Latest / Crypto Coin Show / Is Wormhole the best Blockchain Bridge in the industry? w/ Dan Reecer | Blockchain Interviews
Transcript
- 0:00I'm Ashton Addison from block West Capital for Investment Pitch Media and today on the
- 0:04Cryptocorin Show with Dan Research, the head of operations at Wormhole Foundation. Dan,
- 0:09welcome to the show and thank you for taking the time, thanks for
- 0:13having me. Very welcome. Excited to dive into all things bridging, which
- 0:18has been an important topic, especially for people that are looking to have secure
- 0:22transfers over to different blockchains and make sure that their funds are safe. And
- 0:26I feel like it's especially important because there's all these new blockchains popping up and
- 0:31ways to transfer assets between them. It needs to be understood better. And
- 0:34I know that Wormhole is more than just a bridge. So we're going to
- 0:37dive into all of that today, but I'd love to start out our conversation
- 0:41by just first of all, hearing a little bit on her background and blockchain
- 0:45how that led up to being a part of the Wormhole Foundation, and then
- 0:49we'll dive into all the details. Yeah, of course. So I've been
- 0:54in the blockchain industry for a little over five years, spent by first four
- 1:00years of my career in the healthcare and pharmaceutical space, where I got a
- 1:03lot of good training and kind of fundamentals of branding and marketing. I took
- 1:07that into Crypto, almost went and got my MBA, but decided to come
- 1:11full time into Crypto before doing that. And I actually started in the interoperability
- 1:17space in my first team. So there was a team called wand Chain back
- 1:22in twenty eighteen was when I started, and I came on and led their
- 1:26marketing for about a year and a half. It was my first foray into
- 1:29the industry. I've learned a lot and that made me want to get a
- 1:34little bit deeper in the interoperability space, so I went to the Web three
- 1:38Foundation and helped with the launch of Kusama in the launch of Polka Dot back
- 1:42in twenty twenty or so. I spent about a year and a half at
- 1:48Web three Foundation, met a lot of teams building on Polka Dot, and
- 1:52that led me to a collam Akala was building a DeFi focused and now liquid
- 1:57staking focused parachain on p and I led their growth team for two and a
- 2:04half years, spanning marketing and VD and in that role I did One of
- 2:09the integrations I did was with Wormhole to get Wormhole assets and the bridge set
- 2:15up for a cola and the broader polkadot Ecosystem got to know that team really
- 2:19well, ended up having a guy that I hired at Acala moved to the
- 2:23Wormhole team and then later on texted me about a role that I'm currently in.
- 2:30So now I'm co leading the Wormhole Foundation along with Robinson, who I
- 2:34just mentioned, I'm leading all the kind of operations. He's working on operations
- 2:39with me as well, and then he's also doing some of the business development
- 2:45type work. So I've been here for a little over three months, so
- 2:49I definitely still have a lot to learn, but have gotten really deep and
- 2:53all the products and the tech and all the kind of internal operations as well.
- 2:59Amazing. That's a great background. And I remember that first company you
- 3:01mentioned back in the twenty nineteen days, and now I want to dive into
- 3:07what is Wormhole. And I feel like there's a lot of people that,
- 3:10you know, they trade on centralized exchanges, they're very familiar with bitcoin ethereum,
- 3:15but they've yet to sort of be bridging assets. So I would love
- 3:19to sort of pose it as like a problem solution. You know, what
- 3:22is the problem that arose that actually requires bridging? If you could explain that
- 3:28a little bit, and then the solution and why wormhole exists on that front,
- 3:32of course, well, as we know, crypto started around bitcoin and
- 3:38that led to the creation of ethereum smart contracts, and there's been people over
- 3:43the years predicting that there would be kind of this proliferation of more and more
- 3:47layer one blockchains and compete with Ethereum and three ecosystems like Cosmos and Polka Dot
- 3:53and l L twos. That has definitely been confirmed the hypothesis of those people.
