Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Black Mirror - Joan Is Awful (Chapter 1)
Transcript
- 0:00So burto I thought that Black Mirror might never come back on. I thought
- 0:05about it recently and I was like, huh, no more. It seemed
- 0:08like there was a regular pace at which they had been released, and I
- 0:11thought maybe Black Mirrors over it seemed like maybe it did run its course,
- 0:17they petered out or whatever. But then yeah, that they had explored a
- 0:21lot of topics. Yeah, and then all of a sudden, Stacy and
- 0:24I are on Netflix, and of course they're promoting it right because it's very
- 0:29Netflix, flagshippy. And it's also the first episode very Netflix flagshippy and in
- 0:36a while, right, so it's they got to promote it, right,
- 0:38So boom, there's it right there on the front page. And I'm like,
- 0:44oh, Black Mirror, huh so boom start Watchman. And I'm thinking,
- 0:50oh, well, I gotta have we got to have a podcast about
- 0:54it. And I don't know, but at this point, I'm thinking maybe
- 0:58we'll do an episode on each episode this season. It'd be great because it's
- 1:03a jumping off point to talk about a lot of things. What do you
- 1:04say, let's do it. This is the Psychology in Seattle podcast. My
- 1:07name is doctor Kirk Conda. I'm a therapist and a professor. And my
- 1:12favorite episode of Black Mirror is White Christmas? Who are you Berto? My
- 1:17name is? I just sign anti logos and I Yeah, I'm pretty sure
- 1:22that's still my favorite, although I really enjoyed the Bender's Natch experience, but
- 1:26my episode still White White Christmas. So let's talk about Joan is awful.
- 1:32First episode, season six spoilers obviously, So I'm gonna lay out the plots
- 1:38because I feel like it needs to be discussed. Plus there's some kind of
- 1:42questions and then we'll get into some more specifics after that. It gets a
- 1:46little primer towards the end. So a woman named Joan is in therapy talking
- 1:52about how she doesn't feel like she's the quote unquote main character in her own
- 1:56story. Have you noticed people talking about main character in culture today? Yeah?
- 2:00What are they referring to? So, but we're so used now culturally
- 2:05for decades, especially more and more now with shows and movies where there's definitely
- 2:09a main character. We've also gotten more and more familiar with the meta concepts
- 2:14about storytelling because you know, we hear about it, plus shows explore it
- 2:17and all these things. So just the idea that Okay, there is a
- 2:21main character. And then this idea. I think what you're maybe referring to
- 2:24is when we were growing up in the seventies and eighties, there would be
- 2:30movies and TV shows with very little meta commentary, right, just people the
- 2:35more what you see is what you get. Yeah, there wasn't the internet,
- 2:38so and you had journalists who would review movies, but they would be
- 2:43a paragraph long and then that would be it and you were just left talking
- 2:46with your friends. So there wasn't the level of sophistication that people have.
- 2:52And movies, yeah, I mean there were, don't get me wrong.
- 2:55There's always been underground movies or more niche movies, but nowadays there's very mainstream
- 3:00movies that get very very meta about storytelling and about movies themselves, and about
- 3:05characters and things. So I think we've developed a comfort level with saying,
- 3:08oh, primary character, the story arc, the character are all these kind
- 3:13of things, and I think people are now using it as you know,
- 3:16I go through my life and things happen to me. So I feel more
- 3:21like an MPC a non player character, right right, I'm not the main
- 3:25characters. Interesting, I didn't even think about this, So the late great
- 3:30Phil Cushman, my mentor, one of my mentors. One of the things
- 3:34that he talked a lot about, and he talked about He talked a lot
- 3:37about a lot of things, but this is one of the main things he
- 3:38talked about, one of the means things he wrote about and thought about,
- 3:42which is how humans define the self. And psychology and particularly psychotherapy is completely,
- 3:50at least somewhat foundationally based on the view of the self. And we
- 3:55take for granted that the way we see the self, the way we see
- 4:00ourselves, the way we see the definition of who we are, or even
- 4:03how we look at who we are, we take for granted that, well,
- 4:06that's just the way it is, right, you have the sun and
- 4:11the moon, and the earth and the self. But it changes over time,
- 4:14and there's evidence of that when you look at history, when you look
- 4:17at the way people operated, the way people thought of themselves. And Phil
- 4:21Cushman, we would enter a class expecting to talk about psychology, for example,
- 4:27to learn skills to be a therapist or something, and the entire class
- 4:31he would hijack as an excuse to teach us about philosophy and the basis for
- 4:42human life and the way we see everything through a cultural lens and the assumptions
- 4:46that we make. And on one hand, I think it was kind of
- 4:49a disservice to the students because it was a little advanced for them, and
- 4:54also it was replacing maybe some more fun something, maybe some more fundamental things
- 4:59that they had. But it was good for me because by the time I
- 5:01was in his classes, I was already a professor and a therapist. This
- 5:05is when I went back to graduate school. Could use more of that meta
- 5:09Yeah, and I did. I was expecting to be bored out of my
- 5:13mind having to review things that I already knew, but then he would go
- 5:15off on these things and anyway, so one of the elements that I learned
- 5:21from him is that the way society and the and the things that have power,
- 5:28the power structure, will start to infuse in how we see the self.
- 5:32So as an example the twentieth century, you know, the major turning
- 5:38point in our society in the United States and beyond is the market is capitalism.
- 5:44You know, prior to nestrilization and particularly prior to Madison Avenue in nineteen
- 5:48fifty, people woke up. They mainly worked on farms or they had some
- 5:54sort of trade they ran into a few people that they ran into every day.
- 6:00And the news they might not even ever know anything beyond what happens in
- 6:05their town, beyond rumor. They might not even be able to read if
- 6:09a newspaper managed to come their way. Sure, there's actually a really interesting
- 6:13movie about this. I think it's called News of the World. It went
- 6:17yeah with Tom Hanks and a movie with Tom Hanks, I think during the
- 6:23pandemic that just completely no one talked about. And it's a really good movie.
- 6:27And I looked into the history of it, and essentially the eighteen hundreds,
- 6:30you would have these traveling news tellers. Sure. So Tom Hanks was
- 6:35a guy who would travel from town to town and he would bring with him
- 6:40newspapers from New York City and all these stories from the world. Yeah,
- 6:44and he would just tell stories to a crowd of people that would pay a
- 6:46penny eat it's the news channel, yeah live. Yeah, So it might
- 6:50be this community's chance because they can't read the newspaper even if they got it,
- 6:56And so he would tell it in this very lively way. And it
- 7:00was how we made money anyway. So for people back then, the way
- 7:04they viewed the self was very different from the way we view the self now,
- 7:08and the way we view the self now is primarily as a vehicle of
- 7:13consumption. We see ourselves as the way the marketers want us to see ourselves,
- 7:17and it is reflected in a lot of our language. You will hear
- 7:20phrases like well, I'm not really bought into that idea, bought in,
- 7:27why are you? Why are you buying? Why are you pay purchasing?
- 7:30And there were lots of other phrases that he could point to that I don't
- 7:35have the dot toot man, but there there are many. Then the computer
- 7:39age started to emerge and that started to add to the way we see ourselves.
- 7:45So you would hear about people saying, my my ram is full,
- 7:48my yah, oh I'm overflowing, Yeah, my my processor, my processing
- 7:56speed, or I don't have enough bandwidth for this. Yeah, I'm sure.
- 8:00We could think of, you know, a lot of examples, and
- 8:03on one hand you're just like, well, you know, it's just metaphoresis
- 8:05language, but it does show people today think of themselves as brains that have
- 8:13capacities and hard drives and you know, processing speed, you know, And
- 8:20so then you also have maybe gaming culture, and you have this notion of
- 8:26the main character or you the player char character, and all this language,
- 8:30by the way, comes from D and D, but we'll put that aside
- 8:31for a second. Like NPC is directly from Gary Gygax and company. But
- 8:37you have the non player character, which is this, uh, you know,
- 8:41you're the player character and you run into a non player character and they're
- 8:45just kind of an automaton that you run into a limited role in this world.
- 8:50Yeah, they're like, you know, someone stole my dog, please
- 8:52retrieve it for me. And then you go on that mission and you bring
- 8:56the dog back and you get to move on in the story. And so
- 8:58people today start to refer themselves as I feel like I'm an NPC. Am
- 9:03I am I a player character or an MPC that people would view it that
- 9:07way now with movie metaphor movie sophistication, because it is true, and I
- 9:15feel like I'm one of these people, Like I consume not only a lot
- 9:16of TV and movies, and when I watch TV and movies, I'm not
- 9:20only really analyzing it, but there's all this commentary. You know, sometimes
- 9:24I'll watch a movie. I'll watch a movie and it'll be an hour and
- 9:28a half, but I'll watch ten hours of YouTube commentary analysis. So I
- 9:33live in that world where you know, And so when you're in that world
- 9:35and you start thinking along those lines, it's like, okay, who am
- 9:39i? Am I a Tony Stark? Or am I Bruce Banner? Or
- 9:43am I you know? And you start thinking about yourself and all these terms
- 9:46because because it's your life and so main character, right, So people start
- 9:50walking around and saying, what, you know, am I the main character?
- 9:54Where am I in the in the hero's journey? Am I in the
- 9:56belly of the whale? Or am I? You know? People start thinking
- 10:01that way, right? Imagine how because it seems like, well, yeah,
- 10:05these are these are modern problems. And I do think the meta analyzes
- 10:07and the over analyzes and the constant analyzes is there. At the same time,
- 10:11I'm kind of wondering because there was a whole period of time including now
- 10:16I actually but it's different where let's say you live in a little, small
- 10:20little house in England or France in the middle of the royal periods, which
- 10:26still exist, but and you're not royalty, you're not blue blood at all.
- 10:31About the feudal period or something, sure, any any of the last
- 10:35you know, thousand years, other than the last one hundred. You're not
- 10:39blue blood. You'll never be account You'll not even be anything. Right.
- 10:43But you see them walk by go by on their horses and their carriages,
- 10:46and you hear, like you said, you don't get that much news,
- 10:48but you do get some. And if you do get news, it's probably
- 10:50about the royals. Talk about feeling like a non player character, right,
- 10:54So Phil Cushman and I won't worry it the details, and I don't even
- 10:58remember it that well. Has a lot of talk about that because for the
- 11:01majority of recent history, at least in the Western world and really around Japan
- 11:05China, the ninety nine percent of people were in that situation. They wouldn't
- 11:11even have a last name because it didn't matter, because they didn't even own
- 11:16their land, right They lived on a baron or a lord or account.
- 11:22You know, they lived in service of that person. They had no legal
- 11:26power, no landownership. No one cared about their lives TK four to one.
- 11:31Why are you not at your land tilling post? There was no concern
- 11:35about a legacy, or very little concern about anything. You're just trying to
- 11:39survive and trying to stay out of trouble. And you know, how do
- 11:43you see the self when you start to see this self in those situations as
- 11:48maybe toiling until the afterlife or something, or maybe you don't even necessarily care
- 11:56what you think at all? Why even think? Who? Who am I?
- 11:58Because because well, not only just survival, but also what's the point
- 12:03in thinking about who you are? What you are, what your goals are?
