Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / Intuit Stock Crash Exposes a Value Trap?
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to The Deep Dive. Today is Friday, February 27th,
- 0:042026, and I want you to picture something for a second.
- 0:08OK? Imagine you bought a house, like
- 0:11a really beautiful, sturdy house in the absolute best
- 0:14neighborhood in town. That everyone calls a safe
- 0:16investment. Exactly the kind of place you
- 0:18pay top dollar for because, hey, it's a blue chip property.
- 0:20It's never going to lose value. Yeah.
- 0:22That is the dream. That's why we pay up for
- 0:23quality. Right.
- 0:24But then picture this. Two months later, an appraiser
- 0:29knocks on your door. He looks around, checks the
- 0:31foundation, looks at the roof, and then he just looks you dead
- 0:34in the eye and says that your house, that incredibly safe
- 0:36asset, is suddenly worth almost half of what you paid for it.
- 0:39Oh man, that is a stomach churning feeling.
- 0:42That's the moment the floor just drops out from under you.
- 0:44It's panic, pure and simple. And that is exactly what is
- 0:48happening right now to literally anyone holding shares of Intuit.
- 0:51Ticker symbol INTU. Right, the Giants.
- 0:53The parents of TurboTax. The owners of QuickBooks.
- 0:56We are looking at a stock that was trading comfortably around
- 0:59$670 just what, 8 weeks ago? Yeah, early January.
- 1:03And as we sit here today, just looking at the turmoil right
- 1:06now, it is struggling to hold 380 dollars.
- 1:10It's a 43% haircut in 60 days. Which is insane.
- 1:14It is. And for a company of this size,
- 1:18I mean, we're talking about a massive market cap, the staple
- 1:20of the S&P 500. That isn't just a simple
- 1:22correction. No, that is 10s of billions of
- 1:25dollars of wealth just evaporating into thin air.
- 1:28It's the kind of drop that makes you stop scrolling and actually
- 1:30say whoa out loud. It really makes you question
- 1:32your sanity. You look at the screen and
- 1:34think, did the CEO get arrested? The servers meltdown.
- 1:37They lose all the customer data. But that's the mystery we are
- 1:40solving today because on the surface, the tax business is
- 1:44still there. People are still filing their
- 1:45taxes right now, right? The lights are still on, the
- 1:48software still works just fine. So the question, and this is
- 1:51literally the multi billion dollar question we are going to
- 1:53try to answer, is this a fire sale?
- 1:55The sale of the century, right? Is this a fire sale on a classic
- 1:59American monopoly where you should be backing up the truck
- 2:01to buy cheap shares? Or is it?
- 2:03A trap. A value trap?
- 2:04Exactly. Is there something fundamentally
- 2:07rotting inside the business model that the market is finally
- 2:10woken up to? And to answer that, we aren't
- 2:12just going to look at a stock chart.
- 2:14We have a massive stack of research.
- 2:16Today we are breaking down a really comprehensive
- 2:20Intelligence Report from Deep Value Intelligence, literally
- 2:24dated yesterday, February 26th. And this report is fascinating
- 2:28because it's not just one guy's opinion.
- 2:30It's a debate. Yeah, we're looking at an
- 2:32adversarial analysis between a bull, a bear and a neutral agent
- 2:36using methodologies from Warren Buffett and Peter Lynch.
- 2:39We're going to see the argument from every single angle.
- 2:41Which is exactly how you want to stress test a thesis.
- 2:44Our mission today is to dismantle that whole by the DIP
- 2:47narrative and really look under the hood at their capital
- 2:49allocation. Real quick before we jump into
- 2:51the carnage, a heads up on where this Intel comes from.
- 2:54The specific report we are analyzing today including that
- 2:56multi agent debate comes from the Advanced Research available
- 3:00at Deep Values dot AI. It's an incredibly powerful
- 3:02platform. It is to access more advanced
- 3:05researches, applications and our latest published personal
- 3:07intelligent Multi agent Deep value intelligence.
