Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Nuts and Bolts of Determining Disability in Workers Compensation Cases
Transcript
- 0:03Hello, and welcome to Nuts and Bolts of Determining
- 0:07Disability in Workers' Compensation Cases. I'm
- 0:10Michael Falati, and I'm chair of the Workers'
- 0:12Compensation Law Section. I'm an attorney at
- 0:15Greyward Kaplan, Vernic and Evans, and a certified
- 0:17specialist in Workers' Compensation Law. Next,
- 0:20I'd like to take a moment to plug the Workers'
- 0:22Comp Section. The Workers' Comp Section is a
- 0:24new and fast -growing section of the Beverly
- 0:26Hills Bar Association. I obviously encourage
- 0:29all work on practitioners to join, and I also
- 0:32highly recommend that practitioners in overlapping
- 0:34specialties like personal injury and labor and
- 0:37employment law also get involved. And for those
- 0:40who want to get even more involved, as a section
- 0:42leader perhaps within the section, I encourage
- 0:45you to reach out to me or to contact the Beverly
- 0:46Hills Bar Association Help Desk. We'll throw
- 0:49my email and the Help Desk email in the chat.
- 0:52And now without further ado, I'm delighted to
- 0:54introduce our speaker for today, Laura Rosenthal.
- 0:57Laura is the president and attorney -at -law
- 1:00of Laura Rosenfeld Law in Sonoma County, California,
- 1:06where she represents injured workers, including
- 1:08public safety personnel, such as law enforcement
- 1:10officers, firefighters, and first responders,
- 1:13with a practice built on compassionate advocacy
- 1:15and rigorous legal skill. A certified specialist
- 1:18in workers' compensation law, Laura brings decades
- 1:21of litigation, discovery, and trial experience
- 1:24having previously served as a shareholder at
- 1:26a Santa Rosa workers' compensation and employment
- 1:28law firm. Beyond her practice, Laura serves as
- 1:32an adjunct professor of law at Empire College
- 1:34School of Law and administrative hearing officer
- 1:37for Sonoma County municipalities and a member
- 1:39of the workers' compensation section executive
- 1:42committee of the California Lawyers Association.
- 1:44And now let's get started. Thank you, Michael.
- 1:49So first slide here. So good afternoon, everyone,
- 1:53and thank you for spending part of your Friday
- 1:55with me. I do appreciate your time. In addition
- 2:00to practicing workers' comp law, I also teach
- 2:03legal research and writing to second year law
- 2:05students. So there's one thing I've learned from
- 2:07law students is that they are not shy about letting
- 2:10you know when something is boring. So I take
- 2:13that as a challenge. My challenge today is to
- 2:16make disability ratings at least more entertaining
- 2:19than a lecture on how to properly cite legal
- 2:22authorities or what the A in IRAC means. So,
- 2:26like most lawyers, I went to law school because
- 2:28I did not want to do math. Then I became a work
- 2:31comp attorney and I do math every day. The good
- 2:35news is that disability ratings are basically
- 2:38algebra. The hard part is making sure that you
- 2:41have the right variables to plug into your algebra
- 2:45equation to get the correct answer. So next slide,
- 2:48please. By the end of the day, my hope is to
- 2:55help you understand how ratings are calculated,
- 2:57understand what rating strings are, spot rating
- 3:01errors, and know when ratings can be challenged.
- 3:05Next slide. So. Here's a simple explanation of
- 3:11the difference between disability and impairment.
- 3:14Impairment is medical, and disability is a legal
- 3:18determination. So a doctor provides impairment,
- 3:22and the legal system converts that impairment
- 3:25into disability. Next slide. We have temporary
- 3:32versus permanent disability. Simply put, temporary
- 3:35disability is paid when you can't work. Permanent
- 3:39disability is paid when your work injury has
- 3:43lasting effects and is intended to pay you for
- 3:47that lasting effect ongoing. Very simple explanation.
- 3:52So next slide. So our question is, who determines
- 3:56disability? Well, it's not the doctor. The physician
- 4:00determines impairment. And they do that through
- 4:06using the AMA guides. So let's move on to the
- 4:10next slide, which is a picture of the lovely
- 4:14AMA guides, fifth edition, which is used by physicians
- 4:17to determine impairment. The AMA guides were
- 4:21published in 2001. And in 2004, California state
- 4:26legislature mandated the use of the guides for
- 4:30use in determining an injured workers impairment.
- 4:33So until there's a change in legislation, those
- 4:35are what we are using. We use AMA guides until
- 4:39such time as the legislature and its infinite
- 4:42wisdom decides we can use something else. Next
- 4:45slide. So basically, injured workers are evaluated
- 4:50by what are called QMEs or AMEs. QME is a qualified
- 4:54medical evaluator, and AME is an agreed medical
- 4:57evaluator. Qualified medical evaluators are basically
- 5:02trained by the state, and they have to take a
- 5:04test and be... listed with the state is called
- 5:07a panel qualified medical evaluator, which means
- 5:10that their names appear on a panel list that
- 5:13you select one of them from. An agreed medical
- 5:16evaluator is also certified by the state, but
- 5:19is an agreed upon position between the attorney
- 5:22and a claims adjuster. I'm going to refer to
- 5:26both AMEs and QMEs as QMEs throughout the rest
- 5:29of this presentation. So next slide. The role
- 5:36of a QME or AME is to evaluate an injured worker's
- 5:39body parts and to come up with a diagnosis and
- 5:45also to provide impairment ratings. So this can
- 5:50turn into a big dispute among the parties, but
- 5:53that's basically a simple statement of what they
- 5:56do. Ultimately, when they come up with impairment
- 6:01ratings, they send out evaluation reports to
- 6:03both parties. In my years of practice, I've never
- 6:06seen a QME report with impairment ratings that
- 6:09all the parties agree upon, but it could still
- 6:11happen. Let's move on to the next slide and talk
- 6:15about how a rating is built. Oh, back up for
- 6:19a minute. Let's also talk about what QMEs can
- 6:21do in terms of how they... Next slide, I'm sorry.
- 6:26QMEs can also provide some legal conclusions
- 6:28or... opinions that lead to legal conclusions,
- 6:32which is apportionment, which is when they allocate
- 6:35an impairment to some kind of pre -existing injury
- 6:37or illness or prior impairment. They can opine
- 6:41about causation, what causes injury, whether
- 6:44it was actually industrial or not. They can come
- 6:48up with an opinion about whether those impairments
- 6:50should be combined or added, which we'll address
- 6:52a little later. And they can also provide work
- 6:54restrictions. Next slide. So we have the PDRs
- 7:04here, the permanent disability rating schedule.
