Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Speculative Attack: Pierre Rochard on Bitcoin's Endgame
Transcript
- 0:02It all comes down to computers communicating.
- 0:06The information superhighway can be a confusing mix of on ramps
- 0:09and off ramps. Bitcoin is worthless artificial
- 0:14gold. Is it still rat?
- 0:16Poison. Probably rat poison squared.
- 0:19We need to get into the world of OK, this is actually
- 0:22foundational. Technology.
- 0:24What the Internet of Money does is it creates a single.
- 0:27Network which can do a microtransaction to a giga
- 0:33transaction. The Internet is going to be.
- 0:38One of the major forces for reducing the role of gun.
- 0:42The one thing that's missing that that will soon be developed
- 0:46is a reliable E cash. All right, welcome back to
- 0:54another episode of Final Settlement.
- 0:56Super special episode today very excited for this one been
- 1:00looking forward to it all week and we have Pierre Rochard in
- 1:04the show and so I'm sure many of many of our audience members
- 1:08will will know who Pierre is and and know of his work.
- 1:10But in case you're unfamiliar here, Pierre has been at the
- 1:14forefront of of Bitcoin advocacy and and really education for
- 1:17over a decade as a, you know a very early adopter of Bitcoin, a
- 1:21prolific writer, a Co founder of the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute.
- 1:26He's really played a a critical role in sort of shaping the
- 1:30intellectual foundation of of Bitcoin in general over the
- 1:33past, you know, over a decade. And so, you know, he's also
- 1:36helped sort of Dr. institutional adoption and education through,
- 1:40you know, his work in the corporate world, most recently
- 1:43at Riot platforms. And so we're really excited to
- 1:46dig into, you know, his journey, his views on bitcoins future and
- 1:50in particular the the Bitcoin bond company, which was
- 1:53announced recently that Pierre will be, will be launching soon.
- 1:57And so very excited to to dig into all of that and maybe a few
- 2:00other topics because there's no shortage of, of things happening
- 2:04in the Bitcoin space right now. It feels, it feels a little
- 2:08overwhelming at times the the amount of the deluge of news on
- 2:11a on a daily basis. But Pierre, welcome to the show.
- 2:14Thanks for thanks for joining us.
- 2:16Thanks, Ryan. Thanks Liam for having me on.
- 2:19Yeah, Well, let's, let's get into it.
- 2:22I think, you know, a logical place to start is, you know,
- 2:28sort of what preceded your vision for the Bitcoin bond
- 2:32company, which I think is, is something that's been rattling
- 2:34around in your brain for for over a decade.
- 2:36And so you wrote a piece back in 2014 called Speculative Attack.
- 2:44And so maybe, you know, just for the audience, if, if you could
- 2:46give a brief overview of, of what your thesis around sort of
- 2:49speculative attacking the dollar with Bitcoin was at that time.
- 2:53And then sort of maybe talk about how that's evolved over
- 2:57time over the past decade from when you first had the these
- 3:00ideas and into, you know, where we sit today, Everything that's
- 3:04going on from corporate adoption to sovereign level of adoption.
- 3:08And you know, one, I guess has, has, have things gone according
- 3:13to how you thought they would? And then beyond that, you know,
- 3:16how did that influence how you're thinking about things
- 3:19going forward? Yeah, absolutely.
- 3:21So I think that the place to start would be back in 2005, I
- 3:26was a high schooler and I stumbled into Austrian economics
- 3:31and sound money. And what I really liked about
- 3:33that was that they had an explanation for the business
- 3:36cycle that actually made sense to me versus some of the
- 3:40alternative explanations that I heard in school.
- 3:44And that that drove me to really being a silver and gold type,
- 3:49you know, focused, you know, intellectually, right?
- 3:57But at the same time, I was really interested in free and
- 4:00open source software. So I was installing Linux on
- 4:02computers and listening to Richard Stallman lectures on the
- 4:07philosophy of users controlling their own code, and I didn't
- 4:12think that those two paths would really cross until my last year
- 4:16of grad school. I was getting my master's in
- 4:19financial accounting here at UT Austin and got introduced to
- 4:24Bitcoin as sound money, that there would only ever be 21
- 4:28million and that it was open source and so this monetary
- 4:32policy had credibility to it. So really went down the rabbit
- 4:37hole at that point and started writing about Bitcoin from my
- 4:41perspective, which was very focused on monetary economics
- 4:46and wrote a series of articles leading up to speculative
- 4:52attack, where on speculative attack, I really wanted to dig
- 4:55into what's the end game for Bitcoin and how does it
- 5:00ultimately prevail in currency competition.
- 5:04And so in the world of monetary economics, there's a concept of
- 5:09a speculative attack. The, the term was coined by Paul
- 5:13Krugman of all people. And he, he, he was looking at it
- 5:18from an academic perspective of what had occurred in the Asian
- 5:22currency crises that were in the 90s.
- 5:25And the the broad strokes of it is that you have investors who
- 5:32are borrowing in a weak currency in order to sell that weak
- 5:38currency and buy a strong currency, have the strong
- 5:42currency appreciate in value, and then sell the strong
- 5:47currency to pay off the loan that was denominated in the weak
- 5:52currency. And that this has the effect of
- 5:58first of all, creating more weak currency because when you're
- 6:01doing a loan through the commercial banking system in a
- 6:04fractional reserve Fiat system, they do create more currency.
- 6:09And that the, the, it's, it's a cycle where the weak currency
- 6:17can either be defended by raising interest rates.
- 6:21So that just makes it more expensive to, to borrow it.
- 6:24And so then the the carry trade falls apart or through capital
- 6:30controls where the Monetary Authority will find ways to
- 6:34clamp down on the the speculators and to prevent them
- 6:37from borrowing the weak currency or by defending it using
- 6:43currency reserves. And so having having the strong
- 6:47currency in reserve that they can use to stabilize the
- 6:50exchange rate and to make the trade unprofitable for the
- 6:55speculators. So with that framework in mind,
- 6:59I, I looked at it through that lens of, well, what would it
- 7:04look like if people were borrowing in, in this context,
- 7:08the strong currencies, Bitcoin. So they're borrowing the weak
- 7:11currency, which might be dollars, it might be Swiss
- 7:14francs, you know, which is generally thought of as a strong
- 7:17currency, but not as strong as Bitcoin or Indian rupees or, you
- 7:23know, Turkish lira could really be any currency that they're
- 7:26funding the trade with. And that that would be the end
- 7:30game for Bitcoin in the sense that it would it would wreak
- 7:34havoc on the currency markets and cause all of these weaker
- 7:37currencies to hyperinflate and to disappear if if they were not
- 7:43defended. Now, what we've seen over the
- 7:48past 12 years since I wrote that is that indeed there has been
- 7:53that dynamic. And the ultimately the limiting
- 7:58factor for it has been the the one limiting factor that I did
- 8:02not write about that I didn't even think about was the fact
- 8:05that so many people would make so much money off of the strong
- 8:09currency, off of Bitcoin, appreciating that they actually
- 8:13want to rebalance their portfolios even if they're not
- 8:16involved in the speculative attack at all, right?