- 3:09Welcome to subscribe on Deep Values dot AI.
- 3:12And you know, for listeners who want to track total market
- 3:15temperature, welcome to search and download iOS app Buffett
- 3:18Indicator from Apple App Store. It's a great way to see these
- 3:21valuations yourself. Absolutely.
- 3:23Also, standard timer time. All analysis is based on
- 3:26publicly available sources and may be subject to revisions or
- 3:29differing interpretations. All contents from this channel
- 3:32is for educational and research purposes only and does not
- 3:35constitute investment advice. Please conduct your own due
- 3:39diligence before making investment decisions.
- 3:41Always. And hey, if you like to access
- 3:44wider topics including life and investing philosophy, please
- 3:47subscribe to our sister channel at Deep Values.
- 3:50Don't forget to like this deep dive.
- 3:51Much appreciated. OK, disclaimer done.
- 3:55Let's go to the crime scene. Let's do it 43% down.
- 3:58The stock is trading way way below its 200 day moving
- 4:01average. It feels like pure panic
- 4:04selling. It does.
- 4:05But whenever I see panic, I always wonder if the market is
- 4:08just overreacting. This is just raw emotion.
- 4:10It's not just panic. Panic is when everyone sells
- 4:13because they're scared of a headline.
- 4:14This looks more like a structural rerating.
- 4:16Structural rerating. Yeah, the market isn't just
- 4:18scared. The market is waking up to a
- 4:20totally new reality about how it valued this company for the last
- 4:23few. Years.
- 4:24But Intuit has been a darling for a decade.
- 4:26It's one of those stocks you just buy and hold forever.
- 4:28It has been, but think about how most people identify into it.
- 4:32When you hear the name, what do you actually think of?
- 4:34I think of the tax guys, right, TurboTax, or maybe the
- 4:38bookkeeping guys with QuickBooks.
- 4:39I just think of software. And for a long time, that was
- 4:42completely true. That was the old into it.
- 4:44But the new into it, the one that exists right here in 2026,
- 4:48is a very different beast. How so?
- 4:51It's a conglomerate now. Remember, they spent about $19
- 4:54billion acquiring MailChimp and Credit Karma. $19 billion. 19
- 4:59billion. That is a staggering amount of
- 5:01capital. It's an empire building amount
- 5:03of money, and this deep dive is largely about the consequences
- 5:07of those specific purchases coming home to roost in 2026.
- 5:11The source material suggests that Intuit is currently
- 5:13suffering from a massive identity crisis.
- 5:15Meaning what? Are they a software company or
- 5:17are they a financial services company?
- 5:19Exactly because the market pays very, very differently for those
- 5:22two things. That's a great point.
- 5:24Look at the valuation tease in the report right now.
- 5:26It says Intuit used to trade at a price to earnings ratio APE of
- 5:30around 50. 50 times earnings, right?
- 5:33And now, after this crash, it's at 26.
- 5:35To the average person, 26 sounds a hell of a lot cheaper than 50.
- 5:38It does sound cheap. I mean if you're shopping for a
- 5:40luxury car and it's 50% off, you buy it obviously.
- 5:43But what if you find out the engine has been swapped out for
- 5:45a lawnmower engine? Great, that's the earnings
- 5:48quality argument. Cheap is relative.
- 5:51We have to decide if the dollar of earnings into it makes today
- 5:54is as high quality as the dollar of earnings they made five years
- 5:57ago. And.
- 5:58Spoiler alert from the report, the quality has degraded
- 6:01significantly. Significantly.
- 6:03OK, let's hold that thought on the rotten engine, I want to
- 6:05play devil's advocate first. Go for it.
- 6:07I want to look at the bowl case because even if the engine is
- 6:10smaller, the stock is down 43%. Here's a serious temptation
- 6:15here. Oh, absolutely.
- 6:16The report outlines the risky analyst argument perfectly, and
- 6:20if you are a contrarian, your ears really perk up when you see
- 6:23a chart that looks this bad. So let's hit the arguments for
- 6:25buying. The first one is
- 6:26straightforward, the discount. The margin of safety.
