Latest / CIC’s Small Business Intelligence / Growth On Paper, Pressure On Main Street. A Conversation With Connecticut’s Comptroller Sean Scanlon, Episode 16
Transcript
- Hello and welcome to Small Business Intelligence by Community Investment Corporation, the podcast where we analyze the latest news headlines and address the all important question of what does this mean to you as a small business owner.
- 0:11We'll share our insights in this regard so you can be better prepared for what might happen in the days, weeks, and months ahead.
- I'm Louis Silva, president and CEO of CIC, and my co-host is CI's Business Advisor, Joe McCaffery.
- Today we're joined by a very special guest, Connecticut State controller, Sean Scanlon.
- As a state's chief fiscal officer, comptroller Scanlan oversees Connecticut's finances and plays a key role in shaping the economic environment for small businesses across our state.
- Today we'll talk about the outlook for Connecticut's small business community, what the state's fiscal health means for entrepreneurs, and how decisions in Hartford translates to growth on Main Street.
- Comptroller Scanlon, welcome to the podcast.
- Great to be on, guys.
- Thanks for having me.
- We've been looking forward to this conversation.
- We're big fans of your monthly economic update report as it tracks a lot of the same issues we focus on here on the podcast, and really helps to put into context what small businesses across Connecticut are experiencing.
- I.
- Yeah, you're welcome.
- You know, um, in my office, right, uh, by the door where I come in and out of is the very first comptroller's report from 1789.
- And, uh, we're the land of steady habits and a lot of comptrollers before me have been doing things the same way.
- I've tried to change up things a little bit.
- We do a economic update instead of a boring 12 page dry letter that my predecessors used to send.
- I try to do video whenever I can, and since you guys are doing this pod, you know that the way to reach people now is so different than it was even five years ago, 10 years ago.
- And so I really appreciate what you guys are doing and to have me on to talk about what I'm doing and hopefully through both of what we're doing, more people get to know what's important to them and what's important for them from your perspective and from mine.
- So it sounds like you're like a 50th generation business, right? I mean, you're just continued Right.
- Continuing with all, with all the people before you, so that's fabulous.
- That's really great.
- What's, I'm the six 67th comptroller.
- Wow.
- Which is kind of crazy.
- 67 generations and 66, so that's good for you.
- So it's great to have you with us.
- Um, is it okay if we address it by your first name or, absolutely.
- Yeah.
- Be less formal.
- Appreciate it.
- Good.
- Okay.
- So, uh, we'll start off with, uh, our first question.
- Uh, for those who may not be familiar, can you provide our listeners a brief overview of your function? Yeah, so I, I wear many hats, but I guess the easiest thing to say is I'm the chief financial officer of the state, along with the state treasurer and the chief fiscal watchdog.
- And so I pay the bills, I keep the books, I run all of the benefit procurement.
- So I run the largest healthcare plan in the entire state.
- 250,000 lives on our plan.
- So do, do a lot of the, the things that you think of A CFO doing.
- But then just by the nature of being one of our six statewide elected officials, I get into a lot of other stuff too.
- I have a good relationship with the governor.
- He gives me a, a lot of different projects to work on.
- So right now I'm doing a big thing with our hospitals on healthcare and dealing with Medicaid.
- And so, uh, my job is, is a little bit different and hard to define.
- Uh, but at the end of the day, uh, CFO is probably the easiest thing that I could, could say as a cop for your audience.
- Good.
- Okay.
- That sounds good.
- Um, a lot of conversations, particularly nowadays, they start off with talk about the weather.
- So let's talk about the weather.
- The weather is one of those things that can be a major disruption to small businesses.
- Is there anything you folks in Hartford can do about all the snow and subfreezing temperatures we've been having lately? I wish, man.
- Yeah.
- You know, uh, I feel like we're in like Russia these days.
- It's, it's like the snow has never melted.
- My kids are super young, but they don't like playing it because it's so icy, right.
- So it's not fun.
- They're wrestling each other.
- But, uh, it's gonna thaw out a little bit, but I'm, I'm ready for spring today.
- It's warm up a little bit.
- Yeah.
- It's almost like too cold to even be out for the kids, you know? So, but, um, I'm joking.
- Of course.
- So, let me rephrase the question another way.
- What has Hartford done in terms of building a reserve of funds to address uncontrollable emergencies like the weather? So I answer this question with a story, which is that I first ran for office as a state rep when I was in my early twenties, and I got elected in 2014.
- And when I showed up in Hartford, we were in the middle of a huge fiscal crisis.
- We had record tax increases, we had record spending cuts, huge out migration of people, businesses, just really, really bad situation.
- In 2017, we did a really, really good thing, which was that we passed the first bipartisan budget in about three decades, and that bipartisan budget changed the way we budget in significant ways that we can walk out with if you guys really want.
