Latest / Once Upon a Time at the Oscars / Ruggles of Red Gap (1935)
Transcript
- 0:13Hello everyone and welcome to Once Upon a Time
- 0:15at the Oscars. The show that takes you through
- 0:18every Best Picture nominee from 1927 to today.
- 0:21I'm Kyle. And I am Ryan. I tried my best. I've
- 0:25noticed that I get in the rhythm and I wanted
- 0:28to kind of throw it off a little bit. But I need
- 0:30to, Gloria Estefan, I need to not do the Uncle
- 0:33Sam version. Like even like in the room I pointed
- 0:37at like I think your server. My computer? Yes.
- 0:41No, that is your computer. That's the monitor.
- 0:43Okay, you're right. I don't know what to do.
- 0:45Anyway. We're doing things. We are. I tried something
- 0:48different. That's fine. Hey, I liked it. Hey,
- 0:50have you ever thought about having a butler?
- 0:52No. No. The closest was when I used to use Ask
- 0:55Jeeves, RIP. Oh, man. Yeah. Yeah. Did you ever
- 0:59treat Ask Jeeves like your butler? Or was it
- 1:02just like, like, would you treat him like, hey,
- 1:05tell me what the weather's like outside? Or is
- 1:07it more like? Hey, what movie was Brad Pitt in?
- 1:10Like, would I treat him like AI? Is that what
- 1:13I was asking? Kind of. Like, did I have a conversation
- 1:16with him? Or was I like... Like, would you make
- 1:17requests of him? Like, give me this information
- 1:19rather than like a question. I see. Yeah, I was
- 1:22always nice to Jeeves. As me. I feel like anytime
- 1:25I would use... I was nice to you, too. Thank
- 1:28you. But I feel like, as would I, is what I meant
- 1:31to say. as me as would i i the reason i asked
- 1:36that is i feel like when we think of butlers
- 1:40in this time period watching these movies in
- 1:43the 1930s i feel like we would see them ask questions
- 1:47like to get to know them a little bit like hey
- 1:49do you like this do you like that rather than
- 1:51like what's the weather like going to be outside
- 1:52go do this for me so ask jeeves i wasn't sure
- 1:55if it was more like a Hey, tell me what the weather's
- 1:57like outside. Or if it was like a... I see. Hey,
- 2:00what's considered the best movie of this year?
- 2:03Yeah. Right? Like, am I going to the concierge
- 2:05desk as me or as, like, a Karen? Exactly. Yeah.
- 2:10And for me, maybe it's the blank check of it
- 2:12all, like, watching that when I was, like, a
- 2:14kid. But there's something really fun about having
- 2:16a butler that's like, I just have a friend. But,
- 2:18like, you're definitely paying that friend. Yeah.
- 2:20Like, it's not like, go do this stuff for me,
- 2:22but it's more like, hey, let's go race, like,
- 2:24go -karts. Yeah. Rent that out. That's that's
- 2:26how I would be with a butler. I make sure I liked
- 2:28him. And then I'd be like, look, I appreciate
- 2:31everything you've done. This one's on me. It's
- 2:33like it's like what Mr. Deeds wanted from his
- 2:37friendship with all of his relationship with
- 2:39all of the people in the mansion. But they're
- 2:41just like, I I'm just the butler. He said, no,
- 2:44we got to hang out. We got to talk and chill,
- 2:46which is funny because that's kind of what this
- 2:48movie. is today and it's also a little bit of
- 2:52the criticism that i have in it of it so it it's
- 2:55a perfect full picture or full i don't know what
- 3:00i'm doing today you guys are gonna love the circle
- 3:04It is a full circle moment for that. That's what
- 3:06I meant to say. Nice save. We are talking about
- 3:08Ruggles of Red Cap. We are. Not the Ruggles of
- 3:11Red Cap like I had it written down. That was
- 3:14my own naivety. Which is like a Mario Brothers
- 3:16spinoff. Yeah. And with that said, let's go.
- 3:20And I wanted to note this is the two of three,
- 3:25second of three. We are just firing on all cylinders
- 3:29today of Charles Lawton films in 1935 to be nominated
- 3:32for Best Picture. We've already talked about
- 3:34Les Miserables. We did. And a fantastic Charles
- 3:37Lawton performance. One of the best. As Jean
- 3:40Valjean. No, sorry, Javert. Correct. Yeah, Jean
- 3:44Valjean was Frederick. Yep. Nailing it. Killing
- 3:47it. I'm so glad I got that right. I needed one.
- 3:49So with this one, we see kind of a departure
- 3:52for Charles Lutton. Everything we've seen of
- 3:54him has been very dramatic, very prestigious.
- 3:58Him in Private Lives of Henry VIII, him in Les
- 4:03Miserables. There is definitely something else
- 4:05we've seen. He was toned back a little bit in
- 4:07Les Mis. Yes, Barretts of Wimple Street. Yeah,
- 4:10you got it. So we've seen him in his highest
- 4:13caliber. And he takes on his first comedic role
- 4:17here. And not just comedic role, but comedic
- 4:19film. And that's Ruggles of Red Gap. So let's
- 4:23dive right in. We have one nomination and only
- 4:25one nomination. No surprise here. That's Outstanding
- 4:28Production. And it is on behalf of Paramount.
- 4:32Yeah, so this was based on the 1915 novel by
- 4:36Harry Leon Wilson. And it was adapted by Humphrey
- 4:39Pearson. Screenplay by Walter... de leon and
- 4:42harlan thompson uh this was directed by leo mccary
- 4:46and like you said stars charles lawton as marmaduke
- 4:50ruggles although that's i guess kind of a spoiler
- 4:53a little bit more like maybe 45 minutes in yeah
- 4:56and uh i'll go through the plot a little bit
- 4:59here you have charles lawton who plays a butler
- 5:02to this wealthy british duke And the Duke loses
- 5:08his loyal butler, his loyal servant, in a card
- 5:12game to an American family, Effie and Egbert
- 5:16Floud, played by Mary Bolin and Charles Ruggles.
- 5:19And Ruggles makes the journey over to the United
- 5:22States and kind of learns that he wants to...
- 5:27Be his own man. He wants to be independent and
- 5:29he wants to stop being a servant. So a lot of
- 5:32the comedy is built around this like fish out
- 5:34of water kind of story. He is very proper and
- 5:39he lives to serve until he doesn't. What did
- 5:44you think of the comedy in this movie? Not to
- 5:49ask you a question and then be like, my turn.
- 5:52But I think that comedy is one of the lesser
- 5:56genres that shows up in the Academy Awards overall,
- 6:00especially now. Early on, this happens quite
- 6:03a bit. But this feels like one of the comedy
- 6:07movies where I'm like, wow, really? Best picture.
- 6:10Interesting. But what did you think in terms
- 6:13of that? Yeah, no, I'm with you on that. I think
- 6:15that this is a comedy. And it is one that I was
- 6:19kind of surprised to see was nominated for Best
- 6:21Picture because I think there's a world in which
- 6:25it could have been Best Picture nominated and
- 6:28feel that way. And it is Best Picture nominated.
- 6:31It just doesn't feel like it should be. And one
- 6:34big part of it has got to be Charles Lawton's
- 6:36performance. I think having anything with Charles
- 6:39Lawton attached to it, I think that that makes
- 6:42it a higher caliber. And in previous entries,
- 6:45we've seen that to be true. right, Barrett's
- 6:47and Wimple Street, Private Lives of Henry VIII,
- 6:49even with something like Les Mis. Like, you're
- 6:53right, he's more toned down, but it has a prestige
- 6:55nature to it. So in this, I think there's a prestige
- 6:58belief behind it. And, I mean, I guess I'll just
- 7:03go ahead and rip the band -aid off. I didn't
- 7:04really laugh at this. There's a couple moments
- 7:07where I was like, oh, hmm, like kind of humorous,
- 7:09but I wasn't really laughing. You know, I've
- 7:12laughed at a lot of things that we've seen so
- 7:14far. uh specifically you know we talk about ned
- 7:17sparks in imitation of life like there are performances
- 7:19given where you're like oh i'm really into that
- 7:21thin man which i just watched for the second
- 7:24time last night i'm still laughing out loud at
- 7:26things like that and i've been laughing out loud
- 7:28at some things that we've seen recently and like
- 7:30i'm really into it and with this i was like i
- 7:32mean i understand this is a comedy but it's just
- 7:35more kind of a a comedy of errors than it is
- 7:37like something actually funny yes um and that's
- 7:40what it seems to be going on here Kind of an
- 7:43interesting way that this happened, because Charles
- 7:45Lawton specifically was signed on to this first,
- 7:47right, for Ruggles of Red Gap. And he knows that
- 7:50this is going to be his comedic debut. And he
- 7:53wants to make sure he's ensuring that this is
- 7:54going to be a hit and, like, be done correctly.