- 6:29Right. The bull analyst says that 26
- 6:32times earnings for a classic American monopoly is a
- 6:34generational buy. They're pointing to a 50% margin
- 6:38of safety compared to historical pricing.
- 6:40That is your classic reversion to the mean trade.
- 6:43You assume the market will eventually fall back in love
- 6:45with Intuit and price it at 40 or 50 times earnings again.
- 6:49And if that happens, you basically.
- 6:50Double your money. Exactly.
- 6:51The logic is just it's into it. They aren't going anywhere.
- 6:54But the bull isn't just relying on hope or mean reversion.
- 6:58They have a very specific thesis about AI.
- 7:01Intuit Assist. Right, the Gin AI savior
- 7:03narrative. Intuit isn't just sitting there
- 7:05letting AI eat their lunch, they are rolling out Intuit Assist to
- 7:09automate all the boring stuff. Data entry a categorization, the
- 7:12grunt work. The idea is that this is going
- 7:14to massively improve their margins.
- 7:16It's a completely fair argument to make.
- 7:17The bull view is that AI could fix their cost structure.
- 7:20It helps them pivot from do it yourself software where you just
- 7:23struggle through TurboTax on your own to expert LED services.
- 7:27Without actually hiring an army of humans.
- 7:29Precisely. They use AI to do 90% of the
- 7:32heavy lifting and a human expert just signs off at the end.
- 7:36So they charge the customer for a premium human expert, but
- 7:39their actual cost is just running an AI bot.
- 7:42That is a recipe for printing money.
- 7:44In theory, it would drive up their average revenue per user
- 7:47without driving up costs linearly.
- 7:50Which is the Holy Grail for software.
- 7:51The bull thinks Intuit Assist is the catalyst that proves all the
- 7:55bears wrong. If they can pull that off, maybe
- 7:57that 50 multiple actually comes back.
- 7:59And then there is the third pillar of the bull case, the
- 8:02data mode. Stickiness.
- 8:04They have data on everyone's personal taxes and through
- 8:07QuickBooks they have the Ledger for basically every small
- 8:10business in America. The bull thinks this makes them
- 8:12completely invincible. And there's truth to that.
- 8:15If you run a small business, are you really going to switch your
- 8:18accounting software? It's a nightmare.
- 8:20It's a total nightmare. The switching costs are
- 8:22astronomically high. You have the entire central
- 8:24nervous system of the business tied up in QuickBooks.
- 8:27I've switched accounting software once in my life and I
- 8:29swear I'd never do it again. It literally felt like
- 8:32performing open heart surgery on my own company.
- 8:34Exactly. And that stickiness is what the
- 8:36bull is banking on. They believe the customer base
- 8:39is locked in, almost trapped, and that gives Intuit pricing
- 8:42power indefinitely. So if you just listen to the
- 8:45bull wide Moat, massive discount AI margin kicker, it sounds
- 8:50really convincing. Why are we so worried?
- 8:51It sounds convincing until you turn the page to the bear case.
- 8:55This is where the SAFE analyst in the Deep Value Intelligence
- 8:58Report starts throwing punches. And these punches land hard.
- 9:01Really hard. Let's get into the bear case.
- 9:03Section three of our outline is called the mutation of the
- 9:06business. That is such a great phrase.
- 9:08It sounds ominous. It's meant to be.
- 9:11The core thesis of the bear argument is diversification.
- 9:14Peter Lynch's favorite term? Deversification when a great
- 9:17company expands into worse businesses.
- 9:19Exactly. The Bear argues that Intuit has
- 9:22mutated. It used to be a pure software
- 9:25monopoly, but now it is mutated into a cyclical financial
- 9:29conglomerate. Break that down for the
- 9:30listener. What is the fundamental
- 9:31difference there? Why does the market care if they
- 9:34are software or finance? It comes down to unit economics.
