Latest / Kentucky Tonight / Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) in Higher Education
Transcript
- 0:05[♪♪]
- 0:11GOOD EVENING.
- 0:14WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:16I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:17THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:18OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: D-E-I IN
- 0:19KENTUCKY COLLEGES AND
- 0:20UNIVERSITIES.
- 0:20THOSE LETTERS STAND FOR:
- 0:22DIVERSITY, EQUITY, AND
- 0:23INCLUSION.
- 0:25SOME REPUBLICAN LAWMAKERS ARE
- 0:27PUSHING TO END OR RESTRICT DEI
- 0:28PROGRAMS IN KENTUCKY HIGHER
- 0:29EDUCATION.
- 0:31THEY ARGUE DEI IS DIVISIVE AND
- 0:32DISCRIMINATORY.
- 0:34DEI SUPPORTERS SAY DIVERSITY
- 0:36PROGRAMS ARE NECESSARY, BECAUSE
- 0:38THEY HELP PREVENT
- 0:41DISCRIMINATION.
- 0:41LAST WEEK, GOVERNOR ANDY BESHEAR
- 0:43CALLED DIVERSITY AN ASSET, NOT A
- 0:44LIABILITY.
- 0:45TO DISCUSS THIS, WE ARE JOINED
- 0:47IN OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO BY:
- 0:49STATE REPRESENTATIVE TINA
- 0:51BOJANOWSKI, A LOUISVILLE
- 0:52DEMOCRAT; RICHARD NELSON,
- 0:53FOUNDER AND EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
- 0:54OF THE COMMONWEALTH POLICY
- 0:55CENTER; TRAVIS POWELL, VICE
- 0:58PRESIDENT AND GENERAL COUNSEL OF
- 1:00THE KENTUCKY COUNCIL ON
- 1:02POSTSECONDARY EDUCATION; AND
- 1:03ANDREW WALKER, ASSOCIATED
- 1:05PROFESSOR OF CHRISTIAN ETHICS
- 1:06AND PUBLIC THEOLOGY AT THE
- 1:07SOUTHERN BAPTIST THEOLOGICAL
- 1:08SEMINARY.
- 1:10WE’LL TALK TO THEM LATER• BUT
- 1:12FIRST, I SPOKE EARLIER TODAY TO
- 1:13STATE REPRESENTATIVE JENNIFER
- 1:17DECKER, A SHELBY COUNTY
- 1:18REPUBLICAN, WHO IS SPONSORING A
- 1:18BILL TO DISMANTLE DEI OFFICES AT
- 1:20KENTUCKY’S PUBLIC COLLEGES AND
- 1:22UNIVERSITIES, AND BAN WHAT THE
- 1:24BILL CALLS DISCRIMINATORY
- 1:26CONCEPTS.
- 1:28AS SHE TELLS US, DEI HASN’T
- 1:32LIVED UP TO ITS PROMISE.
- 1:36>> REPRESENTATIVE DECKER, THANK
- 1:38YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
- 1:39>> THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME,
- 1:42RENEE.
- 1:44>> Renee: A QUESTION BASIC TO
- 1:44YOU ABOUT WHY YOU FILED HOUSE
- 1:46BILL 9.
- 1:47WHAT DO YOU WANT TO ACCOMPLISH
- 1:49WITH THIS MEASURE?
- 1:52>> I FILED HOUSE BILL 9 PAUSE I
- 1:54CARE ABOUT THE STUDENTS OF
- 1:56KENTUCKY.
- 1:56ALL THE STUDENTS.
- 1:58THE LOW INCOME STUDENTS THE
- 2:01UNDERREPRESENTED STUDENTS I WANT
- 2:02ALL STUDENTS TO HAVE AN EQUAL
- 2:04OPPORTUNITY TO GO TO
- 2:07POST-SECONDARY SCHOOL, THE GREAT
- 2:10EQUALIZER.
- 2:12>> Renee: SOME WOULD SAY IT
- 2:14SEEMS LIKE IT IS AN ANTITHESIS
- 2:16TO THAT PHILOSOPHY BECAUSE IT
- 2:19DOES TARGET PROGRAMS, ACTIVITIES
- 2:20PERHAPS THAT HELPS
- 2:23UNDERREPRESENTED MARGINALIZED
- 2:24STUDENTS.
- 2:25DO YOU AGREE OR DISAGREE WITH
- 2:26THAT?
- 2:27>> I DISAGREE WHOLEHEARTEDLY.
- 2:29IN FACT, THE DATA THAT IS
- 2:34WONDERFUL DATA PRODUCED BY THE
- 2:37KENTUCKY STATS, SHOWS JUST THE
- 2:39OPPOSITE TO BE TRUE.
- 2:41THE DYE INITIATIVES HAVE BEEN
- 2:44DYE HAVE BEEN ON OUR CAMPUS
- 2:48STARTING IN 2011 AND THE DATA
- 2:51SHOWS SINCE 2011 WE HAVE LOST
- 2:55OVER 39,000 STUDENTS FROM OUR
- 2:56COLLEGE CAMPUSES.
- 2:59AND OF THAT NUMBER, OVER HALF
- 3:01MORE THAN 24,000 STUDENTS HAD
- 3:06BEEN LOW INCOME, BLACK STUDENTS.
- 3:08AND OF THAT NUMBER, LOW INCOME
- 3:12INSTATE BLACK STUDENTS WE HAVE
- 3:16LOST 34% SINCE 2011.
- 3:19SO I BELIEVE JUST THE OPPOSITE
- 3:20IS TRUE.
- 3:21I DO NOT BELIEVE DEI HAS LIVED
- 3:23UP TO ITS PROMISE TO BRING MORE
- 3:27DIVERSITY AND TO MAKE STUDENTS
- 3:29FEEL LIKE COLLEGE IS MORE
- 3:31ACCESSIBLE TO THEM.
- 3:32>> Renee: IN YOUR LEGISLATION,
- 3:33YOU CALL FOR ELIMINATING,
- 3:38DEBUNKING AND DEFUNDING DEI
- 3:42OFFICES, DEPARTMENTS, PERSONNEL,
- 3:44TELL US, DO YOU THINK THAT THAT
- 3:47IS APPROPRIATE AT THIS TIME?
- 3:49AND DOES THAT SUGGEST THAT THERE
- 3:52IS NO REMNANTS OF RACISM LEFT TO
- 3:54BE DEALT WITH IN YOUR PROPOSAL
- 3:58FOR ABOLISHING THOSE OFFICES?
- 4:00>> THE DEI OFFICES ON OUR CAMPUS
- 4:04ARE NOT WHO IS CHARGED WITH
- 4:07ENSURING AGAINST DISCRIMINATION
- 4:09ON OUR CAMPUSES.
- 4:11FEDERAL LAW ALREADY REQUIRES
- 4:13THAT EACH COLLEGE CAMPUS THAT
- 4:16RECEIVES FEDERAL FUNDING HAS
- 4:17OFFICES TO ENFORCE
- 4:21NONDISCRIMINATORY CONDUCT TO
- 4:24ENSURE EQUAL OPPORTUNITY FOR
- 4:26ALL.
- 4:26THOSE OFFICES ARE ON EVERY
- 4:28COLLEGE CAMPUS AND THEY SHOULD
- 4:30BE ADEQUATELY FUNDED TO ENSURE
- 4:33THE VERY THINGS YOU ARE TALKING
- 4:35ABOUT.
- 4:37THE DEI OFFICES ARE NOT THOSE
- 4:40OFFICES.
- 4:40THEY ARE SUPERFLUOUS AND THEY
- 4:43NEED TO END, THEY NEED TO STOP
- 4:46THAT FUNDING SHOULD BE SPENT ON
- 4:48INITIATIVES AT THAT TIME
- 4:49ACTUALLY HELP.
- 4:50WE CANNOT CONTINUE TO FUND THOSE
- 4:53OFFICES WHEN THE DATA SHOWS THEY
- 4:55HAVE NOT HELPED.
- 4:59>> Renee: ARE DISCRIMINATORY
- 5:01CONCEPTS DEFINED IN HOUSE BILL
- 5:039?
- 5:03>> THEY ARE DEFINED AND WE ARE
- 5:05LOOKING AT THAT DEFINITION MORE.
- 5:07IT MAY CHANGE.
- 5:08BUT, YES, IT IS DEFINED IN THE
- 5:10BILL.
- 5:11>> Renee: AND HOW IS IT DEFINED?
- 5:13>> IT'S NOW DEFINED AS CONCEPTS
- 5:17THAT ARE TAKEN AS TRUE THAT ARE
- 5:22PROMOTE PREFERENCES AND THAT
- 5:25PROMOTE DISKIMMER TO CONCEPTS
- 5:27WITHOUT DEBATE, WITHOUT ALLOWING
- 5:29FOR DEBATE.
- 5:30SO THERE IS NO CONCEPT THAT IS
- 5:31OFF LIMITS ON A COLLEGE CAMPUS.
- 5:34BUT IT CANNOT BE PROMOTED IN IT
- 5:37IS A DISCRIMINATORY CONCEPT BY
- 5:40THE UNIVERSITIES.
- 5:41>> Renee: AND ARE YOU CONCERNED
- 5:42THAT THIS LEGISLATION COULD
- 5:46INFRINGE UPON ACADEMIC FREEDOM?
- 5:47THERE IS A SECTION OF YOUR BILL
- 5:49THAT SAYS IT SHALL NOT INFRINGE
- 5:52UPON ACADEMIC FREEDOM BUT
- 5:54SOMETIMES THE INTERPRETRATION OF
- 5:56DISCRIMINATORY CONCEPTS AND THE
- 5:58OTHER PROVISIONS THAT YOU
- 6:00OUTLINE COULD BE SUBJECTED COULD
- 6:01IT NOT AND OPEN TO
- 6:03INTERPRETATION?
- 6:04>> IT SHOULD NOT BE, NO.
- 6:06I THINK THE BILL IS VERY CLEAR
- 6:08THAT ALL CONCEPTS ARE TO BE
- 6:11DISCUSSED.
- 6:11WE ARE TO HAVE A FREE EXCHANGE
- 6:13OF IDEAS WHICH IS NOT TAKING
- 6:15PLACE ON OUR CAMPUSES OR SO
- 6:18WE'VE HEARD FROM FACULTY AND
- 6:19FROM STUDENTS.
- 6:21WE WANT NOTHING TO BE OFF
- 6:23LIMITS.
- 6:23WE WANT ALL IDEAS TO BE
- 6:26DISCUSSED.
- 6:26ALL MATTERS OF HISTORY.
- 6:28BUT NOT IN THE LENS OF ONE
- 6:33IDEOLOGICAL CONCEPT TAKEN AS
- 6:34TRUE THAT CANNOT BE REFUTED.
- 6:38>> Renee: HAVE YOU HEARD DIRECT
- 6:39COMPLAINTS IN KENTUCKY, I KNOW
- 6:41THERE IS OTHER LEGISLATION AND
- 6:43LAWS FLORIDA, TEXAS, SIMILAR TO
- 6:46THIS, BUT IN KENTUCKY, ARE THERE
- 6:48SUBJECT STAINIATED CASES OF BOTH
- 6:50STUDENTS AND FACULTY FEELING
- 6:52LIKE THEY'VE HAD TO BELIEVE AND
- 6:55EXPRESS THEIR BELIEF IN A
- 6:57PARTICULAR IDEOLOGY THAT YOU
- 6:59WOULD CONSIDER DISCRIMINATORY IS
- 7:01THAT SUBSTANTIATED?
- 7:02>> IT IS SUBSTANTIATED.
- 7:05THERE WILL BE TESTIMONY IN
- 7:06COMMITTEE ON THOSE POINTS BY
- 7:08FACULTY AND BY STUDENTS.
- 7:10AND IT'S NOT WHAT I CONSIDER
- 7:12DISCRIMINATORY.
- 7:13IT'S WHAT OUR CONSTITUTION AND
- 7:15OUR CASE LAW CONSIDERS
- 7:19DISCRIMINATORY.
- 7:19>> Renee: AND AS YOU MENTIONED
- 7:21EARLIER, YOU BELIEVE THERE IS
- 7:24INFRASTRUCTURE ALREADY IN PLACE
- 7:26TO ALLOW FOR ATTENTION TO
- 7:30DISADVANTAGED, MARGINALIZED, LOW
- 7:32INCOME STUDENTS THEREFORE KNEE
- 7:34DATING THE NEED FOR DEI OFFICES
- 7:36AND EFFORTS?
- 7:38>> YES.
