Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Advanced Trial Tactics: Tips From the Experts on Motions in Limine
Transcript
- 0:03Welcome to Advanced Trial Tactics Tips from Experts
- 0:07on Motions and Lemonade. My name is Edward Weiss.
- 0:10I will be moderating today's discussion. I'm
- 0:13delighted to introduce our impressive and highly
- 0:15accomplished speakers today, the Honorable Randolph
- 0:19Hammack, Jay Spillane, and Paul Kiesel. Judge
- 0:23Hammack is a Superior Court Judge currently sitting
- 0:25in an independent calendar court at the Stanley
- 0:28Moss Courthouse, in which he presides over unlimited
- 0:31civil cases. During his almost 25 years of practicing
- 0:35law, primarily as a civil trial attorney, Judge
- 0:38Hammack was admitted to and actively practiced
- 0:41law in a total of 15 states, as well as over
- 0:4520 federal district courts and courts of appeal.
- 0:48As such, he is likely to have had passed more
- 0:52bar exams than any other practicing lawyer in
- 0:55the United States. Jay Spillane is the founding
- 0:59shareholder of Spillane Trial Group PLC, a firm
- 1:03of business trial lawyers representing private
- 1:05companies and individuals in bet the company
- 1:08cases. For over three decades, Mr. Spillane has
- 1:12tried cases for entertainment and sports personalities
- 1:15such as Robert Redford, Harold Ramis, surf champion
- 1:19Kelly Slater, and beach volleyball gold medalist
- 1:22Kent Steffes, and for companies and high level
- 1:24executives in cases involving entertainment.
- 1:27intellectual property, technology, real estate,
- 1:31finance, corporate control, and family wealth.
- 1:34And we also have Paul Kiesel, who is a nationally
- 1:38recognized trial attorney with decades of experience
- 1:41representing consumers in complex litigation.
- 1:44That's enough said. That's no more. You got that.
- 1:46Perfect. Anyone can find me later. Keep going.
- 1:49Sorry. including personal injury, class actions,
- 1:53environmental cases. He's an early adopter of
- 1:55legal tech and co -author of key legal treatises.
- 2:00Paul brings deep insight into building and sustaining
- 2:02a successful modern law practice. Thank you.
- 2:07And for myself, I'm a neutral with ADR services.
- 2:10My background is I practiced business litigation
- 2:14at Manette Phillips and Phillips. I was an assistant
- 2:16U .S. attorney in the criminal division here
- 2:19in the central district. I spent about half of
- 2:22my career at Ticketmaster, where at various times
- 2:24I was general counsel and oversaw litigation,
- 2:27including trials where motions and limine were
- 2:31involved. So that's how I landed on this as the
- 2:35moderator on this August panel. So let's get
- 2:38started for an overview of motions and limine.
- 2:41Jay, what are they? What are they for? And what
- 2:44are some tips, do's and don'ts? All right. Well,
- 2:47thank you very much. So let's cover the absolute
- 2:50basic. A Motion Lemonade is a written motion
- 2:55filed before trial. It's a fully, fully briefed,
- 3:01one motion like anything else, the motion, memorandum,
- 3:04opposition, reply, typically set for hearing
- 3:07at a final status conference, final pretrial
- 3:09conference. The judge may or may not hear it
- 3:13on that day or may reserve it and see if the
- 3:14party's settled, but these would be resolved
- 3:17if not at that final pre -trial conference then
- 3:20before the jury is brought in. The classic use
- 3:27of emotion eliminate is to exclude evidence that
- 3:31one thing should not come in. It would be the
- 3:36type of thing where it wouldn't lend itself to
- 3:40standing up and just objecting right there. You
- 3:44may or may not have enough time to fully explain
- 3:46why it's not admissible. Something could come
- 3:49out in front of the jury and then it started
- 3:51to unring the bell. So you want to sort of write
- 3:55this up and have the judge really think about
- 3:57it before you get there at trial. There's some
- 4:06basic requirements of motion to eliminate. We
- 4:08all have to keep in mind. We have in the outline,
- 4:13and some courts expressly require people to affirm
- 4:17that they're following the principles well explained
- 4:20in Kelly versus New West Federal Savings. We
- 4:23have that citation in the materials. And what
- 4:26are some of these broad principles? First of
- 4:29all, the motion should be directed at a specific
- 4:32identifiable piece of evidence, right? We don't
- 4:35want to bring the court with motions for general
- 4:38propositions like a motion to exclude evidence
- 4:41that isn't relevant without specifying what specifically
- 4:44you think is not relevant. A motion to prevent
- 4:49the other side from introducing a document that
- 4:52wasn't produced during discovery. Well, no, that's
- 4:55too general. You have to talk about a specific
- 4:58document you think someone's going to bring in
- 5:00and explain why it was requested discovery and
- 5:03not given. Another common misuse is what's really
- 5:10a de facto motion for summary judgment, although
- 5:13not described as such and using the detailed
- 5:16procedures as such. For example, let's say in
- 5:21an employment case, the defense says the plaintiff
- 5:24really doesn't have enough evidence of discrimination
- 5:27so that we want a motion barring them from telling
- 5:31the jury they should return a verdict or they
- 5:33suffered any damages. Well, that's not really
- 5:36a motion to exclude a specific piece of evidence.
- 5:39That's effectively a motion to throw a cause
- 5:42of action out without following the rules of
- 5:45summary judgment. That should be avoided. practice.
- 5:58Look, I find that you can, there's only so much
- 6:01time in a trial, right? We're going to be there,
- 6:04you know, four and a half hours a day, how many
- 6:07every days the trial lasts. Not only are there
- 6:09so many things that you can get a jury to focus
- 6:12on, but there's only so many things you can get
- 6:17a judge to focus on or want the judge to have
- 6:19to struggle through. I mean, our good LA Superior
- 6:22Court judges are struggling with, I'm sure Judge
- 6:26Hammack will tell, that's my impression, it's
- 6:27a thousand or two thousand cases, especially
- 6:30because the injury cases are floating back in.
- 6:34So you don't want to flood your judge with twenty
- 6:38motions and lemonade. I like the number three.
- 6:44What are the three things I want to make sure
- 6:46the jury can remember and what are the three
- 6:48things I really want to bring in front of the
- 6:50judge that should either stay out of evidence
- 6:53or come into evidence. I like to focus on something
- 6:59that I think is really high impact and ineffective
- 7:01that really underscores a couple of important
- 7:04themes about my case. Now, one of the things
- 7:09we mentioned in the outline, and I encountered
- 7:13this, being a business trial lawyer as opposed
- 7:17to an injury lawyer, I get my share of arbitration
- 7:21clauses. I get references because it's a complex
- 7:24accounting. Sometimes if there's no real emotional
- 7:29issue and it's a bunch of financial stuff, people
- 7:32just waive jury and it's a bench trial. A primary
- 7:38purpose of emotion and lemonade is having mentioned
- 7:42unringing the bill. You don't want to get something
- 7:45that you don't want the jury to hear out there
- 7:47in front of them. you know technically the judge
- 7:50says please ignore that but they've already heard
- 7:52it it can be hard to unpack with a bench trial
- 7:57or an arbitration trial you know the judge is
- 8:01going to be more objective training these kind
- 8:04of things unringing the bill is easier where
- 8:08the judge is your trier of fact so i i don't
- 8:11do many motions eliminate in in a non -jury proceeding
- 8:15And let me stop and ask the question because
- 8:17I don't think I've ever done a motion in limiting
- 8:20where the trier of fact was my judge that I'd
- 8:23be sharing what the emotion is because the whole
- 8:26idea is to unring the bell and you don't want
- 8:29the judge is going to hear it right. Right yeah
- 8:32I mean in preparing for this I couldn't I went
- 8:35back and I made notes as to some ones I've done
- 8:38that we may talk about later. and they were all
- 8:40in jury trials, right? So yeah, I'm hard pressed
- 8:44to think of one. I mean, I suppose if there's
- 8:47something just really complicated, maybe one
- 8:49thing that requires a lot of briefing and exposition
- 8:53of what there's some dispute in the public authorities,
- 8:56maybe that's something that might be complicated
- 8:58enough. But otherwise, I think you can just talk
- 9:01about it at the hearing and the judge is going
- 9:04to understand why they should ignore it. Yeah,
- 9:06I agree with that. Let me see if there's anything.