- 9:37Software is magical because it has 0 marginal cost, right?
- 9:41Once you pay your developers to write the code for TurboTax,
- 9:44selling the second copy costs you basically nothing.
- 9:47Selling the millionth copy costs you nothing.
- 9:49It scales infinitely. You are just selling organized
- 9:52electrons. Exactly.
- 9:53You are selling air, but air that provides massive value.
- 9:56That is why pure software companies get those juicy 50 PE
- 10:00ratios. OK.
- 10:01Pure profit, high margins. Got it.
- 10:03But look at what Intuit is doing now.
- 10:05They are getting heavily into lending and expert services.
- 10:08And services involve humans. Humans are very expensive.
- 10:11Humans do not scale like code. If you want to sell more expert
- 10:15reviews, you need more experts. You have to pay their salaries,
- 10:18health insurance 4 O1 KS. It puts a hard ceiling on your
- 10:21profit margin. It absolutely does.
- 10:22And then look at the lending side of the house, Credit Karma
- 10:25and Intuit Capital. Right, lending money is capital
- 10:27heavy. You have to actually have the
- 10:29cash to lend out. You are selling bricks now, not
- 10:32air, and more importantly, you take on the risk that you won't
- 10:36get paid back. So they basically traded a
- 10:38business model that was print code, get money for a business
- 10:41model that is hire people, lend money and just hope you get
- 10:45paid. Back precisely, and the numbers
- 10:47prove it. I want to highlight the most
- 10:48damning statistic in this entire report.
- 10:51It's in the fundamentals table. Return on equity.
- 10:53Yes, Roe, read those numbers out loud because they tell the whole
- 10:56story. OK.
- 10:57Looking at the table here in 2019 into its return on equity
- 11:01was 44% elite and now in 2026, the trailing 12 months, it is
- 11:06roughly 15%. That is a collapse. 15% A. 44%
- 11:11Roe is a world class compounding machine.
- 11:14That means for every dollar of shareholder equity, they were
- 11:16generating 44 cents of pure profit.
- 11:19That is rarefied air. And 15% is just?
- 11:21It's an average bank. It's a utility company.
- 11:24It is absolutely not a software monopoly.
- 11:26So when the bull says it's cheap at 26 times earnings, the bear
- 11:31says no, it's actually expensive because the company is less than
- 11:34half as efficient as it used to. Be exactly why on earth would
- 11:38you pay a premium multiple for a company that has actively
- 11:41degraded its own efficiency? Which begs the question, why do
- 11:45the efficiency drop so violently?
- 11:47Because they spent the money. They spent $19 billion buying
- 11:51Growth, MailChimp and Credit Karma.
- 11:53At the absolute peak of the tech bubble.
- 11:55Right. And when you overpay for
- 11:57acquisitions, you bloat your balance sheet with goodwill.
- 12:00They destroy destroyed their own capital efficiency just to get
- 12:03bigger on paper. We hear that term goodwill a lot
- 12:06in these financial reports. Can we unpack that?
- 12:08Because it sounds nice, but it's actually a drag.
- 12:11Right. In accounting, goodwill is
- 12:12literally the premium you pay over the actual fair value of
- 12:15the assets you bought. Give me an example.
- 12:17So you buy a lemonade stand. It has $10 worth of lemons and
- 12:20paper cups, but you pay $100 for it because you really like the
- 12:24brand name. You now have $90.00 of goodwill
- 12:27sitting on your balance sheet. It's essentially hope recorded
- 12:30as an asset. Hope recorded as an asset.
- 12:32Wow. And that 19 billion into it
- 12:34spent didn't just disappear, it sits there weighing down the
- 12:38denominator of that return on equity calculation.
- 12:41They took a Ferrari engine, their core tax software, and
- 12:44they bolted it inside a dump truck.
- 12:47The heavy capital intensive new businesses.
- 12:49The report actually compares Intuit to Kraft Heinz.
