Latest / Newcomer Pod / How Tech's San Francisco Values Gave Way to the Right
Transcript
- 0:00Early Internet era industries are dying.
- 0:02Like was there a sense the city was like, please, we need you or
- 0:05or not? No, no, no.
- 0:07But so no, we would throw huge parties like, you know, we did
- 0:11some really fancy stuff at the. Conferences well and we.
- 0:14And and so that so that fed the, you know, that kind of created
- 0:18the impression, you know, of like, you know, spending all
- 0:21this money, you know, which we were, but, you know, it was all
- 0:24sponsor money anyway. So I was very upset about that.
- 0:27And so I wrote this long letter to The Washington Post.
- 0:30You could at least correct these factual errors and but then 911
- 0:34so. On the podcast A History of San
- 0:36Francisco, it is defining the Nation Today with companies like
- 0:41Open AI and Anthropic threatening to destroy every job
- 0:44in the world. Jonathan Weber, the newcomers
- 0:46editor at large, former editor in chief of the Industry
- 0:49Standard and the San Francisco Standard, and a top tech editor
- 0:52at Reuters, He's seen it all, is out with a new book on the
- 0:55history of San Francisco and what tech did to it.
- 0:58That book City on the On the Edge.
- 1:00He comes on the show just as audiences are booing
- 1:04commencement speakers. Interesting.
- 1:08In the book, he captures the disconnect between the
- 1:11technology set and the rest of us, and we start off the episode
- 1:15talking about why people are so sour on what San Francisco is
- 1:19building right now. This is the Newcomer podcast
- 1:22hosted by me, Eric Newcomer, author and creator of The
- 1:24Newcomer Substack. Find us at newcomer.co for
- 1:26insider's look into venture capital and everything going on
- 1:29in Silicon Valley. Literally this week, Eric
- 1:37Schmidt, you know, the former CEO of Google is getting booed
- 1:42during a commencement speech for talking about AI and sort of the
- 1:46coming disruption. So I wanted to take sort of, you
- 1:50know, from thinking about the history of the tech industry,
- 1:52what, what do you make of sort of how out of touch the tech
- 1:56executives are or I'm, you know, once out of touch, but also, you
- 1:59know, I'm an AI sympathetic. Yeah.
- 2:02What do you make of him getting booed on stage?
- 2:05Yeah, well, that was was quite dramatic to see.
- 2:08And I, I do want to say first of all, thanks Eric for for having
- 2:12me here. It's been a great pleasure to
- 2:14work with you over the years in various capacities.
- 2:17Yeah. No, we've had you on the
- 2:18podcast. We've had you on an earlier
- 2:20iteration in the podcast. Right.
- 2:21Yeah, very. No, I don't think so.
- 2:23This is our first, first I think our.
- 2:25Podcast appearance. I love it.
- 2:26Here. We are in New York City.
- 2:28Yeah, so, so that's very exciting.
- 2:30I really appreciate it. And it's been a lot of fun to
- 2:33work on this book alongside working with you and, and, and
- 2:37seeing how the AI industry has developed.
- 2:40A lot of that post dates the kind of conclusion of the book.
- 2:43The book really ends in 24, but it certainly looks ahead at at
- 2:48at the AI developments and and the theme that we see kind of
- 2:54coming to a certain kind of fruition with Eric Schmidt being
- 2:57booed is really a shift, very dramatic shift in popular
- 3:02sentiment towards technology, towards towards the industry and
- 3:05towards Silicon Valley, which is kind of the metaphor for the
- 3:08industry. And historically America is a is
- 3:13a techno optimist country, right?
- 3:15We believe in in technology as a means of making the world a
- 3:19better place, making our lives better.
- 3:22That was certainly true in the 1990s, which is when the book
- 3:26starts and kind of the beginning of the commercial Internet, the
- 3:29rise of the World Wide Web. And the culture in San Francisco
- 3:33at the time was was a very kind of effervescent, very optimistic
- 3:37culture. We're going to change the world
- 3:39with technology. We're going to make the world a
- 3:40better place. And then over the course of 30
- 3:44years, you know, that kind of that had an arc to it and, and a
- 3:49lot of those hopes and dreams from the beginning were really
- 3:53ended in disappointment. And I think now with, with AI,
- 3:59we have a real, you know, real cynicism about, about tech and,
- 4:04and, and A, and a kind of distrust of the elites who are
- 4:09kind of selling this tech to us. Which is not a San Francisco
- 4:13specific thing. It's, you know, across the
- 4:15United States. The United States in particular
- 4:18feels like, relative to some, to like developing countries.
- 4:22The US in particular seems very anxious about artificial
- 4:25intelligence. Yeah, I think, I think that's
- 4:27true. And I, and I do think it's very
- 4:31related to the political dynamics in the country
- 4:34actually, because I think that, and you certainly see this in
- 4:37San Francisco, where the rise of AI essentially coincided with a
- 4:43big political shift where the, the tech industry had
- 4:47traditionally been a, a fairly capital D democratic industry,
- 4:51certainly committed to kind of liberal social values.
- 4:56And that sort of flipped in the, in the Trump era.
- 4:59And you have the rise of a, of a cadre of right wing tech
- 5:03executives. And, and they've been very, very
- 5:06dismissive of, of public concerns about, about AI, about
- 5:10the job impacts and environmental impacts and other
- 5:13things. They're very, very dismissive of
- 5:15that. And I think that that is a huge
- 5:17error and and is part of what's contributed to the public
- 5:20backlash. I mean, I think one thing that
- 5:23people need to understand going into this conversation today,
- 5:28you know, we're pretty sloppy at newcomer between Silicon Valley
- 5:31and San Francisco because Silicon Valley sort of moved up.
- 5:35They're like, Oh yeah, you know, there are a lot of the venture
- 5:38firms spend a lot of their time in San Francisco.
- 5:40The junior partners want to be there. start-ups are, you know,
- 5:43building there. Of course, some of the bigger
- 5:46companies then leave. But you know, like the zeitgeist
- 5:49is San Francisco. But when the book starts,
- 5:53there's Silicon Valley with Apple that's booming, and San
- 5:57Francisco has some, you know, a few quirky tech companies.
- 6:02Or how would you describe San Francisco in the beginning of
- 6:05the Internet era? Yeah.
- 6:06So if you so 1990, it's essentially when the book
- 6:10begins, there really isn't a tech industry in San Francisco
- 6:14at all. I mean, there, there's one or
- 6:16two tiny companies I talk about a, an outfit called Jasmine
- 6:20Technologies that made hard disk drives, but that was essentially
- 6:24it. There was no substantial
- 6:25companies. We're no substantial companies.
- 6:29Technology was a Silicon Valley thing.
- 6:30It was S it was an hour to the South.
- 6:33It was a different world. It was very much a, a kind of
- 6:36government driven, military driven technology industry
- 6:40historically. So the Silicon and Silicon
- 6:43Valley, the chip industry was government driven at the
- 6:47beginning. And so it was a very different
- 6:50culture, a very different world. San Francisco was in a it's kind
- 6:54of post counterculture period. It was coming out of some pretty
- 6:59pretty rough economic and and cultural times in the in the 70s
- 7:04and the 80s. People have been like killed,
- 7:05right? I mean, obviously politicians
- 7:07have been killed and a sort of radical.
- 7:10Dramatic, you know, after that there was sort of the, the
- 7:13Summer of love in the 60s. And then the 70s were just a
- 7:16very traumatic time in the city. There was the assassinations of
- 7:21of George Moscone and Harvey Milk in City Hall by a by a
- 7:24former policeman and and it was a very, very fraught time.
- 7:30There was the zebra killings. There.
- 7:32I'd never heard of that before. Killings were basically black
- 7:37people were killing randomly, shooting white people on the
- 7:40streets, a small band of of black guys and.
- 7:44For ideological reasons or. Yeah, it was, it was a little
- 7:47bit unclear, but yeah, you know, revolution, you know, and there
- 7:50was the Black Panthers in Oakland and they were then Patty
- 7:53Hearst was kidnapped. So there was all of that, you
- 7:56know. And so so the 70s were a time of
- 7:58kind of big trauma in a way. And then that sort of calmed
- 8:03down a little bit in the in the 80s.
- 8:05But the but the economy of the city was a very was a real mixed
- 8:09bag. You know, there was tourism was
- 8:11strong, but all the manufacturing was going away.
- 8:14You know, there used to been, you know, steel mills and other
- 8:17kinds of manufacturing that was all going away.