- 9:17I think those are the main points I wanted to
- 9:21make just on an overview. Edward, we're going
- 9:25to turn it over to the judge. Yeah, that's great.
- 9:29Thank you for now, Jay. But don't go anywhere.
- 9:33Judge Hammack? Yes. Maybe you could begin by
- 9:39telling us about the outfit that you selected
- 9:41for today. You could do this in the chat later.
- 9:45You're going to guess what my costume is. It
- 9:47actually is a specific fictional character from
- 9:51television. Don't shout it out. You could type
- 9:55it later. There'll be some sort of small award,
- 9:58a free continuance in Department 49 for anybody
- 10:02that gets it correct. And just to give you an
- 10:04outline, I'll give you the whole costume. There
- 10:06it is, okay? And it took me a long time to gain
- 10:10all the weight to fit into that costume. Decades,
- 10:15okay? So I'm committed to this costume, okay?
- 10:18So put it in the chat, okay? Now let's turn to
- 10:21reality. Let me follow up on that one point that
- 10:24council, they both just talked about. You know,
- 10:27I've been doing this. I've been a judge for 17
- 10:29years. I was a lawyer for 25, so 42 years, civil
- 10:33litigation. Always, of course I know what a motion
- 10:35and eliminate is, but I always say to myself,
- 10:37where is that from? It ain't in the CCP. The
- 10:42word motion and eliminate doesn't even appear
- 10:44in the CCP. It appears once in the rules of court.
- 10:50I just found it. Rule 3 .1112F. And it's literally
- 10:59one sentence. It says, notwithstanding A, which
- 11:03doesn't apply, a motion and eliminate filed before
- 11:06or during trial need not be accompanied by a
- 11:10notice of hearing. The timing and place of a
- 11:13filing in service of the motion are at the discretion
- 11:15of the trial judge. So CCP rules of court. The
- 11:20only time motions eliminate. The word motion
- 11:22eliminate even appears. So a lot of times I get,
- 11:25I've had a case where 80 motions eliminate were
- 11:27filed, 80, eight zero. Okay. And that first thing
- 11:31I say, where's your authority for even me hearing
- 11:33a motion to eliminate. Okay. They're all like
- 11:36dumbfounded. Now the local rule does talk about
- 11:40measure. Okay. There is a local rule. Write it
- 11:44down. 3 .57. Okay. So that's where it comes from.
- 11:50It comes from our local rule. And believe it
- 11:53or not, the case law that I found, it's all based
- 11:55on our inherent authority under 128. Whenever
- 11:59you start citing me 128 of the CCP, I know you're
- 12:03desperate, okay? Because that's the catchall.
- 12:06Inherent authority to control my proceedings,
- 12:09okay? Inherent authority of the court. So that's
- 12:11where that came from. And the local rule is very
- 12:13specific. Please read it and follow it. That's
- 12:17critical. For example, if you're in my court,
- 12:23almost every IC judge has a pre -trial, a trial
- 12:28preparation order that talks about the motion
- 12:31to eliminate. They talk about when they want
- 12:33it and how they want it. There is a meet and
- 12:37confer requirement and a declaration requirement.
- 12:41It's in the local rule. Read it. Here's what
- 12:44I want in most good experience I see judges want.
- 12:49I want a binder and I want every motion to eliminate
- 12:55one and then I want the motion, the proposed
- 12:59order, the opposition, the reply. Tap two, motion
- 13:02to eliminate number two. Literally, I mean, I
- 13:05don't want 80. Three seems low, you know, a reasonable
- 13:12amount. If you swamp me with 30, I may just say,
- 13:15choose your best five. Okay. If you, but I'm
- 13:19willing to go, I've done 80 before it. It took
- 13:21me a week to do the motions, eliminate if the
- 13:23case justifies it. Okay. But focus on where you
- 13:28want to choose your battle. Oh, this is the important
- 13:30point. And you've touched upon it. I've seen
- 13:33many motions, eliminate and bench trials. I kind
- 13:36of smile when I see them because it's not within
- 13:39the definition of emotion and eliminate emotion
- 13:42and eliminate as both counsel just pointed out.
- 13:44You want to prevent the jury from ever hearing
- 13:46this because you can't unring that, but you want
- 13:48to prevent them from hearing that he has five
- 13:51prior felony convictions for DUI. Okay. You don't
- 13:54want them to hear that. You don't want it to
- 13:56even come out an opening statement. That's why
- 13:58we have motions eliminate for jury trials only.
- 14:02The judge is always going to have to hear it.
- 14:04Oh, we don't want him to, you know, he's been
- 14:07convicted seven times while they're too remote.
- 14:09They're not, you know, I'll make a finding. Okay.
- 14:12And, uh, And here's my other clue. The rule of
- 14:16court, I mean the local rule, it says, motions
- 14:19made for the purpose of precluding the mention
- 14:22or display of inadmissible and prejudicial matter
- 14:25in the presence of the jury. I just underlined
- 14:28it. So there's your basis. It's only for juries.
- 14:33Now, do I have a problem that you call it a motion
- 14:35to eliminate instead of a trial brief? No. Maybe
- 14:41you do want to exclude this expert from ever
- 14:44testifying because he wasn't designated or whatever.
- 14:48Okay. Why am I going to make you spend all that
- 14:50money to bring an expert when I'm never going
- 14:53to, if I'm going to properly exclude them for
- 14:55some reason, wasn't proper. That's the type of
- 14:58motion that you want to file. Okay. Well, it's
- 15:01a practical motion. If not, you know, like I
- 15:04say, it's prison rules. Just bring your stuff.
- 15:06I'll figure out what's relevant. I'll figure
- 15:08out what's triple hearsay. I've been doing this
- 15:10a long time. okay so but I'll be honest with
- 15:14you maybe there's some judges you need to explain
- 15:17it to them a little bit more carefully I'll let
- 15:19that sit simmer okay okay so uh okay so that's
- 15:26my thing here's my other uh and I have all the
- 15:30again think about the battle you want to choose
- 15:34you know most almost all motions eliminate should
- 15:37be based on 352 I'm convinced of that let me
- 15:39say that again 352, because that's the stuff
- 15:44that for some reason it might be relevant, but
- 15:48it's probative value is outweighed by undue prejudice
- 15:51or undoubtful consumption. Most motions to eliminate
- 15:55should be your good 352 ones, right? Even though
- 15:58it's a fact, we're not disputing it, it's too
- 16:02prejudicial. You know, I always love to say,
- 16:04your honor, it's prejudicial. Yeah, that's what
- 16:06makes a good evidence. In fact, it's pretty damn
- 16:09good evidence, isn't it? It's really prejudicial
- 16:11against your client. Why am I going to exclude
- 16:13that? But I'll push back for a second, Judge,
- 16:17and say this. There may be irrelevant pieces
- 16:20of information that the defense or the other
- 16:22side wants to introduce that has nothing to do
- 16:24with the case. It's not a 352. It's just pure
- 16:26prejudice. Well, no, that is 352, Mr. Kiesel.