- 12:52Yes. That honestly sent a shiver down
- 12:54my spine. Kraft Heinz was an absolute
- 12:56disaster for value investors. It's a scary parallel, but it
- 12:59fits perfectly. Kraft Heinz was a company with
- 13:01incredible historic brands. Ketchup, Mac and cheese.
- 13:05Everyone assumed they were untouchable.
- 13:07Monopoly. So they cut costs, jacked up
- 13:09prices, and just assumed the customers would never leave.
- 13:11But they stopped innovating. They stopped focusing on the
- 13:13core product and eventually the Moat dried up, the bearer
- 13:17argues. Intuit is doing the exact same
- 13:19thing right now. They are buying growth instead
- 13:21of building it and assuming their users are just trapped.
- 13:23But are they trapped? We're going to get to the
- 13:26regulatory threat in a second, but I want to dive into this
- 13:28credit risk first. Section 4 of our outline is the
- 13:322026 debt wall. This is the macro context that
- 13:35we absolutely cannot ignore. We are sitting here in February
- 13:392026. What does the world look like?
- 13:42According to the news analysis in the source stack, interest
- 13:44rates are higher for longer. The Fed funds rate is sitting
- 13:47right around 3.75 to 4.00%. Right, the era of 0% free money
- 13:53is dead and we are hitting a debt wall.
- 13:56Meaning what exactly? A ton of companies, especially
- 13:58small businesses, borrowed heavily in 2020 and 2021 when
- 14:02money was basically free. Now those three to five year
- 14:05loans are coming due. They have to refinance.
- 14:07But they have to refinance it 4-5, maybe 8%, not 0.
- 14:10Exactly. And many of them simply cannot
- 14:12afford the new payments. So what happens?
- 14:15Traditional banks are tightening up.
- 14:16They're looking at the risk models, looking at the macro
- 14:18environment and saying no to small businesses.
- 14:20And this is exactly where the bull gets excited about Intuit
- 14:22Capital. Yep, the bull says.
- 14:23Look, the banks are pulling back.
- 14:26Intuit can step right in and lend money to all these small
- 14:29businesses because they have all the proprietary QuickBooks data.
- 14:32And the bears screaming stop. That is a massive trap.
- 14:36Why is it a trap? If they have the data, shouldn't
- 14:39they know who is safe to lend to?
- 14:41It's a concept called adverse selection.
- 14:43OK, think about it rationally. Banks are in the business of
- 14:47lending. That is their only job.
- 14:49They have risk models that have been battle tested for 100
- 14:52years, right? If a traditional bank looks at a
- 14:54small business and says it is too risky to lend to you right
- 14:58now, and then Intuit comes along and says here, take some money.
- 15:01Their Intuit is literally just lending to the people the banks
- 15:04rejected. Exactly.
- 15:05Imagine you are an insurance company and you set up a booth
- 15:09selling life insurance. But you only sell it to people
- 15:12who run eagerly toward your booth, completely out of breath,
- 15:15frantically waving cash at you. I'd be terrified.
- 15:18I'd assume they know something I don't like they have terminal
- 15:20illness. Exactly.
- 15:22If the smartest lenders in the room are rejecting these
- 15:24borrowers and Intuit says yes, Intuit is not getting the cream
- 15:28of the crop. They are getting the rejects.
- 15:30Desperate ones. They are acting as the lender of
- 15:32last resort. So Intuit is taking on subprime
- 15:35risk. Yes, they traded a perfectly
- 15:38safe toll bridge business where they just collect a fee for
- 15:41software for a highly risky subprime lender business.
- 15:44And remember, Intuit does not have the fortress balance sheet
- 15:47of a generic Mega Bank like JP Morgan.
- 15:50So if we hit a real recession or if that debt wall causes a wave
- 15:54of small business defaults. Intuit is going to take massive,
- 15:57massive losses on those loans. And you definitely do not pay 26
- 16:00times earnings for a subprime lender.
- 16:02Not a chance. Banks usually trade at what, 10
- 16:04times earnings? Eight times.
