Latest / Bad Decisions Podcast / #49 Sketchfab's Origin and Epic Games Acquisition with Alban Denoyel
Transcript
- 0:00When we started monetizing we were burning like 500,000 bucks
- 0:03a month. This is Alban de Noyo, he's a
- 0:07French entrepreneur and Co founder of Sketchfab.
- 0:09Under his leadership, Sketchfab grew into a community of
- 0:12millions of creators who published millions of 3D models,
- 0:15making it the largest library of 3D content.
- 0:17I have seen some amazing work on Sketchfab and I only downloaded
- 0:22it to figure out how the they made it.
- 0:24You pitched to 85 VCs for our seed round until finally getting
- 0:28to a yes. First time entrepreneurs to
- 0:30today and they're like I pitched 10 VCs and I got 10 Nos.
- 0:32Like 10 VCs is nothing. You have to keep going.
- 0:36Epic Game announced that we are acquiring Sketch found.
- 0:41The story for the book. How would an early founder would
- 0:44go out and talk to investors? Founders are often scared to go
- 0:48too early because if things are not ready, a good trick is to
- 0:51ask for. What do you think is the future
- 0:54of 3D and photogrammetry? People think AI will kill
- 0:58photogrammetry, and one of the beautiful things of
- 1:00photogrammetry is capturing something that is unique to you.
- 1:04We love to take it back to the origin stories and if we go back
- 1:07and open the 1st chapter of that book, where would it start?
- 1:12Alban, welcome to the Bad Decisions podcast.
- 1:15Hi, thanks for having me. Absolutely.
- 1:18It's a pleasure to have you here.
- 1:20And before we begin, Albon, I have to be very honest.
- 1:24I want to send a huge thank you and gratitude, not just from me
- 1:28and Farrak here at the Bad Decisions team, but also from
- 1:31all of our audience. Because you and your team over
- 1:34the past few years working really hard, have basically
- 1:38created and revolutionized the workflow of 3D artists around
- 1:42the world. And since the beginning of our
- 1:453D journey, we've used Sketchfab religiously.
- 1:49And it is, I'm, I'm gonna be unbiased about this, by the way,
- 1:53not because you're here. This is something that Farrat
- 1:55can swear by. It's the, it's basically the
- 1:58website, the the best 3D content library that we swore by and
- 2:03used every single day. I mean, there were other ones,
- 2:06but nothing came close to the design.
- 2:09Nothing came close to the user friendliness and just the
- 2:12content moderation in the sense that when whenever you wanted to
- 2:14get a 3D object to be used for your scene, SketchUp just was
- 2:19the best place to go. So I want to say thank you
- 2:22before we begin. Thank you.
- 2:24Happy to hear that. Avan, we love to take it back to
- 2:29the origin stories and we saw that you posted on your LinkedIn
- 2:33that you were considering writing a book about the story
- 2:36of Sketchfab from inception to acquisition.
- 2:39And if we go back and open the 1st chapter of that book, where
- 2:43would it start? It started in January 8th, 1012.
- 2:51I left. I was working in photography and
- 2:54then I left my job December 30th, 2011 and seven days later
- 3:02I I was at a startup party startup called Stupidfix, French
- 3:10startup that was acquired by GoPro, the first app to edit and
- 3:17and mount videos on on mobile. And anyway, I was talking to
- 3:23people about 3D printing. I do sculpture as a hobby.
- 3:25And so I and I had just discovered I just heard about 3D
- 3:29printing and makeup art and so on.
- 3:31And so I would, I would tell anyone and everyone about 3D
- 3:35printing and how we would all have 3D printed mugs very soon
- 3:39and so on. And someone told me, hey, if you
- 3:43are interested in in 3D printing you you should talk to this guy
- 3:46in the back is you know the figure or two about 3D.
- 3:49And this guy was Cedric who became my Co founder and CTO.
- 3:55And he happened to be one of the first maybe 5 developers on
- 4:00earth to work on Webgl from the very beginning 2011.
- 4:04He made the first demo of Webgl for the release for the launch
- 4:08of Firefox 4. Webgl was was launched with
- 4:12Firefox 4, the beta version of Firefox four in 2011.
- 4:15And he was one of the very first guys along with guys like Mr.
- 4:19Doob. We, we did for JS.
- 4:23And yeah, that's how it it all started.
- 4:26Wow, that's honestly one of the craziest stories.
- 4:29Because one, one thing I want to know is when we go all the way
- 4:33back to that year when you left your job, did you know this is
- 4:38something you're going to be getting into?
- 4:39Was this a passion of yours to begin with?
- 4:42No, that's it. I just knew I wanted to start a
- 4:44company and I was, I'm very creative and so I wanted to work
- 4:50in a, in a creative field. And I, I've always been
- 4:53passionate about publishing and how the Internet leads you
- 4:57broadcast something and things are kind of inexistent until
- 5:00they are published on the web. And I was just fascinated by all
- 5:05that. And I was just in the, in the
- 5:09process of making, meeting a lot of people just to find the
- 5:13potential Co founders and IDs and so on.
- 5:16And this happened very organically, but it was a good a
- 5:19good match. I actually I'm curious about
- 5:22something because 3D printing at the time must not have been very
- 5:25big, must have been quite early on.
- 5:28How? Why were you so interested in 3D
- 5:29printing? How did you even come to know
- 5:31about it? I think it really came from
- 5:33sculpture. I I was working on a large
- 5:36sculpture and I was planning to do it in the wood and it was a
- 5:42Commission and I was very late. And so I ended up doing it with
- 5:49thick clay and I had to, to mold it with silicone.
- 5:55And through that process, I kind of heard about 3D scanning and
- 6:003D printing and how with this this type of technologies, I
- 6:03could have make everything much faster.
- 6:07And so that's kind of how I, I learned about 3D printing.
- 6:09But yeah, it was, I mean, the early days of make about and
- 6:14Shapeways and, and all those guys.
- 6:16Yeah. Wow, that's a that's a crazy way
- 6:20to begin chapter one of the the book and what happened after you
- 6:24met Cedric at the party. So you guys basically shared the
- 6:27ideas around. Of course you guys had the same
- 6:29passion and that was the the origin of what came to be
- 6:33Sketchfab. So it's a bit more complex I
- 6:36guess, but so you had already built an, an MVP of, of a
- 6:41web-based 3D player. It was called Show Web GL with
- 6:44two WS. And he had already shown it to
- 6:51yeah, yeah. He had only shown it to to our
- 6:543D artist friends or our devs. And I was kind of the first non
- 6:59sorry, I went for a business call and that technical and I
- 7:02was the first non-technical person he would he would share
- 7:07this with and we would be interested in that.
- 7:09And so we decided to have lunch together the one week after he
- 7:14showed up 90 minutes late at the time you didn't leave and I
- 7:21didn't leave. I had nothing going on like it
- 7:24was jobless and he, he seemed to be knowing what he was doing and
- 7:28he was freelancing and working mostly at night and so he would
- 7:31wake up at noon. Anyway, he he showed up super
- 7:35late, but I didn't leave and he showed me his prototype and, and
- 7:40I just started helping him out on, on the.
- 7:43So for him it was side projects. He was freelancing, doing web GL
- 7:48freelancing projects, like a lot of projects around 3D globes.
- 7:52Like he did a project with Twitter where you could see, uh,
- 7:57the trajectory of tweets in real time on the glove or things like
- 8:01for we transfer or like this type of stuff.
