Latest / Vertical SaaS with Fexingo: Industry-Specific Software for Healthcare, Construction, Legal / How Vertical SaaS Is Automating Independent Insurance Adjusting
Transcript
- Lucas: So I was talking to an independent insurance adjuster last week — guy named Derek, been doing it for fifteen years. He drove from Houston to Fort Myers two days after Hurricane Ian in twenty-two, spent three weeks living out of a hotel, inspecting damage on a hundred and forty homes. Luna: That's the freelance life most people don't see. No salary, no benefits, just per-claim fees and a lot of windshield time. Lucas: Exactly. And Derek told me something that stuck: his entire workflow still runs on a piece of software called Xactimate that was designed in the late nineteen-nineties. It's basically a glorified calculator with a drawing tool. He sketches the floor plan by hand, codes each line item from memory, and then types in the dollar amounts. Luna: Wait — in twenty-twenty-six, a guy who inspects a hundred and forty homes after a hurricane is doing line-item data entry like it's nineteen ninety-nine? Lucas: That's the vertical SaaS story right there. The independent adjusting industry is enormous — there are roughly forty thousand independent adjusters in the US, and they handle the majority of catastrophe claims for carriers like State Farm, Allstate, and Farmers. But the software ecosystem has been incredibly slow to evolve, because the incumbents had a lock on the workflow. Luna: So who are the incumbents, and what's finally changing? Lucas: The dominant player is Verisk, which owns Xactware — that's the company behind Xactimate and XactAnalysis, the platform carriers use to receive and review estimates. Verisk has been in this space since the eighties. They have network effects: every carrier requires adjusters to submit estimates in Xactimate format, so every adjuster has to use it. It's the Microsoft Word of claims. Luna: That's a tough moat to crack. But I've seen a few startups trying, especially on the photo and estimation side. Lucas: Yeah, and the most interesting one is Tractable. They're a uk based company that uses computer vision to assess property damage from photos. You take twenty pictures of a roof, upload them, and their AI identifies the damaged shingles, measures the square footage, and generates a materials list. No manual sketching, no line-item hunting. Luna: I've heard they're also doing it for auto claims. But property is a harder problem because every roof is different — different pitch, different angles, different wear patterns. Lucas: It is harder, and their accuracy still isn't perfect. In a 2025 benchmark, Tractable's AI matched human adjusters on about seventy percent of straightforward claims — single-family homes with wind or hail damage. But on complex claims with multiple perils, like fire plus water damage, the error rate jumped. So they position themselves as a co-pilot, not a replacement. Luna: That's smart. Because the adjuster's real value is in judgement — deciding whether that dent came from hail or from a dropped tool, or spotting pre-existing wear that the carrier shouldn't cover. Lucas: Right. And Derek confirmed that. He said the AI estimates are good for the easy stuff, but he still has to walk the roof, take his own photos, and override about twenty percent of the line items. The time savings come from not having to type out the estimate from scratch. He told me it cut his per-claim paperwork from ninety minutes to about forty-five. Luna: That's a fifty percent reduction. For an adjuster who does a hundred claims a season, that's an extra seventy-five hours. That's real money. Lucas: It is. But here's the catch: Tractable doesn't integrate natively with Xactimate. So the adjuster has to export the AI estimate as a PDF, then manually re-enter the line items into Xactimate because the carrier won't accept a Tractable file. That friction kills adoption. Luna: So the moat isn't just about habit — it's about the carrier's requirement. If State Farm says 'we only accept Xactimate XML files', then no matter how good the AI is, the adjuster still has to use the old tool at the final step. Lucas: Exactly. And that's why the real opportunity isn't in replacing Xactimate — it's in building a layer that sits on top of it, automating the input side. A few startups are trying that. One is Claim Genius, which does photo-based damage detection and then auto-populates a Xactimate-compatible estimate. Another is Tractor — yes, spelled like the farm vehicle — which focuses on inside water damage, using thermal imaging from a smartphone camera to map moisture behind walls. Luna: Thermal imaging on a phone? That's a specific vertical play. Water damage is one of the most common claims, but it's also one where adjusters waste a lot of time drying out walls that aren't actually wet. Lucas: Right. Tractor's software uses the phone's infrared sensor — some Android phones have them, and there's a FLIR attachment for iPhones — to create a heat map. It then generates a drying diagram and a scope of work. That's something that would have taken an adjuster an hour with a moisture meter and a notepad. Luna: I want to hear more about how these tools price. Are they per-claim, subscription, or what? Lucas: Most are per-claim, because that matches the adjuster's income model. Tractable charges between ten and twenty dollars per estimate, depending on volume. Claim Genius is similar. Tractor is about fifteen per inspection. For an adjuster who does, say, five hundred claims a year, that's seven to ten thousand dollars in software costs. If the tool saves them two hours per claim at a billing rate of fifty dollars an hour, that's fifty thousand dollars in saved time. The math works. Luna: But only if they actually use it. And you mentioned adoption lags. What's the biggest barrier — besides the Xactimate integration issue? Lucas: Trust. Independent adjusters are a skeptical bunch. They've seen software vendors promise the moon before. In the early two-thousands, there was a wave of 'paperless adjusting' tools that were clunky and slow. Many burned money and went under. So there's a deep memory of that. Also, these are people who work alone, often in remote areas after a disaster. They don't have an IT department to call. If the software crashes during