Latest / Birds 365: A Philadelphia Eagles Podcast / Is Howie Roseman STILL the Best GM in the NFL?
Transcript
- 0:00[SPEAKER_00]: and good opening segment here on birds 365.
- 0:04[SPEAKER_00]: I want to pivot a little bit here and start to look a little bit at the NFL draft.
- 0:08[SPEAKER_00]: Before we do that, I want to take a look at the German manager who will be making a pick or making the picks in the NFL draft will be negotiating the deals or at least be the forefront of negotiating the deals in free agency.
- 0:21[SPEAKER_00]: John, how he rose.
- 0:23[SPEAKER_00]: How do you think he's been the last year?
- 0:26[SPEAKER_00]: You know, coming off the Super Bowl, everybody had him as the greatest GM, you know, maybe to ever exist in the history of all pro sports.
- 0:32[SPEAKER_00]: I don't know if that was a little bit off that I do think he's a great general manager.
- 0:36[SPEAKER_00]: How about the last year?
- 0:38[SPEAKER_00]: How much do you think how he roseman has to do with the Eagles coming up short in the last season?
- 0:45[SPEAKER_01]: Well, I, you know, I, I think he's the best GM in the NFL.
- 0:50[SPEAKER_01]: I thought that coming into last off season.
- 0:53[SPEAKER_01]: I thought that coming out of last off season.
- 0:56[SPEAKER_01]: I think that today, I think he's the best GM in the NFL.
- 1:01[SPEAKER_01]: Now, John Snyder is going to get a bunch of love.
- 1:04[SPEAKER_01]: It's showed this week and there's guys in the conversation.
- 1:12[SPEAKER_01]: less need, obviously, would be in the conversation, but very small list.
- 1:18[SPEAKER_01]: And I think he's at the top of it.
- 1:21[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think that changes.
- 1:22[SPEAKER_01]: Look, he told you what they were doing last year.
- 1:25[SPEAKER_01]: He was above board.
- 1:27[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I think everybody, well, he didn't sign anybody.
- 1:30[SPEAKER_01]: He told you why he didn't sign anybody.
- 1:34[SPEAKER_01]: You know, so I think for those people, it's difficult to understand.
- 1:39[SPEAKER_01]: You know, nobody had spent more cash over the past decade than a Philadelphia Eagles and they had to sort of reset the copper, so to speak, for what's coming, on the deep end subsided of the football.
- 1:57[SPEAKER_01]: You know, we talked about that draft success, didn't materialize as much this season,
- 2:04[SPEAKER_01]: Um, this past season, not because J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J-J
- 2:32[SPEAKER_01]: They moved up from 32 to 31 to get you high, but they were trying to move up to, I think it was 22, as high as 22 to get them.
- 2:43[SPEAKER_01]: And then as I said, last picking the second round, you get through McCuba.
- 2:47[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's pretty good.
- 2:49[SPEAKER_01]: Now after that, not much.
- 2:51[SPEAKER_01]: But I mean, look, we go through this every year.
- 2:56[SPEAKER_01]: We went through it the year prior,
- 3:02[SPEAKER_01]: Anious Smith and Trevor Keegan in the tribe.
- 3:06[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, it's like, come on, guys, you can't expect day three picks to just be immediate different smakers.
- 3:16[SPEAKER_01]: It doesn't work that way.
- 3:18[SPEAKER_01]: And so all the Thai Robinson's and Mac McWilliams and Small Monday and Stroop Candle, they had a bunch of picks.
- 3:25[SPEAKER_01]: Kyle McCord, Miles St. and Cam Williams, Antoine Powell, Rylan.
- 3:32[SPEAKER_01]: Cow's gone, so you know, but he's a six round pick.
- 3:35[SPEAKER_01]: It's the 180 first pick in the draft.
- 3:39[SPEAKER_01]: Powell, Rylan's the two hundred and I've picked in the draft.
- 3:43[SPEAKER_01]: You know, I would have liked to have seen more from Ty Robinson.
- 3:47[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's fair.
- 3:48[SPEAKER_01]: I would have liked to have seen more from Mac McWilliams.
- 3:52[SPEAKER_01]: I think that's fair.
- 3:55[SPEAKER_01]: I thought smiled at a nice job in his role, and I think the offense of lime in her worthwhile swings, all three of them.
- 4:03[SPEAKER_01]: So yeah, I don't look at last year as a failure from how he roseman's perspective, understanding that what he was trying to accomplish, which I think people are going to leave that out that you might not like it,
- 4:24[SPEAKER_01]: You should like it when they're able to re-sign jailing Carter and Jordan Davis, and putting on Mitchell Cooper to sheen down the road.