- 8:05And then working on his MVP of the 3D player was also working
- 8:09in the video game industry with three artists.
- 8:12We needed a solution to show and share the freely files.
- 8:15So essentially built a solution for himself.
- 8:18And I just offered to help him out on anything that was not not
- 8:22technical. It's a very basic thing like
- 8:24IDKFAQ starting to answer user support requests and then mostly
- 8:30getting the word out so that people would hear about it
- 8:33because he had 10 users at the time.
- 8:37And so I started doing everything that was
- 8:38non-technical and I suggested to change the name because the name
- 8:45of show Webgl wasn't very friendly.
- 8:48And so we landed on Sketchfab. And then I I started trying to
- 8:53get the word out and to get press and so on.
- 8:57And so we officially launched in March, March 26th, 2012.
- 9:03And the first article we got was the trick is that it only worked
- 9:08on the beta or alpha versions of Chrome or Firefox.
- 9:11So a lot of people would click on sketchup.com and you wouldn't
- 9:14work for them. And so it was.
- 9:15It was hard to to convince. People, how would how would you
- 9:19send that link to other people and convince them to get the
- 9:22beta version you? Should send the manual first.
- 9:24Download the beta version, then only you can.
- 9:27Well, so 3D artists were really eager to, for them, it felt kind
- 9:32of magic. It was very new and they
- 9:35couldn't believe it would work. And so they were eager, eager to
- 9:38give it a try. And so we get our, our first
- 9:41article on Blender Nation's site about all Blender news.
- 9:46And, and yeah, that's how we got our first 1000 users, all from
- 9:50the Blender community. It crashed the website and.
- 9:57You were not expecting the traffic.
- 9:58Right, you were not expecting traffic and my it was the same
- 10:01day the first son of Cedric, my Co founder was born.
- 10:04So he was at the maternity. So he's usually always connected
- 10:08and online and and Bart, the editor of blend donation was
- 10:12texting me, hey, like your site is down so I have to remove the
- 10:15story unless you put the site back on.
- 10:19And Cedric was unreachable and eventually, after two hours, he
- 10:21was back and the site was back and then and the article stayed
- 10:26up. Wow.
- 10:28You know I can I just say something?
- 10:30If Album decided not to stay for that 90 minutes, we would not
- 10:34have Sketch back. Even decided not to go to the
- 10:37party, we wouldn't have this sketch.
- 10:38Back, yeah. You know what one thing I think
- 10:40about? And me and Farrah discussed this
- 10:42when we heard the story first. Do you believe in luck and
- 10:46destiny or do you think we we sort of fabricate that
- 10:49ourselves? Because if you're telling me
- 10:52from your story that this was not necessarily an intention,
- 10:55right? You didn't go to that party to
- 10:57find yourself a cofounder or or basically get into this line of
- 11:00job, whereas it is something that has not only revolutionized
- 11:04your lives as the founders, but also every 3D artist I know.
- 11:08So what? What is it lesson or take away
- 11:11there for someone who wants to start a business and doesn't
- 11:13know exactly what they should do?
- 11:15I think it's a mix of luck and and and work or activity.
- 11:20Like it was proactively meeting a lot of people.
- 11:22So having a breakfast, lunch and and a dinner like every day to
- 11:26meet people and was really trying.
- 11:29I was not from AI had no developer network and I was
- 11:32trying to to mingle with tech people and I was really
- 11:37receptive to new ideas and mingling with people and being
- 11:42curious about everything. And also really got, I mean, I
- 11:45started helping out Cedric like with no, I mean no strings
- 11:49attached, like not asking for any compensation, not asking for
- 11:53shares, like out of pure love for the project and the
- 11:57curiosity and just to see where it would take me.
- 12:01So I was, I mean, I was open, I, I got lucky, but I was also, I
- 12:08provoked that luck by meeting people and being, yeah, open to,
- 12:13to new ideas, I guess, Yeah. I love that.
- 12:15It means that you you've worked hard to be lucky.
- 12:18I think sometimes luck, it's about how much work you put out
- 12:22there. And the more the harder you
- 12:24work, the luckier you get. Yes, and we love this story.
- 12:27And now you had 1000 users coming in, but still no revenue.
- 12:31These thousand users are just trying out the product.
- 12:35Yeah, just for users. I mean, we started monetizing
- 12:40for real only in year seven, so, so.
- 12:44How are you paying for the servers and and?
- 12:46Because I think the more traffic that you get the the bigger
- 12:49server that you needed. So in year one we bootstrapped
- 12:52on in France, it's called the Acidics.
- 12:55It's unemployment benefits in France.
- 12:57It's money you get from the government if you worked before
- 13:01to actually get something like 60% of your salary for something
- 13:06like 18 months. And then we raised money.
- 13:12We raised an Angel around like 300K at the end of 2012.
- 13:16And then we just kept raising money for the first six years
- 13:22until we started monetizing. So the company started in
- 13:27France, but when you guys started raising money, did the
- 13:30first raise happened in France as well or you guys had to move
- 13:33out? So the first round happened in
- 13:37France with business angels, which we are actually, we spent
- 13:40the last quarter of 2012 in San Francisco participating in the
- 13:44in an accelerator organised by Mozilla called Web Forward
- 13:47doesn't exist anymore. And so we really considered,
- 13:51we're already in the process of fundraising with French business
- 13:55angels, but we had a lot of interesting conversations in San
- 13:58Francisco and we considered like dropping everything in France to
- 14:03just try to raise in the US And then we figured we should close
- 14:08what we have now, go back to France and figure out a way to
- 14:13move back to the US as soon as possible.
- 14:15And that's what we did. Wow.
- 14:18So technically then are you saying that you guys were
- 14:22operating from the US or from France?
- 14:24So from France, we just spent like two months and a half in,
- 14:27yeah, in San Francisco end of 2012.
- 14:29And we moved back to, to Paris at the end of yeah, like
- 14:34December 20th, 2012. And then we, we kept applying to
- 14:40US accelerators like Y combinators and Techstars and
- 14:44everything we could try. We got rejected a lot of times.
- 14:47And then eventually we got accepted in Techstars New York,
- 14:51which started in April 2013. So just three months after that.
- 14:55And so that's when we moved back to the US for the for the
- 14:58program, yeah. What was the advantage for you?
- 15:02The main benefit of moving to the US to grow Sketchfab.
- 15:07It's a mix of things, but first we needed funding because we had
- 15:12no business model and the tech was super early as I explained.
- 15:16And in France back then there weren't a lot of early stage
- 15:19investors. It was mostly like user friends
- 15:22and family and business and jobs for like small amounts of money
- 15:26or actual VCs for bigger rounds. But they would mostly fund like
- 15:32e-commerce businesses or fintech or stuff that makes money.
- 15:36So they're more like banks essentially.
- 15:38And so I mean, it was clearly it would be easier to to find
- 15:44capital in the US, which was there was more money and more
- 15:47risk taking. And we're also the first movers
- 15:50globally. And you probably don't know
- 15:54that, but France had a lot of innovation for all media
- 15:59formats, like maybe you know, Dailymotion.
- 16:01But so Dailymotion was started at the exact same time as
- 16:05YouTube and YouTube was in the US.
- 16:10Dailymotion France and YouTube is times bigger.
- 16:14Deezer was started the exact same time as Spotify.
- 16:18Spotify moved very fast to the US these or didn't and Spotify
- 16:22is is I guess even times bigger. And for us, there was no way we
- 16:26didn't want to be the dailymotion of free device.
