Latest / Engineering Influence from ACEC / Engineering Outlook 2025: Sentiment Surges as Uncertainty Lingers
Transcript
- 0:05Welcome to Engineering Influenced Podcast from the American Council of Engineering
- 0:08Companies. Coming to you from our 2025 Fall Conference in San Diego, California.
- 0:13And we are joined, it's an annual thing. We do it twice a year. It's the Joe Bates Show.
- 0:20Ladies and gentlemen, welcome Joe Bates, Senior Researcher, ACEC Research Institute.
- 0:25We've got a lot to talk about today. Thanks, Joe.
- 0:28We've got workforce study, firm of the future. We've got sentiment reports.
- 0:32You guys are putting out research constantly.
- 0:37You'd presented a couple of times already at the conference.
- 0:40You did the top 10 takeaways from the workforce studies coming out.
- 0:43Talked about the economic sentiment stuff that we've been working on for a while now.
- 0:47And I guess where to begin, you know, let's kick it off with sentiment. Okay.
- 0:52Yeah. How's the, how are, how's the industry doing? So in the third quarter,
- 0:57which was in late July, early August, when we conducted that study,
- 1:01we saw a rebound from the lows of the second quarter.
- 1:05And the second quarter, obviously, that was early April when all the tariffs
- 1:08were being announced and sentiment took a pretty steep dive.
- 1:11So on pretty much every single metric, we saw huge improvements in the third quarter.
- 1:18Overall, current sentiment rebounded very, very nicely.
- 1:22It's actually to an all-time high of a plus 50.
- 1:25And that was just barely above the first quarter, which was a plus 49.
- 1:30So current sentiment was very, very positive in the third quarter.
- 1:34Of course, as you know, the industry sentiment as well as firm finances,
- 1:38it's always been very, very solid, very high in the plus 70s, plus 80s.
- 1:42So we're doing very well in those areas as well.
- 1:45We had a mid-quarter update, which we have now sort of dubbed the business climate
- 1:51lightning poll, and we're getting a really great response rate to that.
- 1:55And it's really helpful because within three months time,
- 2:00especially in the last year you know we've got a
- 2:02lot happening a lot that's changing and so
- 2:05what we're seeing as of just two weeks ago is
- 2:09overall u.s sentiment has come back down
- 2:11just a little bit it's more in line with where we were all of last year in 2024
- 2:16but oddly enough and we'll have to see what happens with this industry sentiment
- 2:22hit a low it's a plus 71 i think and it's the lowest it's ever been in the four
- 2:28years we've been conducting this study.
- 2:30Now it's obviously still very strong, but it's, it's the lowest reading we've ever had.
- 2:35So I think that this macroeconomic U.S.
- 2:39Sentiment and uncertainty is starting to eat a little, weigh a little bit.
- 2:44Low bleed through into the industry.
- 2:46But firm finances, again, it's a plus 85.
- 2:49We just can't get much better. It's looking good. It's just,
- 2:52you know, and, and, you know, I think some of the tariff,
- 2:56uncertainty has kind of been now built in, priced in to the industry? That's right.
- 3:04Uncertainty or concern regarding the tariffs is actually only at about mid-plus 20s right now.
- 3:10So it's not that bad.
- 3:13Inflation and costs are much more of a concern. That went up again in the third
- 3:18quarter, and it went up again in the mid-quarter sentiment.
- 3:22So that's actually a bigger concern than tariffs right now.
- 3:26So really, it comes down to the Fed and what are they going to do?
- 3:31And that I guess that constant give and take between the Trump administration
- 3:35and Jerome Too Late Powell, as the president liked to call him.
- 3:40You know, it has an impact on what the industry is starting to look at right
- 3:44now. Are they going to cut rates?
- 3:45How far are they going to cut? How quickly are they going to do that?
- 3:48Yeah. And what does that mean? Yeah.
- 3:50And, you know, we are seeing a more favorable GDP and economic picture at the
- 3:56moment, despite the weakness in the jobs market.
- 4:00A lot of that's being driven by the lack of migrants who are coming into the country now.
- 4:06But we're also seeing firms are they're not hiring. They're not firing in a
- 4:10broad economy. Yeah. In the engineering industry, we're still hiring.
- 4:13Yeah. We still can't get enough people. We don't have enough. We don't have enough.
- 4:17We're not going to have enough for quite some time. and you
- 4:20know many people are hoping ai can help fill the
- 4:23gap but that's you know it's still going to take some time yeah
- 4:26it's not there yet and i think what we've heard over the two days
- 4:29of programming is even when that comes online you're still going to need the
- 4:32people it's not a panacea ai is not going to reduce the need for workforce but
- 4:38it can create efficiencies and allow firms to do more of less yes but you still
- 4:43need the people absolutely engineering is a very unique industry in this country,
- 4:48you can only automate so much so quickly, right?
