Latest / Consumerpedia / 64 - EV Update 2024
Transcript
- 0:01Maybe you've noticed electric vehicles are becoming more
- 0:04common. E VS now represent about 7% of
- 0:07all new vehicle sales in the US American car buyers bought a
- 0:11record 1.2 million E VS last year, according to Kelley Blue
- 0:15Book. EV sales continue to grow in the
- 0:17first quarter of this year, but that growth was noticeably
- 0:20slower. Experts believe most of the
- 0:22early adopters, those who wanted to ditch their vehicles with
- 0:25internal combustion engines, have already made the switch to
- 0:28electric. Now automakers and government
- 0:30policy makers will need to find ways to convince skeptical
- 0:33mainstream buyers to plug into this new technology.
- 0:36I'm Her Weissbaum, the consumer Man, a contributing editor at
- 0:39checkbook.org. Welcome to Consumerpedia.
- 0:43At checkbook.org, we're the nonprofit that helps consumers
- 0:46select services, avoid trouble, and save money.
- 0:49Because we don't accept any advertising or take money from
- 0:52any business, we recommend you can rely on checkbook.org to be
- 0:56completely independent and objective.
- 0:58Now here's the host of Consumerpedia America's consumer
- 1:02expert, the consumer man Herb Weissbaum.
- 1:05In this episode, how to decide which non conventional vehicle
- 1:09might be right for you? Do E VS live up to their range
- 1:12promises? Consumer Reports creates a
- 1:14special test to find out. Plus why are electric vehicles
- 1:18less reliable than conventional cars?
- 1:20Let's start with how to decide between the big three options, a
- 1:23hybrid a plug in electric and hybrid electric vehicle.
- 1:27Here to help with that is a manager of auto testing and
- 1:29insights at Consumer Reports, Alex Kneesek.
- 1:32Yeah. Thank you for having me on the
- 1:33show. So I think everybody knows what
- 1:35an electric vehicle is. You plug it in and charge it, it
- 1:37goes on electric battery and a hybrid is the best of both
- 1:40worlds. Has got a gasoline engine that
- 1:42also charges the battery and it goes to battery when it can tell
- 1:45everybody what a plug in hybrid is.
- 1:47I think they may not be familiar with that.
- 1:48Yeah, a plug in hybrid is kind of in this weird spot in between
- 1:52both of those two things you just described.
- 1:54So it, you know, functions a lot like a regular hybrid except for
- 1:58it has a larger battery on board essentially.
- 2:02So you know instead of just like a regular hybrid that'll kind of
- 2:06accelerate at times on electric only power maybe you know taking
- 2:09off from a stop sign or something like that or you know
- 2:12meandering through a parking lot.
- 2:13And then other times it's kind of both power trains working
- 2:16together, right, the electric and the gas working together.
- 2:18The plug in hybrid, you can plug it in as the name suggests and
- 2:21you can charge it and you know most of them get anywhere
- 2:24between 20 and up to 40 or even close to 50 miles of all
- 2:28electric driving. So you kind of end up with this
- 2:32EV type of experience for however many miles the the
- 2:36vehicle's rated for, let's say 40.
- 2:38And then once that electric battery is kind of depleted or
- 2:41the charges, you know, used up, so to speak, basically just
- 2:44reverts back to a regular hybrid operation.
- 2:47So it's really for somebody who kind of wants to take advantage
- 2:51of, you know, some of the benefits of an electric car,
- 2:54smooth acceleration, quietness, no tailpipe emissions, at least
- 2:57for those 40 miles, give or take.
- 3:00So it's a really interesting option that kind of gets you
- 3:02most of the way or at least part of the way towards an EV.
- 3:04But one of the huge things is that you really don't have to
- 3:06worry about the whole public charging aspect of an electric
- 3:09vehicle, right. With a full on EV you you're
- 3:12subject to the public charging infrastructure.
- 3:15If you're going to take it on a long trip, you got to figure out
- 3:17where you're going to charge and you don't know necessarily how
- 3:19that charger's going to look or function when you show up.
- 3:22So the nice thing with the plug in hybrid is you can just kind
- 3:24of bypass all that and just drive it regularly on a long
- 3:27trip. And you know, once that
- 3:28battery's depleted, you just keep going and you can just fill
- 3:30it with gas, you know, like you normally would.
