Latest / Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective / SWM 156 – Pornography, Erotica, and AI Companions – When You Replace the Person with a Fantasy
Transcript
- 0:43Hello and welcome to the Sex Within Marriage podcast. My name is JD and I'm a marriage educator, coach, writer, and podcaster.
- 0:50And at UncoveringIntimacy.com, we offer a wide range of resources to help couples strengthen intimacy in all areas of their marriage.
- 0:58And today I'm going to be continuing our series on sex as worship with this idea that God created sex to be a certain way, to be handled a certain way.
- 1:07And every time we ignore some part of that, some principle within it, we tend to get ourselves into trouble.
- 1:14And today we're going to be talking about pornography, erotica, and AI companions.
- 1:18Because this is what happens when you replace the person in the covenant with a fantasy.
- 1:25And pornography has become ubiquitous. You can access it for free from any smartphone.
- 1:30In fact, you often have to pay to use tools or buy a not-so-smartphone to make sure you don't get it accidentally.
- 1:37Erotica now is so widely accepted that women in church talked about how much they enjoyed Fifty Shades of Grey when the books came out.
- 1:44And now so-called spicy books are considered healing, empowering, and a common recommendation for wives struggling with low desire.
- 1:51And now AI girlfriends and boyfriends are being advertised.
- 1:54And the unique selling proposition for many of them is just how sexual they can be.
- 1:59And according to much of our society, this is amazing.
- 2:01It's sex without any downside at all.
- 2:04No risk, no burden of a relationship, just on-demand eroticism.
- 2:08Even a romantic partner in a box who is there when you want them, but with an off switch for when you don't.
- 2:15No rejection, no responsibility, no vulnerability required.
- 2:19Because all of those things are scary.
- 2:21And they can hurt.
- 2:22And they're a part of life that people are becoming intolerant of.
- 2:25More and more people are gravitating towards relationships or alternatives that don't involve vulnerability.
- 2:32They can't quite cut the need for other humans out yet.
- 2:35They still feel lonely and anxious without them.
- 2:37But with the advent of AI, that's starting to shift.
- 2:40We see more and more people moving from hookup culture to digital-only relationships.
- 2:44The problem is that we're not designed to work with synthetic relationships.
- 2:49We were designed to have real relationships with real people.
- 2:52Because our God also wants real relationships with real people.
- 2:56And we are made in His image.
- 2:58Not only were we designed to have relationships with real people, but they were intended to be intimate.
- 3:03Vulnerable, hiding nothing, holding nothing back.
- 3:06In Genesis 2, we see that Adam and Eve are created.
- 3:10They are created both naked, being fully vulnerable.
- 3:13You know, this man and his wife.
- 3:15And they were not ashamed.
- 3:17And I think that is why the biblical euphemism for sex is to know.
- 3:21It was meant to be such an intimate and vulnerable experience with someone that everything that you are is laid bare.
- 3:28Physically and emotionally.
- 3:29You are meant to be fully known by someone and to fully know them.
- 3:34And this was God's intent for us.
- 3:36And as we've been discussing in the series on sex as worship, when we worship, we give God worth.
- 3:42We believe and enact His plans for us.
- 3:45Deviation from that plan is then the opposite.
- 3:48It is telling God, you know what?
- 3:50I know better.
- 3:51We decide we want to be God.
- 3:53Because we think we have a better way of doing it.
- 3:56And you can tell God is serious about real relationships.
- 3:59Because prior to the fall, He spent time with Adam and Eve in the garden.
- 4:02When they fell, His first action was to go to them and to be present with them.
- 4:06And then God continued to push a real relationship agenda with us since.
- 4:11In Exodus, the second commandment is that we make no images of Him.
- 4:15Why?
- 4:15Because He doesn't want us to try and build a synthetic relationship with an inanimate object.
- 4:21He wants a real relationship with us.
- 4:23In the same way that we should have real relationships with others.
- 4:26Especially our spouse.
- 4:27Because God has chosen to use our relationship with our spouse as a living metaphor of His relationship with us.
- 4:33And this continues right through, including Jesus coming down to earth.
