Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / Silent Power: The Audi A6 Avant e-tron Review
Transcript
- 0:10OK, let's unpack this. I want you to just picture the
- 0:12current car market for a second. What do you see?
- 0:16I'm betting it's a sea of massive bulky SU VS crossovers
- 0:22on every corner in a blocking your view at junctions.
- 0:25It feels like the world has just collectively decided that
- 0:28bigger, taller and heavier automatically means better.
- 0:31It certainly feels that way. I mean, the dominance of the SUV
- 0:34has been the defining trend of the last decade.
- 0:37Really, it's almost the default choice.
- 0:38Exactly. But then along comes this, the
- 0:412026 Audi A6 Avant E Tron. It's low, it's sleek, it's
- 0:45aerodynamic, it's an estate car or a station wagon.
- 0:48And honestly, it feels like a breath of fresh air.
- 0:50It's the anti SUV. And today we are going in a deep
- 0:54dive to figure out if this is just, you know, a nostalgia trip
- 0:56for wagon lovers or if this is actually the best electric
- 0:58vehicle on the market. It is a fascinating pivot and to
- 1:01answer that question, we've got a really interesting stack of
- 1:03sources. We're pulling from a detailed
- 1:05Rd. Test in the Scottish Highlands
- 1:07from the Courier. Some pretty rigorous technical
- 1:09breakdowns from totally EV and then comparative data from Cinch
- 1:13putting it up against the big guns.
- 1:14Porsche, BMW. So we've got the romance of the
- 1:17Highlands and the cold hard facts of the spec sheet.
- 1:20I love that mix. It's the best way to get the
- 1:22full picture and well, straight off the bat the vibe is
- 1:25interesting. You look at recent BMWs and they
- 1:27can be a bit shouty. Totally.
- 1:30Look at me this Audi though. It's got this kind of low key
- 1:34elegance. It's stylish, but it isn't
- 1:37trying too hard. It feels confident.
- 1:39That confidence comes from what's underneath.
- 1:42This isn't just an old A6 with a battery shoved in the trunk.
- 1:45It's built on what they call the PPE, the Premium Platform
- 1:49Electric. Right.
- 1:50The PPE, we see that acronym a lot.
- 1:53Why does that actually matter to the person holding the steering
- 1:55wheel? It matters because of the DNA.
- 1:57This platform was Co developed with Porsche.
- 2:00It's the same architecture under the new electric Porsche Macon,
- 2:03the Audi Q6E Tron. It dictates the entire packaging
- 2:06of the car, where the wheels sit, how low the center of
- 2:09gravity is, and crucially the electrical architecture.
- 2:12It means this car was born electric, not adapted to be
- 2:15electric. So it's got Porsche cousins.
- 2:17That's a good start, but let's get to the number everyone cares
- 2:20about range, because on paper this thing sounds like a
- 2:24marathon runner. It does.
- 2:26Let's just look at the claims. The entry level models have an
- 2:2983 kWh battery which is already substantial, but the ones
- 2:33getting all the attention, the performance and Quattro models
- 2:36are packing a massive 100 kWh battery.
- 2:40That is a huge battery. Just for context, that's
- 2:42significantly larger than what you'd find in most standard EVs
- 2:45today. It is a massive slab of energy
- 2:48and that allows Audi to claim some, well, very impressive WLTP
- 2:52figures. Depending on the trim, they're
- 2:54quoting anywhere from 430 7 miles up to maybe 463 miles on a
- 3:00single charge. That's the kind of number that
- 3:02supposedly cures range anxiety forever.
- 3:04Supposedly is the word, because here's where it gets really
- 3:07interesting. One of our sources, Jack Mccune
- 3:09from The Courier, actually took the launch edition, which claims
- 3:12402 miles, and drove it around the Scottish Highlands for a
- 3:15week. Real roads, real weather.
- 3:18And this is where we get the reality check.
- 3:19So what did the real world have to say?
- 3:21It's at 300 miles. The classic reality check, Yeah.
- 3:26He said over a week of driving around Perthshire, Fife, Dundee,
- 3:30he managed about 300 miles on a full charge.
- 3:34Now he did admit he was playing with the performance bit Which?
- 3:37Let's be honest, you're going to do in a powerful new Audi.
- 3:39Of course, he reckoned judicious driving.