- 7:07And in California, that is used to assess and
- 7:10determine disability ratings. So that's the little
- 7:14book you use to do so. And there are two schedules.
- 7:19So there's what we call the PDRs, or the old
- 7:21schedule, which is from 1997. And then there
- 7:25is the 2005 PDRs, which is was published in 2005,
- 7:32and then for injuries after January 1, 2013,
- 7:35one change was made, and that has to do with
- 7:37the DFEC, and we'll talk about that a little
- 7:40later when we address rating strings. Okay. Next
- 7:44slide. So, there is a disconnect between the
- 7:51AMA guides and the 2005 PDRs, and when there
- 7:55is a conflict, The instructions in the PDRs win,
- 8:00basically. So it can get to be a little confusing,
- 8:04but there's a few differences between the two.
- 8:07I'm putting a few up here. For example, the PDRs
- 8:09say you can add 3 % if someone has more pain
- 8:13in a certain body part due to their injury. The
- 8:17AMI guides say you can't. The AMI guides go region
- 8:21by region, so upper extremities and lower extremities.
- 8:24but the 2005 PDRs require impairments and adjustments
- 8:28for each individual body part. It's a little
- 8:31bit technical, but if there's any question about
- 8:34which one is correct, you go to the PDRs. Next
- 8:37slide. So how are ratings determined? So the
- 8:45permanent disability rating schedule will convert
- 8:48that whole person impairment from the doctor
- 8:50into a disability rating. The difference between
- 8:53the two, the 1997 and the 2005 PDRs, is that
- 8:57the 1997 actually uses work restrictions. The
- 9:022005 utilizes the AMA guides. And these ratings
- 9:06appear as a string. So you'll hear people refer
- 9:10to a rating string. Next slide. These are the
- 9:16components of a rating string. We have that whole
- 9:18person impairment. We have what's called the
- 9:21diminished future earnings capacity, or the DFEC.
- 9:25And that applies to all dates of injury. Before
- 9:302013, you determine it by using a chart in the
- 9:35book. And 2013 and after, it's a multiplier of
- 9:381 .4 or 40%. We have what's called the occupational
- 9:42variant. So it's based on the injured worker's
- 9:45occupation at the time of injury and the body
- 9:48part injured. And then we have the age adjustment.
- 9:51So that's your algebraic equation. Next slide.
- 9:59And here is a link to the 2005 PDRs. If you would
- 10:05like to go and read it, maybe tonight when you
- 10:07can't fall asleep, you can pull it up and access
- 10:09it there. Next slide. And here's an example of
- 10:17what we call the rating screen. And here we have
- 10:21a 30 -year -old furniture mover with a 2012 injury
- 10:25to their low back. And it says it's a DRE category
- 10:30two, which is basically an AMA guide's designation.
- 10:35And the rating string consists of the impairment
- 10:37number and whole person impairment, what we call
- 10:41the DFVC rank and then the adjustments thereafter.
- 10:45And so I'm kind of gonna walk through the components
- 10:48of that here. So let's go to the next slide,
- 10:51please. So how to determine a DFEC? If you'll
- 10:58see on this slide, the impairment number was
- 11:03a 15 .03 .01 .00. 15 refers to chapter 15 of
- 11:09the AMA guides, and then the various numbers
- 11:12after that address the individual body parts.
- 11:15So based on that, we have a five, which that's
- 11:21called the DFVC rank. And if you have an injury
- 11:24of 2012, you would still be using that number.
- 11:27So if we have an 8 % impairment assigned by the
- 11:32QME, we multiply it by five, and that gets us
- 11:37to a 10%. Next slide. Then we have occupation
- 11:44codes. And the occupation code here for furniture
- 11:47mover is a 560. And that occupation code is important
- 11:52because it determines whether a rating goes up
- 11:55or down based upon the body part that's injured.
- 11:58So in this situation, an injury to the back under
- 12:02a 560 gets you what's called the occupation code
- 12:05of J. And that actually increases the rating
- 12:09from a, we had a 10 % up to a 16%. Next slide.
- 12:19This is the occupational variant. Sorry about
- 12:21that. That's for the increase. It shows you where
- 12:24the 15 .030100 on there gets you to that increase.
- 12:30Next slide, please. Then we have age adjustment.
- 12:36Because this furniture mover was 30, actually,
- 12:39the rating is going to go down. Age adjustment,
- 12:45it means essentially the older you get, the higher
- 12:48the impairment, the younger you are, possibly
- 12:51the more likely you're going to recover, and
- 12:53the less you get. So if you'll see on there,
- 12:57if you are, this occupational adjustment, sorry,
- 13:00that was not the age. So the age adjustment actually,
- 13:04if you are between the ages, 37 to 41, it stays
- 13:13the same. Once you hit 42, that adjustment will
- 13:16go up. Next slide. And here's another example,
- 13:22but this one is based in 2013, date of injury.
- 13:27And for this one, we don't even have to bother
- 13:29to figure out what the DFDC is, which is everything
- 13:33gets multiplied by 1 .4. And that's been the
- 13:36only change really to the PDRs. since 2005 is
- 13:40in 2013 on, we have that multiplier of 1 .4.
- 13:44Everything else pretty much remains the same
- 13:46and coming up with your rating strength, which
- 13:48is at the bottom there. We have another lumbar
- 13:52spine injury and a percentage there. And because
- 13:56this individual was actually 62 at the time of
- 13:59injury, that rating goes up quite a bit from
- 14:02a 45 to a 55. So I guess The idea is if you're
- 14:06going to get injured, do it when you're older.
- 14:10That's terrible advice. Don't listen to that.
- 14:13So next slide, please. So let's kind of get to
- 14:19the meat of this and talk a little bit about
- 14:22challenging the ratings. So the impairment ratings
- 14:27are based upon, of course, what the QME says.
- 14:32And then we get to a point where we can also
- 14:34challenge the ratings based upon the various
- 14:39aspects of it. So here what we're looking at
- 14:41is challenging the rating based upon the occupation
- 14:44code. And that's sort of the simplest way to
- 14:48initially, if you look at a rating and you don't
- 14:50agree with it or think it's too high or too low,
- 14:53you look at what the occupation is. So a same
- 14:56injury can affect different occupations differently.
- 15:01So, for example, if you have a loss of grip strength,
- 15:04that means something different to a receptionist
- 15:06than an electrician, a forklift operator, or
- 15:10a surgeon, because it all goes about the use
- 15:13of your hands and the ability to grip. Next slide.
