Latest / The Great Retirement Debate with Ed Slott & Jeffrey Levine / S1 Ep19: GRD019 - Season 1 Finale and Recap
Transcript
- 0:00Intro: Hi, I'm Ed Slott.
- 0:01And I'm Jeff Levine.
- 0:02And we are two guys who just love to talk about retirement and taxes.
- 0:06Look, our mission is simple to educate you, the savers, so that you can make
- 0:10better decisions because better decisions on the hall lead to better outcomes.
- 0:14And here's how we're going to do that.
- 0:15Each week, Jeff and I will debate the pros and the cons of a particular
- 0:20retirement strategy or topic with the.
- 0:23Helping you keep more of your hard-earned money.
- 0:26Yeah, but we won't know which side of the debate we're taking until we flip
- 0:29a coin winner of the coin flip gets to pick which side of the debate they want
- 0:33to argue, and both of us will have to argue in favor of our respect positions,
- 0:38whether we agree with them or not.
- 0:40At the end of each debate, there's going to be one clear winner you, a more
- 0:45informed saver who can hopefully apply the merits of each side of the debate
- 0:48to your own personal situation to decide what's best for you and your family.
- 0:52So here we go.
- 0:53Welcome to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:02Jeffrey Levine: All right, welcome back to the Great Retirement Debate.
- 1:04Ed.
- 1:04How's it going today?
- 1:06Ed Slott: Pretty good.
- 1:06We're down to the end now.
- 1:08Uh, this is our 19th episode coming up.
- 1:11Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 1:12And the last of season one.
- 1:14So this is gonna be, uh, a special episode for us.
- 1:16This is our last episode for season one and, uh, a little bit of a different
- 1:20format today, instead of our typical debate, we're gonna kinda look back at,
- 1:25uh, some of the discussions we've had.
- 1:27And Ed, you know, we, we've covered a lot of ground this, uh, this season.
- 1:33A lot of different topics.
- 1:35Ed Slott: Well, I'm looking at the list.
- 1:37I have it in front of me and I'm amazed how many questions, you
- 1:40know, it's based on listeners.
- 1:42We we're out in the field a lot.
- 1:44We hear a lot of these questions people have, should
- 1:47I do this or should I do that?
- 1:48And that's the point of this debate to give you both sides of the pros
- 1:52and cons and benefits and drawbacks.
- 1:54And we did cover a lot of ground, but the big items that people are asking about.
- 2:01Jeffrey Levine: So lot of big items as you just mentioned.
- 2:04Let me ask you, looking back at, at, at the first season, what,
- 2:08what was your favorite debate?
- 2:10Like, which one, like, which one sticks out in your mind as perhaps the one
- 2:14where, whether you just had the most fun discussing it or whether it was
- 2:18a surprise as we went through it?
- 2:20You know, what, what, what, which one was your favorite?
- 2:22Ed Slott: Well, I have to pick two.
- 2:24Our recap of Secure 2.0 deal or no deal, part one and part two.
- 2:30Those are the two.
- 2:30That was a, a shift, a lot of new provisions, but as we found out, there
- 2:35was nothing earth shattering there.
- 2:37It wasn't transformative.
- 2:39It wasn't groundbreaking like the original secure Act was, but there was still so
- 2:44many provisions, so many little ones.
- 2:46I think there were over 90 retirement provisions and secure 2.0 a little
- 2:51something for everybody and a lot of little things that you have to know.
- 2:55And it took us two episodes to go through it and some people are still
- 2:59surprised of what's in Secure 2.0.
- 3:02Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, we probably could have done four or five
- 3:04episodes to cover every provision as, uh, as we look back at that one.
- 3:08You know, that was one where we had 90 plus provisions in a, in a bill, and
- 3:14boy, you know, if you like secure Act one, the original that was roughly a
- 3:18dozen, there was a lot more to look at.
- 3:20As you said, maybe not anything as impactful as perhaps the death of the
- 3:25stretch was in the original secure act.
