Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 136 - Ben Gunn: Three Rules For Life - Part 1
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:13My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 136 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:37Yes, hello indeed.
- 0:38And welcome to this very special two-part conversation with the one and only Mr. Ben Gunn.
- 0:47Now, this is a three and a half hour conversation full of absolute signal, as they say,
- 0:54but the rather long length of it is not the only reason that I have split it into two parts.
- 1:01Let me explain.
- 1:02I am trying out something new this week with the folks over at Fountain app.
- 1:08For those of you that don't know, Fountain is one of the biggest players in the value-for-value podcasting space.
- 1:15Their platform has been the preferred one for people who want to stream and boost Bitcoin
- 1:21to their favorite shows for a few years now,
- 1:24and I've been using it to swell the Free Cities podcast's
- 1:28strategic Bitcoin reserve ever since they integrated the platform
- 1:33with the decentralized social network NOSTA
- 1:36that everyone we know uses.
- 1:38Remember, guys, Bitcoin and NOSTA.
- 1:41These are the two pieces of tech you probably need
- 1:44to get your head around as soon as possible.
- 1:47In fact, after this conversation with Ben,
- 1:49I might even say it's quite urgent now.
- 1:52Well, as of last week, I have started using Fountain to host the Free Cities podcast.
- 1:58We've migrated it away from Spotify.
- 2:01And as a result, I can now try out a whole new roster of features,
- 2:06including bonus episodes and subscriptions, etc. to name but two.
- 2:12So what does this mean in reality?
- 2:15Well, this week's episode with Ben is available to everyone as per usual.
- 2:21But if you would like to listen to the second two hours, that will be a bonus episode available to subscribers only.
- 2:30That means if you subscribe to the Free Cities podcast, once you finish part one, you can just connect immediately with part two for the full three and a half hour interview experience.
- 2:42experience. It will just show up in your episode feed as per usual. As a subscriber, you will also
- 2:50get all the bonus episodes in the future and early access to all the very long form shows
- 2:56that get split into two parts, such as this one. You will also get a shout out each week if you
- 3:03choose on the show and a subscriber badge on fountain. Woohoo! Plus any comments you make
- 3:10will be read out in the intro of each show.
- 3:14What's not to like?
- 3:15There is a price to this, of course.
- 3:18What is it?
- 3:18Well, the price of a large Starbucks, in fact, for one month.
- 3:23Yes, that's right, six US dollars per month.
- 3:27And you not only get all the premium content I've mentioned,
- 3:30but you also get to sleep deeply at night,
- 3:33safe in the knowledge that you are supporting this show,
- 3:36which is, well, this show is obviously something
- 3:39I do as a passion project amongst other things. It does currently still require subsidizing with
- 3:46my own personal time. However, my plan in the long term is to run it as an extremely profitable
- 3:52business and subscriptions on Fountain will certainly be a step in that direction. So please
- 3:59click the subscribe button on your Fountain app and commit to just six bucks a month. And did you
- 4:07know you can even pay with your fiat that's right dirty fiat i would prefer sats of course but if
- 4:14you would like to make a recurring payment from your bank account well go ahead and choose that
- 4:19option on fountain now if you don't want to subscribe don't worry i still appreciate you
- 4:25as a loyal listener you can still boost and stream sats to us and you will still be able to listen to
- 4:32part two of this interview. You will just have to wait seven days to do that right onto the show.
- 4:41I should say that if you're new to Ben, my guest, go and check out episode number 97 of this podcast,
- 4:50which was the last time I spoke with Ben back in September of last year. That episode has a lot of
- 4:57background on him and introductory stuff etc. Ben doesn't do a lot of interviews as you may know
- 5:05to date I think only four over the last few years. This may be his fifth. Don't quote me on that.
- 5:11Anyway this time I went up to his citadel in the Welsh mountains with nothing much in mind
- 5:19other than to as we say shoot the shit and see what happens. Those are my favourite types of
- 5:26Conversations, as you may well know well, the result did not disappoint.
- 5:30This was an excellent conversation.
- 5:33In part one, we explore key ideas around privacy, anonymity, digital identity and the evolving role of decentralized technologies like NOSTA and Bitcoin.
- 5:46You may not know, but Ben's planning to use NOSTA as a decentralized identity and access control system for his place in Wales, aiming to balance privacy, trust and, most importantly, accountability.
- 6:04We also touch on the broader themes of governance, digital freedom and what to expect if you choose to reside in the decentralized future.
- 6:16really hope you do. Come and join us. Come on. Part two of this conversation, which you'll need to
- 6:23subscribe on Fountain to listen to, is where it really gets going as far as I'm concerned. Probably
- 6:30my favorite conversation of the year so far, if not this whole podcast. This part critically
- 6:38examines Bitcoin's evolving role in the global economy. And if you know Ben, you'll know he
- 6:45doesn't mince his words. He's a no-nonsense talker. We dissect its utility, adoption barriers,
- 6:52political implications, and the broader philosophical meaning of the age which we are all living through.
- 6:59There's some phenomenal stuff here in the second two hours. Here's a few bullet points to get the
- 7:05juices flowing. Bitcoin's identity crisis and its polarised adoption in what's called a barbell
- 7:12economic way. Look that one up. The middle class squeeze, debt and leverage, governments and the
- 7:19mafia, the reality of Bitcoin versus the state and the state's slow motion looting of its citizens.
- 7:28Ben frames the baby boomer narrative in a phenomenal way that I'd never thought of before,
- 7:34resulting in his assertion that understanding demographic dynamics is key to navigating
- 7:41the future. We also talk about societal breakdown and reset, leadership morality,
- 7:49and Ben's vision for the future, including how to position yourself for the best path through this
- 7:57mayhem, which we can all see coming. In particular, and this is my takeaway from the whole conversation,
- 8:04this means finding the meaning in your life, my friends. Meaning is the key,
- 8:10and it's also in my opinion the key to real freedom my meaning partly is this podcast and
- 8:19i'm truly thankful that you come here each week to listen to the well let's call them weird and
- 8:25wonderful people that i love to seek out in this world many thanks from the bottom of my heart for
- 8:32supporting us take a look at the new features available on fountain.fm and join us if you're
- 8:40not on fountain already come and join the value for value community don't forget to check out my
- 8:45show sponsor also veritas village they're building an off-grid community of luxury homes built for
- 8:53freedom lovers just like you www.ecovillages.life forward slash free cities everything you need to
- 9:01know about all these things is in the show notes. Right, time for the man like Mr. Gunn.
- 9:08I suppose you should grab your favourite rocking chair, put it out there in the woods nearby,
- 9:15make sure your dog is tucked up nicely at your feet whilst you sit back, relax and enjoy part one
- 9:23of my conversation with Ben Gunn.
- 9:31okay nice one cheers welcome back thank you i think i'm going to prelude this episode by saying
- 9:48yes you are looking every now and then at a picture of a cartoon character of a ben gun
- 9:54no it's not the real ben gun obviously it's not even your your pseudonymous yes i think it's fair
- 10:02to say but interesting though because i quite like to talk about that because i've had that thought
- 10:08obviously i'm not obviously no um but in this day and age why be even anonymous i mean when you
- 10:15think about it right what's it protecting you against because um number one someone can identify
- 10:24you by your voice as easy as anything you know number two if i wanted to find out who you were
- 10:29even if i'd never met yeah exactly so what is the point of like hiding your face just out of interest
- 10:34it's deciding what the principle is and defining it so if it's privacy
- 10:40then being sued anonymous is a means to that end right and if then you say well do i believe in
- 10:50privacy as a principle and i think there's a lot of listeners who will and they know that everybody
- 10:55else will say that but then how do you express that because privacy it's a little bit like hygiene
- 11:02you know in the sense that there's a good practice to not be outright dirty which is to say you have
- 11:09curtains on your windows and you have a reasonable amount of privacy but if you take it to a to an
- 11:14extreme and become jason born digging a hole and live in a faraday cage it's the same as someone
- 11:20who can't stop washing their hands and it's got that same kind of profile where you never can do
- 11:24enough to be absolutely private but you can do something in the middle proportionately to support
- 11:32the truth the principle of it which is privacy and the idea of of my maybe not being filmed or
- 11:38going to the other side and just being public is because it's i'm quite small scale so it's not
- 11:46going to matter to there's an element of what I'm doing that is not about me so it's about the fact
- 11:51that anybody could do it and so therefore I don't need to be part of it and then there's this support
- 11:57and a principle where just being a little bit private and a little bit more difficult to find
- 12:02and not so easy to graph helps people who really get the benefit of the use of that graph where now
- 12:09they're having to be sorted through 10,000 people like me or 10 million people like me
- 12:14and they're in that and for people that do need to be private because their rights can't be enforced
- 12:20in the way mine are currently then that's all to the good and i don't want to be hidden or secretive
- 12:27because that identity still carries a reputation and so you can abstract that and you can you can
- 12:36use that as a way to build trust with people they don't need to know everything about you
- 12:40uh it's what nost is doing well and you can build up essentially legal like legal entities
- 12:47up on these end pubs now and they don't need to be a real name because they might have a reputation
- 12:53that is abstracted from that but i think in the future right how are we not gonna interact with
- 13:03all that stuff like and i'm thinking like i've just been to america right and it's it's
- 13:09it's different over there even more well it's definitely different from wales put it that way
- 13:13you know i got in a car and the whole thing lit up like a bloody google services this certainly
- 13:20other cameras pointing at me blah blah you know uh everywhere i went i was being monitored
- 13:25basically in that world and that's going to happen here we know it especially i think cars
- 13:32it's going to be very i'm already like on my old you're the same actually on my old truck i'm
- 13:37already paying more more tax more road tax than a normal car because it's old right yeah and that
- 13:44will keep going up keep until i'm i'm like why am i paying so much on the independence of that
- 13:49versus something that can be turned off i think true but what i'm saying is how are we in the
- 13:54future gonna stay anonymous like is it not we're not no so what do we do like what do you do
- 14:02particularly because you really don't like being identified necessarily or it's not you don't like