- 7:58So what he does is he actually tags in the director,
- 8:00Leo McCary, handpicks him himself. Because he
- 8:03saw what he did with Duck Soup in 1933. Marx
- 8:06Brothers movie. With the Marx Brothers, exactly.
- 8:08So he knows, hey, this is a guy who knows his
- 8:10way around a comedy. And I want to make sure
- 8:12I feel comfortable, confident in the direction
- 8:16behind this. So everything was done to support
- 8:19that. But, and I guess I'll go ahead and, you
- 8:21know, reveal this too. This is a Frank Capra
- 8:24movie. Like this top to bottom. The plot of this
- 8:28is a Frank Capra movie. And I think that it wants
- 8:31to be funny, but at the same time, it wants to
- 8:33be very emotional. And it wants to be like, well,
- 8:36look at the evolution of this character. Look
- 8:38at how Ruggles is specifically, you know, this
- 8:41very prim and proper, like, I live for this job.
- 8:44And that's who I am. And I've made my personality
- 8:46around it. And now as being a fish out of water,
- 8:48you know, coming to Red Gap. Is it Montana? Indiana?
- 8:53It's the Midwest. Midwest. Yeah, I don't. They
- 8:56definitely say it at one point, but we've already
- 8:58forgotten that. And I think it's 1908? Yes, that's
- 9:01true. Because it opens in Paris of 1908. And
- 9:03then via the family that he lives with, the Flauds,
- 9:08via the Flauds, he ends up going to Midwest America.
- 9:12And that's where we really see the fish out of
- 9:15water nature from him. But it's also... That
- 9:17allows him to become himself. And he becomes
- 9:20more Americanized. But instead of becoming a
- 9:22stereotype, he finds what he really wants to
- 9:24do. And that's, you know, he wants to run his
- 9:26own saloon, his own kitchen, his restaurant.
- 9:29And is that a possibility? He thinks no, because
- 9:32this is the life that he's, you know, given himself.
- 9:34And he has such a low view of himself because
- 9:39of this role. Right. You can't call me by my
- 9:42name, my first name. You can't call me nicknames
- 9:44like we can't be seated at the same table. I
- 9:46can't drink with you. People are going to think
- 9:48we're equal. And aren't we equal? There's a lot
- 9:52of really interesting things that are like proposition
- 9:54to this movie, but there's not enough time to
- 9:57kind of give weight to those to make it feel
- 9:58like that's the point of the movie. The point
- 10:00of the movie is more the comedy. Yeah. Which
- 10:02is just not really present to me. I think the
- 10:05comedy is present, but I just don't think it
- 10:08works. That's it. Yeah. Because like you said,
- 10:12there are a lot of movies that we've covered
- 10:14that the jokes have withstood the test of time.
- 10:19And I don't even know that time is the issue
- 10:23with this comedy. I just don't think it was ever
- 10:25that funny. But like even back then, I can't
- 10:29imagine. People sitting in the seat and just
- 10:31losing their mind at the comedy here. I think
- 10:34maybe if you're familiar with Charles Lawton
- 10:36and you know the types of roles he's taken up
- 10:39to this point, I can see some comedy there of
- 10:42just being like, wow, look at how reserved and
- 10:44silly this very dramatic and an actor who typically
- 10:49overacts, look at how reserved he's being now.
- 10:52That's funny. But yeah, I don't know. There's
- 10:56kind of like a Beverly Hillbillies element to
- 10:58this as well, which again is a fish out of water
- 11:00story. But the flouds are very reminiscent of
- 11:03those characters. Because while most of the story
- 11:07does revolve around Charles Lawton in America,
- 11:11the first bit of that, hey, I'm in the wrong
- 11:14universe here, is the flouds being in Paris.
- 11:17Well, let me start with a compliment. I say start.
- 11:20We're already like 10 minutes into this. But
- 11:22let me start with a compliment. I think that
- 11:24this movie picks up extremely quickly. And I
- 11:27think sometimes there's kind of a lead up to
- 11:29the plot. And the introduction of Charles Lawton
- 11:34as Ruggles is him waking up his sir in the morning.
- 11:39And his sir immediately is like, hey, have you
- 11:41ever... you're open to different things right
- 11:44like you're open to changes isn't that a cool
- 11:47thing and it's revealed very quickly that he
- 11:49had a poker game he played the what do you call
- 11:52it uh drawing poker or oh i don't remember he
- 11:56called it something but it's poker yeah um and
- 11:59he's like yeah i've never really heard of poker
- 12:00before but i played it it turns out that you
- 12:02can bluff but they were also bluffing too so
- 12:04i kind of bet you and now you have to go stay
- 12:08with them yeah and uh I guess one of the only
- 12:11things I thought was really funny in the moment
- 12:13was how seriously Ruggles took this, where he
- 12:18wasn't like, I have to leave? He was like, well,
- 12:21I suppose, yes, I can go to the Midwest and live
- 12:25with these new people. Sure thing, sir. I suppose
- 12:27that's fine. I was like... I mean, that's really
- 12:30good that he's just immediately like, well, I
- 12:31have to listen to you, and you just told me to
- 12:33leave, so I guess I have to leave. Yeah. But
- 12:35it takes off. Just immediately, it's like, well,
- 12:37this is the plot. We're into it. We're 90 seconds
- 12:39in, and you already know what this movie is.
- 12:41Right. And you're right. We meet the Flauts,
- 12:43and we see that this is also fish out of water
- 12:46for them. It is specifically in Effie, who wants
- 12:51to live more of a lavish lifestyle, but in Egbert,
- 12:55who is more actually of the Midwest. And this
- 12:59is from his attire, painfully so. This is from
- 13:02his personality, the way he interacts with everyone,
- 13:06not just anyone he knows. He is Midwestern and
- 13:09Effie wants to be French and she wants to be
- 13:12high class. And she thinks that having a butler
- 13:16is going to make them that. And Egbert is very
- 13:18hesitant to having someone dress him and, you
- 13:22know, take care of him and drive him. He can
- 13:24do this himself. And this opens some interesting
- 13:27doors, but not enough to carry your interest
- 13:30throughout the movie. No. It's more in the, you
- 13:33know, well, hey, I'm going to treat you like,
- 13:36yes, I have this really Midwestern accent. And
- 13:39yes, I seem like a cowboy, but also like you
- 13:42are equal to me and I'm going to treat you as
- 13:45such. And I don't really want a butler. I just
- 13:47kind of want like, you know, someone who can
- 13:49help me with this stuff, but also like hang out.
- 13:51Yeah. And I like that aspect, but that gets worn
- 13:54out very quickly. Absolutely. I want to go back
- 13:58to when you said this is a Frank Capra movie.
- 14:00Yeah. Because I'm curious to know, like, how
- 14:03do you think this painted both like English culture
- 14:07and American culture? I think that it handled
- 14:11both as well as it could have. It doesn't feel
- 14:15like it makes a stereotype of French culture
- 14:17any more than it makes a stereotype of American
- 14:19culture. Thank you for correcting me. It is French
- 14:21culture. Yeah. I said English. Oh, well, it's
- 14:24English because of Charles Lawton. I think that's
- 14:27why we think that. Yeah. And I think the Duke
- 14:29is English as well. He might be. Yeah. Maybe
- 14:32they're both visiting. I'm actually not super
- 14:33aware of that. That's Roland Young as well. Yeah.
- 14:36We just talked about him. He played Uriel in
- 14:38David Copperfield. Yeah. Very different character.
- 14:40And I actually like him in this. He's like very...
- 14:45Like his mouth doesn't open when he talks. A
- 14:48lot of like quite and rathers. Yeah. Yeah. Which
- 14:51it seems like he's happy to say anything other
- 14:54than he's wrong and he made a mistake. Yes. But
- 14:57I thought that was kind of ingenious. Yeah. Ingenious
- 15:01is the wrong word, but clever, I guess. And it's
- 15:03weird because I feel like, and I'm going to try
- 15:06and understand what I mean by this as I say it
- 15:07out loud. There are funny characters, but the
- 15:10script isn't funny. Yeah, that makes sense. Like
- 15:13the characters, you can see where the humor is
- 15:16and you're like, yeah, I guess that's kind of
- 15:17funny, but you're not actually like laughing
- 15:19with it. Right. So it is a comedy in that sense.