- 4:33[SPEAKER_00]: Yeah, it's fair.
- 4:34[SPEAKER_00]: It's going to look at it.
- 4:34[SPEAKER_00]: It's kind of how I see it, too, as well, John.
- 4:36[SPEAKER_00]: I don't think how we, like, I don't think he had a great year, but I think you nailed it where you talk about what the expectation was.
- 4:43[SPEAKER_00]: And I just don't think the person else was problem number one on this team this year.
- 4:47[SPEAKER_00]: I know you and I have disagreed to some extent on that or maybe I'm over rating the players,
- 4:53[SPEAKER_00]: I really don't look at the way the team didn't reach expectations this year as a personal issue.
- 5:00[SPEAKER_00]: I really didn't.
- 5:01[SPEAKER_00]: I'll just run it back for everybody.
- 5:04[SPEAKER_00]: John, tell me if I missed anybody, I think I got this pretty comprehensively.
- 5:08[SPEAKER_00]: All right, so who left last year?
- 5:09[SPEAKER_00]: Milton left, sweat left, sliced left, Bradbury heads in a matter.
- 5:14[SPEAKER_00]: CJ Garner Johnson left, Isaiah Rogers left, McCide Beckden left, or in Berks' left
- 5:23[SPEAKER_00]: All right, that's the part of the team post Super Bowl last year.
- 5:27[SPEAKER_00]: Then who you brought in?
- 5:28[SPEAKER_00]: Josh Gouche is the team of science, a little rattle law for you.
- 5:33[SPEAKER_00]: Josh Gouche, Aziz Ojalari, Patrick Johnson, Adori Jackson, AJ Dillon, Harrison Bryan and Kyle and Grant and Kendall Lam and Matt prior, every Williams and Kenny on Green, and then your draft, first time I picked you hot, Campbell, second time I picked Andrew McCuba,
- 5:51[SPEAKER_00]: fourth round pecti Robinson, fifth round pecti Mac Williams, fifth round pecti again, small munden, six round pect miles hidden, and I think there was a couple more in there, I'm leaving out on the round seven, and then the mid-season moves that were made with Jalen Phillips, obviously the big move, Michael Carter, Jai-Year Alexander,
- 6:15[SPEAKER_00]: two of those guys walked out of here.
- 6:16[SPEAKER_00]: So that's kind of what you're looking at all the moves trying to did feel like a lot of moves for not a lot of value or not a lot of production.
- 6:24[SPEAKER_00]: But maybe that's what was necessary last year.
- 6:27[SPEAKER_00]: I just wanted to take a look at kind of the what how we did last year and if that's considered a down year for him too, you know, we talk with the players a lot.
- 6:36[SPEAKER_01]: Well, yeah, I mean, if you don't add in the context, yeah, I guess it will be considered a bad year because if you're just pretending like, well, you're son in a bunch of one-year guys because you're trying to reset in the one-year guys didn't hit and, you know, people talked and said, look, how many times we hear in the off-season coming in the season, we got a big Harrison Bryant fan.
- 7:07[SPEAKER_01]: Look, contracts tell you a lot.
- 7:09[SPEAKER_01]: They don't tell you everything, but they tell you a lot.
- 7:12[SPEAKER_01]: And if guys are signing for one year at the better and minimum, or the most expensive player with those you'll already who didn't work out at all, and I think you got $3 million somewhere in that range, not a lot.
- 7:29[SPEAKER_01]: I mean,
- 7:30[SPEAKER_01]: as big said you get what you pay for you go to North Strums you get something nice you get talent Phillips you know go to the wall bar clearance all yeah you maybe find something every once in a while i mean yanky span i i found a nice Mickey Manel print in in in the wallmark clearance all once it's really nice there you go John I spent like five
- 8:01[SPEAKER_01]: But, best majority, you got a bunch of nothing, right?
- 8:06[SPEAKER_01]: And, look, I don't want to over, I thought, Josh, you should have played very well early in the season, and then they shipped it off and kind of screwed them.
- 8:15[SPEAKER_01]: But, I mean, that's the life of the NFL player.
- 8:21[SPEAKER_01]: You know, guys were coming back and they traded for Jalen Phillips and they convinced BG to come back and he, you know, and there's not a spot for him.
- 8:28[SPEAKER_01]: That's what happens.
- 8:30[SPEAKER_01]: AJ Dillon, you know, a lot of people were hyped about him.
- 8:34[SPEAKER_01]: Nothing, Harrison Bryant didn't even make it to the season, but did a decent job in Houston as a playoff team, a Dory.