- 8:19The Navy was going away. And so the so the economy was
- 8:22kind of weak, but the culture sure was very rich.
- 8:26So there. Was one thing that stood out to
- 8:28me about Jasmine as you were just describing it as, you know,
- 8:31customer obsessed. You know, they're they're making
- 8:33like what external hard drives effectively for the Mac.
- 8:36But but it's like, oh, these are sort of they're, they're just
- 8:38very worried about their customer and sort of build a
- 8:41brand in a way that almost felt like not about, you know, even
- 8:44sort of making money necessarily.
- 8:47Yeah, that's right. Yeah.
- 8:48True. Like it was just, it feels like
- 8:50everybody's ruled by, you know, optimizing for money these days
- 8:55it. Yeah, and it really was very
- 8:57different in that regard. Like so as the 90s wore on and
- 9:03the web was created, you know, so the web didn't exist before
- 9:07the early 90s. I mean, the Internet did, but
- 9:09the web started in the early 90s and the web, the 1st website as
- 9:15we know it really was probably hotwired.
- 9:18So at Wired magazine, they were not only writing about this
- 9:21stuff, but they were also actually inventing the website
- 9:24as we know it in the banner ad and and other things.
- 9:26So it was a very kind of creative moment and there was a
- 9:29lot going on. And so as, as it proceeded
- 9:33through the 90s, people became aware that like, oh, you know,
- 9:36maybe there's like money in this.
- 9:38So that was interesting to, to to some people, certainly, but
- 9:42it was not really the main driver for most people through
- 9:47that early period. And it was really more the
- 9:50possibility of doing something really cool and really
- 9:53interesting and that, you know, that was the main motivator.
- 9:57And then in the late 90s you had so Netscape went public and that
- 10:02sort of in in the mid 90s, I want to say 90, five, I always
- 10:08get this year mixed up 9495. But Netscape went public and
- 10:12that was kind of the starting gun for like, Oh my God, you
- 10:14know, there's money, money to be made.
- 10:16There's money to be made here. So so that started to change the
- 10:21dynamic a little bit, right? That was Marc Andreessen's
- 10:23company. So Marc Andreessen had been a
- 10:26graduate student at the University of Illinois at the
- 10:28supercomputer center there. And then together with
- 10:32colleagues, they had written a web browser called Mosaic, which
- 10:36sort of advanced the kind of protocols originally developed
- 10:41by Tim Berners Lee for the World Wide Web.
- 10:43So there. So the Mosaic browser was the
- 10:46first tool for mere mortals to use the Internet.
- 10:50And. And so then Jim Clark, who was a
- 10:53frustrated entrepreneur who had, who had started Silicon Graphics
- 10:58and then been kicked out by his board and had a huge chip on his
- 11:01shoulder about proving himself and he saw the mosaic and he
- 11:08called Marc Andreessen. Mark came to Silicon Valley.
- 11:12They agreed to start a company together, originally called
- 11:14Mosaic Communications, actually, but then for trademark reasons,
- 11:18they had to change that. There was a lot of litigation
- 11:22etcetera. It didn't ultimately matter too
- 11:24much. But so they started Netscape and
- 11:26that was kind of the first sort of Internet company as as we
- 11:30think about that did. San Francisco, invite the tech
- 11:34industry in like you think in the beginning, you know, early
- 11:38Internet era. It's like industries are dying.
- 11:41Like was there a sense the city was like please, we need you or
- 11:45or not? No.
- 11:46No, no, so, no. So the city was like very
- 11:49disconnected. You know, one of the strange
- 11:51things through the whole book is like there's, there's a, there's
- 11:54quite a bit of disconnect really between the city government and
- 11:57the industry. So the city was like practically
- 12:00not even aware of what was going on.
- 12:03And so there were a lot of people, you know, just
- 12:05individuals and creative people, techies, different kinds of
- 12:08artists and stuff who would commandeered like these
- 12:11abandoned warehouses and soma and stuff.
- 12:13And they were just kind of doing stuff.
- 12:15I mean, Wired showed up and these, I mean, South Park was
- 12:18still kind of a dangerous neighborhood actually back then,
- 12:21but but you could rent space for $0.50 a square foot.
- 12:25And so people just kind of started doing stuff.
- 12:28And the, and the, the reason that it was happening in the
- 12:32city was because the people who were creating it were the
- 12:35creative types who wanted to be in the city.
- 12:39They did not want to be living in boring Silicon Valley
- 12:43because. And part of this is the Mac and
- 12:46the idea that you could use a mouse and there are graphical
- 12:48interfaces and images were going on the Internet.
- 12:51All of a sudden, what had been sort of the nerdy domain of
- 12:54chips was now opened up to sort of the designers and other
- 12:58people in San Francisco. Exactly.
- 13:00So tech became a somewhat different kind of thing.
- 13:03It wasn't just about the hard science, about the physics and
- 13:06the engineering now, about the design and the creative
- 13:09expression and the writing. You know, the web is, you know,
- 13:13EV Williams, the CEO of Twitter, said this to me, you know, that
- 13:16that Silicon Valley was, you know, about chips and, and the
- 13:19web, you know, was something different.
- 13:20The web was about writing and arts and expression, you know,
- 13:23So it was quite different. And that was much more of a San
- 13:26Francisco zone of expertise, as it were, than than it was in
- 13:31Silicon Valley. We'll keep in our timeline, but
- 13:34it is interesting in this present moment, if you're
- 13:37bullish on sort of AI coding and that means that machines are
- 13:42more able to be commanded basically with plain English.
- 13:45You do have to wonder if like, oh, what will happen if
- 13:48similarly a new set of people is able to sort of shape the
- 13:52future. Like what, what pockets of the
- 13:54world will embrace tech in sort of a in a different way?
- 13:58Yeah, well. I mean, I certainly, you know,
- 14:00an optimistic case around AI would be that it will, it will
- 14:03liberate the creative, the creative impulses and, and, and
- 14:08really elevate creativity above the sort of mere mechanics of
- 14:12programming a computer. So.
- 14:16San Francisco city government sort of oblivious to, you know,
- 14:19that I mean what EFF and people are coming up, you know, all
- 14:23sort of these people see the Internet coming or doing
- 14:25creative things, building out forums, building websites.
- 14:29When we we talked about Netscape going public being the moment
- 14:34sort of is that when San Francisco sort of wakes up that
- 14:36there's if there's money, there's a tax base or when's it
- 14:41start changing? When's it start registering, I
- 14:44guess with politicians? Yeah, well.
- 14:45I I think it really was in the in the latter part of the 90s.
- 14:49So Willie Brown was elected mayor in in 95.
- 14:54He took office 96. Willie was a was a a brilliant
- 15:00politic is still he's 91 years old, still a brilliant
- 15:05politician take. Some of the credit for Kamala
- 15:08Harris, right? Yeah.
- 15:09I mean, he was, yeah, she was his protege.
- 15:12I mean, Willie is responsible for the political careers of
- 15:15essentially everyone in San Francisco at the moment.
- 15:18He's. About.
- 15:19Gavin Newsom is also, I wouldn't call quite call him a Willie
- 15:23protege, but certainly Willie was instrumental in his in his
- 15:26rise. Yeah, anyway.
- 15:29Willie Brown I just wanted to for people I I, I think it's
- 15:32worth saying you know, San Francisco with the boom of AI is
- 15:37obviously poised to shape the entire country as we're now
- 15:39touching on some of the San Francisco politicians could be
- 15:42coming to you soon, America. So I do think why should you
- 15:47consume an episode very focused on San Francisco and then go
- 15:50read a book very focused on San Francisco.
- 15:53It's because San Francisco is making a lot of the calls that
- 15:56are going to shape your life. And anyway, so to go back, why
- 16:00should people care about Willie Brown?
- 16:03We explained it. It's like, OK, bringing up some
- 16:05of the big politicians. You were getting into how he
- 16:08recognized the tech industry. Yeah.
- 16:10And so Willie, you know, for those who aren't, aren't
- 16:14familiar with him, I mean, he's probably, you know, among the
- 16:16greatest politicians in American history, literally.
- 16:19I mean, he, you know, he was born a poor kid and a segregated
- 16:23town in Texas and, and from there, you know, rose to be
- 16:28longtime speaker of the California Assembly before he
- 16:30was the mayor and very, very powerful, very, very shrewd guy.
- 16:34Brilliant, brilliant guy. And, and so Willie was elected
- 16:39mayor in 90, in 95, he took offs in 96.