- But the, the most significant thing that it did though was basically bifurcate volatile money that we get from people who live in Fairfield County, but work on Wall Street, so that we were not riding the volatility of the market to balance our budget.
- And with that key change, uh, we have had now eight consecutive years of ending the year with the surplus.
- We've built up a $4 billion rainy day fund.
- We've paid $10 billion of our pension debt off.
- All of these things are possible because we made that significant change to how we budget.
- And I think as a result, Connecticut has gotten out of the immediate fiscal crisis.
- But we still have a lot of things left to do and a lot of work that I think we have to do to continue getting out of that crisis while also addressing the crisis that I think we all know we're facing now, which is that Connecticut is just too expensive for people to raise a family, start a business, uh, you name it.
- And that's what I think our central challenge is going forward.
- Yeah, I think we, we'll touch on all those great points and we'll touch on them as we get to some, some of the other questions.
- Uh, you know, we tell small businesses like the state government, you should have a rainy day fund.
- That's one of the things that we encourage.
- We also encourage our listeners to have a working capital line of credit.
- To smooth out any short-term fluctuations in cashflow.
- In addition to the rainy day fund, does Connecticut have any type of short-term credit facility that can tap if needed? They do.
- And you know, Connecticut is a weird state and, you know, I'm the 67th comptroller.
- We also have a state treasurer.
- So in a lot of other states, uh, my functions and his functions would be the same guy or, or gal.
- But because we have that bifurcation here, he's really the one that does that.
- But he has some short term cash management tools, uh, in his toolkit that could smooth out, you know, time mismatches or, uh, you know, issues like that.
- But you hit it on the head, which is that rainy day funds really matter.
- When we, uh, had that big bad budget in 2017, um, the rainy day fund was at $200 million.
- Uh, now as I said, we're at $4.1
- billion and we've succeeded, uh, in, in building up a lot of that, which, as you guys know, is important as we'll talk about.
- When we go into recession, um, when we see federal cuts, that rainy day fund is really gonna be the thing that's standing between us and going back to the bad old days of the lost decade of the 2010s after the last recession that we were not prepared for.
- Yeah.
- Part of what I'm doing here is holding you up as a, as a good example of, you know, good financial management and you know, the next question you had mentioned before that you're essentially the CFO of the state.
- And for many small businesses, the owner wears many hats, including that of the CFO.
- We always encourage entrepreneurs to know your numbers.
- That's a common saying.
- And as the CFO is the state of Connecticut, how often do you review the state's financial metrics and what specifically is on your dashboard of key performance indicators? The honest answer is every day.
- Right? Which is what most business owners that you guys work with are doing too, right? We tell 'em to do the same.
- Yes.
- If, if you're not doing that, there's probably a problem, right? Um, but, but every day, and then, you know, every month, uh, we put these numbers out to the public, right? And so we try to make this as transparent as possible.
- We have other tools.
- I run a great website called Open Connecticut, so if your listeners really want to get.
- Really wonky.
- They can go on this tool and search what every single employee is making.
- They can look at how many stamps an agency bought, they can see the budget in real time.
- We update this every single day.
- Um, and I just think knowing those numbers and being able to work with them in real time is obviously important for me, given what I do.
- But I think it's important for the public because they have a right to know exactly what's happening with their government.
- And when they see things on there, uh, you know, that are, are wrong to them or different, they can call their state rep or state senator or the governor or me and try to change it.
- And I think there's a misconception out there that nobody looks at this.
- Trust me, A lot of people look at this.
- We have tens of thousands of clicks on this all the time.
- And, uh, I think having more transparency is always a good thing in government.
- As Louis said, we, we love the report.
- I recommend it to, uh, clients I work with, you know, suggest that they, it's an easy read.
- Might take you 15, 20 minutes to read it, but, uh, it's a, it's, it's a really good report.
- It, it's a lot of really good information that business owners need to know.
- Um, okay, let's shift gears a little bit here.
- We'll, uh, you had mentioned earlier about consumers.
- So let's talk about consumer spending.
- As disposable income has become less discretionary as a result of inflation or maybe hyperinflation.
- In some cases, small businesses are being impacted.
- The most, many small businesses, with the exception of some service business may be, you know, would be deemed non-essential purchases to most budget conscious households.
- Non-essentials is where consumers are making the first and biggest budget cuts right now, aside from the economic impact, this could have a big cultural impact on our state by changing the main street feel of every town and city for residents and tourists alike to big industries.
- Uh, you know, what more can the state do to help small businesses remain relevant? As you guys know, it's a really strange time in the economy right now, and it's almost a tale of two economies where there are some factors that you'd look at that are off the charts great, right? Look at the market, right? The market has been tremendous, but then you look at other parts of the economy and it almost looks as if we are in a recession on the spending side, you know, the, the thing that I think is the most illustrative that I tell people is this idea of the khap economy, right? Where you see those high income consumers are driving a ton of spending right now because they have the disposable income to do it, whereas other people sort of on the lower end of that k are, are in the opposite direction.