- 7:38IN FACT, ONE OF THE BEST
- 7:40EXAMPLES OF THAT IS DUAL CREDIT.
- 7:44THERE IS WHERE YOU SEE A GREAT
- 7:47GROWTH IN CREDENTIALING AND
- 7:51ACADEMIC ACHIEVEMENT.
- 7:52THAT HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH
- 7:55PREFERENCES BASED ON RACE,
- 7:59RELIGION, NATIONAL ORIGIN OR
- 8:00SEX.
- 8:00THAT IS THE KIND OF INITIATIVE
- 8:02WE NEED.
- 8:03WE NEED TO FOCUS ON PLACE AND
- 8:05NOT RACE.
- 8:07WE NEED TO REACH STUDENTS IN
- 8:10APPALACHIA OR IN OTHER PARTS OF
- 8:12OUR STATE THAT ARE IN THE WEST
- 8:14END OF LOUISVILLE.
- 8:16IN VARIOUS PLACES WHERE THERE
- 8:18ARE DISADVANTAGED STUDENTS WHO
- 8:22NEED EXTRA ATTENTION BY OUR
- 8:24COLLEGES.
- 8:25THAT'S WHERE WE NEED TO FOCUS
- 8:26OUR EFFORTS SO THAT KENTUCKY
- 8:30UNIVERSITIES CAN RETURN TO THE
- 8:32GREAT EQUALIZER THAT THEIR
- 8:35PROMISE WAS.
- 8:36IF THEY FAILED IN THE PAST WE
- 8:37NEED TO CORRECT THAT THROUGH THE
- 8:39PROPER FOCUS.
- 8:41>> Renee: REPRESENTATIVE DECKER,
- 8:43SOME MAY BE CONCERNED THIS IS A
- 8:45SLIPPERY SLOPE WHEREBY PROGRAMS
- 8:47THAT FOCUS ON ETHNIC STUDIES,
- 8:50WOMEN'S STUDIES, CELEBRATE BLACK
- 8:53HISTORY DURING FEBRUARY OR
- 8:55WOMEN'S HISTORY DURING MARCH,
- 8:57COULD BE IN DANGERED.
- 8:58IS THAT THE DIRECTION THAT YOU
- 9:01AND OTHERS WOULD LIKE KENTUCKY
- 9:03TO GO IF HOUSE BILL 9 IS
- 9:06SUCCESSFUL IN FINAL PASSAGE?
- 9:07>> HOUSE BILL 9 DOES NO SUCH
- 9:10THING, DOES NOT START DOWN ANY
- 9:12SLOPE IN THAT AREA.
- 9:16ACTACADEMIC THOSE DISCIPLINES TT
- 9:18YOU'VE TALKED ABOUT, TO MY
- 9:20KNOWLEDGE DO NOT INCLUDE THE
- 9:23PROMOTION OF PREFERENCES.
- 9:27THE DISCRIMINATORY CONCEPTS OF
- 9:30THAT OUR CONSTITUTION PROHIBITS.
- 9:33I TOOK BLACK STUDIES.
- 9:34I DIDN'T MAJOR IN IT BUT SOME OF
- 9:39MY GREATEST TIMES AT COLLEGE
- 9:40WERE STUDYING THE GREAT WRITINGS
- 9:45OF --
- 9:45THOSE WILL NOT DEI CONCEPTS.
- 9:47AT ALL.
- 9:49SO I'M SURPRISED WHEN I HEAR
- 9:52THAT, BECAUSE AS DEFINED IN OUR
- 9:57STATUTE, DISCRIMINATION, THE
- 9:58CONCEPTS THAT WE WANT TO STOP ON
- 10:00OUR CAMPUS ARE UNCONSTITUTIONAL.
- 10:03THEY ARE DISCRIMINATORY.
- 10:08THEY PROVIDE PREFERENCES OR HARM
- 10:12BASED ON GROUP MEMBERSHIP.
- 10:15I DON'T BELIEVE THOSE
- 10:17DISCIPLINES DO THAT AND I'M
- 10:20SURPRISED WHEN PEOPLE SAY THEY
- 10:22FEAR THAT'S ALMOST AN ALLEGATION
- 10:25ON THEIR PART THAT THOSE
- 10:27PROGRAMS INVOLVE THAT KIND OF
- 10:29TYPE OF DISCRIMINATORY CONCEPT,
- 10:31I DON'T BELIEVE THEY DO.
- 10:34>> Renee: MY FINAL QUESTION
- 10:35REPRESENTATIVE DECKER AND I
- 10:36APPRECIATE YOUR TIME, ALONG
- 10:39THOSE SAME LINES ABOUT
- 10:42DISCRIMINATORY CONCEPTS AND JUST
- 10:43SO WE CAN HELP OUR VIEWERS
- 10:45UNDERSTAND SPECIFICALLY WHAT YOU
- 10:48MEAN, WOULD A CONCEPT SUCH AS
- 10:50WHITE PRIVILEGE BE CONSIDERED
- 10:52DISCRIMINATORY CONCEPT?
- 10:55>> WHITE PRIVILEGE THROUGHOUT
- 10:57HISTORY HAS GOT TO BE STUDIED.
- 10:59THERE'S NO DOUBT THAT THERE
- 11:02IS --
- 11:03THAT IS A DYNAMIC.
- 11:05WHAT THE BILL IS THAT WHAT IS
- 11:09PROHIBITED IS THE THOUGHT THAT
- 11:12EVERY INSTANCE THAT IS SPOKEN OF
- 11:15WHITE PRIVILEGE IS TO BE TAKEN
- 11:17AS TRUE NOT DEBATED, NOT
- 11:20DISCUSSED, AND THAT IT PERSISTS
- 11:24TODAY.
- 11:25AND IN EVERY POSSIBLE WAY THAT
- 11:26IT'S DISCUSSED.
- 11:28WE WANT OPEN, HONEST DEBATE WITH
- 11:33GOODWILL.
- 11:35WE WANT TO HAVE A FREE MARKET OF
- 11:39IDEAS.
- 11:40BANNING NO CONCEPT, WHATSOEVER,
- 11:45OTHER THAN THE CONCEPT THAT
- 11:48THESE MATTERS HAPPENED, THEY
- 11:51STILL HAPPEN, THEY PERSIST,
- 11:55WITHOUT DEBATE ON THE SUBJECT.
- 11:58>> Renee: AND THE REPERCUSSIONS
- 11:59THAT UNIVERSITIES COULD FACE FOR
- 12:01FAILING TO COMPLY WITH THE
- 12:03PROVISIONS OF HOUSE BILL 9
- 12:06INCLUDE WHAT?
- 12:06>> WELL, CURRENTLY THEY INCLUDE
- 12:09THE FACT THAT THE ATTORNEY
- 12:11GENERAL CAN HAVE A WRIT TO
- 12:15ENFORCE THESE LAWS ON THE CAMPUS
- 12:17AND THEY ALSO PROVIDE THE BILL
- 12:20CURRENTLY PROVIDES A PRIVATE
- 12:21CAUSE OF ACTION INCLUDING
- 12:23DAMAGES THAT CAN BE AWARDED.
- 12:25THAT MAY CHANGE PERHAPS WE WOULD
- 12:29CONSIDER LOOKING ONLY AT THE
- 12:31WAIVER OF IMMUNITY FOR
- 12:34INJUNCTION AND DECLARER TO
- 12:36RELIEF.
- 12:36THAT PART OF THE BILL IS STILL
- 12:38UNDER CONSIDERATION.
- 12:39>> Renee: REPRESENTATIVE DECKER
- 12:40THANK YOU SO VERY MUCH FOR YOUR
- 12:42TIME.
- 12:42WE APPRECIATE IT.
- 12:43>> THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
- 12:45THANK YOU FOR HAVING ME.
- 12:47>> Renee: SO NOW LET'S HEAR FROM
- 12:49OUR PANEL IN THE STUDIO.
- 12:50RIGHT NOW TO TRAVIS POWELL THE
- 12:52VICE-PRESIDENT GENERAL COUNSEL
- 12:54FOR THE CPE.
- 12:56YOU HEARD REPRESENTATIVE DECKER
- 12:57EXPLAIN HER BILL AND I WANT TO
- 12:58ASK YOU, CRITICS OF DIVERSITY
- 13:02RELATED OFFICES AND PROGRAMS
- 13:04THEY VIEW THEM AS DISCRIMINATORY
- 13:06AND YOU HEARD REPRESENTATIVE
- 13:08DECKER MAKE HER CASE ARE FOR
- 13:10THAT.
- 13:11YOUR REBUTTAL.
- 13:11>> AND THANKS FOR HAVING ME,
- 13:14RENEE.
- 13:14IT WAS INTERESTING BECAUSE WE'RE
- 13:17PROUD OF OUR DEI POLICIES AT CP
- 13:21DEFINE THEM BROADLY AND MAKE
- 13:23THEM AS INCLUSIVE AS WE CAN.
- 13:25AND IT'S INTERESTING THAT DEI
- 13:28POLICIES WOULD BE TIED PACK TO
- 13:30DECREASES OF ENROLLMENT OF LOW
- 13:33INCOME STUDENTS.
- 13:34I DON'T REALLY SEE I FAIL TO SEE
- 13:37THE CONNECTION.
- 13:38REPRESENTATIVE DECKER AND I WE
- 13:40HAVE TALKED ABOUT THIS.
- 13:41I CAN TELL YOU FROM OUR DATA
- 13:43WHILE ALL ENROLLMENT WAS DOWN
- 13:45ACROSS THE BOARD FROM 2011, AND
- 13:472011 WE WERE IN THE MIDDLE OF A
- 13:49RECESSION.
- 13:50LOTS OF FOLKS WENT BACK TO
- 13:52SCHOOL WHICH WAS GREAT AND WE
- 13:53HOPE TO GET THEM BETTER EMPLOYED
- 13:55MOVING FORWARD AND WE WOULD LIKE
- 13:57TO REENGAGE THAT POPULATION WITH
- 13:59LOW INCOME STUDENTS THEY WENT
- 14:02BACK TO WORK.
- 14:03WE LOST STUDENTS OF ALL TYPES
- 14:05LOW INCOME AND NON-LOW INCOME.
- 14:07BUT WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE SUCCESS
- 14:08RATES OF OUR LOW INCOME AND
- 14:11UNDERREPRESENTED STUDENTS FROM
- 14:142012-2013, RETENTION RATES ARE
- 14:15UP 8.5 POINTS.
- 14:21FOUR-YEAR RATES ARE UP 7.7
- 14:24PERCENTAGE POINTS FOR LOW INCOME
- 14:26STUDENTS AND 8.6 PERCENTAGE
- 14:30POINTS FOR UNDERREPRESENTED
- 14:32STUDENTS.
- 14:32GRADUATION RATES ARE UP 18.4
- 14:35PERCENTAGE STUDENTS AND 19.7
- 14:39POINTS FOR LOW INCOME.
- 14:41AND OUR FOUR YEAR INSTITUTIONS,
- 14:45OVERALL GRADUATION RATES ARE UP
- 14:4710.3 PERCENTAGE POINTS.
- 14:50URM IS UP MORE 12.4
- 14:54UNDERREPRESENTED MINORITY
- 14:55STUDENTS ARE UP 12.4 PERCENTAGE
- 14:58POINTS.
- 15:01I WOULDN'T SAY THAT ALL THAT
- 15:03EVEN THE SUCCESSES I TALKED
- 15:05ABOUT ARE ALL ATTRIBUTED TO THE
- 15:08DEI POLICIES BUT I CERTAINLY
- 15:09THINK THEY WOULD HELP AND THEY
- 15:11TAR DEATH THOSE POPULATIONS TO
- 15:13HELP THEM BE MORE SUCCESSFUL.
- 15:15>> Renee: WHEN YOU SAID THERE IS
- 15:17A BROAD DEFINITION FOR
- 15:19DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND INCLUSION
- 15:20WHO ARE THE GROUNDS AND HOW
- 15:21BROAD IS THAT GIVE US SPECIFICS?
- 15:23>> THE DEFINITION WE'VE HAD OF
- 15:26DIVERSITY IS PEOPLE WITH VARIED
- 15:28HUMAN CHARACTERISTICS, IDEAS,
- 15:30WORLD VIEWS AND BACKGROUNDS.
- 15:33DIVERSITY IN CONCEPT EXPECTS THE
- 15:34CREATION BY INSTITUTIONS OF A
- 15:36SAFE AND SUPPORTIVE ENVIRONMENT
- 15:38THAT HONORS AND RESPECTS THE
- 15:40DIFFERENCES.
