Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Manage an Employee Who Always Says I Will Handle It
Transcript
- Lucas: Luna, I want to talk about the employee who says 'I'll handle it' and then goes radio silent for three days. Luna: Oh, I know that type. The one who treats every question as a sign you don't trust them. Lucas: Exactly. There's a senior analyst I've been thinking about — let's call her Priya. She worked at a mid-size SaaS company, about three hundred employees. She was brilliant, but whenever her manager asked how a project was going, she'd say 'I'll handle it' and shut the conversation down. Luna: And then she'd deliver, right? At least at first. Lucas: She did. Her manager stopped checking in because the work always got done. But over six months, her output started slipping. She missed a couple of deadlines, and when her manager finally asked what was going on, she admitted she was working sixty-hour weeks because she'd taken on too much. 'I'll handle it' was her way of avoiding the conversation about capacity. Luna: So the phrase wasn't confidence — it was a shield. Lucas: That's the insight. For high performers, 'I'll handle it' often means 'I don't want to admit I'm struggling, so I'll just work harder.' And the manager who hears it can mistake it for competence. Luna: So how do you break that pattern without coming across as micromanaging? Lucas: There's a framework I like called the 48-hour check-in. It's not a status update request — it's a structural prompt. You set a norm early: 'When you tell me you'll handle something, I'm going to circle back in two days not because I don't trust you, but because I want to make sure you have what you need.' Luna: That reframes it from surveillance to support. Lucas: Right. And you do it consistently, even when there's no problem. That way, when the check-in happens during a tough week, it feels normal instead of accusatory. Luna: But what if the employee still pushes back? 'I said I'll handle it — why are you checking?' Lucas: That's where you name the pattern directly, but without judgment. You say something like: 'I notice you often say you'll handle things, and you do — but I've also seen that sometimes it means you're carrying more than you should. I want us to get ahead of that.' Luna: That's honest. But it requires the manager to have built enough trust to have that conversation. Lucas: It does. And it's easier if you start early. Priya's manager waited until after the missed deadlines. If they'd set the 48-hour norm in the first week, they might have caught the overcommitment sooner. Luna: Speaking of catching it early — I wonder if this is harder with remote teams. When someone's in the office, you can see the stress: tired eyes, skipped lunch, that kind of thing. Lucas: It's definitely harder. Remote employees can hide the physical cues. But the 48-hour check-in actually works better remotely because it's more structured. You're not dropping by someone's desk — you're scheduling a five-minute video call or even a voice note. The key is that it's consistent, not reactive. Luna: So it's about building a rhythm, not checking in when you're worried. Lucas: Exactly. And there's another layer: for some employees, 'I'll handle it' is a bid for autonomy. They want to prove they can own something end to end. The manager's job is to give them that autonomy but with guardrails. Luna: Right. Autonomy without visibility is just abandonment. Lucas: That's a great way to put it. So the framework isn't about taking control away — it's about creating visibility that protects both the employee and the project. Luna: Let's talk about the employee who genuinely can handle everything — the superstar who never drops the ball. Do you still check in on them? Lucas: Especially with that person. Because the superstar is the one most likely to burn out without anyone noticing. They've trained everyone to believe they're fine. Priya was that person — she delivered for a year before anyone saw the cracks. Luna: So the check-in becomes a wellness check, not a performance check. Lucas: Exactly. You ask different questions. Not 'where are you on this?' but 'how's your energy right now?' and 'is there anything you'd take off your plate if you could?' Luna: I think a lot of managers are afraid to ask those questions because they don't want to imply the employee can't handle it. Lucas: That's the irony — by not asking, you're making it worse. The employee internalises that asking for help is failure, so they keep saying 'I'll handle it' until they break. Luna: You know, that reminds me of something I came across last week. There's this idea that a small number of listeners — a few hundred at most — fund shows like this through buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It's what keeps us ad-free and honest. And honestly, it makes me think about how we handle our own workload. Lucas: Yeah, it's a good reminder that saying 'I'll handle it' alone doesn't sustain anything. For us, having that listener support means we can focus on making these episodes better instead of chasing sponsors. It's a collective 'we've got this'. Luna: Right. And back to Priya — what ended up happening with her? Lucas: Her manager finally had a direct conversation after the second missed deadline. They reset her priorities, and they started weekly fifteen-minute check-ins focused on capacity, not status. She stopped working weekends within a month. Luna: So the fix was structural, not motivational. Lucas: Exactly. She didn't need a pep talk — she needed a system that made it safe to say 'I'm full.' Luna: What about the manager who's dealing with this pattern across multiple team members? You can't do 48-hour check-ins with everyone every two days. Lucas: You can't. So you prioritise. The people who say 'I'll handle it' most often are usually your most reliable people — so they get the check-in. The ones who ask for help naturally? You can give them more space. Luna: That's counterintuitive. You'd think the reliable ones need less attention. Lucas: They do — until they don't. And by then it's often too late. It's like tending to the strongest tree in a storm; you assume it'll stand, but the roots might be shallow. Luna: I like that metaphor. So the takeaway for managers is: don't take 'I'll handle it' at face value. Build a rhythm of check-ins that normalise conversations about capacity. Lucas: And name the pattern early. If you hear it three times in a week from the same person, that's a signal. Have the conversation before there's a crisis. Luna: One last thing — what if the employee says 'I'll handle it' and then actually does, every time, without any issues? Do you still intervene? Lucas: That's a great question. If they consistently deliver and seem happy, you might not need to change anything. But I'd still check in quarterly on their wellbeing. Because the cost of not checking is burnout — and that's much harder to fix than a conversation. Luna: Fair point. Thanks, Lucas. I think I'll be listening a little more carefully to that phrase now. Lucas: Same here. See you next week.