- 16:42The boom, the Internet boom started to kind of really take
- 16:46off in sort of 97. And Willie being a shrewd guy,
- 16:50started to notice that there was something going on here that he
- 16:54kind of needed to be aware of a little bit.
- 16:57And he, he still didn't really understand it really, but he had
- 17:01a little bit of a sense. And there's a there's a
- 17:04hilarious story in the book, you know, where so at one point, you
- 17:08know, some shrewd, like stockbroker at Morgan Stanley
- 17:12was like, hey, but Mr. Mayor, you know, you want to make a
- 17:15little money on, on some, you know, dot coms.
- 17:17And like, this was an era when the so the dot coms were going
- 17:21public often with very little revenue or much of A business,
- 17:26but it was a real bubble moment. And so if you could buy shares
- 17:30at the opening price, that was guaranteed profit.
- 17:33And so that was kind of used as currency to pay people off in
- 17:37different ways. So, so this guy was given given
- 17:41some shares to Willie and he had to report that as part of his
- 17:44mayoral financial disclosures. And so at first he denied any
- 17:48special access. He was just another day trader,
- 17:52you know, it was all pretty, pretty funny.
- 17:54And he made a little bit of money on that.
- 17:55But but Willie was, you know, he was shrewd.
- 17:57So he saw, you know, that that something was coming here and he
- 18:01started to pay a little bit of attention to the industry.
- 18:04But it was still, you know, relatively small beer.
- 18:08Like even in the late, even at the peakofthe.com boom, as a
- 18:12percentage of the city's economy, it was still fairly
- 18:15small, you know, maybe 1010%, something like that.
- 18:17So the, the politicians, you know, mostly, mostly had other
- 18:22concerns, you know. A fun element of the book.
- 18:25You start off your reporter at the Los Angeles Times assigned
- 18:30by now famous Marty Baron to go to San Francisco when many in
- 18:35the media class didn't get the importance of the tech industry
- 18:38and it was fairly boring. By.com, you're running, you're
- 18:43the editor of the Industry Standard, which was one of, if
- 18:47not the sort of like, for good and bad, synonymous with the.com
- 18:52bust and boom. What?
- 18:56Yeah, what? I guess tell us thestoryof.com
- 19:00through sort of a little bit of the story of your time at the
- 19:04Industry Standard. OK, sure.
- 19:06So, so I was working at the LA Times and I was recruited.
- 19:09I got a call from a recruiter to who is working on behalf of John
- 19:13Battelle, who was starting a new magazine, a weekly business
- 19:18magazine about the digital economy.
- 19:20It didn't have a name at the time.
- 19:22And he had been been referred to me and he had been hired by
- 19:27IDGA, big trade publisher to create this new magazine.
- 19:31So, so I talked to John and he was, you know, he was clearly a
- 19:36super smart guy and, and it was very controversial decision in a
- 19:41way to leave the LA Times at that time.
- 19:43Like, so when I finally decided to take the job, you know,
- 19:47people looked at me like, is it? Such a good job.
- 19:50Well, cuz the in the 90s, you know, the LA Times was, was
- 19:53among the top papers in the country.
- 19:56You know, big newspapers were the place to be if you were an
- 19:59ambitious journalist. There were three or four top
- 20:02papers, New York Times, Washington Post, LA Times.
- 20:05So if you were an up and Comer with a good job at the LA Times,
- 20:08you were kind of. On the top track of the
- 20:11profession. So why would you leave that for
- 20:14a weird start up trade thing, huh?
- 20:16What? You know, but it was somewhat
- 20:19obvious to me, honestly, I was had the chance to build a build
- 20:24a magazine and I could and I knew that tech was a big story.
- 20:27I mean, I, I was the tech editor at the LA Times.
- 20:30I had started a section. I'd convinced the bosses that
- 20:34tech was really a thing. There would be advertisers and
- 20:37we should do a little weekly tech section in the paper, which
- 20:40which we did. It was called the Cutting edge.
- 20:42I was very proud of that. So I knew there was a big story
- 20:46there. And, and then, you know, I, I
- 20:49quite like John after a number of conversations and he hired
- 20:52me. And so we, so then I went out
- 20:55and hired a bunch of people. There was a little work going on
- 20:57with a prototype when I got there and then hired up initial
- 21:01staff, 15 or 20 people. And it was funny, we launched in
- 21:0498 in the spring and, and it's, it's hard to get traction for
- 21:07new magazines. It, it, it's very expensive.
- 21:10And, and at the beginning, you know, we weren't really going
- 21:15anywhere. Like the, we didn't have much of
- 21:17A circulation strategy. IDG didn't want to spend the
- 21:21money for paid circulation. And, and also it was hard to
- 21:25compete like we had inexperienced reporters.
- 21:28We are pretty small. We're trying to compete with the
- 21:30Wall Street Journal, you know, so like getting the big scoops
- 21:32that would really put us on the map was not that easy.
- 21:36So the first six months were kind of a struggle and, and we
- 21:39were under a lot of pressure from IDG.
- 21:41Like they were going to shut us down.
- 21:43They, you know, they didn't like the name.
- 21:45They didn't, they didn't like a lot of things.
- 21:48And it became clear that John and Pat McGovern, the owner of
- 21:51IDG, had very different visions for what this thing would be.
- 21:55So there was a lot of stress. But then like just kind of
- 22:01overnight, like we were confident.
- 22:03We were like, we know this is going to work, you know, And
- 22:06then just bam, like what was the?
- 22:09Core story type or what resonated?
- 22:11Well, you know, the core story type was basically news analysis
- 22:17about these new.com companies. So there would be, you know, we
- 22:22would have some scoops on. Oh, you know, here's I remember
- 22:25one of our early scoops was the formation of a company called
- 22:29drugstore.com. You know, Kleiner Perkins was
- 22:32gonna put a bunch of money in and, you know, create this
- 22:34company, you know, So that was a, that was a big, it was.
- 22:37Covering the business. It was covering well in at
- 22:39first, right? It was covering the business of
- 22:42like the businessof.com, you know, So that was sort of the
- 22:44heart of it. But then it was part of that
- 22:48whole thing was the idea that this isn't just about like,
- 22:52you're gonna have a.com. It's like the Internet is going
- 22:55to change business as we know it.
- 22:57That's gonna change everything, you know?
- 22:59So as we went on, we started to write more about bigger picture
- 23:02stuff, you know, the Internet and politics and the Internet
- 23:05and culture and this. What I'm about to use is a
- 23:07loaded expression in the context of San Francisco.
- 23:10But did you drink the Kool-aid like was?
- 23:14Well, you know that. That's a great question because
- 23:17you know, by disposition and, and, and you know, by
- 23:20profession, I, I mean, I'm a journalist and I've always been
- 23:23a skeptical, I've been a skeptical journalist.
- 23:25I kind of my, my job is to kind of ask questions and, and, and
- 23:30sort of poke at the soft spots of the story, whatever it is.
- 23:33And so when I, when I was talking to John about what I
- 23:37would do if I were editor of this new magazine and I, and I
- 23:41told him that I thought what was really needed was for a
- 23:45publication and journalism, they really played against the hype,
- 23:48you know, because it was all, you know, hype.
- 23:50But people really want to know like what's real and what's not.
- 23:53So we positioned as the skeptics, we're going to cut
- 23:56through the hype. We had like our slogans, like
- 23:5999.9% hype free. That was what that was one of
- 24:03our T-shirts, I think, you know, so, and, and if you read the,
- 24:07you know, the tone of the editorial, I mean, if you read
- 24:09the magazine from back then, we were very much like that.
- 24:12You know, we were very tough, very, very critical.
- 24:17And that formula proved very successful.
- 24:20People really did like that for the reasons that I thought they
- 24:23would, which is that when there's tons of hype, you want
- 24:26to know what's real. And then, but then we were so
- 24:30successful that we we became a symbol of the hype, right?
- 24:33So we were like, you're just overspending.
- 24:35Like what happened like? What did you what?
- 24:36Did you do well? It was to me employees.
- 24:40Well, so we had these parties, you know, so we started having
- 24:42party. We, we had beer and chips for
- 24:44the staff. So the magazine closed at 2:00
- 24:47on Friday afternoon. We shipped the last pages and
- 24:50then we would have beer and chips for the staff on the roof.