- 3:32I know some folks in that plug in hybrids and they drive to
- 3:35work. It's only like a 15 mile commute
- 3:37and they rarely use any of the gasoline.
- 3:39So they basically have an electric vehicle, but have the
- 3:41backup in case they need it. Yeah, you really have to think
- 3:44and kind of look at your situation, I suppose.
- 3:46And you know, if you have a commute like the one you're
- 3:49describing, maybe 1520 miles something like that where you
- 3:51can get to work, maybe you can charge it at work, but even if
- 3:54not, you can get back home. So you're doing most of your
- 3:57driving on that electric power and you know, if you kind of
- 4:00read around or talk to people who own these vehicles, it's
- 4:03almost like a sport to see how few or how little you can go to
- 4:07the gas station, right? How often you can keep it
- 4:08charged and and drive around on the electric power.
- 4:11Now we're going to talk more in the reliability report about
- 4:14plug in hybrids, which did not rate as well as hybrids or even
- 4:18electric vehicles. Yeah.
- 4:19When you look at plug in hybrids from a systems perspective and
- 4:23kind of what the vehicle is, you're really combining 2 power
- 4:27trains under one you know vehicle in a sense.
- 4:29And hybrids do that to some degree.
- 4:31But the battery's a lot smaller and the electric components are
- 4:34a lot smaller and you don't really have to worry about the
- 4:36vehicle functioning as an electric for these 50 miles or
- 4:3940 miles. But when you do, in the case of
- 4:41a plug in hybrid, you have to add a lot of different stuff in
- 4:43terms of making sure that the car can still heat up the cabin
- 4:46when the engine's off, for example, cool that big battery,
- 4:50charge it up. So there's a lot of extra stuff
- 4:52that basically goes along with that plug in hybrid.
- 4:55And when you do Add all that extra stuff compared to a
- 4:57regular hybrid, the weight goes up and therefore you know when
- 5:01it's operating as a hybrid, once that battery is depleted, it
- 5:04doesn't get the same fuel economy as say the regular
- 5:08hybrid version. Let's say you have the choice
- 5:10between a plug in hybrid and a hybrid of the same car.
- 5:12Generally speaking, it's going to get worse fuel economy just
- 5:15because it's heavier and it has to work a little harder.
- 5:16So if you're somebody who you're like, eh, I'm probably not going
- 5:19to plug it in all that often or I do a lot of long distance
- 5:22driving. I don't really have that short
- 5:23commute. You might be better off just
- 5:25getting the the regular traditional hybrid, if you will.
- 5:28As you well know, everyone is concerned about how far an EV
- 5:31can go before it needs to be charged.
- 5:32Consumer Reports decided to find out by doing some real world EV
- 5:36range testing and I got to say the results were surprising.
- 5:40Before we get to the results, could you explain to folks the
- 5:42mileage estimate ratings for conventional cars and hybrids
- 5:45and how that differs from what you for an electric vehicle?
- 5:48Yeah. I mean, when you're looking at a
- 5:50window sticker for a hybrid or conventional car, you're going
- 5:53to see fuel economy estimates, right, miles per gallon and both
- 5:57city and Hwy. right? And then it could give you a
- 5:59combined rating and the range is on there somewhere too.
- 6:01But typically, we don't care so much about the range just
- 6:04because there's gas stations everywhere and you aren't
- 6:06inconvenienced by having to fill it up with gas so much.
- 6:08But on an EV, you do have a city and Hwy. efficiency rating from
- 6:13the EPA. So they're going to come across
- 6:15as kilowatt hours per 100 miles is the way they do it, right?
- 6:18So we're thinking about different units now than miles
- 6:20per gallon. But ultimately, what the EPA
- 6:22gives you as far as range for the vehicle is a combined
- 6:26rating. So it's let's say 300 miles.
- 6:29That 300 miles is based on some city driving, some highway
- 6:32driving and the mix of conditions.
- 6:34So it's not a bad estimate by any means, but it's conducted in
- 6:37a laboratory and it doesn't really account for different
- 6:40types of situations in the way that we think our test does.
- 6:43So by doing this 70 mile per hour highway range test that we
- 6:47developed, we really think it's useful because it let's you know
- 6:51how far the EV can go on the highway when you are traveling
- 6:54to somewhere that might be unfamiliar, where you're not
- 6:57sure about the charging situation right.
