Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / The Psychology of Amy Winehouse (2015 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, guys. So a listener wrote in and said that they saw the
- 0:04new documentary about Amy Winehouse, and the whole time she was wondering what we
- 0:11would have to say about this, because because we talk about movies sometimes,
- 0:15you know. And so I thought, hey, let's all go see the
- 0:18documentary and let's talk about it on the podcast. So we all went and
- 0:23saw the documentary the movie, and now we're ready to talk about it.
- 0:26Are you guys ready to talk about the documentary? Let's do it. This
- 0:30is the Psychology in Seattle Podcast. I am your host, doctor Kirkanda.
- 0:35I am chair of the Couple in Family Therapy program at Antioch University, Seattle,
- 0:39and I'm also a practicing therapist. My name is Paultte Perhatch. I
- 0:44am a Seattle writer, and my name is Sumberto Cas. I am a
- 0:47bodyguard for a starlett who's on troubled times lately. Interesting. That's interesting parallel.
- 0:54So I thought I would start with just what I knew about Amy Winehouse
- 0:59before she died, before the documentary, I thought we might talk. I
- 1:02thought we might just go and sequential order here. Okay, So what I
- 1:06knew about her was her song Rehab. I remember hearing that song. It
- 1:10was hey huge in what like two thousand and seven or eight or something,
- 1:15and I remember seeing pictures of her, and I saw someone who was marketing
- 1:21herself as a tattooed retro rebel. You know. It was like she had
- 1:26an interesting combination of things. She was like low class England and she was
- 1:33tattooed, but she was singing these super old jazz tunes. But her hair
- 1:38was like sixties bouffont beehive kind of thing. She had all these really interesting
- 1:42visual elements to her. The first time I heard of Amy Winehouse was also
- 1:48when I heard the song Rehab. I had not heard about her before,
- 1:51and I gotta say that until I saw the movie. Honestly, I think
- 1:56that might be the only song I ever heard of hers. Really, Yeah,
- 2:00and I had an impression about her that was really negative. I'm not
- 2:05saying the documentary, actually I'm not. I don't spoil the party, but
- 2:08I will say this, My preconceived notion of her was actually that it was
- 2:14another front, like a Lady Gaga type front, like she was faking.
- 2:20I know, I didn't think she was faking being dysfunctional, because I kind
- 2:23of got the sense like, man, this is a train wreck. But
- 2:25I also got the sense like she was proud of it or something. And
- 2:29this, by the way, from like probably five seconds of media that I
- 2:31might have ever seen about her and the song itself, and I felt that
- 2:36the song itself was kind of like so transparent, like because at first I
- 2:40was like, I thought it might be like, you know, a tongue
- 2:43in cheek, like, no, she's not really, But then just a
- 2:46little bit I read at the time, I remember thinking, wait, if
- 2:47this is true and this is the song you got big about and then you're
- 2:51proud of this or so like what a double train wreck. That's what I
- 2:54remember. I remember thinking that too. Man, all right, Firstly,
- 2:58I love Amy wine House. I love her music. I didn't really know
- 3:00who she was when I enjoyed her music. And there's one of the most
- 3:05important things in art, I think, is that there's a difference between the
- 3:07art and the artist. So like I love Kanye West's music, Do I
- 3:12like some of his actions not so much. So what I loved was her
- 3:15music, and I just I didn't think she was marketing herself at all.
- 3:19I just thought she seemed so real back in the day back in the day,
- 3:23and I felt pleased that who I got a sense that she was she
- 3:28actually was. It wasn't like Lana del Rey, where it's like, well,
- 3:30this kind of music career didn't work for you. Let's take you into
- 3:34the shop and install some lips and some other things, and then we'll put
- 3:38you out as a totally different kind of person. And it's like, to
- 3:39me, that's not art. And so I think that she was really a
- 3:43real artist. Did you so you had heard some of her music prior to
- 3:47Rehab coming out. I'm not sure of the chronology, you know, It's
- 3:52kind of hard. I'm really bad at keeping up with music. I'm just
- 3:54like whatever's on Spotify or hair on the radio or other people playing. So
- 3:58I'm not sure exactly when I started listening to her music. But I have
- 4:00a really funny story about Rehab. I can tell you guys later later on.
- 4:05So, my mom loved that song, Rehab, and she did her
- 4:12like mom clap to it. She's so cute, and so she would always
- 4:15listen to it. And then we were it was years later, the song
- 4:19was already old, and my mom's mom was dying, and we were driving
- 4:26in the car like from the home where she was dying, to know,
- 4:29back to this other house. And my mom was, you know, obviously
- 4:31really sad, and she was just like, well, we put on that
- 4:34Amy wine House song. At this point, Amy wine House had already died,
- 4:40and it was like, I don't know, mom, she really should
- 4:42have gone to rehab. My mom was just like, I don't care,
- 4:46just I need to hear it. So we just put on Rehab and it
- 4:49was like this, I don't know, like I think that it was just
- 4:53a real song about what was really going on in her life. Yeah,
- 4:57yeah, all things. Yeah, did you know the other song? Were
- 5:00you did? So you listened to her album? Yeah? I really liked
- 5:02the Back to Black and I just especially like sad music like Bonie Vere and
- 5:09just like soulful I'm sad music, Yeah, like Rayla Montagne. I just
- 5:14asked my boyfriend to change. I'm like, can we listen to Rayla Montanne?
- 5:16He's like, it's not suicide hour, She's fine, that's pretty much
- 5:20my entire taste. Suicide or you're drinking yourself to death. Yeah, I'm
- 5:25more like Berto. I knew Rehab. I had seen pictures of her,
- 5:30uh, and I heard jokes about her on TV, and she was often
- 5:34a punchline. And then I remember seeing a bad video of her where she's
- 5:40or a picture or something on the internet where she was so drunk or high
- 5:45or something that and she was so bullamic that her her panties were falling down
- 5:50while she was singing on stage. Have you seen this footage? Oh oh
- 5:55god, she's so intoxicated and she's singing and she's so emaciated that her you
- 6:01know, her previously snug panties were slowly falling down her legs and you know,
- 6:08she wore really short screwts and she's just sitting there on stage singing and
- 6:13her panties are are like saggy sliding down, not like far, but like
- 6:17but saggy, you know what I mean. Like, but she was so
- 6:23intoxicated, she didn't know, and she's on stage in front of tens of
- 6:26thousands of Yeah, that's so bad. It's like, why I'm glad there
- 6:29weren't camera phones when I was in high schools, Like, oh god,
- 6:31cause your panties are videos that would have no but equally inappropriate crazy weird stuff,
- 6:39which is another element of this documentary. It's like now whenever anyone dies,
- 6:44We're going to have hours and hours of footage to make a documentary about
- 6:47them. That is actually fascinating. I was thinking about something while I was
- 6:51watching the movie. You know how they show a lot of scenes, they
- 6:55make a point of it. I think of showing the paparazzi barrage. Yeah.
- 7:00Right. A few things went through my head. One of them was
- 7:02is it still like that? Meaning? Do more and more of him?
- 7:04Use digital cameras for example, where you might not hear so many clicks and
- 7:09things like that. Are the clicks to flashes? And if the flashes are
- 7:12the clicks? Are there different kinds of flashes nowadays? That are? I
- 7:15mean it's I know it's only been five years, but like in those five
- 7:16years, like a lot of shit has changed, you know, And so
- 7:19I'm wondering is it still like that? Because that alone can drive someone mad.
- 7:25It is because in order to take even a digital photograph at night or
- 7:30even like twilight, you need a flash. And is that what makes the
- 7:32sound? No, it's it's the camera and digital SLRs still make still have
- 7:36a mechanism at slash. Okay, well, because the other thing else,
- 7:41the thing that I was thinking about it was at first I was like,
- 7:43God, these you know, vicious leeches, right, And then I was
- 7:46thinking, we wouldn't have a documentary without a lot of this footage. Well,
- 7:50so it was kind of like a give and take for me. Not
- 7:54me, it was all take. It was all terrible, But you watched
- 7:57the movie. You were there. I actually had to not look at the
- 8:00screen while they were doing those because just watching it was, oh, the
- 8:05flashes. My brain was going to go, I mean, and I was
- 8:09like, I can't imagine being ground zero on that. I mean, that
- 8:13is something that you could do as a form of torture when you're interrogating.
- 8:16So I just have a bunch of flashing lights. I think they do that
- 8:18with I mean, the bodies hit the floor is actually the song I just
- 8:20learned. They I could see them passing some regulations like, look, you
- 8:24can't have more than any number of people in an area when blah blahah.
- 8:28But I was thinking, I mean, it is capitalism, and it's probably
- 8:31worst. And yet I will stand by this one common which is that a
- 8:35lot of the footage they had was in fact from those kind of moments.
- 8:39It's so true, it's so weird. It's like when Kurt Cobain's Diaries were
- 8:43published. I picked it up at a bookstore and I was like, oh
- 8:46my god, Like I get to know what Kirk Cobain was thinking about.
- 8:48It's like diary. And then I just opened the first page and read the
- 8:52first line and I was like, oh, it made me feel horrible,
- 8:54and I just put it back on the shelf. So I don't know.
- 8:56And one thing that struck me was how they I like, when they update
- 9:00you with what age she is at certain points, and it's like she was
- 9:01twenty three, and you're just like, oh my god, she's twenty three.
- 9:05Like I think back to what I was doing at twenty three, and
- 9:07would I want cameras following me everywhere? It's like no. Yeah. But
- 9:11the last little bit I'll say that I knew about her before watching this documentary
- 9:16was burto you remember Lita, right, yep? Our first lia, the
- 9:20first paulette was was our my friend from from preschool, Leita Katibi. She
- 9:28was the third co host of Psychology in Seattle. She was there in the
- 9:31beginning and she is a singer and she loved Amy Whinehouse and sings a lot
- 9:39like Amy Winehouse and has a similar style to her. And back in the
- 9:43day, I was in a cover band called the living Room Butchers because I
- 9:48was in Me and Burdo were in all these bands where we had all this
- 9:50tech stuff and videos and lights and like electronic stuff and computers and videos and
- 9:54like everything was just super complicated. And so after that, I just wanted
- 9:58to like play music in my living room with friends and we butchered songs.
- 10:03And so we were the living Room Butcher's and Leita, one of my friends,
- 10:07came over and we butchered Rehab. We played Rehab in my living room,
- 10:09and I remember thinking that Leita was very similar to Amy Winehouse in terms
- 10:16of her vibe music life. And then when I watched the documentary, it
- 10:20was even more so because you know, when you see Amy Winehouse with just
- 10:24just her and a guy playing guitar and she's just singing and she has that
- 10:28sultry jazzy voice, Leita has been doing that exact same style since the late
- 10:33eighties. Wow, And so like she used to play with this guy who
- 10:37did the exact same thing, and they'd play like moon Dance by Van Morrison
- 10:43or a Beatles song, and she would just do that total jazzy, sultry
- 10:48voice. It's like if Amy Winehouse. I think she totally copied Lesa KATV.
