Latest / Bloomberg Law / Supreme Court Rejects Controversial Election Theory
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 1: It was one of the most watched and feared cases
- 0:12Speaker 1: of the Supreme Court term, advancing a sweeping Republican backed
- 0:16Speaker 1: effort to outstate judges from their long standing roles in
- 0:20Speaker 1: federal elections. But in a six to three decision, the
- 0:24Speaker 1: Supreme Court rejected the novel theory that would have given
- 0:27Speaker 1: state legislatures virtually unchecked power to make rules for congressional
- 0:32Speaker 1: and presidential elections, essentially without any oversight. Just as Elena
- 0:37Speaker 1: Kagan had warned about the consequences during the oral arguments.
- 0:41Speaker 2: It would say that legislatures could enact all manner of
- 0:46Speaker 2: restrictions on voting, get rid of all kinds of voter
- 0:50Speaker 2: protections that the state constitution in fact prohibits. It might
- 0:55Speaker 2: allow the legislators to insert themselves to give themselves a
- 0:59Speaker 2: role in the certification of elections.
- 1:02Speaker 1: And even some of the conservative justices expressed concerns about
- 1:07Speaker 1: the so called independent state legislature theory, with Justice Brett
- 1:11Speaker 1: Kavanaugh saying Republican arguments went beyond what three conservative justices
- 1:17Speaker 1: had laid out in a concurring opinion in the Bush v.
- 1:20Speaker 1: Gore case when they said that the Florida Supreme Court
- 1:23Speaker 1: had overstepped its authority by ordering ballot recounts.
- 1:28Speaker 3: Your position seems to go further than Chief Justice Ranquist
- 1:31Speaker 3: position in Bush fe. Gore, where he seemed to acknowledge
- 1:34Speaker 3: that state courts would have a role interpreting state law.
- 1:39Speaker 1: Joining me is an elections law expert Richard Brefald, a
- 1:42Speaker 1: professor at Columbia Law School. Rich this case was one
- 1:47Speaker 1: of the most watched of the Supreme Court term. How
- 1:50Speaker 1: important is this decision?
- 1:52Speaker 4: I think decision is very important, even if its significance
- 1:55Speaker 4: is not entirely clear. It's very clear that the Court
- 1:58Speaker 4: rejected the most extreme version of the argument that state
- 2:03Speaker 4: courts cannot interpret state constitutions in a way that limits
- 2:07Speaker 4: state election laws dealing with federal elections. The case was
- 2:09Speaker 4: brought to challenge the ability of state courts to read
- 2:13Speaker 4: their state constitutions to ban jerrymandering in federal elections in
- 2:16Speaker 4: congressional elections, and the Court rejected the most extreme version
- 2:20Speaker 4: and said that no state courts have a proper role
- 2:23Speaker 4: to play in reviewing the decisions of state legislatures, and
- 2:25Speaker 4: that includes applying state constitutional divisions that could limit state legislatures,
- 2:30Speaker 4: such as provisions limiting jerry mandering. But the Court left
- 2:33Speaker 4: open the possibility of some federal judicial review of state
- 2:37Speaker 4: court decisions to make sure that they were not to
- 2:40Speaker 4: extreme or extreme departures from prior state law. So the
- 2:44Speaker 4: Court kind of kept some space for itself to review
- 2:47Speaker 4: state court decisions, although it rejected the most extreme version
- 2:51Speaker 4: of the effort to limit state courts.
- 2:53Speaker 1: So explain what the independent state legislature theory is and
- 2:59Speaker 1: whether this this decision is a complete repudiation of that theory.