- 4:00So over time there's been become more and more of a need for connectivity,
- 4:06secure connectivity between these different networks. In the same way blockchain has a
- 4:13need for connectivity. The Internet also had this need. I think a lot
- 4:15of us forget the fact that the Internet infrastructure was built by human beings pioneers
- 4:23back in the seventies and eighties who were literally laying cables across oceans to connect
- 4:28the US to Europe and Europe to Africa and so on. Now we can
- 4:32all enjoy the benefits of all that work that was done by the early Internet
- 4:35Internet pioneers, and we don't even think about interoperability. We don't even really
- 4:41talk about these protocols that were built back then, but here we are in
- 4:45crypto kind of doing that process over again. It seems it's fundamental, and
- 4:51it seems like it should be something that we don't even think about, but
- 4:54we're actually just we are really early in the industry and we're building that connective
- 5:00infrastructure now to bridge these networks together and allow flow of information and data between
- 5:05them. So that led to the creation of Wormhole. Wormhole was the first
- 5:12team to build a what we call generic messaging protocol, which allows to send
- 5:15any sort of message between one network and another. Wormholes historically been known as
- 5:24a bridge, but in reality we've built kind of a suite of products.
- 5:28Of course, our first degree user our developers, and then there's users and
- 5:32users who use the products of the developers who use our products. Wormhole dot
- 5:39com is our website and you can go check out in more detail what I'm
- 5:44about to explain. But we have three different kind of product categories. First
- 5:48is protocols, So this is Wormhole Messaging, and this is the protocol that
- 5:54any blockchain developer or application developer can use to integrate bridging into their blockchain or
- 6:00in their application. Why this is important for those developers is because they've built
- 6:06a product, they've built a team, and what their goal is to grow.
- 6:10They want to grow their transaction volume, they want to grow their users,
- 6:15and how can they do that if they're on a new layer one,
- 6:18Well, a lot of it is to tap into existing user bases and existing
- 6:23pools of liquidity. So if you're an l one, let's say you're ap
- 6:27Dose or Suite who launched recently with wormhole, they're also going to be working
- 6:31with a lot of users who are they're trying to pull over from the ethery
- 6:34and ecosystem or maybe pull over from Salona for example, and that's what wormhole
- 6:40messaging enables. There's also bridges built on Wormhole messaging. So Portal and Carrier
- 6:46Bridge are two bridges who have built a front end like a website, a
- 6:51user interface that integrates with Wormhole Messaging and allows them to provide a bridging application
- 6:58for users. So that's category one. The second category is front ends.
- 7:04So what I just mentioned with wormhole messaging is very technical, it's very low
- 7:10level infrastructure for developers to use. What wormhole connect is is it makes it
- 7:15very easy for any application on any Wormhole connected chain to integrate integrate bridging inside
- 7:21of their application. The problem this is solving is that with bridges like I
- 7:28just mentioned, portal bridge or carrier. You're an application developer. Let's say
- 7:32you're a a and you have a link on your website to a bridge.
- 7:36What you're doing is you're sending users away from your application and there's there's a
- 7:42drop off there where a user goes to this bridging page and then all of
- 7:46a sudden, maybe they get distracted by Twitter or whatever, they fall off.
- 7:49You want your users to stay in your application and focus on the job
- 7:55that they want to get done, whether it's like slopping something or what an
- 7:59NFTs case or whatever it may be. So now application developers can integrate Wormhole
- 8:05bridging in app inside of the existing application and the look and feel with just
- 8:11a three lines of code to basically integrate this widget into their application. So
- 8:16that's been very well received by all the application developers that are that are using
- 8:20Wormhole because it's just a much easier way to integrate and better for their users.
- 8:26And the number three is blockchain. So we actually built our own blockchain
- 8:31and announced this just a couple of weeks ago in Paris at the Osmosis event.