- 12:07That's not how I see who I am? You know, you can
- 12:09imagine that as we move into today's time, which I can vary much relate
- 12:13to because of the way that we see ourselves not only as consumers but also
- 12:18as the main character. We all see ourselves as the main character that we
- 12:24would Perhaps on one hand, there'd be a pro to that that you're able
- 12:28to think about what you want, what you need, so I think that's
- 12:31actually a good thing. On the downside, you might over emphasize yourself instead
- 12:37of knowing or just falling into a lifestyle where you're in service to your family
- 12:43or your community or to God or whatever it is that in the past might
- 12:48have actually produced a tremendous amount of happiness and contentment for people that research actually
- 12:52shows that when you actually focus on others and helping other people in general,
- 12:58of course it kind of depends. Then people tend to be more content,
- 13:01to tend to be more happy. And when we only focus on ourselves and
- 13:03self improvements and optimizing the self and how much money can I earn and how
- 13:09can I look the best? And you know, people tend to not do
- 13:11so long. So, Brito, let me ask you, when we shift
- 13:15into this model of understanding through the meta story, the main character, the
- 13:20MPCs, what could be the downside of that? Well, I think the
- 13:26thinking of oneself as a character in a movie or a video game goes with
- 13:31it goes the things that you expect out of a movie or a video game.
- 13:33For example, quite literally, in a video game, you expect that
- 13:37if you make mistakes, you can just you know, start over, start
- 13:39the level over. The flip side is you expect you are going to win.
- 13:43You will win, you will complete the video game, and you're going
- 13:46to beat the bad guys and you will be the star. Like that's the
- 13:50thing. And if you're watching a movie, even more so, because in
- 13:52the movies and the TV shows you don't even see the failures. There are
- 13:56no failures, that the character actually saves it everything just in time and makes
- 14:01it to the end. It gets a little hairy and dice, whereas it
- 14:03at least in the video game you do fail and you gotta say not in
- 14:05the movies. Right, So there's that, And so therefore, if you're
- 14:09really literally over applying this, then you're gonna be disappointed a lot, right,
- 14:13and you're gonna be potentially really sad about that. Like, wait,
- 14:18I thought that I was gonna be blah and I'm not or. By comparison,
- 14:22I'm not or and uh if so, if you're going too far down
- 14:26the movie TV show analogy, it's really like, yeah, look why I'm
- 14:31I'm not the famous one here, what's going on? I'm not the one
- 14:33with all the richest ba. If you're going down the video game thing,
- 14:35it could also be damaging. For example, Columbine comes to mind. They
- 14:41treated their last thing, their last bit of life, as a video game,
- 14:48with all the lack of care that comes with that. Right, And
- 14:52that's that's and they were avid video game players of those kinds of games.
- 14:56Yeah, yeah, so it's it can it can be down imaging in the
- 15:00extreme. Yeah, so I thought about the different usages. I would hear
- 15:05main character, and in one way of using it, people will like,
- 15:11there's a subreddit called I am the main character. Have you seen this?
- 15:15You don't look at? You don't look at. I don't spend most time
- 15:16on Reddit other than when I do a search and there's like a reddit thing
- 15:20there. Well, this subreddit, and I'm pretty sure that's what it's called,
- 15:24but it's something along those lines. People will post videos or stories of
- 15:30people who make themselves the main character when they shouldn't be making them So I
- 15:33see it's Iran. It's like, I see what you're saying. It's almost
- 15:37like they they are entitled, and here's this video showing them being entitled.
- 15:41Right like today or yesterday, there was a video that someone posted and there's
- 15:46zero context, So I have no idea as to whether or not the person
- 15:50in the video was right or wrong. They're either very right or very wrong.
- 15:56I can't tell which one it is. There's but they're that's not in
- 15:58the middle because it's a graduation ceremony. I don't know if it's college or
- 16:02high school or something. But a woman is on stage and she grabs the
- 16:07microphone from what looks to be like a school administrator, maybe the president,
- 16:12I don't know. It's a cordless microphone. And the video starts with her,
- 16:17and you know, there's all the regalia, the gowns and the caps,
- 16:19and this woman is fighting this woman for the microphone, rips it out
- 16:25of her. It's older woman and a younger woman ripping a microphone out of
- 16:29the older woman's hands, and everyone's just kind of standing there in shock.
- 16:33And she starts yelling into the microphone that you snubbed me essentially in this ceremony,
- 16:41and so now I'm going to make up for that fact by angrily yelling.
- 16:45Now, on one hand, it looks like she's a bad person,
- 16:49but who knows, maybe she was absolutely snubbed in a way that would explain
- 16:55this, you know, but at the very least, without any context,
- 16:57it looks very damna for the woman grabbing them. And that's on, you
- 17:02know, I am the Maine. The other way that people use main character
- 17:07is that people will say they don't feel like the main character, meaning like
- 17:11the woman and jo Joane, meaning that they're just drifting through life. They
- 17:15haven't made their own choices, they don't have purpose, they don't have a
- 17:19meeting. They're just doing it everybody else wants for them to do. You
- 17:22know, they don't have any control over their life, that kind of thing.
- 17:26So run a hand, that's a good thing to focus on. On
- 17:29the other hand, no one is the main character of any you know what
- 17:33I mean, Like, I'm not the main character. You're not the main
- 17:36character, you know, in terms of having this this notion that somehow because
- 17:41by definition, every other character is a non player, is a non mainause
- 17:47the humanizing to the rest of the world. Yeah, you in order for
- 17:49you to feel okay with yourself, you have to be the only person in
- 17:52the room, or the or the main person in the story. And it's
- 17:57more like an ensemble like friends. Yeah, I'm just one of seven billion
- 18:04main characters all compared to the universe. Back to the pot, we have
- 18:08a woman Jane doesn't feel like she's the main character in her own stories.
- 18:11She's therapy and she does the bidding of her boss. She's in a safe
- 18:15relationship but doesn't seem to be really into him. There's a former partner of
- 18:19hers that she seems like she might want to be with, but this past
- 18:25guys are very nice to her. It seems like she's kind of disconnected from
- 18:27others. It seems like she's just kind of a stressed out worker who just
- 18:33doesn't really happy with her life. She goes home, she's with her boyfriend.
- 18:37Very typical story. Sit down on a couch, turn on Netflix,
- 18:38but Boom recommends this this this show. What's it called Snuggleberries Stream? Yeah,
- 18:47and I was thinking, okay, well, obviously stream, but are
- 18:51they referring to member Berry? Do you think what's member? You know what
- 18:53member Barry is from south Park? Are you joking? Oh? I forgot
- 18:59the member Marries. I literally forgot the members. You're mister south I know,
- 19:03but I the context through me, So you're right, member Barries.
- 19:06I don't think it. Nah, I don't think so okay, but it's
- 19:07funny that, yeah, I forgot the member Bear. Yeah, that's why
- 19:11I thought you were joking. But your face, I was joking. That
- 19:14was on a super meta joke. So she they start watching Netflix, which
- 19:18is called stream Barry, but let's just call it a Netflix, and she
- 19:23is watching the show called Joan is Awful, and she's watching an amazement,
- 19:27going, oh my god, that's my day today. But it's a little
- 19:33exaggerated. It makes me look worse, and it's starring Samahayak. Sama Hike
- 19:37is playing me in my life right because the show starts and she's like,
- 19:41wait, what this looks like me? That's my name, and and the
- 19:45boyfriend's like, what, no, that's sama Hyak. It's fine, it's
- 19:48a show. Yeah, but the boyfriend doesn't know, doesn't know what's coming.
- 19:52What Joane knows, which is that exact scene happened for me, but
- 19:56it's just played. Okay, So she goes on hygiene. Eventually she discovers
- 20:02that Netflix has been spying on her through her phone. Not Netflix, well,
- 20:06Netflix is a Netflix has been spying on her through her phone, and
- 20:11they have used AI to recreate her life without anyone writing the show that they
- 20:19pumping out the show. The AI gathers the information from you through your phone
- 20:25and writes the story, maybe even purposely making it a little bit more negative.
- 20:30And then Samahayak isn't even acting in the show. They're using a AI
- 20:36representation of Samahayak that Samahaiak is signed off for and Joan has also signed off
- 20:41for in the terms of agreement, saying yes, it's fine. That you
- 20:45actually spy on me and use that exclamation. Neither of them. Well,
- 20:48she definitely doesn't know what she's signed up, right, so um, and
- 20:52she finds out that not only well later she finds out that it's not only
- 20:57her, Joane, but literally almost everyone on the planet has been spied on
- 21:03and an AI generated show has been created or at least spoiler alert, at
- 21:07least in the show she's in. That's true. We don't know in base
- 21:11reality if that's exactly true, but we believe it. I think it's implied.
- 21:15I think it's implied that literally everyone well in the real world, right.
- 21:18But the tricky thing is because in the show they showed that they exaggerate
- 21:22things, so we don't know if it was exaggerated or not. So Berto
- 21:29in twenty years, is as possible to eat barring any kind of pushback from
- 21:33the government or the voters against this kind of spying. Let's say we did
- 21:37hand over that level of privacy to the marketers. Is this possible? Well,
- 21:45yes, as in Black Mirror already, every time we have to look
- 21:49at a Black Mirror episode, we have to understand, well, look,
- 21:52they're dialing it to eleven or twelve so that it can be really entertaining.
- 21:56But the core concept of hey, people are already giving digital you know,
- 22:00Bruce Willis has given digital rights. I just saw Howie Mandel has this thing
- 22:04where he can do a holographic show, and he's right, they've filmed them
- 22:08the whole thing. He signed away that rights. Whatever the point is,
- 22:11So Bruce Willis has said, you can use my three D capture, me
- 22:17use my three D images and as long as as long as my estate signs
- 22:22off, exactly because he's starting to experience some sort of declining decline he's got
- 22:27and so so you know he's saying, yeah, yeah, I approve,
- 22:33because why do you think you sold my estate can make more money or well,
- 22:37also so that his I mean, so that his acting and memory can
- 22:41live on, which is the first kind of immortality, right, It's essentially
- 22:45before there was immortality, was like I wrote about you, so now you're
- 22:48kind of remembered. Then you could be filmed. So now there's like film
- 22:52of you. But this is more, it's like new you on film.
