Latest / Decrypted: The UK Cyber Briefing / A failed airline's inbox is up for sale to train an AI: whose data is it?
Transcript
- 0:03This is Decrypted. Sunday, the eleventh of October.
- 0:07A failed airline's inbox is up for sale to train an AI: whose data is it?
- 0:14.
- 0:21And this week, 121 US lawmakers asked Google to stop.
- 0:27Spirit Airlines announced in May that it would shut down.
- 0:31Google has now proposed paying $10 million for its internal data, reportedly including about 100 million emai
- 0:39ls and 500 million Microsoft Teams messages.
- 0:43On Thursday, the lawmakers wrote to both companies asking them to halt the deal.
- 0:49It's an American sale, but the question belongs to every UK board.
- 0:54When your company fails, who controls what your staff wrote?
- 0:59Next.
- 1:03According to The Record, the data would also include employment contracts, timecard records, and payroll and
- 1:11tax information. Google wants it to train AI models.
- 1:15Google says the data will be deidentified.
- 1:18A Google spokesperson told the outlet the company is not seeking to buy personal information, and that data w
- 1:25ill either be fully excluded or deidentified by an independent third party before Google receives it.
- 1:32The deal is described as proposed.
- 1:36I couldn't confirm whether it has closed.
- 1:38The lawmakers acknowledged Google's assurances.
- 1:42Then they argued that standard deidentification may not protect employee privacy in the age of modern AI.
- 1:48And also.
- 1:53Imagine redacting a diary by blacking out every name.
- 1:57The reader still knows who wrote about "the pilot who argued about the Tuesday rota in Las Vegas".
- 2:04Chat is free text. Identity lives in context, not in the name field.
- 2:09The lawmakers put it plainly: "Removing names, email addresses, or other direct identifiers does not necessa
- 2:18rily make a dataset anonymous.
- 2:20"
- 2:24The aim is to reduce the risk of identifying people to a "sufficiently remote level".
- 2:29That's a judgement about risk.
- 2:32It's not a find-and-replace job.
- 2:34And also.
- 2:39The design decision that created this problem was made years ago.
- 2:43It was to keep everything.
- 2:45Collaboration tools make storage cheap and deletion an afterthought, so a company accumulates a decade of can
- 2:52did conversation. In insolvency, that archive becomes an asset.
- 2:57And the people who wrote it have no seat at the negotiating table.
- 3:01Secure by Design says the safest data is the data you no longer hold.
- 3:06For a UK organisation, that means four things.
- 3:10First, set retention limits for chat and email, and enforce them automatically, rather than relying on staff
- 3:17to tidy up.
- 3:21Grievances and health details turn up in "casual" chat.
- 3:25Third, read your supplier terms.
- 3:28Check what happens to your data, and your employees' data, if the supplier fails or is acquired, and whether
- 3:34it can be used to train models.
- 3:36Fourth, plan for your own insolvency.
- 3:39Ask your advisers now how an administrator would treat your archives, and tell staff what the answer is.
- 3:46A retention policy is a configuration setting and an uncomfortable meeting.
- 3:51And finally.
- 3:55UK G D P R doesn't stop at the bankruptcy door.
- 4:00In my reading, a buyer who can't show that identification risk is remote is holding personal data, with the d
- 4:07uties that follow. UK companies should expect insolvency practitioners and AI developers to ask how clean thei
- 4:14r archives are.
- 4:17The written version and every source are linked in the show notes.
- 4:20Thanks for listening.