- 10:54That's my point. So if Lisa had just not gone to rehab,
- 10:56she could have been huge, exactly Grammy winning. So let's start at the
- 11:01beginning of Amy wine House's houses life. So this has so I took notes
- 11:05as I usually do while I watch a documentary, and I also looked on
- 11:09the Internet for information. So this information might be wrong, so take it
- 11:13or leave it. But anyway. She was born in nineteen eighty three and
- 11:16she was born in North London to Jewish parents of Russian and Polish descent.
- 11:22Her dad was a taxi driver and her mother was a pharmacist, which I
- 11:24found to be sort of interesting given her life. Right. She had an
- 11:28older brother who was four years older. I believe his name was Alex or
- 11:33something. Her mother's brothers were jazz musicians, which I thought was interesting,
- 11:37and her dad's mother was a jazz singer and her dad, who was in
- 11:41the documentary, would sing Frank Sinatra songs to her. So there was a
- 11:45lot of jazz and retro stuff happening in her household. While she was growing
- 11:50up, because if they didn't portray that in the documentary, no, it
- 11:52started writ in on assuming that it came out of nowhere. It seems to
- 11:56have come out of nowhere in it. Right, It's like, there's this
- 11:58fourteen year old old girl singing like a jazz singer. It's like, it's
- 12:01like what, yeah, and even to the point that you are led to
- 12:07understand that her dad played almost no role in her life, right, right,
- 12:11which is mostly true, But at the same time, it seems like
- 12:13there was a musical influence there. Yeah, we'll get to that narrative in
- 12:16a bit. Okay. So then in nineteen ninety three, we're talking about
- 12:20the grunge age. She's nine years old and her parents separate. In the
- 12:24documentary, they highlight this moment when her parents separated. I love when the
- 12:28dad is just like, I think she got over it pretty quickly, and
- 12:31you're just like, oh my god, yeah, it was really sad.
- 12:35Actually, it's a common misunderstanding because what parents are looking for in their children
- 12:41is tears or some kind of like overt emotionality regarding the difficulty of their separation.
- 12:48But children don't do that, and adults don't usually do it either.
- 12:52But yeah, she was separated. There was sort of a theme. And
- 12:56tell me if you think this seemed to be true, that the doc documentary
- 13:00at least was trying to tell us that the parents were not all that nurturing
- 13:05of amy. Did you find that to be true. Oh, I've definitely
- 13:09found it to be the I don't know if it was true in real life,
- 13:13but it's certainly the vibe I got from the documentary, And I certainly
- 13:16from the documentary got the vibe that the dad was very much to blame for
- 13:20a lot of her issues and lack of addressing the issues. I think that
- 13:24like when the mom didn't stand up to her and the mom will letter get
- 13:28it with murder, that can be a kind of neglect, right, So
- 13:31I think that's one of the ways in which they weren't that nursering, right.
- 13:35It is a nurturing act to dedicate the energy to disciplining your child.
- 13:41So she says that when her parents separated, she rebelled. She said she
- 13:45rebelled at the age of nine. She knew she could get away with whatever
- 13:48she wanted, she said, And she also said she became quite depressed.
- 13:52And she said that music was her outlet at the time. She also learned
- 13:56how to tap dance. I read this on the Internet, which I thought
- 13:58was interes saying they didn't have that in the documentary. And she also started
- 14:03a rap group called Sweet and Sour like Salt and Peppa. They didn't talk
- 14:09about that in the documentary, although she did. There was the illusion to
- 14:11rap later talk about everything. I mean, you have to cut it down.
- 14:15It's a whole lifetime. But I always find it interesting what they choose
- 14:18to ye, what they choose hard. I mean, I used to like
- 14:22write profiles of people, and it's it's hard because even there you're kind of
- 14:26having an opinion about what's important and what's not. Actually, that is one
- 14:30of my complaints about the documentary is that I could almost accuse it of being
- 14:35exploitative. And because I say that, because I mostly just focused on her
- 14:41dysfunction, Like there were a few moments where it highlighted her talent, and
- 14:46but I'd say the bulk of it was about the dysfunction, and since pretty
- 14:50it was very dysfunctional. Well that might be, but I think the more
- 14:54that it's like that's the story, that's the tension that her destruction was as
- 14:58big as her talent. But I didn't like, for example, we were
- 15:01just saying how where did her talent come from? Like I didn't get a
- 15:03sense of like who was she as an artist as much as I did who
- 15:07was she as a dysfunctional person? Yeah? And that might be fair because
- 15:11in the end she was dysfunctional and she sadly killed herself for it. But
- 15:16I think that all the parts that they just let her sing and put the
- 15:18lyrics up on the board on the movie, I think that was kind of
- 15:22a moment to be like, look how freaking good she was without having to
- 15:26say that, you know, yeah, and she's saying in a style that
- 15:30made it hard to understand what she was saying, and so it was helpful
- 15:33to have her lyrics displayed, which I thought was really a good idea.
- 15:37Also, before the documentary begins, I read that she attended theater school,
- 15:41which I also thought was interesting. You know, it's like, so she
- 15:45was groomed to be on stage by her family, she went to theater school.
- 15:50She wanted to be you know, she's a tap dance and she wanted
- 15:52to She had a rep a rap group. So by the time we see
- 15:58her start in the documentary in nineteen ninety eight at the age of fourteen.
- 16:03You know, we already have someone who's set up for at least some something
- 16:07happy to do with music, you know what I mean. So we see
- 16:10her at the beginning of the documentary she's fourteen, and around this time I
- 16:14also read that she started playing her older brother's guitar, and then she bought
- 16:18she bought her own guitar. I probably like, bought it to pick up
- 16:21chicks and then his little sisters just like kills it. Never mind. I
- 16:27was so shocked when I saw that early video footage of her, how innocent
- 16:33and clean and happy she looked. Did you guys notice that? Yeah,
- 16:38yeah, you're right, that's very happy. Yeah. And another sort of
- 16:41notable thing that I'm just realizing right now is people are singing happy birthday,
- 16:48kind of you know, the way that people do, like a happy birthday,
- 16:49And then she pipes in with her beautiful voice, and everyone stops singing
- 16:55because she sounds so much better. And then she does a full on life
- 17:00like you know, I'm on the stage kind of rendition with this trill at
- 17:03the end, you know what I mean. Anyway, before even that point,
- 17:07though, there's a bit where they start off with her singing the song
- 17:11moon River. Do you guys know this song? You don't know what?
- 17:15Call it? Moon River, moon Wider than a Mile. I want to
- 17:22actually talk about the song for a little bit. Can we talk about that
- 17:23song? Sure? Let me just tell you the lyrics. Okay, tell
- 17:26me what it means, Moon River, wider than a mile. I'm crossing
- 17:30you in style someday to drifter, you heartbreaker, wherever you're going, I'm
- 17:41going your way to drifters off to see the world. There's such a lot
- 17:45of world to see something something my Huckleberry friend, Moon River and me.
- 17:52I'm obviously leaving stuff out, But from those lyrics, can you tell what
- 17:56that song means? No? I kind of always thought two things. One
- 18:00is moon River. I pictured the literally the reflection of the moon on a
- 18:04river at night. But then the metaphor I got from it was actually like
- 18:07death. But maybe I'm kind of what I was saying is like across you
- 18:11one day. Yeah it means I don't know. Yeah, but my Huckleberry
- 18:14friend, Yeah yeah, huckleberry word, You'll be there till the end with
- 18:18me. Huh. I don't know, well, maybe it's not just death,
- 18:21but maybe it's like the path of life and then including death. I
- 18:23don't know, but I'm making shit. I like it. I like it
- 18:26well anyway. My relationship with this song goes way back when I was in
- 18:30high school. I was in vocal jazz, you know, with jazz hands,
- 18:33that's hard thing, and you had to sing a final, you know,
- 18:37because every class has to have a final test, right, So what
- 18:40do you have to do in vocal jazz, Well, you have to sing
- 18:41a song in front of everyone. Yeah, And so I sang. So
- 18:45they gave us these these tapes that just had It was basically like a karaoke
- 18:51tape with all these standards on it, and I just listened to all the
- 18:55different tracks and I was like, Man, which one am I going to
- 18:56sing? And then this Moon River song came right and I'd never heard it
- 19:00before, and I was like, oh, I'll sing that one. So
- 19:02I sang it for for my vocal jazz final. I don't know how it
- 19:04did, don't ask me. Probably got an a because how'd you do,
- 19:07Probably got a name because I'm awesome. But I fell in love with the
- 19:10song at that point, and then I found out that it was popularized popular
- 19:15popularized by the singer Andy Williams and Audrey Hepburn and Breakfast at Tiffany's. That's
- 19:19right, so Audrey Hepburn sings this sings that song in breakfast tificy, Why
- 19:23are you making signs with your hands? She play it on a ukulele,
- 19:29she plays it on a guitar. Nice Hepburn one in Oscar in sixty one
- 19:33for her rendition of the song, which is and then the song also won
- 19:37a Grammy in sixty two. Everyone has covered it, according to the Internet,
- 19:41including R. E. M. Morrissey, PJ. Harvey, The
- 19:45Killers, Willie Nilson, Rod the Bod, bar P Rod Stewart Man Rod
- 19:52the Bod. Did you write Rod the Bod or did you read that of
- 19:55No No no Rod? That was his nickname. That was his nickname,
- 19:57Rod the Bob, one of his nicknames. And Barbara, you know,
- 20:00Barbara so Abs and all sorts of other people. My parents actually found out
- 20:06that I liked this song, and they took me to see Andy Williams play
- 20:08at the Paramount. We sat in the front row. Oh oh, I
- 20:12never sat in the front row. Zach Borer made me think that I would
- 20:15be in the front row always from Save by the Bell. Tell me you
- 20:18guys what I'm talking about it Zach Morris always had front road seats. I'm
- 20:22like, oh, you just have front roast seats all the time when you're
- 20:25an adult and just like, oh, those are ten thousand dollars and you're
- 20:27like, okay, yeah, I'm not going to have those. See if
- 20:30I'm back here Beyonce, I've been hookuler is no big deal. You're wearing
- 20:33your Beyonce shirt. Yeah, actually I got This was the closest I was.
- 20:37Like, I told my boyfriend, like one time, I want to
- 20:38be up close in an awesome concert. So this was my awesome Were you?
- 20:42I was there? Were you? We were both there. I have
- 20:45a picture where she's like we're kirkd Yeah, you're right up. Oh you're
- 20:48way closer than me. Then we were like down in the front and security
- 20:51was so bad that when the lights went out, everyone just rushed forward.
- 20:53We were like one hundred feet away. It was still amazing. I was,
- 20:56I was around the same place and we did the same I mean I
- 21:00didn't have that ticket. I had a ticket and then we rushed in.
