Latest / eMotors: Electric Revolution / PHEV Market Analysis: Competitive Landscape and Segment Leaders
Transcript
- 0:10Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Today we are opening up a file
- 0:14that I think is going to make a lot of people look at their
- 0:17driveway a little differently. We're talking about the magic
- 0:20bullet of the green transition. You know the pitch, right?
- 0:23It's the best of both worlds. The plug in hybrid electric
- 0:26vehicle or the PHEV as the industry just loves to call.
- 0:30It exactly. It's the car that promises to
- 0:32solve everything. You get the electric motor for
- 0:34your commute, so you feel good. You save money, you save the
- 0:36planet. But you keep the gas engine for
- 0:38that summer road trip so you don't have to suffer through
- 0:41range anxiety. It's the ultimate have your cake
- 0:43and eat it too technology. And that's exactly how it's
- 0:46marketed. It's the perfect bridge, a way
- 0:48to get people out of pure combustion engines without
- 0:52forcing them to, you know, change their entire lifestyle
- 0:56overnight. And regulators, they love this
- 0:58idea. They incentivized it heavily.
- 1:00But looking at the stack of research we have on the desk
- 1:02today, specifically a massive new study from the European
- 1:06Commission, it, it looks like that bridge might be a little
- 1:09more wobbly than we. Thought wobbly is a polite way
- 1:12to put it. In fact, if we look at the
- 1:13numbers, it might not even be a bridge, it might be a trapdoor.
- 1:17That is a very, very apartment description.
- 1:20We're looking at a discrepancy here that is honestly hard to
- 1:23wrap your head around. When you look at the gap between
- 1:26what these cars claim to emit versus what they actually emit
- 1:30on the road, the numbers are just shocking.
- 1:33And we're not talking about a 10% variance here, are we?
- 1:36This isn't a rounding error, no. Not at all.
- 1:39According to the data, real world CO2 emissions for plug in
- 1:42hybrids are approximately 300% higher than the official test
- 1:46numbers. Wait, wait 300%. 300, yeah, and
- 1:49that's the average. For some manufacturers, it's
- 1:51actually even higher. That is a structural failure of
- 1:54the entire system. I mean, that means the green car
- 1:56you bought for the tax break might effectively be polluting
- 2:00just as much as the old gas car you traded in.
- 2:02Yeah, in some cases more. Yeah.
- 2:04And our mission today is to figure out why we need to unpack
- 2:07this thing called the utility factor, which is it's basically
- 2:11the math behind the lie. And we're going to look at the
- 2:14specific cars driving this market, from the sensible family
- 2:18haulers like the Kia Sportage to, well, the absolute beasts
- 2:22like the Ford Explorer. And we have to ask the hard
- 2:25question, is this technology actually working or is it just a
- 2:28regulatory loophole on wheels? Before we get into the cars
- 2:32themselves, be some of these specs are just wild.
- 2:35I really want to drill down into this 300% number because usually
- 2:39when we see studies like this, it's, you know, a guy with a
- 2:41clipboard standing on a corner somewhere counting cars.
- 2:45But that's not what this is. No, this is the absolute gold
- 2:48standard of data. This comes from the OBFCM
- 2:51database. The onboard fuel consumption
- 2:53monitoring. Exactly.
- 2:55Since 2021, the EU has essentially mandated that new
- 2:58cars come with a snitch box. A snitch box.
- 3:01It's software, right? It's deeply integrated into the
- 3:03car and it tracks exactly how much fuel is burned and how much
- 3:06electric energy is used. It records the real world
- 3:08performance and sends that data straight back to the Commission.
- 3:11So there's no hiding. You can tell a survey guy you
- 3:13charge every single night but the car is telling government.
- 3:16Nope. He hasn't plugged me in since
- 3:17last Tuesday. Precisely.
- 3:19And the sample size here is just enormous.
- 3:22This study analyzed 457,303 vehicles between 2021 and 2023,
- 3:29nearly half a million cars. Wow.
- 3:31So this is an anecdote. This is a census.