- 15:25Oh, yeah, I'm sorry, back up one. I'm sorry,
- 15:26we can go back to assessing and challenging.
- 15:32Basically, one of the best ways to improve a
- 15:35rating is not medical, it's occupational. So
- 15:38I have here what the occupational variants are.
- 15:41So C, D, and E are less demand, F is average,
- 15:45and then the further you get up in the alphabet,
- 15:47the higher the adjustment is typically. So I
- 15:52provided a handout that's based upon one of my
- 15:55cases. and she was a forklift operator and she
- 16:01was also a forklift sales administrative aide.
- 16:06She was originally, she was injured when she
- 16:09was helping to unload a forklift from a truck
- 16:12and it fell and her hand was pinned against a
- 16:17fence with one of the forks. So she had pretty
- 16:20severe injuries to her left hand. Initially,
- 16:24she was rated by what we call the DEU, the Disability
- 16:28Evaluation Unit, under the occupation code 360.
- 16:32And you'll see in the handout that I actually
- 16:34wrote a few letters to that DEU about that. I
- 16:38initially wrote and said, well, it doesn't look
- 16:41like 360 is correct, because that's for what
- 16:44we call porters and packers. 351 applies to a
- 16:49forklift operator. And the result was that they
- 16:52came back and said, well, that's probably correct.
- 16:55And it increased her rating from 16, I believe,
- 16:57to 21%. So the point is here that the occupation
- 17:05code is very important to determining the accuracy
- 17:08of your disability rating. And it's the simplest
- 17:11way to challenge a rating. And I've actually
- 17:14had quite a bit of disputes. in my career over
- 17:19what the proper occupation code is. In determining
- 17:23that, it's important to know what the job duties
- 17:25are because an injured worker will probably tell
- 17:27you that they're a manager or that they are a
- 17:30supervisor, but that does not necessarily define
- 17:33what their job duties are. So as an example,
- 17:36I represented a client who worked for the Yellow
- 17:38Pages, for those of you who remember what Yellow
- 17:40Pages are, and she injured both of her shoulders.
- 17:44So her job title was sales manager. And the initial
- 17:48rating for her shoulders used the occupational
- 17:51code for sales representative advertising, which
- 17:53was a 212, 2012. But what she was actually doing
- 17:58when she was injured was delivering stacks of
- 18:01hard copy yellow pages, directories to businesses.
- 18:05So she would have to pull them out of the car,
- 18:07lift and carry them into the office. And as a
- 18:09result, she ended up hurting both of her shoulders.
- 18:12And in the PDRs, there's actually something called
- 18:16a telephone directory deliverer with an occupational
- 18:20code of 350. So I made that argument that the
- 18:25adjustment was necessary. It wasn't a lot. Basically,
- 18:29under 2012, her rating would have gone down.
- 18:32And at 350, it stayed the same. So it was a modest
- 18:36increase. But that's the point. Those small corrections
- 18:40in the string can create incremental increases.
- 18:44And over the life of a case, those small increments
- 18:47do matter. So let's go to the next slide, please.
- 18:55So there's something called dual occupation.
- 18:59And there's a couple cases I've listed up here
- 19:01for your review. And this means that Typically,
- 19:05it means that if you have different job duties,
- 19:08or you perform two different jobs with two different
- 19:11employers, or you perform different job duties
- 19:13for the same employer, your disability is rated
- 19:17based on the job you're performing at the time.
- 19:20So for example, a teacher who's also a school
- 19:23basketball coach is injured acting as a basketball
- 19:26coach, possibly. But in this particular case,
- 19:30in Grossmount, it was rated on his basketball
- 19:33coaching. because it produced a higher rating
- 19:36even though he was not coaching at the time of
- 19:38injury. So there's that argument to be made.
- 19:41There's actually a case I believe that involved
- 19:43an attorney who was injured moving office furniture
- 19:47when they're moving their office. And I don't
- 19:50think that one went through because technically
- 19:52lifting and moving office furniture is not part
- 19:55of your job as an attorney. But again, you can
- 19:59try and make that argument. I've moved plenty
- 20:01of furniture as an attorney myself. Also, different
- 20:06occupation codes can be used for different body
- 20:08parts for the same injury. And then the situation
- 20:12with my forklift operator, that was my argument.
- 20:16So she basically held two positions and one of
- 20:19course was the forklift operator. The second
- 20:21was administrative sales of forklifts. She, in
- 20:26addition to having her hand injury, she also
- 20:28had PTSD, which is from watching her hand getting
- 20:32penned and thought she thought she lost her hand.
- 20:36We had her go to a psychiatric QME and I made
- 20:40the argument that the occupation code that should
- 20:43be used for her psych injury should be based
- 20:47upon her work as an administrative sales and
- 20:50not as a forklift operator. As a forklift operator
- 20:53it went down as a administrative sales because
- 20:59you have to use your brain more. it actually
- 21:01went up. And so I got that rating. Again, I wrote
- 21:04to the DEU. They're probably sick of me at this
- 21:06point with this pace. But I wrote to them again,
- 21:09and I asked them to consider her dual occupations
- 21:12and gave them my estimated ratings. And they
- 21:15came back and provided the consultative rating
- 21:17for me on that. And this is a situation where
- 21:22it's very important to understand the occupation
- 21:26of the worker. Going through the 2005 PDRs, they
- 21:31have not updated it since 2005. If you're ever
- 21:34really bored and want to go through and review
- 21:36those occupations, you'll find interesting ones
- 21:38like microfilm processor and furrier. And there's
- 21:44some others that are in there that I'm pretty
- 21:46sure don't exist anymore. So it can be a little
- 21:48challenging to try and figure out which ones
- 21:50match which. But it's well worth it to kind of
- 21:53dig a little bit deeper into your Clients occupation
- 21:57and on the defense side, of course, you want
- 21:59to also make sure you're getting the correct
- 22:02occupation and job duties. So you have the most
- 22:04accurate rating. Okay, so next slide is determining
- 22:13ratings. And my push here and my my plug here
- 22:18is that attorneys should always know how to prepare
- 22:21their own ratings. When I very first started
- 22:23out practicing workers comp. My supervisor at
- 22:27the time told me never accept anybody else's
- 22:30rating. Do it yourself. And so I did algebra
- 22:34every freaking day to do my own ratings. I still
- 22:38use a yellow legal pad and my staff refers to
- 22:43my notes as Laura's yellow notes and they get
- 22:45scanned into the system that way. But that way
- 22:48I know that I've done my own rating and I can
- 22:49look at that. And then I often will take the
- 22:55report of the QME and send it into the DEU, which
- 22:58is the Disability Evaluation Unit. There are
- 23:03different roles for different players in our
- 23:06system for determining a proper rating. And of
- 23:09course, as I mentioned before, we have the physician.