- 22:56It's still not him, but it's still anyways. Stipulations like no porn or
- 23:00something. I'm sure they hopefully you read the contract. But the point is
- 23:06that part's already happening. People writing yes, I will shiek and and her
- 23:11involved exactly, she can already the second part making simulations of videos, Well,
- 23:17that's and it's that's nascent right now, like it can be done with
- 23:19a but not of course a full episode that all makes sense or anything of
- 23:22that. But sure, let's give it ten years or less, depending on
- 23:26right. There are different elements to this that are scarily nascent, as you
- 23:30said, right that you can and for I think not much of a cost
- 23:37to the consumer, to you and I if we just wanted to do this,
- 23:38because I know people who have done this for themselves. Is you go
- 23:42to some AI outfit and you perhaps like for you and I could eventually you
- 23:48and I are gonna this will happen at some point in the next two or
- 23:52three years, you and I, it'll probably be me will go to one
- 23:56of these websites and I will feed in like ten twenty maybe more episodes of
- 24:02the podcast of you and me talking and then the AI just based and then
- 24:07you might give it a query of just like, please write and record a
- 24:11twenty minute episode of psychology shattle with Kirkenburg, right and today, right now,
- 24:17an AI can spit out something in a bit that is noticeably not us
- 24:22and noticeably not an episode of Psychologists yet. But someone who doesn't know wouldn't
- 24:26know. But someone who doesn't know, they potentially wouldn't know. I mean
- 24:29there's a there's especially if you dial it in a little bit more and said,
- 24:33like, well that that what you just spat out at me was a
- 24:34little weird because of this, and you give it some feedback maybe five iterations
- 24:38later. It's not super good, but it's pretty fucking good man. And
- 24:44and your voice can already be matched, right, so not only voice but
- 24:48also like what we might say, and not only voice, but inflection,
- 24:52like it knows how to inflect, especially in our case because there's so much
- 24:56audio right to generally copy the voice. It's gotten so good that you need
- 25:02thirty seconds of audio and you're done. Yeah, but that's just like all
- 25:04the well you didn't know just from that that when they say the word psychology,
- 25:08they go say ecology, you know whatever, But when you listen to
- 25:12you know, thousands and thousands, and then you got it all right,
- 25:15so absolutely that part's done. So then and then and also you have deep
- 25:19fake faces. So right, So maybe in five years you feed it a
- 25:25bunch of video episodes that we've made, right, and then you say,
- 25:29okay, make it a video episode. And actually it gets more general too,
- 25:32because you don't necessarily have to train it on our specific videos. You
- 25:36just need our likeness because it will already be able to do. You could
- 25:38say the setting. You could say, hey, look, put them in
- 25:41a podcasting booth. Here's a couple of photos, maybe one video of them,
- 25:45generate them. That's done. Here's their voice done, and here's their
- 25:51episodes for the content type. Done? Yeah, done right, absolutely right.
- 25:55So that if you would have asked me a few years ago, in
- 26:00my sense of how things were progressing, I would have said, well,
- 26:03that's pretty far off. But seeing me overnight what obviously had been work with
- 26:08a lot of people have been working on for decades and you know, and
- 26:11it also is sort of rewriting my sense of other episodes of Black Mirror,
- 26:15like the episode where the woman loses her husband be right back and Domino Gleason
- 26:25comes back right yeah, And in that episode I remember thinking like, okay,
- 26:29yeah, I could see it because it starts out as a chatbot that's
- 26:33right, and that one's doing you can do that right now. You can
- 26:36do them now, right now. And at the time, I thought,
- 26:38okay, well, we're probably talking you know, fifty years because I was
- 26:42under the assumption that that sort of AI requires, you know, we can
- 26:48go down a whole road of what is sentience, you know that you would
- 26:52need like data from Star Trek level sentience. But it's been demonstrated that you
- 26:57need you know, whatever we call sentience. You don't need anything close to
- 27:03that to create a very convincing version of a person, you know, in
- 27:07terms of what they might say given what is said to them. Right,
- 27:10most humans alive, including most of the researchers in the field, did not
- 27:14anticipate the inflection point that the massive quantities of data would provide without having sort
- 27:22of figured out the secrets behind intelligence, right, because it seems like that
- 27:26was the assumption, like you need that that singularity, if you will,
- 27:30if we're just look at in terms of that language where it becomes self aware
- 27:36and then then you start feeding it information about a person and then it can
- 27:41start to emulate that person. But we have gone through it through the back
- 27:45door where never mind the singularity just based on the data and the machine learning.
- 27:51And you don't even exactly know what the machine learning is learning, but
- 27:55it you just it's a black box that you feed information in and then stuff.
- 28:00Yeah, and you have to tailored a little bit like that's okay,
- 28:03but you know, keep you know, go back to the drawing board black
- 28:06box. But then eventually it starts spitting out Domino Gleason even though he's dead,
- 28:11you know, And so I away that how quickly this is advancing,
- 28:15absolutely, and a lot of it is due to the fact that as humans,
- 28:19how many books can a human read, just even read, let alone
- 28:22remember, right, like in their lifetime if they write a book a day,
- 28:26right that, there's still a limit. You don't come close to reading
- 28:29the library. But so it's it's really hard for a human, any of
- 28:33us, to understand what it means to know all books, to like actually
- 28:37read every single piece of writing on the internet and books that I've been written,
- 28:41all of them and have it basically in short term memory exactly. So
- 28:45what that means all of a sudden, since we can't conceptualize that, it's
- 28:48hard to predict that that would result in something that sounds human. But it
- 28:53kind of makes sense from a data perspective because every combination of words that you
- 28:56could imagine give or take has been put down on paper somewhere or on digital
- 29:02form, at least every combination of words that is likely and we would care
- 29:06about. Hence, yeah, statistically, you can basically predict a pseudo human.
- 29:11Right, It's incredible. So you're right, So you have a lot
- 29:14of these pens in the movie her with exactly like that seemed so far fetched.
- 29:18Now it's basically here, So you have a lot of these pieces.
- 29:21The one part that I think they definitely waved their hands with was the quantum
- 29:26part. They said they did a little bit of the devs thing. They
- 29:29said, because you know, you have to you have to not only do
- 29:33you have to do not only what we're discussing, but also the idea that
- 29:37the cell phone was able to capture enough data to then basically recreate everything seen
- 29:44by scene. Right, It's like, okay, and how did they do
- 29:45it? And that's when they said, well, you know quantum stuff that
- 29:49well there were two hand waving yeah, that, but also that your phones
- 29:53are picking up on everything that you're doing. Well but right, But that
- 29:57was so that's the one where you can see it right, Like, because
- 30:00the phone knows everywhere you are, assuming you haven't turned all these things off,
- 30:03you have GPS, you know everywhere you're going, it conceivably could be
- 30:07listening. You can be listening to you. Now, it can't. It
- 30:10doesn't currently record video, but it could, like you could, so sure
- 30:14there's some hand waving us there. And then the thing is what they might
- 30:17point out as like, wait, we don't need to record video. We
- 30:18have enough other video examples from those workplaces, from the roads, from everything.
- 30:22All we need is the audio and the location, and we're done,
- 30:25right. It could infer right, So yeah, you could, but it's
- 30:29a stretch. And then the quantum part is like, that's how they make
- 30:32it work for all these people all at the same time. They simulate whole
- 30:33world's blah blah blah. But but if we're just talking about computing power and
- 30:40they need a hand wavy thing that you could destroy with an axe, then
- 30:45it's a convenient plot device, it right, Because if it wasn't a quant
- 30:48a delicate quantum computer, and quantum computers are by its nature, at least
- 30:53today, extremely extremely delicate. But if it wasn't that, and it was
- 30:59just regular servers. There are backups on backups, so no axe is going
- 31:03to destroy and there's you know, like to make a story that makes has
- 31:08that story arc that that sort of climax, you need some sort of thing
- 31:14to smash absolutely. And there's also a question whether whether we ever saw base
- 31:18reality at all, Like there might have never been a quantum computer. It's
- 31:21just the thing they called the base reality show is a TV show being computer
- 31:26generated in a more normal version of the future, right right, like in
- 31:30five years there is a show not you know where it's about a real person
- 31:34and that person is suing the company. But they've already blah blah, And
- 31:37that was the thing that they were presenting at the end as being base reality,
- 31:41and there was no real quantum computer, right yeah, And we'll get
- 31:44into that in a second, but going out with the plot here, So
- 31:48she discovers that she's been spied on and that Netflix has been making a show
- 31:52about her, and we'll continue too, and she has no power over it,
- 31:56and the lawyers are saying, yeah, your hands are tied. There's
- 31:59nothing to do. But because of this show, people start hating her.
- 32:01She loses her job because they're watching the show and she's horrible, and she's
- 32:06awful. It's exaggerating her, but it's also revealing things that she will be
- 32:10saying about people behind their backs. So she gets fired. Her boyfriend breaks
- 32:15up with her, people are rejecting her, people are yelling at her on
- 32:19the street, and hijinksinsue. Eventually, she learns that she is just an
- 32:24AI character herself played by Annie Murphy, the actress who plays Joane in the
- 32:31show. The real person. The real Joane breaks into Netflix headquarters with the
- 32:37real Annie Murfried your side, and of course if you watch the episode,
- 32:40you understand why that happened, and she learns that she's a fake Joane.
- 32:45She gets to the computer. She learns that if she breaks the computer,
- 32:47billions of people who believe that they are real will die, including herself and
- 32:52including Samahayaks standing right next to her. Right, all they're all going to
- 32:54die. Right. There's one line that on one hand is very handwavy,
- 32:59but on another hand, correct me if I'm wrong is actually accurate. When
- 33:02the woman says it's a quantum computer, we barely understand it. It's basically
- 33:06magic. So on one hand, that sounds like completely idiotic, because normally
- 33:10when you hear that kind of thing, you're just like no, no,
- 33:13no, no, no, Like engineers understood. Now, of course engineers
- 33:15doing. But isn't it like a little confusing to the engineers in terms of
- 33:20how well it works? I think they were mixing things because you were,
- 33:24first of all, earlier you were eluding how these large language models. It
- 33:29is a little bit like a black box in that. Of course, we
- 33:31fully understand the math of what's happening, but by definition, since no one
- 33:36figured out, oh, this is how intelligence works, here's the little formula
- 33:39equals. Since that's not the case, all we know is data went in
- 33:44the huge matrix, multiplies through with some parameters, and the thing that comes
- 33:47out makes sense somehow. But we still don't have the formula. From that,
- 33:51we can't learn the formula intelligence works. No one dialed in the algorithm
- 33:54exactly the algorithm or or figured itself based on a lot of data that is
- 34:01being fed in and feedback from the outside. Yeah, it's like the algorithm.
- 34:06There is obviously an algorithm to these programs, but the algorithm isn't about
- 34:08how to be a human. The algorithm is how to grab a whole bunch
- 34:12of data and distill a prediction that makes sense. Right, that's the algorithm.
- 34:15Well, so that makes sense, meaning that real humans on the outside
- 34:20click yes or no, that makes sense, which gives it feedback right on
- 34:23how it did with its algorithms, and it further refined that unknown algorithm.
- 34:30That's the humans absolutely designed, and there was a lot of total engineering,
- 34:34but they didn't they didn't purposely design it exactly. You can't ask the engineers
- 34:38that developed the large language models, nor even the engineers currently looking at all
- 34:42the data coming inside. You cannot ask them. Okay, now that you
- 34:45understand how human intelligence fully works, what's the formula that? That's not the
- 34:50thing. But can you just copy the whatever algorithm it? Can you make
- 34:53two two versions of that? Black can grab the trained model, the train
- 34:59model is a whole gigantic matrix of numbers and copy it onto one other machine
- 35:05and it'll operate the same. And it'll operate the same. Yeah, well
- 35:07you again, what you can't do is you haven't It's like what imagine the
- 35:12laws of gravity? Right, But you can't go in there and go like
- 35:15and I'm going to tweak this number and have it work different. Well,
- 35:17they are kind of doing that, but in the you know, ironically,
- 35:21the same way they do it with the brain. They'll poke at it and
- 35:22see what breaks, and then they're like, oh, this area seems to
- 35:25be about this. Yeah, but they don't know what they're poking exactly.
