Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Always Volunteers for Extra Work
Transcript
- Lucas: You know that direct report who raises their hand for every assignment, every stretch project, every 'does anyone have bandwidth for this' email within about thirty seconds? Luna: I was literally just thinking of someone I managed a few years ago. It starts off feeling like a godsend. Lucas: Exactly. For a first-time manager especially, that person is your comfort blanket. You're thinking, 'Finally, one person I don't have to chase.' But there's a real risk underneath that enthusiasm. Luna: Which is what — that they burn out and then you've lost your best player? Or that they start delivering lower quality because they're stretched thin? Lucas: Both, plus a third one that I think is less obvious: if you keep handing them everything, you never build capacity in the rest of the team. You end up with a single point of failure. So the question for today is: how do you manage the person who always volunteers without killing their motivation? Luna: Right, because you don't want to punish initiative. That's the trap a lot of managers fall into — they clamp down, and suddenly the employee stops raising their hand at all. Lucas: Exactly. You want to redirect, not discourage. I think the most practical tool here is what I call a capacity audit. It's a structured conversation where you and the employee look at everything on their plate — not just the tasks, but the energy each one takes. Luna: So it's more than just a to-do list review. Lucas: Way more. The classic mistake is a manager says, 'Hey, you've taken on four projects this quarter. Let's figure out which two you drop.' That's still a top-down fix. A capacity audit is collaborative. You ask the employee to rate each commitment on two axes: impact and personal energy cost. Luna: So they self-diagnose which activities drain them versus which energize them. Lucas: Exactly. And that's where the coaching lives. I had a case a couple of years ago — a marketing coordinator, very early in her career, who was saying yes to everything. She was on the social media team, but she'd volunteered to help with the annual report, the sales kickoff deck, a product launch event. She was working until nine regularly. Luna: And she probably thought that was the path to promotion. Lucas: She did. And to be fair, her manager — my peer — was encouraging it because the output was good. But when we did the capacity audit, she realized that the sales kickoff deck, the one that looked great on paper, was the thing that drained her the most. It was all logistics and formatting. Zero creative input. Luna: So the solution wasn't 'take things away from her.' It was 'give her better things to say yes to.' Lucas: Bingo. She stayed on the annual report and the product launch, dropped the sales deck, and within six months she was leading the social strategy. Her energy went up, her quality went up, and the team stopped being dependent on her for every random request. Luna: But what about the manager who doesn't have a peer like you to run that process? What's the actual script for the capacity audit conversation? Lucas: I'd frame it around three questions. First: 'Of everything you're working on right now, what are the two things where you feel you make the biggest impact?' Second: 'What are the two things that leave you feeling the most drained at the end of the day?' Third: 'If we could redesign your workload for maximum impact and energy, what would you add, drop, or shift?' Luna: And you ask those in a one-on-one, not an email. Lucas: Absolutely. In person or on video. You want to see their face. And you want to give them permission to be honest. A lot of employees who volunteer for everything have a fear of being seen as not a team player. So you as the manager have to explicitly say, 'I'm not asking you to do less because I think you're slacking. I'm asking because I want you to do your best work, and that means being strategic about what you take on.' Luna: That's good. It reframes the whole thing from constraint to strategy. Speaking of things that help people do their best work — and I don't want to derail us too much here — but it occurs to me that tools like this podcast itself are part of that support system for a lot of managers out there. Lucas: Yeah, that's a good point. We hear from listeners pretty regularly who say these episodes have helped them handle a specific conversation or reframe a problem. Luna: And if this show has helped you think through a career move or a management challenge, a couple of dollars a month is genuinely what keeps these going — buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo, if you've gotten something out of them. Lucas: It really does make a difference. And we mean it — small amounts add up. Okay, back to the over-volunteer. So you've done the capacity audit, you've identified the drainers. Now what? Luna: Now you have to actually protect that employee's time from the rest of the organization. Because the moment you say 'Sarah is dropping the sales deck,' three other people will ask her for help. Lucas: This is the part most managers skip. They have the coaching conversation, the employee feels great, and then on Monday the VP of sales emails Sarah directly saying, 'Can you pull some data for my presentation?' And Sarah says yes because she hasn't unlearned the reflex. Luna: So you need a system. What do you recommend? Lucas: I tell managers to give the employee a 'standard response' they can use. Something like: 'I'd love to help, but I'm at capacity on my core projects right now. Let me check with my manager and get back to you.' That buys them time and creates a circuit-breaker. Luna: And then the manager can triage. Maybe that VP request is actually important, and you do need to shuffle priorities. But at least it's a conscious decision, not a reflex. Lucas: Right. And the other piece is: you as the manager have to be willing to say no on their behalf when the request doesn't align. That's hard for first-time managers who want to be seen as helpful. But protecting your star player's energy is part of your job. Luna: Let me push back on something. What if the employee genuinely enjoys all the extra work? They're not burning out, their quality is fine, and they just like being busy. Is there still a problem? Lucas: I think so, yes. Because the risk isn't just burnout — it's single point of failure. If that employee wins the lottery and quits, you have a knowledge vacuum. So even if they're thriving, you should still be asking, 'Who else on the team could learn to do some of this?' That's a development opportunity for everyone else. Luna: So you're using the over-volunteer as a lever to build team capability. I like that. Lucas: Exactly. You say to the employee, 'Hey, you're really good at X. I'd like you to mentor Jenna on that so she can handle some of the requests. That frees you up for the higher-impact stuff.' Most high-achievers actually appreciate that framing because it positions them as a leader. Luna: And it solves the capacity problem without taking anything away from them. It's a promotion in responsibility, not just workload. Lucas: Exactly. And that's the real win. You keep the enthusiasm alive, you build the team, and you avoid waking up one day to find your best person has a resignation letter drafted because they realized they were doing everyone else's job. Luna: I wish I'd known this four years ago. I had a designer who took on every request because she loved the variety. I thought I was being supportive by letting her. Then she left, and we had no documentation, no backup, and the whole design process ground to a halt for weeks. Lucas: That's exactly the scenario I'm talking about. The cost of not managing the over-volunteer is invisible until it's too late. So the takeaway I'd leave managers with is: treat your enthusiastic yes-person as a resource you're building for the long term, not a fire extinguisher you use every day. Luna: And start with that capacity audit. Three questions, one conversation. It's a small time investment that can save you a huge headache. Lucas: Exactly. And if you try it, let us know how it goes. We read every note that comes in through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. Even just hearing what worked helps us shape future episodes. Luna: Alright, next week we're going to talk about something that came up a lot in listener questions: how to manage someone who is clearly disengaged but not performing badly enough to fire. That's a tricky one. Lucas: It really is. The 'quiet quitter' label gets thrown around, but the reality is more nuanced. We'll dig into it. For now, thanks for spending part of your Monday with us.