Latest / Herbert Smith Freehills Kramer Podcasts / Deal Talk EP9: The Star Decision: Lessons for dealmakers
Transcript
- 0:00SPEAKER_00: Welcome today for an episode of our Deal Talk MA podcast.
- 0:05SPEAKER_00: You've got Mia Harrison Kelf and Rebecca Maslin Stanage with you today talking about the star decision and all that it holds for deals.
- 0:15SPEAKER_00: Hi Rebecca.
- 0:16SPEAKER_00: Well, lovely to be with you today.
- 0:19SPEAKER_00: I'm Mia Harrison Kelf, an MA partner in the HCF Kramer Sydney Corporate Practice.
- 0:24SPEAKER_01: And I'm similarly an MA partner here, Rebecca Maslin Stenage, and I also chair our firm.
- 0:30SPEAKER_00: So listen to Becky Finja.
- 0:34SPEAKER_00: So Rebecca, today we're going to sit and talk about one of the recent decisions that's been getting a lot of attention among our clients, NEDs, and lawyers alike, and I think more broadly it was a long-awaited decision.
- 0:47SPEAKER_00: And maybe to set the scene, if you're happy to start off by telling us a little bit about the case and the facts and what was relevant.
- 0:53SPEAKER_01: Sure.
- 0:54SPEAKER_01: And I mean it was a decision that was actually a great relief to directors in many ways, but also gives a lot of guidance in terms of directors and how they should go about doing things.
- 1:05SPEAKER_01: So on the facts, you had Star Entertainment, so they had casinos as their business.
- 1:13SPEAKER_01: And ASIC commenced proceedings against actually the directors and some executives of STAR about something that was a bit unexpected.
- 1:24SPEAKER_01: Basically, the main allegations in the case related to two circular resolutions that the board passed, and each of them concerned a junket operator.
- 1:34SPEAKER_01: So that's someone who brings high rollers to the casinos in return for commission.
- 1:40SPEAKER_01: So the junket operator, long-standing counterparty of Starr that worked with them for years and years, and they were bringing lots of business.
- 1:50SPEAKER_01: So Starr wanted to increase the credit limit it would extend to the junket operators so they could basically provide more business.
- 1:58SPEAKER_01: And so what the circular resolution was to do was to increase the credit limit of the junket operator.
- 2:07SPEAKER_01: So management provided a paper saying this is why they're credit worthy, and the board approved it.
- 2:15SPEAKER_01: What ASIC said is the directors should not just have thought about credit factors.
- 2:23SPEAKER_01: The directors should have taken stock and taken that as a moment to reflect on is there anything else about this counterparty?
- 2:33SPEAKER_01: Should we be doing business with them in the first place?
- 2:36SPEAKER_01: And relevantly, that ASIC felt they should have taken it as a time to reflect on anti-money laundering or AML exposure and test in relation to that.
- 2:51SPEAKER_01: There were also the suggestions from ASIC that the director should proactively, even outside of that, decided to look into these junket operators and whether the company should be doing business with them at all.
- 3:04SPEAKER_01: But we were really quite concerned about these facts because, while now, having subsequently had a lot of publicity around AML issues in casinos, society would be conscious of it.
- 3:18SPEAKER_01: Back then that was not the case when this happened.
- 3:21SPEAKER_01: And so if that was the standard expected of directors, that basically in making a decision that might seem quite unremarkable, you have to do this very holistic review to meet your duties.
- 3:34SPEAKER_01: That's such a high standard.
- 3:36SPEAKER_00: And you can see that being quite unworkable, right?
- 3:38SPEAKER_00: In practice, actually, every decision has to be refreshed from the beginning.
- 3:42SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 3:42SPEAKER_00: So I agree.
- 3:43SPEAKER_00: We're all a little anxious, I think.
- 3:44SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 3:45SPEAKER_01: And so fortunately, what the judge said was no, that's not the standard.