- 3:34OK, so let's look at the scorecard then under the
- 3:36official test cycle, the WLTP, which is what gets you the tax
- 3:40breaks and the sticker in the window.
- 3:42What are these cars supposed to be doing?
- 3:44On paper, the average plug in hybrid in this data set is rated
- 3:47at about 46 grams of CO2 per kilometer. 46.
- 3:51Yeah, which is incredibly clean. That is sustainable transport
- 3:54territory. That's the number that makes you
- 3:55feel good about buying the car. But the OBFCM data, the niche,
- 3:59the reality says. The real world average is 138g
- 4:03per kilometer. 138 that's that's effectively a standard gas car.
- 4:08It's worse than some modern diesels, and the reason for this
- 4:11huge gap lies in a regulatory assumption called the utility
- 4:14factor. This sounds like one of those
- 4:16really boring terms that hides a massive problem.
- 4:18It is. It really is.
- 4:20When the regulators wrote the rules for the WLTP test, they
- 4:23had to make a gas. They had to guess how often a
- 4:26driver would actually use the electric mode versus the gas
- 4:29mode. And what did they guess?
- 4:31They assumed that if you bought a PHEV you would drive roughly
- 4:3684% of your kilometers on pure electricity 84.
- 4:40Percent that. I mean, that assumes you are
- 4:42charging every single night, maybe even charging at work, and
- 4:45you rarely take long trips. It assumes you are the perfect
- 4:48user, the ideal driver, but the real world data shows that the
- 4:52actual electric drive share is only about 45.5%.
- 4:56So we're using the battery almost half as often as the
- 4:59government thought we would. And that's just the average.
- 5:01The study notes that in some contexts it drops as low as 27%.
- 5:05Why? Why is it so low?
- 5:06Is it just people being lazy? It's incentives.
- 5:09It all comes down to incentives. Had to talk about the company
- 5:11car problem. This is massive in Europe.
- 5:14Right. A huge chunk of these cars are
- 5:16fleet vehicles, not privately owned.
- 5:18Exactly. So imagine you're an employee.
- 5:21Your company offers you a nice new car as a perk.
- 5:23You pick the plug in hybrid because the tax benefit is
- 5:26really really low. It's cheap for you to own on
- 5:29paper. So I take the car.
- 5:30You take the car and usually the company hands you a fuel card, a
- 5:34corporate credit card that works at any gas station.
- 5:36You swipe it. The couple of pays, but do they
- 5:40give you a charging cart? Probably not.
- 5:43Or if I want to charge at home, I have to plug it in, pay for
- 5:46the electricity on my own bill, and then what?
- 5:48Fill out an expense report to get reimbursed.
- 5:51Exactly. It's friction.
- 5:52So you've got free easy gas versus inconvenient, potentially
- 5:56paid by you electricity. What do you do?
- 5:58I drive it like a gas car, I never plug it in, I just haul
- 6:01around this heavy battery burning free gas and I enjoy the
- 6:04heated seats. And that is exactly what the
- 6:06data shows is happening. You have hundreds of thousands
- 6:08of vehicles hauling around 300 to 500 kilograms of battery and
- 6:12electric motor, just dead weight and using a combustion engine to
- 6:16do it. And this brings us to what the
- 6:18study calls the battery paradox. Because my first thought would
- 6:21be, OK, the problem is range. If we just give these cars
- 6:26bigger batteries, people will use the electric part more.
- 6:29That seems logical, right? It makes perfect sense, but the
- 6:32study found the exact opposite. Really.
- 6:34Yeah, a larger battery capacity is actually correlated with a
- 6:38wider gap between the promised emissions and the real world
- 6:42ones. Hold on, the car with the bigger
- 6:44battery is lying more. How does that work?
- 6:46In a sense, yes, it's because of mass.
- 6:50If you put a huge battery in a car to give it a long range,
- 6:53you're usually putting it in a massive SUV, a vehicle that's
- 6:56already heavy and not very aerodynamic.