- 3:27But lots of things with more modest impacts still add up to potentially
- 3:33very important things to know.
- 3:35I gotta say on on my end, maybe a little bit of, um, you know, nostalgia,
- 3:39looking back to episode one, but I really enjoyed our debate about should
- 3:43I take social security or use my ira?
- 3:46And that, you know, that just continues to be a question I hear all the time.
- 3:51Uh, there continues to be new research in fact.
- 3:54Uh, just in this last January, Ed, in January of 2023, I don't know
- 3:58if you saw, but there was a, uh, a really interesting article in the
- 4:03Journal of Financial Planning by, uh, Steve Parrish and Wade Pfau, uh, two,
- 4:08you know, retirement, uh, experts.
- 4:10Ed Slott: I know them both from the American College.
- 4:12Jeffrey Levine: That's right.
- 4:13That's, that's exactly right.
- 4:14Two professors from the American College and, you know, they, they look at not just
- 4:20the insurance value of social security, which we often talk about, but they went
- 4:24a step further and said, um, if we're just concerned about leaving more money
- 4:29to your heirs, what does that look like?
- 4:33And you know, we, we could spend a lot of time just covering
- 4:36this, but we, we already did.
- 4:37Uh, but, but there are new research basically showed that even if
- 4:40we're just talking about I want to leave the greatest legacy, like
- 4:43what, what leaves me at death?
- 4:46Forget about the insurance element of social security and delaying,
- 4:49but just the idea of can I, do I get more money when I die on average?
- 4:54They actually found that you would have to have a particularly aggressive allocation
- 4:59in throughout your kind of retirement and have good fortune of the markets in
- 5:04order for, uh, using, uh, in, in order for using your own money not to work out well.
- 5:13Right?
- 5:13So in other words, delaying social security still really comes out to be
- 5:16a winner for many, many individuals and there's just more research about that.
- 5:20It continues to be the single most asked question of any that I think we had.
- 5:25Maybe along with should I use the trust as a beneficiary.
- 5:27Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 5:27I was surprised at that one.
- 5:29Back on the social security, that's something we can do all the time because
- 5:33so many people have different types of questions and the demographics are
- 5:38there where you have the baby boomers moving in, into social security area.
- 5:43So, uh, the demographic is just tens of thousands of people, uh, applying
- 5:48and starting to collect or making a decision on when, when to begin each day.
- 5:53So that's always going to be a big issue, especially like you said, if they have
- 5:56other assets, IRAs, which to use, where to invest, but the trust is beneficiary.
- 6:02That was actually our second episode and one of the most
- 6:05popular, and that surprised me.
- 6:07And maybe because people, a lot of people had these trusts that seemed
- 6:12to work before the Secure Act.
- 6:14The original Secure Act and the Secure Act really put the kibosh on a lot of these
- 6:19trusts with the 10 year rule in higher taxes for the post death protection.
- 6:24So I think, uh, people got a lot out of that episode.
- 6:28Jeffrey Levine: So I, I got another question for you, ed, like, was, was
- 6:31there a particular episode where, where you really felt that one of
- 6:34us had the short end of the stick?
- 6:36You know, like...
- 6:37Ed Slott: Oh, yeah.
- 6:37Uh, you did.
- 6:38I, I'm trying to, I'm looking at the, the list.
- 6:41Uh, I, I can't remember.
- 6:43Jeffrey Levine: Well, I'll, I'll give you one.
- 6:44I mean, one of us had to argue in favor of 72 T payments.
- 6:47Ed Slott: Oh yeah, right.
- 6:48Yeah.
- 6:48That, no, I think it was Roth related, where I had a sweet, or one of us had
- 6:53a sweet deal because I think we're both Roth IRA fans because we like the idea
- 6:57of, uh, having, uh, locking in tax free, uh, savings and income in retirement.
- 7:03So it's hard to argue against that, but it's not, but that's
- 7:06the point of this program.