- 16:29And so we wanted to be the I mean the the market leader and
- 16:34it was scared. We needed to be in the US like
- 16:36all the the bigger software players and the potential
- 16:40partners were in the USA. Mix of funding and then the tech
- 16:44ecosystem and the ambition to to be a market leader essentially.
- 16:50Wow. So you went, you went to us to
- 16:51make sure there is no competitor coming out of.
- 16:54US. Getting Sketchfab.
- 16:55Oh wow, that's. The competitor would be
- 16:57Sketchfab themselves. Yes, I want to, I want to ask
- 17:01you then another question about this, because right now in 2024,
- 17:05right, this is a post COVID era, during COVID, a lot of things
- 17:08change when we talk about the economics and the, the business
- 17:11world, right? Things move much quicker.
- 17:13People work online and remotely. There's a lot of online work and
- 17:17the global market being used at the same time.
- 17:19Do you? Of course, if you talk about
- 17:21funding alone, perhaps US is still the one to go to.
- 17:25But when it comes to anything else in terms of opportunities,
- 17:27finding partners, networks, do you think in in 2024 companies
- 17:32outside the US have a higher chance now to be able to operate
- 17:36from that country? Or do you still think moving to
- 17:38the US for a new startup would be super duper beneficial?
- 17:43I think it's much easier now. I mean, I mostly know about
- 17:48France and the US, but the tech ecosystem.
- 17:54And if you think of San Francisco versus New York,
- 17:57people often say that New York is like San Francisco, 10 years
- 18:00behind. And so when we arrived in New
- 18:04York in 2014, it felt like it was the beginning of New York
- 18:07becoming important on, on the, on the start up scene.
- 18:11And 10 years later, now New York is really a major tech, I mean,
- 18:15I guess the second major tech hub in the US.
- 18:18And I feel Paris is like 10 years behind New York.
- 18:20And, and so I came back to Paris 10 years after and there are
- 18:24definitely much more funding. And this is it's easier to fund
- 18:29innovation and and many more large companies in France, we
- 18:35didn't left immediately. I mean, there are a bunch of
- 18:38repeat founders getting like me, we start their second company in
- 18:41France and stay there. And then all the AI seen a lot
- 18:44of those companies are in France.
- 18:47And so I think it's definitely easier.
- 18:51I mean, it's still helpful to be in the US if if you intend to be
- 18:56a a market leader. But I think it's definitely
- 18:58easier to operate from France today than 10 years ago.
- 19:03If we set aside the funding part, what would be the biggest
- 19:06challenge in the early days of Sketch File?
- 19:12Tech side like I mean the fact you needed the beta version of
- 19:16the browser it it wasn't working on the Internet Explorer, it
- 19:20wasn't working on iOS couldn't use it on mobile and we knew it
- 19:26would eventually come but we didn't know when so a bunch of
- 19:29other the companies working on 3D players actually built native
- 19:35players for iOS. We spend a lot of resources on
- 19:37that and it was a waste because you know, like two or three
- 19:41years later it, it was supported on iOS and we decided we
- 19:45wouldn't waste those resources. But so this side of things and
- 19:52then explaining what we what we were doing and why I could have
- 19:59people in the 3D because for the first five years you couldn't
- 20:04download anything from the platform.
- 20:06You could only view things a lot of people in the 3D World
- 20:10couldn't understand. Like, why would you want to show
- 20:12a 3D file only to see it if you can't use it?
- 20:16And we're like, but that's the point, Like a lot of people want
- 20:17to show their, their, their work.
- 20:19We're all having to give it away.
- 20:22And so a lot of people at, you know, like Coto de Escordeso,
- 20:25like kind of the, the Ogs, we don't really understand what
- 20:30we're doing and, and how we were.
- 20:34I mean, we're, we're trying to get 3D outside of the 3D World.
- 20:38And so people outside of the 3D World didn't know the 3D World.
- 20:42And then people in the 3D World didn't really understand and
- 20:45wanted to make 3DA media a medium like a media format, like
- 20:49image or video or sound. And for them, 3D was a brick to
- 20:53build something else like a video game or a movie.
- 20:56And we wanted to bring 3D for itself.
- 20:59And so it was. It was hard to explain this,
- 21:03Yeah. I cannot imagine how hard was it
- 21:07to explain in 2012, 2013. Now you can of course refer to
- 21:12ARVR video games, it 3D engines are getting really, really
- 21:17popular. They are used in movies.
- 21:19But ten years ago, explaining the whole story would have been
- 21:22really, really different. I can only imagine user demands
- 21:25must have been crazy because you guys are getting all these
- 21:27different requests and they're all asking for different things.
- 21:30How do you, how do you as the CEO respond to all of that?
- 21:35Because you have to make decisions based on, as as you
- 21:37mentioned, based on the funding that you have, based on the
- 21:39budget, based on the team's resources.
- 21:42How do you define the the demand based on the demands that the
- 21:46users have? What is the right trajectory for
- 21:48the company? The North Star was, was pretty
- 21:52well, I mean, was very clear from the get go and all along,
- 21:56which was being the best 3D player and it's always been the
- 22:01North Star and so best meaning the best rendering.
- 22:05And so we kept adding new rendering features, you know,
- 22:07like specific shaders and very, I think 3D super complex, but
- 22:12our specific shaders for skin, for hair, for glass, for metal,
- 22:17for stones and so on. So keep refining the rendering
- 22:20because I mean, we wanted, we wanted to attract the very best
- 22:243D artists like the guys using 3DS Max and Substance and all
- 22:27that. And we knew that until our 3D
- 22:30players could match the rendering of their native
- 22:33desktop software like 3DS Max, they wouldn't, they would rather
- 22:36use photos and run like 2D renders.
- 22:39And so they wouldn't use our product.
- 22:40And so we needed to match the very best.
- 22:43And, and our thinking artist is whether if we can attract those
- 22:46guys who are like the top 1%, everyone else would follow.
- 22:50And so best rendering being the the fastest and so like loading
- 22:55faster, working on all devices, really being a universal player
- 23:00and then accepting as many 3D file formats as possible.
- 23:03Being part of being a universal want it to be like YouTube, like
- 23:07you put a file and you don't have to worry about like what's
- 23:10the format, what's the, what's the file size, whether it's the
- 23:15texture and so on. Like you put whatever you have
- 23:17and we make it work for you and, and a lot of other services you
- 23:21had to manually attach the textures.
- 23:24It would only take OBJ files. And for us like we, I mean, we
- 23:29support more than 35 formats, all sizes and so on.
- 23:33And so we just kept pushing those things.
- 23:35And then of course we listened. The, I handled all user support
- 23:39myself for the first two years, like until we reach 200,000
- 23:42users, I think. And so I would, I would take in
- 23:45all, all the requests and then and then kind of filter it and
- 23:50pass it to the dev team. And then, yeah, alpha of our
- 23:53road or alpha of our road map was our own instincts and vision
- 23:57on what we wanted to build. And the other half was really a
- 24:00kind of almost a voting system, like one of the things the most
- 24:02requested by the community. And, and we want to show them
- 24:07we, we were always very close to the community.