- 35:29Yeah. Yeah, that's It's like when you're looking at gravity. You're like,
- 35:31oh, okay, when we drop things, they fall. So on
- 35:34the one hand, you can write the math of that. Eventually you can
- 35:37say, oh, it seems like it accelerates it blah blah blah. The
- 35:39mass has something to do with it. Okay, but you serawly haven't explained
- 35:43why, right, Okay, Well, in this case, maybe a better
- 35:45analogy, if you will, is you have a car that has a lot
- 35:51of moving parts, and it's complex, especially today's cars. But an engineer
- 35:55and a set of engineers totally understand every element, every physical, every chemical
- 36:00element in that car. It's not confusing to them. They understand it.
- 36:05They might understand some micro bits of it, and if they get a complaint
- 36:07like this car is too bouncy, they know exactly Now. They have to
- 36:13run tests, of course, but they know exactly what to target. You
- 36:15know that the struts and the suspension or the weight or wheelbase or something.
- 36:21Right. And that's very different than the engineering of a language model, right,
- 36:27because it's it's more like a brain like you're saying, it's like,
- 36:30well, let's see what this. I'm pretty sure it's in this area,
- 36:32but we won't know until I start poking around. Yeah, it's it's sure.
- 36:37Yeah, It's like if the car was being used for something not driving.
- 36:40You know, It's like the car is being used for something that happens
- 36:44to work, but you now can't explain why those parts did what it did.
- 36:47Yeah. So yes, and so that's true. And so that's a
- 36:51little hand wavy to say, hey, listen, we know how large language
- 36:54models work, so now we can do all these things. But with the
- 36:57quantum computer, what's funny is today the types of problems that can be solved
- 37:01with quantum computers are not at all the same kinds that can be solved with
- 37:06normal computers. Yeah, I've heard it's like not as good as regular computers
- 37:09with normal computation like mathematics exactly, and a quantum computer. The thing that
- 37:15is true in this whole magic thing, I think is because when you have
- 37:19a quantum calculation, the whole power of it is that, in a sense,
- 37:22it's resolving an infinite set of possibilities into something that's finite. And that's
- 37:28where you could say, oh, that's like magic. So if you combine
- 37:30those two ideas that on the one hand, these large language models and predictive
- 37:32ais and all these things we don't exactly know how they work, and that
- 37:37on quantum computers you're resolving these infinite possibilities to something finite. Yeah, you
- 37:40get something handwavy and magical. Yeah, it would quantum computers. Given our
- 37:47current trajectory regarding technology of AI, would you even need to involve a quantum
- 37:53computer? Is that the application? Because my understanding is a quantum computer might
- 37:58be superior at climate models. Yeah, in theory. So what happens like
- 38:04you, I'm sure you've heard that or maybe you have. But encryption,
- 38:07like when you encrypt something with normal computers, the reason you can't I can't
- 38:12hack your password right now on a normal computer is because the number that you're
- 38:16using to encode that is so big, the math is so big that a
- 38:20normal computer would take the life of the universe because it has to try every
- 38:23single possibility is not going to work, yeah, to never finish, whereas
- 38:28a quantum computer can do it very quickly because it's this again in theory,
- 38:31what it's doing is it's it's using the fact that quantum, the quantum realm
- 38:36literally resolves an infinite set of possibilities into something specific. It's doing that with
- 38:40these set of ranges of numbers that are technically infinite. But then it's going,
- 38:45oh, there's an answer. And that's the part that's a little magical.
- 38:47But but as you can imagine, you have to configure the problem just
- 38:52right. I don't know how long it will take for us to get from
- 38:54what right now, they can configure a massive computer that costs billions of dollars
- 39:00and takes the size of a room with all these things to solve like one
- 39:04problem that they spent like two years configuring, and it goes boom. It's
- 39:07it's sort of solved. It to like it's simulating a full TV show and
- 39:10blah blah blah, because A it's not built to do that and b there's
- 39:15better ways to simulate the TV show with current computers. Right that, Because
- 39:19that's my question is that is that even what quantum computers will be helpful for
- 39:25in that in the future. Or are they using quantic computers in this TV
- 39:30show? You could just be because they just wanted to use it in this
- 39:34show, like something to smash, but and it's like future tech or something,
- 39:38or these quantic computing actually lend itself maybe to that in that the idea
- 39:45at least was in the first iteration of fakery that the quantic computer for Netflix
- 39:51was creating not only a TV show for literally everyone on the planet, but
- 39:57all those people on the first layer of fakery, we're also watching an infinite
- 40:01number of shows. So it's that infinity that maybe they're getting at. Yeah,
- 40:07Okay, it's kind of like how in Dev's Remembering the Dev's TV show.
- 40:10The reason that the quantum computer was necessary for what they were trying to
- 40:14do is they were regress retro. They were rebuilding the universe from today backwards
- 40:20by solving differential equations. Differential equations there's many that are not solvable and certainly
- 40:25not by current computers, but they can be solved in theory by these quantquations,
- 40:30and they were doing it at a scale that's incomprehensible. So similarly to
- 40:35your point of like, if you're trying to simulate quote infinity or very very
- 40:39very large numbers, Yeah, maybe that's where it comes in. But still
- 40:43it's quite hand wavy. But yeah, it's fun. It's a good break.
- 40:46When we get back, let's continue. What do you say, Let's
- 40:49do it all right, we're back from the break. So I want to
- 40:57remind everyone who are patrons you are. Portion of your monthly pledge goes towards
- 41:01various charities that we support, including Petfinder, which helps find homes for needy
- 41:07pets, Plymouth Housing Group which helps to give people homes, Camp ten Trees,
- 41:12which is a camp that provides a safe place where queer youth to have
- 41:15a camp, The Trevor Project, which helps to prevent suicide among queer youth,
- 41:19Special Olympics, National Alliance on Mental Illness, Animal Aid and Rescue Foundation
- 41:24or ARF Prevent Child Abuse, America Animals Lebanon which rescues pets and bay Rout
- 41:30and connects them with loving homes, which is where I got two of my
- 41:32cats. From Environmental Defense Fund, Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund,
- 41:37Wikipedia, and Doctors out Boarders. I support Wikipedia because although there are problems
- 41:44obviously a very much support its mission and its outcomes. Yeah, I've supported
- 41:50Wikipedia for years. Yeah. Also let's get it do an opp Burdo opp.
- 41:57So these people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty. We
- 42:00have Alexis and annual patron all most of these are any So annual patron Alexis
- 42:05from Deep Gap, North Carolina. What Deep Deep Gap annual patron? Danielle
- 42:10from Gabriella, BC, Holly from Indiana, Soul from Manchester, Juliet from
- 42:19Montreal, Ben from Nottingham, Great Britain, Brian from Seattle, Stephanie from
- 42:27Finland. I think it's Finland Fi, Kyoko from Torrence, California. I've
- 42:36talked to Uco Kyoko, Lena from Finland another Finland person. I think Sonia
- 42:42from God Knows, where as Casey from Godnoz or Kim from Gudnos or Samantha
- 42:45from Santa Cruz, California. Who's an equatier patron. Gwentz from Austin,
- 42:49Texas. Gwentz, I like that. I like that named Gwentz from Gwents.
- 42:52You came wait Um James from Baltimore, Maryland. Thank you so much
- 42:59for becoming a patron and staying a patron through thick and thin. Nice.
- 43:02So we have the show Joan and she destroys the content computer so Netflix can't
- 43:08make this content anymore. And she knows that by breaking the computer, she
- 43:13will die. Right, Joan knows that she and she well and she What
- 43:16she realizes too, is that it's not really her making the decision anyways.
- 43:21Yeah, so what she's realizing is that the real Joane is potentially about to
- 43:28do it and that that's going to kill all of Yeah, exactly. So
- 43:31in the moment when I was watching Annie Murphy playing Joane breaking the computer,
- 43:37I was like, yeah, and then we switched to the real life Joan.
- 43:40And then when I was prepping for this episode, I rewatched that scene,
- 43:45I thought, well, the computer is gonna get broken anyway, because
- 43:49the real Joane is going to break the computer. And also the show it
- 43:54doesn't make the I guess it makes the show as it's happening, because if
- 43:58it made it to break the computer, then you know what, right.
- 44:02There's some inconsistencies because, for example, it's not the conversation that they started
- 44:08having with uh the guy from super Bad, Michael Sarah in theory if we
- 44:15are to believe that the other Jane was really base reality Jane, she didn't
- 44:19have said conversation with someone because yes, yeah, yeah, if she did,
- 44:23then she's not base reality. Why because Michael Sarah's character is saying,
- 44:29this is not base reality. There's another Jane. Huh right, yeah,
- 44:32right, that conversation could have only happened going up the chain, right,
- 44:38and so then and we already have we do see that she's alive after well,
- 44:43it's right, And so I hate it when it was just a dream.
- 44:46It's like, come on, like, it's just like one. And
- 44:51I don't even care what Charlie Brooker says, like there are some things when
- 44:54writers jump the shark on their own show. Did they say it was a
- 44:58dream? No? No, I don't know what they say. But for
- 45:01the sake of how I see the show, the real Jane was the real
- 45:06jone. And I guess what happened was she goes to a real computer guy
- 45:10who isn't Michael Sarah but maybe looks kind of like Michael Sarah, and this
- 45:15guy in the real world says something like, uh no, the TV show
- 45:20you're watching is the is the But so I guess so I guess you know,
- 45:25to make it work, the character that one character has a little bit
- 45:31of meta awareness and so well, actually maybe all the employees at Netflix did
- 45:37because the other the CEO or whoever was in charge, she comes in and
- 45:43she says, if you break that, we're all gonna die. So she
- 45:45also knows, so maybe they everyone knows it like some exects. So there's
- 45:52two things we know about the system. One, it's not an exact replica.
- 45:54For one thing, we know it's not exact because that uses different actresses.
- 45:59Also, they're small differences and uh, small differences in dialogue, exaggerations,
- 46:04dramatic exaction, things like that. So we know that number one.
- 46:06Number two, we also know that there is that there is a time delay
- 46:13right at least as percented that there's a slight time delay, or it just
- 46:16doesn't publish it until it could be it right next day. But where it
- 46:21starts falling through the cracks unless you believe that the thing we see at the
- 46:23end isn't base reality, is that that whole conversation with the one going,
- 46:29wait, don't destroy because that'll kill all of us. Well, that can't
- 46:30be exactly the thing that bass Joan was having. But it could have been
- 46:35that the CEO of the Base Reality goes, you're gonna kill you, You're
- 46:37gonna kill a billion people, and that the other Michael Sarah in Base Reality
- 46:40is like, listen, these simulations are blah blah blah, real people blah
- 46:44blah blah. Yeah, so you could you can kind of yeah, I
- 46:46guess I don't remember. I didn't scrutinize this. The CEO might have actually
- 46:51been saying the same thing in it, just a slight tweak to the center,
- 46:54or maybe not even I didn't. I didn't because I think she said
- 46:58kill all of us, and she said she know, she said billions of
- 47:00people who believe. Oh, I see, she didn't say in fact,
- 47:04you know, CEO, don't say me. So maybe Michael Sarah is the
- 47:07only one who actually has a meta understanding of even who because he says,
- 47:13I'm played by Michael Sarah. Yeah, but in the real war, is
- 47:17Selma Hyak is still in character on her side? Right. The other thing
- 47:22that was weird is at the end after that in the end credits, when
- 47:24they're rolling the credits, they show those other scenes. Did you see those
- 47:29those pieces? Yeah? And they show at one point, they show her
- 47:31the bass Joan talking to the actress, the bass actress, what's her name?
