Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Munchausen By Proxy (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:07Hey, deserving listeners. Today we're going to talk about Munchausen by proxy or
- 0:11factitious disorder imposed by another. Listeners Jeanette, Salem and Anne all have asked
- 0:19me to talk about this in recent times, and so here we go.
- 0:24This is the Psychology at Seattle podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkanda.
- 0:29I am a therapist and a professor. The reason why I'm talking about this
- 0:34now is not only because listeners Jeanette, Salem and Ann have asked me to
- 0:39talk about it, but a new documentary by HBO called Mommy Dead and Dearest
- 0:44came out I think recently, and I just watched it, and man,
- 0:49this is an amazing documentary. Highly recommend it. I wouldn't be surprised if
- 0:54this one the oscar come, you know, February or whatever the oscars are
- 0:59next year. It's well made, it's compelling stuff. It illuminates something that
- 1:08happens sometimes and we need to know more about it. Also kind of points
- 1:12to our medical system in terms of some flaws there. So not only am
- 1:18I I talk about not only am I going to talk about munchasm by proxy
- 1:22or factitious disorder imposed by another, but I'm also going to be talking in
- 1:25detail about this documentary. I recommend that before you listen to this episode,
- 1:30you go out and watch this on HBO. If you have HBO, you
- 1:34can watch it on demand. Mommy Dead and Dearest, excellent documentary. All
- 1:40right, so let's talk about munchasm by proxy. The name has changed over
- 1:45the years, and in other countries it's referred to by something else, you
- 1:49know, multiple personality disort. People still call it multiple personality disorder, but
- 1:55it is formally known as the associative identity disorder. Also manics. People still
- 2:00refer to manic depression, but its technical name is bipolar. And it's similar
- 2:06to Munchausen by proxy. A lot of people still refer to it as Munchausen
- 2:09by proxy, but its technical name is factus factitious disorder imposed by another.
- 2:16It has two different kinds. You have you have factitious disorder imposed by another
- 2:22or factitious disorder imposed on the self. In the past, you had met
- 2:27Munchausen by proxy or Munchausen or just Munchausen. Basically, in a nutshell,
- 2:32Munchausen by proxy is when you fake or induce an illness in a child or
- 2:39someone that you're taking care of. And the motivation is often to get sympathy,
- 2:45attention, or care, or some other kind of social benefit. It
- 2:51could also be for just fraud, you know, getting money in that kind
- 2:53of thing, but usually it's it's to get sympathy, because there are easier
- 2:57ways to make money if you're trying to make a quick that this is not
- 3:00an easy way to make money. It's also different from malingering, which some
- 3:07people might say, well, isn't that malingering, and it's a bit of
- 3:10a tough line to draw. But the usually malingering we call something malingering when
- 3:20you are acting sick or mentally ill for personal gain. Like a classic example
- 3:25is someone commits a murder or something and they want to get out of responsibility
- 3:32for the crime by acting as though they have schizophrenia and they were not on
- 3:38their meds or something, and therefore they can claim that they were not saying
- 3:44at the time of the crime and get out of a certain kind of sentence.
- 3:49And so they will malinger by acting as though they have schizophrenia when in
- 3:53fact they don't have schizophrenia. So that's an example of maling ring. Now,
- 4:00factitious disorder, uh, infectitious, you know, effecticous disorder imposed by
- 4:06another. They don't have obvious rewards, is the way that it's defined.
- 4:13So malingering has obvious rewards. There's a there's a very obvious reason as to
- 4:19why someone would malinger or fake an illness or a mental illness with factitious disorder,
- 4:27in fact, factitious disorder posed by another. It's not always clear what
- 4:30the person is getting out of it. There often are gains, but they're
- 4:34not they're not like a super immediate if that makes any sense. So,
- 4:43but honestly, it's it's hard to differentiate between malingering and factitious disorder and so,
- 4:49and I'll get more into that in a second here. In fact,
- 4:53I'm gonna talk about right now because I'm looking at my notes, and that's
- 4:55what I'm going to talk about. Not all the experts agree that it's a
- 5:00legitimate mental illness, because it all comes down to whether or not you think
- 5:06or whether or not the research demonstrates that people are doing this because they can't
- 5:14help it or not. For instance, let's say that these people, you
- 5:21know, parents who fake illnesses in their children are doing it because they want
- 5:27to get sympathy and they want people to feel sorry for them and they want
- 5:32people to give them money, you know and charity and stuff. Well that
- 5:40is you know, a straight up crime, right, And but why do
- 5:46we have to label that as a mental disorder? If someone was stealing money,
- 5:51you know, someone's working at the burger king and they're taking money out
- 5:57of the register because they want, you know, money, or a better
- 6:03example would be someone someone accidentally crashes their car and when they get home and
- 6:14their parents are saying, like, how did the car get crashed? And
- 6:17the teenager is like, well, someone hit me. I was just sitting
- 6:20at a stoplight and someone just hit me and then they ran off and it
- 6:24was you know, a hit and run. Well, that teenager is lying
- 6:27straight up to their parents for a personal gain, right, They're trying to
- 6:30get out of that personal responsibility, or they're trying to get insurance or whatever.
- 6:35They're lying to get something out of out of other people. Well,
- 6:40we don't call that a mental disorder. We just call that lying. We
- 6:43just call that manipulation. We call that fraud or whatever we call it.
- 6:46So when someone fakes illnesses in their own children to get something out of society,
- 6:53why do we have to call that a mental disorder, Why don't we
- 6:55just call it illegal behavior or bad behavior or child you know. Another example
- 7:00is if a parent is is physically abusing their children when you know, they
- 7:06get angry sometimes and they physically beat their child. As defined by the law,
- 7:12that person doesn't necessarily suffer from mental disorder, and we don't have to
- 7:15apply a mental disorder to that child abuse perpetrator. We just say that person
- 7:20is committing child abuse. So in this situation, when you have a parent
- 7:25who is faking illnesses in their child, why are we calling a disorder?
- 7:30Why don't we just call it illegal or child abuse or something like that.
- 7:35Well, So the controversy is some people believe that people who do this they're
- 7:42not exactly in control of their behavior and it's a compulsion similar to anorexia or
- 7:47something, and therefore worthy of mental illness status. But there's just not a
- 7:54lot of research out there, and it's been debated over the years, and
- 7:58it's hard to differentiate between someone who is doing it compulsively or as motivated by
- 8:03what we might consider to be a mental illness, or someone who's just doing
- 8:07it because they're just not a nice person. You know. It's also controversial
- 8:13because sometimes there are cases in which the legal system tries to figure out whether
- 8:20or not someone is guilty of killing their children or not. And I'll get
- 8:24more into some of the famous cases. Essentially, there are cases in which
- 8:28children will die mysteriously and there people will come out and say, well,
- 8:33obviously this this mother has Munchausen bi proxy or factitious disorder imposed by another.
- 8:43And the facticious disorder imposed by another, by the way, is just a
- 8:46terrible name. It's it's it's basically your I don't know, it's it's like,
- 8:52it's a very weird name. Now, Munchausen by proxy has got to
- 8:56be the weirdest name ever, because you know, if you just said munchaus
- 9:00and by proxy to someone, they'd say, like, what language are you
- 9:03speaking? Or is that a movie? Or it sounds like a matrix movie.
- 9:07Munchausen biproxy you know. So, but factitious disorder imposed by another,
- 9:13I don't know. It just it's funny. Personally, I guess I would
- 9:16rather be phrased factitious disorder imposed onto another I don't know anyway, because it
- 9:24sort of implies that it's anyway, let's move forward here. So basically,
- 9:30there would be these cases where children would die mysteriously and the mother would be
- 9:37accused of having Munchausen by proxy and therefore accused of murdering the children, and
- 9:43then later on there's evidence that comes out that the mother had nothing to do
- 9:46with the disorder or nothing to do with the death of the children, and
- 9:50it was, you know, was an accident or some mysterious illness or something,
- 9:54and vice versa. There will be children who die mysteriously, no one
- 10:00cares them. Later on they're like, wait, you know, Munchausen biproxy.
- 10:03And so there's just a lot of over the years, in legal battles
- 10:07and in the media, there's just been a lot of and among clinicians,
- 10:11there's just been researchers. There's just been a lot of controversy around whether or
- 10:16not this thing actually exists or if it's how we understand it. So anyway,
- 10:24the first thing I'll say is that it's very rare. It's it's a
- 10:28very uh you know, according to research and according to just anecdotal evidence,
- 10:33it's a it's a very rare condition for someone to suffer from. It's a
- 10:39very rare thing for people to do. But it's hard to study the prevalence
- 10:43rates because people don't admit that they're doing it, right, So there could
- 10:46be millions of people around the world who are doing these kinds of things,
- 10:52and if they're if they're really good at manipulating people, we'll just never know
- 10:56that they have it. But honestly, in my experience, it's pretty easy
- 10:58to TechEd it because people with Bunchausen by proxy end up dragging their children to
- 11:05so many doctors, and it's and it and it's so compulsive and it's so
- 11:11over the top that eventually one of the clinicians will start raising the question.
- 11:16And then once that question is raised and people start working together, it usually
- 11:22can be triangulated, so to speak. But having said that, a lot
- 11:28of people, including in this documentary that that I'll talk about, can manipulate
- 11:33the medical system pretty easily because of the way the medical system is, you
- 11:37know, set up, and the way they the way their culture is,
- 11:39which I'll get more into you later. So so it's hard to study,
- 11:45but it appears to be one of the more rare disorders in the DSM,
- 11:50meaning that you know, the prevalence rates among the normal population might be you
- 11:56know, less than zero point one percent or something extremely rare. Studies have
- 12:01shown that out of the people who are in hospitals or you know, people
- 12:07who are in hospitals that have parents that are dragging their kids into the hospital,
- 12:11it seems that maybe about one percent of the patients have munchausends or infectitious
- 12:18disorder involved. Either they are the ones who infecticious disorder and they're faking their
- 12:24own illnesses, or they're you know, people who are being cared for by
- 12:28people infecticious disorder. So so you know about one percent. So it's pretty
- 12:33rare if you're just doing a wide swath of patients in a random hospital.