- 14:07being identified it's like you i think i get the sense you just want to be annoying to some people
- 14:12that want to know who you are you know what i mean and that that annoying part is a personal
- 14:17thing it's not that i use it and an ominous identity to be able to do that i think that
- 14:26the schism you've got in in bitcoin circles and and freedom forums is that we do mix up secrecy
- 14:33and privacy and and and privacy is just a level of dignity that you can have affairs inside of
- 14:40loops that are private and you can express yourself in them in their proper context
- 14:45and reveal them selectively or not and secrecy is where you are not visible to anybody for any
- 14:54reason and yet want to still interact and go back out onto a social graph to do business or for
- 15:00someone to invest trust in you and you've you're just like you've got a paper bag on your head and
- 15:05when that paper bag carries a reputation that you don't do what you say you can take it off throw it
- 15:10in the bin and put a new bag on and so i think people make mistakes when they mix up secrecy and
- 15:17privacy where secrecy could be it's a neutral good it's a way to hide yourself now that could
- 15:23be hide yourself so you can shoot somebody who you shouldn't be shooting or it could be hiding
- 15:27because you're trying to hide from someone who's trying to shoot you so to the degree that you can
- 15:31be hidden or revealed it's just a technique and it can be put towards good purposes and bad
- 15:37where the tug of war is going on is that we want the society's trying to push for people to be
- 15:44visible completely visible and it takes the choice of that away completely sometimes that freedom can
- 15:51be used for bad to collude to plan and coordinate on things that are just evil and they're the
- 15:58arguments made to reduce all freedoms but we shouldn't be using freedom and the ability to
- 16:04express yourself privately or publicly as the way to throttle down on bad behavior it's the bad
- 16:10behavior that's bad and the means to find that bumps up against free privacy and people have a
- 16:17gut check when they hear that they're like right so i've got to have an identity card now
- 16:21but that's obviously not just going to shut down criminality that's going to stay and now we're
- 16:27just going to be identified for other reasons like vaccines or extra taxes or a new level of
- 16:33regulation or to track what you think or say based on your internet profile that's linked to an id
- 16:39so it's nefarious and they use arguments adjacent arguments to open that door and people can see
- 16:47that this is neutral it can be used visibility is good total visibility is bad and people need
- 16:53the control of that and they need to have some level of personal dignity how though do you i
- 16:59mean let's face it most people out there in the world and i say out there because it feels like
- 17:04it's out there when you're here to this nice but most people out there in the world don't care
- 17:09and we'll just go along with it and be be tracked and be this be that so it's almost like you've
- 17:15only got you've you've got these two lives one where you're behind your wall walled garden or
- 17:21whatever citadel yeah and the other one when you go out in the world and you can't even be you can't
- 17:26even be anonymous out there because you stand out by trying to be anonymous so is that is that is
- 17:31that where we're at is it like citadels or nothing is it yeah it the pressure is pushing it there
- 17:37and it's making people have to decide um and i don't want to sound despondent but yeah the
- 17:44technology is fierce enough to sort of remove the even the ethical side of the argument if if a
- 17:49government can cheaply deploy something that monitors you very closely and there isn't enough
- 17:54will to press back on it as a population it's going to be enforced and i know that sounds terrible
- 17:59i just suppose you wait for whatever happens in that environment that doesn't happen healthily
- 18:06in a free society and then they'll get the consequences of it afterwards the problem is
- 18:11we're all carried along with our majorities and it doesn't matter if there's 10 of you and 60
- 18:16billion of 60 million other people you're you can't enforce that with with your own violence
- 18:24or with your own protect you can't do that i mean you're making the case for small independent
- 18:29jurisdictions with their own rules right there and i've always got to check myself when i because i
- 18:36I often come back to that again and again and again.
- 18:39And it's like,
- 18:39um,
- 18:41because,
- 18:42and it's not just because this is the free six podcast is because when you
- 18:46go down all the routes of the future,
- 18:48you discover this place where,
- 18:51like you say,
- 18:52technology will very cheaply monitor everything you do very cheaply.
- 18:56And even going in the future,
- 18:58there'll be little tiny little nano drones flying around.
- 19:01I don't know.
- 19:01Or whatever.
- 19:02But even,
- 19:03even what we can imagine,
- 19:05because it's already happening.
- 19:06if you go out into the real world yeah you have to try to not be tracked it's not that you you kind
- 19:11of like you know that you have to make a concerted effort to not be tracked so and you know within
- 19:18not being trackable it gets to a point where you're more visible like you said you're more
- 19:23visible by having no footprints than you are by having some that are obscured or along a lot of
- 19:29other footprints and that's the level of conviction i have in my private identity i could care less
- 19:35if I get quote unquote doxed or tracked down.
- 19:37It doesn't matter.
- 19:38I'm one hop away from finding out who I am
- 19:40because my work is out there facing the public
- 19:43and I don't really care that much.
- 19:46But it's just small steps that make a bigger anonymity set
- 19:49for people who really need it
- 19:50or people who might need it once.
- 19:54A sort of semi-obscured way to communicate.
- 19:59And I just hold it open for that.
- 20:01It's just a way to join a bigger group
- 20:03where some people in that group need to not be found
- 20:08or need to communicate in a context that isn't public and shouldn't be.
- 20:13And that's my part of it personally.
- 20:17But it's a complicated principle.
- 20:19It's complicated.
- 20:20And we've got to try and go into the middle of the two extremes,
- 20:23which is complete secrecy,
- 20:25where we cannot be sure of anything from a counterparty
- 20:28we need to do business with or live around.
- 20:30Because this is the other side of it for privacy people.
- 20:33It's like, don't think that you can do what you want now
- 20:36because you've got a mask on, you can do what you want
- 20:39and then drop away and you're in a different network.
- 20:42You just plug out like the matrix
- 20:43and you're not that guy anymore.
- 20:45Because it sounds good, but you're going to stay hidden
- 20:49and people aren't going to see your values
- 20:51because you can't show them anywhere that's public.
- 20:54And you're going to be able to hide the bad aspects of you
- 20:57in a way other people can't see.
- 20:59So when we give up that visibility,
- 21:01at its extreme the visibility is bad because people can take everything that you you are
- 21:06on the digital map and turn it to oh look what he did there and look what he said there
- 21:11but if you take it to the other extreme where everybody doesn't have any record of the other
- 21:16person in their life we can't build up a pattern of good and bad behavior all right then so
- 21:22correct me if i'm wrong but one of your sort of like methods slash theories is to use nosda as
- 21:31identity yeah and okay so in in one sense you're you're basically and just a number
- 21:39so you are kind of you know slightly private and in it and everything you do is based upon
- 21:45the connections you have with other people so you can you can be vouched for very easily even in an
- 21:51anonymous way but the truth of that system even is once you throw enough computer power at it you
- 21:56can work out who's who and what who's doing what and everything so what's the what have we got just
- 22:03do we just have to surrender to this idea that we going to be found out everything i think i think this without blowing the conversation up too much we at a time when there a lot in the headlines and sorry for the noise in the background no wait we at
- 22:19we're at a working sawmill yeah so amongst other things but i was just going to say that it's a
- 22:24really uncertain world and there's stuff going on in it that looks massive and stuff that we cannot
- 22:29even control uh or influence it's just it's just borderline nuclear war regional conflict and all
- 22:36the rest of the misery and it's very hard to just think and take it back to your individual life and
- 22:41try and work out you know oh what should i be like on the privacy and what should i be doing and
- 22:47under that it's just very hard at the moment to make definitive decisions and it isn't something
- 22:52that i've thought a lot about i just had a avatar on twitter from years ago and just enjoyed that
- 23:00kind of abstraction from me uh but understood it was more important to a group than it was to me
- 23:06and the individual and that's really where i fell out on privacy but it under under what we're seeing
- 23:12in the world i think it's one of those things as long as it's not one of the two extremes
- 23:17and as long as gnostic and help i don't know record good behavior like an uber score and do
- 23:26it under certain rules and it doesn't need to enforce like black marks and nasty comments and
- 23:31things but we do have to have some sort of decentralized review system and use these mpubs
- 23:36as entities and they can be companies or they could be groups they could be guilds private and
- 23:42then using the same technology in bitcoin we can use that to control access to places
- 23:47physical places or or forums or connections with other people that goes by goodwill and that's just
- 23:55the way that we can make things cheaper because we don't have to interact with people who have got
- 23:59a record of not pulling through on what they said uh it's where people wanted to put bitcoin directly
- 24:05they wanted bitcoin to be the court of law and okay you know i can't see court cases going onto
- 24:12the onto the time chain onto the base layer and i think nost is just a good it's the bitcoiner
- 24:18layer and i think it will come with accountability and i think that's the square that the
- 24:25privacy absolutists if you call people if there are people like that is that yeah you've got you've
- 24:31got a right to hide and you've got a right to have some things that you keep to yourself
- 24:34and that can be abused when they're given away that's all obvious but we've got to go more than
- 24:41that if we go to the other extreme and just have total anonymous economic participants they're
- 24:47going to realize costs by not knowing who they're dealing with and that's a big loss that's as much
- 24:53a loss as having zero privacy so i just think that's how nostr is gonna divide the difference
- 25:01and let you show a record of what you're best at and let it be verified in different ways by other
- 25:07people and it isn't that you have to have your whole life put up in spotlight because obviously
- 25:13that's being used to coerce people and threaten them to make decisions and things and introduce
- 25:18an opinion they have in one area to the detriment of their life in another.
- 25:23And it just chills everybody down.
- 25:25The same way that dealing with people who are completely secret would be,
- 25:29not knowing who the other person is.
- 25:31You only need to know enough to transact.
- 25:35If we're talking about capital allocation,
- 25:37we don't need to know everything about you.
- 25:39And I don't need to know what you were like at your worst moment.
- 25:42That's private.