- 47:37And any uh, what's the Annie Murphy? Yeah, any Murphy.
- 47:40So they're talking and then it says Jones cafe like zooms out, it says
- 47:44Jones, which looked like a show, like like a little show logo intro
- 47:49um. And at the end they also show people recording the quote unquote bass
- 47:53Joan defecating in the church with their cell phones, and that seemed to be
- 47:59another kind of reality show. So I'm left one ring like if we ever
- 48:04even saw base reality. That's one of the things. Yeah, I know
- 48:06we've been over this real, but I don't. I don't like that because
- 48:09of course anyone could say, you could literally say anything, like when people
- 48:14say that they believe we're in a simulation, right, it's like, yeah,
- 48:20we could be in a simulation. Let's move on with our lives.
- 48:22Well, but oh sure, I'm just saying that they didn't leave zero clues
- 48:27that that might be the case. Is it was what I was saying,
- 48:30the fact that they will because you know, the when in the church when
- 48:35the I'm just gonna say real, Jane takes a dump in the middle of
- 48:37the church. Yea, yeah, there are people filming who presumably uploaded it
- 48:42to TikTok or something, and that's what they're watching. Sure. Yeah.
- 48:46Look. The other thing about this is I actually thought the show was going
- 48:50to take it in a different direction when she finds out that they're making all
- 48:53the other shows, because I thought what they were going to say is like,
- 48:57look, we thought of making positive content, but everyone is horrible or
- 49:00something like this, right, like, look at all these lives. Look
- 49:04at you. You think you're good, Look at you are doing this.
- 49:06You're doing this, you're doing this. That was one thing I thought they
- 49:08were going to do. And then the other thing I had thought a little
- 49:10earlier in the show, you know, when she first realizes that if she
- 49:14does something terrible, maybe Selmahayak will go and complain. I thought that the
- 49:19arc was going to go that. At first she does that, selmahiaks complain
- 49:21nothing else, and then they finally either her or them together realize maybe we
- 49:25gotta be good people because that's boring, and they'll cancel the show. I
- 49:30thought they were going to go in that direction. Well, and the show
- 49:35the computer but purposely manipulated it to make Joan look bad, right, Like
- 49:40the first time Joan accidentally drops her bait pen and they made it worse.
- 49:45But then the selmahiak throws it at her. So it's even if you were
- 49:50to do good things, presumably the computer just would have made mad. Yeah.
- 49:54So the real Joane is prosecuted and she's under house arrest and she's in
- 50:00therapy and she learned something. It's kind of subtle actually because it's in the
- 50:04end credits, right, Yeah, and she learns something from watching her life
- 50:07on the TV show. I think that's implied that she wanted to be the
- 50:12main character, but she wanted to be good. She wanted to enjoy her
- 50:16life. I think that's what she learned. It's like, I'm I'm not
- 50:20grabbing a control of my own life, you know. So she opens her
- 50:22own coffee shop. Now, I wish that they would have had it a
- 50:25little bit more subtle, because it's kind of a Hollywood ending. I find
- 50:30it to be this aspect of our culture, maybe of younger people. I
- 50:34don't know, but if you, for example, opened a coffee shop,
- 50:37I would be terribly concerned for you. Not because opening a coffee shop is
- 50:42bad but opening a coffee shop, I don't think one makes you a lot
- 50:45of money too. There's bills all the time, the lease of the building,
- 50:52the heat, the employees you've got to deal with. Not because you
- 50:55can't pay your employees that much because you're not making that much. I'm not
- 50:58saying everyone. I'm saying like, if you've ever been a manager or a
- 51:02business owner where you've had to employ people, yes, nine out of ten
- 51:07people they're fine, but one out of ten end up being a problem because
- 51:10you can't vet everyone perfectly and it ruins your life. You know, like
- 51:15all sorts of things go wrong. So you know, if someone came to
- 51:17me and said, I want to be the main character of my life,
- 51:20at what should I do? Opening your own entrepreneur thing would not be the
- 51:25first thing I would recommend off the top of my head. You know,
- 51:29you can absolutely be the main character being a drone for a company. You
- 51:32know you can absolutely put in your time and try to push back. But
- 51:37you know you can't win them all. But at least you are purposeful about
- 51:42the choices you make in your life that Okay, this one I'll give into
- 51:44the bosses, but this one I'm not going to or she's it would have
- 51:46been in my version of the best story, she would be at the same
- 51:50job. They would have rehired her, and she has to fire someone,
- 51:52but this time she's less of a dick about This is, by the way,
- 51:55where I was thinking the show was going to go, which is I
- 51:59thought that the uncher Berry or whatever it's called. I thought their whole goal
- 52:01with squat Squatsberry, I thought their whole goal was to teach people, through
- 52:07their own viewing addiction and addiction to reality and stuff, teach them that they
- 52:12just need to be good people, right, And so to your point,
- 52:14not only good people, but also just a little bit more intentional with with
- 52:19your life. And so in that ending that you foresee the same thing like
- 52:22where it would have been, like, oh, okay, and then in
- 52:23a way everything gets a little more quote boring, but it's good. It's
- 52:28it's a good boring. It's like, you're nice to people, you don't
- 52:30have so much drama because you're a mean bich Okay. The other thing is
- 52:37I agree with you that it's weird that she was this professional in the tech
- 52:42industry and she goes through this horrible experience, but now her being the main
- 52:45character is like running a coffee shop. It's like wait what And the other
- 52:51thing that bothered me, but then I guess I kind of understood is do
- 52:53you remember when she first gets home before they watch the scruntch Er Little Berry
- 52:59and her her boyfriend feeds her the food he's cooked, so she just got
- 53:05done telling you know, the therapists like even the food is bland, right,
- 53:08and she tasted? She goes, is that salt? Right? When
- 53:13they When that scene happened, at first, it bothered me because I'm like,
- 53:15well, that's on the nose, because like, why would you say
- 53:17that that's an insult? Right? Well, that's the comedy, but that's
- 53:22because it's a show. Then I later I was like, oh, it's
- 53:24a show, that's why it was written that way. Oh right, So
- 53:28the real Jane would have said something like a little different, right, Yeah
- 53:32right? Actually I thought about that, like, because Sam a high X
- 53:36version was worse than any Murphy, so the real Jane might have actually been
- 53:43pretty nice. So how bad is the hundredth reality like murdering everyone? Um?
- 53:51So I want to I just want to. I feel like I just
- 53:52need to summarize what I was saying earlier because it wasn't solidified in my head
- 53:55and it could come across as bad. But when I saw Joan in a
- 54:00coffee shop, given my experience in my little niche of the world, all
- 54:04I had was concerned for her that she will go into debt opening a business
- 54:08that won't succeed because most I think half of restaurants, including coffee shops,
- 54:13are out of business within a couple of years, and the owners worked themselves
- 54:16to the bone, they call in a lot of favors and go into debt,
- 54:22and at the end of that process they're worse off. And even if
- 54:24it succeeds. I know people, I'm a friend of a friend who he
- 54:29owns like twenty thirty restaurants in the United States and a lot of them in
- 54:34Seattle, like nice restaurants. And when you hear about that, you're like,
- 54:37oh, well, that guy, that guy owns crazy twenty fifty restaurant
- 54:40he owns he owns I won't say which, but he owns a very successful
- 54:45chain that you and I have been to, Okay, and it's a fancy
- 54:47restaurant, like you'd think, wooh, that's just got to be amazing and
- 54:51In fact, if I went there with you, I might have might have
- 54:53name dropped him got free stuff once, and so you think, oh,
- 54:59man, I must just be so fancy. He is. He every from
- 55:04everything I understand, every day, every hour, every minute of every day.
- 55:07He is constantly stressed out about scraping by because there's not a lot of
- 55:14margins, and there's a lot of overhead, and there's a lot of problems
- 55:16because it's been with a lot of employees and people getting food poisoning, and
- 55:22you know, there's it's just really stressful. But if you are on the
- 55:25customer side, and even or the employee side, and you've never been on
- 55:30the other side, you think they must have it all, you know.
- 55:31I'd i'd a similar thing that happened to me when I was a professor and
- 55:36not the boss of the professors. I looked up to my my other mentor,
- 55:39Paul David, and said, man, he must have it all.
- 55:43He's boss of all. But he's he's the boss of dozens of professors,
- 55:46he's in charge of hundreds of students. He can do whatever he wants,
- 55:51and often his decisions annoy me, you know, but I can't say anything
- 55:54because he's the boss man, it must be really I never wanted to be
- 55:58the boss actually, because I knew it was a little stressful, but he
- 56:01really wanted me to take over for him, and so for ten years he
- 56:05really like built me up and taught me the ways, and a lot of
- 56:08it I just did out of favor to him because I just felt like I
- 56:12had to and I was into it. But it only took me about a
- 56:16year once I did become boss that I was like, oh, this is
- 56:22horrible. Okay, yes, I quote unquote have power, but if no
- 56:27one likes you when you're the boss, you can't get anything done. And
- 56:30so I found out that in that position I felt more subservient to more people
- 56:37than I had ever before. Oh yes, because I had to have my
- 56:40professors, who technically I'm the boss of, I had to have them do
- 56:45things for me, you know, in their own time. You know.
- 56:47I would have to give them a directive and they would have to go do
- 56:50it, and if they didn't do it, it was my fault. It
- 56:52was your responsibility. So I'm beholden to them. So now they can call
- 56:57in a lot of favors from me of what it was like. Well,
- 56:59I mean not directly, but I would have to really massage things with them
- 57:04because you know, they don't professors or I'm one of them, prima donnas.
- 57:07You know, we don't like to be told where are the masters of
- 57:10our own universe? Because students love less, you know, and so we
- 57:14don't like to be told what to do. And the other thing is is
- 57:15when I was an employee, when I was not the boss, I usually
- 57:20did what I was told. I found out I was kind of weird.
- 57:22Maybe that's why I became boss. Became boss when I didn't want to,
- 57:25because you're like, oh, everyone does what you tell them. Yeah,
- 57:28And I found out so not only professors, but you kind of feel below
- 57:30students because if they could plain against you or they leave your school and the
- 57:36revenue goes down, then it's blamed on you. You're now subservient to all
- 57:39the other departments in the school. I mean not subservient, but you're beholden
- 57:43you depend on them. Whereas when I was just a professor, I basically
- 57:46just had to work with other people kind of and I had one boss.
- 57:51I only had to work with my boss. And I was boss, I
- 57:52had to deal with hundreds of people and it was the worst. I mean
- 57:58when I so, when I graduated at high school, I worked as a
- 58:02carpet cleaner. And at first that summer it was a dream come true because
- 58:06I was working at McDonald's prior to that, making four fifty an hour,
- 58:09and here I was making seven dollars an hour. What year would this was?