- 8:37But we built a Cosmos app chain specifically for Wormhole. It's not the
- 8:43core that kind of runs all of Wormhole, but rather a component within the
- 8:46broader Wormhole platform. Wormhole Gateway is the name of this chain, and it
- 8:52has two primary purposes. One and in the most significant is being a router
- 9:01in and out of the Cosmos ecosystem for every connected Cosmos chain. So we
- 9:05just talked about the fact that there's a lot of these different app chains and
- 9:07layer ones that are sprouting up, and it's historically been difficult in time consuming
- 9:13to add new chains to Wormhole. So this allows there to be one focal
- 9:16point for Cosmos and then any Cosmos chain can connect to that chain using the
- 9:22IBC tech which is kind of native to Cosmos. And then number two Gateway
- 9:28actually helps improve the security and accounting of the entire Wormhole network. So we
- 9:35have at the center of Wormhole, we have nineteen validators that we call guardians,
- 9:41and those validators are responsible for watching everything that's happening around the different networks,
- 9:46accounting for how many tokens have been locked on this network and how many
- 9:52have been minted here. Historically those validators were doing that accounting on their own.
- 9:56Now all that is being done on chain using Wormhole Gateway and helps with
- 10:01the accounting process for these validators. And then the second security feature that it
- 10:07allows is called Governor and this essentially limits the amount of assets that can flow
- 10:15from one network to another to avoid major incidents happening as someone where to find
- 10:20a bug let's say app dose and wanted to send a billion dollars worth of
- 10:26assets to another network. This will prevent them from being able to complete that
- 10:31exploit that they may have found on any given chain. So I know that
- 10:35was a lot, but that's the kind of overview of the three product categories
- 10:39of Wormhole. Overall, Wormholes really just the cross chain platform for developers,
- 10:45and like I said, at wormhole dot com, people can read more about
- 10:48those those products that I just mentioned. Amazing, Jan, thank you for
- 10:52explaining that all. And it's great to hear about the latest innovations with the
- 10:56Cosmos ecosystem. I've spoken to the cause most team quite a few times and
- 11:01it seems like their IBC, which is the inner blockchain Communication Protocol, is
- 11:07the meant for, you know, helping ease the transition from like all these
- 11:13isolated styles of different blockchains, as you mentioned, trying to bridge to all
- 11:18these new layer ones that are coming out. It seems like the Cosmos ecosystem
- 11:24is like if there's new blockchains that are with that, it's going to say
- 11:26probablem you guys and other people the hassle of extra security risks and extra steps
- 11:31to bridge assets to new chains and new innovations that are coming out. Yeah,
- 11:39exactly. It was cool that we were able to go into the Cosmost
- 11:41ecosystem start working with a lot of teams, but most importantly integrate their technology
- 11:46into our tech stack. So we still use our guardian network, our validators
- 11:54to send messages to non Cosmos chains, but then we're able to add another
- 12:00verification method as we call it, using IBC or any transaction or a message
- 12:05going through the Cosmos ecosystem. So it's been well received by the Cosmos teams
- 12:11because they want to see the proliferation of IBC, and then also great for
- 12:15us because we're able to kind of expand the verification methods for Wormhull developers.
- 12:22It's great to hear and you mentioned they're also about having the security measures of
- 12:26if there's a huge sum of money. That's like, you know, sort
- 12:30of a red flag. I guess like they would in the banking system.
- 12:33If there's all of a sudden millions being moved at once, sort of out
- 12:37of the blue, is a good chance it's some kind of exploit or vulnerability
- 12:41or something's going on. You can block that, you know. I'm sure
- 12:46there's a lot of people that are probably transferring tens of thousands, maybe hundreds
- 12:48of thousands, but sometimes in defy there's something that like catastrophic amount can move.
- 12:56And we actually saw that a couple days ago here with Curve Finance was
- 13:01hacked and exploited some way, and you know, these very detailed hackers,
- 13:05and they started draining liquidity pools. And I feel like when hackers make these
- 13:11exploits, the first thing they want to do is move it to a different
- 13:13chain to sort of start obscuring where the funds were going. I feel like
- 13:20your guy's technology it would be something that they would want to use, but
- 13:24also would be beneficial to have these security measures to prevent hacking and if somebody
- 13:31hacks into you account, that they're not transferring the funds away exactly. Yeah,
- 13:37with I mean that was maybe just yesterday and the Curve exploit and what
- 13:43it shows is just a Curve has been around for a while pretty much has
- 13:46had a clean history in terms of exploits. But with blockchain and open source
- 13:54tech, you just have to assume that there are hackers looking every single day
- 14:00for another way to exploit your protocol. And even every upgrade adds new risk
- 14:05because you have to re audit everything. So the way we look at security
- 14:09is just you have to have multiple levels of security and fall back measures in
- 14:15case something happens, and assuming that things will happen. So in Curve's case,
- 14:20if users were using Wormhole, I think the amount was around twenty five
- 14:24million, this guard, this governor feature would have caught that large amount being
- 14:31you know, transacted through the wormho network and hopefully it would have been stopped.
