- 1:16:19and speak to Akiv and then go out to a different shul or a
- 1:16:23different political environment and understand what the language
- 1:16:28they're speaking or, or, or what's going on to a certain
- 1:16:31degree. That was a very big.
- 1:16:33Deal. It made you more empathetic.
- 1:16:35You're now, you're not very inclusive, you're less
- 1:16:37judgmental, but you you realize they're all coming from the same
- 1:16:40place, not from the same place. We all want the same thing.
- 1:16:43And your, your vision or what you're trying to do, you have to
- 1:16:46do it together, no matter where you came from.
- 1:16:49Yeah, and also we're all the same man.
- 1:16:50Like we really are all the same. We're.
- 1:16:52Cut from the same cloth. Same thing and what we want and
- 1:16:54what's important to us. If you look at the bigger
- 1:16:57pictures, we all want family, health, wealth, you know, like
- 1:17:00we all want literally the same things.
- 1:17:02The question is how we make it together and we're able to get
- 1:17:05to the same goal. That's that's a big deal.
- 1:17:08Nobody should be left behind. That's one thing that I learned.
- 1:17:11I think I was able to really understand to a whole new level
- 1:17:16how small things we do have a tremendous impact on the bigger
- 1:17:22picture. And I'll give you an example,
- 1:17:24OK, if we go into a mission now to this one building, right,
- 1:17:27what am I? I'm a foot combat soldier,
- 1:17:29right? But if I take 5 more minutes to
- 1:17:32just fill up my bottle or I didn't do one radio check right
- 1:17:36that I should have done and now I got to change the wire or
- 1:17:38whatever it is. My laziness and not being on top
- 1:17:42of this small thing has now an impact on the Air Force or when
- 1:17:47the when the planes are going to come in to drop the bombs on the
- 1:17:51tanks and how they're going to move on the helicopters who are
- 1:17:54standing behind on the radio systems, on the food that has to
- 1:17:57come in 20 minutes later. So I was able to see that a
- 1:18:00small thing that you don't do could literally have an effect
- 1:18:05on 20,000 people just like that with by by by small things.
- 1:18:10That's number one was super important for me to learn and I
- 1:18:12think it was very difficult because then everything you do
- 1:18:16is such a big and like if I say the wrong thing on the radio,
- 1:18:19like the wrong word, it could affect doho everyone, like
- 1:18:23literally everyone. So that was one big deal and
- 1:18:27it's that's another one. And then I think understanding
- 1:18:30the value of just life and family and people and what's
- 1:18:34important and what like coming back from there, you know,
- 1:18:37speaking to you know, one of my good friends died right next to
- 1:18:40me. His name was more Levy father of
- 1:18:42four kids and and you know, seeing that and then coming home
- 1:18:46and saying, how am I not forgetting his family now and
- 1:18:49how am I going to be the best father I can be for my family?
- 1:18:52And what does it mean to be a good father?
- 1:18:54Like like what does all those small things make?
- 1:18:58I think this was, I would say, the biggest 3 lessons.
- 1:19:01I would give it to those. Each one, by the way, honestly,
- 1:19:04that's a book of its own, each one of those lessons, but it's.
- 1:19:07I'm not going to argue with him, I think 100% and I can tell you
- 1:19:12times where people did not wait for us to move at how intense it
- 1:19:15was. And that it had an effect on the
- 1:19:18mission on on everything. Yeah, where the mission was Even
- 1:19:21so important that they didn't care.
- 1:19:23But then means your job wasn't important enough.
- 1:19:25On that well, we were we were, we were there was a a battle in
- 1:19:28Rafa and there was a Hummer that broke down in the middle of the
- 1:19:31battlefield and they sent us to go get them out.
- 1:19:34And it was, I mean, if I have explained even to Rafa, right,
- 1:19:38you know what, the sand there, even these hummers, you're
- 1:19:41getting stuck because the tanks are crushing sand into dust.
- 1:19:45It you, you can't. So we were trying to get these,
- 1:19:48the, this, this Hummer out with four guys and they're like, we
- 1:19:51need you guys to move. We have to blow up.
- 1:19:52I think it was a tunnel or a building. 5 more minutes, 5 more
- 1:19:55minutes. They just blew it up.
- 1:19:56We were all knocked right off our feet.
- 1:19:58Wow. But it's true, you felt very
- 1:20:00dangerous. I know it's dangerous.
- 1:20:01It was nuts. It was awesome, but nuts.
- 1:20:05So. I don't know.
- 1:20:08I can't say it wouldn't happen by by us, but we were trying.
- 1:20:10It shouldn't happen. Yeah, I can, but you were saying
- 1:20:12you resonated with the three things that he said.
- 1:20:14But what? Give us your own personal
- 1:20:16antidote of what it is. Maybe I haven't figured it out
- 1:20:18yet. OK, why?
- 1:20:19I'm agreeing with him, OK. That's fair.
- 1:20:21I agree. That's fair.