- 21:03Who but that's amazing. Yeah, I saw your pictures on Facebook. It
- 21:07seemed like you were right there. I best to be on the walk down
- 21:11here. Wow, I didn't realize I had the shirt on too. You
- 21:14have much. I have a similar thing with another jazz stand and the blackface
- 21:19is just taking it too far. Yeah, you got to stop. This
- 21:22is still not okay. I thought I came back. It's back in In
- 21:27the documentary. Getting back to the documentary, the mother said that Amy was
- 21:32very defiant as a child, but she was kind of a whish. She
- 21:33didn't this upon her, and the mom was a whish, she says she
- 21:37She literally says this in the documentary. I wasn't strong enough to say no
- 21:41to her. And Amy told her about her bolimia, and she's just like,
- 21:45I didn't think it really meant anything, right, what right? She?
- 21:48So Amy goes to her mother at the age of fifteen or something and
- 21:53says, oh, I found a new way to diet. I vomit everything
- 21:56out and the mom didn't do anything. Amy was to her dad says it
- 22:00to I mean, talk about a cry for help. Yeah, And her
- 22:04mom was certified, right, she was a certified parent, right, she
- 22:07had gone through the training. Yeah, she should have known. I guess
- 22:11My sarcastic point is, you know, how do people know what to do
- 22:15with teenagers? Okay, but there is a point where you're just like,
- 22:18hey, mom, I've been taking the knives out and slicing it against my
- 22:21skin to see if I bleed. Okay, I mean there's something you don't
- 22:23have to freaking learn in parenting school for kids puking up every meal to diet.
- 22:27That's crazy. It's not like it's in some third world country. But
- 22:30what year? What what you're talking? We're talking internet time of nineteen ninety
- 22:36eight, ninety eight, not internet time for a lot of people though in
- 22:40England. No, No internet time starts like in two thousand and and for
- 22:44me, I started. She should have known by then. All through the
- 22:47eighties people had Bolivia was she. I never knew about it about Bulimia till
- 22:52I was in high school and there was a beliemic and she was in he
- 22:55exic, And then even then I was like, oh, and no one
- 22:57knew what to do or how to relate to her. It doesn't seem like
- 23:00anyone ever said anything. No. I agree. I agree that it's hard
- 23:03to look back in time and judge someone because it's hard to remember what it
- 23:07was like that. I mean, it was a lot less culturally known that
- 23:12you're supposed to respond to that. Having said that the way that she said,
- 23:18she responded with basically indifference, you know what I mean. It's not
- 23:22like she said, well I asked a friend about it, or well I
- 23:26went to Amy and I said, hey, I don't know if this is
- 23:29a good thing. And you know, she literally the story is she tells
- 23:33her parents, and her parents do nothing. Now granted, one caveat is
- 23:38that's one quote they put in the documentary. It's a lifetime. Maybe it
- 23:42wouldn't be so annoying if it wasn't like then there were ten other similar situations
- 23:48which they were equally as negligent. You know, it's like the whole mom
- 23:52is just makes me crazy. Yeah, well the dad too. Dad,
- 23:55you could even argue, is more immoral by literally not even being there.
- 24:00He looks so bad in that movie. And okay, so clearly she was
- 24:04crying out for help. She wanted. Amy even said, there's you know,
- 24:07interviews with her in the documentary saying that she needed discipline back then and
- 24:12her dad was never there and this is a this I can't even okay,
- 24:15I'm just gonna kind of cut to the chase. I can't tell you how
- 24:18quintessential, how typical, how cliche Amy's life was really, even with how
- 24:26her everyone around her was well, she was mega famous, which was very
- 24:30you know, rare. But to me, after I kind of digested the
- 24:36entire story and documentary, if I just get rid of all of the fame,
- 24:40it's so mundane the story. This stuff happens every day and it always
- 24:45looks the same or not always. But this is such I mean, parents
- 24:49separate, they break up, very common parents. Dad disappears, Dad doesn't
- 24:55pay enough attention. Girl daughter feels neglected once dad's attention starts to rebel,
- 25:00feels depressed. Mom is also stressed out, can't pay attention to her children.
- 25:07Daughter develops eating disorder and acts out, sexually, acts out, sexually,
- 25:11starts to you know, as a cry out for help, gets a
- 25:15tattoo early in life. I have to say I had the same feeling when
- 25:19I was driving away from the movie. I thought to myself, if this
- 25:23were a fiction, Like, let's say this was a fictional movie and it
- 25:26wasn't a documentary if it was just like I swear, I would have felt
- 25:30halfway through it, like Jesus, you're just like writing the book into a
- 25:34movie. That's it, Like you know, like they're going page by page
- 25:37from the psychiatric manual or something. Because it seemed too contrived, even down
- 25:42to the song choices and the lyrics. And she's like, I'm paraphrasing,
- 25:47but she's like, I'm well aware of my contradictions, but I still have
- 25:51them and I can't do anything about them. She even mentions, she even
- 25:55mentions Freud. Yeah. So then let's skip to nineteen ninety nine, a
- 25:59year later, or she's she's fifteen, and again this is this is where
- 26:03she starts talking about Bolimia. And I was just wondering what you guys think.
- 26:08Why would you think the parents would not take this seriously? Aside from
- 26:12them just being ignorant, but in general, why would the parents not pay
- 26:18attention to their daughter. I think it's denial. Why would they Why would
- 26:22they be in denial? Because no one wants to think that they're not doing
- 26:26a good job as a parent or their child is coming up a little crooked.
- 26:30If they believed that and had to accept that what would that mean and
- 26:34why would they want to avoid that? That would mean that they were bad
- 26:38parents and that kind of failed in this huge undertaking, and they would have
- 26:41to face that that possibility. Yeah, so it's easier to deny and say
- 26:47it's not happening. It's not happening. This's why I'm scared to have kids,
- 26:49so scary. Well, I don't know if if it implies that they
- 26:53would have bought a ticket to Egypt, but what I do know is that
- 26:57they they were very much much in the from what you get from the documentary,
- 27:02So I don't know if this was all real or not, especially the
- 27:03dad, Like I mean, there was that obvious scene where they're like,
- 27:07hey, we tried to literally we tried to get her to go to rehab,
- 27:10and the dad said no, and he has she has it in her
- 27:11lyrics. The dad admits it. He's like, I don't think she needed
- 27:15rehab, et cetera. I mean Jesus, like you know, and and
- 27:18like they said, maybe it wouldn't have saved her, but he was clearly
- 27:22in denial, right, and he was clearly not helping her, right.
- 27:26So here's what they didn't go into that I wish they would. That is
- 27:30more in my world, which is what are the parents' childhoods? Like?
- 27:34What was their upbringing like? Because I wouldn't be surprised if their own families
- 27:41had addiction and denial and neglect. They hinted at the mom. Remember they
- 27:47said the father's mom was more of a mom to Amy's mom, right than
- 27:52I know. That's confusing, but because because she said, my mom was
- 27:56never there for me and the grandma was there. Yeah. So a question
- 28:00like if a family has a history of drug abuse and alcohol abuse, how
- 28:04should you be how should you be talking to preteens about that? You know,
- 28:08Like I feel like you don't find that out until you're in your twenties
- 28:12and it's like, oh, yeah, by the way, I have a
- 28:14history of alcoholism, and then you're like, hmmm, am I okay?
- 28:17Like I you know, I know people who would get clean themselves and then
- 28:22would tell their kids, you know, from a fairly early age, maybe
- 28:26fourteen fifteen that, by the way, in our family, genetically is the
- 28:33predisposition toward addiction. And if you start drinking or using cigarettes or something else,
- 28:38you have a much higher likelihood of getting hooked than other people. Do,
- 28:41and so you should be you know, you should be really careful about
- 28:45that. Yeah, I wonder do you know any status? Because I remember
- 28:48even maybe a tougher bluff we did where it was something like if children of
- 28:52parents that admit to drug use are in fact more likely to try the drugs
- 28:57because maybe subconsciously they end up thinking, well, he survived or she survived
- 29:02something like that, right, I forget, I mean, And of course
- 29:04those kinds of studies are difficult to determine exactly what they mean, and they're
- 29:10funded by the DEA. But but I'm sure that research has found that if
- 29:15your I mean, well, the main thing is is to protect children from
- 29:19addiction is secure attachments and good upbringing that is stable and loving. If because
- 29:26the whole the whole other time I was thinking throughout the documentary was I was
- 29:30thinking, who is going to love Amy for who she is? And will
- 29:33she stop long enough to allow herself to be loved by somebody. I think
- 29:37it was probably the guy that left her and then got back with her once
- 29:41she was really famous. That guy seemed legit. I was like, oh,
- 29:47yeah, one thing that that occurred to me during that sequence when they
- 29:49were first talking about how she got into drugs. Is growing up, all
- 29:53I heard was that drugs are terrible for you. Right, But I think
- 29:57there's a bug in how it's percented because the impression that I remember getting and
- 30:03I think is percented, is you so much as taste one drug and you're
- 30:08basically dead. Well, that screw you up. That was the eighties and
- 30:12nineties. Yeah, and I don't know. Maybe maybe it's a lot better
- 30:15now, but it's probably not. But so so here's what I think happens
- 30:19with some people. I've seen it around my circles in the last twenty years.
- 30:26It's, hey, what but these people do it seemingly every weekend and
- 30:30they seem fine, so maybe this is all bs. And then then they
- 30:33actually rebel against the standard. It's like, you know what, this is
- 30:37all bullshit. Drugs are more than okay, blah blah blah blah, and
- 30:40then they don't realize when they get hooked, and then they actually get addicted
- 30:42in blub blah. Right. Well, it's it's the same with food.
- 30:45Our relationship with food and exercise, it's it's a very complex thing, you
- 30:51know what I mean. I mean, simply put, don't eat as many
- 30:53calories and exercise a lot of calories off. It's simple idea, right,
- 30:59how come so many intelligent Americans struggle with that all the time. It's so
- 31:03ridiculous though, Like just today a residents like you don't have to drink eight
- 31:07glasses of water a day. I'm like, it's a billion different notions and
- 31:12behaviors. The same with substance use. If you're going to use substances,
- 31:17the navigation of how to use it with the least amount of consequences is a
- 31:25billion different decisions and notions. And so you as parents can help that with
- 31:30children, you know, the way I presented it, just that one idea
- 31:34when I said, as a parent, it's like what you say, if
- 31:37you start using, you might you have a greater likelihood of becoming hooked on
- 31:41it. Right, That's not I didn't say if you use once, you
- 31:45will become like, come, this is weed and this is heroin and meth.
- 31:49They're different things, you know. Like I think that's part of the
- 31:53problems, are like everything's lumped together. And I think especially now, it's
- 31:56so much more accepted. Like you look at a Rihana video, It's like,
- 32:00oh, roan is like smoking a bong and a video and you're just
- 32:01like, okay, Like it's becoming so much more normalized, and you're like,
- 32:05but still not meth or heroin everyone. Well, but and alcohol is
- 32:09even more accepted totally, and and all of those things can be just as
- 32:15destructive as people's And it's and again, it's not that you drink, it's
- 32:20when do you drink. How do you drink? Do you drink to escape
- 32:22all of your problems all of the time? Do you allow yourself, you
- 32:28know, to feel feelings without turning to substances to modify it? Yeah,
- 32:32I mean I think it's totally final. Like smoke and drink if you want
- 32:36to every now and then. But I think that especially with smoking, it
- 32:37can become like, oh, if you were doing if you're drinking alcohol at
- 32:42the same rate, you'd be like, oh, there's a problem, right,
- 32:45you know, right, And if you're high all the time, which
- 32:46plenty of people are, then something like five percent of Americans smoke every day.