- 23:12The physician will provide the whole -person
- 23:14impairment pursuant to the AMA guides. A judge
- 23:20reviews the medical evidence and can provide
- 23:23instructions to the rater or A judge is considered
- 23:26an expert rater themselves. And then we have
- 23:31the DEU. They can follow the work comp judge's
- 23:35instructions, but they can also respond to requests
- 23:38from attorneys for something called a consultative
- 23:41rating. And these are for litigated cases. These
- 23:45consultative ratings are advisory. They're not
- 23:48binding. However, as I did in my handout example,
- 23:53you can write to that rater for clarification,
- 23:55you can provide additional information about
- 23:58job duties or dual occupations, and that consultative
- 24:02rating will also provide information from the
- 24:05rater about possible issues with the QME's report,
- 24:08such as using an incorrect table or chart or
- 24:14that the addition was wrong. And so if you have
- 24:18that consultative rating and it has the notations
- 24:21at the bottom saying where the problems in the
- 24:23report are, you can take that consultative rating,
- 24:26send it to the QME and say, hey, listen, this
- 24:29is what the DEU said about you. Can you please
- 24:32address this and correct it? That way, they're
- 24:34the bad guy and not you when you're asking for
- 24:36a supplemental report or a change in their rating.
- 24:40There's also a summary rating, and that's typically
- 24:42obtained when there is not an attorney representing
- 24:45an injured worker yet. a claims adjuster will
- 24:48request it, and that one can often be changed
- 24:51or challenged. A formal rating occurs typically
- 24:55at trial, and that is based on a work comp judge's
- 24:58instructions. If you disagree with a formal rating,
- 25:01then you have to set up something called cross
- 25:03-examination of the DEE rater, or you have to
- 25:07literally challenge the instructions of the judge.
- 25:11That is a little more complicated. My suggestion
- 25:15is always start with those consultative ratings
- 25:17before you even get to a judge and see if you
- 25:20can come to some kind of agreement first on that
- 25:23versus going into a process where you're going
- 25:26to be kind of, I don't know, cross -examining
- 25:28the rater and questioning what they're doing.
- 25:33So next slide. When you rebut the ratings using
- 25:41the... the next few steps I'm going to explain
- 25:43to you. This is typically when you go back to
- 25:47the QME or the AME. It's not after the rating's
- 25:50done or you're going to the judge or the DEU
- 25:54rater. So in this scenario, there's a few ways
- 25:57you can do this. One, of course, is called Almariz
- 25:59Guzman, and that refers to a series of cases
- 26:03that basically said that if a QME is using the
- 26:07AME guides and the... cannot find a way to properly
- 26:12rate an injured worker, then they can rebut that
- 26:17AMA standard using a process that was outlined
- 26:20in these cases. So next slide, please. And so
- 26:27the way to properly rebut the rating is an example
- 26:32I'm giving here, is by having the physician provide,
- 26:39first of all, the strict rating, the rating that's
- 26:41provided in the AMA guides by saying why it is
- 26:45not appropriate for the injury or the impairment
- 26:48to go within the same, it's within the four corners
- 26:53of the AMA guides. You still have to use AMA
- 26:55guides and find something that's analogous and
- 26:58basically tie it back to what we call ADLs or
- 27:01activities of daily living to explain why that
- 27:04is more appropriate. And this case, which is
- 27:06referred to as the Cannon case, The injured worker
- 27:09was a law enforcement officer who had plantar
- 27:12fasciitis, and that is not addressed in the AMA
- 27:15guides. Neither is carpal tunnel syndrome, by
- 27:17the way. So the strict rating when there's something
- 27:21that's not actually in the AMA guides is typically
- 27:23a 0%. But that doesn't really account for the
- 27:27issues that someone can experience with plantar
- 27:29fasciitis, which is very painful if you've ever
- 27:31had it, or carpal tunnel. So in this situation,
- 27:35the QME said, The 0 % does not account for the
- 27:40individual's limitations. They can't stand for
- 27:44prolonged periods of time. It's affecting his
- 27:46walking. So by using an analogous condition,
- 27:50which was Achilles tendinopathy, they were able
- 27:54to provide the injured worker with a 7 % whole
- 27:57person impairment and advise that that was more
- 27:59accurate because of the limitations. in the activities
- 28:03of daily living, because you kind of need to
- 28:04be able to walk and stand as part of your regular
- 28:08daily life. And that's sort of the seminal case
- 28:11in determining how to correctly apply. There's
- 28:15a lot of cases that say incorrectly applications
- 28:17of Almaraz -Guzman, but this is a helpful one
- 28:19to kind of take a look at when you're asking
- 28:21a CUNY, hey, can you please take a look at your
- 28:24rating again, and maybe come back and tell me
- 28:26why you didn't use Almaraz -Guzman. Typically,
- 28:30I'll go back and ask this question. If a CUNY
- 28:34comes back and says, well, there's nothing in
- 28:35the AMA guides that provides for an impairment
- 28:38on this, so it's a 0%. And that's usually an
- 28:42indication to me to go back and be like, well,
- 28:44if it's 0%, how come my person can't go grocery
- 28:47shopping or, you know, bathe themselves? And
- 28:51that leads to hopefully another and updated rating.
- 28:55Okay. Next slide, please. Then we have An older
- 29:00case, that's Ogilvy versus Workers' Comp Appeals
- 29:04Board. And this one basically means that you
- 29:09can challenge the rating because you say it does
- 29:12not accurately represent the earning loss of
- 29:16an employee. So next slide. So in order to use
- 29:24Ogilvy, to challenge this. We typically use vocational
- 29:28evidence, which means I'm obtaining a vocational
- 29:31rehabilitation specialist. So this is typically
- 29:36used to argue that an injured worker is not amenable
- 29:39to rehabilitation, that they have suffered a
- 29:43loss of future earning capacity that is not reflected
- 29:46in the PDRs, and that the combination of both
- 29:50of these are due to the industrial injury. and
- 29:54it results in a situation particularly relevant
- 29:57where an injured worker is totally disabled,
- 30:01even if the rating they're provided is less than
- 30:04100%. And this type of rebuttal is typically
- 30:10used when you're trying to make that argument
- 30:12that your injured worker is permanently and totally
- 30:15disabled, they can't return to work, their level
- 30:17of disability is so high that they should be
- 30:21found at 100%. So next paragraph. I mean, I'm
- 30:27sorry, next slide, not next paragraph. So this
- 30:32leads us to an important relatively recent case,
- 30:36Nunes versus State of California. There's actually
- 30:38Nunes 1 and Nunes 2. Both were en banc decisions,
- 30:42which means that every commissioner signed on
- 30:45and agreed with this. And There's been a couple
- 30:49of interpretations of NUNEZ. One is that there's
- 30:52no such thing as vocational apportionment. And
- 30:55one is that, well, yes, you can still use vocational
- 30:59experts, but they have limitations in what they
- 31:03can opine about. So in this situation, if you
- 31:12have a vocational expert that provides an opinion,
- 31:14they can address employability. They can address
- 31:17permanent disability. They can address apportionment.
