Latest / Success Story with Scott Clary / John Downey - Chief Information Security Officer at GoFundMe | Your Company Isn't Safe From Hackers
Transcript
- 0:00You start to see more and more prevalent security threats and more complicated security threats.
- 0:04There's always been threats. You notice that more companies are creating dedicated teams.
- 0:08Is this more of a like a 2023? Is you have to have like a CISO in your organization?
- 0:13In 2013, there was a couple of major retailer breaches. It became clear that a security
- 0:17incident was not just going to affect the chief security officer. It was also going to affect
- 0:22other sea level executives. Fast forward to 2016, you had the election interference and the
- 0:26hack of the DNC. Fast forward to 2020, everybody went to work from home.
- 0:32You know, the joke of like which C word drove the technology innovation at your company?
- 0:36Was it the CTO, the CEO, or the COVID-19? Because everybody overnight went work from home.
- 0:40That's wild. That is absolutely wild. Today, my guest is John Downey, chief information
- 0:45security officer for GoFundMe in Classy, where he leads the security strategy and operations
- 0:50for both platforms. He has over 20 years experience in software development and security.
- 0:55He's worked for some of the most reputable and innovative companies in the world.
- 0:59On average, nonprofits do not have the expertise that the for-profit business world has.
- 1:06I'm interested. A case study is to what made you want to move into the nonprofit world?
- 1:11My passion is for payments and it's weird to say, but like, I learned a lot about how the
- 1:15banking system works, how messy it can be, but how... What are your thoughts on how do nonprofits
- 1:22build back trust and compete in a 2023 environment? I had a leader of the company I worked at many
- 1:28years ago who kind of talked about like, you know, you can... Welcome to success story. I'm your host,
- 1:35Scott Clary. The success story podcast is part of the HubSpot podcast network. They've supported
- 1:39the show for almost two years now. So I want to just give a shout out to them. HubSpot is an
- 1:44incredible tool for business leaders. If you've never tried it before, you obviously have to check it
- 1:49out. You've heard a lot about it on this show, but outside of just HubSpot being amazing,
- 1:54they're incorporating AI tools that as a business leader, you have to pay attention to,
- 1:58because right now we're living through the industrial age of AI. There are already tons of
- 2:03innovative ways to leverage AI tech to streamline and grow your business. HubSpot just launched two
- 2:09free AI tools that can help you automate some of the more tedious parts of marketing and managing
- 2:14the CRM. So content assistant and chat spot are brand new GPT-powered features that can instantly
- 2:21brainstorm blog topics, write ad copy, filter contacts, run reports, and so much more. They're like
- 2:28virtual assistants that never complain, never quit, that quickly dig through data dumps to find
- 2:33you the needle in the haystack. So to learn more about using AI to grow a better business,
- 2:39head to HubSpot.com slash artificial dash intelligence.
- 2:52Yeah, so I'm very fortunate that I can kind of remember very clearly what that moment was for me.
- 2:58So the moment that kind of set me down this path was my like 12th or 13th birthday,
- 3:05went over to my grandfather's house to kind of say hi to him, and he gave me a $20
- 3:09bill. He's like half birthday, here's a $20 bill. And on the drive home, we stopped because we
- 3:15saw a garage sale. And I grew up in the Midwest, so very common to see garage sales all over the
- 3:19place. So we stopped saw a garage sale, figured we'd browse around. And up until that point,
- 3:24we had a family computer that had internet access through AOL, got the free CDs in the mail.
- 3:30But my parents were adamant because it was the 90s that I couldn't have a computer in my
- 3:35room that had internet. And so I really wanted the computer in my room, they said no. So we
- 3:41stopped at this garage sale, and they had a Commodore 64, which if you don't know what that is,
- 3:46it's kind of an older computer that was really popular in the 80s, CRT-TV clunky keyboard.
- 3:53And they were selling it for $20. And my mom was really concerned, she's like, well you can't have
- 3:58internet in your room. And the person's like, oh don't worry, it doesn't get internet.
- 4:04And so they're like, okay, so I brought it home. And like that, you know, started playing with that,
- 4:08you know, at first it was video games. But the thing that really kind of set me down this path was
- 4:12they gave me all the manuals and all of the books that they had about it. And I had all the
- 4:17software. And one of them was how to program computer games and basic. And it was just print
- 4:24out some source code for games that you could type into the Commodore and get it to go. And
- 4:28actually, I've since lost the book, but I went and found one on eBay years later, because I wanted
- 4:34to keep that as a memento. But that's kind of what set me down this path. Like I was really
- 4:38interested in software and computers. And like this moment has solidified that I wanted to do
- 4:42something with computers. And as you go down this career path, what makes you want to be responsible
- 4:50for the mission critical systems that are literally like the gate of all the bad actors in the
- 4:58world trying to sabotage a company. That is the most stressful thing I think anybody could ever
- 5:04want to do. And I mean, like there's a lot of different developer jobs and engineer jobs that
- 5:10can make a ton of money. And you can build and create a ton of great products that I mean in a
- 5:16larger company, you don't have to be responsible for this level of item in the company, but you
- 5:22went down this path. Because if I look at actually your background, you've been in information
- 5:27security for several of the past. This is not like something that you just did. Yeah, I had a
- 5:33later stage. Yeah, so I can, you know, for me, I was always really interested in security. And
- 5:39actually it was kind of a weird, I did kind of a weird flip thing, right? So I started developing
- 5:43software really early on late teens, like writing PHP and like sharing it out, you know, on forums.