- 15:40WE DON'T CALL OUT THE
- 15:42DIFFERENCES WE DEFINE IT
- 15:44BROADLY.
- 15:44WE LOOK AT LOW INCOME STUDENTS
- 15:47AND SET TARGETS THERE FOR OUR
- 15:50INSTITUTIONS FOR
- 15:51UNDERREPRESENTED MINORITY
- 15:52STUDENTS BECAUSE THERE ARE
- 15:53ACHIEVEMENT GAPS WITH THOSE
- 15:55POPULATIONS AND I MEAN THE GAP
- 15:56BETWEEN THE SUCCESS RATE OF
- 15:57THOSE STUDENTS AND THE GAP RATE
- 16:00OF OVERALL STUDENTS.
- 16:01SO WE'RE TRYING TO CLOSE THOSE
- 16:03GAPS.
- 16:03BUT WE DEFINE DIVERSITY TALKING
- 16:06ABOUT CAMPUS DIVERSITY AND THE
- 16:09EDUCATIONAL BENEFITS OF
- 16:10DIVERSITY FROM A DIVERSE STUDENT
- 16:13BODY WE ARE TALKING ABOUT LGBTQ
- 16:17STUDENTS, RELIGIOUS DIVERSITY,
- 16:18GEOGRAPHIC DIVERSITY ALL THE
- 16:20THINGS MAKE US WHO WE ARE WHICH
- 16:22MAKES A MORE INTERESTING AND
- 16:24INVITING STUDENT BODY AND ONE
- 16:26WHERE EVERYBODY CAN LEARN FROM
- 16:27EACH OTHER.
- 16:29>> Renee: ARE KENTUCKY
- 16:30UNIVERSITIES ASKING FACULTY OR
- 16:31CURRENT FACULTY AND STAFF AND
- 16:34STUDENTS TO EXPRESSLY GIVE THEIR
- 16:37CONSENT TO AGREE WITH AND ABIDE
- 16:39BY A SET OF IDEOLOGICAL POINTS
- 16:42WHETHER THEY BE POLITICAL,
- 16:44SOCIAL OR WHATEVER?
- 16:46PARTICULARLY UPON A CONDITION OF
- 16:47EMPLOYMENT?
- 16:48>> NOT THAT I'M AWARE OF.
- 16:50I'M NOT AWARE OF ALL THE
- 16:51EMPLOYMENT PRACTICES FOR ALL THE
- 16:53DISCIPLINES AND ALL THE CAMPUSES
- 16:55BOTH FACULTY AND STAFF.
- 16:56IT IS NOT MANDATED ANY POLICY
- 16:58LEVEL AT CPE AND NO OVERALL
- 17:01POLICY AT ANY INSTITUTION THAT
- 17:03I'M AWARE OF OUR ACCEPTANCE RATE
- 17:05AT MOST OF OUR UNIVERSITIES ARE
- 17:07IN THE 90% WE ARE LETTING ALL
- 17:10STUDENTS THAT ARE QUALIFIED TO
- 17:11COME TO OUR INSTITUTIONS.
- 17:13I AM NOT AWARE OF ANY.
- 17:15IT DOESN'T MEAN IT HASN'T HAPPEN
- 17:17AND I KNOW IT IS NOT A SYSTEMIC
- 17:19THING THAT WE'RE MANDATING.
- 17:22>> Renee: WE WANT TO INVITE YOU
- 17:23AS WE DO EVERY MONDAY NIGHT TO
- 17:25SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 17:28COMMENTS BY
- 17:31SEND US YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 17:32COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 17:33-- AT K-Y TONIGHT K-E-T.
- 17:33SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 17:34K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 17:34OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 17:35O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 17:36OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 17:37WELCOME TO OUR GUESTS.
- 17:43LET ME GO TO THIS SIDE I KNOW
- 17:45YOU ARE READY.
- 17:46I DO WANT TO ASK YOU, Mr.
- 17:48NELSON ABOUT WHAT YOU HEARD
- 17:49REPRESENTATIVE DECKER SAY AND WE
- 17:51WILL GET INTO ANOTHER BILL,
- 17:52SENATE BILL 6 PROPOSED BY THE
- 17:55WHIP MIKE WILSON IN JUST A
- 17:56MOMENT.
- 17:57TELL US YOUR PERSPECTIVE ABOUT
- 17:59THE BILL HOUSE BILL 9 AS
- 18:01REPRESENTATIVE DECKER EXPLAINED
- 18:02IT.
- 18:03>> WE SHOULD START FROM A POINT
- 18:04WHAT IS BEHIND DEI.
- 18:06I THINK THERE WAS A LOT OF
- 18:08GOODWILL BEHIND IT.
- 18:09THE GOAL WAS TO FIGHT RACISM,
- 18:12BIGOTRY AND MAKE HIGHER-ED
- 18:14WELCOMING TO ALL.
- 18:15TO BREAKDOWN SOME OF THE
- 18:17BARRIERS.
- 18:17I THINK THE ISSUE AT POINT THAT
- 18:20REPRESENTATIVE DECKER WAS TRYING
- 18:21TO SHARE PREVIOUSLY WAS THAT
- 18:24IT'S THE EQUITY PART AND THERE
- 18:25IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN EQUITY
- 18:28AND EQUALITY.
- 18:31EQUALITY AS WE UNDERSTAND IT IN
- 18:33THIS COUNTRY WE HAVE EQUAL
- 18:34OPPORTUNITY BEFORE THE LAW.
- 18:35WE ARE A COUNTRY UNDER LAW THE
- 18:37RULE OF LAW.
- 18:39EQUITY ON THE OTHER HAND IS
- 18:41EQUAL OUTCOMES AFTER THE LAWS IS
- 18:43APPLIED.
- 18:44AND I THINK WHAT WE'RE SEEING
- 18:46MANY OTHER STATES IN PARTICULAR,
- 18:47WHERE WE SEE DEI POLICIES AND
- 18:51PROCEDURES OR MANDATES THAT ARE
- 18:53COMING DOWN PARTICULARLY ON
- 18:55CONSERVATIVES, POLITICAL
- 18:57CONDITION ACTIVES AND RELIGIOUS
- 18:59CONSERVATIVES WHERE THEY ARE
- 19:00PUTTING THEIR FINGER ON THE
- 19:01SCALE AND THEY ARE ESSENTIALLY
- 19:05SAYING YOUR VIEWS ARE NOT
- 19:07ACCEPTABLE HERE.
- 19:07I DID GET AN E-MAIL FROM A
- 19:10PROFESSOR AT UNIVERSITY OF
- 19:11KENTUCKY WHO SHARED WITH ME HIS
- 19:14EXPERIENCE WITH DEI PROGRAMS HE
- 19:16DID NOT WANT HIS NAME TO BE
- 19:18MENTIONED HE DID NOT WANT HIS
- 19:20DEPARTMENT TO BE REFERRED TO.
- 19:21HE IS AFRAID TO TALK ABOUT IT.
- 19:23BEHIND THE SCENES CONVERSATIONS
- 19:25THAT HE'S HAD WITH COLLEAGUES,
- 19:27JUST BRINGING UP SOME REASONABLE
- 19:29CONCERNS, HE'S GOTTEN PUSHBACK.
- 19:32HE IS AFRAID FOR HIS JOB JUST TO
- 19:35SHARE HIS PERSPECTIVE ON THIS.
- 19:36JUST TO SHARE CONCERNS THAT HE
- 19:38HAS.
- 19:38THAT TELLS ME AND I DON'T KNOW
- 19:41THE DETAILS I WASN'T IN ON THE
- 19:42CONVERSATIONS BUT IT TELLS ME AT
- 19:44LEAST IN THAT SITUATION, THERE
- 19:46IS A CLIMATE THAT IS NOT
- 19:48FAVORABLE TO ANOTHER VIEW JUST
- 19:49QUESTIONING SOME OF THE DEI
- 19:51PRINCIPLES AND I SAY ANY POLICY
- 19:53ESPECIALLY THE THE UNIVERSITY
- 19:55LEVEL THAT WOULD STIFLE FREEDOM
- 19:58OF SPEECH, FREEDOM OF THOUGHT,
- 20:00THAT WOULD HAMPER DISCUSSION, WE
- 20:02NEED TO LOOK AT THOSE POLICIES.
- 20:04I DON'T HAVE ALL THE EXAMPLES
- 20:07AND TRAVIS DOESN'T EITHER, IT'S
- 20:09GOOD TO SEE YOU ON THE PROGRAM.
- 20:10I THINK THIS IS SOMETHING WHERE
- 20:12WE HAVE EXAMPLES FROM ACROSS THE
- 20:14COUNTRY WHERE YOU HAVE
- 20:16PROFESSORS, YOU HAVE STUDENT
- 20:19GROUPS, YOU HAVE OTHER PEOPLE
- 20:20THAT HAVE BEEN AFFECTED
- 20:23NEGATIVELY BY DEI POLICIES THAT
- 20:26IS WHY REPRESENTATIVE DECKER
- 20:28INTRODUCED HER BILL AND MIKE
- 20:29WILSON INTRODUCED HIS BILL IN
- 20:31THE SENATE TRYING TO PUSHBACK
- 20:33AGAINST THAT.
- 20:33WE ALL BENEFIT ONE THING WE CAN
- 20:36AGREE ON IS WHEN THERE IS
- 20:39FREEDOM TO DISCOURSE ON THE
- 20:41PUBLIC CAMPUS, WHEN THERE'S
- 20:45VIEWPOINT DIVERSITY, WHEN WE CAN
- 20:48FREELY ENGAGE IN THE
- 20:49CONVERSATIONS THAT BENEFITS
- 20:50EVERY SINGLE PERSON ACROSS THE
- 20:52POLITICAL SPECTRUM.
- 20:54AND THAT'S THOSE ARE THE THINGS
- 20:56WE SHOULD BE LOOKING FOR AND
- 20:56WHEN THERE IS A POLICY IN PLACE
- 20:58THAT WOULD UNDERMINE THAT THAT
- 21:00IS WHY WE ARE HAVING THIS
- 21:04CONVERSATION.
- 21:04>> Renee: REPRESENTATIVE, ARE WE
- 21:06UNDERMINING THAT TYPE OF
- 21:08ACADEMIC FREEDOM AND EXPRESSION
- 21:09WITH DEI POLICIES CURRENTLY IN
- 21:12PLACE.
- 21:12>> I WANT TO GO BACK AND RESPOND
- 21:13TO A COUPLE OF THINGS IF I
- 21:15COULD.
- 21:16THE FIRST ONE IS TO REP DECKER
- 21:18CORRELATION IS NOT CAUSATION.
- 21:20SO JUST BY HAVING DATE THAT
- 21:23CORRESPONDS WITH CERTAIN YEARS
- 21:24DOESN'T MEAN THAT DEI CAUSED AN
- 21:28INCREASE OR A DECREASE.
- 21:29I WOULD ALSO LIKE TO SHARE A
- 21:31DIFFERENT UNDERSTANDING OF
- 21:33EQUITY THAN Mr. NELSON.
- 21:35EQUITY IS AN EFFORT TO ENSURE
- 21:38EQUAL OPPORTUNITY NOT EQUAL
- 21:40RESULTS IN EDUCATION I AM A
- 21:41TEACHER AND EDUCATION THERE IS A
- 21:43GRAPHIC THAT COMES OUT.
- 21:45AND EQUALITY IS ALL THE THREE
- 21:48CHILDREN STANDING THE A FENCE
- 21:49LOOKING OVER THE FENCE.
- 21:51ONE IS A TALL CHILD, ONE IS A
- 21:53SHORT CHILD THEY ARE ALL
- 21:54STANDING ON THE GROUND AND THE
- 21:55SHORT PEOPLE CAN'T SEE OVER THE
- 21:57PHELPS.
- 21:58EQUITY IS GIVING EACH OF THEM A
- 22:01CUBE SO THEY CAN ALL SEE OVER
- 22:03THE FENCE ADEQUATELY.
- 22:06SO YOU KNOW, GIVING FINANCIAL
- 22:08AID FOR LOW-INCOME FAMILIES
- 22:10MIGHT BE AN EXAMPLE OF EQUITY.
- 22:13MY DAUGHTER BY THE TIME SHE GOT
- 22:15TO HIGH SCHOOL, WE HAVE SIBLINGS
- 22:18AND SHE HAD BEEN TO EUROPE THREE
- 22:21TIMES.
- 22:21THAT IS AN OPPORTUNITY THAT
- 22:23OTHER CHILDREN HAVEN'T HAD.
