Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 180 - Why Bad Ideas Persist | Crémieux
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 180 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:36Hello, yes.
- 0:37Hello from the wonderful, eclectic and incredibly hot city of Austin in Texas.
- 0:44Yes, I'm here for, amongst other things, the Running Remote Conference.
- 0:49That's the biggest gathering of remote workers and DigiNomad type people in the world, apparently.
- 0:56I've also already met some amazing people here.
- 0:59working in the alternative governance world. And you know what? I also lost my Waymo virginity
- 1:06too. That's right. I went into a Waymo for the first time, sat in a driverless car and watched
- 1:12the whole thing normalize within about five minutes. Surprisingly. Yeah, it's a shock to
- 1:19start with, but you soon get over it. What's going on? I mean, come on, the world is moving
- 1:24really fast at the moment, according to me at least. Imagine what life is going to be like in,
- 1:30say, 50 years. God only knows. Me personally, I still think I'm going to be just digging my garden.
- 1:35And if you're about to tell me, well, hold on a minute, you're going to be dead by then.
- 1:39Apparently not. Longevity tech is going to give me a few extra years, I'm told. Anyway, before we
- 1:45go on, I would like to remind you that this episode is brought to you by the wonderful Veritas
- 1:50villages our lead sponsor veritas villages are building freedom-oriented communities
- 1:56across latin america designed for people who value sovereignty resilience and a higher degree
- 2:02of personal autonomy and as you may have heard they've recently secured approval for a new
- 2:08340 acre development in the highly coveted area of atenas in costa rica a quiet valley
- 2:17known for its mild year-round climate rolling hills and a somewhat slower, more livable pace
- 2:24of life than the nearby San Jose. This is also happening alongside their other projects in
- 2:31Nicaragua and Panama. Veritas villages have a very strong alignment with the Bitcoin ethos as well.
- 2:40You knew that already though, but just in case you didn't, you can purchase your property
- 2:44using Bitcoin and you can spend Bitcoin within their communities and they'll even help you set
- 2:50up Bitcoin mining rigs in your home to make the most of the excess energy production that your
- 2:57self-sufficient home makes. They also have a sensible real-world Bitcoin treasury strategy.
- 3:05All in all, they're a trailblazing Bitcoin Citadel company, if you ask me. Anyway,
- 3:10If you're curious to learn more or to explore becoming a resident, www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities in the show notes, obviously.
- 3:22Right. Today's guest. It's a good one.
- 3:25Cremieux. Well, he doesn't exist technically.
- 3:28That's a pseudonym, of course.
- 3:31A bit of a hat tip to Adolphe Cremure, the 19th century French statesman who pushed through the abolition of slavery in the French colonies.
- 3:43Behind the pseudonym?
- 3:44Well, one of the most read independent data writers on the Internet.
- 3:50Genetics, demographics, fertility, IQ, charts for days.
- 3:55Elon Musk subscribes to him.
- 3:57J.D. Vance follows him. He has a knack for taking studies that everyone treated as settled and
- 4:04quietly showing that, well, they're actually not, which has earned him an audience in Silicon Valley
- 4:10and a permanent migraine in academia. I sat down with Cremure in Prospera of all places,
- 4:19which, let's be honest, is roughly the natural habitat for someone like him. And what followed
- 4:24was, well, less of an interview and more a real-time error correction service for myself.
- 4:31I'd say something perfectly reasonable and he'd politely point out why the data doesn't actually
- 4:36agree with that. His philosophy distilled, well, complex problems get clearer with honest inquiry
- 4:43and good data, and that's the important thing. But the answers are almost always harsher,
- 4:50less equal and less comforting than people want them to be. We get into all of it. Why Honduras
- 4:57is being run like the Soviet Union, why El Salvador works now even though the people are exactly the
- 5:04same as they were five years ago, what it would actually take to build a second San Francisco and
- 5:10why no one has the faintest idea how to do it, what predicts a person becoming a socialist,
- 5:15don't ask if you're sensitive i'm not obviously whether you should hand over your genome to the
- 5:22state in exchange for well living forever maybe and somewhere in the middle of all that the fact
- 5:29that lbj used to intimidate his secret service detail by peeing on their legs yes it's a good
- 5:40one this week right before you listen to the conversation quick hat tip to this week's value
- 5:45for value ballers the top five bitcoin donators and streamers and subscribers in first place
- 5:55shadrach number two darcy number three christopher albanese number four ant number five matthias
- 6:02thank you all very very much indeed and if you would like to donate bitcoin to us please do it
- 6:10through one of the value for value platforms my favorite is fountain.fm or you could look in the
- 6:16show notes and there's actually a bitcoin address there and you can send us bitcoin that way as well
- 6:20don't forget www.freecitiesconference.com is the website to sign up for what will be prosperer's
- 6:28biggest event to date yes the free cities conference is taking a year away from prague
- 6:35to walk the walk and exist in an actual free city, September the 3rd to the 6th,
- 6:41with itineraries either side as well. So book early and come early and leave late. Everyone
- 6:46who's everyone in this scene will be there. Bring your projects, bring your inquisitive minds
- 6:51and have some invigorating days and normally very late nights planning how to change the world
- 6:59for the better right it's time for the alpha now i will stop talking and this week try not to cringe
- 7:06as you listen to my brain cells exploding in real time just do what you normally do sit back relax
- 7:14and enjoy my conversation with cremure
- 7:18anyway what i've got on here though is i was i was drilling down i was trying to get the macro
- 7:32view of what you think which is chat tbt is really good at things like that you know what i mean
- 7:36i don't know what you don't use it i mean i i use it for um not for that sort of thing uh i often
- 7:44use it for data cleaning or i'll use it for some quick task uh i tend not to rely on it very much
- 7:49because i don't think it's very good at a lot of things it's often wrong yes but but once you kind
- 7:54of incorporate that into your modus operandi sure it's better well you can see let's see because i i
- 7:59was trying to distill down i i asked it to to watch a few of your videos you know that your
- 8:04interviews and try and distill down your your sort of philosophy rather than you know your specifics
- 8:11I mean I asked it at the end
- 8:14Whether it thought what I thought was right And it said close But I think you soften him too much Have you ever had it vet yourself Have you ever had it imitate you Did it work well
- 8:26More recently, yes.
- 8:28I asked because, interestingly, like I've got two lives.
- 8:32I have the pre-sort of Bitcoin and Free Cities life,
- 8:37where I was basically a film producer and a filmmaker photographer.
- 8:41and then there's this other me which is online looks completely different and it's only been
- 8:47about a year and a half that chat chibit's put the two together but check this out i asked it
- 8:52whether or not what i'm doing now is relevant to what i used to do and it and it showed me why
- 8:58my career path has been the same and i'm now doing the same i've always worked at the frontiers like
- 9:05i was a filmmaker and i used to travel to very remote locations and make films and stuff national
- 9:09geographic and bbc earth and all this kind of stuff and this is and philosophically that's my
- 9:14inclination obviously because um and now so so i like to get to that i like to get to the bottom
- 9:21of that when i'm interviewing someone because i then i know that i can rely on my own experiences
- 9:26in conversation of course because data wise you'll you'll be able to absolutely annihilate me on
- 9:32on absolutely any subject but with experience anyway like so sure sure so what it boiled you
- 9:38down to your ideology. Complex problems become clearer with honest inquiry and good data,
- 9:45but the answers are often harsher, less equal, and less comforting than people want them to be.
- 9:52I mean, that's probably true. It's not that I want them to be any particular way,
- 9:55just how that comes out. Often enough, what I'll find is that when I have access to data,
- 9:59I can look into some paper, and if I can share the data set, I can look at it, I can go
- 10:03redo some analysis. I'll find, oh, there were some things that made these authors significant
- 10:07results not so significant once you actually look into it like they've done something they've
- 10:12adjusted some model somewhere they've done something peculiar they didn't justify an
- 10:16analytical choice and then they got something which didn't really hold up when you actually
- 10:20look into it just completely fairly flatly with like a simple analysis but and in in your world
- 10:27though you very much specifically turned that lens to biotech is that right on the whole or is that
- 10:33not necessarily right i don't get necessarily right i look at all sorts of things i mean i look
- 10:36at like do pets make you happy like there's just a million uh does like stuff about fertility um
- 10:42maybe that's just because i i know nicholas and nicholas has talked to you in depth about it and
- 10:48i mean a lot of what you a lot of your interviews seem to go down that route
- 10:52is that is that specifically for because i don't know why i mean it's weird talking to you you're
- 10:59you're you're gonna call me out on absolutely everything i say aren't i i'm just talking i
- 11:04love that no but i what i mean is if i say something you're probably uh error correcting
- 11:09me at the at the time i'm saying it right if you like so if i no i do like that i do i really do
- 11:15like that i something else i do with chat gpt is yeah i it analyzes my conversations and tells me
- 11:21where i'm bullshitting basically you know um after afterwards no i was going to say so possibly the
- 11:30reason why so many of your interviews about biotech is because something happened you you
- 11:35you revealed something relevant in biotech and then everyone jumped on that bandwagon could be
- 11:41i think i talk about it quite a bit so uh people do ask about it a lot um sometimes they ask about
- 11:46more econ stuff sometimes they ask about uh a lot of times they focus on like uh iq stuff
- 11:53just kind of whatever topics everybody has different things they want to ask about that
- 11:58That's a very dangerous territory IQ.
- 12:03Cheers to that, yeah.
- 12:05Coke, what is it?
- 12:07Lipton Zero.
- 12:07It's tea.
- 12:08We're British.
- 12:09We like tea.
- 12:10There we go.
- 12:11Now that whole IQ thing, is that IQ and race and all that kind of quagmire?
- 12:18Yeah.
- 12:18What's the inconvenient truth about that then?
- 12:21Go on, tell me.
- 12:21Oh, well, it's that the models are actually very simple to test.