- 58:14Ninety three? Oh yeah? And then guess what, that's good money.
- 58:17I worked overtime time and a half, baby ten fifty Are you kidding
- 58:22me? So a few years later, Bob and I get our first jobs
- 58:24as therapists. Bob's first job as a therapist paid fifty cents more than that.
- 58:30Wow. So I'm sitting there just to tell you how a little therapists
- 58:35get paid when I first graduate. So I'm sitting there enjoying life, you
- 58:38know. And I am I am an assistant, so I'm not the driver
- 58:43of the vehicle. And there's things I'm not allowed to do. So when
- 58:45we get to the houses, I can take the pads out of the truck,
- 58:50I can help take all the equipment out. I can vacuum, I
- 58:52can rake. I'm not allowed to use the main machine. I'm not allowed
- 58:57to accept the money from the customer. The driver's the one that accepts the
- 59:00money, does the main business, and I'm not allowed to drive the truck,
- 59:02but the driver gets commission. So while I'm sitting there the first month,
- 59:07I'm like just loving life and slowly jealousy, Hey, jealousy. I
- 59:10start thinking, Man, would it be nice to be a driver? Look
- 59:15at that? They look at them. Mama sits. That's the way you
- 59:17do it. You get money for nothing and your percentage cut for free.
- 59:22So I'm thinking, I want to be a driver. That's that's the life
- 59:25right there. Guess what I eventually got my wish. I became a driver
- 59:31and it was horrible. Dude, Why I gotta do all the driving?
- 59:36Number one? I can't sit there and chill in the passenger seat. I'm
- 59:38responsible for the vehicle and everything that happens to it. I'm responsible for whether
- 59:45See before, I worked on an hourly basis. If they cancel the job
- 59:49that day, guess what I still got paid. The drivers work on commission.
- 59:52If we didn't do the job. The commission of zero is zero.
- 59:57Right If they complain they lane about the driver, the assistant doesn't care.
- 1:00:01They don't care. It's the driver. Driver, driver, all the responsibility
- 1:00:06for margin. Ye, I feel like that maybe a lot of of course,
- 1:00:10a lot of people because of just the opportunities, they are never given
- 1:00:15an opportunity to be in that driver position. And so I don't know,
- 1:00:20but you tell me if you think this makes sense that a lot of people
- 1:00:22are out there in that position maybe their whole life where they're envious of the
- 1:00:28boss, they're envious of the owner of the coffee shop. It just looks
- 1:00:31so awesome. Actually, I had another Okay, this is totally off topic,
- 1:00:36I guess, but this is very important for me. It was life
- 1:00:39changing. So when I was growing up I loved music. I thought,
- 1:00:44well, I know, it's not really possible to make a living as a
- 1:00:47musician, and this year a session musician and I'm not that good. And
- 1:00:51so you know, I'm twenty one years old and I'm thinking I'm not going
- 1:00:54to be the next Billy Corgan. It's just not going to happen. So
- 1:00:58what could I do? Well, I knew enough about the music industry to
- 1:01:01know that people owned their own recording studios and they owned the place they owned.
- 1:01:08And that looks sweet, doesn't it. Yeah, Because as a musician
- 1:01:13and as a recording artist myself. I had in college. I had this
- 1:01:16really jankie but kind of at least for the time, a sophisticated home recording
- 1:01:23student. I had, you know, tapes and you know processing and instruments
- 1:01:29and sound places, and I thought, man, that would just be the
- 1:01:32best because I could play with other musicians, I could work, I would
- 1:01:36have all that equipment. My own band could record there. Well, we
- 1:01:39meet, incidentally, this drug dealer who became we were friends with him,
- 1:01:45and he had a lot of money from drug dealing. You know, I
- 1:01:50guess looking back, questionable ethics as to why you'd be friends with someone like
- 1:01:54that. And I don't know his his selling ethics, you know, selling
- 1:01:58to kids or whatever. I don't all had friends in the gray zones of
- 1:02:01life. But he sold hard and soft. He sold it all and made
- 1:02:07a lot of money, and he wanted to pay for our you know,
- 1:02:13it's during the grungy or so. Yeah. I think he thought of it
- 1:02:15as one he could just because he wanted to be part of the crowd,
- 1:02:22you know, he wanted to play a part, and it was his kind
- 1:02:24of way in socially, I think, because you know, when you're in
- 1:02:29a band. You know a lot of people I saw anyway, And also
- 1:02:30I guess maybe he thought he might actually strike it rich if he owns the
- 1:02:35contract, because a lot of bands of Seattle are being signed the time.
- 1:02:37Anyway, So he we work with him, and he says, yeah,
- 1:02:42I'll pay for you to record, and so he gets this pretty snazzy total
- 1:02:47one of the top of the line recording studios and s battle in Ballard actually
- 1:02:51and sets us up to record there. We go into the studio and the
- 1:02:54owner actually lived upstairs and so and some old school Seattle people. I even
- 1:03:00know the exact studio I'm talking about, and if you know which one,
- 1:03:02please email me because I've actually tried to look this up. And anyway,
- 1:03:07so yeah, I end up talking to him and I'm like, oh my
- 1:03:10god, you're living You're living in my dream. You're living the life.
- 1:03:13Because he wasn't even that much older than us, I know, he's maybe
- 1:03:15dirty or twenty eight, And I'm like, you own your own recurses.
- 1:03:19This is so awesome, you know. Tell me, like, how do
- 1:03:22I get to be you? And he's like, uh, you do not
- 1:03:25want to be me? Like I hate my life and let me tell you
- 1:03:30why I can't play music anymore because literally, seven days a week I'm terrified
- 1:03:37that one of the band, one of the outfits that have rented to Space,
- 1:03:40won't show up and won't pay the bill, and I can't pay the
- 1:03:44least in two weeks and I'm out of business and all my debt will just
- 1:03:47completely hound me with the rest of my life. I'm in a constant state
- 1:03:52of stress. Yeah, And I'm like, well, how good is are
- 1:03:54you? Like ramping up? He's like, no, We're full all the
- 1:03:58time. Yeah, I've made it. This is this is the tip of
- 1:04:01the mountain. I've I can't There's nowhere to go from here, and I
- 1:04:06wish I never would have done this, Oh my gosh. And I heard
- 1:04:09him and I thought, so, you know, in my warped normal,
- 1:04:15warped sense of lack of awareness, like it just looked like this paradise,
- 1:04:20but when you get there, it fucking sucks. And so when I saw
- 1:04:24Joan in a coffee shop, I was like, ah, I mean,
- 1:04:27Joan, do you know worry about you? I went through that lesson.
- 1:04:30So my friend Eric, whom you know in college, we had a band
- 1:04:35and we thought, so, here's the deal. To make it. We
- 1:04:39gotta record a record. That makes sense, right, So we gotta record
- 1:04:42a record. But why go pay someone money to record? Why don't we
- 1:04:45build our own studio. We thought, oh, yeah, that makes sense.
- 1:04:48And he had gotten a little bit of money from his grandma passed away.
- 1:04:51He had not a lot, but just a little bit of money.
- 1:04:54And we're like, great, idea, let's just spend money on recording gear.
- 1:04:58We'll set it up. We were renting this house that had a basement.
- 1:05:00We're like, we'll set up in the basement. But to make it
- 1:05:03work financially, we need to record some people, right, But we'll mostly
- 1:05:08record our stuff and then we'll get some people to come in and pay us.
- 1:05:12Oh my god. So I became the lead engineer and I learned more.
- 1:05:15I've I've forgotten more about recording that I'll ever know. And you know,
- 1:05:18we had a man. No, I don't think you've ever hold told
- 1:05:21me, because I I haven't. At the time I met you, you
- 1:05:25had a very yeah, but that was on the way down of all that.
- 1:05:28You had a very very I mean you have microphones that were ten grands,
- 1:05:31right, right, and you had all the bells and you still do.
- 1:05:34Yeah, but this was before all that. These were like we had
- 1:05:38sures and I'm just saying, yeah, this is the precursor, the precursor.
- 1:05:41We had a Mackie twenty four channel console, we had the nice you
- 1:05:45know, uh event twenty twenty speakers, the whole thing, and I became
- 1:05:48the lead engineer. And at first I was so excited. We were so
- 1:05:51excited. We were We started getting clients and like everything you're saying rings so
- 1:05:57true, because you start getting clients, Okay, first they canceling you.
- 1:06:00Then they do show up, but they show up and they're very inefficient and
- 1:06:02it takes forever to set them up. Then they don't have the songs like
- 1:06:05fully written, and then and then you think you're billing them by the hour,
- 1:06:09but like they're they're poor, so that you're making deals with them.
- 1:06:13And then then they record and they're not happy with the results, so you
- 1:06:16have to like record now it feels like it's your faults, like you gotta
- 1:06:19do it for free. Then you get literally insane people. We had a
- 1:06:23person who was more like an R and B and every time he's sang it
- 1:06:29sounded beautiful to us. He was never happy with it. He would say,
- 1:06:32erase it, and we're like, listen, it's digital. We don't
- 1:06:34have to raise it. I know, erase it all start from scratch.
- 1:06:38I don't want it to existactly, it was these nightmares. We never made
- 1:06:42money with it. We barely got to record harm music, complete waste of
- 1:06:46time. Yeah, and then we and you spent how many thousands of dollars
- 1:06:50some stuff. Now, I did learn a lot in about recording, so
- 1:06:56that's I'll take that with me. But as far as like the dream of
- 1:07:00having the studio, I'm like, oh boy, so Berto, let's take
- 1:07:01a break. What do you say? Let's do it all right? Back
- 1:07:08from the break. Okay, so Berto, let's say that the Michael Sarah
- 1:07:12character in the episode right, We're too. For whatever reason, a glitch
- 1:07:18in the quantum computer decides to convince Joan and Samahayek to become patron of podcast.
- 1:07:26What would you sound like? Okay, okay, okay, hold on,
- 1:07:29hold on, before you do anything drastic, you gotta listen to me.
- 1:07:32I know you think you are who you are, and that makes sense.
- 1:07:36You know we all think that, but you're not. I'm this is
- 1:07:41gonna blow your mind. I'm actually here it looks like I'm mean, but
- 1:07:45I'm not really me. I'm an actor. My name I am. I
- 1:07:49actually don't work in this stuff here. But but you think you are who
- 1:07:54you are because you're also not in base reality. There's someone below you.
- 1:07:59Oh, I know, it's freaky, but there's a way through this,
- 1:08:01trust me. There's a way. You just gotta become a patriot. I
- 1:08:05know. But you just gotta become a patron psychology in Seattle. That will
- 1:08:11bring us back to base reality. Man, you're almost as good as a
- 1:08:15chat boat. All right, let's get back to what we were talking about.
- 1:08:19Okay, this is completely off topic from black beer, but this is
- 1:08:24a very important psychological topic. Yeah, and it's very personal to me.
- 1:08:27So I have another example is that everyone wants, or at least in Seattle.