- 24:53Then we started inviting people. Then a lot of people started
- 24:56coming. Then companies wanted to
- 24:58sponsor, you know, So then it became like, you know, gourmet
- 25:01booze and, you know, fancy food sponsored by HP, you know, come
- 25:06to the rooftop. And then there'd be a line out
- 25:08the door and then there, you know, then we started having the
- 25:10rooftop at bigger venues and it's amazing.
- 25:12That HP has been fueling the events business like course
- 25:16sponsors. Not not this year, but my
- 25:20events. It was like such a huge time
- 25:23gap, I. Remember totally that that one
- 25:25of the we had a rooftop, A rooftop, standard rooftop at
- 25:29Bimbos nightclub, which is a very large club, you know, and
- 25:33this place was packed out, all sponsored by HP, you know, top
- 25:37shelf booze, you know, everything.
- 25:39So that stuff, you know, and then we had a conference
- 25:41business and the conferences also were just tremendously
- 25:45successful, you know, so we would sell out these
- 25:47conferences, 3 or $4000 tickets, you know, for three days at a
- 25:50fancy resort and sponsors paying 100 grand, you know, so it was
- 25:54very lucrative. And then in association with
- 25:57that, we would throw huge parties.
- 25:59You know, we did some really fancy stuff at the conferences.
- 26:02And. So that so that fed the, you
- 26:05know, that kind of created the impression, you know, of like,
- 26:08ah, you know, spending all this money, you know, which we were,
- 26:11but you know, it was all sponsor money.
- 26:14What? What is the?
- 26:14Lesson I need to learn from this or you know what?
- 26:17How similar does this moment feel to the.com?
- 26:22I would say it feels a little bit similar.
- 26:24Yeah, it does feel a little bit similar.
- 26:26I mean, there's there's, you know, there's a big kind of
- 26:29disconnect between, you know, the amount of money, you know,
- 26:33that's going into these companies and the sort of
- 26:35evidence, you know, business that they have to justify that
- 26:39amount of money. So, so that certainly feels
- 26:43quite similar and I feel. Like all this sort of like, I
- 26:47don't know, decadence gets written in after the fact,
- 26:51right? Things that just seem sort sort
- 26:54of normal then when you have to write a narrative are decadent.
- 26:58I don't know. Do you really think there are
- 26:59these times that are like drastically more decadent than
- 27:03others or people just zero in to like this?
- 27:05I mean, there's some. Better parties.
- 27:07I, I do think, you know, to me, and maybe I'm just older and not
- 27:12in, you know, the same, same rooms, but you know, it, I don't
- 27:15see the, the visible decadence isn't quite as extreme as it was
- 27:19in the in the.com area. You know, I think people are a
- 27:21little more conscious of at least, you know, keeping that
- 27:24inside maybe, you know, the Super decadent parts.
- 27:28Yeah. Soyouknow.com crashes, but San
- 27:32Francisco is not so dependent on the tech industry that that sort
- 27:38of ruins the place or anything. Yeah.
- 27:39Well, so after 9, you know, 911 Oh I.
- 27:43Love the I love the moment. What you you were complaining
- 27:47about your how someone had covered you or something you
- 27:51asked for like a correction. And then like you said it
- 27:54September 10th and it's like whatever.
- 27:57So it captures the moment that like September 11th, you know,
- 28:00obviously horrible reoriented all culture, but it was sort of
- 28:03like declare bankruptcy on everything you cared about
- 28:06before then and just like move on.
- 28:07What was the what was the quibble or I forget what you
- 28:10were fighting about? Yeah.
- 28:11Well, the so when we we went bankrupt with with a loud a
- 28:16bang, it was quite a surprise to most people, including me.
- 28:22The we still had a lot of money in the bank.
- 28:25There was a game of chicken between the two factions on the
- 28:28board, and I thought surely they would come to an agreement, but
- 28:32they didn't. And we went bankrupt and the
- 28:36bankruptcy. So we were a symbol of the end
- 28:39of the.com era. And so people had, you know, the
- 28:42the market had crashed in the spring of 2000.
- 28:45It took about a year for all that to play through.
- 28:48So by the middle of 2001, like it was just a meltdown out
- 28:53there, you know, and it was clearthatthe.com party was over.
- 28:58But there hadn't been a good event to symbolize it, and so we
- 29:02were that event. So the bankruptcy, the industry
- 29:04standard became a symbol of the end of the.com era.
- 29:08And so there was a lot of press. So we have gotten a lot of press
- 29:11on the way up, you know, the most successful magazine, new
- 29:15magazine in history, blah, blah, you know.
- 29:17And so that's fun, you know, and then on the way down, you kind
- 29:20of get the other side of it. As I say in the book, it was now
- 29:23our turn in the barrel. And so there was a lot of very
- 29:27critical press and one story in particular that really pissed me
- 29:32off, which was a a style section story in the Washington Post by
- 29:35Sharon Waxman, who now runs the rap.
- 29:38And and it was just the easiest, like, oh, they blew all their
- 29:42money on parties and now they're, you know, getting what
- 29:45they deserve kind of tone and, and it just really, really
- 29:50rankled. Yeah.
- 29:51And there were a lot of errors, you know, there, there were a
- 29:53dozen errors and it you know, and it like relied super heavily
- 29:56on like low level people who didn't know anything about what
- 29:59was going on, but who she happened to know, you know, and
- 30:02then. 9/11 happened. You never got.
- 30:04It was in the Washington Post. It was in the.
- 30:06Washington Post and, and I, you know, I wrote this long letter,
- 30:10you know, about how like, you know, the story was unfair.
- 30:13Well, the other thing that made me really mad actually, was that
- 30:16this was really the real thing. Is that a principle that I've
- 30:19always adhered to as a journalist?
- 30:21Is that anonymous blind quote, like blind quotes that are
- 30:27personally critical of someone are not allowed, you know, So if
- 30:30you want to be a, if you want to be personal about somebody's bad
- 30:35actions, you got to put your name behind it.
- 30:38And so the story was full of anonymous quotes from IDG
- 30:42executives blaming me and John for the failure, like they owned
- 30:47the company, you know, and blaming management, you know.
- 30:50So anyway, so I was very upset about that.
- 30:53And so I wrote this long letter to the Washington Post so that
- 30:56you could at least correct these factual errors.
- 30:58And but then 911, so the tech. Industry loves to talk about
- 31:01this idea that whenever you see the media cover the thing you
- 31:04actually know a lot about, you become disillusioned with media.
- 31:08And in some ways this is sort of what you're saying.
- 31:10You got covered and you were disillusioned.
- 31:12There was another moment in the book.
- 31:14Let's step out of time in archaeology here for a second.
- 31:17Where you're at Burning Man, which is another big character
- 31:22in or place of importance in the book outside of San Francisco,
- 31:26but created and populated by San Francisco people.
- 31:29And, you know, there's like terrible, like mud storm where
- 31:33like there it rains really badly and then there's so much mud and
- 31:36everybody who wanted to get out early was sort of inconvenience.
- 31:39But the media makes it seem like people are like starving and all
- 31:42the rich people are suffering. And and it basically was one of
- 31:45these cases where like don't let a good story get in the way of
- 31:49the facts sort of situation. It's like, oh, people want the
- 31:52shortened fraud and don't really reporters don't don't check it
- 31:55too good, too good to check. I don't know, like you're
- 31:58professionally in media yet in these two sort of pivotal
- 32:02moments where you're in the news, you're, you know, you have
- 32:04a negative experience. Like, I don't know what is what
- 32:07is your gloss on sort of such a big question?
- 32:12I'm trying to narrow it for you. But yeah, what do you make of
- 32:14those 22 incidents, Right? Well, I think that, you know,
- 32:19certainly in the, I mean, the first instance I think of really
- 32:26as just a good lesson in sort of feeling, you know, as a
- 32:30journalist, it was it was very educational to be on the other
- 32:34side of it and not. All media is the same, like some
- 32:37of the coverage was fair and some was well.
- 32:38Exactly, And and so that was really more my you know, my take
- 32:43away was not that Oh my God, you know, the media is all fucked
- 32:47up. But but more like, yeah, you
- 32:49know, this can really turn against you sometimes in in ways
- 32:53that you don't expect and you can't really control.
- 32:56And and that's very frustrating and kind of upsetting.
- 33:01You know, I thought that on bounce.
- 33:04You know, as I think I also mentioned in there, you know,
- 33:07there was that story that I hated.
- 33:08But, you know, the, the Wall Street Journal did a very long
- 33:11story about, you know, the, the, the end by Matthew Rose, who's
- 33:17still around. And that was a very good story.