- 4:40Porn, erotica, AI companions, and likely in the future robotic ones as well,
- 4:44are a rejection of God's mandate of having real relationships.
- 4:47Especially with our spouse.
- 4:49We use a stand-in instead.
- 4:52And these replacements, this porn, erotica, AI companions, and in some cases even sex toys,
- 4:57they replace a human with an image of that human.
- 5:00In some cases literally, in others figuratively.
- 5:02We boil it down to the pieces that we want, and then take that part, and only that part.
- 5:08And the problem is that it creates a fantasy of a relationship rather than a real one.
- 5:13In similar ways to the other posts in the series, you sidestep conflict and vulnerability,
- 5:19but because of that, you also miss out on intimacy and trust.
- 5:23That sense of being known, being accepted, being loved.
- 5:27You create a lover who never resists, never disappoints, never requires compassion, grace,
- 5:33selfless love.
- 5:34You can focus entirely on selfish love.
- 5:36How you want it, when you want it.
- 5:39And it's no wonder that there's a correlation between all these activities and struggling
- 5:43relationships later on.
- 5:44You are training your brain to be an uncaring partner, a selfish partner, and an impatient
- 5:49partner because you've turned love into something that you can consume rather than something
- 5:53you cultivate.
- 5:55Real relationships are slower.
- 5:57They are harder.
- 5:58They take nurturing.
- 5:59Trust takes time to grow.
- 6:01Intimacy takes time to build.
- 6:03And you have to train your spouse how to love you as you train yourself how to love them.
- 6:08We have to deal with the rest of the world that we live in as well as the world they live
- 6:12in.
- 6:13At times, it can feel unrewarding, and there's no pause button or off switch to skip by that
- 6:19until you want them again.
- 6:20You have to work through it in order to get to the depth that we are all searching for.
- 6:26And this has implications in our worship as well.
- 6:28I think one of the reasons God equates marriage to a relationship with him is that it requires
- 6:32a lot of the same skills and habits.
- 6:35It takes time.
- 6:36It takes intentionality.
- 6:37It takes being open and vulnerable.
- 6:39Intimacy and trust build slowly.
- 6:43But with these distortions of relationship, we build none of these components.
- 6:47Desire turns inward and becomes all about ourselves rather than learning to look outward
- 6:53and care for others.
- 6:54Instead of giving of ourselves, we seek only to feed ourselves.
- 6:58As the Gen Z kids might say, we think we're the main character.
- 7:03And my Gen Alpha kids would respond, and you're not him, bruh.
- 7:06I don't know if anybody else hears bruh 100 times a day now.
- 7:09I definitely do.
- 7:10And this is a problem because when we seek to feed our own desires, there is nothing good
- 7:16in them.
- 7:16We look inward and feed our selfish nature rather than look to God's perfect nature and
- 7:21dying of our own.
- 7:23And often the objection to saying that porn, erotica, and AI companions are sinful is that
- 7:29it's harmless.
- 7:30No one is getting hurt.
- 7:31And this has long been the defense of porn, and it's always been false.
- 7:35In some cases, the lie is obvious.
- 7:37The porn industry is rife with abusive actresses.
- 7:39However, in the case of so-called ethical porn and erotica and AI, which don't have actors
- 7:46and actresses, the external harm isn't the only thing to consider.
- 7:50These activities shift your sexual identity as well.
- 7:53They reshape your desires and retrain how we relate to people.
- 7:57Just because it's private and involves no external entities in the consumption doesn't
- 8:01mean it doesn't harm us or the people around us by how it shapes us.
- 8:05Regardless of your method of consumption, be it porn, erotica, or AI, these activities
- 8:11flood the brain with dopamine tied to novelty.
- 8:13Over time, this dulls your response to normal sexual stimuli.
- 8:17This causes the users of these to need more extreme or novel content to achieve arousal.
- 8:23This is a well-known response to porn.
- 8:26The content is shifting to more and more extreme sexual practices, but it also happens with erotica.
- 8:32Watch some TikTok videos about spicy novels, and those who have been reading them a while
- 8:36will even warn the newbies off of some of the darker books.
