Latest / Manager Mondays with Fexingo: People Management, Team Leadership, and First-Time Managers / How to Coach Your Burned-Out Star Performer
Transcript
- Lucas: A few weeks ago I talked to a senior engineer at a mid-size SaaS company. Let's call her Priya. Luna: Okay. What's Priya's story? Lucas: Priya had been the team's rock for four years. Shipping code, mentoring juniors, stepping in during incidents. Her performance reviews were glowing. But her manager started noticing something — she stopped asking questions in design reviews. She used to push back on timelines. Now she just said 'okay'. She stopped going to optional social events. And she was working longer hours, not shorter. Luna: So on paper she's still exceeding. But the texture of how she shows up is changing. Lucas: Exactly. And this is the hardest burnout to catch — the quiet kind. Not the dramatic collapse. Just a slow withdrawal. The output stays strong for months. Sometimes a year. But the person is running on a reserve tank. Luna: And a lot of managers, especially first-time ones, only look at output. If the tickets are closing, they assume everything's fine. Lucas: Right. A Gallup survey from late 2025 found that nearly 70 percent of managers said they felt ill-equipped to recognize burnout in their team members. Not to fix it — just to see it. And part of the reason is that we reward the behaviors that mask burnout. Reliability, consistency, never dropping a ball. Those are the things we praise in reviews. Luna: So the system itself makes it harder to spot. Priya's manager had to look beyond the metrics. Lucas: That's where we're going today. How do you coach someone who's still performing but clearly running on fumes? Priya's manager tried the obvious move first. She pulled Priya aside and said 'I'm worried you're burning out.' And Priya said 'I'm fine. Just busy. I'll take a long weekend next month.' Luna: Yeah, that's a classic deflection. And the manager backed off, I assume. Lucas: She did. Because Priya said all the right things. Acknowledged the concern, offered a solution, expressed gratitude. But nothing changed. Luna: So what worked? How did they actually turn it around? Lucas: The manager tried a different approach. Instead of labeling it burnout — which Priya resisted because it felt like a weakness — she reframed the conversation around sustainability. She said 'Priya, I want you to be able to do this job for another five years, not just survive the next quarter. What would need to change for that to be true?' Luna: That's a subtle but powerful shift. You're not diagnosing a problem, you're co-designing a future. Lucas: And it worked because it gave Priya permission to be honest without admitting defeat. She started listing things. The weekly report that took four hours and nobody read. The onboarding buddy role she'd had for three years. The expectation that she'd be the one to handle every escalation. Luna: So the manager now had a list. What did they do with it? Lucas: They used a framework I like to call 'drop, delegate, redesign'. Drop the things that have no real impact. The weekly report — gone. Delegate things that someone else could learn. The onboarding buddy role — they rotated it to a mid-level engineer who wanted more mentoring exposure. Redesign the things that are essential but draining. For escalations, they set up a rotation and added a post-mortem step so the lessons were shared, not held by one person. Luna: And what happened to Priya's hours? Lucas: Within six weeks, she was logging off at a reasonable time. She started contributing in design reviews again not because she had to, but because she had the energy to. Her manager told me the biggest change was that Priya's questions came back. That's the tell for a star performer — curiosity. Luna: Love that. Because curiosity is the first thing to go when you're just trying to survive. Lucas: Now, this isn't just a feel-good story. There's a lesson here about what managers get wrong. The go-to response when someone seems burned out is usually 'take some time off'. A week off, a sabbatical, a mental health day. And time off can help, but it's rarely the cure. Luna: Right, because the problem isn't the person's battery. It's the system that keeps draining it. Lucas: Exactly. A 2024 study from the Harvard Business Review looked at knowledge workers who took burnout leave. A full 85 percent said their symptoms returned within three months of coming back. Because the workload hadn't changed. The expectations hadn't changed. The culture hadn't changed. Luna: So the real fix has to be structural. Not just 'rest', but 'restructure'. Lucas: And that's hard for managers because it means taking things off someone's plate, not just validating their feelings. It means making choices about what doesn't get done. And that requires a level of trust and permission from above. Luna: Speaking of permission, one of the hardest things for a first-time