- 3:52SPEAKER_01: The judge felt that ASIC was judging it with the benefit of hindsight, which of course is always a risk.
- 3:58SPEAKER_01: And is in fact how you judge things, you know.
- 4:01SPEAKER_01: Exactly.
- 4:02SPEAKER_01: And the judge said directors are not required to get out in there and operate the company.
- 4:09SPEAKER_01: They basically are meant to be there having a governance role.
- 4:12SPEAKER_00: I thought one of the interesting things in ASIC's case that it sought to run was that on the one part, and and you know, I think you mentioned this, they did bring proceedings against executives on the basis that the executives had not given directors the information that they needed, and you know, they hadn't complied with their duties by providing that information to the board.
- 4:32SPEAKER_00: But the flip side was also that the board had breached their duties by not asking for the information, and it was it it always felt a little tense in trying to kind of run both those arguments at the same time.
- 4:43SPEAKER_00: And I think we saw that in the outcome, right?
- 4:45SPEAKER_01: Completely.
- 4:46SPEAKER_01: I mean, how hard to be cross-examining one set of people about why didn't you provide this information to the board?
- 4:52SPEAKER_01: And at the other saying, but directors, even though you didn't get the information, we think you should have got, you made a bad decision.
- 4:59SPEAKER_01: And in fact, there's quite a lot in the case about what executives should provide to the board.
- 5:06SPEAKER_01: There were actually findings against a couple of the executives that they hadn't met that required standard.
- 5:11SPEAKER_01: So there's quite a lot in that and the need to provide insight rather than volume and so on.
- 5:19SPEAKER_01: But it is a really welcome relief from directors that the standard's realistic unless management has given you a reason to doubt the information they're providing.
- 5:30SPEAKER_01: You're allowed to take it at face value.
- 5:32SPEAKER_00: And I think on one read you could say, you know, that there were kind of adverse findings and I guess judgment against some of the executives.
- 5:39SPEAKER_00: And obviously that's, you know, for those executive, not the ideal outcome.
- 5:43SPEAKER_00: But in some ways, you could potentially say that the decision itself is quite helpful because at least it's giving everyone guidance on what is expected.
- 5:52SPEAKER_00: And I think, again, one of the things I thought was quite helpful is reaffirming, you know, the James Hardy position.
- 5:56SPEAKER_00: I think you saw the general counsel who had adverse findings, you know, ultimately made against her, kind of saying, Well, my reporting line is into the CEO, and I felt like I was satisfying my obligations by doing that.
- 6:09SPEAKER_00: And you can see from a practice perspective that actually it's very hard to then, if your reporting line is to that person, to go around and report to the board.
- 6:18SPEAKER_00: But but it in some ways the decision says, no, that is your duty, that is your obligation.
- 6:23SPEAKER_00: And and although, you know, probably not the outcome that the general counsel was looking for in that situation, it is helpful guidance, at least for our general counsel clients, as to what is expected of them and how they are, they should be kind of discharging their duties and and really owing it to the kind of the board and the company as a whole.
- 6:41SPEAKER_01: Yeah, and a great irony about the case is if we focus on the directors, say bringing it to a deal context and thinking about what directors should do, the judge at the same time said they met the required standard and said, but I would have liked them to do better.
- 7:00SPEAKER_01: And so the judge gave quite a bit of context about he would have liked to see greater test and challenge, uh, directors not necessarily taking things at face value but really testing it.
- 7:12SPEAKER_01: And we have obviously had a lot of clients asking, how do I think about this in a deal context?
- 7:21SPEAKER_01: And we may think that there's a lot of reassurance from the types of processes that we have in, say, a significant MA transaction that are both protective of directors and tick the boxes that the judge would be expecting of test and challenge.
- 7:38SPEAKER_01: And I mean a classic due diligence process would be part of that.
- 7:42SPEAKER_00: And I thought it was, and you mentioned this briefly, but I thought it was really helpful to make clear that there is a lot of volume, you know, and we've seen that over time.
