Latest / Film And Whiskey / Double Indemnity / Old Grand-Dad 114
Transcript
- 0:00For robots, radio presents in 1944 director, Billy Wilder and
- 0:05star, Fred MacMurray gave the world.
- 0:07A mysterious foray into murder mystery and a bit of film Noir
- 0:12in 2020. We return skeptically to a fan
- 0:16favorite bourbon brand. The film is Double Indemnity.
- 0:19The whiskey is old, Granddad 114 and we'll review them both.
- 0:24This is the film and whiskey podcast.
- 0:45Welcome to the film and whiskey podcast for each week.
- 0:48We review a classic movie and a glass of whiskey.
- 0:51I'm Bob book, I'm Brad G and this week, we are looking at the
- 0:541944 classic double indemnity Brad.
- 0:59How you doing today, man? I'm doing really good.
- 1:02I got to You today? Yeah, we actually met up today
- 1:05halfway between where we live. We live about two hours apart.
- 1:08We had to swap whiskeys for the next few weeks.
- 1:10So it was good to see you in person.
- 1:11My friend, it's been a long time.
- 1:13Yeah, it's a terrible thing. Hopefully, the fates will draw
- 1:17us back together at some point but for now we have to meet in
- 1:21the parking lot of a Cracker Barrel and just hang out and
- 1:23talk. Well, and in addition to seeing
- 1:26you we also got to both watch this movie.
- 1:29I have made no bones about it over the past few weeks.
- 1:31This is one of my favorite movies of Classic Hollywood.
- 1:35We know this is the second Billy Wilder film that we've done in
- 1:38season one. We did Some Like It Hot.
- 1:40So Brad I have to ask you. First of all, had you ever seen
- 1:43Double Indemnity before we washed it for the podcast?
- 1:46Well, I hadn't I had heard of it.
- 1:48I knew that it was an early film Noir example.
- 1:54But honestly, Bob having watched it now, I am so surprised that I
- 1:58hadn't seen it before and like, when I think about the word,
- 2:02Film and all that it connotes, this is a classic film.
- 2:08You know what I mean? Absolutely, yeah, it's one of
- 2:11those films that doesn't kind of get mentioned in that first
- 2:13group of all time. Hollywood Classics with the
- 2:16Citizen, Kane's and the Casablancas and Gone With the
- 2:18Wind. And yet, I don't think I've ever
- 2:21met anyone who watched this movie and didn't like it.
- 2:24Yeah. I it's a spectacular movie.
- 2:27And honestly, it's a much better movie than Gone With the Wind
- 2:31honestly. Yeah, I would put it up there
- 2:33with Casablanca as like these are some of the best movies of
- 2:37the 1940s. Well and I think one of the
- 2:39things that connects those two movies Brad is they both have
- 2:42just incredible scripts. Billy Wilder, is I think one of
- 2:46the most underrated directors in Hollywood history, but no one
- 2:50has ever left him out of the conversation of potentially
- 2:53being the best screen writer of all time.
- 2:55And we saw it with Some Like It, Hot and how quick and witty has
- 2:59his dialogue, can be, and you see it again in this movie and
- 3:02There's moments where it's really hard edged and cynical
- 3:05but then there's also these great dialogue exchanges between
- 3:08characters and Billy Wilder really, really shines as a
- 3:11screenwriter with this movie. Yeah.
- 3:14Well I mean, I've said this before about older films and you
- 3:17know, this isn't always the case, you know, what I'm about
- 3:20to say, isn't always true because there was bad films made
- 3:23back in the 40s and 50s and, you know, that's fine.
- 3:26But back in the day before, you had all this technology to
- 3:31really flash and wow, Wow. And pop on the screen the the
- 3:35way that you kept people's attention was with good witty
- 3:39smart dialogue. And unfortunately I just don't
- 3:44think you get that quite as often in modern film because
- 3:48it's not quite as necessary. You're able to enhance other
- 3:52parts of the film which is great and I love those other parts of
- 3:55film and you know I'm glad that the film industry has come as
- 3:58far as it has. But there is something inside of
- 4:01me that The type of dialogue that I feel like you more often
- 4:05find when you watch things with Cary, Grant and Humphrey, Bogart
- 4:09and apparently Fred MacMurray. That's right.
- 4:12Well and one thing I want to say before we move on into our
- 4:15favorite segments here, Brad explains is that I think another
- 4:18reason for the dialogue being so good and so witty and so Snappy,
- 4:23is that it kind of had to pull double duty.
- 4:25Like it not only had to fulfill all the functions that dialogue
- 4:28normally does, but we're dealing with a time in Hollywood
- 4:31history. That we talked about the Hays
- 4:33code and that's essentially the film censorship board that was
- 4:37still in place in the late, 1930s.
- 4:39All the way until the 1960s and films had to be reviewed for
- 4:43their content and so screenwriters, really had to
- 4:45come up with clever ways to introduce kind of double
- 4:49entendres. Like, things that the characters
- 4:51were talking about that, we all know what they really meant, but
- 4:54they couldn't quite get away with saying things explicitly.
- 4:57And this movie is, I think one of the best examples of a movie,
- 5:00kind of ducking, or Around the laws of the Hays code, to convey
- 5:05something that they weren't quite allowed to say.
- 5:08And I think that's really one of the areas where Billy Wilder
- 5:10shines, the most with this script.
- 5:13But before we get any further Brad, I don't know how many
- 5:16people in our audience will have seen this movie, if you're into
- 5:18classic film, I'm sure you have. But I think for a lot of people
- 5:21listening, this might be their first exposure to the movie
- 5:24Double Indemnity. And so, we're going to move into
- 5:26our segment. Brad explains where Brad breaks
- 5:28down the plot of a movie that he's just seen most of the time
- 5:31for the first time and we have the treat of that happening
- 5:34today. So Brad, can you explain with
- 5:37full spoilers? What happens in the movie Double
- 5:40Indemnity? The film Double Indemnity is
- 5:43about a insurance salesman named Walter Neff, who makes a call on
- 5:48a client who is about to let his auto insurance lapse and he
- 5:52arrives at the house and finds the wife at home alone, Phyllis
- 5:56dietrichson, and he's soon drawn in by her sultry charm.
- 6:02And she involves him in a plot to take out a life insurance
- 6:05policy on her husband, who is, you know, apparently a cruel and
- 6:09uncaring, man, and they decide to finish him off to kill him
- 6:14and get the insurance policy and then they're going to run off
- 6:16together, and, you know, be wildly in love.
- 6:19And as the film goes on, you see Walter fall into more and more,
- 6:24paranoia there, the the claims manager at his insurance
- 6:28company. The guy who checks in make sure
- 6:30that the deaths are legit. Did and the insurance claims are
- 6:33what they seem to be is a man named keys and he always talks
- 6:37about this little man in his stomach, that just tells him
- 6:40when something is wrong and he needs to investigate further.
- 6:43And so, Neff has to essentially draw up a policy without the
- 6:47husband knowing, it has been drawn up on him and get the man
- 6:51killed in a way that isn't, you know, suspicious enough to cause
- 6:55his claims manager to get suspicious about it.
- 6:58And then, you know, they can get the money.