- 12:37But when you think that there are you know, tens of thousands of patients
- 12:43in hospitals in a particular region, you know, it's a sizable number that
- 12:48are likely involved in fecticious disorder. Okay, so again just to be clear
- 12:56about what it is, it's when a caregiver deliverately exaggerates or fabricates or induces
- 13:03health problems in someone that they are caring for. So a caregiver, which
- 13:09could be a parent, or doesn't have to be a parent, but just
- 13:11a caregiver who deliberately, on purpose exaggerates health problems or fabricates health problems or
- 13:18induces health problems in someone that they're caring for. And this victim can be
- 13:24a child, it could be a dependent adult like an older adult who is
- 13:28dependent on someone else, or it even could be a pet. There's not
- 13:33a lot of research on that, but there is talk about that it could
- 13:39be done on a pet, which just you know, really breaks your heart
- 13:41right and incidentally, it can result in the death of the person being cared
- 13:46for. Literature suggests that an increase in physician awareness of this disorder can prevent
- 13:54or reduce its morbidity and mortality, meaning it's voce and it's death rate.
- 14:01So we really need to be educating people about it. And that's part of
- 14:03the reason why I want to do this episode is because I want I want
- 14:07more people to know about this. And I think that the documentary Mommy Dead
- 14:11and Dearest, that's also kind of a weird Mommy Dead and Dearest have a
- 14:16weird title. But anyway, this documentary will absolutely raise the awareness because it's
- 14:20such a compelling documentary. I wish it was on Netflix or YouTube or something,
- 14:24because not a lot of people have HBO. But anyway, in the
- 14:28literature the symptoms are classified into four main groups. They have people who poison,
- 14:35they have people who bleed, and they have people who will start infections.
- 14:39And there are people who injure, and so factitious sort of can either
- 14:43be done on the cell or on someone else. And so people will poison
- 14:48themselves or poison another person. They will cause bleeding in themselves or another person,
- 14:52they'll cause infections in themselves or another person, or they will injure themselves
- 14:56or another person. The most frequently reported problems for biproxy for the person being
- 15:07taken care of, So when someone with munch as and biproxy, when they
- 15:13drag their the person that they're caring for into the hospital or when they call
- 15:16nine to one to one or call the physician, here are the things that
- 15:18they will say that the person they're caring for has. The most common is
- 15:24apnea, which is interesting mostly because it's usually a child and it's usually the
- 15:30mother, so it's usually like a young child, like three to four years
- 15:35old, and so apnea is for whatever reason, one of the things,
- 15:39and that's one of the things that's in the documentary. Apnea was the first
- 15:43thing that the mother came to, which is interesting because I imagine that people
- 15:48with munch as and biproxy they don't get together and say, okay, let's
- 15:52all do this one. There's probably not websites that say, like, here's
- 15:56how you trick your physician. It's just interesting to see what sort of symptoms
- 16:00emerge in a culture, you know, regarding just you know, what's popular.
- 16:07It's it's akin to like what are popular baby names and how that changes
- 16:12over time. It's just interesting to see what emerges in the culture. But
- 16:15anyway, apneas the most frequent symptom that's reported by the caregiver. Second is
- 16:22anorexia or feeding problems. Third is diarrhea in the in the child for as
- 16:29seizures. Five is blue skin. Blue skin meaning that the child isn't getting
- 16:34enough oxygen. Next is behavioral problems, which I have a hard time understanding
- 16:40what that means exactly. Behavioral problems anyway, moving on asthma, allergies and
- 16:45fevers, and lesser reported symptoms of the person they're caring for is failure to
- 16:52thrive, which is a you know, an infant thing, vomiting, bleeding,
- 16:57rash, and infections. So again just to raise awareness if you have
- 17:03patients who are talking about the following mixture of things. It's a yellow flag.
- 17:11So apnea, feeding problems, diarrhea, seizures, blueskin, asthma,
- 17:17allergies, fevers, vomiting, failure to thrive, bleeding, rash, and
- 17:21infections. The reason why these ones are the most common is in theory because
- 17:30they're easy to fake. It's hard to fake a you know, it's hard
- 17:34to fake cancer, for instance. Right, you can't say my kid has
- 17:38cancer and then they do testing they're like, no, your kid does not
- 17:41have cancer. But it's easy to fake diarrhea for instance, right, because
- 17:48if you're taking care of your two year old child and your child, you
- 17:52can call the doctor and say, say, my child has had diarrhea for
- 17:56the past ten days, and there's the Usually doctors will just believe that,
- 18:03right, So you can just fake that, Or you can call your doctor
- 18:06and say, my child's blue skin, or my child as a seizure.
- 18:11My child, that's something that seemed like a seizure or something. It's easy
- 18:15to fake that because there's no way for the doctor to run a test to
- 18:21make sure that you're telling the truth. Apnea, these allergies, fevers is
- 18:27you know, fever would be really easy, right, You just you call
- 18:30the physician. You say, my child has had a temperature of one hundred
- 18:34and six for the past ten hours. What should I do? You know,
- 18:40physicist says, oh, my god, bring the child to the er.
- 18:41And then you come to the r and you tell them what you've been
- 18:45seeing, and and you know they're gonna they're gonna jump to attention on that,
- 18:49and because what's the chance that the parent is lying? Right? So,
- 18:55but some are. And that's how these people get away with it is
- 18:57it's such a rare thing for a parent to be this dis abusive and disabusive
- 19:06in this way. All right, So let's talk about the usual presentation of
- 19:10munch asm bi proxy or factitious disorder, factitious disorder imposed by another. That's
- 19:18the DSM five. Okay, So common presentations. Studies show that the perpetrator
- 19:26is more commonly female and generally is the mother of the victim. Men have
- 19:33been perpetrators, according to research about seven percent of the time. So out
- 19:38of everyone who commits much as by proxy, seven percent of them are men
- 19:44and ninety three percent are women. And generally it's the mother of the child
- 19:51the victims that children are usually under the age of five, so that's important.
- 19:56I think the average was like four years old or three or something.
- 20:00Characteristics of the perpetrator. They are often self sacrificing, you know, they're
- 20:07like a martyr. You know. They will say I've been staying up all
- 20:10night with my child, or I'll sleep in the hospital with my child.
- 20:14They will appear very devoted to their children. They are also highly supportive of
- 20:22the physicians, so they might be very nice and complimentary to the physician,
- 20:29which is actually another kind of red flag. If you're a physician out there,
- 20:32if you have a a parent of a child and they are being extremely
- 20:37complimentary to you, it's it's a it's a yellow flag for this sort of
- 20:42thing. Not to say that parents should never compliment their their you know,
- 20:48children's physicians, but it's just a yellow flag, you know. And usually
- 20:52physicians who have enough experience will know the difference. They'll they'll know the difference
- 20:56between someone who's being normally complimentary and someone who's being overly complimentary. There are
- 21:03other things that could be besides Munchausen by proxy. They could just be anxious,
- 21:07or they could have a personality disorder. But anyway, other characteristics of
- 21:12the perpetrator is they are very knowledgeable about medical things, and they are also
- 21:18very fascinated with medical things. For obvious reasons. They often will interfere with
- 21:25treatment. They will sort of get there, you know, they'll butt in
- 21:29into treatment and sort of get in the way of things. Sometimes they are
- 21:34extremely open to very invasive behaviors. If I was a physician and I had
- 21:41and I you know, had a question mark about whether or not I had
- 21:45a parent who had Munchausen by proxy, I would suggest a very invasive procedure
- 21:52and just see what the reaction would be from the parent, because you know,
- 21:56the vast majority if you say, well, well, you know,
- 22:00I think there's about a three percent chance that if we do open heart surgery
- 22:07that that might help. You know, if you say something like that and
- 22:11if you have you know, most people be like, what open heart surgery?
- 22:15No, like three percent chance of that working. No, that's that's
- 22:18you know, it's not worth it. Open heart surgery. That's terrible.
- 22:22Whether or it's true open art surgery is bad or not. Most people,
- 22:26I would surmise, would be pretty scared of that. You know, if
- 22:29it's your two three year old child, but a parent who as much as
- 22:33in by proxy will be like, We'll be gleeful about it. They'll be
- 22:36like, oh, tell me more. Yeah, I think that's a good
- 22:38let's do that. I think it's a good option. Now, you know,
- 22:40I'm generalizing here, but it's one way you can maybe as a litmus
- 22:45test. People who are perpetrators often appear to be very calm in the face
- 22:52of serious difficulties in their child's medical situation. So again, most if you
- 23:00if you said something like I think your child has a heart condition that is
- 23:07potentially life threatening, most parents will just faint right there in your office.
- 23:12Right. They're just they're not going to take it well, They're going to
- 23:15be very upset. They're going to have a wide variety of emotional reactions.
- 23:21And however, if you have Munchausen by proxy, then you'll you'll appear very
- 23:26calm. You'll just be like, huh, okay, well tell me more.