manager is knowing they have the authority to actually change someone's role or workload. A lot of them think 'my boss won't let me cut that project' or 'we have to keep that report.' Lucas: And sometimes that's true. But more often, managers don't even ask. They assume there's no flexibility. Priya's manager had to go to her own boss and say 'If we want Priya to stay, we need to eliminate the weekly ops report.' And her boss said 'Fine. I never read it anyway.' Luna: Ha. Classic. We hold onto work because we assume it's important, but nobody's actually using it. Lucas: Which is why a regular 'drop audit' is a good practice. Take one hour every quarter with each team member. Ask: what are you doing that feels low-impact? What could be automated, eliminated, or done by someone else? If you're not doing that, you're probably wasting a lot of energy. Luna: And that audit is especially important for your stars, because they're the ones who accumulate the most invisible work. The extra mentoring, the last-minute requests, the 'this needs a senior eye' tasks. Lucas: Right. Priya's manager realized that Priya had become the default for anything ambiguous. And that's a pattern I see a lot. Top performers get rewarded by being given more responsibility, until the weight of it slowly crushes them. Luna: If you're listening and this episode has given you a new framework for supporting your team, especially your strongest members, that's exactly what we're here for. We keep Manager Mondays ad-free because listeners like you help make it sustainable. If you've gotten value from the show, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure — just a simple way to keep this going. Lucas: And we appreciate every single one. Now, back to Priya. The drop delegate redesign approach worked, but it wasn't a one-time conversation. The manager checked in every two weeks for about three months. Not to ask 'how are you feeling?' — that's too vague. She asked 'what was the most draining part of your week, and what's one thing we could try to change about it?' Luna: So it's ongoing. It's not a fix it once thing. Lucas: No. And that's important because burnout isn't a moment. It's a pattern. And patterns need repeated adjustments to shift. The manager also found that simply offering Priya more autonomy — letting her choose which projects to take on — made a huge difference. Luna: Autonomy is a huge piece. A lot of burnout comes from feeling like you have no control over your own time and work. Lucas: A 2023 study by the University of Michigan looked at over 5,000 workers and found that the single strongest predictor of burnout was low decision latitude — how much control you have over your tasks and schedule. More than hours worked. More than workload volume. Luna: So giving Priya the choice to opt in rather than being assigned everything was part of the recovery. That's a concrete lever any manager can pull. Lucas: One more thing from Priya's story. The manager also started documenting the invisible work. She kept a simple log for two weeks of everything Priya did that wasn't in her job description. It added up to about ten hours a week. That evidence helped make the case to leadership for hiring a second senior engineer. Luna: So the manager used Priya's burnout as data to advocate for the team. That's managing up in the best way. Lucas: Exactly. And that brings me to a broader point. If you're a manager and you see a star performer pulling back, don't just try to fix them. Fix the environment. The workload. The expectations. Burnout is rarely a personal failure. It's a system failure that lands on one person. Luna: And that system failure is especially dangerous when the person is high-performing, because everyone assumes they can handle it. They've been handling it for years. Lucas: Right. So to wrap up today, here's a quick checklist for any manager who suspects a star performer is running on fumes. First, look for changes in behavior, not output. Withdrawal, less curiosity, fewer questions, more 'sure' and 'fine'. Second, don't label it burnout. Reframe around sustainability and long-term success. Third, do a drop delegate redesign audit. Ask the person what they'd change. Fourth, increase their autonomy. Let them choose. Fifth, document the invisible work and use it to advocate for structural changes. And sixth, check in regularly but specifically. Not 'how are you?' but 'what was the most draining part of your week?' Luna: That's a solid actionable list. And managers, if you have one of these on your team today, the best time to start is this week's one-on-one. Lucas: Agreed. Priya is still at that company. She's not just surviving — she's leading a new initiative and mentoring again. But her manager learned that you can't take that for granted. You have to protect the people who carry the most. Luna: Protect, not just praise. That's a good note to end on. Lucas: Thanks for listening. See you next Monday.