- 16:29It is 352. Well, it has no value. We need to
- 16:33say 350. I'll give you 351. It's not relevant.
- 16:36You can do that, okay? But I like it under 352,
- 16:41okay? So, normally that's what your motion should
- 16:44be about. So really, and don't, I know you all
- 16:47file it, you cut and paste it, don't, are you
- 16:50reptile theory, or the golden rule, or my favorite
- 16:55of all times, which I think Mr. Splane just did,
- 16:58you know, exclude all evidence not produced in
- 17:01discovery. Well, that's nice. Did you ask for
- 17:04it? You know, we had live in an adversarial system.
- 17:07Okay. It's not, we don't have Brady obligations.
- 17:10All right. You specifically have to have asked
- 17:12for it and they didn't give it to you and they're
- 17:15sandbagging you. Okay. And I take it like a Kenmore,
- 17:19even though Kenmore technically is about experts.
- 17:21I consider it like a Kenmore analysis. Okay.
- 17:25When you were asked to produce something and
- 17:29you didn't produce it. And now you're trying
- 17:31to produce it and you're trying to introduce
- 17:34it that I'm gonna we're gonna talk about that
- 17:37Now here's an interesting point and maybe this
- 17:40I'll throw this out for council There's this
- 17:44motion lemonade exclude exhibit 19 Oh by the
- 17:48way that you should always tell me the exhibits
- 17:49you want to exclude don't you know? I'm not gonna
- 17:52just issue a catch -all order. Which exhibits
- 17:55do you want exclude? You've got the exhibit list
- 17:57X Y and Z, right? or all whatever and then you
- 18:02say I asked this in discovery here's the rfa
- 18:06the uh rpd request and here's their response
- 18:10and if they say I'll produce all evidence you
- 18:14know we'll comply in full then we can have a
- 18:17really good discussion but if what if it says
- 18:20objection take a hike I'm not producing anything
- 18:24and you don't take them to the mat you don't
- 18:27follow motion to compel further You let it stay.
- 18:31What do we do now? Mr Queso, what do we do? I
- 18:36think it's incumbent upon the attorney trying
- 18:38to exclude evidence to have done all he or she
- 18:40can to make sure it's not admitted. And so failure
- 18:43to bring a motion to compel to really know what
- 18:45the evidence is, I think is a problem for the
- 18:47moving party if they haven't done all they need
- 18:49to do to exhaust their remedy. How about you,
- 18:52Mr Splane? What do you think? Well, look, I think
- 18:56you have to be specific. You have to say Exhibit
- 18:5819, and you have to prove that they said they'd
- 19:02give it all, or you filed a motion to compel,
- 19:04and you got an order to give it, and they didn't
- 19:06do it. It's insufficient just to say, here's
- 19:08something I haven't seen before, if you didn't
- 19:10overcome that. I wouldn't file that motion if
- 19:14that's all I got. I asked for the document, and
- 19:17I got a bunch of objections, and I'm just busy.
- 19:19I didn't do anything else. OK, and those are
- 19:21things I'll consider. But to me, the most important
- 19:24is the importance of the document. The more important
- 19:27the document, the more I feel strongly they should
- 19:30have given it to you, because that reeks of sandbagging.
- 19:33You see what I mean? So if it's the classic smoking
- 19:36gun, you're going to have a problem with me.
- 19:40OK? And with any, I think, good judge. But if
- 19:44it's just something innocuous, it really doesn't.
- 19:47You know, I'm going to probably let it go, because
- 19:49you didn't follow the motion to compel further.
- 19:51And you could use it to impeach them. You know,
- 19:54you could use it to impeach them. Didn't you
- 19:56say under oath, you know why? These RPDs mean
- 19:59something. The mandatory language. I'm sure you've
- 20:02read all my published articles, right? One of
- 20:04them on common mistakes on RPDs. We make you
- 20:08say something for a reason. I'm producing, I'm
- 20:12complying in full. That means something. or I
- 20:18made a due diligent effort to look and I'm unable
- 20:21to comply and here's why. Because you can use
- 20:25that language to impeach them later when they
- 20:27were sandbagging you on something or not being
- 20:30straightforward and complete. So anyway, I don't
- 20:34want to delve up into RPDs, but the point back
- 20:37in MILs, choose them wisely. Focus on the ones
- 20:41that really hurt your... Do you care about evidence
- 20:45that actually helps you? I've seen most of the
- 20:47eliminate filed, excluding evidence that actually
- 20:50could help you. You could spin it your way because
- 20:52it just wasn't produced or whatever. Think about
- 20:56this evidence is going to hurt me or mislead
- 20:59the jury. It's got to be some reason, practical
- 21:02reason that you want to keep it out. Okay. And
- 21:05then right away, this is what I want out. Or
- 21:09I don't want the person to say X, Y, and Z. You
- 21:13know how many times I have to say, what is it
- 21:14that you want out? And you know what I do? It
- 21:17drives me crazy. Council, are you intending to
- 21:20elicit that response? No, not at all. Why did
- 21:26we have the motion? Because that's what the meet
- 21:27and confer is supposed to do. A meaningful meet
- 21:29and confer says, I'm not going to do that. I'm
- 21:31not going to introduce this evidence. I'm not
- 21:33going to ask that question. You see my point?
- 21:36So I don't really have a lot of confidence that
- 21:39we have a lot of meaningful meet and confers,
- 21:41to be honest with you. Be honest with yourself.
- 21:44How many times have you said, I agree with that
- 21:48motion to eliminate, I'm not going to use it?
- 21:52I would say from my perspective, I oftentimes
- 21:55ask my opposing counsel to let me know areas
- 21:57that they want to bring motions and eliminate
- 21:59on. And I say, I'll stipulate to that. I'm not
- 22:02going to violate the golden rule. I'm not going
- 22:04to address insurance. I don't want to burden
- 22:06you with the need to rule simply. And I want
- 22:09to have agreement where we can have agreement.
- 22:12I've reached and I've reached and filed stipulations
- 22:15that we shall not introduce the following evidence
- 22:18and the other side won't introduce this. I take
- 22:20that very seriously. Hey, Judge, I wanted to
- 22:23throw an issue at you because you said the most
- 22:27popular, the big one is 352. There's a big section
- 22:30in the outline I wanted to mention. I'm seeing
- 22:33a lot of motions limit on experts and we've got
- 22:36You know, Sanchez that you can no longer bring
- 22:38in the hearsay. Sargon, Sargon, those are all.
