Latest / Gaming The System - The Feminist Gaming Podcast / GTS News: DLSS 5 Slop, Accessibility Non-features and Fortnite V-Bucks Inflation (Episode 272)
Transcript
- 0:00Matt: The battle pass is normally a thousand V bucks, but it now costs 800 V bucks.
- 0:05Matt: Hooray.
- 0:06Matt: But you used to be able to earn 500 V bucks in the battle pass, but they have removed that.
- 0:15Matt: I am stunned.
- 0:17Jem: One of the places that the vast majority of games are sold through doesn't use this particular list.
- 0:25Jem: There's no standardization, which means that, someone's gonna have to move or everyone's gonna be confused.
- 0:34Alex: They've changed the shape of her lips to make them, I guess, appear more, attractive, quote unquote.
- 0:40Alex: And then the shape of her jaw, I feel like is different as well.
- 0:59Jem: Hello and welcome back to another episode of Gaming the System, the podcast where three intersectional feminists examine gaming and games through a feminist lens.
- 1:10Jem: I'm your host for today.
- 1:11Jem: I'm Gem, and I'm here with my friends Alex and Matt.
- 1:16Jem: Today we are going to be looking at some of the current news stories in the games industry.
- 1:26Jem: Does anyone have a burning story they would like to kick off with?
- 1:31Alex: I can start if you like.
- 1:33Alex: Yeah.
- 1:33Jem: Go ahead, Alex.
- 1:35Alex: my story is quite a few days old now but it's news about Nvidia maker of graphics cards.
- 1:42Alex: They've faced a lot of backlash over their latest breakthrough graphics feature, which utilizes AI to enhance graphical output.
- 1:53Alex: and it's called the DLSS five.
- 1:57Alex: And they did sort of a tech showcase
- 1:59Jem: Catchy name now.
- 2:00Jem: It's not difficult to forget.
- 2:01Alex: rolls off the tongue.
- 2:02Alex: Yes.
- 2:03Matt: You know what it stands for?
- 2:05Alex: What does it stand for?
- 2:06Matt: Deep learning.
- 2:07Matt: Super sampling.
- 2:08Alex: Oh, I dunno
- 2:10Jem: Mm.
- 2:10Alex: I like that.
- 2:11Alex: Hmm.
- 2:12Alex: Yeah, that's a really intriguing name.
- 2:14Alex: Deep learning, super sampling five.
- 2:18Alex: Yeah.
- 2:18Alex: They did a tech demo and showed different images of different games.
- 2:22Alex: So like the latest resident Evil Requiem.
- 2:26Alex: they also did Hogwarts legacy and there's been a lot of backlash because of the quote unquote gassification, that is happening to the game.
- 2:37Alex: So essentially it's making everything look like it's got some kind of.
- 2:41Alex: AI Instagram filter.
- 2:43Alex: was the general consensus from most of the gaming community.
- 2:47Alex: see if I can show a picture with you of the difference on, resident Evil Requiem, because this was what caught most attention, I think was most relevant for our podcast as well.
- 2:58Alex: The one on the left hand side, the view's left is a screenshot from Resident Evil Requiem with DLSS five off.
- 3:08Alex: and then the one on the right hand side is with it on, and you can see is it Ashley, the character?
- 3:15Matt: Grace Ashley's from Resident Evil four.
- 3:18Matt: Another young blonde, skinny woman.
- 3:21Alex: Thank you, Matt.
- 3:22Alex: Okay, so this is Grace and, what are the key things that you kind of can pick up on based on this image here?
- 3:28Alex: I'll try and zoom in a little, for you.
- 3:32Alex: Anything spring to mind
- 3:33Jem: I want to be kind to them.
- 3:37Jem: I don't know why, 'cause I know that we we're very quickly going to get un kind.
- 3:41Jem: I think that the image on the right with the DLSS five on is a much sharper and crisper image, but it sort of takes away some of the grittiness of the scene for me.
- 3:55Jem: And, I'm actually looking at the background and
- 3:58Alex: Yeah.
- 3:59Jem: Without the, DLSS five, it looks more.
- 4:04Jem: Realistic actually.