- 6:58When you're driving around town. The maximum range of your
- 7:01electric vehicle is more of a convenience, but you're probably
- 7:03charging at home, that sort of thing.
- 7:05So you really want to know how far you can go when you're going
- 7:07to travel somewhere unfamiliar and at higher speeds, right?
- 7:09Because E VS. They're not as efficient at
- 7:11highway speeds as they are around town for a number of
- 7:13reasons. So this test that we developed,
- 7:15it's not to counter the EPA necessarily.
- 7:18It's really just another data point for consumers to use to
- 7:20say, hey, I think this EV would work for my situation or not.
- 7:24So tell me about this real life test, what you did and what you
- 7:27found. Basically this is a a real world
- 7:29test. We buy all the cars that we test
- 7:31at Consumer Reports. So this is a vehicle that we
- 7:33purchased the same way anybody would.
- 7:35We charge it up to 100%. We have a bunch of kind of
- 7:38conditions to control the tests as much as possible as far as
- 7:41temperature and wind and tire pressure and you know kind of
- 7:43the settings in the vehicle. And then we basically get onto a
- 7:47stretch of Hwy. that's out you know near our test track in
- 7:49Colchester, Connecticut and we set the cruise control at 70 mph
- 7:53and we keep driving this about 50 mile loop over and over
- 7:57essentially until the vehicle gets just about down to 0 miles
- 8:00of range at least indicated on the gauge cluster there.
- 8:03And then we pull off and we actually tow the vehicle back to
- 8:06our facility. And then we keep driving it on
- 8:09our track because a lot of these vehicles have you know
- 8:12essentially A buffer behind the zero indication where they'll
- 8:15keep driving some a lot more than others, which is really
- 8:18interesting. And your gas car does a similar
- 8:20thing too, right, to give you a safety net.
- 8:22But we decided to take them all down to 0 just to see a how far
- 8:26they can actually go. And then also, you know, what
- 8:28does the car do to help the person or the driver as it
- 8:31starts to get really far down into the discharged state, if
- 8:34you will. So some of them, for example,
- 8:36will say, hey, you have 30 miles of range left, but the nearest
- 8:39charger is 25 miles away. So if you're going to charge
- 8:42this thing, you got to do that now.
- 8:44So it's really interesting. They all kind of handle the
- 8:46situation differently. And then of course the range
- 8:49numbers themselves. I mean we saw some cars, you
- 8:51know, on average I would say they were all pretty close
- 8:53actually to their EPA number, which was refreshing.
- 8:55That means that even when you put them into a more demanding
- 8:59test, they actually stayed close to what their window sticker
- 9:01says, which is great. And I think that's, you know,
- 9:03helpful for consumers. But we saw some that went way
- 9:06further. We saw some that went more than
- 9:0940 miles beyond their EPA rating, which you know, on one
- 9:13hand that's good because the car went further than I expected.
- 9:16That's not necessarily a bad thing.
- 9:18But we know that most EV owners, you know, they're not going to
- 9:21drive the vehicle all the way down to 0 necessarily every
- 9:23time. They're going to get down to say
- 9:251510% state of charge and and then start looking for a
- 9:28charger. So if you put a lot of that
- 9:30range behind the 0 mark so to speak, and that's a lot of the
- 9:34battery that the consumer paid for that they're not necessarily
- 9:37utilizing. So definitely interesting
- 9:39strategies across the board. All these automakers kind of
- 9:42handling things differently as you drive them as far as they
- 9:45can go. So of the 22 EVs you've tested
- 9:47so far, how many fell short of their EPA estimated ranges when
- 9:51you drove them at highway speeds?
- 9:52Yeah, it was about half actually were close but under and then
- 9:56some were significantly under their advertised range.
- 9:59So just for example, one that was close but a little bit under
- 10:02was the Hyundai Ionix 6, which is kind of this sleek electric
- 10:06sedan rated for 270 miles. We got 265 miles out of it, so
- 10:11under but close. Others on the other hand were
- 10:14quite a bit under their rating. Two that come to mind are the
- 10:18Lucid Air Touring. This is rated for 384 miles, but
- 10:22it actually fell 40 miles short at 3:44.