- 8:42[SPEAKER_01]: I said played pretty well.
- 8:44[SPEAKER_01]: Patrick Johnson, a good special team's player.
- 8:51[SPEAKER_01]: Every Williams did nothing.
- 8:52[SPEAKER_01]: There was a lot of hype about him as the manufacturer touched guy, the returner didn't even make the team.
- 8:58[SPEAKER_01]: Colin Granson, OK, did a good job on special teams.
- 9:02[SPEAKER_01]: Ozilari didn't play much.
- 9:04[SPEAKER_01]: Kendall Lam didn't make it to the season.
- 9:07[SPEAKER_01]: Matt Prior didn't do a great job as a backup when he had the opportunity, which was a little bit disappointing, considering the year was coming off of in Chicago.
- 9:21[SPEAKER_01]: Um, but I mean, I would say temper your expectations this year if you get some one year got when yeah, everybody does you get one year guys and temper your expectations on those guys.
- 9:38[SPEAKER_01]: That would that would be my moral of that story.
- 9:41[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I think one part of the broken thought process, which I'm pretty sure you would learn it to us to at the time, was how good Zach Bon was, and remember, yeah, yeah, I say everybody's a nice piece.
- 9:52[SPEAKER_00]: I'm making mental print in the one part.
- 9:55[SPEAKER_00]: He's the making, you know, you keep coming back, John, you keep going back to Walmart and you're walking with the small sliver of optimism, maybe.
- 10:04[SPEAKER_00]: Oh.
- 10:04[SPEAKER_00]: Maybe I'll get lucky again, but but years have gone by John and you still haven't gotten lucky like you did that Mickey Manel print, but it's enough to keep you coming back just in case you can find another diamond in the world.
- 10:18[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, so I mean, that's what you're shooting for and they did that purposefully though, so I think that port is missed.
- 10:26[SPEAKER_01]: They wanted to resets and, you know, because.
- 10:31[SPEAKER_01]: Pain guy's cash up front is a lot of what has made this team successful and they know they're going to have to do it with some big time talent so.
- 10:45[SPEAKER_01]: That's where we are, and that's what happened, and, you know, I get it from a band perspective.
- 10:51[SPEAKER_01]: They want to go hell or high water to win every year, but it's just not realistic.
- 10:55[SPEAKER_00]: And now, I'm, I didn't bring this up to rip alley.
- 10:57[SPEAKER_00]: I just wanted to look at the year and and think get, get a gauge, like, how much do you think the personnel situation they were in, even if you think how we, you know, get, get what it could with him?
- 11:08[SPEAKER_00]: Well, I, you know, personnel.
- 11:16[SPEAKER_01]: to me that the issue and where we differ on personnel is you had a bunch of guys with big reputations that didn't play up to those reputations.
- 11:24[SPEAKER_00]: That's a big issue.
- 11:27[SPEAKER_01]: Specifically on an offensive side of the ball, you know, if you can somehow replicate Sake Juan Barclay, I'm probably out Northern California, you know, again, not, you know, you get the point for the Super Bowl,
- 11:46[SPEAKER_01]: But, you know, if you can replicate that offensive line performance, probably talking to you from San Francisco right now, if you, you know, if AJ plays like AJ, typically does, you know, it's just a bunch of guys I talked about it, everybody.
- 12:11[SPEAKER_01]: took it down take now different reasons right offence of line lane wasn't healthy didn't play the last eight games obviously didn't have the same season.
- 12:21[SPEAKER_01]: Cam had the back surgery struggled coming off it especially early in the season not the same player landed multiple injuries not the same player.
- 12:30[SPEAKER_01]: Jordan my lot I think still played well but you might have been according to
- 12:39[SPEAKER_01]: the 2024 season, he didn't live up to that standard.
- 12:43[SPEAKER_01]: Again, not a drastic fall off.
- 12:47[SPEAKER_01]: Tylerstein was okay as a first time starter.
- 12:51[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think he was as good as McCoy back then, who, by the way, was terrible with the chargers.
- 12:56[SPEAKER_01]: So it's not like bringing him back would have been the right decision either necessarily.
- 13:03[SPEAKER_01]: Dallas got it.
- 13:04[SPEAKER_01]: I realized people are going to look at, well, he had all those touchdowns.
- 13:08[SPEAKER_01]: Yeah, he did, but he also had a big, big drop off from a typical level when it comes to blocking game and what's more important for this team than the running game.
- 13:21[SPEAKER_01]: So I, I still argue that Dallas didn't play quite as well as all around player.