- 8:18So they want to rotate into, unfortunately, sometimes
- 8:24altcoins, right? And they want to ride some kind
- 8:26of altcoin wave, or they're just buying stocks and bonds or
- 8:30paying off their mortgage or putting their kids through
- 8:32college or just taking chips off the table after, you know, a 10X
- 8:37or 100X. And so we've seen lots of
- 8:39people, they end up regretting making that decision because
- 8:43then, you know, Bitcoin recovers eventually.
- 8:46But that's, you know, what drives a lot of the selling at
- 8:49the top of the cycle. But we also have seen with after
- 8:54the covet inflation, U.S. dollar monetary policy tightened and so
- 8:59we saw a rate hiking from 0% to 5% and we also saw capital
- 9:06controls. So this was what we described as
- 9:09Operation Choke .2 point O where the banking system and the the
- 9:15wider financial system, because we could include the SEC not
- 9:18approving the Bitcoin ETF in this kind of capital control
- 9:24where they're trying to gate investor access to the strong
- 9:27currency in order to defend the weak currency.
- 9:31Although maybe they consciously didn't think of it that way.
- 9:33That would the the effect of that.
- 9:37And also, you know, that they were able to seize Bitcoin
- 9:42through, you know, the criminal justice system and develop a
- 9:47currency reserve of the strong currency.
- 9:50And we also saw them, you know, selling off Bitcoin, which had
- 9:54the effect of suppressing the Bitcoin price.
- 9:58So that that was now all of this is, you know, in flux now with
- 10:04this new administration. So we're we're looking at
- 10:09lowering interest rates, removing capital controls and
- 10:13building up a reserve instead of selling one off.
- 10:16So I think that, you know, bitcoins going from headwinds in
- 10:20that regards to tailwinds. And so I think that in, in many
- 10:24ways the speculative attack is going to continue unabated.
- 10:32But I think that my, my thesis was really that it would cause
- 10:37the dollar to collapse. But I, I now I wonder if that's
- 10:42actually not the case in the sense that if we're building up
- 10:46a reserve of Bitcoin, that the dollar ultimately could just be
- 10:50backstopped by Bitcoin and that it becomes a, a proxy for
- 10:55Bitcoin. Maybe one day we'll have like
- 10:58$1.00 = 1 satoshi equilibrium. And it's all, you know, 100%
- 11:04reserve and the dollar is just an overlay on top of the larger
- 11:09Bitcoin monetary system. You know, in terms of like what
- 11:13I got wrong with the speculative attack, I think was really
- 11:17something that should have been obvious at the time, but I, I
- 11:20didn't really think through this part of what are the speculators
- 11:24borrowing against. So I had it in mind that they
- 11:27were borrowing against traditional financial assets,
- 11:30whether it's treasuries or mortgages, real estate and the
- 11:36like. But I, it didn't cross my mind
- 11:40that they would actually be using Bitcoin itself as a
- 11:42collateral, which, you know, what better collateral could you
- 11:46ask for than than the hard currency itself?
- 11:48And so that was probably the, the biggest missing piece of in,
- 11:56in speculative attack. And also, what are they
- 11:59financing? What are the financing
- 12:01mechanisms specifically? I limited my my observations and
- 12:07my thinking to the commercial banking system.
- 12:09And so there, you know, they would only really accept
- 12:12traditional forms of collateral in the commercial banking
- 12:15system. Sailor opened my eyes to the
- 12:18fact that you could actually use the equity markets to to be the
- 12:23financing mechanism, you know, outside of the commercial
- 12:27banking system. So that's, you know, in at the
- 12:34same time that I was writing a speculative attack, I was
- 12:38working in the traditional financial system.
- 12:40So I was working at Deloitte, sorry, auditing mortgage-backed
- 12:46securities and other kinds of new issuances of securitization
- 12:51transactions. And even back then I thought
- 12:55even though I didn't write about it in speculative attack, I did
- 12:59have an Excel spreadsheet open of what would it look like to
- 13:02securitize Bitcoin and to put Bitcoin as collateral and to
- 13:06issue bonds against it. It was way too early one on the
- 13:12regulatory part where the SEC was not even approving the
- 13:16Winklevi Twins ETF back then. But also just in terms of the
- 13:21maturity of the market that, you know, the there was not a broad
- 13:25acceptance of Bitcoin as a store of value, as a digital gold that
- 13:30that really emerged over the subsequent 12 years.
- 13:33So now now is the right time though.
- 13:36So that's why I decided to found the Bitcoin Bond Company and to
- 13:40to pursue this dream I've had of issuing bonds to finance
- 13:45Bitcoin. Yeah, that's.
- 13:47Very well said and many of the people that have been selling
- 13:53their bitcoins after their 110X gains definitely have not read
- 13:58the Satoshi Nakamoto Institute about hoarding bitcoins too.
- 14:02Which was definitely prior to the speculative attack and, and
- 14:07that whole line of research too. But yeah, on that point, I guess
- 14:13like over time you've, you talked through a bunch of
- 14:17different ways to borrow against Bitcoin.
- 14:20I guess can you speak to what you perceive as a trade-offs
- 14:23between personal and and localized spec speculative
- 14:26attacks versus the the corporate and and pulled speculative
- 14:29attacks both in terms of access to liquidity and you know what
- 14:34the the end benefit can be to the?
- 14:37User and also just to add to that, sort of like the, you
- 14:39know, how these ideas and concepts have evolved because
- 14:44like I remember, you know, I first started learning about
- 14:47Bitcoin in sort of 20/17/18. I didn't have a lot of money.
- 14:51I, I didn't have a, a massive salary, but I was personally
- 14:54speculated speculative attacking the dollar by just taking on
- 14:57credit card debt and buying Bitcoin with my entire salary
- 15:02effectively. And so we've gone from that like
- 15:04individuals taking it upon themselves to do this to now
- 15:08corporates and nation states thinking about these strategies.
- 15:12Yeah. So I think that individual like
- 15:17retail buying of Bitcoin and leveraging up you know in
- 15:21various ways at at the individual level is going to
- 15:24continue. I would caution folks that that
- 15:27does come with risks, right? That you're, you're on, on
- 15:32credit cards, you're, you're paying a higher rate of interest
- 15:35then, then, then you can access at the institutional level of,
- 15:41you know, there's essentially an economies of scale part where
- 15:47they have a lower cost of financing, but also there's a, a
- 15:50structural part that they, you know, there's the difference
- 15:54between personal credit risk and corporate risk.