- 5:48It was early 2000s, late 90s. And someone actually found a security issue in one of the things,
- 5:54and they reported it to me. And I thought that was so interesting that I really got into security
- 5:59for a while. And then it kind of flipped it around that I found like the most interesting security
- 6:04aspects to me were about software and the like bugs and software. And so I really went hard into
- 6:09that, stayed to computer science. And then I started off as a software engineer because it was the
- 6:15job I could get, but I was always really passionate about security. And it wasn't until I ended up,
- 6:19I ended up joining a startup called Brain Tree, which is a payments company. I was the 12th
- 6:25engineer, 40th person of the company, very small. I wrote software, I wrote banking software for,
- 6:31you know, we were powering, you know, companies like Uber and Airbnb and GitHub. So not small
- 6:36companies, very fast growing companies. And it was fascinating got to learn a lot about banking
- 6:42and finance and payments. But then I, you know, I was kind of looking around going, you know,
- 6:47I was still this passion for security. And you know, as we got bigger and bigger, I was like,
- 6:52we really kind of need a dedicated security function. And I, you know, proposed it to the CTO. And
- 6:58like, and you could leader, he was like, okay, that's not your problem. Go build out our security
- 7:01function. I'm like, okay, I go figure this out. And so I, you know, we did it. We started to hire,
- 7:07build that, build off the team. Then PayPal came and acquired the company in 2013. And then towards
- 7:14the end of my time at PayPal, I actually ended up leading security for all their acquisitions. So
- 7:18for Venmo and Paydient and Zoom with an X, as well as Brain Tree. So it was, it was a great experience,
- 7:25but like I end up going there because, you know, I, you know, someone found a bug in my software.
- 7:31Like I, I made a mistake that would, you know, or the kind of things that I'm trying to help our
- 7:35engineers here find your software. And set me down this path of like, this is fascinating to me.
- 7:40But you're right. It's lost stress. It takes kind of a personality like deal with it and like,
- 7:45kind of take the waves as they come and just sort of figure out what the best path forward is.
- 7:50Well, you know, in today's landscape, I feel like, and I'm not living in this world. So I'm just
- 7:55making assumptions based on news, which is a horrible way to make assumptions. But you, you start
- 7:59to see more and more prevalent security threats and more complicated security threats. And there's
- 8:03always been threats, right? But do you notice that more companies are creating dedicated teams?
- 8:09Is this more of a like a 2023? Is this like a, you have to have like a CISO in your organization
- 8:15as soon as you can get one because there's just so many bad actors and they're so sophisticated.
- 8:20Is this like the norm now? I think it's been kind of developing as the norm for a number of
- 8:25years. And so I kind of like in my career, I kind of see a few of miles. So it was 2013. There's
- 8:31a couple of major retailer breaches. So you saw like Target and a few others. And that was kind
- 8:35of the point at which it became clear that a security incident was not just going to affect the
- 8:40chief security officer. It was also going to affect other sea level executives at the company.
- 8:46So that was an interesting kind of development. And then, you know, fast forward a couple of years,
- 8:50you had 2016, you had the election interference and the hack of the DNC. That kind of, you know,
- 8:54was another big aspect. Fast forward to 2020. Everybody went to work from home. There's the, you know,
- 9:00the joke of like which C word major, you know, drove the technology innovation at your company was
- 9:06the CTO, the CEO or the COVID-19, because everybody overnight went work from home and that brings,
- 9:12you know, radically changed the security landscape. And then, you know, kind of, you know, fast forward
- 9:16to today, you know, these inflection points keep hitting. And then we have a big one for at least
- 9:20for public companies with the SEC rules that, you know, are currently a proposal, most likely going
- 9:26past that are going to require that you start to report on the cybersecurity expertise of your
- 9:32board, that the board has to acknowledge that they have cybersecurity oversight responsibility,
- 9:36kind of setting out rules and requirements for reporting of cybersecurity incidents. And then,
- 9:40just even a couple of days ago, the Biden administration putting out the national cybersecurity
- 9:45strategy from the, from the system, the critical infrastructure security administration as part
- 9:50of DHS, they set out kind of like, here's how, you know, technology is critical. Security issues
- 9:56in technology are, you know, kind of affect the entire American people. And here's what we're going
- 10:00to do to make sure that companies are taking responsibility for this because there's really an
- 10:04underlying current of, you know, kind of so what? Like, we have a security issue, the stock price
- 10:09rebounds, you know, maybe someone loses their job, but it's like not that big of a deal.
- 10:13Except for it has, you know, started to become a big deal. And companies are starting to realize it,
- 10:18but I think politically, the regulators are starting to say, look, we have to get involved and push
- 10:22companies harder and faster. So it makes a ton of sense that there has to be some more formalized
- 10:28security process regulatory oversight because I think it, you know, when you start playing out
- 10:35a big enough level, it is a lot more, it can be a lot more impactful than just the stock price,
- 10:39right? Like you just, like you just mentioned, but it's interesting. When you look at what the,
- 10:45the SEC is doing, your background, the SEC is not, is not a, is not the most forward looking
- 10:52organization in the world. And, and you even, you look at when we speak to tech leaders and we,
- 10:58and we bring them before the Senate and we're, you know, we're speaking to them and asking them
- 11:01questions and some of the questions are so rudimentary and silly. And it's just like, how do these people
- 11:06keep up with the most advanced threats in the world? So when you look at what the SEC is doing,
- 11:12is it enough? Does the SEC know what good looks like? Or is there more that has to be done?
- 11:18So I think that's a, that's a great question. I think where the SEC is largely, in my opinion,
- 11:22catching up with where highly regulated organizations, right? So like financial services,
- 11:29healthcare, places like that, had already had a lot of these kind of requirements in place,
- 11:34where the SEC is kind of coming in as it's clarifying that this isn't just those industries,
- 11:38it's all industries. And also clarity, you know, clarifying wise at, you know, SEC's goal is always
- 11:44we need to empower investors and protect investors. And so what, what requirements are there?