- 4:05Jem: Like it looks more sort of blurry and difficult to see what's going on in the background, which is how it would look if it was rainy and misty.
- 4:13Jem: And we've lost that.
- 4:14Jem: It's sharpened everything up in the right hand side.
- 4:18Jem: And yeah, I am, ignoring the elephant in the room, but I'll let Matt describe that.
- 4:24Matt: Yeah, so this is an interesting situation because neither of you have Nvidia graphics cards, do you?
- 4:33Alex: No
- 4:34Matt: I've, the only graphics card I've ever had is an NVIDIA one.
- 4:38Matt: So I've, been using DLSS for, since I got it, and what DLSS has done up till now has been, it takes the, the raw.
- 4:51Matt: Image of everything is rendered and then it's presented on screen.
- 4:56Matt: And what the DLSS does is, it is ai, but it uses it to, increase the image quality, without it needing to be as intensive on the graphics card.
- 5:12Matt: So it's basically a force multiplier.
- 5:15Matt: So you can have a game playing it natively at full hd.
- 5:21Matt: But if you've got a 4K monitor, rather than having to render it at 4K, which is literally four times the size, which means four times as many pixels, you can use DLSS to upscale it.
- 5:34Matt: And DLSS is incredible for doing that.
- 5:39Matt: What this seems to be doing is rather than just making the raw data look better, they have gone right?
- 5:48Matt: We've got the raw data look better, but now we want to use AI filters to actually change the characters.
- 5:57Matt: And this one looks cheap because.
- 6:00Matt: AI filters are the cheapest form of editing you can put on anything.
- 6:06Matt: And so that is the thing that everyone puts on everything.
- 6:10Matt: So we've now got makeup and.
- 6:16Matt: Lipstick and eyeliner and that AI just softness that all AI images have, which is what I immediately noticed about the background.
- 6:27Matt: They've all got that slight softness to them because they are, they are mud mudge together, different elements.
- 6:38Alex: Mm-hmm.
- 6:39Matt: So it seems like they've gone from an actual technical impact that they're having on the raw data.
- 6:47Matt: They're going, this is what we think games should look like.
- 6:50Matt: This is what we think the next step of graphics cards is, putting AI filters over things and that that is a mind blowing decision for them to have made, and not just to make, but to double down on the way they have.
- 7:08Alex: I feel like, I don't know if it's just me, but I feel like the lips in the right hand side image, are like fuller.
- 7:17Jem: Yeah.
- 7:17Alex: just the
- 7:18Jem: Yeah.
- 7:18Alex: or
- 7:18Jem: And
- 7:19Matt: Yeah.
- 7:20Alex: yeah, definitely.
- 7:21Alex: So that they've changed the shape of her lips to make them, I guess, appear more, attractive, quote unquote.
- 7:28Alex: And then the shape of her jaw, I feel like is different as well.
- 7:31Jem: Hmm.
- 7:32Alex: But yeah, they've definitely, it feels like they're just, yeah, it, it,
- 7:38Matt: This is,
- 7:39Alex: sit well with me, I don't think.
- 7:40Matt: it's confusing 'cause it's bad for everyone.
- 7:43Matt: For Nvidia straight away, it shows that they have a catastrophic lack of self-awareness.
- 7:49Matt: To think that this is to one, come up with it and two to go, right?
- 7:54Matt: This is the next evolution.
- 7:55Matt: This is our DLSS.
- 7:57Matt: This is number five.
- 7:59Matt: It's the name.
- 7:59Matt: It's not a spinoff thing.
- 8:01Matt: It's the DLSS.
- 8:02Matt: This is our new flagship.
- 8:04Matt: This is gonna be our foundation for the next one that we do.
- 8:08Matt: So it's bad for them, like in their internal awareness of what they do.
- 8:14Matt: It's bad for gamers because you look at that and you immediately go, that looks awful.
- 8:22Matt: I didn't choose for it to look like that.
- 8:23Matt: I didn't choose what filter I want to have put on it.
- 8:27Matt: And it's also awful for the artists.
- 8:33Matt: They make these things a very specific way.
- 8:36Matt: They engineer them to be a specific way and to just stick a filter on it is.