- 15:57And so when on the lender side, when they're underwriting these
- 16:02bonds that are loans that it just comes with different risks,
- 16:07right? So, and also at the individual
- 16:11level, we've seen products like margin trading at exchanges
- 16:16where there you have a risk of getting liquidated if Bitcoin
- 16:20flash crashes. And so I think that at the
- 16:24individual level, it can really be challenging because of, of
- 16:29the different economics. Then, for example, Sailor can
- 16:33have with a convertible bond where it's just a completely
- 16:37different ball game. And so in, in some ways, I think
- 16:42it'll continue at the individual level.
- 16:44I, I would encourage people to, to do it in a responsible way
- 16:47where they're just focused on spending less than they earn so
- 16:51that they can plow their free cash flow into Bitcoin.
- 16:54And, and that that's, you know, you got to stay humble and stack
- 16:57stats. And then at the corporate and
- 17:00institutional level, I think that's where because you know,
- 17:04it's a limited liability company and that they, they, they have,
- 17:09I would argue perhaps more expertise in leveraging up and
- 17:13access to different products that might be a little bit safer
- 17:17to leverage up that they're going to be at the forefront,
- 17:21the tip of the sphere of the speculative attack.
- 17:24And that you know it, the financial engineering does does
- 17:28take a lot of nuance at that scale. 100% and there's also
- 17:33legal and controls that are in place that can help get lenders
- 17:38more comfortable with lending to large corporates rather than
- 17:42individuals like myself. If I just went to a bank and
- 17:46tried to ask for a big loan to buy a ton of Bitcoin.
- 17:49But you know, Liam, that that that might be changing now that
- 17:52the the Fed recently, just today or yesterday announced that
- 17:56they're going to allow commercial banks to work with
- 17:59Bitcoin. So it might not be long before
- 18:02we can just deposit Bitcoin at JP Morgan and take out a
- 18:06mortgage against it. Essentially that because you
- 18:10know, from the risk perspective, I think that the biggest risk is
- 18:13essentially term risk, right, that bitcoins very cyclical.
- 18:18So if you're taking out a loan that's a one year term, then you
- 18:22could be underwater after one year and you can't refinance it
- 18:25and then you're in trouble. If you get out to 510 years now
- 18:31you're you're really going through the cycle.
- 18:34And that if as long as there's no liquidation clause in that,
- 18:38that now it's I think a much more constructive relationship
- 18:41between the lender and the borrower and maybe less
- 18:44extractive. 100% yeah. There's something to be said
- 18:48about just keeping dollars in your checking account and
- 18:52Bitcoin in your savings account with banks moving forward as
- 18:55well. Yeah.
- 18:58Yeah. One other question is like in
- 19:01the past you discussed roughly like micro strategy imitators
- 19:05being not too far behind similar and metaplanet were early on and
- 19:10and 21 capital this week. On a long enough time horizon,
- 19:15you said we we should expect the share of the equity market
- 19:19participants adopting a similar strategy to to trend to 100%.
- 19:22I guess like why do you think this is the case?
- 19:26And how do you see different Bitcoin corporate security
- 19:30vehicles kind of changing over over time?
- 19:33And I guess like on top of that too.
- 19:37Anything you could share about the M NAV and how long this
- 19:41arbitrage can take place would be helpful.
- 19:44Yeah, so when, when when Sailor first announced his first $500
- 19:49million buy, I was working at Kraken and I remember we we had
- 19:54a webinar and one of the questions was like, what's your,
- 19:57what's your craziest prediction for, for the year, which mine
- 20:01was that, you know, half the SP 500 would imitate Sailor and
- 20:06and, you know, go all in on Bitcoin.
- 20:09That did not pan out and so. Add that to the long list of
- 20:14overly bullish predictions that Pierre Richard has made.
- 20:17But the the principle I think still stands that on a long
- 20:21enough time frame that will be true.
- 20:24And it's true because these companies are either going to be
- 20:29decapitalizing themselves and not have not have access to
- 20:36capital anymore because all the capital is going towards Bitcoin
- 20:39companies. And so I think that they would
- 20:43end up either getting acquired by a Bitcoin back company or,
- 20:47you know, you've got an activist shareholder telling them to put
- 20:50Bitcoin on the balance sheet. And that the the second part of
- 20:57the question I forget now. I guess how long do you think
- 21:00that the arbitrage can take place and do you think this is
- 21:05something that can do you see like I'm NAV kind of trending
- 21:08towards one or yeah, what's your view there?
- 21:12So this is something, you know, I I learned about securitization
- 21:18before I learned about Bitcoin. And one of the most
- 21:20counterintuitive things about that that world is that when
- 21:25you, let's say you're just repackaging a set of mortgages,
- 21:32you would think that the total value of the securities on the
- 21:38liabilities and equity side of the balance sheet would equal
- 21:40the total value of the assets on the collateral side of the
- 21:44balance sheet. And to my surprise, that was not
- 21:49the case. You do end up with a premium to
- 21:53the NAV. And the reason for that premium
- 21:56is because contrary to what a lot of Bitcoiners think, but
- 22:02also just I think the average layperson assumes financial
- 22:07engineering does create value. And so by tranching up the risk
- 22:11return of the asset, you're able to grow the pie of people who
- 22:16want exposure to the asset. And so that's really where the M
- 22:22NAV multiple comes from. And then we're also there's a
- 22:26speculative element when you're talking about it in the terms
- 22:29of, you know, a liquid equities where you're, you have to think
- 22:34about how will Sailor or anybody else be able to manage the
- 22:39capital structure in the future to further drive value to the
- 22:44equity tranche by taking on debt and by leveraging up.
- 22:49And so to me, the M NAV is, is the combination of today's
- 22:55leverage with tomorrow's possible leverage because we're,
- 22:59we're, we're discounting future cash flows.
- 23:01And so that's where I think it comes from.
- 23:04When does it go away? Well, I, I would argue when
- 23:09we've succeeded. So when you know, the, the
- 23:13dollar is at SAT's parity and that we've reached an
- 23:18equilibrium between the Bitcoin and the dollar.
- 23:22If, if, if U.S. dollar policy makers are prudent and have a
- 23:30path to that equilibrium. If they are not, then I fear
- 23:34that the dollar will trend towards 0 and the M NAV in in
- 23:39you know dollar terms will will continue to to exist.
- 23:43So. Maybe sort of an extension of of
- 23:46what we're talking about. What I'm curious to get your
- 23:49thoughts on is, you know, from the perspective of any sort of
- 23:53company or entity, it's completely rational to adopt A
- 23:56strategy, right for the good money and, you know, effectively
- 24:00short the bad money. And what we've seen over the
- 24:04past 12 to 24 months is, is, you know, increased sort of
- 24:08perpetual new adoption of this strategy.