- 23:29Because the munch as and biproxy person, this is this is music to
- 23:33their ears. It's not terrifying at all to them. Really, this is
- 23:38why they're there is for that kind of thing. It's what they're thinking is,
- 23:42well, if my child has a heart condition. Then then I will
- 23:47get even more benefits from you know, all this all this mascinations. You
- 23:52know. Anyway, it's also another characteristic. Other perpetrator is someone who enjoys
- 23:57the hospital, because most people don't enjoy the hospital. I'm one of those
- 24:03people. I walk into a hospital, particularly like particular wings of a hospital,
- 24:07I'm just like, yesh, get me out of here. Well,
- 24:10someone with munch asen by proxy or munch asen for that matter, infectious disorder,
- 24:15they will be very comfortable at a hospital and it won't freak them out
- 24:18because that's where they get all the good stuff. Okay. Another usual presentation
- 24:26detail is the caregiver usually manipulate, manipulates the situation to make them look like
- 24:30the best caregiver in the world. You know, look at that mother.
- 24:33She loves her daughter so much, she's so brave. Is kind of the
- 24:38thing. So they usually manipulate everyone around them to see them in that way.
- 24:45And in the documentary you definitely see that. As I'll talk about in
- 24:48a second. What are the causes of infectitious disorder imposed on another or munch
- 24:56asm by proxy. Well, it's hard to say, because it's hard to
- 25:00nail us down, and many people don't even think it's an actual disorder,
- 25:04but there seems to be an association with the obvious things like child abuse from
- 25:11their own caregivers, or emotional neglect, or specifically growing up in a family
- 25:17that only gave you attention if you were sick or if you were taking care
- 25:21of someone who was sick. So if you're a young girl and your family
- 25:26is falling apart and your father abandons you, and your mother is extremely depressed,
- 25:37We're talking like off the charts depressed, and your siblings are just sort
- 25:42of staying away from the house, and you're left alone and no one is
- 25:45paying attention to you, and you're scared and you're alone, and you don't
- 25:49know what else, what else to do. And over time you learn that
- 25:55when you take care of your mother, that people give you love and a
- 25:59little bit to love and attention. You know, the father comes back around
- 26:03every once in a while and says, oh, I'm it's so great that
- 26:06you're taking care of of your mom. So that's one element. Another element
- 26:11is when you make it known that your mother is is in dire straits then
- 26:19and people come running. Then you solidify that behavior in your brain. So,
- 26:29for instance, if you are you know, you just kind of look
- 26:33at your mom. You're saying, well, you know, she's depressed and
- 26:34she's in bed all day. She I don't think she's going to try to
- 26:38kill herself. But the last time she was suicidal and I told everyone,
- 26:45everyone came running because everyone didn't want her to die. So I wonder what
- 26:48would happen if I told everyone that she told me that she was going to
- 26:52kill herself even though she didn't. And I wonder if everyone will come running.
- 26:59And let's say, you know, this young girl does that, and
- 27:03you know, she calls the authorities, and she calls her biological father,
- 27:07and she calls her aunts and uncles, and she says, Mommy said that
- 27:11she's going to kill herself, and I don't know what to do, and
- 27:14then everyone comes running. Well, what do you think that teaches that child?
- 27:19What it teaches them is the only way they can gain love and attention
- 27:23is if they are taking care of someone who is in grave danger. And
- 27:30so the grandparents and the nine one one people, and the biological father they
- 27:36come running and they say to her, you're doing such a great job.
- 27:40If you hadn't told us that your mom was going to kill herself. She
- 27:44might be dead right now. You're such a brave little girl, You're so
- 27:48good, so you're getting all of that attention, and you learn that the
- 27:52only way that anyone will love you, because deep down you believe you're not
- 27:56lovable, the only way anyone will love you is if you have some one
- 28:00in your life who is ill and who needs to be taken care of,
- 28:04and you are that brave person taking care of them. Well, you grow
- 28:08up and you try to find people to take care of, and if you
- 28:15have problems getting a job in a legitimate way, taking care of people one
- 28:21of the easy routes to and if you have psychopathic tendencies as a result of
- 28:26neglect, then all you need to do is have a child, which is
- 28:30a process, obviously, but it's not a hard you know, you don't
- 28:36have to pass a licensing exam to have kids, And so you get pregnant
- 28:41and you have a kid, and then all you have to do is just
- 28:45lie and say that your child has symptoms. And suddenly you're in the sweet
- 28:48place where you're taking care of someoney needs help, and everyone is running to
- 28:52you and paying attention to you, and you're getting all that love and attention
- 28:57that you don't think you can get other ones. That's the key thing is
- 29:02that people with Bunchausen by proxy have both psychopathic tendencies in that they don't have
- 29:07empathy for other people obviously, and they don't believe that they will get any
- 29:12attention through legitimate means because of the way they were raised. Okay, so
- 29:18I want to talk about famous cases. But before we do that, let's
- 29:22take a break. Okay, we're back from the break. A couple of
- 29:30little things you can do if you like the podcast. You can join the
- 29:33Facebook fangroup. We have two different Facebook pages, but once the fangroup,
- 29:37and that one is not run by me. It's run by a famous patron,
- 29:41Lindon. More people are starting to participate on the fangroup fun stuff.
- 29:45People are posting stuff kind of fun. Also, become a patron of the
- 29:49podcast Do that go to patreon dot com. When you become a patron of
- 29:52the podcast, you get access to all of our premium episodes. We have
- 29:56hundreds of them in which we do deep dives on all sorts of stuff.
- 30:00So become a patron of the podcast do it now. Also if you become
- 30:03a twenty dollars patron, you'll get one of our awesome mugs. And I
- 30:07have to say these, these Psychology and Seattle mugs are the best ever.
- 30:11They have the best handle, they're the best shape. I narcissistically use my
- 30:18Psychology and Seattle mug every day. Every morning, I get up and I
- 30:22pour myself a coffee coffee. The one day I don't use the cup is
- 30:26when I have clients. I have a home office, and when I when
- 30:30my clients and supervise ees and supervisors of superviss are coming to my office,
- 30:34I don't want to be seen walking around with a mug that has my face
- 30:38on it, So I use a different mug. But every once in a
- 30:44while I forget and I and I'm talking to a client. I look over
- 30:47at my table and I'm like, oh my god, my Psychology and Seattle
- 30:49mug is there with with pictures of my face and Embardo's face, and this
- 30:53is this is embarrassing. Anyway, It's a great mug for coffee, and
- 31:00and it you know, has very different pictures and different things on there.
- 31:03It's it's a collage, if you will, So, Okay, famous cases,
- 31:08this is all from Wikipedia. By the way, Lisa Hayden Johnson was
- 31:14jailed for three years after subjecting her son to a total of three hundred and
- 31:18twenty five medical actions, including being confined to a wheelchair and being fed through
- 31:25a tube in his stomach. This is very weird because in the documentary this
- 31:30is exactly the same thing that d D did to Gypsy, which we'll get
- 31:37into more in a second, but confining a child to a wheelchair and then
- 31:41making the child get a a tube into the stomach that goes through the abdomen.
- 31:48You know, it's a tube that goes directly into your stomach, you
- 31:51know, through your through your belly, right, and you know that was
- 31:56one of the three hundred and twenty five medical actions that Lisa Sayt Johnson did
- 32:01to her child, and she was jailed for three years. Convicted. She
- 32:06claimed her son suffered from a long list of illnesses, including diabetes, food
- 32:09allergies, cerebral palsy, and cystic fibrosis. She received numerous cash donations and
- 32:15charity gifts, including two cruises. Another famous case from Wikipedia twenty fourteen,
- 32:22Lacey Spears was charged with second degree depraved murder, second degree depraved murder,
- 32:29second degree depraved. That must not be an American, doesn't sound American depraved
- 32:34murder, second degree to prave murder, and first degree manslaughter. She allegedly
- 32:39fed her son dangerous amounts of salt after she conducted research on the internet about
- 32:45its effects. Her actions were allegedly motivated by the social media attention she gained
- 32:51on Facebook and Twitter. She was sentenced to twenty years to life in prison.
- 32:58So because she was getting attention on Facebook and Twitter, she decided to
- 33:02poison her son with salt, and her child ended up dying, and then
- 33:07she is sentenced to twenty years of life in prison. Okay, So the
- 33:14documentary Mommy Dead and Dearest, I just watch it. It's a great documentary,
- 33:21very effective, very creepy, but not sensational though. It's one of
- 33:24the least sensational documentaries I've seen in a while, because, you know,
- 33:30one of the ways you make a documentary entertaining is to make it very sensational
- 33:34with lots of you know, dum dump, you know, all these kinds
- 33:37of bells and whistles to make things look more ominous than they actually are.
- 33:40But the director, Aaron Lee Carr, she just kind of kept it to
- 33:46the facts, and she just showed you the interviews, and she just showed
- 33:52you what was actually happening. Because the story is so compelling anyway, it
- 33:57doesn't need any bells and whistles. It's so creepy be anyway, it doesn't
- 34:01need to be creepified at all. Okay, So the two main people here
- 34:07are d D who is the mother name is Dede. Her real name was
- 34:12something else, but I'm just gonna refer to as Dede and her daughter,
- 34:15Gypsy Rose. So we have d D and Gypsy Rose. The daughter DEDI
- 34:21is the one who has munch asen by proxy or factitious disorder induced on another.