- 22:40We've got the Sargon, which is the modern good
- 22:43bear. We've got Kenamur. Aren't you seeing a
- 22:45lot of those? Yeah. You know what? No. You see
- 22:49them now and then. Almost we see the same cut
- 22:53and paste. The first 10 of the cut and paste,
- 22:56you know, you know, broad ones that mean nothing
- 23:00to me. I like to focus on the ones that are meaningful,
- 23:04like an expert. I don't want an expert to say
- 23:06this, or I don't want an... This expert is not
- 23:10qualified to give these opinions. That's a righteous
- 23:14motion to eliminate, okay? And let me tell you
- 23:16the importance for anyone listening, at least
- 23:19from my perspective, on motions to eliminate.
- 23:21I am most concerned about the lawyer's opening
- 23:26statement to the jury. And I want to be certain
- 23:29that that opening statement is going to be the
- 23:31evidence they intend on producing. And I want
- 23:34to make sure I can limit to the extent that there's
- 23:36any vulnerability for my case of issues that
- 23:40are going to raise to prevent them from making
- 23:43a statement and opening that is not already established.
- 23:46So that's my purpose and emotion limiting. That's
- 23:49the key. You don't want the bell rung because
- 23:51we even know we tell them disregarded. You can't
- 23:54unring the bell. Okay. And you know what, Mr.
- 23:57Kiesel, that's the case. And you know what? You
- 23:59tried cases in front of me. I defer a lot of
- 24:02rulings. Yes. I always say you cannot talk about
- 24:05this in the opening statement. You can never
- 24:07mention it until I give the green light. I'm
- 24:10not ready yet. I can't decide in this context.
- 24:13I do that a lot because I need to hear more and
- 24:15hear how you are trying the case and what your
- 24:17theory is before I can make it one way or another.
- 24:20Sometimes it's clear you're never going to bring
- 24:22this up or no, it's green light. You're wrong.
- 24:25Okay, I'm letting this but a lot of times I just
- 24:28say a lot of judges I assume do this. I'm going
- 24:30to defer this ruling, but no one's to mention
- 24:33it to anyone in front of the jury. And once you
- 24:37now want to bring it up, you have to go sidebar
- 24:40ask me for permission to get the green light.
- 24:43Right. A deferred ruling is a victory in a motion
- 24:46and limiting from my perspective because the
- 24:47jury is not hearing it in the opening statement.
- 24:49A lot of times what the court will do if it's
- 24:52an expert driven issue is I'll say let's do a
- 24:54402 before that is introduced to the jury, have
- 24:57the witness come in and make an offer of proof.
- 25:00So at least there's a foundation for what's going
- 25:02to be presented to the jury and not just a statement
- 25:04by lawyers in their opening. No, I agree. And
- 25:07I think we all agree that the whole purpose is
- 25:11to prevent jurors from hearing something that
- 25:13they really shouldn't hear. OK, the judge is
- 25:15going to hear it all the time because the judge
- 25:17has to make a ruling under 352 and weigh the
- 25:23factors into 352. But I, Mrs. Back to your point,
- 25:27402, I see them now and then. But those are more
- 25:30for more complex cases, you know, which, you
- 25:34know, Saragon or. Yeah, yeah. So right now I'm
- 25:38in the attorney conference room of the complex
- 25:40court today because we've got two trials beginning
- 25:42one upstairs and one downstairs. And we've got
- 25:45Sargon happening in both departments. We have
- 25:48M .I .L .s happening in both places. But here's
- 25:50a couple of points. Number one. make sure you
- 25:53talk to your witnesses about what they can or
- 25:56cannot do with regard to a motion in limine that
- 25:59the court has granted. You've got to talk to
- 26:01your witnesses on both sides to make sure the
- 26:04witnesses don't give answers that violate the
- 26:07court's rulings regarding motions in limine.
- 26:09Right, Judge? Right. Here it is. It's an N in
- 26:12the local rule. It's E. If the motion to eliminate
- 26:16is granted, it is the duty of counsel to instruct
- 26:19associates, clients, witnesses, and other persons
- 26:22under their control that no mention of display
- 26:24may be made. It's in the rule. I sometimes forget
- 26:28to tell you to admonish your clients or witnesses.
- 26:31I'm generally pretty good at it, but that's your
- 26:33duty. And your duty, if I punt, which I punt
- 26:36a lot, it's always forth and long in my courtroom.
- 26:43you have to say don't mention this don't unless
- 26:46we get the green light don't ever mention this
- 26:48word or put the slide up or say something like
- 26:51that in front of the jury and one more practice
- 26:53pointer is and i've done this myself tragically
- 26:55is i've opened the door uh having a motion it
- 26:59literally granted at my request i inadvertently
- 27:03elicited testimony from a witness that then opened
- 27:05the door widely on what i had prevented the court
- 27:09and i can talk more specifically but but i opened
- 27:11the door against my own mil You know what a standard
- 27:15order for me is? I grant the motion to eliminate
- 27:18subject to the opening of the door. I say that
- 27:20all the time. And it's almost reminding them
- 27:22what's good for the goose is good for the gander.
- 27:24Be careful how you ask your questions. Because
- 27:26right now, I'm ruling for you. I'm keeping it
- 27:28out. But if you open the door, by the way, counsel,
- 27:32if you think the door is open, just don't barge
- 27:34in. Come sidebar and say, judge, I think he's
- 27:37opened the door. Okay. So I'm going to give you
- 27:39a war story. It was 1996. So nearly 30 years
- 27:42ago, I was trying a case in front of Judge Stoll.
- 27:45Gerald Stoll in the Glendale Courthouse and Jack
- 27:51Daniels. The great lawyer, Jack Daniels, was
- 27:54the defense attorney. And I had a young girl
- 27:56who died in a swimming pool in an apartment next
- 27:59door to where she lived. And the argument was
- 28:01going to be that the nanny was the one who lost
- 28:03track of the child, which is why the child drowned.
- 28:05That wasn't my theory. My theory was that the
- 28:07pool's construction and attractive nuisance.
- 28:10And I brought a motion to eliminate that there
- 28:12should be no mention of the nanny's failure to
- 28:14supervise. She was not a Prop 51. defendant,
- 28:20no issue. Judge grants my motion. I've got the
- 28:24mother on the witness stand and I say to her,
- 28:26was there ever a time that the nanny lost sight
- 28:29of the child? And as I was saying, the last of
- 28:32the words, Judge Jack Daniels popping up and
- 28:35went to sidebar and said Judge Stahl, Kiesel
- 28:38open the door. And he said, as wise as you can
- 28:40open the door. And all the evidence came in that
- 28:43I had originally kept out. Yeah, thank you. Okay,
- 28:53one more question before we go on to the next
- 28:56segment, Your Honor. You might have already addressed
- 29:00this generally, but certainly with respect to
- 29:03requests for productions of documents, but with
- 29:06regard to the general point that Jay mentioned
- 29:09about, there's a delineation between specific
- 29:12pieces of evidence where motions in limine are
- 29:16generally appropriate and broad swaths of evidence
- 29:20where they're generally not. Where do you draw
- 29:22that line typically? Hopefully I covered that.
- 29:25I was trying to say, don't just say, oh, disclude
- 29:29all evidence not produced in discovery. That
- 29:31doesn't help me. And like Mr. Splane said, right
- 29:34on point, give me the number, the exhibit number.