- 8:43Matt: Just insulting and it's bad for the AI impact on art because it wants to project itself onto art that exists rather than just mimicking art that exists.
- 9:02Matt: It wants to go right.
- 9:03Matt: This art does exist.
- 9:04Matt: We are going to put the put art filter on.
- 9:09Alex: Mm-hmm.
- 9:10Matt: So it's just baffling.
- 9:13Alex: Indeed.
- 9:13Alex: And I think I remember also reading that, a lot of the defense of it was that it's an optional feature.
- 9:20Alex: That's not exactly how you sell something by saying, oh, you don't have to put it on, you can turn it
- 9:24Matt: Yep.
- 9:26Alex: That's really gonna help sell it, isn't it?
- 9:28Alex: Imagine if you went to a shop and you were like, oh, you don't have to buy it.
- 9:32Alex: You can if you want, but you can choose not to.
- 9:34Alex: That's not exactly what, you really want from a product, is it?
- 9:38Matt: And they don't want the older version to be better than the new one.
- 9:42Alex: definitely not.
- 9:44Jem: You can get these apps that let you try on different haircuts or different hair colors or whatever, and they cannot not mess with the face.
- 9:54Jem: So it's like, I want to know what a different haircut might look on me or a different color.
- 10:01Jem: But then suddenly they've done this whole filter to.
- 10:05Jem: the way that I look so it doesn't look like me anymore, or it looks like, a younger version of me and it's like, well, yeah, younger me may well be able to rock.
- 10:14Jem: You know, platinum blonde, but
- 10:16Alex: Hmm.
- 10:17Jem: nearly 49-year-old me cannot, you know, and I just, I find it so frustrating that there's this assumption that means that they make these changes to the faces because they could have done stuff to that imagery to make it look better without looking, a certain way and they haven't.
- 10:39Jem: Thank you for that, Alex.
- 10:40Jem: That was a really interesting story.
- 10:52Jem: So, I'm going to do my one next if that's all right, Matt.
- 10:56Matt: Go for it.
- 10:57Jem: Game companies are being expected to standardize accessibility labels on storefronts and product pages according to
- 11:08Matt: Hmm.
- 11:09Jem: EnGadget.
- 11:10Jem: A couple of days ago on 20th of March.
- 11:12Jem: So there's a new initiative that is asking, game developers such as Microsoft, Nintendo, and EA come together and, make a list of accessibility features that their games have.
- 11:28Jem: And these have been defined as a set of 24 accessibility tags that will appear in participating game storefronts and product pages, that players can know the features that a game has before they buy it.
- 11:46Jem: And it is generally a positive story.
- 11:49Jem: It's good that they're doing this.
- 11:51Jem: It's good that they're thinking about it.
- 11:53Jem: However, apparently don't cross reference with the similar.
- 12:01Jem: System that Steam has.
- 12:03Jem: So one of the places that the vast majority of games are sold through doesn't use this particular list.
- 12:12Jem: There's no standardization, which means that, someone's gonna have to move or everyone's gonna be confused.
- 12:21Jem: For example, steam has a playable without timed inputs tag, and that's being frequently misapplied.
- 12:31Jem: By games developers, and because it's due to a mismatch between the public facing and the developer facing descriptions of the tags.
- 12:40Jem: So it is one of these things where on the surface it sounds like a great idea, and yet clearly a lot of the thought and the thinking and the research hasn't actually gone into it behind the scenes, which might make it.
- 12:57Jem: Unhelpful than helpful.
- 12:59Alex: is quite ironic, that they're not thinking about it in an accessible way because obviously if you have a consistent, way of naming things or a consistent name on the back end.
- 13:10Alex: On the front end, then that's gonna make it a lot easier, isn't it?
- 13:14Alex: I'm not sure how much they would've looked into the already existing accessibility lists, which have been generated by the disabled gaming community.
- 13:26Alex: There's something that's been built up through the community and kind of drummed together in a lot of the ways that accessibility information is for the disabled community by disabled people themselves built up, through that knowledge and passed on around the community.
- 13:42Alex: There's never anything coming from.
- 13:45Alex: The developers themselves so much or whatever it is you're thinking of, whether it be public transport or, information on accessible toilets or, just generally public infrastructure.
