Latest / Automotive State of The Union / GM Goes Nasdaq, China’s Car Quake, LiveWire Loses Its Charge
Transcript
- 0:00Good morning. It's Wednesday, October 28th. It's the Automotive State of the Union. I'm Paul Jay Daly. That's Kyle Mountserre.
- 0:06Today we're talking about GM going NASDAQ, Chinese car earthquake, not literally, and, uh, Livewire, uh, not being so live- Oh... was missed a charge. We'll, we'll let you have a moment. Yeah.
- 0:18We'll, we'll, we'll pour one out for you on the last one. [laughs] I could, I could spend a half an hour on this first one, though, just roasting. Yeah. Oh. [laughs] But don't, don't... So don't get me started yet. Okay.
- 0:29We'll just, we'll go with, we'll go with the things- Oh, wow... people need to know about what we're doing. Went roasting on a Wednesday morning. That's amazing. Roasting on a Wednesday. [laughs] That's amazing.
- 0:37Um, we have, uh, wanted to let you know a few things.
- 0:39Number one, we have a webinar coming up on November 4th, The Hidden Cost of Disconnected Dealership Conversations, uh, with, uh, Trish Callion Dasani of Car Review and Earl Wheeless of Gaffney Buick GMC.
- 0:51Two amazing people.
- 0:52I've spent a little bit of time with them, and, um, awesome conversation we're gonna have about what's happening inside the dealership and what happens when your stuff isn't talking to your other stuff, and what can happen when your stuff talks to your stuff in the right way.
- 1:06Oh, yes. So, yeah, that's how it works. Earl, Earl is- Connected data ecosystem. Let's go. Earl is, like, a super chill but super, like... I want...
- 1:13I was about to say the word, the, the term smooth operator in a different way than the song means. Um, [laughs] but- Yeah... but, uh, you can- Let's not go with that...
- 1:21you can make sure you're gonna be on that webinar or that you get the recording by going to asotu.com and signing up for the webinar. You know how webinars work.
- 1:29You can actually, now that we have a new asotu.com, you can, like, click on the Webinars tab and the Podcast tab and look around and see all the stuff. We got it all dialed in nice and, nice and tight for you.
- 1:39This is so random, by the way. Yeah, it is. I, I think I just, I think I just created a new acronym that I want someone to come out with a product under. Okay.
- 1:47So whenever anybody wants to come out with a, a new CDE, connected data ecosystem, you just let me know, and I'll, I'll, I'll help you with the primer for the idea. [laughs] Oh, okay. Okay. All right. Done. Done.
- 2:00We're not gonna say it live on the show. Uh, also, ASOTU CON West coming up hot and fast November 18th. Oh. You're gonna start seeing a bunch of this on social media. Come on. Oh, look at those pictures.
- 2:10Look at them guys. Whenever we're gonna see those. What do you got? Woo. Alex Lawrence on that one. There's Jack Hollis looking like he's taking a mugshot in what looks like in front of a really nice marina.
- 2:18Me and the mystery person in the upper left. We know who it is. You might know who it is too. But either way, you have to go to asotuconwest.com, check out the speaker, the agenda. Um, fly in, fly out event.
- 2:29You should be there. You should be there with us. Go check it out, asotuconwest.com. Get your tickets. Be with us. And, uh- It's gonna be the best one day event I've ever been to... those fa- those cats on that picture.
- 2:37Oh my gosh. I'm so excited. I don't know. You may, you may, like, cry, laugh, fall out. I don't know. All of the things. All of the above. Yes. I think all the above. All the above. Mm-hmm. Okay.
- 2:46Speaking of crying, laughing, and all the above. [laughs] Oh, man. Segway. Time. [upbeat music] Hey, hey, you gotta call your shot, right? Okay.
- 2:54GM is moving its stock li- stock listing from the New York Stock Exchange to the tech-heavy NASDAQ. This came out yesterday, actually, becoming the first legacy automaker on the exchange.
- 3:04It's pitching itself, "We're a tech company, everybody." GM is gonna keep its GM ticker and begin trading on the NASDAQ on November 17th.
- 3:12The switch is making it eligible for the NASDAQ 100, home to Apple, Microsoft, Nvidia. A couple little small tech companies are not car companies. They're tech companies.
- 3:21The news came less than a week after GM's Manhattan tech event showcasing AI software and eyes-off driving. Walmart, Hilton, and Palantir have also made similar moves. Um, Hilton did? Wow, that's an interesting one.
