Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / The Last Trade E020: Building the Bloomberg Terminal for Bitcoin with Alon Shvartsman
Transcript
- 0:00What you're telling me is that music is about to stop, and
- 0:04we're going to be left holding the biggest bag of bodarous
- 0:07extras ever assembled in the history of doubtless
- 0:131974198792972000? Whatever we want to call this,
- 0:19it's all just the same thing over and over.
- 0:21We can't help ourselves. I say when we.
- 0:24Sell, hey, I say when we sell. And we're live, gentlemen,
- 0:33another edition of the last trade.
- 0:34It's a very rainy, rainy day here in Austin, TX.
- 0:38And wake up at 6:00 AM To drive my brother to the airport.
- 0:44Usually takes 30 minutes round trip.
- 0:46Get to the airport, drop off, get back home.
- 0:49Took me an hour today, double the time.
- 0:53People in Texas don't know how to drive in the rain,
- 0:55apparently. What's up with this, Mr.
- 0:58Tangoma? Why don't Texans know how to
- 1:00drive in the rain? I don't know.
- 1:02I just, I got lost in thought when you mentioned your brother.
- 1:04And I just, I always laugh at, you know, your brother coming
- 1:07into the scene a few years ago and people being confused at
- 1:09conferences or on Twitter and and AD reads and people's heads
- 1:12exploding and not sure if they should bring it up.
- 1:14Is it like to Marty change? Is he the same?
- 1:16Is he work for Unchained? Is he not?
- 1:18That's my brother. We look a lot.
- 1:21There's another. Marty Dent or Marty Dent?
- 1:29Man of mystery, Man of mystery. We're not here to talk about
- 1:34mystery today, though. We're here to talk about
- 1:36hardcore facts. The data of the Bitcoin network.
- 1:41Big launch at Onramp. Today the onramp or yesterday
- 1:45this week the onramp terminal terminal.
- 1:48Dot onrampbitcoin.com if you guys wanna check it out.
- 1:51We are joined today with Elan from New Hedge, which is the
- 1:56back end infrastructure of the terminal that that onramp is
- 2:00using, and we're gonna dump into it.
- 2:03We're gonna dive into the data today.
- 2:05Elan, welcome to the show. Thank you so much.
- 2:08I'm really happy to be here. And speaking about, I guess
- 2:12you're talking about Austin Bergstrom Airport.
- 2:14Is that the one you're talking about?
- 2:15Yes. Yeah.
- 2:16So. Raised in Austin, TX and I think
- 2:20the problem is, is that Texans know how to drive.
- 2:23The problem is that people not from Texas are coming to Texas
- 2:27and they're ruining the roads for the Texans.
- 2:29That's that's the main issue. Is this a dig at me?
- 2:32Is this a dig at me? It's it's a dig at non Texans
- 2:37whether that's you. Yeah, that's been that's been me
- 2:42before and will be me again. I guess that's me right now.
- 2:47Coming from the Northeast, so you were bit more aggressive
- 2:49drivers in the Northeast. Not everybody's strapped up
- 2:52there, so everybody's everybody's willing to be a bit
- 2:57more aggressive. It's funny how everybody's a lot
- 2:59more, a lot more polite when when violence is is is a is a
- 3:06draw away. That's the basis of Southern
- 3:10hospitality. We talked about not getting off
- 3:13the rails before we hit record. We're a little bit off the rails
- 3:15now on. What you've built is incredibly
- 3:19impressive in new Hedge. Before we dive into what you're
- 3:23building, what I would describe is the Bloomberg Terminal for
- 3:27bitcoiners. Let's talk a little bit about
- 3:30your journey and how you ended up building New Hedge.
- 3:33Specifically, what were you doing before and what made you
- 3:36decide? Like, all right, I'm going to go
- 3:38build the Bloomberg Terminal for bitcoiners.
- 3:41Yeah, sure. So I was actually part of, I
- 3:44guess, the class of 2017. That's when I was introduced to
- 3:48Bitcoin and immediately became enthralled.
- 3:51And I actually took, I guess, a similar approach where I kind of
- 3:56didn't understand what was I looking at.
- 3:58And in 2017, you already had a lot of crypto assets as well.
- 4:02So I kind of assumed naively that, you know, Bitcoin is old
- 4:06technology and there's newer technology out there.
- 4:08So let's let's start looking into that.
- 4:11So I went down the, you know the I had a bear market which kind
- 4:15of put me in my place and then that's actually when I started
- 4:19going very deep down the rabbit hole.
- 4:21So I think Safe Dean's The Bitcoin Standard was kind of
- 4:25like my first stepping stone into that to kind of realize
- 4:28that I'm not just looking at technology, I'm looking at I'm
- 4:31looking at economics. I'm looking at philosophy.
- 4:33I'm looking at human nature. And then like like everyone else
- 4:39I guess in the space I wanted to contribute as well.
- 4:41I just, I didn't want to be on the sidelines.
- 4:44So I wanted to do something to kind of contribute to to
- 4:46Bitcoin. So around 2018 I started
- 4:50building a educational site called Bearar.
- 4:53It's one that probably a lot of bitcoiners have not heard of cuz
- 4:56it's geared more towards newcomers and newbies.
- 5:00But essentially what the site does is it helps people find.
- 5:04The best place to buy Bitcoin based on their country.
- 5:07So when I got in in 2017, it was a little bit easy because the
- 5:12only options for, you know, for someone from the US was was
- 5:16Coinbase. So that was kind of like a no
- 5:17brainer to just kind of dive in as someone who doesn't know
- 5:20anything about the space. And as that became a little bit
- 5:23more rich, I started noticing that there's a lot of countries
- 5:25where they have their own, you know, exchanges, their own
- 5:28regulations, and people aren't using the exchanges that I'm
- 5:31using. So I kind of built out this.
- 5:34This really cool website that helps people.
- 5:37So they would kind of come in, they would say okay, I'm from
- 5:40Albania, Croatia, and we built me and my cofounder just a small
- 5:44ranking algorithm that would take all the exchanges that work
- 5:47in that jurisdiction and rank it based on web traffic fees.
- 5:52We would take the live price from the trading book, add the
- 5:55fees onto it so people could gauge exactly like at what price
- 5:59they're going to get it at premiums and stuff like that
- 6:02and. So that was so that was fully
- 6:05launched in 2019. So that was that was like a big
- 6:08wow for me to to to actually contribute to to Bitcoin in in
- 6:13the way that I could coming from kind of like a web development
- 6:16and programming background. So that site now gets around 2
- 6:21million organic visits per year, and that kind of started my kind
- 6:26of like my Bitcoin business journey.
- 6:28But obviously on the side, I've been delving into podcasts and
- 6:32books and I've been kind of like a full time bitcoiner since
- 6:352017. Awesome.
- 6:42So what drove you to data particularly?
- 6:44Did you notice? Yeah, so there was something
- 6:47missing. The mark is obviously we have
- 6:48things like coin metrics, glass node, I guess you can say men
- 6:53pulled out space. There's all these types of
- 6:56different data sites. Drove you to build new hedge
- 6:59specifically in the way that you did?
- 7:02Yeah. So I'll try without not, you
- 7:06know, without digging too much into kind of like other, you
- 7:10know, other sites and other players out there.
- 7:12But I kind of saw that not looking at them pulled up space.
- 7:16But there was a lot of these like really, really cool
- 7:19cryptoanalytic websites that gave you like deep insights into
- 7:23what's happening. But it looked like.
- 7:26From my perspective that they were kind of looking at, you
- 7:29know, the whole crypto space as one conglomerate.
- 7:32You know, obviously you don't know the ideologies behind the
- 7:34people who are working on these projects.
- 7:36But it just kind of seemed like I would jump onto Masari for
- 7:39instance, just to take a look at some Bitcoin data and I'd get
- 7:42like a pop up like do you want to see our, you know, full in
- 7:45depth research on Solana And I'll just be like, well that's
- 7:49not what I'm, I will never be here for that so.
- 7:55So, so around 2020, just because my personal site bearer was
- 8:00getting a lot of traffic and it was helping a lot of people, you
- 8:03know, take their first steps into Bitcoin, I started saying
- 8:06with my cofounder like, you know, like Bitcoin is open.
- 8:10Like let's let's run a node, let's let's try to see if we can
- 8:14create some of these like really cool metrics.
- 8:16So we first started off with trying to recreate like Plan B's
- 8:20stock to flow, which actually has nothing to do with the node,
- 8:22it's mostly just price. But then we started building a
- 8:26lot of these really cool things with like the node that we were
- 8:28running and we started seeing a lot of the traffic from just
- 8:33kind of like the retail side that would just come to visit
- 8:35the site just to see, you know, what's the best hardware wallet
- 8:39to store their Bitcoin and where's the best place to buy.
- 8:41It's actually these charts that we were running, which was
- 8:43mostly like Bitcoin and SMP correlation or.
- 8:48You know, we started building a very early version of like
- 8:50companies that were putting Bitcoin on the balance sheet.
- 8:53So like that was around Michael Saylor's time in 2020.
- 8:56So we started building a lot of these metrics and a lot of the
- 8:59website traffic started gearing towards that.
- 9:02So, so I kind of realized that we were in the early stages of
- 9:05building a Bitcoin focused terminal and when I started
- 9:08looking at what everyone else was doing, you know they had
- 9:10amazing metrics and they had like these amazing data
- 9:14scientists and Python scripts running.
- 9:18But I always saw that it was, it was, it was almost taking the
- 9:21user and leaning them into crypto as like take a look at
- 9:25everything that's happening. And I didn't really get a lot of
- 9:27deep insights into Bitcoin. And when I did, I would have
- 9:31like 20 tabs open and I'd be looking at different websites,
- 9:34one for nodes, one for mining activity, one for, you know,
- 9:39price action and stuff like that.
- 9:41So I'd have these 20 tabs open and I kind of realized, why
- 9:44don't we just? Condense this all into into one
- 9:47terminal. So give kind of users a
- 9:49Bloomberg Terminal esque experience and keep it Bitcoin
- 9:53focused, which allows me, my cofounder and now our team to to
- 9:58really dig deep into Bitcoin and to create a lot of metrics that
- 10:02I would assume that a lot of people haven't seen.
- 10:04So. So we have like a lot of
- 10:05proprietary metrics and a lot of things that if a team wasn't
- 10:09solely focused on Bitcoin, they'd probably just skip over
- 10:12it. They would have never gotten to
- 10:13it so. That's how the Edge came about.
- 10:17Yeah, I love the sharing about the Origin because I think I
- 10:21started to get a little nostalgic in that like we're
- 10:24getting ready. I think if we've been around
- 10:26long enough, we know this like next wave of adoption comes and
- 10:28I think we've, I've said this multiple times.
- 10:29We've been in this like phase for the past almost five years.
- 10:32And if you'd like, if we can discuss a little bit about 2019
- 10:35and anchor back to that. I think there's a lot of folks
- 10:37that weren't around. And it's kind of like really
- 10:39beautiful to see when you think of like a Bitcoin only terminal
- 10:42or Bitcoin only companies were very rare back that multi sig
- 10:44was just like coming out of like OK maybe this might work but the
- 10:48user it wasn't very user friendly.
- 10:51So it's fascinating here like you were in the midst of it.
- 10:54There was, you know the crypto the block and Masari, but you
- 10:56had got push this and then take a Bitcoin from first principles
- 10:59thinking of like OK, I understand data.
- 11:00This is interesting. Now I need to like build it and
- 11:03eventually it'll come and it feels like this is right about
- 11:06the time where when they're coming because.
- 11:08We talked about this a few episodes ago with Chris Kuiper
- 11:10from Fidelity and he said exactly, almost exactly what the
- 11:14Bloomberg this terminal would be for is that to institutional
- 11:17allocators. If you just take your eyes off
- 11:20the price and you look at all the fundamentals that we'll dive
- 11:22into, it looks like all time highs.
- 11:24It looks like this thing is never going back.
- 11:25That's. Exactly right.
- 11:27And that's exactly what you can see with the on terminal as
- 11:30well. So I guess we'll dive into those
- 11:31metrics and then you'll see that that's exactly right if you
- 11:36just. To remove kind of like the the
- 11:38crypto hype cycles and focus on Bitcoin, you'll actually see
- 11:41that you know this is the 600 pound grill in the room, this is
- 11:44what's moving the market, whether that's, whether that's
- 11:46trading volume, whether that's long term holders, whether
- 11:50that's miners entering like we'll see, everything is
- 11:54becoming all time high and that's completely adjacent to
- 11:59price. And it bears repeating that for
- 12:03almost everyone in the world. All that they know is the
- 12:07Bitcoin price. All that they know is the
- 12:09headlines about Bitcoin. And for for almost everyone in
- 12:12the world, Bitcoin is dead, right?