- 32:52Nearly all of the people that live in the Himalayas are high all the
- 32:57time. God, what a fantastic joke. Getting back to the timeline,
- 33:01year two thousand, the year two Oh you got it, the one joke
- 33:07we all get. Age seventeen, she starts getting recognition as a serious singer.
- 33:13For example, she was the featured vocalist for the National Youth Jazz Jazz
- 33:17Orchestra in Britain Sea. I would like to know that. That's what I'm
- 33:22talking about. Yeah, skipping ahead two thousand and one, she's eighteen.
- 33:24She meets Nick, who is in the movie quite a bit as a positive
- 33:29force in her life. Yeah, he's the talent scout and a good friend.
- 33:35We see a video of her playing a light blue strat. Did you
- 33:37notice that? Or a strat knockoff of some kind? Did you notice that
- 33:40she played a lot of strats? I didn't actually pay attention to that.
- 33:44Oh my god, how can you not pay attention? I had a light
- 33:46blue strat knockoff, and when I saw her playing strats, I was so
- 33:52happy because strats are my favorite guitar, but they're also the nerdiest guitar.
- 33:55Like, no one ever plays strats, Like all the cool kids. The
- 34:00only musicians you don't get laid play stratt. Yeah. Only real Nashville guitars
- 34:05play stratt. Yeah, and Eric Clapton and Stevie Ray Vaughan and just the
- 34:08Jimmy Jimmy Hendricks, all those guys play strats. But for whatever reason,
- 34:13if you're caught with a strat past nineteen eighty eight, you're this big nerd,
- 34:17especially in Seattle. You gotta play jazz Master. You got to play
- 34:21the Jaguar, you gotta you gotta play the les Paul, you gotta play
- 34:23the sg You cannot have a Fender stratocaster, but I know you do,
- 34:30and I do too. You do, I have, I have. I've
- 34:32owned several strats and several strat knockoffs, and when I saw her playing that
- 34:37strat, I was I was so happy to see it. Do you have
- 34:40the Advanced D and D Edition? I played D and D. I still
- 34:44played D and D. In fact, one of my favorite podcasts about D
- 34:46and D called The Adventure Zone. If you're out there listening, Okay,
- 34:52he's taking ladies, he's taking Wow. I was paying more attention to her
- 34:57wardrobe choices, So that's why I missed the strat choice. Its interesting.
- 35:00I also liked that they showed her playing gigs to no one. Since Berto,
- 35:06you and I are musicians, we know that very well. Playing gigs
- 35:09to no one in clubs? What does that feel like? I came to
- 35:14a show. Okay, so I've had gigs to no one. Berto said,
- 35:16gigs and no one. But there was this one show a few months
- 35:20ago where Berto's band played. Where usually when you say gigs to no one,
- 35:23there's usually like a bartender or like the other band might be in the
- 35:28back corner. There's usually at least a smattering of people. It's every literally
- 35:32to no one. Well, this one show and I went to Burtos,
- 35:36there was literally no one except for me in the entire room. In the
- 35:42entire room, the bar was actually in a different room, and so it
- 35:45was Berto's band and me for the first eight out of ten songs, just
- 35:52me. That's because you misunderstood what was happening. It was a love proposal
- 35:55from us to you. We didn't invite anyone else. It was just an
- 36:00Onion article that said author gives her all, whether reading to a group of
- 36:04three or a crowd of nine. It's like, oh god, it's so
- 36:07true. I still love those events though I don't know. No, it
- 36:12was a fun night. That's how art starts. It's so crazy. It
- 36:15starts so small. Even when you make it so big. I gotta be
- 36:17honest. I'm a pretty selfish person. So when I'm playing and I suppose
- 36:23this is how it should be, I actually just enjoy playing. So even
- 36:27when we jam, unless I have a cold or something, I really just
- 36:30enjoy it. Oh yeah, and I always just pretend like I'm playing to
- 36:34a stadium. It just doesn't you know. Well, I'm the same way,
- 36:36except they don't pretend I'm playing to a stadium. I like to play
- 36:40in that way so much that I actually don't like to play gigs because playing
- 36:45gigs means I have to haul everything around, and I can get just the
- 36:49same satisfaction playing in our practice space by ourselves and have that inner piece,
- 36:52you know. So I actually hate gigs, as you know, Berto,
- 36:57but then you don't make the big books. Yeah, okay, So interesting
- 37:00observations that I had are things that I noted from the documentary right away is
- 37:06that she had a very classic voice. She kind of had a Billie Holiday
- 37:09ish kind of situation. Even I mean, she got the highest compliment from
- 37:14mister Tony Bennett, right Yeah. He was like, oh, she's like
- 37:16up there with these other ella and all these guys. That was awesome.
- 37:22Personally, I would not put her even close to Ella Fitzgerald. Very few
- 37:27people can get up that high in my mind. I don't know if he
- 37:29did he say, I don't know who he said. He said some people,
- 37:30Yeah, he named names. Also, she wrote her own music,
- 37:35which was amazing, amazing and great lyrics. Actually yeah, but by the
- 37:38way, so remember how at the beginning we said what we thought about her
- 37:42before having heard the movie. Now I'm actually really interested in getting some of
- 37:46her early stuff, especially because and this is so tragic, and they kind
- 37:51of called it out in the movie. The song Rehab does not at all
- 37:55showcase her talent. It's a great catchy song. I never liked it that
- 38:00much, partially because I felt guilty of the fact that that might actually be
- 38:04a real story. Yeah, you're like, I love this, like you're
- 38:08saying. But what I will say is some of those songs she was playing,
- 38:13I was super impressed with the lyrics. The melodies were so interesting and
- 38:17complex, and I'm gonna absolutely like, uh use the iTunes of music thingy
- 38:23to get her, all right. I think my Tears Dry on their own
- 38:27and Love is a Losing Game are like two great songs and tears are on
- 38:30their own is a little more up, and love is a losing game is
- 38:32like super slow and nice and amazing. But I mean, she doesn't have
- 38:37that much music, so it's not that hard to listen to everything she had
- 38:38because that third album was like just kept getting pushed back farther and farther.
- 38:43Yeah. Another thing that was pointed out that I want to remind people of
- 38:49is that her friend Nick said that she had a way of making people feel
- 38:52very important and then very unimportant. And this is something to a lot in
- 38:57therapy, and it's something that I see a lot personally. Is this this
- 39:01way? You know? I don't know if you've had a friend like this.
- 39:05I just realized I'm totally writing a character that does exactly that. So
- 39:08I want to I want to hear how we think she does that so I
- 39:10can steal that. Yeah, it's essentially a minor borderline is what we might
- 39:15call it. But essentially it's a it's a way of seeing other people in
- 39:22a way of coping with closeness. It's also a I don't want to get
- 39:28too technical, projective identification that that they're recreating. Essentially, what happened was
- 39:31she was growing up, and she's a little girl, and she really wants
- 39:36to be important and loved and paid attention to and cared about and held and
- 39:42safe. And she didn't have that too close to home, right, She
- 39:45felt unimportant, she felt uncared for, she felt a drift, you know,
- 39:52uh. And and what that creates is this in this inner conflict between
- 40:00wanting other people to be close to her, because she's even more desperate than
- 40:07the average person for someone to be close to her, but she also is
- 40:10extremely afraid of getting close to someone because that opens her up to vulnerability and
- 40:15being rejected by someone that she depends on. So when you're interacting with her,
- 40:22at first, she'll pull you in because she wants someone to she's desperate
- 40:25for closeness. She really wants you to get close because she's so needy of
- 40:31closeness. But at the same time, she's really afraid of it, and
- 40:36she'll push you away and make you feel off kilter. Why do people get
- 40:40afraid of it though they want it so much? Because to open yourself up
- 40:45to dependency opens yourself up to rejection. And if you are the one to
- 40:51reject, then you will not get rejected. If it's you defining the landscape.
- 40:57I that person didn't reject me. I rejected them first. And people
- 41:00with these with this sort of upbringing will do this literally to everyone around them.
- 41:05And Nick was talking about that, and she talks she almost says that
- 41:08in her songs, at least one of them that she was playing, where
- 41:13the lyrics were something along the lines of like I had to take the step
- 41:16to end it or to whatever item, totally like butchering it. But but
- 41:21it was about her and Blake or whatever his name is, and it's that
- 41:24kind of thing like, well, yeah, I had to make sure that
- 41:27I was the one to like stop this or whatever. So is that always
- 41:30just a neglector can it be from other things too? Yeah, it's basically
- 41:35betrayal, it's basically rejection. It's it's basically not being cared about, and
- 41:39that there's many roads to that result. Okay, I think if that's just
- 41:44what I have going, I'm excited about that. You could be abused,
- 41:46you could be neglected, you could you could have someone die, you could
- 41:51I mean anything that compromises that needed attention that children need from both of their
- 41:55parents. I think that works with the plot that I have going I'm excited
- 41:59about that. So hard to write fiction, so I can I can so
- 42:02identify with that from the so like, uh, you know, my mom
- 42:06exited my life day to day when I was about three, and I she
- 42:12stayed in my life right now, that's right the way she's you're reabusing me.
- 42:15What's the what's the thing that you call out when someone is retraumatizing you?
- 42:21Trigger warninggger warning, trigger warning. Paulette got up to get a glass
- 42:27of water just as Bruno started talking, because she was about abandonment issues.
- 42:31No, but basically, so you know, she she leaves my my dad
- 42:36and I and so I I developed a that kind of push pull with women,
- 42:40you know, the idea that I desperately want that attention, but I
- 42:45will also end it at the first sign of trouble or or do something to
- 42:50end it because or do nothing to end it, but by doing nothing ending
- 42:53it. And I had that repeatedly with you know, looking back with several
- 42:59early relationships where it was like, oh, oh, this one's about to
- 43:02this one's about to hurt me, No no, no, I'm done,
- 43:05or oh you meant, or this one's going really well, I'm going to
- 43:07not call her at all, or take her calls again. Yeah, like
- 43:12really ridiculous behaviors of either complete preemptive strike or like avoid or feeling at unease
- 43:21when something's actually going well and you know, right, and I feel that's
- 43:23that feeling. It's like, wait, things are going well, why do
- 43:28I feel uneasy? Well, that's because that person now can hurt you if
- 43:31they call you up and break up with you. You have another example of
- 43:37being rejected. I feel like adulthood is always just this extreme reaction to childhood.