- 16:06Often less so. If the market fully digests that
- 16:08into it is actually just a cyclical bank now, the stock
- 16:10could get cut in half again. That is a terrifying thought.
- 16:13OK, so we have the disversification into lending,
- 16:16but let's look at the core business, the golden goose,
- 16:20TurboTax. The cash cow.
- 16:21The reason? Everyone knows the name.
- 16:23For decades, TurboTax has been an absolute machine.
- 16:26You have to file taxes. You don't want to hire an
- 16:28expensive CPA. You use TurboTax.
- 16:31They raise the price 20 bucks every year.
- 16:32You grumble about it, but you pay it anyway.
- 16:35But now there's a new competitor on the board, and it's the one
- 16:38competitor you cannot buy out and you cannot bankrupt.
- 16:41The US government. The IRS Direct File program.
- 16:44It was a pilot program for a few years, but here in 2026 it is
- 16:48expanding aggressively. It allows people to file their
- 16:51taxes directly with the IRS for free.
- 16:53No middle man, no TurboTax. The report calls this permit
- 16:57risk. We usually talk about businesses
- 16:59having a Moat, right? But into it's Moat was partly
- 17:01just the fact that the government permitted them to be
- 17:04the middle man. The government essentially
- 17:06outsourced tax collection software to private companies
- 17:09like Intuit and H&R Block. But now they are taking it back.
- 17:12Taking it in house. But can't Intuit just make a
- 17:15significantly better product? I mean, let's be honest,
- 17:18governor websites are historically awful.
- 17:20They can and they do. TurboTax is incredibly slick,
- 17:23the UX is great, but free is a very, very powerful price point.
- 17:28It's true if you have a simple tax return, just AW 2, maybe a
- 17:31little bit of bank interest, Why on earth would you pay into it
- 17:35$100 when the IRS will do it for 0?
- 17:38So Intuit just automatically loses the entire low end of the
- 17:41market. All the simple filers are gone.
- 17:43Correct. Which forces Intuit to move up
- 17:46market. They have to chase the
- 17:47complicated filers to survive. The gig workers, the
- 17:50freelancers, the small business owners, people who actually need
- 17:53help. But those people need more than
- 17:55just a slick software interface. They need actual advice.
- 17:58They need to talk to a human. And we are right back to the
- 18:01human problem to serve those complex customers into it has to
- 18:05push TurboTax live. They have to connect you with
- 18:07ACPA or an enrolled agent. Which costs money.
- 18:09It crushes their margins. Moving from software to services
- 18:12creates a hard ceiling on how profitable they can be.
- 18:15The bear analyst makes it very clear the Moat is leaking.
- 18:17The easy high margin revenue is being eaten by the IRS, and the
- 18:21revenue that's leftover is harder and much more expensive
- 18:23to earn. It really seems like every
- 18:25single path leads back to lower quality earnings, whether it's
- 18:29lending or services. Nothing is as good as the old
- 18:33pure software business. That is the ultimate tragedy of
- 18:36the mature monopoly. They completely conquered their
- 18:38world and then they had nowhere left to go but into worse
- 18:41businesses. OK, let's talk numbers, hard
- 18:44numbers. The report has a dedicated
- 18:46Buffett valuation section. What does the Deep Value
- 18:49Intelligence model actually say this stock is worth today?
- 18:52This is where we take all the narrative and emotion out of it.
- 18:55The model runs a rigorous discounted cash flow analysis.
- 18:59Basically predicting how much cash the company will generate
- 19:02over the next 10 years and discounting it back to present
- 19:04value exactly. In the result, the base case,
- 19:07which still assumes pretty decent growth, about 12% for the
- 19:10next decade, puts the intrinsic value at around $410 per share.
- 19:14OK. So if the stock is trading in
- 19:16the three 80s or three 90s right now, it's technically slightly
- 19:20undervalued. Silly.
- 19:22Basically treating right at fair value.
- 19:23Right, you are buying a dollar bill for about $0.95.
- 19:27That does not sound like a screaming bargain.