- 12:15As it has been several times before, many times before.
- 12:19And it's been dead for at least a year, right?
- 12:22Like we had the crash, it it's dead and done, it's been
- 12:26flatlined for at least a year. And that's the perspective, the
- 12:30mentality of almost everyone in the world at meanwhile, all
- 12:35these. Actual fundamental metrics show
- 12:37the the opposite is very much true.
- 12:41And and so you know, I just think it's I think it's so
- 12:44interesting how people who are paying attention to Bitcoin and
- 12:47have taken Bitcoin seriously have just such a fundamental
- 12:53mindset difference versus people who are just listening to the
- 12:55headlines. Because the people who are
- 12:58listening to the headlines have no idea that there's any merit
- 13:01under the surface here. All they think is it's tulips
- 13:05and that there's a price and it's dead and and anybody who's
- 13:09paying attention has a massive advantage over 99% of the world
- 13:15who's not paying attention. And all you have to do is look
- 13:17at these metrics in order to to show yourself to like build
- 13:22conviction in your own mind that you know what, there is
- 13:26something happening here. I can see it.
- 13:28It's in the data. But 99% of the world is not
- 13:31looking at this data. So that's your, that's your
- 13:34opportunity to have an advantage in this market.
- 13:38Exactly. And actually it reminds me of an
- 13:40article that you actually wrote and I had not made the
- 13:43connection that you were Creases BPC until actually a couple of
- 13:47days ago. But I actually read your article
- 13:51and this was back in 2020. The Why the yuppie elite
- 13:55dismissed Bitcoin. And then you accompany that with
- 13:58a podcast with Preston Fish, which which I found fascinating
- 14:02because that was a, that was a concept that like I think we
- 14:05were all thinking. But no one put it into words
- 14:08like why are all these people just missing this and just
- 14:10following I guess kind of price and headlines and not
- 14:14understanding that underneath there's this like fundamental
- 14:16shift of what like monetary policy looks like on a, you
- 14:21know, when you get central parties out of it.
- 14:23Like that's that's what we're looking at here.
- 14:25And yeah, I just want to say that I think that article was
- 14:27amazing. I can't help but think, but
- 14:30think. And Marty, I'd love for you like
- 14:32thoughts on this because you're in the middle of it.
- 14:34But like, there's the data that comes in, right?
- 14:37And the data is, it's almost like it's out there, you're
- 14:40pulling it, you're seeing it, you can't really touch it.
- 14:43But there's this thought of, like, what happens in Bitcoin,
- 14:45how do we live in this world where we get to that point?
- 14:48And it's it's never it's assumed the world will be different, but
- 14:51it's not known. Because like $1,000,000 BTC in
- 14:54the world's difference just inherently will be whether it's
- 14:56the price of other assets or the dollar.
- 15:00But then if we think about from back to 2019 to today, think
- 15:03about how much has changed from like minor percentage in China
- 15:07to. In this reference, Marty, Marty,
- 15:09like we were in New York City that was the capital of the
- 15:12world for Bitcoin, no matter what anybody says when it comes
- 15:14to developers and it's not anymore.
- 15:16And it had to move to a different jurisdiction.
- 15:18And all these things that have like completely changed over the
- 15:21past three years that are underneath the data in the real
- 15:23world that like it meets. It's just an interesting thought
- 15:27that like we're sitting here and it's very different than 2019.
- 15:30Yeah. If we go back to 2019, I mean, I
- 15:33was deeply immersed in the mining industry back then.
- 15:37Beginning my mining journey or the year into my mining journey
- 15:412019, just to think of the mining industry learn, I mean
- 15:43you mentioned China, the China ban and the great migration of
- 15:47hash rate across the world in 2021 was pretty massive.
- 15:52But then also in parallel, you had this sort of shift in the
- 15:58industry where up until that point it was a bit of a cottage
- 16:01industry where you had the bunch of these digital wildcatters, if
- 16:05you will, just plugging in machines.
- 16:07Where they could at the cheapest electricity, with the chip, with
- 16:12the cheapest electricity cost. Everybody thought miners were
- 16:15crazy, but over the last four years we've really seen the
- 16:18theme of energy companies beginning to grok Bitcoin mining
- 16:22and implement to get into their operational stacks, take hold,
- 16:26which is massive for the industry.
- 16:27And then likewise, in 2019 the Lightning Network was only a
- 16:30year old. We're now 5 1/2 years in.
- 16:35And so and it's becoming mature, it's becoming much easier to
- 16:38build on. It's got more liquidity.
- 16:39I mean River, Alex Leishman Sweeting out yesterday, their
- 16:43node facilitated 4 million transactions in the month of
- 16:47September. So those metrics are going up.
- 16:51You mentioned Multicig earlier, Michael.
- 16:53It was very nation then and now obviously on ramp exists
- 16:57Unchained had the big announcement for their key list
- 16:59Multicig. Solution This week it's becoming
- 17:02abundantly clear that that Multicig is an incredible
- 17:06primitive to build off of. You have companies like
- 17:08Anchorwatch and the the Wizard Sardine guys in Lania bringing
- 17:14their products to market. That the landscape is completely
- 17:17different and this is just the technical aspects of physical
- 17:21infrastructure, the mining industry, the technical
- 17:23infrastructure at the lightning layer, the technical
- 17:25infrastructure at multicig and then all the while.
- 17:30Even though the price has gone up and down over that time and I
- 17:33think we'll dive into it, the metrics, the on chain metrics in
- 17:36terms of the amount of wallets that are holding 1,000,000 Sats,
- 17:4010 million Sats, one whole Bitcoin are going up, people are
- 17:44holding for longer, people are pulling their Bitcoin off
- 17:46exchanges. And so the fundamentals from
- 17:50mining at the protocol level, at 2nd layers and at the adoption
- 17:54have all significantly increased up and to the right over this
- 17:58time despite. The volatility and price running
- 18:00up to 65, whatever it was down to 16 and a half 15 1/2 and
- 18:06currently sitting at at 28,000 during that that price roller
- 18:10coaster, all these fundamentals have gotten significantly
- 18:13better. And and part of that also is
- 18:17like the greater sophistication of business models.
- 18:21You talked about how the mining industry has evolved, but a
- 18:25great little tidbit from from just yesterday from.
- 18:29Riot is in September. Pierre Rashard tweeted about how
- 18:33in September Riot produced 362 Bitcoin from mining and received
- 18:40511 Bitcoin worth of payments for demand response, Stabilizing
- 18:46the Texas grid. You know, so, so Riot has
- 18:50cleverly incorporated playing ball with the Texas grid to help
- 18:54stabilize it, you know, using the programs that they have
- 18:57available there. To make that part of their
- 18:59business model help stabilize the Texas energy grid and
- 19:03improve their, you know, economics as a result of that,
- 19:07that's like that's the the mining industry going from
- 19:10wildcatters just four years ago to like an integral part of how
- 19:15Texas is approaching grid stabilization and making money
- 19:20for it. It's it's fantastic to see in
- 19:22just four years. Yeah, And when you think about
- 19:25that time scale, four years, it's really not that long.
- 19:27It feels like an eternity in Bitcoin, but it's not even a it
- 19:33hasn't even been like a whole presidential cycle.
- 19:35Biden's not even done his first term yet, and all this has
- 19:38happened. But I guess let's look at the
- 19:42data. Elan, you've been building New
- 19:45Edge, really trying to surface these metrics and these high
- 19:48signal data points in the Bitcoin network.
- 19:51As you were building New Edge, what were some of the metrics?
- 19:54That stuck out to you. That really emboldened your your
- 19:59conviction in Bitcoin. It's, it's it's kind of good
- 20:03that we were talking about mining right before this
- 20:04question because everything related to mining was absolutely
- 20:08amazing to see because as you see price drop around 50 to 60%
- 20:12from all time highs. If you're looking at these
- 20:14mining metrics like hash rate and difficulty, we're reaching
- 20:17all times high in those. So, so you're you're putting a
- 20:20strain on minors where they're actually it's harder to mine,
- 20:23there's more people mining the hash rate is going absolutely
- 20:26hyperbolic and and the actual rewards minor revenue is
- 20:30actually coming down it's it's almost it's like you know we can
- 20:33show it on the screen minor revenue is absolutely stagnant.
- 20:37So it's it's actually really interesting to see that even in
- 20:42times where price price action is suboptimal I guess and you
- 20:47would you would assume that that's kind of what minors are
- 20:49looking at. Minors are actually doubling
- 20:51down and they're plugging in and they're and they're pushing
- 20:53network difficulty to all time highs and hash rate as well.
- 20:56So I think that was kind of like the most interesting just base
- 20:58layer just kind of like when we were looking at the data like
- 21:01that was insanely interesting. So, so yeah, so there you can
- 21:04see in the blue and that's the hash rate and then obviously the
- 21:08price is in orange and you can see from that all time high, you
- 21:12know we've, you know prices drawn down 50 to 60% yet in that
- 21:16same time hash rate has just absolutely been on a rip.
- 21:20Yeah, I think. Looking at this chart
- 21:22particularly, you can see the China ban in 2021 with that 25%
- 21:27reduction in hash rate. And I think the Shard is
- 21:30beautiful because it just highlights the anti fragility of
- 21:33the Bitcoin network. Hash rate fell by 25% and it
- 21:37recovered within a year, within six months back to where it was
- 21:42before the China ban because the economic incentive to figure out
- 21:46where to plug those miners in was so high.
- 21:49And it's worth that. It's worth.
- 21:51Reminding everyone of of what it felt like then and what the
- 21:54narratives were in that 234 month period where hash rate.
- 21:59You know, at that point in time, the the chart looked really ugly
- 22:02because, you know, it had been up and to the right.
- 22:05And then suddenly it's it's Thanksgiving.
- 22:08Turkey's Wellness. So, you know, suddenly dropping
- 22:11off precipitously. And it looked like this could be
- 22:15a mortal blow to the Bitcoin network.
- 22:17And that narrative people ran with that narrative.
- 22:20The the people who. Who frankly want to see Bitcoin
- 22:23die were were loudly proclaiming its death at that point in time
- 22:29But then the antifragility of of economic opportunity on Bitcoin
- 22:35for for anyone who had hash rate available and could step in to
- 22:40take advantage of China going offline, you know that one in
- 22:46the long term but at that moment in time it felt like Bitcoin
- 22:49could die. It felt like it felt like people
- 22:53thought Bitcoin could die and that we were in some sort of
- 22:56negative headline news spiral as a result of that.
- 23:00And then, you know, a few years have passed and you can look
- 23:05back on that moment in time as just another blip, another test
- 23:10of Bitcoin's antifragility, where Bitcoin passed with flying
- 23:14colors. And you know, I think it's for
- 23:16for longterm holders. You live through a bunch of
- 23:19those. Narratives for different reasons
- 23:23and different points in time why Bitcoin is doomed.
- 23:26And time and again they end up amounting to nothing.
- 23:31And you stop putting any weight in those.
- 23:36The next narrative that comes around, you know, maybe, maybe
- 23:39it's going to be with the 2024 election, politicians are going
- 23:44to ban Bitcoin. And you know, who knows what
- 23:47it's going to be next, but. It ends up not working out
- 23:50because the fundamentals of this thing are just so, so resilient
- 23:55to and and and rooted in human behavior and in human incentive
- 24:00rather than anything else. And you know, the China mining
- 24:04ban is the perfect example of Bitcoin's antifragility and why
- 24:10whenever the next FUD comes around, the next narrative for
- 24:13why Bitcoin is doomed, You have to.
- 24:16Take a step back and and think about from first principles,
- 24:21Does this does this hurt people's opportunity to make
- 24:25money by adopting Bitcoin? And if not then Bitcoin will
- 24:29survive. And the answer is always there's
- 24:32opportunity to adopt Bitcoin or or mine Bitcoin and make money
- 24:37and that's why Bitcoin keeps surviving.
- 24:40And I don't want to hog the mic too much, but I do think.
- 24:44That period during the China ban, since I was in the mining
- 24:46industry, that's when I became most convicted.