- 3:43You know, staying in efficiency mode could add maybe 20 or 30
- 3:45miles, but we're still looking at 100 mile gap between the
- 3:49brochure and the tarmac. That feels like a big haircut.
- 3:52It sounds significant and yes it is a let down if you were
- 3:55banking on 400. However, 300 miles of real world
- 3:59range is actually excellent. Think about it, that's London
- 4:02and Newcastle comfortably. The reviewer even noted he
- 4:05didn't need to charge for a full week of normal use.
- 4:08He only plugged it in the night before giving it back.
- 4:10That's a fairpoint. If you can go a whole week
- 4:12without even thinking about a plug, does the specific number
- 4:15matter as much? The real question is can I get
- 4:17through my week? And the answer seems to be yes.
- 4:20Precisely. And Speaking of plugs, this is
- 4:22where that PPE platform and the Porsche influence really shines.
- 4:26This car uses an 800 Volt architecture which lets it
- 4:30charge at a peak of 270 kilowatts.
- 4:32Which? Goes it means the bathroom brake
- 4:35charge is a reality. You can go from 10% to 80%
- 4:38battery in just 21 minutes. Wow.
- 4:41Find powerful enough charger and you're adding 180 miles of range
- 4:45in 10 minutes. That is fast.
- 4:47That's grab a coffee and a sandwich fast.
- 4:50It changes how you think about Rd. trips.
- 4:52It does, but there is a quirky feature here I have to mention
- 4:56about the charging ports. Oh, I read about this.
- 4:58It has two, right? Yes.
- 4:59Dual ports. You have an AC/DC port on one
- 5:01side and just an AC port on the other.
- 5:03It's incredibly convenient because you don't have to worry
- 5:05about which side of the charger you park.
- 5:06On that sounds brilliant. A big practicality win.
- 5:08Ideally, yes, but the execution, they are covered by these huge
- 5:13electronic motorized flaps. Oh no, motorized you?
- 5:17Push the logo and this door just slowly slides down
- 5:21electronically. I can already feel the
- 5:23frustration. It's pouring with rain.
- 5:25You're in a hurry and you're waiting for a little robot door
- 5:27to slowly reveal the plug. And from an engineering
- 5:30standpoint, it's just another thing to brake.
- 5:33What happens in five years when the motor burns out?
- 5:35A simple manual flap would have been faster and more reliable.
- 5:39It's a classic case of over engineering something just to
- 5:42signal luxury. Classic luxury car move OK, so
- 5:45the range is solid, charging is lightning fast.
- 5:48But it's an Audi, it's got to drive well.
- 5:51How does it feel? Well, the comparison that keeps
- 5:53coming up is Tesla. If you've driven a Model S, you
- 5:56know that feeling. It's savage.
- 5:58It snaps your neck. Back.
- 5:59Yeah, it's like being launched from a cannon.
- 6:01Great for showing off, terrible for your stomach.
- 6:03Exactly. The A6 E Tron isn't doing that.
- 6:06It's fast. The S6 model does zero to 62 in
- 6:093.9 seconds, but the delivery is described as smooth.
- 6:14It's composed, it builds speed. It doesn't just explode forward.
- 6:17One reviewer called it quiet as a library.
- 6:20Even at 70 mph, that acoustic glazing must be doing some heavy
- 6:24lifting. It is.
- 6:25It's all about refinement. It's a mile muncher.
- 6:28But this brings us to a bit of a controversy the suspension.
- 6:32Uh oh. What's the issue?
- 6:33So in the UK the standard models, even the ones costing
- 6:36upwards of £65,000, come with steel dynamic suspension, just
- 6:41standard springs. Steel springs on a car that can
- 6:44push. Six figures precisely.
- 6:45Now you compare that to its main rival, the BMW I5 Touring.
- 6:50The BMW comes with air suspension on the rear axle as
- 6:53standard. That seems like a big miss for
- 6:55Audi. Why does that matter to the
- 6:56driver? Air suspension gives you that
- 6:58wafting quality, it levels the car out and it just absorbs Rd.
- 7:02imperfections so much better. The expert from Total EV really
- 7:06pointed this out. The Audi handles potholes well
- 7:08enough, but for this price you expect that magic carpet ride.
- 7:11You can get it on the Super expensive S6, but for most
- 7:13buyers you might feel a little shortchanged compared to the
- 7:16BMW. That's a tough sell.
- 7:18Pay US 80 grand and we'll give you springs.