- 13:59Alex: It's very rare that that information comes from the organizations themselves.
- 14:05Alex: So there is a lot of reliance upon the community.
- 14:09Alex: So it's positive to hear that they are thinking of actually making this a more visible feature of the shopfronts and product pages, et cetera.
- 14:19Alex: But again, like you say, there's a real trick that's been missed there with the not aligning with steam.
- 14:24Alex: And also I don't know how much they would have actually consulted with the community 'cause the information is there.
- 14:32Alex: In one place or another.
- 14:35Alex: and we have talked about it previously on the pod before, but you know, that's, that's parts of it positive.
- 14:41Alex: I'm hopeful that it will just continue snowballing and then eventually people at the top will be like, let's make this normal for everything we do all the time.
- 14:50Alex: That's the hope,
- 14:52Matt: This is one of those situations where this is a nothing thing because what they've said is we are going to make sure that games.
- 15:03Matt: Can put their accessibility features as visible on their store pages.
- 15:09Matt: PlayStation already do that, and every time I see a game that has accessibility features, I go, Ooh, I'll look at that and see, if it's talking about their accessibility features, they must be following the example of God of war and the last of us, that's as good as it can be.
- 15:26Matt: That's the gold standard.
- 15:28Matt: So I think, surely, if they're putting it in the storefronts, that must mean because the number of accessibility features is going up.
- 15:35Matt: But every single one of them always has, oh, you've got subtitles.
- 15:39Matt: Oh, you can change the audio to, mono or you can, change the color scheme of the user interface.
- 15:47Matt: And that isn't.
- 15:49Matt: Enough for anything.
- 15:51Matt: It's not specific enough to solve any accessibility issue more than one thing, maybe one issue that you have.
- 16:04Matt: So rather than, maybe we're going to try and maybe get a standardized thing like.
- 16:11Matt: Most games have content warnings now that are more detailed than they would've been in the past.
- 16:15Matt: If they have a list of accessibility features, that would be a good thing, but the games aren't getting more accessible, developers aren't making on mass games that are implementing this infrastructure.
- 16:32Matt: What would be good is if the game developers said.
- 16:37Matt: Oh, , we've seen this infrastructure, we've played God of war, and we've played the last of Us and gone, oh.
- 16:44Matt: What we could do is force all of our game developers to make their games that fit into this structure.
- 16:52Matt: And that would be something because it's doable.
- 16:55Matt: That is a completely manageable thing.
- 16:58Matt: 'cause the last of us, part two and God war rag are two of the most.
- 17:03Matt: Well, certainly God, war Ragnar is one of the most Com complex games.
- 17:07Matt: Like of this recent generation.
- 17:10Matt: And the last of us, part two is, a staggering story told in an incredible way.
- 17:17Matt: So it doesn't need, to make the art less artful, but the finding out, the coming up with this infrastructure and making it be implemented, that is, the hard work.
- 17:35Matt: That's the institutional change that needs to happen in order to get.
- 17:41Matt: The end result of making all games as accessible as possible, or they could just say, oh, we're gonna have a list.
- 17:50Matt: We're gonna get people to list their accessibility options and do nothing else apart from that.
- 17:55Matt: Because anything that isn't based entirely on them being able to make as much money as possible, which means them having control over.
- 18:05Matt: The projects that they do, they want it to be, there are a small number of people at the top that control everything that goes on underneath rather than going, oh yeah, it doesn't matter what a savant you think you are, what an au you think you are.
- 18:19Matt: You need to fit your stuff into this infrastructure.
- 18:24Matt: So that is incredibly frustrating to see areas where we need systemic.
- 18:31Matt: Institutional consistent change things that are codified, and that's when things can start.
- 18:38Matt: We can start fixing things.
- 18:41Matt: If they're not that kind of change, then the change that is gonna come as a result of that is gonna be inconsistent and unreliable.
- 18:49Matt: Just the hearing, the word accessibility more hasn't made games more accessible.
- 18:54Matt: Whatever's been.
- 18:56Matt: Tried to be done.
- 18:59Matt: Hasn't worked yet.