- 33:20You know, it was very accurate. It was, it was a little painful
- 33:23to read, but you know, it was accurate.
- 33:27You know, the Burning Man thing, you know, I, I see as a little
- 33:32bit like, I guess I draw a distinction in, in, in media
- 33:35terms there. There's sort of the kind of mass
- 33:40market, you know, popular media around, you know, television and
- 33:45celebrities and this kind of stuff, which which is not
- 33:49something that I've been too involved in.
- 33:51And, you know, I've always considered that to be a like a
- 33:53slightly different realm of from the journalism that I do.
- 33:59And, and I think in the case of Burning Man, it was very much
- 34:02kind of caught up in that sort of, oh, that sort of celebrity
- 34:05media world, you know, where the facts aren't really the point,
- 34:09you know, and, and so that kind of stuff is, is not not very
- 34:14inspiring to to see I. I want in our chronology, let's
- 34:17skip to sort of Twitter's rise because Twitter becomes very
- 34:21important to San Francisco. What that's where?
- 34:27Is this like 2014 era or Yeah. Sort of early 2000 tens, yeah,
- 34:31yeah. Why?
- 34:32Why is Twitter in particular, such an important company for
- 34:36the city of San Francisco? Well, there are several reasons.
- 34:40First of all, it was actually the biggest of the, I mean, it
- 34:45was the the biggest Internet. In the city.
- 34:49You know they. Didn't build it in San
- 34:51Francisco. Based was not.
- 34:52In, you know, it was S, you know, Google was S, you know, so
- 34:55so Twitter was, was actually in the city.
- 34:58So that was significant. And also, you know what, what
- 35:01Twitter was, I mean, it was and what their kind of philosophy
- 35:04was early on, you know, where the free speech wing and the
- 35:07free speech. And we're going to give, you
- 35:09know, a means of expression to oppressed peoples around the
- 35:13world. And we're going to enable the
- 35:15Arab Spring and we're going to enable the social justice
- 35:18movement. And so all of these things were
- 35:22kind of very consistent with San Francisco values.
- 35:26So, so the company was kind of a good fit for the city and in
- 35:30that way and kind of expressed a certain political zeitgeist of
- 35:34the city. And then it also became a kind
- 35:39of a physical symbol around its building because the the
- 35:42building and the negotiation around that building resulted in
- 35:47a a deal with the city where the city granted a tax break for
- 35:50companies to to locate in that part of the city.
- 35:54And that became known as the Twitter tax break.
- 35:56Twitter was at the center of that discussion.
- 35:58So that's. When that?
- 36:00Helped them really become a symbol of San Francisco, San.
- 36:02Francisco is sort of inviting tech in.
- 36:04It's like if you're giving tax breaks, you want the tech
- 36:07industry there. Well, correct.
- 36:09And so later on, so again in the night, you know, it was a
- 36:12progression. So in the 90's the industry kind
- 36:16of grew up and the book reflects us.
- 36:18So the book at the beginning is sort of more about the growth of
- 36:21the Internet and the the the, the rise of the San Francisco
- 36:26tech community and has a little bit less to do with the
- 36:29politics. And then the politics come more
- 36:32later on, because as once you're big.
- 36:34And there's money to be had. Then the politicians start.
- 36:37Yeah, exactly. So then it starts to become a
- 36:39thing, you know, and it's a big industry.
- 36:42So that started to happen in the in the 2000s.
- 36:44So. So Newsom was mayor during the
- 36:482000s. And Newsom, you know, he saw the
- 36:50tech coming and he wanted to do certain things, but citywide
- 36:55wireless was one of his big ideas.
- 36:57So I write about this in the book and and Gavin, you know,
- 37:00he's he's he's he's an idea volcano as somebody who I spoke
- 37:06to called him and he's he's a smart guy and he has a lot of
- 37:08ideas. He's very bad at the follow
- 37:10through. So that was pretty
- 37:13characteristic. So there is no free citywide
- 37:15wireless and, and many of the other programs that he was
- 37:20excited about didn't, didn't really happen, but it certainly
- 37:23was becoming clear in the 2000s that tech and, and this was sort
- 37:27of the Web 2.0 era, I guess. And, and then at the end of the
- 37:322000s, you really had this new wave of companies starting to
- 37:37come up and that sort of coincided with the Great
- 37:41Recession. So there was a funny dynamic
- 37:44there where the all the, a lot of the jobs in banking and
- 37:48finance and stuff were going away.
- 37:50The city was really hurting, actually the city.
- 37:52Become Wells Fargo, Bank of America.
- 37:54Wells Fargo was important to the city, Yeah.
- 37:58They were very, very important and you know, Schwab and other,
- 38:02you know, financial services was it was big thing.
- 38:04And so the great financial crisis hurt the city in that
- 38:09regard and and tourism, you know, was down.
- 38:12People didn't have money. But then sort of underneath
- 38:16that, without people noticing too much, you know, the, the
- 38:19tech was really starting to, to boil.
- 38:23And then that really started to explode in 2010, two, 1011,
- 38:28where you had a whole new wave of companies.
- 38:30So then you had, you had Twitter and you had Facebook.
- 38:34Google was getting huge. And even though Google wasn't in
- 38:36the city, a lot of people, a lot of Google employees lived in the
- 38:40city. And then and then you had in
- 38:44kind of 2002 thousand, 2010 and 11, you had Uber, Airbnb,
- 38:50Dropbox, you know, so then you have the whole kind of next wave
- 38:54of of companies that grew up in the 2000 tens.
- 38:57There's a lot of them associated with their smartphone and what
- 39:00that enabled now. We're in the era of the open a
- 39:03eyes and anthropics and the labs are, I mean, literally now we.
- 39:07Have now we have another wave. You know, you can think of it as
- 39:10like the you know there was the first wave around the rise of
- 39:14the web. Then you had you had kind of a
- 39:17the web 2 point O phase, the rise of blogging, which you know
- 39:21was very interesting. There was a lot of interesting
- 39:23things happening, although it wasn't quite such a big boom.
- 39:26Then you have the next kind of big boom around the smartphone
- 39:30in the 2000 tens. Then you had COVID and so forth.
- 39:35And now we're in kind of the AI boom, which is yet another era
- 39:39of of growth the I. Mean the housing market in San
- 39:43Francisco is insane are we do is this sort of a Twitter or an X
- 39:47invention or you think it's real.
- 39:49I feel like I see all these listings where housing is like,
- 39:53you know, houses in San Francisco are going for, I don't
- 39:55know, 50% above their value or something.
- 39:58Yeah, well, they're all these. AI employees are getting, yeah.
- 40:01There's a huge amount of money coming in, you know, at the, at
- 40:04the sort of the high end. And, you know, San Francisco's a
- 40:06small city. There hasn't been that much
- 40:08construction, so there isn't that much inventory.
- 40:11And, you know, suddenly, you know, if you have, you know, if,
- 40:15if, if 500 people make enough money, suddenly have enough
- 40:21money to buy, you know, a $10 million house, you know, that's
- 40:25going to change the market. It doesn't take that many
- 40:27people, you know, at that, at those kinds of price points
- 40:31'cause there just aren't that many houses, you know, and the
- 40:35city has done a terrible job. I mean, one of the big crises in
- 40:37San Francisco is that there hasn't been enough housing
- 40:40instruction for decades. So there's very little
- 40:42inventory. And so when you get, you know,
- 40:46an influx of money and influx of people, as you have now with the
- 40:50AI, you know, it's just really sent prices through the roof,
- 40:53both rental and sale prices. And that's a real problem for
- 40:57the city because it, it, it drives out everyone else.
- 41:02And you know, the service workers, you know, you need the
- 41:06service workers both because you need people to work in the
- 41:09restaurants and, and and so forth.
- 41:11But also like the service workers are often a part of the,
- 41:16of the cultural economy, right? So it's, it's kind of a cliche
- 41:20about the, you know, the actor who's waiting tables in the
- 41:22restaurant, right? But that that's a real thing,
- 41:25you know, So if, if that, if that person, you know, can't get
- 41:31the job in the restaurant and there's and and they, you know,
- 41:35theater business is sort of soft like that person is going to
- 41:38move and and then you know this. Is adjacent to sort of the, I
- 41:43think where we might have some disagreement or where I'm
- 41:46interested to tease out. I mean, I think, you know,
- 41:49there's an argument in the book, basically, you know, in the
- 41:52beginning of the Internet, the government sort of funded it.
- 41:55It was these quirky researchers doing fun stuff.