- 7:08It's not for the, the answer is not the same for everybody.
- 7:12Everybody has their own customized facts and circumstances and
- 7:15family and financial situations.
- 7:18So I'm glad we give both sides even a side that we're both on, because we
- 7:22both kind of like Roths, but for some people it's, it's not for everybody.
- 7:27Jeffrey Levine: All right.
- 7:27So I, I, I got, I got, I'm gonna rapid fire here and I got another one for you.
- 7:32Did, did you change your mind about anything after having one of our debates?
- 7:38Ed Slott: I'm looking through the, uh, through the list here.
- 7:43Uh, I, I'm trying to think.
- 7:45I don't, I don't see.
- 7:48Uh, I don't see anything where, you know, I felt we gave, uh,
- 7:52good sides on both of them.
- 7:55And it's not a question of changing my mind.
- 7:57I think we gave both sides of the argument, uh, whatever
- 8:01the, whatever the debate was.
- 8:05We, we gave, like I said, the pros and cons on each one.
- 8:08So I think those were all good.
- 8:10And, and when we talk about these things, you can go by episode and
- 8:13look at the ones we're talking about.
- 8:15They're all numbered, they're all on there for you to, uh, listen to, and
- 8:19it might pay to listen to them again.
- 8:21Especially things you don't hear a lot about, like gifting versus inheriting.
- 8:25That was a good one.
- 8:26Most people don't realize the difference between the two or one
- 8:30that was uh, kind of interesting.
- 8:32A Roth IRA versus Roth 401k.
- 8:36A little confusing.
- 8:37And I think we got good points out on that because especially with
- 8:41Roth, uh, 401k starting in 2024, not having RMDs for Lifetime.
- 8:47That's a big change that may change some people's minds or keeping, uh, Roth 401K
- 8:53dollars in the plan and instead of rolling 'em out to a Roth IRA, I think it's
- 8:57important to understand the difference because there were many differences
- 9:00between having your own Roth IRA or keeping the Roth 401k in, in the plan.
- 9:09Or downsizing my home in retirement.
- 9:11Uh, we, we had a debate on that.
- 9:14I think that was one where I said, I don't remember which side.
- 9:19Jeffrey Levine: I, I, I took the, I took the side of, no, don't, don't, don't
- 9:22take, don't downsize in retirement.
- 9:24Enjoy it with your kids and your grandkids.
- 9:26That was my argument.
- 9:27Yeah.
- 9:27Ed Slott: Right.
- 9:27And I said, well, it's good to simplify and things, but I like being in my home.
- 9:32You know, like my father, he stayed in the home until he died.
- 9:36And then the minute he died, my mother went out, sold the home and got an
- 9:39apartment like she always wanted.
- 9:43. Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 9:43Yeah.
- 9:43I actually really enjoyed that one too.
- 9:45I think of all the discussions we had, that was one that really stuck out to me
- 9:50as, as one of the most earnest because we were both drawing from things, you know,
- 9:54in, in our actual lives that you know, that, that, that lead us to a certain way.
- 10:00You know, again, you thinking about the simplicity of the situation, but
- 10:03enjoying your house and me, you know, having just finished building a house.
- 10:07You know, the, uh, the idea of just envisioning, you know,
- 10:11generations in that house to come.
- 10:14Uh, maybe my kids won't want that, but you know, I hope to make that
- 10:17the place where we all come visit.
- 10:19And I, I thought that was a great discussion and the type of discussion
- 10:23that is so good to have with, you know, an independent person there, whether that's
- 10:28your tax advisor, your financial advisor, uh, or in some cases just a good friend.
- 10:33You know, sometimes you, you, you have blind spots and a good financial
- 10:37professional can help you uncover those.
- 10:40But, but just even talking through it, you begin to understand what your,
- 10:44what your true values are in life and, and that today is what a great
- 10:51financial advisor can do for you, not just the numbers and the dollars and
- 10:56the cents and knowing the tax rules.