- 3:33Yeah. CFO Paul Jacobson called NASDAQ a natural home for our listing as we grow.
- 3:37Shares jumped more than 5% Tuesday through Morningstar as David Whiston said GM remains "a cyclical capital-intensive automaker with a growing tech business." Yeah. The, the, that last phrase, like- Mm-hmm...
- 3:52yes, they are a cyclical capital-intensive automaker, and then till they radically shift and change that, I mean, start making moves like Tesla makes where, you know- They're gonna be a cyclical capital-intensive automaker...
- 4:04they will continually be that. So I- Mm-hmm... understand why you're like, "Yeah, yeah, yeah, we're a tech business now. We're gonna get tech," you know, kinda like voting machine type stuff. Mm-hmm.
- 4:13But you can't do that until you've absolutely gone full tech enabled, full- I mean- Like-... obviously they can do that... you, you have to deploy tech into other ecosystems. This is just mindless to me.
- 4:23I think that it's silly. I think, I think this is, this is like, uh, this is like say before you do instead of do before you say. I know that they just had that tech event, and they purported all this stuff.
- 4:34Um, but this is a wild one to me. I, I don't think it's gonna do much, um, you know, for their stocks. The only reasons why those shares jumped is because they're looking for kind of like that initial move- Boost...
- 4:45and, and probably shareholders are going, "Hey, hey, maybe we get a little out of that," but, um- Yeah, I don't see, I don't- This is why... I don't see anybody buying it because it's in the NASDAQ and stuff- No...
- 4:54like, in, in the, the natural sense. Now, um, here, here's what I like about it. If Walmart can do it and say we're a tech company, right? Yeah. And, and Walmart, obviously, you're keeping up with the times.
- 5:04They have all kind of tech deployed, but Walmart's a place that has, you know, capital intensive, labor intensive physical stores all over the country, lots of real estate, right? That's not...
- 5:13If Walmart signals they can do it, I mean, Palantir makes more tech on that list- But their tech is so much more pervasive at this point... right, it go, it crosses outside of- Yes... their specific ecosystem.
- 5:22I think, here's what I do like about it. If they hold the line, this kind of thing signals to your company. It gives you a filter by which you can lead to say, "We are a tech company first.
- 5:35We're trying to- That's true... adopt that mindset." I think that's the biggest benefit. So, um, look, let, let's just be honest. This sounds like something that we would do. [laughs] Totally something we would do.
- 5:46It's a fo- it's just a brand play, fam. It's just a lo- it's a big brand play. So I'm a fan. I'm a fan. Now, will they follow through? That's where it all ma- you know, we're gonna figure out.
- 5:54If they're, they're gonna start making some moves and really leaning into this and, and stop doing things like cutting out CarPlay with, uh, you know, less- To, to put in place a, you know, a, a less effective infotainment.
- 6:05So we gotta stop doing that stuff, right? Stop. 'Cause tech companies d- do this, they work together with other tech. Hey. That's what they do great. [laughs] All right. Speaking- Okay... speaking of tech. Stop. Segway.
- 6:17It's time. This is true. [laughs] A, a capital-intensive automakers. [laughs] Chinese car industry is wowing the world while crashing down at home.
- 6:24Chinese consumers bought 22% fewer passenger vehicles through September than a year ago. Just absorb that for a minute. Wow. Imagine if our SAR dropped 22% next year. Good night. Okay?
- 6:36Full year sales tracking toward 18.5 million, the worst since 2014. So- Oh, my goodness... over a decade low. China, China can build roughly 63 million vehicles a year, more than triple their expected domestic usage.
- 6:51EV brands hit a record 143 at the end of 2025. That's 143 EV brands. Brands. [whistles] Many were propped up by local governments reluctant to close the plant in their neighborhood.
- 7:03Prices have fallen nearly 20% since 2023, and industry margins sank to 3.6%. So it's like reverse affordability problem. Holy cow. Right? It's demand problem. So automakers are doing what? Exporting.
- 7:16They're on pace for exporting 12 million vehicles this year. The five largest Chinese brands took 11.7% of Europe's market in September.
- 7:25Michael Dunne, good friend of Dunne Insights, warned, "You get an earthquake in China, you get a tsunami outside, folks."
- 7:33Yeah, the question is whether they can spin up the export game fast enough to recover their domestic game. They're giving it a go, boy. That's always been the point.