- 14:35I'm automatically by that feature. Yeah, yeah, that's good to know.
- 14:41And you know, bridges are a blessing that in disguise that we need
- 14:46to be able to transfer assets. But often when people hear about it,
- 14:50it's a news article about some bridge was exploited or something that went wrong,
- 14:54you know, and people know like it sort of puts it in your head.
- 14:56Okay, if there's a bridge, one of the main things I need
- 15:00to worry about is the security of my funds to make sure that I'm not
- 15:03being duped or fished or you know. This is the funds are actually going
- 15:07to get to the other chain so that I can start using the applications on
- 15:11the other chain. I feel like security is of the utmost importance. Yeah,
- 15:16security is the number one priority for us by far. And like you
- 15:20said, it's kind of funny. It's like the the IT teams at corporations.
- 15:26They never get the pad on the back when things go well, but
- 15:28when things go wrong, they they're sure to hear about it. It's kind
- 15:31of the same way with bridging protocols, Like it's great when everything's working,
- 15:33but no one really says anything, and then the moment something goes wrong and
- 15:37there's there's chaos. So we just saw that recently with the multi chain bridge.
- 15:45There's yeah, there's there's exploits, I mean with various protocols every week,
- 15:48But the best thing people can do is learn from these and continue adding
- 15:54various security features to their products. Definitely, and I did see a more
- 15:58positive report on bridging protocols come out recently, although more technical and probably most
- 16:04people haven't seen it, but UNISWAP came out with a security report that was
- 16:10sort of detailing some of the top bridging protocols and I know Wormhole was involved
- 16:15in that and it was more on the positive side than the negative. I'd
- 16:18love for you to shed some light on sort of what the report said and
- 16:22what it's that about Wormhole and you know, yeah, that would be great
- 16:26to just sort of explain that a little bit. Yeah, I'll give some
- 16:30contexts as far as why this report was commissioned and then get into the results.
- 16:34So some of your listeners may have seen this, but I think it
- 16:41was around four months ago earlier, probably Q one of this year, in
- 16:45twenty twenty three, the UNISWAP governance So on their forum, there's a lot
- 16:51of discussion around what bridge to choose to allow governance data to flow from the
- 16:57ethereum made not to be in beach chain, so that if a decision and
- 17:03the governance is made on eth MAInet that decision, the results of that decision
- 17:07could be implemented on B and B chain. So this is this was a
- 17:12massive integration for any bridge to kind of win in terms of getting getting selected
- 17:18by the UNISWAP community. And through that discussion, there was a lot of
- 17:25back and forth about which bridge to choose and why, and lots of different
- 17:29people responding on the forum and nothing. There was not a lot of well
- 17:34organized kind of information as far as how to make the selection given how technical
- 17:40these bridges are and how much time and assessment like that would truly take.
- 17:45So what that resulted in, Well, first of all, they selected Wormhole
- 17:48as the bridge for the UNISWAP governance with B and B chain. Wormhole now
- 17:52has six deployments with UNISWAP governance. I think the next closest is around two.
- 17:57So we've had a lot of integrations with UNISWAP. But then the result
- 18:03of this was the UNISWAP I believe it was the UNISWAP Foundation along with probably
- 18:08people from UNISWAP Labs, said okay, we went through that whole, this
- 18:14whole governance process, but now we want to commission a UNISWAP Bridge Assessment committee.