- 6:58Right, You're not putting a 30 kWh battery in a little Fiat
- 7:01500. Exactly, so now you have a 2.5
- 7:04ton SUV if the driver doesn't charge it, or once that battery
- 7:07runs flat on a trip, the small gas engine has to work
- 7:10incredibly hard just to move all that mass.
- 7:13You're effectively dragging an anchor.
- 7:14So the penalty for failing to charge a long range pH EV is
- 7:18actually much steeper than for a small one.
- 7:21Precisely. The bigger the battery, the
- 7:23harder the fall when it's empty. This is a perfect setup to talk
- 7:27about the actual cars because we aren't just talking about
- 7:30abstract units here. We are talking about some of the
- 7:33most popular cars on the road and the marketing for these
- 7:36things is it's genius. It really masks this reality.
- 7:40It is masterful and we have 3 perfect examples in our deep
- 7:43dive stack today that kind of represent the three flavors of
- 7:47this problem, the sensible, the muscle, and the rebel.
- 7:50Let's start with the sensible, the default choice.
- 7:53I mean, if you look out the window in the UK or Germany
- 7:55right now, you'll probably see a Kia Sportage PHEV.
- 7:59The Sportage is a sales juggernaut, and for good reason,
- 8:02to be fair. I was reading their marketing
- 8:04materials and they aren't really selling saving the planet as the
- 8:06main hook, they're selling refined space.
- 8:08Yes, they focus so heavily on the interior experience.
- 8:12The curved 12.3 inch displays the Harman Kardon sound system,
- 8:17all the clever storage. They even mentioned coat hangers
- 8:19integrated into the headrests. It's designed to be a mobile
- 8:22living room. And that works.
- 8:24It's a very comfortable, very practical family car.
- 8:27It's got a seven-year warranty. It feels safe, it feels
- 8:30responsible. But looking at the physics, if
- 8:34you're driving that refined space around on the gas engine
- 8:37because you didn't plug it in, you're just driving a heavy,
- 8:40boxy SUV that is not at all efficient.
- 8:43It just becomes a gas car with a very expensive tech package that
- 8:46does nothing. Exactly.
- 8:48It's sort of the passive offender, yeah.
- 8:49You buy for the practicality and the hybrid system is just there.
- 8:53OK, so from the passive to the active offender, Yeah, Messel,
- 8:57the Ford Explorer, PHEV, this. Is where the whole green
- 9:00pretense really starts to crack. For me, I looked at the specs on
- 9:03this thing. 451 horsepower. That makes it the most powerful
- 9:08hybrid production vehicle Ford offers.
- 9:10And it is huge. It has a towing capacity of 2500
- 9:13kilograms. It's basically a truck.
- 9:14It is, and it carries a price tag to match.
- 9:17In Germany this lists for between 76,000 and €82,000.
- 9:22So it's competing with a BM WX5. Right up against it, yeah.
- 9:25But here's the punchline. What is the official electric
- 9:28range on this beast? The WLTP rating is 42
- 9:32kilometers. 42 that's nothing. That is barely a trip to the
- 9:36shops and back. And remember, that's the lab
- 9:38number. The second you use any of that
- 9:40451 horsepower, if you merge onto the highway aggressively,
- 9:45or heaven forbid you actually tow that boat you bought, that
- 9:48range is going to evaporate in minutes.
- 9:50So essentially you've got a car that is green for the 1st 15
- 9:54minutes of your drive and for the rest of the day it's a
- 9:57massive high performance American SUV with AV6 engine.
- 10:01Correct. The electric motor here isn't
- 10:03really about the environment, it's about the tax code.
- 10:05It's a compliance dongle. It allows Ford to sell this 450
- 10:09horsepower monster in Europe and still get the low emission stamp
- 10:12on the paperwork. It's a loophole you can drive.
- 10:14Now the third category is when I find most fascinating from a
- 10:17marketing perspective, because they aren't selling practicality
- 10:20and they aren't just selling power, they're selling an
- 10:23identity. Let's talk about Cupra.
- 10:25Cooper is fascinating case study.
- 10:27They are absolutely the rebel. They spun off from seat part of
- 10:30VW coupe. Yes exactly.