- 3:04Speaker 4: The independent state legislature theory grows out of the language
- 3:07Speaker 4: and the Constitution that says that the rules for running
- 3:10Speaker 4: congressional elections and the election of presidential electors are to
- 3:14Speaker 4: be set by the state legislature. The language literally says,
- 3:17Speaker 4: the times places in manner of holding elections for congress
- 3:21Speaker 4: is in one part of the Constitution. Of holding the
- 3:23Speaker 4: elections of the presidential electors another part of the Constitution
- 3:26Speaker 4: is to be set by the state legislature. That's what
- 3:28Speaker 4: the constitution says. So the question is if it says
- 3:30Speaker 4: the state legislature, do state courts have any role to
- 3:33Speaker 4: play in reviewing actions of the state legislature or in
- 3:37Speaker 4: even an interpreting actions of the state legislature. And this
- 3:40Speaker 4: came up in a case from North Carolina where the
- 3:43Speaker 4: North Carolina Supreme Court said that the North Carolina legislature
- 3:47Speaker 4: violated the North Carolina Constitution when it jerry mandered its
- 3:50Speaker 4: congressional plan. And the argument was made that basically, state
- 3:54Speaker 4: courts and state constitutions have no role to play in
- 3:57Speaker 4: limiting state legislatures when dealing with federal elections. And that's
- 4:01Speaker 4: the argument that the Supreme Court rejected. That's an independent
- 4:05Speaker 4: state legislature, that the state literature is independent of the
- 4:08Speaker 4: state court and the dependent of the state constitution. And
- 4:10Speaker 4: the Supreme Court flatly rejected that. But it did say
- 4:14Speaker 4: that since we are talking about federal elections and that
- 4:18Speaker 4: there is some role for the US Supreme Court in
- 4:21Speaker 4: reviewing state Supreme Court decisions reviewing state laws that impact
- 4:26Speaker 4: federal elections. So they didn't completely give state courts a
- 4:29Speaker 4: blank check, but they did affirm the idea that state
- 4:33Speaker 4: courts and state constitutions have legitimate roles to play in
- 4:36Speaker 4: reviewing state election laws that affect federal elections.
- 4:40Speaker 1: So the justices could have taken an off ramp and
- 4:43Speaker 1: not decided this. Why do you think they went forward
- 4:46Speaker 1: to decide it.
- 4:47Speaker 4: That's a good question, and a good part of the
- 4:50Speaker 4: court's opinion goes into why the case is not moved.
- 4:53Speaker 4: As you know, after the twenty twenty two election in
- 4:57Speaker 4: the North Carolina Supreme Court actually reversed its and said
- 5:01Speaker 4: that we no longer read our state constitution as banning
- 5:05Speaker 4: jerry mandering, and that the decision was now moved. The
- 5:08Speaker 4: court had kind of a technical reason as to why
- 5:11Speaker 4: it wasn't mood, saying, well, actually, the North Carolina Supreme
- 5:13Speaker 4: Court never withdrew the old decision, and indeed the old
- 5:17Speaker 4: decision striking down the original map that the state legislature
- 5:21Speaker 4: adopted is still law. The state is now actually writing
- 5:23Speaker 4: a new map. So the court had a technical argument
- 5:26Speaker 4: as to why it wasn't moot, and three justices dissented
- 5:30Speaker 4: from that. I think they felt that this issue has
- 5:32Speaker 4: been percolating now for some time. It came up and
- 5:34Speaker 4: wasn't directly addressed several times in the twenty twenty election,
- 5:38Speaker 4: and I think they felt this was a good case
- 5:40Speaker 4: as any for addressing the issue. It's likely to come back,
- 5:43Speaker 4: and right now there's no election pending, and if it
- 5:46Speaker 4: comes back, it'll come back next year. We're getting close
- 5:48Speaker 4: to twenty twenty four elections. So though they don't say this,
- 5:52Speaker 4: I think they felt this case was fully breathed. It
- 5:54Speaker 4: was argued an incredibly long argument. There were like two hours.
- 5:57Speaker 4: It got a huge amount of attention, and I think
- 6:00Speaker 4: they felt this was a good case as any for
- 6:02Speaker 4: actually putting down an opinion.
- 6:04Speaker 1: So it was six to three, with Justice as Brett
- 6:06Speaker 1: Kavanaugh and Amy Connie Barrett joining Roberts and the Court's
- 6:10Speaker 1: three liberals and the majority, just as Clarence Thomas, Samuel Leito,
- 6:14Speaker 1: and Neil Gorswitch dissented. Does the place of any justice
- 6:18Speaker 1: in that lineup surprise you at all?