- 22:25OTHER CHILDREN MAY NEED AN
- 22:27OPPORTUNITY OR COLLEGE STUDENTS
- 22:28TO LEARN A LITTLE BIT MORE ABOUT
- 22:32SOCIETY AND HAVE EXTRA SUPPORT.
- 22:34SO I DON'T SEE EQUITY AS BEING
- 22:38AN INTENTION TO GIVE EQUAL
- 22:40RESULTS.
- 22:41I THINK IT IS HAVING THE
- 22:45ACCOMMODATIONS AND SUPPORTS IN
- 22:46LINE SO THAT PEOPLE HAVE EQUAL
- 22:49OPPORTUNITY.
- 22:51>> Renee: PROFESSOR WALKER
- 22:52WELCOME.
- 22:52I THINK YOU MAYBE TRAVIS HAS
- 22:54BEEN ON BEFORE IF I DENT'S
- 22:56WELCOME YOU I SHOULD HAVE.
- 22:57AS A NEW MEMBER THANK YOU FOR
- 22:59BEING HERE.
- 22:59I WANT YOU TO PICK UP AND YOU
- 23:02CAN COMMENT ON WHAT YOU HEARD
- 23:03REPRESENTATIVE DECKER DESCRIBE
- 23:04TO US AND REPRESENTATIVE TINA
- 23:09BOJANOWSKI'S QUETD OF OUTCOMES
- 23:11VERSUS EQUITY OF OPPORTUNITY AND
- 23:12HOW YOU VIEW THIS DISCUSSION
- 23:14AROUND DEI.
- 23:15>> I THINK EVERYONE SITTING UP
- 23:17HERE WE ARE ALL IN THE SAME PAGE
- 23:19THAT WE WANT TO CELEBRATE HUMAN
- 23:22DIVERSITY.
- 23:22I AMANY A CHRISTIAN.
- 23:24I BELIEVE EVERY HUMAN PERSON IS
- 23:26MADE IN GOD'S IMAGE THEY ARE THE
- 23:28BARRIER OF PROFOUND WORTH AND
- 23:30DIGNITY.
- 23:30I THINK THAT IS THE BEST
- 23:32STARTING PLACE TO THINK IN THIS
- 23:34DISCUSSION.
- 23:35THE IDEA THAT IF WE ARE EQUAL IN
- 23:37THE EYES OF GOD WE SHOULD ALSO
- 23:39BE EQUAL IN THE EYES OF THE LAW
- 23:40AS WELL.
- 23:41AND IN ALL OF THESE DISCUSSIONS
- 23:43THAT WE'RE HEARING ABOUT DEI,
- 23:46THEY ARE LOFT IDEALS THAT IN
- 23:48SOME RESPECTS A THE OF US COULD
- 23:50GET AROUND.
- 23:51BUT IN PRACTICE, DEI IS
- 23:54SOMETHING THAT IS FAR MORE
- 24:00NEFARIOUS IT IS A TROJAN HORSE
- 24:03FOR VERY PROGRESSIVE IDEOLOGY.
- 24:05WHENEVER THE TERM DEI IS BROUGHT
- 24:08INTO THE CONVERSATION IT IS
- 24:09BASICALLY A CODE WORD FOR
- 24:12PROGRESSIVE IDEOLOGY AND IF YOU
- 24:14DARE DISSENT FROM IT IT'S GOING
- 24:15TO HAVE A NEGATIVE REPERCUSSION
- 24:17ON YOU.
- 24:19I THINK ESPECIALLY WHEN WE SAW
- 24:22THE UNIVERSITY PRESIDENTS WHO
- 24:25GOT CALLED BEFORE CONGRESS IN
- 24:28THEIR INABILITY TO DENOUNCE
- 24:31GENOCIDAL LANGUAGE ON THE CAMPUS
- 24:33OF THESE ELITE IVY LEAGUE
- 24:36INSTITUTIONS.
- 24:37WHY WERE THEY UNABLE TO DENOUNCE
- 24:39GENOCIDAL LANGUAGE?
- 24:40IT WAS BECAUSE DEI STYLE
- 24:44POLICIES HAVE DESIGNATED JEWISH
- 24:46INDIVIDUALS AS AN OPPRESSOR
- 24:48CLASS AND EVERYONE WHO IS NOT, A
- 24:50PART OF THE OPPRESSED CLASS.
- 24:53AND SO THIS GOES TO SHOW YOU THE
- 24:56IMBALANCES, THE RELATIVISM THAT
- 24:59GOES INTO THIS DISCUSSION AROUND
- 25:00DEI.
- 25:01A STUDENT AT U OF L TODAY COULD
- 25:04MAKE A STATEMENT DEROGATORY
- 25:07TOWARDS A JEWISH STUDENT AND
- 25:10FEEL VERY LITTLE NEGATIVE
- 25:12REPERCUSSION.
- 25:13BUT IF YOU HAVE EVANGELICAL CAL
- 25:16STUDENT DARE TO OFFER THE WORDS
- 25:18THAT MARRIAGE IS THE UNION OF
- 25:20ONE MAN AND ONE WOMAN THERE
- 25:22WOULD BE A BIASED RESPONSE TEAM
- 25:24AND SOME TYPE OF INTIMIDATION
- 25:27TACTICS SPOKEN OR UNSPOKEN
- 25:29MAKING SURE THAT THAT STUDENT IS
- 25:31NOT GIVING OPPORTUNITIES BECAUSE
- 25:34THEY ARE DISSENTING FROM
- 25:36PROGRESSIVE IDEOLOGY.
- 25:36AND WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE MAKEUP
- 25:38OF THESE DEPARTMENTS THEY ARE
- 25:40UNIFORMLY HOUSED AND STAFFED BY
- 25:43PROGRESSIVE IDENTIFY LOGS THAT
- 25:44IS A FACT.
- 25:45YOU DO NOT SEE DEI OFFICES BEING
- 25:50PROPONENTS OF DIVERSITY.
- 25:50YOU SEE THEM BEING PROPONENTS OF
- 25:55COERCION, OF INTIMIDATION AND OF
- 25:57SILENCE.
- 25:57AND THE BILLS THAT
- 26:00REPRESENTATIVE DECKER, SENATOR
- 26:02WILSON HAVE PUT FORWARD ARE
- 26:04MERELY TRYING TO BRING A BALANCE
- 26:05TO THE EXCESS OF THESE
- 26:07DEPARTMENTS THAT HAVE BEEN
- 26:08RUNNING AMOCK FOR A GENERATION
- 26:11IT SEEMS NOW ALL OVER KENTUCKY
- 26:12AND ALL OVER THE NATION.
- 26:14>> Renee: I WANT YOU TO RESPOND
- 26:15TO THAT Mr. POWELL ARE THEY
- 26:18RUNNING AMOK WITH PREROGATIVE
- 26:22LIBERAL IDEOLOGY?
- 26:22>> I DON'T KNOW THE POLITICAL
- 26:24MAKEUP OF THE INDIVIDUAL MEMBERS
- 26:25OF THOSE OFFICES BUT I CAN TELL
- 26:28YOU LET ME TALK ABOUT OUR
- 26:30INVOLVEMENT IN DEI AND RICHARD
- 26:33YOU KNOW THIS BEING ON OUR BOARD
- 26:35FOR SEVERAL YEARS WE TALKED
- 26:36ABOUT IT AND I MENTIONED HOW
- 26:39BROADLY WE DEFINE IT.
- 26:41CPE IS CHARGED WITH APPROVING
- 26:43ACADEMIC PROGRAMS THE
- 26:44INSTITUTIONS BUT WE ARE TO
- 26:46POSTPONE THE APPROVAL OF NEW
- 26:48PROGRAMS UNLESS PUBLIC
- 26:50INSTITUTIONS MEET THEIR EQUAL
- 26:52EDUCATION OPPORTUNITY GOALS.
- 26:54WE OFFER OUR DIVERSITY, EQUITY
- 26:55AND INCLUSION POLICY.
- 26:56PTD WE DEFINE DIVERSITY BROADLY,
- 27:00EQUITY IN THE SAME WAY THAT HAS
- 27:01BEEN DISCUSSED WITH THE CREATION
- 27:03OF OPPORTUNITIES FOR
- 27:05HISTORICALLY UNDERREPRESENTED
- 27:06POPULATIONS TO HAVE EQUAL ACCESS
- 27:08AND PARTICIPATE IN EDUCATIONAL
- 27:09PROGRAMS.
- 27:10SO WE DEFINE THIS IN AN OPEN AND
- 27:12HONEST WAY.
- 27:14AND IT IS NOT ABOUT ANY --
- 27:16WE MAKE INSTITUTIONS PUT
- 27:17TOGETHER A DIVERSITY PLAN TO
- 27:20LOOK AT STUDENT SUCCESS AND
- 27:22ENROLLMENT AND LOOK AT CAMPUS
- 27:24CLIMATE.
- 27:25SO NONE OF THAT AND ANYTHING WE
- 27:27HAVE IN OUR POLICY THAT WE
- 27:29MANDATE WOULD REQUIRE ANY
- 27:31IDEOLOGY, REQUIRE THAT THOSE BE
- 27:32STAFFED BY ANYBODY THAT HAD A
- 27:35PROGRESSIVE IDEOLOGY.
- 27:36REALLY AND TRULY, AT LEAST FROM
- 27:38OUR PERSPECTIVE THOSE DEI
- 27:40OFFICES ARE SETUP TO HELP
- 27:42STUDENTS BE MORE SUCCESSFUL,
- 27:44FEEL MORE INCLUDED ON CAMPUSES.
- 27:47COULD WE BROADEN OUR FOCUS?
- 27:49PROBABLY SO.
- 27:50AND WE COULD CERTAINLY TAKE A
- 27:51LOOK AT THAT.
- 27:53AND REALLY MAKE SURE THAT WE'RE
- 27:54ADHERING TO OUR POLICY AND
- 27:56MAKING SURE WE'RE TAKING THAT
- 27:57VIEW OF A BROADVIEW OF DIVERSITY
- 28:04BUT ALL STUDENTS CAN BE
- 28:06SUCCESSFUL AND THEMSELVES.
- 28:07THAT IS THE GOAL.
- 28:09CPE AND WHAT WE TALK TO OUR
- 28:11CAMPUSES ABOUT.
- 28:11WHEN THEY TALK ABOUT THE
- 28:13STRATEGIES WHICH THEY HAVE TO
- 28:14TELL US EVERY YEAR, TO DO DEI
- 28:17EVERY YEAR ON THEIR CAMPUSES AND
- 28:19THEY ARE HAVING TO TELL US HOW
- 28:21EFFECTIVE THEY WERE AND AFTER
- 28:23THAT ANALYSIS DECIDE WHETHER OR
- 28:24NOT THEY WANT TO CONTINUE THEM.
- 28:26WHEN YOU LOOK AT THE POLICIES
- 28:28THEY DO NOT INCLUDE THE
- 28:30IDEOLOGICAL THINGS.
- 28:32>> Renee: Mr. POWELL WHO COULD
- 28:33BE AT RISK IF DEI OFFICES ARE
- 28:37ELIMINATED?
- 28:38>> I THINK IT DEPENDS.
- 28:39A LOT OF THIS AND OF COURSE, AS
- 28:41PART OF MY ROLE AS A LAWYER I
- 28:44LOOK AT THE LANGUAGE OF BILLS
- 28:45AND PART IS DEFINING HOW DO YOU
- 28:48DEFINE DEI OR DIVISIVE CONCEPTS,
- 28:52WE HAVE USED DEI AND I WOULD
- 28:55AGREE THEY HAVE BEEN USED AS A
- 28:57NEGATIVE TERM IN MANY WAYS AND
- 28:58MEANT SOMETHING IN THE MINDS OF
- 29:00A LOT OF PEOPLE PARTICULARLY ON
- 29:01A NATIONAL SCALE.
- 29:02I TOLD YOU HOW WE DEFINE IT AND
- 29:04I WOULD GUESS YOU WOULD AGREE
- 29:06THAT IS A GOOD, BROAD
- 29:10DEFINITION.
- 29:10BUT WHAT IS DEI?
- 29:13WHAT IS IT TO US?
- 29:14AND SO IF YOU GET RID OF WHAT WE
- 29:16CALL DEI, I WOULD BE VERY AFRAID
- 29:19THAT STUDENTS WOULD NOT GET THE
- 29:21SUPPORTS THEY NEED TO BE
- 29:22SUCCESSFUL.