- 10:58Tho those are, I, I hate to say almost table stakes because it, it's a lot.
- 11:03You have to invest a lot of time and knowledge to, to build up that, that
- 11:08reservoir of information and wisdom.
- 11:10But it's Taking that knowledge and information and the ones and zeros, right,
- 11:17the, the stuff that is factual, right?
- 11:20And then really helping you dive in and applying it to your specific values.
- 11:25You not only your set of facts and circumstances, as we say in every episode,
- 11:29but your values what's most important to you in life versus someone else.
- 11:34And, and that just is different for every.
- 11:36Ed Slott: And it's, you know, in many of the programs that we did, many of
- 11:40these episodes, I pointed out that there's a generation between you and I.
- 11:44So we have different perspectives,
- 11:46Jeffrey Levine: Right.
- 11:46Mine is correct and yours is not.
- 11:50Ed Slott: That's where you are.
- 11:51Uh, you see in 30 years if you still wanna maintain that house, but maybe it will.
- 11:56Jeffrey Levine: I like the idea of having the place where everybody comes
- 11:59to for holidays and get togethers.
- 12:02Have a nice place like that.
- 12:03You know, it, it sounds like, uh, one of those Hallmark movies.
- 12:07That's, that's that.
- 12:08Well, that's, that's what I envision.
- 12:09You, you pretty much, pretty much have it.
- 12:12Ed, let me ask one more question here before maybe we we start
- 12:16to, to wrap up Season one.
- 12:18Insert tear emoji right there.
- 12:20All right, so, uh, Ed emoji, you know, is something that is like a
- 12:25picture that is, I'm just teasing.
- 12:27That's a generation.
- 12:29So the, you know, as we, as we sit here, was there, did
- 12:33you get any specific comments?
- 12:34I know you know.
- 12:36Meet with a lot of people as you do.
- 12:37We speak with a lot of, uh, advisors and a lot of consumers.
- 12:40Was there one particular, you know, episode or topic that you got a lot of,
- 12:45you know, feedback on personally or any, any specific comment and you're like,
- 12:49huh, that was, that was interesting.
- 12:51Or, or just that really stuck out to you?
- 12:53Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 12:53In the beginning we got a comment.
- 12:55I don't remember if you saw it, but we always acknowledge in the
- 12:59beginning when the other person, you or I made a good point, we're arguing
- 13:04one side of the debate and I'll say, oh Jeff, that is a good point.
- 13:07But it's the other side of the debate and people say, well, we
- 13:09wanna hear, we don't want to hear that you agree with each other.
- 13:12We wanna hear opposite sides.
- 13:15. . Jeffrey Levine: That's right, that's right.
- 13:17So we try to, you know, look like everything else Ed you.
- 13:19You start something and you refine it over time and hopefully here by our 19th
- 13:24episode we're, we're a little bit better at this than we were when we started.
- 13:28And, uh, you know, for, for me, I think the episode that stuck out for me in
- 13:32terms of feedback was episode 10 when we talked about tax diversification.
- 13:36Ed Slott: Yes.
- 13:37That was one of the most popular, I'm looking on the list.
- 13:40It was the third most popular of all of them.
- 13:43Jeffrey Levine: Yeah.
- 13:43And, and, and it stuck out for me because that was one where I really felt that
- 13:48we had a good earnest debate and I, I actually got feedback from a number of
- 13:54people that after we had a discussion about that, they they really reframed
- 14:00how they go about thinking about things.
- 14:02That was one of the ones where I, I felt that we really changed some opinions or
- 14:07created, uh, a different viewpoint amongst people where they didn't have it before.
- 14:11So to me, that's what this is all about, right?
- 14:13Is, is not, again, that you pointed out earlier.
- 14:16Not that the thing is right or wrong, but that there's two sides to, to, but...
- 14:20Ed Slott: To learn from it!
- 14:21Jeffrey Levine: That's right to learn, and that's what we set out to do.