- 6:21Speaker 4: Not really. I mean, I think I was less certain
- 6:24Speaker 4: about where Justice Barrett would come out. But I think
- 6:26Speaker 4: if you paying attention to the oral argument back in November,
- 6:31Speaker 4: I think you heard some skepticism from Roberts, from Kevanaugh,
- 6:35Speaker 4: and I think even from Barrett about the extreme nature
- 6:38Speaker 4: of the North Carolina Legislature's argument, And I think they
- 6:42Speaker 4: all had to point out that legislatures don't exist in
- 6:45Speaker 4: a vacuum. That they're creatures of state constitutions and they're
- 6:48Speaker 4: part of the state legal system. And I think the
- 6:50Speaker 4: extreme argument that North Carolina the legislature made, I think
- 6:55Speaker 4: helped shape the outcome of the case. And so I
- 6:58Speaker 4: think you also it was a case where there was
- 7:00Speaker 4: some concern that the argument that the legislature was making
- 7:04Speaker 4: would be like an extreme disrespect for state supreme courts,
- 7:08Speaker 4: and I think the justices also wanted to show some
- 7:11Speaker 4: respect for the role of state supreme courts that they
- 7:14Speaker 4: also engage in judicial review of state legislatures. Three of
- 7:17Speaker 4: the justices dissented on the mootonists. I mean, the first
- 7:20Speaker 4: part of Justice Thomas's opinion, which was joined by Justices
- 7:23Speaker 4: Corsage and Alido, was on Mootonis grounds that the case
- 7:27Speaker 4: really shouldn't have been taken. The remainder of the opinion,
- 7:29Speaker 4: which Justice Leader did not sign, was on the merits
- 7:32Speaker 4: and basically said we agree with this independen state legislature
- 7:34Speaker 4: theory that it's up to the legislature to make these
- 7:37Speaker 4: decisions and that there's no role for state courts.
- 7:40Speaker 1: Thomas dissented should he have accused himself since his wife,
- 7:44Speaker 1: Jinny Thomas was known to have been pushing the independent
- 7:48Speaker 1: state legislature theory.
- 7:50Speaker 4: Well maybe, but per involvement forces in the presidential election,
- 7:54Speaker 4: and this is a separate issue. Technically, it didn't involve
- 7:57Speaker 4: presidential elections and involved in elections. It's a separate litigation.
- 8:02Speaker 4: I think justices don't normally recuse either when they or
- 8:06Speaker 4: the spouse's the more unusual have expressed general views on
- 8:10Speaker 4: a legal theory, and then more likely to recuse or
- 8:12Speaker 4: to think about recusing when they or a family member
- 8:15Speaker 4: have a direct involvement in the particular case. And I
- 8:17Speaker 4: don't think there was anything like that in this case.
- 8:21Speaker 1: The mid term showed that control of Congress can depend
- 8:25Speaker 1: on the drawing of congressional lines. So what does this
- 8:29Speaker 1: decision mean for the twenty twenty four elections.
- 8:32Speaker 4: It doesn't really resolve anything in terms of that. I mean,
- 8:36Speaker 4: it leaves some role for state courts to review state
- 8:41Speaker 4: electional laws in light of state constitutions. But it also
- 8:44Speaker 4: means that the Supreme Court may be reviewing those decisions.
- 8:48Speaker 4: So I mean, I think we're going to see cases
- 8:51Speaker 4: citing this case and lawyers making arguments based on this case.
- 8:54Speaker 4: But I think it's too soon to tell how exactly
- 8:57Speaker 4: it's going to impact. I mean, this case involved with
- 9:00Speaker 4: an interpretation of the state constitution in North Carolina that
- 9:02Speaker 4: the North Carolina Court said kind of bar jerrymandering. There's
- 9:06Speaker 4: I think a case coming out of Ohio which raises
- 9:08Speaker 4: similar issues involving jerrymandering. But Ohio has a constitutional amendment
- 9:13Speaker 4: which clearly addresses jerry mandering. So there may be continuing
- 9:17Speaker 4: litigation involving districting, but I think most of the districting
- 9:20Speaker 4: issues from the current election cycle I think have been resolved.