- 24:49I mean, I was pretty convicted, but being behind the scenes,
- 24:51everybody over here in the US and the mining industry was
- 24:55brokering basically the facilitation of the migration of
- 24:59the A6 from China. Either they here in the USI mean
- 25:02a lot of people with the Kazakhstan, South America, the
- 25:06Nordic countries, but just being behind the scenes and literally
- 25:09as soon as the ban came down. That's what a lot of people
- 25:12don't realize is yes, China is a communist country, but there's
- 25:16very hyper capitalistic aspects of their economy and so the I
- 25:22make the argument that the Chinese Bitcoin miners in the
- 25:251st 15 years. Of Bitcoin's existence are
- 25:29probably the most hyper capitalistic subsect of the
- 25:33whole market, and it was crazy to see as soon as the ban came
- 25:36down, just how creative they got and how quickly they moved to to
- 25:39get their ASICS out of China into, say, for shores outside of
- 25:44the Ccp's borders. Isn't there like a case?
- 25:48I haven't thought deeply about it, but just from a, you know,
- 25:51first principles like don't tell me or.
- 25:55The whole saying like show me your portfolio, I don't want to
- 25:56hear what you say. It's like minors are the old
- 25:59ultimate bullish on the network. They're putting all their
- 26:02capital in it. And that's where like when you
- 26:03see that chart with the hash rate continue to grow
- 26:06independent of the price. It's like they're as long as you
- 26:09can be physical, you know mental professional in it and
- 26:13continuing to like plan for that growth of the the price because
- 26:17eventually you can be upside down there.
- 26:22What's your. Yeah, I'm just curious like the
- 26:24thought cuz that's always been in that thought in my head, but
- 26:26I know there's probably other bullish charts are fundamental,
- 26:29but I'm curious like the thoughts after looking at that
- 26:31chart. Yeah, so actually on top of that
- 26:34chart, if speaking on anti fragility, I think another chart
- 26:38to just actually show how anti fragile the network is is the
- 26:42Bitcoin node map. So I don't know if we could pull
- 26:44that up right now, but after that mining ban, so we were
- 26:48running this script that was actually put together by the
- 26:52team of bit nodes, which was a methodology to actually gather
- 26:55the amount of reachable and listening nodes in the network,
- 26:58extract their IP addresses and put that in kind of on a globe.
- 27:06So that's exactly what we did here.
- 27:08And if you spin over to China, so you'll see that there is
- 27:13still what is that number, is that 50?
- 27:16Yep. So there's still 50 individual
- 27:20IP addresses running Bitcoin Core.
- 27:22So we don't know if they're mining nodes, if they're
- 27:25archival nodes, pruned nodes or full nodes.
- 27:29But this speaking on antifragility, this was kind of
- 27:32like an amazing metric to see. Obviously the number was higher
- 27:35before the Bitcoin mining ban, but to know that there's fifty
- 27:39individual IP addresses still running Bitcoin Core is
- 27:42absolutely fascinating. And I think on the one year
- 27:45anniversary NASDAQ was actually looking into into you know the
- 27:51one year anniversary of the Bitcoin mining ban and actually
- 27:54featured that chart that we that we produced in their in their
- 27:59kind of research. So that was kind of more
- 28:02testament as to, you know, like this thing is unstoppable.
- 28:07Like even when you have the most authoritarian government banning
- 28:11the act of mining, you still have IP addresses running it,
- 28:14which is amazing. That would only be the non Tor
- 28:18nodes right? Like the Tor nodes wouldn't be
- 28:21like Geo located IP, right, Exactly.
- 28:25Yeah. So if you actually go back to
- 28:27that chart and scroll a little bit down, we actually identify
- 28:29the amount of the percentage of nodes that are actually Tor.
- 28:34So I think, yeah, if you scroll a little bit down, OK, yeah,
- 28:40node exactly. So the torrent so around 63% are
- 28:43actually running through Tor and those are ones that we cannot
- 28:45get IP addresses on. And so there could be a ton of
- 28:48Tor nodes in China, and they just don't show up like, you
- 28:52know, And that's part of why you can't stop Bitcoin, because the
- 28:56Chinese authorities would like to find what nodes are running
- 28:59in China and stop them, but they can't because of Tor.
- 29:04There's a impossible thing to. I mean, and it should be it
- 29:08should, Michael, before you join.
- 29:09It should be highly the fact that more than half the nodes
- 29:12running in the world are running behind Tor is extremely bullish.
- 29:16They're hard to identify. Yeah.
- 29:18And these are just reachable. So there's other methodologies.
- 29:23So there's you can obviously run a node and have it not connect
- 29:25with other nodes, which is I think what most people are
- 29:28doing. So I actually think that this is
- 29:29a very small percentage of the actual nodes running Bitcoin
- 29:32Core. It's.
- 29:33A good distinction. What's also really bullish,
- 29:35there is and we talk about this a lot as soon as we get in
- 29:38trouble about where Bitcoin adoption will ultimately, you
- 29:41know, come from or grow. And you see like 1600 nodes in
- 29:45the US on this chart. And it was good that Logan
- 29:48pulled it up, because it looks like second, which is kind of
- 29:50surprising. I didn't expect Germany to be.
- 29:51Like 21 Germany's. Number one or two, I think it's
- 29:56#2 number. One US #1, the point in that,
- 30:00the point in that being that that.
- 30:04The US really leading the way and like innovation you because
- 30:07you think about the nodes as a number of like a proxy for the
- 30:09number of individuals that are facilitating other things other
- 30:13than just running a node, right. Whether it's businesses they're
- 30:15they're putting in like intellectual thought to like set
- 30:18that up. But anyway, it's just like a it
- 30:22was a common thing that's come up if you actually look in this
- 30:25ties into discussion on emerging markets where emerging markets
- 30:28are important, but if you go to the back to the top Logan.
- 30:32Look at the the, the number. So we have 1600 US, 1200
- 30:35Germany, 400 France and then drops in Netherlands, in Canada.
- 30:39But this is where you'll see Bitcoin adoption from an actual
- 30:43like activity and innovation. I would expect in these top ten
- 30:46countries before you start going to, you know other markets that
- 30:49you'll hear a lot of the focus but ultimately won't move the
- 30:51needle, at least in my opinion. Well, this is probably
- 30:54indicative of business formation too.
- 30:56Because you're running a a proper Bitcoin business, you're
- 30:58going to run your own node to ensure that.
- 31:02You're validating the data that you're providing your customers,
- 31:04or using to facilitate businesses as well.
- 31:07I would say that's a part of it. But at the same time, if
- 31:10somebody's facilitating their safety or like their savings,
- 31:16they're inherently educated if they're gonna put money and
- 31:19capital there. So they would inherently like
- 31:20part of that be running a node to make sure that it confirms
- 31:23so. Yeah, it's certainly correlated.
- 31:27People running nodes or orange peeling the people around them
- 31:30and maybe starting Bitcoin businesses or incorporating
- 31:33Bitcoin into their existing business.
- 31:35And so it certainly correlated with societal Bitcoin adoption.
- 31:41Yeah. What are some of your favorite
- 31:44non mainstream metrics that you guys have in the terminal that
- 31:48sort of stick out to you. So obviously we have some fun
- 31:52ones just to kind of like play, you know play into kind of like
- 31:55the memification of a lot of these, you know, Moon Boy
- 31:59metrics like we have the rainbow charts which is just kind of
- 32:03like a fun one. It's a log logarithmic
- 32:05regression with these colorful bands just to kind of just to,
- 32:09you know, I guess people use it just to kind of gauge on a on a
- 32:13log scale tops and bottoms. That's kind of like a fun one
- 32:17just to look at and just to. Jesse, Love.
- 32:19Jesse knows. Jesse knows that chart very
- 32:22intimately. It's the stock to flow chart.
- 32:27No, Marty, not. Yeah, it's the chart that
- 32:30lampoons stock to flow rather effectively.
- 32:34Yeah. Yeah.
- 32:36So there you can kind of see just just bands and this is just
- 32:40logarithmic regression. And then you kind of see the
- 32:42price moving through the bands. And I guess, I guess what like
- 32:45the only I guess interesting thing here without it being a
- 32:48meme is that you can kind of see that based on this, there was no
- 32:52blow off top in the 2021-2022 kind of bull cycle.
- 32:59And I guess that's the only interesting thing to gather from
- 33:03this. I guess, like, I also obviously
- 33:06like looking at some fun metrics as well.
- 33:09I think another really cool one that I like to look at and
- 33:14update a lot is Treasuries, which is the amount of Bitcoin
- 33:21being held on public and private balance sheets of companies.
- 33:26Yeah, so this is kind of a pie chart just kind of showing where
- 33:29most of that Bitcoin is being held.
- 33:30But if you scroll a little bit further down, you can actually
- 33:33see each company when when they purchased their cost basis,
- 33:39today's value, the amount of Bitcoin that they hold a percent
- 33:42of the 21 million. And this one I really, really
- 33:46liked like obviously, like we've probably seen Bitcoin, a Bitcoin
- 33:50treasury table before. What I kind of noticed was that
- 33:54it's kind of community sourced. So people just kind of drop in
- 33:57and say like, hey, I know this company that's holding 66
- 34:01Bitcoin on the balance sheet, but there's kind of no proof of
- 34:03that. So with this approach, I kind of
- 34:06really wanted to look at filings to see like, all right, if it's
- 34:09a public company, is there like SEC filings and 8K that I can
- 34:12look at to actually see if they're buying or selling?
- 34:16And then obviously with private companies like I think block one
- 34:19is there. So not block, but block One that
- 34:23is a company. They're the ones that launched a
- 34:28shake coin called EOS back in 2017.
- 34:31And what's actually interesting is that a lot of the proceeds
- 34:35that they got from selling the ICO, they converted to Bitcoin.
- 34:38So they're actually holding, I don't know if we can see that.
- 34:42Yeah, block one is actually holding 140,000 Bitcoin.
- 34:46That's a, that's a huge amount and that's a private company.
- 34:50And what we did is actually linked to where the CEO of that
- 34:55company actually made the announcement that this is how
- 34:57much they hold on their balance sheet, which so this one I
- 35:02really like to look at. Yeah.
- 35:07And that. Yeah, Sorry.
- 35:07Go ahead. I was gonna say just the whole
- 35:11just thing about 1 caliber of holder like corporations holding
- 35:14Bitcoin on their balance sheet this is.
- 35:17One subset of the potential Hotler base and that is a theme
- 35:21that's increasing, especially as we have treasury markets going
- 35:25haywire right now. There's definitely people
- 35:27looking for different assets to hold their liquid reserves in.
- 35:32Yeah, we're actually interesting.
- 35:33If you go further down, you can actually see the amount actually
- 35:35being held in treasuries and it actually is correlated with the
- 35:38amount of Bitcoin that's actually left the mine.
- 35:41So, you know, we only have 92 percent, 90 or close to 93% of
- 35:46the Bitcoin supply actually circulating.
- 35:48So we have another, you know, 7 to 8% that's going to be mined,
- 35:53which equates to around 1.4 million Bitcoin that's left to
- 35:57mine. And so these treasuries actually
- 35:59started with Michael Saylor and that was in 2020.
- 36:02So since then they've accumulated these public and
- 36:05private companies $1.6 million, that's, I'm sorry, 1.6 million
- 36:10Bitcoin is being held on the balance sheets, which is, Which
- 36:13is actually incredible. That's 44 billion USD value
- 36:16today, yeah? It's awesome.
- 36:22I'm just going through the the terminal right now on the on the
- 36:25side panel of all the various charts you have and I've never
- 36:28seen this Never look back price chart which is a pretty cool
- 36:32metric. Logan, if you want to find that
- 36:36and pull it up, the the chart just shows the Bitcoin price
- 36:39chart. And if you if you click you know
- 36:41the all year's view, you can see how you know there's a lot of
- 36:47noise and there's bubbles along the way.
- 36:49But over time it's kind of the never look back price, the price
- 36:54at which you know the the the, the price that you know, you
- 36:59never go below. It never returns.
- 37:03It rises in a stepwise fashion over time and it kind of lines
- 37:07up with the havings a little bit.
- 37:10Yeah, you gotta click that all at the top right Logan?
- 37:15Yeah, cool metric to see. This is why a Bitcoin terminal
- 37:20is so valuable to take a look at the data and find the signal in
- 37:25the noise, right? Cuz the Bitcoin price chart has
- 37:28a ton of noise and it's easy to not make sense of it.
- 37:32But by looking at these various metrics, you can say.
- 37:36You know what? There's something here of of
- 37:37Bitcoin is frankly Bitcoin is monetizing, right.