- 24:11And I guess in my mind, I, I struggled to, to think about,
- 24:15you know, is there a point of saturation effectively where we
- 24:20don't need all of these different tickers that are
- 24:23Bitcoin treasury strategies? Obviously, again, from the
- 24:26company perspective, totally rational thing for them to do,
- 24:28but from like the perspective, shareholders perspective in your
- 24:33mind is like, does most of this flow towards the largest player,
- 24:38IE strategy? And then like beyond that,
- 24:40there's obviously advantages to specific jurisdictions, right?
- 24:44So like if you think about a metaplanet, they're the only one
- 24:47there. So that's why I think they have
- 24:49an advantage in that respect. But maybe if we're just thinking
- 24:52about the United States, like if we wake up in five years and
- 24:55there's a hundred different companies doing this strategy,
- 25:00does that impact, you know, what M NAV looks like for the long
- 25:03tail of these these companies? Because most people will just go
- 25:08to the largest one that has the most flexibility and optionality
- 25:12to tap capital markets to do these things.
- 25:15Yeah. So I, I think I, I agree that
- 25:17if, if other entrepreneurial publicly traded companies don't
- 25:23find ways to differentiate themselves from strategies
- 25:27approach and the capital structure that sailors
- 25:32developing with, you know, strike strife and the converts
- 25:39and you know, we'll, we'll see what, what else comes out of
- 25:42their, their, their quarterly call that that's coming up.
- 25:47I think that if they don't find ways to differentiate
- 25:49themselves, then it is challenging because of the
- 25:53liquidity network effects right where now we have even a layer
- 25:59on top of MicroStrategy of the yield farming, if we want to
- 26:04call it that, the volatility harvesting with MSTY and IMST
- 26:11where you know, you do need to have a liquid options chain to,
- 26:15to be engaging in those activities.
- 26:17And so it becomes a flywheel effect that becomes really hard
- 26:22to, to challenge on top of the fact that how do you acquire
- 26:26500,000 Bitcoin? You know, he's, he's, he's very
- 26:31far ahead of like #2 or #3 or #4.
- 26:37So I, that said, there are lots of other very smart people in
- 26:43the world who could find a differentiating angle and maybe
- 26:49could have ways of approaching this that, you know, for
- 26:53example, for myself, when I, when I think about it from, from
- 26:57my securitization background in the debt side, that's where, you
- 27:01know, the way I think of differentiating with the Bitcoin
- 27:03bond company is by just doing all debt and no equity and
- 27:08essentially redistributing the equity to the bondholders, which
- 27:11is something that a publicly traded company just can't do
- 27:14just because of the path dependency that they're on that,
- 27:17you know, they're, they're on the, they need to accrue value
- 27:20to the shareholders of the common stock.
- 27:23And so, and that's the fiduciary mandate.
- 27:25And so, you know, in terms of accessing different pools of
- 27:30capital, I think that there are differentiated strategies that
- 27:34are possible. Some of them we could think of
- 27:37today, others will be caught by surprise, you know, tomorrow the
- 27:41like, wow, why didn't anyone think of that sooner?
- 27:44And I think that, you know, that was, that was the experience
- 27:46with micro strategy of, Hey, why didn't anyone think of doing
- 27:50this sooner? Because there were publicly
- 27:52traded vehicles before strategy, you know, tackled this.
- 27:58So there's also, you know, maybe and I, I personally, I, I like
- 28:07the approach of just keep the Bitcoin in cold storage, you
- 28:11know, don't try to get fancy on on the collateral side.
- 28:15Maybe some will take more risk and try to generate yield off
- 28:18their Bitcoin or offer, you know, kind of different
- 28:22approaches on the collateral side.
- 28:25Even, you know, we've heard of people trying to do this with
- 28:27Solana. Obviously as a Bitcoin
- 28:30maximalist, I think that, you know, they're building on sand
- 28:33and that that's really going to underperform strategy.
- 28:37But from a narrative and marketing perspective, maybe
- 28:41they attract a different set of investors.
- 28:44You know that I I hope that answers the question.
- 28:47Yeah. No, that's, that's all super
- 28:48helpful context and and thinking around it, maybe maybe we can
- 28:53sort of pivot and and jump into more about the Bitcoin bond
- 28:56company. So maybe just sort of high
- 28:59level, how you're thinking about it, what types of credit
- 29:03instruments you're planning to offer and how you're thinking
- 29:05about distributing them, various sort of cohorts and investors
- 29:09that you think are going to be interested in this and we can
- 29:12just sort of start high level and then we'll dig into some
- 29:14details. Yeah, absolutely.
- 29:16So I think that what I'm interested in is shifting the
- 29:21Overton window and that's, I always try to find kind of
- 29:26what's, what's the hardest thing to to work on right in, in
- 29:29Bitcoin. And I enjoyed doing that a lot
- 29:34with Bitcoin mining and the environmental impact, you know,
- 29:37with Elizabeth Warren and, and her her goons, as I think
- 29:43President Trump put it. So on on the capital market
- 29:48side, I think that the, the hardest shift is, is in the bond
- 29:52market because that is where the most conservative investors are.
- 29:56And so sailors taking a crack at it with the converts.
- 30:00And I think that that that makes a lot of sense.
- 30:03It's still, you know, when we think about the convertible bond
- 30:05market, that's a a subset of the overall bond market that the
- 30:12natural buyers of that might be arbitrage traders who at the end
- 30:17of the day are, you know, very active in the equity markets.
- 30:21And so it's it's as adjacent to the equity as as one can get in
- 30:26from a bond perspective. And so I'm really interested in
- 30:30going deeper in the capital stack of finding ways to open up
- 30:36the Bitcoin conversation with institutional investors who
- 30:40might balk at the volatility of spot Bitcoin and also not have a
- 30:46mandate to invest in a commodity, right?
- 30:48From a regulatory perspective, that's what it's categorized as,
- 30:53for better or for worse. Even if it were categorized as a
- 30:57currency, they still wouldn't have a mandate to hold a
- 31:00currency. And they're focused on credit
- 31:03instruments. So first of all, providing A
- 31:06wrapper around Bitcoin that is credit focused and doing it in a
- 31:12way that is also institutional grade, meaning that it's inside
- 31:17of a bankruptcy remote SPV, there's no counterparty risk,
- 31:22corporate risk, you know, the way the traditional financial
- 31:26institutions think of that as bitcoiners, we think of
- 31:29counterparty risk very differently, right?
- 31:31We think about you got, you know, not your keys, not your
- 31:34Bitcoin. That's that's not how a
- 31:36traditional financial institution thinks of
- 31:38counterparty risk. And so beyond just having the
- 31:44the wrapper of bankruptcy, remote SPV, also having the risk
- 31:49transfer in the capital structure, So being able to
- 31:53tranche up the risk so that there's a senior tranche that
- 31:56appeals to somebody who wants an instrument that's over
- 32:00collateralized, they're willing to give up upside in order to
- 32:05achieve that that risk mitigation.