- 9:24Speaker 4: But I do think we may see some impact of
- 9:26Speaker 4: this ant case coming out of Ohio.
- 9:28Speaker 1: I was going to ask you about that case because
- 9:31Speaker 1: the Supreme Court is reviewing an appeal right of that case.
- 9:35Speaker 4: I think this case helps the anti jerrymannoring position in
- 9:38Speaker 4: Ohio a bit because in North Carolina, one of the
- 9:42Speaker 4: problems for the anti Kerrymnnory position, so the North Carolina
- 9:45Speaker 4: Constitution doesn't literally address jerry mannering. It just talks about
- 9:48Speaker 4: free and fair elections, and the North Carolina Supreme Court,
- 9:51Speaker 4: in a decision which it has since dropped, said well,
- 9:54Speaker 4: that means no jerrymandering. Pennsylvania in court to set something
- 9:57Speaker 4: similar in Ohio, the voters actually amended their constitution to
- 10:01Speaker 4: put in restrictions on partisan cherry mandring. I think what
- 10:05Speaker 4: this case does is make it clear that that's valid
- 10:08Speaker 4: and isn't persable. So I think for states that have
- 10:12Speaker 4: actual provisions that expressly address cherry mandering, that might include
- 10:16Speaker 4: New York or Florida or Ohio now and I think Michigan.
- 10:20Speaker 4: I think this confirms that those are valid. I think
- 10:23Speaker 4: the trickier cases will be ones that states, like the
- 10:26Speaker 4: old North Carolina position or what the Pennsylvania Supreme Court
- 10:30Speaker 4: has done, has to read into general language talking about
- 10:34Speaker 4: free and fair elections a restriction on cherry mandering.
- 10:37Speaker 1: In the recent past, this court has significantly cut back
- 10:40Speaker 1: on the Voting Rights Act with the Chief Justice at
- 10:43Speaker 1: the helm, but this month we saw it gave an
- 10:47Speaker 1: unexpected boost to the Voting Rights Act with Chief Justice
- 10:51Speaker 1: John Roberts surprise, surprise in the majority. What do you
- 10:54Speaker 1: think is happening on the court. Is it a question
- 10:57Speaker 1: of the disapproval of the Court. I mean, it's it
- 11:00Speaker 1: seems like a reverse for Justice Roberts.
- 11:03Speaker 4: Well, I think the case you're referring to Alan versus
- 11:06Speaker 4: Milligan coming out of Alabama. Yes, it was I think
- 11:09Speaker 4: a big surprise to a voting rights advocates and a
- 11:11Speaker 4: pleasant surprise in that case. But in some sense it
- 11:15Speaker 4: was I call it a small c conservative decision in
- 11:18Speaker 4: that the court basically sustained the status quo. It sustained
- 11:23Speaker 4: existing rules for interpreting the Voting Right Seck. It affirmed
- 11:26Speaker 4: the decision of a three judge panel coming out of
- 11:28Speaker 4: Alabama that Alabama's districting was discriminatory. In effect, Alabama was
- 11:34Speaker 4: challenging that, and Alabama was presenting a kind of radical
- 11:38Speaker 4: theory which would have significantly undermined forty years worth of
- 11:42Speaker 4: interpretations of a voting rights act. So although it was
- 11:46Speaker 4: surprisingly protective of the voting Right seck, it was, as
- 11:51Speaker 4: I say, small sea conservative was more or less saying
- 11:54Speaker 4: we're going to stick with the status quo. We're going
- 11:56Speaker 4: to stick with the presidents that we've been following since
- 11:59Speaker 4: the nineteen eighties. I mean it was an important case.