- 7:00And then in addition to all of this, There is something in a
- 7:03lot of insurance policies called an a double indemnity clause,
- 7:08which is basically really specific ways of dying or having
- 7:11an accident that will pay out double on the insurance policy.
- 7:16So there's a Double Indemnity that if the the husband dies on
- 7:20a train it'll pad a hundred thousand dollars instead of
- 7:23fifty thousand dollars. So they kill the husband, they
- 7:27frame it so that he falls off of a train and eventually the the
- 7:32the boss Boss Keys figures out that it was a murder and he
- 7:36eventually pins it on the daughter of Phyllis and her
- 7:40husband on her boyfriend at the end of the film Walter, Neff,
- 7:46realizes that Phyllis has no intention of running away with
- 7:49him. That she might even off him as
- 7:52well. And so he goes into Keys as
- 7:55office and offers a confession and recognizes that he is the
- 7:59one who killed the the Husband and it's that's it.
- 8:05There you go. Yeah and Brad I think it even
- 8:07goes a little bit further than that in terms of how kind of
- 8:10dark and cynical it gets I mean both of the main characters,
- 8:14likely die. We watch Walter actually goes
- 8:17over to Phyllis house and shoots her dead, because he realizes
- 8:20that she's either going to find a way to bump him off or
- 8:23implicate him when she gets on the stand.
- 8:26And so she's dead. He gets shot by her before she
- 8:29dies and he's bleeding out. He Records.
- 8:32This confession and is basically caught by his boss keys in the
- 8:37office because he was trailing blood, and then the guy who
- 8:40operated the elevator called keys, and the movie ends in this
- 8:44really kind of ambiguous way where he's probably going to
- 8:47bleed out and die. If he doesn't, you know, he's
- 8:49gonna go basically to the gas chamber and die.
- 8:52It's a really dark movie and it's not the kind of uplifting
- 8:55ending that you're used to seeing in a 1940s movie.
- 8:59And it really sparked this genre called Film Noir, and we're
- 9:03gonna get into talking about what a film Noir is later.
- 9:06But I think one of the first things that you can say about it
- 9:08is that these kind of movies. They always feature these sort
- 9:11of hard-boiled cynical protagonists who are maybe up to
- 9:16no good. They usually feature a femme
- 9:18fatale, you know, a woman who is obsessed with murder in some
- 9:21way. And they have this really sort
- 9:23of pessimistic. I guess I would almost have,
- 9:26like, nihilistic kind of tone to them where, you know, maybe
- 9:30people get their comeuppance but it's also, Like at what cost.
- 9:33And this is, this is a really great example of that.
- 9:36Because as you watch this movie, you really just get a sense that
- 9:40most of the characters in this movie are just kind of sleazy
- 9:43people that do sketchy things and there's really no clear-cut
- 9:48protagonist in the film. Yeah.
- 9:51And I think, for me, the more I, you know, reflect on this movie,
- 9:55I really do. And this is going to be really
- 9:57bad pun. I really do think that Keys is
- 10:01the key to this film. As, as a character, he's
- 10:04introduced as this kind of harsh mean, crotchety old claims
- 10:10investigator who doesn't find any good in anyone.
- 10:15And, you know, even Walter says, he's like, you know, I've worked
- 10:18with him for a long time, but I know that he's actually got a
- 10:20heart of gold behind that tough exterior.
- 10:23And so you kind of realized like oh this guy is actually kind of
- 10:26a good dude. And by the end of the film, you
- 10:29realize that Keys really is the moral Center.
- 10:32This Movie that he believes in the goodness of Walter Neff.
- 10:35He is the one who defends him to his boss, saying, no, there's no
- 10:41way Walter could have done this. He told me that he sold the
- 10:44insurance policy. It was all on the up-and-up and
- 10:47I can personally vouch for him as a human being and, and like
- 10:52that gave the film so much emotional weight to me that that
- 10:57makes you so much more disappointed and Walter for what
- 11:00he did. Well, And I think part of it
- 11:03too, is that you have such a great actor, filling this role,
- 11:05it's Edward G Robinson who had been super famous throughout the
- 11:091930s but had always been Typecast and kind of gangster
- 11:12roles. He became really famous with
- 11:14this movie called A Little Caesar in the early 1930s.
- 11:17And at this point, you know, he was getting kind of advanced in
- 11:20age to be a leading man and he realized he needed to start
- 11:23taking smaller roles. He really didn't feel super
- 11:25comfortable about making the transition into supporting roles
- 11:29and actually said that in order to Vince him.
- 11:32They basically paid him the same salary as both the leads for
- 11:35way, fewer days of shooting and he said that made it a lot
- 11:38easier for him to make the decision but I think that having
- 11:41that would that would make it a lot easier for me to Bob but I
- 11:45think that having an actor of his caliber in that supporting
- 11:49role it almost kind of elevated the role to like a third lead
- 11:53because like you said that the relationship between him and
- 11:57Walter Neff is this really kind of father-son dynamic and it's a
- 12:00very tragic sort of Shit because, you know, you see, at
- 12:03the end of the film that Keys finds out that he was wrong all
- 12:07along, and you see the kind of love that he had, for Walter
- 12:10Neff playing out. And I think having Edward G
- 12:12Robbins, and in that role elevates, that sort of emotional
- 12:16weight to being just as important as the main
- 12:18relationship between, you know, Walter and Phyllis.
- 12:21Yeah, there's no doubt that if you don't have keys in that in
- 12:26this movie and if he's not played by somebody as talented,
- 12:30there's just no chance that You care so deeply about meth and
- 12:35honestly you kind of find yourself recognizing that.
- 12:38Neff made a mistake that he kind of dove in with this woman who
- 12:43he didn't realize was up to no good and you see him pay the
- 12:48price for it and you kind of Wonder kind of like when you're
- 12:52watching the prequel movies for Star Wars and you get 2 episode
- 12:563 and it's like you know that Anakin is going to do the wrong
- 13:00thing. You know, he's going to turn
- 13:01into Darth Later. And yet, I think that the
- 13:03Brilliance of episode 3, is that you still find yourself.
- 13:07I I still find myself, you know, watching it for the 30 millionth
- 13:11time going, oh Anakin don't do it.
- 13:14Like what if you just don't make the wrong decisions and I think
- 13:18that that's what you have in this movie and it's, it's just a
- 13:22great place to be as a viewer where, you know, the outcome
- 13:26like, from the very start of the movie.
- 13:27Neff is narrating you you think you got the right man, but you
- 13:31didn't. I'll tell you got.
- 13:32The wrong man because you got hit, you got the boyfriend and
- 13:34it was actually me. You're pretty good in there for
- 13:37awhile keys. He said it wasn't an accident.
- 13:41Check he said it wasn't suicide check.
- 13:46He said it was murder. Check.
- 13:51You thought you had a cold engine?
- 13:54All wrapped up in tissue paper with pink, ribbons around it.
- 13:57It was perfect. Except it wasn't because you
- 14:00made one mistake. Just one little mistake when it
- 14:06came to picking the killer. You pick the wrong guy.
- 14:10You want to know who killed dietrichson.
- 14:14Hold tight to that cheap. Cigar a keys.
- 14:18I killed dietrichson, maybe Walter Neff.
- 14:22Insurance salesman, 35 years old unmarried, no visible scars.