- 25:43so we need the tech that can enforce that stuff that is just group agreed that you have no right
- 25:49to see and if you do see it we've got to be sensible enough to say that's taken out of
- 25:53context because that was in a private group and you've just published it on a on a daily mail blog
- 25:58of course it's going to look terrible you've taken it out of the way it was said abstracted it
- 26:03and curated it and put it somewhere else to set mischief and that's harder to do when you've got
- 26:08this n-pub relay structure and all it's going to take is more development to take it from social
- 26:15media uh clones like twitter and the type of stuff we see on nostr which is good and develop it so
- 26:23that you can put more scale and weight and more economic significance on it so we go from funny
- 26:28memes and zaps to prove the fact that we can swap content for money on a micro scale but when you go
- 26:33up orders of magnitude in what we're trying to do and we talk about free cities and circular
- 26:37economies and things it's not one degree more difficult to do something that you'll have to do
- 26:44on on a jurisdiction that wants taxes and things done to regulations and things um i'm trying to
- 26:52do something in the middle and i'm trying to support these technologies as they come along
- 26:56and use them immediately when they are so i mean you in a way like is this correct i don't know
- 27:05is this public knowledge that you would like this place to be,
- 27:13like your ID to be verified by NOSTA to even come in and out?
- 27:16Is that right?
- 27:17Yeah.
- 27:17Yeah, yeah, okay, right.
- 27:18People know that, right?
- 27:20Well, it's not something I'd hide.
- 27:22But it's a good experiment because it's...
- 27:25No, I've got to spend money in one place, right?
- 27:29And it's security.
- 27:31So you can't have...
- 27:32It's rural Wales, so it's not...
- 27:33it's not like downtown Baghdad,
- 27:36but you also sometimes lose your quad bikes.
- 27:39And sometimes you've got people on who are a nuisance,
- 27:41who can visit because they can walk in the gate.
- 27:44And you could see them or not see them,
- 27:46but they've not booked an appointment.
- 27:47And the minute they're on ground that you're responsible for,
- 27:50you're sort of legally responsible for them.
- 27:52So you've got to buy a gate.
- 27:54And then you look at the tech
- 27:56and you've all these different proprietary systems,
- 27:5920 pound a month, and they do your NFC.
- 28:01but NOSTA is doing it alongside open source and you can and it's it's translatable into other use
- 28:08cases so I might use NOSTA I might say to you right use your NSEC and I'll add you to a whitelist
- 28:14and then you can just beep in with a signing device or something on this day and then when
- 28:19that window closes if you try and beep it there's no one home and that's a great use case but that
- 28:25same NPUB that does access control you know under another use case let's say we develop badges
- 28:30and I say, right, it's cheaper for me to be a host of people who've got first aid training.
- 28:34Do I need to know where you did it? No. I need to see a badge associated to your end pub that says
- 28:40you've done first aid. And I need that badge to be issued by someone who's known and verified to
- 28:44do good first aid training. And they've said, right, you did a course with us. You're a good
- 28:48bloke. You didn't kick off and you'd listen to what we'd said and you've got a skill you didn't
- 28:52have stamp. And it makes the, it makes the privileges I can give here cheap to give out.
- 28:58but if we did total secrecy who are you mate don't know you from adam well trust me it's like
- 29:06well hang on a minute we were doing trust a minute ago and now we're going to go total maximal
- 29:11privacy where we don't know anybody where anybody's from or what they do or they can't show anything
- 29:15about themselves that's makes things expensive again to host so nostre if we develop on nostre
- 29:22for access control we've got a nostre user that can use the other suite of tools in nostre
- 29:27along different use cases that are common to a site, this site and others.
- 29:33All around the world, someone will need, if they've got a location,
- 29:37they need to know who that other person is on their development.
- 29:41Now that's like, oh God, what, you've got an ID system?
- 29:43Yeah, we've got an ID system.
- 29:45So it's not Chinese social credit score stuff.
- 29:50It's identification.
- 29:53I suppose that's the middle of these two extremes.
- 29:57is that you don't want to be identified, over-identified,
- 30:00where your entire transcript of your life is stood up in light
- 30:03against its purpose.
- 30:05And you don't want to be a complete black hat.
- 30:08Because you can't get anywhere.
- 30:09You'd always be meeting an interaction
- 30:11at someone else's maximum defensiveness, right?
- 30:15So, you all right?
- 30:19Yeah, sorry, that's flashing.
- 30:21Never seen that flash before.
- 30:22As long as I'm not flashing.
- 30:24We were talking about NOSTA.
- 30:27identity and you said um you know it's very this isn't a kind of chinese style
- 30:36you know governance system right blah blah but right it it's not that dissimilar to it
- 30:44no it's not that dissimilar to it right it's not now check this out because i had this really
- 30:47interesting conversation in america about a couple of few months ago with this guy ian underwood his
- 30:53name was he's a libertarian in new hampshire lives out on a homestead in the middle of the woods it's
- 30:59amazing you'd love it out there and he had he told me about this new way of governing that he thought
- 31:07no one had sort of like mentioned before and it's quite incredible and it's actually probably
- 31:12the way few the way forward but when we were talking about it i noticed the same thing that he
- 31:18that we are just thinking about there is that oh shit this is quite near the social credit system
- 31:23I'll give you an example. His idea was you have everyone basically decides.
- 31:29He said this is a cure for the democratic system, which basically means like you vote for mob rule.
- 31:35Yeah, you vote for the difference. You vote for someone and half the people lose out.
- 31:40Why don't you turn it back the other way? Why don't you say you can decide what you want to vote, but not geographically you vote.
- 31:48so if you want to say you believe in um free health care right so you just so you just assign
- 31:54yourself to that party and you pay into that party for free health care but you don't do it
- 31:59geographically you do it you do one country it's a good uh way to it's like a it's like a rhetorical
- 32:06way of understanding two things better but it's not a viable way to run an area no but you could
- 32:12do it like follow it follow it because i'll tell you why sorry i'll tell you why because the because
- 32:17the people that sign up for free health care don't pay for it yeah i know but that's the thing it
- 32:20would it would it was a be a free market in governance so those those kind of ideas would
- 32:24disappear they're not voting because they have the choice to buy health care or not they just
- 32:29want the principal it does voting because you get it for free if they vote and they don't get it yeah
- 32:33but the point is if you really are say you're in america if you're really a democrat and you really
- 32:38believe in free health care for example you're willing to pay into the system so you don't but
- 32:44now you don't you don't vote to get your guy in and force everyone to pay into the system
- 32:48you just get all the democrats to pay into the system and they basically identify themselves
- 32:54because it's very technologically it's very easy now so so you you don't need a geographical
- 32:59boundary to your you know your political sphere the democratic model works by setting
- 33:06the majority against minorities in turn yeah we're not doing a democratic model here we're
- 33:12doing everyone so everyone has an identity so you have an identity say you have a nostril identity
- 33:18and in that identity you say what you believe in and what you're prepared to do and if you go if
- 33:23you go against that so say in your identity it says i will not steal if you steal then you get
- 33:28punished if you don't steal everything's fine um if you believe in free health care because you want
- 33:33free healthcare at some point then you say yeah i'm willing to pay into that system and you're
- 33:38like cool so you're you're you agree to those ideas but you might be dispersed amongst your
- 33:43neighbor over there may not he's like no i don't i don't actually want to pay into that system
- 33:46and and um every everyone has a unique id which basically carries with it what what they believe
- 33:56in and what they want to do and how they want to operate in the world and everyone gets what they
- 33:59want basically why because the people that want free healthcare can't afford to deliver free
- 34:05healthcare even to themselves let alone to the majority yeah but wouldn't theoretically there'd
- 34:10be enough people that believe in it no right in that case free healthcare is not a good idea
- 34:14correct right exactly but that's how that's a good system we're not here because it's the best idea
- 34:19we're here because it's the easiest enforced they can you can you can abstract 80 of your rights
- 34:26you're born with into a voting box for a four-year renewable promise to be treated well when you're
- 34:34ill and they go for it or you could invest some money wisely as an individual and you would have
- 34:42enough money to pay for your health care yourself no no but i mean like you could do that if you
- 34:48wanted to yeah but then all but that that incentive to invest is taken away from your taxes which pay
- 34:54So you're charged to win and you're given 100% of the right to lose.
- 35:00But in this system, taxes are almost non-existent because you can choose whether or not you pay them.
- 35:06You can be someone, all you have to pay for is the upkeep of the system because the system is basically very cheap to upkeep.
- 35:14It doesn't need a huge amount of bureaucracy.
- 35:15No, you have to pay for the cost of defending that from a next door state or next door town that are like, well, that's not going to work for us.
- 35:26So why don't we just go and brass them up?
- 35:29Right.
- 35:29But that might be the one thing you pay for.
- 35:31Well, that's what you pay for in government.
- 35:33It's a set menu.
- 35:34Your health care and stuff, that's like political preference.
- 35:37But what you're really connected to is the peace of mind.
- 35:40You're not being invaded right now.
- 35:42Right.
- 35:42But when you look at it.
- 35:44And when you pay for that, it can enforce all of the other things that majorities want in that.
- 35:50Yeah, but I agree.
- 35:51You might want to pay for that one thing, which is the protection of private property anyway, or rights, some kind of rights that you deem are rights.
- 36:00The rest of it is a choice.
- 36:02The rest of it is a choice, like the health care, the way the schools, the funding of schools, the things, the that, the rest of it is a choice.
- 36:09And as a free market, what should transpire over the long term is quite a properly kind of democratic so far.
- 36:20You're talking about a partnership, like an old-fashioned equity partnership where votes are done to form consensus, but they're prorated against your stake in whatever your entity's voting on.
- 36:31So, you know, old Goldman Sachs, old banks, 20 partners, each, let's say, each has 5% stake and their votes represent five in every hundred votes on a particular issue.
- 36:44And then it's done on majority there.
- 36:48But that's a fairer form of majority because it's not nominal, like just a show at hands who thinks that we should burn the teachers and not pay them anything and give them money to the police.
- 36:56like that's a different format than all the partners having equity
- 37:01and long-term upside in that system.