- 1:20:22Your your. Your mission know how to how, no
- 1:20:24matter how small you think it is, is part of a much bigger
- 1:20:27plan, especially as Jews, right? Never know, you take care of
- 1:20:31this, who you helped, who you're going to meet who this, but I
- 1:20:35mean, the biggest thing for me is you're right.
- 1:20:36You enter a room of 30-40 guys, whatever it is that you don't
- 1:20:41know their backgrounds, where they're from, they're religious.
- 1:20:44Why they're not religious. They got to fight with their
- 1:20:46girlfriend. They're why they you have no,
- 1:20:48but bottom line is there's a a a a mission and by by way of all
- 1:20:54having that shared goal unify. And I think that it's important
- 1:20:59to to not only forget that it's important in Gaza, yeah, because
- 1:21:05lives could be lost, but it's important anywhere.
- 1:21:07Imagine if you don't. Imagine if you start treating
- 1:21:10red lights like a like a suggestion.
- 1:21:13I'll say this. I mean, I think we're going to
- 1:21:14agree. One thing that Hamas did
- 1:21:16accomplish is they brought us a lot closer together, obviously
- 1:21:21at a very heavy price. And it takes sometimes moments
- 1:21:24like this in our history to remind us that we're much more
- 1:21:28alike than we are different. And as Jews, you know, we're
- 1:21:30more than just under one nation, under one rule, one law.
- 1:21:34We are brothers, we're family. It goes way beyond that.
- 1:21:36We're really our family. And when tragic things like this
- 1:21:39in our history happens, it really brings us together.
- 1:21:41But this one, especially, this one, especially from all of the
- 1:21:44world because of social media that people are able to see
- 1:21:47things there just literally clicked.
- 1:21:49Everybody clicked all together at once, which I guess is one
- 1:21:52maybe small silver lining that you.
- 1:21:54I have to say, Haim and Akiva, this clicked for us.
- 1:21:57This was amazing, the sense of togetherness and the the little
- 1:22:00things that we're learning and picking up from it.
- 1:22:02So I really want to thank you both individually and as a group
- 1:22:04for coming here together today. I'm, I'm going to, I'm going to
- 1:22:07take one second to plug in the boot one more time to your
- 1:22:10millions of viewers. Yeah, doesn't matter.
- 1:22:13We have the coolest viewer listeners.
- 1:22:15Fine for the millions. Of vote and.
- 1:22:17Vote Yeah. Well, you will get the details
- 1:22:20on how to vote. Yeah, but the bottom.
- 1:22:23Line is is for people who can't donate money, right?
- 1:22:26Ask what you can do, but definitely therapy costs money
- 1:22:31and therapy is one of the biggest things that a lot of
- 1:22:34these guys need. Yeah.
- 1:22:36And just so if you do have the ability to look in the boot up,
- 1:22:40there is a link on that page to be well either to contact these
- 1:22:43guys so you can. Yeah, definitely.
- 1:22:44We're going to be plugging it as well.
- 1:22:45We could put the. Link up, Michael.
- 1:22:47Yeah, yeah. So.
- 1:22:48There's also there is a need aside from throwing barbecues,
- 1:22:52there's a need to to financially support because therapy's not
- 1:22:57free. I'm going to give you an
- 1:22:58example. We had a retreat a couple months
- 1:23:00ago in America for 12 guys now. It was a full week intensive
- 1:23:05retreat where we had to bring down special guys like big
- 1:23:10people in the therapy world. One of them was like a former
- 1:23:13Green Beret that is now understanding the combat drama
- 1:23:17and knows how to work with it. Just a retreat like that for 12
- 1:23:20guys costs over $60,000. Because he got it.
- 1:23:25Because I don't want to. Like I know, at least for
- 1:23:26myself, when I tell a soldier I'm going to help him or tell
- 1:23:29his family I'm going to help him, I'm not going to be OK with
- 1:23:32any low class Medicaid therapist, right?
- 1:23:35You got to bring him the top of the line because you're talking
- 1:23:38about a whole family on the line there, right?
- 1:23:40His parents, him, his kids, his wife, you want to be able to
- 1:23:42support. And we need the best.
- 1:23:44We need it. And, and that's why it's a lot
- 1:23:47of money to really bring the best people down to support and,
- 1:23:51and give this help. And I can tell you that the
- 1:23:52people who did that retreat, I spoke to two of them just
- 1:23:56yesterday and said, Oh my God, this like, I'm still so much
- 1:24:00better about it. More than that.
- 1:24:01The guy told me, just so you know, last time I went back to
- 1:24:05Gaza, I was hoping that I'm never coming back alive because
- 1:24:09I just couldn't deal with it anymore.
- 1:24:11And now with the help that you guys are helping me get and
- 1:24:14providing, I want to live, I want to get back on my feet.
- 1:24:17I want to continue life normal, which is for me the biggest
- 1:24:21thing you can get. It's amazing.
- 1:24:22Again, thank you guys so much for joining us.
- 1:24:24Thank you to all our subscribers and listeners.
- 1:24:26Please don't forget to get involved like subscribe comment.
- 1:24:30Thank you again to the wonderful team at Prime Source.
- 1:24:33We appreciate you listening. See you next time.
- 1:24:35That's a Rep.