- 14:28Until a while ago. That is It's a, you know, it
- 14:31right away and you know, he's gonna do it, the whole movie and
- 14:35yet because Keys sees goodness in Neff, you're wanting Neff to
- 14:41make the right decision, despite the fact that, you know, he's
- 14:44going to make the wrong decision.
- 14:45And I think that that that only really brilliant movies are able
- 14:48to do that well and again that speaks to how brilliant Billy
- 14:51Wilder is as a screenwriter. And I think what makes it even
- 14:55more brilliant Brad is that he's not presented as a guy that was
- 14:58totally good. Who got sucked in by this.
- 15:00Evil woman, like she clearly had a plan.
- 15:03She clearly wanted to bump off her husband but I think what's
- 15:06what makes it even more great? Is that from the very beginning,
- 15:09you kind of get the sense that Walter is a little bit sleazy to
- 15:12like when he first. Yeah, first shows up to Phyllis
- 15:16house to deliver these insurance papers.
- 15:18He just openly starts flirting with this married woman, and you
- 15:22actually get some incredible dialogue in that scene, where
- 15:25it's like the sexual tension is off the charts.
- 15:28These people are clearly into each.
- 15:31And you get that great exchange about she basically says like,
- 15:35hey you you're moving a little too fast here and he says, how
- 15:37fast was I going officer and they have this exchange about
- 15:40him going over the speed limit mr.
- 15:42Neff, why don't you drop by tomorrow evening around 8:30?
- 15:45He'll be in. Then my husband.
- 15:48You're anxious to talk to him. Weren't you?
- 15:50Yeah. It was but I'm sort of getting
- 15:53over the idea if you know what I mean, the speed limit on this
- 15:56date. Mr. Neff. 45 miles an hour.
- 15:58How fast was I going officer? The around 90 suppose you get
- 16:02down off your motorcycle. Give me a ticket.
- 16:04Why would I let you off with a warning this time?
- 16:07Suppose it doesn't take what I have to work.
- 16:09You over the knuckles suppose I bust out crying and put my head
- 16:12on your shoulder but you tried putting it on my husband's
- 16:15shoulder. That tears.
- 16:18It it's already tomorrow evening.
- 16:22Then that's what I suggested you be here, too.
- 16:25I guess. So, I usually am same chair,
- 16:28same perfume, same anklet, I wonder if I know what you mean.
- 16:32I wonder if you want. There's tons of double entendre,
- 16:38there's tons of stuff that's implied, but what it really goes
- 16:41to show is that Walter even though he's the guy telling the
- 16:45story from his perspective, he's the quote-unquote protagonist
- 16:49that doesn't make him a hero that doesn't make him a guy that
- 16:52is completely free from sin, even at the start of the movie.
- 16:56Yeah. Bob I I'm right there with you.
- 16:59I will say that that first opening scene.
- 17:02He is so sexually aggressive in that.
- 17:05Oh my gosh. I I was just like, man, this is
- 17:08just going to be another example of like old Hollywood, abusing
- 17:13women and being sexually harassed, you know, sexual
- 17:16harassment, and all this stuff. And like, it's not that.
- 17:19That didn't happen. Because I think it did, but once
- 17:23you start to know the character that Barbara Stanwyck plays a
- 17:26little more, your kind of like, okay, no, she's like, she is
- 17:29just as much in this trying to use Walter as he is just trying
- 17:34to have sex with her if In a weird way, he's trying to have
- 17:38sex with a married woman which is bad and she's trying to a
- 17:42kill her husband, and be make a lot of money off of it.
- 17:45So I don't know if that makes her worse or not, but like,
- 17:48they're both really bad people. Yeah, in a certain sense and
- 17:52what's really great is that at no point in the movie until
- 17:56maybe the very end, do you get the sense that like one of them
- 17:58is more evil than the other? Because even as she kind of
- 18:01tries to feel him out of like my wonder if he would kill my
- 18:05husband, It's kind of like this dance that they play, he starts
- 18:08to figure out what she's doing and he calls her out on it.
- 18:10And she's like, no, no, no, I'll totally drop it.
- 18:12I won't discuss it again. And then all of a sudden he's
- 18:15like, well, you know I have always wondered about what it
- 18:18would be like how I would kill somebody and what it would be
- 18:21like to try to get away with it. So then he's the guy that's
- 18:23advancing this idea and they really do like their their
- 18:26terribleness plays off of each other and I think that only goes
- 18:30to improve, you know, the character building that Billy
- 18:34Wilder's doing right. Well and See, I think it's an
- 18:37example of how you might have somebody who never would commit
- 18:42murder in their life, but when they're around the wrong person
- 18:46or the wrong group of people, they almost egg each other on to
- 18:51doing things that they never imagined that they would have
- 18:53done in their normal life. And I love that you kind of get
- 18:57a picture of that when Keys comes to Neff and he's like,
- 19:02trying to pitch him on taking a pay cut to become a claims man.
- 19:05Instead of a Salesman. And he has this great line about
- 19:09a claims man, being a doctor, and a bloodhound, and a
- 19:13Confessor. And, you know, it's this great
- 19:15line. He's really pitching.
- 19:17He's trying to sell the salesman on a new job and it's a
- 19:21brilliant scene. And I think you have a moment in
- 19:25that scene where Neff looks at keys, and you can tell that he's
- 19:28gone so deep in with Phyllis that in another life, if he
- 19:33hadn't delved into this evil side of himself, Maybe, you
- 19:38know, sure. He was a bad guy but maybe this
- 19:40would have been an opportunity for Redemption to move forward
- 19:43with his life to try a new hat on try.
- 19:45New set of clothes on, see if it fits, but because he has met
- 19:49this person, he's met Phyllis and he's dove headfirst into
- 19:53this pool of darkness and murder, and theft, and all these
- 19:58terrible things. He can't move forward with
- 20:01another Avenue in his life. And so I, there's something
- 20:05about that scene that you're You're just like, man, you just
- 20:08see what life could have been for Walter.
- 20:10If he had never shown up at the dietrichson house.
- 20:14Absolutely. Well and Brad, I kind of want to
- 20:16shift a little bit into talking about this script that Billy
- 20:19Wilder co-wrote with the mystery writer Raymond Chandler.
- 20:22The story for Double Indemnity was actually based off of a
- 20:24short story that was written by this guy.
- 20:26James M, Cain, Billy Wilder had a writing partner that he wrote
- 20:29with all the time. Charles Brackett said that he
- 20:31didn't want to make this movie because he didn't like how
- 20:33sordid the subject matter was. So Billy Elder needed.
- 20:36A new writing partner. He wrote the script with Raymond
- 20:39Chandler, and they absolutely hated each other.
- 20:42They disagreed on everything. While they're said that, when
- 20:45Raymond, Chandler, showed up, he was like, in a 12-step alcohol
- 20:48recovery program. And by the time they finished
- 20:50writing the script, he was like a raging alcoholic again.
- 20:54So, these two guys hated each other, but they recognize what
- 20:57each brought to the table. And one of the things that I
- 21:00really love is how they both contributed to the dialogue in
- 21:04this movie. Like you have these great.