- 11:49You know, if you have an incident, but the incident maybe doesn't reach this, you know,
- 11:53this kind of mythical material level, well, what does that even mean? Like, it's the SEC's kind of
- 11:57laying out like, well, no, here's what that means. Here, you know, here's we have to put into your 8K,
- 12:01which is the form that you have to file when there's a, you know, material incident. And here's
- 12:06like specifically how long it's been going on and kind of like the criteria of it. You know,
- 12:10are they going far enough? I think that's, that's a great thing we'll kind of see over the next few,
- 12:15you know, over the next few years, if, you know, companies really start to increase the reporting
- 12:19and the visibility if it, if the sunlight actually, if the sunlight actually kind of acts as a,
- 12:24you know, acts as an agent of change. But I don't know, you know, I think the, a lot of the,
- 12:30a lot of the regulated industries were already this, or already this way, especially if you
- 12:34are regulated out of states like New York, where they already have very stringent requirements
- 12:38for financial services companies. You know, you're seeing a lot of these things are, things that you
- 12:43had to do already. And, and, you know, now I'm actually more curious about, this is going to be
- 12:49about your career path too and how you moved from one, like you were working with PayPal. I mean,
- 12:55you could not have picked a more important organization for there to be some sort of information
- 13:01security oversight. Like when you're working in financial industries, it's, I mean, a breach is
- 13:07just like it can be horrifying. But I've always found that on average non-profits do not have the
- 13:15expertise that the for-profit business world has. And I'm interested as to you as like a case study
- 13:23as to what made you want to move into the nonprofit world. Because somebody with the information
- 13:29security background from PayPal, I would say there's unlimited career opportunities, potential
- 13:34money out there that you could go chase after. And I think that's actually a problem that a lot
- 13:38of nonprofit have. I think that they do not know either how to or cannot afford to pay because
- 13:43the business model is suffering to some degree to pay the salaries of the people that can move the
- 13:49organization forward and not even just information security like sales, marketing, everything.
- 13:54But you made that conscious decision. And I think that like that's remarkable. So I feel safe
- 13:58with, with GoFundMe, I feel safe with Classy, but I think a lot of nonprofit suffer from this,
- 14:02which is why you see trust in nonprofits start to be great, to be quite honest. So what was
- 14:07that thought process for you? How did you make that jump? Why were you able to do that? Why did GoFundMe
- 14:12look towards somebody who was highly capable to bring into the organization?
- 14:17Yeah, so I spent, as you mentioned, I spent a number of years at PayPal and I knew my next steps.
- 14:24I wanted to stay in financial services. So I actually went to and spent a little bit of time in
- 14:28insurance, just to try out, try my hat on another financial services sector. But my passion is
- 14:34for payments. And it's weird to say, but I kind of got really good at it. I learned a lot about
- 14:38how the banking system works, how messy it can be, but how functional. In a lot of ways it is,
- 14:44and how important it is, you look at a lot of the last couple of weeks here with the Fed and the
- 14:50banks in the US. And so I wanted to stick to that. And so GoFundMe and Classy offer a way to
- 14:58for me, stay in payments, but also feel a lot better about what I was doing on a day-to-day
- 15:01system. Not that, obviously, I hold no animus towards any of my prior employers. We were doing
- 15:07great work, but it helps day-to-day. I feel they impact a lot more at GoFundMe and Classy.
- 15:13In terms of, you raised a great point around nonprofits and the whole government
- 15:19in geosector has a real deficit of talent in a lot of cases. There's recently been a case
- 15:28where the NSA and others have been like, hey, we want to do a talent swap with industry where
- 15:33they want to go to Google and Facebook and others and say, hey, we'll swap people with you.
- 15:40You can send your best security engineers to us and we'll train them to help us in our fight
- 15:44against whatever it is. And then they'll work for us for a few years and then we'll swap them
- 15:48back and as a way to maybe get talent. That's something they've floated recently. I think this
- 15:54just goes to show that there's a real issue here and a lot of that kind of stems back to
- 16:00just non-profits have a lot of the, from my experience, have a lot of the issues startups do.
- 16:06They're small, they usually have very limited resources, scrappy team, everybody's,
- 16:10the thing I love about being a startup is everybody did everything, right? My job is when I joined
- 16:14Brain Tree said that I maybe asked to take the trash out. I thought that was awesome because I
- 16:18was something I was really passionate about. I think the people who work at small nonprofits,
- 16:22small to medium sized nonprofits have the same passion, but maybe a little bit different mission
- 16:27alignment, right? They're very philanthropic like kind of looking to do the most good.
- 16:33And the key thing I see is sort of the funding, right? So in a startup, another dollar going towards
- 16:40AWS or GitHub or some developer tool can make sense, it's an investment that you're kind of
- 16:46making towards the future. When you're in a nonprofit, a lot of these dollars, you want to maximize
- 16:51your dollars going to programs. How can I deliver whatever help my nonprofit is trying to deliver?