- Um, that's a hard thing for a small business owner to navigate.
- Uh, and it's been that topsy-turvy time.
- So I frankly think that the best way that we can help these small businesses navigate it is to lower their costs, right? So if we can make it more affordable for them.
- To, uh, pay their Eversource bill or deal with their healthcare costs if they're even in a position to still offer health insurance, which most of the companies are not.
- If we can try to lower some of those costs, then they can deal with the unpredictability of markets, because that's just the nature of capitalism.
- They now have one hand tied behind their back because of the unaffordability of doing business here in some cases.
- And I think if we can try to figure that side of this out, um, riding the volatility of the market will be much more manageable for them.
- Yeah, I mean, one thing that a lot of people don't realize or, or know, the, the public in general is that many of the small businesses in Connecticut and other states who do offer healthcare, like you said, not everyone does, but those who do, they do it through the Affordable Care Act.
- And so the major changes that take place there are having a super big impact on small businesses who are already under pressure.
- So these are very timely.
- Issues and, and topics of discussion.
- So, uh, you know, really, really good that we're, we're talking about them.
- Um, next question is pertaining to food.
- Food insecurity in in particular has also been rising changes in SNAP benefits that, uh, that they're making will hopefully have a positive effect on the labor participation rate.
- They're tying work to, uh, to benefits, uh, which hopefully will lead to an increase in per capita and household income.
- That could be very beneficial for small businesses in terms of labor avail availability and sales.
- However, it will likely take some time for those benefits to be realized.
- And I'm wondering, does the state have an interim plan to carry us through to the point of stabilization? Yeah, it's something that we think a lot about as we head towards the end of the year when a lot of the things from the one big beautiful bill will take effect, and particularly that, that means snap.
- Um, which as you said, is just about food assistance and then Medicaid, which is health insurance for poor people.
- You know, the thing about our situation here with SNAP is that we have a pretty decent high labor participation rate in the state.
- The thing that I'm worried about is that the people who have been added to that requirement on SNAP are older.
- Um, you know, they're veterans.
- They're homeless.
- There's all these new categories that folks now have to prove that they're working, where otherwise they did not.
- And it, it's not, our biggest concern is not so much that.
- You know, people are gonna go out and run to join the workforce.
- Although if that happens, that would be great.
- Obviously, it's more that they're gonna not really understand how to navigate the system and will therefore fall through the cracks.
- Or we'll have a tough time proving they are working when they in fact are working just because they don't know how to navigate the system.
- And then you see potentially, you know, we estimate 36,000 people in our state will now need to prove that they're working to keep those benefits.
- And I think that, um, you know, while we don't anticipate a huge change in labor participation over this, uh, it's something that we certainly will watch very closely in my office.
- Mm-hmm.
- So one variable that was only briefly mentioned in your economic report, uh, was childcare.
- And, uh, we all know the cost of childcare has become prohibitive for a lot of folks, and the supply of service providers remains very low.
- The same is true for eldercare, by the way.
- We have clients in, in both of those businesses.
- So we're familiar with it.
- You know, these are major obstacles to raising the labor participation rate, which you just mentioned.
- You know, that's one of those, um, you know, employment metrics that is, in my opinion, doesn't get enough attention.
- Everybody seems to focus on the, uh.
- You know, the unemployment rate, but the labor participation rate, I think is a more telling number.
- And as you mentioned, Connecticut's labor participation rate is pretty good.
- It's above the national average, although below where it was pre COVID.
- Uh, so we've still got some room to run there, but, um, again, it seems we need to do more of a pub.
- You know, it seems hopefully we could find a more of a public private solution to this problem, not just at the state level, but at the local level.
- And, uh, I believe doing so could have a positive impact on the state economy.
- So do you know if there's any proposals being discussed in this regard? Well, I, I think it's the right question.
- I'm, uh, gonna turn 40 this year and I'm in what's called the sandwich generation.
- So I have a 3-year-old and a 6-year-old.
- But I also have a mother who is in her mid seventies and in-laws who are getting up there too.
- And the crunch that people that are my age are increasingly feeling is you're caring for your young kids.
- And you're caring for your older parents and there's not enough money to make that work, and there's not enough resources out there to make that work.
- So you see multi-generational families, right? You see, you know, your in-laws moving in with you.
- I love my in-laws, but I don't wanna live with them.
- No offense, uh, to them.
- Hope they're not listening to your podcast.
- But, uh, the, the point is that, um, I think we're woefully behind as not just a state, but as a country in dealing with this growing phenomenon and problem.
- Um, that problem only gets worse as the kids get older.
- For my friends that have college age kids who are in a lot of debt, they have nowhere to go to live 'cause they can't afford it.
- They have tons of, uh, liability from the high cost of education and then they move in.