- 21:06Why? Elder touches of some really
- 21:07clever witty lines, but then you also have like some great
- 21:11hard-boiled, detective type lines, even like at the end of
- 21:15the movie when Walter shoots Phyllis and the last thing he
- 21:17says is just byebye baby. Like, it's just that there's
- 21:21something so classic about every line in this movie, and I think
- 21:26you really do, get the best of both worlds.
- 21:28You get that great witty cynical Wilder dialogue.
- 21:31And then you also have those great, detective novel type
- 21:34lines that you here Walter. Keys say did you have any other
- 21:38lines that you thought like really stood out or anything?
- 21:41Oh man, I do find it hard with these movies to keep track of
- 21:45all the lines because there's so many good ones that I'm like,
- 21:47wait, what he said something about this or yeah, there are
- 21:51there's so many good lines, but even like the kind of little
- 21:54throwaway like one-liners that they put in the movie, I laughed
- 21:57out loud at a couple of them. Like, there's one right at the
- 21:59beginning. When Walter shows up to the
- 22:02house and the maid tells him, you know, yeah, you can go sit
- 22:04in there but they keep The Liquor Cabinet locked up.
- 22:06Up. And he's like, that's okay.
- 22:07I always carry my own keys. And then like later on in the
- 22:10movie, they bring this guy down from Oregon.
- 22:13Who was a witness to, you know, seeing who he thought was mr.
- 22:17Dietrichson on the back of the train and they're kind of
- 22:19interrogating him and it's all on the insurance company's dime.
- 22:23And right before he leaves, he's like, well, I don't think I'm
- 22:25gonna go back to Oregon yet, there's a really good osteopath
- 22:28in town that I want to see, Ever G.
- 22:31Robinson's like osteopath, huh. Well don't put her on the
- 22:34company card and it's like, very clear that he thinks.
- 22:36This guy's going to go see a hooker like yep, there's so many
- 22:39just little witty things that they're not necessary but they
- 22:43just help build out the world of the movie.
- 22:45So well yeah, you find yourself in the midst of it.
- 22:49Believing that everyone in the world lives like these people do
- 22:53which is which is funny because they're very clearly caricatures
- 22:58of real human beings like nobody actually acts like he's or Neff.
- 23:03And yet, these witty one-liners Einar's and the way that they're
- 23:08just cynical about the world draws you.
- 23:10And like you said, Bob, it's brilliant world-building.
- 23:13Absolutely. And you mentioned, mrs.
- 23:14Dietrichson. And I think it probably is time.
- 23:16We talked about our two leads and they're acting performances
- 23:19Barbara. Stanwyck plays Phyllis
- 23:21dietrichson, who is maybe the most famous Femme Fatale in
- 23:25movie history. And for good reason because she
- 23:27is just incredible in this movie at the time.
- 23:31This movie was made. She was the top grossing
- 23:34Hollywood actress of the prior year.
- 23:36And so, when she read the script for this movie, she was like, I
- 23:38don't know if I really want to do a roll like this.
- 23:40This could be really damaging to me, and Billy Wilder in his
- 23:44typical kind of bully way was like, are you an actress, or are
- 23:48you a mouse? And she was like, all right, I
- 23:50guess I'll do the part and it ended up.
- 23:52I don't want to be a mom. Exactly.
- 23:53It ended up being hurt. Obviously, her most famous role
- 23:57and I think she knocks it out of the park in this movie.
- 24:00Yeah, I think from the very start you can tell that she is
- 24:03in control of every room. That she is in like like as a
- 24:08character. She has so much Swagger and
- 24:11confidence and almost like this quiet braggadocio sness of like,
- 24:17I know who I am. I know what I want, and I'm
- 24:19going to get it the way that she sits at the very start of the
- 24:23film. And her, she's like, kind of
- 24:26swinging her leg out in front of her and the anklet is right
- 24:28there, and he comments on it and she makes sure to wear that.
- 24:31Again, the next time he comes like, you can just tell that she
- 24:35is in. Control of herself what she
- 24:38wants where she's going to go. And so when it finally cracks at
- 24:42the very end of the film and she shoots him and can't shoot him a
- 24:45second time and he kills her, you're just kind of like, oh my
- 24:49gosh, like it's almost like you're on this wild roller
- 24:52coaster ride of like what is she going to do?
- 24:54Because she's very clearly, a psychopath.
- 24:57Well and I think one of the things about her that is so
- 24:59interesting is that she is so Shameless at the beginning of
- 25:03the film like not even knowing who This insurance salesman is
- 25:07not even knowing that, she's going to rope him into this
- 25:10murder plot. Like in front of her maid, she
- 25:13shows up in a towel and nothing else.
- 25:14She's flirting with this guy that comes to the door,
- 25:17everybody knows who she is. She's not, she doesn't love her
- 25:21husband, like she's an opportunist.
- 25:23And I think that really sets the stage for the rest of the movie.
- 25:25Because as these plot twists kind of come to light, it
- 25:30totally makes sense that she would do stuff like that.
- 25:32It totally makes sense that she would be sleeping with her
- 25:35stepdaughters Friend and maybe trying to rope him into this
- 25:38somehow? All of these things continue to
- 25:41stack up and like, yes she's a terrible person but you also
- 25:44just like Walter Neff, like you signed up for that we were we
- 25:48were drawn in by her Allure of how Shameless and kind of brash
- 25:52she is and kind of along with Walter.
- 25:55Like we, as the audience, get our comeuppance for getting
- 25:58involved with somebody like that.
- 25:59Yeah. And I think that her daughter,
- 26:02well, her step daughter Lola. She is like the canary.
- 26:06In the mine shaft, if you will that like from the very moment,
- 26:10you actually meet Lola. That's the first time where you
- 26:14go, there's something off about phyllis's story, because she
- 26:19talks about how her husband is mean, and kind of a drunk and
- 26:23gets angry with her. And then the first time you meet
- 26:25him, he's mean, he's, you know, he's not nice to her and you're
- 26:29like, okay yeah, her story is kind of verified her husband's
- 26:33kind of a jerk. But the thing is, she That's a
- 26:36few times that her stepdaughter is kind of lousy and and not
- 26:40trustworthy and just make stuff up.
- 26:43But from the very first time you meet Lola, you go huh.
- 26:46Something's off. Phyllis is story isn't quite
- 26:49stacking up and she ends up being the one that really helps
- 26:53Walter realize, like, yeah, Phyllis is the one who actually
- 26:57killed her, original mom, you know, dietrichson's, first wife,
- 27:01and that she forced her way in to get married.
- 27:04And now she's she thinks that she killed her.
- 27:06Dad and and Walters like, holy crap.
- 27:09I am in so much further than I thought I was going to be.
- 27:13And that's our segue Brad into talking about Fred MacMurray.
- 27:15I want to get your thoughts before we go to the break.
- 27:17He is our main character. He is the one who is narrating
- 27:21the film through his eyes, as we're seeing the whole world of
- 27:24Double Indemnity. How did you think Fred MacMurray
- 27:27did in this movie? Oh my gosh, dude.
- 27:29I I struggled at the very start because you could tell that he's
- 27:32just a womanizer and I really wasn't enjoying that.
- 27:36Scene with Phyllis. But as the movie went on, I just
- 27:40think he has a smoothness about him.