- 29:22WE HAVE BEEN ABLE TO MAKE THAT
- 29:25SYSTEMIC PROCESS AT ALL OUR
- 29:27CAMPUSES TO HELP STUDENTS THAT
- 29:28WE KNOW OFTENTIMES BASED ON RACE
- 29:30AND BASED ON SEX, BASED ON
- 29:33GEOGRAPHIC WHERE FOLKS ARE FROM,
- 29:35LOW INCOME STATUS TO TARGET
- 29:37THOSE INDIVIDUALS AND HELP THEM
- 29:39GET THE SUPPORTS THEY NEED.
- 29:40MAYBE THE WAY THE DEI IS DEFINED
- 29:42IN A BILL DOES NOT IMPACT THAT.
- 29:44BUT IT SURE SOUNDS LIKE IT
- 29:46WOULD.
- 29:47AND THEN I WOULD HATE TO GET
- 29:49INTO A SITUATION WHERE THE
- 29:50DEFINITION WAS DIFFERENT AND WE
- 29:51STILL HAD A DEI OFFICE AND BEING
- 29:54ACCUSED OF CONTINUING TO DO WHAT
- 29:55IS OUTLAWED IN LEGISLATION, NO
- 29:58WE'RE NOT BECAUSE IT'S NOT
- 30:00DEFINED THAT WAY AND WE GET
- 30:01ACCUSED OF IT.
- 30:02AND IF THERE'S LANGUAGE IN THE
- 30:04BILL THAT WOULD ALLOW LAWSUITS
- 30:06TO BE FILED THEN WE'RE DEFENDING
- 30:09LAWSUITS.
- 30:09AND IF WE WIN THOSE ON OUR
- 30:11CAMPUSES PAY THOSE ATTORNEYS
- 30:12FEES TO DO THAT.
- 30:13THAT IS PROBLEMATIC THING.
- 30:15BUT TO ANSWER YOUR ORIGINAL
- 30:17QUESTION IF DEI IS OUTLAWED IT
- 30:20WOULD BE DETRIMENTAL TO OUR
- 30:22STUDENT BODY.
- 30:23>> SO THIS IS DEFINITELY A
- 30:26NATIONAL INITIATIVE.
- 30:27THERE ARE CURRENTLY 59 ANTI-DEI
- 30:30BILLS IN 25 DIFFERENT STATES.
- 30:34AND ALL STEMMING FROM THE
- 30:36JANUARY 2023 REPORT BY THE
- 30:38MANHATTAN INSTITUTE AND
- 30:41GOLDWATER INSTITUTE, CONCERNS
- 30:43THAT CONSERVATIVE VIEWPOINTS ARE
- 30:44BEING STIFLED.
- 30:46SO IF THAT'S HAPPENING WHY ARE
- 30:49WE THROWING THE BABY OUT WITH
- 30:51THE BATH WATER?
- 30:54WHY ARE WE CANCELS EVERYTHING
- 30:57DEI SOMETHING FRAMED THAT IS
- 31:00ANTIWHITE, ANTIMALE,
- 31:02DISCRIMINATING AGAINST WHITE
- 31:04MALES.
- 31:04AND TAKING AWAY PROGRAMS.
- 31:06CAN WE NOT DO WOMEN IN
- 31:08ENGINEERING ANYMORE?
- 31:09THAT WOULDN'T BE ALLOWED BY THIS
- 31:11PROGRAM.
- 31:12CAN WE NOT HAVE COURSES ON
- 31:15OPPRESSION IN HORRIFIC
- 31:16SITUATIONS FOR WOMEN IN OTHER
- 31:18COUNTRIES AS I READ THE
- 31:20LEGISLATION, REGARDING COURSE
- 31:21WORK, YOU COULDN'T HAVE AS TRUTH
- 31:24THAT WOMEN ARE OPPRESSED IN
- 31:28AFGHANISTAN.
- 31:31SO CHRISTOPHER'S GOAL WAS TO
- 31:33UNDO DECADES OF LIBERAL
- 31:36IDEOLOGICAL DOMINANCE IN THE
- 31:37ACADEMY.
- 31:37ALL RIGHT.
- 31:38SO IF THAT'S THE CASE, WHY DON'T
- 31:40WE WORK ON MORE EQUITABLE
- 31:44CONVERSATIONS, A SURVEY IS
- 31:45MENTIONED IN THIS BILL.
- 31:46I THINK THAT WOULD BE A GREAT
- 31:48THING.
- 31:49LET'S FIND OUT WHAT IS ACTUALLY
- 31:50HAPPENING BEFORE WE CANCEL
- 31:53PROGRAMS.
- 31:54OUR AFRICAN-AMERICAN STUDENTS
- 31:55ARE GOING TO FEEL LIKE WE DON'T
- 31:57CARE FOR THEM.
- 31:59THAT WE ARE NOT GOING TO SUPPORT
- 32:02YOU AS A GROUP BECAUSE IT WOULD
- 32:04BE NOW ILLEGAL TO CALL OUT A
- 32:06SPECIFIC GROUP OF PEOPLE FOR
- 32:07SUPPORT.
- 32:08IF WE HAVE STUDENTS WHO WE KNOW
- 32:11STRUGGLE WHEN THEY GET TO
- 32:13COLLEGE, MAYBE IT'S
- 32:15AFRICAN-AMERICAN MALES ARE WE
- 32:16GOING TO BE ALLOWED TO BRING
- 32:17THEM IN A WEEK EARLY FOR AN
- 32:19EXTRA PROGRAM TO TRY TO BENEFIT
- 32:22THEIR IMPROVE THEIR SUCCESS?
- 32:25CONSERVATIVE PRAUD BANDS ON DEI
- 32:28ATTACK THE FREE SPEECH RIGHTS OF
- 32:30STUDENTS, FACULTY AND
- 32:32ADMINISTRATORS WHO MIGHT WANT TO
- 32:33ENGAGE IN CONVERSATIONS ABOUT
- 32:35IDENTITY OR RACE.
- 32:36AND MY UNDERSTANDING OF THIS
- 32:37BILL IS THAT WOULD BE ILLEGAL.
- 32:40>> Renee: YOUR UNDERSTANDING OF
- 32:41THE BILL WOULD THAT BE ILLEGAL?
- 32:42>> IT IS NOT.
- 32:52YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT SOMEBODY
- 32:54GETTING IN FRONT OF A GROUP AND
- 32:58THEY START DOWNGRADING THE
- 32:58UNITED STATES AS BEING
- 33:00INHERENTLY RACIST, THE CASE IN
- 33:02DIVERSITY TRAINING IN A FLORIDA
- 33:04SCHOOL.
- 33:05FLORIDA BANNED DEI INITIATIVES.
- 33:08YOU KNOW WHAT IT'S CONTEXT
- 33:10INTENT OF WHOEVER IS PRESENTING.
- 33:13I THINK THAT ONE OF THE GREATEST
- 33:15DEI PROGRAMS WE HAVE IS OUR
- 33:17FOUNDING DOCUMENTS THE
- 33:19DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE AND
- 33:20THE CONSTITUTION WHICH ANDREW
- 33:23ELUDED WE'RE MADE IN THE IMAGE
- 33:24OF GOD.
- 33:25AND THAT IS PART OF THE --
- 33:29>> WE ARE CREATED.
- 33:30THAT WAS A PROMISE THAT OUR
- 33:32FOUNDING FATHERS DID NOT FULFILL
- 33:33ON.
- 33:35THE CONSTITUTION MADE PROVISIONS
- 33:38INSTITUTIONAL PROVISIONINGS TO
- 33:39RECTIFY THE WRONGS THAT WERE
- 33:41COMMITTED AGAINST THE BLACK
- 33:42POPULATION FOR SO LONG.
- 33:43ONE OF THE GREAT THINGS ABOUT
- 33:44THIS COUNTRY WE TALK ABOUT
- 33:46DIVERSITY WE ARE THE GREATEST
- 33:48MELTING POT IN THE HISTORY OF
- 33:49THE WORLD.
- 33:49PEOPLE FROM ALL NATIONS AND
- 33:51ETHNICITIES COME HERE AND WE DO
- 33:53A GOOD JOB.
- 33:54WE HAVE WARTS AND BLEMISHES
- 33:57WE'VE MADE MISTAKES BUT WE'RE
- 34:00WORKED TOGETHER AS A PEOPLE TO
- 34:02RECTIFY THE STATES BECAUSE THE
- 34:03CONSTITUTION ALLOWED US.
- 34:05JIM CROW, BUT WE HAVE BEEN ABLE
- 34:07TO RECTIFY IT.
- 34:09BECAUSE WE HAVE FIRST AMENDMENT
- 34:11FREEDOMS THAT HAVE GIVEN US THE
- 34:13DISCOURSE WE ARE ENJOYING RIGHT
- 34:15NOW.
- 34:15FREEDOM OF ASSEMBLY.
- 34:17FREEDOM TO PETITION OUR
- 34:19GOVERNMENT.
- 34:19WE HAVE USED THE FREEDOMS WE
- 34:21HAVE TO FIX THE WRONGS.
- 34:23AND I THINK THE MAJOR PROBLEM
- 34:25WITH DEI IS AGAIN GOING BACK TO
- 34:28THE E, THE EQUITY PART.
- 34:30AND WE DO DISAGREE
- 34:31REPRESENTATIVE ON HOW THAT IS
- 34:33INTERPRETED.
- 34:33>> Renee: I WANT TO GET TO THAT
- 34:35POINT.
- 34:36PROFESSOR WALKER CHIME IN QUICK.
- 34:37>> I WANT TO AGREE WITH
- 34:41REPRESENTATIVE TINA BOJANOWSKI
- 34:42CONTINUE WE HAD A DECLARATION OF
- 34:44INDEPENDENCE CREATED WITH
- 34:49CERTAIN INALIENABLE RIGHTS BUT
- 34:51IT WAS THE SAME DECLARATION THE
- 34:54CONSTITUTION THAT ENABLED US TO
- 34:55HAVE A PROCESS TO RECTIFY THOSE
- 34:58WRONGS WHICH WE DID IN THE 14TH
- 35:00AMENDMENT WHICH GIVES US
- 35:01EQUALITY UNDER THE LAW, DUE
- 35:04PROCESS WHICH IS VERY RELEVANT
- 35:05TO THIS DISCUSSION BECAUSE THE
- 35:07SUPREME COURT HAS WEIGHED IN ON
- 35:10THIS DISCUSSION RELATED TO DEI
- 35:13IN THE FORM OF AFFIRMATIVE
- 35:15ACTION AND SAYING THAT IS
- 35:17UNCONSTITUTIONAL.
- 35:17BECAUSE WHAT IS DEI?
- 35:20IT HAS THESE LOFT IDEALS IT
- 35:22SOUNDS IN PRINCIPLE HARD TO
- 35:24DISAGREE WITH.
- 35:25BUT THEN HOW DOES THAT CASH OUT
- 35:27PRACTICALLY?
- 35:28IT CASHES OUT IN REVERSE RACISM
- 35:31AND REVERSE SEXISM.
- 35:33EVERYPLACE DEI HAS TAKEN ROOT
- 35:35THESE TYPES OF DIVISIONS HAVE
- 35:38BEEN EXACERBATED.
- 35:39IT HAS DONE THE EXACT OPPOSITE
- 35:41OF WHAT THEY HAVE TRIED TO DO IN
- 35:42THE NAME OF DIVERSITY, EQUITY,
- 35:45INCLUSION WHICH CONSERVATIVES
- 35:46HAVE TAKEN RIGHTFULLY AND
- 35:49RECOINED AS DIVISION, EXCLUSION
- 35:52AND INDOCTRINATION.
- 35:54>> SO Mr. NELSON DISCUSSED
- 35:55FLORIDA.
- 35:56SO FLORIDA PASSED A BILL AND LET
- 35:59ME READ A QUOTE FROM A FLORIDA
- 36:02FACULTY ADVISER TO THE
- 36:06FEDERALIST SOCIETY LAW SCHOOL
- 36:07REPUBLICANS AND CHRISTIAN LEGAL
- 36:08SOCIETY.
- 36:09HE SAID ABOUT THE DEI BILL, BIG
- 36:11BROTHER IS WATCHING.
- 36:12HE'S TAKING NAMES.
- 36:14IF I AM ON THE WOKE LIST, IF
- 36:16THEY FIND ME THREATENING, THE
- 36:18REST OF YOU ARE DEAD IN THE
- 36:19WATER.
- 36:20BEWARERY AND BE AWARE.
- 36:21IF I DON'T HAVE ACADEMIC FREEDOM
- 36:24NEITHER DO YOU.
- 36:24IF YOU DON'T, NEITHER DO I.
- 36:28A CORNERSTONE OF OUR DEMOCRATIC
- 36:30SOCIETY IS THE SURVIVAL OF
- 36:32INSTITUTIONS OF HIGHER
- 36:33EDUCATION.