- 19:29It's not a bargain at all. Warren Buffett, and really any
- 19:32disciplined value investor, strictly demands a margin of
- 19:35safety. You do not buy a stock when it
- 19:38is hovering at fair value. You buy it when it is selling
- 19:41for $0.50 on the dollar. Because what if your assumptions
- 19:44are wrong? Exactly.
- 19:45What if the IRS takes way more market share than expected?
- 19:49What if the recession hits hard and those small business loans
- 19:52default? You need a buffer.
- 19:53You need a massive room for error.
- 19:55You do, and the report suggests that to have a proper margin of
- 19:59safety to truly protect yourself against all these mutating risks
- 20:03we just discussed, you shouldn't touch the stock until it hits
- 20:06308 dollars Three. 108, that's another, what, 20% drop from
- 20:10where we are today? Roughly, yeah.
- 20:12And I know that is hard for people to hear.
- 20:13The stock is already down 43%. Saying it needs to drop another
- 20:1720% sounds almost crazy to a casual observer.
- 20:20Right, they think it can't possibly go lower.
- 20:22But you have to remember, it started from a valuation that
- 20:25was frankly insane. It fell from the stratosphere to
- 20:27the roof. We need it to fall all the way
- 20:29to the basement before it's safe.
- 20:31Let's talk about the technicals for a second.
- 20:33The charts, because I know a lot of listeners are looking at
- 20:36their screens thinking it's down so much.
- 20:38It absolutely has to bounce. It is extremely oversold.
- 20:42The report specifically addresses this.
- 20:44Yes, the relative strength index, the RSI is very low.
- 20:46It is technically oversold, but the analyst uses a very specific
- 20:51classic phrase. Don't catch a falling knife.
- 20:53The ultimate Wall Street warning.
- 20:55The momentum is completely broken.
- 20:57The stock is trading way, way below its 200 day moving
- 21:01average, which is still way up at 660 dollars.
- 21:04See a massive gap? That moving average acts like
- 21:06gravity. When you are that far below it,
- 21:08it means the trend is overwhelmingly violently
- 21:11negative. And the report mentions there's
- 21:13absolutely no bottoming pattern yet.
- 21:15None. You want to see the stock stop
- 21:17falling? Go sideways for a few weeks or
- 21:19months. Maybe build a base that shows
- 21:21that institutional buyers are finally stepping in and
- 21:23defending a specific price level.
- 21:26But into it hasn't done that. No, it's just sliding lower
- 21:29every week. If you buy right now, you are
- 21:31purely guessing. You are gambling that today is
- 21:33the exact bottom and the market historically punishes guessers.
- 21:38OK, so we've surveyed the crime scene.
- 21:40We heard the bulls play for an AI salvation, and we heard the
- 21:43bears very stark warning about the rotten engine and the
- 21:46subprime debt trap. Let's synthesize this.
- 21:49Let's bring it all together for the final verdict.
- 21:51Let's recap the four main structural points that came out
- 21:54of this multi agent debate. OK, .1 Business quality has
- 21:57degraded. We went from a pure 0 marginal
- 22:00cost software monopoly to a cyclical finance conglomerate.
- 22:04That fundamental shift deserves A structurally lower PE ratio.
- 22:07.2 Capital allocation was incredibly poor.
- 22:10Management spent $19 billion at the very top of the tech market,
- 22:14and the return on equity collapsed from 44% to 15%.
- 22:18They haven't proven they could be trusted with shareholder
- 22:20capital. That Roe drop is the one stat
- 22:23that really sticks with me. It just perfectly illustrates
- 22:26the actual damage done to the engine of the business.
- 22:28It's the smoking gun .3 Macro risk is high right now.
- 22:32We have the 2026 debt wall hitting.
- 22:35Credit Karma and Intuit Capital are exposing the company to
- 22:38credit defaults precisely when small businesses are the most
- 22:41vulnerable. The adverse selection.
- 22:42Problem exactly. And finally .4 regulatory risk.