- 16:56I want to maximize that, which means paying less on salaries, investing less on training,
- 17:01investing less on other things. Until you get bigger and you hit this inflection point,
- 17:05which you kind of have to make that risk based decision, but smaller organizations, green
- 17:09organizations, they're really trying to maximize the program, how much they can put into the program,
- 17:15which means they have to minimize a lot of other stuff. You all know the success story podcast is
- 17:19part of the HubSpot podcast network. They have incredible podcasts. So please go check out the
- 17:23roster. But one of my favorite shows is Nudge hosted by Phil Agnew. You just have to understand that
- 17:28some of the smallest changes can have the biggest impacts on your life and on Nudge. This is what
- 17:34Phil goes through. He speaks about evidence, back tips to help you kick bad habits, get a raise,
- 17:41grow a business. Every single episode is bite sized, 20 minutes comes packed with practical
- 17:47device from some of the most prolific entrepreneurs, behavioral scientists in the world. And it's the
- 17:53UK's fastest growing business podcast. I definitely recommend you go check it out. You should listen to
- 17:59Nudge wherever you get your podcast. And I've seen that a lot, but that means that there's a lot
- 18:07of vulnerabilities and liabilities in the nonprofit sector. So maybe speak to some of the things
- 18:15that you see as a tack vectors that could be a major issue if these are not more addressed and
- 18:23if people don't put more of an emphasis on information security. Because I feel like to your point
- 18:27before, private industry is taking it more seriously than they did before, but I feel like
- 18:32nonprofit is potentially still lagging. Now I think that's very true. And I think one of the things
- 18:38I always recommend to folks is, you know, you have a couple different types of attackers who may come
- 18:43after you, right? So you have people who are doing it just because they don't like you or they don't
- 18:47like what you stand for. They don't like someone involved with you. They kind of hacked us.
- 18:52You're going to have a hard time defending against them. And you know, if you're a nonprofit,
- 18:55like they're nonprofits that are politically motivated and they have, and therefore they're going
- 18:59to have someone with the opposite persuasion attacking them. But the vast majority of people that
- 19:04they're probably going to deal with are people who are financially motivated. So financially motivated
- 19:07attackers are, you know, they're usually at the at the lower levels at these kind of smaller
- 19:13companies. It's more of a drive-by issue unless of a targeted issue, right? So I always describe it
- 19:18to, you know, it's not Tom Cruise and Emission Impossible like breaking into the facility and like
- 19:23dropping down, you know, and like stealing the information. It's someone walking down the street
- 19:27and juggling the handles on the car doors, right? Like that's the kind of person. They're just,
- 19:31they're just looking for a car that was left unlocked that they can rob. And so what you need to do
- 19:36as an organization is do the things you have to do to lock your car doors and make sure that your
- 19:40employees are doing it. And so that's things like good password hygiene. So, you know, having strong
- 19:45passwords, unique passwords for website, using a password manager, turning on multifactor authentication,
- 19:50probably the best thing you can do is enable MFA everywhere you can. And then last thing is
- 19:56patching. So like patching your software, patching your phones, encouraging everybody to make sure
- 20:01like, hey, keep everything up to date. And then you're going to be, at that point, you're going to be
- 20:06pretty close to being the one who's had their car door locked. The one I've added that we're very
- 20:10recently is just double checking that all your laptops are encrypted. So this is something that,
- 20:15you know, is starting to come more of a norm out of the gate, but like if you get a new windows
- 20:20or Mac laptop, just make sure that it's the encryption's enabled. And this is where it kind of,
- 20:24you know, helps to have a partner to do this, right? Like if you're a nonprofit, if you can partner
- 20:28somebody, because I'm not expect an executive director at a local foundation to be an expert on
- 20:32technology, you know, how to turn on Bitlocker. But hopefully there is an organization they can work
- 20:36with, an IT consultant or someone who can do that. And the reason I kind of go into the laptop
- 20:42thing is because people like any mobile device, the mobile phones are very good. Like, you know,
- 20:48modern mobile phones are pretty secure. It's the mobile laptops just because you do lose them,
- 20:53you leave them in cabs, you leave them, you know, restaurants, like things happen. And when that
- 20:58happens, you want to make sure that you have fairly high confidence that the data on it is safe.
- 21:02So you're saying like from what I'm hearing that the majority of problems still, the majority of
- 21:07potential attacks are still human, are still focused on the human, are still focused on the human
- 21:13screwing something up basically or getting fished or losing something.
- 21:18Yeah. So the, you know, Verizon every year publishes a great report that kind of outlines data
- 21:22statistics. And it's something like 80 plus percent of attacks that are, you know, going to be like
- 21:28really wildly successful start with known credentials. So they start with someone, you know, it's not
- 21:33that like someone hacked the matrix and kind of broke in. It's like, no, they got scots using
- 21:38them in password. They logged in a scot. And I'm assuming actually, if you're, if you have a
- 21:46workforce that's not working from home, which is a reality post-COVID, then you, to your point
- 21:53actually. So you don't have, you don't have the proper encryption on the devices that people are
- 21:59working off of because they're taking something home or they're combingling the files from their
- 22:03work with the files on their personal computer at home. And every, all the, all the security
- 22:09requirements that in office, you could sort of control. Now it's like the Wild West. It's like
- 22:15craziness because everybody goes home and they can use whatever device they want and using
- 22:19their personal device, using their work device, using personal phone, work phone. Is that what
- 22:23you're dealing with right now? I mean, I think so. And I think a lot of folks have been dealing with
- 22:27it since 2020, you know, March of 2020. I remember talking to competitors at the time when I,
- 22:33where I was, where they were sitting people home with desktops because it was all they had. They
- 22:37didn't have laptops. You couldn't buy a laptop. I don't know if you, if you were in the mode of
- 22:41trying to buy a laptop in August or sorry, in April. It was like a selling panic. Yeah. You couldn't,
- 22:48and like, because all the students were going to remote learning, all the employees were going
- 22:52to remote. If they didn't already have these, the supply chains were immediately jammed. And so
- 22:57because of this, things were skipped. You know, efficiency was needed to get people up and running.