- So, uh, I don't have the the silver bullet answer other than to say.
- Um, I think we have to figure out a way through this.
- And with my mom in particular, who was a small business owner through most of my life, she never had the money to set aside for retirement, nor did she have the financial literacy to do so.
- And that's not a knock on her.
- I'm the first person in my entire family to ever go to college.
- Um, so it wasn't like we had that generational financial literacy instruction.
- And now she is, like I said, in her mid seventies, still working because she can't afford to retire.
- But there will come a time when she has to physically retire.
- And then that burden, I hate to say it that way, will fall to me.
- Um, and I just think we, we don't talk about that enough as a society.
- And I would love to see a federal solution to that, even though whether the Democrats are in power or the Republicans are in power, nothing is working in Washington.
- We're in huge gridlock, and I think it's gonna fall to the states to try to solve some of these problems.
- I mean, there's a lot of people in, uh, in, in the state that you just described, myself being one of them, my college, you know, graduate daughter is living at home with us.
- So it's the reality for, for a lot of people.
- And you know, you ask her, you say, you know, why are you living at home? She'll say, because I can't afford to live on my own.
- Yeah.
- And it's true.
- So, um, I can totally relate to that too, Sean, as someone who has a three and a 6-year-old and also has aging parents and in-laws, knock on wood, Russ, we've had the privilege and the opportunity for my in-laws to watch my children while my wife and I worked.
- But not everyone obviously has that opportunity and or that privilege, and I know sooner or later those tides will turn and it'll be our turn to watch my parents and my in-laws.
- So it's fascinating to hear that.
- There are people in the same boat, but I also do worry about those who are not in that same position to receive this type of care that our children are, because it can be obviously very difficult for those folks to manage the financial burden that comes along with childcare.
- It's a, it's a huge problem.
- And, you know, the, the governor, um, to his credit has done something I think is really, really significant, which is that last year he created this thing called the Early Childhood Endowment, which, uh, is, is seeking to help make sure that anybody under a hundred thousand dollars, uh, is getting, uh, assistance to pay for childcare and that people over a hundred thousand dollars, which maybe a lot of your listeners might be, are getting some form of assistance for that too.
- Um, it's not just about helping those families, it's also about training the next generation of childcare providers.
- Um, you know, my, uh, older son went to kindergarten last year, but before he went to kindergarten, my wife and I were paying almost as much for childcare as we were for our mortgage, which is kind of crazy if you think about it.
- And I just think this problem is getting worse and worse, and I think we need bigger solutions.
- But I don't have, uh, the easy talking point off the top of my head.
- It's a really hard problem to solve, but we have to solve.
- Yeah, we've seen similar metrics with regard to, um, healthcare.
- People are spending more on healthcare than they are in their mortgage, and used to be that mortgages were the, the biggest outlay for most households.
- But as you, as you indicated, that's, that's shifting.
- I mean, we're seeing, we're seeing that change for sure.
- Uh, let's, uh, let's shift gears and, uh, we'll talk about labor and employment.
- So, uh, we all know Connecticut recently bumped the minimum wage rate, um, which adversely affects small businesses more so than larger employees, employers, because small business, small businesses tend to hire more entry level workers.
- Much like the benefits of the one big, beautiful Bill Act should put more after tax dollars in people's pockets, but rising prices are likely to absorb potentially more than the re the tax re reduction.
- A lot of people don't realize that, but that's probably gonna be true.
- It makes me wonder if the same will be true for minimum wage hikes.
- Workers will make more money, but the things they will buy will go up in price to reflect the increase in cost.
- So in the end, is it worth it? Look, I, I mean, I certainly recognize that these wage, rising wage costs are a burden on small businesses, right? And especially those businesses who've just lived through the highest period of inflation in 40 plus years.
- Right? That's a, a double whammy that that is hard to, to deal with.
- But, you know, I, I do think, as you just suggested, Joe, it, it can be a, a bit of a vicious cycle when those higher wage costs flow through to higher prices.
- But it is a benefit that those workers are also consumers too.
- And so there are additional spending power does help our economy.
- I think finding the balance as we sort of get to the tail end.
- Of those wage increases that passed way back in 2019 pre COVID.
- Um, we're sort of get the tail end of that now.
- Um, that we have to be thoughtful about going forward.
- Where of, of course, you want more people to earn more money for what they're doing, uh, but we also have to recognize that, uh, it's hard for those small businesses to deal with this rising cost.
- Anything to add, Liz? Look, I'm in favor of the minimum wage being increased.
- There has been wage stagnation, so there needs to be a rise to keep up with the economic times we're dealing with.
- Um, but hopefully, while I know it will cause some short-term pain for small businesses, it should lead to long-term gain for all involved.
- Um, and that's the perspective that I would maintain.
- Yeah.
- Um, okay.
- Let's, uh, move on to the financial markets.