- 31:21And so when an injured worker is not amenable
- 31:24to vocational rehabilitation, as I mentioned
- 31:26when we were talking about Ogilvy, that expert
- 31:29must also address medical apportionment. But
- 31:34they cannot create vocational apportionment as
- 31:37a standalone. This means that they have to follow
- 31:40the medical experts. If you want a shortcut way
- 31:44to remember what NUNAS stands for, essentially
- 31:47it's that the vocational expert has to stay in
- 31:49their own lane. So they can't practice medicine
- 31:52and the medical evidence is required to prove
- 31:56apportionment. So I suggest reading the cases.
- 32:03They're very helpful and they are also a good
- 32:08way to determine whether or not you actually
- 32:10want to have a vocational expert. provide their
- 32:12opinion and how you want to instruct them to
- 32:15do so. So next slide. I keep saying paragraph.
- 32:20Next slide. And finally, another way of rebutting
- 32:25the ratings is to, again, you have to go back
- 32:29to your QME, is to ask them to please consider
- 32:33whether or not they should add the impairments
- 32:37versus combine them. So typically, there's a
- 32:40formula in the PDRs, and also, by the way, in
- 32:44the AMA guides, it's called the combined values
- 32:46chart. And the purpose behind it was to ensure
- 32:49that when there's multiple impairments, they
- 32:52are combined so that they never add up to be
- 32:58more than 100%, which is the whole idea behind
- 33:01it. However, there are times when it is appropriate
- 33:05to add those impairments. Next paragraph, I mean,
- 33:10next slide. And the case of Vigil versus County
- 33:16of Kern, which came out in 2024, establishes
- 33:20how that's done. So, for example, you would think
- 33:25if you have a 20 % impairment, another 20 % impairment
- 33:28to a different body part, that should be 40%,
- 33:31but that's not true. That's not how the combined
- 33:34values chart works. However, under the case of
- 33:39Vigil and it's actually in the AMA guides chapters
- 33:42one and two, you can consider whether or not
- 33:47the different body parts have more impact on
- 33:52what we call ADLs or activities of daily living.
- 33:54So it's very important to address those and to
- 33:58basically explain how these body parts affect
- 34:02or the injured body parts affect. and injured
- 34:04workers' activities of daily living, such as
- 34:07hygiene, housekeeping, errands. I often ask my
- 34:15injured women if they're able to put on a bra,
- 34:19because if you have an arm injury, that does
- 34:21affect it. There's things like, are you able
- 34:24to grocery shop? Can you push a cart? Can you
- 34:26lift up a gallon of milk? Those are all considered
- 34:30ADLs. and a CUME has to sort of evaluate those
- 34:33and determine how the impairment affects those.
- 34:37So they talk here about an overlap, and it's
- 34:42taken me a really long time to figure out what
- 34:44the heck an overlap means. And as an example,
- 34:48I have a client who underwent knee replacements,
- 34:51bilateral knee replacements on both right and
- 34:53left knee. These are essentially considered the
- 34:56same body part because they're both knees. However,
- 35:00because having both knees replaced created more
- 35:03of an impact on his activities of daily living
- 35:06than one knee being replaced. The argument is
- 35:10that the impairments assigned to both knees should
- 35:13be added and not combined, which is a result
- 35:16in a higher impairment rating. So, for example,
- 35:19if it was only one knee replaced, then he could
- 35:22probably use his other leg to balance getting
- 35:23in and out of the shower, stepping in and out
- 35:25of a car. just the things that you take for granted
- 35:30every day, but because both needs are replaced,
- 35:32it made it that much more difficult or amplified
- 35:35or increased the impact on those activities of
- 35:38daily living. Therefore, the addition was, in
- 35:42my mind anyway, more appropriate. So the question
- 35:46for that evaluation, if you're sending out a
- 35:48letter to a QME or AME, is to ask if there's
- 35:51more than one injured body part, How do the impairments
- 35:55for each body part affect the daily functioning
- 35:58of your injured worker? And again, I suggest
- 36:04if you haven't read it, you take a look at the
- 36:06vigil case. There's been several cases interpreting
- 36:09it since then, which are always helpful, but
- 36:12that was also another en banc decision and was
- 36:18an important one that helped distinguish that
- 36:19because for a long time we would get reports
- 36:22back from QMEs that would say something like,
- 36:24well, because it's two knees, they should be
- 36:26added, or it's two elbows, they should be added.
- 36:29And that was not enough. So having that clarity
- 36:33from this case is very helpful if you want to
- 36:35challenge that and get a higher impairment rating.
- 36:44Here, it's a good example of the proper application
- 36:47of Vigil. And this is from a doctor. Actually,
- 36:49she's up here in our area, Dr. Chitnis. And she
- 36:53correctly assessed how to add and why to add.
- 36:58And I'll point out that when you are asking a
- 37:02physician to add impairments, you also have to
- 37:04go through the same process as the Omra's Guzman
- 37:08rating. So start out with, here's a strict rating.
- 37:12and the strict rating doesn't apply because of
- 37:15the pain and symptomology. And then she went
- 37:19on to talk about how the symptoms cause issues
- 37:22of strength, deconditioning, and affected activities
- 37:25of daily living, provided that alternative rating,
- 37:29and then said that the impairment should be added.
- 37:34So it's a similar kind of a analysis as you would
- 37:37use in an Almariz -Guzman assessment. So it's
- 37:41important to remember, if you're challenging
- 37:43the ratings and you're going back to your QME,
- 37:46you want to start by looking at Almaris Guzman
- 37:48and make sure that's done correctly. Because
- 37:52challenging the ratings means that you're challenging
- 37:54the AMA guide strict rating. So you want to follow
- 37:57those steps all the way through each time, right
- 38:00up until you're going to make the argument that
- 38:02addition applies. In this situation, we had an
- 38:06individual who had impairments in both hands.