- 18:21And this was a third party team of security experts, blockchain experts kind
- 18:26of enacted by the UNISWAP Foundation to do a multi month very deep technical analysis
- 18:32of six different bridging protocols in the industry that included Wormhole, Axceller, Multi
- 18:40Chain, d Bridge, Seller, and Player zero, and the analysis took
- 18:49multiple months, went deeply into various categories like security measures of the protocol,
- 18:56the decentralization or centralization of the way the network operates, the architecture, various
- 19:03risks involved, so network risks, implementation risks, even operational risks. So
- 19:11that you can maybe add the report to the show notes here. But the
- 19:17result of this was that Wormhole came out ranked the number one bridging protocol of
- 19:22the six evaluated. A lot of that was due to the decentralization of Wormholes.
- 19:29So the Guardian network, the validators that I mentioned earlier, we have
- 19:32nineteen Guardian guardians and every time a transaction goes through the network, thirteen of
- 19:37them must sign off on that transaction to verify it and move it on to
- 19:44the next step, which is to relay that onto the networks. This was
- 19:48much more decentralized than the many of the other solutions, and also the security
- 19:55of that solution was highly regarded by the Unit Assessment committee. The second team
- 20:03that was approved with one condition was axceler they're also well decentralized. They're belts
- 20:08also on A they're belts on a specifically at an application blockchains, application specific
- 20:15blockchain and Cosmos. But then all the other four teams we're not approved by
- 20:21the committee for various reasons, and teams like Layers zero, many people don't
- 20:25realize, but that the entire security of Layers zero depends on a two of
- 20:29two multi sig for all, if not all, almost all of their integrations.
- 20:34So Layers zero is more of a Web two company than a crypto project,
- 20:40and it's a lot easier to run a Web two company. But Wormhole
- 20:42and axceler we care a lot more about security and decentralization because that's kind of
- 20:48what we're here for. I'm in the blockchain industry. A couple other things
- 20:53just from the report, even just to mention, because we get a lot
- 20:56of questions about security and the measures that we've taken to the pup security.
- 21:00So another thing is that Wormhole is fully open source. Accelara also has open
- 21:07source, is kind of one of its prime kind of tenants to live by.
- 21:11Layers zero is completely closed source, so again it's it's a lot harder
- 21:15to evaluate to even evaluate a bridging protocol when the code isn't even open source
- 21:22to begin with. We have a massive list of ongoing audits. These are
- 21:29all public on our website, so internal audits, external audits with some of
- 21:33the best auditing firms in the industry, and one of the biggest bug bounties
- 21:37in the industry as well. We're offering two point five million dollars for severe
- 21:41bugs that any white hat hacker may want to find. So we're encouraging people
- 21:48to go into the code, find exploits, and then let us know for
- 21:52their for their reward on the bug bounty program. Yeah, that's a that's
- 21:56a few things. Let me know if you have any questions on that.
- 21:59Yeah, no, that that sounds amazing. And I've heard a lot about
- 22:03Layer zero, but and Axcelar as well. I've had on the show before
- 22:07Axcelar, but I didn't know those differences, and that sort of really paints
- 22:11a beautiful picture for myself and for the viewers. So I appreciate you sort
- 22:15of explaining the report and where everything stands. And I see it that as
- 22:25defy and decentralized exchanges and more protocols only continue to grow and get bigger,
- 22:30the security only gets stronger and bridging, and it just becomes more more and
- 22:34more positive and more secure. It's sort of like the days of the wild
- 22:37West are hopefully over and it's like positive moving forward. Do you have you
- 22:45seen I guess you know from before because you're you've joined the company this year,
- 22:51but since it when it started, I'm guessing that's only continues to get
- 22:56easier, has other exploits happen, and then they get patched, and security
- 23:00gets tighter and tighter and sort of more regulating. Yeah. I mean,
- 23:04at this point we have about two two and a half years under our belt,
- 23:08so really standing the test of time, you learn, You're constantly learning
- 23:14things. Our security team is constantly improving, operationally improving, and then as
- 23:19we go a couple of a couple of things that we're looking into even to
- 23:23expand on the security set. Unrelated to kind of exploits is zero knowledge,
- 23:30So there's I'm sure many people have heard about these. ZK L two's zero
- 23:37knowledge tech in general is being talked about quite a bit right now. One
- 23:41way to use ZK is with an L two blockchain, but another way to
- 23:45use ZK that you'll begin seeing student is zero knowledge bridging. This is kind
- 23:52of the the end all, be all and bridging with what is, which
- 23:56is what many of the product and security people think is to enable as many
- 24:02connection points or what we call corridors between two blockchains to be enabled by ZK.