- 10:33But they realized they couldn't compete with Audi on luxury or,
- 10:37you know, Porsche on heritage. So they went for pure attitude.
- 10:40I love this quote I read from their marketing director.
- 10:43We don't want to be liked by everyone, we want to be loved by
- 10:47some. It's tribal marketing.
- 10:48It's brilliant. They're targeting a specific
- 10:51psychographic, not an age group, but a mindset.
- 10:54People who just love driving. They have this 7 second rule for
- 10:58their ads. The idea is that you should
- 11:00decide if you love the car or hate it within 7 seconds.
- 11:03If you're indifferent, they failed.
- 11:05They want you to have a strong reaction.
- 11:07And it is working. The data shows their average
- 11:09buyer is 810 years younger than the market average.
- 11:13That's the Holy Grail for car companies.
- 11:14But here's the rub. They're targeting people who
- 11:16love driving. People who like those copper
- 11:19accents, the aggressive styling and the sporty handling.
- 11:22Right. And sporty handling is the
- 11:23absolute enemy of efficiency. If you buy a Cupra because it
- 11:27looks mean and you want to drive it fast, are you the kind of
- 11:31person who's going to gently hyper mile your battery to save
- 11:34a few electrons? No, you're going to put it in
- 11:36Cooper mode and blast down some back roads.
- 11:38Exactly. The brand identity itself almost
- 11:41discourages the very behavior needed to make the technology
- 11:46environmentally viable. The Rebel doesn't want to be
- 11:48tethered to a charging cable every night.
- 11:50So we've got the sensible Kia, the Muscle Ford, and the Rebel
- 11:54Cupra. All of them are selling really
- 11:56well, but all of them are contributing to this massive
- 11:59emissions gap. Now, does the study?
- 12:02Does it name names? Is there a Hall of Shame?
- 12:05It does break it down by manufacturer and there are some
- 12:09some surprises when we look at the deviation that gap between
- 12:12the test result. In the real world, the biggest
- 12:15offender is Mazda. Mazda.
- 12:17Really? That is surprising.
- 12:19They usually pride themselves on efficient engineering.
- 12:21Sky Active and all that. The data shows a gap of over
- 12:24400% for their pH EV's. 400% that is just staggering.
- 12:28It suggests that whatever strategy they're using to pass
- 12:31the WLTP test is incredibly fragile.
- 12:34You know it works perfectly in the lab, but as soon as a real
- 12:36human touches the steering wheel in the real world, the
- 12:39efficiency just collapses. And on the flip side, who's
- 12:42doing better? Who's keeping it somewhat
- 12:43honest? Well, better is relative, but
- 12:46Fiat and Toyota generally have smaller gaps.
- 12:50They're still significant, don't get me wrong, but they're closer
- 12:52to reality than Mazda is. That makes sense for Toyota,
- 12:55they've been doing hybrids longer than anyone and Fiat
- 12:58tends to make smaller, lighter cars so I guess the penalty for
- 13:01a dead battery isn't as severe. Exactly right.
- 13:04Speaking of Fiat, I wanted to touch on the sales data from
- 13:07Italy that was in our sources because Italy is a pretty unique
- 13:11market. It's the land of the small car.
- 13:13It is. It's dominated by the Fiat Panda
- 13:15and the douche Sandero economy is king there.
- 13:18But the data for 20/25 showed something really interesting.
- 13:21THV sales were volatile, but in December of 2025 they jumped 88%
- 13:26compared to the previous year. That is a crucial signal.
- 13:30It shows that this technology is really starting to penetrate the
- 13:33mass market. It's not just for wealthy
- 13:35executives in Germany anymore. Regular people in cost sensitive
- 13:38markets are buying these cars. Which makes solving this
- 13:41emissions gap even more urgent, right?
- 13:44If everyone starts driving these and nobody charges them, we are
- 13:47sleepwalking into a climate disaster while patting ourselves
- 13:50on the back for buying green cars.
- 13:52We are effectively replacing efficient small gas cars with
- 13:56inefficient heavy hybrids. So what's the fix?