- 10:26And then the Tesla Model S, which is actually a very similar
- 10:29vehicle in some ways rated for 405 miles and we only got 366
- 10:33out of it now. I think, you know, despite them
- 10:36achieving less than their EPA #366 miles for the Tesla and
- 10:413:44 for the Lucid are still very far and and very long
- 10:45ranges for electric vehicles. So I think that's worth
- 10:47mentioning. But yeah, they did fall short of
- 10:48their claim. And reading your article, the
- 10:50biggest difference in range was the much hyped Ford F-150
- 10:54Lightning pickup truck. Yeah, that one, our specific
- 10:56version, the Lariat extended range with the larger battery
- 11:00pack rated for 320 miles and when we drove it on the highway,
- 11:03we got 270 miles out of it. So pretty interesting.
- 11:06And that was one that didn't really give us much buffer where
- 11:09pretty much all the other cars had at least some small amount,
- 11:12some larger than others. This one, once we got to zero,
- 11:15it was pretty much over. And you know, the Ford is
- 11:17interesting, right, because it's so large, heavy and not
- 11:21aerodynamic compared to a lot of these cars.
- 11:23It suffers more when you get it on the highway.
- 11:25So it does benefit from a test like the Epas where it is taking
- 11:29into account slower speed driving, higher speed driving
- 11:31and kind of mixing it all together, whereas we're strictly
- 11:33focused on that high speed. So I think potential reason
- 11:36there for such a large delta. So something I learned in
- 11:39reading your articles about this that I didn't realize is that
- 11:43with an EV, unlike gasoline powered cars, they tend to be
- 11:46less efficient on highways and in cities where a conventional
- 11:51gasoline powered vehicle is more efficient on the highway than in
- 11:53the cities, it's exactly the opposite with an EV.
- 11:56Yeah, that's true and something that people kind of have to I
- 11:58guess change their mindset a little bit.
- 12:00We're used to seeing the MPG increase a little bit on the
- 12:03highway in our gas powered car. That's just because that's where
- 12:06they're most efficient with their gas engines.
- 12:08And when you're doing a lot of city driving with a lot of stop
- 12:11and go accelerations and things like that, that's just more
- 12:14taxing and takes you know, away from that fuel efficiency.
- 12:17Where as an EV, you know in the city you're getting it to take
- 12:19advantage of regenerative braking, right, which basically
- 12:23uses the motors to convert the energy back into electricity,
- 12:26send it back into the battery. So you kind of recuperate energy
- 12:29in that way. And then also an EV when it's
- 12:31sitting still, doesn't use any power, right?
- 12:33So it, you know, gets an advantage there.
- 12:35And on the flip side, with an EV, aerodynamics really takes
- 12:37over at highway speeds. That really becomes one of your
- 12:40biggest things. That starts to degrade the
- 12:42efficiency, if you will. So the faster you go.
- 12:44While still true with a gas car, the influence on the overall
- 12:47efficiency is higher with an EV. Straight ahead, Consumer Reports
- 12:50creates a new test to see if EV manufacturers can deliver on
- 12:54their mileage claims. I'm Herb Weissbaum and this is
- 12:56Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 13:00If you like what you hear, we hope you'll consider being a
- 13:03consumer PDS supporter by using the link at the bottom of the
- 13:06show notes to make a small contribution each month.
- 13:09This is Consumer Pedia. So most of the surveys recently
- 13:14about why people have concerns about buying an electric vehicle
- 13:17are the price point #1 and also the range anxiety.
- 13:21Do you think that's a little overblown or people getting too
- 13:24carried away with how far they can go with these things?
- 13:26Yeah, I think range is interesting.
- 13:28I I do think that it is something that you have to get
- 13:31used to if you're coming from a hybrid or gas powered car
- 13:34because on average the range is going to be less the distance
- 13:37that you can go before you have to charge or or fill up the gas
- 13:40car. So you do kind of have to
- 13:41account for that. Now that being said, the longer
- 13:43you own the vehicle, we tend to see that people can kind of get
- 13:47used to what that range is. They kind of learn it.
- 13:49They understand how far they can go when they need to charge
- 13:52things like this. And you know, also range can be
- 13:54impacted by a lot of different outside factors, right?
- 13:57We've we've all seen how temperature can kind of be a big
- 14:00thing with electric vehicles. When it gets really cold, it can
- 14:02kind of have a huge influence on the range.