- So Sean, you mentioned earlier that, uh, you know how closely Connecticut's economy is tied to, uh, to the financial markets.
- And, uh, you know, this is, uh, this is one of those things that I track on a regular basis for the work that we do for the podcast.
- You know, when I'm looking through the news headlines, I really pay attention to, uh, to this because, you know, if the market were to turn down consumer confidence in spending in Connecticut, particularly small businesses, will likely become much more discretionary, which could have a detrimental effect on the Connecticut economy of, uh, of, uh, as a whole.
- So, in fact, I'd put this probably near the top of the risk factor list.
- Would you agree? Yeah, I, I, I absolutely would.
- I, you know, like everyone, especially with the guy with a 401k, right? I, I love to see what's happening on the market.
- Um, but I also worry that this party's gonna end, uh, at some point.
- Not, not that I worry it's gonna, it is gonna end.
- We know that, right? Yeah.
- That's just economics.
- Um, I think as I mentioned, um, one of the smartest things we've done as a state is to wall off, uh, the money we get from the folks whose income is really tied to the market so that we're not dependent on that party to continue to pay our bills and to balance our budget.
- I think it's the smartest thing we've done in a very long time.
- Um, but as I mentioned, that khap economy, right, those consumers are driving most of the spending that's happening right now.
- And if they decide to, uh, slow that down because of the market slowing down, uh, then I think we really have to, you know, think about what that will mean for us in terms of not just the economy, but also our revenue as a state, right? Mm-hmm.
- We're reliant on income tax, sales tax, uh, just like a business is relied on, on what they rely on for their market share.
- So, um, i's something I watch very closely.
- You know, uh, I'm somebody who does believe that we're in dangerous territory with an AI bubble.
- And, uh, I think it's a matter of, of when, not if, and I just think that I'm trying to do everything I can to make sure the state is prepared for that by all accounts.
- If you trust the rating agencies, they said we needed 2 billion on hand to deal with this.
- We've got four, so we're in good shape.
- Um, but most small businesses in the state are not sitting on reserves like that.
- And hopefully the fact that we are, we'll protect them in some ways, uh, where we wouldn't have to raise taxes, we wouldn't have to cut spending for different programs.
- But it is something that I think we're gonna have to grapple with.
- I mean, hopefully it'll be a gradual escape of air from the balloon instead of a a pop.
- Um, you know, but like the weather, the market is, is completely uncontrollable.
- None of us have any control over.
- Yeah, over that.
- And this is similar to the risks that, you know, other risks that small businesses face.
- There's very little that they're in control of in their ecosystem.
- And the things that they are in control of can have a major effect on their performance.
- The volatility that we're seeing can be highly disruptive.
- And, uh, you know, what we tell small businesses is, is to anticipate potential disruption and to try to prepare for all potentialities.
- So with that in mind, what is the state doing to mitigate its own exposure to the market? I think you kind of touched on this a little bit, maybe you could expand and what more can you do to make the small business environment more stable and less volatile? Well, from a policy perspective, that volatility cap that I talked about, uh, you know, changing the way we account for, for the money from high earners that live in Fairfield County, but work in Manhattan, I think is, is the biggest thing.
- The, the second thing is I try to get out as much as I can from the office, at least a day or two a week, to go out and, and meet with small businesses, to meet with bigger businesses, to hear what's on their mind, you know, um, tariffs, I think, uh, the impact of them is less than we thought.
- I think mostly across the board.
- But I remember going to a large businesses in Connecticut that I, I won't name, because we had confidential conversations where they had drastically cut production because the costs of some of the goods that they needed to make their product had gone up.
- And that on again, off again, policy really hurt them.
- I, I'll give you another one.
- Um, I was at another really, really big company in Connecticut and, uh, the owner was somebody who is a supporter of the president and, and a Republican.
- Um, but he was telling me how much of a concern some of the immigration changes were for him, where they had had ice agents literally showing up at their warehouse, uh, and just taking people right off the line during the middle of his production schedule.
- Um, and he said, look, I agree with the president what he's trying to do, but the way he's doing it is, is hurting our business.
- And so, you know, not to get political with you guys, but I think that some of these policy changes do make an impact on these businesses and, and make the what is already a little bit of a cloudy picture, a little bit murkier for people and makes decisions harder.
- What I want your listeners to know though.
- Is that the state for the first time in a long time is in a good place so that the thing you don't have to worry about is Hartford being unpredictable.
- That was a problem for a very long time where no business owner knew what was gonna happen because we were just raising taxes.
- We were cutting spending, we were changing policy left and right.
- We've tried to make government predictable.
- It's one of the things I think this governor has done really, really well.
- I think it's the reason why he's very popular too, because he's brought predictability back to government and predictability is the single most important thing that any business owner wants to see from government, in my opinion.
- Yeah, absolutely.
- A hundred percent.
- That's, that's the, that's the key, I think, and that's what's creating a lot of the instability.