- 8:39Not because they think it's wrong, but because it's too jarring at first.
- 8:43You need to work your way up to it.
- 8:45They know that it's not something the uninitiated can handle.
- 8:49They need to have been exposed to lower levels of distortion in order to be able to tolerate
- 8:54it and then enjoy it.
- 8:56And this is using what is a God-given mechanism in a disordered way.
- 9:00We should be adapting ourselves to our spouse, growing with them, our preferences shifting
- 9:05to make us better lovers for each other.
- 9:08And instead, users of these shift their preferences not towards their spouse, present or future,
- 9:14but rather towards the limits of what society will tolerate.
- 9:17And that limit is shifting further and further outside of what is safe.
- 9:22These methods of fantasy consumption also reduce relationship satisfaction because you're
- 9:27living in a fantasy.
- 9:28This is actually a problem not just with erotic content, but with non-sexual romantic movies
- 9:33also.
- 9:34They do the same thing.
- 9:35We see a fantasy of a partner without any of the negatives.
- 9:39And we look at our spouse and think, why can't they be more like that character?
- 9:42And yes, we know it's scripted or just a snapshot of real life or even an AI that's using pattern
- 9:49recognition to match our desires, but our brain still takes it in and starts a comparison.
- 9:55Both porn and erotica have long been shown to decrease sexual satisfaction over time because
- 10:00the further our fantasy drifts from our spouse, the more we perceive our spouse as lacking.
- 10:05This leads to emotional withdrawal, resentment, reduced empathy, and we see our experiences with
- 10:12them as increasingly disappointing or insufficient.
- 10:16When desire is trained on fantasy, real people do not fail.
- 10:19They are simply compared to an unreal standard that they cannot match.
- 10:23And the more we disconnect sexual arousal from an interaction with a person that we care
- 10:27about, the more we tend to evaluate our spouse based on their performance, appearance, or
- 10:32availability, rather than seeing them as a whole person with many facets to our relationship.
- 10:38And spouses struggle enough with sex drive differences and thoughts of, you only want me for sex,
- 10:43that we don't need to exacerbate that by actually making it true.
- 10:47Because sexual fantasy trains control, not love.
- 10:50These are partners that never resist, disappoint, or require sacrifice, unlike a real person.
- 10:56Your desire becomes oriented around control and predictability.
- 11:01Real love requires patience, negotiation, and vulnerability.
- 11:05And love requires seeing your spouse as a subject, not an object.
- 11:08But porn, erotica, and AI companions train consumption of an object rather than the mutuality of a real
- 11:15relationship.
- 11:16We should train for the partner we wish to have, or else we'll find ourselves with our training partner.
- 11:21In this case, you'll be left alone to your porn, erotica, and AI partner instead of a human.
- 11:27Because fantasy doesn't prepare us for intimacy, it prepares us for frustration with real people.
- 11:33And so the objection of, well, I don't have a spouse yet, doesn't help.
- 11:37Because while these fantasies feel like they provide some relief, they don't provide connection.
- 11:42Over time, this reduces the motivation to pursue real relationships.
- 11:46Users of all three report loneliness despite frequent sexual stimulation, because what they
- 11:51want is a relationship, not just sex.
- 11:54And what's often seen as a coping mechanism becomes a crutch that they become dependent on,
- 12:00and so it actually deepens the pain it promises to relieve.
- 12:04Fantasy soothes loneliness without healing it.
- 12:07Over time, they make connection feel harder, not easier.
- 12:11And all of these are built on a simple premise, give you what you want when you want it.
- 12:17There is no conflict unlike in a real relationship, because all healthy relationships have conflict.
- 12:23AI in particular simulates affirmation and responsiveness, and aims to have you form
- 12:29emotional attachment without reciprocity or accountability.
- 12:33It trains you to be conflict-avoided, because the longer you go without conflict,
- 12:37the less comfortable you are with it.
- 12:39I have had coaching clients who have never had a fight in decades-long marriages, and
- 12:45that's not healthy.
- 12:46In every case, they were on the brink of divorce.
- 12:49Not because they fought, but because they never fought.