- 4:53It's based on human safeguards, human designs, things that computers just can't do right now.
- 5:01So automating parts of those processes will happen. Absolutely.
- 5:06But that's just going to take some time. So that's sentiment.
- 5:10I encourage anybody out there to go up on the ACAC Research Institute website
- 5:15and look at all of the sentiment surveys that have been done.
- 5:18Enough have been performed to actually get some trend data so you can actually
- 5:22see long-term trends on the industry.
- 5:24The lightning poles are great because they allow you to have some quick snapshots mid-quarter.
- 5:29And that also feeds into a lot of the work that's being done by the Institute
- 5:34on the larger Firm of the Future project.
- 5:37So for those watching who don't know what the Firm of the Future project is,
- 5:42explain that and some of the work that's going into do research within that?
- 5:46Sure. So the Firm of the Future concept and project is what the Research Institute
- 5:52is doing to help prepare the industry for the 10-year horizon, 2035.
- 5:58And we have been doing lots of work with sort of the brain trust of the industry,
- 6:05the people that are volunteering their time to help us understand what are the
- 6:10pressing issues, what are the most important issues.
- 6:13We've done lots of scenario planning with groups of,
- 6:16who are donors as well as other contributors outside the industry.
- 6:20And we have now a research plan. So the first project was AI,
- 6:25and we unveiled that at the spring convention earlier this year.
- 6:28The second project is the workforce study, which we have highlighted here at all conference.
- 6:34We'll be releasing it within the next couple of weeks.
- 6:37It's got a ton of data and information in it, which I'm just like so excited
- 6:43about. We have not had anything like this for our industry, and it's a very well-sourced project.
- 6:50I did it all myself. There you go. Gold standard.
- 6:53We have the gold standard. Yeah. And I know we're going to talk a little bit
- 6:56more about workforce, but we also have several projects on the horizon as well.
- 7:01And when we talk about firm of the future, there's sort of three levels of horizon.
- 7:06One is more near-term, one is sort of mid-term, and the other one is long-term. AI is long-term.
- 7:12Workforce is long-term. But we're going to start to work on some of the short
- 7:15and medium term projects early next year as well.
- 7:18Yeah. So, you know, there's a lot coming out. There is a lot.
- 7:21We're cranking it up for next year.
- 7:24And so while this year we had sort of two flagship studies in addition to the
- 7:28sentiment survey, we're probably going to have four next year.
- 7:33All right. And we're really going to ramp things up. A lot of actionable business
- 7:36intelligence that executives can use and kind of using their strategic planning.
- 7:42Yeah, Workforce, you previewed that yesterday.
- 7:44You had a top 10 takeaways.
- 7:47Give us a snapshot of some of the highlights that are really top of mind on
- 7:53what you found in that research.
- 7:55So one section of the report is on Workforce Population Statistics.
- 7:59And this looks at the number of,
- 8:03people in the U.S., you know, this population, college-age population students,
- 8:09as well as how many enrollments we have, how many people are graduating.
- 8:15And we also look at how many international students we have and the whole immigration
- 8:20issue, as well as people who are retiring and leaving the profession.
- 8:24So lots of different data points.
- 8:27And the bottom line is that we are not graduating enough students to replace
- 8:34the folks who are retiring or leaving the profession with an asterisk.
- 8:40The real issue at the moment is that we have over 40,000 international students
- 8:46graduating each year with an engineering degree and only 9% we estimate,
- 8:53and that's the highest estimate we can provide, right?
- 8:57Only 9% are able to stay in the U.S. because they could get an H-1B visa.
- 9:01And that, and those are, those are people who are trained at U.S.
- 9:05Institutions. Yes. There are people who have completed their educations here
- 9:08and firms want to hire them and they can't get the paperwork to actually stay
- 9:13here and fill those rules. Correct.
- 9:15If we were able to expand the number of h1b visas or provide some other mechanism
- 9:21you know say if you graduated with a engineering degree you get a green card
- 9:26or whatever you know automatic visa to stay in work we could actually fill all
- 9:32of the needs that we need right yeah,
- 9:34a lot of the messaging coming out of washington right now and it's and it's
- 9:37the the especially from the white house is that.
- 9:41These jobs should go to Americans first. That's not the situation for our industry.
- 9:45It's not a question of people being replaced by foreign workers or,
- 9:49or, or, or foreign American trained workers.
- 9:52It's a question of, we have a deficit that we don't have.
- 9:56We can't give this job to a, to a native born American engineer because they're not graduating.
- 10:02We need to have that backfill of the people who we train here to actually stay
- 10:07here because we also don't want the brain drain because these are highly trained
- 10:11people who will go back to their home countries and apply those skills there.