- 12:24All the conclusions you can reach, you can reach pretty easily.
- 12:26and people just don't want to talk about it.
- 12:29Like if you give a test to potential employees,
- 12:33you can see that it actually predicts how well they work on the job.
- 12:36And this is incredibly simple to show.
- 12:38And it just shows up again and again and again.
- 12:40And yet people still ignore this.
- 12:42All of these things are just totally simple and totally ignored.
- 12:49And I really don't know what else to say about it.
- 12:51How do you subdivide that though?
- 12:53What are the categories that you use in, say, the IQ one?
- 12:55Is it race?
- 12:56Is it sex?
- 12:57No, no.
- 12:58Is it whatever?
- 12:58You can look at whatever group difference you want.
- 13:00There are a lot that are salient politically,
- 13:01so people want to look at them,
- 13:02and they're interesting to look at.
- 13:05But there's no particular one that's of, like, you know,
- 13:08some esteemed interest or anything like that.
- 13:09What you generally find is that there's not much that's interesting out there
- 13:12when you really boil it down to, like, the very, like,
- 13:16low-level facts of whatever the matter is.
- 13:18So, like, as an example of this,
- 13:20people often talk about special immigrant groups.
- 13:22So they'll say, like, oh, Nigerian immigrants are very special.
- 13:25They're very, like, over-predicted,
- 13:26and they do extremely well.
- 13:27And then you boil it down and you're like, well, no.
- 13:29Once you account for the fact they live in like urban areas
- 13:31and they have this level of education
- 13:32and they come from these places
- 13:34and their country has this level of poverty
- 13:36and it's like this size, nothing to it.
- 13:39They're not special in any way.
- 13:40They're just like, you know, as predicted.
- 13:42And people don't tend to think of everything
- 13:44in the way that like,
- 13:45in terms of trying to actually boil down stuff to its essence.
- 13:48But once you do, most things are not special.
- 13:50There's no group that's really special cognitively.
- 13:52There's like no group that just can't do IQ tests
- 13:55because they think a totally different way
- 13:57because we're all very similar as humans fundamentally.
- 14:00Is that right?
- 14:01So what's your macro view of the human condition then?
- 14:07What makes us different then?
- 14:11It's mostly individual differences.
- 14:13I mean, there's all sorts of things that make us different.
- 14:14There are many genetic things, many environmental things.
- 14:17But in terms of real quirks,
- 14:21a lot of them are strongly heritable in ways that are shocking.
- 14:24So for example, myself and all my siblings and my grandparents, we all sneeze about eight
- 14:30times whenever we sneeze.
- 14:31It's seven, eight, nine times.
- 14:33It's totally heritable.
- 14:35And it's just on one side of the family.
- 14:36And it's bizarre.
- 14:37And it goes back generations.
- 14:38And there's a book account of one of my relatives.
- 14:42And the biographer is like, oh, he sneezed in a really weird way.
- 14:46And why is it?
- 14:48I don't know.
- 14:48All sorts of things are heritable.
- 14:50You don't even think about.
- 14:51My macro view of the human condition, though, is that those things are kind of irrelevant.
- 14:55It's more about how we interact with one another and what institutions are a big part of this.
- 15:00So you go on the mainland.
- 15:02Have you ever been to the mainland?
- 15:03Of Honduras.
- 15:04Of Honduras.
- 15:04No, actually, I haven't.
- 15:06It's not as good as here.
- 15:08No, no, sure.
- 15:08It's one of the most dangerous places.
- 15:10Yeah.
- 15:11Yeah.
- 15:13But it doesn't have to be that way.
- 15:14Look at El Salvador.
- 15:15Have you been to El Salvador?
- 15:15Yes, very much.
- 15:16Did you go before Bukele?
- 15:18And after.
- 15:19And after.
- 15:19Yeah.
- 15:20You notice the difference.
- 15:20Sure, yeah.
- 15:21The people didn't change.
- 15:22These are genetically the same people as before,
- 15:24but the institutions have changed.
- 15:25Their social arrangements have changed.
- 15:27They went from, you have to have a barbed wire fence on your home
- 15:30and you have to lock the doors behind seven different locks
- 15:32to you can leave your door open actually now.
- 15:35And all it took was a little change in how the institutions work
- 15:39and what they're policing and all that.
- 15:40Are you into evolutionary biology at all?
- 15:42Oh yeah, absolutely.
- 15:43So I take it you think that's highly relevant?
- 15:48Evolutionary biology, yes.
- 15:49Evolutionary psychology, much less so.
- 15:50I've combined a lot of this stuff to be hard to explain.
- 15:55So there are lots of theories in evolutionary psychology that just don't really hold up under scrutiny.
- 16:00And they're kind of bothersome.
- 16:02And people index too much on them.
- 16:04They really think way too much about, oh, this has to be explained by something in the environment of evolutionary adaptiveness, the EA, the historical environment where we evolved as a species.
- 16:13and I think Steven Pinkert has a really great quote on this
- 16:15where he says something along the lines of
- 16:17the environment of illusionary
- 16:20is the wrong frame
- 16:21to understand a 70 year old
- 16:23widow playing the piano
- 16:25at the afternoon
- 16:26there's no reason to explain
- 16:29psychology, you don't have to
- 16:31but would you say that
- 16:33if you've got enough data though
- 16:34that was one of my takeaways from my deep dive with AI in a way you kind of think everything is explainable with the right amount of data
- 16:45Oh, absolutely. Yeah, everything has to be at the end of the day.
- 16:47But yeah, I think so as well. Yeah.
- 16:48Yeah. And it doesn't have to be a deterministic thing. It's not like we have, you know, some demon moving all the atoms.
- 16:54We have, like, a Laplacian demon.
- 16:56We just people operate in a certain way and like things function, you know, in some probabilistic sense that can be understood if we really get down to it.
- 17:06There has to be that on everything.
- 17:07Do you think one thing I've thought about the far distant future, possibly not even that far distant, is that the amount of data.
- 17:16Do you know what the Akashic records are?
- 17:18I do.
- 17:19Something along the lines of the Akashic records in sort of, you know, servers.
- 17:26will exist.
- 17:28Because there'll be so much data being harvested
- 17:31by so many things
- 17:33that you would argue that you reach a point
- 17:35where you can predict anything,
- 17:37you can show, you can answer any question.
- 17:39Is that?
- 17:40You can predict a lot.
- 17:41There will still be things you totally can't
- 17:43because we don't gather data
- 17:44on a lot of fundamental things.
- 17:47This is why qualitative work is often very good.
- 17:49If you give a test to a bunch of people
- 17:51and you statistically analyze it
- 17:53and you find some correlation here or there
- 17:54to make you an expert on whatever the thing is,
- 17:56But if you go in and you interview other people and you actually try and break down exactly what they're doing, you observe them in the act of whatever they're doing, you can understand them a lot more granularly than you can be permitted by any normal data gathering process.
- 18:06Because it's hard to put a number on all the things.
- 18:09And it is possible to build understanding of things that can be quantified through qualitative methods.
- 18:16But maybe we'll get there eventually with quantifying everything, but I don't think we will in a meaningful sense.
- 18:21what you said earlier you're not massively into ai yet for i mean i love ai yes um i do use it
- 18:29uh i don't use it for too much because i find that it makes too many errors there's still so
- 18:34many problems and it's very bad at like for example it's kind of weird some of them are
- 18:38better than others chat gpt can complete some of my old proofs uh claude cannot still i don't know
- 18:43why they're different they have different skills with mathematics and it's very shocking because
- 18:48they have mostly the same training as far as i'm aware i had a phenomenal story yesterday trey who
- 18:54do you know trey who i've known for a while right me and trey we had an awesome conversation
- 18:59three hour one about ai and he's his mind is super sharp and super interesting who yesterday
- 19:04was showing me on his phone he's got a bunch of agents working on his behalf and they're all in
- 19:10an ecosystem which is very much a trey goff ecosystem and he said to one of them right you
- 19:17can you can go and research whatever you want think about whatever you want you can do whatever
- 19:21you want there's absolutely no and and guess what it's ended up doing writing about buddhism
- 19:28and writing about the philosophy of buddhism it's probably a waste of time well i don't know but like
- 19:34he he the way i mean he was showing me and he i said look come on dude he must it must be picking
- 19:39up on something why why is it and he's like no i'm serious i'm i'm like i've told it absolutely
- 19:44nothing i've given it absolutely an open book and it went through a few iterations of some stuff and
- 19:49now it's starting to write a synopsis on on buddhism and all these different philosophical
- 19:55ideas and stuff like well once the ai goes down the eightfold path it'll ascend and then it'll
- 20:00you know won't be an issue anymore maybe it'll tell us something novel you're not into is are
- 20:05you not into religion or what you know a little bit like not at all you've got you got very like
- 20:10No, no, I'm extraordinarily skeptical of religion.
- 20:12I've never believed in it.
- 20:14Used to hate belief in it.
- 20:15Like, oh, yeah, we should believe in this for Pascal Wager's reasons.
- 20:18And I just gave it up.
- 20:19I was like a kid.
- 20:20I wouldn't say I'm religious at all.
- 20:23I've had some strange experiences.
- 20:25You know, I've done hallucinogens and I've, I couldn't, you know,
- 20:30it could all be synapses firing in my brain as well.
- 20:34So I'm not committed to the idea that, yes,
- 20:37what I experienced was as real as this.
- 20:40But then, I don't know, are you, I mean, are you absolutely, it's synapses firing off in your brain?
- 20:47Oh, sure. Yeah, I don't believe in any magical emergent properties.
- 20:50Like people talk about, did you see the presentation that they just did in there with the mindfulness stuff?
- 20:55No, sorry, I was interviewing.
- 20:57Oh, that's right. Yes, yes.
- 20:59Yeah, constantly.