- 24:09We wanted to show them we care about the request and, and ship
- 24:12what they want. And so every year, every quarter
- 24:15or every semester, we tell them, hey, like we've shipped like 70%
- 24:19of user requests and we would, I mean it would ship two or three
- 24:23times a week. And so we kept improving the
- 24:25platform constantly. Well, you know when you said the
- 24:29first two years, you answered everything yourself 200,000
- 24:31that's like having 200,000 girlfriends texting you at the
- 24:34same time. This is what I want, this is
- 24:37what I need. And you have to respond to
- 24:38everything as as. Many as you can don't know
- 24:40they're talking to the CEO and Co founder.
- 24:42They're talking to the support team.
- 24:44Hey why this is not working? But often they would notice like
- 24:47in my signature, I'm the CEO and I mean they were very honored.
- 24:50And so I think it really helped build and we the community,
- 24:55yeah, community and we have a good, a loyal community and I
- 24:59think it's helped with that for sure.
- 25:02Oh yeah, the trust is built, right?
- 25:04If I were to let's, let's use Epic Games as an example, right?
- 25:07If I were to text Unreal Engine and then get the CEO to respond
- 25:11back, that's when you really feel like, oh, OK, these guys
- 25:14give a shit. And I think that matters.
- 25:16And clearly that shows. And I think you partially
- 25:19already answered this question, but I'm still going to mention
- 25:21anyways because I I want to lead it somewhere else.
- 25:24We are both reading Steve Jobs book right now and understanding
- 25:28exactly why Apple products have been the best in, in our
- 25:33opinion. And a lot of people's opinion in
- 25:35terms of the iPhone, the iPod, the iPad, the MacBook, the
- 25:38Macintosh, going all the way back right when, when he was
- 25:41still alive. And it's very clear why those
- 25:44happens when you read the book. Steve was a a bitch when it came
- 25:48to the quality. He was really harsh about the
- 25:51way the quality control happened to the point that the screws
- 25:55that were inside the computer had to have the same expensive
- 25:58plating as the ones on the outside.
- 26:00Even though no one saw them and they were unseen, they were only
- 26:03seen by the repairman, he still cared which is why the products
- 26:06had such high quality. When I use Sketchfab, and I'm
- 26:10going to compare this to when I go to Turbo Squid or CG Trader
- 26:13or other 3D platforms, I can see the difference.
- 26:16And that's the the main reason why unconsciously I use
- 26:19Sketchfab is because when I go on there, I feel like I'm on the
- 26:22Apple of 3D platforms. What do you guys think?
- 26:25Aside from the rendering you guys did right that caused that
- 26:29feeling for many 3D artists around the world, but.
- 26:34Definitely attention to detail, the fact that we're all, I'm a,
- 26:39a big, I'm a power user of my platform.
- 26:42So I, I eat my own dog food. And so, I mean, I would
- 26:44constantly report bugs and issues to the tech team.
- 26:49Cedric, my Co founder and CTO is very, very also very careful
- 26:58about small detail and, and piano and our first Co founder
- 27:01as well. And we, we had great designers
- 27:09and yeah, I think I mean three, 3D is complex and fragmented and
- 27:13we really wanted to make it simple and easy.
- 27:16And so we, we kept, I mean, we were OK removing features even
- 27:20though it was wasted work. Like wanted to simplify things
- 27:23like less balance, less UI. And it really participates in
- 27:27the, in the purity. Actually.
- 27:31The thing is, the hard thing is that you only notice when things
- 27:34don't work. That's Sketchfab.
- 27:36Like a lot of things worked. It's it feels like like magic,
- 27:39but like you feel it's normal. Like of course it should work.
- 27:42But then it's really when you try other products, like you
- 27:45realize, like it's hard to make 3D work seamlessly.
- 27:48And I think you did a good job at that scene.
- 27:52And another, I think aspect beside the design and also the
- 27:55quality of work that you guys did, the content that is on
- 27:59Sketchfab, if you compare it to other 3D libraries, when you
- 28:03want something, you search it on Sketchfab, you will find it.
- 28:06Sometimes it's a pizza or you want a Starship or what.
- 28:10Pizza was from Alba. Yeah, Yeah.
- 28:14How did you, I mean, I don't know if it was even in your
- 28:17control to make sure that you guys getting quality content on
- 28:20Sketchfab. And when I compare it to other
- 28:233D libraries, we don't see that level of quality.
- 28:26I think it's a mix of what I said about striving for the best
- 28:30rendering, and I mean really, and we really pushed that very
- 28:35far and adding features for very specific things that would
- 28:39attract the best artists. And then all the work we did
- 28:43around community and showing a lot of love and respect for the
- 28:47best three artists and showcasing their work on our
- 28:50blog and so on. And then focusing on a key part
- 28:54was focusing on art. I mean, the other platform, the
- 28:58other platform like 3D or Turbo Squids, they, they started as
- 29:02marketplaces. We didn't start as a
- 29:03marketplace. We started as a 3D player as a
- 29:07technological play, technically technical challenge, like
- 29:11displaying a 3D file in the browser as as best as we could
- 29:14and being just a 3D player and just like a A-frame for for a
- 29:19piece of 3D artwork. And the frame should disappear
- 29:22to to kind of glorify its content.
- 29:27And. And people would post on
- 29:29SketchUp just to showcase their work, not to sell it not to.
- 29:33I mean, there was no utility to like art is art.
- 29:36Art is a, is a not that art is free, but it's art is yeah, I
- 29:41mean, art is beautiful because it's useless.
- 29:43And lot of work was was shared just as a showcase, like a
- 29:48portfolio. And actually, actually it was a
- 29:51lot of people working in in big gaming studios, they were
- 29:55definitely not allowed to to sell their work.
- 29:58They could showcase it. And as a result, I mean, for
- 30:01them, it was a way to show 3D work in 3D.
- 30:04And this type of work would definitely not not show in the
- 30:06marketplace and see whether our our DNA of being a community and
- 30:11and the showcasing platform before being a marketplace.
- 30:14And also the type of content like in the marketplace you want
- 30:18reusable utilitarian thing like a chair or truck.
- 30:23Again, where I don't sketch. Like a lot of things are
- 30:26completely useless, but they're just beautiful.
- 30:31Oh my God, can I add to that because I didn't even think
- 30:34about that until you brought it up.
- 30:36You guys studying it as a a media player, let's just call it
- 30:39that for the sake of the argument.
- 30:40And then the others as a marketplace.
- 30:41That's so true because sometimes back in the day when I was
- 30:44trying to, let's say, find a model, CG trader and all again,
- 30:47I don't remember exactly he was CG trader.
- 30:49I think it was when I was looking at a model of a shoe.
- 30:51It was photos of it, but I. Couldn't see the actual. 3D and
- 30:55then now that I think about it, I have seen some amazing work on
- 30:59Sketchfab and I only downloaded it to figure out how the fuck
- 31:03they made it. Because I saw the, the, the fact
- 31:05that you guys had that rendering engine that can run like it was
- 31:08like a space I remember with stars.
- 31:10And I was like, how do you, how are you guys even rendering that
- 31:12on the web? I probably can't even do that in
- 31:14Blender myself. So I downloaded it just to
- 31:16reverse engineer how they created it.
- 31:19And then that makes a huge difference in what kind of
- 31:21content was up there. That makes a lot of sense now.
- 31:24It keeps me thinking that you guys let people put their stuff
- 31:27for free online and that would be a cost to your server because
- 31:30people would upload it. Just because people could upload
- 31:33their beautiful 3D arts and it would make the entire ecosystem
- 31:37and platform more beautiful with higher quality content and
- 31:41higher standards. Wow, that's really amazing.