- 7:20But I did see one feature that got a lot of love, the one pedal
- 7:24driving. Yes, this is something they've
- 7:27nailed. It's fully customizable, but it
- 7:30has a true one pedal mode that brings the car to a complete
- 7:33stop. There's a godsend in the city.
- 7:35You just lift off and the car stops.
- 7:38No juggling pedals in traffic. It's seamless.
- 7:41It shows that while they might have missed on the suspension
- 7:43spec, the actual drivetrain calibration is top tier.
- 7:47OK, let's hop inside, because if you're spending all this time in
- 7:49a library quiet car, the interior better be nice.
- 7:53And wow, there are a lot of screens in here.
- 7:55It is a digital utopia or a nightmare depending on your
- 7:59view. You have the 14.5 inch central
- 8:02touchscreen, the 11.9 inch driver display, and then the
- 8:06passenger screen. The passenger screen.
- 8:07Talk to me about this. Is this useful or just a gimmick
- 8:11to add a few £100 to the price? It lets the passenger watch
- 8:14videos or change music, and it has a privacy filter so it
- 8:17doesn't distract the driver. But in practice it's often just
- 8:20considered a gimmick. Most passengers are just looking
- 8:22at their phones anyway. It feels like tech for tech's
- 8:24sake, but there is one piece of tech that isn't a gimmick,
- 8:28right? The augmented reality head up
- 8:30display. This is fascinating.
- 8:32Most Huds just project a flat image.
- 8:35This system projects navigation arrows that look like they're on
- 8:38the road ahead of you. So you don't see an arrow on
- 8:41your screen, you see it hovering over the actual turn you need to
- 8:44take. That's some Iron Man stuff.
- 8:46It is. One reviewer called it a work of
- 8:48art. It genuinely reduces cognitive
- 8:50load because you're just, you're looking at the road.
- 8:53I love that. But, and there's always a but, I
- 8:56keep reading about an Ouch moment with the materials.
- 8:58This is the contradiction. You have this incredible AR
- 9:02tech, lovely leather seats, and then you reach down to the lower
- 9:06center console or the door frames.
- 9:08Hard, harsh plastics. In a car approaching 100,000
- 9:11lbs. It's unacceptable.
- 9:13Frankly. The totally EV review was pretty
- 9:15scathing about this. You expect that tactile quality
- 9:18everywhere in a premium Audi. To find scratchy plastic and
- 9:22high touch areas is just. It's a real disappointment.
- 9:25It feels like they spent the budget on the screens and forgot
- 9:27the door bins. It breaks the illusion.
- 9:29Speaking of which, we have to talk about the roof.
- 9:31The panoramic glass roof. Yeah, the one that switches from
- 9:34transparent to opaque. That is a very cool party trick.
- 9:37It is. It uses polymer dispersed liquid
- 9:40crystal tech. It eliminates the need for a
- 9:43physical roller blind, which saves headroom and weight.
- 9:47That's clever. Very clever, but let's get to
- 9:49the most controversial feature, the mirrors, or the lack of
- 9:54them. The virtual exterior mirrors.
- 9:57This is a debate that divides everyone.
- 9:59So for anyone listening who hasn't seen this, instead of
- 10:02mirrors, you have little cameras on stocks and inside there are
- 10:05screens on the door pillars showing you what's behind,
- 10:08correct? Why?
- 10:09I mean, why reinvent the mirror? It's a piece of glass.
- 10:12It's worked for 100 years. Two reasons, aerodynamics and
- 10:15aesthetics. Audi claims these little cameras
- 10:18improve airflow enough to add about 7.4 miles of range. 7
- 10:22miles, is that it? Is that worth it?
- 10:24That is the question. The downside is significant.
- 10:27The reviewers found that depth perception is off because it's a
- 10:302D screen. Everything looks closer than it
- 10:32is and you have to retrain your brain.
- 10:34You look outside for the mirror, but you have to look down at the
- 10:36door panel instead. And I just keep thinking about
- 10:38the cost. Clipping A cyclist or a garage
- 10:41door, a normal mirror? Annoying a high tech camera
- 10:46stock that sounds like a mortgage payment to replace.
- 10:48It's a valid fear. 1 reviewer explicitly said.
- 10:51I'd hate to think how much they cost to replace it feels like a
- 10:55cool talking point maybe, but is it safer or easier?
- 10:59The consensus seems to be no. Yeah, give me glass, mirrors and
- 11:02seven miles less range any day of the week.