- 14:00We can't just ban them. Consumers clearly want them.
- 14:03The study outlines a few policy scenarios.
- 14:06What's the best case scenario look like?
- 14:08They call it scenario 3 perfect alignment.
- 14:11And this just assumes we find a way to make the real world
- 14:13performance actually match the test results.
- 14:16And what's the prize if we managed to do that?
- 14:18If we close that gap entirely, we would save 555,000,000 tons
- 14:22of CO2 annually. 555,000,000 tons.
- 14:26That's a hard number to visualize.
- 14:27To put it in context, that's roughly 61% of the entire
- 14:30transport sector's 2030 reduction target.
- 14:33Wow, so we don't need magic hydrogen planes or nuclear
- 14:36fusion cars to hit our goals, We just need the cars we already
- 14:39have to work the way they're supposed to?
- 14:41Exactly, it's the lowest of low hanging fruit.
- 14:43The hardware works, the batteries work, we just need to
- 14:47ensure they're actually used. So how do we force that?
- 14:50Is it just scolding drivers? You know?
- 14:52Please plug in. Scolding never works.
- 14:55The experts are pushing for a move to what's called real
- 14:57driving emissions, or RDE testing.
- 15:01Explain that for us. Currently we test cars in a
- 15:04perfect lab. It's 23°C, the battery's 100%
- 15:08full, the acceleration is gentle.
- 15:10RDE means you test the car on the actual Rd.
- 15:13You test it when it's cold outside, you test it when the
- 15:16battery's half empty. You test it driving up a hill.
- 15:18You test it the way a normal person actually drives.
- 15:20Exactly. And most importantly, you update
- 15:23those utility factors instead of assuming the driver's in
- 15:25electric mode 84% of time. Maybe you assume 40%?
- 15:29If you did that, the emissions rating on the sticker would
- 15:32shoot way up. It would, and that wood forest
- 15:34manufacturers to attempt. They'd have to build cars that
- 15:36are efficient even when the battery is low, or they'd have
- 15:39to put in batteries that actually deliver usable real
- 15:42world range so the electric chair goes up naturally.
- 15:45It stops the gaming of the system.
- 15:47It forces honesty through physics.
- 15:49Exactly. It feels like we're at a
- 15:51crossroads. The PHEV was sold to us as the
- 15:53perfect bridge, but a bridge is only useful if you actually
- 15:57cross it. If you just park on the bridge
- 15:58and run your engine, you're just blocking traffic.
- 16:00That's a great analogy. These cars, the Sportage, the
- 16:04Explorer, the Cupra, they are triumphs of engineering and
- 16:09branding, but as environmental tools they are currently failing
- 16:13because of the human element. The technology works.
- 16:16We don't. That's the heavy truth of.
- 16:17It. And that leads to a pretty
- 16:19provocative thought for anyone listening who might have one of
- 16:21these in their driveway right now.
- 16:23It does if you own a plug in hybrid and you aren't rigorous
- 16:27about charging it. Are you actually part of the
- 16:31green revolution, or are you just driving a vehicle that is
- 16:34heavier, more resource intensive, and less efficient
- 16:38than if you had just bought a standard gas car in the first
- 16:40place? That is going to make the
- 16:42evening commute a little more reflective for some people.
- 16:44You think you're saving the polar bears, but you might just
- 16:46be hauling dead weight. The battery is only green if it
- 16:50has energy in it. A simple truth, but a hard one
- 16:52to execute. Look, we covered a lot of ground
- 16:55today, from European databases to Ford muscle cars, but the
- 17:01take away is clear, the tool is only as good as the user.
- 17:05Absolutely. We want to say a huge thank you
- 17:07for sticking with us through this deep dive.
- 17:09We know there are a lot of numbers today, but we hope it
- 17:11shed some light on what's really happening under the hood of the
- 17:14Hybrid Revolution. Yes, thank you for listening.
- 17:17It's so important to look past the marketing and understand the
- 17:19reality of the machines we use everyday.
- 17:21Absolutely. Thank you for listening.
- 17:23We'll catch you on the next deep dive.