- 34:29Wait, what in factitious disorder imposed on another? Such a weird name,
- 34:32But I'm just going to call it munch asm by proxy because it's easier
- 34:36to say. So. D D has munchasm by proxy. And in interviews
- 34:42with DD's father and stepmother and nephew, they all reveal the following things about
- 34:50d D. D D is from the Bayou and Louisiana and everyone has I
- 34:58think what they call some sort of buy you accent, Cajun accent of some
- 35:01kind. Anyway, people in her family said that she always got her way
- 35:07and that she would make people pay if she didn't get what she wanted,
- 35:09even when she was a young young kid, So from an early age,
- 35:13she always had some kind of psychopathic tendency. She took out credit cards in
- 35:17her family members' names, she wrote bad checks. She committed a lot of
- 35:22crimes in this way, in terms of money crimes, you know, fraud
- 35:25crimes. She also there were there was there was talk that she had been
- 35:31poisoning her stepmother. I think maybe her mother, I can't remember. I
- 35:37think maybe was his stepmother. Anyway, she was poisoning someone in our family
- 35:42with roundup, you know the roundup that you put in plants. And the
- 35:47woman was left bedridden for nine months because of this poisoning. And the family
- 35:53members said she always got away with these things. She never got she never
- 35:58was really caught. They also said that her mother, her biological mother,
- 36:02was like DDI. So her biological mother has since passed away. But the
- 36:08family was saying that Dede's mother was a shoplifter and she would steal people's clothes
- 36:14from the laundromat, she stole money from family, and she probably did other
- 36:17sorts of things and so this is probably a case in which we have both
- 36:23a biological component for psychopathy and an environmental component, meaning that d D was
- 36:30raised by a psychopathic mother and learned how that psychopathy was the way to get
- 36:37things done. You know, when you are not given empathy. When I
- 36:45mean by psychopathic, the main characteristic I'm talking about here is lack of empathy.
- 36:49And so if you don't have empathy for other human beings and you are
- 36:53raising a child, then your child will not get the proper attachment needs met
- 36:59that will build the neurological building blocks for you to have empathy for other people,
- 37:05and the cycle just continues. So it's it's environmental for sure, but
- 37:08it also might have a biological component in that some people might be biologically predisposed
- 37:14to a lack of empathy. It's hard to tease those out all the time.
- 37:17You need twin studies and adoption studies. But anyway, so Dede's mother
- 37:23had issues with crime and with psychopathy and antisocial behavior. Also, the family
- 37:32was looking back and saying that DEDI might have even killed her own mother by
- 37:38starving her, which is so I'm going to spoil the documentary again. You
- 37:43really just have to watch the documentary. But even if the document even if
- 37:47I do spoil it, I'm guessing it's it's not going to ruin it because
- 37:51that the documentary is just so interesting. Plus the things I'm about to tell
- 37:54you, I think they reveal in the very first scene of the documentary.
- 37:58So gipsy. So we have we have d D Dede's mother, who was
- 38:02a shoplifter and would steal money from family and this sort of thing. Then
- 38:06we have Dedi, who had who obviously had Munchausen by proxy and also would
- 38:12uh you know, was had fraud tendencies like her mother. But then Dedi
- 38:17had a child, Gypsy Rose, this this girl, and she would fake
- 38:23a lot of illnesses in Gypsy Rose. Well, Dedi, uh what might
- 38:30have killed her own mother by starving her mother, maybe because Dede had a
- 38:36bone to pick with her mother, because her mother might have abused her unknown
- 38:38but it seems likely that Dede's mother was not the best. And then in
- 38:45a if that's true, then how poetic or you know, darkly poetic it
- 38:51is that Gypsy Rose Dede's daughter ends up killing her as well. So we
- 38:55have like two generations of killing your mother's essentially, which is fascinating. Also
- 39:04in the interviews in the documentary with the family members, they they think that
- 39:08she got what she deserved. You know, they're saying, so, you
- 39:13know, Dedi was killed by her daughter's boyfriend at the behest of her daughter.
- 39:20Basically, her daughter killed her, and so you know, what do
- 39:23you think about that? And they asked this question to Dede's father. They
- 39:28asked Dede's father, do you think your daughter got what she deserved by being
- 39:32murdered by your granddaughter? And he's like, yep, got what got what
- 39:38she deserved. And then they're talking about how d D's ashes was sent with.
- 39:45People were trying to send Dede's ashes around and no one wanted it,
- 39:49and people were saying, I just flush it down the toilet and stuff.
- 39:52Now, when you watch it, it seems really just you know, mean,
- 39:58because even though Dedi is a legitimate monster, I mean, once I
- 40:02tell you everything that d D did, you're just like, well, I
- 40:06could see how the family wouldn't necessarily be all too caring about the fact that
- 40:12Dedi was murdered. So when you're watching it, you're like, well,
- 40:17jeez, they're being pretty harsh, So it can mean a couple of things.
- 40:22It could mean one that d D was such a monster. And if
- 40:25you've ever lived with one of these kinds of people, even for a short
- 40:30amount of time, you understand that your hatred for these kinds of people can
- 40:36run very deep, and the lack of compassion that you can have for these
- 40:38people can be very pronounced. So it could be just a result so that
- 40:45the family members sort of callousness could just be a result of that, or
- 40:51it could be an indication that many people in this family lack empathy for other
- 40:54people and all of that played a role in DD's development. Hard to tell,
- 41:00but anyway, Okay, So the other character, not character, but
- 41:05you know, human being that is in this documentary is Gypsy Rose. So
- 41:09I'm just going to give you the veryous different medical claims that Dedi had Gypsy
- 41:15Rose's mother about Gypsy Rose from a very early age, at the age of
- 41:21six months. When Gypsy Rose was just six months old, Dedi was already
- 41:27making stuff up sleep apnea. Again, remember from the most that's the most
- 41:31common Munchausen by proxy claim is my child as apnea. And she even got
- 41:40the three year old on a breathing machine of some sort, which is crazy.
- 41:46And she ended up having this breathing machine this you know, I don't
- 41:51know what you call those things. Would you call those things respirator kind of
- 41:53things that you wear while you're sleeping. Gypsy Rose had to sleep with that
- 41:59thing on for years and years, like into her childhood, you know,
- 42:02and too her teenagers. Other medical claims, I'm just going to rattle them
- 42:07off. Problem with her eyes, you know, my daughter has problems that
- 42:10she can't see. My daughter has problems with her hearing. My daughter has
- 42:15problems with in her GI system, she has GI reflex. Now remember there,
- 42:22none of these things are likely to actually have been happening, So so
- 42:28just keep that in mind that she not only made these claims, but she
- 42:32got treatment for all these things GI reflux, anemia, anemia, It's like,
- 42:39okay, hypoventilation, allergies, incontinence, lung disease, heart murmur,
- 42:47she multiple sclerosis to the point where she confined her daughter to a wheelchair.
- 42:53And I say confined her daughter because her daughter could walk and knew she could
- 42:58walk, but she basicly abused her daughter into faking like she couldn't walk and
- 43:04she was in a wheelchair. For a long time, you know, because
- 43:07there's nothing more obviously my you knows, there's nothing more obvious as a signal
- 43:13that my child has problems than having a child in a wheelchair, right,
- 43:16Because if your child has you know, acid reflux, you can't wear that
- 43:21around like a badge. But if your child can't walk and he's a wheelchair,
- 43:25then you put your child on a wheelchair and suddenly everyone is looking at
- 43:29you as the mother of like, oh, you're so brave. Right,
- 43:31So now this isn't to just count actual bravery and courage and dedication that actual
- 43:40mothers have for actual kids who have actual disabilities and medical problems. So I
- 43:45just want to be clear about that. But these people like DD with bunch
- 43:51as by proxy, they prey on that cultural attention that we give people.
- 44:00Also claimed that her daughter was developmentally disabled, even though she was not.
- 44:06She claimed that her daughter had a chromosome disorder that was causing all sorts of
- 44:08problems. She claimed her daughter had leukemia. She made it so that her
- 44:14daughter needed to be fed through a tube in her so they every six months
- 44:19they had to renew this this tube that went through her stomach into her into
- 44:25her gut and h Just think about that. You know, you're this child
- 44:32with this unnecessary tube running through your abdomen into your stomach. It's just terrible.
- 44:39She claimed that her daughter had asthma epilepsy. She claimed that her daughter's
- 44:45legs were paralyzed. She even had several different dates of birth, to the
- 44:51point where Gypsy Rose didn't even know how old she was, because if she
- 44:58kept Gypsy young than one, that would make Gypsy more dependent. But it
- 45:01also kept doctors paying more attention to her, because the younger your child,
- 45:07presumably the more attention you get when your child is suffering in some way.
- 45:12They showed a picture in the documentary of this closet that was full of medications.
- 45:16I mean, one whole closet just full of Gypsy's medications. It's crazy.
- 45:23Also because of the feeding tube. She talks about this in the documentary.
- 45:27Gypsy says that she didn't even have to be awake for her mom to
- 45:30put whatever she wanted to into her body. So Gypsy might be asleep and
- 45:36her mother would just you know, put stuff into her stomach, including you
- 45:39know, all sorts of medication and possibly even poisonous. Right to make it
- 45:45so that Gypsy would have more symptoms that would cause more medical concerns. Right,
- 45:51And also looking back, it seems that when you look at the medical
- 45:54records, it seems that all of the various different procedures and medications that were
- 46:00being prescribed by the way and given to Gypsy were causing all these various side
- 46:07effects that seemed that made it seem as though Gypsy had actual medical issues that
- 46:12needed treatment, and so they would pile on even more treatments. You know,
- 46:16you somehow DD would convince a physician that Gypsy had some disorder and then
- 46:25she's like, Okay, I'm going to give you this medication, and then
- 46:29that medication would cause some sort of symptom, and then d D would take
- 46:32Gypsy to another physician and say this, my child has this thing, and
- 46:37then the position would say, oh, well, let's treat it with this
- 46:42medication. And then you just sort of work your way around the physicians long
- 46:45enough, and before you know it, you have twenty different medications pulling this
- 46:49child in on these different directions, giving the child all these side effects,
- 46:52and then it's hard to determine what's being caused by medication and what isn't.
- 46:57For instance, a lot of her teeth fell out because of the medications she
- 47:00was taking, which caused her to have to go to the dentist a lot.