- 38:10And I've actually had physicians, I think I just
- 38:13had one recently, a case where they, QME said,
- 38:16well, even though both hands are injured, one
- 38:20hand is worse than the other one, so they can
- 38:22still use the hand that's less injured. So I'm
- 38:26gonna combine the ratings instead of add them,
- 38:29which I guess if you think through logically,
- 38:33it would seem like that wouldn't work, but I'm
- 38:35not gonna make that argument on this particular
- 38:37case. Sometimes you just want to put it in front
- 38:40of a judge if it doesn't make sense from that
- 38:44aspect. Or you go back to your treating physician
- 38:47and ask them for their opinion. But that's another
- 38:49topic in another seminar. So I want to talk about
- 38:55some practice tips. Next slide. So it's very
- 39:05important when you get that QME and AMRE report
- 39:08to read it carefully. And I'll admit sometimes
- 39:13it's helpful to have AI help you with that if
- 39:15you use your AI properly. But a lot of times
- 39:18it's easy to miss things that are in there that
- 39:21are helpful. And that is to also make sure that
- 39:25you've got all the body parts are addressed and
- 39:27rated, that the impairments are done, that they
- 39:31give you the proper charts, pages to the AMA
- 39:35guides, that there's nothing missing in the report,
- 39:40such as work restrictions or a review of medical
- 39:44records. There's a whole list of required items
- 39:47that should be in an AME QME report. And also,
- 39:51most important right now, did the QME provide
- 39:54an assessment of the effect of impairments on
- 39:57activities of daily living, which is super important
- 40:00right now. And one thing that I typically ask
- 40:03also is for the QME or AME to provide me with
- 40:06a copy of a form filled out by the injured worker,
- 40:12where they write out or they provide where they
- 40:15feel that their activities of daily living are
- 40:18affected. So it's kind of a chart, but you'll
- 40:21want to get a copy of that to make sure that
- 40:23it was actually done. That helps you, of course,
- 40:26with rebutting the ratings. And then again, It's
- 40:30important to understand how to rate the report
- 40:33like old school by using your copy of the PDRs
- 40:38and your AMA guides and your yellow pad and just
- 40:42do what's called a hand reading so that you go
- 40:45through it and it helps you also determine whether
- 40:48or not something's missing and you want to make
- 40:51sure the occupation is correct, that the age
- 40:53adjustment is correct, that you have the correct
- 40:56occupational code when you do that rating. And
- 41:00then at that point, I typically will request
- 41:03a consultative rating, especially if there's
- 41:05a dispute about how the rating is done with my
- 41:08opposing counsel, because that can kind of help
- 41:11us determine whether or not there is an actual
- 41:13issue with the way that the QME report or the
- 41:16QME found it. Because again, we can blame it
- 41:18on the DEU rater instead of you if you find a
- 41:21problem with a report, but you don't want to
- 41:23go back to the QME and say, hey, you screwed
- 41:25up. You can just say, hey, the DEU rater found
- 41:28this when they did the consultative rating, can
- 41:30you please address this? And then you can get
- 41:35an updated report or supplemental report from
- 41:38them. And then also, of course, when you're going
- 41:42through and you look at your rating string, it's
- 41:46the subtle things, like I said, the incremental
- 41:48changes or the increases that are very helpful.
- 41:52I've had situations where my client went from
- 41:55age 46 to 47, between two injury dates. And that
- 42:01actually made a big difference. So applying the
- 42:04correct age to the correct injury. Again, I've
- 42:07had cases where like my forklift operator, she
- 42:11performed two different job duties. And she actually
- 42:14performed both of them on the day she was injured.
- 42:17There's also situations where you have an injured
- 42:19worker who works for two different employers.
- 42:23And they might have gotten injured at an employer
- 42:26where that injury is for their back, and they
- 42:29were lifting and moving things around, and their
- 42:32other job might have been sitting at a desk.
- 42:34So it's important to make sure you have the correct
- 42:36employer and the correct injury. And then you
- 42:40want to think about, do I have a rebuttal argument?
- 42:43If I don't agree with this QME report, is there
- 42:46a basis to go back and ask for Amr's Guzman?
- 42:49Is there a basis for me to get a vocational report?
- 42:52Is there a basis for me to to go back and confirm
- 42:57my client's job duties, because they were real
- 42:59proud of being a manager, but it looks like they
- 43:01were moving boxes at the time. It won't work
- 43:04if you're a lawyer, but could work in other job
- 43:07situations. So the important thing to remember
- 43:16is that just because you get a disability rating,
- 43:19that is not the end of your case. and disability
- 43:22ratings are just algebra. And the challenge isn't
- 43:26doing the math, because no, you do have to do
- 43:30math as lawyers. The challenge is making sure
- 43:33you're using the correct variables and maybe
- 43:36go brush up on your algebra. I know we have a
- 43:40little more time left here. I kind of went fast
- 43:42through everything. Are there any questions that
- 43:45I can address for anyone at this point? It looks
- 43:52like we have two questions in the Q &A at this
- 43:54time. One first one big, I'm Stephen. Let's see,
- 43:58looks like that is a comment actually. Carpal
- 44:04tunnel syndrome is addressed on page 495 of the
- 44:07AMA guides but requires surgery and optimal recovery
- 44:09time before impairment can be addressed. It is
- 44:11not completely unaddressed like plantar fasciitis.
- 44:16Michelle Gonzales says how to challenge a QME
- 44:19report when it says there Or no, there is no
- 44:22psychiatric injury and defense wants to withdraw
- 44:25the application. Oh, well, it depends on who
- 44:29says there's no psychiatric injury. So I mean,
- 44:32if you have obviously have a psychiatric human,
- 44:33they said there's no psychiatric injury. It's.
- 44:39It's I always say there's a 0 % go back and ask
- 44:42them again. Also, I'm finding that if there is.