- 41:58There wasn't that much money to be made.
- 41:59They just literally one of the characters in the book wants to
- 42:02go to raves and do drugs. You know, it's like, how do I
- 42:04invite people to do rave, go to raves and do drugs?
- 42:07Like I'll post about it online. Email's not enough.
- 42:10We need forums, you know, and they're so you're having like
- 42:12fun and then, you know, we build real businesses and it's sort of
- 42:16the businesses, I guess, suck out some of the like creativity
- 42:20and like San Francisco Ness of it all do.
- 42:23Why? Why do you think sort of the
- 42:25businesses are sort of killing that sort of spark of joy and
- 42:30creativity? Like that's still possible, Like
- 42:32those people can still go and be creative.
- 42:35Maybe it's more expensive to do in San Francisco, so you move
- 42:37somewhere else. I guess, you know, I to me it
- 42:41reads more just like the ebbs and flows of culture or like
- 42:44people feel driven to do certain things at a given moment.
- 42:48It's like nobody's stopping sort of a creative, quirky person
- 42:51from doing creative quirky stuff today.
- 42:54They're just different sort of cultural moments or.
- 42:58Yeah. Well, that I mean, yeah, you
- 42:59could certainly, certainly argue that, you know, I think that the
- 43:04the incentive structures are very are very different.
- 43:06And you know, these days, if you're, if you're kind of an
- 43:13entrepreneur, if, if you're not optimizing for being successful
- 43:20as a, as a start up and the funding and all of that and the
- 43:25growth and all, you know, the whole package of what you need
- 43:28to be a VC funded startup. Like if you're not doing that,
- 43:31then you're sort of not a serious person.
- 43:33You know, then you're just, oh, you're just a, oh, it's just a
- 43:36lifestyle business or oh, it's just a, you know, you're not
- 43:40really enough to win it. And so not, not a serious
- 43:43person. So there So there's there's kind
- 43:45of a a disrespect towards non entrepreneurial endeavors.
- 43:51So, you know, making, you know, making money with your start up
- 43:55is sort of the prestige thing to do and everything else is just
- 44:00kind of for the lightweights, you know, so that so that I
- 44:03think is different and in an earlier era it's shaped.
- 44:07The culture. The culture has become this
- 44:09pressure to build a better and Better Business.
- 44:12Or. Fundraising vehicle, Yeah.
- 44:15Well, and, and you know, when I, and this is of course super
- 44:20anecdotal, it's very, it's very hard to prove, but, but just in
- 44:23my casual interactions, you know, the, the young, you know,
- 44:27the 20 somethings, they're like really focused on like making
- 44:31this thing work, you know, I mean, they're like, you know,
- 44:33grinding and they want the money and they want, you know, and
- 44:36that's like, that's really a very intense thing and 9:00. 96
- 44:42now, yeah. 996 and you know no time for sex and no time for
- 44:46drinking and no time you know and again, like some of this can
- 44:49be a cliche in its own right and you know I, I don't want to be
- 44:54too categorical about the universal truth of it, but but I
- 44:58think that is a is a thing at this moment that the success in
- 45:03business like making your money it's like now's the moment you
- 45:07know the AI is coming so if you don't do it now like forget it,
- 45:10you know and you and you better get there now 'cause like the
- 45:13kid behind you it's like the last period of the day it's like
- 45:16if. You don't make money now you're
- 45:18life's over here. Exactly.
- 45:20And, and, and I think that, you know, 20 years years ago, it
- 45:24wasn't really like that, you know, like you were excited
- 45:27about your startup, but like it was also like, yeah, I'm going
- 45:31to Burning Man, you know. And so like, you know, if we
- 45:34have to do that after Burning Man, no biggie.
- 45:37You know, like that, you know, it was just a slightly different
- 45:40but significant, I sort of subtle but substantial
- 45:45difference I would say in the in the sort of the attitude of the
- 45:48priority of of kind of making money versus like the rest of
- 45:52life, you know. The I want to get into like the
- 45:57San Francisco politics of it all.
- 45:59I mean, there's a great and and it collides with this sort of
- 46:01capitalism issue we're talking about.
- 46:03But you have like an amazing synthesis right in the beginning
- 46:06of the book. You know, San Francisco has
- 46:09always occupied a special place in the national psyche.
- 46:11The mythic fog shrouded city on the edge of the continent,
- 46:14mesmerizing its beauty, founded by fortune seekers and
- 46:17freethinkers, the birth place of the counterculture and pretender
- 46:20to the title of the greatest city in the world.
- 46:25And then you're sort of like, OK, what?
- 46:27What what a political streak is sort of undermining that.
- 46:31For the right, San Francisco is exhibit #1 for the argument that
- 46:35progressive policies on crime and drugs have ruined Democratic
- 46:38run cities. Among moderate Democrats, San
- 46:41Francisco is a great example of the failures of anti growth
- 46:44liberalism as outlined in the abundance theory popularized by
- 46:49journalists Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson.
- 46:51The progressive left has its diagnosis too.
- 46:54If only the tech companies and the billionaires weren't so
- 46:57greedy, there'd be plenty of resources to solve social
- 47:01problems like homelessness. So which camp are you most
- 47:05sympathetic to? Yeah.
- 47:07Well, you know, when I started this book, I knew that there was
- 47:10going to be a lot of pressure to to blame somebody to, to decide,
- 47:15you know, it's it's it's always easier when you have good guys,
- 47:18bad guys, you know, it's their fault.
- 47:20And I found it very difficult to do that in all honesty.
- 47:23And, and, you know, they say that, you know, success has many
- 47:28fathers, you know, and, and you know, in the same way, I think
- 47:32in this case, like there's plenty of blame to go around,
- 47:35you know, so, so I, I really do think that that each of the, you
- 47:40know, this is an unsatisfying answer to the question, but I,
- 47:42but I think that each of the camps, you know, has a lot to
- 47:45answer for in terms of, of how they've, you know, really not
- 47:49met the moment and, and some of these challenges.
- 47:53What? What is the biggest like failure
- 47:55in San Francisco? Like, I mean, I'm the abundance
- 47:58zone, so I'm, I would say a failure to build, but there are
- 48:01lots of people. If you're, if you're in the
- 48:03degrowth category, I don't know if you stay out of the
- 48:05Tenderloin and don't go downtown, San Francisco's pretty
- 48:09great for the people who can afford it.
- 48:12I don't know what what is your core critique?
- 48:14What has been the failure? Well.
- 48:16I, you know, I think the biggest failure of San Francisco is the,
- 48:20is the inability of the factions to work together better.
- 48:23And, and that, you know, because it is a it is a very wealthy
- 48:28city and the there is a lot of consensus actually around a lot
- 48:37more than you would sort of think based on reading the
- 48:41headlines, you know, about some basic kinds of issues.
- 48:45But the political factions are kind of so dug into their
- 48:50positions, you know, that they won't work together.
- 48:53And that is very, very damaging to the city.
- 48:55And I think that, you know, an example of it that I use in the
- 48:58book is that in terms of the fentanyl problem, right?
- 49:02So, so drugs are are are very, very tough issue.
- 49:06It's very tough issue to deal with, right?
- 49:09You know, many cities, countries, you know, struggled
- 49:12with these problems, right? So you have a fentanyl crisis,
- 49:17people dying in the streets, three people a day.
- 49:20And and so you have on the right, it's like, well, we just
- 49:25need, you know, law and order, just throw everyone in jail, you
- 49:28know, just more cops on the streets, you know, and that'll
- 49:31be that, you know, and then on the other side of the spectrum,
- 49:34you have no, you know, these people are victims and they're
- 49:38sick and we need treatment and we need compassion and, you
- 49:41know, da, da, da. And so those are the entrenched
- 49:45camps now, you know, it is to me, just screamingly obvious
- 49:51that the solution such as one, you know, first of all, there's
- 49:54no like solution there. There's like solutions, you
- 49:58know, ways to mitigate, try to work on the problem lies
- 50:02somewhere in the middle. You need some law enforcement
- 50:05and you need some compassion together.
- 50:07And so they had a program called lead a law enforcement assisted
- 50:12diversion, where they had cops and social workers working
- 50:15together to help the most troubled of these addicts.
- 50:19And but the thing fell apart because the the cops didn't want
- 50:25to work with, you know, where like the social workers are like
- 50:27you, you know, bleeding hearts, you know, don't know that these
- 50:30people are just criminals and you know why we don't even want
- 50:33to deal with you. And then the social workers
- 50:35like, yeah, law enforcement is no answer.