- 7:50SPEAKER_00: I think board packs and materials provided to board people have have felt that a way to kind of satisfy their obligations is to provide everything to the board.
- 7:59SPEAKER_00: And I think helpful guidance that actually what is best for directors and and management to discharge their duties is to kind of focus on providing the important things and making sure that the kind of, as you say, the insight is given rather than necessarily the detail.
- 8:17SPEAKER_00: Now that's not to say that in every circumstance sometimes the detail isn't also relevant, unfortunately, but but I thought that was also quite quite a helpful guidance for everyone of it's not just piles and piles of paper being handed over and that's what you do.
- 8:29SPEAKER_00: It's like we are gonna have to think about what are the real issues here, provide those directors, arm them with that that key information.
- 8:37SPEAKER_01: Yes, it's fascinating because the judge's take was that the reason directors receive so much information in board packs was perhaps executives trying to abdicate responsibility by saying you have it and you make the decision.
- 8:56SPEAKER_01: That's not actually our experience of how things operate on a daily basis.
- 9:01SPEAKER_01: It appears to me that the two real drivers of volume in board papers are regulatory requirements and uh not so relevant in a deal context, but for example, APRA mandates that a lot of things must go to the board.
- 9:17SPEAKER_00: So you can't having diligence APRA regulated businesses and their boardbacks, I can tell you that is true.
- 9:24SPEAKER_01: It's not fun, right?
- 9:25SPEAKER_01: There's there's so much in there.
- 9:27SPEAKER_01: But the other is things often happen incredibly quickly in a classic MA transaction.
- 9:35SPEAKER_01: You've got to respond quickly.
- 9:37SPEAKER_01: And the management team both negotiating the deal and having to put the board packs together at the same time.
- 9:44SPEAKER_01: It's that old uh saying about sorry, this is such a long letter, I didn't have time to write you a short one.
- 9:52SPEAKER_01: It is hard to be concise and make sure that you're drawing out the right information in that context.
- 9:58SPEAKER_01: And the sorts of things that people can do in that uh situation to make sure that they are providing insights and focused information are lean on your advisors.
- 10:09SPEAKER_01: I mean, we love it, we love to draft a broad board package.
- 10:13SPEAKER_01: You know, summarise agreements.
- 10:15SPEAKER_01: I'm not a big believer in giving complete agreements to the board unless there's a particular purpose.
- 10:22SPEAKER_01: So a scheme implementation deed, sometimes we provide the whole document.
- 10:26SPEAKER_01: Many directors would like to see that because it's going to be a public document.
- 10:30SPEAKER_01: But legally, a summary is adequate.
- 10:34SPEAKER_01: And if you provide both, you can say to the directors, if you would like to read it, you can see that detail.
- 10:41SPEAKER_01: However, and make this really clear, you can just look at the summary.
- 10:46SPEAKER_00: We are comfortable that the information we've provided to you in the summary is sufficient.
- 10:49SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
- 10:50SPEAKER_00: And this is kind of only if you want to go look at the source material.
- 10:53SPEAKER_00: I mean, we have a lot of directors who are former lawyers and they and they sometimes get nostalgic for an agreement.
- 10:58SPEAKER_01: So yes, that's definitely the case.
- 11:01SPEAKER_01: So there there are things of that nature that you can do.
- 11:05SPEAKER_01: I I mean, let's talk about urgency in a deal context and how you mitigate that.
- 11:09SPEAKER_01: Because as we know, time kills deals.
- 11:13SPEAKER_01: Sometimes there's genuine urgency, and we've certainly had occasions where the team's done an all-nighter to sign a deal, the board has come together with great urgency, and you think, how would this look to a regulator or a court later if people worked all night and the board convened with urgency, were given an oral briefing rather than a written briefing.
- 11:40SPEAKER_01: Now that doesn't mean you can't do it, right?