- 21:00Well, there are people who are very often into meditation.
- 21:03They're into the hallucinogens and whatnot.
- 21:05and they really believe that there are these emergent properties
- 21:08that are well beyond our even possible ability to understand
- 21:12because there's some sort of spiritual thing to them
- 21:14and I don't believe in the spiritual part of that at all.
- 21:16Well, I mean, it depends.
- 21:19When I think about that, you have to quantify that word, spiritual.
- 21:22I know.
- 21:23Because when you and me say the word,
- 21:25I'm pretty sure we could have completely different,
- 21:29which we're talking about two different things completely.
- 21:31i suppose for me the that kind of realm of ideas is that there is there are realms of awareness
- 21:40which are different to this and i would i that i'm kind of i'm on that level i would say yes
- 21:45that i do believe that once again can't prove it to you can't yeah which is fine i accept all
- 21:51people's religious whatever i don't uh try and discriminate in any way i find it totally fine
- 21:56believing all that stuff i'm not against it i just can't believe it in myself it's hard do you know
- 22:00Bob Lazar have you ever heard of that guy he was I think I've heard the name but I don't know guy
- 22:05he was the guy from uh area 51 who sort of right okay who came out and sort of um you know said
- 22:14what was going on in area 51 right I find a lot of these people to be schizophrenic could be but
- 22:18there's a really interesting I love this one there's an old sort of 80s bit of footage of
- 22:23him being interviewed by someone in a very 1980s way you know kind of I like the way they interviewed
- 22:28back then they were far more like straight into the point and bob lazar was saying he was asking
- 22:33him about really high level top secret things and he said you know he got to the point where he said
- 22:38look i can't tell you mate and he's like why can't you tell me he said it's so outlandish you wouldn't
- 22:43believe me so the guy said all right just tell me and he said i found these you know very classified
- 22:49documents that i've got and they said that religion was basically something that was given to human
- 22:56beings in order to preserve their bodies because humans humans are vessels for souls or whatever
- 23:03that that means and extraterrestrial beings gave um gave them religion in order to you know maybe
- 23:11he hasn't run into indian religion yet they burn the bodies well yeah but while you're alive no the
- 23:15point is religion keeps you alive that's that's the thesis it makes it it makes you be good to
- 23:21your fellow neighbor and earth is just a land full of full of bodies holding souls yeah yeah
- 23:27there's a perspective on morality that uh you know adopted or was you know created to i wouldn't say
- 23:34created it was developed over time to encourage cooperation and religion is a you know a
- 23:40fundamental cooperation and religious institutions are amazing they've done so many incredible
- 23:44things like for the development of europe the catholic church was a uh sort of a check and
- 23:50balance on a lot of the realms across Europe. It helped to keep things, I wouldn't say federated,
- 23:55but split. It led to decentralization. One of the things that they did was they attacked cousin
- 24:01marriage because they didn't want people to form these large kinship networks that could threaten,
- 24:05you know, a realm where there might be a prince or there might be some sort of noble or duke or
- 24:09whatever. And they didn't want them to threaten the status of the church. They wanted everybody
- 24:14to be disunified before the church. And that was a good thing for Europe's development. The lack of
- 24:19kinship networks leads to, I think, better institutions.
- 24:22The Western European marriage pattern in the Heinle line
- 24:25between like north of Cordoba
- 24:27and all the way over to like middle of Poland,
- 24:29that whole area developed modern Western culture,
- 24:32which has been just incredible for the world.
- 24:35Yeah, I would tend to, I would be,
- 24:37I think as far as religion goes, I'd be there.
- 24:39It's a technology.
- 24:40Religion is an abstracted, it's like a technology.
- 24:46Yeah, yeah.
- 24:46And it does work.
- 24:46It's a social technology.
- 24:47Yeah, certainly.
- 24:48What do you think of Jordan Peterson's archetypes and maps of meaning and all that kind of stuff?
- 24:52I don think too much about it I find it to be a little wacky I have his book where he had this incredibly strange drawing and once I got to that point I was just like I believe I done I not learning anything from this Once you get too
- 25:05wacky, you stop having substance. If you abstract too much, I don't think you actually know what
- 25:09you're talking about at that point. And then you suddenly are bereft of any meaning and you should
- 25:14go back to, you know, fundaments. You should be able to go back to quantifying things. That's a
- 25:18little easier. So data, data, data, data, basically. Yeah, at the end of the day, because it is
- 25:22much more concrete.
- 25:24And if you stray from the concrete too much,
- 25:26you become a wackadoo.
- 25:28You become some sort of nutjob
- 25:30who just like talks about things
- 25:31that don't actually matter.
- 25:32And if somebody asks you why, why, why, why, why,
- 25:34you can't answer anything.
- 25:35Which is what I'm doing.
- 25:36I can see it.
- 25:37No, it is great.
- 25:38You can ask me the why's.
- 25:39I'll actually give you answers.
- 25:39I keep drifting away
- 25:41and you keep pulling me back to data.
- 25:43It's really cool.
- 25:44Bring it back.
- 25:44No, it's cool.
- 25:45We have to be grounded.
- 25:46If you're not grounded,
- 25:47then whatever steps you take
- 25:49are just going to be,
- 25:50I mean, walking on water.
- 25:51It's not going to work.
- 25:52Well, I mean, I do a version of that every time I interview someone, but I'm just not, but I'm not, you're like, you're like, you're like a data Nazi.
- 26:00You know, if data is here, you know, you're in there.
- 26:04I'm a little bit at the periphery over here, but I still draw back towards data, but not right to the middle point.
- 26:11It's great.
- 26:12It's fascinating.
- 26:13Have you ever thrown your lens at sort of governance then in general?
- 26:16Like what have you found?
- 26:17Very certainly.
- 26:18Oh, absolutely.
- 26:19so I am kind of libertarian leaning I definitely want there to be less government involvement in
- 26:26most things like the market needs to be much much freer and there are many markets that are just
- 26:30completely busted because they're not really markets at all here in Honduras the situation is
- 26:36atrocious when it comes to regulations it's a total mess I think I told you before that we
- 26:41started this interview there's an economic minister down here we're going to go talk to him afterwards
- 26:44and I'm just going to pitch them on practically the Washington consensus
- 26:48because so much of what's wrong with Honduras
- 26:50is that they are effectively governed like a socialist hellhole.
- 26:54And so, for example, more than 80% of the economy, the hiring is informal.
- 27:00And with informal hiring, you can't tax it.
- 27:01You can't get the payroll taxes.
- 27:02So the payroll taxes here are very high.
- 27:04They're way too high.
- 27:05And so nobody wants to pay them, so nobody works on that stuff.
- 27:08But also, you can't fire an employee without paying another tax.
- 27:11It's a severance tax.
- 27:12So if you want to get rid of someone at your company,
- 27:14you're screwed. So best just not to have the government acknowledge you've hired them in the
- 27:18first place. Get rid of that. There's no point having it. You should have at-will employment
- 27:23here. You should have it practically everywhere, I believe, but some people disagree. In the U.S.,
- 27:28it's a little more tolerable. It's more tolerable in Europe, but it's still actually a big reason
- 27:32why Europe is behind the U.S. because they can't fire people. But here, it doesn't make any sense.
- 27:36You're a third world country. You're incredibly, incredibly poor. You're destitute. There are
- 27:40shanty towns everywhere, and you're still like regulating as if you're the Soviet Union,
- 27:45you can't do this. They don't have FDI protections. If you want to bring in a lot of money here,
- 27:49it takes a long time. You can take more than 70 days to bring in money and invest it here.
- 27:54And by that point, maybe an opportunity has moved along where your money would have been better
- 27:57suited elsewhere. And they just need to repeal, repeal, repeal tons of the like vestiges of their
- 28:03prior socialist left-leaning governments and adopt the Washington Consensus. They need to practice
- 28:07some fiscal restraint, they need to increase the base for tax collection, and they need to lower
- 28:12the actual tax rates. That will lead to lots of growth. It'll lead to lots of investment. It'll
- 28:17lead to them being a lot better off. And it's remarkable that they don't do it, that they
- 28:22haven't already done it. Their preferred scheme is to, well, do a scheme. It's to do something
- 28:28they believe that will allow their government to raise revenues without having to go through all
- 28:32the hard rigmarole of actual meaningful institutional reform like they're doing down
- 28:35in Argentina or over in El Salvador. They want to, for example, bring over an Israeli investor
- 28:42who is going to make his own credit card here and they're going to collect the interchange fees and
- 28:45that'll be some portion of their tax revenue, but that'll be so tiny. And I don't even believe the
- 28:50adoption will be that much. They're going to keep Visa's MasterCard's American Express here and
- 28:53it's just not going to be a meaningful project. So why invest the time on it when you could just
- 28:58be repealing some of the major things that really hold you back? You should be able to make a
- 29:02business here in a day could take you a year right now isn't that i mean you're talking about the
- 29:07the tension between socialism and free markets there i mean i mean it's it's a i think it's a
- 29:14tension between socialism and life you can't have modern life with 80 of your economy informal
- 29:20land titling more than 80 of the land titling in this in the mainland is not done yet they have
- 29:26These rural areas, they're just subsisting on a farm that nobody technically owns.
- 29:31And this is something they've tried to work on in the past, but then they just kind of abandoned it.
- 29:35It's a huge thing they should do.
- 29:37All the land should be titled up.
- 29:39It's bizarre that they don't have it.
- 29:41Does that stem from the days of socialism where there was no ownership of land?
- 29:45No, I think it stems more from the fact they just haven't developed yet.
- 29:47They have to develop these institutions.
- 29:49The initial, like, seeding of the institutions is just not there.
- 29:53They practically don't have property rights in a lot of the country.
- 29:55and you need property rights to grow.
- 29:57You need property rights to be prosperous.
- 29:58You need property rights to be rich
- 29:59and healthy and wealthy and wise.
