Latest / The Sperrins: Mining, Power & Community in Northern Ireland / #63 🎙️|Public Inquiry Roads Week Beginning 19th May 2026 | Day 3
Transcript
- 0:05talk about prevarication. I answered every email that needed
- 0:09answered and made all the phone calls necessary and unnecessary,
- 0:14cleaned the kitchen, washed the floors, saw some moving
- 0:17wallpaper on television before I finally forced myself to sit
- 0:21down and write about today's events, and I knew why I was
- 0:25doing it. I was angry, angry at once again finding myself
- 0:30witnessing the further erosion of our precious democratic
- 0:33values by the very government departments that are supposed to
- 0:36be protecting and upholding them. The sad thing is that this
- 0:44is no longer an isolated instant or a one-off failure in process.
- 0:49It is much part of a bigger pattern that people right across
- 0:52Northern Ireland have been watching develop for years now.
- 0:58Little by little, public confidence in our civil service
- 1:01has been chipped away through lobbying, political influence,
- 1:06the growing power of large corporations, and a system that
- 1:10seems more comfortable accommodating big business than
- 1:13listening to ordinary communities. You start to notice
- 1:19that scrutiny becomes weaker, difficult questions become
- 1:24inconvenient, and people with genuine expertise, like Doug
- 1:28Hill, can find themselves pushed to the margins on one when what
- 1:33they are saying no longer fits neatly into the direction things
- 1:37are moving. For me it feels like a race to the bottom in public
- 1:43life where democratic safeguards are slowly hollowed out and
- 1:48trust in institutions becomes harder and harder to hold on to.
- 1:56An extraordinary moment in the roads inquiry occurred today
- 2:00when retired senior roads engineer Doug Hill, a man with
- 2:05roughly 45 years experience delivering and assessing major
- 2:09road and infrastructure projects across the north effectively
- 2:14warned the commission that the process itself is neither
- 2:17compliant nor robust enough to safely proceed. Doug's concern
- 2:23was that critical engineering safety and procedural issues
- 2:27around the proposed abandonment of the road were not being
- 2:30properly interrogated or independently scrutinised. He
- 2:36wanted to raise concerns about road safety, visibility,
- 2:40drainage, heavy vehicles, movements, long-term maintenance
- 2:45liabilities, emergency access, and even the legality and
- 2:50adequacy of the road abandonment procedures themselves. Instead
- 2:56of these warnings triggering deeper examination, Doug was
- 3:01effectively shut out of the process after challenging the
- 3:05procedure being used. In other words, one of the most
- 3:09experienced road engineers in Northern Ireland attempted to
- 3:13formally raise concerns that the inquiry itself is not following
- 3:17a sufficiently robust or compliant process, and rather
- 3:21than opening that discussion up the system appeared to close
- 3:24ranks around it. After heated exchange between Doug and the
- 3:31commissioners, he voluntarily excluded himself from the room,
- 3:35disgusted that his stand for engineering integrity and his
- 3:39concern for risk and public safety were being totally
- 3:43disregarded. He did this as the commissioner was reading out the
- 3:48Rise Act that is used to exclude people from the inquiry, and
- 3:52also seems to trigger simultaneously called for police
- 3:56help, because within 10 minutes two policemen also appeared. How
- 4:01I wish they were as quick to appear when community needs
- 4:05urgent help. However, that topic is for a different day. I'm
- 4:10guessing the system has them on speed dial. It wouldn't be for
- 4:13the first time. Whilst I admit that Doe goes noisy and maybe
- 4:18not as polite as he might have been, I do think it could have
- 4:21been handled differently. You can imagine the headlines,
- 4:24either now or perhaps in the future, after a fatal accident.