- 37:03We're breaking here because people aren't brave enough
- 37:08or intelligent enough perhaps to understand
- 37:11that this way of getting things done is terrible.
- 37:17As in the democratic system.
- 37:18The democratic system and the way it's funded
- 37:20and the purposes it's turned to, often to them.
- 37:24uh i just think we're in a very low courage very low confrontational mindset take that all right
- 37:31take your idea of using nostor to be an identity and finding a middle ground then in it where you're
- 37:38private enough but not too private yeah when that scales say say for some reason it scales
- 37:45say it's not just a bunch of well maybe you think it is do you think it'll scale
- 37:50I think it'll definitely have to scale because it's got the lowest route to...
- 37:57You've got a right to use it without any requirements.
- 38:01And the other thing is it's not mutually exclusive.
- 38:04You're not saying, right, pick up NOSTA and burn your passport.
- 38:07This is an extra sort of form of membership, sort of a form of a LinkedIn.
- 38:12And you get an Uber score and you live and die on your reputation.
- 38:16And it's okay to record that as long as it's pre-agreed.
- 38:19and NOSTA's open. You don't have to associate any activity to your NOSTA profile. If you want to
- 38:24post cats and get zapped and have a bit of fun and just show a tiny little bit of yourself,
- 38:30just a couple of funny posts, it doesn't have to be anything to do with you. That's one end pub.
- 38:34But what about the one where you're a plumber? Do you want to have a secret plumber
- 38:40who's got a type of work that could manifest itself as poor in six months or more?
- 38:46no i want to i want to go on google i want to search by average review on amazon i want to
- 38:53speak to people i want anecdotal evidence i want to hear both sides of a blow up and i've got to
- 38:59decide like how much risk do i put on that counterparty and this is a way to show the
- 39:05aspects of your character that you want to market or show in these subsets of groups or into the
- 39:11public on a broad relay or in a group within nostr where you sort of have an access to it and you can
- 39:18make comments and do activity in the context of that private group that's exciting because it's
- 39:23not that hard to do as far as code and it hacks quite a lot of bitcoin's technology except proof
- 39:30of work and finite supply and it keeps the encryption side and we can build quite a lot
- 39:36on that i mean i'm talking about utilities for real economy and the only difference between that
- 39:41and a social credit system is it's decentralized if decentralized it's peer-to-peer as opposed to
- 39:45hub and spoke where the central panopticon maintainer of the database that sits you know
- 39:52under westminster or under uh washington or wherever and they just make pseudo admin changes
- 39:59to who you are based on the situation as it changes and what you think of it um and you don't
- 40:04get to choose what's being recorded like that's another big thing isn't it like on nosty like set
- 40:08you could have a setting you could have different accounts and it's like don't track my location
- 40:12whereas what they want is the all or nothing they want right you did slide d anything but up to
- 40:17basically a tattoo on your head so you can be recognized wherever you are and and once you're
- 40:22in your own front door it doesn't stop there because it's ring doorbells and it's alexas and
- 40:27it's all mapped and that's what that's what they want and they'll take it because they can
- 40:31because no one else is going to fight back on it.
- 40:34So basically, it will arise inevitably
- 40:39in the same way that decentralized money is inevitable.
- 40:43Inevitable.
- 40:43So decentralized identity is inevitable.
- 40:46Yes.
- 40:47It's the cheapest to deliver on the problem
- 40:49of transacting with other people
- 40:51without the centralized court
- 40:54and without the social credit system.
- 40:55What's the cheapest to deliver way
- 40:57for you to reveal an aspect of yourself
- 41:00that can't be forged that lets someone else make a decision to take risk with you
- 41:06or for you to take risk with them and then you're into commerce you're into commerce you're into
- 41:11contracts and bills of credit and you can build end pubs up with transcripts of quasi public so
- 41:18we did a contract did you get to see the price of it no did you get to see the nature of a contract
- 41:23yes and can you see what both parties said about it very similar like to a peer-to-peer bitcoin
- 41:28exchange if you were to go on one of the big ones like peach uh then if that's big or not but it's
- 41:33a nice one yeah hodl hodl bisque they all have reputation systems they have to because it makes
- 41:39things so precipitously cheaper if you prove that you do that side of an escrow consistently and you
- 41:46don't push things into into the grievance the mediation or the governance system of swapping
- 41:52money so you just extend that into social interactions and into certifications for
- 41:58instance for people you can demonstrate a competence or a capability something you're
- 42:03good at something you're professionally good at hobbyist and it's combination of badges to
- 42:07confirm certifications which is just a decentralized same way that you get university degrees and
- 42:13qualifications for adventure training and stuff like that you just do it on NOSTA with badges
- 42:18isn't though the centralized version more efficient because it's it's a it's as in
- 42:25yeah more efficient basically you know in a way it depends what you're what you're what you're
- 42:32it depends like efficient for i mean if it's if it's well let's let's look at an efficient hub
- 42:37and spoke identity system because i have a small background in diving in scuba diving
- 42:43and look these are plastic cards that come out in the mail from Paddy and from these they're great
- 42:50until you dive with a Chinese guy who's got fewer dives in his logbook than the minimum entry
- 42:57requirements for the badge he's got to get on the boat it can't manage his buoyancy and then it's
- 43:03not efficient then and the way that Nostra improves on that is that it becomes it's a matter
- 43:09of fidelity you can go an extra step with NOSTA and prove not perfectly but prove well that
- 43:17something went down the way it went down and peer-to-peer keeps that more honest than us
- 43:21hub and the hub and spoke thing oh yeah we've got some certification mill problems yeah you've got
- 43:27people double spending your certification stamp and the the quality of that to the people who
- 43:34get the cost of it which is the introduced scuba instructor or guide have to roll the dice to the
- 43:41degree that sir is could be milled or it could be not quite legit in the dive that you're taking
- 43:48your life to take people out onto the ocean on and i imagine that would be the same with welding
- 43:52qualifications and structural engineering and all sorts of things that are issued out of a tower
- 43:57that still have a low fidelity
- 44:01compared to just proof of work
- 44:02and progress and transcript
- 44:04and doing things by practice.
- 44:07And we can record all that on NOSTA.
- 44:09And it's going to sit wrong on people
- 44:11because some people are like,
- 44:11I'm not going to show myself on there.
- 44:13I don't know.
- 44:14I'm not going to show.
- 44:14And it's like, hang on a minute then.
- 44:16Because you get to keep the choice
- 44:18and you won show any part of you that will stand up to scrutiny in any community small or big maybe you not as good as you say you are Maybe you just going from group to group and emptying pockets or telling fibs and moving on like a gypsy
- 44:36And you're getting away with it because it's the downside of a privacy argument which can be turned left into total secrecy or right into total visibility.
- 44:47and the issue in the middle is identity so we capture them bits that we get the benefit of
- 44:52identifying another person and we take it out of that low end scale of friends and you know that
- 44:59sort of informal way to identify somebody and try and extend it so i can get a good impression of
- 45:06somebody at distance that i can make a reasonable decision to interact with them and have an
- 45:11expectation that's going to make things cheap and it's going to mean we can do things at bigger scale
- 45:16of economy than we do at the moment, like a hackathon, blog post, one-man band, one-man
- 45:22armies, which go by well on total secrecy or the right to. But if you're trying to build
- 45:28up to bigger levels of investment, you're trying to do bigger things, bigger things
- 45:32at scale, you need to have more surety. I think it'll come through as well in insurance
- 45:39because the other thing that building up a profile on NOSTA would allow you to do is
- 45:43prove that you've lowered an average risk in whatever you're asking to be covered by
- 45:49and insurance is a good pricing mechanism for the types of risks that we take you know so if you've
- 45:56got a good track record like having a no claims bonus nobody's screaming at the rooftops because
- 46:01the insurance companies know how many years it's gone since you've left last crashed no one's
- 46:07arguing that that should be private data and the reason is because everyone understands it's like
- 46:11ah I get it
- 46:12if you can prove
- 46:13you don't crash your car
- 46:14you get your insurance quote down
- 46:16and you get my insurance quote down
- 46:17so that's alright
- 46:18it doesn't mean
- 46:19but they want to put a tracker
- 46:21in your car though
- 46:21to track you
- 46:23to work out
- 46:24whether you're going too fast
- 46:25it's this constant argument
- 46:26like there's a
- 46:26there's a good reason
- 46:27to have a tracker in your car
- 46:28if it gets robbed
- 46:29it's easier to find
- 46:30like if you're an insurer
- 46:31tracking your car
- 46:32it might not be nefarious
- 46:34on one aspect of it
- 46:35but the ugly part
- 46:37is when they take good reasons
- 46:38to have tech do things
- 46:40and smush them in to a set menu where in a click of a finger or the change of a boss,
- 46:47they can use that same map to attack somebody.
- 46:51Having sold it to them as something that will defend them,
- 46:54which is put a tracker in your car, get your insurance quote down.
- 46:57Because when it gets robbed, we can track it and you can prove to us live
- 47:00that you're not going 80 mile an hour around the B roads as a 17 year old.
- 47:04That's not that.
- 47:05That's how we get your insurance quote down, mate.
- 47:07If you don't like that, it's five grand a year.
- 47:09and if you don't like that it's because look at the statistics for children who crash cars
- 47:14at your age your front your brain's not connected to the back till you're 24 so it's a box in your
- 47:20car in it so there's a validity in that but then you get caught on the wrong side of it it's like
- 47:24ah you want people tracked it's like well no i don't want people tracked i want to track what
- 47:29they're doing when i'm underwriting the risk of it i don't need to know what that guy's politics
- 47:34are to throw them out of the insurance market so I don't need the rest of it.
- 47:38And I think Nostas are just a really readily available
- 47:42back end to build these utilities on the front end and people can pick
- 47:46to what level they're visible and how much they connect one thing
- 47:50to another in their life.
- 47:53You can be private in the things that should be private
- 47:57and you can be public in the things that we benefit from being public in.