- 19:01Matt: We've got God of war and we've got the last of us part two.
- 19:05Matt: That's all we've got to lead the way.
- 19:08Matt: But what those developers should be doing as part of their responsibility, they've got the massive studios, massive success, massive resources.
- 19:20Matt: They should have entire wings.
- 19:22Matt: Forcing other game companies to make their games more accessible.
- 19:25Matt: We are going to create our own ecosystem of accessibility consultants that will go in and lobby for these things and make them happen, and that isn't happening.
- 19:38Matt: So this is just another frustrating accessibility story for me, unfortunately.
- 19:43Jem: Yeah, one would hope that this will encourage games to think more about accessibility and to include it because they obviously recognize that it is a marketing win.
- 20:00Jem: To include this information.
- 20:02Jem: That's the only reason they're gonna do it is 'cause they think they're gonna sell more games.
- 20:06Jem: So I think that they obviously think that that's a positive thing.
- 20:12Jem: When you see games next to each other and suddenly you are seeing these different tags or whatever that might just make people think like, why is this one got more than that one?
- 20:24Jem: And that might influence people's purchasing.
- 20:27Jem: And then hopefully that will encourage the industry to, Make games more accessible overall.
- 20:35Jem: However, I feel like that is going to happen so slowly that it's hardly going to be helpful.
- 20:42Jem: And actually the, organization that are in charge of this, the Entertainment Software Association, told the verge that the timeline for implementation of the tags is company dependent.
- 20:55Jem: So we don't even have an actual timeline for this.
- 20:58Jem: Doesn't fill me with confidence.
- 21:01Jem: I think it's positive that they've even thought about it, but it, it feels a little bit performative and perhaps just an empty effort,
- 21:12Matt: And the infrastructure part is the critical bit,
- 21:14Alex: Mm-hmm.
- 21:15Matt: because not.
- 21:17Matt: Not everyone needs every feature.
- 21:19Jem: Hmm.
- 21:19Matt: Some people will need one, some people will need lots of them.
- 21:24Matt: And it's just like with physical infrastructure.
- 21:27Matt: It's like they're building that hasn't got any accessibility stuff in it, it goes well, we've got a lift so when people do come in if they're on crutches, they could use the lift so they don't have to walk up the stairs.
- 21:39Matt: But what this is missing is if there isn't a ramp, then there are a large number of people who just won't be able to get in the door and then, but even say, oh, we saw lots of other.
- 21:50Matt: Buildings that have ramps, and I've seen people in wheelchairs going in and out.
- 21:54Matt: So we'll get a ramp are the lifts big enough to fit a wheelchair in?
- 21:58Matt: Are there disabled toilets?
- 22:01Matt: The point being that the idea of an ecosystem of accessibility is the mindset that they need to start with.
- 22:11Matt: So rather than it being bit by bit here and there where it fits in
- 22:15Alex: It mustn't be an afterthought.
- 22:16Jem: Hmm.
- 22:17Matt: yeah.
- 22:17Alex: That's the key Like you say, so often accessibility is an afterthought that's just added on to existing things and.
- 22:25Alex: That proves that it's not fit for purpose, because if it was fit for purpose, it would've been built in at the design stage anyway.
- 22:34Alex: And that's far from what happens.
- 22:36Alex: Yeah, I agree.
- 22:44Jem: If you want to support us, you can subscribe to our patron at patron.com/gaming the system for some exclusive content.
- 22:53Jem: Or you can send us a one-off donation via PayPal to our email address.
- 22:59Jem: We are gaming the system@gmail.com.
- 23:07Jem: Okay, so Matt, come on, bring us something to cheer us up.
- 23:12Matt: Yeah, well the cheering up part will have to be from you laughing at me for playing Fortnite.
- 23:18Jem: I have been sending, Instagram posts about Fortnite to you, Matt, on our group chat because every time I come across a Fortnite one I'm like, oh, I should send this to Matt.
- 23:29Jem: He'll find it so funny.
- 23:30Jem: I dunno whether you do, but
- 23:31Matt: I do, but I do.
- 23:33Matt: But it's, it's.
- 23:35Jem: I have to send, Instagram post to everyone all the time.