- 27:42That is amazing. And and honestly, I think that
- 27:45these movies the the film Noir genre part of the reason they're
- 27:49so famous is because their protagonists are so so cynical
- 27:54about the world and yet I think one of the reasons I like Walter
- 27:58Neff as a character is because Fred MacMurray doesn't choose to
- 28:02play him as a. Crazy cynical doesn't believe.
- 28:06Anything really is real in the world as much as it's probably
- 28:10more about sex than about love. He definitely portrays himself
- 28:14as a man who is falling head over heels with this idea of
- 28:18being with Phyllis dietrichson and so he's not your typical
- 28:23cynical private eye, that doesn't think anything.
- 28:26Good is out there, he's someone who falls in love with a woman
- 28:29on a whim almost and he kind of gets burned because of it and I
- 28:34like him because of that. Absolutely.
- 28:37It's a very different Dynamic than if you'd had like a
- 28:39Humphrey Bogart in this movie, you know, Bogart had one of
- 28:42those faces that just kind of looked like it had been worn
- 28:45down by Years of Living in the real world.
- 28:48Fred MacMurray is like a baby face.
- 28:50You know what I mean? And he had made his bones in
- 28:52Hollywood by being in star of like really light
- 28:56family-oriented comedies. He became one of the highest
- 28:58paid actors in Hollywood and then he took this role because
- 29:02his contract was expiring with Paramount and normally they
- 29:05would have advised him. Against it but he was playing
- 29:07Hardball with the company and so Paramount was like let's let him
- 29:10take this role, it'll ruin his career and then we won't have to
- 29:13pay him any more money and it had obviously the opposite
- 29:16effect. But I think that casting
- 29:18somebody like McMurray in this role really works to the benefit
- 29:21of the movie because he's not the kind of guy that's like a
- 29:25bogart worn down and just skeptical of everything in the
- 29:28world. He's a guy who's, you know, for
- 29:31lack of a better term. He's like a regular guy.
- 29:33He works in an insurance office and he's seen enough of these
- 29:36Kind of bogus claims come in that he has a healthy sense of
- 29:39skepticism, but it's not really until he gets caught in this
- 29:43sort of web of murder and deceit and lies that you really see the
- 29:46extent of how Bleak his worldview comes to be.
- 29:50And I think having this sort of like, baby-faced good-looking
- 29:54guy in the part really brings that home.
- 29:56Yeah, I mean I mean think about it.
- 29:58Bob if you had Fred C Dobbs as the insurance salesman like it
- 30:03just it just would be too harsh. It It'd be too over the top and
- 30:08like you said, I honestly, if I had to describe Neff at the
- 30:12start of the movie, he's an insurance salesman, he makes
- 30:14good money. He's, you know, and this is more
- 30:17of a dream. I don't think this is actually
- 30:19the best that the world has to offer.
- 30:22But like, you know, he's on top of the world, he can womanize
- 30:24all he wants, he's got the money he needs, he gets to travel.
- 30:28Like this is in a certain way, a perverse American dream.
- 30:33And so you know that like you said that baby face, the He
- 30:36plays the character as being kind of eager and Suave and
- 30:40confident. I just I really, really think
- 30:43that Fred MacMurray had the best performance out of anybody in
- 30:46this movie, but Brad, I think this is a good note for us to
- 30:49press pause. When we come back, I want to
- 30:50talk a little bit about Billy Wilder.
- 30:52The director and we've talked about the writer, but I want to
- 30:54talk about his Direction in this film, I want to talk about the
- 30:57themes of the movie. What makes this a film Noir?
- 31:00What is a film Noir. And then, we're going to kind of
- 31:02talk about, you know, the legacy of Double Indemnity.
- 31:05But before we get to that, that lets press pause here.
- 31:07Let's try this old Granddad 114. What do you say?
- 31:10Let's get to it. Hey, everybody.
- 31:47If you've been listening to the podcast for any length of time
- 31:49than you know, that I am a huge nerd when it comes to movies.
- 31:53But the question is, what are you nerdy about?
- 31:55What is the thing that makes you nerd out more than anything?
- 31:58Is it video games is it D and D like Brad we know you have
- 32:02something in your life that you like to be nerdy about and for
- 32:04the inner nerd in all of us there is a place called Loot
- 32:07Crate. It's a subscription service that
- 32:09sends all kinds of different bundles directly to your door
- 32:12with different kinds of themes. If you're a fan of the robots
- 32:15Radio Network, You may want an Elder Scrolls themed box.
- 32:18You may want to fall out box, a Marvel box.
- 32:20There's gaming, there's anime. There's tons of different
- 32:23subscription themes that you can sign up for at Loot Crate.
- 32:26The great part about a Loot Crate Box is that they try to
- 32:29give you a variety of things. Each month, that actually have
- 32:31more value in the Box than what you would get buying each things
- 32:34separately. And the best part is that we as
- 32:36a part of the robots radio network are excited to be able
- 32:39to offer you a 15 percent off your first order with Loot
- 32:42Crate. If you're interested in checking
- 32:44out Loot Crate, make sure you use.
- 32:46The link in our show notes go to the episode that we're listening
- 32:49the show notes there and click the exclusive link that we have
- 32:52there and make sure you enter the code robots radio at
- 32:55checkout. You have to do both things.
- 32:56Click the link and enter the code robots.
- 32:59Radio for 15 percent off. Your first purchase from Loot
- 33:02Crate. Alright, so today we are
- 33:09checking out old, Granddad 114. Now if you've been following our
- 33:13podcast for any length of time, you've probably guessed that.
- 33:15The 114 means that it is 114 proof, and you would be correct,
- 33:19why? I know this comes from the Jim
- 33:23Beam corporation. Last week, we tried the old
- 33:26Granddad bottled and bond back in season one.
- 33:28We tried old Granddad, 80, proof.
- 33:31We were not fans of either of them, but we keep getting
- 33:33people. Telling us, you know, when we
- 33:35tried the 80-proof people were like you got to try the hundred
- 33:38proof. It's so much better now.
- 33:40We've tried the 100 proof and everyone's like well wait till
- 33:42you try 114. So we said listen, I don't think
- 33:44we're going to like this but we're going to do the 114 so
- 33:47that we stop having people tell us that we're drinking the wrong
- 33:50whiskey somehow. If we like give this a bad score
- 33:54their old granddad's going to suddenly come out with like but
- 33:57wait, wait wait there's this 137 cast with that.
- 34:01We really think would be good. It's really The top, it puts the
- 34:05114 to shame. This whiskey is pretty Limited
- 34:08in its distribution. You can't find it in Ohio.
- 34:10You really have to go to Kentucky, to get it anywhere
- 34:12around, where we live, Brad, honestly.
- 34:15After the first two expressions of old Granddad, I'm a little
- 34:18bit leery, but I'm kind of excited.
- 34:20It'll be fun to get into it now. Old Granddad is a high rhyme Ash
- 34:25Bill meaning that we know bourbon has to be 51% corn to be
- 34:29called bourbon. But after corn, the next highest
- 34:32used grain in the mash bill is right.
- 34:34Bye. And so Brad, I expect us to have
- 34:36quite a bit of that Rice. Pais.
- 34:37It's actually 27% Rai but let's get into nosing it.
- 34:41What are you picking up on the nose of this old Granddad 114?