- 14:05And that does happen with gas cars too, but to a far less
- 14:07degree. And again, you're not so worried
- 14:09about making it to the next gas station as you are with
- 14:12charging. You know, when we talk to EV
- 14:14owners and and we survey them and do these things, you see
- 14:17that range anxiety might be the top barrier to entry as they're
- 14:20kind of shopping and considering if an EV is going to work for
- 14:22them. But if they do make that
- 14:24purchase decision, the range anxiety kind of starts to fall
- 14:27down the list of concerns, right?
- 14:28And charging stays at the top. So people still, you know,
- 14:32regardless of ownership, they're still concerned about being able
- 14:34to charge the vehicle, whether that's mostly public charging,
- 14:38right when you need to go on a trip or something like that,
- 14:40just because the network is not as accessible and widespread as
- 14:44gas stations are. And of course, it takes longer.
- 14:46And you know, a lot of things can happen, if you will, when
- 14:49you show up to an electric charger, will it be a line or
- 14:53the charger's broken or the car doesn't charge as fast as you
- 14:55expect? So yeah, a lot of things to
- 14:58consider with the charging side of things.
- 14:59So based on this real world testing of EVs, have you changed
- 15:03the way you rate them and the ratings on Consumer Reports?
- 15:05Yeah, we have. You know, we've been testing
- 15:07electric vehicles for a long time, since basically the first
- 15:10Nissan Leaf came out. But we pretty much put them
- 15:12through a very similar process as the regular test cars, which
- 15:15meant we were leaving some things off the table as far as
- 15:18charging and the range that we talked about.
- 15:20And some other features too, like route planning, for
- 15:23example, which is basically the infotainment system inside the
- 15:26car. It can kind of help you find
- 15:28chargers. You know, let's say I want to go
- 15:30from Connecticut to Chicago, and some of the best systems will
- 15:33automatically plot every single one of my charging stops along
- 15:36the way and tell me how long I'll be there.
- 15:38Whereas some other cars don't do that for you at all.
- 15:41So just a lot of different kind of systems and features that
- 15:44make living with an EV easier or at least better experience.
- 15:48So it's really to incorporate all that into our testing and
- 15:52reflect that accurately. So based on all the testing
- 15:54you've done, both the real world and also the test track your
- 15:57thoughts on who's making the best EVs right now.
- 16:00Oh. Man, that's a that's a a great
- 16:02question. You know, I think a lot of the
- 16:04different brands and EVs have a great aspects to them.
- 16:07I don't know that anybody has totally nailed it yet.
- 16:10We're in the infancy of this whole technology and kind of
- 16:13transformation into the EV world so to speak.
- 16:16But of course Tesla's, I've been doing this for a really long
- 16:18time, longer than pretty much anybody else, so I think they
- 16:21have a lot of the aspects of the drivetrain nailed down as far as
- 16:24regen braking and smoothness. And of course the integration
- 16:28with the charging networks is is phenomenal, or at least their
- 16:31own charging network, right? And I think the other surprising
- 16:33one is BMW. You know, if you don't want a
- 16:36car that screams EV, with the way it's designed and the way it
- 16:39looks, you can get a BMW that looks like the gas powered
- 16:42version. But they tend to be really
- 16:43efficient, they drive really smoothly, they're really quiet
- 16:46and they can charge pretty quickly and they have one of the
- 16:49best route planning systems in them.
- 16:51You know, that feature that I just mentioned as far as
- 16:53plotting chargers, they have a really, really fleshed out and
- 16:56full-featured system. So they offer a pretty solid EV
- 17:00option at this point. Are there too many electronics?
- 17:02Some of these dashboards look like, you know, disco, ballrooms
- 17:04or whatever. Is it?
- 17:05Is it getting a little bit out of hand?
- 17:07Yeah, I mean, I would say that's a trend for vehicles in general
- 17:10at the moment, but certainly electric vehicles get all the
- 17:13latest and greatest, if you can call it that, technology thrown
- 17:15at them, right. So you have the biggest
- 17:17infotainment screens and the most ambient lighting and all
- 17:21these things kind of going on in the inside.