- 32:08And then on the other end of the spectrum, the the junior tranche
- 32:11that essentially wants to go leverage long Bitcoin while
- 32:15still having yield visibility so that they they they have a, a
- 32:19percentage number to it, but that in terms of participation
- 32:23in the profit share, if Bitcoin really, you know, hits a home
- 32:27run, that they are strongly participating in the upside.
- 32:32And so then in the middle of the mezzanine, which is really, you
- 32:36know, okay, for the credit fund that they're constructive on
- 32:39Bitcoin, they might not necessarily buy the moon math of
- 32:42Bitcoin going to $1,000,000, but they, they think that Bitcoin is
- 32:46going to continue to perform pretty well that way.
- 32:50We're, we're opening up Bitcoin's risk return profile to
- 32:53a wider set of investors that that has, you know, not had
- 32:58access because frankly of the regulatory roadblock of the SEC
- 33:03just not wanting to approve this for even a spot ETF, which
- 33:09should be uncontroversial. But now I think the new SEC is
- 33:13merit neutral. They're not going to prejudge
- 33:16any of the securities as long as everything's disclosed on the up
- 33:20and up that they're going to approve more innovation.
- 33:28That's really helpful to understand and think that's a
- 33:32smart way to go about it. So multiple different cohorts
- 33:35can get different types of exposure.
- 33:36I guess if you're comfortable sharing, would love to hear a
- 33:39little bit about how you think collateralization as well as
- 33:43kind of terms and the timing of these loans and vehicle.
- 33:50That all goes into areas where there's a fine line from a
- 33:55regulatory perspective of what I can talk about and what I can't.
- 34:00I think that in terms of over collateralization, it really is
- 34:04about making sure that it, when we look at Bitcoin's price
- 34:08history, the worst performing and, and I I like the number of
- 34:13five years just because that gets you through the traditional
- 34:16Bitcoin cycle. The worst performing five years
- 34:19was December of 2017 to December 2022 where you round trip to
- 34:25let's say 20 grand because that was the top of the cycle to the
- 34:31bottom of the next cycle, you know with Sam Bankman freed and
- 34:34all of his shenanigans. And so if you look at that worst
- 34:39period, you could say, well, as long as you're decently over
- 34:44collateralized on the senior, the principal and interest in
- 34:47that scenario would have been paid on the senior and that the
- 34:51junior tranche would have gotten wiped out because they would
- 34:54have contributed to up the stack interest on the senior in the
- 34:58Mes. And the Mes would likely have
- 35:00taken a haircut on the interest, but they would have gotten their
- 35:03principal back. And so that I think, you know,
- 35:06when we're thinking about putting ourselves in the shoes
- 35:09of, of a, a, a bondholder that is looking for something that
- 35:16is, is, is mimicking or close to investment grade, they, that's
- 35:21what they want to see. Is that it now in, in between,
- 35:26right? That's where, when we look at
- 35:28during the life of the vehicle, that's where you want to make
- 35:31sure that there's no liquidation.
- 35:33Because ultimately, if you underwrite something at the top
- 35:37of the cycle and it grinds down for two years before recovering
- 35:42for three years, if you sell at the bottom, you realize losses.
- 35:47But if you don't sell and you have a recovery rate and you
- 35:50have a constructive view on that recovery rate, then you can hold
- 35:54through the cycle and ultimately create value for the whole
- 35:58capital stack. And so I think that's where it's
- 36:00important to have a vehicle that is not liquidating at the at the
- 36:05bottom of the bear market. But you know, it has a longer
- 36:08term view that bitcoins going to continue to be around every 10
- 36:12minutes, a new block gets added to the chain.
- 36:15And so there's not really a real physical impairment of the
- 36:19network itself. It's just that there's there's a
- 36:22cyclical adoption phase for Bitcoin.
- 36:26Got you. Yeah, that, that makes a ton of
- 36:28sense. I think maybe one, one question
- 36:32just turn in terms of how you think about demand for these
- 36:37products in these structures and the pools of capital that you
- 36:40expect to to come into this. Because in on one hand, you
- 36:44know, I think part of part of my mind goes to well, you know,
- 36:48someone who's looking for sort of downside mitigated a little
- 36:54lower upside exposure to Bitcoin doesn't really fully understand
- 36:57Bitcoin. Otherwise maybe they would just
- 36:59outright buy Bitcoin. But obviously there's cohorts
- 37:02and swaths of the investment world that have a specific
- 37:04mandate and they need to be investing in credit or bond
- 37:07instruments. So could you speak to that a
- 37:10little bit and how you sort of would handicap the sort of
- 37:14landscape of demand for products like this?
- 37:18And you know, would you agree with like that notion that, you
- 37:21know, at least some portion of that if they if they don't have
- 37:24a specific mandate, we'll just wake up one day and be like,
- 37:27well, why would I want capped upside?
- 37:29I'll just own the thing out, right?
- 37:32Yeah. And and so they now have access
- 37:34to BlackRock ETF and that's a great product for them.
- 37:38I think that in the institutional context, a lot of
- 37:41investment decisions are not made by one individual.
- 37:45They're made by a committee. And to get consensus on the
- 37:49committee, you sometimes have to negotiate.
- 37:53And so that's where, you know, you might want to have a product
- 37:57that does cap the upside in order to have have the over
- 38:04collateralization and to protect the downside in order to get it
- 38:09through a committee where you might have a lot of different
- 38:11views on Bitcoin. And so I think that that's where
- 38:16you know, having the right product for the right audience
- 38:20matters a lot. The and so that I think is the
- 38:27short answer, the longer answer, or maybe it's not that much
- 38:31longer, but in practice it will be longer.
- 38:34It's the education, right? I love doing Bitcoin education.
- 38:37And so this provides a product where for these institutional
- 38:43investors, they might not necessarily be interested in
- 38:48Bitcoin education if there is not a product behind it.
- 38:52And so getting, getting the foot in the door is, is important
- 38:57there. And if at the end of the
- 38:58conversation, they're like, hey, Pierre, we're, we're happy about
- 39:01what you're doing. We we like Bitcoin, but we're
- 39:04going to buy a spot ETF. You know, I'm really happy about
- 39:09that outcome, even if it's not my product or what I'm talking
- 39:13about. At the end of the day, I think
- 39:16we're all on the same team. And so that's the same way I see
- 39:19what sailors doing with strategy and what Jack Mullers is doing
- 39:22with 21. And you know that that it's all
- 39:27about driving Bitcoin adoption in general.