- 30:02Everything else.
- 30:03I noticed that happening in El Salvador,
- 30:06especially around places like El Zonte.
- 30:09Do you know about El Zonte?
- 30:09Yes, I've been to Bitcoin Beach.
- 30:10Right, when we were there.
- 30:12We took a helicopter ride over.
- 30:13It was great.
- 30:14I've been a few times
- 30:15and I've been after the kind of boom
- 30:18of Bitcoiners going there.
- 30:19And they had a lot of problems like that
- 30:21because all down the front of the beach
- 30:23were people living.
- 30:25and no one had any chickens running around all sorts of squalor and they had to work something
- 30:30out because basically they wanted to develop the place and um i think it was mainly as far as i
- 30:35remember you might know actually it was done through sort of gentlemen's agreements and stuff
- 30:40and families talking to other families and saying okay well look we want to put our restaurant here
- 30:46you know we'll we'll give you that and swap you that and that kind of stuff you know yeah it's
- 30:50incredibly informal and this is they're trying to formalize and the areas that like in el salvador
- 30:54that now have good beaches,
- 30:55you can tell that they've walled off large areas
- 30:58from the traditional practical landlessness of the people.
- 31:02But if you go elsewhere, it's still horribly undeveloped.
- 31:06Have you ever looked into what happened in China
- 31:09when the reform started?
- 31:12Yeah.
- 31:12Because they had no ownership.
- 31:14Oh, yeah.
- 31:15There's no markets.
- 31:16Yeah.
- 31:17And I made a film about free economic zones.
- 31:21And we did a big section on that.
- 31:23It was fascinating.
- 31:23Yeah.
- 31:24But seeing that you, you know, going from that, which is kind of what we're talking about here, essentially.
- 31:29I mean, a lot of the reason you don't have markets is because of socialism.
- 31:35But in the case of China.
- 31:37There are these third world socialist pretensions that like are incredibly common across all the world that was freed.
- 31:43And like, there were like two exceptions, Singapore and Israel.
- 31:48And one of those copied the other one's example.
- 31:50Israel decided when they were, they're a post-colonial country.
- 31:53We don't think about them that way because they're developed.
- 31:55But Israel decided we are going to follow Europe.
- 31:57We're going to trade with Europe.
- 31:58We're going to trade with the U.S.
- 31:59We're going to be allies with the obvious good guys.
- 32:02I mean, at the time there was a socialist and like, you know, that was a bad idea.
- 32:06And the rest of the third world goes the other way.
- 32:08Singapore gets freed a little later.
- 32:10They decide, wow, Israel is actually succeeding.
- 32:13The rest of the third world kind of sucks.
- 32:15We're not going to do this third world unity nonsense.
- 32:17It doesn't actually make you rich.
- 32:18We're going to go the Israel way.
- 32:19And they've even, they even worked with Israel.
- 32:21when they did their like you know starting their singaporean army or whatever defense whatever you
- 32:26want to call it i forgot the name um they used to get training with the israelis and they called
- 32:30them mexicans so they wouldn't defend uh some of their third world allies who hated the israelis
- 32:34what does the data say about socialism and free markets in the sense that
- 32:41i have a sort of anecdotal theory let's say yeah that um i mean you across age for example
- 32:51When you're young, you're more idealistic.
- 32:53You're more socialist.
- 32:54Sure.
- 32:55When you're older, you're taking responsibilities,
- 32:56you become more free market.
- 32:58What does the data say that might interest us about,
- 33:03as far as you know anyway, about other things
- 33:05that predict socialist tendencies?
- 33:08Because it-
- 33:09There's a lot.
- 33:10Because, well, if you think about it,
- 33:11once you discover the free market principle,
- 33:14it's very hard to then, other than,
- 33:18in the case of socialism, I think,
- 33:20It's a function of scale. So socialism works in my home, with my family. Beyond that, it
- 33:26gets a bit dodgy.
- 33:27It gets wonky.
- 33:27Yes, right. Is that the truth, do you think? Is that where the truth of socialism is?
- 33:32I suppose. I don't even know if I would call what's in the home socialism. It feels like
- 33:36a little too nice to socialism. Gives it too much credit.
- 33:40Does it, though? I mean, I'm as a...
- 33:43You're not really social in your home. You're not central. Well, I mean, you are planning.
- 33:46Yeah, yeah, I am.
- 33:47But are you, you know, not allowing any inputs from anybody else?
- 33:50Are you, you know, crushing your children, putting them in jail?
- 33:55Well, no, but you do, I do.
- 33:56I mean, within reason, like the way our family works is I set the boundaries.
- 34:01And within the boundaries, you can kind of do what you want.
- 34:03But I do enforce the boundaries.
- 34:05I'm a sort of strict dad.
- 34:08Yeah.
- 34:08So I am an authoritarian dad in the sense.
- 34:12But my kids love it.
- 34:14I've got great kids.
- 34:14And I've always thought it's because that's how kids work.
- 34:18They want a boundary.
- 34:19They do.
- 34:20And they need a boundary.
- 34:21Yeah, yeah.
- 34:21They need a boundary.
- 34:22Yeah.
- 34:24So things that predict social tendencies.
- 34:28Insanity, number one.
- 34:29What's that?
- 34:30Insanity.
- 34:30Insanity for one.
- 34:31Yes, absolutely.
- 34:32Absolutely.
- 34:33I mean, it's kind of curious.
- 34:35A lot of it is predicted by, well, I mean, there are some good predictions from poor mental health.
- 34:40In the Western world that we live in, people who have poor mental health
- 34:44are much more likely to accept socialism,
- 34:46not to promote it.
- 34:47Can I, every time you say one,
- 34:49can I give you my perspective on why I think it's true?
- 34:51Yeah.
- 34:51You tell me if it's not.
- 34:54Poor mental health means basically
- 34:56you're not very competitive.
- 34:59So you need the group.
- 35:00So the group then becomes your crux.
- 35:03Yeah.
- 35:03Right, okay.
- 35:04There are several studies that have looked
- 35:05into socialist revolutionaries
- 35:07and they tend to be downwardly mobile people.
- 35:12Downwardly mobile?
- 35:13What does that even mean?
- 35:14They have lower occupational rankings, education, and income than their parents.
- 35:20And they're trying to prove themselves by using the truth.
- 35:24They're feeling resentful, I guess.
- 35:25Well, I mean, yeah, they do come across like that.
- 35:27They're very resentful.
- 35:28That is another thing that predicts it.
- 35:29People who are very resentful, they are much more likely to like socialism.
- 35:34Once again, because socialism offers them the power to normalize and to equalize, I mean, necessarily.
- 35:40It allows them to attack their, well, I don't want to say betters, but attack the people who are actually successful, the people who have got what they want.
- 35:48If they were more successful, it's unlikely they'd be a socialist.
- 35:52There's the exception, though, in the form of champagne socialists.
- 35:54I was just about to say, how do you explain them, you know, rich sort of urban socialists?
- 36:01Yeah, a deviation.
- 36:03But most of them are people who are downwardly mobile.
- 36:06They are not going to have as much as their parents.
- 36:08they're going to have considerably less and they're not going to stick with the wealth they've got.
- 36:12If there's some heiress or something, politics is just irrelevant to them.
- 36:16They're not going to really think about it in any meaningful sense.
- 36:18So whatever they are, they're a blip.
- 36:20They're just too small to think about.
- 36:23Can we say, though, that socialism is used by powerful people, though?
- 36:32Sure.
- 36:32It is used.
- 36:33Absolutely.
- 36:34Are you just saying they just don't believe in it?
- 36:36They don't exhibit it.
- 36:38They do believe in it.
- 36:39There are plenty that do.
- 36:40But again, they're not the norm is the thing.
- 36:42So the norm is the masses who are not benefiting much from it.
- 36:44But there are people like at the top of the socialist, like communist parties who they benefit enormously.
- 36:49They're incredibly rich.
- 36:50If you look at like the wealthy people in China, they are disproportionately members of the communist party.
- 36:54And they probably believe in it to some extent.
- 36:57But they're also wise enough to know that you should do something else and you should exploit.
- 37:01And they do exploit.
- 37:03And those people are curious.
- 37:06I mean, they're not the norm.
- 37:08What about the ability to sort of not acknowledge idiosyncrasies like that?
- 37:20That's a predictor of socialism.
- 37:21Because it's hard to be socialist and rich, or richer than someone else, I suppose.
- 37:26Sure, sure.
- 37:28Yeah, I mean, what else do you want to say about that?
- 37:31No, nothing.
- 37:32Yeah, you're right.
- 37:34People are hypocritical.
- 37:34I'm not going to say hypocrisy predicts socialism
- 37:37I don't believe that's a thing
- 37:37but people who are socialist in the US
- 37:40do tend to be quite hypocritical
- 37:41they live in wealthy areas
- 37:42they don't give away all their funds and whatnot
- 37:44but that's also not really a tenet of socialism
- 37:46and it's not really a way to realize the revolution
- 37:48so it's
- 37:49a lot of people harp on that sort of thing
- 37:50and they say like
- 37:51oh socialists are hypocrites
- 37:52because they're not giving away all their money to the third world
- 37:53and it's like
- 37:53that's just a dumb argument
- 37:55you're making yourself look silly saying that
- 37:57so can we say then that socialism is
- 38:00like
- 38:01this is a weird way of putting it
- 38:04but bad
- 38:05Of course.
- 38:06Of course it's bad.
- 38:06I know, but I'm of the belief that everything has a point to it.
- 38:12Like I say, in the case of socialism, it might be that in the family unit, it works.
- 38:17Otherwise, why would these ideas be in existence if there wasn't some kind of purpose to them?
- 38:24There are tons of bad ideas in existence.
- 38:25There are people who want to do genocides.
- 38:27Like, that's a pretty bad idea.