- 17:23And yeah, I mean we see that reliability can be an issue with
- 17:27certain EVs because they tend to be new platforms with all the
- 17:30latest and greatest stuff. So, yeah, maybe in some cases
- 17:34we've we've gone a little far. You know, there are simpler EVs
- 17:37out there that don't necessarily give you that experience.
- 17:40Because I've been around long enough to realize that the more
- 17:43screens and the more tech and the more Hoo ha you have in the
- 17:45cabin there, the more likely it is to break.
- 17:47Which could be one reason why there's some reliability
- 17:50problems with some of these vehicles.
- 17:51Yeah, absolutely. I mean you know in this
- 17:53conversation I'm thinking about our Fisker, Ocean.
- 17:56Fisker is kind of a smaller, you know, start up automaker at this
- 17:59point, and the center screen in the car controls pretty much
- 18:02everything. And you know, not only are there
- 18:04some software issues that maybe some people have heard about, so
- 18:07some of the features don't necessarily work, but you know
- 18:09the whole screen, if you hold down this button, it flips 180
- 18:12or 90°. Rather it goes from, you know,
- 18:15standing upright to rotating onto its side.
- 18:17So there's a motor back there to control that.
- 18:19All the air vents are controlled electronically, right?
- 18:22You don't just reach over and move it, you know the little
- 18:24knob yourself. You have to go into the screen
- 18:25and drag things around. Yes, a lot of extra little
- 18:28actuators in modules to make all that stuff.
- 18:31Happen. Final question Aside from price
- 18:33and aside from possibly range anxiety, are there still
- 18:36barriers? What's hindering the adoption of
- 18:38electric vehicles right now? That's a great question.
- 18:40I mean, I think the early adopters, if you will, are kind
- 18:43of waning, I suppose, right? You had people who are are
- 18:46really excited about the latest and greatest technology and
- 18:49they're kind of ready to make a change to something like an EV,
- 18:51you know, and don't really have any hesitation.
- 18:53And it seems like a lot of those people have kind of signed up
- 18:56and they've gotten their EV and they're kind of all set at this
- 18:58point, right. And so we're kind of seeing that
- 19:01the more mainstream consumers aren't necessarily ready to take
- 19:04that plunge. And I think the cost like you
- 19:06said is one thing, the range, the charging and I think there's
- 19:10also just a lack of maybe familiarity with these cars.
- 19:13It is something new. It's a fundamental shift in the
- 19:16way we we've been doing things. So I think, you know, ultimately
- 19:18that's going to take time for people to experience and realize
- 19:22is a viable option for them. So even if it's not one specific
- 19:26issue that's keeping the majority of people, I think it's
- 19:29a new thing that can be a little scary in some ways.
- 19:32Alex Nesik is manager of Auto Testing and Insights at Consumer
- 19:35Reports. Alex, it's always a pleasure to
- 19:37talk to you. Thanks for spending so much time
- 19:38with us today. Yeah.
- 19:39Thank you so much for for having me.
- 19:41They have fewer moving parts and require less maintenance.
- 19:44But how reliable are EVs when compared traditional vehicles
- 19:48that answer straight ahead. I'm Herb Weissbaum and this is
- 19:51Consumerpedia, powered by checkbook.org.
- 19:55Consumerpedia Fast Fax electric vehicles have been around for
- 20:00more than 100 years. The first full size electric
- 20:03carriage was made by Scottish inventor Robert Anderson in
- 20:061832. Thomas Parker built the first
- 20:09electric car in London in 1884. E VS have faster acceleration
- 20:13than gasoline powered vehicles. The electric motor can generate
- 20:16100% of the available torque instantly.
- 20:20Federal regulations require automakers to provide an 8 year
- 20:23or 100,000 mile warranty on their EV batteries.
- 20:26All E VS sold in California must have battery warranties that
- 20:30last ten years or 150,000 miles. EVs are generally more expensive
- 20:37than conventionally powered vehicles.
- 20:39According to Kelley Blue Book, the average non luxury new car
- 20:42sold for $48,000 in April while the average EV went for 55,500.
- 20:48With fewer moving parts in a higher price point, you might
- 20:51expect an electric vehicle to be more reliable, but Consumer
- 20:54Reports finds that's not always the case.
- 20:56Let's dig into that with CR Senior Automotive Data Analyst
- 20:59Stephen Elick. Hi Herb.