a fifteen-hour workday, they can't afford that downtime. Luna: So reliability is non-negotiable. That's why Xactimate survives — it's ugly, but it never crashes. Lucas: Exactly. And the carriers aren't exactly pushing for change either. They don't pay for the adjuster's software — the adjuster does. So the carrier gets the efficiency gain without the cost. There's no incentive for them to force a migration. The only pressure comes from the adjusters themselves, and only the most tech-savvy ones are making the switch. Luna: That reminds me of a stat I saw from a 2025 survey by the Society of Insurance Research: only about twelve percent of independent adjusters use any kind of ai assisted estimation tool. The rest are still doing it the old way. Lucas: That twelve percent is the early adopter wedge. And those are the adjusters who get claims done faster, which means they can take on more work during catastrophe season. In a bad hurricane year, a fast adjuster can double their income. The ROI is clear, but the behavioral shift is slow. Luna: And catastrophe season is exactly when you'd want these tools most. I mean, after a major hurricane, there's a surge of claims and every adjuster is maxed out. Any efficiency gain is pure profit. Lucas: Yeah, and that's actually the hook for the startups. They market heavily before hurricane season — May and June — with webinars and free trials. They know that if an adjuster uses the tool on one big storm and it works, they're likely to keep using it. The stickiness comes from a single positive experience under pressure. Luna: So the product-market fit is tied to weather cycles. That's wild. You can't accelerate adoption; you have to wait for the next hurricane. Lucas: That's the reality. And it's why I think the real disruption won't come from a single AI tool. It'll come from the carriers themselves, eventually. If one major carrier — say, Allstate — tells its network of adjusters that it will now accept estimates in a new format, the entire ecosystem shifts overnight. But that hasn't happened yet, because the cost of switching for the carrier is also high: they'd have to retrain their internal reviewers and update their claims management systems. Luna: So we're in a classic innovator's dilemma. Verisk has the locked-in network, and the startups are nibbling around the edges. But the edges are getting bigger. Lucas: They are. And one thing that could accelerate it is the generational shift. Younger adjusters — people in their late twenties, early thirties — grew up with apps and expect software to be intuitive. They look at Xactimate and think, 'I can't believe I have to use this.' That cohort is growing, and they're the ones picking up the AI tools. Luna: It's funny — we talk about vertical SaaS in so many industries, from funeral homes to pet care. But insurance adjusting feels like one of the last holdouts. It's so analog, so paper-based, even though the stakes are high and the volume is enormous. Lucas: It is. And honestly, recording these episodes, I keep coming back to the same realization: the verticals that are hardest to digitize are the ones where the workers are most independent. There's no boss mandating software adoption. The decision is a personal one, based on trust and trial. And that means the software has to be genuinely good — not just good enough. Luna: That's a high bar. But when it works, the impact is real. Derek told you he saved seventy-five hours a season. That's time he can spend with his family, or take on more claims and make more money. Lucas: Yeah, and that's the part that keeps me interested. These tools aren't about replacing the adjuster — they're about letting the adjuster do more of the work that actually requires human judgment, and less of the data entry. It's a better job, not a different job. Luna: And that's a message that resonates. By the way, speaking of things that resonate — you know, a small group of listeners help keep this show going through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's how we can keep making these deep dives without ads or sponsors. Lucas: Yeah, it's genuinely appreciated. It lets us spend the time to talk to people like Derek and really understand an industry. So thanks to those who chip in. And if you find these episodes useful for what you're building or running, that's the place to find us. Luna: Alright, back to adjusting. Lucas, you mentioned that some startups are also tackling the supply chain side — ordering materials directly from the estimate. Is that a thing? Lucas: It is. There's a company called Buildertrend — well, they're more construction project management — but in the adjusting space, a startup called Roofr is integrating with Tractable to let adjusters order roofing materials directly from the estimate. So the AI estimates the damage, generates the materials list, and then Roofr sends the order to a local supplier. The adjuster just approves it. Luna: That closes the loop. From inspection to estimate to materials order, all in one workflow. That's the kind of integration that could really stick. Lucas: Exactly. And once you have that data flowing, you can start doing predictive things — like which suppliers have inventory after a storm, or which crews are available. The real value is in the network, not just the estimation. Luna: So the future might not be a single killer app, but a platform that connects adjusters, carriers, suppliers, and contractors. A kind of operating system for the claim. Lucas: That's the vision. And there's a company trying to build exactly that: it's called ClaimPort, and it's essentially an API layer that lets different tools talk to each other. They integrate with Xactimate, Tractable, Roofr, and a dozen others. They're not trying to replace anything — they're the glue. Luna: That might be the smartest play of all. Don't fight the network, join it. Lucas: Yeah. And that's where I think the vertical SaaS story in adjusting is heading. Not a revolution, but a quiet integration. Piece by piece, the analog workflow gets automated from the edges inward. Luna: And maybe one day, Derek won't have to sketch a floor plan by hand. He'll just walk a room with his phone and the estimate appears. Lucas: That day is probably closer than we think. Maybe not next hurricane season, but the one after that.