- 13:29[SPEAKER_01]: And I think he would say the same thing.
- 13:31[SPEAKER_01]: Devante, Devante's the closest, he's probably more in the just place like he always played.
- 13:40[SPEAKER_01]: But if you force me, I'd say it wasn't quite as good as he typically is.
- 13:46[SPEAKER_01]: So you're talking a whole offense and the quarterback, which did not play as well, or efficiently, I think it, you know, the first seven eight games, I think it was playing better
- 14:03[SPEAKER_01]: from an efficiency standpoint.
- 14:05[SPEAKER_01]: So, that's, that's top to overcome, man, when everybody's going in a negative direction.
- 14:12[SPEAKER_01]: And you can blame it all on Kevin Patulov, if you want.
- 14:17[SPEAKER_01]: But, yeah, I mean, yeah, who said it?
- 14:24[SPEAKER_01]: Oh, I thought it was great because I've been talking about this a lot because,
- 14:29[SPEAKER_01]: Todd Muckin was, I don't know if you saw him talk in yesterday, got introduced as the little browns head coach and there was a lot of Jim Swartz talk because Jim is obviously unhappy out there and wondered the job and probably should have gave it to him to be honest because he's been through it all there with that crappy organization.
- 14:52[SPEAKER_01]: Um, so I get that he's unhappy and they were asking Todd and he started off and he was very smart.
- 14:58[SPEAKER_01]: He said, well, I, you know, I don't feel numb.
- 15:01[SPEAKER_01]: I'm a position to talk about that right now.
- 15:04[SPEAKER_01]: Something in a paraphrasing.
- 15:05[SPEAKER_01]: But then they kept pressing him and then he kind of lost his goal a little bit from my perspective and he was like, I have a lot of respect for Jim sports.
- 15:15[SPEAKER_01]: I would think he has a lot of respect for me.
- 15:17[SPEAKER_01]: And then
- 15:21[SPEAKER_01]: When I play the Browns, I didn't, I didn't scheme to chip Jim Swords.
- 15:27[SPEAKER_01]: I scheme to chip Miles Garrett.
- 15:29[SPEAKER_01]: What he's saying is, I'm worried about the fucking players.
- 15:34[SPEAKER_01]: Not, not the coaches.
- 15:36[SPEAKER_01]: So I wish that would resonate with people.
- 15:39[SPEAKER_01]: It will not.
- 15:40[SPEAKER_01]: I get it.
- 15:41[SPEAKER_01]: But Jim's not going on out on the field.
- 15:44[SPEAKER_01]: Miles Garrett is.
- 15:46[SPEAKER_01]: Jim's a great deep answer corner to love the guy.
- 15:49[SPEAKER_01]: I always say nobody's taught me more about the fence of football than Jim's words love the guy.
- 15:57[SPEAKER_00]: Players man, players, players, players, players.
- 15:59[SPEAKER_00]: It's true, Jim.
- 16:00[SPEAKER_00]: It's very true, no doubt about it.
- 16:02[SPEAKER_00]: Good stuff there.
- 16:03[SPEAKER_00]: John, appreciate that little rundown right there.
- 16:06[SPEAKER_00]: It's good to see where this team is.
- 16:09[SPEAKER_00]: There's a lot on the table here this
- 16:15[SPEAKER_00]: wonder which way they're going to go here or how aggressive they will be.
- 16:19[SPEAKER_00]: But there is a lot out there.
- 16:21[SPEAKER_00]: So players first, John, what you're early in the end is way too early to say this, but you don't take Degos, they're going to have a big drop off D. I mean, the only reason I say that this early is because AJ Lane, well, I think it would be a lose.
- 16:37[SPEAKER_01]: I think it'd be a lose those guys.
- 16:38[SPEAKER_01]: There's the potential for that.
- 16:41[SPEAKER_01]: But I don't expect, I think Lane is gonna play.
- 16:44[SPEAKER_01]: I still think that.
- 16:46[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think he wants to end on that note, missing the final eight games.
- 16:54[SPEAKER_01]: AJ is more, as I said, I'm 5248, I don't think he'll be here, but I think the Eagles will try to talk him in there, run in a back for one more season at least.
- 17:06[SPEAKER_01]: So I'm more optimistic than not to have them both, but if you lose two players of that level, that would be very difficult, and if you lose jail and Phillips, that would be very difficult to replace.
- 17:26[SPEAKER_01]: You know, you have these issues with the coaching staff a little bit different in experience again after talking about all, all anybody talked about was the experience an hour, everybody's good with it.