- 21:01You know, we always hear that electric vehicles require less
- 21:03maintenance in traditional gasoline powered cars trucks.
- 21:06And that's true. For instance, there are no tune
- 21:08ups and no oil changes. But that's not the same as
- 21:11reliability, right? That's exactly right.
- 21:13I mean, just because there are less moving parts, EVs are
- 21:16really not there yet for reliability.
- 21:18It's new technology and they tend to have approximately 79%
- 21:23more problems than internal combustion cars.
- 21:26And you're basing that number on a survey of 330,000 Consumer
- 21:30Report subscribers who told you about their vehicles, right?
- 21:33That's right. It's on 330,000 vehicles from
- 21:35our members. So why are EVs less reliable
- 21:39than conventional vehicles and even hybrids?
- 21:41So EVs tend to be less reliable because they're a new
- 21:45technology. Gas cars have been around for a
- 21:48century, whereas EVs are a new technology and they just have a
- 21:53lot of new things in them. And those are what's going
- 21:57wrong. You know, we see issues with the
- 21:58EV charger, the EV motor and the EV battery packs.
- 22:03In other cases there are build quality issues, like some of
- 22:06these are are newer brands like Rivian or Tesla.
- 22:09So they haven't figured out the build quality part of it yet.
- 22:12And that's where we're seeing a little bit of more issues.
- 22:15So let's talk about Tesla. It's been building EVs for more
- 22:18than a decade now, but it landed in the middle of the pack and C
- 22:21Rs brand reliability. What accounts for that?
- 22:23Yeah, that's right. And so it's mostly build quality
- 22:27issues for Tesla. They figured out the whole EV
- 22:29part, their power trains and drive trains, Their batteries
- 22:32are all OK, but it's really you're seeing issues with the
- 22:35paint and trim, mismatched paint, certain issues with trim
- 22:39pieces falling off and and things like that.
- 22:41A lot of the issues are also on the Model S and the Model X,
- 22:46whereas the Model 3 and the Model Y, they're volume sellers,
- 22:50tend to be more reliable. They actually moved up in
- 22:53reliability a little bit this year.
- 22:55So both of those, the Model Y and the Model 3, are recommended
- 22:58this year because of average reliability.
- 23:00What about Rivian, the other all electric company?
- 23:02How are they doing? So Rivian is seeing some issues.
- 23:06They have EV charge problems but also various different issues.
- 23:11There are some climate system is on the Rivian R1 T and they're
- 23:15also seeing some build quality issues as well.
- 23:18So of the 33 EV models noted in in the reliability report, which
- 23:22ones had the highest scores? The Hyundai Ionic 6 is well
- 23:26above average. They had a score of 70 out of
- 23:28100, which is quite good for predicted reliability.
- 23:32And what's interesting about that is the Hyundai Ionic 5 is
- 23:36below average reliability. So it's almost like a situation
- 23:39where they figured out the kinks from one model to the other.
- 23:41Let's move on to hybrids. They do rate well for
- 23:44reliability. Yeah, that's correct.
- 23:45So hybrids have 26% less problems than internal
- 23:50combustion cars on a whole, which is interesting because
- 23:53there are more moving parts on the hybrid as well.
- 23:55They have a battery pack. And so you would think there'd
- 23:58be more issues. But the fact of the matter is
- 24:00this is kind of tried and true technology.
- 24:03Hybrids have been around for, you know, 25 years in some cases
- 24:06where the Toyota Prius started and they've really worked out
- 24:10those kinks. They tend to be built by more
- 24:13reliable automakers. There are a lot of hybrid
- 24:16Toyotas. So if there's a good brand
- 24:19building the hybrids as well, then they tend to be more
- 24:22reliable as well. So let's move on to the third
- 24:24category, PHEVS or plug in hybrid electrics.
- 24:27So how did the plug in hybrids rate?
- 24:29Well, the plug in hybrids tend to be way less reliable in gas
- 24:33cars. They're actually they have 146%
- 24:36more problems than internal combustion vehicles.
- 24:39So unfortunately they did not do as well as the hybrids.
- 24:42Any explanation for why or what kind of problems people are
- 24:45saying? So a lot of the problems
- 24:47associated with these vehicles tend to be with the EV charging
- 24:51and EV battery problems, and they tend to be built by less
- 24:55reliable automakers. So for example, the Volvo XC60
- 25:00plugin. If you look at the Volvo XC60
- 25:03full gas version, it's already below average reliability.