- 48:00and that's the that's the middle i think of this whole issue about privacy and secrecy
- 48:07and and you can argue both ends and the extremes of it kind of comes around to the same problem
- 48:12so does it begin in this world in these kind of and then become adopted and does it ever
- 48:22become adopted on the scale of what you know the the the opposing thing being id cards does it ever
- 48:32get adopted at that scale or is it always this parallel system where people use bitcoin more
- 48:38people use privacy tools more people use noster more you know the i think the the truths of any
- 48:47of the issues are where the world's trying to pull to so what i mean by that is if we did go
- 48:52full china there's still a pressure in that society to be free and it goes somewhere and i
- 48:59think that's where the situation is the least sustainable i don't think a chinese total totality
- 49:05model is an end game it's a it's it's necessarily fragile and the problem with them is that will go
- 49:12down and it will fall in on itself one day and when it does there'll be total collapse after it
- 49:16and i suppose the other side of it is we can't all live in sort of hobbit holes and
- 49:22not not not engage and do anything or take risk because you're not really realizing the potential
- 49:28of your identity of like who you are as a person you're not going to get there if you're constantly
- 49:33defending yourself and we're we're just going to go through the middle of it and all these attempts
- 49:38to be free they'll manifest as extremes they'll manifest as events these sort of volatility blips
- 49:46that point out where we're missing the truth of something and we're delivering a system that
- 49:51steers away from it and it'll just have to play out some some organizations are trying to go in
- 49:58at the top down and then approach a government get the government top cover for their project
- 50:04where it's free over here and we'll just have to trust that that entity will follow through on
- 50:10what they've agreed with and then you've got bottom up which is it always risks being
- 50:14a little bit larpy you know part-time anarchism and but living on the suburbs of uh fiat developed
- 50:23country and just sort of moonlighting on the weekends uh being a being a sort of edward snowden
- 50:29and not really having any impact so it's hard to draw the middle and i think all these projects
- 50:35are trying to do it in a different way obviously a lot in bitcoin and free cities is grassroots
- 50:40So it's people have deep convictions and have to live in an environment that's not the same values.
- 50:47Do you abdicate that?
- 50:49And you're just like the black sheep in a society and making comments on it and sort of adapting to it.
- 50:58Or what, revolutionary guerrilla warfare or something?
- 51:02No, it's not that either.
- 51:05and I think the pressure just to transact freely and get things cheaper and make things better
- 51:12quality and give people what they want is just going to force a path through the middle and
- 51:17that's why I like the NOSTA stuff so much. You could argue that it might follow the same trajectory
- 51:24as Bitcoin which was quite larpy to begin with you could you could say and now we sit at this
- 51:32moment in history when it's bizarre i remember you know one news article about bitcoin coming out
- 51:42like yeah eight years ago and going off and it being a big deal just to get a mention in a
- 51:46newspaper right it was just this remarkable same feeling by the way same sort of disorienting like
- 51:51what i've just heard that from and like eight pieces of news every day about about something
- 51:57weird happening you know like we take a 24-hour snapshot just for everyone to remember inside a
- 52:0224 hours we've had Israel bombing the tar out of Iran's nuclear facilities we've had the US Nimitz
- 52:09carrier strategic group move away from Taiwan towards the Middle East that's that's huge stuff
- 52:16we've had a Bitcoin venture capital sorry a gold miner VC based in UK move into Bitcoin mining
- 52:24just only a constellation of events inside of one little slither of time
- 52:28gold miners are becoming bitcoin miners in the year that the the america the u.s created a bitcoin
- 52:34strategic reverse yeah um within two years of the biggest head fund in the world creating the biggest
- 52:41etf in history yeah i mean it's all a bit like it's almost like a joke now it's almost like well
- 52:47if you nothing nothing matters you're trying to track the path of something that's sort of like
- 52:50the cousin of bitcoin the younger cousin of bitcoin i think in nostor it's not the same it's not like
- 52:55brother sister because it lacks vital aspects of bitcoin but it's just it's a network that's not
- 53:00optimized to be money it's a network to optimized for the user of bitcoin it's the bootloader for
- 53:07the user of the emergent tech which was bitcoin so we got our money right before we found a way
- 53:14for us to interact with it safely bitcoin's fine bitcoin doesn't care about the battle groups
- 53:20not much it doesn't care about the this or that things that affect bitcoiners bitcoiners are still
- 53:26in big trouble we're still carbon and we're still subject to the laws of violence we can still be
- 53:32coerced we can still be threatened there's a massive spike in bitcoin kidnappings crypto
- 53:39kidnappings uh ledger ceo got shut down for five million quid with it just a straight up robbery
- 53:46so that bitcoin didn't care like the bitcoin was all safe it didn't crack the encryption of bitcoin
- 53:51they didn't interrupt the mining supply they didn't change the amount of nodes pointing this
- 53:56way or that bitcoin is fine the problem is that we we are using it and it's the only reason it
- 54:02exists is to serve us and we can't interact with it as safely as it can interact with itself it's
- 54:08abstract it's completely digital and abstract and that's great but it's over there we just
- 54:14just having that asset it's a big deal because it's an ultimate right of property isn't it you
- 54:19no one else can destroy that ownership but they can still definitely have fun with you and the
- 54:26demand and the implications of good money that can't be used at scale because we're still trying
- 54:31to use it on a fiat map that has regulations and taxes and orders by violence force things that are
- 54:38majority popular but aren't true huge issues things that push costs into the future health
- 54:45care everyone has a right to free health care but it's always on the generation that's not been born
- 54:50yet to pay so that's why we're generous we're just eating our own grandchildren to get kidney
- 54:55dialysis today and it's gross the reason is the money isn't enforced in the analog world
- 55:02it's a perfect principle and it can be perfect because it's digital it has zero grams of weight
- 55:08without stating the obvious you can't stab it and you can't destroy it
- 55:13and that's already happened in a way that already come out the canon and it's already
- 55:19been adapted to the world has it completely shattered the system it's in no it's kind of
- 55:23warped it the the system can't destroy it so it has to adapt to it it's like a it's like skin
- 55:29going around a splinter or something so it's adapting bitcoin's not ubiquitous they have got
- 55:35control over aspects of it bottlenecks and flows but they haven't defeated it and it doesn't feel
- 55:41captured and now we've got nostos of what three five ten years behind it it's hard to tell but
- 55:48like in the in the in the street in the what you call it the stream like in behind bitcoin benefiting
- 55:55from what and we also get the look at what where did we stop where did bitcoin stop where was
- 56:00bitcoin attacked along the way and we can sort of have a guess at where nosta will go based on where
- 56:06bitcoin is and i think that's gonna i think that's where it's aiming at it's aiming at this middle
- 56:12economy this real economy and it's saying okay this is interesting um here's bitcoin i log in
- 56:18with that and i move utxtos here's nosta i log in with that with the exact same encryption and i post
- 56:24notes and they're informal and there's an unlimited amount of them but you know they're from me and no
- 56:29one else can send them and we just build on that but where it builds to like lego is out of social
- 56:34media accounts and you follow your mate who's a funny guy or the guy who just checks in every now
- 56:38and then and you follow a business and you follow them to look at their history and decide whether
- 56:45you want their product or not and the more that that business can show that's provable and at high
- 56:51fidelity instead of just marketing bump and the more it's punished for doing poor products leaving
- 56:56people worse off than they find them i don't think that's an erosion of privacy at all i think that's
- 57:02highlighting exactly what you're meant to highlight in a productive economy what you're good at what
- 57:06will you come through and do and what does it cost you not to because you only have to cock one thing
- 57:12up to not have that reputation anymore as we know so that's what nostril do it'll allow us to scale
- 57:19to hire projects than one person
- 57:24without needing to go right the way up to a state-level government
- 57:28and argue a clause in the constitution
- 57:30and bet that they're going to follow through on that and not change it.
- 57:36It's funny, over the years of being into the free cities thing,
- 57:41I've learned to really appreciate the difference between, you know,
- 57:47i always i see it like this now bitcoin was um freedom in the digital realm and as much as is
- 57:56possible the ideas that we look at on this podcast and in the whole movement are trying to create
- 58:05freedom in the physical world which is is probably not possible it's certainly not possible to the
- 58:10degree you get it in the digital world put it that way that's so true right but let me let me
- 58:14just go on a bit so so if you think about bitcoin and the freedom in the in the digital world
- 58:22that's new it's new the the scarcity is new that there's lots of aspects of bitcoin which is brand
- 58:29new to the human mind to actually live this thing what does that show us in the physical world
- 58:36how do we get it right in the physical world because i know that we probably can never get
- 58:41true freedom in the physical world so we're trying to optimize it aren't we we're trying to get the
- 58:45best thing you know one one method is put a fence around your bit of land and and then within there
- 58:51you get freedom another thing you know blah blah so where what do we where do we go with this where
- 58:57where do where do we go to get maybe using NOSTA maybe using whatever you know because we've got
- 59:02all these new technologies yeah you know so it's this is a strategic question and it's a really
- 59:08hard question this is this is us stirring into the constellation and guessing where the future's
- 59:12going and while things are so uncertain it's it's hard it's to take account of what you've just asked
- 59:17is where does this like absolutely batshit never happen before thing travel across a map that's
- 59:24never happened before and never been more volatile but strategically if you were talking about a
- 59:30freedom movement in a reverse of the way potentially like a socialist revolution happens
- 59:36where one of the pillars of socialism is fractional reserve banking what you would see in an emergent
- 59:42freedom movement that is persistent and and and reinvesting its gains and enjoying more space than
- 59:49before is in a removal of that pillar that undermines what that pillar puts up which is
- 59:57socialism collectivism and mob rule until it runs out of food and so let's let's look at this as a
- 1:00:05strategic thing and we've already unlocked a denied area of economics and society by being
- 1:00:12able to ultimately transact on a separate network so there's a now there's a there's a there was a
- 1:00:17closed prison cell and bitcoins broke open a door that allows your property to step in there and
- 1:00:24lock itself up safely and can't be destroyed that's crucial if you can destroy something
- 1:00:29and have the final say in its destruction with no repercussions or repercussions no one's prepared
- 1:00:35to take on you.