- 23:02And so I think a lot of companies in places are dealing with the fact that like they kind of,
- 23:07there's still this COVID fog of like, you have this technology out there. Now, fortunately,
- 23:11unfortunately, you know, it's a couple of years old. So maybe it's, you know, entering the place
- 23:14where it's going to be replaced. But you have a lot of technology out there that was kind of like
- 23:17rushed into production, if you will. And these kind of early days of COVID that maybe, you know,
- 23:23didn't get, you know, the firewalls didn't get configured or the laptops didn't get encrypted.
- 23:28If you're not a sophisticated organization, then, you know, has the remote management capabilities
- 23:32like a small nonprofits, you, you may have this risk out there. And so, you know, kind of going back
- 23:36to what I mentioned a little bit earlier is partnering with someone who can help you out with this.
- 23:40Like, I don't expect people to have this, you know, these people on staff at that level,
- 23:45you outsource it, you know, just like a kind of a how startup would for, you know, for, for
- 23:50things that aren't going to be core to what they're trying to build, you kind of have to outsource
- 23:53it to someone who's an expert. But also, like, so you're saying that a lot of this comes at, yes,
- 23:57so you're outsourcing some of the actual very technical items. But there's a, I'm sure there's a lot
- 24:03of education that can be built into an organization that probably also isn't there that could mitigate
- 24:07tons of these problems. So, I mean, let's talk about the human component and these breaches,
- 24:13because the human, that's, that's the fallacy, that's the weak point, right? That's the Achilles
- 24:16heel. So, outside of pure technical, what are the, for us, for a, for any, I was going to say
- 24:22small business owner, but for any business owner that doesn't have this knowledge in house,
- 24:26what are the like the best practices that you would teach over to your team or your employees
- 24:31so that they don't fall victim to this stuff? Because I'm even spouting off stuff like, don't
- 24:35get fished. Okay, maybe people don't even know what that means. You know, I, I get the, dude,
- 24:40I get these like scam emails all the time and they're getting actually quite complex and I can
- 24:43see it because I'm a technical person and I'm not, I'm not oblivious to this, but I get emails
- 24:47from my own team where they've like changed the name of the, of the email, but this, if you actually
- 24:54go into, or they change the name of the sender, but the email is this weird obscure email and it's
- 24:58like, hey, Scott, like, you know, oh, it's Patrick and it's like, changed my banking information on
- 25:03my payroll and I need my ACHFD. Yeah, exactly. So it's like, people also pay me in iTunes gift cards.
- 25:10Right, exactly. And it's like, oh, don't, don't, don't, don't call me. I'm in a meeting,
- 25:15just do this urgently, like stuff like that. So I mean, not everyone's going to fall for that, but
- 25:20yeah, no, so you say that, you know, the recent, so a few days ago, the FBI released their
- 25:252020 cybercrime statistics. And so they categorized that under kind of this thing called BEC or
- 25:32business email compromise. And it, for years and years and years was the number one thing on
- 25:37their cybercrime, always in, you know, a couple billion lost reported to them. This year actually
- 25:43dropped number two. The number one is now investments game, so the crypto scams. But it's still
- 25:49number two, it's still a huge deal. And it takes the form that you, you mentioned, which is,
- 25:54all, you know, often somebody will reach out, usually they'll impersonate an executive or CEO,
- 25:58CFO, president, someone. They'll send, we've been, we've actually been seeing a lot more text messages
- 26:04than emails recently, where they'll text our email and say like, hey, I'm the CEO. I have
- 26:10something really important. You can't reach me, but I need you to do something and it always
- 26:13involves like wiring money or changing and ACH information or buying gift cards or something
- 26:18for some reason. Anything that you can do to extract value out of the person or the organization.
- 26:24And you know, they're playing there a couple of things, right? They're playing to urgency,
- 26:27they're playing towards people's sense of wanting to help out, especially like the CEO, you know,
- 26:32hey, like I, you know, I'm special. They reach out to me because they thought I could handle it.
- 26:35I want to let them down. And, you know, and people unfortunately do fall for it. And that's
- 26:40that, yeah, to the tune of a couple billion a year that we know of so far, at least from the FBI,
- 26:46and in the US. And like that, I think a lot of that kind of goes back to
- 26:49creating a foundation of trust inside the organization to, you know, no, you know, basically,
- 26:54you have to make people where these are a big thing. So, you know, awareness and security,
- 26:58awareness and training is a big for organizations of all size. You know, make sure people have the
- 27:03feel, feel comfortable to kind of stop and say like, hey, this is weird. Like maybe I should
- 27:08like validate this. And so, yeah, how would I go about validating that the email that the email
- 27:13I just got from the CEO isn't correct. Like is the CEO even approachable at my company? So,
- 27:18you know, I'm very fortunate at the place where I work at GoFundMe. Our CEO is actually like,
- 27:23you know, come out and town halls and say like, I will never text you. I will never email you
- 27:26and ask you to do this. We will always use proper channels. And that's that's helpful. But for
- 27:30organizations that are a little bit smaller, they haven't seen this before. You know, I, I'm involved
- 27:35in an organization where they they had this and the person actually kind of went along with it for
- 27:39a little bit. This is at an organization I've consulted with in the past. What do you mean they went
- 27:44along with it? They were like down the street about to buy gift cards for long rains. When they
- 27:49stopped and said, wait a minute, this makes no sense. Why should I be doing this? Yeah.