- 29:37This is the one. You know how many times I've
- 29:39said, what is it you're trying to exclude? And
- 29:42they're reaching in a book and they were handing
- 29:43it to me. They're like, really? Don't you want
- 29:46to just give me a copy of it beforehand so I
- 29:48can look at it? You know, because I don't know
- 29:52if it's something that I'm going to exclude.
- 29:54I don't really. I mean, it's not brain science,
- 29:57you know. Uh, so that's, I mean, I think that's
- 30:01very important is don't make broad through strokes.
- 30:05Be specific. This is the exhibits that I'm worried
- 30:08about or what someone's going to say specifically.
- 30:12I don't want this person to say X. or y or z
- 30:16you know don't if that if that answers your question
- 30:19it does you've got to be very the more specific
- 30:22you are the more likely i'm to rule and not punt
- 30:28i i think i was asking more more generally with
- 30:31uh more with respect to witness testimony as
- 30:34opposed to documents where you want the exhibit
- 30:36number yeah but i would do the same thing i go
- 30:39and then i like i said I always ask the other
- 30:42side, do you intend to ask that question? And
- 30:44they always say, oh, no. Of course, what's my
- 30:47response? Good, then I'll grant the motion to
- 30:49eliminate. Easy peasy. Let's move on to the next
- 30:53one. OK, great. Thank you very much. All right,
- 30:56let's talk about some more specific motions.
- 31:00Jay, do you want to go through some of the motions
- 31:03that you like to bring in your business cases?
- 31:07Sure. So there's a couple of cases that I thought
- 31:10were worth mentioning. Now, actually, I'd like
- 31:14to start with a case that I won. And it's awfully
- 31:17brave of Paul to talk about one where he made
- 31:20the mistake. So we were the plaintiffs. And it
- 31:24was a joint venture case. My clients were two
- 31:28gentlemen who formed a company. And they went
- 31:30to the defendant. And they said, hey, we have
- 31:33a great idea. You have a great product. But there's
- 31:35a whole consumer base you're not selling your
- 31:37product to. We know this consumer base. We'll
- 31:40introduce your product to these customers you've
- 31:44never sold to before. And you'll deliver it.
- 31:47And after deducting the cost of goods sold, we'll
- 31:50split the profits. And so the parties did that
- 31:54for about a year. And then the defendant, maybe
- 31:58because they figured out how to exploit this
- 32:00market, they didn't need my guys anymore, claimed
- 32:03they were merely sales agents and they were fired.
- 32:06So we filed, we were the plaintiffs, we filed
- 32:09basically a breach of a joint venture case. Now,
- 32:14after my clients were fired and the suit was
- 32:19filed, my two clients got into a pissing match.
- 32:23over one another and who may or may not have
- 32:26been responsible for what. One of the guys holds
- 32:30a meeting where he fires the other guy under
- 32:34the corporation's code and he videos it. There's
- 32:40some email where he says he exploited the bleep
- 32:42out of the corporation's code. The other side
- 32:45was going to introduce this. To Judge Hammack's
- 32:49point, these were the video. and the email were
- 32:52designated exhibits. So I followed the motion
- 32:55under 350, 352, and also, I forget the statute,
- 33:00but it's the one about conduct, they conformed
- 33:03it with character, saying, look, this was after
- 33:06the joint venture was breached. And there's really
- 33:09no relevance. It's just to show that my guys
- 33:11are whorlsome dudes who f -bomb one another,
- 33:16and this shouldn't be considered. And the judge
- 33:19agreed with me. and granted that motion. So that
- 33:23evidence didn't come in. There's another case
- 33:29that I really wanted to mention because it illustrates
- 33:31larger tactical use of motions and lemonade as
- 33:38opposed to simply trying to make sure you don't
- 33:42have to unring the bell in front of the jury.
- 33:46I came in on a very difficult case, a prior counsel.
- 33:50My client was a defendant and he was accused
- 33:54of wrongful foreclosure. It was this crazy loan
- 34:00where the plaintiff borrowed it ostensibly to
- 34:05develop this unimproved property into a car service
- 34:10and car wash complex. The cookie intermediaries
- 34:16who had brokered this loan took the money and
- 34:19they went off and spent it on gold ventures.
- 34:21It was crazy. The plaintiff sued and said, hey,
- 34:25the money was absconded with and you couldn't
- 34:29foreclose upon me because I didn't even get the
- 34:31loan proceeds. There was a bench trial. I wasn't
- 34:35involved in this and the judge found that my
- 34:37client had committed wrongful foreclosure and
- 34:40he had done so with malice, oppression, or fraud.
- 34:43and she purported to say that a jury was going
- 34:45to be convened only for the purpose of assessing
- 34:48damages. So I had one very strategic motion to
- 34:53eliminate, which taught the judge, and I know
- 34:57there's been some questions about whether the
- 34:58motion could be to admit evidence as opposed
- 35:01to exclude it, which taught the judge that it's
- 35:04unlawful for a jury to award damages based on
- 35:10mal suppression or fraud. It has to be the same
- 35:12trial effect that finds the mal suppression or
- 35:15fraud. In other words, the judge couldn't instruct
- 35:18the jury that she found it and they're just tabulating
- 35:21the numbers. That motion was so effective that
- 35:26the plaintiff conferred about this and they agreed
- 35:29to avoid the impact of my motion that they'd
- 35:33waived the penal damages, that they had enough
- 35:36actual damages weren't taking the case to trial.
- 35:42So that was a strategic victory. The other motion
- 35:45I brought in this case, and I think this may
- 35:47have been the one that got attached to the written
- 35:49materials is, and this was, we cited Sargon in
- 35:55this one, there was gonna be testimony for the
- 35:59plaintiff as to the damages were the lost profits
- 36:04from this business venture. to build and operate
- 36:08this car service and car wash facility. And we
- 36:12said, wait a minute, when it was foreclosed,
- 36:16the property was unimproved. And in deposition,
- 36:21I asked this guy whether he had any experience
- 36:23running these particular facilities, and it was
- 36:26pretty thin. So. We induce these cases, which
- 36:30would say that when you're talking about damages
- 36:32based on lost profits, it can't be too speculative.
- 36:36Obviously, if Apple has a claim for lost profits
- 36:41for not being able to sell iPhones, they've got
- 36:43a pretty good track record. But if the business
- 36:45really never even existed, that can be a bridge
- 36:49too far. Now, the judge didn't agree with me.
- 36:54She denied the motion in Lemonade, and the jury
- 36:58did hear that evidence, and that influenced the
- 37:01damage award. But we really kept wrestling with
- 37:05this, and we kept arguing to the plaintiff that
- 37:07they'd bait a reversible error into this case.
- 37:13And this is going to be a huge issue on appeals.
- 37:16And speaking of what you do, we wound up resolving
- 37:21this for a fairly good discount off the judgment
- 37:25because of the interjection of an appeal issue
- 37:30by that motion. So those are a couple I wanted
- 37:34to mention. I thought we used a good tactical
- 37:38effect beyond just keeping out something crappy.
- 37:41You don't want the jury to hear. That's interesting.
- 37:44Beyond the case that you just mentioned, in your
- 37:47practice, have you seen favorable or unfavorable
- 37:50rulings on motions in Lemonay affecting the settlement
- 37:53value of a case and precipitating further settlement
- 37:57discussions on the courthouse steps? Well, I
- 38:01have. Now, of course, this depends on whether
- 38:03you really get the motions in Lemonay heard at
- 38:06the final pretrial conference or the status conference.