- 1:00:35You own it.
- 1:00:37That's a physical,
- 1:00:38that's the physical realm.
- 1:00:40Sam's not too happy about that.
- 1:00:42I think we've got to talk about security.
- 1:00:45Yeah, yeah.
- 1:00:45This or chickens is probably the best.
- 1:00:48What's that noise?
- 1:00:49It's a slow moving tractor
- 1:00:51he thinks is on the land
- 1:00:52and it's not.
- 1:00:53It's just coming up the road.
- 1:00:56All this fares up and all that.
- 1:00:58But it's super handy.
- 1:00:59Yeah, we've got a very small dog
- 1:01:01but she still barks
- 1:01:03when anyone's like half a mile
- 1:01:04down the drive.
- 1:01:05And then like within three metres
- 1:01:06of getting towards him
- 1:01:08having looked like that.
- 1:01:09Yeah.
- 1:01:10It's just squeaking,
- 1:01:11lick your face.
- 1:01:12Lick you to death.
- 1:01:13Yeah, it's just a guy
- 1:01:15moving some...
- 1:01:17He's been on this
- 1:01:18like 10 runs a day.
- 1:01:19Is that the rocks guy?
- 1:01:20Yeah.
- 1:01:21Where's he taking it?
- 1:01:21Are they building a road
- 1:01:22or something?
- 1:01:23I don't know.
- 1:01:24I just know that you can't
- 1:01:25bag it and sell rock.
- 1:01:27You're into the environmental stuff.
- 1:01:29But if you've got a rock pit,
- 1:01:31you can take it
- 1:01:33and you can put it
- 1:01:34another site and and because you're not selling it you're allowed to just keep going at it well
- 1:01:39you could i mean we we've ordered a few tons of rock to build a wall you know off a quarry yeah
- 1:01:44they'll be like they'll have all this regulatory this and environmental that and planning rights
- 1:01:49but if a farmer i mean you've got a hill and it's made of rock with grass on top if you're chipping
- 1:01:54away at it to cap your own road it's okay but if you do that put it in bags and sell it to you for
- 1:01:59your driveway you're a quarry you're into quarrying see like these division of labors and the way they
- 1:02:05regulate stuff and that but that's just the environment we're in yes and it's hard to do
- 1:02:10commerce like that's uh sympathetic to bitcoin its principles oh yeah you think i need more of that
- 1:02:17i i bought cold coffee because i thought we'll probably i thought you won't give me coffee
- 1:02:23it's the caffeine i just yeah me too i'm just gonna nip out for a little all right subject
- 1:02:27Go on.
- 1:02:29Hold your question, though, mate.
- 1:02:30Sounds like a good one.
- 1:02:34Sorry, mate.
- 1:02:36Are we still recording?
- 1:02:37Of course it is.
- 1:02:38Okay.
- 1:02:39I always like that.
- 1:02:41Sorry.
- 1:02:41Rogan does that.
- 1:02:44People go out and have pisses.
- 1:02:45Apparently, you can go for like six hours.
- 1:02:46Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:02:47I think that's one of the...
- 1:02:48I think he did one with Alex Jones,
- 1:02:50which was six and a half hours.
- 1:02:52Now, I want to go back to this question.
- 1:02:54Yeah.
- 1:02:55Bitcoin digital world freedom.
- 1:02:57free cities or something yeah it's the biggest blue bottle of everything something in the real
- 1:03:05world that's the equivalent and it's to do with governance because it's to do with freedom and
- 1:03:10it's to do with should i be governed should i be free right this this area of adoption is the bit
- 1:03:17that i'm at and it's the hardest it's it's outside of the net the lower bound of larping and part-time
- 1:03:23activism which is fine and it's nice to know at conferences and things that people are into the
- 1:03:28same things you are feeling the same way about things but above informal and outside of black
- 1:03:34markets which were illegal anyway and probably for good reason the root of it things like silk road
- 1:03:39doing sending heroin to teenagers or whatever the narratives are the ability to do that's probably
- 1:03:44wrong but they're they're things that are enforced and they just happen anyway but then there's this
- 1:03:50other thing and while everybody's still frothing at the mouth about like ripping down fiat institutions
- 1:03:56and it's all gonna pop and the money's all debt it's it's true but there's an element of overlap
- 1:04:03in in what of all this shit we have to put up with that's still valuable and still quite a good way
- 1:04:09of doing things you know let's take out good like building regulations because they're bureaucratic
- 1:04:14okay but let's keep the principles of the values of the structures so that we're not building houses
- 1:04:20that flop over and i say this because if we're going to reduce the state influence we have to
- 1:04:28diminish its responsibilities and its and its ability to have to hold them properly and it
- 1:04:34doesn't enforce the laws it speaks to be responsible for broadly it doesn't always enforce borders it
- 1:04:41doesn't always give you a good health experience and when they fuck up it's an inquiry or an
- 1:04:47apology at best 10 20 years after something's happened and in the free market it would be a
- 1:04:53right quick dust up and a bankruptcy and the people who got the benefit and profits from doing that
- 1:04:59lose everything that part of the economy we want to keep that like family businesses are adaptable
- 1:05:08in fiat economies you can still have them they might be undermining the reasons why families are
- 1:05:14important and and all of that with regulations where they can set on and off but but the bit
- 1:05:21where we work with a family business or work with someone with a long reputation why keep that
- 1:05:26and this area of adoption is the one that sits above what you can do furtively or no one cares
- 1:05:33about because it's like el salvadorian coffee or something it's not to diminish that is to say
- 1:05:39that's below a scale that these entities these governments and state authorities care about
- 1:05:44as long as you do it on the edges of their map they don't care the bit that's hard to do
- 1:05:50is the bit that still allocates capital at scale so you have a meaningful life and you need skills
- 1:05:57and you need to feel good about what you're doing and have it that it's sympathetic to bitcoin
- 1:06:03sympathetic to privacy and sympathetic to freedom but can still grow to a scale where it's not
- 1:06:09attacked in the real economy so it has to render to caesar and pay its taxes but it also has to
- 1:06:17support the mission and the progress of freedom and that's hard won ground and going back to your
- 1:06:24question about bitcoin and nostril and strategic i think this area of the economy is where the tools
- 1:06:32on NOSTA will be picked up and developed for real use cases and help us demonstrate the alternative way without the full cost of an alternative system We can map NOSTA to the processes that fiat
- 1:06:47channels use and can chop and bend and coerce you with and just build a parallel scaffolding
- 1:06:55framework around the same risks so that when they get cut their perceived damage to you is
- 1:07:02lower because they know you've got a rope to fall back on so nosta might go a long way just keeping
- 1:07:09up with the basic affairs of the people that use it in terms of commerce and reputation and it might
- 1:07:16only be used when the fiat rails fail and so you'll get the nosta adoptions in spikes like we did with
- 1:07:24bitcoin this is why it's similar over crises and over things that draw the eye and draw the attention
- 1:07:30wiki leaks huge period of time for bitcoin silk road huge period of time for bitcoin
- 1:07:37uh public adoption with the uh recent deification of michael saylor
- 1:07:44it it's a big moment and uh there's loads you disagree with with mr saylor but you don't have
- 1:07:52his perspective so why would you agree with him on everything as a piece of litigation and
- 1:07:58investor management, it was a masterclass.
- 1:08:01He rotated an investor base
- 1:08:03legally
- 1:08:05and profitably
- 1:08:07and ethically into a Bitcoin
- 1:08:09treasury and did it on a public
- 1:08:11company that templated it and shown
- 1:08:13every other company that's listed exactly what
- 1:08:15course they plotted through the map to get
- 1:08:17the bit they wanted out of the Bitcoin tech
- 1:08:19but not make themselves
- 1:08:21so adapted to it that they're illegitimate.
- 1:08:25And that's a hard, that's a
- 1:08:27fucking hard thing to do run that thought experiment with nostor then what would be
- 1:08:34a situation or a person or a company that would do the operate a similar plan with nostor okay
- 1:08:45well let's take something we know exists already uh and it's simple but it's in use and we don't
- 1:08:52need to argue it let's go back to these peer-to-peer exchanges so it's the simplest level
- 1:08:57of abstract commerce you have bitcoin utxos i have a fiat bank account we enter into an escrow
- 1:09:04there are time windows there are standards to meet like an old law contract old english law
- 1:09:13is not written into the bitcoin blockchain so it won't serve as a basis for us to do legal contracts
- 1:09:18but if you log in and you've got your hodl hodl account and you've done a few good trades in the
- 1:09:24past you're set up to be able to show that you can do a future contract from your ability to do
- 1:09:30previous ones and then you enter into that contract and it's pretty it's like all of the
- 1:09:35iterations inside that add up to one in terms of probability which is to say once you've put your
- 1:09:41deposit down and once i put mine down and we both agreed to do this one of two things happens
- 1:09:46either both parties do it and they transact as agreed or one fails and there's a there's a
- 1:09:51grievance procedure not a single point is the local jurisdiction been involved
- 1:09:56this is where it is applicable in two places because you've got the local site-based reputation
- 1:10:03system and its rules that are enforced first and after that transaction is still eligible for
- 1:10:12potentially a small claim like when you don't get your amazon parcel delivered then you claim
- 1:10:17against the seller and it can be enforced by a fiat law and so the way to adopt bitcoin is not
- 1:10:25to think of it that when things are adopted in bitcoin it's at the expense of what's there
- 1:10:29already what you want to do is make shapes and transactions and products that run on fiat rails
- 1:10:35but also can run on bitcoin rails and you try and match them as closely to each other as possible
- 1:10:41and it's hard that is that is damn hard to do if you stand out too much and you make yourself so
- 1:10:47not uh like alien to where you live and the community you serve it becomes an exclusivity
- 1:10:55thing you're alienated and then you're attacked and brought low and so the best thing to do is to
- 1:11:02be eligible for both systems i think which is to say we don't take anything we meet our requirements
- 1:11:07we follow our law but we've also got tech that we're doing that because if we don't we'll be
- 1:11:15destroyed by somebody we're not doing it because it's the way to regulate the structure of buildings
- 1:11:20we do it because we're told to but if we had a customer who wasn't subject to those laws we can
- 1:11:27still demonstrate that something's strong or of a certain quality just by itself evident proof
- 1:11:33proven the qualities of it and that and the way that that's shown on and potentially on a nostr
- 1:11:37account is that you do go through that with somebody and they don't need all the stamps and
- 1:11:42stickers but they still get a product they like i'm just thinking about and then tell people that
- 1:11:49they had a good interaction hey i got this product i paid what i expected and i got what i expected
- 1:11:55I'm just thinking about maybe NOSTA
- 1:12:00maybe the digital identity thing
- 1:12:03once again is
- 1:12:05Bitcoin and NOSTA are so important to work together
- 1:12:09because
- 1:12:11do you believe Bitcoin defunds the state first?