- 37:40It's going from Internet Monopoly money that's not worth
- 37:43anything and and it it is bootstrapping itself, monetizing
- 37:48its way to becoming digital gold for the Internet era and that
- 37:53never look back. Price shows that process with
- 37:56the noise removed. I think that's really cool
- 37:59metric and one of the gems in here that that you guys have
- 38:02made. Yeah, it's it's a great call out
- 38:04Jesse about part of this and investing in this and we're glad
- 38:09to meet Alon and work together on this is really like I think
- 38:12there's a subset of individuals listening to this that this
- 38:15could be helpful. But it's really individuals
- 38:18looking to, to Jesse's point about like this common thought
- 38:21that the price of Bitcoin at any given time, whatever the number,
- 38:24is right now $27,000. And you know.
- 38:28Allocators, skeptics, there's this inherent bias because if
- 38:30you didn't get in when you heard about it at 3K, it's like, oh,
- 38:33and probably going to go to 0 at a certain point.
- 38:35And that this realization that there's a lot happening between
- 38:38zero and $27,000 and it's all in this terminal.
- 38:41And so to the extent that somebody's interested, you can
- 38:43share this, we'll get them access and then they can go in
- 38:45and pull through and we'll be producing content and reports to
- 38:48go and show that. Some of the most bullish, I
- 38:50think Jesse shared 1 Logan, if you can pull up on the market
- 38:53tab, the one that's always stuck with me and it was really cool.
- 38:56I don't know if we added. Feedback or you already had it
- 38:59along, but it's Bitcoin profitable days because it's
- 39:02it's such a great like snapshot of just like looking at this
- 39:06thing and you just have this, like you know, we're a little
- 39:08bit more in red than you generally see on this chart.
- 39:10But still it's just a great like 15 years and you have these like
- 39:14little periods where you're just if you if you didn't hold long
- 39:17enough, you're sitting in red. But as long as you can have a
- 39:19longer, you know, lower time preference, longer term view,
- 39:22you're going to be okay in preserving wealth and value.
- 39:27Michael did clarify. We just said that.
- 39:29I mean, there were times in Bitcoin's history, if you pulled
- 39:31the chart back up, Logan, where it looks similar to this where
- 39:35you had red at the end, like that red that is red right now
- 39:38will eventually be green. Like if you go back to 2018,
- 39:44everything to the left of that was probably red.
- 39:46Yeah, that Marty. I think that's a good
- 39:48distinction. Really to to me, what this chart
- 39:50says is even though it feels like Bitcoin is dead.
- 39:54This has happened before and and everybody who bought at the top
- 39:57in 20/18/2017 in December 2017, they're they're sitting pretty
- 40:03now, right? Like they're even though it was
- 40:06a painful few years, they are in the profit.
- 40:10They are in profit now. If you bought the top in 2013 at
- 40:13$1000, you were an idiot for three years and and now you've
- 40:18made a 27X on your money. And so, even though right now
- 40:23people who bought at the top probably regret it, history
- 40:27shows that that you know, as Bitcoin keeps doing its thing,
- 40:32you will be happy that you bought at at 65,000 in 2021 in a
- 40:38few years. Yeah, and this goes back to
- 40:43another point too. Like, it could actually have
- 40:45been more read. Alon, you brought it up during?
- 40:49The part of the show we were looking at the rainbow chart,
- 40:51but we didn't have a blow off top in 2021.
- 40:55And this is The funny thing about narratives in the market,
- 40:58particularly around FTXA lot of people were trying to proclaim
- 41:01that FTX was artificially pushing the price higher with
- 41:06their wash trading. But the reality the situation is
- 41:10they were taking Bitcoin and selling it to buy real estate in
- 41:15the Caribbean, to buy politicians, to buy shit coins,
- 41:17whatever it may be. You know you could.
- 41:19Arguably it went higher if FTX wasn't participating in overt
- 41:24fraud. Another like a totally different
- 41:28type of Alon has so many cool metrics in here.
- 41:33We've been talking purely about the the market section.
- 41:36But you know, on the on the side panel here there's a bunch of
- 41:39different categories and one of them is derivatives.
- 41:43And there's another chart in here that I've I've never seen
- 41:45pulled together so cleanly before.
- 41:48So, Logan, if you want to go to the derivatives category and go
- 41:50to the BTC Futures open interest chart, this shows align.
- 41:58Correct me if I'm wrong here but this shows the nominal futures
- 42:03contracts on Bitcoin across these various exchanges at every
- 42:10point in time over the last few years really since the the
- 42:14advent of futures markets in Bitcoin.
- 42:18And you can see how there are certain moments in time like
- 42:21like recently futures interest was was ticking upwards in I I
- 42:29guess that was probably August of 2023 and right then we got a
- 42:35a bunch of longs long leverage wiped out with our our drop from
- 42:4030 down to 25 or whatever that was thousand per per Bitcoin.
- 42:47And this tells I I think this is a very helpful dashboard to be
- 42:52able to pull up and take a look at is the market perhaps over
- 42:57leveraged right now or what explains the recent drop, was it
- 43:02leverage getting wiped out And and that we can see to hear that
- 43:05that was the case with the most recent drop about a month ago
- 43:11where we took off a fair bit of leverage out of the market and
- 43:15it hasn't really returned which is while meanwhile the price has
- 43:19been slowly ticking back upwards towards 30,000 which to me is a
- 43:24very bullish indicator that the price is drifting upwards.
- 43:27Leverage is not being added, at least not to the level that it
- 43:31was. And that is a healthy market, a
- 43:34healthy Bitcoin uptrend, even though it's very modest at at
- 43:38this point in time. So it's a cool metric along
- 43:44that. I don't, I don't know.
- 43:45Did you guys, did you guys build this from scratch?
- 43:47I I've never seen this anywhere else.
- 43:50Yeah. Alon's nodding.
- 43:51Yep. Yeah.
- 43:52So this was, this was a difficult 1 to get and we're
- 43:56still, we're still building it out.
- 43:58So we want to add more exchanges.
- 43:59Obviously we kind of started with the ones that we know have
- 44:02I guess more reputable numbers of kind of trading volume.
- 44:07So there's no spoofing, there's no watch trading something like
- 44:09that. So we kind of started off with
- 44:11four or five, but it's it's quite difficult to get this data
- 44:14and to to plot it you know with with a little bit of like
- 44:16historical, historical data as well.
- 44:19But yeah, we plan on really going hard in derivatives.
- 44:23There's a lot of really, really cool data there that you can
- 44:26also kind of within the terminal also look at other metrics and
- 44:30kind of combine them together and get like a a bigger picture
- 44:32of what's happening in Bitcoin, which was, you know, the initial
- 44:35idea of having a Bitcoin focused terminal.
- 44:37So it's kind of cool that when I was looking at these metrics,
- 44:40you'd have to go to, you know? 10/10/15 different sites and
- 44:44kind of have one of those, you know, old school, you know,
- 44:48setups to just kind of get a picture of what's going on.
- 44:51So yeah, it's kind of cool that you can see this here with
- 44:53mining with network, with all this other kind of cool data
- 44:56that we show. Yeah it's awesome that you
- 44:58pulled this all together here and and and you're right I think
- 45:00that derivatives is is sort of it's the the tail that often
- 45:04wags the dog in in Bitcoin and I think you know Dylan Leclair
- 45:11who's on ramp advisors often putting the spotlight on
- 45:17derivatives and how that is is the explanation many times for
- 45:21when a certain when a sudden price movement happens it it can
- 45:25it can often be explained by changes in the derivative market
- 45:29and with this chart you can you know come check that and and see
- 45:33ah yeah it was derivatives making a you know that's
- 45:36responsible for the the recent drop or the recent pump whatever
- 45:40it is and I'm just really cool chart here.
- 45:44And it's got me wondering, Elan, do you think getting people
- 45:50access to this data in a more consolidated form will lead to a
- 45:55more, I don't want to say efficient market, but better
- 45:59actions within the market. You have better equipped
- 46:02individuals with better data making better decisions at the
- 46:05end of the day. I think so.
- 46:07I think I think what happened in 2020 and 2021, there was a lot
- 46:11of kind of VC plays into the analytics space in crypto.
- 46:16And what you ended up seeing was a lot of these, you know,
- 46:19massively overvalued companies that were just throwing massive
- 46:23Nets over crypto data and spending so much time
- 46:27researching NFTS and Luna and Solana and things that kind of
- 46:31are all noisy, that are all going to trend to zero against
- 46:34Bitcoin, that's for sure. And I think the market, you
- 46:37know, like someone enters the market and just it's very hard
- 46:42to delineate, takes a little bit of research to understand that
- 46:45there's Bitcoin and then there's a crypto industry which is 2
- 46:50very separate things. So I think to have a product
- 46:53that's Bitcoin focused and it's gonna continually have a team
- 46:57dedicated focused on Bitcoin only metrics.
- 47:01I think this is kind of where smart money is going to end up
- 47:05filtering through and we kind of like we don't know what's gonna
- 47:12happen in the next hype cycle. I'm sure the crypto VCs and the
- 47:16insiders will create some NFT like hype that's going to bring
- 47:21the next cohort of users in, but I think.
- 47:25After that hype dies down, which it has this time, and in the
- 47:282017 era with IC O's, they're going to come back and see that
- 47:32Bitcoin all this time has been just moving up and to the right,
- 47:37and I have to understand why. Yeah, can we actually unpack
- 47:41that a little more on the, like, social aspect because we talked
- 47:44about this last week with the intermediary advisory firm for
- 47:48pensions that he felt very comfortable in coming out
- 47:51because he ultimately had his, his boss.
- 47:54You know was there giving air cover and exposure and talking
- 47:59about it openly. And I I think back of like you
- 48:02know my personal journey and being, you know in 2017,
- 48:05eighteen and I'm sure we've all gone through this, whatever the
- 48:09time period where you you're going on the rabbit hole and the
- 48:12price is also going down and you're just like am I dumb?
- 48:15Does not make sense and that's where like the pods and a lot of
- 48:17this information comes in. But your point along you
- 48:20referenced smart money coming in and you've created social
- 48:24aspects of this whether it's incorporating you know your
- 48:27background the individual you know allocator enthusiasts
- 48:31background their Twitter handle things about them, the ability
- 48:36to chat with other folks inside the terminal research to help
- 48:41add more qualitative reports and quantitative along with the
- 48:45data. Can you speak some of the speak
- 48:46to the vision around that we we? For the listeners, we're gonna
- 48:50incorporate an onboarding emails, maybe a few to help and
- 48:53share this so you don't just get thrown directly into the mix.
- 48:56We did it at this launch, but maybe along can walk through
- 48:59some of the things that we will help in educating when you sign
- 49:01up so you can get the best use of it from the data, but then
- 49:04also to interact with other folks in the industry if you
- 49:07want to, you don't have to, but I think that this could be a
- 49:09very valuable tool for that as well.
- 49:12Yeah, exactly. And that kind of plays on what
- 49:14you're talking about smart money is that I think that?
- 49:17The social aspect is very interesting because if you were
- 49:19to have just the static site kind of showing charts that
- 49:22update regularly, well you kind of want to know what's happening
- 49:26and what the community says about them.
- 49:27So then you know, the natural next step is to maybe go to
- 49:30Reddit or to go to some forums or to go to Twitter.
- 49:33But then you don't know who to follow.
- 49:35You don't know whether they're reputable.
- 49:36You know they're you go to YouTube and I think the YouTube
- 49:39Bitcoin slash crypto communities as a whole generally is, is, is.
- 49:44There's really not much to learn.
- 49:45There's maybe like a few like BTC sessions that actually
- 49:48creates amazing content, but it's very hard to get to that.
- 49:50So the idea was like, so this is a terminal, we should build a
- 49:55social layer on top of this as well.
- 49:56So we want users to talk about the metrics.
- 50:00So each metric there's a small little chat icon there and users
- 50:04are able to chat about the metric.
- 50:06So they can also while they're looking at these charts
- 50:09updating, there's kind of a feed going on from the community of
- 50:12just gathering sentiment about what they're looking at.
- 50:14Maybe something that you wouldn't have known or it would
- 50:17have taken you hours into, you know going through Twitter
- 50:20threads just to find a specific information about that certain
- 50:24metric, network difficulty or hash rate or nodes or something
- 50:28like that. So, so I think we we built the
- 50:31terminal with that in mind where we wanted this Bloomberg
- 50:33Terminal esque experience. So we do have like a research
- 50:37tab, which takes research from a lot of a lot of like very
- 50:42reputable research groups and it consolidates them, so you can
- 50:45kind of pick and choose which one you want to read.
- 50:46It updates I think every 30 minutes as new ones come in.
- 50:52We also have a News tab, so you're able to search through
- 50:56news and see. As it's coming and you're also
- 51:00able to chat there with the community as well and you have
- 51:02profiles, so you're able to, I think.