- 15:22It's just not a very effective one. And what
- 15:25I mean by it being a Frank Capra film is that
- 15:27I think by the end of this movie, the journey
- 15:30that we have seen Ruggles go on and these characters
- 15:32is the whole like, I mean, we'll get there, but
- 15:36there is a song that is saying at the end of
- 15:38the movie. for Ruggles that just to me was like,
- 15:42this is Lady for a Day. It's a wonderful life.
- 15:46It happened one night. This is just the whole
- 15:49like, hey, let's hear it for this guy. And it
- 15:52feels like Mr. Deeds comes to town, goes to town,
- 15:57sorry. It feels like those movies where it's
- 15:59like a celebration of one person's life. And
- 16:01that's what I think felt like the inspiration
- 16:04behind this movie. But at least that like knew
- 16:08what it was and like the comedy lives within
- 16:10that story. With this, it felt like it kind of
- 16:12realized halfway through, hey, what if we did
- 16:14that? And it just it has a tone problem for me.
- 16:17Sure. I really like the Capra analogy because
- 16:20not only are the things you said like those are
- 16:24they make sense to me, but Capra spends so much
- 16:27time talking about like the ideal America and
- 16:30kind of like the American dream. And I think
- 16:34that. It's a big part of this. Yeah. Paris and
- 16:37like English and all of that that's showcased
- 16:40in this movie is played as like, look at how
- 16:43ignorant they are to what is going on in the
- 16:46United States. And they kind of look down upon
- 16:49the flouds and all of that because they're loud
- 16:51and they're boisterous. And while you're supposed
- 16:54to laugh and think like, oh, they're they're
- 16:56so ridiculous, they meet in the middle of the
- 16:58street outside of a French cafe and like piggyback
- 17:01each other and pretend they're. like bucking
- 17:04broncos or something you you almost look to them
- 17:08or the movie wants you to look to them and be
- 17:10like oh look at how much fun they're having i
- 17:12love being american and then that's further emphasized
- 17:15when you get back to america and especially egbert
- 17:19floud who is uh wesley ruggles uh charles charles
- 17:24ruggles thank you wesley ruggles is a director
- 17:26also a weird thing i noticed that in the opening
- 17:28scroll uh he's charlie ruggles oh yeah But also
- 17:32Charles is – we've known him as Charles Ruggles
- 17:34previously. So I don't know when that changed
- 17:36or when he started pushing that a bit more. Yeah,
- 17:38I wonder if he just changes it and he's like,
- 17:40yeah, in this movie I was more of a Charlie.
- 17:42But I think it's interesting because all of the
- 17:46American ideology comes from Charles Ruggles.
- 17:50Yes. And he's very much like, this is the land
- 17:53where you get to choose what you are. And that
- 17:56feels very Capra to me. It does. And, you know,
- 17:59it's interesting that you say that because I
- 18:00think that Egbert is the true American. We see
- 18:04Ruggles as the true English. And then we see
- 18:07Effie as the fish out of water. And like, I am
- 18:10American, but I want to be English and I want
- 18:12to be like high class. And this is what I think
- 18:14high class is. And she's not succeeding at either.
- 18:17Right. She is thriving enough in Midwest by trying
- 18:21to be something different. So there's an interesting
- 18:22class conversation about that, which is also
- 18:24very Capra. But ultimately, to me. the the ideal
- 18:29state of like you know a capra of like you know
- 18:31addressing this stuff is in the balance of how
- 18:35we view each other right americans versus otherwise
- 18:38and i think there's a really interesting conversation
- 18:40in this in that there isn't really a stereotype
- 18:43or a incorrect assumption or not assumption but
- 18:48like incorrect labeling like it's just more oh
- 18:50yeah they're very loud we don't we're not as
- 18:52loud over here and then Over there, they're completely
- 18:55fine people. There's nothing wrong. That's just
- 18:57of their nature. Yeah. So interesting things
- 18:59there. I do want to go back one step. I did say
- 19:02that I didn't really laugh in this movie. There
- 19:04is one thing that I laughed out loud at. And
- 19:06I like Charles Ruggles in this. I think him as
- 19:09Egbert Floud is very funny for the most part.
- 19:11But again, just not very laugh out loud funny.
- 19:14But the thing I did laugh out loud with. is in
- 19:16that scene that you're talking about where Egbert
- 19:18meets his other friend. They're both dressed
- 19:20to the nines. They are wearing suits and ties
- 19:23and the top hats. They're giving each other like
- 19:26piggyback rides, you know, bucking at each other.
- 19:28And then they sit down and they convince Ruggles
- 19:32to sit and drink with them. And they have roughly
- 19:35about three to four drinks each. And we fast
- 19:37forward in time to them sitting there. And Charles
- 19:40Ruggles says, let's get some ham and eggs. And
- 19:44his friend tries to order ham and eggs from the
- 19:46waiter at this French restaurant. And he says,
- 19:49give me a ham and eggy. Hammy and eggy. Hammy
- 19:53eggy. Hammy eggy. Yeah. And the waiter's like,
- 19:56what are you asking for? And he just says, hammy
- 19:59eggy again. And he's like, OK. And he leaves.
- 20:02And about 30 seconds goes by of conversation.
- 20:05And Egbert Flau just goes, I wonder what we're
- 20:08going to get instead of ham and eggs. Yes. That
- 20:10was very funny. It was so good because again,
- 20:13it felt kind of like self -aware of him being
- 20:15like, cause he says like beautiful French, beautiful
- 20:17French. Yes. And then says that afterwards. It's
- 20:20like, okay, cool. So he's self -aware. Like at
- 20:22times you want to think he believes that like
- 20:24they're speaking perfect French, but then him
- 20:26to say that just felt kind of like, all right,
- 20:28cool. So you know your place. He's my favorite
- 20:30character in this. He's my favorite. And you
- 20:32know what? When this started, I was like, oh
- 20:34no. I hear that voice, and I see your suit, and
- 20:37I see everyone making fun of you, and I just
- 20:39kind of feel like you're going to be the butt
- 20:40of the joke, and I hate it. But I really like
- 20:42what he's doing with it, and I like where he
- 20:44ends up being, too. Because he doesn't end up
- 20:46being the wise old man. He is just like, hey,
- 20:50maybe I'm flawed. This is just kind of who I
- 20:52am, and I don't get much better by the end, but
- 20:54I have this heart of gold. And ultimately, that's
- 20:56what's going to help me get along with this.
- 20:58And it's not nearly as bad as I think we're going
- 21:03to make it sound. Because the characters are
- 21:05good and the performances are good. But this
- 21:07is another movie. Funny, this is coming out right
- 21:10after David Copperfield. This is another movie
- 21:12where something is just off. Yeah. And it is
- 21:15just not carrying throughout. And maybe it's
- 21:18Charles Lawton in a comedic performance. Maybe
- 21:21it's a movie that we're like, cool, Charles Lawton's
- 21:24in this movie called Ruggles of Red Gap. That
- 21:26sounds very Barretts of Wimple Street. I wonder
- 21:28what we're going to get out of it. And it's just
- 21:30like kind of a culture shock of like, oh, this
- 21:32is not. what you've done previously. But regardless
- 21:36of how you feel about Charles Lawton or the performance
- 21:38that he's giving or the performance anyone's
- 21:40giving here, you still kind of have the question
- 21:42of like, this had one nomination and it was for
- 21:44outstanding production. Why? Yeah. Yeah, and
- 21:48I think we've covered some movies that have only
- 21:50had that one nomination that I'm like, oh, I
- 21:53see what could have been the reason for this.
- 21:57But in this one, I'm like, yeah, I think this
- 21:59is a fine enough movie, but... I'm really confused.
- 22:03Like, what was the selling point? Is it Charles
- 22:05Lawton? And I do think that Charles Lawton's
- 22:10performance is just not enough to carry this
- 22:13movie. It's not. No. I mean... I think if we
- 22:16could find a better name for this, I would call
- 22:18it Leo McCary's Frank Capra's Ruggles of Red
- 22:21Gap. Yeah. Because that's really what it feels
- 22:23like, because it feels like they saw Lady for
- 22:25a Day, and they saw it happen one night. And
- 22:27I'm not going to say they saw the movies that
- 22:29are yet to come, but they saw those type of,
- 22:31like, slice of Americana, like... We have to
- 22:35get back to a time of where freedom meant these
- 22:37things. We even have, towards the end of the
- 22:40movie, the crux of this performance in this movie
- 22:44lies in the reciting of the Gettysburg Address
- 22:47in a saloon with a bunch of other Midwest Americans
- 22:51that we go down a painstaking amount of people.
