Latest / Comeback Project: Human strength, healing & change / How to Hold Space for Pain Without Trying to Fix It | Comeback Project
Transcript
- You know that sudden, frantic urge to hand someone a tissue when they’re crying? Or the way your brain instantly scrambles for a silver lining just to make the silence stop? That is not love; that is panic. I want you to take a deep breath with me right now. In through the nose, out through the mouth. Let’s breathe into that tension in your shoulders, because I suspect you might be carrying some guilt about how you handled a friend’s heartbreak last week. Maybe it was your sister, or your coworker, or that person who just sent you a text at 2 AM saying everything is falling apart. Here is the truth: We are terrified of other people’s pain. Not because we are cruel, but because their pain triggers our own helplessness. When someone we love is suffering, it feels like an emergency in our chest. It feels like a broken bone that needs setting immediately. So, we become first responders. We offer solutions. We say things like, "At least you still have your health," or "Have you tried meditation?" or "This will pass." We do this because we think if we can fix the problem, we can stop the hurting. But here is what happens instead: The other person stops sharing. They feel misunderstood. They feel like their pain is a nuisance to be solved rather than a reality to be witnessed. And you? You end up feeling exhausted and rejected because your good intentions weren’t accepted. You wanted to help, but you ended up pushing them away. It’s a tragic little dance we’ve all done. Let’s talk about the difference between fixing and witnessing. Fixing is active. It’s loud. It involves moving pieces around on a board until they fit the pattern you think should exist. Witnessing is quiet. It’s still. It involves sitting in the dust with someone and admitting that the house has burned down. When you try to fix someone’s pain, you are implicitly telling them that their current state is unacceptable. You are signaling that you cannot tolerate seeing them sad, so you must change their mind to make yourself comfortable. It sounds harsh, but it’s often true. We fix to soothe our own anxiety, not theirs. Witnessing, on the other hand, says: "I see you. I am here. This is hard. And I am not going anywhere." It does not require you to have answers. It does not require you to be strong. It only requires you to be present. Think about the last time someone truly listened to you without interrupting, without checking their watch, without offering advice. How did it feel? Did it heal you? Maybe not immediately. But did it make you feel less alone? Absolutely. There is a profound dignity in being seen exactly as you are, even when you are messy, angry, or broken. I see you rolling your eyes slightly, knowing that one of your favorite phrases is "What happens in life prepares us for what comes next." Yes, I said it. And I stand by it. But let me tell you why that phrase can be harmful in the immediate aftermath of grief. When someone is in the thick of it, they don’t need perspective. They need presence. If your best friend loses her job, she doesn’t need to hear that this is an opportunity for growth. She needs to hear that it sucks. She needs to know that it’s okay to be furious and scared and embarrassed. If you rush to find the silver lining, you are invalidating her current experience. You are rushing her through her humanity. Realistically optimistic doesn’t mean ignoring the dark. It means trusting that light will eventually return, but respecting the darkness for where it is right now. It means sitting in the valley with them, not standing on the mountain top pointing at the sunrise. It’s okay to say, "I don’t know what to say, but I’m glad you told me." Those words are more powerful than any motivational quote ever written. They acknowledge the weight of the moment without trying to lift it for them. What does resilience look like on a Tuesday? It looks like making tea. It looks like opening the curtains. It looks like sending a text that says, "Thinking of you," and then waiting three weeks for a reply without taking it personally. We often mistake resilience for strength. We think it’s about bouncing back quickly, about being stoic, about grinding through. But real resilience is softer. It’s the ability to remain open to life even when it hurts. And part of supporting someone else’s resilience is allowing them to move at their own speed. When you hold space, you give them permission to fall apart. You create a container where their emotions can flow without judgment. This is radical. In a world that rewards productivity and positivity, choosing to sit in the mess is a rebellious act of love. It tells them: You are safe here. You don’t have to perform happiness for me. You don’t have to be fixed to be whole. You just have to be. Think about who in your life is currently holding space for you. Who sits with you in the quiet? Who doesn’t try to cheer you up when you’re grieving? Cherish them. They are giving you the greatest gift possible: their undivided attention. And chances are, you want to give that same gift to others. So, how do we actually do this? How do we train ourselves to stop fixing and start holding? Here are three simple shifts you can make today. First, pause before you speak. When someone shares a struggle, count to three in your head. Notice the itch in your throat to offer a solution. Resist it. Instead, ask a question. Ask, "How long has this been weighing on you?" or "What does support look like for you right now?" Questions invite them to explore their own feelings. Solutions shut down the conversation. Second, validate the emotion, not just the event. Say, "It makes sense that you’re angry." Say, "That sounds incredibly lonely." Validation doesn’t mean you agree with their actions, but it means you understand their feelings. Feelings are never wrong. They are just data. Third, allow silence. Silence is not empty. It is full of connection. If there is a pause in the conversation, don’t rush to fill it. Let it breathe. Sometimes the most healing thing you can do is just sit together in the quiet, listening to the sound of each other breathing. It reminds both of you that you are alive, and you are not alone. I remember when my mother passed, I was surrounded by people who brought casseroles and checked on me every hour. But the ones who stayed were the ones who sat on my floor, didn’t say much, and just existed with me. They didn’t try to explain death. They didn’t try to make it better. They just held the space for my grief. That is the power of presence. It is the antidote to isolation. When we hold space for someone, we are saying, "Your pain matters. Your story matters. You matter." We are reminding them that they are part of a community, not a solitary island. This practice changes us, too. It teaches us patience. It teaches us humility. It reminds us that we are not saviors. We are companions. And there is immense beauty in that role. You don’t have to carry the world for anyone. You just have to walk beside them. So tonight, when you listen to your friend, your partner, your child, or even yourself, try letting go of the need to fix. Try just being there. Watch how the dynamic shifts. Watch how the tension dissolves. Watch how love grows in the spaces between the words. It is enough. You are enough. Just being there is enough. Take care of yourselves. Be gentle with your hearts. I’ll be right here next time, ready to listen. Goodnight, friends.