- 39:30Yeah, 100%. I'm glad you said that because,
- 39:35you know, I think it's easy for folks to get wrapped up in a
- 39:41line of thinking that I, I personally struggle with this
- 39:45line of thinking. But like that somehow any of
- 39:48this adoption from the corporate and sovereign level is, is
- 39:51somehow a bad thing. Like you do see these takes on
- 39:53Bitcoin Twitter though, where it's like, oh, like, you know,
- 39:56the institutions are Co opting Bitcoin and it's just like,
- 39:59well, you know, if you step back, like, well, how did you
- 40:01think this was going to happen? If if Bitcoin is to become
- 40:04global money, obviously institutions, nation states,
- 40:06corporates are going to get involved.
- 40:08And so like this is, I think how in my mind, how it was always
- 40:11going to play out. How do you have any thoughts
- 40:14there just in terms of like, yeah, yeah, should there be any
- 40:18concern about any of this? I I personally don't think so.
- 40:21I think everything is good. Bitcoin adoption, to your point,
- 40:23the education I think is a massive factor here of like, OK,
- 40:26SoftBank is getting into Bitcoin.
- 40:28That is a massive signal for institutions, high net worth
- 40:31folks all over the world to start Start learning about
- 40:34Bitcoin. Yes.
- 40:37So two thoughts on that. One is that over the past 12
- 40:45years I've developed a tremendous amount of conviction
- 40:48on bitcoins decentralization. And so whether it's large
- 40:53Bitcoin miners like Riot or large custodians like Coinbase,
- 40:59I think Bitcoin is anti fragile. We we saw it with the failure of
- 41:03Mount Gox in the early days like that did not destroy Bitcoin.
- 41:08The failure of FTX did not destroy Bitcoin.
- 41:11So I, I think that I, I have no concerns on, on the Bitcoin side
- 41:17of things. My concern is really, you know,
- 41:22for example, the the teachers that have been saving up through
- 41:27their pension fund and they are relying on that to retire and
- 41:34that if that pension fund is underperforming or, you know,
- 41:40just doesn't have enough Bitcoin exposure that it undermines
- 41:43their purchasing power in retirement.
- 41:47Do we as bitcoiners, do we want to say, oh, I told you so you
- 41:52should have been buying spot Bitcoin and putting it on your
- 41:55hardware wallet and running your own Bitcoin node.
- 41:58And you know, too bad for you that you put your money in this
- 42:02pension fund. Ha, ha, right.
- 42:05Like that to me is not a great outcome.
- 42:08It's, it's also, I think it's an immoral outcome like that.
- 42:13We, we don't want to have a society where the, the teacher
- 42:18or whoever is the end recipient of because again, these
- 42:23financial institutions, they're aggregating capital from normal
- 42:26people, right? And so through the division of
- 42:30Labor, that's the position that they are in.
- 42:33And they have a mandate to help normal people, whether it's an
- 42:37insurance company that's going to, you know, pay out claims or
- 42:41it's a pension fund or an endowment or any other kind
- 42:44where they, they're on a mission.
- 42:47And that I really see Bitcoin as a way to help them accomplish
- 42:51their mission and that to deliver the results for their
- 42:55constituents. So I think that it's, it's
- 42:59crucial to have them have a financial exposure to Bitcoin
- 43:03because I think Bitcoins going to be the best performing asset
- 43:06for the next 10 years, right? Just as it has been for the past
- 43:0910 years, and finding a way to build a bridge to them so that
- 43:13they are actually benefiting from Bitcoin in the same way
- 43:17that all of us sovereign individuals are.
- 43:21They're well said. Yeah, there's, there's a lot to
- 43:25be said about the, the timing of this company launch too.
- 43:29I know the, the regulatory front is, is definitely shifted from
- 43:32where it has been, but I guess like there's, there's a lot of
- 43:37shifting perception of Bitcoin as well.
- 43:40I guess. Do you have anything you would
- 43:43like to share with the, the timing of the launch of of this
- 43:45company? It's obviously something that
- 43:47you've been thinking about for for a long time.
- 43:50Yeah, the the, so, you know, the SEC having its hand for us last
- 43:54year and, and approving ETFs, I think that that that certainly
- 43:59shifted the, the acceptance of Bitcoin as an asset in
- 44:04traditional finance. And so now we have Larry Fink on
- 44:08national television saying things that are unimaginable,
- 44:12you know, 10 years ago of Bitcoin sits above governments.
- 44:17You know, Can you imagine the CEO of BlackRock saying that
- 44:20it's just, and then having the, the president of the United
- 44:25States say, oh, Bitcoin is a strategic asset.
- 44:29You know, the, this is the kind of, for better or for worse,
- 44:33the, the kind of social acceptance that is necessary in
- 44:38institutional finance to make progress for Bitcoin as an
- 44:42asset. And so the, I think the timing
- 44:46is perfect in that regard as well.
- 44:48And at the same time though, there's lots of work to be done
- 44:52right. So I, I don't think that it's an
- 44:55immediate overnight success. I think that there's lots of
- 44:58education that that needs to happen to, you know, to, to, to
- 45:03further bitcoins acceptance, because that's also why there's
- 45:07so much upside for Bitcoin that all of these institutions have a
- 45:120% allocation to anything Bitcoin related and that it's
- 45:17only going to go up from here. Yeah.
- 45:19And and that's, that's exactly right.
- 45:22That's that is the opportunity, that's the asymmetric
- 45:24information based on publicly available information that, you
- 45:28know, people are just still very slowly waking up to.
- 45:30I think one of the more interesting things really over
- 45:33just the past couple months or so, I would say is, you know,
- 45:37people like to talk about this divergent, the decoupling from
- 45:40risk assets. You know, I don't put a lot of
- 45:43stock in any short window of data, but I'm curious your
- 45:48thoughts on that dynamic because you know, once I started really
- 45:51understanding Bitcoin, and I think this is true of most
- 45:54people, but like once you really get there, you start to view it
- 45:58as the most possible risk off thing you could own.
- 46:01And you know, the the reality is that most people in traditional
- 46:06finance and most normal people haven't done that level of work.
- 46:10So they lump it in with tech stocks, the NASDAQ.
- 46:13And you know, for the past, probably two to two to four
- 46:16years, there have been short term correlations with the
- 46:19NASDAQ and it it's sort of trades as such.
- 46:23I think we're starting to see little blips of that that
- 46:26changing. And, and part of that in my mind
- 46:29is literally due to what you referenced around like the
- 46:32President of the United States calling it a strategic asset,
- 46:36various corporates adopting it as a store of value, not as a
- 46:39emergent tech play like that. That's not why they're buying
- 46:41Bitcoin. They're buying it to store value
- 46:44into the future and propagate that forward with, you know,
- 46:47various risks mitigated relative to other assets they could do
- 46:50that with. So I do think we're we're sort
- 46:53of obviously still in the early stages, but I'm seeing small
- 46:56little signs of people starting to to perceive Bitcoin for its
- 47:01true nature, its true underlying monetary properties that make it
- 47:05risk off in my mind. Would you agree with that?