- 22:57Even like a weird tracking shot of like, hey,
- 23:00do you like that tracking shot in Ruggles of
- 23:02Red Gap? You mean the one where a bartender asks
- 23:05seven people if they can recite what Abraham
- 23:08Lincoln said at Gettysburg? And then it just
- 23:11comes back and then the shot's over? Why was
- 23:13that a one -take track shot? It just doesn't
- 23:16make a ton of sense. Outside of him kicking the
- 23:18chair underneath a guy's feet. That was funny.
- 23:20Although I did like his line. That was another,
- 23:22like, I chuckled moment. Yeah. He asks everyone,
- 23:26what did Abraham Lincoln say at Gettysburg? And
- 23:28they're like, I don't know. Oh, he said, oh,
- 23:30I can't remember. And then he asks one guy sitting
- 23:32in a chair. I think he wakes him up, actually.
- 23:34Yeah, he does, to give him his drink. And he's
- 23:35like, what did Abraham Lincoln say at Gettysburg?
- 23:37He's like, I don't know. I wasn't there. And
- 23:39I was like, oh, that's cool. Yeah. And then he
- 23:41kicks his chair from underneath him. He's like,
- 23:42you weren't there. I love that he comes back.
- 23:44Like, he moves forward, asks another guy. And
- 23:47on his way back, he's like. It's literally like,
- 23:50I can't believe you said that. Yeah. Yeah. I
- 23:52thought that was, that was pretty funny too.
- 23:54But that, that whole, like, you know, it shows
- 23:57the entire like saloon. No one can say what he
- 24:01said at Gettysburg. And then we have kind of
- 24:04like, I mean, probably the best scene in the
- 24:08movie is Charles Lawton, like not just reciting
- 24:11the Gettysburg address, but also like saying
- 24:14it under his breath at first, almost kind of
- 24:16like. almost like a possession. Did you catch
- 24:19that? Yeah, it was. It was like someone did the
- 24:22Manchurian candidate of the Gettysburg Address.
- 24:25Like he's been sleeper -celled into like, oh,
- 24:27now I can say the entire Gettysburg Address.
- 24:30And then it's not until Egbert kind of stops
- 24:32him. He's like, say that out loud. Like, say
- 24:34it again. And he starts reciting it louder and
- 24:36everyone can hear him and then, you know, surrounds
- 24:39him. And I don't know if you caught this, but
- 24:41in the background, there's a wide shot of everyone
- 24:44kind of like... encompassing him sitting at this
- 24:47table. At the top right, you can see a portrait
- 24:50of Abraham Lincoln. Oh, really? While he's reciting
- 24:52this. So obviously, Gettysburg Address means
- 24:55a lot to the movie. It also means a lot to Charles
- 24:58Lawton. So specifically in this, he was pretty
- 25:01emotional when he was reciting this, obviously
- 25:04in character and everything. But also because
- 25:06at the time, Charles Lawton was considering American
- 25:09citizenship. oh so he was also kind of like seeing
- 25:13like what america can be the the portrayal of
- 25:16america but also what it really stands for and
- 25:18the history of that especially gettysburg that
- 25:20was really resonating with him so this was pretty
- 25:23emotional for him at the time that's pretty cool
- 25:25i i know that like it was very cool to do this
- 25:28is something that continues with him uh while
- 25:30he was on the set of mutiny on the bounty he
- 25:33did the same thing Uh, while he was on the set
- 25:35of another movie that I forgot the name of in
- 25:361936 or 1937, he did the same thing. So he does
- 25:40kind of wear out this party trick, the parlor
- 25:42trick a little bit of like, I'm just going to
- 25:44recite this, not on film, but like on the set.
- 25:47Uh, Hey everyone get together. I'm going to do
- 25:50Gettysburg. Oh really? Yeah. Uh, that's, it's
- 25:53kind of like, I'm going to lead us in Gettysburg,
- 25:54like leave us in prayer kind of thing. Uh, I
- 25:57don't necessarily know if I think that's as in.
- 26:01pactful as this is uh this feels like kind of
- 26:04a cool one and done to do it again is just kind
- 26:06of like charles latin's greatest hits i love
- 26:09that this man just he's constantly performing
- 26:12out in the streets he does the gettysburg address
- 26:14he'll eat a chicken with his hands like that's
- 26:17all he does he is doing it to himself a little
- 26:19bit isn't he yeah it's like hey man yeah recite
- 26:21the gettysburg he's like uh man i don't please
- 26:24him with my family and he's like Four score.
- 26:26You did it on Mutiny and the Bounty. You did
- 26:29it on Ruggles or Red Gap. Do it now. Or I'm getting
- 26:32the chicken. You're doing one or the other. And
- 26:35this one's cleaner. And I'll give you $150 if
- 26:38you do both. Yeah, I just saw a clip of Indy
- 26:42Navarette. Navaretti. Navaretti, yeah. She got
- 26:45approached by a fan to take a photo. And they
- 26:48were like, can you do the frown? And she was
- 26:50like, no, I actually don't do that anymore. And
- 26:52I'm like. Good for you, girl. Yeah. Because you
- 26:54don't want to end up like Charles Lawton and
- 26:56have to eat a chicken every time you leave the
- 26:58house. I feel so bad when those things happen
- 27:01because the first thing I think of is that Simpsons
- 27:03meme where everyone looks back at Bart. It's
- 27:06like, do the thing. Say the thing, Bart. Say
- 27:08the line. That's it. Say the line, Bart. And
- 27:11I feel bad because I know Never Ready's like,
- 27:13frown. Everyone's like, yay, she did it. Same
- 27:16thing with Charles Lawton and the chicken. But
- 27:18it's also very funny that she said, anymore.
- 27:21that movie came out like four months she may
- 27:23not have okay but i mean even if she did like
- 27:26four months ago with the amount of hype that
- 27:28movie's gotten yeah she's going to have permanent
- 27:30frown lines from doing it correct as many times
- 27:33as she has and also that is a pretty pretty drastic
- 27:35frown that's a deep frown deep frown in that
- 27:37movie like that's got to be like at least five
- 27:39frowns for regular people yeah you're getting
- 27:41more than crow's feet i don't mean to say regular
- 27:43people like she's not a regular person but for
- 27:45anyone who's not in obsession that's like five
- 27:47you know yeah frowns that's that's ultra mega
- 27:50frown you have to practice i cast ultra mega
- 27:53frown 358 by two ultra mega birth by sleep um
- 27:58i feel like that was a sleeper show with someone
- 28:00like someone just woke up and was like they have
- 28:02cast yeah they're like four score seven years
- 28:04ago yeah and again like there's absolutely like
- 28:08it is heartwarming to see like charles lot in
- 28:11this uh emotional over like reciting the gettysburg
- 28:14address and it's a great scene it is a good scene
- 28:17But it just, again, kind of feels like at the
- 28:1980 % mark of this movie, you're kind of like,
- 28:23oh, this is a Frank Capra movie. Yeah. But it
- 28:25doesn't feel like that beforehand. It's so funny.
- 28:27I feel like, you know, I said, what was the draw
- 28:30in 1935 for this movie? And I think maybe this
- 28:34was like a very patriotic reminder to a lot of
- 28:37people. Because you do get to this scene and
- 28:40it shows, like, look at all of the Americans
- 28:43who have forgotten, like. What the point is of
- 28:46this country and having the Gettysburg Address,
- 28:49you know, and the relation to like slavery and
- 28:52then Charles Ruggles playing the servant character.
- 28:55There's even a line, a very ignorant and kind
- 28:59of crass line at the beginning of the film where
- 29:02he mentions, oh, I'm being sent to America, the
- 29:05land of slavery. And oh, yeah, Roland Young,
- 29:09his response is like, no, I think they sort of.
- 29:11That out. Pocahontas sorted that out. Yeah. And
- 29:14it's just like, there's your example of like,
- 29:17oh, look how ignorant these Europeans are. But
- 29:20then you get to this Gettysburg scene and it
- 29:22is a reminder of like, look, we've forgotten,
- 29:24you know, what we are as a country and the important
- 29:27things that have happened in our past. And, oh,
- 29:31look, don't worry. This man is here to remind
- 29:33us. And I imagine if you're sitting in the theater,
- 29:36you know, and you're coming, you're going through
- 29:38the Great Depression right now. You just had
- 29:41World War I. But, like, that's not weighing on
- 29:43your mind. You're thinking about, like, how am
- 29:45I going to afford anything after I leave this
- 29:48movie? That reminder of, oh, this country is
- 29:52great. Like, that's got to be the selling point.