- 36:34FREE FROM POLITICAL INTERFERENCE
- 36:36AND IDEOLOGICAL AGENDA OF OUGHT
- 36:40CONTRACTS.
- 36:40WE NEED TO PROTECT ACADEMIC
- 36:42FREEDOM.
- 36:43WE NEED TO PROTECT FROM
- 36:44CENSORSHIP AND I THINK THAT THIS
- 36:46BILL WOULD IMPACT BOTH OF THOSE
- 36:48THINGS.
- 36:48>> Renee: LET'S TALK A MATTER OF
- 36:52PRACTICALITY Mr. NELSON YOU
- 36:53MENTIONED THE E BEING THE MOST
- 36:57SUBVERSIVE TO MANY ON YOUR SIDE
- 36:58OF THIS CONVERSATION.
- 37:00INSTEAD OF PERHAPS THE SUPPOSE,
- 37:03INSTEAD OF DISMANTLING DEI
- 37:06OFFICES YOU RENAME THEM AND IT
- 37:07HAS HAPPENED.
- 37:08THE UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA
- 37:09CHANGED ITS OFFICE OF DIVERSITY,
- 37:11EQUITY AND INCLUSION TO THE
- 37:12DIVISION OF ACCESS, CIVIL RIGHTS
- 37:14AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT.
- 37:16IN TENNESSEE, THE DIVISION OF
- 37:19DIVERSITY BECAME THE DIVERSITY
- 37:23SHIFTING THE LANGUAGE WITHOUT
- 37:25UPENDING THE MISSION AND
- 37:26PURPOSES FROM AN ADMINISTRATIVE
- 37:28STANDPOINT WOULD THAT SUFFICE?
- 37:29YOU CHANGE THE NAME BUT PERHAPS
- 37:32THE FUNCTIONS WOULD STILL APPLY?
- 37:33>> ITH I THAT UNIVERSITIES
- 37:36SHOULD BE WELCOMING AND OPEN TO
- 37:38ALL THAT WANT TO ATTEND.
- 37:39I THINK THEY SHOULD ALSO BE
- 37:41WELCOMING TO DIVERSE VIEWPOINTS
- 37:43FROM FACULTY AND PROFESSORS
- 37:45WHICH THAT IS A BIG ISSUE, BY
- 37:47THE WAY, WHETHER IT'S OKAY FOR
- 37:51CONSERVATIVES TO FIND TENURE GET
- 37:53TENURE IN KENTUCKY OR ANY
- 37:55COLLEGES OR UNIVERSITIES.
- 37:56THAT IS AN ISSUE.
- 37:57BUT WE CAN CHANGE THE NAMES.
- 37:59I THINK IN PRINCIPLE AND I WILL
- 38:02SPEAK TO THAT THAT WE SHOULD
- 38:03WELCOME ALL.
- 38:04AND WE SHOULD LOWER BARRIERS.
- 38:07BUT WHEN YOU SINGLE OUT RACES
- 38:10AND ETHNICITIES WHEN YOU PUT
- 38:12YOUR THUMB ON THE SCALE THAT IS
- 38:13WHERE THERE IS AN ISSUE AND WHAT
- 38:15WE'RE DEBATING HERE TONIGHT.
- 38:17>> Renee: TO THE POINT THAT THE
- 38:18REPRESENTATIVE RAISED WHAT THIS
- 38:21COULD MEAN FOR STUDENT
- 38:23ORIENTEDDED CLUBS AND SPACES TO
- 38:24SUPPORT STUDENTS WHO ARE
- 38:27MARGINALIZED, LGBTQ CLUBS OR THE
- 38:28BLACK STUDIES OR BLACK UNION, IF
- 38:31THIS BILL COULD IT --
- 38:33LET ME ASK YOU FIRST, TRAVIS
- 38:34POWELL COULD THIS MEASURE
- 38:37IMPERIL THOSE TYPES OF EFFORTS?
- 38:39AND STUDENT BASED GROUPS FROM
- 38:41ORGANIZING?
- 38:41>> I THINK IF THE STUDENTS IF IT
- 38:43ROSE UP FROM THE STUDENTS AND
- 38:45WAS NOT PART OF THE
- 38:46ADMINISTRATION IT WAS SOMETHING
- 38:47THAT THE STUDENTS DID ON THEIR
- 38:48OWN I THINK IT WOULD BE FINE.
- 38:50THE ISSUE WOULD COME IN THE WAY
- 38:52THAT THE DISCRIMINATORY CONCEPTS
- 38:56AND DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT SO TO
- 38:58THE EXTENT THAT INSTITUTIONS TO
- 39:00YOUR EXAMPLE, HAD BLACK MALE
- 39:03STUDENTS COME IN A WEEK EARLY
- 39:05BECAUSE THEY FOUND IN A CERTAIN
- 39:06PROGRAM THAT THEY WERE BEING
- 39:08LESS SUCCESSFUL THAN THE OVERALL
- 39:10POPULATION COME IN A WEEK EARLY
- 39:11AND GET ACCLIMATED TO COLLEGE
- 39:14AND GET A FEELING OF THE
- 39:15ENVIRONMENT SO THEY WOULD BE
- 39:17MORE COMFORTABLE WHEN SCHOOL
- 39:18STARTS.
- 39:19THAT'S TREATING THEM
- 39:20DIFFERENTLY.
- 39:20SO I MEAN, IS THAT A PREFERENCE?
- 39:23IS THAT UNCONSTITUTIONAL?
- 39:26DISCRIMINATION?
- 39:27I DON'T THINK SO.
- 39:28BUT IT IS TREATING SOMEBODY
- 39:29DIFFERENTLY BASED ON THEIR RACE.
- 39:31SAME THING WITH THE EXAMPLE
- 39:32WOMEN IN ENGINEERING THAT IS
- 39:35TREATING SOMEONE DIFFERENTLY
- 39:36GIVING THEM AN OPPORTUNITY
- 39:37BECAUSE OF THEIR SEX.
- 39:40SO I DO THINK AS IT'S WRITTEN IT
- 39:42WOULD PROHIBIT THAT AND THAT IS
- 39:44A BIG TOOL IN THE TOOLBOX FOR US
- 39:46TO HELP AS WE DEFINE DEI AND
- 39:49WE'VE CHANGED THE NAME, CHANGE
- 39:51TO DO TO THE ACCESS, ENGAGEMENT
- 39:53AND BELONGING FOR THE REASON YOU
- 39:54ARE SAYING BECAUSE IT'S GOTTEN
- 39:56THIS CONNOTATION AND THE LETTERS
- 39:58PEOPLE DON'T KNOW WHAT IT STANDS
- 40:00FOR HAVE STARTED TO DIVIDE FOLKS
- 40:02AND WE DON'T WANT THAT.
- 40:04WE WANT TO BE MORE INCLUSIVE.
- 40:05WE ARE IN THE PROCESS OF
- 40:08REVISING OUR DIVERSITY, EQUITY
- 40:09AND INCLUSION POLICY AND WE'RE
- 40:11CONTINUING TO EVALUATE AND
- 40:12LOOKING AT WAYS TO EXPAND OUR
- 40:14DEFINITION AND LOOK AT DIFFERENT
- 40:16ASPECTS OF THE STUDENT
- 40:18POPULATION FOR DIVERSITY.
- 40:19LOOKING AT FIRST GENERATION
- 40:24STUDENTS.
- 40:25REGIONAL DIVERSITY.
- 40:26ADULT STUDENTS.
- 40:27VETERANS THAT SORT OF THING.
- 40:29AND THIS IS TOO SOMETHING THAT
- 40:30WE GET THAT DEMOGRAPHIC
- 40:32INFORMATION FROM STUDENTS.
- 40:33TRYING TO BROADEN OUR
- 40:35PERSPECTIVE BECAUSE AGAIN IF THE
- 40:37TERM DEI DIVIDES FOLKS AND NOT
- 40:40INCLUDE THE FOLKS AS YOU WERE
- 40:41TALKING ABOUT, MORE CONSERVATIVE
- 40:44PERSPECTIVE LET'S CHANGE THE
- 40:45NAME AND CALL IT SOMETHING ELSE
- 40:46BECAUSE THAT IS THE LAST THING
- 40:47WE WANT TO DO.
- 40:49>> Renee: WE TALK ABOUT
- 40:51REPRESENTATIVE JENIFER DECKER'S
- 40:53BILL AND ANOTHER BILL IN THE
- 40:54SENATE IT IS DIFFERENT
- 40:55TRANSPLANT DOES NOT CALL FOR
- 40:56DOING AWAY WITH DEI OFFICES AND
- 40:58WHEN I TALK TO MIKE WILSON WHO
- 41:00IS THE REPUBLICAN FROM BOWLING
- 41:02GREEN AND THE SENATE MAJORITY
- 41:04WHIP HE SA SAID THAT IS NOT THE
- 41:06GOAL BUT HE DOES VIEW DEI AS
- 41:09DISCRIMINATION.
- 41:10HIS IS PART OF OUR CONVERSATION
- 41:11FROM A COUPLE WEEKS AGO.
- 41:13SENATOR WILSON IT IS A PLEASURE
- 41:14THANK YOU FOR YOUR TIME.
- 41:15>> THANK YOU, RENEE IT'S ALWAYS
- 41:17A PLEASURE TO BE WITH YOU.
- 41:18>> .
- 41:19LET'S TALK ABOUT SENATE BILL 6
- 41:21THIS IS LABELED AS THE
- 41:25ANTI-DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND
- 41:25INCLUSION MEASURE.
- 41:26WHAT DOES IT SEEK TO DO AND THE
- 41:28POST-SECONDARY EDUCATION SPACE?
- 41:29>> WELL, I DON'T THINK IT'S
- 41:33ANTI-DEI MEASURE BECAUSE IT
- 41:34DOESN'T DO AWAY WITH DEI OFFICES
- 41:36OR TRAINING.
- 41:37WHAT IT DOES IT ACTUALLY
- 41:41PROHIBITS ABOUT 16 THINGS THAT
- 41:43HOPEFULLY YOU'VE READ THOSE AND
- 41:46UNDERSTAND.
- 41:46BECAUSE EVERYBODY I TALK TO LOOK
- 41:47AT THEM AND SAID WELL WHO COULD
- 41:50BE AGAINST THOSE.
- 41:51AND YOU KNOW, BEING ABLE TO
- 41:55ACTUALLY DISCRIMINATE AGAINST
- 41:56SOMEONE BECAUSE OF THEIR RACE,
- 41:57SEX, GENDER OR THOSE THINGS.
- 41:59AND WHAT WE'VE SEEN IN DEI
- 42:02ACROSS THE COUNTRY AND EVEN AS
- 42:04I'VE HAD PEOPLE TALK TO ME THAT
- 42:06ARE HERE IN KENTUCKY, THAT
- 42:08STUDENTS ARE EXPERIENCING THAT,
- 42:10HAVING TO TAKE THE TRAINING AND
- 42:13ASCRIBE TO A LITMUS TEST OF A
- 42:16POLITICAL IDEOLOGY THAT GOES
- 42:18BEYOND WHAT OUR FEDERAL, STATE
- 42:20LAWS ARE IN REGARDS TO RACISM
- 42:23AND ANTIDISCRIMINATION MEASURES
- 42:26WHICH I DON'T THINK WE NEED TO
- 42:27BE DOING THAT.
- 42:28>> Renee: THERE ARE SOME
- 42:30SUBSTANTIATED CASES OF STUDENTS
- 42:32FACING THAT.
- 42:33IS THAT ALSO COMING FROM SOME OF
- 42:35THE UNIVERSITY PERSONNEL?
- 42:36ARE YOU HEARING THAT AS WELL?
- 42:38HAS THAT BEEN SUBSTANTIATED?
- 42:40I AM.
- 42:41I'M HEARING THAT FROM UNIVERSITY
- 42:43PERSONNEL AS WELL LOCATED HERE
- 42:45IN KENTUCKY AND THERE ARE
- 42:46DOCUMENTED CASES ACROSS THE
- 42:47COUNTRY WHERE THEY'VE BEEN
- 42:49DENIED PROMOTION, THEY'VE BEEN
- 42:51DENIED HIRING BECAUSE OF THEIR
- 42:54STATEMENTS TO DEI THAT DOES NOT
- 42:56AGREE WITH THE UNIVERSITY.
- 42:58IN REGARDS TO THAT, YOU KNOW, WE
- 43:01ALL BELIEVE IN DIVERSITY.
- 43:03WE ALL BELIEVE IN BEING
- 43:05INCLUDED.