- 47:07And and what do you think the next potential catalysts are to
- 47:10continue that sort of transformation in the perception
- 47:13of what Bitcoin really is? Yeah.
- 47:16So I, I think that the, the correlations are, as you pointed
- 47:21out, they change so much over time.
- 47:24So if we look at the Bitcoin cycles, arguably in, in the
- 47:30past, they've been triggered by the halvings.
- 47:32So, you know, you, you cut the supply coming onto the market in
- 47:36half and then it, it just causes a bull market and that's
- 47:40unrelated to anything happening outside of Bitcoin.
- 47:43It's this endogenous shock. And now we could argue that
- 47:48because more than 90% of the Bitcoin supply is already mined,
- 47:53that the halvings are going to have a smaller and smaller
- 47:55effect. Maybe the previous one just, you
- 47:59know, had a de minimis effect compared to the exogenous shock
- 48:04of President Trump getting elected and the the ETFs getting
- 48:09approved. And that those were really the
- 48:11catalyst for going from 20 grand to 100 grand, right, Right.
- 48:16So then going forward, what other catalysts will there be,
- 48:21you know, beyond just incremental adoption?
- 48:25I, I, I, I don't know, I think we'll be surprised just by the
- 48:28nature of that one macro argument would be that the other
- 48:34big variable is U.S. dollar monetary policy and fiscal
- 48:38policy for that matter. And so if US monetary policy
- 48:44loosens from where it currently is, that that would be a huge
- 48:48tailwind for Bitcoin and for other risk on assets.
- 48:52But as you pointed out that, you know, and this is something that
- 48:56BlackRock themselves also pointed out was Bitcoin is not
- 48:59neatly in either bucket of risk on or risk off.
- 49:03And so, but I do think that it could enter a period of
- 49:08correlation with risk on if you're loosening monetary policy
- 49:14and vice versa, right? So if we have a financial crisis
- 49:19and hopefully that doesn't materialize, but if that were to
- 49:22happen, like we saw March 12th of 2020 with the COVID crisis,
- 49:27like everything gets whacked. And so that's because Bitcoin,
- 49:32it's an asset that, you know, if you're trying to meet a margin
- 49:35call on your portfolio, you just have to sell anything and
- 49:38everything. And so you'd see a sell off in
- 49:42Bitcoin in a crisis moment. But that in response to that
- 49:46crisis, what would happen? What would happen is that we
- 49:49would need to print lots more dollars.
- 49:50And so then you go back into, OK, who benefits
- 49:54disproportionately? I think Bitcoin benefits more
- 49:58than NVIDIA in that scenario of a monetary loosening.
- 50:02And so that's where you know, the, the correlation it, it can
- 50:06still be directionally the same. But in terms of magnitude, I
- 50:09think Bitcoin will will outperform.
- 50:13Agreed. The one one thing that I would
- 50:16maybe take the other side of is the having having less of an
- 50:20effect moving forward because I would argue that I expect
- 50:24bitcoins market cap to more than double each having somewhat
- 50:27offsetting at least the dollar amount of Bitcoin supply
- 50:31issuance moving forward. But.
- 50:34Yeah, it might take. It's you know, it it was nice
- 50:39that so I would argue that it was nice that in the past that
- 50:42having's caused a, you know, parabolic bull market, but the
- 50:47not so nice part was then the bear market, which actually kind
- 50:51of prevented adoption, right. Nobody wants to buy into
- 50:56something that's going down. So a large part of from a factor
- 51:00perspective, Bitcoin's very strong on momentum to the upside
- 51:04and the downside. If if we have less of a having
- 51:09impact and the Bitcoin can kind of drift upwards and have, you
- 51:14know, a run up and then go sideways and then another run up
- 51:18and go sideways over a much longer time period.
- 51:22Then that I think has its advantages as well, right?
- 51:26Rather than the manic and panic. Yeah.
- 51:30Now that that's a great point because there's obviously just
- 51:33a, you know, what I would call like a fear factor of people who
- 51:38again, don't fully understand what they're looking at, but
- 51:41they see it so volatile. They also probably don't
- 51:44understand that, you know, bitcoins volatility is unique
- 51:48relative to other assets and that it's positively skewed,
- 51:50whereas most other assets have a negative skew in terms of their
- 51:53volatility. But that's, you know, that's in
- 51:56the weeds and most people looking at it just see it going
- 51:59down 7080% and they're like, no way.
- 52:02So I agree with you. Like there's, there's actually
- 52:05there could be benefits to, you know, volatility sort of
- 52:08dampening over time and a a slower grind upward would just
- 52:11be less scary for folks and and maybe incentivize them to, to
- 52:15learn about it faster than they otherwise would.
- 52:18So yeah, I think that's, that's a great point.
- 52:20I wanted to pull up on the screen here.
- 52:25Just hash rate just ripping. I guess it it just a little bit
- 52:30recently, but you know, giving your expertise in the the mining
- 52:35space of the Bitcoin world. I'm curious what your thoughts
- 52:38are on just what we've seen in terms of hash rate really since,
- 52:44you know, this this dip in in 21, the China mining ban.
- 52:48Ever since then, it's kind of just been, you know, up into the
- 52:51right and you know, is this is this nation states getting into
- 52:57the game in in your view. You know, I, I think there's
- 53:01long been rumors of that being the case, but you know, any, any
- 53:04thoughts in general on, on the mining space and, and hash rate?
- 53:09Yeah. So 11 factor is just the
- 53:13generational change in ASICS. And so as ASICS become more
- 53:18efficient, you can hold out, hold everything else constant
- 53:21hash rate increases. The other is that Bitcoin mining
- 53:28is the most competitive industry in the world, right?
- 53:31It's entirely permissionless and all you need is access to
- 53:35electricity. And there's a thriving secondary
- 53:38market of ASIC mining rigs and lots of service providers, you
- 53:43know, finding lots of nooks and crannies to hook into, to be
- 53:48mining economics that you know can be almost like free
- 53:54electricity, right? If you've got a hydro dam that
- 53:57is underutilized that you're able to hook into or flared
- 54:02natural gas that nobody else is using that you got free fuel
- 54:06there. So that's, that's for one.
- 54:10The, the other part of it too, is that the, the, the, the
- 54:17global competition of it makes it such that, you know, if, if,
- 54:22if Russia, for example, and I, I'm no fan of Russia, obviously,
- 54:25I, I, I, I, I'll start with that.
- 54:28But that because they have been cut off from a lot of the
- 54:34international financial system, one of their incentives is to
- 54:37access hard currency like Bitcoin by monetizing their
- 54:41energy assets. And so you know that there's
- 54:45there's that part. And then here in the US, that
- 54:49Bitcoin mining company is being publicly traded.