- 29:54It does. And ultimately, I think it is. But it
- 29:59takes a while to get there. It does. And it feels
- 30:02almost kind of like, I don't know. I wonder if
- 30:05it's almost incidental. That it gets there. Because
- 30:08I don't want to say that the movie doesn't feel
- 30:11like it knows what it's doing, but it does just
- 30:14kind of land there ultimately. It does. And it
- 30:16feels like, oh, was that what we were doing this
- 30:18whole time? It meanders throughout a lot of this
- 30:20movie. It does. And again, you enjoy your time
- 30:23with Charles Lawton enough to where it's like,
- 30:25yeah, I mean, I'm... I'm paying attention and
- 30:27I'm into it. But then that Gettysburg scene happens
- 30:30and you're like, yeah, okay, cool. I understand
- 30:31where we're going. And I feel like this is finding
- 30:33a natural, like, you know, wrap up conclusion
- 30:35spot. And there's 20 more minutes. Yes. And it
- 30:38just, you're like, all right, now we're doing
- 30:40this and now we're doing that. And then we're
- 30:42getting here and there's a lot of misunderstandings
- 30:44and now we're back at it. And it ends with Charles
- 30:49Lutton, Ruggles, seeing through. The dream that
- 30:53he's had. And that is, you know, having his own
- 30:56restaurant. Yeah. The Anglo -American Grill.
- 30:58Great name. I think we can workshop it a little
- 31:02bit. A little, probably. Maybe the AAG. Maybe
- 31:04Ruggles of Red Gap. Ag. Ruggles of Red Gap. Yeah.
- 31:08Or Shea Ruggles. Ooh. Even though he's not French,
- 31:12but again. Well, you know. Ruggles isn't a bad
- 31:15name. Now, Ruggles. Get these bergs. If he only
- 31:19serves, and again. Please don't steal our ideas.
- 31:22This is our novel from 1929. Yeah. Please don't
- 31:27steal my ideas. Yeah. Yeah. By Jackie Cooper.
- 31:31So what if we only served iceberg wedged sandwiches?
- 31:37Iceberg wedged? Not wedged salads. My God. I'm
- 31:40already losing my mind. Iceberg wedged salads.
- 31:42Okay. Okay. Yeah. And it was historical themed.
- 31:46Yeah, I see. Get these bergs. Get these bergs.
- 31:50Get these bergs address. See, and I was actually
- 31:53thinking of a burger restaurant. That's so much
- 31:55better. Wow. How did I get wedges? Iceberg wedges.
- 32:00Iceberg wedges. I mean, people love a wedge salad.
- 32:03They do. That's true. But get these burgers.
- 32:07Yeah. Get these burgers. Get these burgers. There's
- 32:10got to be a place in Gettysburg that has that
- 32:13name. There's got to be. What if Geddy Lee? Okay.
- 32:18Opens up his own burger restaurant and calls
- 32:22them Getty's Burgers. That's good. Right? Man.
- 32:27I love these pitches that are only for one person.
- 32:30Yes. I also love the idea of like you show up
- 32:33to any of these things or like you get the Ruby
- 32:35Keeler kicks and you're just like, where did
- 32:37that come from? The same reaction people have
- 32:39to showing up to Getty's Burgs and being like,
- 32:43okay, but what is that? That's the same reaction
- 32:46I have when I show up to Ruggles of Red Gap or
- 32:48Barrett's of Wimple Street. I'm like, what is
- 32:50this about? Yeah. What is a Ruggles? What's Charles
- 32:52Lawton doing right now? Yeah. So I think we're,
- 32:56you know, we're doing great. We're pioneers.
- 32:58Yeah. It's truly what we are. How long did that
- 33:01bit go on for? If the restaurant was called Ruggles.
- 33:05Yes. Do you think of it more as a Chili's? Hi,
- 33:08welcome to Ruggles. Sir, this is a Ruggles. Man.
- 33:12I feel God in this Ruggles tonight. Is that doing
- 33:14anything? This is good. Is it more of a chili?
- 33:17I think it's a chili. I think it is. If I heard
- 33:18of a restaurant called Ruggles, I'd be like,
- 33:20so you have like burgers and like. He made a
- 33:22meat sauce as well. Yeah. Which is. The English
- 33:26were like, you can just bring me some ketchup.
- 33:27What is a chili if not a meat sauce? I literally
- 33:31just imagine you on top of a mountain, like legs
- 33:34crossed, just like one with the earth. Yeah.
- 33:36Asking that question. With. What is a ketchup
- 33:39if not a meat sauce? Not a ketchup. A chili.
- 33:42What is a chili? Ketchup is not a meat sauce.
- 33:45No, you're right. It is a tomato sauce. I think
- 33:49historically that has been true. Okay, yeah,
- 33:51thank you for going off that little tangent with
- 33:53me. There had to be a better name. That's all
- 33:55I'm trying to say. I hope people didn't listen
- 33:57to that and they're like, oh, that's why they
- 33:59didn't like this comedy movie. They have zero
- 34:01understanding of comedy. They don't know what's
- 34:03in ketchup. No, so I'll finish my thought. So
- 34:07he opens his own restaurant called the Anglo
- 34:09-American Grill, workshop that, and he invites
- 34:13everyone. from the Midwest to anyone that he
- 34:16interacted with back in England, including people
- 34:20he's worked for previously, invites them to come
- 34:23try this. And he sees the culture clash. He sees
- 34:26there's some people that really are like, oh,
- 34:28well, this is wonderful, and I'm your clientele
- 34:30moving forward. And then you have people from
- 34:33the Midwest that are like, yeah, it's a little
- 34:34different, but okay, I guess I'm willing to try
- 34:36it. And he sees specifically there is one man,
- 34:39and I got to tell you, this is probably my own
- 34:41ignorance than it is the movie's fault. It might
- 34:43be both. I'm not sure the man who is being vocal
- 34:47about judging people and judging the food, if
- 34:50that was his previous, I'm going to say master,
- 34:53doesn't feel good, but I can't think of another
- 34:55way to put it, employer. If that was his previous
- 34:57master or if it was another person who had it
- 35:01out for him. You know who I think it was? Because
- 35:04he kept saying a name, and the name that he'd
- 35:06say was Belknap Jackson. I'm pretty sure that's
- 35:10who it was. That was the couple who were friends
- 35:14of the Flouds, and they fired Ruggles at one
- 35:18point. Yeah. And then the Flouds were like, you
- 35:20don't work for them. Yeah, exactly. You work
- 35:22for us. So George Earl of Bernstead, who was
- 35:25Roland Young, he was not... Okay, that makes
- 35:29more sense. I was like, man. Because he at one
- 35:31point tries to bring him back. That's the Duke.
- 35:33Yes, that's the dude. He tries to bring him back,
- 35:35and he's like, ah, no, I'm good. Well, and the
- 35:37detractor there, he's introduced to Nell, I believe,
- 35:42who's just this pretty dame, I guess, and he
- 35:46falls for her. He plays a drum set. He does.
- 35:49It's like watching a British man be like, yes,
- 35:53look at... That scene was painful as a drummer.
- 35:58I have to let you know. When she leaned over
- 36:00and she was like, hey, when I say boom, boom,
- 36:02you got to do that on the drum. He's like, great.
- 36:04And then he says boom, boom. Look, maybe this
- 36:07is me, a result of me being in a band where so
- 36:10many people are like, hey, Ryan, I'm thinking,
- 36:12I want you to realize, you're a guitarist. I
- 36:15want you to realize that when people tell you,
- 36:17hey, play this, I'm thinking more maybe like
- 36:19an A over B flat with a C sharp ring out. They're
- 36:23specific. with drummers anyone else who plays
- 36:27an instrument is like hey maybe you can do like
- 36:29a like something and i'm like i i need a little
- 36:35bit more i speak that so when she said boom boom
- 36:38when i say this i'm like yeah i got you i know
- 36:40what you need he didn't he wasn't speaking drummer
- 36:43and that's his fault i want to remake this movie
- 36:45and have kurt kurt russell younger Everybody
- 36:49would be younger than they are right now, but
- 36:51Kurt Russell would play Egbert Flaude. Yep. Oh,
- 36:55great casting. The Duke here, Tim Curry. Oh,
- 36:58yeah. Yeah. And would you still do Charles Lawton
- 37:02as Ruggles? Yeah, I haven't thought that far
- 37:05into it, so sure. He can stick around, I guess.
- 37:09It's fine. We're just playing with time here.