- 43:05WE BELIEVE IN EQUALITY,
- 43:07OPPORTUNITIES AND THINGS LIKE
- 43:09THAT.
- 43:09SO WE'RE NOT TRYING TO GET RID
- 43:12OF DEI BUT WE'RE TRYING TO MAKE
- 43:14SURE THAT WHAT WE'RE DOING IS IN
- 43:15LINE WITH OUR STATE AND FEDERAL
- 43:18LAWS.
- 43:18AND WE'RE NOT TRYING TO PROHIBIT
- 43:20TEACHING HISTORY OR SLAVERY AND
- 43:23ALL OF THOSE THINGS WE'RE BEING
- 43:25ACCUSED OF THAT.
- 43:26WE ARE NOT.
- 43:27AND PROBABLY AN ADDITION TO THE
- 43:30BILL TO STATE THAT THIS BILL
- 43:31DOES NOT PROHIBIT THAT.
- 43:33>> Renee: THERE IS CONCERN THAT
- 43:35PROGRAMS MEASURES LIKE THESE
- 43:37COULD DISINCENTIVIZE CERTAIN
- 43:39POPULATIONS OF STUDENTS
- 43:41UNDERREPRESENTED MINORITIES,
- 43:42FROM GOING TO KENTUCKY PUBLIC
- 43:45UNIVERSITIES AND THERE BY THAT
- 43:47COULD EXACERBATE THE LABOR
- 43:48SHORTAGES THAT KENTUCKY IS
- 43:50EXPERIENCING.
- 43:51FROM AN ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
- 43:53STANDPOINT, HOW WISE HOW SMART
- 43:55IS THIS LEGISLATION?
- 43:56>> I DON'T REALLY THINK THIS IS
- 43:59SOMETHING THAT PEOPLE REALLY
- 44:01FOCUS ON.
- 44:01LIKE I SAID I THINK OUR FEDERAL
- 44:04LAWS, STATE LAWS THAT WE HAVE
- 44:06THAT ARE ON THE BOOKS WAS DOING
- 44:09A GOOD JOB OF THIS.
- 44:10I THINK THAT THIS WAS SOMETHING
- 44:13THAT'S BEEN DEVELOPED OVER THE
- 44:15LAST 8 TO 10 YEARS.
- 44:16AND THAT SEEMS TO BE A LOT OF
- 44:19PEOPLE ADOPTING.
- 44:20BUT I FOUND THAT THERE ARE
- 44:21COMPANIES NOW THAT ARE GETTING
- 44:22RID OF ALL THEIR DEI BECAUSE
- 44:24THEY SAY IT CREATES SUCH A TOXIC
- 44:27WORK ENVIRONMENT THERE FOR THEIR
- 44:30EMPLOYEES.
- 44:31AND IT'S JUST NOT BEEN
- 44:33BENEFICIAL FOR THEM.
- 44:34SO WE SEE A LOT OF PEOPLE DOING
- 44:36AWAY WITH IT.
- 44:37AND THERE SEEMS TO BE A MOVEMENT
- 44:39TOWARDS THAT BECAUSE OF THAT.
- 44:42AND I THINK THAT STUDENTS WANT
- 44:44FREEDOM OF SPEECH.
- 44:45I THINK THIS IS SOMETHING THAT
- 44:47PRESERVES THAT.
- 44:49YOU KNOW, I KNOW FOR ME, I LIVED
- 44:5217 YEARS IN SOUTHERN CALIFORNIA.
- 44:54THE CHURCH I WENT TO I WAS A
- 44:57MINORITY.
- 44:58BECAUSE WE HAD SO MANY DIFFERENT
- 45:01RACIAL DIVERSITY WITHIN OUR
- 45:02CHURCH.
- 45:03AND IT WAS GREAT.
- 45:04WE LOVED IT.
- 45:06I THINK THAT IS WHAT WE ALL
- 45:08WANT.
- 45:08WE ALL WANT TO SEE AND I JUST
- 45:10DON'T THINK THIS HELPS PROMOTE
- 45:12IT.
- 45:13>> Renee: TO YOUR POINT ABOUT
- 45:14NOT INC. FRINGING ON ACADEMIC
- 45:17FREEDOM AND THE INTELLECTUAL
- 45:19DISCUSSIONS THAT A PROFESSOR
- 45:20COULD LEAD THAT IS NOT WHAT THIS
- 45:22BILL IS DESIGNED TO DO?
- 45:23>> NO IT IS NOT.
- 45:24>> AND THAT WILL BE CLARIFIED
- 45:26FURTHER.
- 45:26>> WE'RE GOING TO DO A
- 45:29SUBSTITUTE AND MAKE SURE WE ADD
- 45:30THAT IN THERE TO CLARIFY THIS IS
- 45:33SPECIFICALLY THIS BILL DOES NOT
- 45:35DO THIS.
- 45:36AND DOES NOT PROHIBIT THIS.
- 45:39>> Renee: WE'RE WAITING BECAUSE
- 45:40THESE BILLS VNTS' GONE THROUGH
- 45:42THE COMMITTEE PROCESS YET.
- 45:43BUT HE MENTIONED 16 CONCEPTS I
- 45:46WILL NOT GO THROUGH ALL 16 THEY
- 45:48ARE ON THE LEGISLATIVE WEBSITE.
- 45:50BUT I WILL GIVE YOU A COUPLE SO
- 45:52THAT VIEWERS HAVE AN IDEA WHAT
- 45:54WE'RE TALKING ABOUT.
- 45:55JUST THE FIRST COUPLE, ONE RACE
- 45:57OR SEX IS INHERENTLY THIS IS HOW
- 46:00A DIVISIVE CONCEPT IS DEFINED
- 46:02ONE RACE OR SEX IS SUPERIOR OR
- 46:06INTERIOR AN INDIVIDUAL BY VIR
- 46:09USE OF THE RACE IS SEX OF THE OR
- 46:12OPPRESSIVE WHETHER CONSCIOUSLY
- 46:15OR SUBCONSCIOUSLY AND
- 46:16INDIVIDUALS SHOULD RECEIVE
- 46:17ADVERSE TREATMENT BECAUSE OF THE
- 46:20INDIVIDUAL'S RACE OR SEX AND 13
- 46:22OTHER DEFINED CONCEPTS IN SENATE
- 46:24BILL 6.
- 46:25YOUR PERSPECTIVE ON THIS BILL,
- 46:27TRAVIS POWELL, ABOUT COMPARE AND
- 46:29CONTRAST THIS NO HOUSE BILL 9.
- 46:30>> SO I THINK THE BIGGEST
- 46:33DIFFERENCE IS THIS REALLY
- 46:35FOCUSES ON THESE DIVISIVE
- 46:37CONCEPTS AS OPPOSED TO DEI.
- 46:41I MEAN DEI IS NOT IN THE
- 46:43LEGISLATION.
- 46:44THE TERM DEI IS NOT IN THE
- 46:47SENATE BILL.
- 46:48WHEREAS IT IS AND TALKS ABOUT
- 46:50OFFICES GETS INTO DETAIL OF THE
- 46:52OPERATIONS OF INSTITUTION AND
- 46:53WHAT THEY CAN AND CAN'T DO.
- 46:56DEI OFFICES AND OFFICERS A LOT
- 46:58OF INTERPRETATION INVOLVED IN
- 47:00THAT.
- 47:01AND THE PRACTICAL IMPACTS ON HOW
- 47:03TO APPLY THAT AND IMPLEMENT THAT
- 47:05AND COMPLY WITH STATE LAW COULD
- 47:07BE VERY DIFFICULT.
- 47:08THIS BILL FOCUSES ON THOSE
- 47:10CONCEPTS THAT YOU LISTED AND THE
- 47:12REST.
- 47:12AND TALKS ABOUT THOSE IN THE
- 47:14FORM OF TRAINING AND MANDATORY
- 47:17TRAINING FOR INSTITUTIONS AND
- 47:18MAKES IT CLEAR THAT IT IS NOT
- 47:20IMPACTING ANYTHING TAUGHT IN THE
- 47:22CLASSROOM.
- 47:22IT DOES PROHIBIT INSTITUTIONS
- 47:24FROM PROVIDING AINCENTIVE FOR
- 47:27TEAMING DIVISIVE CONCEPT.
- 47:29THAT IS NOT THE WAY THAT
- 47:33UNIVERSITIES INCENTIVIZE
- 47:34PROFESSOR TO TEACH ANY CONCEPT
- 47:36NECESSARILY.
- 47:36IT IS A LITTLE BIT DIFFERENT IT
- 47:38FOCUSES ON THE TRAINING.
- 47:39IT IS A MUCH SHORTER BILL.
- 47:41A LITTLE BIT EASIER TO DIGEST.
- 47:43>> Renee: HAS THE RIGHT TO
- 47:44ACTION BILL.
- 47:46REPRESENTATIVE DECKER HAS
- 47:48PROVISIONS TO SEEK PUNITIVE
- 47:49DAMAGES AND HIS BILL HE LAYS IT
- 47:51OUT THAT IT DID GO FROM $1,000
- 47:55TO AS HIGH AS $100,000 PER
- 47:57ACTION.
- 47:58>> AND THAT IS STILL PROBLEMATIC
- 48:01ANYTIME OUR INSTITUTIONS OUR
- 48:02PUBLIC ENTITIES ANY WAIVER IN
- 48:05OUR SORN ENTITIES AND CAN BE
- 48:10SUED TO THE GNAWED NEWED THIS
- 48:12WOULD OPEN THEM UP TO LIABILITY
- 48:13AND IT IS NOT SO MUCH THAT THEY
- 48:16COULD BE FOLLOWING THE LETTER OF
- 48:17THE LAW ANYBODY CAN FILE A
- 48:19LAWSUIT AGAINST IT THEY HAVE TO
- 48:20DEFEND IT.
- 48:22INSURANCE COSTS GO UP BECAUSE OF
- 48:23THIS.
- 48:24BECAUSE THEY ARE NOW OPEN TO
- 48:25MORE LIABILITY.
- 48:26AND IT BECOMES MORE OF AN ISSUE
- 48:28EVEN IF YOU WIN AND DOING THE
- 48:30RIGHT THING IT CAN BE CAN BE
- 48:32COSTLY TO OUR INSTITUTIONS AND
- 48:35WE FIND THAT PROBLEMATIC.
- 48:36>> I WANT TO SPEAK ON POINT
- 48:38NUMBER SIX AND THIS HAS BEEN
- 48:40AROUND NATIONALLY THESE DIVISIVE
- 48:44TOPICS.
- 48:44THAT AN INDIVIDUAL SHOULD FEEL
- 48:47DISCOMFORTED, GUILT OR ANGUISH
- 48:49OR DISTRESS BECAUSE OF THEIR
- 48:50RACE OR SEX.
- 48:51AND IT MAKES ME THINK ABOUT MY
- 48:53MOTHER'S GERMAN OUR HERITAGE IS
- 48:55GERMAN I HONESTLY DO FEEL GUILT
- 48:57ABOUT THE HORRIFIC THINGS THAT
- 48:59HAPPENED DURING THE HOLOCAUST.
- 49:02AND I WAS READING HANNAH GRAY, A
- 49:06FORMER PRESIDENT OF THE
- 49:06UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO SAID
- 49:07EDUCATION SHOULD NOT BE INTENDED
- 49:09TO MAKE PEOPLE COMFORTABLE, IT
- 49:12SHOULD MAKE THEM THINK.
- 49:13AND SO I WONDER WHAT KIND OF A
- 49:17CHILLING EFFECT IT COULD BE ON
- 49:19TOPICS THAT ARE PRESENTED IN THE
- 49:21CLASSROOMS, WITH THESE DIVISIVE
- 49:23CONCEPTS THAT YOU MIGHT DO
- 49:25SOMETHING THAT MAKES SOMEONE
- 49:27FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE AND THEY'RE
- 49:28GOING TO SUE YOU, YOUR PROFESSOR
- 49:31YOUR UNIVERSITY.
- 49:35IT'S CONCERNING TO ME PAUSE
- 49:37THERE ARE THINGS THAT HAVE
- 49:38HAPPENED IN HISTORY THAT SHOULD
- 49:42MAKE US TEAL UNCOMFORTABLE.
- 49:43NOT LIKE WE'RE RESPONSIBLE BUT
- 49:46DEFINITELY, YOU KNOW, WHAT
- 49:48HAPPENED TO OUR INDIGENOUS
- 49:50PEOPLE, IT SHOULD MAKE ONE FEEL
- 49:52UNCOMFORTABLE THAT THEY WERE
- 49:54FORCED OUT WHERE THEY WERE
- 49:56LIVING AND ALL THOSE THINGS.