- 34:45Honestly, it-it's very alcohol forward.
- 34:48Yep. But once you kind of push past
- 34:50that a little bit, it has man, it has a little bit of vanilla,
- 34:55it has some of that rye kind of spiciness, but there's also I
- 35:01might sound weird but it almost smells kind of like A hmm, that
- 35:06that musty kind of old feel to it?
- 35:10Yeah, that I haven't noticed on other versions of old Granddad.
- 35:14Yeah, it definitely has almost like a raw grain smell to it.
- 35:19That's pretty prominent. I actually didn't think this had
- 35:22much of a nose to it. And I'm kind of surprised
- 35:24because, you know, typically as we increase in proof, we're
- 35:27usually increasing in age a little bit too.
- 35:29I don't know if that's the case here.
- 35:31But I was expecting something a little bit more complex and All
- 35:34I really got was a huge blast of ethanol on the nose, a little
- 35:38bit of spice and it's kind of like your typical bourbon e or
- 35:42rice spices, but it also smells you get that that rye comes
- 35:46forward in an almost sour type way.
- 35:49Like it's a it's like a rye bread.
- 35:50There's like a yeast Enos to it and it smells like like just
- 35:55milled grain. It's very I don't know what the
- 35:58word I would use to describe this is but it's almost like
- 36:00rustic smelling. You know what I mean?
- 36:02Like it smells like, yeah. Smells like yeast.
- 36:05It smells like grain and then it's just like, here's a bunch
- 36:08of ethanol to go with it. I don't find this to be a really
- 36:11satisfying knows, I don't know. Are you enjoying the nose Brad?
- 36:14No, I mean I will say there's not a lot of richness or depth
- 36:20to this 114 proof that you would like you said, Bob, when you get
- 36:24up above 110, 115 proof, you start to expect a depth and a
- 36:30richness to it that I'm not getting here.
- 36:32Even even as I looked Look at this.
- 36:34The color doesn't even look that deep know compared to other
- 36:38things that you get at this proof.
- 36:40Yeah, totally agree. I'm going to give this a 4 on
- 36:42the nose. Um, I'm gonna give it a five.
- 36:45It's right down the middle average for me.
- 36:48All right, well, that takes us to The Taste so hopefully this
- 36:50improves from here. Let's give it a sip.
- 36:57Wow. Bob I'm yeah, that's, that's a
- 37:03whiskey. Yep, it has alcohol in it, so it
- 37:06sure it. Sure has alcohol.
- 37:09And then on top of the alcohol is some more alcohol.
- 37:13Honestly, the more I taste bourbon, the more you do get to
- 37:18recognize like a front of the tip Taste of middle of the
- 37:22tongue taste of Finnish taste and like a good whiskey can
- 37:26balance and yet Change in all those areas this whiskey.
- 37:31It tastes like ethanol on the tip of my tongue.
- 37:35On the middle of my tongue, it has a corn sweetness to it and
- 37:41then it goes down my throat and it tastes like ethanol.
- 37:45Yeah. Is that about the experience?
- 37:47You had bottle. Absolutely.
- 37:48And I think you're totally right Brad, As We Sip some of these
- 37:51whiskeys. I've started to realize that
- 37:52there's kind of like two or three basic Umbrellas of
- 37:56bourbon. It's and one of them is this
- 37:58sort of like high-rise? I unsweet harsh grainy Mash Bill
- 38:05and you get it in these old. Granddad's you get it a lot in
- 38:07for roses and I've just found that I don't care for Whiskey's
- 38:11that tastes like this and this is no exception to that Brad.
- 38:13I don't know if you would compare this to a Four Roses but
- 38:16that's kind of the same thing. I get it's it's really thin for
- 38:19a 114. There's a little bit of spice
- 38:23and there's that alcohol tingle throughout it's just alcohol all
- 38:26the way. And I found that that sour note
- 38:29from the Rye on the nose carried through as well.
- 38:32It's not a pleasant ride flavor. It's just this really sort of
- 38:37sourdough almost yeasty bread. It doesn't have much flavor to
- 38:43it. I let it sit for about five
- 38:45minutes. I've taken two sips of this now,
- 38:47and it has a little bit more character after about 5 minutes
- 38:50that it really kind of develops, some more sugar.
- 38:52But again, it took five solid minutes to just like calm down
- 38:56in my Glass enough to be palatable.
- 38:59I do not like this. I'm going to give it a 4 again
- 39:02on the taste man. Bob I'm trying to come up with
- 39:04something for this and I just can't it's a three on the taste
- 39:07for me that there's not much going on here you know I've read
- 39:12a few different reviews of this and it seems like it's pretty
- 39:17universally praised that there's a lot going on and I don't know
- 39:20if I'm just doing something wrong but I feel like I've drank
- 39:24enough Barrel proof whiskey at this point.
- 39:27To know what I'm doing when it comes to high proof whiskey.
- 39:30This one doesn't have a lot of flavor, you know.
- 39:32I swish it around on the front of the tongue a little bit, but
- 39:35even as I finish and I tried to look for notes, I try to find
- 39:38anything on there. Even just something, you know,
- 39:42some sort of spice or some sort of anything.
- 39:44It's just so overwhelmed by the ethanol that any flavor I find
- 39:49isn't really worth finding. Yeah, Brad, I totally agree.
- 39:52I actually found myself about halfway through scoring this
- 39:54saying like why am I trying so hard?
- 39:57To find good things to say about this.
- 39:59Yes, it gets. Yeah, yeah.
- 40:00I think it's because I've read and seen so many people who love
- 40:03it and at a certain point I had to say like, no, I'm not going
- 40:06to just like grade this on a curve anymore.
- 40:09And I have to be honest about the fact that I do not think
- 40:11this is good and that that takes me to the Finish as well.
- 40:15And literally, the only note that I took down for finished
- 40:17was ethanol. Just ethanol like there really
- 40:21is no lingering flavor that lasts on this.
- 40:24It is a hugely alcohol, forward. Ski the burn going down is
- 40:29prominent and it. Honestly, last week we said that
- 40:32it seems like to get to 100 Proof.
- 40:35They just added a bunch more grain alcohol to get to go from
- 40:3980 to 100. And this time it seems like the
- 40:41same thing as we've gone up in proof.
- 40:43I do not notice a lot more flavor a lot more depth or
- 40:46complexity in these whiskies. And at this point I think it's
- 40:50just getting harsh. Yeah.
- 40:51Bob it's I am not understanding the obsession with this whiskey.
- 40:57I honestly kind of feels like when we reviewed mellow corn.
- 41:00Now granted milk horns in a very different category as far as you
- 41:03know, that everybody would recognize that's a low-end cheap
- 41:07whiskey but a lot of people really like it.
- 41:09This one I don't know what the price is but I can't imagine
- 41:13it's a Super Cheap whiskey and so I'm just going to sit here
- 41:16and go man, like for the Finish, it's going to be a three for me
- 41:20balance, I guess it's well balanced it smells like ethanol
- 41:25and corn and a little bit of spice and It tastes like that.
- 41:28So I guess I'll give it a 5 on balance, but I'm really curious
- 41:33to get to this value score because I'm, I want to know how
- 41:36much it cost. Yeah, so just for me, I gave it
- 41:39a 4 on finish. I gave it a 4 on balance.