- 43:42It's just like whatever happens in your childhood, you're just like, it's
- 43:45crazy. Everyone, it's so hard. And you're like, oh, I
- 43:47know, I'm like this because of this, and yet and you're like,
- 43:50well, I'm still like that. So I don't know that it's almos like
- 43:53you should have a little reset button by the time you hit eighteen. Oh
- 43:58my god, Yeah, I know. And I try to keep thinking that
- 44:00I can change, but I'm like, I'm thirty three, and at some
- 44:04point evolution is just like, well, you're old enough, you probably have
- 44:07kids, you don't have to learn anymore change where you're just like setting your
- 44:08ways. But I keep I don't know. It's like trying to change or
- 44:13just accept whoever the hell you are. Yeah, evolution, like you're saying
- 44:15evolutions Like, wait, you're still trying. Yeah, you can die now
- 44:19if you want. Yeah, go ahead. We're kind of gotter with your
- 44:22purpose. So some other things about amy is that you might turn to sex
- 44:28in order to modify and modulate this as well. Wait, I'm sorry,
- 44:31what sex from modifying modulating? Because because when you when you modulate a man's
- 44:39nether regions to deflatter. Yeah, when when you when you are desperate for
- 44:49closeness and security, a very quick road to getting pseudo closeness and pseudo security
- 44:59is through sex. We know this. Yeah, if you Bardo really knows
- 45:02this. If you become if you become very sexual and very seductive, men
- 45:09and your hetero men will respond to that, and you will feel sought after,
- 45:15and you will feel like people love you, and you will feel like
- 45:19you have closeness. But at the same time, you're setting yourself up for
- 45:22feeling like you're just a piece of meat and your only worth is your sexuality
- 45:30and your body, which ultimately is rejecting even if the man actually does have
- 45:35feelings for you, because you'll always wonder is it just because of the sex
- 45:39that he loves me or is it something else. Let's do an offshoot podcast
- 45:44for middle school girls. Let's tell him how life works. Having said that,
- 45:49in two weeks, I'm going up into the mountains for a camp and
- 45:52I'm going to talk about sex head to children. You've done that before,
- 45:55and I've done it before, and I'm going to do it again. You
- 45:58can't stop me. It sounds terrible, but it's a good thing. You
- 46:02would have gotten away with it too if it weren't for those meddling kids.
- 46:07So so there's that. The other thing is is a way of getting friends.
- 46:13A way of getting closeness and getting camaraderie is through sneaking off behind the
- 46:19bushes and smoking weed. If you are desperate for closeness and for security and
- 46:24love and attention and a group of people that you can depend on, then
- 46:29especially with marijuana because it's sort of low grade illegal and you have to do
- 46:32it away from a crowd that if you get with the weed smokers, you
- 46:37instantly have a little group of loyal friends that you need. You depend on
- 46:44each other because of the law and because of the teachers and your parents,
- 46:47nagan way too close at home, and so it's a and cigarettes can be
- 46:52this way too. It's like it's a it's a quick way. It's it's
- 46:54a quick way to get a you know, a group of friends. Is
- 46:58that what happened to you? Yeah, you know, I was thinking about
- 47:00So I went to college two months after my dad died in an accident seventeen,
- 47:06and I mean it was just bad, you know, it was just
- 47:09so bad. And I went to one of these schools that, like some
- 47:12years is ranked as the number one party school in the nation. So I'm
- 47:15what's school? University of Florida, Oh, Florida. Oh. I seriously,
- 47:20like I was in shock even until, like I think a month after
- 47:23I arrived it hit me and it was like the worst year of my life.
- 47:28So I think after that, you know, you kind of are just
- 47:30like you feel like such an outsider that you want to feel like an insider
- 47:34again. And I'd had this funny experience when I was seventeen where I was
- 47:37already had been drinking and smoked weed for the first time and puked everywhere,
- 47:42So I hadn't tried it again until years later, and that was definitely you
- 47:46know, You're like, you just feel like your little group is like the
- 47:50bad kids, and you just like the bad kids because everyone's like funny and
- 47:53crazy and smart and bad and those are my kind of people. Right,
- 47:57It's not like they aren't good friends. But it can be. And actually
- 48:00it could be even a good thing, you know, it's like, oh,
- 48:04we have this thing together. I can depend on you people to smoke
- 48:07weed with me behind the bushes. But it can also be a bad thing
- 48:09because it locks you into particular people. It's also dependent on substances in order
- 48:15to get closeness. It's not, you know, closeness for closeness sake,
- 48:19it's it's all around substances. So substances become your way of loving and get
- 48:24love and getting love from other people. And right from the beginning, you
- 48:29can see her very much addicted to weed. You know, she she she
- 48:32on the home video. She you know, she talks about smoking weed all
- 48:37the time. And right, so, another another thing about weed is that
- 48:39it will modulate your feelings of depression and rejection. Will you define modulate for
- 48:46me? I think I know what it means. It'll change, it'll it'll
- 48:49mitigate, it will admitigate, probably means to change for the better. Mitigate
- 48:52means to lessen through some agent. And so through the agent of marijuana,
- 49:00you become less distressed, you become less hurt, you become less connected to
- 49:07the world, you become more euphoric, you become you know, all those
- 49:13things. You become more numb. And so right away, she's using marijuana
- 49:17from an early age. Probably now what people say is like, oh,
- 49:21she's just a juggie, she likes to get high. But you know,
- 49:24she had several moments where throughout the documentary where clearly she knew it was a
- 49:30bad idea for her to use right well, and she was also on quote
- 49:32unquote legal drugs. She mentioned she was on air zipan or something. And
- 49:37I want to say that I think labeling on any level is destructive or just
- 49:44not the way to connect with people. And what I love about people's stories,
- 49:47especially when people tell their own stories, is I always say, like,
- 49:50no label survives story. If you hear someone's story, you're just like,
- 49:53oh, you know, because everyone really is a human being and we're
- 49:58all born in these totally different circumstances, so you never know what someone else
- 50:01is going through. There's a lot of this going on right now with that
- 50:05Ashley Madison leak, and people are just like, you don't know what my
- 50:07situation was. You know, my husband stopped having sex with me twenty years
- 50:10ago or something like that. So I don't know. I think that totally.
- 50:15That's what documentaries can do. Yeah, for a person. Yeah,
- 50:17the Ashley Madison thing, I was thinking the same thing. It's like,
- 50:21one you don't know, Yeah, you don't know where they were. I'm
- 50:24pretty sure you can be on Ashley Madison and not be cheating on someone.
- 50:29They release stats and they higher percentage were single people. Yeah, so there's
- 50:34that and also like, yeah, like you're saying, maybe they just got
- 50:38they just found out they were being cheated on, and on an impulse,
- 50:42they went on the site because they're like I'm going to get back at my
- 50:45spouse or something, or they decided to cheat. But so what they're like,
- 50:49you're saying, that's one thing in their life. That's one aspect of
- 50:52a very rich, complete life. I mean, I suppose at some point
- 50:55you have to draw a line when you say, hey, this person murdered
- 50:58three people on purpose. Oh well, I guess we can call him member.
- 51:00Yeah, if there's an Ashley Madison for that, then less shame those
- 51:06people. But since our country is so backward when it comes to sex and
- 51:09moralizing, this is just like right up our alley. And I'd say,
- 51:14like, maybe I'm wrong, but if she had never if she had always
- 51:19just done the pot, she might have been Okay, totally might have been.
- 51:23I mean, well, drinking is what killed her, right, drinking
- 51:25in Bolimia, well, drinking bliven heavy, heavy excess of crack cocaine.
- 51:31What's it called heroin cocaine? Probably other stuff, probably math, like who
- 51:37knows, right, Yeah, So did you guys read the Rolling Stone article
- 51:42during the It sounded like the height of her drug use. It was crazy.
- 51:45This Rolling Stone reporter was in her house all night long and it just
- 51:49kept saying how she just kept disappearing and coming back, and it was really
- 51:52really crazy. It was like she wasn't even trying to hide it, almost
- 51:55her. It was just too out of control. Everyone knew or she was
- 52:00crying out for help. Yeah. Well, and we'll get to that in
- 52:01a second two because there's some there's some interesting things that were revealed in the
- 52:06documentary along those signes. But just kind of getting back to my early impressions,
- 52:09her singing style was very The word that I thought of was was she
- 52:15attacked the songs like she did not hold back, you know, she even
- 52:20when she was just kind of messing around, she just belted out these songs,
- 52:24you know, just this big voice would just come boom, you know,
- 52:28right out of her. Yeah, And it was very unexpected what she
- 52:31did in those attacks, because remember when she's singing the duet with Tony Bennett,
- 52:35and it's early in the in the scene when she's feeling insecure about what
- 52:38she's doing. But even right off the bat, you know, they showed
- 52:40Tony Bennett doing his oh no no da very nice, and all of a
- 52:44sudden, it's her turn, and I'm not sure what I'm expecting, but
- 52:46what she does is probably the last thing I expect her to do. Both
- 52:52in the melodies she sings, the way she sings it, the way she
- 52:54pronounces the words, it's so interesting. And that was her bad version,
- 52:58right, yeah, it's crazy. Yeah, that scene was particularly painful because
- 53:01she was really intoxicated when she was singing that duet with him, right,
- 53:06no, no, no, not that one. I don't think she was
- 53:07very intoxicated. She was just coming off from probably a bender and blow up,
- 53:13but she was she seems sober. It's just that she was very insecure
- 53:15and it took her a lot of takes to get it right. But Tony,
- 53:20everything he was saying was very encouraging and it's obvious that she finally got
- 53:23an amazing take. So just kind of racing through her history. Twenty two,
- 53:28aged nineteen, she gets signed with a management company, so she's very
- 53:30young, and she was paid two hundred fifty pounds a week, which is
- 53:35about three hundred dollars a week or something, and she was it's like four
- 53:39hundred yeah, So that's a lot of money for a nineteen year old,
- 53:44right, And she was a regular singer at a jazz club and apparently the
- 53:46music industry. People in the music industry were fighting over her at the time,
- 53:51island Emi and Virgin and other people, which is kind of weird.
- 53:53It's like fighting over this jazzy singer, you know, But apparently they were
- 53:58looking for someone in response to the plastic pop stars of two thousand and three.
- 54:02You know, who are you listening to in two thousand and three?
- 54:05Oh got okay? So that was I was a junior in college, a
- 54:08lot of Tom Petty, Flaming Lips, Radiohead, all those really plastic fake
- 54:15people. I was really plastic. I'm going right. I have great music
- 54:19snab friends, so I learned a lot my boyfriend who were the big plasticky
- 54:22people in that of that time. Oh god, well, I worked in
- 54:24a skating rink in like nineteen ninety seven nineteen ninety eight, so I can
- 54:29tell you every single freaking pop shit from then, which was like so Spice
- 54:35girls were going on, Britney Spears, christneaguilera terrible I don't know who was
- 54:38poppy later like two thousand and three, I don't know. I tried to
- 54:42ignore that stuff at that time. I loved it when she was talking about
- 54:45how she was super angry at her producers for putting fake strings on her first
- 54:51album, Frank, because I just love it that from right from the beginning,
- 54:55She's just like, do not put fake shit on my on my homeungs,
- 55:00you know, because that's such an easy thing to do. It's like,
- 55:01oh, we need some strings here. Well, I have a whole
- 55:04bank of fake strings that sound really good that no one will be able to
- 55:07tell. Let me put some fake strings on here, and she was really
- 55:10angry at them and like yelled at them, right, and she had no
- 55:14problem just yelling at her label saying like, you fucked me on that song.