- 31:43It's crazy. I want to, I want to quote you
- 31:46here. You have amazing articles on
- 31:48Medium that you've written previously in the past.
- 31:51And one of the things that you mentioned in one of one specific
- 31:54article said starting to charge for something that was initially
- 31:57free and then increasing the price because you realize you
- 32:00were not charging enough and then managing the backlash and
- 32:03then trying to explain the insurance and outs of things.
- 32:06Of course, this is after the funding and this is when the
- 32:09monetization has started. I want to ask you, what did you
- 32:13learn afterwards, after that entire thing over the over the
- 32:17years from setting prices for a product or service that others
- 32:21could learn? So maybe they can do it better,
- 32:23they can do it more efficiently and more effectively.
- 32:27All right, it's, it's a, it's a complex play because we, I mean,
- 32:35we raise money, which allowed us to be free for a while and, and
- 32:41focus. I mean, when we started France,
- 32:43before raising money, we started doing AB2B custom projects on
- 32:48top of Sketchfab. Like for very large French
- 32:51corporate companies, essentially they wanted their own Sketchfab
- 32:56and actually productized this in 2020 Sketchfab for teams.
- 33:00But back then we did, I mean, the product was very early.
- 33:04And actually a lot of French companies end up doing that.
- 33:06Like they have the beginning of a product, they don't have
- 33:08financial resources. So they start do doing like B2B
- 33:13consulting, using their tech. But as a result, they become
- 33:16like service companies, like tech agencies, and they can
- 33:21never invest in their product and productize all the features.
- 33:24They do custom things for each B2B customer.
- 33:28And as a result, they don't productize and downscale.
- 33:31For us, we're lucky to be able to move to the US early on and
- 33:34to find investors who would believe in our vision.
- 33:37And so we spent six years just investing on the product, which
- 33:42meant that when we started monetizing a, we had a super
- 33:47solid product, like way better than six years before.
- 33:50I kept accepting all the file formats, the best rendering
- 33:52integrated everywhere. We had strike partnerships with
- 33:55Facebook and Twitter and WordPress and all those guys.
- 33:58It was very fast, very reliable and we had already over
- 34:021,000,000 users. And so there's two ingredients
- 34:04like the best product integrated everywhere and with critical
- 34:08mass of users meant that when we when we shifted like turn
- 34:12pricing on it was it was a fair thing to we.
- 34:17We wanted to find a way that it would be cheap or free for
- 34:21artists, while companies using it for commercial purposes would
- 34:24pay a fair price for it. And we felt good about this
- 34:28decision and and yeah, and it was hard to charge at the
- 34:34beginning because we were a community and we loved art and
- 34:37artists and we we knew it was a lot of free artists are
- 34:43freelancers and they don't make a lot of money and so on.
- 34:45But we also find out a lot of three artists would find work
- 34:49thanks to sketch file and would would get notice there and then.
- 34:54And then anyway, like for artists was like 10 bucks a
- 34:56month, which was, which was fair.
- 34:58And most of the revenue was from the Nikes of the world.
- 35:01And for them who charge like, I mean, we felt it was a lot, but
- 35:05compared to the price would cause them to build the
- 35:09solutions themselves internally. Like it was super cheap.
- 35:12So we we felt, we felt good about it.
- 35:15Oh, absolutely. And I just want to clarify, I
- 35:17don't think it's a problem at all to charge.
- 35:19And as artists, we love to pay for things we we love using,
- 35:23right that help revolutionize the workflow, make it more
- 35:25efficient, more effective. It's more so just asking what's
- 35:28the best way to price a product or service, you know, because I
- 35:32feel like that's always really difficult to do, especially when
- 35:35you're doing it for the first time for a product that you
- 35:37you've built for so long. Yeah.
- 35:39But we try to find the comparables like look at the
- 35:43free software market and then the other media players like
- 35:46Vimeo and guys like that. So we looked a lot at Vimeo and
- 35:50they had a similar like offering for creators and offering for
- 35:54B2B companies. And then we looked at usage.
- 36:00But I mean, it was hard initially we were thinking about
- 36:04charging based on the number of models.
- 36:07But then we figured like, if we had a customer like Apple, like
- 36:11they have 10 products total. Now they have many more, but
- 36:14like they have one iPhone, 1 Mac, one iPad.
- 36:17And so if, if we work with Apple and which are based on the
- 36:20number of model, like we're going to make no money.
- 36:23So their metric is going to be traffic on the player because
- 36:26it's going to be embedded on, on their website.
- 36:28And that's where that would be the metric.
- 36:31And we, we eventually figured the, the best metric of the size
- 36:34of the customer would be it's, it's web traffic.
- 36:37And this metric worked even if you had only one model embedded
- 36:40on your website. If you have a lot of traffic, it
- 36:42means you're a big company. And then it depended how I mean,
- 36:46one thing was tricky was for newspapers, because they got
- 36:50news sites got a ton of traffic, but weren't necessarily big
- 36:53companies. And I mean, we're pretty
- 36:55flexible. Like for high traffic sites that
- 36:58were not selling something, it would be cheaper.
- 37:00And then otherwise we just implemented rules based on the
- 37:04traffic the player got. Similar to what yeah, JW Player
- 37:08or Vimeo would do. Wow, very interesting.
- 37:11And then when you guys started monetizing, when was the first
- 37:15time that you guys went to the break even point and you
- 37:18realized, OK, finally we have enough cash flow coming in, we
- 37:21can save your break even? So it was four years ago, May
- 37:262020. So after you took it from 1819,
- 37:30it took three years and it was a great, a great time.
- 37:35How do? You feel that day.
- 37:36How do you feel that? Day it was amazing, like it was
- 37:39moving from potential death to immortality.
- 37:42I mean we got pretty close to when we started monetizing.
- 37:46We're burning like 500,000 bucks a month.
- 37:50And so and people, people on the other side, like the community,
- 37:53they don't see that. And you can't really tell them
- 37:55that they're like, what you're asking me to pay like, well, I'm
- 37:58burning a ton of money and say either that or I die.
- 38:03And so, and from that point on, like we spend the first six
- 38:07years looking at our Google Analytics and sign ups and our
- 38:10core KPI or number of users, number of models, number of
- 38:12traffic and overnight And by the necessity of survival, we
- 38:18shifted to like monetizing and looking at our PayPal accounts
- 38:21and bank accounts and how much did we make today, how much did
- 38:24we spend and like being like super focused on that and
- 38:28prioritizing features based on what we could monetize.
- 38:32And it was the most focused period of time of the history of
- 38:35the company. And, and yeah, within not even
- 38:38three years, we were profitable and the company was super proud
- 38:43and yeah, it was great. So.
- 38:46So was it the when was the first moment that you thought to
- 38:49yourself, OK, Skip, Sketchfab is working.
- 38:52We made it. Well, it was, no, it was always
- 38:55working because for 10 years every day there was more users
- 38:58than the previous day. So even when we're pretty low
- 39:02and like burning a lot of cash and struggling to raise money,
- 39:05we, we kept going on because of that.
- 39:08Like there were always more users coming in.
- 39:11So we knew there was product market fit.
- 39:14We just just needed to figure out the business model.
- 39:18And then I mean, as soon as we start closing B2B deals with
- 39:21large customers and the Nikes of the world and then start, start
- 39:25starting to see every month we made more revenue as in the
- 39:29month before. I mean, our costs stayed
- 39:34completely flat. Like we stopped hiring anyone
- 39:36and we're 30 people and then revenue kept growing and it was
- 39:40clear that we would eventually make it.