- 27:53And they felt super embarrassed as you would. And they like didn't want to report it. Didn't want to
- 27:57talk about it because it's very natural. You know, you, you, you can be embarrassed. You can, and
- 28:02you know, you can find yourself like feeling like a fool. And that's why it's important to always
- 28:06create this like, you have to lead with empathy. You have to say like, look, this happened
- 28:10to anybody. I would feel embarrassed too. Here's what we can do to like make sure that we, you know,
- 28:14we're resilient to this in the future. And just sort of, you know, focus on improving the
- 28:19situation. There's, there's an aspect in security we call the human firewall, which is, you know,
- 28:24knowing that we could have the best security in the world. But we, you know, if we don't have humans
- 28:28out there kind of helping us out as well, like we're going to miss things. And the example I always
- 28:32go back to with this is the solar winds breach from a few years ago. So the solar winds got
- 28:37compromised. You know, the US has blamed the Russian government for doing this. And they,
- 28:42they were in organizations like Microsoft and the State Department and a company called Fire.
- 28:46I Fire is a very famous security company. It was actually an employee at Fire. I got a
- 28:52multifactor authentication reset email reached out to their security team said, I didn't do this.
- 28:57This is weird. Launched investigation found that they had this breach that hits them from
- 29:02solar winds. And that's how the whole thing was uncovered. If they, if this human hadn't kind of
- 29:07been aware, it felt comfortable going to their security team with this that the whole solar
- 29:12winds incident may have lasted for another few months of nine years. That's wild. That is absolutely
- 29:18wild. It's such a, it's such a, somebody who needs to feel psychologically safe to speak up.
- 29:26And that's really what stopped this from going on. Actually, I was just thinking, you know, as
- 29:31you're telling me that story, I actually do have a friend who ran a very large business. And I
- 29:36think, I think it was just under 500,000. And it was a payment. It was a payment for a service.
- 29:42And basically, there was an email sent to change the, the wire information or the ACH information.
- 29:47And it was gone. But that employee in particular, felt embarrassed, but like, spoke up immediately.
- 29:52And the founder and CEO of that company was like a very good friend and he's a good person.
- 29:57So like, obviously not, not an ass about it. But yeah, I could see that. And I could actually see
- 30:02this is, it's almost like a, a leadership lesson can do more for reinforcing the security of
- 30:08your organization than than anything really. Because if you create a psychologically safe environment
- 30:14and somebody's going to be willing to speak up and like raise their hand when they screw something
- 30:17up, that's great. That's a very healthy organization. If somebody screws something up and you
- 30:22reprimand them and you fire them, that is actually potentially going to do more harm to your
- 30:27organization than the long term. Because everybody who saw that action is going to be like scared out of
- 30:32their mind to ever say anything if they ever do anything wrong. And that's going to cause more
- 30:35repercussions. Yeah, it's very similar to in the DevOps world coming up at, see, there's this
- 30:41thing called blameless post-portals. I don't know if you're familiar with it, but the idea is,
- 30:45you know, so if you haven't incident the site goes down, there's an outage. Somebody, you know,
- 30:49somebody may be misconfigured something. And there's this idea that when you kind of get together
- 30:54to talk about what happened and find the improvements going forward, that you do in a blameless
- 30:58fashion. So you don't say, John pushed this update and John caused the site to go down. You'd be like,
- 31:05an update was pushed the site went down. Here's what we're going to do going forward. You don't,
- 31:08by not attaching blame, you're creating this, you know, this environment in which you can kind of
- 31:14lead with empathy, create this space for people to, you know, kind of, you know, be safe to share
- 31:18these things on it, not, you know, you kind of create this, you, you know, actually create
- 31:23a situation which they won't try to cover it up, ideally, like they, if you do go with blame first,
- 31:28maybe somebody's like, okay, I messed up, but like, I can fix it really quickly. I don't know
- 31:32if anybody has to help me and then nobody will know and then I'll be fine, nobody, I won't get fired.
- 31:37Instead, you can kind of stop and say, oh, I messed something up. I need to ring the bell, call
- 31:42for help because I can't fix this on my own. I love that. I love blameless post-mortems.
- 31:47I mean, I love, I love the concept. Okay. So we've kind of covered like best practices for
- 31:52somebody that has really not put any thought towards this, but I want to like take it up a notch
- 31:56and I want to understand maybe something that's innovative that could be like a step two. So look
- 32:01at, look at your own work, look at GoFundMe, look at classy. What are more innovative things that
- 32:06you're dealing with right now in this world that are just top of mind that somebody who is operating
- 32:11at a higher level and is operating with more complex threats should start to think about.
- 32:18That's a great question. I think a lot of it really kind of comes back down to like picking
- 32:22best in class partners, right? So we, you know, we have to operate a very, you know, kind of limited
- 32:27scale with our teams. We're, you know, doing the best we can, but a lot of this kind of comes down
- 32:31to really keeping our finger on the pulse of technology and trying to pick the best partners
- 32:37and the best platforms to build on top of, you know, I think in terms of like being truly
- 32:41innovative, like we, you know, I don't think we have like the light bulb that's going to like,
- 32:45you know, kind of flash and solve the industry's, you know, problems. I think for us are, you know,
- 32:52really worried with us, like we're trying to be empathetic, training big people where
- 32:57yeah, help our customers out and like, you know, a lot of that kind of comes down to like offering
- 33:01a lending hand, offering being, you know, kind of a someone who you can kind of offer consultation,
- 33:07kind of best in class support for. And you know, with that, like we can kind of like hope that we
- 33:11can lead organizations that aren't, you know, through this that aren't, you know, so they don't
- 33:15end up having some of these same issues. But you know, in terms of like, I want to talk about the
- 33:19Kelly Road show. I do not take my podcast recommendations lightly, but I have truly admired
- 33:24Kelly's journey from the get-go. She was a fresh employee at a Fortune 500 received seven
- 33:29promotions in eight years, all this while building a company that blossomed into an eight-figure
- 33:34empire. Today, she's a best-selling author, top-ranked podcaster, the proud owner and co-owner of
- 33:40six thriving companies. And let's not forget, she's an ink 500 awardee proving that growth isn't
- 33:46just a goal. It is a lifestyle. Now, her podcast, the Kelly Road Show, dies deep into business
- 33:51growth strategies, specifically targeted for those hitting these six and seven figure mark,
- 33:55but it's not all business. She also explores the habits, mindset and disciplines of the world's
- 34:00most successful people. It's a podcast. It's perfect whether you're just getting started,
- 34:04or you're trying to up-level your success game. But here's a deal kicker for me. She is a super mom
- 34:09and a wife. She embodies the truth that you don't have to sacrifice your home life for success.