- 25:07When you add some more components, like a charger, an
- 25:10electric system, a climate system that operates a little
- 25:13bit differently than the conventional one, it tends to
- 25:16have more problems, and it has the problems that the regular
- 25:19XC60 has plus these extra ones. So putting everything together
- 25:23that we've talked about and looking at all the data you got
- 25:25from these 330,000 members, what's the bottom line?
- 25:29What do you want people to know when it comes to reliability?
- 25:31Really, the bottom line is that these are trends.
- 25:33There's always a a vehicle that bucks the trend and each model
- 25:38has a story in and of itself. O we say that hybrids are more
- 25:42reliable than gas cars, that doesn't mean go out and buy a
- 25:45Ford F-150 hybrid. It's actually far less reliable
- 25:49and in the same way there's exceptions for plug in hybrids
- 25:52as well. So if you want to get a plug in
- 25:54hybrid, the Toyota Rav 4 prime is well above average
- 25:58reliability. I mean it's a it's an excellent
- 26:01choice. So it doesn't always mean you
- 26:03have to follow the trend of what we see here.
- 26:06If you dig into it and look at our model pages, that's really
- 26:09the best way to find out the reliability of a specific model.
- 26:12Based on past trends, is it logical to assume that in the
- 26:15years ahead, down the road, they're going to get better at
- 26:17building these newer type vehicles?
- 26:18It just takes some time to figure out how to do it.
- 26:21Absolutely. We think that's going to be the
- 26:23case where once EVs get past that learning curve really and
- 26:27the kinks get worked out, they'll get more reliable.
- 26:30I mean, gas cars have had 100 years to work all those issues
- 26:33out. EVs are are just starting and
- 26:35the same thing for plugging electric.
- 26:37So it'll get there, it just needs a little bit of time.
- 26:39Some people always want the newest, the latest and greatest
- 26:42when it comes to any vehicle, but specifically electric.
- 26:45It sounds like what you're finding from your subscribers is
- 26:48that you might want to wait a year to with a brand new
- 26:50electric or a hybrid electric to see if they worked out the bugs
- 26:54and how reliable it is. Don't assume it's going to be
- 26:56reliable just because it's brand new.
- 26:58That's exactly right. And that's the advice for not
- 27:01just electric cars, but almost every car.
- 27:02If there's a redesigned model, it's best to wait a couple of
- 27:05years until the kinks are worked out on that redesigned model,
- 27:09because a couple years later it may be a more reliable version
- 27:12of it. Steve Ellick is senior
- 27:14automotive data analyst at Consumer Reports.
- 27:16Steve, thanks for making us smarter.
- 27:18Thank you for having me. You know, we just scratch the
- 27:20surface on what's happening in the EV market right now.
- 27:23You can use the links in the show notes to read a lot more.
- 27:26Well, we've come to the end of the road, so to speak, for this
- 27:28episode. We hope you'll rate it and
- 27:30follow us on Apple Podcast, Spotify or wherever you listen
- 27:34to your podcast. Remember, we release new
- 27:36episodes every other Thursday. Another way you can support this
- 27:39show is to follow us on Consumerpedia on Facebook and
- 27:43Instagram, and at my Consumerpedia on X, formally
- 27:46Twitter, I'm her Weissbaum. Thanks for listening and drive
- 27:49safely. Consumerpedia is a public
- 27:52service of checkbook.org. We're a unique non profit that
- 27:55helps you save money and make smarter choices.
- 27:57You can count on Checkbook to help you find the best services
- 28:00and avoid the worst with local ratings that are accurate and
- 28:04unbiased. If you live in or around these
- 28:07seven cities and haven't joined Checkbook yet, check us out
- 28:10Boston, Chicago, Philadelphia, Seattle, San Francisco,
- 28:15Minneapolis, Saint Paul, and Washington DC To get your free
- 28:1830 day subscription, go to checkbook.org/consumerpedia.
- 28:23If you like what you've heard, we hope you'll become a
- 28:25supporter by using the link at the bottom of the show Notes to
- 28:28make a small contribution each month.
- 28:30Consumerpedia Empowering consumers to save money and make
- 28:34smarter choices.