- 4:28Safety questions raised a senior road engineer shut out of
- 4:32inquiry, or the day road safety concerns were pushed aside, and
- 4:38so on. Doug Hill today effectively became the
- 4:42whistleblower around the shambolic public inquiry, and
- 4:46the establishment did not respond well. They say that
- 4:52being seen as authentic is the most valuable crown of the
- 4:55realm, but having integrity around your authenticity is
- 4:59quite a different process. Position not only is Doug Hill a
- 5:03whistleblower, but he's also a stand for compliance and duty of
- 5:07candour, which Cormac McAleer has constantly highlighted the
- 5:11glaring absence of almost every day during this inquiry, but I
- 5:18think hurt Doug most was not simply the technical
- 5:22deficiencies or the procedural concerns. Doug was a man who
- 5:27spent the greater part of his life working within a system
- 5:31that was built around standards, compliance, public safety, and
- 5:35professional integrity. And, as an aside, if you check out the
- 5:39podcast notes, you can see a list of his professional
- 5:42achievements. Those values are more than his job; they're
- 5:47literally a part of his identity. And when someone's
- 5:51identity feels compromised, something very deep is touched
- 5:55in the human psychic. Sitting in that room, you could sense the
- 5:58weight of realising that many of the principles he had spent
- 6:01decades defending now seem to be slowly diluted, negotiated away,
- 6:07or treated as obstacles to be managed. I also think there was
- 6:12a hurt in watching former colleagues and institutions he
- 6:15once respected and believed in appearing willing to accept
- 6:18standards that years ago would simply have never passed without
- 6:22challenge. It was a moment of genuine distress, and he was a
- 6:26man who had reached the limits of his professional frustration.
- 6:30You could feel the quiet and heavy disappointment in him. To
- 6:35abandon the public road for the benefit of a private gold mine,
- 6:39while fundamental concerns around process safety and
- 6:42accountability remain unresolved, risks becoming an
- 6:47erosion of democracy itself. Shame on DFI, shame on the
- 6:53planning appeals process. If on your watch the quality of public
- 6:57infrastructure is compromised, safety is surrendered, risk
- 7:01increase solely to accommodate a private commercial company, all
- 7:06while communities are excluded from meaningful decision making,
- 7:10and maybe this realisation is exactly the point where systems,
- 7:15either institutions, begin to recover themselves or continue
- 7:18sliding further away from the public interest altogether,
- 7:23which brings me neatly to tonight's very special
- 7:26recruitment opportunity. Unfortunately, it's only open to
- 7:29DFI or PAC employees. The role is for a full-time DFI or PAC
- 7:37whistleblower. Now, I should say from the outset applicants would
- 7:41need to be highly motivated, because the package and offer is
- 7:45frankly terrible. There's no salary attached to the rule. In
- 7:49fact, there's a reasonable chance you lose the salary, you
- 7:52have pension possibly gone, career finished, you may be
- 7:59isolated, quietly disappeared, talked about in corridors,
- 8:05avoided at conferences, and suddenly find yourself no longer
- 8:09invited for tea and biscuits in the staff room, and candidates
- 8:13should also be comfortable with prolonged levels of stress, mild
- 8:17paranoia, and the possibility of becoming that person who made
- 8:21things awkward by insisting on standards, compliance,
- 8:25integrity, and duty of candour. However, there are few benefits.
- 8:30Successful applicants will receive the undying gratitude of
- 8:34a small rural community in the Spurns. There's also a strong
- 8:38possibility of getting into heaven, or at the very least,
- 8:42avoiding a very uncomfortable conversation at the Pearly Gates
- 8:46about DFI compliance agreements. You will also enjoy the rare
- 8:50personal satisfaction of being able to look yourself in the
- 8:53mirror and say, at least I tried, which these days is
- 8:57becoming a surprisingly valuable thing. There is also honour, a
- 9:03certain amount of glory, maybe not immediately, possibly not
- 9:07even while you're alive, but definitely the sort of quiet
- 9:10reputation that lasts a lot longer than a consultancy
- 9:13contract or an internal memo. So, if you are currently sitting
- 9:19somewhere trapped inside these systems, staring into the middle
- 9:23distance, wondering what on earth has happened to the
- 9:27standard you once believed in. Our lines are open, and to
- 9:33finish this evening, I have one final thought. As far as I'm
- 9:37concerned, Dog Hill's response was the only thing that mattered
- 9:41today, because when a man who has spent 45 years building,
- 9:45assessing, and safeguarding public roads stands up in
- 9:48obvious distress and effectively warns that the process itself is
- 9:52failing basic standards of scrutiny, compliance, and
- 9:56integrity, then the entire inquiry should have. Stop there,
- 10:00and then in its tracks. Instead, it just rolled on, and from that
- 10:06moment on, everything else I heard in the room today felt
- 10:10diminished by it. I'll see you all tomorrow.