- 55:17And when people interviewed her about that album, she was like, I'm
- 55:22really only about eighty percent behind that album because of what they did to that
- 55:25song. I mean, she was she was vocal about how her label,
- 55:30even though it was her first album and she's nineteen, where most people will
- 55:32be totally kissing the ass of their label, she was like already rebelling.
- 55:37And this is actually what went through my mind through that scene, the scene
- 55:42where she's being interviewed and the one Gala is psychoanalyzing Dido or some other female
- 55:47singer of the time, and Amy's like like clearly like cleaning her lips and
- 55:53her teeth and kind of like uh huh ah uh huh, like you know,
- 55:58obviously bothered by the person. But but so I got two ideas in
- 56:01my head. One of them was like, well, that's kind of the
- 56:06this is kind of the push pull with some of these people. That it
- 56:08is that uncompromising weirdness that probably gave her some of her a great edge,
- 56:14but it is also kind of a symptom of some of her personality issues,
- 56:17do you know what I mean, Like the inability to stay focused, the
- 56:22inability to relate at a more quote unquote normal level. I mean all artists
- 56:27talk about that a lot. It's a big theme in art where is the
- 56:30crazy related to the creativity? And Ellen Fourney has a really great graphic memoir
- 56:37called Marbles I think I've talked about on here before that addresses that. And
- 56:40it's either a definitely patterns you know where you're just like, yeah, definitely,
- 56:45you know, it's something that artists know about. Yeah, I agree
- 56:50with that. And I think that if she wasn't an artist, she would
- 56:53have had that disposition as well, or that personality totally and probably would have
- 56:58had a hard time working place right because she, like I said, was
- 57:02just so cliche as a client of a what we call a polys substance addict,
- 57:07someone who isn't like a like just an alcoholic or just the heroin addict.
- 57:13You could tell that she would put anything in her, anything that was
- 57:17around. She wanted to put every substance in her possible, and she she
- 57:22just she wanted to be not sober, like there was that the The one
- 57:28line in the documentary that just killed me was she just wins a Grammy,
- 57:32yeh. And you know, you can see her face and she's so humble,
- 57:36you know, she's just like, oh my god, I won,
- 57:38and she's hugging her. It is like the pinnacle, you know, and
- 57:42she seems sober, and you're just like you're so happy for her, you
- 57:45know, and you're just thinking, oh my god, you know. And
- 57:47then and while I'm watching it, I'm like, oh, she wasn't fucked
- 57:51up all the time. She was just fucked up some of the time.
- 57:53And so it's like it's nice to see her like sober and clearer eyed.
- 57:57And and then her best friend says, yeah, so I'm crying in the
- 58:01front row because she won the Grammy and I'm so happy for her. And
- 58:05then she grabs me and brings me backstage and says, I can't remember the
- 58:09exact line. This is so boring. Without drawing, she says, this
- 58:14is all so boring, Like she it wasn't just even that moment. It's
- 58:17like like the implication was that like the pinnacle of her success. I mean,
- 58:23granted she kind of but you know, you're a musician if you win
- 58:27a Grammy presented by Tony Bennett, your idol, Right yeah, Like that's
- 58:31kind of a pinnacle of your success at some point, right yeah, And
- 58:35that's nothing to her, right. And this is the tragedy of people like
- 58:38this that I found, is that they're so obsessed on being high and and
- 58:45the process of getting high on anything that they can't enjoy anything else, even
- 58:52a success like that where you have won a Grammy for the Best Record of
- 58:55the Year and you are the best musician of the world in that moment,
- 59:00and all you can think about is the fact that all of this is so
- 59:05boring without substances. But on the flip side, they could already be the
- 59:08kind of person that can't enjoy anything, and that's why they started using drugs,
- 59:13right, you know, totally, And I think that's true. And
- 59:16the more you use, the harder it is to enjoy life without using,
- 59:21you know what I mean. People who will quit substances will say that for
- 59:25at least a year, everything is so boring until they learn how to enjoy
- 59:31life again. But you'll talk to people that are thirty years sober and say,
- 59:36yeah, life was a lot more exciting when I use substances, and
- 59:39the past thirty years has been somewhat boring. But I would be dead if
- 59:45I kept that exciting life up the way that Amy Wine has to. And
- 59:50that's where the sad really hits, which is, oh, I see,
- 59:53like you're saying, it's just one of those stories, so common, and
- 59:55yet it's only in this big flashlight, light limelight. This story happens all
- 1:00:02the time. And one of the reasons why this one just seems particularly interesting,
- 1:00:07not only is because she famous, but she couldn't escape the cameras.
- 1:00:10If the other addicts in Seattle had cameras around them all the time like she
- 1:00:15did, we would see the same thing, but none of us see it.
- 1:00:17Because addicts are very good at hiding their life from other people. They
- 1:00:22become very good, very good at putting on a face that everything is okay.
- 1:00:29Oh. And speaking of that, like she there's that segment of the
- 1:00:32documentary where she's in that island or something, and the implication seemed to be
- 1:00:37that she was drinking very heavily but the other drugs had subsided, which is
- 1:00:42not necessarily great, but hey, maybe that's an inroads to something. But
- 1:00:45her dad shows up with cameras, So it's like she might have had a
- 1:00:50chance to maybe do something, but her dad shows up with cameras. I
- 1:00:53disagree that was the story they were trying to tell. The story was.
- 1:00:58The story was she gets this Saint Lucia, and she's totally happy and everything's
- 1:01:02great. She's she's got away from the big city and she's not taking drugs
- 1:01:07anymore, she's drinking more. But the dad shows up and ruins everything with
- 1:01:12the cameras and and they have this little scene where Dad's yelling at her for
- 1:01:16not like pleasing a fan or something and not being better on camera, which
- 1:01:22was actually kind of interesting. It's like Jesus, Dad, like, stop
- 1:01:24exploiting your daughter. Jimmy says Jimmy Creek. Yeah, and it's a reality
- 1:01:30show, but yeah, but the what I saw was I mean, anyone
- 1:01:34who knows anything about addicts will say that she was not any better than she
- 1:01:38was when she was in London. Probably, yeah, But the only the
- 1:01:43only thing that would have been better, and she was never better throughout the
- 1:01:45entire The only thing that would have been better was I have a massive problem.
- 1:01:52I need lots of help. I need to get rid of all my
- 1:01:55friends. I need to go to meetings every day. I need to stop
- 1:02:00touring. I need to stop hanging out with men because they trigger me.
- 1:02:04I need to work on my bolimia. I need to be in therapy every
- 1:02:07few days. Anything short of that is not recovery. And so when they
- 1:02:12were trying to portray that, it's like, oh, she was doing so
- 1:02:15well, Oh she was drinking more. Maybe that was a problem. Yes,
- 1:02:17that was a problem. The only reason why she wasn't drugging was because
- 1:02:21she's in another country and she probably couldn't smuggle them in. Well, they
- 1:02:23did say, I guess, to be fair to them, they actually the
- 1:02:27quote from the dude was like, but when you have access to a free
- 1:02:30bar, then she just started drinking more than ever. Yeah, I think
- 1:02:35it was the issue. But they did definitely portray Saint Lucia as like she
- 1:02:39was getting better until her dad screwed it up. You know what I mean.
- 1:02:43I could see that. I was. I was bringing it up because
- 1:02:46you know, from my perspective, the dad could have had an opportunity to
- 1:02:51play a better role from the way that they present it, better role in
- 1:02:55her life. But it seemed like at this point the only role he was
- 1:03:00interested in playing was like basically he's shooting his own reality series totally. I
- 1:03:05mean there were several examples of that where like I read this on the internet
- 1:03:09where because you know, around this time in the late two thousands was when
- 1:03:15iTunes was taking over, and you know, shared music was was taking over,
- 1:03:19and the music industry was tanking. Well, the only reason why they
- 1:03:22didn't tank then was because Amy Weinhouse was selling so many records. I mean,
- 1:03:27she sold so many records around the world. She was huge everywhere,
- 1:03:31and without that income they would have, they would have failed. And so
- 1:03:37in order to sell records, they got to get her to tour, and
- 1:03:39and she hated touring, and instead of saying no like a healthy person,
- 1:03:45she self destructed by drinking and drugging so much that she couldn't even go on
- 1:03:50to stage. Hence all that footage of her on stage completely messed up.
- 1:03:54Now would you would you say, like, from my perspective, I did
- 1:04:00thinks she had the best advisors around her. Right the whole time, I
- 1:04:02kept thinking, where are her handlers? Yeah, where are her handlers?
- 1:04:08And even that the one her new manager, he kind of washes his hands.
- 1:04:11He's like man, I mean I was just setting up the gigs and
- 1:04:14stuff. But at some point, the family's got to take care of this,
- 1:04:15right, Well, there's lots of things. I mean, one,
- 1:04:18she probably would have fired Ray if he tried to intervene one. But also
- 1:04:24it's just like does anyone care? But the other thing is is she has
- 1:04:28so much power she can you know, she pushed people out of her life.
- 1:04:31You know, she pushed Nick out of her life, She pushed her
- 1:04:33best friends out of her life, and so you know a lot of it
- 1:04:36went down to her. And then there was that one thing she actually signed,
- 1:04:41which was for her to go to rehab. They you know that that
- 1:04:45thing that was like you can no longer tour or record until you go and
- 1:04:48do this. The CEO like made her yeah yeah, And it seems like
- 1:04:53it still didn't help her enough. But I thought it was so interesting when
- 1:04:57they were in rehab for a hot second and take video and they were like
- 1:05:00making fun of it, and she just goes like She's like I rather like
- 1:05:03it here. Like I thought that was like a little hint of like,
- 1:05:05yes, this is what I need, this is what I need to be
- 1:05:08doing. And like Blake was there, which is I like, come,
- 1:05:11I was just like, I would never send two addicts to rehab together.