- 54:52They've had access to a lot of capital and have been able to
- 54:55put that to use in turning on mining rigs.
- 54:59And so right now, if you look at the mining economics on a
- 55:04dollars per MW perspective is cutthroat.
- 55:08And so that, I think reflects the fact that it's just this
- 55:12global commodity that there's so much competition in.
- 55:17And now we're seeing a lot of Bitcoin mining companies start
- 55:21to look at, OK, how do we redeploy capacity towards AI and
- 55:26HPC that can have higher margins than Bitcoin mining itself at
- 55:31this point in time? Yeah, that's fascinating.
- 55:37Maybe I wanted to one, just give you a kudos for the new podcast
- 55:43that you started, which I think is fantastic.
- 55:47It's you want to talk a little bit about that sort of just back
- 55:50on the the angle of of why education is so important and
- 55:52what you guys are trying to do with the new pod.
- 55:55Yeah, absolutely. So Michael Goldstein and I, we
- 56:00met in college. He started a Austrian economics
- 56:03reading circle, the Meses Circle.
- 56:06And I was attracted to it because I had gotten into
- 56:11Austrian economics through the Meses Institute, which is a an
- 56:16academic think tank essentially of, of researchers in Austrian
- 56:21economics based in Auburn, AL that had been publishing on the
- 56:27Internet. And when I was in high school, I
- 56:29was downloading MP Threes onto my iPod to just kind of give you
- 56:34an idea into how early I was into the podcast game.
- 56:38So the when we were learning about Bitcoin, the information
- 56:44was in lots of different places. And so we wanted to and, and
- 56:50Michael especially, you know, he's he's the, I would, I would
- 56:52really say he's the founder. He's the president of the Meses
- 56:55Institute or sorry, of the Nakamoto Institute.
- 56:58Yeah, Sushi Nakamoto Institute to pay it forward and to get all
- 57:02these resources into one place, translate them into lots of
- 57:06different languages and to help drive forward Bitcoin adoption.
- 57:10Because ultimately, yes, Bitcoin is software, it's code, but it's
- 57:15also, I think, an ideology and ethos around it, a culture that
- 57:21is, you know, if we want people to understand what bitcoins
- 57:25value proposition is and why we shouldn't, you know, go and
- 57:31change Bitcoin or start another cryptocurrency and all of all of
- 57:34these big questions kind of be be putting out thought
- 57:38leadership on that. And so the Nakamoto institute
- 57:41has been, I think, the the the best Ave. for looking at even
- 57:48pre Bitcoin thought. You know, there's lots of
- 57:50cypherpunk writings that Satoshi Nakamoto drew from all of
- 57:54Satoshi's writings. And then kind of the post
- 57:57Bitcoin thought of, OK, Bitcoin exists.
- 58:00Let's try to wrap our heads around it and try to explain it
- 58:03in different ways that might be, you know, relatable to folks and
- 58:08so and, and be timeless, right? So it's not like it's not about
- 58:13current events. It's really about trying to
- 58:15figure out what are the timeless aspects of Bitcoin with, with
- 58:19the benefit of hindsight. We wanted to go and look at what
- 58:23what had been written 10 years ago and take a fresh look at it.
- 58:29And so that's what we've been doing on the podcast, the reorg,
- 58:33which is a technical term from from Bitcoin that Michael and I
- 58:38have been recording. I think when we got 10 episodes
- 58:40now under our belt, we recorded two more today.
- 58:44There you go. You know, just to, to keep, keep
- 58:47it fresh and also to, to, to for people who are not around 10
- 58:52years ago to resurface these articles and to look at it with
- 58:56our, our, our 2025 eyes. Yeah, I've I've been listening
- 59:02to all of them and they're great.
- 59:03I would highly recommend to anybody.
- 59:05Throw it in the show notes. It's.
- 59:06Fantastic. Stuff.
- 59:09Please, please check it out and there are a lot of great
- 59:11writings in there too. And really appreciate your
- 59:14perspective on, you know, old ideas with a little bit of a
- 59:19fresh look too. And many of them are very
- 59:21timeless as you mentioned. So if you have a question or
- 59:25thought or concern, it's probably answered within the the
- 59:29reorg or somewhere on the website.
- 59:32Yeah, well, thank you, Liam. And, you know, we're standing on
- 59:35the shoulders of giants because obviously if, if I were to say,
- 59:39like everything on the Nakamoto Institute was already discussed
- 59:42in the Bitcoin talk forums in 2011, right?
- 59:46There's, there's a lot of history there.
- 59:51So yeah, it's, it's been a lot of fun to to to put together
- 59:56those resources. Yeah, it it's truly fantastic.
- 1:00:00And Pierre, I will say I'm jealous that you started
- 1:00:02learning about Austrian economics in high school.
- 1:00:04My high school teachers and even my college professors, I, you
- 1:00:07know, I mean, majors in economics didn't learn 1 lick
- 1:00:10about Austrian economics. So that, that tells you
- 1:00:12everything you need to know about, you know, the
- 1:00:15institutionalization of, of Keynesianism over the years.
- 1:00:19Maybe one, one question because we're, we're coming up on time
- 1:00:22and want to be respectful of your time, but maybe just sort
- 1:00:26of going forward, what can people expect in terms of, you
- 1:00:30know, quasi road map, if you will, for the Bitcoin bond
- 1:00:33company and where can people learn more about it?
- 1:00:36Yeah, so, you know, it's it's a ton of work behind the scenes
- 1:00:40and just follow me at Bitcoin Pierre on X as I have updates.
- 1:00:47That's where they will go. But yeah, this is not, you know,
- 1:00:50it's not a a retail facing product.
- 1:00:53And so in many ways, it's just meet me out here in the trenches
- 1:01:00and I, I hope to have more over the coming, let's say, years.
- 1:01:05Awesome. Well, thank you very much for
- 1:01:08for joining us. This is a a great conversation
- 1:01:10and and always appreciate your insights and and thoughts,
- 1:01:12Pierre. So thanks again for joining us.
- 1:01:15Yeah. Thanks, Brian.
- 1:01:15Thanks, Liam. Thanks, Pierre.
- 1:01:17All right, take care, Royce. Thanks for listening to this
- 1:01:21week's episode of the show. If you found the information
- 1:01:24valuable, please share the episode with a friend or leave a
- 1:01:26rating on your favorite podcast app.
- 1:01:28All the links we discussed in today's show will be in the show
- 1:01:30notes inside your podcast app. Before we finish, a quick
- 1:01:33reminder that On Ramp Media is for informational and
- 1:01:36entertainment purposes only, and nothing should be construed as
- 1:01:39investment or legal advice. Regardless of where you are on
- 1:01:42your Bitcoin journey, we'd love to hear from you.
- 1:01:44Visit on rampbitcoin.com/contact to schedule a consultation with
- 1:01:48one of our private Client advisors.