- 37:10Yeah. Yeah, so he... He opens this restaurant
- 37:15and he's getting some detractors specifically
- 37:17from Belknap Jackson. And he really loses it
- 37:22whenever someone at the floud's table announces
- 37:25that they're getting engaged. Yeah, I don't remember
- 37:27who that was. And the woman, the bride -to -be,
- 37:31used to be a dancer. And Belknap Jackson is saying,
- 37:34once a dancer, always a dancer, judging her.
- 37:37And when Ruggles overhears this... That's when
- 37:40he stands up and he's like, this is too much.
- 37:42You can judge my food and you can make fun of
- 37:45me all you want. You can't make fun of someone
- 37:47for the life that they chose. Right. And he kicks
- 37:51him out and makes it very public. And Belknap
- 37:54Jackson says, hey, if you kick me out, you're
- 37:56kicking out all my clientele, your clientele
- 37:58with me. Because they are all the people who
- 38:00are also going to eat here. Yes. And he takes
- 38:03that chance and says, too bad, and kicks him
- 38:05out. The line he says is what? Yeah. He's basically
- 38:08like, if. The clients who are like you. If my
- 38:13success is determined. Yes, that's what it is.
- 38:15I should have just had you say it. I'm hoping
- 38:17you can finish it because I know that first part.
- 38:19That's it. If my success is determined by your
- 38:23type, then I don't want it, basically. That's
- 38:26basically it. He's more Charles Ruggles than
- 38:29that. Well, he's more Charles. It's good. I like
- 38:32that scene. Ultimately. I think it's cool when
- 38:34he kicks him out. I'm like, finally. Yes. A little
- 38:36backbone. And then you see some people stand
- 38:38up. There's a woman who's like, well, I never.
- 38:40And her husband's like, just sit down. And like
- 38:42makes her sit down. And you see Charles Lawton
- 38:45Ruggles run into the kitchen. And he's like,
- 38:47well, that's it. I'm done. I'm finished. I failed.
- 38:49We've both done the same thing now where we say
- 38:51Charles Ruggles, but it's just Ruggles. I said
- 38:54Charles Lawton Ruggles. Okay. Yeah. But he plays...
- 38:57This is confusing. His name is Ruggles in the
- 39:00movie, but Charles Ruggles plays another man
- 39:02named Egbert, but Charles Lawton plays Ruggles.
- 39:04This is... So many Ruggles. We're off the plot.
- 39:07Ruggles runs into the kitchen and says, I failed.
- 39:09I'm done. This is it. I've lost it. Everyone's
- 39:12leaving. And what he doesn't know is that in
- 39:14the room, they have started a chant for him.
- 39:19And they have done a toast in the name of Ruggles.
- 39:22And Charles Lawton's... character is then celebrated
- 39:26and it is he's a jolly good fellow that's what
- 39:29it is for he's a jolly good fellow and this is
- 39:31to me when i'm like yeah i know like i i see
- 39:35what we're doing we are capra all the way down
- 39:37is we are doing a two minute for he's a jolly
- 39:41good fellow ceremony for charles lotten and it's
- 39:46emotional and a little like a little bit it's
- 39:49not like you know i'm not in tears but i was
- 39:52like okay that's nice But I see what we're doing.
- 39:54I'm seeing like we are accepting of your culture.
- 39:56And you thought that like by standing up, you
- 39:58were going to be this bad person. But actually,
- 40:00that makes you a good person. And we're going
- 40:01to celebrate that. And that's what America is.
- 40:03And I was like, yeah, I get it. But it also feels
- 40:07a little unearned. And I'm not sure why that
- 40:09is. Maybe that's something I have to like wrestle
- 40:10with in myself. But there's something about that
- 40:13that just feels kind of like we got to wrap this
- 40:14up. Yeah, yeah. I don't think that. It's displayed
- 40:18enough throughout the movie, like him coming
- 40:20to terms with, oh, I am my own person and stuff.
- 40:23It all kind of hits at once. And it is at the
- 40:26end of the movie, unfortunately. He does have
- 40:28that moment where he says, oh, the Duke has come
- 40:32back to take me to England. And I guess I'll
- 40:34go because that's what I am. And we didn't mention
- 40:37Zazu Pitts plays Miss Judson, like the love interest.
- 40:42She kind of convinces him, like, listen. I thought
- 40:46you were better than that. Like I knew you weren't
- 40:49American, but now I'm finding out you're not
- 40:51a man, which was a sick burn. That's a sick burn.
- 40:54Yeah. And she kind of convinces him to, to stand
- 40:56up for himself, which leads to the end of the
- 40:58movie. But that's kind of the only moment of
- 41:01like, like I felt he was really starting to change.
- 41:05And it takes away from that, that finale of really
- 41:09hitting hard. I think I did think it was funny
- 41:11when he comes out to, for he's a jolly good fellow
- 41:14and he starts singing. himself yeah that was
- 41:17pretty funny yeah and everyone starts laughing
- 41:19but not kind of at him more just more like oh
- 41:21you don't know what we're doing yeah oh that
- 41:23that ruggles that ruggles so cute the only other
- 41:26thing that i liked about that i'm sorry i think
- 41:28charles ruggles in that moment calls him like
- 41:30uh An old bowl of soup. He does. You old bowl
- 41:33of soup. Yeah. But like, that's a continuation
- 41:35of what he did previously where he and his friend
- 41:37were like, you coyote, you old donkey, like just
- 41:41making fun of each other with things I didn't
- 41:42understand, but that's fine. The other thing
- 41:44I liked about this was when Charles Lawton comes
- 41:47out, he's embracing that this song is about him
- 41:50and he sees his love interest kind of coming
- 41:53out of the kitchen and she like, you know, is
- 41:54cheering for him and he tries to pull her out
- 41:56and she pulls herself back in. Pulls her out.
- 41:58She pulls herself back in. Pulls her out. She
- 42:00pulls herself back in. And then Charles Ruggles'
- 42:03character, Egbert, just pushes both of them into
- 42:06the kitchen so they can have their moment and
- 42:08then everyone else out can celebrate. And I thought
- 42:11this was great. Like, you know, it's a good ending,
- 42:13but again, it just feels kind of unearned for
- 42:16what came before. And there's that connective
- 42:18tissue of the ending that is missing throughout
- 42:21the rest of the movie. So in a further breakdown
- 42:24with you, I'm seeing more of the vision. Like
- 42:27it's not easy to see that vision when you're
- 42:29watching this movie. And I see the vision now.
- 42:31I think it is inconsistent. And I feel like it
- 42:34was not saw through all the way. Yeah. Which
- 42:37might be the same thing. But it stops it from
- 42:40being what I effective. It stops it from being
- 42:43ultimately effective. I agree. So when the movie
- 42:45ends, you're kind of like, okay. And you just
- 42:48kind of walk away from it. And it doesn't like
- 42:50sit with you and like, you know, resonate. And
- 42:53you're not like, wow, what a great performance
- 42:55overall. It's good. Charles Lawton is good. Imagine
- 42:58a world where that's not true. Even movies I
- 43:01can't really enjoy a ton, he's so over the top
- 43:05in Private Lives of Henry VIII and Barretts of
- 43:07Wimple Street. But I found that little subtlety
- 43:10in his performance in Les Mis that's like, oh,
- 43:12I've unlocked Charles Lawton. And I have a lot
- 43:15of appreciation. for him now that i know that
- 43:18he can pull off a comedic performance like this
- 43:20but i think that maybe they anticipated it to
- 43:23be more of a comedy than it really was and it
- 43:26was just more kind of like a slice of life americana
- 43:28version of something we've seen before and we'll
- 43:31see again yeah but not done as well i i really
- 43:35do feel like capra over at columbia was was working
- 43:39on so many other things and if he would have
- 43:42picked up this story the 1915 novel yeah like
- 43:46This would have been a greater success, at least
- 43:49for us, I think. Obviously, it did well at the
- 43:54box office, quote unquote. But yeah, I think
- 43:57it would have held like more weight historically
- 43:59if Capra had been the one to do it. Because like
- 44:02you said, I love that you brought this up at
- 44:04the beginning of the episode because it has kind
- 44:06of shifted my perspective on the movie. Not that
- 44:08I've enjoyed it more, but I can see how this
- 44:11is a very traditional like Capra -esque story.
- 44:14You know what I love about that? Thank you for
- 44:16saying that, because it doesn't mean a lot that,
- 44:18like, you know, I can say something that kind
- 44:19of influences this, and I have influence on the
- 44:21conversation, which is nice. But... I think it's
- 44:24very funny that the two times I've done this
- 44:26so far are when I mention Frank Capra and Baby
- 44:28Girl. Yeah. You're like, yeah, you're right.