- 23:39Matt: It's more that I go, yeah, that's true.
- 23:43Matt: Every meme I see is go, yeah, that's accurate.
- 23:47Matt: But Fortnite is due.
- 23:49Matt: It's a fairly big success.
- 23:52Matt: It's quite a big deal.
- 23:54Matt: But unfortunately.
- 23:56Matt: In a recent post, epic games shared the news via Fortnite blog post.
- 24:02Matt: The cost of running Fortnite has gone up a lot and we're raising prices to help pay the bills.
- 24:11Matt: And.
- 24:11Jem: That was a worry.
- 24:13Matt: But it's a free game.
- 24:14Matt: So how do you raise the prices on things?
- 24:17Alex: I wonder what they could do.
- 24:18Matt: Well, the answer is digital inflation.
- 24:21Alex: Hmm.
- 24:22Matt: 'cause it turns out that digital currency can, suffer from deflation as well.
- 24:27Matt: Inflation, excuse me, because V bucks are now worth less.
- 24:34Alex: Hmm.
- 24:34Matt: I think nearly 10 years since Fortnite came out.
- 24:37Matt: What was a thousand V bucks is now 800, and what is 2,800 is now 2,400.
- 24:47Matt: So it's interesting.
- 24:48Matt: They said they're raising prices.
- 24:50Matt: They're not raising prices.
- 24:51Matt: They're making the digital currency buy you less.
- 24:56Alex: Hmm.
- 24:57Matt: So the things in the store cost the same, but you're going to need to spend more
- 25:06Jem: More real money to buy Fortnite money.
- 25:08Matt: Yep,
- 25:09Jem: Hmm?
- 25:10Matt: yep.
- 25:11Matt: And this is just, it's wild because, can you guess how much money Fortnite made last year?
- 25:20Alex: Several million.
- 25:20Alex: I dunno.
- 25:22Matt: Several million.
- 25:23Jem: I think we're probably into billions.
- 25:25Alex: Yeah.
- 25:27Matt: Okay.
- 25:28Matt: $6 billion.
- 25:30Alex: done.
- 25:30Alex: Yeah.
- 25:31Matt: 6 billion.
- 25:33Alex: Goodness.
- 25:33Matt: The battle pass is normally a thousand V bucks, but it now costs 800 V bucks.
- 25:39Matt: Hooray.
- 25:40Matt: But you used to be able to earn 500 V bucks in the battle pass, but they have removed that.
- 25:49Matt: I am stunned.
- 25:51Matt: Megan plays a ton more Fortnite than me.
- 25:54Matt: I only play when I'm playing with her.
- 25:56Matt: And she watches a ton of Fortnite streamers, so when I went in, I ask her have you heard about these V Bucks going up?
- 26:02Matt: And she goes, oh my God.
- 26:03Matt: Yeah, it's a thing.
- 26:04Matt: It's a thing.
- 26:06Matt: Jem, is this something that you've come across with, your daughter and Roblox Does she use digital currency?
- 26:12Jem: She doesn't, well we have gifted her, some over the years, but, she generally just gives it away to people.
- 26:21Jem: She's not a very materialistic person actually, which I'm very proud of, but it's got nothing to do with me.
- 26:28Jem: So, yeah, not a lot of things that she's bought in game for herself, Little avatars and things like that.
- 26:36Jem: So, but there was a case, reminded me about this just the other day, where there was an item that had been in the game and then had been taken out.
- 26:47Jem: So they do that quite a lot.
- 26:49Jem: They remove items from the store, and even if you've bought them.
- 26:54Jem: you get the money back, but you lose the item.
- 26:58Jem: So you can buy like an avatar part.
- 27:02Jem: this one that they all love called headless, which is basically where your, yeah, you have no head.
- 27:07Jem: You have hair and a body, but your avatar doesn't have a head, which they all love she had that and then it got taken away.
- 27:17Jem: And they refund them the money.
- 27:19Alex: It's quite worrying really, isn't it?
- 27:21Alex: Because it's like you don't own it.
- 27:23Jem: yeah, I think it basically increases inflation because then they bring it back later and everyone wants to buy it.