- 11:43SPEAKER_01: But it does mean it's super important if there is commercial urgency, because the market might move, the counterpart's about to walk.
- 11:53SPEAKER_01: If you've got commercial urgency like that, it's actually legitimate to do those things.
- 11:59SPEAKER_01: But what we'd be focusing on is how can you make sure that you minute the genuine urgency?
- 12:05SPEAKER_01: In fact, I want to be a hero and do an all night, I will sadly not cut it, but genuine commercial urgency will.
- 12:13SPEAKER_01: How can we mitigate risk?
- 12:15SPEAKER_01: So is that a situation where you can lean on the advisors to say, what were the late developments that the board should be across and make sure that those are carefully minuteed?
- 12:26SPEAKER_01: What are the other steps that we can take to mitigate the risk and apply the business judgment of the directors in that circumstance and make sure you're really capturing in the record the genuine commercial urgency in that situation?
- 12:38SPEAKER_00: And I mean, I actually think that that is advice that we give to clients all the time.
- 12:43SPEAKER_00: It's so true in transactions because there is often an urgency, as we both know well, but that you will never regret documenting well the basis of your decision and ensuring that contemporaneous records are kept because decisions are not always made in perfect circumstances.
- 13:01SPEAKER_00: But if you're able to explain later, potentially years down the line, when people's actual memories of the event may not be perfect by reference to good corporate governance practices, good materials, good records, that will just always be helpful.
- 13:17SPEAKER_00: You will never regret that, I think.
- 13:18SPEAKER_00: It's it's kind of universal advice that I give to clients.
- 13:21SPEAKER_01: Absolutely.
- 13:22SPEAKER_01: And I don't like when you get into the situation where you feel like it's become form over substance.
- 13:29SPEAKER_01: However, there really now is an art to documenting these processes at the right level to, as you say, Mia, give a prompt later so that people can understand and remember what was discussed and why it was discussed, without going into a transcript or complete low by blow and striking that balance correctly.
- 13:48SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
- 13:49SPEAKER_00: I feel like we've covered some of the really key points coming out of the judgment.
- 13:53SPEAKER_00: I think some of the other things that were really helpful is other areas to kind of where directors, executives should be on a bit of a higher alert, and where are circumstances where, as we've discussed, the judgment didn't say in every single interaction or decision you have to start from scratch and give enhanced consideration because that's just not practical.
- 14:13SPEAKER_00: There is an element of being able to rely on previous judgments and assume practices are being continued and so on.
- 14:18SPEAKER_00: But there are certain circumstances where directors should be asking additional layer of questions.
- 14:24SPEAKER_00: I think one of the things that again comes up a lot for us, does come up regularly in transactions and is particularly relevant and was called out is conflicts.
- 14:32SPEAKER_00: And what do we do?
- 14:35SPEAKER_00: What enhanced focus, you know, maybe the maybe the answer is enhanced focus is needed.
- 14:41SPEAKER_00: If there's any kind of actual conflicts, obviously, but also any potential perceived conflicts.
- 14:47SPEAKER_00: That's just an area where, and again, I think in out of our experience, directors do already bring a greater level of care in those circumstances, but the judgment really reinforced that, which is always helpful.
- 14:58SPEAKER_01: Yeah.
- 14:59SPEAKER_01: I think a key point from the star case itself is think about what is your highest or most existential risk in the circumstances, with the benefit of hindsight, in that case, AML, in a deal, if you have got a conflict, then you just know immediately.
- 15:21SPEAKER_01: There's greater risk to all concerned.
- 15:24SPEAKER_01: You've got to make sure that you're doing that transaction in an appropriate manner.
- 15:27SPEAKER_01: The much higher risk of regulatory scrutiny later on, or complaint by someone who feels disadvantaged by that conflict.
- 15:35SPEAKER_01: So it's got all the make sure you focus on the high-risk elements to it.