- 34:13She believes in shows that life-changing wealth, wild success, a happy marriage, and fulfilling
- 34:19home can coexist. That is goal. So tune in to the Kelly Road Show on Apple Spotify.
- 34:25Wherever you get your podcast, trust me. It's time well invested. By the way, I don't mean
- 34:30like you're like changing the industry. I just meant like this stuff that like I know for factors
- 34:34like threats that you're aware of that are much more complex than just like the human element.
- 34:41Yeah, I think that's definitely true. I mean a lot of artists comes down to
- 34:45defending against actors who are against what's happening on our platform, right? So we have
- 34:51open-platforms where organizations are on many sides of many issues. And sometimes there are
- 34:58people out there who don't like what's happening. And they're not the jiggling the car door.
- 35:03Yeah, they're not the jiggling the car door. They're nation-states, they're
- 35:08activists, they're others. And so what they're doing in these cases, they're throwing whatever
- 35:12they can at us to help bring this down. And it's not always like the things that you would think of,
- 35:16like the big political flashpans, it's things like helping victims of earthquakes and stuff like
- 35:22that. Like some people just don't, you know, some people just like have eternal enemies and they
- 35:26don't want to like see people provide support. And so we're there to kind of help our organizations
- 35:31are, you know, the donors, all the campaigns and try to help make sure that we're providing a safe
- 35:36platform for them to provide as much help. So our goal here is to deliver help through whatever
- 35:41means we can and like we're providing that platform. And, and, you know, you're, you're actively
- 35:47going out on on podcasts and obviously speaking about this and I think it's super important.
- 35:52But just from what you've seen in the world of nonprofits, the role of trust and transparency,
- 35:58how does that impact the actual success, the confidence of the investor or the or the
- 36:03donor or the contributor? Because I don't see, you know, no, no other non-profit CISO has ever
- 36:11approached and wanted to speak about cybersecurity. But I do see the not just, I guess, a
- 36:17roting trust with nonprofits across the board. So what are your thoughts on how do nonprofits build
- 36:24back trust and compete in a 2023 environment? Yeah, I think, you know, it comes from a lot of
- 36:30different aspects. So I had a leader of the company I worked at many years ago who kind of talked
- 36:35about like, you have to build, you know, you can build trust kind of like in a football game.
- 36:40You inch the ball forward line, but, you know, you know, kind of yard by yard, but like one mess up
- 36:46and it's completely, it's completely gone. They're going to run the wall back the other direction.
- 36:49You've lost it all. And like, unfortunately, it's a slow slog. You got to build that trust back up
- 36:55by doing things that enable trust. And some of that is like, you know, there are like kind of some
- 36:59flashy things you can do like good design. We know is like great, is linked to like providing
- 37:04trust. Like if you come to a website and it looks like it hasn't been updated since 1999, you're
- 37:09inherently not going to trust that like that. Like who are these people? What are they doing? So
- 37:14good design, leading with empathy, you know, and then, you know, kind of attaching itself to a brand
- 37:19partnering yourself with best in class, you know, partners, like these are the things that you can
- 37:24have helped do it. But unfortunately, it's hard. Like you're building your guy build that trust
- 37:28up slowly over time. And then, you know, do the do all the things you can to make sure you're not
- 37:33going to lose it. I love that. And and and more on like on a on a product level, just to touch on
- 37:38this briefly, because I'm actually just like personally interested. What what is classy doing
- 37:44that go fund me is not doing? What's what was the actual and and listen? I know you're not like
- 37:48CPO and whatnot, but there's like, we can bring someone else on and go into the the finite, you
- 37:53know, mining details. But like what what are you what are you trying to build out with like the
- 37:57second platform? Yeah. So if you look at GoFundMe kind of historically, GoFundMe has, you know,
- 38:04works with both nonprofits and just individuals. So we know that, you know, we know that a lot of
- 38:09people are helping raise money for friends, family, especially after disasters. Medical emergencies
- 38:15were kind of, you know, in COVID, we kind of, you know, became mean worthy for helping out people
- 38:19with, you know, being kind of a backstop for the healthcare system. Trevor Noah mentioned that
- 38:23on one of his daily shows. And classy is hyper focused on helping nonprofits. So it's helping nonprofits,
- 38:32fundraise, you know, through all the different ways they can through live events, on platform,
- 38:37you know, recurring donations, everything about that. And GoFundMe had, you know, had done some
- 38:41things like this in the past, but we were really focused on this kind of crowdfunding platform,
- 38:45both for both individuals and nonprofits. And classy is there really there for if you're a
- 38:50nonprofit, if you're, you know, kind of a medium to large nonprofit and you want to raise money
- 38:54and have a fundraising platform, class is there for you. And, you know, we're doing our best to,
- 38:59you know, build a top class platform, best in security and privacy, trust and safety,
- 39:04working with the best partners. And then, you know, if you're if you're an individual and you need
- 39:08to like help raise money because you're, you know, there's an earthquake and you need to, you know,
- 39:12help your friend rebuild their house. Yeah. GoFundMe is there to kind of help you set up those campaigns.