- 22:46The IRS Directfile program is a permanent structural headwind.
- 22:50It permanently caps their pricing power and forces them
- 22:53into those lower margin human heavy services.
- 22:55When you stack those four massive issues up, it is really
- 22:58hard to get excited about paying 26 times earnings.
- 23:01It is 26 times the premium you pay for a high growth, low risk
- 23:04compounder into. It is now a medium growth, high
- 23:07risk hybrid. So what is the official final
- 23:10stance from the Deep Value Intelligence team?
- 23:12The final verdict from the synthesis is a void weight.
- 23:15It's a pass. It's a hard pass, even though it
- 23:18is down 43%. The fundamental risk profile of
- 23:21the business has changed too much, the report says it
- 23:24explicitly. We want to own toll bridges, not
- 23:27subprime lenders. We want to own toll bridges, not
- 23:30subprime lenders. That is a powerful, powerful
- 23:33line. It summarizes the entire deep
- 23:35dive and until management can fix their return on invested
- 23:38capital, until they actually prove they can make money
- 23:40efficiently again without just buying it, we stay safely on the
- 23:43sidelines. We aren't buying the dip just
- 23:44because of the chart looks scary.
- 23:46So if you are currently holding the bag, say you bought a 600.
- 23:49Ouch. Well, the report says if you are
- 23:52a current holder, it's a wait. You don't necessarily panic sell
- 23:56here because it is currently hovering near its mathematical
- 23:58fair value, but you definitely, definitely do not add new money
- 24:03to the position. You hold and hope that the AI
- 24:05thesis plays out. Or you wait for a technical
- 24:07bounce to exit, but you do not treat this as a buying
- 24:10opportunity for fresh capital. Fascinating.
- 24:13It really is a master class and how a giant can stumble just by
- 24:16trying to get too big too fast. It's the ultimate lesson of
- 24:19diversification. Just because you have the cash
- 24:21to buy a company doesn't mean you should.
- 24:24Intuit had a literally perfect business model.
- 24:27And they got bored. Bored or greedy or scared of the
- 24:29future? So they bought imperfect
- 24:31businesses and now, years later, the shareholders are paying the
- 24:35price. And it's also a massive lesson
- 24:37in price anchoring. Just because a stock was at
- 24:40$700.00 does not mean it is fundamentally worth $700.
- 24:43Exactly like Ben Graham said, the market is a voting machine
- 24:46in the short run, but a weighing machine in the long run.
- 24:49And right now the scale is saying into it is heavy.
- 24:52Heavy with debt, heavy with goodwill and heavy with risk.
- 24:55Spot on. Well, that is a wrap on this
- 24:58deep dive into into it. A very sobering look, but
- 25:02definitely a necessary one. Absolutely, Always better to be
- 25:04safe than sorry when capitals on the line.
- 25:06Remember, if you want to access more advanced researches,
- 25:09applications and our latest published personal intelligent
- 25:11multi agent deep value intelligence, welcome to
- 25:14subscribe on deep Values dot AI. It's an incredible resource for
- 25:18seeing these debates played out in real time.
- 25:20And if you want to track total market temperature, welcome to
- 25:23search and download iOS app Buffett Indicator from Apple App
- 25:26Store. It's a great tool to keep your
- 25:29macro perspective grounded. Don't forget to like this deep
- 25:31dive. Much appreciated.
- 25:33Really helps us keep bringing you this level of analysis.
- 25:35Keep your eyes open out there. The market is always mutating.
- 25:38Thanks for listening, everyone. I want to leave you with one
- 25:40final thought to Mull over. If the IRS Direct file keeps
- 25:44expanding and AI agents get so smart that they can literally
- 25:48read the tax code and file for you automatically, will the very
- 25:51concept of consumer tax preparation software just cease
- 25:54to exist entirely in five years? Something to think about.
- 25:59Stay curious. And stay disciplined.
- 26:01We'll. See you in the next deep dive.
- 26:02Goodbye.