- 51:04I think the bigger vision there is like if you're familiar with
- 51:07Seeking Alpha, you're able to like write an article and go
- 51:12through a paywall to write that article.
- 51:14So the idea was you have a profile and let's say a Lynn
- 51:16Alden comes in, or a Will Clemente or a Dylan and they
- 51:21want to write an article. We could put a small paywall
- 51:24behind, maybe like a lightning invoice.
- 51:26And then everyone within the terminal can pay that lightning
- 51:29invoice and then get direct access to that article.
- 51:31And all of it is kind of just creating this stickiness and to
- 51:35be synonymous with Bitcoin data. So this is kind of like, I guess
- 51:40the way I like to see it is Bitcoin's front end to its
- 51:42massive back end network. It's so cool.
- 51:45I was just looking at it and there's already people talking
- 51:47on the news articles about this is awesome.
- 51:50And then? Yeah, you could just see how
- 51:55that kind of grows with I lost my train of thought.
- 51:58But there was also like video I I could see a world where to.
- 52:01To your point, like YouTube, it's a it's accessible, it's
- 52:05it's a mess for people to find the the signal.
- 52:08Except for the show. Well, of course, but to to be
- 52:13able to like aggregate the best content from like the video,
- 52:17because I think a lot of individuals consume the media.
- 52:20You know podcast via this format and to be able to go into the
- 52:23terminal and just see like the thumbnails from the most
- 52:25relevant or the things you're following and just have an
- 52:28aggregator, not have to be sleuthing all over the Internet
- 52:30trying to just dodging bullets on what is noise and crap cuz
- 52:34that happens a lot. I've talked to a lot of
- 52:36potential clients or people come through and they're just like
- 52:38looking at YouTube. Just like especially in a bull
- 52:41market. It's different in a bear cuz you
- 52:42have more time, there's less people out there, but in a bull
- 52:44you're just getting thrown. You know, moon Safe Moon.
- 52:47Or, you know, Dave Portnoys out there chilling whatever he is.
- 52:52I just couldn't imagine a smart money investor sitting on a
- 52:55terminal and just getting all this noise thrown into their
- 52:59face and completely missing like the the, the huge revolution
- 53:04that's happening just with all these, all these like the noise
- 53:07happening above it. And I guess we kind of see that
- 53:09with the YouTube community you have like the bit, the bit boys
- 53:12I guess. And and people like that and
- 53:14it's just terrible that like when someone enters this
- 53:16community and there's an actual idea and problem that's being
- 53:20solved with Bitcoin and there's a lot, a lot of deep knowledge
- 53:23that can be that can be kind of sourced from that.
- 53:26You get kind of, you know, the grifter community and stuff like
- 53:29that. So I think having a Bitcoin only
- 53:31focused product for smart money is, I guess kind of like the
- 53:35natural progression of where Bitcoin goes.
- 53:39And. Again, a lot of what you've
- 53:41built is incredibly impressive and obviously we're using the
- 53:45Bloomberg analogy a lot because in my opinion, it is like the
- 53:48perfect analog to what you're building.
- 53:51And that's something that Bloomberg shifting gears toward
- 53:54putting your founder hat on and actually producing a product and
- 53:57historically. In the Bitcoin industry, it's
- 54:00been hard to create a profitable business.
- 54:02But I think what you're building with New Hedge could be
- 54:04extremely profitable. People need the data, they need
- 54:07the social aspect, they need the signal, and then adding that
- 54:10social aspect where people can communicate.
- 54:12And that's one of the biggest drivers for the Bloomberg
- 54:14terminals, all these traders being able to talk to each
- 54:17other, to DM each other directly in the terminal.
- 54:19And so just having that functionality I can only imagine
- 54:24like the. Amount of high quality
- 54:26conversations that will go in with the data right there that
- 54:29you can just share, hey, this is what I'm seeing.
- 54:32This is what's happening in the market, like it's happening.
- 54:36And we actually closed a. It was like a small precede.
- 54:39This was back in February, March of this year.
- 54:42And it was actually very interesting because I kind of
- 54:45reached out to traditional VCs and then crypto VCs as well.
- 54:49And then you have the Bitcoin VCs.
- 54:51And obviously, Bitcoin VC's are hard to come by.
- 54:54There's maybe a handful of them that are that are actually
- 54:56allocating capital to, you know, like lightning companies and
- 55:00very cool things that are happening on Bitcoin.
- 55:02And then crypto VC's are plentiful, plentiful.
- 55:05And when when I came to them and show them this product and show
- 55:08them that there's kind of a gap here in the market that I've
- 55:10noticed that there's really no Bitcoin focus terminal.
- 55:14That's. Going to be helping the new
- 55:16cohort of Bitcoin users to kind of get this rich and deep
- 55:20information. They kind of said, okay, cool.
- 55:23But like, when's the token coming?
- 55:26Let's do a token grant. You're gonna decentralize this?
- 55:29And I was like, no, no, no. We're running like.
- 55:32Huge AWS servers we're we're not decentralizing that for for what
- 55:35purpose like the purpose we're we're presenting data that's
- 55:38that's what we want to do we're we're a data company and it was
- 55:42it was it was a little bit difficult to kind of come around
- 55:45to kind of show people who aren't in the Bitcoin space what
- 55:49the vision is because they all because of what we're talking
- 55:52about earlier they just kind of see the whole crypto is this
- 55:55massive altogether same thing Bitcoin old now we have new you
- 56:00know why are you doing the old. But fortunately I was you know
- 56:04lucky enough to find some some great investors that did believe
- 56:06in the project and and I think it's being validated.
- 56:09I think that like the feedback that you have gotten in the one
- 56:12day since launch of the honor and terminal has been insanely
- 56:16positive and and I think that that's kind of like a validation
- 56:20that that something like this needs to exist.
- 56:22And that's not to say that there isn't amazing places that are
- 56:25also showing Bitcoin data, but you you really need a dedicated
- 56:28team to to really build it out because.
- 56:31Bitcoin, I think, is the market. Everything else is just kind of
- 56:34like it's an industry made to profit.
- 56:36Bitcoin is, you know, the new financial system.
- 56:41Yeah, absolutely. There's there's chaos out there.
- 56:44There's so much noise and what you have done is created a
- 56:46little walled garden of curated Bitcoin only content where it's
- 56:51like this is the place where people can really learn and get
- 56:55high signal Bitcoin only focus and then you know even even
- 57:00socialize with other people who are on the same journey or maybe
- 57:03have you know already established themselves in the in
- 57:06the Bitcoin community. That is like that is what's
- 57:09necessary when there's when there's so much noise out there.
- 57:12You need a curated walled garden that you know is is being
- 57:19lovingly curated really like the.
- 57:22You have to have somebody managing that in order and and
- 57:26and letting people come into their environment rather than
- 57:30being like exposed to all the the snake oil salesman on
- 57:34YouTube or because the YouTube algorithm incentivizes whoever
- 57:38can you know shout the loudest and create the most drama like
- 57:42that gets the most eyeballs. And that is not a a good
- 57:46barometer for signal. You know, that's a good
- 57:49barometer for controversy and the Bloomberg Terminal approach
- 57:53is to provide actual signal underneath noise and that's
- 57:57that's the like the fundamental difference of what you guys have
- 58:01done and commend you for it. Yeah, you'll know, New Edges
- 58:05officially made it when there's a bunch of Twitter accounts.
- 58:08Just just take the tape headlines from New Edge and
- 58:10tweet it out. Yeah, Walter Bloomberg.
- 58:14New hedge, huh? Yeah.
- 58:16Not to. Not to get too sentimental, but
- 58:20like, This is why we're going to ultimately win, because really,
- 58:24like, if you think about it, Alon, he said.
- 58:27Bitcoin only, this is what we're going to do.
- 58:28The market is here, but we know where the pucks going.
- 58:31So it takes people to take a chance.
- 58:33That's entrepreneurship. But then ultimately you need
- 58:35distribution. You need to get it out and
- 58:37independent of like there was two sides to making this happen
- 58:40because when I approached Alon, he could have said no.
- 58:42We're focused on other things, but on the same side, even if he
- 58:46would have said no, just personally.
- 58:47And I think you guys know me well enough.
- 58:50And just like this idea between Marty and what you've developed
- 58:54on the content and media side, it's like it would have been the
- 58:56right thing to do to get this out and distribute it to the
- 58:59market because it's just a better tool and it's what
- 59:00they've needed. And so as we think about that
- 59:03and like grow different products and services to the point that,
- 59:07you know, maybe a crypto VC doesn't see it or get it.
- 59:10There's enough of us out there now that want to see like
- 59:12success and be able to make the introductions and to facilitate
- 59:15you know, incorporating different products and services
- 59:18into other businesses that you don't find that in other
- 59:21industries or another you know, way that people are building.
- 59:24It's more of like a 0 sum game. So it's just it's exciting to be
- 59:27able to like partner with the lawn on this.
- 59:29And I think that this is just the beginning.
- 59:30We're going to have a lot of interesting things that are
- 59:32going to come about, and I think the lawn is probably going to,
- 59:33more than likely not just because of this show, but other
- 59:35things that we can support each other with.
- 59:37Get more exposure for this which ultimately helps Bitcoin when at
- 59:41the end because we're talking about smart money.
- 59:43Like this whole game's about trust.
- 59:46And the idea is a lot of people don't know what's happening.
- 59:49So they're looking for trusted individuals to support them in
- 59:53saying okay, this is where you start your journey.
- 59:56But then if they come in, and I remember this very distinctly
- 59:59when we, you know, had Unchained people came in and it was almost
- 1:00:02like a I would, I would say. Very boldly.
- 1:00:06And it might even been arrogant, but I really believe that.
- 1:00:09I still believe it's like you found your end point here on
- 1:00:12your crypto digital asset Bitcoin journey.
- 1:00:14If you choose to like, let it be that that's up to you.
- 1:00:17But we can provide all the signal, like all the signal on
- 1:00:20education, custody, don't go to block FI, you know all those
- 1:00:23things. And so I think of like what
- 1:00:25we're ultimately that extends to what honor I's doing, that also
- 1:00:28extends to this terminal in the sense of, like, if you're coming
- 1:00:30to the terminal because you believe there's something here,
- 1:00:33there's some trust being developed, then when you just
- 1:00:36see only Bitcoin, you only see only Bitcoin research.
- 1:00:39You may not fully be bought in, it's only Bitcoin.
- 1:00:42But you're at least willing to like, extend that, like leap in
- 1:00:44your mind versus going somewhere else and seeing all these
- 1:00:47things. And you just start off on the
- 1:00:48wrong basis, which I think is ultimately what's rubbed a lot
- 1:00:51of people the wrong way. And where we've seen the past 15
- 1:00:53years be a big problem is that like it's just so much noise and
- 1:00:56all the VC capital and all the things aren't incentivized to
- 1:00:59let somebody do just anchored to this one asset.
- 1:01:02And so it's just kind of like pushed everybody in a like
- 1:01:05moving backwards. And so anyway, just a long
- 1:01:08winded way of saying like I think it's very cool and
- 1:01:11commendable along to build Bitcoin only even though when
- 1:01:13people are saying you know hey, when's the token, when's this
- 1:01:16and then have that kind of like visibility is like if you build
- 1:01:19it they will come and and I think they're gonna start
- 1:01:20coming. I think so as well, yeah.
- 1:01:23I actually turned down quite a bit of V C's like, especially
- 1:01:26ones that are here in Israel. There's quite a bit of, I guess,
- 1:01:29crypto companies being built here.
- 1:01:31And one was actually interested in the vision but said like,
- 1:01:35look, we need a token grant. And I was like, well, that's
- 1:01:37completely, first of all, almost morally unethical, you know,
- 1:01:42because, you know, essentially we're just raising, you know,
- 1:01:46unregistered security and dumping it just to, you know,
- 1:01:48just for you guys to get quick money.
- 1:01:50So like that's that's not. I would never tie myself to
- 1:01:53something like that like this. This is a, there's an ideology I
- 1:01:57think behind building a product like this.
- 1:01:59Like you really need to have someone who knows Bitcoin well
- 1:02:02and believes in that fundamental up and to the right.
- 1:02:06This is what's gonna bring people in and there has to be a
- 1:02:08reason for it to build a terminal like this.
- 1:02:11But yeah, let's get sentimental. I mean, thank you.