- 1:12:15simple yes or no
- 1:12:16simple yes or no
- 1:12:17yes
- 1:12:18okay
- 1:12:19and NOSTA emasculates the government
- 1:12:23simple yes or no
- 1:12:24yes
- 1:12:24right
- 1:12:25so the the state is kind of co-opting bitcoin slowly they're not they're not fighting it and
- 1:12:33they they've probably got a plan to sort of you know control it in some shape or form whether or
- 1:12:39not it works we'll have to we'll have to see i think people like you and me imagine imagine you
- 1:12:42got two runners in a race and one is freedom tech and one is government tech there's a point where
- 1:12:48the runner stops trying to run for the line and runs to the other runner to beat them up
- 1:12:53and the the boundary we push as bitcoiners is where you push push push in the same direction
- 1:12:59a government's trying to claim like we'll look after your finances we'll look after your food
- 1:13:03supply and bitcoin and the freedom tech and all the stuff that supports it from farms through to
- 1:13:09core devs through to the totally abstract are racing against an ability to do that for themselves
- 1:13:15saying no we don't need these laws i make a choice for my health decisions and as it's like cops and
- 1:13:24robbers when the freedom tech allows you to unlock areas of your life that would have been denied on
- 1:13:31purely fiat rails it gives you an off-ramp it gives you an ability to trade get everything you
- 1:13:38wanted from what the government set menu promised but without any of the side effects and without
- 1:13:42any of the abuse potential that's where bitcoiners get the most benefit it's but it's also the
- 1:13:49hardest area of the economy to win because the minute you go out of the abstract and the hackathons
- 1:13:56and the github forks and the little programs you can put on a torrent and never be seen
- 1:14:01once you move into stuff of substance that affects people's physical quality of life
- 1:14:06and what they experience inside of an actual day in a human skin not as a utxo on a chip
- 1:14:12I think some people live on these Bitcoin signers they think that their money's safe and they're safe
- 1:14:18or they just have two different modes where their Bitcoiners when the Bitcoin hat's on and then
- 1:14:24just part of the crowd the rest of the time and I think the hardest area to sit in is where you're
- 1:14:32still serving the real economy at scale because that's quite a powerful position to sit in and
- 1:14:38you just have to be sympathetic and use as contingency and in NOSTA's case sometimes it's
- 1:14:45cheaper just to run NOSTA than it is to get some privacy uh anti-privacy tech for instance remote
- 1:14:52viewing or access control it's cheaper to use Keet hole punch to do video streaming because it's free
- 1:15:01than it is to get a google account and do meat so the freedom tech stuff is actually sometimes
- 1:15:06on a real project the cheapest to deliver for that capability that you need opening and closing gates
- 1:15:13it's either wall garden ring doorbells that you pay subscriptions to and you don't own the data
- 1:15:19or it could just be a nosta uh pull down but at the end of the day the state can come in with guns
- 1:15:29and shut it down right now but this is why i was saying that the bitcoin element is so important
- 1:15:35because over the long term theoretically bitcoin defunds that ability that's where they work
- 1:15:42together yeah right because like you know i don't think we can ever solve for the state coming in
- 1:15:50with guns basically like or going for communism or for whatever you know like we we don't have to
- 1:15:56uh the truth always wins historically but how do we justify that well truth always wins
- 1:16:05but the truth is often losing
- 1:16:08in that moment
- 1:16:09is the truth not winning
- 1:16:10you know
- 1:16:10it's losing
- 1:16:11it's losing along the way
- 1:16:13you could say that the truth always loses in the end
- 1:16:14it depends which part of the cycle you're in
- 1:16:16that might be a better way of putting it
- 1:16:17the truth
- 1:16:17the truth
- 1:16:18no no
- 1:16:19I mean the truth always loses
- 1:16:21if you're in the point where you're losing
- 1:16:23then you'll think
- 1:16:24this is the end
- 1:16:25oh it'll win in the end
- 1:16:27but then it wins in the end
- 1:16:28it's cyclical I'd say
- 1:16:29and it might be one of
- 1:16:30a little bit like owning bitcoin
- 1:16:32is that you constantly
- 1:16:33every day
- 1:16:33day day
- 1:16:34you feel like you've given something up or you're losing but then there are just these moments and
- 1:16:38days where you go knocking out that's that's gone up a lot it's that constant feeling that we're
- 1:16:43losing ground we're being attacked where things are getting worse things are getting worse but i
- 1:16:48mean historically for us to even be here has been only the result of that argument being won over
- 1:16:55and over and over again in human history so things are different in that the magnitude of everything
- 1:17:01is pretty bad maybe the worst ever but we are only here because this argument's been worn over and
- 1:17:07over and when it's come down to it there's been an awful bloody fight over it but there's been an
- 1:17:13awful bloody fight over it and then it's won on that on that battlefield literally and then it's
- 1:17:18enforced and then it's degraded again and then you have to go and fight for it again and i think that
- 1:17:23um the progress of bitcoin has been non-violent that's what's so impressive about it it's had no
- 1:17:28physical enforcement whatsoever. It's took nobody, well a handful of people maybe arguably,
- 1:17:34to risk themselves physically. It's quite bloodless but there is this all or nothing
- 1:17:42issue at stake and I'm just saying that we need to survive the middle bit
- 1:17:46and not get taken out too quickly and just see if you can support it and keep it going and keep it
- 1:17:55alive and concentrate on that so much as working out whether it's going to win or lose and how
- 1:18:00it's just to keep it going and bring it back use bitcoin principles and use the tools to the scale
- 1:18:06of your life and try and adapt them into your life in a negotiated way if you're too extreme
- 1:18:12you'll stand out if you're not extreme enough you'll have no impact and the movement doesn't
- 1:18:16go on and it's that dangerous middle ground and where we are in terms of like 2025 middle of
- 1:18:21summer is the world's kicking off the volatility that's been stored up over maybe a lifetime
- 1:18:28is starting to crackle like an earthquake and big things are happening big big things we can't
- 1:18:34control but there's this middle ground that's the next challenge i think that extends the freedom
- 1:18:40movement and it's to move into that visible part of society it's not to no longer be furtive and
- 1:18:48separate and satellited but to actually try to adapt the normal comings and goings of life with
- 1:18:56this technology as it improves and as it becomes more ubiquitous i still don't think we have bitcoin
- 1:19:01at an acceptable level in money at least not in the uk and regionally but in the us there'll be
- 1:19:08large sections of places or industries or places where you can just get stuff done in bitcoin
- 1:19:12and that wouldn't have been the case 10 years ago and nost is the same it's just a few years behind
- 1:19:18and it's solving for a different problem it's kind of onboarding bitcoiners and entities into
- 1:19:25this into this web of trust where money went first in its abstract and then humans didn't go with it
- 1:19:32and we need a layer to get the principles of bitcoin but apply them at a human scale
- 1:19:38in a normal life not to get small and hide on a ranch uh not that's a bad thing i like my ranches
- 1:19:44It's just to say there's a run away and hide over there until they've had a fight.
- 1:19:50Or there's a stay engaged and get big enough and stay with the pack enough that when it
- 1:19:57does become critical, you've got some sway.
- 1:20:00You've got some capital allocation and you've got some capability that people have to choose
- 1:20:04between burning you or burning what you do as a job or a life or what you produce.
- 1:20:10and the more responsibility you can have the more protected you are from it being taken off you
- 1:20:16because if they take it off you they lose the capability of what you have so you've got to
- 1:20:22constantly be pushing your values and i think if you just do it at an individual level or you try
- 1:20:28to like go to that small scale you're doing the right thing but you're not having an impact it's
- 1:20:33the difference between someone who litter picks around their village green and it's not to
- 1:20:38criticize that as an intent i'm not saying it's the wrong thing to do i'm saying the scale is
- 1:20:44not big enough to have an impact that's not the work the work is like the ocean cleanup like that
- 1:20:51young lad who took shipping containers out into the pacific ocean he pulls 50 tons of trash out
- 1:20:57of the ocean that's scale that's hard it's the same principle it's just damn hard and i think
- 1:21:04The bit we're pushing into with Bitcoin, Nostra and FreedomTech is into the real economy.
- 1:21:09It's making meritocracy more socially acceptable again.
- 1:21:15It's making doing the right thing valuable again.
- 1:21:20Not having it washed back into a taxation budget.
- 1:21:24And not having it that we've got an anonymous society that can roll through groups and defraud them.
- 1:21:32Or hurt them.
- 1:21:34or just not do what you're going to say and then go
- 1:21:36and have the blanket of that to hide your trail
- 1:21:40under an umbrella of privacy.
- 1:21:42It's perverse.
- 1:21:44You're basically describing like a kind of return to morals
- 1:21:48and, you know, in a very 21st century way.
- 1:21:51No, but it's interesting, isn't it?
- 1:21:52Because lots of generations have said the same thing.
- 1:21:55You know what I mean?
- 1:21:56They haven't had the ability.
- 1:21:57From the minute we were able to scratch words into the paper,
- 1:22:00we've had an ability to record what's happened.
- 1:22:02But it's not had high fidelity.