- 1:08:31I don't know about other places. But if you're a guy of a
- 1:08:35certain lifestyle, the one thing you always want and always wanted was your own
- 1:08:43boat. Oh like, whether it's a ski boat or a sailboat, or
- 1:08:48because you have your boat, you see the movies you see at seafair,
- 1:08:55You see if they can throw the parties on the boat. Yeah, and
- 1:08:58you just think, oh, you can tell people, hey, come on
- 1:09:00my boat, Come on my boat. You could just you could just get
- 1:09:03in your boat and just drive off into the sunset and it's just the best.
- 1:09:09Okay. So I would have been there at some point, but my
- 1:09:14friends bought boats way before I could have even thought about buying my boat.
- 1:09:18And I was very close to these friends. Sometimes I even were was roommates
- 1:09:23with these guys, you know, back in the nineties, and quickly learned
- 1:09:27how shitty it was to own a boat. Constant maintenance problems, right,
- 1:09:34also very expensive, you know, the mooring, and also but the gas.
- 1:09:40I mean, we would let's go on the boat on Saturday. Okay,
- 1:09:44well who has who has fifty dollars? Because all of you have to
- 1:09:49give fifty dollars because that's how much it's gonna cost to fill it, and
- 1:09:55that'll get us three. And sometimes we ran out of gas because we couldn't
- 1:09:59afford. We were using the paddles trying to get our way back, uh,
- 1:10:03you know, through the cut in free We're trying to get back to
- 1:10:06the launch I think, in ballot and no gas and we're just we're all
- 1:10:11paddling. And also being on a boat, it can be euphoric. It
- 1:10:15could be really great times, but there could also be some really shitty times.
- 1:10:18Chopping waters, rain, dealing with other boat people, um, who
- 1:10:25knows, there's just other problems wind and da dada, and in the storing
- 1:10:30of the boat and where to put it. And so very quickly I learned,
- 1:10:34oh the reality of that. And the problem is, you know,
- 1:10:39there's a lot of things in life like that. But the but the difference,
- 1:10:42the theme here is that there's often a barrier of power or money or
- 1:10:46something. And because of that, even though so many people want to be
- 1:10:50a boss, so many people want to be a driver of the van,
- 1:10:55so many people want a boat, but they can never get it, and
- 1:10:58so they only have the fantasy. They only have what they think of it
- 1:11:02to be like. And very few people actually cross that line and report back
- 1:11:08and say, do not cross this line. It sucks. Now. I
- 1:11:12will throw a slight wrench in all this, which is that if you find
- 1:11:15something you love, even if it's owning a studio, owning a boat,
- 1:11:18owning whatever, and that's what fulfills you, then all that work, pain
- 1:11:23and suffering, even if you ever just break even or even lose money,
- 1:11:26that's what you love, that's what you love, right, I guess it's
- 1:11:30sort of like being married, right. Yeah. If you're lonely and you
- 1:11:34want a companion and you see people in companionships and movies and in your personal
- 1:11:40life, you're like, oh, that looks great. But then you actually
- 1:11:43jump maybe too fast into a relationship thinking I want the companionship, and you
- 1:11:47don't stop to think what are the downsides? And am I up for actually
- 1:11:54dealing with those downsides? Yeah? As I look my friend who's here.
- 1:11:58I have a friend from Columbia, as you know, visiting. He's owned
- 1:12:00his own business in Columbia for I don't know, twenty years or something.
- 1:12:05He sells PC equipment and computer stuff and things. It's hard work, he
- 1:12:13tells me. All of it's hard, all that, Like I wouldn't want
- 1:12:15to do it. It's not. But but you know, on the surface,
- 1:12:18like what we've been talking about, like, oh, I own my
- 1:12:20own company. I s but he loves being his own boss. He's really
- 1:12:27it's his thing. Yeah. Yeah. So for me, I own a
- 1:12:30business called this podcast, and there's a lot of annoyances, but I love
- 1:12:35the crap out of it. You have a version of this I mean,
- 1:12:39I don't know if you want to go to specifics, but let's just say
- 1:12:42you broke off, you broke away from working as an employee right fifteen years
- 1:12:47ago and said I want I want to do this on my own, Right
- 1:12:51I can. I can because there's look, there's way too many logos in
- 1:12:56the world to advertise stuff. And I'm like, what about anti logos and
- 1:12:59said, but it was my dream. It was the originally employee, that's
- 1:13:01right, working for a logo ploy company. H Then you're like, what
- 1:13:04if I was my own business, I would make and it seems easy.
- 1:13:09Yeah, and uh, you know, correct me if I'm wrong. You
- 1:13:14know, in the mid ots, you're thinking I could do this better.
- 1:13:17I could make more money, right, Um, I wouldn't have to deal
- 1:13:20with the bullshit. Yes, if I owned, if I did it myself,
- 1:13:25Man, this is just good. I mean, I don't know where
- 1:13:28your head was at, but if you could go back, I'm guessing you
- 1:13:30don't regret it though. No. I ultimately, well a I've I've come
- 1:13:35to not regret my life. And for those who don't know, it wasn't
- 1:13:40long maybe two or two years. It was two years where you're like shit,
- 1:13:43I have to go back to be an employee because this doesn't workings,
- 1:13:46Yeah, and it was. It was really something that I needed to try
- 1:13:49to learn what I wanted to do, not wanted to do what was good
- 1:13:54at it was not good at. And you know, one of the things
- 1:13:57that you were alluding to in all these examples is that the only things we
- 1:14:00usually see when we see someone else or when we see it in movies or
- 1:14:02whatever, are the positives, because by default, you just don't see the
- 1:14:06mess in the kitchen, right, But there's so much mess in the kitchen.
- 1:14:12And if you're happy doing it, like if that's what you want to
- 1:14:14do, but if you're not ready for it, or if there's other things
- 1:14:17you gotta like maybe mature, or maybe it's just not a thing you actually
- 1:14:20want to do, Yeah, then the glamour quickly fades away. Right,
- 1:14:25I think that's it, the glamour. Yeah, Like when I see someone
- 1:14:29like Elon Musk or whoever, you know, those those sorts of folks.
- 1:14:32Now that I know more about what it's like to be in that position of
- 1:14:38power, so to speak, all I see are just constant headaches, at
- 1:14:42least for me anyway. And so like another part of this actually related an
- 1:14:46episode about Black Mirror. Just I don't know what we would call this topic.
- 1:14:50It'd be like life fulfillment, it'd be it's something like wrongful, upward
- 1:14:57mobility, illusion, envy like because there's the word envy has to be in
- 1:15:02there, in there, misplaced envy for the upper for power or for something.
- 1:15:10Well, although, okay, so it is, you know it is.
- 1:15:12It's kind of power related, not like I want power over others,
- 1:15:15but I want I want to be the main character Bardo. I want to
- 1:15:18I don't want to work for anyone. I want to work for myself.
- 1:15:21And it's just like, there are a lot of fucking benefits to working for
- 1:15:25someone else because that someone else has to deal with headaches that you do not
- 1:15:29have to deal with, not everywhere but often. Although yeah, I see
- 1:15:32that. I wonder if there is a thing here though, and maybe this
- 1:15:34is what they were trying to do with the coffee shop. As an example,
- 1:15:39years ago, you're one of your predecessors in one of the things you
- 1:15:44did for for a school, right, that person was a psychologist or a
- 1:15:47therapist, and they were an educator, and one day they decided they wanted
- 1:15:53to quit and become a carpenter. Right. So, I mean, look,
- 1:15:57the idea of being a carpenter to me doesn't sound appealing at all.
- 1:15:59I can't do it. First of all, I'm not good at it.
- 1:16:00A second, it just sounds like so boring. I don't know, mind
- 1:16:03numbing. I don't know, I don't I'll say you're a very smart dude.
- 1:16:06You could probably do a lot of things carpentry is. But I wonder
- 1:16:11if you literally can't probably wouldn't excel carpentry. The things you say that are
- 1:16:16related to that, Yeah, working with your hands area, right, I
- 1:16:20just don't think. I mean, it would take me another twenty years maybe
- 1:16:24to just kind of get started. Yeah listen. But when this person talked
- 1:16:29about it, they it was their dream. Yeah right, So I kind
- 1:16:32of wonder there is that upward mobility that you're bringing up, but there is
- 1:16:36also this thing that what the confusion between Wait, why do you want to
- 1:16:41do this? Because if the reason that you want to open the coffee shop
- 1:16:45is because, man, when you were a kid, your uncle always came
- 1:16:48with a fresh coffee and it made your family so happy, and you want
- 1:16:51to provide that. Okay, great, and are you okay for the first
- 1:16:56five years, so maybe indefinitely actually living on an income that is say,
- 1:17:01below average for your town, and you can never move out of your rental
- 1:17:06like it would you take it. A lot of people who are truly into
- 1:17:13that life's, you know, that life of owning a coffee shop or something,
- 1:17:15they would say yeah. I mean, for example, for me,
- 1:17:18yeah, starting this you too as well, but me, because I did
- 1:17:23know a lot more of the work. We did this podcast for seven eight
- 1:17:26years losing money, so obviously I really wanted to do a podcast, right,
- 1:17:31So if some you know, and I remember people would ask me,
- 1:17:34and I would often ask myself, do you want to make this podcast for
- 1:17:39the rest of your life even though it makes you no money? I repeatedly
- 1:17:42every day for that full seven eight years, said yes, I love it.
- 1:17:46I love to do this stuff. It's so gratifying on so many levels.
- 1:17:50I got to connect with people, I got to learn things, I
- 1:17:51get to express myself, I get to interact with people around the world.
- 1:17:56I feel like I'm contributing to society kind of, and absolutely I want to
- 1:18:00do this even if I'm losing money. So when I started making money and
- 1:18:03it increased the amount of work for it and thus increased the amount of headaches.
- 1:18:09Obviously, it was worth it to me because I was willing to do
- 1:18:11it without any money at all. And I think, Okay, I think
- 1:18:13that's a lot of the disconnect is that since we don't live in an infinite
- 1:18:16resources environment, so they're actually for example, if three hundred million people in
- 1:18:23this country, including babies, I guess, decided they wanted to open a
- 1:18:27recording studio, guess what, that's impossible. Yeah, that that's impossible by
- 1:18:32a factor of like one hundred, you know, Like, so it just
- 1:18:35doesn't work. So not everyone can do everything. Take meaning that not everyone
- 1:18:41can be the boss the boss or ask that or like take professionals. Most
- 1:18:45people need to be employees. To be the top NBA player or even one
- 1:18:49of the top NBA players, first of all, you have to start young.