- 39:42We had to be like super careful and and patient but it worked
- 39:47out. Wow, that that is crazy.
- 39:50And while we're on the topic of money, I know this is going a
- 39:53little bit behind the the time that we're discussing right now,
- 39:56but I do want to quote again another one of your articles.
- 40:00You mentioned somewhere that you pitched to 85 VCs for our seed
- 40:04round until finally getting to a yes.
- 40:07Or how we failed to raise AB round after pitching over 100
- 40:10firms. 85 and 100 are gigantic numbers.
- 40:15I cannot even imagine going into 85 different presentation
- 40:19slides, conversations, getting Nos because every single no is a
- 40:23hit to you. It's like a like a mini punch
- 40:26because then you have to question your reality.
- 40:28Am I on the right path? Am I on the wrong path?
- 40:31Are we doing everything right? So the question begs, at which
- 40:35point should one continue pitching or should one say, you
- 40:39know what, we need to reconsider our strategy.
- 40:46I guess really this story is different, but for us, I mean,
- 40:48the fact that every day with more users and the day before
- 40:51and less than the day after really helped us keeping going
- 40:55on. And also always had a lot of
- 40:57momentum on the integration front, like integrating the
- 41:01player with networks and 3D tools.
- 41:06And I don't know, I, I, I, I had the Super strong belief that we
- 41:11deserve to, to win. And I mean, we could have, could
- 41:18have always fall back on raising less money with, with less fancy
- 41:24investors. But I, I kept aiming for good
- 41:29investors and good terms. And I mean, it worked out.
- 41:33I kept, I kept trying until it worked out.
- 41:35And every time it worked out early enough, I mean, before our
- 41:38death, which was a mix of, and I see first time entrepreneurs
- 41:45today and they're like, oh, I, I pitched 10 VCs and and I got 10
- 41:49Nos like I was like 1010 VCs is nothing like you have to keep
- 41:54going. 10 VCs I have for breakfast.
- 41:57Yeah. Wow, that's yeah.
- 42:01So 8500, all these different numbers.
- 42:04I understand that it's subjective, right, Depending on
- 42:06the case. But what I guess the lesson here
- 42:09is you shouldn't freaking give up.
- 42:10If you believe in the product and you're seeing results,
- 42:13especially if you're seeing results, don't give up.
- 42:15Keep going because you'll find the right people love that.
- 42:18And now I want to go a little bit further because I think it
- 42:21was few, few years ago during GDC me and Fallas are watching
- 42:24it live. Epic Game announced that we are
- 42:27acquiring Sketchfab and I'm sure the conversation had started
- 42:31long before the GDC when the announcement had happened.
- 42:34And how did the entire conversation started?
- 42:38Oh, it's a long story, but it's the story for the book.
- 42:44No, I mean. I we're gonna we're gonna buy
- 42:46the book, by the way, we're gonna buy we.
- 42:48Wanna sign copy? We wanna sign copy for of the
- 42:50book. I know.
- 42:52I, I had known Mark Petty. So Mark Petty was the general
- 42:56manager of Henry Legend back then and I had known him for
- 43:00almost 10 years, like since 2014.
- 43:03He had actually invested in two of our main competitors based in
- 43:09Canada. I guess I don't know, but one
- 43:11was Virold that got acquired by Box.
- 43:14I don't know if you're familiar with those guys.
- 43:16And the other one was Clara dot AO, which became freakit.
- 43:22And anyway, so with this relationship, and there are a
- 43:26lot of French people in the, in the, in the 3D scene, you know,
- 43:29like Sebastian Dougie from Allegory to me, Councillor Marc
- 43:32Petit and, and a lot of French people at Autodesk and Adobe and
- 43:36so and so on. And so every year we would catch
- 43:39up, you know, meet at GDC and trade notes and so on.
- 43:43And, and every quarter I would send an update to our key
- 43:51partners about our latest progress.
- 43:56And so I had a, a list of people, lots of people from
- 44:00Unity and Adobe and Facebook and Apple and Epic and so on.
- 44:05We were partnered with all the other guys and not Epic
- 44:09actually. So we our free player was
- 44:12integrated in the Unity Asset store, were integrated with
- 44:17Photoshop at Adobe and so on. The big one one was one of the
- 44:21few we weren't partners with for a number of reasons, but they
- 44:24they were not really for a long time, not not big believers in
- 44:29the web for freely like that kind of, I mean, they aim for
- 44:32the IS quality and you like desktop, desktop AAA.
- 44:37And so quality for them matters more than like reach or in some
- 44:41occasions. But anyway, I sent so in early
- 44:47January, I sent my update to my network of partners about Q
- 44:514/20/20. And in this update, I shared
- 44:56this blog post that you quoted like that we became profitable
- 45:00and that's where they essentially win the game.
- 45:03And that in Q4 and that that quarter like both Google and
- 45:08Microsoft, they're both launched Sketchfab copycats like Remix 3D
- 45:13and Google Poly and they both shut down.
- 45:19And so as essentially sharing more profitable, like the Google
- 45:22and Microsoft copycats are dead. We just launched Sketchfab for
- 45:26Teams, which is very well received and so on and so on.
- 45:30And, and I guess Mark followed up saying, hey, we should, we
- 45:36should catch up. Like you guys seem to be doing
- 45:38great. And we, we spoke and we realised
- 45:43we had more and more traction around configurators at car
- 45:46companies. The car companies using
- 45:48Sketchfab and our APIs to build the car configurators.
- 45:52And Epic was, it was looking to expand beyond gaming and the
- 45:57Unreal Engine was used for a lot of things outside of gaming and
- 46:01all those customers like car companies, boat companies and
- 46:05and so on, or architecture companies, they wanted a web
- 46:09solution. And so Epic was starting to
- 46:12realise they, they needed that. So it was on the tech side of
- 46:16things. And so Sketchlab was kind of the
- 46:17little brother of Unreal Engine from a tech standpoint.
- 46:21And then they were also in the middle of thinking through
- 46:24platformizing, I mean, Fortnite opening up Fortnite, yeah, UEFN.
- 46:30And so they needed a library of content and Sketchfab was the
- 46:32biggest one out there. And so there are two very, two
- 46:35very clear opportunities to work together.
- 46:39And so, yeah, that's how that's how it worked out.
- 46:42Did you guys get any other offer from other big companies that
- 46:46they come and buy out Sketchfab like before copying you guys
- 46:49like? Google yes, with a lot of
- 46:51conversation with a lot of those guys and I wish are more in the
- 46:59book, I guess, but until we were profitable like every time it
- 47:06was kind of lowball offers like acquire yours and amounts.
- 47:11I mean, we loved what we're doing and we're working well and
- 47:14we, we would only take a check we couldn't say no to and until
- 47:19we're profitable, it was never there.
- 47:21And then the, the day we became profitable, I mean, we could
- 47:25kind of dictate the term, not dictate the term, but
- 47:28essentially be much clearer. Like, hey, it's there's no point
- 47:31to to talk to the boss. Now with the.
- 47:35Boss, now be. Killed the copycats.
- 47:37The copycats on the ground you're talking to sketch fast.
- 47:42Now we, we got to approach for acquisition like in February
- 47:452012 and from that point on like it kept going on like all the
- 47:49guys and we became profitable in in December 2020 and three
- 47:55months later we had an an offer we were ready to accept from
- 47:59Epic. It's it's was really AI mean the
- 48:02leverage change camps when we became profitable.