- 12:01Speaker 4: I mean not to minimize it, because it has implications
- 12:05Speaker 4: for districting in Alabama and in Louisiana and possibly in
- 12:09Speaker 4: a few other states. And so it is likely that
- 12:12Speaker 4: seats some changes in congressions certainly in Alabama that's likely
- 12:16Speaker 4: to be a new congressional district created, and possibly in Louisiana.
- 12:19Speaker 4: The Supreme Court just this week, relying on the Alabama case,
- 12:23Speaker 4: rejected an effort by Louisiana to challenge the decision of
- 12:27Speaker 4: a district federal court in Louisiana, saying that there's discrimination
- 12:30Speaker 4: in Louisiana's districting.
- 12:31Speaker 1: Am I reading too much into it that Brett Kavanaughs
- 12:36Speaker 1: is drifting toward the middle?
- 12:38Speaker 4: I think in this one he is, But he did
- 12:41Speaker 4: make a point. I mean, the Chief Justice's opinion is
- 12:44Speaker 4: largely one that defends a judicial review by state supreme courts,
- 12:49Speaker 4: and at the end says, but you know, we don't
- 12:51Speaker 4: give them free reign. There could be cases that go
- 12:54Speaker 4: too far. This does involve the federal Constitution. We have
- 12:57Speaker 4: a role to play, and I think Kavanaugh and act
- 13:00Speaker 4: wrote a current opinion that largely restates that. But I
- 13:03Speaker 4: think you can see it as underscoring it, and maybe
- 13:06Speaker 4: Yankee the opinion a little bit more towards I don't
- 13:10Speaker 4: if I cult the right a little bit more towards
- 13:12Speaker 4: emphasizing the role of federal courts in reviewing state court
- 13:16Speaker 4: determinations that involved federal elections, so you know, at least
- 13:20Speaker 4: in this area, he may be you know, the middle Justice.
- 13:25Speaker 1: Have the Justices taken up any cases for next term
- 13:29Speaker 1: involving elections voting?
- 13:32Speaker 4: There is one coming out of South Carolina, again involving
- 13:36Speaker 4: the issues of race and congressional districting. And actually that's
- 13:39Speaker 4: going to be an interesting case because it's really about
- 13:41Speaker 4: the mix of race and party, and it basically involves
- 13:45Speaker 4: the redrawing of the district that's in the greater Charleston
- 13:48Speaker 4: area to make it more Republican. Essentially, it's a district
- 13:52Speaker 4: which I think has gone back and forth in recent years,
- 13:54Speaker 4: whereas the Democrat elected in twenty eighteen Republican elected in
- 13:58Speaker 4: twenty twenty and twenty two, and the captionline of legislature
- 14:01Speaker 4: redistricted in a way that made it somewhat more Republican,
- 14:04Speaker 4: mostly by moving, in effect, a lot of black voters
- 14:07Speaker 4: out of the district. And so it's been challenged as
- 14:10Speaker 4: racial discrimination, so kind of a racial cherrymander, which the
- 14:14Speaker 4: lower court found that it was. But I think Alabama
- 14:18Speaker 4: is appealing in one of the questions is if the
- 14:20Speaker 4: court has struggled with before is how to disentangle partisan jerrymandering,
- 14:24Speaker 4: which is not illegal, from racial cherrymandering, which is Thanks.
- 14:29Speaker 1: For those insights, rich That's Professor Richard Brufalt of Columbia
- 14:32Speaker 1: Law School, And that's it for this edition of The
- 14:34Speaker 1: Bloomberg Law Show. Remember you can always get the latest
- 14:37Speaker 1: legal news on our Bloomberg Law Podcast. You can find
- 14:41Speaker 1: them on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and at www dot Bloomberg
- 14:45Speaker 1: dot com, slash podcast Slash Law, and remember to tune
- 14:49Speaker 1: into The Bloomberg Law Show every weeknight at ten pm
- 14:52Speaker 1: Wall Street Time. I'm June Grosso and you're listening to
- 14:56Speaker 1: Bloomberg