- 10:14We should actually be using that talent to increase and enhance America's infrastructure.
- 10:19Absolutely. We do not have enough American-born students graduating in engineering.
- 10:27We just don't have enough. And I did the work. I wanted to see,
- 10:33is this going to add up or not.
- 10:34And we quantified the deficit. So there's just not enough people.
- 10:40That's all there is to it. And we need those international students. Yeah.
- 10:43Which is, again, underlines the work that ACC is doing broadly on workforce,
- 10:48trying to get more people into STEM, into engineering, and then after they graduate.
- 10:54Coming into the industry and staying.
- 10:56Absolutely. And we do need to do that long-term. We need to get into the K through
- 11:0012 schools. We need to get students more interested in STEM,
- 11:04but that's going to take a long time.
- 11:06Yeah. We have tens of thousands of international students every year who would
- 11:12like to stay in the United States and work, and they're not allowed to.
- 11:14Especially at a time when we're five years past IIJA, the money slowly coming
- 11:20out, but it is coming out, and these are long-term institutional projects.
- 11:24If you're trying to invest in America, build out all of the infrastructure that
- 11:28we need to actually accomplish the AI industrial evolution, the data centers,
- 11:33the energy systems to support it, you need the people.
- 11:36Yeah. And if you don't have those people, then how are you going to actually
- 11:39create the future that you're promising today? Yeah.
- 11:42And international students, by the way, it's a very high bar to be able to come
- 11:46to the United States and study as an international student. You not only have
- 11:50to be the best of the best in the country you're coming from,
- 11:53but you have to have the financial resources as well.
- 11:55And a lot of people don't realize that international students,
- 11:59they don't pay out-of-state tuition. They pay an international student rate.
- 12:02It's really expensive. Yeah.
- 12:04So immigration, of course, is a big issue. It's not going anywhere. Yeah.
- 12:08Workforce is tied right into it. What else have you found coming out of the
- 12:12research? So we did a survey of over 2,000 individuals who are working within
- 12:18the engineering industry.
- 12:20And we included 200 students who are studying engineering.
- 12:25We had non-engineers included in the study, as well as engineers.
- 12:30And we included people who are young, mid-career, as well as older professionals.
- 12:35So this was the most comprehensive survey ever conducted of the engineering industry.
- 12:40And we asked about motivations, why they want to become an engineer,
- 12:44or why do they want to work in the engineering industry in HR or IT or whatever their field is.
- 12:50We asked about what the ideal firm is and what people are looking for.
- 12:55We also asked about the skills needed to succeed for young people in the profession.
- 13:00And we also asked older professionals what they think young people need in terms
- 13:05of skills in order to succeed.
- 13:07So a lot of data there. Out of the data, did anything really rise to the top
- 13:10as a surprising answer? What were the trends?
- 13:13Yeah, so we found that there are more similarities than not.
- 13:16Between non-engineers, engineers, younger professionals, older professionals.
- 13:21So many more similarities than I had expected to see. So that's the good news.
- 13:25But there are really key areas of differences as well.
- 13:28So for instance, students who are coming into the profession,
- 13:32they're mostly concerned with getting, having the skill set to,
- 13:37and translating that into real world experience.
- 13:40They're nervous about that. They haven't worked in engineering firms yet.
- 13:44And so that's a big concern for them. I can tell you anecdotally,
- 13:46I spoke to a scholarship winner yesterday who said the exact same thing.
- 13:50A student in geo, he wanted to be, he wants to be a geotech engineer and he's
- 13:56like, I need a firm that gives me hands-on actual experience.
- 14:00And it's just not an engineering title in Word, but it's an actual engineering title.
- 14:04So that, there you go. Some anecdotal validation. Yeah, absolutely.
- 14:09One of the other things we found, and we've heard this anecdotally,
- 14:12but we've quantified it, that younger professionals as well as students really are seeking purpose.
- 14:18And they're seeking to make a difference in their communities and have an impact
- 14:22on the communities, much more so than mid-career or older professionals.
- 14:26It's a driving force. And even if it's not a primary motivator,
- 14:30it might be a secondary motivator for them.
- 14:32So that's something that I think really impacts all firms.
- 14:37They have to rethink how they're going to attract individuals who actually want
- 14:42to make a difference through their work.
- 14:44So, you know, we have a lot of data on that. Yeah, it's a marketing and messaging thing.
- 14:49It's not just look at the amazing projects we do, but it's the delivery and
- 14:52the impact that it has after those projects are actually delivered. Yeah.
- 14:56Another really interesting stat when it comes to skill set is that older,
- 15:01younger, engineer, non-engineer, everybody really focused on the same skills needed to succeed.
- 15:08So there's a lot of coalescence around what those skills are.