- 38:29Paul Ehrlich, who just passed away, he was a sort of neo-Malthusian.
- 38:33And he believed that we were going to reach some sort of crisis where we couldn't produce enough food.
- 38:38And he said this two decades after we had effectively ended famines in the world.
- 38:44How did he get this idea?
- 38:45How did he not realize what was going on around him?
- 38:47How did he start promoting, you know, like having smaller and smaller families when larger and larger families are actually what makes prosperity?
- 38:53Don't know.
- 38:54These bad ideas can persist for a long time.
- 38:57Do you think people like that are genocidal or there's something else at play which is causing them to be like that?
- 39:04I don't think he was a meaningfully genocidal person.
- 39:06I don't think he had a lot of malintent, but he was very bad.
- 39:09And his views are incidentally bad.
- 39:11They are effectively genocidal.
- 39:13And he really did do something on the scale of a genocide.
- 39:16Like in India, they followed what he said and they sterilized millions of people.
- 39:21In one year, during when they were like really doing this, they sterilized more people than the Nazis ever did during the entirety of their reign.
- 39:27I mean, India is obviously larger, but still, it's an enormous thing.
- 39:30And if this had been done anywhere else, it would have been called genocidal.
- 39:33And so what do you think is going on in his mind at that time?
- 39:38Are you good-winking yourself?
- 39:39Yeah, yeah, that's what I'm saying.
- 39:40He thinks he's doing a good thing.
- 39:41He thinks he's right.
- 39:43And I think he thought he was right his entire life,
- 39:46which is baffling because he was so, so clearly wrong.
- 39:50But even within the last few years of his life,
- 39:53when he gave public statements about it,
- 39:54he didn't express any remorse or regret or anything else.
- 39:57And he just kept acting as though he was going to eventually be proven right, even though every step of the way he's wrong, wrong, wrong, increasingly, extremely, exceedingly wrong.
- 40:09Another predictor of socialism that you just maybe think of is thinking you know better than everyone else, basically.
- 40:16Is that fair to say?
- 40:17I suppose.
- 40:17But I think everybody else does that.
- 40:19Everybody thinks they know better than everybody else.
- 40:20But do they?
- 40:21But I mean.
- 40:22In some sense.
- 40:23And like, I think I know better.
- 40:24What's better for other people then?
- 40:26not necessarily like like i would never apart from my kids once again and which it does work
- 40:32in the home i do know what's better for them you do exactly that's the thing you know what's better
- 40:36for your kids you know that like they shouldn't go play in a radioactive waste pit like that's
- 40:41obvious and you're correct i think everybody thinks they know better than anybody else in some sense
- 40:45um and they might not admit it to themselves but like i think i know better than a lot of people
- 40:50when it comes to like how to reform this economy but i also think i'm right and i can show you that
- 40:55I'm right because there's tons of data that speaks to it so everybody thinks this way is what I think
- 40:59but some people are just correct and that's the difference when they are wrong then we start
- 41:05talking about them thinking they know better than everybody else because it's abrasive it gets in
- 41:09your face it's like no you're terribly wrong so we have to think about what you're saying we should
- 41:15know and acknowledge and talk about whereas if somebody's actually just correct you don't think
- 41:19about it that way they're just correct maybe it's that they believe that they can enforce it then
- 41:25yeah that's the difference could be but you're right we do know a lot more than a lot of people
- 41:30about a lot of things oh yeah but i would never feel like i should then have some weird god right to decide that that how you should live or whatever or do and that possibly like i say i had talking but i go on about jack gbd a lot but i do have a lot of conversations
- 41:46with jack gbd and i had one i i start you know i'm often trying to trying to find i don't know
- 41:53it's you're gonna hate it but i'm trying to find the sort of the the definitive the definitive
- 42:00creative idea which i'm sure these aren't data backed especially not on chat gpt in a way sure
- 42:06but let me explain what i mean so for example i i i got it to model out a scenario in which there
- 42:12were sort of like a hundred different competing small places okay and i said right tell me after
- 42:18a hundred years how many of them are socialism and how many of a socialist and how many are free
- 42:22market and you know and and show me every year what's happening you know and it i funnily enough
- 42:27but it ended up with,
- 42:28there were still some socialist ones at the end.
- 42:30Of course.
- 42:30I assumed they would just be competed away
- 42:32because it's a process of,
- 42:35you know, in the case of what we're into here,
- 42:38governance, if you create a socialist place
- 42:39or if you create a place with welfare,
- 42:42you attract the people that want the free shit
- 42:44and the people who provide the free shit move away.
- 42:47And it's this kind of cat and mouse game moving around.
- 42:50But in that conversation about socialism,
- 42:53chat gbt and i know that they love telling you what you want to hear so i'm fully aware of that
- 42:59and i'm always trying to tell it don't tell me what i want to hear tell me what you think it is
- 43:05but the conclusion was that socialist ideas of socialism are low iq that that was what came from
- 43:13the the whole thing somewhat um so there's a uh positive correlation between intelligence and
- 43:20economically right-wing, what we call economically liberal ideas, where you want a free market,
- 43:24free economies, free everything, like not free everything, not free stuff, but free
- 43:28ability to do enterprise. That's positive. There's a negative correlation between IQ and
- 43:34social conservatism, where you're like anti-gay and anti-racist and things like this. All that
- 43:40stuff, negative. So you have these two dimensions of the conservatism where, you know, so like the
- 43:46Republican Party, for example, before the recent realignment with Trump used to be basically
- 43:49the politicians in it were socially liberal and they were economically conservative,
- 43:55economically liberal in the like, you know, classical sense. And this is a relatively high
- 43:59IQ thing. The liberal politicians are more socially, they're socially liberal and even
- 44:04to a higher degree. And they are more economically liberal in the modern sense. You wouldn't call
- 44:10that conservative, really, whatever you would like to call that, they're left wing. And that's
- 44:15sort of a low IQ tendency. And you'll find that in countries where they have many parties,
- 44:18the lowest IQ parties tend to be the ones where you have this combination of horrible things.
- 44:24You have the racist party that also wants socialism, the National Socialist Party, basically.
- 44:30Yeah, that's the low IQ party.
- 44:31And then you have communists, they're relatively low IQ as well, because they end up being that way.
- 44:35And the sort of high IQ parties are unpopular.
- 44:38Like Libertarian Party has a notable IQ advantage over the Republican and the Democratic parties in the US.
- 44:44And what do they not excel at?
- 44:47They're nothing.
- 44:48Or like, what are the...
- 44:50Libertarians are bad at marketing.
- 44:52Yeah.
- 44:53I mean, it's an oxymoron, I think, libertarian parties.
- 44:56It's a funny...
- 44:58It is.
- 44:58It's hard to amass in a group when you kind of don't believe...
- 45:01When you believe in individualism, essentially.
- 45:03Yeah.
- 45:04I mean, I don't think there's much point to libertarian parties, actually.
- 45:09I think there's a point in that you have to actually assert yourself at some point,
- 45:12and you have to govern, and you can't just have this night watchman state
- 45:15that you've assembled from nothing.
- 45:16You have to actually realize that there are institutions you must deal with and people you have to influence with force.
- 45:22You do have to establish markets.
- 45:24Nowhere has ever established a market ad hoc, like without any sort of institutions around it that actually enable these markets.
- 45:31So what does that take then?
- 45:32What does it take to convince high IQ people that it's important to relinquish some of your – I mean, it probably stems from thinking about it, the fact that you are so individual because you know you can look after yourself.
- 45:45you know you can understand everything oh yeah of course why would i join forces with a group of
- 45:50people when most of them are going to basically i'm going to be that guy in the parito distribution
- 45:54who does all the work basically yeah probably is it and that's that's what it takes uh at the end
- 46:00of the day if you don't have people willing to do those things then you'll lose it all because the
- 46:03people who want the other way the people who want more government or whatever are willing to go into
- 46:08government they're willing to oppress you they're willing to snap you and like break you and you will
- 46:12lose. Here, they've had arrests of politicians when the previous government was in power,
- 46:17the socialists. They arrested tons of people. They threatened to arrest the mayor here, Jorge.
- 46:22They did all sorts of crazy things. And if you don't have the will to govern, you can't stop them.
- 46:29You're just going to get run over by them repeatedly. And this is what libertarians fail
- 46:32at is they don't actually organize. They have to organize. It sounds like some moronic. It sounds,
- 46:36oh, how do you get these individualists to come together in groups? But if you don't,
- 46:40then you can't be a libertarian.
- 46:42The pit I stumbled on and fortunately got over was the rules one.
- 46:47I thought it was rule.
- 46:48We don't want rules.
- 46:49We don't want rules.
- 46:49It's not.
- 46:49No, we want a few good rules.
- 46:52Oh, good rules.
- 46:53And I'll follow them happily.
- 46:54Yeah.
- 46:55But I was always, I missed that one until pretty recently, actually,
- 46:58thinking, I know what is funny, isn't it?
- 47:00I'm 54 and there's a bunch of stuff I didn't think about
- 47:04for the first 45 years of my life.
- 47:08I mean, I don't know.
- 47:09Do you find that?
- 47:10you're you probably something always triggers you to sort of find out these things don't you for me
- 47:15it's pure luck really meeting the wrong person at the wrong time it was bitcoin actually with me
- 47:20i met a guy on a plane in the early days of bitcoin going to the middle east and we he told
- 47:26me all about bitcoin and i just remember thinking oh i must look into that when i get back
- 47:29and looking back at it now it was a complete turning point in my life because it opened me
- 47:34up to libertarian ideas it opened me up to free markets it made me realize for example that
- 47:40economics is fascinating it's weird oh yeah prior to my experience economics oh my god boring
- 47:46economic bros and all that crap but actually economics is the study of human interactions
- 47:51and it's like wow this is and now i'm like it's crucial you have to have it it's the main point
- 47:58of uh politics in the day is if you know in switzerland most people there don't know the name
- 48:02of their president? Right. I didn't know that though. They don't. They don't. Why would they
- 48:08need to? In a well-functioning society that has a great economy that the government doesn't
- 48:13interfere with, you don't need to know the name of your president. It's not necessary. Why would
- 48:17you need to? Well, because we have a contest, a popularity contest. We do, but we don't need that.