- 38:09I know I get judges who just hold it in advance
- 38:13and say that they'll rule on the first day of
- 38:16the trial hoping you just settle. But yeah I
- 38:18mean if you can get it done far enough in advance
- 38:20I have had the experience that someone taps me
- 38:23on the shoulder and you know we get a resolution
- 38:27either before the trial starts or maybe during
- 38:29it because you know the client wakes up and says
- 38:32hmm this I'm not sure I really want to see the
- 38:36end result of this trial with that ruling. Talking
- 38:40about the three, whether Judge Hammond thinks
- 38:44that's too few, maybe I should up it to five.
- 38:47Certainly a motion that I think would not only
- 38:51practically keep an evidence out, but will interject
- 38:54an issue or cause the other side to have second
- 38:57thoughts or cause the other side to worry, could
- 38:59be worth it even as in the case that I just mentioned.
- 39:03the motion's denied, and it laid an appellate
- 39:06issue into the case. And so that really raises
- 39:09the issue that we're asked. Two questions came
- 39:11in while we were doing this. One is, do you need
- 39:13to have a formal written motion in limine? And
- 39:17the answer is no. In my view, if there's something
- 39:19that comes up in the middle of the trial, you
- 39:21can bring a request to the court on the motion
- 39:24in limine. Judge Hammack, you want to talk about
- 39:25that? Where if someone just says during the course
- 39:28something's coming up and brings an MIL orally?
- 39:31But, you know, I saw it as I was typing in the
- 39:33chat. Ask the question again, Mr. Q. Sure, sure,
- 39:35sure. Of course. Can you bring an oral motion
- 39:37in limiting? Does that be a written motion? Right.
- 39:39So let's talk about that. Why not? So the other
- 39:41question. Right. So there's two points. One is
- 39:43someone says, can you bring it in? Don't wait
- 39:44a minute. Don't make it in front of the jury,
- 39:47obviously. Thank you. So the only reason. You
- 39:49know, I'm not. In the accomplished court. The
- 39:52judges oftentimes say, if you think evidentially
- 39:55there might be something that's not going to
- 39:57be coming in and it's important to you, bring
- 39:59an early motion and eliminate. Bring it early,
- 40:02right? So judges do it early, right? Well, I
- 40:04tell you what, if you think it's going to help.
- 40:06If I make a decision on one issue. Now there's
- 40:11always here's someone going to learn something.
- 40:14Subdivision T force 37 C subdivision T. I defy
- 40:21anybody. Who knows that? It's been around for
- 40:24almost 10 years. I've never seen a subdivision
- 40:27T motion. You know what that is? Remember, some
- 40:31of the judgments, it has to go to a cause of
- 40:34action, a defense, to the complaint, an issue
- 40:38of duty, a particular damage. You just can't
- 40:41have it to an issue, right? So let's say an issue
- 40:45that would be dispositive potentially, or help
- 40:48you settle the case. You could file a subdivision
- 40:52T motion, it's, I've never seen anyone do it.
- 40:5510 years in an IC court, never seen one. Most
- 40:58judges don't even know the statute exists because
- 41:00no one's ever filed a motion. And you both stipulate
- 41:05to hear the motion and you say it'll help us
- 41:08resolve the case, even though it won't adjudicate
- 41:11the case, because you can always file a motion
- 41:13for some adjudication on a thing that you're
- 41:16allowed to do. or something but it doesn't fit
- 41:18that it's not it's a subdivision t -motion that's
- 41:22how you do it and then i can agree or not to
- 41:25agree why wouldn't i agree you're both telling
- 41:28me if i decide this one issue that can't be on
- 41:32a summary adjudication or summary judgment but
- 41:36i can that'll help you solve the case i'll do
- 41:40it now whether you want to do it as emotional
- 41:42eliminate that's fine with me too if it's going
- 41:45to help you I have to believe it though, okay?
- 41:49So you have to convince me that this motion in
- 41:53limine or T -motion, because I still think you
- 41:56have to give the 81 days, but here's the beautiful.
- 41:59Remember, you guys all know this because you
- 42:01all know the CCP by heart. You can always stipulate
- 42:04to less than 81 days, right? You can stipulate
- 42:09to whatever you want. I always say I have all
- 42:11this power. I could sentence people to death,
- 42:13but I can't. lower the 81 days. I don't have
- 42:16that power. Only you guys can stipulate to lowering
- 42:19the 81 days. So if you really think it's important,
- 42:23and it's really, remember, like Mr. Spillane
- 42:25correctly noted, you can't file a motion and
- 42:27eliminate it's disguised MSJ or MSA. You couldn't
- 42:31even do it on a T, right? But if you guys want
- 42:34to all agree, judge, hear this motion two weeks
- 42:37before or three weeks before the trial. before
- 42:40we have to spend all the time and money working
- 42:41the case up. And this will help us maybe settle
- 42:43the case, stipulate to a quick T. OK? Right.
- 42:48So for those watching the presentation, number
- 42:50one, you can bring an early motion in limine
- 42:52if the court invites it, and you can do it. And
- 42:55additionally, you can do it orally during the
- 42:57course of a trial. There's no requirement that
- 42:59it be a written motion, right? I agree. OK. But
- 43:03well, yes and no. Remember the rule of court
- 43:08that talks about motions eliminate. It's it is.
- 43:12I think it contemplates a written motion and
- 43:15so does the local rule. I think you need to.
- 43:18I would hear it as a practical matter, but one
- 43:22could say you know this should be in writing
- 43:24because the role contemplates, but I can excuse
- 43:26writings. Right? Yeah, under 128 under that ominous
- 43:31power that the motions are based upon. So I would
- 43:34say from a plane standpoint. I don't have a notebook
- 43:39of MILs that I bring in every case. I just do
- 43:42not. I look at each individual case and what
- 43:44facts and what issues am I concerned about coming
- 43:47out in this trial that I think they ought not
- 43:50present to this jury. And that is the basis for
- 43:52the motion and limiting. It's very fact -intensive.
- 43:56Right. And you know what I generally see? I don't
- 43:59see that. I see a lot, unfortunately, employment
- 44:02law, Song Beverly. that are attorney's fees driven
- 44:06cases, and I see the same cut and paste motions.
- 44:10Isn't that sad? And it's the same ones, identical.
- 44:14And I'm not saying there's nothing wrong with
- 44:16that, but when you come in with your attorney's
- 44:18fees and ask me for 15 hours for preparing those
- 44:20motions to eliminate, that you've used the same
- 44:2317 other cases you've had in front of me, I'm
- 44:26a little skeptical about that. As a pure contingency
- 44:31fee lawyer, I'm always very jealous of the time
- 44:34I spend on all this stuff. So I agree with you
- 44:36100%. Yeah. So again, choose your battles. Choose
- 44:41the ones that really make a difference. Don't
- 44:43do it for academic purposes, OK? And now here's
- 44:48a question, Judge. I think we're gaining the
- 44:50favor of the court by not overwhelming you with
- 44:53motion you've limited where they're really unnecessary.
- 44:57Again, I don't do tentative rulings rarely. I
- 45:00do them on the huge complicated cases, but I'm
- 45:03not going to, some judges write out tentatives.
- 45:05I don't, I'll just orally do it from my book.