- 14:24Ed Slott: There's so much bias stuff out there that sometimes people hear
- 14:28what they want to hear or they're told what they want to hear and they're
- 14:32not giving, you know, it depends who has, is there an ulterior motive from
- 14:35the person that's telling you that.
- 14:37What I like about this is there's no such, it's independent, objective, unbiased,
- 14:42this, these are the pros, these are the cons, and you know, these are factors
- 14:46you have to take into account before making a major financial decision.
- 14:50And if I just go through, so the list of the topics we covered, I think
- 14:54almost every one of these are major financial decisions and some of which
- 14:59you don't even get a second chance at.
- 15:01Like, should I take social security early or not?
- 15:04Name a trust as a beneficiary.
- 15:06Should I take a pension, lump sum, or the, uh, an annuity income stream?
- 15:12Should I buy long-term care insurance?
- 15:13Every one of these titles, these are separate episodes where
- 15:17you can gain a lot of insight.
- 15:19Should I use a Roth IRA or life insurance?
- 15:21Should I pay off debt before I retire?
- 15:23Should I use a Roth IRA or 529 plan to save for college?
- 15:28That was interesting.
- 15:29Many people don't look at Roth IRAs as a a education funding vehicle.
- 15:34Uh, should I own maybe in , should I own cryptocurrency?
- 15:39Maybe we'll wait on that.
- 15:40I, in my retirement account, uh, was that before or after
- 15:44the crash we had that episode?
- 15:45I don't even remember.
- 15:47Jeffrey Levine: I, I think maybe like during the crash.
- 15:49Yeah, it was, uh, yeah.
- 15:51You know, there was just a lot of ground covered this season and.
- 15:55You know, I guess Ed now would be a good time to, uh, to, to let people
- 15:58know the, the good news, at least we hope you would find it to be good
- 16:02news, is that The Great Retirement Debate has been renewed for season two.
- 16:06Yes.
- 16:06We've, we've got approval to go.
- 16:08Of course, when I say it's been renewed and we have approval, basically, Ed, you
- 16:11and I said, hey, we'll do this again.
- 16:13Like it was, it was, uh, it was, it was fun.
- 16:15We had a good time doing it.
- 16:17Ed Slott: Things change too.
- 16:18Like we did that two part series on secure 2.0 that wasn't on the, uh, blackboard
- 16:24or, uh, planning when we started this.
- 16:26That, that's right.
- 16:27But a lot of people were asking about it and we took a different spin there rather
- 16:31than pro or con, we said deal or no deal.
- 16:33Which provisions are good, we're more useful, less useful, more impactful.
- 16:37So we'll be doing things like that.
- 16:39As laws or changes develop, and they're always changing these things.
- 16:44Look at the secure 2.0, there are provisions going out for 10 years.
- 16:48Do you really think that any of those provisions or many of them
- 16:52will hold for the full 10 years?
- 16:53I don't think so.
- 16:54I think we'll see lots more changes.
- 16:56Jeffrey Levine: I, one thing that we can almost always bet on Ed is,
- 16:59is, is change, especially, you know, with a divided Congress, or I should
- 17:04say divided political parties.
- 17:06You know, one party gets in and their agenda's completely
- 17:08different than the other.
- 17:09As soon as they have control, they pass laws.
- 17:12Uh, you know, and, and you know, we focus on tax policy, Ed.
- 17:16Which is, you know, we, we look at some other things, but we
- 17:20focus primarily on tax policy.
- 17:22And, and that is different than just about everything else because of the
- 17:26special congressional rule, um, or the senate rule on reconciliation, right?
- 17:30You can do things with a simple majority in the Senate for taxes
- 17:33that you can't do for, for just about all other types of major issues.
- 17:38And so that just means that there's more likely to be changes here.
- 17:41But hey, it's, it's more fodder, it's more, uh, it, it's more topics
- 17:47for a potential or not a potential, but it's more topics for season
- 17:50two of the great retirement debate.