- 1:02:18For building it, #1 but #2, again, going back to just like
- 1:02:20the entrepreneur entrepreneurship aspect of it,
- 1:02:24like you described it earlier in the show, I think what's really
- 1:02:28beautiful about this product too is that you just saw that your
- 1:02:32users, a bit raw, were interested in these charts and
- 1:02:35you saw the signal there. You're a savvy entrepreneur who
- 1:02:38said, all right, there's something here, let's go build
- 1:02:40around this. And it materialized in this
- 1:02:43terminal which. As we've been describing is
- 1:02:46extremely robust, invaluable for for the industry and that's the
- 1:02:52data is incredible, but it wouldn't be there without you as
- 1:02:56an individual and your cofounder being sort of widely
- 1:03:00entrepreneurs were able to see the signal and the products that
- 1:03:03people actually wanted and needed.
- 1:03:06Exactly. And I think, I think because
- 1:03:09we're Bitcoin driven, I think we could pull up maybe like another
- 1:03:12metric just to kind of show. People may be something they
- 1:03:15haven't seen before because when we were building it, we didn't
- 1:03:18see it before. It's the difficulty estimator.
- 1:03:22And actually what's really, really interesting is that I
- 1:03:25actually know quite a bit of minors that actually look at
- 1:03:27this religiously. So foundry, riot, marathon, a
- 1:03:31lot of solo minors as well. So this this metric is actually
- 1:03:37trying it's a forward prediction.
- 1:03:39So we don't actually know what the difficulty will be at the
- 1:03:43end of the mining epoch, but what you're looking at here.
- 1:03:46So those those little blocks that you see there that that
- 1:03:49visualization, that's 2016 blocks, that's the mining
- 1:03:55difficulty epoch. So every 2016 blocks there's a
- 1:03:59there's a retarget calculation being made and and we just kind
- 1:04:05of wanted to represent that and so.
- 1:04:09So what you're seeing right now is actually we're we're very
- 1:04:11early on in this epoch. So each one will take around 2
- 1:04:15weeks. That's at an average of 10
- 1:04:17minutes per block. And what you can actually see
- 1:04:19here a little bit above is actually the ranges that we're
- 1:04:23calculating. So we're actually trying to see
- 1:04:26what's the current pace, the previous difficulty, the current
- 1:04:30difficulty and then the next difficulty, which gives kind of
- 1:04:33like a low end and then a high end.
- 1:04:35And then we're actually trying to calculate what the difficulty
- 1:04:38will be. Early on, it's very hard to do.
- 1:04:41I think around the first block you'll get like right when the
- 1:04:44difficulty retargets and then you you get into the next block,
- 1:04:47you'll see ranges from like you know -20% to plus 50%.
- 1:04:52But as you start getting further down into that, the lower end of
- 1:04:57those 2016 blocks, it becomes very, very, very accurate.
- 1:05:01And a lot of people use that. And this actually is.
- 1:05:05Really interesting because the last two adjustments were
- 1:05:06positive ones and I think that actually ties into another
- 1:05:09bullish all time high indicator if we could pull it up, which is
- 1:05:13actually network difficulty. So what you're actually seeing
- 1:05:17is that, yeah, exactly right. So it's the same thing that we
- 1:05:19kind of saw with hash rate as you know, the prices overlaid
- 1:05:22here, prices down 5060%, network difficulties on on the same rip
- 1:05:27that hash rate is. So minors are doubling down.
- 1:05:30So kind of what we're talking about the beginning of the
- 1:05:32podcast. Once you kind of start digging
- 1:05:34into actually what's happening under the surface, under the
- 1:05:38hood, everything is, everything's pointing towards
- 1:05:41bullish. So that's kind of like another
- 1:05:43kind of cool metric that we built that a lot of people
- 1:05:48haven't seen before. It's a really popular kind of
- 1:05:51tool that we have. And you can easily see this
- 1:05:54being a primitive, I mean one of the big themes in the mining
- 1:05:57industry as that hash rate. It goes parabolic and the profit
- 1:06:02margins on an individual operation get thinner and
- 1:06:05thinner. The whole idea of hash rate
- 1:06:08forwards contracts, hash rate derivatives more broadly becomes
- 1:06:13a sticking point, something that's probably going to need to
- 1:06:15come to market so that these miners can hedge their risk and
- 1:06:19having. A difficulty calculator like
- 1:06:21this, I could see being a primitive for creating those
- 1:06:23products where you want a very accurate depiction of what
- 1:06:27difficulty's gonna be at the end of an epoch.
- 1:06:28And then you can use that to price these derivatives
- 1:06:31contracts in certain ways, yeah. Exactly right.
- 1:06:35Yeah. That's such a cool piece of
- 1:06:37math, the difficulty estimator, so correct me if I'm wrong here.
- 1:06:43So you're taking the sample size of how many blocks we've seen in
- 1:06:47this epoch. And the the times to mine all of
- 1:06:52those and that's the sample set. You know that you're
- 1:06:55extrapolating okay. If we continue at the that
- 1:06:58average block time then then we're going to need to
- 1:07:01difficulty adjust by X percent, right.
- 1:07:04And then as that sample size grows and gets closer to the
- 1:07:07end, you know that the probability that you're within
- 1:07:09those air bars, like in the air bars, that's so cool.
- 1:07:12Yeah, yeah, that I didn't know anybody had done that.
- 1:07:16That's awesome that you guys built that.
- 1:07:19Yeah, I actually spoke to the the, I think the CTO of men
- 1:07:23pulled out space and they actually added a difficulty
- 1:07:26estimator as well. And we were talking about it
- 1:07:30over Telegram and he said that he actually took the inspiration
- 1:07:33from our difficulty estimator. So they show kind of like just a
- 1:07:38percentage of like where they think it's it's either going to
- 1:07:40go up or go down by what percentage.
- 1:07:42And what we actually do is show the visualization and the ranges
- 1:07:45and what's really cool. Is that Bitcoin talk?
- 1:07:49There's actually quite a vibrant mining community.
- 1:07:51They're still talking on Bitcoin Talk about about obviously solo
- 1:07:56mining and and mining pools and stuff like that.
- 1:07:59And they they they use this tool religiously.
- 1:08:04That's so cool. So what's the blinking red
- 1:08:08block? You know that you've got two
- 1:08:10blinking ones on the on the chart.
- 1:08:14Yeah. So if you go down a little bit
- 1:08:16further right after that 2016 block, yeah, exactly.
- 1:08:21So if you wanna zoom in there so it's kind of just showing if
- 1:08:26this block is being mined and expected or unexpected based on
- 1:08:32previous pace and current pace so.
- 1:08:36So right now it looks like the next the next block after the
- 1:08:40one, the one that's currently blinking, is the one that's
- 1:08:42currently being mined. So if you actually hover over
- 1:08:44it, we actually link to mempool dot space, so you can actually
- 1:08:48hover over it. That's the that's the block
- 1:08:50height, and if you click on it, it'll actually take you to
- 1:08:52mempool dot space and you can actually see what's going on.
- 1:08:57I'm having one of those moments where I think I might be about
- 1:09:00to learn something that I didn't know about Bitcoin.
- 1:09:02What is an expected Bitcoin block?
- 1:09:07So, so when you have a difficulty and then you're
- 1:09:11trying to target that kind of that average 10 minute based on
- 1:09:15that we kind of know if if that's, if that's going to be
- 1:09:18the current difficulty, we know if there's going to be an
- 1:09:20expected block at this timestamp, right.
- 1:09:22So, so we know if pace, if if the pace is up or down, we know
- 1:09:27if it's expected or unexpected and that it and that's kind of
- 1:09:30represents the it's a visualization.
- 1:09:34Just for us to make the assumption if the difficulty
- 1:09:38will be retargeted positively or negatively.
- 1:09:42Okay, I see. So you're just you're taking the
- 1:09:44extrapolation of the current pace and saying when that's
- 1:09:48gonna be expected? Exactly.
- 1:09:51Gotcha. Yeah.
- 1:09:54There's so much to build the data, like going back to the
- 1:09:57hash rate derivatives to even get to that financial instrument
- 1:10:02you need. Accurate data underlying that.
- 1:10:05And so when you talk about the order of operations and things
- 1:10:08that need to be built out in this industry, I think new hedge
- 1:10:12what you guys are building is on the front end of that order of
- 1:10:15operations. You need good data and good
- 1:10:17metrics to make good decisions from a financial perspective.
- 1:10:23Yeah, that's that's the thesis. So I'm I'm happy that we kind of
- 1:10:26ran with it and I think like the partnership that we did with on
- 1:10:29ramp just just validated it that like there is a need for this.
- 1:10:33People do want to see this and smart money.
- 1:10:36Like we're currently in a bear market right now and smart money
- 1:10:39is making its way to terminals like this and trying to trying
- 1:10:41to filter out, like we said, all that, all that noise and find
- 1:10:44the signal. So it's yeah, cool, go.
- 1:10:48For it, Michael, I was gonna say I knew, Alon, you mentioned when
- 1:10:53you launched the, you know, the traffic and just seeing, you
- 1:10:56know, incredible people coming through and similar on this
- 1:10:58side, it's like they're out there.
- 1:11:00We have them on the pod, we're talking them behind the scenes,
- 1:11:01they're using terminals like this.
- 1:11:03Everybody's looking. It's just just a matter of time.
- 1:11:05So it's just very cool. Yeah, I just found another thing
- 1:11:10I didn't know was in here. Logan, if you want to pull up
- 1:11:13the in the adoption category, there's a legality map which
- 1:11:17I've never seen before and that's another awesome.
- 1:11:21Lens for thinking about Bitcoin on like a on an international
- 1:11:25scale and and this this more than any other view I've seen
- 1:11:29before hammers home the like the international game theory of
- 1:11:33Bitcoin adoption So Alan, you wanna walk us through what what
- 1:11:37we're seeing on this chart? Yeah.
- 1:11:40So, so basically what we've done is when I was conceptualizing
- 1:11:44this, there was a lot of, a lot of data just from a lot of
- 1:11:47different places to kind of. Look at like regulation in
- 1:11:50different countries. So we we initially started
- 1:11:53creating a script that would go through like government websites
- 1:11:58find find the word Bitcoin or crypto and kind of you know pull
- 1:12:02that data to see you know whether trading was illegal or
- 1:12:05mining was illegal or kind of what what you know what the,
- 1:12:08what the regulatory landscape looked like.
- 1:12:10So, so this we kind of built. I think it was right after Kelly
- 1:12:14made. Bitcoin legal tender in El
- 1:12:17Salvador which is that little, that little orange dot over
- 1:12:19there, the other one in the middle that's the Central
- 1:12:21African Republic. But I've been notified that they
- 1:12:25have since not gone back on the on the legal tender laws of
- 1:12:30Bitcoin. So, so that and that obviously
- 1:12:33needs to be updated. But if you scroll a little bit
- 1:12:35down what we wanted people to do and we're still building this
- 1:12:37out is for people to kind of come in and search their country
- 1:12:42and to kind of get a very small. Blurb of just the regulatory
- 1:12:47landscape. So and then that obviously
- 1:12:53correlates to the just kind of like the visual representation
- 1:12:56that we have on the map. That's so cool, yeah.
- 1:12:59And this will be a shifting landscape in the coming decade.
- 1:13:04But it does help clarify how like you know you can have you
- 1:13:09can have China ban Bitcoin mining.
- 1:13:13You can you, they can ban Bitcoin entirely, but it's just
- 1:13:17one country on, you know, on the scene.
- 1:13:21And that so long as there are green and hopefully orange
- 1:13:26pockets somewhere on this map, then then Bitcoin.
- 1:13:31Bitcoin continues in in legal, you know, out in the open.
- 1:13:36And even if this map was entirely red, Bitcoin would
- 1:13:39continue as it has in China, which is.
- 1:13:42You know, under the radar with Tor nodes and and so on.
- 1:13:47But I think it's a great, this is a great way to check the I
- 1:13:53don't know, you always hear like when the Bitcoin mining ban
- 1:13:58happened in China, the the headlines were all about how
- 1:14:00China was banning Bitcoin. And you know every other country
- 1:14:04is going to follow suit soon. And you know, you come look at
- 1:14:09this and see, Nope, there's a lot of clarity actually, that
- 1:14:12Bitcoin is allowed most places. Yeah, and it's I'm cross
- 1:14:17referencing this map with the the node map right now in
- 1:14:20Algeria, the only red country in Africa right now, even though
- 1:14:25it's illegal, there are people still running nodes in Algeria,
- 1:14:28and that's just reachable nodes and we don't know how many Tor
- 1:14:31nodes are in Algeria as well. And that speaks to
- 1:14:34antifragility, which is amazing to see.
- 1:14:39Yeah, yeah, that's a cool map. I'm glad you guys built that.