- 41:41I went for is across the board until I got to value.
- 41:44Now the value on this is going to be kind of interesting to
- 41:46gauge because Again Brad it seems like the some people's
- 41:50palates just really appreciate Whiskey's like this and I know I
- 41:54don't. So I'm going to grade it based
- 41:56on that. And if you're a big fan of old
- 41:58Granddad of of Four Roses, I think this this would be right
- 42:01up your alley. This bottle of whiskey will cost
- 42:03you about $30 so it's not an exorbitant amount of money.
- 42:07And it is kind of like, you know, if you're going to
- 42:10Kentucky, it's not distributed by you.
- 42:12You pick up a bottle, it's a good story.
- 42:13It's actually a really beautiful bottle.
- 42:15One of my favorite bottles in the whole of the bourbon world,
- 42:19but Brad, I would never pay $30 for this, and I could list a,
- 42:23you know, just a plethora of Whiskey's that I would
- 42:26recommend. $30 before this, I mean, you know, in the state of
- 42:30Ohio, like you can get well or Special Reserve for cheaper than
- 42:32this, you can get all his Elijah Craig.
- 42:34You could do a Knob Creek, like, even in the Jim Beam line there
- 42:38are things that I would recommend over this.
- 42:40I'm going to give this a 3 on value.
- 42:42I'm right there with you Bob. I think that there's so many
- 42:44Whiskey's you can get for even $20 that are better than this.
- 42:49They're in our Springtime of swill.
- 42:51We probably had a few whiskies that I would prefer over this.
- 42:54So yeah, I'm going to give it a 3 as well.
- 42:56I think there's Thing going on here and people seem to like it.
- 42:59But I'm gonna have to pass on this and not recommend it.
- 43:03I don't recommend as well. That means that both of us come
- 43:06out to a 19 out of 50 on this. So well below average, I have a
- 43:11feeling that some people are going to write us Brad or maybe
- 43:13call in and tell us that they think differently about this.
- 43:16And I would love to hear if, if you like this whiskey, I want a
- 43:20description. Not just that we're wrong and
- 43:22you liked it, but what is it about it that appeals to you?
- 43:26Because for us, it The crosses as sour as harsh as too much of
- 43:31an alcohol burn. Do you agree with that
- 43:33assessment or are we completely missing something in this
- 43:36whiskey. So please if you disagree with
- 43:39us, call in right in and let us know what it is.
- 43:41That you think is good about old Granddad 114.
- 43:44Yeah, Bob this might be our Back to the Future take of the in the
- 43:49whiskey world. But regardless of that I think
- 43:53I'm about ready to move past not just old Undead 114, but any
- 43:58version of Old Granddad, I would much rather talk about the 1944.
- 44:03Classic double indemnity. Well, Brad, let's get back into
- 44:06it. Alright, so that was old
- 44:50Granddad. 114 a whiskey that. Neither of us recommends, a
- 44:54neither of us enjoyed. Let's get back into talking
- 44:56about this movie that both of us, enjoy and that I will be
- 44:59much happier to talk about Brad before we left for the break.
- 45:03I said that we were going to get into talking about Billy Wilder
- 45:05as a director. And I think that Billy Wilder is
- 45:08a really underrated director because he also wrote all, you
- 45:11know, all or most of the movies that he made I think people give
- 45:16him a lot of credit for being a great screenwriter but Kind of
- 45:19infer that like he was using that as a crutch with his
- 45:22Direction. And I don't think you can make
- 45:24that argument here. I think this is Wilder, at his
- 45:27most kind of hitchcockian like this.
- 45:30This movie reminds me so much of a Hitchcock movie, obviously,
- 45:33very different tonally, but the two major themes in this movie
- 45:37are, like, sex and suspense. And that's a Hitchcock movie,
- 45:41you know what I mean? Like, Everything About You movie
- 45:43is either about the tension of, are they going to get caught or
- 45:47it's about the tension of? Are they going to have?
- 45:49X, that is the definition of a Hitchcock type movie.
- 45:53And I think that Billy Wilder really leans into those kind of
- 45:56directorial, tricks, obviously, we talked about the sexual
- 46:00tension in the first couple scenes with the leads, but I
- 46:03think it's also really hitchcockian in the way that you
- 46:06as the viewer are watching this crime play out, you're watching
- 46:09these two horrible people planning to commit murder and
- 46:13then when it comes time to actually do it, you're surprised
- 46:16to find out that you're like on their side like your kind of
- 46:19Only hoping they get away with it when they lay his body on the
- 46:22tracks and run back to the car to get away and the car won't
- 46:25start. It's so suspenseful and you
- 46:28don't want to admit it but it's suspenseful because you're
- 46:30hoping that they don't get caught.
- 46:33And and like that is the definition of a Hitchcock type
- 46:36suspense thriller in Vertigo when Jimmy Stewart finds the
- 46:40letter and he's realizing everything that happened.
- 46:43Like I feel like you have a moment like that and this movie
- 46:47when f is Everything that really is happening here and he finally
- 46:53figures out. Oh, this is what's actually
- 46:55going on. And so, yeah, I think Hitchcock
- 46:58is a perfect perfect look like for you know, what is happening
- 47:03in this Billy Wilder film. But like you said, I think that
- 47:06Hitchcock has a weirdness about him that Billy Wilder doesn't
- 47:13have. And so with wilder, you get the
- 47:15snarky comments, the double entendres you Get those moments
- 47:20of lightness and of laughter that I think allow you as, you
- 47:24know, just as an average moviegoer to engage with the
- 47:29film on a deeper level, because it doesn't feel so.
- 47:33So, foreign to real life. Does that make sense?
- 47:37Yeah, I think it does. And I think that that's what
- 47:38really makes Billy Wilder, a great candidate for directing, a
- 47:42film Noir. Now, this is a term that we've
- 47:44used. Like, I don't know, probably 20
- 47:46times already on this episode Brad, but film Noir is Really
- 47:49hard to Define. It's not really a genre, it's
- 47:53more about the style and yet, any movie, that, that gets
- 47:56designated or gets called a film Noir, you do see like certain
- 48:00elements, creep back up again, and again.
- 48:03So, the term film Noir. It actually, it comes from the
- 48:06French for black film or dark film.
- 48:08They're usually characterized by the fact that they have these
- 48:11really harsh lighting patterns that, you know, when you're
- 48:14lighting a scene, you've got, like, a couple main lights in
- 48:16the one is called the key light, that's where most of the light
- 48:18comes from. Um, and let's say that you're
- 48:20shining a light on somebody's face.
- 48:21The key light is going to create a whole bunch of shadow on the
- 48:24other side of the person's face. The usually, what they would do
- 48:26is they would put a second light called, a fill light, to kind of
- 48:29balance that out. Well, in film Noir, they're all
- 48:31about the Shadows. They're all about the contrast.
- 48:33So like they're not going to put a fill light in the scene.
- 48:35And so you get these incredible like Silhouettes, you get the
- 48:39light pouring in through the Venetian blinds.
- 48:42That really create these kind of expressionistic visuals in a
- 48:46movie and then you also have that they To have the same
- 48:49themes. There's always like a cynical
- 48:52world view, there's usually a femme fatale, they're usually
- 48:54about murder. Sex is always kind of bubbling
- 48:57underneath the surface, creating all the tension.