- The volatility, it's, uh, it's that, that unpredictability.
- So anything that can be done in that regard is definitely a, a huge plus.
- Um, okay.
- So we'll, uh, we'll move on to, uh, taxes.
- Uh, we talked about the one big beautiful act.
- Uh, you know, the OBBA, I guess it goes by, it's a double-edged sword for Connecticut.
- You mentioned this in your report, uh, we'll talk about it from the perspective of the state taxpayers may receive bigger refunds.
- We, we noted that before, but the state revenue now will be less.
- So how are you preparing for that potentiality? Yeah, anybody who wants to, you know, really nerd out, they can go to my website.
- We did a 40 page report on the big beautiful bill, and as I said at the time, uh, you know, there are definitely pros and cons of, of the bill and, uh, and pros and cons in terms of the, the impact on people here in Connecticut.
- Um, at the end of the day, I think we are prepared for the tax changes.
- It's gonna have an impact on us, specifically on the corporate tax, but, um, at the end of the day, I, I think we're in good shape and I don't an anticipate it's gonna have as big of an impact as it might for other states that not prepared for it.
- Yeah, that sounds great.
- And, um, in addition to the, uh, the, the, the new federal tax law, the, um, the state expended or, uh, expanded r and d tax credits for businesses, can you share some of the details of this new program? Yeah, so I, I think as a result of, um, you know, some of the, the big fiscal progress that we've made there, there's sort of a bipartisan consensus in Hartford right now that we should cut more taxes.
- Uh, a couple years ago, uh, the governor passed the biggest cut to the income tax in the history of that tax, uh, which is great.
- Um, there's a lot of tax proposals right now in the legislative session that just began about cutting taxes.
- And one of the things that he announced as part of his budget, uh, was that he wanted to restore, uh, the state's pass through entity tax, uh, which had been cut, uh, a number of years back.
- Um, and this is something that's gonna help about 120,000 small businesses in the state that utilize.
- Uh, you know, that form of a business registration, and I think it, it's projected to save about $60 million annually to these individuals.
- So it's a lot of people, it's a lot of money.
- Uh, and I think the fact that we can make these changes is a testament to the fact that we've gotten to a better place and we're now trying to shift the state from crisis mode to solving, uh, the, the, the thing that's really held us back in my entire lifetime of almost 40 years of our state is just an expensive state.
- And, and we haven't been in a position to make it less expensive.
- Now we finally are, and now I think it's incumbent on us to do that.
- Yep.
- Um, so talking about, uh, small businesses, uh, wallet Hub, perhaps you saw this.
- They released a report about the worst places to do business, and Connecticut was one of the highest on the list.
- The reasons that they cited were business environment, access to resources and high costs.
- In, in your opinion, do you think this is a fair characterization of our state? You know, I get in trouble for saying this all the time, but I, I don't think any of these reports mean anything.
- So even the ones that show us that we're the top three in, in something, right? I, I think you can never get too excited or never too bummed about what these reports are because the metrics are all different.
- I think what matters most is what I actually hear from small business owners.
- I think a lot of them like the fact that we've been more predictable.
- A lot of them love Connecticut and our quality of life that we have here, they just want it to be less expensive.
- And I think our central challenges, what can we do as a state? To attack some of those big cost drivers.
- To me it's really three.
- Um, yes, childcare we've talked about, that's a big one.
- But the three biggest things that I hear about is healthcare, housing, and energy.
- And I think we have a unique opportunity right now as a state to try to tackle those big three things and do it in a way that, uh, is not just, you know, putting together a blue ribbon panel that's gonna put out a report that makes everybody feel good or incremental solutions.
- I think it's time for us to be really big in bold.
- And I think that, um, if we can do that, um, we've got good things going for us.
- You know, most people don't realize this, but, um, this isn't a W Hub ranking.
- This is actual math, which is our GDP was the fourth highest in the country in the third quarter last year.
- We were the ninth highest in the, in the se in the second quarter of 20.
- 25.
- Right? Um, at the same time we have 70,000 unfilled jobs in the state.
- And so if we were to invest in things like workforce, if we were to make costs lower for people, if we can train that 70,000, our economy's gonna continue to see this really good GDP growth.
- 'cause we have a lot of good fundamentals.
- We just gotta drive the cost down.
- And that's something that I'm deeply involved in as the comptroller and trying to use my platform to talk about.
- I'll be, I'll go out on a limb here and I'll be a little bit, you know, controversial and say I did not agree with the wall hub assessment of Connecticut, particularly as it pertained to accessibility of resources.
- There's lots of government supported resources available for small businesses in the state, most of which are free to use.
- And my experience as a SCORE mentor, the awareness of these resources is very low across the state.
- Yeah.
- And even where there is awareness, the number of businesses taking advantage of these resources is also low.
- Uh, Connecticut's Department of Economic and Community Development in particular, does a great job of directing people to the appropriate resource partners.