- 1:05:15Let's talk about that. But then they like finagled it. I was thinking
- 1:05:17about that when when they said that, I was thinking that, you know,
- 1:05:19I wanted to ask you about it, because the guy said, I'd
- 1:05:23consider it even unethical to like, I would never take in a drug addicted
- 1:05:27couple into the same rehab. Yeah, they interviewed a drug counselor and I
- 1:05:32think maybe the intake person or somebody, and he was saying, yeah,
- 1:05:36Amy really wanted to come in with her husband, Blake, and because they
- 1:05:41were attached to the hip, and we were saying, no, that's not
- 1:05:45recommended. In fact, it's even potentially unethical. The reason why you would
- 1:05:47say unethical is that it's substandard treatment that you're It'd be like saying, yeah,
- 1:05:54you know, if someone says they want to come in and it's like,
- 1:05:56I'll only come in if you let me shoot a perroin every day,
- 1:05:59Oh sure, you know what I mean. You'd be like, no,
- 1:06:00that's bad treatment, you know what I mean? And so, and in
- 1:06:06the addict world, they wisely have the notion that you can also be addicted
- 1:06:13to relationships, and that your dependence on relationships also has to be recovered from,
- 1:06:20in addition to your dependence on substances, in addition to your dependence on
- 1:06:25bolimia, and so you have to abstain from relationships. They'll say that when
- 1:06:30you're in early recovery, they say, do not involve yourself with a romantic
- 1:06:34partner. Don't do it, because that's essentially just opening the door to relapse.
- 1:06:40And so now, having said that, as someone who's outside the chemical
- 1:06:43dependency world, I'll say that I don't believe in that as dogma or as
- 1:06:47always the case. You can certainly have two addicts in my mind as a
- 1:06:51couple go to rehab and recover just fine. But there's also a lot of
- 1:06:58wisdom to saying that they you to split up. Well, I think,
- 1:07:00especially I don't know that they knew this, but especially seeing that he was
- 1:07:05her enabler and she was his enabler from what they showed right to the point
- 1:07:12where it wasn't there the one point where she was doing better for a little
- 1:07:15second and he shows up and gives her heroin. Right, But you know,
- 1:07:18if both of them were on board and both of them really wanted to
- 1:07:21recover, then maybe it would have worked. Yeah, Paula, if you
- 1:07:25were an addict, would you want your boyfriend to go with you addicted?
- 1:07:30If both of you were addicts, you're a coke addict and heroin addict.
- 1:07:32Yeah, I mean yeah, because like you know when we were talking about
- 1:07:38earlier, where you do this bad thing together, it can be this real
- 1:07:41binding relationship factor, you know, so I think she like feels safe with
- 1:07:45him. I mean, you would want to believe that your relationship could survive
- 1:07:50you getting clean, and that might be the only way you could believe it,
- 1:07:54because if you go separately or if he I mean, you have to
- 1:07:57choose between yourself as a healthy person and your drugs and everything that's comfortable to
- 1:08:01you. So it's one more thing on the balance toward going back to doing
- 1:08:05drugs, right, I mean to me, I see two sides of the
- 1:08:10coin. One is that you definitely want to have your attachments there with you
- 1:08:15going through recovery, because to lose that is an additional loss that you have
- 1:08:18to recover from. But in the other hand, what's the chance that two
- 1:08:21massive addicts are going to both hit bottom and desperately want to recover at the
- 1:08:27same time, because that's basically what you need, because if either one of
- 1:08:30them is on the fence of recovery, they're going to drag the other person
- 1:08:33back into using you know what I mean. And so that's the hang up.
- 1:08:36And he had a lot of symbolism in her overall psychology because they were
- 1:08:42both in relationships when they got involved, so it was kind of like feeding
- 1:08:45into that kind of impulsive behavior. They were both very reckless individuals and very
- 1:08:53impulsive individual and again this is just from what they showed, right, but
- 1:08:56very impulsive, very reckless. Obviously both addicted, and you could even see
- 1:09:01this through her lyrics. And there's that one moment where what was it the
- 1:09:06thing he when they were really high, he cuts his arm I don't know
- 1:09:10if on accident or not. Yeah, and then she's like, well i'll
- 1:09:12do it too. Yeah. Yeah. It's like it just seemed like in
- 1:09:15their case it was like a Sid and Nancy type of situation. Well,
- 1:09:18the way that I see that is when you are so desperate as she was
- 1:09:25for closeness and security, you will do anything to have it, and when
- 1:09:30you're in a close relationship, you know, when she was in a close
- 1:09:32relationship with Blake, there would be challenges to that closeness. You know,
- 1:09:36they weren't perfect together. They would fight and a way to cope with that
- 1:09:41is to use substances. But when you use substances, you tend to lose
- 1:09:45control of your emotions and fight more. And so it would be this cycle
- 1:09:47that she's recreating, right and so so yeah, so she's massively famous,
- 1:09:55all the paparazzi, which is fricking crazy in England. I mean, we
- 1:09:58thought America was bad, but in his holy crap. And in the midst
- 1:10:00of all this, her grandmother dies, who was basically her mother. She
- 1:10:04was extremely close to this woman. She basically she apparently was her emotional mother
- 1:10:10growing up, you know what I mean. And she dies and she goes
- 1:10:14completely off the deep end at that point, right, she starts using more
- 1:10:16substances, she starts using her eating sort even more. Then then Blake comes
- 1:10:23back. As you pointed out, Paula, I just thought that was just
- 1:10:26hilarious. It was like, oh, Blake broke up with me. And
- 1:10:29that was very telling too, the way she reacted to the after Blake broke
- 1:10:32up with her. I felt like they didn't even talk about the tattoo she
- 1:10:35got. I was just like it's on her chest and it says Blake,
- 1:10:39and it's got like a little pocket. Yeah, it's like I carry you
- 1:10:42around in my pocket, Blake. Yeah. But like after a breakup she
- 1:10:45gets that tattoo, that's insane. Well she got it after they broke it,
- 1:10:48I believe so, Like from the footage, I didn't see it when
- 1:10:51they were together, and then I only saw it afterwards, But I don't
- 1:10:54know for a fact. Yeah, yeah, they really portrayed her clinginess.
- 1:10:59Well you know what I mean. And again, when you are insecure and
- 1:11:02you find someone that will pay attention to you and love you, you will
- 1:11:06hold on so tight because you're so desperate and you've been missing it your entire
- 1:11:12life, and you'll regress. I mean, she seemed like a young child
- 1:11:15next to him, you know, like a four year old clinging to her
- 1:11:17father, you know, because she needed that corrective experience given her childhood neglect.
- 1:11:24And it seemed like when he went back to her his girlfriend, that's
- 1:11:27when she as a way to like in her own words, like put a
- 1:11:31final dagger in it. Went back to Nick, you know, and she
- 1:11:36sang about that and commented about it. So it was like, as we
- 1:11:40were talking about the self defensive techniques, she you know, he hurts her
- 1:11:44by okay, you know what, I'm going back to my old girlfriend.
- 1:11:46And then she she tries to do the same by going back to Nick,
- 1:11:50therefore unfortunately using Nick in the process. Right, So, skipping to the
- 1:11:55end of the story, I didn't realize that she died so later in life.
- 1:12:00To me, it was like she was massively famous and then she died.
- 1:12:04She was twenty eight, and it was twenty eleven, and Back to
- 1:12:09Black came out four or five years before that, so and she was already
- 1:12:13pretty famous in England before that and using substances a lot before that. I
- 1:12:16mean, she had a long run. It's amazing she lasted as long as
- 1:12:19she did, honestly, ypes. And so she was found dead in her
- 1:12:24room by her bodyguard. Her bodyguard apparently came in in the morning and you
- 1:12:28know, nudged her and she didn't wake up, which was very common for
- 1:12:30her to do. And then he came back in at three, like like
- 1:12:33hour, like five six hours later and poked her again and she was in
- 1:12:38the exact same position. And then he was like uh, oh, and
- 1:12:41you know she had already died. Oh my god, he probably felt so
- 1:12:44bad. He did feel bad. Her heart had stopped. The doctor had
- 1:12:46said that she had a point four to two blood alcohol level, which is,
- 1:12:53you know, four to five times that of the legal limit, which
- 1:12:56is in state of Washington point eight. You know, zero point four sounds
- 1:13:00like a lot, but to a to a you know, to an addict,
- 1:13:03it's actually not that much. Point you know, you can actually,
- 1:13:08if you weren't a heavy drinker and you had a point four, you would
- 1:13:11be out cold, and you know, bad things would happen. But if
- 1:13:14you're a heavy drinker, point four, you know, well, I think
- 1:13:17the point is that by itself, a point four is not like a guaranteed
- 1:13:20death for a heavy drink. Right. The reason why I'm saying that is
- 1:13:23a lot of people say, oh my god, point four, you know,
- 1:13:26no, wonder she was dead, and it's like, no, it's
- 1:13:29it's actually what this tells me is that, I mean, one is is
- 1:13:31that that it's it was probably higher before, you know, when she fell
- 1:13:35asleep. But really, I think it seems to me, and I'm not
- 1:13:41a physician, that the combination of her bulimia, just the wear and the
- 1:13:46blimia is very destructive to your body. And dying from bolimia and anorexia is
- 1:13:54actually very common. It's something like ten or twenty percent of people diagnosed with
- 1:13:58blemia and anah will die just from it, you know what I mean.
- 1:14:02It's actually more likely you'll die from it than depression or something, you know,
- 1:14:06how we deal with suicide. Yeah, I mean, she's she's lacking
- 1:14:10in very necessary nutritional components. She has probably esophageal like early stage esophageal cancer
- 1:14:17at some point, right, and she has repetitive stress to her heart for
- 1:14:24years, like hardcore, you know, just abuse, abuse, abuse,
- 1:14:29So I'm sure her heart muscles were not in great shape. Yeah, and
- 1:14:32then she probably right, like if she was point four when they analyzed her.
- 1:14:35Yeah, she was. She probably drank like so much that she blacked
- 1:14:41out and everything just came together in the perfect storm unfortunately. Right. Yeah,
- 1:14:45I think it was kind of a freak accident because I'm sure she was
- 1:14:48that drunk many many times previous, and on several other drugs. Probably.
- 1:14:53Let me ask you one last question. So I was thinking about it,
- 1:14:56and I was saying, Okay, she's a woman, and she's and she
- 1:14:58was treated a certain way by the media and really kind of soaked that in
- 1:15:02because you know, Kurt Cobain, you know, similar kind of story,
- 1:15:05treated differently, I would say than Amy white House, is this an example
- 1:15:11of women being treated differently and therefore society is somewhat culpable for the pain she
- 1:15:16experienced. I mean there is some there's been some discussion about within the arts,
- 1:15:23how like men's depression is more like respected, like always a depressed artists,
- 1:15:29but women it's like, oh, come on, cheer up, you
- 1:15:31know, And so that might be true. I'm trying to think if I
- 1:15:35have like a concrete example of you know, was Kurt Cobain ridiculed as much
- 1:15:41as she was? Yeah? Right, yeah, I don't think that men
- 1:15:44are well to be fair though, So she's coming up for years in an
- 1:15:49in now for real, in an internet age where Kurt Cobain died before the
- 1:15:55Internet was even in colleges generally, you know. Yeah, so it's a
- 1:15:59different I'm not true that is a different time, but I'm just trying to
- 1:16:01imagine another a male in that position being made fun of as much, you
- 1:16:08know, but maybe they would be well, yeah, I mean that's a
- 1:16:11good point. It's just I felt like and I didn't even I didn't really
- 1:16:14even follow the story because I remember when when the announcement came that she died,
- 1:16:17like it was so like my understanding was one minute a song comes out
- 1:16:20about rehab. No time goes by and I'm doing air quotes here, and
- 1:16:25all of a sudden, I hear that she's dead. In reality, it
- 1:16:28was many years, how many five years or something, But for me,
- 1:16:30it was kind of a very simplistic story. In reality, the people that
- 1:16:33were following it would have seen all these like, oh, geez, look
- 1:16:36at that picture. Oh my gosh, what a man. Oh look look
- 1:16:40at this performance, like the one they showed was she wasn't singing. Yeah
- 1:16:43like that they you know what. That happened several times. But they did
- 1:16:46make fun of guns N' Roses guy when he started going a little bananas.