- 1:14:44Well, I mean we've touched on obviously the on ramp new hedge
- 1:14:48partnership integration and before we hit record, Michael
- 1:14:53was singing your praises for how quickly this integration came
- 1:14:57together, I think in a little more or less than a month and I
- 1:15:02guess we could jump into speaking too.
- 1:15:04Like how you plan on integrating this across the industry, what
- 1:15:08individuals who would like this type of terminal on their sites
- 1:15:12or for their products, how they can engage with new edge to
- 1:15:15integrate it into their stacks? Yeah, exactly.
- 1:15:19So initially, because I found that there was this gap which
- 1:15:23there's no really deep rich Bitcoin analytics, I kind of
- 1:15:26knew that that data would. Eventually be needed to be seen
- 1:15:30by people who are running other terminals whether those are
- 1:15:32crypto terminals or or you know traditional finance terminals
- 1:15:36like like Bloomberg. Essentially we just thought you
- 1:15:41know if we can hunker down and create amazing metrics and and
- 1:15:44people want to see those, you know we'd love to give that out
- 1:15:47in in API forms to to all these places so that kind of more
- 1:15:51people get to see these Bitcoin metrics.
- 1:15:53And I think what's interesting is that like with with Onram.
- 1:15:58You know you have your client base that are custoding Bitcoin
- 1:16:02and going down the kind of the rabbit hole with multi sig.
- 1:16:05And then what's interesting is that like well after that
- 1:16:07they've done that they kind of have a Peace of Mind, you know
- 1:16:10of their custody solution for Bitcoin and then what do they
- 1:16:13do? Well, eventually, you know,
- 1:16:15they're still interested in Bitcoin.
- 1:16:16They want to see what's happening.
- 1:16:17So then they have the terminal to kind of fall back in and it
- 1:16:20creates kind of stickiness. So I'd I'd love for our data to
- 1:16:23be used in different terminals in different sites.
- 1:16:28Just because I think it it contributes to the stickiness of
- 1:16:31Bitcoin. I I like like I was saying
- 1:16:33earlier I don't want to hit another analytic site to find
- 1:16:38something really cool and have a pop up of check out Salana
- 1:16:41Research. I I really would like you know
- 1:16:44like would love to reiterate the fact that like this is the
- 1:16:48signal like people are going to be looking for this and and if
- 1:16:53we can provide data for those people to eventually fall back
- 1:16:55on. And I think new hedges a
- 1:16:57success. Yeah, we, we talk about that a
- 1:17:00lot, Marty. Like in general like the
- 1:17:03Internet, it's kind of just descended into this like
- 1:17:06fragmented broken shell of what it used to be.
- 1:17:09If you think about like before, whether it was like news or
- 1:17:13sports, you could leave a tab open and then just like go and
- 1:17:15get every all the content you wanted from a particular area of
- 1:17:18the market, whether again news, sports, whatever it is.
- 1:17:23And so Elan's point, like we produce a lot of content
- 1:17:26research and to be able to incorporate that into the data
- 1:17:29component where you can go and and this is live now and you
- 1:17:32edge, there's some other research as well.
- 1:17:34But to be able to like access it all under one kind of whether
- 1:17:37it's a tab or within your browser, we think to Elan's main
- 1:17:41point, it's like there's stickiness but it's also utility
- 1:17:46that's baked into that because or maybe they're one of the
- 1:17:48same, but there's just there's utility there versus having to
- 1:17:50like go somewhere else. If we're reproducing that
- 1:17:53content, it just maps perfectly next to a lot of the
- 1:17:57quantitative data. One thought Elan, I don't know
- 1:18:01if you if if this has come up and it's probably like a bigger
- 1:18:05ask from what you guys are trying to do.
- 1:18:08But maybe it's not as like reports like to be able to.
- 1:18:10And I know there's like a functionality where you can
- 1:18:12create, you can click a button and and it likes or or hurts it
- 1:18:17or favors it. And I'm assuming there I think
- 1:18:19it moves it to like a main dashboard for the user.
- 1:18:22But to be able to like check off a few and it would have spit it
- 1:18:25out into like almost like APDF or a slide base.
- 1:18:29Because I think that's where a lot of the.
- 1:18:30I don't know if it's virality but I think of a lot of
- 1:18:34evangelists and it always just sailors my anchor point that
- 1:18:37read out a bunch of people's stuff and then went into a
- 1:18:40boardroom and said hey we're going to do this and they're
- 1:18:42like you're crazy. And he's like, well, he pulled
- 1:18:43out like laminated, you know, writings from the best writers
- 1:18:47at that time in 2020 and then said, well, here, read it over
- 1:18:50the weekend and they came back and they had to read it because
- 1:18:52he was their boss. And they, they were like, okay,
- 1:18:54you're not crazy. We're going to do this.
- 1:18:56And you can imagine a world where you can do that with with
- 1:18:58some of the terminal insights where you can pull, you know,
- 1:19:01relative things like this legality map when people are
- 1:19:04worried about countries banning it.
- 1:19:05You know, hash rate transactions, all the things
- 1:19:07that we know profitable days. And then be able to share that
- 1:19:11in something that is digestible from a boomer standpoint where
- 1:19:13they still love to like get that PDF in the e-mail and open it
- 1:19:17and put it on their iPad and read it Sunday morning over
- 1:19:19coffee. Have you thought anything
- 1:19:22thought about that at all? Yeah, of course.
- 1:19:25I think what we've seen with New Hedge is because there's a lot
- 1:19:28of users and they're clicking different things and they're
- 1:19:30viewing different things. You you have to kind of come
- 1:19:33together and do an amalgamation of like what what people are
- 1:19:37interested in and obviously that changes, that sentiment changes
- 1:19:39within the market. So I actually think that's like
- 1:19:41a that's a great idea because we know like as the having is
- 1:19:45coming, you know more metrics that are looking at having
- 1:19:48cycles or anything having to do with that for your cyclical
- 1:19:51cycle with Bitcoin that's going to be the forefront.
- 1:19:53So it'd be really cool to kind of condense that data, like you
- 1:19:55said, into a PDF or an e-mail newsletter and just be like,
- 1:19:58hey. Because we have all this Bitcoin
- 1:20:01focused data, this is what people are looking at and this
- 1:20:04is their sentiment. I think that's a spectacular
- 1:20:07idea. Awesome.
- 1:20:10Yeah, we go, I mean, we've been doing this for years.
- 1:20:12You go into a meeting with a large asset allocator and they
- 1:20:15come out and they have certain things they want.
- 1:20:17You have to build the decks and reports and emails and imagine
- 1:20:20just clicking a few buttons you're like here it is you can
- 1:20:24look at your terminal but sometimes you know it's it's a
- 1:20:26friction point to go through the sign up.
- 1:20:28Some people just want it like nicely condensed there.
- 1:20:30I think that could be that could be big and when we think about
- 1:20:33getting you know hundreds of billions if not trillions in you
- 1:20:36just imagine being able to just like make that signal even
- 1:20:39tighter and tighter just lets the let's it spread.
- 1:20:44I also think it creates like a base for a lot of a lot of kind
- 1:20:47of untested Bitcoin projects to build on top of it.
- 1:20:50So for instance like integrating Gnoster.
- 1:20:52Or doing lightning invoice payments to talk between users.
- 1:20:56I think like having a terminal like this is kind of like a like
- 1:20:59the central meeting point of like, you know, this is where we
- 1:21:02talk about Bitcoin. This is where we get to see
- 1:21:04what's happening with Bitcoin as well.
- 1:21:07It also creates this like you're not gonna get a, you know, let's
- 1:21:13say like a like a Nanson, which they're also a data provider,
- 1:21:17but they're raised to kind of create an NST.
- 1:21:21Dashboard analytics and insights, like you're not gonna
- 1:21:24get them anywhere near interested in what's happening
- 1:21:27with Lightning or what's happening with Gnoster or kind
- 1:21:30of where the Bitcoin community is moving as a whole.
- 1:21:33So I think that creating that kind of central meeting point
- 1:21:35and breeding ground, like we can be the base for a lot of these
- 1:21:39Bitcoin projects to build on top of and to see how Bitcoin users
- 1:21:43interact with them, I think that'd be also really cool.
- 1:21:48Yeah. I was going to say going back to
- 1:21:50the Bloomberg analogy, I mean you have the opportunity here.
- 1:21:54If we believe that we're going to transition to a Bitcoin
- 1:21:56standard in the world of finance will be operating via products
- 1:22:02and services that anchor into the Bitcoin network.
- 1:22:05Like, you can build the new Bitcoin, the Bloomberg Terminal,
- 1:22:08the Bitcoin terminal, and then integrate bitcoins, native
- 1:22:12properties, whether that's lightning payments, whatever it
- 1:22:15may be, to to actually modernize it instead of paying.
- 1:22:19Whatever it is. For Bloomberg, 20 grand a seat a
- 1:22:21month. Yeah, really.
- 1:22:23And I think the. Users of Onramp, Tyrone, they're
- 1:22:26gonna see a lot of cool things coming.
- 1:22:27Like, I haven't even talked with Michael or the rest of the team,
- 1:22:30but obviously we're still focused on creating like Bitcoin
- 1:22:33metrics that are hard to come by that you haven't seen before.
- 1:22:36So I think like in the next coming months.
- 1:22:38Like you're gonna see that in on ramp terminal.
- 1:22:41It's gonna be interesting to see like what those on RAMP users,
- 1:22:44how they interact with that and whether they can find
- 1:22:46correlations with other things. I think that's what kind of
- 1:22:49builds this kind of robust analytics platform.
- 1:22:53Is this like kind of like just to get kind of like a like a
- 1:22:58story behind what's happening? You just made me think of
- 1:23:02something really cool and I didn't know the use case and how
- 1:23:04I do is we talked about YouTube and content and they're both one
- 1:23:08of the same in the sense of like how do you surface what's the
- 1:23:10most valuable for the type of individual.
- 1:23:13It's all subjective but like we know we have a certain archetype
- 1:23:17that's using this or looking at this and imagine having like
- 1:23:20YouTube tab. But then based on you know where
- 1:23:23everybody's like oh value for value and doesn't make sense
- 1:23:25where just out of the goodness like this provided value whether
- 1:23:28it's a 2 hour pod that was explained in XY&Z and now you
- 1:23:31can start either by like you know tags, whether it's mining
- 1:23:35evaluation of Bitcoin and then you can just see where it starts
- 1:23:38to filter it's its own self-serving algorithm of the
- 1:23:41best pieces because people have actually saying that I found
- 1:23:44value in this, right. And then you go to those tabs
- 1:23:47and that's a very simple thing. You have a lightning wall that
- 1:23:49already tied into your terminal. You're just like there now when
- 1:23:53you log into the terminal you're just seeing the best content.
- 1:23:55Again, subjective, but the best content by somebody's actually
- 1:23:58producing proof like proof of work into like saying that it's
- 1:24:01the best content because they found it valuable could be
- 1:24:04really cool feedback loop from like content that we produce
- 1:24:07along with other things we bring in but also like the video
- 1:24:10stuff, which is the video. Again, I keep anchored because
- 1:24:13it's just so much noise out there, but imagine finding the
- 1:24:14best videos because videos are powerful.
- 1:24:17Like you watch it for an hour and you can learn a whole
- 1:24:19lifetime of like information that you didn't you couldn't
- 1:24:22have done or read faster in an hour and then you just get it to
- 1:24:26the top on specific topics. Like I think that it's crazy
- 1:24:29education feedback cycle for people coming in.
- 1:24:34I agree. And I think like most of the new
- 1:24:35users coming in, especially in the 2020 kind of like Bull Cycle
- 1:24:39was a lot of a lot of millennials and a lot of Gen.
- 1:24:41Z. And it's really hard to kind of
- 1:24:43put the Bitcoin standard or the sovereign individual in front of
- 1:24:46them and say, hey have fun over the weekend.
- 1:24:48You know, they're, you know, they're they're probably going
- 1:24:51to watch a piece of content. And and yeah, I think that's
- 1:24:55also a great idea. I think like there there's a lot
- 1:24:57of verticals that can happen with the terminal like this.
- 1:25:00And I just can't wait to see where it goes from here.
- 1:25:04That's awesome. Bullish.
- 1:25:10Bullish. Very bullish.
- 1:25:12What I mean you mentioned the having cycles, people looking at
- 1:25:16that data, but to wrap up like what else do you think people
- 1:25:20are gonna be looking at as we head into the end of the year
- 1:25:23into 2024? Yeah.