- 48:08Oh, and would you, would you be putting the amount in the book
- 48:12amount in the book? You will see.
- 48:19Man I really want that book now, have to get it ASAP.
- 48:23Where Where are you considering selling the company in the early
- 48:26days of Sketchfab? Was it something that you had in
- 48:29your mind? Well.
- 48:30I mean not, not particularly. I mean anyone is interested in
- 48:37not anyone is interested in. I mean, for life changing amount
- 48:41of money, anyone, I mean, every, every company is for sale for,
- 48:45for the right offer, I guess. But I didn't like, we had good
- 48:50traction and we loved what we're doing.
- 48:52And so we never, I mean, yeah, could have probably sold earlier
- 48:59and we wouldn't have built as many things.
- 49:01And so, yeah, I mean that we never proactively looked for it
- 49:08like we, I mean, we spoke with people who would reach out, but
- 49:11we never really pushed for it, I guess.
- 49:17I know you had this question about VCs.
- 49:19There was this part of the article.
- 49:21I think no, it wasn't an article.
- 49:23I think you shared a LinkedIn post and there was a follow up,
- 49:26a WhatsApp conversation with one of your friends.
- 49:28And I want to quote you here again where you mentioned time
- 49:32is the best due diligence. I really loved it that I looked
- 49:35at that LinkedIn post you. Told me about it like 10 times.
- 49:38You mentioned from experience no VC.
- 49:40We invest in you within a couple of weeks of getting introduced
- 49:43to you. Business plans are useless and
- 49:45ideas are free. We've been talking about this
- 49:47for the longest time and you said what really matters down
- 49:51the line is the team and execution.
- 49:54So I I want to ask you, how would an early founder would go
- 49:59out and talk to investors? When is the best time to connect
- 50:03with investors and VC? I mean, founders are often
- 50:08scared to go too early because they films are not ready.
- 50:11But I think it's, it's totally OK to go early just to, to build
- 50:15the relationship and present yourself and present your
- 50:17vision, even if your product is not on par with your vision yet.
- 50:22And then just start this relationship.
- 50:26And, and then I mean the easy way, so you start this
- 50:33relationship as early as you can, I guess, And then you start
- 50:39asking, a good trick is to ask for help to VC, like, hey, could
- 50:43you make this intro to this founder at your portfolio?
- 50:46And so most VCs will say no, but the few ones will say, yes, it
- 50:50means they are interested in what you're building.
- 50:52And it's also a way for them to track your progress.
- 50:54Like they're going to make this intro and then they're going to
- 50:56ask the other founder like, Hey, how did it go?
- 50:59Like, did you enjoy talking with this guy and so on.
- 51:02And then if you ask for help, like the VC becomes de facto
- 51:06part of your story because it's helping you out.
- 51:09And so it's a great way to, to, yeah, to build a relationship.
- 51:13And then just maintain it with frequency, like send up dates
- 51:17and try to meet in person if you can, or resume like frequently.
- 51:22And then when you, when you are actually entering the time when
- 51:25you, when you want to fundraise, the VC is already up to speed on
- 51:31where you are, what you're doing.
- 51:33And you can very quickly say yes or no.
- 51:35And maybe it will be no, but you're not going to spend
- 51:38another six months building the relationship.
- 51:42You know what's really cool at this point?
- 51:45If you look back just a few years ago, you're the one
- 51:48pitching to VCs and now at this point, you're the one investing
- 51:51in companies and we see it in LinkedIn, the companies that
- 51:54you're investing in. And they're really interesting
- 51:56as well. One of the recent one that you
- 51:58post about was, I believe Dolly is the name, am I right?
- 52:01And what's super cool is when the video that you shared, it's
- 52:05using Gaussian splatting, which is a technology we've covered on
- 52:09our YouTube channel, if I'm not mistaken, that is what they're
- 52:11using to do product, professional looking product
- 52:15photography. Well, not photography, I have to
- 52:17say video at this point. So for instance, if you got Air
- 52:20Jordans, you're going around, you're taking a capture and then
- 52:23you got this amazing video that comes out of it.
- 52:26How does it feel now being on the other side, being well, I, I
- 52:31are you being pitched to at the moment as well from different
- 52:34companies? Oh yeah, I receive almost one
- 52:37pitch per day, I would say. Do you say no once a day?
- 52:41Or I say no one once a day, Yes. How does it feel being on the
- 52:47other side? Well, I, I, I wouldn't enjoy
- 52:52just doing that. Like I'm an entrepreneur, so I
- 52:55need to build things. And so I like, I, I mostly
- 52:58invest in founders I know and believe in.
- 53:00And so Dolly was started by Raymir Russo, who was one of the
- 53:05very first guys to work on the volumetric video capture with me
- 53:09misses that got acquired by a magic lip.
- 53:11And we integrated the solution with sketch hubs that you could,
- 53:15I mean, I used their solution to record the first steps of my son
- 53:19with a Kinect in the, in the, in the volumetric moving point
- 53:23cloud. And so I've known Remy for 10
- 53:25years. And when he started his new
- 53:27company, like I, I, there was no due diligence.
- 53:31I knew him and so I, I knew I could, I could back him.
- 53:33And so that's really my angle is investing in entrepreneurs I
- 53:38believe in. And so I received a lot of
- 53:40pictures from entrepreneurs I don't know.
- 53:42And I pass on most of them because that's not my angle.
- 53:46But sometimes I do it if I really love the the angle and I
- 53:51have a good fit with the founders.
- 53:53But it's it's pretty wary. What qualities do you look for?
- 53:57So when you get a pitch from a founder, what qualities are
- 54:00essential for you? We are not trying to send you.
- 54:04Yeah, yeah. No, don't lie.
- 54:07What are you talking about? Well, first I, I look if I mean,
- 54:17I want to see that the founders background is relevant to what
- 54:21it's building. I look for passion, like how,
- 54:24how passionate is about the, the project.
- 54:29I look for tenacity and I mean persistence, like are they going
- 54:33to follow up a lot? I look for I, I, I like good
- 54:40presentation. And so I look at the the format
- 54:42of the deck and how it's presented and, and like, is it
- 54:46well crafted and are there like tipos or like small detail?
- 54:50Like is there attention to detail?
- 54:54And then, I don't know, like human feet.
- 54:57And then is this person smart or not?
- 55:00It's hard to to put a name on it, but yeah.
- 55:07I wanted to ask you one question which I think is going to be
- 55:10helpful to a lot of people. Do you have any resources that
- 55:14you recommend? And this could be resources that
- 55:17you use in terms of books, videos, documentaries, articles
- 55:21that have helped you when you were leading the team at
- 55:24Sketchfab or even now when it comes to VC and when it comes to
- 55:27funding. Is there any resources that ring
- 55:29a bell that really helped you in your journey?
- 55:34Yeah, I guess. I mean, I use Twitter a lot and
- 55:36so following like do you know guys like Naval, Ravi Kent or
- 55:43Jason? Jason Lemkin is really great for
- 55:46all the tips on a lot of things to be honest.
- 55:49But like a lot of things on pricing and SAS and the
- 55:52fundraising like amazing, very practical advice, a lot of
- 55:56volume, like he covers everything.
- 55:58And so I really love his advices.
- 56:03Alex is called shares a lot of great tips as well.
- 56:07He was on our board. And then, yeah, we we went
- 56:11through three accelerators. That was also very helpful.
- 56:17Yeah. And then I read the.