- 45:08You bought me the book. I'm just saying denied.
- 45:11Well, I do the comical, you know, do you really
- 45:12care about this? No, you're granted. Do you really
- 45:14care? Oh, do not, and then punt or whatever I
- 45:17do. So I'll give you, and here's what I do. I
- 45:19don't, a lot of judges, and I think you should
- 45:22be prepared for this. Most judges want to rule
- 45:24and the motions eliminate. at the final status
- 45:27conference, right? Most judges do that, not me.
- 45:31Why do I not do that? Because you guys usually
- 45:35settle. And I'm going to read five binders of
- 45:39motions lemonade, and you're going to show up
- 45:40at the FSA, oh, we resolved the case, Judge.
- 45:43OK? I do it a week before. Are you really going
- 45:47to go? Is the train on the track? Is my calendar
- 45:50clear? Everybody's going to go. Then I'll read
- 45:52the motions of the lemonade, okay? And then we'll
- 45:55do it on the day of the trial because I'll call
- 45:57the panel the next day. That's what I typically
- 46:00do. It's more efficient. But going back to your
- 46:03point, Mr. Queso, I think it's a fair point.
- 46:05Again, I don't, you know, overwhelmed, we're
- 46:07overwhelmed. Yes, of course. But you know, you
- 46:11got to do what you got to do to protect your
- 46:13client. And if you think there's 20 motions of
- 46:15lemonade, follow the 20 motions of lemonade,
- 46:18okay? My average... And I don't mind three. I
- 46:23think I would love it if it was just three from
- 46:26each side. But I'm more realistic. I'm thinking
- 46:31five to 10, I won't really get too concerned.
- 46:37Once it gets past that, it does concern me. I
- 46:43just did the Google case, long case sued for
- 46:47$3 billion B. stole Google ads. I want you to
- 46:53think about this for a second. Long trial. Three
- 46:56months. The plaintiff says Google stole, somebody
- 47:01stole the idea for Google ads. Google ads made
- 47:05three trillion dollars in gross revenues in the
- 47:08last 10 years with a T. So this was huge. Three
- 47:13motions eliminate. They were very complicated
- 47:17and it took me forever to go through them. But
- 47:20these were good team of lawyers, 20 lawyers on
- 47:23each side. They each had three limine, motions
- 47:25of limine. How about that? Three billion dollar
- 47:30case. I just wanted to pick up a procedural point
- 47:33because Paul brought up you can make a motion
- 47:35and orally and you need to be in writing. I had
- 47:39a case in Ventura which may be a little more
- 47:41in length toward this big multi -month thing
- 47:43Paul tries and maybe it was like six or seven
- 47:46weeks it complicated. doctors suing each other
- 47:49for breach of fiduciary duty, and every morning
- 47:51the judge would appear on the bench and says,
- 47:53is there anything counsel wants to address outside
- 47:56the presence of the jury? And there we did things
- 47:59like you go to the other side, hey, tomorrow
- 48:02I see you're bringing witness Smith, are you
- 48:06going to try to elicit this and say yes or no?
- 48:09And then you can bring it up to the judge. We've
- 48:11had the discussion and agree that they're not
- 48:12going to. have Smith say this, or they say, hey,
- 48:15they are gonna ask Smith say this, and we couldn't
- 48:17agree, and so we want an order on this. And the
- 48:21judge was fully willing to take that up on that
- 48:24kind of early morning basis without everyone
- 48:30have to put that in writing. Or maybe if you
- 48:33had the conversation at five o 'clock when everyone's
- 48:35going home, you file a two -pager or something.
- 48:37But - Every judge is different. Notice the rule.
- 48:40It's based upon inherent authority and the discretion
- 48:43to control your calendar in courtroom. That's
- 48:46what it's all from. So a judge can honestly could
- 48:48say without abusing their discretion, counsel,
- 48:52it needs to be in writing. Okay. They could say
- 48:55that and that's a proper order or they could
- 48:57do like I do. I always have the lawyers come
- 48:5915 minutes before the jury because just in case
- 49:02something comes up. Okay. And I got in that group
- 49:05there. Oh my God. Are you ready for this? They
- 49:08were filing. between five and 10 motions to eliminate
- 49:11every day during the trial at three o 'clock
- 49:14in the morning. So much for the three in the
- 49:17beginning, right? I'm not making this up. They
- 49:21both had 20 lawyers. They had teams of lawyers.
- 49:26Yes, especially Google. All right, so and they
- 49:30were literally following stuff at two or three
- 49:31o 'clock in the morning. So upstairs, I have
- 49:34upstairs Google. TikTok and Metta, Snap and Instagram.
- 49:38I've got two trillion dollars worth of market
- 49:40capital. There's maybe a thousand lawyers. So
- 49:42I suspect there's gonna be a lot of MILs flying
- 49:44around. And they did it during the trial. Every
- 49:46single day there was a MIL file. They did it
- 49:49in writing. But if someone said to me, judge,
- 49:52I just heard they're gonna bring this person
- 49:54that weren't on the witness list. You know, hey,
- 49:57and what are they gonna, you know, we're gonna
- 49:58talk about it, right? We're gonna talk about
- 50:00it. Let me ask you a question, because I have
- 50:02a case going back to a war story. This is about
- 50:0515 years ago. I had a client who was involved
- 50:07in a rear -end collision. He was in a pickup
- 50:09truck, an attractive trailer slammed into him
- 50:12and just crushed it. And he had surgery. He was
- 50:15in a coma. But at the hospital, he was a 22 -year
- 50:19-old kid. At the hospital, he had a joint in
- 50:22his pocket and $5 ,000 in cash. OK? and had nothing
- 50:28to do with this case. There was no, there was
- 50:30no intoxication. There was nothing. They did
- 50:33all the blood tests. It was a pure, innocent
- 50:36collision. And so I burned an M .I .L. There'd
- 50:38be no mention of money in his pocket and no mention
- 50:41of the joint in his pocket and that the motion
- 50:43was granted by the judge. It was clear that they
- 50:46were near the very end of the trial. And I've
- 50:50got my client on the witness stand and the defense
- 50:52attorney says, sir, how can you explain that
- 50:55you had $5 ,000? and a joint in your pocket?
- 51:00Well, they saw that person willfully violated
- 51:02the motion in Lemonade. The judge asked the jury
- 51:06out of the courtroom. What do you want? Do you
- 51:08want an admonition? Do you want a new trial?
- 51:11Do you want me to report him to the state bar?
- 51:13Do you want me to sanction him? It's up to you.
- 51:15You've got to make the call. And that's exactly
- 51:17what the judge did. He basically said, Mr. Keisel,
- 51:19if you want to declare a mistrial, I will declare
- 51:21a mistrial. I was three weeks into the trial.
- 51:24I'll declare a mistrial. I'm going to start again.
- 51:26I can admonish the jury. And that's all I could
- 51:29do. I couldn't possibly have started this trial
- 51:32all over again. And someone asked a question
- 51:35earlier about, in your closing argument, you
- 51:39weave in the theme that got thrown out there
- 51:42so viciously to just show how bad it is. Yeah,
- 51:45Judge. This is not legal advice, it's an observation.
- 51:50Somebody willfully, obnoxiously violates the
- 51:53MIL because they're begging for the mistrial,
- 51:56right? It's not going well, right? They're begging.