- 44:48even if you claim psych and it's out of orthopedic
- 44:50injuries, most of you probably know after 2013
- 44:52that's not considered something where you get
- 44:55permanent disability, you can still get work
- 44:58restrictions. And that's important for, in terms
- 45:01of getting somebody to be, if you think they're
- 45:04permanent and total, if there are work restrictions
- 45:06caused by that psychiatric disability, you want
- 45:09to get to that. And also, again, this gets a
- 45:13little more complicated, but if they don't find
- 45:15an industrial cause for the psychiatric injury,
- 45:17We may be looking at SIBTF, but that's gotten
- 45:20a lot more complicated lately. However, if someone
- 45:25has an injury and it has to do with chronicity,
- 45:30typically, I would say that you have some kind
- 45:33of psychiatric disability, even if it's just
- 45:35related to chronic pain. I hope that helps answer
- 45:37the question a little bit. Also, I just had a
- 45:44an opinion come down from the commissioners where
- 45:47we were reminded that you can get outside opinions,
- 45:53medical opinions pursuant to Valdez to challenge
- 45:58what's being put on the record. And so in this
- 46:03particular case, I had a report from an IME or
- 46:06disability retirement that I tried to put into
- 46:10evidence and got challenged on. And the commissioner
- 46:12said, you can submit it under Valdez. And again,
- 46:18it's up to the judge how they want kind of weight
- 46:19they want to give to it. But if you have an outside
- 46:22report that does find psychiatric disability,
- 46:25it's worth trying to bring that in. Do we have
- 46:31any other questions? Sorry, it went a little
- 46:32faster than I thought. All right, let's see.
- 46:38I have one here. What are the most frequent mistakes
- 46:41attorneys make when performing their own hand
- 46:42ratings under the 2005 PDRS, particularly when
- 46:46the PDRS instructions appear to conflict with
- 46:48AMA guides? So in doing hand ratings, typically
- 46:53what I found is that after 2013, people tend
- 46:58to shortcut and not go to the actual number.
- 47:02So for example, if you have a rating I just have
- 47:06my PBRs right here to run a DM. So if you have
- 47:08a rating that basically is a number, it's like
- 47:10we have the lumbar spine is 15 .03 .01. I think
- 47:14everything under 15 .01 to 15 .03 falls within
- 47:17the same line. But there are some injuries to
- 47:20other body parts where you still have the specific
- 47:23code. So it still could be, I'm just making this
- 47:26up like a 16 .02 point whatever. And that can
- 47:30actually get you to a higher rating even with
- 47:34Don't just dismiss it because you're going to
- 47:36multiply it by 1 .4. You can still get a higher
- 47:39rating once you determine that occupation code
- 47:42by using the actual chart in the PDRs. So I've
- 47:47actually gotten higher ratings that way. And
- 47:51then because it is still applicable. So I hope
- 47:55that helps out a little bit. If you go back and
- 47:57you look at the very beginning, even when you
- 47:59don't have a DFAC to determine, use the actual
- 48:03numbers, the actual assigned, you know, AMA guys,
- 48:08chapters, charts that are in there, because it
- 48:11could get you to a higher rating. That's the
- 48:12first mistake. And the second one I often see
- 48:15is, again, this occupation code, ensuring that
- 48:18you actually know the job duties of your client,
- 48:21and then kind of digging your way through the
- 48:24PDRs, because who knew there was something called
- 48:26a directory deliverer. But in 2005, there was
- 48:32one. So it can take a little bit of digging,
- 48:34but it's worth looking at. And also, making sure
- 48:41that you always want to make sure that you include
- 48:44the apportionment. Because I've done that before,
- 48:46where I forgot to include apportionment. And
- 48:48then I get all mad at the opposing council. I'm
- 48:50like, what do you mean that was only a 10 %?
- 48:51I come up with a 15, and I forgot to put the
- 48:54apportionment in there. So those are the typical
- 48:57problems that I have. Oh, one other one is that
- 49:01the combined value chart, the numbers are super
- 49:04tiny. So oftentimes when you're trying to figure
- 49:07out where it intersects, you can get the wrong
- 49:12number. So use a ruler. I have another question
- 49:20here. When selecting an AME, what qualifications
- 49:23or characteristics should counsel look for if
- 49:25the case is likely to involve a sophisticated
- 49:27rating dispute rather than simply a straightforward
- 49:30impairment assessment? So in offering AMEs, typically
- 49:37what I look at is, is it somebody who's going
- 49:40to request diagnostics? Is it someone who is
- 49:45going to be write a very thorough report? A lot
- 49:49of times with QMEs we have some, and sometimes
- 49:51they're just new. They don't take the time to
- 49:55basically say, well, I don't have diagnostics.
- 49:57I want to go and get it. So if you want to have
- 50:00a thorough report and you want an AME who does
- 50:02a good job, that's sort of the first place I
- 50:04look. And the second one is I tend to look for
- 50:08people who only do AMEs. They don't provide QME
- 50:12evaluations because they tend to operate a little
- 50:16differently. I don't know if it works that way.
- 50:18and down south, but here we have kind of a limited
- 50:22pool of agreed medical evaluators, and they tend
- 50:25to be very thorough. They're a little more demanding
- 50:28in what they want, but it's worthwhile to go
- 50:31to them. And I also try not to be too particular
- 50:35about specialty. I know often I have defense
- 50:40attorneys who tell me they want orthopedic physicians
- 50:43to be evaluators. But there happen to be some
- 50:46very good orthopedic AMEs up here. So sometimes
- 50:50I don't agree to one simply because I know that
- 50:53they write a very good report. And something
- 50:58else too, if you want somebody who's going to
- 51:01defer to a different specialty, they're not going
- 51:03to say, because I am whatever, an orthopedic
- 51:06doctor, I can also make an assessment of neurological
- 51:08injury. You want them to defer to a different
- 51:11specialty if that's needed. What evidence is
- 51:22sufficient to establish that two impairments
- 51:24have separate or amplified effects on ADL so
- 51:26that impairments can properly be added rather
- 51:29than combined? So a lot of it has to hinge on
- 51:35the way the report is written up. So for example,
- 51:38the one I provided from Dr. Chitnis, I think
- 51:42that was actually in a panel decision that you
- 51:43can probably locate. If you can't find it, let
- 51:46me know. I'll be happy to send it to you. It's
- 51:48important that the specifically address the activities
- 51:53of living and which ones are impaired and how
- 51:57they are impaired. And if it's two body parts,
- 52:01like the knees, the cumi I had in that case basically
- 52:04said, well, if he only has one knee replaced,
- 52:09then he could use the other knee to balance or
- 52:11get in and out of a car. He actually said get
- 52:13in and out of a car, get in and out of a bathtub.