- 47:05Right, she had been to the hospital over one hundred times within the
- 47:09span of nine years from five to fourteen. She had many surgeries, many
- 47:16many surgeries on her stomach, on her eyes. She had a surgery on
- 47:22her eyes. She had surgery to remove her salivary glands. I mean,
- 47:27I just like, why did that happen? And a Gypsy thought that everything
- 47:32was real. The only thing she thought was fake was the fact that she
- 47:36couldn't walk, because she knew she could walk. But Gypsy grew up from
- 47:42the time she was three months old, having her mother seemed like her mother
- 47:45loved her and seemed like her mother knew what was best, and so Gypsy.
- 47:50And because Dedee kept Gypsy in a super dependent childlike state, and Gypsy
- 47:55was never taught how to think for herself, Gypsy just thought, well,
- 47:59I guess I have all these disorders. Incidentally, d D also would make
- 48:06claims that they were Katrina survivors, which I don't think they were. Okay,
- 48:14now we have to watch this documentary because it's so interesting to see,
- 48:17because there's a lot of video of d D and Gypsy together prior to you
- 48:23know, recent events. They are at different benefits. You know, one
- 48:30of the things that different charities will do is they will ask one of the
- 48:34beneficiaries of the charity to come to a luncheon or a fundraising activity and give
- 48:42a testimonial. Right, So, if a charity gave money to d D
- 48:46and and Gypsy and they benefited from it, then they might ask Gypsy and
- 48:52charity or Gypsy Gypsy and charity, Gypsy and de Dy to come to a
- 48:58charity luncheon to talk about how the charity benefited them, so that other people
- 49:04will donate more money essentially, right. And so there's a lot of these
- 49:07little videos in which not charity, no asume charity, in which Gypsy is
- 49:14being carted off on stage, or she's being or she's posing with different you
- 49:20know, charity people, and and it's it's it's just really interesting. But
- 49:25you can also see that it seems as though Gypsy felt very close to her
- 49:31mother. They it almost seemed like Gypsy felt in a certain way kind of
- 49:37very loved by her mother because her mother gave her so much attention. So
- 49:43anyway, another thing you notice is how childish Gypsy comes across. I won't
- 49:51go and tell all the details, but when you watch it, you just
- 49:53you really see how Gypsy was made to act very so even though she would
- 50:01she would be like fifteen or eighteen years old, she if you heard her
- 50:06voice, it sounded like she was four, like literally, you know,
- 50:09she would be this grown teenage girl and talking in this three year old high
- 50:17voice. And this is, you know, because Dede forced her and socialized
- 50:23her to act like a very young child. In other words, when when
- 50:30Gypsy would act older, Dedie would punish her, or would ignore her or
- 50:36something, you know. And so that's very pronounced, almost hard to watch,
- 50:42almost hard to listen to. Actually, as a listener, it's just
- 50:44like, man, her voice is so high and so shrill. This is
- 50:50common to abuse children. One of the defenses that abused children will engage in
- 50:55is to act as though they're very young because the abuser, the perpetrator of
- 51:01abuse, will sometimes go easier on a child if the child seems very dependent
- 51:07and needy and young. Also, Gypsy didn't appear to know how old she
- 51:15was, as I was saying, because Dede wouldn't let her know. For
- 51:19instance, the father, So, the father of Gypsy, who was only
- 51:24briefly married to Dede, had occasional contact with her daughter Gypsy, and a
- 51:34lot of the documentary focuses on him and on him talking about how guilty he
- 51:38felt. But anyway, there's this part in the documentary in which the father
- 51:42is saying, yeah, so I called my daughter Gypsy on her birthday,
- 51:45on our eighteenth birthday, and Dede told me to not tell Gypsy that she's
- 51:52eighteen. So Dede controlled everything, right she. I mean, imagine the
- 51:59amount of things you'd have to control. She was homeschooled, by the way,
- 52:01after like second grade or something. Imagine the things you would have to
- 52:06control in a child's life so that the child doesn't even know how old they
- 52:10are. You would have to isolate that child from so many different people.
- 52:17So that's another thing that they they portray I think kind of well in the
- 52:22documentary, showing how controlling ded was, how so all encompassing Dede was in
- 52:34Gypsy's life. I mean she made she Ddy, made Gypsy into someone who
- 52:42couldn't even walk, who needed to be pushed around in a chair. So
- 52:46that Gypsy wasn't able to escape or wasn't able to walk up to someone or
- 52:53walk away from d d. It was just you just get this sense that
- 53:01Dede was very, very systematic in terms of controlling her. There were accounts
- 53:08that she would beat her. She would beat her daughter hard whenever they were
- 53:15talking to other people, because they have again, they have all these interviews
- 53:20talking about how Gypsy was surviving cancer and surviving all these different things in the
- 53:25media and stuff, and so there's all this footage of these interviews and Dedi
- 53:31is always holding on to her when they were talking to other people, and
- 53:36Gypsy would say that when Gypsy would step out a line while being interviewed by
- 53:42the media, Dede the mother would squeeze her hand. You know, she's
- 53:45to indicate your you know you're stepping out a line here, and that would
- 53:51give Gypsy knowledge that she, oh, I better step back in line or
- 53:54else I'm going to pay the price about this. Interestingly, when Gypsy was
- 54:00a little older, maybe I don't know, twenty years old or something,
- 54:05she actually got out of the house. She escaped, and Dede quickly found
- 54:10her and brought her back home and broke her laptop and her phone with a
- 54:16hammer and said that if you escape again, I'm going to break your hands.
- 54:23And you know, I'm sure she didn't use the word to escape.
- 54:25She was probably just you know, saying, if you ever break my rules
- 54:28again, I'm going to break your hands or something. And so it's interesting
- 54:30that at one point Gypsy actually did manage to escape this prison. When there
- 54:38were allegations of child abuse and CPS would be called and police would be called
- 54:44and they would go to the house. And when they come to the house
- 54:45to investigate these things, Dede would figure out a way to manipulate them and
- 54:51they would just go away. Also, you know, they talk about a
- 54:58little bit about this in the documentary, and I wish they went into more
- 55:00detail. But there were a number of benefits that Dedi had from this bunch
- 55:06Ausen by proxy. They had a free house that was built just for them
- 55:10by Habitat for Humanity. They were given a lot of funds by charity.
- 55:15They were given donations from people online, you know, because DD or someone
- 55:22helping out the family made a website and you could give donations. And they
- 55:27also got attention from the media, and they got attention from the community,
- 55:30good attention, you know, just all this. You know, just just
- 55:34think about when a child is suffering from cancer and the mother is struggling,
- 55:40and you have what's perceived as a single mother with a child that's suffering from
- 55:45all these different medical problems, and and you know, it's a it's a
- 55:51feel good story. You see these kinds of stories. You know, Russell
- 55:55Wilson of the Seahawks will go to the hospital and pose with the families and
- 56:00we'll talk with them. And there's just not to say that having cancer or
- 56:07having a child suffering from cancer is this wonderful life. It's it's horrific.
- 56:13I know that from talking with people about it. But you do get some
- 56:16benefits, which is you get free stuff, you get famous people might say
- 56:22hi to you. There was a famous case of munchaus of by proxy,
- 56:27which Hillary Clinton actually visited the family during the nineties, I think, and
- 56:32then it later came out that the child didn't have any kind of actual problems,
- 56:36that it was actually munchaus and by proxy, and so so yeah,
- 56:38they got a lot of attention that way. They got to spend a lot
- 56:43of time in Disneyland because of you know, playing up the illnesses and they
- 56:49got a lot of help from social workers and stuff. Okay, so the
- 56:54documentary, the main focus is Munchaus bi proxy, but the other focus is
- 57:01that is that Deedie is murdered by by Gypsy and Gypsy's boyfriend. I mean
- 57:10specifically, Gypsy's boyfriend is the one who carries out the actual murder. But
- 57:15Gypsy asked her boyfriend to kill her mother. So this was recently, I
- 57:22think like twenty fourteen, twenty fifteen or something. So now let's talk about
- 57:25our third person is Nicholas. Nicholas is Gypsy's boyfriend. They met on a
- 57:31Christian dating site, probably because she couldn't meet people in real life, his
- 57:38parents said. Nicholas's parents said, so they interview them in the police you
- 57:44know, they show a lot of police interviews, which is just chilling to
- 57:46see. But the parents said that Nicholas was a loner and that everyone hurt
- 57:53his feelings. He was very sensitive, and he was also developmentally delayed in
- 57:59some way. Throughout the documentary you learn that he has he's a the BDSM,
- 58:07and that he was arrested for masturbating at work for nine hours. I
- 58:10think is one of the things they found that he was he was fired from
- 58:16his job at McDonald's because I don't remember this exactly, but I think they
- 58:22said he was masturbating at work for nine hours and he was fired. He
- 58:25says in the police interview that he has the associative identity disorder or multiple personalities,
- 58:30and he also hears voices in his head. It's hard to it's hard
- 58:36to believe these accounts. You know, when someone is being accused of murder
- 58:37that they'll say a lot of things, right, But but really, from
- 58:43both of their accounts, I think it's possible. From both. You know,
- 58:45Gypsy talks about Nicholas's mental condition and Nicholas talks about his own in these
- 58:52police interviews, and I think it's possible the way that he talks about it.
- 58:58You know, Nicholas might have experience it's a fair amount of abuse himself,
- 59:00and seems to be exhibiting adult indications of early abuse, which could result
- 59:07in dissociative identity disorder. It's just hard to tell, especially now that the
- 59:14murder has occurred, because Nicholas has reasons to claim that he has mental illness.
- 59:17Right, So, Nicholas and Gypsy they meet on this Christian dating site,
- 59:25and they start, you know, communicating over the internet all the time.