- 52:00You can't create your own mistrial, right? But
- 52:03you know what I would ask the judge to do in
- 52:06that one? Admonish him publicly in front of the
- 52:09jury and tell the jury that he specifically violated
- 52:13your order. and that you gave an order. Are those
- 52:17all facts? Be careful for what you ask for. So
- 52:22that might be an appropriate remedy for me not
- 52:25just to admonish the jury. Don't disregard that.
- 52:29That's not admissible blah, blah, blah. Publicly
- 52:32admonish counsel. Counsel, I gave you an order.
- 52:36It was an expressed order that you were never
- 52:37to bring this up and you brought this out willfully
- 52:40in violation of my order. And the jury is going
- 52:43to know that. And you can consider that, Count,
- 52:47in assessing whether you want to believe anything
- 52:49he says that comes out of his mouth, which is
- 52:51not evidence anyway. I mean, that's a fair point.
- 52:54That's a fair and important point. You cannot
- 52:56do something to invite a mistrial yourself. And
- 52:59that occasionally happens in my practice, where
- 53:01the cases are not going well. And they sort of
- 53:04do something to invite a mistrial to really do
- 53:07that. Yeah, and if you do get the mistrial I
- 53:10would ask for all the money that you spent up
- 53:12to then but of course You get a piece of paper
- 53:15that says they owe you money. I don't know what
- 53:16that means One of my funniest motions in this
- 53:19trial I had I had to fly two witnesses up to
- 53:22testify from LA the cases of Northern, California
- 53:25and I At that time, I had a plane. So I flew
- 53:28the witnesses up in the aircraft to testify.
- 53:32And I brought a motion in limine that no mention
- 53:34should ever be made of how witnesses were moved
- 53:37in and out of that court. And the defense attorney
- 53:41said, you know, I'm not sure I would have asked
- 53:42the question anyway, because the jury would have
- 53:43figured you didn't need it. I disagree with you,
- 53:46Mr. Queso. That might go to bias, and you're
- 53:50flying them first class, and you have a witness
- 53:54that you flew first class. You put them up at
- 53:56the four -star Beverly Hills Hotel. That might
- 53:58be relevant, to be honest with you. I'm glad
- 54:01I wasn't in front of you. Okay, I think we're
- 54:06nearing the end of the hour. Paul, I think you
- 54:09mentioned several of your cases and motions that
- 54:12you've either brought or encountered, but is
- 54:14there one more that you want to mention or do
- 54:17you want to leave it there? No, I think it's
- 54:19worth saying. You have to look at each and every
- 54:21case. And if it's a fact -specific issue that
- 54:24you want to make sure it does not get before
- 54:26the jury, do one of two things. Bring a motion
- 54:29in lemonade to try to prevent it from coming
- 54:31in. Or at a minimum, have the court deny it without
- 54:36prejudice, but not allow the defense side or
- 54:39the planet to introduce it in opening. I want
- 54:42to limit opening as much as possible. And the
- 54:44motions in lemonade are the best way to do that,
- 54:47sir. Okay. One more question for you, Paul, before
- 54:51we wrap it up. What types of motions are brought
- 54:57against you that you see in your practice and
- 55:00what do you think about those? I would say a
- 55:02lot of the motions involve the photographs. of
- 55:05my clients. It may show their injuries. It may
- 55:09show blood. I may want to have x -rays and other
- 55:13things that shows the hardware inside of bodies.
- 55:16So it's very common that motion and limiting
- 55:18are to prevent. visual evidence I want to present
- 55:22to the jury. So I'm always mindful of the fact
- 55:24that I'm going to have a series of pictures that
- 55:26show injury that they do not show blood or I
- 55:29can use Photoshop to reduce the amount of blood.
- 55:32I'll do things to clean it up, but that's a common
- 55:35motion that we get to prevent visual evidence.
- 55:39Interesting. Okay. Jay, what about you? Do you
- 55:43have any final comments that you'd like to make
- 55:45or things that people listening should keep in
- 55:48mind? in their practice? Well, sure, since in
- 55:52my business cases, I don't know if this really
- 55:55differs from injury cases, but I tend to have
- 55:57a very expert, heavy set of cases on damages
- 56:00and that type of thing that Jerry might not be
- 56:03familiar with. Just in terms of practice, it's
- 56:06very important in the deposition, you read catamaran,
- 56:10and it's very important when you're closing the
- 56:12deposition. or madam, are these all, if you now
- 56:17told me either earlier in your report or both,
- 56:20all of the opinions you anticipate speaking to
- 56:24a trial, is there anything you're still working
- 56:27on? Is there anything that you're halfway done
- 56:32with? If you get that in the deposition and then
- 56:36the experts are trying to come out with something
- 56:38at the trial that you haven't heard before, then
- 56:41you've, The judges are really going to respect
- 56:44your catamaran motion. If you don't set that
- 56:46up with that stock cadence at the end, then you
- 56:51open yourself up to the idea that you didn't
- 56:54close the door. That's a motion I'm seeing more
- 56:58of. I know in this six to seven week doctor fiduciary
- 57:02duty trial, I had a motion because there was
- 57:05a number of the expert was going to come out
- 57:08with. on a category we hadn't seen before. And
- 57:11we had done a very lock -solid job of that. We
- 57:15were able to exclude that because we had the
- 57:19deposition transcript and showed that we'd shut
- 57:21the door on that. So that's something we should
- 57:25all be keeping in mind. Great. All right. Before
- 57:29we conclude, Judge Hammack, do you want to make
- 57:32a final comment about the importance that you
- 57:35see? in motions and limine. I know every case
- 57:39is different and there are different ways to
- 57:42do this, but what do you think generally? Again,
- 57:45I go back, you'll choose your battles, be specific.
- 57:48you know, make sure it's a, be a practical about
- 57:51it. Don't be, you know, academic about it, okay?
- 57:55And then if I don't, if you don't mind, there
- 57:57were two correct guesses on who I was today,
- 58:00okay? It was Claudia Melring and Jonathan Terry.
- 58:05Congratulations. When you show up in my courtroom,
- 58:09this will be the symbol for the, like from the
- 58:11movie The Sting. that you get the continuance
- 58:14if you want it. I can't say it out loud, that
- 58:16looks bad. But I'll give you another clue for
- 58:20everyone else, if you don't mind. I'm a motivational
- 58:25speaker, I'm 35 years old, twice divorced, and
- 58:31I live in a van down by the river. Anybody? It's
- 58:38Matt Foley's character, Chris Farley, from Saturday
- 58:41Night Live. There were two great cases, other
- 58:43good guesses too. So anyway, thank you all for
- 58:46inviting me. It was certainly my honor and privilege
- 58:49to be with these esteemed lawyers. Well, thank
- 58:53you very much. There's no better way to end the
- 58:55program than with Matt Foley. Thank you, Judge
- 58:58Hammack, for your time and your outfit. Paul,
- 59:03Jay, it was a pleasure to be on this panel with
- 59:06you. Really valuable insights. And thank you
- 59:09for allowing me to moderate. Thanks for having
- 59:11us join. Appreciate it. We're right at 1 30.
- 59:15So the Beverly Hills Bar Association won't get
- 59:17mad at me for ending it early. So thank you all.
- 59:21And I hope those who listened got something out
- 59:25of it. And go Dodgers. It goes without saying,
- 59:29for sure.