- 15:14But the interesting thing, the real interesting difference is that younger people
- 15:20and students feel they're fairly well prepared for succeeding with the skills
- 15:26that they think are important.
- 15:27Older professionals and executives, they are like, we're not so sure that those
- 15:32young people are prepared.
- 15:34That's an interesting disconnect because I think there's a lot of...
- 15:38A question about digital transformation and, and just how volatile.
- 15:44I feel like we are in a middle of a, of a revolution of some sort.
- 15:48It's the fifth, you know, we had a speaker called the fifth.
- 15:50You can argue about the number, but there is a industrial revolution happening and there's no,
- 15:55no common answer on the skills needed to actually carry through or what the
- 16:00end result is going to be after this is done. Yeah, absolutely.
- 16:04So some of those skills are, adaptability and being able to collaborate with
- 16:10other team members, being able to communicate with other team members.
- 16:13So there's the technical skills and everybody thinks those are going to be very, very important.
- 16:18So there's no disagreement there, but there's a little bit of a split in terms
- 16:22of how important are those professional skills where you're going to need to
- 16:27talk to somebody as opposed to email them.
- 16:29And there's enough reporting out there about the generational divide between
- 16:34people who are mid or, or late career didn't have the same, you know,
- 16:41exposure to social media and, and the fact that there are generations,
- 16:45you know, digital native generations coming up who, uh.
- 16:48Aren't, aren't that good communicators in, in person.
- 16:52They're great online, but not, not so much in person.
- 16:54Yeah. And the graduates right now, you know, last year, this year,
- 16:59they're the students who were graduating high school when COVID hit.
- 17:04Which was a huge disruption.
- 17:06Huge, huge. My son is one of them. And I saw firsthand how hard that was to adapt.
- 17:12You know, the first year in university, you're fully remote.
- 17:16It was very, very difficult. So, you know, we have young professionals in careers
- 17:21today within our firms, but now we're going to get a new crop of young professionals,
- 17:25We're going to have some very unique challenges as well. So for firms out there
- 17:29who are looking to hire and looking to kind of structure their management and onboarding.
- 17:34This is good data to be able to help them figure out how they would actually
- 17:37do that, to actually culturally bring people into firms. Absolutely.
- 17:43We have a lot of good information in this study about that. So when is the study
- 17:47going to be released? I know it's done.
- 17:49We're kind of carving it and putting it together. But when is the release?
- 17:53We're making final edits right now, and then we have to go to production.
- 17:57So it should be within the next couple of weeks. Fantastic.
- 18:00So stay tuned for that one. Absolutely. So you got Firm of the Future within
- 18:04that workforce. You've got the sentiment study and the lightning polls that are happening.
- 18:07You say that 2026 is going to be even bigger with Firm of the Future.
- 18:12So there's a ton going on.
- 18:14Yeah. Yeah, we've got more on workforce coming next year. We've got more on technology.
- 18:20The technology study we're going to conduct next year is going to look not internally
- 18:23in our industry, but externally.
- 18:25What are firms outside of our industry doing when it comes to technology, when it comes to AI?
- 18:31How are they leveraging it so that we can try to learn something from other
- 18:35industries? Some good old competitive analysis. Absolutely. Fantastic.
- 18:39And then we're going to also talk more, we're going to look more at young people
- 18:41and sort of what's motivating them, How we can keep them engaged in firms so
- 18:45that they don't get, if they don't have that purpose and they don't find what
- 18:49they're looking for, what else can you do to keep them engaged and not have
- 18:52them leave the profession?
- 18:53So we're, you'll be on a lot more. We're going to, we're going to increase the
- 18:57number of, uh, of, of shows focused specifically on this research.
- 19:00Joe, as always, I really appreciate your time. I mean, it's always great to
- 19:04preview the research and look into its findings.
- 19:07And again, keep up the good work. All right. Thanks, Jeff. I appreciate you
- 19:11having me. Yeah, fantastic.
- 19:13And I really do encourage everybody out there to go to the institute homepage,
- 19:17accresearchinstitute.org to look at not only from the future,
- 19:22the economic report, pretty much the forecast and the economic impact of the industry.
- 19:29You've got the other research being done in the future, the AI study.
- 19:34There's just a ton of research you're not going to find anywhere else.
- 19:37And do that, and we'll keep on reporting as it comes out.
- 19:42So stay tuned and follow us. And I'll tell you what, I look at the numbers in
- 19:47the back office, and I see a lot of people watching the videos on YouTube,
- 19:51but not many subscribers.
- 19:52So take that moment right now. Hit that notification button.
- 19:56Ring that bell, follow us for more so we can deliver this information to you.
- 20:02And this has been Engineering Influence Podcast with American Council of Engineering
- 20:05Companies. We'll see you next time.