- 49:58SO THAT'S ONE THAT I HAVE
- 49:59CONCERNS ABOUT.
- 50:00>> THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
- 50:03MAKING PEOPLE THINK AND BEING
- 50:05UNCOMFORTABLE WHEN YOU ARE
- 50:06LEARNING LESSONS ABOUT HISTORY
- 50:08AND THEN GUILTING.
- 50:09YOU ARE GETTING INTO THE CONTEXT
- 50:11THERE.
- 50:11BUT I THINK THIS IS A REAL ISSUE
- 50:13BECAUSE STUDENTS HAVE BEEN
- 50:15GUILTED.
- 50:16EMPLOYEES HAVE BEEN INTIMIDATED.
- 50:18PIANO PEOPLE HAVE LOST THEIR
- 50:20JOBS THERE IS A LOT OF AGREEMENT
- 50:22HERE AS FAR AS ACADEMIC FREEDOM,
- 50:24AS FAR AS HAVING A SAFE
- 50:25ENVIRONMENT WHERE PEOPLE CAN
- 50:27LEARN AND EXCHANGE IDEAS AND
- 50:29HAVE DEBATE.
- 50:30I THINK WE LOOK AT THE
- 50:32INDIVIDUAL EXAMPLES OF WHERE DEI
- 50:34POLICY HAS BEEN ABUSED AND THAT
- 50:36IS WHY WE ARE AT THIS PLACE WE
- 50:38ARE TALKING ABOUT LEGISLATION TO
- 50:39CORRECT THE ABUSE.
- 50:40>> AND I WOULD ADD TO THAT, ONE
- 50:42OF THE THINGS UNDER REPORT IN
- 50:45OUR NATIONAL MEDIA IS THE NUMBER
- 50:46OF STUDENTS THAT ARE EXITING THE
- 50:49PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
- 50:50AT HISTORIC LEVELS.
- 50:52BECAUSE OUT OF COVID PARENTS
- 50:53WERE MADE AWARE OF WHAT WAS
- 50:55BEING TAUGHT OVER ZOOM AND THEY
- 50:58WERE BEING MADE AWARE OF HOW THE
- 51:00DEI WORLD VIEW WAS ETCHING
- 51:03ITSELF INTO THIS VIEW.
- 51:05THE REPORTER BARRY WEISS NOT A
- 51:08CONSERVATIVE BY ANY STRETCH OF
- 51:09THE IMAGINATION HAS DONE
- 51:11INCREDIBLE REPORTING ON THIS ALL
- 51:12OVER THE NATION OF STUDENTS
- 51:15BEING DIVIDED NEWSPAPER THEIR
- 51:17CLASSROOMS BY THEIR SKIN COLOR
- 51:19AND BEING GIVEN OBJECT LIST SONS
- 51:24AND BEING AN OPPRESSOR OR THE
- 51:26OPPRESSED.
- 51:26WE SHOULD ALL AGREE WE SHOULD
- 51:28TEACH OUR HISTORY.
- 51:29PROPONENTS OF THIS BILL BELIEVE
- 51:31WE SHOULD TEACH OUR HISTORY AND
- 51:33LAMENT OVER OUR HISTORY WHERE WE
- 51:35HAVE GOTTEN IT WRONG.
- 51:35WE ARE NOT GOING TO REDEEM THE
- 51:39SITUATION BY JUST DOING THIS IN
- 51:42REVERSE.
- 51:43AND BY PERPETUATING THE
- 51:45NARRATIVES AND REDUCING
- 51:47INDIVIDUALS DOWN TO A GROUP
- 51:49IDENTITY.
- 51:50WE SHOULD BE PRACTICING ACADEMIC
- 51:53FREEDOM.
- 51:55IDEOLOGICAL NEUTRALITY.
- 51:56AND AGAIN THESE DEI BILLS AND
- 51:58THE OFFICES DO NO SUCH THING.
- 52:01>> Renee: I WANT TO GO TO A
- 52:02COUPLE OF QUESTIONS AND COMMENTS
- 52:04WE'VE RECEIVED SO FAR THIS
- 52:05EVENING.
- 52:06AND THIS ONE COMES IN FROM JAMIE
- 52:08FROM SHELBY COUNTY.
- 52:10REPRESENTATIVE DECKER SAYS SHE
- 52:11PROMOTES THE FREE EXCHANGE OF
- 52:14IDEAS YET SUPPORTS BANNING BOOKS
- 52:16HOUSE BILL 150 OR SENATE BILL
- 52:19150 DISCRIMINATORY AGAINST GAY
- 52:20AND THE LGBTQ COMMUNITY CAUSING
- 52:23DISTRESS TO PARENTS AND THEIR
- 52:24KIDS.
- 52:25HOUSE BILL 9 SEEMS TO BE A
- 52:27TAKEAWAY ATTEMPT FROM
- 52:29MARGINALIZED GROUPS.
- 52:30LOTS OF QUESTIONS HOW MUCH DEI
- 52:33EFFORTS COST HIGHER INSTITUTIONS
- 52:35Mr. TRAVIS POWELL HOW MUCH
- 52:37DOES THAT CONSUME THE XPE BUDGET
- 52:40OR INDIVIDUAL INSTITUTIONS?
- 52:42>> WE HAVE THREE FULL-TIME
- 52:43INDIVIDUALS THAT WORK IN THAT
- 52:44AREA IN OUR OFFICE.
- 52:47AND WE HELP COORDINATE THE
- 52:49EFFORTS MAINLY AROUND OUR DEI
- 52:51POLICY AND EVALUATION OF
- 52:55DIVERSITY PROGRESS IN ORDER FOR
- 52:57INSTITUTIONS TO OFFER NEW
- 52:58ACADEMIC PROGRAMS.
- 52:59AS FAR AS WHAT IS BEING SPENT ON
- 53:01THE CAMPUSES IT'S HARD TO
- 53:04AGGREGATE HOW DO YOU DEFINE A
- 53:07DEI POLICY.
- 53:07HOW MUCH ARE YOU SPENDING ON
- 53:09DEI?
- 53:10HOW DO YOU DEFINE IT.
- 53:11I CAN TELL YOU IF SOMEBODY HAS
- 53:13THEIR NAME AND THEY ARE UNDER
- 53:14THE UMBRELLA OF A DEI OFFICE,
- 53:18WELL I CAN TELL YOU HOW MUCH
- 53:19THAT PERSON MAKES AND IF THEY
- 53:20ARE SPENDING MONEY ON TRAINING.
- 53:22BUT IF I HAVE A COORDINATOR
- 53:25INNED ENGINEERING I WILL KEEP
- 53:27THAT EXAMPLE THAT HELPS
- 53:29COORDINATE THIS WOMEN'S GROUP
- 53:30THAT COMES IN BEFORE THE
- 53:33SEMESTER STARTS IS THAT DEI DOES
- 53:36THAT COUNT BECAUSE THAT PERSON
- 53:37DOES A LOT OF OTHER THINGS.
- 53:38WHAT PORTION OF HIS OR HER
- 53:41SALARY WOULD BE DEDICATED TO
- 53:42THAT.
- 53:42A LOT OF THINGS WE DO, YOU
- 53:44TALKING ABOUT OUR DEFINITION ARE
- 53:47WHAT WEDNESDAY INTO THE FABRIC
- 53:48HELP STUDENTS BE SUCCESSFUL AND
- 53:50SOME OF THE THINGS ARE RACE
- 53:52NEUTRAL.
- 53:52WE HAVE A LOT OF COMMUNITY
- 53:54COLLEGES HAVE FOOD BANKS TO HELP
- 53:56STUDENTS THAT THE ARE FOOD
- 53:57INSECURE THAT IS ONE OF THE
- 53:59STRATEGIES WE LIST UNDER DEI.
- 54:01IF YOU ARE ASKING IS THAT A DEI
- 54:04POLICY DO I HAVE TO COUNT HOW
- 54:06MUCH I'M SPENDING ON THE FOOD
- 54:07BANK IT GETS DIFFICULT TO DO.
- 54:11>> I MEAN KIND OF THIS
- 54:12LEGISLATION WILL HAVE A CHILLING
- 54:15EFFECT ON THE ADMINISTRATION'S
- 54:16EFFORTS TO SUPPORT MINORITIES,
- 54:19WOMEN, LGBTQ STUDENTS, FACULTY
- 54:21ON CAMPUSES.
- 54:23BUT THE FIRST LINE OF DEFENSE
- 54:25ARE PROACTIVE EFFORTS AGAINST
- 54:29DISCRIMINATION WOULD BE BANNED
- 54:30WOULD NOT EXIST.
- 54:33SO I ESPECIALLY HAVE CONCERNS
- 54:34ABOUT THE ACADEMIC FREEDOM ABOUT
- 54:37RESTRICTIONS ON COURSE CONTENT
- 54:39AND RESTRICTIONS ON WHAT
- 54:44PROFESSOR CAN DISSEMINATE,
- 54:46PUBLISH ET CETERA.
- 54:46AND I THINK THAT FOR OUR
- 54:51DEMOCRACY THAT WE NEED TO MAKE
- 54:52SURE THAT WE DON'T IMPACT
- 54:54ACADEMIC FREEDOM.
- 54:55>> Renee: OF THE TWO BILLS WE'VE
- 54:57DISCUSSED TONIGHT WHICH IS THE
- 54:58LESSER OF THE TWO EVILS IN YOUR
- 54:59VIEW?
- 55:00>> I WOULD FIND SENATE BILL 6
- 55:05LESS DANGEROUS THAN HOUSE BILL
- 55:069.
- 55:07>> Renee: AND WHICH WOULD YOU
- 55:08PREFER?
- 55:09QUICKLY?
- 55:09>> I THINK BOTH HAVE GOOD
- 55:11POINTS.
- 55:11ONE POINT ABOUT THE FUNDING ON
- 55:14IT, UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY HAS
- 55:16103DEI RELATED POSITIONS WHERE
- 55:19THEY SPEND SPENT 10.5 MILLION
- 55:22LAST YEAR SINCE 2011, WE'VE HAD
- 55:25TO DECHRIST CREASE OF 34% OF
- 55:27BLACK STUDENTS ENROLLING IN
- 55:29HIGHER-ED.
- 55:29WE HAVE TO QUESTION.
- 55:30>> IT'S NOT JUST ABOUT BLACK
- 55:32STUDENTS.
- 55:33>> THIS IS ONE PART OF THAT URM
- 55:36UNDERREPRESENTED MINORITY.
- 55:37BUT WE HAVE TO ASK OURSELVES IS
- 55:39THIS MONEY BEING WELL SPENT?
- 55:41IS IT EFFECTIVE AND WE HAVE THE
- 55:43OTHER ISSUES WE'VE BEEN TALKING
- 55:45ABOUT.
- 55:46>> Renee: THE BILL YOU PREFER,
- 55:47SENATE BILL 6 OR HOUSE BILL 9.
- 55:48>> THEY BOTH HAVE GOOD POINTS IN
- 55:50BOTH OF THEM.
- 55:51>> PROFESSOR 20 SECONDS?
- 55:54>> YES, I THINK IF WE'RE TALKING
- 55:56ABOUT THE LEVEL OF PRINCIPLE, I
- 55:58THINK SENATE BILL 6 IS
- 55:59PARTICULARLY IMPORTANT BECAUSE
- 56:00IT RESTORES A BALANCE TO OUR
- 56:03EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM.
- 56:04DEI OFFICES ARE SO MESHED IN OUR
- 56:08SYSTEM THEY MIGHT BE HARD TO
- 56:10UNDO ALTHOUGH WE SHOULD UNDO
- 56:12THEM BUT RESTORE GOOD
- 56:13PRINCIPLES.
- 56:14>> Renee: THANK YOU ALL FOR
- 56:15BEING A PART OF THIS DISCUSSION.
- 56:16THIS IS WHERE THE HARD
- 56:17CONVERSATIONS ARE HAD RIGHT HERE
- 56:19ON "KENTUCKY TONIGHT" AND WE
- 56:20APPRECIATE YOUR FEEDBACK AS
- 56:22WELL.
- 56:22JOIN US WEEKNIGHTS AT 6:30
- 56:25EASTERN FOR KENTUCKY EDITION
- 56:26WHERE WE TALK ABOUT THE ISSUES
- 56:28AND SO MUCH MORE DURING THIS
- 56:30LEGISLATIVE SESSION.
- 56:31I'M RENEE SHAW AND I WILL SEE
- 56:32YOU SOON.