- 50:38You know, we're you pigs. We're not going to work with
- 50:40you, you know, and and so they wouldn't, they refused to
- 50:43cooperate. And so the program fell apart.
- 50:46So so to me that that is a huge failing.
- 50:49So is, I mean the book, you know, the epilogue is Daniel
- 50:53Lurie, the current mayor, but is mostly focused on pre him.
- 50:57Does he just he's solving all these problems.
- 50:59He's the most popular mayor in America.
- 51:01So if there's ever going to be consensus, will he have it or
- 51:05what? What is your read so far on his
- 51:07morality? Well.
- 51:08I think that he has done very well precisely on this point.
- 51:15So he's kind of been able to get a little bit of a like, hey, we
- 51:20actually all kind of agree on certain basic things.
- 51:23So let's kind of can we just kind of do those things for
- 51:26starters. And that's like, you know, the
- 51:29encampments, for example. So, you know, even now, you
- 51:33know, the left and the, a lot of the social workers, you know,
- 51:36feel that the sweeping of encampments is, you know, a
- 51:39nasty thing to do to the people who live there.
- 51:41But if you, you know, in the city, like people are like, no,
- 51:45you know, clearly it's not OK if people live on the sidewalk in
- 51:50tents, you know, So, you know, they've swept the done a lot of
- 51:55sweeping the encampments. That's been pretty popular for
- 51:58the most part. And, and I think that they've
- 52:02been, you know, at the same time done some things on the other
- 52:06side with more treatment and more shelters and not, you know,
- 52:08not been too harshly, you know, kind of clamped down about it.
- 52:13So, so I think he's done a good job with sort of the low hanging
- 52:17fruit, but the big tests are still are still to come.
- 52:22So he's very popular right now. He's got, he's got a very
- 52:25popular man. You know, he's got a good
- 52:27manner. He shows up everywhere, for
- 52:28every ribbon cutting. He smiles, he tells.
- 52:31Everybody, he likes him. He's like, like, you miss this
- 52:33genial? I like the left he likes.
- 52:35Everybody, he's very genial, he's very consistent in that
- 52:39manner. So it's hard for people to grab
- 52:41on to something to dislike about him, you know, so, so I think
- 52:45he's done a good job. You know, it helps him to be a
- 52:47billionaire, honestly. Like, I, I think that, you know,
- 52:51Trump somehow isn't fucking with him very much, maybe because
- 52:56he's also a rich guy and Trump hasn't, he just has like.
- 53:00Totally avoided the ice fight. He like, yeah, he's.
- 53:03Avoided the ice fight you know the the the Presidio thing you
- 53:09know Trump was making noises like he was really going to try
- 53:12to dismantle the Presidio trust and sell off some of that
- 53:15property but that that isn't happening I mean they just
- 53:19appointed the new presidio trust board with Lynn Benioff on there
- 53:22and Trevor trainer I mean that they're not dismantling anything
- 53:25so I. Wanted to zooming on Wired
- 53:28specifically. I literally had Katie Drummond,
- 53:32the global editorial director on I think the podcast that will
- 53:35run before this one that I've already recorded.
- 53:38You know, recently Trey Stevens at Founders Fund joked about
- 53:42acquiring it. You wrote in Newcomer sort of
- 53:45about that whole incident and Wired is sort of a character in
- 53:51the book. What is your view on how much
- 53:53you know? I don't know.
- 53:54Wired today is betraying the founding origins of the
- 53:57publication and like give give us sort of your your gloss on on
- 54:02the publication's evolution. Well, I think that Wired has
- 54:07evolved in a almost inevitable way, you know, back one thing
- 54:13that's very important to remember in thinking about this
- 54:16history is that back in the 90s when Wired was created and when
- 54:20there was this kind of effervescent optimism that I,
- 54:23that I talk about, you know, the tech industry was very small.
- 54:27It was. It was an.
- 54:28Underdog. It was an.
- 54:29Underdog, yeah, and relative, you know, the big industries
- 54:32were like oil, you know, and and banking, like those were the big
- 54:37industries. You know, tech was kind of this
- 54:39smallish weird dish, you know, thing like important, but it's
- 54:44not like the banks, you know. And and so that was it was a
- 54:49very different thing. And so in those days, you know,
- 54:52it was much, yeah. It was more of a, of a kind of
- 54:56an underdog, you know, feeling so, so now, you know, you have a
- 55:01tech industry which is like so big and so dominant and, you
- 55:06know, has control of, you know, so many aspects of our lives,
- 55:10you know, that it that it's just by nature is going to shift the
- 55:14relationship. So, so back in the 90s, Wired
- 55:19was championing the, you know, these, these idiosyncratic
- 55:24technologists, you know, people, you know, thinking outside of
- 55:27the box. We're going to remake the world
- 55:29with these new technologies. And it's a, you know, it's a
- 55:32glorious moment of, you know, reinvention led by these kind of
- 55:39fascinating idiosyncratic freethinkers, right?
- 55:43So nowadays, you know, you can't frame the tech industry that
- 55:50way. Like it isn't about that.
- 55:52You know, it's it's like the tech industry is not run by if
- 55:56your publication. Is cheers for underdog
- 55:58freethinkers. Those same people would not have
- 56:01the same view of the tech industry today.
- 56:04Exactly. You know, so now the tech
- 56:06industry is not renegade free thinkers.
- 56:08The tech industry is like super rich billionaires, you know,
- 56:12with enormous power and political power and all kinds of
- 56:15other stuff. So, so you can't like, you know,
- 56:19Marc Andreessen would have been a hero, you know, of Wired in
- 56:231994 or and was, I guess, I don't remember exactly, but you
- 56:28know, he would be the type of guy who was a hero in 94.
- 56:30But nowadays, like, how would that guy be?
- 56:33How would he be a hero exactly? Like one of the richest guys in
- 56:37the world? Like he's not an underdog.
- 56:40He's not a renegade. He's not, you know, he's just
- 56:42like, he's like a rich guy, you know?
- 56:46You know, we did the heroic act you wanted.
- 56:48We built the great thing like and now everybody hates us for
- 56:51it, you know, or what do you make of that?
- 56:52Like I do Well they. Haven't built the great they
- 56:55built the they built, they built the thing that benefits them,
- 56:58you know, but it, but it, you know, they've gotten rich, but
- 57:00what's it done for the rest of us?
- 57:01You know, and, and so I, I mean, and I'm not saying that's a I'm
- 57:05being sarcastic in a way. You know, there's plenty of
- 57:08answers to that question, but they have not articulated those
- 57:11answers. You know they have.
- 57:12The tech industry leadership is not sold to the people.
- 57:16Why? You know what they're bringing
- 57:19is going to be good. Exactly.
- 57:21We literally started this episode talking about Eric
- 57:22Schmidt talking about AI and getting booed.
- 57:25I mean, they're not doing a good job selling it.
- 57:27I mean, and I think the question is, you know.
- 57:31And and to go well and to go back to Wired because I think
- 57:34that I think that's a good point.
- 57:35And I don't know how Katie, you know, might have responded to
- 57:38this, but it is certainly true that wired in the early days,
- 57:42you know, was celebrated tech and wired these days is often
- 57:46very critical. Now, to me, that's a that's a
- 57:50kind of a natural evolution. But if you sort of say, well, is
- 57:57wired the same thing as it was then does it represent the same
- 58:01thing? Well, not exactly, no.
- 58:04I mean it's. Clearly more political.
- 58:05I mean, she didn't embrace totally.
- 58:08I think she agreed with this line of argument somewhat.
- 58:10But I think she is sort of casting about for the Renegades
- 58:14and sort of people to be cheered for.
- 58:16I think she sees the critique of like, oh, we need to work on
- 58:20projects that that find sort of people we will designate as
- 58:25heroes. But obviously she's very proud
- 58:27of and should be proud of Wired's work on stuff like Doge
- 58:31and sort of failures of Elon's renegade boys to find government
- 58:36waste and just sort of the chaos they caused.
- 58:38So, I mean, I think she's they're, you know, believes
- 58:40they're doing important work, but is sort of working also on
- 58:43pieces to find some of the optimism.
