Latest / Her Culture: Books, Film, Music & Women in the Arts / Why Your Hometown’s Expectations Feel Like a Heavy Coat | Her Culture
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that falls over your hometown when you say you’re leaving, and it isn’t the sound of pride—it’s the sound of someone realizing they’ve lost their audience. I want you to picture that silence right now, because I think we both know exactly how heavy it feels. Let's unpack that silence for a moment. Because if you grew up in a small town, or even just a tight-knit neighborhood where everyone knows your middle name and your mother’s maiden name, you know that leaving isn't really about geography. It’s about shedding a skin. When you walk out those doors for the first time as an adult, carrying nothing but a suitcase full of dreams and a heart full of fear, you feel the eyes on your back. They aren't malicious. That’s the tricky part. They love you. But they are watching you with a curiosity that borders on suspicion, like you’re a book they’ve read a thousand times and suddenly decided to write a new ending in pencil, hoping no one notices the smudges. I remember standing on my porch the morning I left for college, watching my dad polish his car for the third time that hour. He wasn’t looking at me. He was looking at the driveway, at the perfect symmetry of the concrete, at the life he had built and maintained. And I realized then that my departure wasn’t just a personal milestone; it was a disruption to the order of things. In our hometowns, stability is the highest virtue. Stability means you stay close. Stability means you take the job at the local firm, marry the person from high school, buy the house with the white picket fence that your parents bought thirty years ago. To choose anything else is to suggest that their way of living was perhaps... incomplete. Or worse, wrong. So you carry this invisible weight, this burden of expectation, not because anyone explicitly told you to stay, but because the air itself seems to thicken when you try to move forward. There’s a texture to this pressure, isn’t there? It’s not loud. It doesn’t come with shouting matches or slammed doors. It comes in the gentle, well-meaning questions. 'So, what are you going to do when you get back?' 'Are you seeing anyone nice?' 'You look tired, honey, maybe you need to slow down.' These phrases are designed to comfort, but often they function as anchors. They remind us that while we are out here trying to become strangers to ourselves, trying to find who we are beneath the layers of childhood conditioning, home is holding the space for the person we used to be. And that version of you—the one who fits neatly into the narrative they wrote before you were born—is so much easier to love. She is predictable. She is safe. She doesn’t ask hard questions about why we work sixty hours a week or why we sleep on couches instead of buying homes. She doesn’t challenge the status quo. When you start to change, when you start to speak differently or care about different things, you might notice a subtle shift in the room. A pause. A glance exchanged between friends who haven’t seen you in months. You become a mirror reflecting their own unchosen paths, and mirrors can be uncomfortable things to keep around the house. I think about this a lot when I’m editing old zines from my twenties. The ink is faded, the paper yellowed, but the desperation in the margins is still vibrant. I wanted to scream that I was more than the sum of my zip code. I wanted to prove that my mind was a landscape wider than the county lines I crossed every weekend to visit family. But looking back, I see that I wasn’t just fighting for my identity; I was fighting for the permission to be complex. To be contradictory. To be unhappy sometimes. To be successful in ways that didn’t look like success to them. Here is the part nobody talks about: the grief. Not the grief of losing them, but the grief of outgrowing them. There is a profound sadness in realizing that you will never again share a context with your oldest friends that is as shared as it once was. Your reference points diverge. You talk about therapy sessions, creative burnout, urban isolation, while they talk about property taxes, school board meetings, and the new grocery store opening downtown. Neither conversation is better than the other. Both are vital. But they are no longer the same language. This divergence creates a loneliness that is sharp and cold. You might find yourself editing yourself before you even speak. You soften your opinions. You hide your passions. You laugh louder at jokes that don’t land quite as well as they did ten years ago. You wear the costume of the daughter, the sister, the friend, because it’s safer than showing them the raw, unfinished draft of who you are becoming. And in doing so, you betray yourself. You shrink. You fold yourself into smaller and smaller shapes to fit into the boxes they have prepared for you. I’ve sat across from women in coffee shops who tell me this story, tears streaming down their faces, admitting they feel like impostors in their own lives. They feel like they don’t belong in the city anymore, where they are just another face in the crowd, but they definitely don’t belong back home, where they are a deviation from the norm. They are stranded in the middle, untethered from both shores. This is the burden of expectations: it demands that you choose between authenticity and belonging, as if you cannot possibly have both. As if you cannot possibly build a bridge between the two. But here is the truth, and I say this with all the tenderness I can muster: you do not owe them your stagnation. You do not owe them the satisfaction of watching you live the life they imagined for you. Your creativity, your ambition, your desire to explore the world and yourself—that is not a betrayal. It is an expansion. It is proof that the soil they planted you in was rich enough to support something wilder than they could foresee. Tell me more about why that landed. Why does staying small feel like safety? Often, it’s because we confuse visibility with danger. We think that if we stay quiet, if we conform, we won’t be hurt. We won’t be disappointed. But the cost of that safety is a slow death of the spirit. I chose to leave my hometown, yes, but I also chose to return to it in my own way. I returned as a storyteller. I returned with books and records and ideas that challenged them, not by arguing, but by living. By showing them that a woman can be rooted and winged at the same time. It took years. It took phone calls where I cried. It took holidays where the tension was thick enough to cut with a knife. But eventually, they began to see me. Not the version of me they wanted, but the real one. Flawed, fierce, messy, and magnificent. And when they finally saw me, they didn’t reject me. They adjusted. They made room. Not because I forced them to, but because love, true love, evolves. It grows to accommodate the people we become, not just the children we were. So, how do we carry this burden without letting it crush us? How do we honor where we came from without being defined by it? I believe it starts with radical honesty, spoken softly. It starts with telling our families, 'I love you, and I am changing. Please help me understand what you see in me, so I can understand myself.' It’s not about rejecting your roots. Roots are essential. They feed the tree. But branches must grow outward, toward the sun, even if that means breaking away from the trunk. I want you to think about one thing you’ve hidden because you were afraid it wouldn’t be understood. One dream you’ve shelved. One opinion you’ve swallowed. What would happen if you spoke it aloud? Not to challenge them, but to invite them in. To say, 'This is who I am now. Do you still have room for me?' The answer might surprise you. Or it might not. And that’s okay too. Because your worth is not determined by their approval. Your worth is inherent. It exists in your breath, in your art, in your kindness, in your resilience. No matter where you are, no matter who is watching. We are all archivists of our own lives, Mallory. We collect moments, feelings, memories. And some of those memories are heavy. Some are bright. All of them are yours. Don’t let the expectations of others edit your story. Let them be characters in it, yes. Let them be influences. But you hold the pen. You decide the ending. And honestly? The best endings are the ones no one saw coming. Thank you for letting me sit with you in this quiet space today. Be gentle with yourself as you navigate your own journeys. I’ll be thinking of you. Until next time, keep creating, keep questioning, and keep believing in the wild, beautiful complexity of who you are. I’m Mallory MacGeehan, and I’ll see you soon.