- 12:52We need to learn how to manage conflict, not avoid conflict.
- 12:56Conflict should be welcome as an opportunity to learn about your spouse, not something to
- 13:00be avoided or swept under the rug.
- 13:03On top of these, there are some common rationalizations I hear about all of these that I want to hit as
- 13:08well.
- 13:08Also, I'll hit these rapid fire, because we've already laid the foundations to dismiss all
- 13:12of them.
- 13:13The first is, it's better than cheating or acting out.
- 13:16But it's not.
- 13:17You aren't avoiding cheating, you are cheating, and you're training yourself for an in-person
- 13:21cheating.
- 13:22Porn, erotica, and AI companions will help you distance yourself from your real relationship,
- 13:27make you less satisfied with your existing relationship, and objectify a new partner to make
- 13:32it only about sex, or whatever it is that you're currently missing.
- 13:35You're just easing yourself into more infidelity.
- 13:39It rehearses it mentally and emotionally.
- 13:42The next is that I'm not lusting after a real person, it's just a character.
- 13:46And this is especially common for erotica, anime porn, or AI companions.
- 13:51However, it misses the point.
- 13:52Your desire is being trained towards control, fantasy, and consumption rather than mutuality
- 13:57and love.
- 13:58The object might be fictional, but the formation is real, and is as is the impact to your real
- 14:04relationships, or the barriers you're putting up to form them.
- 14:07The next is, this helps me cope with loneliness, stress, or unmet needs.
- 14:12And porn and fantasy offer the promise of immediate emotional relief.
- 14:16However, relief is not the same as healing.
- 14:18This is the equivalent of getting addicted to pain medication rather than getting the underlying
- 14:22issue resolved.
- 14:24Fantasy soothes symptoms while deepening the underlying wound by teaching avoidance of real
- 14:30connection.
- 14:31The one I hear a lot is, my spouse doesn't meet my needs.
- 14:35However, this, again, doesn't solve the problem.
- 14:37This is a conflict in your marriage that needs to be addressed.
- 14:40Sidestepping it doesn't deal with that conflict.
- 14:41If your spouse is acting in sin by gatekeeping or refusing intimacy, the answer isn't infidelity
- 14:47with a real or fictional person or people on your side, two wrongs don't make a right.
- 14:54You're enabling your spouse's sin, then doubling down by engaging in your own.
- 14:58You're treating sin like a dessert that it's not fair.
- 15:01Your spouse gets to sin and you don't.
- 15:04Others will say it's normal.
- 15:06Everybody does it.
- 15:06And it's true.
- 15:07More and more of the world does.
- 15:08I hear this more and more from Christians that, well, everybody else is doing it.
- 15:13Why can't I?
- 15:13And up to 95% of men and 70% of women will engage in porn.
- 15:19About 70% of men and 35% of women, and that number keeps going up, will do so on a weekly
- 15:25basis.
- 15:27What's also normal is infidelity, divorce, and marital dissatisfaction.
- 15:31And it's no wonder.
- 15:32Normal doesn't mean healthy.
- 15:35Widespread practices can still be destructive.
- 15:37This is why we're warned in Romans 12 verse 2 not to conform to the world.
- 15:42From non-Christians, what I typically hear is, this is about sexual repression or shame.
- 15:47And those who try to hold to a biblically informed life will often be called prude, sex
- 15:54negative, repressive, and more.
- 15:56And when people call me these things, frankly, it makes me laugh because, well, I have over
- 16:00a decade of writing about just about every sexual practice under the sun.
- 16:04I even have a list of literally hundreds of sexual practices that a husband and wife can
- 16:08engage in that don't violate biblical principles.
- 16:11As far as I can tell, anyways.
- 16:14But as soon as you draw any line, it must mean you're anti-sex.
- 16:17But the Bible isn't anti-sex.
- 16:19It's anti-counterfeit intimacy.
- 16:21God created desire, intimacy, and sex.
- 16:23But pornography, in all of its forms, distorts that creation.
- 16:27And the last one I hear from a lot of people is, I can separate fantasy from real life.
- 16:31And the truth is, no, you can't.