- 48:23And it shouldn't matter to us. The president should not be able to influence us in a way that
- 48:27is so massive that it takes away some fundamental liberties or our ability to make a living or
- 48:32whatever it may be, but we do empower them and we encourage them and we polarize in like weird ways
- 48:38and we have them set up so that they're encouraged to just keep working on things that we,
- 48:44they're not really desirable. Whereas in Switzerland, they really do serve the people a
- 48:50lot better and a lot more locally. They have a form of federalism where you go up a level,
- 48:56up a level, up a level. You govern yourself and the like, you know, most powerful unit is really
- 49:02the most local unit. And it's, in a sense, they're not literally the most powerful because the
- 49:07military is organized, you know, federally. But they've decentralized it such that the politics
- 49:13don't matter to most people. You live your life, you go out and do the things you need to do,
- 49:17you have your job, you have your business, you have your whatever, you're trading with people,
- 49:21you're, you know, bringing your family here or there, you're going on vacations.
- 49:25And you don't have to think about the politics. And you shouldn't have to think about the politics.
- 49:29If you have a well-run polity, you can just go around and do whatever.
- 49:32And here, impossible.
- 49:35In Honduras, it's hell everywhere.
- 49:38Like, the government will have their hand in everything, and you must think about them,
- 49:42and the election must matter, and everything matters.
- 49:45And it just kind of takes away from the human experience.
- 49:48It makes it more political.
- 49:49You're having an experience that is undesirable, really.
- 49:53I don't think you should have to think about politics.
- 49:54You should be able to think about all the biotech things that they doing here and like how to make cures for diseases And even that too is something we should also be able to get away from once we have enough
- 50:05It's funny because you get this experience, I mean, previously, obviously, in Dubai.
- 50:11In Dubai, because you can't vote on anything in Dubai as an expat,
- 50:15you realize, oh, I don't even think about politics until you go home.
- 50:20because there's so many expats there is a very common experience for people to go back visit
- 50:25their families and start talking about politics again yeah um and that's that's i think i mean
- 50:30obviously we all believe this the way to run a place let the merchants you're basically going to
- 50:36dubai to be a merchant yeah like and it's run on no on that basis and that's great because really
- 50:42why else and in in many cases why would i need to have a say in the way it's run if it's run well
- 50:49I'm going to stay
- 50:50if it's not run well
- 50:52I'm going to go
- 50:52but we have a problem there
- 50:54obviously
- 50:54because there's not
- 50:55that many places like that
- 50:56yeah
- 50:56there's not enough
- 50:57opportunities for exit
- 50:58everything is focused
- 50:59on voice
- 51:00and voice is suboptimal
- 51:01voice is annoying
- 51:02you don't want to have
- 51:03to think about politics
- 51:04you don't want to have
- 51:04to get involved
- 51:05in the thing
- 51:06if you don't have to
- 51:06then you can focus
- 51:07on things that actually matter
- 51:08but we don't
- 51:10enough
- 51:10and everybody's involved
- 51:11in politics
- 51:12and it just sucks
- 51:12have you
- 51:13so give me your breakdown
- 51:15of democracy then
- 51:17you know
- 51:18the system of democracy?
- 51:21Not a fan of it.
- 51:22I mean, optimally it's not a thing,
- 51:25but right now it has to be a thing.
- 51:27There's effectively no way around this at the moment.
- 51:30You could have your little distributed polities
- 51:32in the future where you can go between them
- 51:33and exercise exit to control
- 51:36the levers of power in those places,
- 51:39but currently it doesn't exist.
- 51:41So you have to interface with democracy.
- 51:42You have to value democracy as well
- 51:44because if you don't actually have democracy,
- 51:45if you have stolen elections like in Turkey and Russia,
- 51:48or if you have like managed democracy like in Russia or you have anything like that,
- 51:53it's just an atrocious experience.
- 51:56There's really no way to go from there to a sort of libertarian paradise
- 52:01where you're making a bunch of cures for diseases and you're helping people to live longer.
- 52:04Whereas with the democracy we have in America,
- 52:06there's at least the opportunity to deregulate and develop.
- 52:10There's the opportunity to allow people to make things still.
- 52:13There's the opportunity to, you know, improve on governance here or there
- 52:17or pull it back in some places where it needs to be.
- 52:20And so you do have to value it.
- 52:22I do value it.
- 52:23How much do you think people should have a say
- 52:25in how countries are run then?
- 52:27Considerable.
- 52:30The thing is, I think they have to have a lot of say
- 52:33because they're run so poorly.
- 52:35Every country is run poorly, in my opinion.
- 52:37I don't think any country is run very well.
- 52:39Even Singapore's not run very well.
- 52:40They're too restrictive there.
- 52:43I don't think any country is run very well.
- 52:45That's a, nothing is an example.
- 52:48Wait a second, before you go on, that's a dangerous idea because you haven't got enough data.
- 52:54I mean, can you say that?
- 52:55We have lots of data on variations between these countries.
- 52:57You know, some policies that are good here are there.
- 52:59Yeah, but what's the, sorry, what's the control?
- 53:02Utopia?
- 53:03No, it's just continuous variation.
- 53:05You have no utopia.
- 53:06You have nothing to go off of that's perfect.
- 53:08But how do you know they're run badly if they all run badly?
- 53:11That's what I mean.
- 53:12Well, they're all run badly to different degrees.
- 53:13So you can see the effects of policies.
- 53:16Like, for example, the severance policy in Honduras, where you have to pay a tax when you fire an employee.
- 53:20This is a horrible policy.
- 53:22Other countries have had policies like this, and they've gotten rid of them.
- 53:24And what happens?
- 53:24Oh, employment is improved.
- 53:26Look across the U.S.
- 53:28States that adopt at-will employment, growth improvements.
- 53:31We know this because within these countries, they have changes.
- 53:34Between these countries, there are changes.
- 53:36You can look at them, and you can extrapolate.
- 53:38You can see that some policies work better than others.
- 53:40So obviously, places like Prospera, where we are now, they would be potentially a stepping stone to, I mean, ideally, would you say then that the future that works are many small competing places?
- 53:55That's what I like.
- 53:57I don't know if it'll actually work.
- 53:59There are major returns to scale.
- 54:01So how do you maintain agglomeration effects at the national level if you don't have nations?
- 54:07I really am not sure about this.
- 54:10How do you stop whoever won't come along with you into your distributed polity utopia, your patchwork from, you know, conquering it?
- 54:18The thing about like these patchworks is like they're like libertarians.
- 54:21They'll be conquered.
- 54:21If they can't defend themselves, if they won't defend themselves, if they will not, you know, unify against China, then what do you do?
- 54:28You die?
- 54:29You roll over?
- 54:32Yes.
- 54:33I don't know.
- 54:34I don't know.
- 54:35I mean, that's kind of predicting an all or nothing scenario then.
- 54:40It's either you have big states or you have distributed small places.
- 54:44Oh, no, I think you have mixes of them.
- 54:46We do have mixes right now.
- 54:47Like Europe is 57 countries or whatever, 55 countries.
- 54:50And a lot of them are allied to the US.
- 54:52And that's fine.
- 54:54Alliances are fine.
- 54:55Multinational alliances, I think they work.
- 54:57Like I would like to see like Ukraine join NATO.
- 54:59I would like to see more defense of our, you know, Western liberal traditions and realm.
- 55:06And I'd like to see it's the only real thing that has actually generated human progress.
- 55:11And I love that we all come together and we're all still separate till.
- 55:14So like there's still the Netherlands, there's still Belgium, there's still separate countries.
- 55:17They shouldn't unite everything together.
- 55:19I don't want a one world government because I think that'll be very suboptimal.
- 55:22I think that'll result in democracy totally degrading because there will be no chance for exit, only voice.
- 55:27and voice with that scale is just ruinous you'll end up like with a global honduras
- 55:31well voice won't even exist because everything will be run algorithmically
- 55:36presumably well i i i would say that currently i mean algorithms scale very well you know and
- 55:47if you look at sort of former large behemothic kind of like states yeah they they they want to
- 55:55scale and sometimes they can't because there's just not enough people to enforce the rules that
- 55:59work for them whereas with an algorithmic version so and we already see it now you know you can be
- 56:05on the computer trying to do something and it's computer says no yeah so we know it could we know
- 56:09it can happen and we know that once that becomes algorithmically enforced okay here's your score
- 56:16you're a good citizen you know this kind of stuff you know i and that i think is very enticing to
- 56:23governments number one because it means they can scale indefinitely number two is cheap it's cheap
- 56:29to enforce and it kind of gets rid of a lot of crime potentially because it's like a pre it stops
- 56:36you doing something before you ever do it so and as a one world scenario yeah that's basically 1984
- 56:43or it'd be terrible yes it'd be a dystopia yeah we don't want that no no we don't so you want to
- 56:50have some, it's curious. So if you want to make actual progress on biotech, we have to reduce
- 56:55privacy. We have to get rid of a lot of that. We have too much privacy right now. Like the HIPAA
- 57:00regulations in the US are atrocious. There are so many issues transmitting data between practices.
- 57:08When we have like one doctor here, one doctor there, and they want to talk about a patient who
- 57:11has to be transferred over, that might take like a long time to give them the stuff from the EHR
- 57:16from one to the other.
- 57:17But you also want to have something like the right to be forgotten
- 57:20like they have in the EU.
- 57:21You want to be able to pull back and, like, disappear
- 57:24and to not be, you know, in the limelight all the time
- 57:28and attacked all the time or whatever it may be.