- 58:45Yeah. Well, and interestingly, within
- 58:48Wire, there's always been a tension between the liberal and
- 58:51the libertarian within Wired. And so Lewis Rossetto, the
- 58:55founder, you know, he was much more libertarian and and he
- 58:59would actually agree with the, I fairly sure would agree with the
- 59:03Trey Stevens critique. Like he thinks that Wired, you
- 59:07know, Lewis has kind of gone to the right and he believes that
- 59:11Wired today does not represent what you know, what he's
- 59:15celebrated. And even Kevin Kelly weighed in
- 59:18on Trey Stevens thing and said, oh that would be a very wired
- 59:21thing to do to buy wired. I mean, I do think, you know,
- 59:26I'm, I think fairly sympathetic to the tech industry, but if you
- 59:30look at, you know, Facebook had some of these sort of San
- 59:35Francisco, it sold the world on connecting everybody.
- 59:38And obviously, you know, I do think people are connected over
- 59:41Facebook, but I don't know that part of the message was, you
- 59:44know, get all your political takes from your aunt or
- 59:47whatever, you know, and and then, you know, the sharing
- 59:51economy, which I really lived through, I really don't think
- 59:55delivered on the message that it's like some guy with a car
- 59:59making a little side money. Like mostly drivers there
- 1:00:01professional. It feels like most Airbnbs you
- 1:00:05go to, it is their job. And so again, you have the tech
- 1:00:09industry embracing sort of. A creative framing, you know,
- 1:00:13the Airbnb guys are like designers, but then once it
- 1:00:16scales you realize it's sort of a nice story on top of what
- 1:00:20feels like a less sort of societally mind bending, acid
- 1:00:25tripping business. And yet again, we find ourselves
- 1:00:30here with AI. You know, it, it, it leads to a
- 1:00:33bad path on where things are going.
- 1:00:35But right now we're in the fun. You know, you have your clawed
- 1:00:38bot and you're like doing, I don't know, you're hacking
- 1:00:40together websites. I don't know what.
- 1:00:42What do you take from that journey we've been on?
- 1:00:46Well. You know, we were talking a
- 1:00:47little bit before about the, you know, the role of the role of
- 1:00:51capital and venture capital. And you know, and I do think
- 1:00:53that in the sharing economy, it's kind of an example of where
- 1:00:59if you if you're really pushing, you know, to optimize for for
- 1:01:04profit, like then that takes you in certain directions that you
- 1:01:09wouldn't necessarily have to go, right.
- 1:01:12So in other words, a service like Airbnb, like there is a
- 1:01:18thing there that would be what it's purported to be, right?
- 1:01:24Like friends, you know, just people making a little extra
- 1:01:27money on their room and, you know, travelers saving a little
- 1:01:30money and having a more personal, you know, natural
- 1:01:34experience. And like, there's a business in
- 1:01:37doing that. It's just not as good a
- 1:01:39business, not as lucrative a business, as the business of
- 1:01:42like professional operators renting apartments and renting
- 1:01:45them out. I feel like there's this world,
- 1:01:48it's not just like the mean money sort of forces that are
- 1:01:51doing it. Like the left.
- 1:01:52There's certain things in the book, right?
- 1:01:54Like you read like like do drugs and like talk about it to your,
- 1:01:57you know, it's just like some of the things that were wild and
- 1:02:00fun, like the left culture wouldn't allow either.
- 1:02:04And like having the, you know, Lyft tried to be the more like
- 1:02:07random guy with a car. And in some ways it's like
- 1:02:10that's pretty dangerous. And like there's something good
- 1:02:12about a professional and like some of the bad Airbnb
- 1:02:14experiences are like, man, the host just wants to talk to me
- 1:02:17the whole time. And like there, there are
- 1:02:19certain things where like some of the some of those examples
- 1:02:23are examples where like left culture itself doesn't
- 1:02:26necessarily want to sustain the wacking weird thing at scale.
- 1:02:30Like you can trust it in sort of a small experiment, but once
- 1:02:34it's becoming sort of societal wide litigious sort of culture
- 1:02:39of of like that, I would put more on the left also sort of
- 1:02:43sands that down. Like so these things just sort
- 1:02:45of get sanded down to a version that like the markets can
- 1:02:48sustain and that like you just can't scale sort of like wild
- 1:02:52unhinged relationships. Or what do you take of the
- 1:02:55critique that there are pieces of the left that are also sort
- 1:02:58of sanding down? Yeah, I would you.
- 1:03:02Know, I think I think that's I think that's fair you know, that
- 1:03:06the you know, the left kind of you could say generically
- 1:03:10there's sort of a prioritization of kind of safety, you know,
- 1:03:14which would lead to a kind of conservative approach to certain
- 1:03:18things. So I think that's AI think
- 1:03:20that's a fair criticism. And you know, I would point to,
- 1:03:26I mean, Craigslist, right, So that that's something in in the
- 1:03:30book. I mean, to the extent they're
- 1:03:31heroes in the book, right, Craig would be a hero.
- 1:03:34You know Brian, Brian Bellendorf, you don't.
- 1:03:37Shame, just keep it out. What?
- 1:03:38Well, you're good and don't over extract.
- 1:03:40But the thing that that I find awesome about Craig's story is
- 1:03:44that, you know, he was just like, no, like, no, I'm, I'm not
- 1:03:49gonna take the money because it's not my main.
- 1:03:53It's not my thing. Like I've, I've got enough money
- 1:03:55and I don't need the money. And if I take the money, I'm
- 1:03:59going to have to do a bunch of shit that I don't want to do.
- 1:04:01And I'm going to have to make the service something that I
- 1:04:03don't want it to be. And so I'm just not going to do
- 1:04:06it. And so he didn't do it and he
- 1:04:08kept the thing the way it was. And, you know, he gets a lot of
- 1:04:13criticism from for like not modernizing the service, but you
- 1:04:18know, there's millions and millions of people who like it
- 1:04:20just the way it is. And, and his insight actually
- 1:04:23was that, you know, well, it's not really an insight, but he's
- 1:04:26the only one whoever acted on it, which is that people don't
- 1:04:28like change, so I'm not going to change it.
- 1:04:33And, and Craig, you know, and The funny thing is that so
- 1:04:37Craigslist still works. It's still the best place to get
- 1:04:42certain things in a lot of cities.
- 1:04:43You know, it depends, but you know, it still works.
- 1:04:46It's still basically free. And Craig has made like a
- 1:04:49billion dollars. Go read City on the Edge.
- 1:04:52It's amazing. We don't read enough these days,
- 1:04:54especially in the tech industry. Go read a book.
- 1:04:57The amazing thing about reading history, and this history in
- 1:05:00particular is, Yeah, you you remember that you fall victim to
- 1:05:04the wins of your time and that there were other times they were
- 1:05:08also awesome, where they think differently.
- 1:05:10And if you really want to think different in the tech industry,
- 1:05:14you have to sort of be aware of history.
- 1:05:17And I think that's one of the things, honestly, that was Steve
- 1:05:19Jobs was, you know, a liberal arts person, someone who really
- 1:05:22had a sense of history. And I think one of the failings
- 1:05:25of this current moment in the tech industry is just people
- 1:05:29sort of myopically in their own time without that sense of
- 1:05:32history. So go read, see On the Edge.
- 1:05:34It is a very readable, enjoyable book and story.
- 1:05:37And I think you will have a sense of perspective that will
- 1:05:41be gained. And so thank you for joining us
- 1:05:43on the show and giving us a taste of what is to be found
- 1:05:46inside the book. Well.
- 1:05:48Thank you, Eric. Thank you very much.
- 1:05:49And if I would just add one last thing that kind of plays into
- 1:05:54your point here, I think. And one thing that I'm very
- 1:05:56proud of about the book is that I think it kind of weaves
- 1:06:00together a story of the rise of the industry and the evolution
- 1:06:03of the politics and the evolution of the culture and
- 1:06:06shows how those things really interrelate with one another.
- 1:06:12And I hopefully that's a unique contribution of the book.
- 1:06:14So great. Thank you very much for coming
- 1:06:16on the show. All right.
- 1:06:17Thank you. That's.
- 1:06:18Our conversation. If you want to see more of what
- 1:06:20Jonathan Weber and I are writing, you got to go to
- 1:06:23newcomer.co. That's our sub stack here on the
- 1:06:26podcast. Please like, comment, subscribe,
- 1:06:28tell us who you want me to interview next.
- 1:06:31And if you're still hankering for more tech podcasting, we've
- 1:06:34got a chat show for you. That's the Shrubal Valley show
- 1:06:37with my Shrubal Valley Co host Max Child and James Wilsterman.
- 1:06:41Otherwise, I'll see you next week.
- 1:06:42This is the newcomer podcast. Thanks so much.