- 44:31So two very different, if you really think about
- 44:34it, ways. Yeah, this is a weird one. And again,
- 44:38it's not like necessarily a terrible movie. It's
- 44:40not. It's just kind of harmlessly meandering.
- 44:45Yeah. There's so much in the middle of this movie.
- 44:48You mentioned Capra, not Capra. You mentioned
- 44:51Lawton and his performance being good. But I
- 44:54really do feel like it is just too little for
- 44:57me to love the main character in this movie.
- 45:00All of the laughs for me came from Charles Ruggles.
- 45:03And most of the comedy kind of comes from looking
- 45:09at Charles Lawton's face and just being like,
- 45:12he's uncomfortable. And that's kind of it. True.
- 45:17Like he has the moment where he... does get drunk
- 45:19with Floud and his buddy, and he starts yahooing
- 45:24and yippeeing and all of that, and you're kind
- 45:27of just supposed to look at it and be like, look,
- 45:29it's Charles Ruggles doing something that he
- 45:32normally does, I guess, over acts, but now he
- 45:35has to do it reserved. It's interesting that
- 45:38it's Charles Ruggles, but it's not interesting
- 45:40in an entertainment sense. Interesting that it's
- 45:44Charles Lawton? Yes. Boy, what are we doing?
- 45:47I know. So maybe that's why they did Charlie
- 45:51Ruggles, honestly, now that we think about it.
- 45:53We should just call him Charlie. I'll push back
- 45:57a little bit. I agree with you that that's kind
- 46:00of like you end up just seeing like, oh, I wonder
- 46:02how uptight Ruggles feels about this. But that
- 46:06scene specifically where he does the yahoo and
- 46:08yippeeing, I actually want to applaud Lawton
- 46:10a little bit with that performance because the
- 46:12way he does it is there's like a beat of silence.
- 46:15Where, like, no one's speaking. And then almost
- 46:17as if he's possessed. Like, his mouth is doing
- 46:20something different than his eyes are. Like,
- 46:22his eyes are just kind of, like, half asleep,
- 46:24like, closed. And he just goes, like, yippee!
- 46:26Over and over. And his eyes are like, who did
- 46:28that? And, like, he looks possessed. Like, he
- 46:30doesn't even know what just happened. And I really
- 46:32like that. Because it feels like, well, that's
- 46:34not necessarily something I would do normally.
- 46:37Right. And I thought that was, like, interesting.
- 46:40Again, it's not very funny, but it's just more
- 46:42like, oh, what a cool character work. That's
- 46:44exactly what I was going to say is I appreciate
- 46:46that and the choices he's making with the character,
- 46:49but did you laugh? No. That's where I'm getting
- 46:53at. And I think he tried his best, obviously,
- 46:56bringing in a veteran comedy director like Leo
- 46:58McCary from Duck Soup. He did the right thing
- 47:01of trying to make that happen. But again, I feel
- 47:03like both in a comedy and in the emotionality
- 47:07of the movie, the heart of it. Maybe just tag
- 47:10in Frank Capra next time. That was a guy who
- 47:12was really threading the needle on those kinds
- 47:14of movies. Because it's not like he came out
- 47:16of the gate with Lady for a Day. He's been doing
- 47:19that for years before. Yeah. It's just like Lady
- 47:22for a Day is what gets him recognized, and then
- 47:23It Happened One Night is what catapults him to
- 47:25stardom. And then that ushers in like, hey, did
- 47:28you make a movie this year? It's nominated for
- 47:30Best Picture. Right. which is kind of what he's
- 47:32known for moving forward. So again, maybe this
- 47:35is like us looking back with 90 year old tinted
- 47:39glasses, like of like what it actually means
- 47:42back then. But it just kind of feels like a lady
- 47:45for a day type story with that slice of Americana
- 47:48and that heart that doesn't really feel as earned,
- 47:51despite a really strong scene in that Gettysburg
- 47:53address in the saloon, which I think was called
- 47:56the silver dollar, silver dollar, which I thought
- 47:58was a cool name. I like that. I think that's
- 48:01the name of like 90 % of saloons in 1908. Yeah.
- 48:05Yeah. Maybe, you know what? Another issue that
- 48:07I have with this movie real quick is at one point
- 48:10you mentioned that Ruggles gets fired by someone
- 48:13who is not his employer. And for some reason
- 48:15he takes it very seriously. And he's like, yep,
- 48:17that legally means I'm fired. I don't think so,
- 48:22but sure. Whatever you say. And he skips town
- 48:24and he's waiting for a train. And he's like,
- 48:26all right, well, I guess I'm going to go grab
- 48:28some free food because now I'm poor. And he goes
- 48:30to the silver dollar spot or silver dollar saloon
- 48:33and waits to get some free food. Sees it's pickled
- 48:37feet. He's like, actually, I don't want to do
- 48:38this anymore. And that's what he runs into Egbert.
- 48:42And Egbert's just chilling out. And he's like,
- 48:44hey, man, what's going on? He's like, I'm fired.
- 48:45He's like, no, you're not. I didn't fire you.
- 48:48So you're not fired. And he's like, oh, yeah,
- 48:49good point. what's going on? Like, why is this
- 48:52a 30 second? I don't mean to do a Tucker Carlson,
- 48:54like what's going on? But like there, there was
- 48:56like a 90 second, like plot point of like, I
- 48:59lost my job. Oh wait, no, I didn't. Anyways,
- 49:01let's keep going with the story. Yeah. All right.
- 49:03And then that ushers in the Gettysburg thing,
- 49:06which kind of makes you forget about how we even
- 49:07got there. But then again, 20 more minutes of
- 49:10this movie is left. Right. I will say that whole
- 49:12sequence just brought up a whole bunch of like,
- 49:15wow, what a, what a weird time. Because he goes
- 49:18to the train station, talks to the guy changing
- 49:20the times. And he's like, hey, do you know where
- 49:22I can get a meal? And he goes, oh, Silver Dollar's
- 49:25serving a free meal. And I'm like, wow, that's
- 49:29cool. And then he's like, hey, do you mind if
- 49:31I leave my bags with you? He's like, yeah, I'll
- 49:33watch. And I'm like, wow, that's cool. The way
- 49:36he's overly friendly and knows that kind of stuff.
- 49:39And the camera kind of lingers on him just a
- 49:41little bit too long as Charles Lawton leaves
- 49:43the screen. I was kind of waiting for some guy
- 49:46to be like. How many times have I told you not
- 49:48to write on this board? You don't work here.
- 49:50Yeah, get out of here. He's like, oh, sorry,
- 49:51and, like, leaves. And then the train comes up
- 49:53immediately. Yeah, and then the bags are, like,
- 49:55left there and someone takes it. Yeah. I was
- 49:57kind of waiting for that because that's the beat
- 49:58that's given. But instead, like, it's just, nope,
- 50:01I'm just very helpful and know everything. It's
- 50:03like, oh, man. And then I got annoyed because
- 50:05Ruggles shows up at the Silver Dollar and he's
- 50:08like, he had just said he's hungry. Yeah. Guy
- 50:10goes, what would you like? A small beer. you
- 50:14need food young man like yeah i think he tries
- 50:17to keep up the appearance like a front in front
- 50:19of all the people that know him as colonel that's
- 50:20the nickname he's been given so i think he's
- 50:22like yeah i'm gonna order a beer because that's
- 50:25what we do here and also hmm i think i'm a little
- 50:27famished i wonder if there's some food i can
- 50:29oh it's free wonderful right i think that's kind
- 50:32of what he's trying to do that's how i took it
- 50:34at least gotcha um but yeah they're like oh we
- 50:37got pickled pig's feet he's like actually i can
- 50:39die right actually i can just start Pass, pass.
- 50:43Let's talk ratings then. Yeah. I think we've
- 50:45done, most of this episode has been summarizing
- 50:48what we did or didn't like from the movie. So
- 50:50I'll just cut to the chase and say, I didn't
- 50:52love this. I gave it two stars. Yeah, I gave
- 50:56it two and a half. And I'll be honest, the half
- 50:58is because I think I've unlocked the Rosetta
- 51:02Stone of this movie. I think that figuring out
- 51:06the Frank Capra of it was like, oh, I see what
- 51:08you're trying to do. And now maybe I'm kind of
- 51:11giving it partial credit. So the half feels more
- 51:14kind of like, I don't want to say a pity half,
- 51:16but it's just kind of like, I think I understand
- 51:18what you're going for more now. And I appreciate
- 51:21it. But at the same time, it's just not effective.