- 7:43I don't think that they were, that they were expecting to see this much of a drop. No. Well- To me, that looks like-... maybe they were... either there's an affordability gap even in China- Hmm...
- 7:53uh, or the cars are actually good enough that people don't wanna trade them in, so there's no reason to trade them in.
- 7:59You start seeing that first trade cycle you thought you were gonna get- You know what, one of the other things mentioned in the article, it's not in the show notes, but they talked about the rise of autonomous transportation as one of the reasons.
- 8:08Yeah. Right? So now you can hop in a thing, it'll take you, you don't need to own the car because, especially, I mean, China's just full of these big cities, right?
- 8:15And you think of a place where it's inconvenient to own a car- Yep... a big city.
- 8:18So if you can hop in a driverless vehicle that just takes you, dial it up on demand, and zip it out, um, you know, I don't know if that's...
- 8:26Our country is, is much different where the population is than where it is, China's spread out a lot more, so that's not as much a threat.
- 8:32But I think it's definitely something worth paying attention to as well as, like, a secondary note on this story is, like, autonomous driving is going to cut into vehicle ownership. Yep. It just is. It absolutely is. Ah.
- 8:42They're dealing with it. Speaking of dealing with it. Stop. Oof. Segway. It's time. [upbeat music] Little tear. [singing] Little tear. Yeah. Uh, Harley-Davidson's electric motor- uh, motorcycle dream is in trouble.
- 8:55Livewire, the EV brand that Harley spun off in 2021, has formed a special restructuring committee following the resignation of CEO Karim Djez.
- 9:04The committee named Ankura Consulting's Roy Gallagher, chief restructuring officer- Hmm... to evaluate, quote, "strategic alternatives."
- 9:12They once predicted that they would sell more than 100,000 motorcycles annually by 2026. By midyear, they've only shipped 358 of them. Oh, my gosh. Uh, and they've lost- Wow... $300 million since the spinoff.
- 9:27Harley still owns nearly 90% of Livewire, but said last year it would invest no more. Shares are down already 62% this year.
- 9:35North Coast Research analyst John Healy said, "It's a great concept, but maybe not for the masses at this point." All right. I was super pumped when this bike came out. I remember talking to- Sure...
- 9:43to Rick Reichardt, 'cause he, they had a Harley, Harley dealership, and he loved his. Um, I've never, I haven't gotten to ride one yet, but it seems like it's more and more possible that I might get to ride one.
- 9:53I think that electric motorcycles- Yeah, they're gonna get cheap. [laughs] I think this is an awesome city, like, city or close suburban- It's a city bike... mode of transportation.
- 10:02The problem is the early adoption could've come through, uh, you know, was, was supposedly gonna come through, you know, Harley riders and- Yeah.
- 10:10See, that, I think that- And everybody wants, "Oh, mama, mama, mama," shut the world out. That's, I think that was the big mistake. I, I happen to think that there's, there's a brand marketing play that could revive.
- 10:19You have to make it niche cool first. Yeah. And I just don't think that happened. I don't think, I think they tried to market these like they market Harleys, like you market- That's right...
- 10:28a Honda sport bike, when I think the marketing for these would probably m- look much closer to the, like, the real high-end e-bikes, right? You're right. Like, and somewhere closer...
- 10:39If you had a sliding scale and Har- Harleys on one side and those, like, dope e-bikes are on the other side, I think this has to be on the e-bike side more than the marketing side. Yeah. More on the social side.
- 10:49Get some influencers on this thing. City, i- in the city. City riders. You know, people that want, like, not to spend money on gas around the city. Gotta get Casey Neistat on one of these things. It's like- For sure...
- 10:57you know, and, like, he can do his thing in the country. I don't know. But, uh, I'm sad to see this, but I think that they will restructure. I think there is a market for these bikes.
- 11:04There's, there's something out there for them. I think, I think the ability- For sure... to charge the battery is so small, and you get so much- Yeah...
- 11:09range out of the small battery, and performance-wise, I think it's just a really viable mode of transportation that, like, doesn't take up a lot of space. You gotta know your target market. That's the story.
- 11:16I, I, that is the story. You gotta know your target market, Paul. Oh, man. T- today was a, boy, it's hard to be a big company. I'm glad we're not a big company. [laughs] It's really hard.
- 11:24It's hard to be a small company too. So we just talk about the big companies. Whatever it is, your life is full of people. Go take care of those people today. And guess what?
- 11:29The big companies, well, they'll work out too. [upbeat music]