- 15:41SPEAKER_01: And in all the transactions where we have had a conflict situation, sometimes I've even been accused of being too conservative early on, let's get a protocol in place.
- 15:52SPEAKER_01: We have never ever regretted it.
- 15:56SPEAKER_01: Because then if a regulator asks later or a court asks later, how did you make sure this was managed?
- 16:02SPEAKER_01: You can say we put appropriate information barriers in place.
- 16:06SPEAKER_01: We had appropriate negotiation mechanisms, it just de-risks a situation like that.
- 16:12SPEAKER_01: And you don't want later on to wish that you had had done that.
- 16:17SPEAKER_00: And I think it's similar to the to the record keeping point, which is decisions aren't always perfect.
- 16:22SPEAKER_00: And so things may attract attention later on from regulators, from from third parties, and the outcome may not have been perfect, right?
- 16:31SPEAKER_00: Mistakes get made.
- 16:32SPEAKER_00: But what will always, I guess, you know, stand you in good course is if you can point to practices, procedures, record keeping, all of the things that show really kind of good intent, solid effort to kind of you know, make the right decisions.
- 16:47SPEAKER_00: Again, that doesn't necessarily guarantee that this perfect decisions will be made, but you are much less likely to really, you know, frankly, end up in in court with ASIC if you've done those things.
- 16:58SPEAKER_01: And that might be a good uh prompt to really think about what are the key things.
- 17:04SPEAKER_01: So if you are doing a deal, whether you're an executive or a director, what are the key things that keep you safe?
- 17:10SPEAKER_01: One, inform yourself.
- 17:12SPEAKER_01: So get information, inputs from the management team if you're on the board, inputs from advisors, input from due diligence processes.
- 17:20SPEAKER_01: So inform yourself.
- 17:22SPEAKER_01: Two, manage any conflicts, make sure you're identifying them and managing them.
- 17:28SPEAKER_01: I'd say the third thing to think about, particularly coming out of START, is take that step back or pause to say, what are the really big things I should be thinking about in context?
- 17:40SPEAKER_01: What else do I know about the company?
- 17:43SPEAKER_01: What else do I know about the industry?
- 17:46SPEAKER_01: What are the things that should be front of mind?
- 17:49SPEAKER_01: Because if they happened, they're like the existential risks or issues.
- 17:54SPEAKER_01: So make sure you factored that in.
- 17:56SPEAKER_01: And then act in what you genuinely believe to be in the best interests of the company because the courts and regulators do have regard to the business judgment of directors as long as conflicts have been managed and they have informed themselves.
- 18:11SPEAKER_01: And so that is always a safe path.
- 18:13SPEAKER_01: And in any deal that you're doing or other circumstance where you're really concerned to ensure that you comply with what would satisfy the judge in the star case, that is the roadmap to doing it.
- 18:25SPEAKER_00: Excellent.
- 18:26SPEAKER_00: I feel like we've given our audience hopefully all of the key tips that they need to know.
- 18:31SPEAKER_01: Is there any final words of wisdom or look, maybe just to note, because it has got increasingly important to make sure that you document things correctly, we now run workshops on how best to do that.
- 18:46SPEAKER_01: So if anyone's interested, they can get in touch or obviously happy to share some of that thinking.
- 18:52SPEAKER_01: But it can be really helpful to try and test that in a practical way.
- 18:56SPEAKER_00: And I think one of the things that clients do appreciate from us is we actually see such a broad range of practice where you get to see the best from everyone and in a non-IP breaching way.
- 19:07SPEAKER_00: Share that and encourage good governance and best practice across the economy.
- 19:10SPEAKER_00: So it's good.
- 19:11SPEAKER_00: Brilliant.
- 19:12SPEAKER_01: Well, thanks, Mir, and thanks for listening.
- 19:15SPEAKER_01: We hope you have enjoyed hearing about how to, in your deals, apply all the learnings from the start decision and make sure that you're doing deals safely.