- 51:23Well, the funny thing for me as well is you bring
- 51:27up Frank Capra and like this being probably most
- 51:29comparable to Lady for a Day. And I didn't like
- 51:33that. Right. So not only is this Lady for a Day,
- 51:37it's like a lesser version of that for me. Correct.
- 51:40So. Did you rate Lady for a Day two stars? I
- 51:43think so. I think I did. Interesting. Yeah. And
- 51:46this is like matched on that. I think, yeah,
- 51:50yeah, in my memory. I think if I went back and
- 51:52I watched Lady for a Day, maybe I would find
- 51:54some more enjoyment. This is why we need the
- 51:55quarter, because I think you would have thrown
- 51:57a 2 .25 and a 2 on this. Yeah, I think you're
- 51:59right. I think that sounds about right. Yeah,
- 52:032 .5 feels appropriate. I can't go higher. I
- 52:07know for a fact it can't go higher, it might
- 52:09go lower. But I feel like I understood what he's
- 52:11going for. And again, that Gettysburg scene is
- 52:13great. And Charles Lawton does give a good performance
- 52:15here. It's just, I think it's kind of not balanced
- 52:18out with whatever Leo McCary is trying to do
- 52:20with the comedy in this. Yeah, I agree. I want
- 52:22to shout out Videodrome in Atlanta. They did
- 52:25have a copy of this. There's a Universal Vault
- 52:28Series Blu -ray. However, it was checked out
- 52:32when I went. And I want to know, if you're listening,
- 52:36And you checked out the Ruggles of Red Gap copy
- 52:39from Videodrome. Call me. Because I want to know
- 52:43who you are. Is this when we find a shadow version
- 52:46of ourselves called Twice Upon a Time of the
- 52:48Oscars? Yeah. And we find out that there's another
- 52:50you? They're like dark versions of us. Dark Kyle?
- 52:54I loved Ruggles. And they all talk like... Who
- 52:59did we mention? Dane DeHaan before we were recording.
- 53:02I hate Claudette Colbert. Yeah, exactly. That
- 53:06is so funny to think there's a dark Kyle that's
- 53:09like, Norma Shear. Ew. Well, a dark Ryan, too,
- 53:12who's like, Wallace Berry is trash. And everything
- 53:17he did was correct and right. Yes. Yeah. I would
- 53:20have shot the dog. I really hope his name is
- 53:24different than mine. Nope. It's just dark Ryan.
- 53:26Do you think it's just dark Ryan? It's Dark Ryan.
- 53:28It's Dark Ryan. You want to do double features?
- 53:30I desperately do. Although I would love to talk
- 53:33about dark versions of us for the remainder of
- 53:35time. I also don't know what I did in my voice.
- 53:37I think I just channeled some kind of demon.
- 53:40Perfect. My apologies to the pod on that. So
- 53:43my double feature, I think previously I've done
- 53:45Miss Peregrine Lives for a Day. I think I did
- 53:48that for Lady for a Day. Okay. And what's so
- 53:50funny is when I was thinking about this, that's
- 53:52how much it's like Lady for a Day, where I was
- 53:54like, oh, it reminded me a lot of Miss Peregrine
- 53:56Lives for a Day. And I was like, I've done that.
- 53:58Because there's another movie that also felt
- 53:59like that. However, I will tell you that this
- 54:03should be so up my alley because I love Downton
- 54:06Abbey. I love Miss Peregrine Lives for a Day.
- 54:08I love a movie that is like, hey, you know what?
- 54:11You deserve to treat yourself and be fancy. And
- 54:14thankfully, there's a whole subgenre of movies
- 54:17that do that. And the most recent one that I
- 54:19can think of was 2022's Anthony Fabian's Mrs.
- 54:23Harris Goes to Paris, in which I believe it's
- 54:26Isabel Hubert is Mrs. Harris. And she is a housekeeper
- 54:32who keeps to herself and her husband has passed.
- 54:34And she's saving as much money as possible for
- 54:37a dress. And she realizes, you know what? I'm
- 54:40going to fly to Paris and I'm going to buy this
- 54:42dress. And she finds herself entangled with a
- 54:46fashion designer and getting more involved in
- 54:48the fashion of France. And it is an absolutely
- 54:51harmless, peaceful slice of life. Like just a,
- 54:54she gets to live for more than a day. a whole
- 54:57weekend perhaps, and they make her a dress. And
- 55:00it is just so sweet and fun and a nice little
- 55:03romantic comedy. I had a great time with it.
- 55:05And she helps other people kind of like unlock
- 55:06their realizations of life of how they shouldn't
- 55:10take things so seriously. So she brings kind
- 55:12of that like English sensibility to like a French
- 55:14lifestyle. And I think that's what they're trying
- 55:17to do with Ruggles of Red Gap is bring an English
- 55:19sense to an American lifestyle or even an American
- 55:21sense to an English lifestyle and find the balance
- 55:24in that. And we're just humans after all. And
- 55:26I feel like that's kind of what should have happened
- 55:28here if they weren't really going for the Americana
- 55:30sense of it, of he's a jolly good fellow. But
- 55:33that's just the inconsistency of this movie.
- 55:36I think there's more of a consistent, like, the
- 55:38movie has a tone, knows what it is, and sticks
- 55:40with it for Mrs. Harris Goes to Paris. Also,
- 55:43it's a very funny, rhyming name. So keep that
- 55:45as it is. But great movie. Totally recommend
- 55:48it. I think I've seen this. I think it was nominated
- 55:50for something one year. Oh, no. Not for Best
- 55:54Picture. I was about to say, don't do this to
- 55:56me. Probably costume designing, honestly. I think
- 55:58that's what it was. I do want to say your Lady
- 56:01for a Day double feature was Mickey Blue Eyes.
- 56:05Did I pair something with Miss Peregrine for
- 56:06a Day? I don't know. Go into your double feature.
- 56:09I'm going to look a little bit. So I went with
- 56:12the kind of fish out of water or just kind of
- 56:15being like showcasing a culture. in kind of a
- 56:20zany way but you're very much like oh that looks
- 56:23fun i like them in the way that like the flouds
- 56:27and all of the americans are very loud and rowdy
- 56:29but you're still like america am i right right
- 56:32so i went with uh my big fat greek wedding oh
- 56:36yeah yeah just you know seeing a greek family
- 56:40just be kind of bonkers but having the absolute
- 56:44most fun with them. Shout out to my favorite
- 56:47line in that movie where, what? No meat? What
- 56:50do you mean he don't eat meat? It's okay, I make
- 56:53lamb. Solid. So good. But yeah, solid double
- 56:57features all around. My God, I haven't done Miss
- 56:59Pettigrew lives for a day. Well, look, you can
- 57:01change it or you can save it because we're definitely
- 57:03going to fall upon this genre again. No, I'll
- 57:06keep it. But man, that's crazy. I could have
- 57:08swear I did that. We just watched Lady for a
- 57:10Day, and I was just screaming Miss Pettigrew
- 57:12the whole time, and I still go with Mickey Blue
- 57:14Eyes. Nope. Yeah. That's so funny. So, yeah,
- 57:17if you guys have any thoughts about, what is
- 57:20this, Ruggles of Red Gap, shoot us an email at
- 57:22outaopodcast at gmail .com. Even if you guys
- 57:26want to let us know, like, your double features
- 57:28or your favorite, like, fish -out -of -water
- 57:30movies, anything at all. Shoot us that email.
- 57:33We read those live. We read those on the ceremony
- 57:37episode. Live to us. Yeah, and that's kind of
- 57:41an element of the podcast that's been a little
- 57:43bit lacking, but we want to see more of that.
- 57:46And if you want access to tons of cool stuff
- 57:50like the community Discord, early access to the
- 57:52shows, Horror of the Overlooked, our horror theme
- 57:55bonus podcast, check out patreon .com slash O
- 57:59-U -T -A -O podcast. And next time, we will be
- 58:04covering Naughty Marietta. Again, my nickname
- 58:08in high school. Yeah. It might be your nickname
- 58:11moving forward. Hey, yo, watch out. Because nice
- 58:13shorts, man. Watch out. Can you see up them?
- 58:15Shut up. Can you? I can't. Stop. No. Stop. Married.
- 58:18I'm just looking at your ankles. Stop. Oh, that's
- 58:20fine. Yeah. You should get out. Anyway, that's
- 58:25going to do it for this episode. As always, I'm
- 58:27Kyle. I feel violated. And we'll see you at the
- 58:30movies.