- 17:38[SPEAKER_01]: Even less experience.
- 17:41[SPEAKER_01]: So you can see that going in a negative direction, you can see the all the stuff around vague.
- 17:47[SPEAKER_01]: Retiring potentially retiring, you know, the same thing's going to happen.
- 17:51[SPEAKER_01]: Everybody knows that this might be his last year.
- 17:54[SPEAKER_01]: So you, you could see, the, the, the, the, the path to have in a, a shit show of a season, you know, it's not going to be hard.
- 18:09[SPEAKER_01]: I mentioned this yesterday that for Jimmy Campsky to do is dumpster fires to the Eagles, because it,
- 18:16[SPEAKER_01]: You know, and well, things not everything is going to go bad, not everything's going to be right, but so I think they're going to be fine.
- 18:29[SPEAKER_01]: I don't think they're going to have a terrible season because, say, I think Lane's going to come back and I don't know about AJ, but I think, you know, I think they'll get jail and
- 18:45[SPEAKER_01]: So they'll be able to get that done and they have, you know, a bunch of projected draft picks and they've done a pretty good job, I think.
- 19:00[SPEAKER_01]: Well, and I'm looking at Wikipedia, so I don't know if this is right, but I know they started 23 and then they have 54, 60, 8.
- 19:12[SPEAKER_01]: in 98 potentially, which is the compensatory selection.
- 19:17[SPEAKER_01]: So, in theory, you're probably going to get four picks in the top 100, and, you know, you can find some valuable players in the top 100 if you, if you do your job correctly.
- 19:33[SPEAKER_00]: We'll see what they end up doing there.
- 19:35[SPEAKER_00]: I do think offensive tackles on the menu.
- 19:37[SPEAKER_00]: Obviously there's everybody thinks I think offensive tackle should be on the menu regardless of what Lane Johnson does now Oh, yeah, well has been for the past two years.
- 19:46[SPEAKER_01]: They've been trying to get that done for years, man It just doesn't work down.
- 19:50[SPEAKER_01]: You know, yeah again You know, you know, hey you have to like the player and he has to be there and when you're picking as Latest the Eagles have been picking that's
- 20:00[SPEAKER_01]: You're trying's not going to get it cut anymore, though.
- 20:02[SPEAKER_01]: I think I got to get it.
- 20:03[SPEAKER_01]: They're going to get an offensive plan.
- 20:04[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you're at the mercy of other teams, like they wanted Fautano a couple of years ago, and Pittsburgh drafted him two spots before him.
- 20:13[SPEAKER_01]: Maybe they were trying to go up to get him, and maybe Pittsburgh didn't want to go that, you know?
- 20:18[SPEAKER_01]: I mean, they wanted to play her.
- 20:21[SPEAKER_01]: It's, I get like, well, just go up and get him, and they went up and got your hot cam.
- 20:30[SPEAKER_01]: They were trying to go up to 22 to get your odd candle.
- 20:35[SPEAKER_01]: So somebody else was in there and wanted the player, you're screwed, but they ended up lasting all the way to 31.
- 20:47[SPEAKER_01]: So, you know, if it's Caden Proctor, you'd a lot of Caden Proctor hype so early in the process, but if he's the guy, you might have to go up to get him if you wanna secure it.
- 21:00[SPEAKER_01]: And he's somebody who could project to start out inside and move outside when you need to replace Lane Johnson, whatever it is.
- 21:15[SPEAKER_01]: So, but yeah, I mean, the draft is, unless you got the number one pick, nothing's guaranteed.
- 21:24[SPEAKER_01]: Then you know, you can take whoever you want it, number one.
- 21:31[SPEAKER_00]: We'll say, how aggressive you think I will be this summer?
- 21:36[SPEAKER_01]: Well, you go back.
- 21:38[SPEAKER_01]: You know, is AJ going to, is AJ a, a mannable plan here is laying going to play?
- 21:43[SPEAKER_01]: I think that affects his aggression greatly.
- 21:47[SPEAKER_01]: If AJs, if they can make up with AJ, they're not going to have all these caparamifications and they have more room to do stuff.
- 22:01[SPEAKER_01]: will up back the outhouse stuff, the out of past up.
- 22:04[SPEAKER_01]: So if they get lean, if they get AJ, if they get lean, he's not going to retire if they get AJ back in the fold, convince him to apply if they re-sign Jalen Phillips, especially at the kind of deals spot right
- 22:29[SPEAKER_01]: And totally aggressive, but to get one or two potential difference making players.
- 22:38[SPEAKER_01]: And I mean, you can see what they end up doing.