- Again, the resources are there, but people have to go looking for them.
- So I'm wondering what more can be done to proactively get the word out to the small business community in Connecticut about the assistance that is available to them.
- So this is, this is our central challenge, right? And I learned this when I was a legislator.
- As a young guy, you pass a bill and you win an award and you pat yourself in the back and you think you've solved a problem.
- Nothing that you do actually matters unless the people who you're intending to do it for know about it and receive that benefit.
- And I think this is a big problem in government.
- Um, I tell this story all the time, I get kind of laughed at, but the first bill I ever introduced as a legislator was to create a genius bar.
- First of all, businesses, I don't know anything about technology.
- When your phone breaks, your computer breaks, you show up at the Apple store and there's a guy there that is not gonna redirect you to 10 different places.
- He's not gonna tell you all this stuff you don't need to know.
- He's gonna say, how can I solve your problem and fix what's wrong for you? And if I can't do it, I know somebody else who can.
- It's a one-stop shop to deal with whatever's wrong in your life.
- And when I was growing up, I saw my mom again, not a knock on her, but she didn't have a ton of education.
- She had never had a real career.
- After my parents divorced, she decided to start a small business.
- That's how she paid the bills.
- She had no idea how to navigate government.
- She had no idea what programs are out there.
- She wasn't reading politicians, newsletters and you know, reading the political news, she was just trying to stay above water.
- And I think I hear you that we gotta make it accessible to them, but I think we also have to go to them proactively to tell us what we're doing because they're too busy doing what they do best.
- We have to do what we do better.
- And I think, uh, you know, people laugh about the Genius Bar, but if my mom had one place to go when she got some letter from some, you know, bureaucrat saying, you know, your issue is wrong, or you have to do this, I just think we could improve the business climate in our state.
- And in some ways I try to be a human genius bar in the sense that I have this jack of all trades job and I, I put my personal cell phone on my website.
- I answer my own email directly and every time I speak to a Chamber of Commerce or a Rotary, I just tell people, if you have a problem and you don't know where to go, call me.
- And I wanna try to help you out.
- And I think we need to take that attitude more in government, not less.
- So.
- You are the genius bar, Sean, is That's what you're saying.
- I'm trying, man.
- I'm trying, I'm trying.
- And you're doing a great job of being transparent.
- Sean, anytime I've seen you in the public, you've always mentioned the same things, that the email is up, that the phone is on, and that you always make yourself available for Connecticut General public.
- And I know it can be difficult, um, but that's what people want.
- They want access to decis decision makers, and they wanna be able to voice their opinion.
- So to to know that they have that in you as our comptroller, uh, it means a lot.
- I did, I did want to jump in here on this segment and just mention, um, mention that I was fascinated by the Hartford Business Journal's economic outlook survey that was published last month.
- You know, earlier you mentioned that Connecticut had the fourth ranked highest, uh, GDP growth, and obviously there's a lot of positivity happening there, but I was fascinated by one of the questions I was asked in the survey.
- Um, and 47 per percent of the respondents, um, felt that Connecticut's economy was worse today than it was last year.
- And I'm like, but the numbers don't make sense.
- And numbers are headed in a positive direction, not in a negative direction.
- So what can you say to that? So my favorite way to answer that question is, um, is a phrase that was coined by somebody whose name is Kyla Scanlan, no relation to me.
- She's a Bloomberg reporter and she refers to that as the vibe session, right? Is the vibes for a lot of people are just off, right? People are just angry about things.
- They feel like their personal situation is worse than it is.
- Uh, people think the economy is worse than it is.
- And we sort of live in like a post-truth world, um, where there's no, uh.
- Universal agreement on facts anymore because we all get news from TikTok or from Bloomberg or from your uncle on Facebook.
- There's no control of that anymore.
- And so, um, some people think that's a good thing.
- Some people think it's a bad thing.
- But one thing that it is made worse is that if you were, um, alive in the 1960s, you would turn on your TV and you would get your news from Walter Cronkite and you would trust that Walter Cronkite told you the truth.
- But you may disagree about what Walter Cronkite talked about.
- And the, the genesis of our disagreements politically were a agreement on a fact or a problem, but a disagreement on how to approach it.
- Now we can no longer even agree on the facts of the problem.
- And each of us have for every wallet hub study.
- I could tell you five other studies that said we're good at something.
- Nobody believes anything anymore.
- And I think my central, uh, challenge here.
- Of being, uh, you know, in government in 2026 in this very partisan moment, is to try to just call balls and strikes and get people to trust that what I'm saying is not with a partisan lens.
- And that's very hard to do these days where the passions are very high on both sides.
- But my hope is that people can, again, find ways to trust, whether it's me, whether it's, uh, you know, a great news outlet like the CT mirror, which tries to just give this stuff, uh, you know, by the numbers.