- 17:52And you know, as we've talked, Ed, we, we've got a couple of
- 17:55surprises . Up our sleeves here.
- 17:56We won't, uh, we won't reveal them yet.
- 17:58You'll have to tune in.
- 17:59This'll, this'll be our big cliffhanger, Ed.
- 18:02Yep.
- 18:02I mean that I, you could see, I, I, I feel that people are sitting
- 18:05on the edges of their seats.
- 18:07Uh, I think as you mentioned before, we, we got on and started recording , Ed, this
- 18:10will be our, our big who Shot JR moment.
- 18:13Like what will they do for season two?
- 18:16Same, same level of interest i, I'm sure.
- 18:18Ed Slott: And Jeff, how would you even know who shot JR?
- 18:22How old were you even alive then?
- 18:26Jeffrey Levine: I, uh, Nick at night when I, I think that might be the answer.
- 18:30You know, when they, when they show the oldies or something like that?
- 18:33Ed Slott: Yeah.
- 18:33But the bottom line is, the reason we're doing this is this, most of
- 18:37people's savings, that's called the Great Retirement Debate.
- 18:40Most of people's savings are sitting in tax deferred accounts, IRAs.
- 18:45401ks and taxes will be the single biggest factor that will eventually
- 18:49separate you from your, uh, from a decent retirement or not.
- 18:53You know, the decisions you make will be the determining factor of how much
- 18:58of your saved retirement funds you get to keep and how much goes to Uncle Sam.
- 19:03So hopefully these programs help you have more, keep more, and pass more
- 19:08on of your hard-earned money, you can only keep when it comes to retirement
- 19:12savings, what you can keep after taxes.
- 19:15Every dollar you save in taxes is another dollar in your bank account.
- 19:19You can save a fortune over a good lifetime of planning in
- 19:23taxes, and that will make a difference in your life and beyond.
- 19:27So that's what we hope to continue in our next season.
- 19:31Jeffrey Levine: Yeah, and, and it bears reminding.
- 19:33You know, while, while we didn't necessarily have a debate today, one
- 19:37thing that regardless of our, our different or same viewpoints that we
- 19:41always agree on, is the fact that whenever you have a big financial decision, like
- 19:46any of these, any of these questions that we discussed this season, whether
- 19:50it's should I name a trust as my beneficiary when to take Social security,
- 19:54have a Roth or not, should I downsize.
- 19:56It's best to talk through these . Decisions with a independent tax or
- 20:02financial advisor so that you can understand both sides of the issue.
- 20:06Understand the pluses and the minuses, the benefits, the drawbacks,
- 20:10the advantages, the disadvantages.
- 20:11Insert your words of choice here, but to understand what it means for
- 20:15you and your family, and that is something we continue to agree on.
- 20:21We hope that we can continue to bring you more valuable information
- 20:25and insights in season two.
- 20:27And, uh, Ed, you know, when we, when we set out to start this, I thought
- 20:31we'd have a lot of fun doing it and, uh, and, and I, I won't speak
- 20:35for you, but I will just say I did.
- 20:37I had a lot of fun this season and I can't wait for season two.
- 20:40Ed Slott: Me too.
- 20:41So onward and upward.
- 20:43Jeffrey Levine: We'll see you next season on The Great Retirement Debate.
- 20:46Outro: Jeffrey Levine is Chief Planning Officer for Buckingham Wealth Partners.
- 20:49This podcast is for informational and educational purposes only, and should
- 20:53not be construed as specific investment accounting, legal or tax advice.
- 20:56Certain information mentioned may be based on third party information,
- 20:59which may become outdated or otherwise superseded without notice.
- 21:02Third party information is deemed to be reliable, but it's accuracy and
- 21:05completeness cannot be guaranteed.
- 21:07The topic discussed in corresponding arguments are those of the speakers
- 21:10and may not accurately reflect those of Buckingham Wealth partners.