- 59:29In fact, that's where most of their contact is because they can't see
- 59:30each other because DEDI won't let Gypsy out of the house. So they're communicating
- 59:36online a lot. And one of the interesting things about this documentary is somehow
- 59:40they got their hands on a lot of the communication between Gypsy and Nicholas,
- 59:45like really explicit details, like even their sexting and stuff. And I don't
- 59:52know if they just gave up that stuff to help, you know, sort
- 59:54of exonerate them. I don't know. But anyway, they were together for
- 59:59a year, and then at a certain point, Gypsy confides in Nicholas and
- 1:00:02says that her mother is very controlling and she doesn't know how to get away
- 1:00:07from our mother. And and when Nicholas and Gypsy are detained by the police,
- 1:00:16eventually they actually admit that that they that they in fact did kill Deity
- 1:00:24Gypsy's mom. They they have different kind of messenging messenger chat between him,
- 1:00:32like there's this one chat between them the day that they were actually going to
- 1:00:40kill the mother. Gypsy says, this shit's gonna go down tonight. Nicholas
- 1:00:45replies babe, it's my evil Sorry, babe, it's my evil side doing
- 1:00:52it. He won't mess up because he enjoys killing. Gypsy says, we'll
- 1:00:58be happy soon after this night. We will never bring it up again.
- 1:01:02So these these texts back and forth are super creepy and chilling. I mean
- 1:01:09the callousness and that the way they talk about it, you know, it's
- 1:01:15it'd be one thing if Gypsy was like, I'm really afraid. I don't
- 1:01:19know what to do. I don't really see any other way. I don't
- 1:01:23want to kill my mom, but I feel like if I don't, she'll
- 1:01:28find me. You know. There's just there's nothing like that that they present
- 1:01:30in a documentary anyway. It's all just this sort of weird Internet kind of
- 1:01:37troll talk or do and it's crazy. And another one, Nick is uh
- 1:01:46saying that he wants to rape his the mom. Nicholas is saying, Okay,
- 1:01:52I'm gonna come over there. I'm gonna kill your mom and I'm a
- 1:01:54raper. And then Gypsy made a deal with Nicholas and said, don't rape
- 1:02:01my mom because I just want you to kill her, but don't rape her.
- 1:02:06But if you need to rape someone, you can rape me instead,
- 1:02:08which is what they did. So Nicholas came over to the house. He
- 1:02:13had to, he lived across the country, I think, and had he
- 1:02:15came to the house and she Gypsy let Nicholas in, and then Nicholas went
- 1:02:22into the bedroom and killed the mother with a knife. And then and then
- 1:02:28Nicholas quote unquote raped Gypsy right after that while they were in the house.
- 1:02:32I mean, do you know what I mean? This story is just completely
- 1:02:37nuts. Anyway, So before we move forward, let's take a break.
- 1:02:46Okay, we're back. So another kind of really creepy Facebook situation here is
- 1:02:54as soon as Gypsy let in Nicholas and then Nicholas went into the bedroom and
- 1:03:00killed Deity Gypsy's mother, Gypsy went on Facebook and posted the following things.
- 1:03:09She said, the bitch is dead. I fucking slashed that fat pig and
- 1:03:15raped her sweet innocent daughter. Her scream was so fucking loud. Lol.
- 1:03:22So they show this on Facebook and I just find, you know, the
- 1:03:25way that you can make documentaries today is just so interesting because people who commit
- 1:03:32these kinds of crimes now will often leave behind these these online moments, you
- 1:03:39know, these these because this happened Gypsy posted this on the internet like right
- 1:03:45after it happened, and it's just so like what and people are are watching,
- 1:03:52you know, or here reading these posts on Facebook, and they're applying
- 1:03:54as Gypsy is posting them. And so again, the bitch is dead.
- 1:04:00I fucking slashed that fat pig and raped her sweet innocent daughter. So Gypsy
- 1:04:04is saying that herself, and all these other people are like, what's going
- 1:04:09on here? Is your account hacked or what's happening? So Gypsy and Nicholas
- 1:04:15are both charged with first degree murder, as they should be, and they
- 1:04:20were facing life or death, you know, death penalty. But once the
- 1:04:26police and the prosecutors started to investigate what was happening, they were like,
- 1:04:31wait a second here, this isn't just a case in which we have just
- 1:04:35this random killing of this mother. We have a situation in which Dedi,
- 1:04:40the mother, had been systematically abusing this daughter for her entire life. And
- 1:04:46you know, that's what we call a mitigating factor, meaning it doesn't it
- 1:04:50doesn't justify the murder, but it provides a context for why it might have
- 1:04:55occurred, and maybe justification for not having as harsh of a sentence a psychologist
- 1:05:03is interviewed in the in the documentary saying that she was like a hostage,
- 1:05:10and in a way, the psychologist doesn't say this directly, but he's basically
- 1:05:15saying that Gypsy had reasons, justifiable reasons maybe for killing your mother. And
- 1:05:21also there's a lot of talk about how Gypsy might have not known what reality
- 1:05:27was, because when you're fed just lies after lies after lies, and the
- 1:05:31world is all buying the lies, and you've been fed this weird reality your
- 1:05:35entire life, you might not know what's up and what's down. And you're
- 1:05:41also made to be very dependent and very childish. And so can someone like
- 1:05:47Gypsy in that situation be held accountable for her actions. It's it's just hard
- 1:05:51to hard to tell. Oh, By the way, before you watch this
- 1:05:55documentary, I mean I already told you you should be watching it, But
- 1:05:59if you haven't it, or you haven't gotten all the way through it yet,
- 1:06:01you should be careful because there's this one scene toward the end in which
- 1:06:04they show crime photos of the mother and her knife wounds in her back,
- 1:06:12and it's pretty brutal, and so if you're not cool with that kind of
- 1:06:18stuff, I would skip over it. So in the end, Gypsy was
- 1:06:21convicted of a crime and sentenced to ten years in prison, eligible for parole
- 1:06:30at eight and a half years. Her lawyer was very happy with this since
- 1:06:35she was facing life or the death penalty, and Gypsy feels really good about
- 1:06:43it. She is one of the most positive people on the planet. I
- 1:06:45just have to say. But she when asked, you know, how do
- 1:06:50you feel about being sent to prison for ten years over this, She's like,
- 1:06:55well, being in jail is better than being with my mom, so
- 1:07:00I'll take being in jail, you know. If she doesn't say this directly,
- 1:07:03but in essence, she's saying, I don't see any other way I
- 1:07:09could have gotten away from my mom, because my mom would have either tracked
- 1:07:12me down or done something, and I needed to maybe kill her in order
- 1:07:17to get away from her. And if that means I have to go to
- 1:07:21jail for ten years, then that's a price worth them, you know,
- 1:07:25worth paying. Now. She didn't say that directly, but I was,
- 1:07:28you know, kind of reading into it, and you know, after watching
- 1:07:32this documentary, I believe that jail is probably a better place than living with
- 1:07:38her mom or under her mom's thumb. Now, Nicholas, on the other
- 1:07:43hand, his trial is next month from the time I'm recording this in his
- 1:07:47trials in June of twenty seventeen, and he might get life in prison,
- 1:07:53which is interesting, right, because well, he was the one who actually
- 1:07:56committed the murder, so it kind of makes sense. But he only did
- 1:08:00it because, I presumeab because Gypsy asked him to do it, and he
- 1:08:05was trying to he was trying to help her, and so it's interesting that
- 1:08:10Nicholas could actually go to a prison for life, but Gypsy would only go
- 1:08:15to prison for eight to ten years. But it does actually kind of make
- 1:08:19sense because when you watch this documentary, you get the sense that Nicholas,
- 1:08:24there's something really different about him. You know, the fact that he was
- 1:08:28so gung ho about killing someone, the fact that he didn't think this through
- 1:08:34at all, the fact that he has lots of different kinds of problems along
- 1:08:40these lines. He you know, wanted to rape the mother and kill her.
- 1:08:45I mean, this isn't just some innocent kid who got wrapped up in
- 1:08:49something. You know. There's something definitely off about this guy. And I
- 1:08:55worry about this guy being on the streets honestly, so but on the other
- 1:08:59hand, would he have You know, there are people who have a sort
- 1:09:02of openness, shall we say, to psychopathic behavior, but never do it
- 1:09:06because there's never really a point to it, and so uh, you know,
- 1:09:12in fact, most psychopaths never do anything like this. So the fact
- 1:09:17that he's off in some ways doesn't mean that he is, you know,
- 1:09:24automatically going to commit a bunch of more crimes. But anyway, watch the
- 1:09:28documentary more for that sort of thing. So in conclusion, let's let's ask
- 1:09:33some questions. One of the biggest questions that I think is being asked after
- 1:09:40watching this documentary is are the doctors and the physicians and the hospitals are they
- 1:09:45Are they responsible for what was happening here? And I think it's a very
- 1:09:49legitimate question. In the documentary, they lay out that many physicians had suspicions
- 1:09:58that Deed had Munchausen by proxy and that the all the claims of physical problems
- 1:10:04for gypsy were just made up by the mother. There were many physicians who
- 1:10:10had questions, some of which had extreme suspicions, some of which actually said
- 1:10:17she has much as by proxy, and yet nothing happened. When they flip
- 1:10:26through a lot of these assessments, there's a majority or some massive amount of
- 1:10:32medical data that they relied upon was all according to the mother this, and
- 1:10:38mother reported that and that sort of thing. Instead of physicians actually doing their
- 1:10:43own assessments, they would just take the account of the mother and run with
- 1:10:47it. So that's problem number one. But again, as I think I
- 1:10:54said earlier, for most parents, they don't lie about that kind of stuff,
- 1:10:59and so reports from parents can be believed. Also, a lot of
- 1:11:05times physicians don't have time or money to conduct a bunch of tests, or
- 1:11:11tests don't exist to test for certain things, and so a lot of times,
- 1:11:16particularly with kids who can't talk, you have to rely on parents in
- 1:11:21terms of their account about things. So, you know, But having said
- 1:11:26that, it seems like if we're going to look on a micro level at
- 1:11:30various different points in Gypsy's life, we could probably see a number of points
- 1:11:35where physicians should have not taken the mother's account as gospel. Also in the
- 1:11:44documentary, there's one particular physician who they interview who had significant suspicions about much
- 1:11:51as of biproxy with regards to this case, and he said he had doubts
- 1:11:57from the beginning, he said that he knew that she could even walk.