- 1:22:04it's been hard to prove you know everybody's got the ability to publish but what if we started to
- 1:22:11tie these data points to things that are harder to forge than noise than words what if we tied
- 1:22:16them to locations well what happens then is you've highlighted yourself as a location to
- 1:22:22people who mean you harm so how do we abstract the ability to say you're here and that you're
- 1:22:28of substance but it not be a big deal if people know where you are you've got to the trick is to
- 1:22:35negotiate what you've learned about bitcoin and how it's better and how it's truthful and what's
- 1:22:41good about it in the long run and take the principles and abstract them into places that
- 1:22:46bitcoin isn't dominant which is the physical world the physical economy what's interesting about
- 1:22:51bitcoin though that i've noticed is years ago the theory of what might transpire was laid out and
- 1:22:59was talked about and discussed and it's kind of happening that way for example um people use
- 1:23:07bitcoin as savings now they do not just people but like or whatever countries right okay you know
- 1:23:14but that's yeah but people people said that would happen and they said that would be part of the
- 1:23:18process as well and it is part of the process and it is happening now and now i hear it on them on
- 1:23:24the most mainstream of mainstream news yes that people are preserving their wealth in this digital
- 1:23:30and gold this is what's interesting a gold miner switched to bitcoin mining and they've been able
- 1:23:34to make the case in an investor note by saying this is gold mining we're still expending energy
- 1:23:40to have something that holds its value so they're getting it on the level that it was it was designed
- 1:23:46that and it's changing because they realize well it's all mining we're doing a difficult process
- 1:23:52for a steady rate of income on something that can't be diluted so why is bitcoin out of the party
- 1:23:57and that's that's where you want to be in a freedom argument is where the merits of what
- 1:24:03you're bringing in in still enforce whatever all the regulation and all the good intent tries to
- 1:24:09but it does it better and it leaves the downsides of dictatorial systems and fiat systems
- 1:24:15out of the picture that's the that is the golden middle of where adoption needs to go it's also the
- 1:24:22hardest place to stand it's miserable to try and adapt something that is supportive of bitcoin
- 1:24:29runs on bitcoin rails to the degree it's possible but also isn't doesn't stand out as an enemy or in
- 1:24:35the wrong side of the law in the place it's operating and you need a place to operate because
- 1:24:40it's real economy it's stuff that bitcoin won't get for us it's soft commodities it's water food
- 1:24:46and all of that prepper stuff but that's the next part to adapt to primary industries and secondary
- 1:24:53industries and small verticals that's a real circular it's a circular economy but it's scale
- 1:24:59it's gdp points it's it's it's productivity with a capital p it's not proof of concept
- 1:25:07and small and proving that the tech works on a little sandbox it's applying it to it to a post
- 1:25:17code and letting it lower the price and increase the quality of goods as a result of using that
- 1:25:23that's the argument you can make and you say right well you take that away you take my prices go up
- 1:25:28or the business is gone so you pop that part of what you're trying to affect me to do
- 1:25:33and you'll take the whole lot you'll take everything away and you can't recreate it
- 1:25:39that's the argument but it's a very hard place to stand and it's very dangerous place to stand i
- 1:25:44think because you are very visible and you don't ever want to be the most visible lightning rod
- 1:25:52because those people get killed coerced made a fun of made example of yes but like you say
- 1:26:00of all the revolutions that's ever happened,
- 1:26:03Bitcoin has been quite a non-violent one.
- 1:26:09So far.
- 1:26:10So far, correct, yeah.
- 1:26:11Because the Tea Party was non-violent
- 1:26:12compared to the War of Independence.
- 1:26:15Like we've got our riots,
- 1:26:18we've got our, I call them volatility blips,
- 1:26:22like these releases of pent-up aggression and energy.
- 1:26:25It's false peace what we're in now.
- 1:26:27I wouldn't mean to say that Bitcoin is bloodless forever.
- 1:26:32It's to say that so far,
- 1:26:34given how much of the area it's unlocked to people
- 1:26:37who just want to transact without banks,
- 1:26:39it's done it with an awful small casualty list so far.
- 1:26:44But...
- 1:26:45Why do you think that is?
- 1:26:46Do they not get it or something?
- 1:26:48Like, why didn't...
- 1:26:49Like, is there a point going to come
- 1:26:51when they suddenly realise,
- 1:26:53oh, shit, you know,
- 1:26:55this is undermining everything we use to maintain power.
- 1:27:01What is the one thing in an entire train set of somebody,
- 1:27:06like these controlling people,
- 1:27:09what is the one thing they can't destroy?
- 1:27:11They can destroy literally anything.
- 1:27:13On a focused beam, they can blow up anyone and anywhere and anything,
- 1:27:19anything except Bitcoin.
- 1:27:22I think that's why it's been bloodless.
- 1:27:25Because blood doesn't take away from its ability to transact.
- 1:27:29There's no way, no way to get that system to die.
- 1:27:34But what I mean is if someone in power decided to confiscate Bitcoin on scale,
- 1:27:43they'd start, there'd be blood in the beginning.
- 1:27:46I think they'd soon realize it's very difficult to enforce.
- 1:27:49I mean, I don't think they can.
- 1:27:50But owners of the Bitcoin, I mean, the first guy that has his door knocked on.
- 1:27:53Yeah.
- 1:27:54What's he going to do, just hand it over?
- 1:27:56What about the second guy?
- 1:27:57Yeah, exactly.
- 1:27:58I think in the end, it goes really quickly.
- 1:28:00You're getting close to your 30th guy,
- 1:28:02and the government costs are $2 million.
- 1:28:06And the yield on that attack might be two.
- 1:28:09Do you think by the 10th and the 50th person on that list,
- 1:28:13they're up in profit?
- 1:28:15And do you think they look any better
- 1:28:16for taking people house to house and looting them?
- 1:28:19How did that look to anybody else
- 1:28:20with Sindhu in history?
- 1:28:21Well, I don't know.
- 1:28:22I mean, funny, I was listening to a pod on the way over here
- 1:28:26and they were talking about the Nixon shock
- 1:28:29and go and listen to that speech
- 1:28:31and realise what an absolutely outrageous thing that was.
- 1:28:36Basically, someone, the premier,
- 1:28:39the powerful person in America stood up
- 1:28:41and said to the rest of the world,
- 1:28:42hey, you know all that gold you gave us?
- 1:28:44We don't have it.
- 1:28:45It's ours now.
- 1:28:45Yeah, we might have it.
- 1:28:47No, no, literally, you can't have it back.
- 1:28:49Well, it wasn't Nixon. I mean, the first time that was 33, it was the banning of gold in the US.
- 1:28:56Right. But what I mean is no one in power has ever been shy to do absolutely outrageous things.
- 1:29:04I mean, when America says, you know, all that gold you gave to us, the rest of the world, and these are big countries, these are ancient countries.
- 1:29:12We've got it now and you can't have it back.
- 1:29:14And because we can, basically, was the answer there.
- 1:29:19They're bullies.
- 1:29:21They're not stupid.
- 1:29:22They're bullies, but they're not stupid.
- 1:29:25And they know, like bullies know, you can't fight everyone.
- 1:29:29You can't.
- 1:29:30You are your profit as a bully is to the degree you can threaten people
- 1:29:36without spending energy.
- 1:29:38And that doesn't mean bullies don't spend energy.
- 1:29:40We see focused attacks all the time.
- 1:29:42but those attacks have to do more than the
- 1:29:44kilowatt value of those punches
- 1:29:46they have to do more, they have to chill
- 1:29:48the nine other people who are represented by the people who are being punished that a public execution It enough to change individual decisions to doing something a certain way by seeing what happens when someone tries it once
- 1:30:06But the lie, and the same lie that goes on in prisons all around the world, is that the capacity of the prison isn't totally strong enough to overwhelm the prison guards.
- 1:30:16it is constantly but it's it's it's kept in place because one crab has to climb out the barrel first
- 1:30:23and nothing good ever happens to that crap bitcoin maybe has been bloodless because
- 1:30:28it's so coordinated and and there's no part of it that stands proud of all the rest of the parts of
- 1:30:35it as it grows it's very hard to pick what point of it you're going to spend your energy on
- 1:30:39because it's it's just so synchronous and so hard so abstract it's not physical you can't check
- 1:30:46someone's house for bitcoin like you could with gold bars or drugs it's it's totally abstract but
- 1:30:52we still keep that hook of value we still use it as a scoreboard to swap value around and it pervasive It not gone anywhere It got bigger And worse it been adopted into the fiat systems in some form of legitimacy
- 1:31:04Ten years ago, it was a scam.
- 1:31:06It was an unregulated scam.
- 1:31:08When did the US start holding it on their balance sheet?
- 1:31:11Is it still a scam?
- 1:31:13So things change really gradually, and under that, everybody's quite down,
- 1:31:17and it's scary.
- 1:31:18but look at the progress that's been made without really any there's been blips there's been people
- 1:31:24who've been made examples of there's been disasters and calamities in bitcoin but bitcoin's center has
- 1:31:30moved it's grown out like directional progress in bitcoin's amazing but the the day-to-day stories
- 1:31:38and threats and arguments are what it feels like but the reality is it's moving directionally in a
- 1:31:46in a freedom direction without having a pitch battle in the middle.
- 1:31:53Right.
- 1:31:54What did you think of that?
- 1:31:55Ben one of my favorite human beings to speak to in real life The next two hours of this conversation is where we really get going So pop on over to the Fountain app to listen to part two
- 1:32:10If you're a subscriber, it will be there for you in the episode list. If you're listening to this
- 1:32:16more than a week after the release date, well, just go ahead and listen as normal in your
- 1:32:22podcasting app. Don't forget, the full episode will also be available on the Free Cities YouTube
- 1:32:28channel, but that will be much later. And before you go, one last reminder to check out our show
- 1:32:35sponsor, Veritas Village at www.ecovillages.life forward slash Free Cities. That link also includes
- 1:32:44a long form interview with Patrick, who founded the company. It will certainly give you a good
- 1:32:50sense of who they are and whether you would like to do business with them right see you in part two
- 1:32:56over and out