- 1:18:51You have to do nothing other than basketball period, just everything, and
- 1:18:55then you have to get extremely lucky and then continue to get extremely lucky well,
- 1:18:59and then the funnel funnels funnels, funnels funnels, right, So to
- 1:19:02think that, but that's one way. I think that's what model that I
- 1:19:05want to counter a little bit because it implies that everyone that gets to those
- 1:19:11envied positions are somehow the best of the best. They're they're often not the
- 1:19:15In fact, research shows they're not necessarily the best of the best, but
- 1:19:18they just for whatever reason, get there or want to be there. Well
- 1:19:21fair, but it's probably the case that most of them had to work their
- 1:19:25asses off. Maybe yeah, I mean, especially in professional sports. I
- 1:19:28mean, you know, you don't have to, but to be a mid
- 1:19:30level manager in charge of one hundred people, you don't necessarily have to be
- 1:19:34good at the job. That certainly there. But the kinds of things we're
- 1:19:39talking about is because like when you think I want to own a recording studio,
- 1:19:42in your mind, what you mean is like, that's super awesome,
- 1:19:45super successful. With all the gracy, awesome recording stude stars come there's like
- 1:19:49one of those, and that one's probably still breaking even right with the sports
- 1:19:54stars. Is what I'm saying. Is like, if you're like, I'm
- 1:19:56going to be in the NBA, well, I mean, there's like not
- 1:19:58that many people in the world that can be NBA players, and it takes
- 1:20:00their whole life effort, and people should consider the realistic nature of their dreams
- 1:20:06or just or just you know, be taught because they you know, we
- 1:20:10can't be born with this infant. We all can't be the main character.
- 1:20:13Well you can, it's just the main the main character of every role is
- 1:20:16not available. Not everyone on Earth can be Michael Jordan, Not everyone on
- 1:20:20Earth can be whatever. So so I think this is one of the main
- 1:20:24characters. You don't have to be the boss. You could be the main
- 1:20:27character as an employee, right, But since so many of us are sitting
- 1:20:30there wishing that we are that specific thing that we see right there. Like
- 1:20:34take a company, any normal company that's hierarchical. Right when you start at
- 1:20:39the bottom, you think, oh, maybe I could be CEO, But
- 1:20:41everyone thinks that how many CEOs are there in that company? One? How
- 1:20:44many vps maybe five? And yet there's like hundreds, maybe thousands of employees
- 1:20:48at the bottom. It's literally impossible that everyone's going to be even a VP.
- 1:20:54So my question for you burto if I went to two thousand and six
- 1:20:59or five and told you and I didn't know the future. Yeah, but
- 1:21:02I said, from my current standpoint, I said, Okay, I know
- 1:21:06you're dissatisfied with being an employee, right, And I know you think you
- 1:21:11could do better, and I know that you have a lot of dreams and
- 1:21:14you just need the time. You want the time to a brake free.
- 1:21:17I'm here to tell you that I've been on the other side of those fences
- 1:21:23and seeing a lot of those examples and know that it's donal, it's cracked
- 1:21:28up to be. There's a lot of problems, and so if you do
- 1:21:30it, maybe heavily consider all of the downsides that could could happen. And
- 1:21:36also maybe you actually kind of have it good right now, but you don't
- 1:21:41know it right. What would you have said? I would have said,
- 1:21:44Yeah, I know why you're saying that, but in reality, I know
- 1:21:46that I can really do this. Look my buddy's such and such he left
- 1:21:50and then he's doing this thing. I can probably do it better, honestly,
- 1:21:55I mean it might take me a year, get me wrong. So
- 1:21:58I think there's a theme of narcissism in there. Right of I'm better than
- 1:22:03this, Right, I'm I'm as good as Mark Zuckerberg, i am as
- 1:22:09good as elam Us, and so I absolutely will succes. Yeah, I'm
- 1:22:14just haven't been given the right opportunity, right Because I wonder if listeners right
- 1:22:17now who are not on that spectrum, they never are in the shoes that
- 1:22:21you and I are talking about. They don't have envy for the boss,
- 1:22:26they don't have envy for that person in power and control, because that's just
- 1:22:30not how they're oriented. They just don't have it. In fact, I
- 1:22:33find some people to be too far in the other directions. Sometimes I'll talk
- 1:22:36to novice therapists and I will be you know, they'll be complaining about how
- 1:22:43stressful, how burnt out they are. Yes, beginning level career therapy jobs
- 1:22:47and work can be low pay and high stress, and lots of clients and
- 1:22:51a lot of the clients aren't super interested in working in therapy, you know,
- 1:22:57they might be kind of forced in this kind of thing. And so
- 1:22:59it's a real slog sometimes and I will say to them, Okay, well
- 1:23:03where do you want your career to go? And they're like huh, Like,
- 1:23:08well, you know, you're you're starting out your career, So where
- 1:23:11do you envision yourself to be in ten years? And they'll say, I
- 1:23:15don't know, I don't know if that's really possible. I mean yeah,
- 1:23:17And and they know conceptually about private practice or other kinds of things, but
- 1:23:23they have these really quick barriers in their head that just kind of just kind
- 1:23:27of screamed to me as someone who just doesn't think the way I do,
- 1:23:30because I've always thought. I think it's because when I was thirteen, I
- 1:23:34was a bus boy at a Chinese restaurant and I was excited to earn five
- 1:23:41dollars an hour, but it was also really hard and stressful work. And
- 1:23:45you're on your feet all day and you're dealing with a restaurant work in general,
- 1:23:48it's just yeah, hard, yes, especially when you're thirteen. And
- 1:23:53I think I learned early and given my personality, that you have to think
- 1:23:59for yourself and you should always be figuring where you want to be and if
- 1:24:04your job kind of sucks, now, start strategizing about how to because there
- 1:24:10are options out there that are like And so by the time I'm at the
- 1:24:14end of my high school years, I have one of the sweet and I
- 1:24:16gamed it, you know, because I thought about things and I and I
- 1:24:20my friends back then will still say, Kirk, you always seem to find
- 1:24:24these like really sweet gigs, even though they're kind of dumb. Like I
- 1:24:29was a security guard, I had actually two security guard jobs, but I
- 1:24:31went in high school. I sat in a booth for those who might know.
- 1:24:35You might know Providence Point, the retirement community on the hill on the
- 1:24:40plateau. There's a little booth on the entrance with a gate. And I
- 1:24:45sat in that booth, this small little hut if you will, and you
- 1:24:50don't have to do anything because and there's no security concerns and if there were,
- 1:24:55you just call the police. So so like I show up with just
- 1:24:58a glorified camera, yeah, exactly. Then that in my other security job
- 1:25:01that I worked downtown Seattle as a security guard, that's what they would say,
- 1:25:05if there's an altercation, you don't fight, you're not trained to fight.
- 1:25:09You're just there as not only glorified police call, but also a smoke
- 1:25:14alarm. So because sometimes smoke alarms don't react fast stuff if there's a fire,
- 1:25:18and thus they can drive insurance rates down if there's a live body at
- 1:25:24night. And so I was there anyway, So I would sit in this
- 1:25:27booth for eight hours something, yeah, and calling my friends. Sometimes my
- 1:25:31friends would come over. I would write music burdo, Oh my gosh.
- 1:25:34I would bring my gutar, I would bring my role in keyboard. What
- 1:25:40I would do homework, I would listen to music. It was like I
- 1:25:45would bring my entire bedroom job. It's a dream job eight hours and all
- 1:25:49I had to do was kind of nod when people would drive through the gate
- 1:25:53and I had my own bathroom is right right there, And I mean it
- 1:25:57was just like this really great job in my friend ends. Meanwhile, they're
- 1:26:00working at McDonald's and Safe Way and other places, and and so I think
- 1:26:05for other people, they're just like too far in that direction where they just
- 1:26:11take what they can get, and maybe they don't have the self esteem or
- 1:26:14the kind of I don't know that spark of For me, it's annoyance.
- 1:26:19I don't want to I don't want to work at it. I get real
- 1:26:23impatient. And if if I don't like a job, like I'm a terrible
- 1:26:26long distance runner for this reason, right, because everyone understands, even long,
- 1:26:30good long, you're a long distance runner. Right, used to be
- 1:26:34that it's it's not all fun in games. Right now you start something mental
- 1:26:40ways to deal with that stress and not with the boredom in a way boredom
- 1:26:45and the pain. Right, you have every reason. There's a lot of
- 1:26:47signals in your brain going just stop. You don't have to do this twenty
- 1:26:51k like, you could stop at any moment and it'll feel better. And
- 1:26:56I cannot turn that voice off in my head when I'm at a job that
- 1:27:00I don't like, then I am in this. It's just this constant voice
- 1:27:04of this sucks. This sucks, this sucks, this sucks. You know.
- 1:27:08That's why I didn't like being chaerished, because I'd be sitting in a
- 1:27:11meeting for three hours and bored out of my mind and there's this voice in
- 1:27:15my head going, this sucks. You could be doing something else, you
- 1:27:16could be doing something else. And I feel like for most people, they
- 1:27:20don't have that voice. It's the pros and cons. But you know,
- 1:27:25I think the pro is that I've oriented my entire life to optimize not only
- 1:27:31my work time but also just my life life, my time time. So
- 1:27:35maybe not everyone is like that and they don't necessarily think like the way we're
- 1:27:40talking about it, but anyway, so no, I mean that I've definitely
- 1:27:44had a lot of conversations over my years with people that they and look,
- 1:27:47there's nothing wrong with this. As an example, there are people that wanted
- 1:27:50to do something they got to the point where they started doing it, and
- 1:27:55that's what they do. Case in point. So my wife, take my
- 1:27:58wife days, she's a she's got a career. She wanted to Like he
- 1:28:02mixed two things, you mix that comedian in the fifties and boat because they
- 1:28:10both have something involving my wife exactly, my wife. Please, So,
- 1:28:16uh, you know, she wanted to do something, she studied for it,
- 1:28:18she started doing it, and that's what she's done and she'll she'll never
- 1:28:21do with something else. And I often would ask her early on, like
- 1:28:25okay, so what's your plan, what's your what's your bigger goal? What
- 1:28:29do you mean? Like, yeah, I'm doing what I want to do.
- 1:28:30Her career has not changed significantly. I mean there have been little advanced
- 1:28:34teenyd like, but but really from just looking at her, her job has
- 1:28:39not changed in twenty years. Yeah, that's what she wanted to do.
- 1:28:43Yeah, when she was coming up, that's what she studied to do.
- 1:28:45Like, her position hasn't even changed exactly. And that's what she does and
- 1:28:49that's what she will do till she's done. And when I would talk to
- 1:28:54her, it would drive me nuts. I'm like, but well, I
- 1:28:56get I get that that's what you're doing now, but like, what do
- 1:28:58you want to do? And I'm us of that on some level, because
- 1:29:01I mean, I'm not envious of people who don't feel they deserve to advance
- 1:29:05when they would benefit from right. Yeah. So getting back to those novice
- 1:29:10therapists, I'd be talking to them and I'd try to say, hey,
- 1:29:14you could be doing this other thing and for the people that needed someone to
- 1:29:18help them with that, they would benefit it from that, right. And
- 1:29:23so but then you have your wife who you might be talking to and she's
- 1:29:26just like, but I'm happy where this is what I always wanted to do
- 1:29:30and I've been doing it. Yeah, And I think and I think there's
- 1:29:32a wonderful aspect of that. Okay, Berto, So as usual, we're
- 1:29:36going along, but I think it's worth it because I like talking with you.
- 1:29:41Yeah. So let's end this episode here and we get back. We'll
- 1:29:45continue talking about this topic of darkness in next episode. So this is the
- 1:29:50end of part one. Tune in next time for the Restless Conversation. And
- 1:29:54everyone, please take care of yourself because you deserve it or