- 1:16:50It would do shit like that. Remember he would jump off the stage,
- 1:16:54he got in a fight with the one dude. He canceled shows, and
- 1:16:57I think he became the butt of jokes as well. And then Chinese democracy
- 1:17:00was never coming out. So I'm not fully defending like women have not been
- 1:17:05made more fun of in similar situations. I'm just saying, I don't know
- 1:17:09that Kirk Cobain is the right example, right, But it just seems like
- 1:17:12there's something different to the whole story. You know, like if she was
- 1:17:15a man, would her handlers have treated her the way that they did treat
- 1:17:18her? You know, it's a question. That's a good that's a good
- 1:17:21point, because they were because she would she would not she hated being on
- 1:17:25tour, and they would force her on tour. They would they would wait
- 1:17:28till she was passed out and then like put her on the plane like bea
- 1:17:30racus on on eighteen. While she's on stage trying to get off stage,
- 1:17:35her her bodyguards would push her back on stage. And I'm just trying to
- 1:17:40imagine if if you were, you know, justin Timberlake, if your handlers
- 1:17:44would do that to you. Although do you remember in the Kirk Cobain thing
- 1:17:46in the documentary, because I never knew that he had these terrible stomach problems,
- 1:17:50which might have been CELIAX or something really bad, like he had these
- 1:17:54terrible, debilitating stomach problems, and I seem to recall something about how he
- 1:18:00would get very little sympathy from the record company and stuff like that. Yeah,
- 1:18:05but somehow it seemed like it seemed like Amy he House. Amy Winehouse
- 1:18:12was particularly not in control of her life, you know, in a way
- 1:18:15that other famous people seem like they would have been given that control. Well,
- 1:18:19maybe she, I don't know, Maybe she wanted someone to do it
- 1:18:24all for her, like to take care of her, you know, but
- 1:18:27they weren't. They were being selfish about it. I don't know. It
- 1:18:30was really weird, and I feel like there's so many situations in life,
- 1:18:32like I feel like everyone's worked at a job where an office like some kind
- 1:18:36of insane situation is going on. You're like, I can't believe this is
- 1:18:40real, And it just takes one person to kind of lead this madness.
- 1:18:44And she was kind of leading her own madness and everyone just let it happen.
- 1:18:47Lastly, I'll say that many people would see this documentary and think that
- 1:18:53the result was inevitable, that she was bound to kill herself this way,
- 1:18:58and it certainly seen that way, But I'm here to tell you that it
- 1:19:01isn't. I've seen plenty of people like her recover. She could have been
- 1:19:05saved if she were given good, stable attachments. If the entire system family,
- 1:19:13the handlers, the CEO, the boyfriends, if everyone was talking to
- 1:19:16a therapist, good therapists. And I'm not saying that all therapists, so
- 1:19:19cliche for therapists say they should have been a therapy. I'm not talking about
- 1:19:24just any all therapy. I'm talking about like coordinated, good sound therapy and
- 1:19:30with clients that actually want to make things better. She after an extended period
- 1:19:35of recovery, which would have taken years, especially with bulimia and all the
- 1:19:40other things, she could have led a happy life. It would have been
- 1:19:44more boring, for sure, it would have been boring, but it would
- 1:19:46have been one with happiness and one with clear you know, a clear mind.
- 1:19:51She could have been that way. I've seen many people recover that way.
- 1:19:55Imagine if she had a better diet and she had better sleep and her
- 1:19:58stress level was lowered, she had better control over her life. Imagine if
- 1:20:02her attachments in her life weren't users and they really paid attention to her,
- 1:20:06and the media wasn't breathing down her neck all the time. I think that
- 1:20:10it could have happened, and it's a tragedy that it didn't. Anything's possible
- 1:20:15for sure. You just look back and you're like, oh god, so
- 1:20:17many things could have been different, like ridiculously different. Well, there have
- 1:20:21been stories, not like thousands, but there's been stories of people that were
- 1:20:27famous musicians that have gone through heavy, heavy addiction and surfaced and now they
- 1:20:31are older and might die a little younger than they might have, but they
- 1:20:35survived longer than freaking twenty eight. There's also sadly many stories of the twenty
- 1:20:42seven year old musicians that die. But I had a thought that like having
- 1:20:47friends had friends that are addicted and stuff, I've often felt like, man,
- 1:20:53like you should like I wish that it was something like, if you're
- 1:20:57addicted, you have to go to like this attic jail for a few years
- 1:21:02and you don't get out. There's no rehab for thirty days. It's like
- 1:21:05a two year process or something mandatory. But because that's the kind of it
- 1:21:10feels like it's like you need long enough for something to finally take hold.
- 1:21:15Because she obviously went through bouts of sobriety repeatedly, and yet yeah, I
- 1:21:21agree, because through our experience with addicts in our lives, we realize that
- 1:21:27even when we fight hard, and they fight hard, and they go to
- 1:21:30rehab and they get clean, and they go to AA and NA and they
- 1:21:36start working the steps that they can easily just fall right back into the pattern.
- 1:21:42And you can have years of this in and out of rehab and in
- 1:21:45and out of hope, and in the end they've never recovered and they need
- 1:21:50that control of their life. I mean, I would go so far as
- 1:21:54to say, wouldn't it be great? And it's just like if I was
- 1:21:57dictator of the world, you know what I mean, wouldn't it be great
- 1:22:00if we had an island that had no substances on it and you just had
- 1:22:04to go there, but it was a beautiful island about like Singapore, Yeah,
- 1:22:09the wrong one. But yes, I mean, it's not an island.
- 1:22:12But isn't it that I'm saying, Well, I'm saying I bet you
- 1:22:15that there are tons of drugs you can get there. Really, I've just
- 1:22:18heard that I have really severe punishments. But one of the biggest black markets
- 1:22:24in the world. Well, an island somewhere in the middle of the Pacific,
- 1:22:28and you got to go there, and you're forced to go there,
- 1:22:30and you know, you just sort of live with it and you know,
- 1:22:32and you recover, Yes, and you have and you don't have to work,
- 1:22:36because honestly, it'd be better to pay someone to live on an island
- 1:22:41somewhere than to deal with all the destruction cheaper, yeah, that they deal
- 1:22:45in our own society. I fantasized there was someone in my life that that
- 1:22:48had addiction problems. Uh, And I fantasized often man if I were like
- 1:22:54a billionaire, I would put him on a boat all staffed with the right,
- 1:22:57trustworthy people for like two years, like he just in the middle of
- 1:23:00the ocean. Great, it's just like a nice yacht and stuff, but
- 1:23:03no substances period, you know. But of course this is all Now.
- 1:23:08What CD people, what chemical dependency treatment people will say is that doesn't fix
- 1:23:12the problem because as soon as they come out, they're going to start using
- 1:23:15again. But but what I'd say is sometimes that'll work. You know.
- 1:23:18I've seen it work with teenagers sometimes, you know, because one of the
- 1:23:23things you can do with kids is you can kidnap your kids and send them
- 1:23:27to involuntary treatment. In Washington State, you can't involuntarily detain children for treatment
- 1:23:34teenagers, but in other states you can oh, you can't in the state.
- 1:23:38You can't in Washington. But the way they get around it in Washington
- 1:23:42is you hire goons to kidnap your children and drive them across state lines and
- 1:23:47then involuntarily place them in treatment facilities in other states like Utah. Whoa,
- 1:23:53Yeah, can you believe that that's so serious? I've worked. Do they
- 1:23:58tell them like, we're this is what we're doing, or is it you
- 1:24:01just think you're getting kidnapped? No? No, no, they tell you
- 1:24:03that, you know, like you know, the kid comes home, the
- 1:24:09parents say, okay, he's he's in the home, and then the goons
- 1:24:11show up, and then the kids like who are these guys? And the
- 1:24:14parents say, these guys are going to bring you a rehab And sometimes the
- 1:24:17kids will be like okay, And sometimes the kids will fight and the goons
- 1:24:21will wrestle you to the ground and hog tie you and put you in the
- 1:24:24van and drive you all the way time. Yeah, it's intense. It's
- 1:24:27it's a part of society that does not get talked about. One element of
- 1:24:30this is this is only rich families, because you got to be rich to
- 1:24:33afford goons. Yeah, and rich to afford these these mental places you're price,
- 1:24:40you're taking notes a you're gonna write. I just think I just love
- 1:24:43situations where you could you should write a story heard of that situation. And
- 1:24:46that's just I have a page called the story Idea Orphanage, and it just
- 1:24:50is scrolling for like five minutes of all these crazy story ideas that I have.
- 1:24:55You could investigate a real story like this and write about it and be
- 1:25:00huge, because again, it sounds crazy, right that your parents hire two
- 1:25:03big, you know, goons. I would think of it as a fiction
- 1:25:08short story from the point of view of one of the goons. Oh,
- 1:25:12just like this is my job because I love some people like this is my
- 1:25:15job? Is crazy, you know, i'd be awesome, like this is
- 1:25:17what you do every day? Yeah, that sounds like very cool because you
- 1:25:21could see the movie. It's like it starts with this guy. You think
- 1:25:24he's a bad guy. He's driving or he's in the passenger seat. They
- 1:25:27put on a mask or whatever what's going on, and they go and they
- 1:25:30take this kid. And then in the moment where it's revealed what they're doing,
- 1:25:33he goes, this is my job, blah blah blah blah, you
- 1:25:35know, and the voiceover comes in dude, we should produce the movie Let's
- 1:25:40get it bat right, but Jaws, but with kidnapping. Yeah, I'm
- 1:25:43good at kidnapping kids. I was always good at kidnapping. Who all right?
- 1:25:50Any final words for Amy? You're the Amy expert. I know,
- 1:25:56I just if I don't really believe in like an afterlife. So it's just
- 1:25:59like she was here and now she's gone. We still have our music,
- 1:26:02you know, and that's well, there's that one song. If there's a
- 1:26:05rock and roll heaven, have you heard this song before? Nope? Oh
- 1:26:11my god, it's so funny. Do you know the song? I think
- 1:26:15so many people loved her, but not enough people loved her. Yeah,
- 1:26:19that's my final thought. Well that does it for another episode of Psychology in
- 1:26:23Seattle. Thanks for joining us out there, and please take care of yourself
- 1:26:28because you deserve it. Bye bye