- 1:12:02So this physician is like, I know this child can walk, and yet
- 1:12:09the child is in a wheelchair. You know what's going on here? And
- 1:12:12he reached out to other clinicians, past clinicians, and one of the past
- 1:12:17clinicians said that Gypsy doesn't even have MS. Also in the documentary, this
- 1:12:24physician said that he didn't see any point in confronting her because there were so
- 1:12:29many other clinicians who were totally convinced. And this is you know, when
- 1:12:34you're watching this part of the documentary, you just want to pull your hair
- 1:12:39out because there are so many different points where someone could have done something,
- 1:12:42and no one did anything, particularly this one physician who actually like had major
- 1:12:47questions and had basically concluded that Dedi had Munchausen by proxy and that Gypsy didn't
- 1:12:58actually suffer from some, if not any of these disorders that were on record.
- 1:13:03And this physician even thought about doing something about it, and yet did
- 1:13:08nothing. You know, I think because the way he was saying it,
- 1:13:15it was like, well, there are all these other clinicians involved, and
- 1:13:17there were like communities of people involved, and if I called this out.
- 1:13:21How many people would have believed me. I don't know if many people would
- 1:13:25have believed me, And I just find that to be incredibly frustrating, which
- 1:13:30I can understand by the way. You know, if you're a physician and
- 1:13:33you're looking at a case and you're like, I'm eighty percent sure that this
- 1:13:39mother is lying and that there's all sorts of problems here, but I'm not
- 1:13:44entirely sure, but I'm pretty sure. I'm pretty sure something's up here.
- 1:13:47And then you look around and you see that everyone is just gobbling it up.
- 1:13:50And not only are they gobbling it up, but they're actually rewarding.
- 1:13:56You know, they're heavily involved and just congratulating this mother, how great of
- 1:14:00a mother she is. The the amount of fallout in your life as a
- 1:14:06physician that will happen if you if you confront this woman, it's it's really
- 1:14:13great. You know, you're predicting. It's like, Okay, I'm going
- 1:14:15to go to the mother. I'm going to start doing these tests, and
- 1:14:17then I'm gonna I'm going to say to the mother, I think you're lying.
- 1:14:21In fact, there's kind of a trail that indicates that you're actually making
- 1:14:25this stuff up. Well, who knows what the mother would do at that
- 1:14:30point, right, would she get violent? Would she I mean, someone
- 1:14:32who would do this amount of manipulation, are they capable of paying someone to
- 1:14:39kill you, you know it's possible, or or finding some way of killing
- 1:14:43you herself, you know, poisoning your food somehow. So there's that kind
- 1:14:46of worry, which I think is totally I legitimate. And then there's the
- 1:14:50worry that she could sue you as a physician. Right, there's also the
- 1:14:55worry that you could be labeled by the medical community as so one who doesn't
- 1:15:00have any compassion. I mean, you know this this family was seen as
- 1:15:03this. You know, the gypsy was seen as this you know, adorable
- 1:15:08suffering child, which she was, but even in reality, but they thought
- 1:15:13she was suffering from all these medical conditions that she didn't have. And then
- 1:15:16you come out and you call everyone a faker, including the child. By
- 1:15:20the way, you're you're you part of your accusation is not toward the mother,
- 1:15:24but you're actually accusing the child of faking that they can't walk. Imagine
- 1:15:28that one, right, It's like walking up to someone in a wheelchair and
- 1:15:32saying you can walk, I know you can, and then you know,
- 1:15:35trying to dump them out of the chair to make them walk, and they
- 1:15:38fall in the ground and everyone looks at you like you's one of the worst
- 1:15:42people on the planet. Right, So there's all these there's all these possible
- 1:15:47negative things that could happen to your life, or you could sweep it under
- 1:15:51the rug, do nothing and nothing bad will happen to you. In fact,
- 1:15:56good things will happen to you because you can continue billing this person and
- 1:15:59getting paid for it. So there's there's very little incentive in this scenario for
- 1:16:04a physician to stick their neck out. The one incentive that I know is
- 1:16:10there is ethical practice, I mean and malpractice. You can get sued.
- 1:16:14And I know some of these physicians are actually, you know, potentially target
- 1:16:17of lawsuits or I'm fairly sure of that because they have a good case,
- 1:16:25because it's like you did not do your job and that resulted in a lot
- 1:16:30of bad things, including the death of this mother. Because presumably if all
- 1:16:34of you physicians had done something, we could have intervened, you know,
- 1:16:38and not had it escalate to murder. So so one of the things that
- 1:16:45physicians should and therapists, frankly should be thinking about is if you don't do
- 1:16:50something, it could come back to taunt you, and you could get successfully
- 1:16:55sued because you didn't do anything even though you saw the signs. So but
- 1:17:00apparently that's not enough because so many physicians, you know, we're talking hundreds
- 1:17:03of physicians who were exposed to this family, including social workers, police officers,
- 1:17:11you know, other kinds of people, and everyone had you know,
- 1:17:14and you know a sizeable percentage of those people had suspicions and yet did nothing.
- 1:17:20So so do I hold the medical community responsible? I would say yes,
- 1:17:29if the medical community had better systems of communication, because essentially this physician
- 1:17:33he was like looking at it and he's like, I think, I think
- 1:17:36this might be Munchausen by process. And then he had to dig up old
- 1:17:41records, he had to specifically reach out to previous physicians, find them one
- 1:17:45and two, like talk to them and all this kind of stuff. Whereas
- 1:17:48if we had a massive medical database that had every single and I know there's
- 1:17:54talk about this for a lot of reasons. You know, another reason why
- 1:17:59we want to centralized medical database is because some people will because they are addicted
- 1:18:06to xanax or something. They'll go to fifty different physicians around around Seattle and
- 1:18:13get you know, fifty different Xenex prescriptions and then they're you know, rolling
- 1:18:17in a bunch of xanax, you know. Whereas if if any of the
- 1:18:21physicians knew that this person was getting prescriptions with other people, they wouldn't provide
- 1:18:27that that that you know, prescription. Now, there are centralized databases that
- 1:18:34can catch situations like that, but they're not as robust as I think they
- 1:18:40need to be. Now, the downside to that is, if we have
- 1:18:44like an easily accessible centralized database of mental reck of health records, then it's
- 1:18:50it's easily hackable, you know, like one if all you'd have to do
- 1:18:56is hack into one site and you could get information on someone, you know,
- 1:19:00every bit of detail about their medical history, which not everyone would want
- 1:19:03out there. And I don't know much about this topic. And maybe there's
- 1:19:08bigger movements afoot, or maybe there are products like this out there or something,
- 1:19:11but it seems to me that in this case of gypsy and d D,
- 1:19:15if there was more ready and easy access to all the various different medical
- 1:19:24documents that had been provided over and created over time that it would have made
- 1:19:30it easier for people to zero in on the Munchausen by proxy diagnosis and to
- 1:19:35actually try to save Gypsy from that abuse. The other and also the fact
- 1:19:45that not a lot of people know that Munchausen by proxy exists because it is
- 1:19:48so rare. So again, part of the reason why I'm doing this is
- 1:19:53I want to raise awareness about that, and this documentary will absolutely do that
- 1:19:56too. The other question here is is the father to blame? You know,
- 1:20:00people are like, hey, you know this father had contact with the
- 1:20:02family, why didn't the father do something? Well, he definitely admits a
- 1:20:06number of times in the documentary that he regrets not having done something and he
- 1:20:13does feel responsible. But you get the impression from the documentary that the father
- 1:20:17was pretty distant to the situation. He met Dedi when he was seventeen,
- 1:20:23and they got pregnant accidentally, and they got married. He was seventeen when
- 1:20:29he married Dedi, and then a year later he got divorced. So you
- 1:20:35know, you're you're eighteen years old, you have a one year old daughter,
- 1:20:42your ex wife isn't so keen on hanging out with you, and so
- 1:20:46you could see how things could kind of drift apart, and the father,
- 1:20:51you know, did stay in contact. Also, it's possible that if the
- 1:20:57father had done something, that d D would have figured out a way to
- 1:21:00manipulate the father out of the equation. You know, DEDE was. This
- 1:21:04is another thing you learned from the documentary on the various details that they portray,
- 1:21:09is that DEDI was just a master manipulator. She was so I mean,
- 1:21:14imagine all of the lies and the ways in which you'd have to be
- 1:21:18adept at manipulating people to to get a physician to put a tube through your
- 1:21:25child's abdomen, right, you know, these physicians, they don't just do
- 1:21:29anything. They have to be at least somewhat convinced that this this you know,
- 1:21:32mother was just so good at that. Well, imagine if the father
- 1:21:35had started to say, hey, I think I think something's wrong. I
- 1:21:39think I would you know, I think I want to fight for custody of
- 1:21:42my child. Don't you think d D is going to you know, smell
- 1:21:45that coming and figure out a way to put an end to that. My
- 1:21:48guess is she would. I mean, an easy solution would be that d
- 1:21:54D would just abuse Gypsy into saying that the father was sexually abusive or something
- 1:21:59right, And so I would imagine that there was probably nothing the father could
- 1:22:03have done given just the level of evil that this woman was capable of.