- 24:10This would be another verification method, so not using the wormhole guardians,
- 24:14but it would be using what's called light clients on the source chain and the
- 24:18destination chain. So let's say from Ethereum to Near is one that we're working
- 24:23on. There would be a light clan on one side on Ethereum that can
- 24:29read what's happening on near and then on near the same thing being able to
- 24:32read the blockchain state on Ethereum, and then the token minting and burning would
- 24:38happen in a nearly trustless manner using zero knowledge. So this is something that
- 24:45we're going to be focusing on quite a bit. Is enabling as much of
- 24:48wormhole to be ZK enabled as possible, so products are rolling out from ethereum
- 24:56to Near. We're also looking into various contributors who had this as a skill
- 25:03set to be able to continue beefing up wormhole security in the ZK space.
- 25:08So I just wanted to mention that as well. Yeah, amazing. I'm
- 25:12very bullish on the near protocol and also on ZK products, and I think
- 25:18and I hope that it will be sort of a standard status quo of you
- 25:22know, things having zero knowledge privacy went integrated into especially transfers and bridging like
- 25:30that in the future. We don't have a lot of time left down,
- 25:33But is there anything else. I'm sure there's more in the roadmap for Wormhole
- 25:38and what's sort of coming up leading into twenty twenty four. Is there anything
- 25:41else you want to mention about, you know, where you guys are at
- 25:45now and what's sort of coming in the future. Yeah. Yeah, Aside
- 25:51from all the products that I mentioned, we're obviously going to be focused on
- 25:56growing and expanding those products. So there is various assets that we're working with
- 26:02that are highly sought after. So TBTC is one. It's basically a decentralized
- 26:07version of wrap bitcoin. They're working with us in a very big way and
- 26:11spreading to right now all the L two's they'll be on, Salana and others.
- 26:17So working with various like major assets like this and helping them expand their
- 26:22markets. If there's developers that are listening. Wormhole Connect is one product that
- 26:29we can definitely talk to you about and it's very easy to integrate using the
- 26:32documentation, and then over time just continuing to add new networks and new applications
- 26:38to Wormhole. The other thing that we're focused on that you'll start to see
- 26:42this year is expanding. I talked about decentralization of the tech, but we're
- 26:48also working to decentralize the contributor and developer that. So right now we have
- 26:56Wormhole Foundation is exists work for Wormhole Foundation, but we haven't formally announced it
- 27:03yet, so that's coming actually pretty soon in a couple of weeks, and
- 27:07then we'll begin rolling out more and more new contributing organizations who are going to
- 27:11be joining Wormhole and helping build Wormhole. So by the end of the year
- 27:15we'll have a very nicely decentralized group of several different companies building Wormhole, and
- 27:22each has its own kind of skill set, whether it's building the Wormhole messaging
- 27:26protocol and expanding and growing that, working on front end tools like Wormhole Connect,
- 27:32like I mentioned, another has kind of a bad team, marketing team,
- 27:36etc. So we're really excited about decentralizing the community and then if people
- 27:41there will be obviously things happening the rest of the year. So the best
- 27:47way to follow us is probably our Twitter account. We also have an email
- 27:51newsletter and yeah, you can follow many of us on the team on Twitter
- 27:56as well. So awesome, Thank you so much, Dan. I will
- 28:00leave the link to the Twitter and the email newsletter and the unit swap report
- 28:04that we discussed, and any other links you want in the description box below
- 28:07For the viewers, I really appreciate you taking the time to come on and
- 28:11just explain about Bridges, where we're at and where we're heading, and about
- 28:15a little bit more about Wormhole, and I'm wishing you guys all the best
- 28:18moving forward and let's definitely follow up in the near future. Awesome, thanks
- 28:23for having me.