- 1:25:28So outside of the having we also we have a pretty accurate having
- 1:25:31countdown which is actually looking at kind of also the pace
- 1:25:35of blocks. So it's kind of not a hard coded
- 1:25:37date. We're actually, it's actually
- 1:25:39changing which is really cool. It was kind of cool to figure
- 1:25:42out like how you can predict when when the having cycle
- 1:25:44happens. Yeah, that's, that's it right
- 1:25:47there. So we're predicting it's
- 1:25:49happening April 24th. So there's a couple of other
- 1:25:51sites that kind of say March or maybe a little bit earlier in
- 1:25:54April. But I guess, I guess because
- 1:25:57we're recording this podcast now, I guess we'll know, we'll
- 1:25:59know in April 24th if we were right.
- 1:26:03But we also have a chart that's actually looking at the price
- 1:26:06performance since having which is another market chart.
- 1:26:09But I think, I think what people will be looking at is just the
- 1:26:14yeah. So this looks at the different
- 1:26:16kind of mining reward epochs and then the line on the very, on
- 1:26:22the very right there in red is an actual four year mark.
- 1:26:25So obviously we know that you know on average it'll it'll be
- 1:26:30four years, but it's not actually hard coded that it's
- 1:26:33going to be a four years that it's every 2010 blocks however
- 1:26:36fast or slow on average those are being mined.
- 1:26:39But this actually also shows kind of I I guess that that
- 1:26:42cyclical 4 year. Cycle nature that people look at
- 1:26:47and I think just in general just when you make kind of like price
- 1:26:51predictions based on based on historical data.
- 1:26:54I think just in general it's interesting to see that like you
- 1:26:57know this could be wrong and this could not predict what the
- 1:27:00next mining epoch reward will look will look like in terms of
- 1:27:04like the next four years. But everything that you kind of
- 1:27:07see in the terminal, you you kind of get the sense that
- 1:27:09everything in general is moving up and to the right.
- 1:27:13Which I think that's really cool, just to kind of see.
- 1:27:16Yeah, and with this particular chart too, it's really
- 1:27:18fascinating and I've never this is producing new information for
- 1:27:22me. If you look at it, pink as the
- 1:27:24first epoch, orange second, blue third, green 4th, which we're
- 1:27:27currently in, But over time it's gotten closer to that four year
- 1:27:31target. Yeah.
- 1:27:34Each epoch, which means. That would be.
- 1:27:37That would be because like in the first epoch, the.
- 1:27:41The amount of of the rate of change of Bitcoin mining hash
- 1:27:45rate was astronomical, right? So, so that would mean that like
- 1:27:51we were the average block time must have been like 6 minutes or
- 1:27:56something in that first epoch to to have it be looks like 2/3 of
- 1:28:01a four year period, right? Yeah, and then over time, as
- 1:28:05more hash rate comes on, it becomes harder to to make steps
- 1:28:09or. That's what I'm looking for to
- 1:28:11make like order of magnitude leaps and hash rate, which means
- 1:28:15they're gonna be trending closer to that 10 minute target and so
- 1:28:19right. But we would never expect it to
- 1:28:21actually ever be at a full four year era so long as hash rate is
- 1:28:27is on average increasing. Right, yes, yeah.
- 1:28:31But I think this chart is visualizing that.
- 1:28:33It's getting more efficient. We're getting closer and closer
- 1:28:36to that four year target over time.
- 1:28:37So it'll be interesting to look at this and. 20 years when
- 1:28:40there's four or five more lines on it, yeah.
- 1:28:44And we can see how close eg pockets to that red line, yeah?
- 1:28:50Very cool. The maturation of the entire
- 1:28:54network and the asset underneath, yeah, it's worth
- 1:29:00calling out that we worked with the lawn to create a a dashboard
- 1:29:04that's like on the front facing site.
- 1:29:06So if you don't want to log in and create an account or do
- 1:29:08anything, you can actually get access to what we thought were
- 1:29:12at least on this first version, the most interesting kind of
- 1:29:15like KPIs. But we'll over time based on
- 1:29:18feedback and maybe what's happening in the market will
- 1:29:21move them around and I'm sure Alon has some thoughts on things
- 1:29:23we can do with it as well. Definitely.
- 1:29:26I think also looking at the monthly transactions, one if you
- 1:29:29look at that throughout all time.
- 1:29:31And you, you know, kind of have in mind that there, you know,
- 1:29:34the prices dropped at 5060%. Then you look at just on chain
- 1:29:37transactions, monthly cumulative is just also up and to the
- 1:29:41right. And you'd have to understand
- 1:29:43like well why that's happening. And obviously this is without
- 1:29:46lightning, this is without lightning transactions.
- 1:29:48So this is base layer Bitcoin transactions.
- 1:29:52That's a really cool chart to look at as well.
- 1:29:56Nobody uses Bitcoin. It's just like.
- 1:29:59Yeah, nobody uses it. You know, it's funny.
- 1:30:01It reminds me of, you know, who do you wertheimer on Twitter.
- 1:30:04Of course he was. Yeah.
- 1:30:07So he, he's Israeli. I actually met him.
- 1:30:10Yeah, he's my neighbor. Yeah, he's down the street.
- 1:30:13But he actually got into kind of like a Twitter debate with Guy
- 1:30:15Swan, and they were talking about how, like Bitcoin isn't
- 1:30:20actually used in merchant kind of like merchant transactions.
- 1:30:25And then someone pulled up kind of like I think it was bit
- 1:30:28refill or bit pay kind of they they kind of had like a just a
- 1:30:32yearly breakdown of which crypto currencies were actually being
- 1:30:36used in merchant transactions. And you see number one it was
- 1:30:40Bitcoin and then number four it was lightning.
- 1:30:44So and then and then you kind of like look at that monthly
- 1:30:47transactions chart and you and you actually kind of see that
- 1:30:50like you know these are real transactions that are happening.
- 1:30:54That this isn't just kind of like, yeah.
- 1:30:58Zoom out to all Yeah, the Alls. Look at that, Yeah.
- 1:31:04There's the fundamentals right there.
- 1:31:05This is actually the most fascinating to me.
- 1:31:09We don't talk about it enough and it's, it is somewhat
- 1:31:12applicable like the cognitive dissonance with all the, you
- 1:31:17know, hundreds of billions of dollars getting allocated right
- 1:31:19now to crypto that when the market right now we've been in
- 1:31:23this like bear for whatever number of years.
- 1:31:25All of their charts look completely the opposite of this,
- 1:31:29like the the market when they launch the token or whatever
- 1:31:31they, you know, trading volumes and they do a bunch of stuff
- 1:31:34where you can actually it looks like there's a lot of activity,
- 1:31:36but then once you kind of get into these lulls, it goes the
- 1:31:40opposite way. And so I don't like these
- 1:31:42stories. I'm not sure what they're
- 1:31:43telling and how they go about. And it gets a little bit more
- 1:31:45complex when the market comes back because then you can play
- 1:31:47around. But anyway, the the point of
- 1:31:49that is like this is the fundamental that even at, you
- 1:31:52know, whatever, 60 plus percent down from all time highs, you
- 1:31:56still have this kind of like growth and utility and usage are
- 1:32:01the things that matter when you evaluate like crypto and then
- 1:32:04digital assets, you know, more general.
- 1:32:06Yeah. Fundamentals have never been
- 1:32:12better. You can see it in the data.
- 1:32:14Very bullish. You had chance in the data.
- 1:32:19Elan, before we wrap up here, where can anybody who's curious
- 1:32:24and excited about what you're building find out more?
- 1:32:27Get involved. Begin using the terminal,
- 1:32:31incorporating into their own businesses.
- 1:32:34Yeah, so they can definitely check out newhedge dot io and
- 1:32:37they can kind of have just a free version to kind of browse
- 1:32:42around and to see a lot of these, a lot of these charts in
- 1:32:45the wild. And then they can also sign up
- 1:32:48to kind of create dynamic alerts to create their profile to kind
- 1:32:52of just get like the just the feel of what a Bitcoin terminal
- 1:32:56is. And then I would obviously check
- 1:32:59out the onramp terminal external dashboard that we created.
- 1:33:02I think that that's kind of like you know, I'd love to create
- 1:33:04kind of like a Clark Moody as dashboard for onramp and to have
- 1:33:08that as kind of just a really cool with visualizations as well
- 1:33:11to kind of give a really big picture of what's happening.
- 1:33:15But yeah, I'm relatively. Quite.
- 1:33:16Also, like on Twitter, I'm not. I'm one of those shadowy super
- 1:33:20coders that Elizabeth Warren talked about.
- 1:33:22So I'm not, I'm not in the public space too much.
- 1:33:24But you know, hopefully I'll be kind of like sharing a lot of
- 1:33:28the kind of research and the charts that come out from us
- 1:33:33building a lot of these cool metrics on Twitter as well.
- 1:33:38And they are awesome. Yeah.
- 1:33:39So for people who have sat through us talking about charts
- 1:33:43and are curious. Where the hell these charts are?
- 1:33:46You can check themoutyourself@terminal.onrampbitcoin.com
- 1:33:52and you can see the. You can see the landing page
- 1:33:55there and the selected metrics. If you want to get access to all
- 1:33:58of them, just pop in your e-mail address and sign up and check
- 1:34:03out everything that Elan and New Hedge have built there.
- 1:34:07Yeah, sign up and create a profile.
- 1:34:09And then I think right now the market's quieter where we can
- 1:34:12respond. I know, Marty, your Dm's and
- 1:34:14probably Jesse's, Yours and Twitter are crazy, But I think
- 1:34:17this is going to serve as a really nice way to connect with
- 1:34:19the audience and folks interested in whether it's
- 1:34:21feedback on like the content, the research, the the charts via
- 1:34:26the terminal. Because it kind of puts a face
- 1:34:28to a name and a background. If you decide you want to
- 1:34:31incorporate that. We were even getting messages.
- 1:34:34So to the extent anybody wants to engage, sign up, create a
- 1:34:37profile and we're all on there. And I don't know if Marty's on
- 1:34:39there yet, but we'll make sure to get them on there, so.
- 1:34:40It'll be on there by the end of the day.
- 1:34:42Nice. Yeah, Marty, it's got all the
- 1:34:46charts you need for all of your other podcast chart needs.
- 1:34:49That, yeah, No. And I mean, I'm gonna spin up
- 1:34:53the TFTC white label as well. Like we need a dashboard.
- 1:34:57I'm just thinking like you mentioned, like set up.
- 1:35:00Alert messages like that's what we need for social is like set
- 1:35:03up alerts, like when this metric hits this point, like, boom,
- 1:35:06take a screenshot, tweet it out. Yeah, that's something you could
- 1:35:09do right now on on Terminal as well.
- 1:35:11I think what we've seen at New Head, there's a lot of people
- 1:35:14that difficulty estimator because the ranges are so kind
- 1:35:17of crazy. They kind of get a picture of
- 1:35:19like, OK, is this going up or is this going down.
- 1:35:21What we see is a lot of people actually send dynamic alerts to.
- 1:35:24OK, let me know if this drops by 2% By 1%.
- 1:35:28Or when it gets to a certain level and you can do that on
- 1:35:31ramp as well. So I think and you can do that
- 1:35:34with the last chart that we did right now as well monthly
- 1:35:37transactions, you wanna see if it goes above a certain
- 1:35:39percentage, below a certain value.
- 1:35:41I think that's also really cool, yeah.
- 1:35:43Yeah, we're gonna win. Thanks to individuals like Elan
- 1:35:48here building the tools necessary to get the good data
- 1:35:52in people's hands. Elan keep crushing it.
- 1:35:55Thank you for joining us. Thank you for thank.
- 1:35:58You for having me. This is really cool.
- 1:36:00Yeah, thank you for the on ramp terminal.
- 1:36:02I mean, Michael was sending me screenshots of the sign ups
- 1:36:05yesterday. It came in hot.
- 1:36:08That's all I'll say. Yeah, we don't know the number
- 1:36:10is, but it's from 1 to 21 million which is like also the
- 1:36:13best is the best answer when the best answer when someone asks
- 1:36:17you how much big one you have. Yeah, that's right.
- 1:36:20It's always not enough. 21 million wouldn't even be enough,
- 1:36:22but that's it. Yeah, that's all we got.
- 1:36:27We'll be back next week. Alon, have a good evening where
- 1:36:31you are. The sun went down behind you.
- 1:36:32Thank. You Thank you so much.
- 1:36:34This is how I spend my Thursday nights.
- 1:36:35This is amazing. Yeah.
- 1:36:38All right. We'll catch you guys later.
- 1:36:40See you guys next week.