- 11:05OK, so it's a tech heavy, smooth cruiser, but it's an Avant and a
- 11:10state. It has to carry stuff.
- 11:11Does it pass the IKEA test? Well this is where the anti SUV
- 11:14narrative hits is a bit of a snag.
- 11:16The boot space is 502 liters. Is that good?
- 11:19It's OK but you compare it to the BMW I5 touring which has 570
- 11:23liters or the VWID .7 at six O 5 and the Audi is lagging behind.
- 11:27That's a big difference. 100 liters is a couple suitcases.
- 11:30Exactly. The sleek styling cuts into the
- 11:32cargo room. Now if you fold the seats flat,
- 11:34you get over 1400 liters, which is plenty.
- 11:37And it does have a front a front trunk of 27 liters, which is
- 11:40perfect for storing muddy charging cables.
- 11:41A frunk is always a win, but what about the people in the
- 11:44back? Lick room is actually quite
- 11:46generous, but there is a vertical issue.
- 11:49A vertical issue. The high floor problem because
- 11:52that massive battery is a slab under the car, the floor is
- 11:56higher than in a gas car. But the roof is low because it's
- 12:00a sleek wagon. Exactly, so the seed bench stays
- 12:03low to keep headroom. The result?
- 12:06Your knees are pushed up higher than your hips.
- 12:08You lack under thigh support. So it feels like you're sitting
- 12:11on a tiny chair in a kindergarten classroom.
- 12:13A little bit, yeah. For taller passengers on a long
- 12:16trip, it can feel like a squeeze, even though the car is
- 12:18so big. It's a common EV problem, but
- 12:21it's noticeable here. That's a shame, but hey, if you
- 12:24can't fit everything in the boot, you can tow it, right?
- 12:26You can, and this is a redemption point.
- 12:28It can tow up to 2100 kilograms. That is surprisingly capable for
- 12:33an electric estate that's. A proper caravan or a horse box.
- 12:36It puts it right back in the running as a practical family
- 12:39hauler, provided you aren't relying just on the boot space.
- 12:42So what does this all mean? We started by asking if this is
- 12:45the best or just a nostalgia trip.
- 12:48I think the verdict is nuanced. The Audi ASICS of on E Tron is
- 12:53undeniably one of the most aerodynamic, stylish and
- 12:57technologically advanced estates ever made.
- 12:59It's a true mile muncher. If you do long highway miles,
- 13:03that's silence. That 300 plus mile real world
- 13:06range and that fast charging make it brilliant.
- 13:09But there are trade-offs. You're paying a premium price
- 13:12for slightly less practicality. The boot is smaller than the
- 13:15BMW's. The plastics are worse than
- 13:17you'd expect. The suspension isn't as
- 13:19sophisticated as it should be. So it's a hard overhead car.
- 13:21You buy it because it looks incredible, not because it's the
- 13:24utilitarian champion. Precisely.
- 13:26It is a flawed beauty. You know, this brings up
- 13:28something I've been thinking about.
- 13:30As we move to this all electric future, are we seeing a shift in
- 13:33what utility actually means? Well, manufacturers are so
- 13:38obsessed with range hitting that magic 400 mile number that
- 13:41they're stuffing these massive batteries in.
- 13:43But to do that, they're raising the floors, compromising rear
- 13:46comfort and sacrificing boot space for aerodynamics.
- 13:49Are we slowly losing the utility and our utility vehicles just to
- 13:54win a game of top Trump's on the spec sheet?
- 13:56That is a profound question. If an estate car can't
- 13:59comfortably haul for adults and their luggage because the
- 14:03battery needs to be huge, have we kind of lost the plot?
- 14:07It's certainly something to watch as battery tech evolves.
- 14:11Maybe density improvements will give us our leg room back.
- 14:14Let's hope so, because I'd like to keep my knees below my
- 14:17waistline, thank you very much. Agreed.
- 14:19Listen, we really appreciate you spending your time with us
- 14:21today, whether you're commuting, working out, or just hiding from
- 14:25your own kids for a bit. Thank you for letting us be part
- 14:28of your day. This show only exists because of
- 14:31your curiosity. Absolutely.
- 14:33Thank you so much for listening. Do yourself a favor, Google
- 14:36those Audi virtual mirrors and ask yourself if you trust them
- 14:39to parallel park, and then join us next time for another deep
- 14:42dive.