- 27:30Alex: more
- 27:30Jem: But we haven't had to get too involved in the whole online and, know that there are problems with it.
- 27:41Jem: And I know other parents who've had lots of issues with their kids and, the whole gambling associated with loot boxes and things.
- 27:50Jem: In some ways you could, perhaps justify it in that it's a way of teaching children about money.
- 27:56Jem: These days we don't give real money in shops very often, and kids often aren't in shops because we do so much of our shopping online and things like that.
- 28:05Jem: So this is a way to understand this idea of transactions and money and saving up and buying something, but that isn't how it works at all.
- 28:15Jem: So it doesn't even teach them those kind of lessons.
- 28:18Jem: So there just isn't really any positive spin on it other than that it's a way for.
- 28:24Jem: Companies to make money without charging a subscription or an upfront fee.
- 28:35Alex: I was just thinking you mentioned things that, have been purchased just disappearing out of nowhere and kind of coming back more expensive later.
- 28:43Alex: It's not the same.
- 28:45Alex: But similar things I had heard have been happening in places like, audible, if you've bought a book and it's in your library, I think there were some terms and conditions that came.
- 28:56Alex: A couple of years back or last year that were saying they have the right to basically remove any content from Audible that they feel like.
- 29:05Alex: And, if you've purchased it, then it's hard luck.
- 29:08Alex: You can't get it anymore, even though you quote unquote own it.
- 29:12Alex: It's the same sort of concept as in, the PlayStation store.
- 29:16Alex: Whenever you hear them saying, content on the PlayStation store is subject to change, and may not be available all the time.
- 29:24Alex: Another sort of thing around digital products and ownership and who owns it.
- 29:31Alex: If you've purchased it, do you really own?
- 29:34Alex: That product it's made me think about that a little bit more, which I know is not quite the point you were making Jim, but it just me of, of all of that and the worrying trend of, of digital products generally.
- 29:48Matt: That's another degree.
- 29:50Matt: Going up in the, the boiling pot of the digital age.
- 29:55Matt: 'cause every single gaming like Steam and PlayStation store, they have in their terms and conditions, just, you don't open your games.
- 30:06Matt: You are purchasing, you are purchasing an, the ability to play this game.
- 30:11Matt: They haven't enforced it like on masse, which is what they could do.
- 30:17Matt: But we are at their mercy with it,
- 30:21Jem: Hmm.
- 30:21Matt: really.
- 30:22Jem: Hmm.
- 30:22Matt: I'll end it with just an idea of the filthy money that they're making.
- 30:27Matt: They're the store where they sell their skins.
- 30:32Matt: It's a rolling store.
- 30:33Matt: You basically only get one.
- 30:35Matt: It'll be there for a week or two and you can buy it.
- 30:38Matt: But then if once it's gone, it's gone.
- 30:41Matt: And they have had literally every single franchise that has ever existed you go, if you play a game of Fortnite, you'll see skims from Star Wars and they've just started with Gaming Thrones and got Walking dead attack on Titan.
- 30:57Matt: So they are.
- 30:59Matt: Getting these partnerships with everyone.
- 31:02Matt: And the biggest sign is that a new event has happened and this, cool warrior guy who's had his helmet on this entire time, finally takes off in the trailer and it's the rock.
- 31:16Matt: And you go, God, the millions, the millions, the untold millions.
- 31:23Matt: And it says one line.
- 31:25Matt: So they've got his face and him saying one line.
- 31:28Matt: And I can't remember.
- 31:30Matt: So it's no more, I think it's no more Mr. Ice guy.
- 31:34Alex: yes.
- 31:36Matt: It's straight out of Batman with Mr. Freeze.
- 31:39Jem: We'll have to watch that space and see what happens with all of these stories.
- 31:43Jem: So maybe we'll come back to some of them in future episodes.
- 31:47Jem: That was a bit of a whistle stop roundup of what we've got going on at the moment and, I'm sure we've missed lots of things.
- 31:54Jem: We'll come back to that.
- 31:55Jem: But thank you ever so much for listening and we are here every Thursday, so check us out and, leave us comment like, and share us with your friends, and we'll see you very soon.
- 32:07Jem: Bye.
- 32:08Matt: Bye bye.