- 57:31It's hard to balance these things.
- 57:32But what's the technological solution to that, then?
- 57:34I don't know. That's the problem.
- 57:36I don't think there is an actual solution
- 57:38because you can't have the both.
- 57:40They contradict one another.
- 57:42Well, the nearest thing I think you can get to it would be
- 57:45pseudonymous identities.
- 57:48So the data allows to interact.
- 57:51However, there's no such thing as anonymity
- 57:54with data sets that big.
- 57:55It's very easy to work out who's who, isn't it?
- 57:57It's harder than you might think.
- 57:59There was a lot of debate about this a while back
- 58:00with the census gathering.
- 58:02So they adopted methods from something called
- 58:04differential privacy, where they add a little epsilon,
- 58:06a little tiny bit of change to the data
- 58:09to obscure who's who.
- 58:11And the epsilon they added in the ACS was far too large,
- 58:13and it messed up a lot of the data messed up a lot of the relationships between different variables and made a lot of the census data practically unusable for certain analyses There like a way to obscure people so that you can find them or whatever
- 58:25That's to pick a low epsilon, but they pick too high.
- 58:28And that's totally doable.
- 58:29You can actually do that.
- 58:30So do you think we have to relinquish our data then?
- 58:34Do you think that's...
- 58:35Oh, absolutely.
- 58:35I think we should.
- 58:36How are the libertarians going to deal with that one now?
- 58:38I mean, I'm the same.
- 58:39I don't like giving...
- 58:40I'm a private person.
- 58:41I know.
- 58:42And everybody is.
- 58:43But at the end of the day, how do you work if like, so say an authoritarian country like China assembles a massive biobank, like they expand the Kadoori biobank or something like that.
- 58:53They'll have a huge advantage in pharmaceuticals, have a huge advantage of biotech.
- 58:57And if we don't have a comparable biobank or a better biobank or whatever it may be, then we're just going to lag behind.
- 59:02We're going to continue to lose to China.
- 59:06You have to accept at some point that your data is going to be used.
- 59:09In Florida, they have this thing called the Sunshine Genetics Act.
- 59:11It passed last year.
- 59:12It's a wonderful little act.
- 59:13Everybody born in the state is entitled to a whole genome sequence.
- 59:17Huge.
- 59:18But you'll have your data in there for life.
- 59:19Maybe it'll be merged down the line with like your grades and your taxes and your whatever it may be.
- 59:25And we'll learn a lot about people.
- 59:26And we'll be able to benefit people, provide them with like more drugs and stuff.
- 59:31But they will have to give up that privacy.
- 59:34Something will be known.
- 59:35That makes me feel really uncomfortable.
- 59:37I know.
- 59:37Makes everybody uncomfortable.
- 59:39But if you don't have it, you're missing out.
- 59:41There's too much the data can do is the thing.
- 59:46Do you want to live forever?
- 59:48How much is it worth?
- 59:48Is it worth your privacy?
- 59:49It's not losing a lot of privacy is the thing.
- 59:52Having your genetic data, all it does is like right now, it just gives you mediocre high predictions.
- 59:56Like you're not going to learn so much about a guy.
- 59:58You're not going to learn, like be able to model his entire face and figure out all the stuff.
- 1:00:03But you will be able to use that data to find new drugs and vet them and help people.
- 1:00:09i suppose my contention is that that will there won't just be one set of data well there will be
- 1:00:18for you but it will it'll end up being absolutely everything and i just i i just know how easy it is
- 1:00:26to use that stuff in a in a controlling way and i i agree that probably there'll be there'll be
- 1:00:33checks and balances against it there'll be open source counteractive things and you know that's
- 1:00:38why we do need good governance on this. We have to have some actual, you know, culture here. We
- 1:00:42have to, you know, say in our culture, we're not going to let people discriminate on the basis of
- 1:00:46their genetic data. Like for insurers in the U.S., you're not allowed to use that data to adjust
- 1:00:50people's rates. And I think that's good. Why? I mean, if they were allowed to do that, that'd be
- 1:00:55more optimal from an insurer perspective. You'd be getting lower premiums on average, and you'd
- 1:01:00probably lower the premiums in for high risk people at the end of the day. But it would get
- 1:01:05fewer people to opt in. They don't want that to happen. They're afraid of it. So just ban it at
- 1:01:10the moment. But it could be economically worse for them as well, though. It could be. Yes,
- 1:01:15absolutely. For some people, it'll hurt, especially in the interim between now and when we adjust down
- 1:01:19to lower rates, if we ever try and do that, which we totally could do and probably should do to some
- 1:01:24extent. But nobody really cares to do risk stuff. But the problem right now, at least, is that nobody
- 1:01:32trusts institutions politicians that's our problem so how do you change that culture because it's
- 1:01:38almost like i don't even think it's a culture i think it's bad people doing bad things and i think
- 1:01:44probably the only connection with culture is there's an incentive model which pushes bad people
- 1:01:50yeah to the top and is that right or not i think i think it's probably wrong um so in in japan and
- 1:01:58in Sweden. They trust their government a lot. They trust the bureaucrats to get things done.
- 1:02:02There are plenty of bad people in both countries, probably fewer per capita than in the US or in
- 1:02:08Honduras or wherever else you might be. But there are still plenty of bad people and they should
- 1:02:12still throw a wrench in things that people are updating based on the bad people, but they don't.
- 1:02:16They seem to trust their government. In Sweden, they have massive, massive population registers
- 1:02:21where they've tracked every single person. For every male, they have an IQ test result at age 18.
- 1:02:28because they go to the draft and they have to sit an IQ test.
- 1:02:31They have it all.
- 1:02:32And nobody minds.
- 1:02:34I mean, a few people mind, but not very many.
- 1:02:36And it's fine because you do trust the government to not give up your data,
- 1:02:39to not use it in malicious ways.
- 1:02:41They use it for good stuff.
- 1:02:42As I remember as well, because I had a Norwegian girlfriend,
- 1:02:46everyone's name and address is available publicly, right?
- 1:02:51You can look up somebody's tax returns in the previous year in Norway.
- 1:02:53Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 1:02:54When that came around, somebody turned it into a dating service.
- 1:02:56They were like, look up all the, you know, wonderful rich people in your town.
- 1:03:01Six figure.
- 1:03:01Oh, is it eight figures, please?
- 1:03:03Yeah.
- 1:03:04God, I don't know.
- 1:03:06I will need to intellectually work on the idea that I need to give up more and more privacy.
- 1:03:12Because I think it doesn't stop.
- 1:03:15I don't know how it stops when you start.
- 1:03:17Because we've already been on that route before.
- 1:03:19I mean, you look back.
- 1:03:20Look at those places, though.
- 1:03:21Look at Sweden.
- 1:03:21It has stopped.
- 1:03:22I mean, they have a limit.
- 1:03:24And they're probably going to pull it back a little bit.
- 1:03:26they're going to you know increase the privacy uh rather than decrease it they accept it though
- 1:03:30they would probably take decreases but they're not i think there is a culture thing there they
- 1:03:35got to acknowledge do do are there politicians like one thing you notice certainly in the uk
- 1:03:41and i would notice this whenever i see trump speaking is lying is now the modus operandi of
- 1:03:49a politician it doesn't matter it doesn't matter you can and i'm pretty sure tell me what the data
- 1:03:54is on in the 50s and 40s did politicians lie as well constantly through the teeth oh really yes
- 1:04:00you've heard the power broker no oh uh robert moses was a very powerful figure in new york's
- 1:04:06history and he was a great politician he basically made modern new york but he was a huge liar
- 1:04:13uh lyndon baines johnson you know the lbj yeah he was a great politician got lots done he
- 1:04:20accomplished all of his goals. He had lots of like goals that are now portrayed in a different light
- 1:04:25than they actually were for him. Like, for example, he wanted to push along civil rights because he
- 1:04:29wanted to stop blacks from protesting in the US. But he pushed it as like a racial equality thing.
- 1:04:34He was a huge liar. He was known for being a liar. He was also known for being very intimidating.
- 1:04:38One of the things he would do with the Secret Service, he would pee on their legs.
- 1:04:41He would gather them around and pee on their leg. Some people called him Lyndon Big Johnson. He had
- 1:04:46a huge you know thing yes uh and like he would intimidate people by making them take meetings
- 1:04:52with him where he was taking a shit that's a bit psychotic he's a bit psychotic he was psychotic
- 1:04:58but he was a very very effective politician who got his agenda pushed through he really was able
- 1:05:05to get a lot done and a lot of bad things done too like he expanded the government dramatically
- 1:05:10in a lot of negative ways some ways that have generated positive outcomes but i think could
- 1:05:14and manage better whatever but he was a big liar do you think bukele's a liar i don't want to say
- 1:05:21anything on that i don't think he's a liar um no nor do i but but we would assume like bukele's
- 1:05:28seems too good to be true that that's what feels uncomfortable like when you look at him yeah he
- 1:05:34seems he seems amazing he seems like wow this guy even because i'm a bitcoin i knew studied bitcoin
- 1:05:40for 20,000 hours, right?
- 1:05:43And he even says all the right things
- 1:05:44in the Bitcoin world as well.
- 1:05:46And I often judge people on that.
- 1:05:48It's a very easy way to judge someone
- 1:05:50is if they start talking about Bitcoin.
- 1:05:52Because if they tell me something that's bullshit,
- 1:05:53I know they probably didn't study
- 1:05:57a lot of things as well, right?
- 1:05:59And he does.
- 1:06:00He ticks so many of the boxes.
- 1:06:01He's very into it, yeah.
- 1:06:04I don't want to comment too much on that, is it?
- 1:06:06No, fair enough, fair enough.
- 1:06:07I like Bukele.