- 1:22:12So the last thing I want to talk about here is just about Gypsy as
- 1:22:16she moves forward. One question that I think the documentary raises subtly is is
- 1:22:26Gypsy herself just like her mother and just like her mother's mother, is Gypsy
- 1:22:30psychopathic? Is she anti social? Is Gypsy capable of doing a lot of
- 1:22:35bad things? Because there's this moment when she is telling her story to the
- 1:22:43documentary people. She's in prison at this point, and she's being interviewed in
- 1:22:46her prison garb, and she's talking and Gypsy's talking about the final moments just
- 1:22:53before her her mother is murdered, and she's crying, and she's making a
- 1:22:59lot of noises like she's crying, but there's not tears at first. So
- 1:23:04she's made you know that the way you act like you're crying, I'm crying
- 1:23:09right now, but no tears. So is Gypsy lying? She even says
- 1:23:16to the documentary people, she sits down and she says, actually, I'm
- 1:23:20going to tell you the truth. And I haven't told anyone the truth.
- 1:23:25I've lied to everybody so far, including my own lawyers. I've lied to
- 1:23:28my own lawyers. But I'm going to tell you the truth. So she's
- 1:23:32admitted to being a frequent liar. Now, the big question is is this
- 1:23:40circumstantial in that she is in a very particular kind of situation and once she's
- 1:23:46released from prison, you know, ten years from now, is she going
- 1:23:50to have a normal sense of morality? Is she going to have a normal
- 1:23:55sense of empathy? Is she going to Is she gonna have a normal sense
- 1:23:58of given to back and forth between other human beings? Hard to say.
- 1:24:01Maybe maybe she will, or does she have the same compulsion to harm other
- 1:24:08human beings that her mother seemed to have. Because when you look at these
- 1:24:12texts between her and Nicholas, you, if you just read it face value,
- 1:24:19Gypsy is just as much of a monster as deed he is. I
- 1:24:23mean, the things that she was saying. You know, she posts that
- 1:24:25she right after the murder of her mother, she posts on Facebook that she
- 1:24:30she you know, yeah, I murdered her and she screamed and it was
- 1:24:33great and da da da lol. I mean, you know, one of
- 1:24:38the creepiest usages of lol ever, and you know, and so you know,
- 1:24:45it's just it's hard to say. Did Gypsy learn a very twisted sense
- 1:24:50of morality from her very twisted mother? Yes? Absolutely? Can Can Gypsy
- 1:24:57unlearn that? Well, that's yet to be seen. Is it in Gypsy's
- 1:25:00bones? You know? Is it hardwired into her brain as a result of
- 1:25:04biology and or environment. Is her psychopathy fixed or is it circumstantial? You
- 1:25:13know, it's hard to say. The last thing I'll talk about here is
- 1:25:15I'm a little worried that this documentary will make people scared of BDSM. There's
- 1:25:20there's some talk about Nicholas is into BDSM, and Nicholas is not the best
- 1:25:28spokesperson for BDSM. If you watch this documentary, and you know, for
- 1:25:33for the BDSM community, I'm guessing they're going to be like, oh boy,
- 1:25:38there's going to be a backlash on BDSM now, because this Nicholas character
- 1:25:43is you know, quite a piece of work, and he's into BDSM and
- 1:25:45da da da da da, you know, and we're just trying to make
- 1:25:48BDSM non pathologized, and so I'm a little worried about that. I'm also
- 1:25:54a little worried that people will blame Gypsy for this whole thing. You know,
- 1:25:59there's talk about she's this master manipulator, and really she's the victim here
- 1:26:05now. She murdered her mother, so that's what that's a hard one,
- 1:26:10you know. Or she hired or got someone to murder her mother, so
- 1:26:15that's obviously not good. There were other options for Gypsy. She could have
- 1:26:21run away, she could have called her father, she could have just you
- 1:26:27know, gone with Nicholas somewhere. But when I hear people talking about that
- 1:26:31sort of thing, I think, I think one thing. I think people
- 1:26:36like that have never been in an abusive relationship. If you've ever been in
- 1:26:41an abusive relationship, or you've been very close to people who have been in
- 1:26:44an abusive relationship, you know that it is so much easier said than done
- 1:26:48than to just than to just walk away. There's so many psychological reasons why
- 1:26:55it's hard to walk away. One because your ego just gets bashed around and
- 1:26:59like just squad, particularly if your gypsy in terms of you've been systematically abused
- 1:27:04and controlled and broken down since you were born. I mean you've been you've
- 1:27:10been socialized to be dependent and were and to feel worthless since you were since
- 1:27:15you were born. So there's that, But there's also practical reasons that I
- 1:27:20feel like people don't often understand, which is that, you know, you
- 1:27:26imagine this, You have a mother who is capable of faking to everyone on
- 1:27:32stage, on the internet, on the news that your daughter can't walk,
- 1:27:36but you can walk, and your mother is is beating you if you step
- 1:27:45out a line on that. You know, if you start walking and your
- 1:27:47mother will take you home and beat you, that is like some really crazy
- 1:27:53stuff right there, right, So that's just one of the things, you
- 1:27:56know, and then you're looking at all these other things like, wait,
- 1:27:57my mom might be faking all these other things, and what kind of person
- 1:28:00does that? Right? Well, when when you have a question mark on
- 1:28:04that, Like a more common example would be if if you have a spouse
- 1:28:11and your spouse just completely flips out because you came home five minutes late from
- 1:28:17work or something, and your spouse just completely loses their shit and starts breaking
- 1:28:23stuff and like takes the tea a thousand dollars TV and throws it off the
- 1:28:27balcony. Well, that raises a lot of questions because you're looking at that
- 1:28:32person. You're thinking, that's not normal behavior, right, That's that's extreme
- 1:28:36behavior. When they're angry, they're capable of doing things that are destructive to
- 1:28:42them. Well, if they're capable of that, what else are they capable
- 1:28:45of? This is the anxiety that is super justified in people who are being
- 1:28:51abused by somebody. So Gipsy is looking at her mother and going like,
- 1:28:56she is capable of such deceit and such evil and such. You know,
- 1:29:00she's playing the long con here. She is dedicated to this, to this
- 1:29:04project. She doesn't just lie every now and that she is. She is
- 1:29:10a lifetime of lies. If she's capable of that, what else is she
- 1:29:15capable of? If I just go with Nick and we just you know,
- 1:29:18ride off into the sunset, what is my mom going to do? Because
- 1:29:21if she's capable of manipulating people, she's going to go to the cops and
- 1:29:25she's going to convince them that Nicholas kidnapped me, or that Nicholas is a
- 1:29:30sexual offender, or that Nicholas raped her. And you know that when you
- 1:29:34look at someone and you see what they're capable of, it raises a lot
- 1:29:38of questions about what else they will do which makes you very afraid of them,
- 1:29:43you know that question mark of like, man, the sky's a limit
- 1:29:45in terms of what this person will do if I was to if I was
- 1:29:48to upset them, and therefore it's easier just to stay with them and please
- 1:29:55them so that they don't do this, you know, mystery bad thing or
- 1:29:59kill this, you know, which is what Gypsy decided to do. Now
- 1:30:03again, I am not justifying murder. The real solution to this is for
- 1:30:08the medical community and perhaps for child protective services to just know the signs more
- 1:30:14and to investigate more. If someone would have just if CPS would have looked
- 1:30:18into more than medical records, or if this physician would have made it more
- 1:30:21of a long term goal of like, look, I don't know if I'm
- 1:30:25going to do anything right now, but I'm going to I'm going to reach
- 1:30:28out to a lot of other physicians and we're going to start consulting, and
- 1:30:31you know, we'll start we'll start talking to the school. And you know,
- 1:30:34if any person just would have made it their kind of a minor weekly
- 1:30:41project, you know, they all they'd have to do is spend like fifteen
- 1:30:44minutes a week on this for a year, or something. They could have
- 1:30:47gotten to the bottom of it and probably put an end to it pretty early
- 1:30:51in in Gypsy's life. And so the now murder obviously is not a good
- 1:31:00idea. But the lesson of this story is that this could have been prevented.
- 1:31:05And in a highly sophisticated, industrialized society like the United States, you'd
- 1:31:13think we would be more sophisticated about this sort of thing. And now I'm
- 1:31:17not saying that, you know, all these physicians are a bunch of idiots.
- 1:31:20I'm not saying that at all, because I could absolutely see myself in
- 1:31:25that situation making a very similar choice. Again, because the way I laid
- 1:31:28it out, it's just like, well, I could make my life very
- 1:31:30difficult, or I can turn the other way and move on with my life
- 1:31:34and you know, not risk having a bunch of bad things happen to me.
- 1:31:40You know. So there should be a different kind of system about that,
- 1:31:43like some kind of anonymous situation or some kind of systematic review process in
- 1:31:48which cases are reviewed by an oversight situation, or I don't know, more
- 1:31:56education, more awareness, more testing, you know, just more of that
- 1:31:59kind of stuf. The last thing I want to say here is that much
- 1:32:03as on by proxy is a very rare condition, it is extremely rare,
- 1:32:10extremely rare that parents will do this because the vast majority of human beings have
- 1:32:15a tremendous amount of empathy for people, and they have even more empathy for
- 1:32:19their own children and therefore would not want to do this to them. So,
- 1:32:25you know, it's a very rare thing. But you know how rare
- 1:32:30is it, because as I was saying earlier, it might actually be actually
- 1:32:34be you know, more prevalent than we know, because there's a lot of
- 1:32:39people getting away with it. Well, that does it for that episode of
- 1:32:43psychology in Seattle. Thanks for joining me out there. Please take care of
- 1:32:45yourself because you deserve it.