- 56:20I love reading books about founder stories like Steve Jobs
- 56:24or Phil Knight, the founder of Nike, the story of Twitter, the
- 56:29story of Foculus. Like all the stories, like a lot
- 56:31of learning, like from the trenches and worth reading.
- 56:35Yeah. I agree with you.
- 56:37I think reading this to the biography of founders is really,
- 56:40really helpful, especially for me and Farras.
- 56:43As Farras mentioned, we we read first Elon Musk's book by Walter
- 56:46Isaacson. He wrote the same book for Steve
- 56:48Jobs. Both books were really
- 56:50fascinating. And you see in the moments of
- 56:53pressure how they're dealing with pressure.
- 56:55You can learn a lot lot from what they did right and also you
- 56:58can learn. What they did wrong?
- 57:00What they did? Wrong at the same time as well.
- 57:02So I think that would be very, very helpful for all the
- 57:04founders. One question I have to ask is I
- 57:09want to know your opinion as someone who's led, you know, the
- 57:13team for the the largest and most premium 3D content library
- 57:17in my opinion, what do you think is the future of 3D and
- 57:22photogrammetry and and and 3D content library?
- 57:25Now that of course, Sketchpad itself was acquired by Epic
- 57:27Games, but you also sort of understand that they're trying
- 57:30to go for that UEFN platform where players and people can
- 57:35create these meta verses quickly.
- 57:36This is something that we've seen from the outside, but as
- 57:39someone who's experienced like you, what do you think is the
- 57:42future of of this industry? It's, it's hard to say the AI
- 57:47will a lot of people working on 2D to 3D, like automatically
- 57:52generating 3D doesn't seem to output great content quite yet,
- 58:00but I guess we'll get there. I'm more interested in in
- 58:04techniques combining clean input, like clean free content
- 58:09and then AI like leveraging AI to assemble things, like to
- 58:15combine things in a smart way or to search things or to, to build
- 58:19a scene or to texture something. So like not trying to have AI
- 58:23solve everything, like just solve a part of it and being
- 58:28smart on that part. But so combine something that is
- 58:32clean and professional with AI. And I mean something for 3D
- 58:39capture. Like people think AI will kill
- 58:41photogrammetry and, and capture. But I mean, one of the beautiful
- 58:48things of photogrammetry is, is capturing something that is
- 58:51unique to you. And AI cannot read.
- 58:54I mean, if you scan, I mean, I love objects with stories and if
- 58:59I scan to like skateboard decks with sketch art on it, I got to
- 59:05ask AI to generate this where they can capture it or like
- 59:10capture. I have 3D portraits of all my
- 59:12kids at every of their ages and AI is not going to generate
- 59:17that. I have scanned all their
- 59:18bedrooms throughout the years. AI is not going to generate
- 59:21that. So for content that is personal
- 59:22to you, photogrammetry will still matter of course.
- 59:29You've photogrammetry the entire bedroom and you photogrammetry
- 59:32your children every year. So technically in 20-30 years
- 59:36they can recreate their childhood and they can walk into
- 59:39it. Oh shit.
- 59:43I just realized. Means you can relive your
- 59:46memory. It's like Harry Potter when you
- 59:48know when, when they were storing.
- 59:51Yeah, they could exactly the same thing.
- 59:53You have your room with the delay because you are keeping
- 59:56the 3D files. Hopefully right, you have all of
- 59:58that. You have it all stored.
- 1:00:00And then when the technology gets better, especially in the
- 1:00:03VR realm, you can upload those rooms and then you can start
- 1:00:07walking. Around and then AI will generate
- 1:00:08the missing frames. So like what happened in between
- 1:00:11those years? Well, that's.
- 1:00:13That is fascinating and I love the way you put it, especially
- 1:00:16when it comes to the AI part of things.
- 1:00:18I understand there's, I think there was Kaden, we just got an
- 1:00:21e-mail to try out. Rodin is the name.
- 1:00:25They also do something similar. And again, these are only gonna
- 1:00:29get better, of course. But I agree with you when an AI
- 1:00:31comes in, in, in one specific part of the workflow and does
- 1:00:35that to the best of its capability.
- 1:00:37Let's use UV unwrapping, which is something I hate doing
- 1:00:40myself. If, if, if an AI can do that
- 1:00:42perfectly, I'm more than happy to use that AI and pay a good
- 1:00:46amount for it. And I think that would be the
- 1:00:48best use case rather than just do this and then I have nothing
- 1:00:51else left to do myself. You know, it's just like, that
- 1:00:54is the best use case in my opinion as well.
- 1:00:57So I think that's the best way to put it.
- 1:01:00I want to ask whether have you started on the book already
- 1:01:04because the poll result was 95% ninety, 7% yes, 2% no, and 1%
- 1:01:11was what is Sketchfab? I should have framed the poll
- 1:01:14differently, but yes, yes, I have started the book.
- 1:01:18Nice. Yeah.
- 1:01:20Any expected release date? No.
- 1:01:24OK. And what is as our final
- 1:01:28question, we always ask Eric, yes, what is the next adventure
- 1:01:31for Alpine? It's a tough question.
- 1:01:35I don't know, Still lots of opportunity in the free space
- 1:01:41and then want to find something I can be passionate about for
- 1:01:46another 10 years. And so I'm also exploring new
- 1:01:50passions and you I want to do something meaningful as well.
- 1:01:53So I'm I'm interested in things like non alcoholic wine, so very
- 1:02:00far from tech, but I think I think it's a meaningful product
- 1:02:05that will be that will have a big market for it.
- 1:02:10And yeah, I don't know, exploring.
- 1:02:15Wait non non alcoholic wine? Have you tried that?
- 1:02:18We have non alcoholic beer. I've tried that.
- 1:02:20I've tried that, I haven't tried non.
- 1:02:21I mean, is it? I can't.
- 1:02:23Juice at the end of the day. To at least in France, to be
- 1:02:28allowed to call it non alcoholic wine, you have to actually make
- 1:02:31wine and then remove the alcohol.
- 1:02:34And there are a bunch of them, but most of them taste bad and
- 1:02:37are cheap. And so I think there is a port
- 1:02:39city for something that tastes good and is expensive.
- 1:02:43But I haven't found the secret formula.
- 1:02:46I mean, I haven't started looking for it, but so yeah, I'd
- 1:02:49be, I'm interested in exploring this.
- 1:02:53If you ever wanted a taster, you know.
- 1:02:55Yeah, we we would love to give it a try.
- 1:02:58Give it a try. Awesome.
- 1:03:02Well, thank you so much, Alvin. It's been a pleasure speaking
- 1:03:05with you, learning so many things from your journey, your
- 1:03:08team's journey. And we wish you all the best in
- 1:03:11writing the book. We cannot wait to read it and
- 1:03:14we're going to be waiting for it.
- 1:03:15I know our community is going to be super excited to to hear
- 1:03:18about it as well. So for anybody as well, I just
- 1:03:20want to say watching and listening right now, your
- 1:03:23LinkedIn is very active. You talk about a lot of things
- 1:03:25that you do. So is there anywhere else that
- 1:03:27they should be checking out when it comes to your updates?
- 1:03:30Twitter. OK, perfect.
- 1:03:31So that's where you guys have to check it out.
- 1:03:33And again, thank you very much. Thanks for having me.
- 1:03:38All right, for everybody watching and listening, thank
- 1:03:39you so much. We'll see you guys on the next
- 1:03:41episode. Until then, Ciao.