- 49:00I think this is a perfect example of that.
- 49:02Because when you think about film Noir, it is about as
- 49:05stylized of a movie genre as you can get and yet somehow Billy
- 49:11Wilder doesn't make it seem like this weird foreign world that
- 49:14we're in happening. Like it all seems realistic
- 49:16because of the touches that he brings to it.
- 49:19It. Yeah, I mean even when you just
- 49:21look at you know the the insurance office that Neff and
- 49:25keys working, it just feels like a normal everyday workplace and
- 49:30I think other film Noir you get these privatized that are you
- 49:33know they're in an office by themselves and their pondering
- 49:37the meaning of life. And they're you know they're
- 49:39there it's like this gritty dark and it's just unrelatable.
- 49:43It doesn't feel like real life, whereas in this film, you know,
- 49:45they just have normal office jobs and keys is done, really
- 49:48well. Himself.
- 49:49So he has an office by by himself and Neff is done pretty
- 49:53good for himself and he shares an office.
- 49:55He's not on the general floor with all the other salesmen.
- 49:58So like their gets, there's this sense of normalcy about his life
- 50:03that makes the vortex that is Phyllis dietrichson so much more
- 50:08enticing for him. You know, it's because he leads
- 50:11this normal life that he's like, man.
- 50:14I have this opportunity to sleep with an or with a married woman
- 50:17and it's a chance to kind of spice.
- 50:19These things up and, and it's just so believable.
- 50:23And I think that that believability that he's able to
- 50:25craft even within such like a highly stylized visual World, it
- 50:31really helps the movie out and I think Billy Wilder even realized
- 50:35this because they filmed a different ending for the movie,
- 50:38you know, as I was watching this movie, I was like, I don't
- 50:41understand why this movies ending in the way that it does.
- 50:43And I don't know if you really had this problem Brad, but like,
- 50:46you know, Walter Neff finds out that Phyllis has been seeing Sky
- 50:49Nino, zachetti hurt, her stepdaughters boyfriend, and you
- 50:52get the idea that like, oh, he's going to pin it on them, but
- 50:56then he makes this really huge jump to like, well, no, I have
- 50:59to actually kill her and I'm going to pin It On zachetti by
- 51:02calling the cops afterwards. And I'm like, why do you have to
- 51:05kill her? Why are you going back into her
- 51:07house? What happens if you accidentally
- 51:08leave some kind of evidence? They're like why are you doing
- 51:11this? And then I found out afterwards
- 51:13that because of the sensors that were in place at the time you
- 51:16actually had to have both of those at Agonist shoot each
- 51:20other in a way that could potentially be fatal.
- 51:23The Hays code had a really strong belief that people who
- 51:27did things like what they did criminals.
- 51:29You know, they had to pay and people who are adulterers had to
- 51:32pay. So it makes sense that you see
- 51:35Phyllis get killed by Walter and Walter get killed by Phyllis.
- 51:38You know, if he does end up dying but the the movie actually
- 51:42went further than that in the original draft of the screenplay
- 51:46and they actually filmed the ending and tested it out for
- 51:48audiences. Walter survives and actually
- 51:51goes to prison and gets executed at the end of the movie.
- 51:54And the last scene of the movie, is him going into the gas
- 51:57chamber and you can actually still find like production
- 51:59stills from this seen online, Edward G Robinson.
- 52:03Goes to the gas chamber and watches from outside as Walter
- 52:06dies, which is like a, a horribly Bleak ending to this
- 52:11movie. But Billy Wilder tested it out,
- 52:15the audience didn't seem to mind the ending.
- 52:16But he actually said, you know what, I don't think we Need
- 52:19this. Even though they spent a whole
- 52:20bunch of money to craft this scene, he's like, you know, the
- 52:24heart of the movie is this relationship between Walter and
- 52:27keys and that last scene that we get where we kind of understand
- 52:30what's going to happen to Walter.
- 52:32Anyway, that's really the ending of the movie.
- 52:34Why don't we just end it there. And I thought that's probably
- 52:37the best directorial decision that he made in the whole movie
- 52:40because that ending, we really would have been completely
- 52:43unnecessary. And, and where they choose to
- 52:46end, it is kind of like the emotional climax.
- 52:49Of the movie and I think it works beautifully.
- 52:51Yeah. And, and Bob, that, that kind of
- 52:53brings me to a place where I'm ready to give my final score
- 52:57because this, this movie is so, so good.
- 53:00That, you know, there's a few issues here there that I
- 53:03wouldn't call this a perfect movie.
- 53:06But for me, it's easily a nine and a half out of ten.
- 53:09I could watch this movie over and over again.
- 53:12And honestly, I'm excited to show to a few friends, who, you
- 53:16know, probably haven't seen it with how old it is, because This
- 53:19is just put plainly, it's a fantastic movie and I really
- 53:23think anybody who enjoys movies should watch this film.
- 53:27You know, I think I'm right there with you.
- 53:28This has always been one of my favorite classic films to watch
- 53:31and I don't know if it's just because of like what's going on
- 53:34in the world? The last few weeks and seeing
- 53:36like the dark side of human personalities.
- 53:40But something about housel easy and dark and unredeemable these
- 53:44characters were really affected me this time and I couldn't
- 53:48quite lean into Thing at a 10 but I think it's absolutely a
- 53:51nine and a half. It's a phenomenal movie.
- 53:54It's probably the best example of a film Noir that's ever been
- 53:57put to film when the movie came out, it actually was nominated
- 54:00for seven Academy Awards and it didn't win any, and Billy Wilder
- 54:04got so mad because his Studio basically, through the movie
- 54:07Under the bus, they promoted a different movie instead.
- 54:10And both of these films were nominated for best picture.
- 54:12And by the time Billy Wilder, lost Best Director to the guy
- 54:16who who directed the other film. He actually tripped him going up
- 54:20the aisle. Billy Wilder was a super sore
- 54:22loser, but I think in the years since this movie has come out,
- 54:25it's come to be seen as one of the best films ever made.
- 54:29And I absolutely think that it holds up 75 76 years after it
- 54:34came out. The Bob do you want to know
- 54:36whose opinion? I want to hear.
- 54:38Who's that bread? Well that would be filming
- 54:40whiskey Nation, our loyal listeners but if they wanted to
- 54:43let us know what they thought. Bob where would they find us?
- 54:46Well, it's such a good question. Brad, if you want to write in
- 54:48call, Tell us what you think about Double Indemnity.
- 54:51You can find us on social media, we're on Facebook, Twitter and
- 54:55Instagram at film whiskey, or if you want to give us a call, our
- 54:58phone number is two one, six, eight hundred 5923 once again.
- 55:02That number is two one, six, eight hundred 5923 or give us a
- 55:07call on our anchor dot f m-- page.
- 55:09You can record a voice mail there and let us know what you
- 55:11think about Double Indemnity next week we will be back.
- 55:14We're actually staying in Classic Hollywood.
- 55:16Brad will be back with a 1951. Classic the African queen for
- 55:21the film and whiskey podcast. I'm Bob book, I'm Reggie will
- 55:25see you next time.