- 16:34Neuroscience shows us over and over again that what gets your brain gets you.
- 16:37Our brain does not distinguish well between fantasy and reality.
- 16:41It doesn't even distinguish well when you're acting out the fantasy versus doing it for
- 16:45real.
- 16:46For example, do you know that if you hold a pencil between your teeth with your lips closed,
- 16:51you'll likely feel negative emotions.
- 16:53But if you hold it and don't let your lips touch it, you'll likely feel positive emotions.
- 16:57Why?
- 16:58Because one forces a frown and the other one forces a smile.
- 17:02You don't even have to know what you're acting out, a frown or a smile.
- 17:06The simple act of you moving your face in that configuration is enough for your brain to go,
- 17:13oh, I must feel like this.
- 17:15We are terrible at separating reality from fiction.
- 17:18The vast majority of the problems in our relationships are due to fictions we create in our own minds.
- 17:24This is why the first rule in marriage coaching for my clients is assume your spouse loves you
- 17:29because too often we decide that they don't.
- 17:33And that assumption impacts every perception that we have about them.
- 17:36When they say what they say, what they do, what they don't say or do.
- 17:41If you assume they're malicious, you'll interpret their actions as malicious.
- 17:44If you assume they're loving, you'll interpret their actions as loving.
- 17:48The actions don't change.
- 17:49Our grounding to reality is tenuous at best.
- 17:53So what if you've been using porn, fantasy, and AI companions?
- 17:58Number one is stop immediately.
- 18:00Chances are that's going to be hard to do, especially if you've been doing so for a long time.
- 18:06It is hard to stop.
- 18:07You will likely feel some depression because you'll have cut off the supply of dopamine from these sources.
- 18:13Ideally, you tell your spouse that you've been struggling with it and they can help support you.
- 18:17I understand that can be difficult though.
- 18:19Some spouses aren't able or willing to forgive that sort of break in trust.
- 18:24But you'll likely not do it alone.
- 18:26Get an accountability partner.
- 18:28Talk to a pastor or an elder or get a coach.
- 18:31I've helped people through this.
- 18:32You can do it.
- 18:34It's just really hard to do on your own.
- 18:35Then refocus your attention on your spouse.
- 18:39Retrain your brain to learn to love them.
- 18:41It's not going to be quick.
- 18:42And the longer you've been addicted to these things, the harder it will be.
- 18:45The longer it's going to take.
- 18:47But our brains are very malleable.
- 18:49That is the problem with these mechanisms.
- 18:51But it's also the path forward.
- 18:54You can change how your brain works.
- 18:56There's a great verse, Philippians 4 verse 8, that says, you know, whatever is true, whatever
- 19:00is noble, whatever just, whatever is pure, whatever is lovely, whatever is good, you
- 19:05know, focus on these things.
- 19:08Healing involves training desire back towards presence, covenant, and embodied love.
- 19:13Because you were made for more than illusion and fantasy.
- 19:17You were created to have real, deep, intimate relationships, especially with your spouse.
- 19:22If you're not, then there was work to be done, not distractions to avoid the lack thereof.
- 19:29Fantasy always promises intimacy without pain, but only reality can deliver intimacy with
- 19:34meaning.
- 19:35And God's design is harder and riskier, but it is more satisfying.
- 19:39This is what we were built for.
- 19:42Now, I skipped over a whole lot of Bible verses.
- 19:44If you're curious about seeing them all, head over to the blog post.
- 19:48There's a link in the show notes.
- 19:49If you have questions about any of them, these feel free to send me an email.
- 19:53It's Jay at uncovering intimacy.com.
- 19:56And we're going to be continuing this with the series because I have lots more to say
- 20:00about this.
- 20:00If you don't want to miss any of them, jump on our mailing list.
- 20:03It's free.
- 20:04There's a link in the show notes.
- 20:06And if you want to join a community where we're discussing these things regularly, jump
- 20:10into our forum.
- 20:12It'll cost you less than a cup of coffee and you'll get a community of people who are all
- 20:16focused on improving their marriages and others.
- 20:19That's it for today.
- 20:20Talk to you next time.