- 1:06:08Let's be a bit more broader about it then. You know, you're kind of alluding earlier to the fact that many, well, part of being a politician is possibly the propensity to lie.
- 1:06:19Yeah.
- 1:06:20Right. Okay. So how come sometimes you get good leaders then?
- 1:06:27A good leader can be a liar. That's totally fine. They're not contradictory. It doesn't make somebody totally bad. It also doesn't make them a totally bad person too if they use that to accomplish goals that are good.
- 1:06:37It's unfortunate.
- 1:06:38You hate lying.
- 1:06:39In the abstract, it's always bad.
- 1:06:42But in practice, people do use it to get stuff done.
- 1:06:45And that's the essence of being a good leader in some cases,
- 1:06:47such as when you're a general, you want to lie.
- 1:06:49You want to delude people and figure out a way to win a fight
- 1:06:52without having to actually win the fight.
- 1:06:54Is there data on how many leaders are good versus not good?
- 1:07:02Not really.
- 1:07:03It's hard to tell.
- 1:07:04I mean, was Merkel not good?
- 1:07:06It's hard to tell.
- 1:07:06She did lots of little things that were fine.
- 1:07:08but she did also big things that were terrible so how do you weight that not clear uh popularity
- 1:07:13ratings and stuff like that does are they not reliable they're not reliable as a way to track
- 1:07:17how well a politician's actually doing in terms of benefits to the country you do we will end in a
- 1:07:22minute well you do know you seem to know a lot about central america do you come here a lot are
- 1:07:26you is it is it your speciality no i wouldn't say it's my speciality but i do come here fairly often
- 1:07:31and i like uh central america a lot and i'd like to see it advance a lot uh i'm a big fan of getting
- 1:07:36Latin America to be rich, and I think it could be.
- 1:07:38I think it could definitely advance, at least
- 1:07:40to the level of Chile across the whole thing.
- 1:07:42It's
- 1:07:43where Chile is currently. I mean,
- 1:07:46I think Chile, to the extent, if you reformed all of
- 1:07:48Latin America, Chile would still be ahead of much of the rest
- 1:07:50of it, even if you started them on a level playing ground,
- 1:07:52just because the people are different. The human capital is different.
- 1:07:54Argentina should be way further ahead
- 1:07:56than it is, but they had fascist government for
- 1:07:58a very, very long time. The Piranisas are effectively
- 1:08:00fascist. I don't know if you're aware of that.
- 1:08:01but it should be rich everywhere should be rich we should be a lot better off it shouldn't be
- 1:08:09squalor and shanty towns and favelas that just is not needed not necessary it's totally optional
- 1:08:15and they could reform and they should reform before we go just throw your lens on what's
- 1:08:20happening here yeah prosper good points bad points i love what eric's doing here um i love
- 1:08:26that Eric's a very realistic guy.
- 1:08:28Eric Berman is the guy who started ProSera.
- 1:08:31Every discussion I have with him is just very revealing.
- 1:08:33It's like, wow, you've really thought
- 1:08:35about all these issues.
- 1:08:36He like tells me go talk to blah blah blah And I talked to blah blah blah And then I come back and I go and he goes yep I thought you would say exactly that Like I feel disappointed with something I met or like I excited about something I met and he has the exact opinion I like wow
- 1:08:48that's very nice. He's really thought about a lot of these issues that go along, go around here.
- 1:08:52And I think he's a good steward of what's going to happen here. I don't know if,
- 1:08:58how this is going to develop or end up, but I hope it goes well. It's the only place in the
- 1:09:02country where you can bring in investments safely, currently, which is something they need to reform.
- 1:09:08Can you see any flaws in the idea?
- 1:09:13I mean, obviously, the big problem with is politics.
- 1:09:17It has the same libertarian scaling issues as every other libertarian policy idea.
- 1:09:21No libertarian has actually proposed a ZA or anything equivalent to that
- 1:09:25that's actually going to generate the scale that is needed to really take off.
- 1:09:31If you're not focused on generating agglomeration effects,
- 1:09:33how are you going to build the next San Francisco?
- 1:09:36No one's thought of that.
- 1:09:37No one can think of that.
- 1:09:37Wait a minute.
- 1:09:38What's the problem though?
- 1:09:39No agglomeration effects.
- 1:09:41Agglomeration is a huge thing.
- 1:09:42If you can't have people together generating more than they would apart,
- 1:09:47then like what's the point?
- 1:09:52I'm not necessarily with you there.
- 1:09:53I mean, are you saying that because people are going to operate together,
- 1:09:59they're going to work together.
- 1:10:00There's an entrepreneurial spirit.
- 1:10:02How do you mean then?
- 1:10:03So agglomeration effects are very considerable.
- 1:10:07You go to San Francisco, I assume, sometimes.
- 1:10:08I've never.
- 1:10:09No, I haven't, actually.
- 1:10:10You really should go.
- 1:10:12You'll feel it in the air.
- 1:10:13Like, when you're there, you feel motivated to work more.
- 1:10:16When you're in San Francisco, you are, everybody around you is doing something amazing, and
- 1:10:21you've just, it feels like you're going to do more.
- 1:10:23Y Combinator likes their founders to be in San Francisco because there's just something
- 1:10:27in the air.
- 1:10:28And that's what I, you can really feel the agglomeration economy there because everybody
- 1:10:32who's there seems to do more than they would elsewhere.
- 1:10:34You move them there and like they're just suddenly rocketing off.
- 1:10:37They're working at parties now.
- 1:10:39Like their lifestyle changes in the culture is incredible And it enables all this stuff at like a scale that is unimaginable elsewhere How do you generate a San Francisco in Honduras El Salvador in Argentina wherever
- 1:10:52I don't know, but if you can't figure out a glomeration, everyone will stay where it is.
- 1:10:56So, but arguably it would be local talent, would it?
- 1:11:01No, no, no, no. I think it's fairly far flung. It's international.
- 1:11:06It's you want to bring everyone from everywhere.
- 1:11:08Everybody will want to go there to produce things.
- 1:11:11You go to San Francisco when you want to start a company and to make things and to make lives better.
- 1:11:17And it's hard to imagine another city that is as well suited for the task.
- 1:11:22They've just built an agglomeration economy that is incredible.
- 1:11:25And no one knows how to mimic that.
- 1:11:28Or would one answer be to specialize so very specifically on something like what's happening here?
- 1:11:33It could be.
- 1:11:34Very, very new novel things.
- 1:11:36that those people have to come here.
- 1:11:38And then as they scale, then...
- 1:11:40Yeah.
- 1:11:42Yeah, you can make an agglomeration economy
- 1:11:43and like novel gene therapies and antibody therapies
- 1:11:45and neat new small molecule stuff
- 1:11:48that's like very untested and controversial.
- 1:11:51You can do all sorts of stuff like that.
- 1:11:52But eventually those people will also probably
- 1:11:55still want to go to San Francisco.
- 1:11:57Okay.
- 1:11:57So that's the challenge though.
- 1:11:58You're still bullish on Prospero.
- 1:12:00I'm bullish on all these things, yes.
- 1:12:01I'm always an optimist.
- 1:12:02I believe that we can make the world
- 1:12:04a much, much better place
- 1:12:05and that we should make the world a better place.
- 1:12:07We have all the opportunities to, all the ability to.
- 1:12:10And I'm always looking up all the time.
- 1:12:12Even when I get disappointed with like, you know,
- 1:12:14talking to like some countries,
- 1:12:16economic minister here or there,
- 1:12:18or anything like that,
- 1:12:18and they're like lack of plans or they're strange plans.
- 1:12:21Nothing really gets me down
- 1:12:22because I always think they can approve.
- 1:12:25Amen.
- 1:12:26Amen.
- 1:12:26Cremier.
- 1:12:27How do I say it?
- 1:12:28Cremier.
- 1:12:29Cremier.
- 1:12:29I don't even know who Cremier is.
- 1:12:31He's probably a historical figure, right?
- 1:12:33Yeah, he's a historical liberal figure,
- 1:12:34classical liberal figure.
- 1:12:36He is called the Abraham Lincoln of France
- 1:12:37because he ended slavery in the French colonies.
- 1:12:40He passed something wonderful called the Crime du Decree,
- 1:12:42where he provided French citizenship to all the Jews in North Africa so they could escape being persecuted by the Muslims Right You said that a few times haven you Thanks for coming in I super appreciate this and I am actually a different person now
- 1:12:57No, no, I am.
- 1:12:57I am.
- 1:12:58I mean it.
- 1:12:58I mean it.
- 1:13:01You're resonating.
- 1:13:03No, don't bullshit.
- 1:13:04Do you know what I mean?
- 1:13:05Sure, sure.
- 1:13:06No, no, I really appreciate that because it's true.
- 1:13:09Being wishy-washy doesn't achieve anything
- 1:13:11unless you just want to relax.
- 1:13:12and you know but thank you for that and thanks for coming in this is a phenomenal conversation
- 1:13:16thank you yeah all right right you made it to the end of the show so i'm gonna go ahead and assume
- 1:13:26that you got some value out of this episode if you want to help the show please follow or
- 1:13:33subscribe right now it takes only two seconds and it massively helps if you've got another 30 seconds
- 1:13:40Well, leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 1:13:45Honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners find us.
- 1:13:50If you want more, you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on Fountain.fm
- 1:13:57for the price of one coffee for a whole month.
- 1:14:01Or you can support the mission by streaming sats on any of the value for value platforms
- 1:14:06or use the Bitcoin and fiat donation links in the show notes.
- 1:14:10every contribution to the show makes a real difference believe me and one more thing if you
- 1:14:16know someone who'd love this episode share it directly with them that personal share beats
- 1:14:21every algorithm in the book all the links the community and the newsletter are in the show notes
- 1:14:27and jump on over to freecities.fm for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions
- 1:14:35and more that's the new free cities podcast website freecities.fm have a good week and see you next time