- 39:17I got it. And I guess like, like, classy is solving a great problem. Like a lot of this is,
- 39:22a lot of the conversation is sort of evolved around nonprofits not really keeping up with or not,
- 39:28not, you know, being forward thinking or forward looking. So I guess like classy is more or less
- 39:33like another way to modernize the way that nonprofits function as a business unit, as an organization.
- 39:39And yeah, I think that's a great way to think about it. You know, if you're a forward thinking
- 39:43nonprofit, you want to, you know, continue to partner with great platforms. Classes here to
- 39:48be that platform, you know, we have, we have a lot of different other companies we partner with,
- 39:52like Salesforce to kind of help, you know, provide the donor management aspect of it. But, you know,
- 39:58kind of like we're here to help you with the fundraising aspect of it. Like we, you know, a lot of the
- 40:02charitable organizations that, you know, they kind of live and die based on how much money they can
- 40:07raise every year. Yeah. And class is kind of there to help fill that. I love that. So before we wrap
- 40:14up, is there anything that I didn't go into that you'd want to talk about teach over to founders,
- 40:20entrepreneurs, C-suite, nonprofits that you think would be very, very valuable that we should just
- 40:24sort of like capture on this? Yeah, I think, you know, something I, when I go and I talk to, you
- 40:30know, kind of unfortunate to consult with quite a few smaller companies. And, you know, it's always
- 40:34interesting because like everybody's, you know, everybody expects me to say like, okay, like,
- 40:38start with security early, which is true. Like you should think about security early. But there's
- 40:42actually, it's a balance, right? Like you want to make sure that you find product, you know, if you're
- 40:46in the for-profit space, you want to make sure that you're finding product market fit. And security
- 40:51can actually slow that down in some ways. So you got, it's kind of like this thing where it's like,
- 40:54it's the salt. You guys sprinkle on just enough for the dish to taste good. But if you dump too much
- 40:59security on to early, it's going to ruin the dish. And so you got to bring it with moderation.
- 41:03You got to do things like building in the culture, empathy, strong password, you know, using
- 41:08password majors. And all these things are easier to do when you have five employees than when you
- 41:13have 500 employees. And so, you know, starting off really early and kind of helping build that up
- 41:18from the start is, is my advice to people. So you have like a, almost like a day, day zero
- 41:23security best practices that will already mitigate a ton of problem in the future that is
- 41:29really frictionless to implement. And that's what you're saying like an entrepreneur should do,
- 41:32like literally right away. And then if you grow and you scale and you get more complex and okay.
- 41:37Yeah. I mean, and you know, if I'm actually talking this specifically to start up, I would say
- 41:41things like, uh, though, make sure you're writing down the serial numbers for your laptops. So like
- 41:47things that you own, like, you don't think about those until you really need it. But like, if you need,
- 41:50if it's lost, you need to file a police report, you need the serial number. And like, maybe you can
- 41:54go back to your, you know, your email from Apple when you bought it and things like that and grab it
- 41:57from there. But like, it's easier if you just have a Google sheet that has a serial number. You
- 42:01can say, John was assigned the serial number. Unfortunately, he left it in a cab and we don't know
- 42:05where it is. You know, we had to file a police report so we can like, you know, potentially get it
- 42:09back in the future. I love that. Um, if people want to, if people want to, I think a lot of people
- 42:16know a lot about GoFundMe. But if they want to go find more about GoFundMe, go find more about
- 42:20Classy, what you're working on there. Or if they want to connect with you, where should they go?
- 42:23The socials website, all that. Yeah. So I, uh, I have a personal blog, which I haven't written
- 42:28on it many, many years, but I know I got to like, I got to build that brand out. And I need to like,
- 42:35I need to, I need something to kind of kick me in the pants to like, hey, you need to get back to
- 42:38blogging. I have like 50, you know, one paragraph blog posts that I've started. Uh, man,
- 42:43so let this be the, let this be the, the, the inception of a personal brand. Yeah. So, uh, so,
- 42:49so JT downy.com. So, uh, uh, uh, John and then T downy. So JT downy, uh, then from there,
- 42:56you can find my master on link and my link didn't stuff like that. I've since gotten off the
- 43:00Bloomberg, uh, and moved on to, uh, there's actually a, a master on, uh, or a fediverse thing called
- 43:05InfoSec Exchange. There was a lot of great security content out on there. No, it's amazing. Okay,
- 43:10perfect. And, um, I ask everybody this to close it out. Uh, so you've had an incredible career,
- 43:15spent multiple companies, obviously, very successful. Um, but at this point in your career, um,
- 43:20what does success mean to you? Yeah, I mean, so for me, success is being happy with what I do,
- 43:27like day to day and like helping like make an impact. So I, you know, I think from me personally,
- 43:32like, the, uh, I, I was very fortunate to be at PayPal and, you know, kind of be acquired and be
- 43:38there during a terrific run up, uh, from in the company, uh, as kind of, you know, finances. So
- 43:43for me, a lot of what I want to do is have the best impact that I can to help people out. So,
- 43:49you know, and I, for me, I joined GoFundMe, like, I used to joke at people like, it wasn't a day
- 43:54they would go by that wouldn't leave, uh, just crying about something because it's, there's so much
- 43:59emotion wrapped up in the site. There's so many great stories, so many things that go on in the
- 44:02world. And GoFundMe is a place where you can find that and you can kind of find people to connect
- 44:07with who are in need and, you know, you can help them out. And like, that's, it's a great part of
- 44:12the website.