- 52:17There was a couple other things he mentioned,
- 52:19going up and down stairs. So he was very specific
- 52:23in enumerating which particular activities that
- 52:26you deal with on a daily basis are affected by
- 52:30the impairments and how much it is affected by
- 52:33both knees rather than just one knee. So it's
- 52:36really contingent upon the medical evaluators
- 52:39report. And I would keep going back until they
- 52:41get it right. Let's see. What types of vocational
- 52:49evidence have actually succeeded in establishing
- 52:51that an injured worker is not amenable to rehabilitation
- 52:55as opposed to merely having difficulty returning
- 52:58to the same occupation? That's a good one. Honestly,
- 53:03I don't use a lot of vocational experts, but
- 53:05I think that if you do SIBTF now, you're kind
- 53:09of going to have to do that, the subsequent injury
- 53:12benefit trust fund cases. For the most part,
- 53:16If you can get that information from a physician,
- 53:19sometimes you can, then I would go that route.
- 53:23A lot of times I do that with my law enforcement
- 53:25cases where I provide them with what are called
- 53:28the essential job functions lists and I send
- 53:30that over to them and I ask them to please go
- 53:32through these and provide your opinion about
- 53:35whether based upon your evaluation, this individual
- 53:39can perform these job duties. In terms of vocational
- 53:43evidence, it gets a little bit trickier because
- 53:45most part, you're going to have to pay for that
- 53:47expert. And the expert report needs to be incredibly
- 53:52thorough. So I've had a couple of those cases
- 53:59where it worked out, where I've had a vocational
- 54:02expert come in and just be very thorough in evaluating
- 54:05potential jobs and potential occupations for
- 54:10the injured worker. There's a recent case. everywhere
- 54:14it was called right now. It's called PARAs, I
- 54:16believe, that kind of outlines what you can and
- 54:17can't consider in terms of amenability to rehabilitation,
- 54:22such as language skills, for one thing. And so
- 54:26I would suggest going through and doing a search
- 54:29of those recent cases and looking at vocational
- 54:32cases that made it or didn't make it. I tend
- 54:34to do that, too. A little plug for CLA. If you
- 54:38are a member of CLA, you have access to something
- 54:40called Fastcase. And if you log into it, You
- 54:43can go every day and look at the most recent
- 54:46panel decisions that have come out and take a
- 54:49look at those and kind of get a sense of what
- 54:52the current issues are and what kind of cases
- 54:54are coming up and what you need to do to ensure
- 54:57that your discovery is complete or correct. So
- 55:01I don't know if that helps much, but. So we have
- 55:07another question here. Are there particular fact
- 55:10patterns where counsel should immediately consider
- 55:13whether the combined values chart is inappropriate
- 55:16rather than accepting the physician's combined
- 55:19rating? Yes. I've had a situation like that where
- 55:25somebody had a electrocution injury. So she had
- 55:30a brain injury, cervical spine, and then she
- 55:33had an arm injury. And the first physician was
- 55:37like, well, we just have to combine those all.
- 55:39but it didn't seem like that was affecting our
- 55:43activities of daily living the same, because
- 55:44a brain injury is not going to be quite the same
- 55:47as a hand injury's effect on things. So that
- 55:50was one where I immediately went back and challenged
- 55:51the QME and filed my objection that that was
- 55:54not correct and wanted to go back and kind of
- 55:57do an assessment of, let's go back to those activities
- 55:59of daily living. So when they have multiple body
- 56:02parts, I think the first thing you should probably
- 56:03do is stop and look at it and say, let's always
- 56:06ask that question. Are these really all combined?
- 56:10I mean, or do we need to look at how each one's
- 56:12affecting activities of daily living? If they're
- 56:14not overlapping particularly. So in this situation,
- 56:18if you have a brain injury and a neck injury
- 56:20and then a hand injury, those are not overlapping
- 56:22body parts. So that's something where you wanna
- 56:25stop and consider whether they should be added.
- 56:32So. All right, it looks like we have one question.
- 56:36Okay. If you were to receive a Q &A report tomorrow
- 56:40with a surprisingly low PD rating, what are the
- 56:44first three things you'd look at before deciding
- 56:46whether the rating can be successfully challenged?
- 56:50So first, I would look at whether or not they
- 56:53viewed all medical reports and records. I'd look
- 56:56at what tables and charts used in the AMA guides
- 57:00or if they even considered Almaraz Guzman or,
- 57:03you know, a different kind of rating. And then
- 57:07I would take a look at the actual evaluation
- 57:12itself. A lot of times, I ask my clients how
- 57:14long they spent with the QME, because there's
- 57:16certain periods of time, obviously. Typically,
- 57:18it's 20 minutes. It's an hour for psych eval.
- 57:21So I will tend to look at that. If it's very
- 57:23low, again, sometimes it is what it is, but also
- 57:31it can be based on a very cursory evaluation,
- 57:34and if there's no diagnostics. So if there's
- 57:37no review of diagnostics, that's also problematic.
- 57:39Typically, I'll just file an objection and then
- 57:42I'll go back and talk to my client and find out,
- 57:44you know, maybe they are feeling better. Also
- 57:47something to keep in mind is that if an evaluator
- 57:51says, well, this person is better and the medication
- 57:53is helping them or the splint is helping them
- 57:55or whatever, you can still increase the permanent
- 57:58disability rating by one to 3 % because the just
- 58:03because the treatment's helping them doesn't
- 58:05mean that they don't have the impairment. So
- 58:08for example, if it's a psych injury and they're
- 58:10taking psych meds and it makes them feel better,
- 58:13you can still add one to 3 % for impairment because
- 58:17absent the medication, they still have that.
- 58:19I hope that makes sense, but it's actually, which
- 58:22is in the guides or the PDRs, but actually it
- 58:24has PsychCumie who just told me that. All righty
- 58:32that looks like the um sit for questions now
- 58:35do you have any other closing remarks that you'd
- 58:38like to make before we close off? No I mean I
- 58:41obviously it's a it's a highly litigated area
- 58:43um it kind of makes things interesting the one
- 58:46thing that I I kind of learned to do is particularly
- 58:49because now I'm just as solo as I kind of a pain
- 58:53in the butt but I always object to a Q &A report
- 58:56um if it's the first one if I see something that
- 59:01I feel like something's missing. You have 10
- 59:03days to do that. And even if it's just a gut
- 59:05reaction, send out that objection. Because sometimes
- 59:09it's just a matter of updating and clarifying
- 59:11your medical record. And we have an obligation
- 59:13to make sure that we have a complete record before
- 59:16we start putting things in front of a judge.
- 59:20I hope that's helpful. And of course, feel free
- 59:23to reach out to me if you have any other questions.
- 59:28This concludes today's presentation. Thank you
- 59:30so much Laura Rosenthal for providing an excellent
- 59:33presentation today and thank you so much to our
- 59:35audience for joining us. Have a great day everybody.
- 59:38Thank you.