- But we just have to get back to a place where we can agree on something and then perhaps disagree on that something.
- But, uh, we, we just have to get back to trying to find consensus on things that are.
- Impacting our world, if that makes sense.
- At the root of it, all we can say is there is a lot of noise.
- And you know, to Joe's credit, a year ago he brought the idea of this podcast, and that's exactly why this podcast exists, to filter through all the noise so that we can get to some common ground that will benefit all of us, specifically those in the small business ecosystem.
- So you hit the nail on the head for me and, and I'll go on record by saying that we are so bullish on Connecticut.
- There's obviously already a lot of great stuff happening here, but the future looks bright.
- for sure.
- Um, you know, with, uh, with technology in mind, you, you highlighted in your report the possibility of a jobless expansion driven by productivity and ai.
- You mentioned before the AI bubble.
- Yeah.
- There's a lot of talk about that, you know, what does that mean for small employers who rely more on people than technology? Well, my personal belief on this is that.
- No matter what happens with ai, there'll be massive economic disruption, either because their big bet on this will fail and they won't be able to do what they say they can do, or they can do what they say they can do and there will be disruption.
- I think it's probably gonna be a middle ground of both those things happening, where I think a lot of these bets will not pay off, but somebody will get it right and therefore there will be that disruption for both the markets and, uh, people.
- Um, you know, uh, I don't think there's much of a fear firm.
- Um, you know, a a, a storekeeper like my mom, you know, having workers replaced by ai because that's just not what AI's function's gonna be.
- The, the function is more on sort of the support systems for people like her, right.
- Um, you know, uh, different kind of, uh, ancillary products and, and different parts of the economy that I think will have a really big impact.
- Um, I, I would tell people that, um, you know, it's not something we can stop, like AI is here and it's gonna keep being here, and we need to learn to adapt to it.
- And there are things that can make your life easier with it.
- Uh, so I'm not somebody who's saying we have to kill the machines and, and, you know, go back to, you know, the way it was before.
- Um.
- In, in my office.
- You know, we don't use it for financial analysis.
- Um, we do use it for something like where, as I mentioned, we run this giant health plan, um, and CVS does all of our prescription drugs.
- They use it for the, the chat bot that talks to you either online or on the phone, and it can detect the tone of the person's voice and the vibes of that tenor so that the person, when they do get on the phone, they can be more immediately responsive to that person's needs.
- You know how you, you've been waiting on hold for 45 minutes.
- You get somebody from India on the phone, and all you want to do is just scream out loud, right? Um, this is to make that not be the case because we can detect from the tone of voice are, is this person scared? Have they had their prescription canceled and their kid is sick and they need to figure this out? And what we've seen is it allows us to be more compassionate and diligent in our care.
- So.
- I think there's good and bad uses of it.
- From my perspective, I don't run a small business, so I can't really say, but I do think that we just need to plan for this to have a bigger role in our lives going forward.
- Yeah, I think there's an order of magnitude issue here.
- Like you said, a lot of small businesses are not gonna replace labor and stuff like that, but you know, there are ways that small businesses, any small business can use it.
- And like you said before, like financial planning analysis, being one of them, you know, gaining some insights into your financial performance and things like that.
- Those are the things that I.
- Talk about with clients just to try to get, you know, just to introduce it, try to get 'em to, for sure.
- To give it a shot, you know, and, um, you know, so those are, we use it here at, at CICI mean the, we, we, we collect 500, 600 news articles a month.
- Well, we can't mentally process all of those.
- Yeah.
- So we, we ask AI to help us do that, and it does a magnificent job.
- So, you know, again, it's an order of magnitude.
- It's, you're not gonna replace your staff or, or have your, your business be completely run by a computer.
- But there's certain aspects of it that, again, we encourage people to explore and, and at least try to, you know, use it to help some, uh, with some productivity gains.
- So.
- All good stuff.
- Um, okay.
- So, uh, what else do we have, Lewis? Yeah, I'll close this out here with just a few questions on insurance and utilities.
- Sean, certain costs for small businesses have been rising dramatically.
- As you know, two of the highest are insurance and utilities, particularly electricity, but also oil and gas for heat.
- In your economic update report, you address both of these issues head on.
- Can you describe what the state is doing to address affordability of insurance and utilities? So on healthcare, um, the single biggest thing I think that we can do is something I'm working on with the governor right now.
- It's to create something called a Connecticut option.
- And basically the Connecticut option would allow small businesses and nonprofits to buy into a health insurance product that leverages what I'm already doing, running a 250,000 person health plan to give them access to affordable options.
- It's something I champion as a legislator.
- The insurance companies unsurprisingly, spent millions and millions of dollars to kill this.
- Um, but I think it's something that is really, really important.
- And you know, again, not to keep going back to my mom, but any small business owner, if you have five or six employees, you've got no leverage to get a good deal from any of the insurance carriers.
- And a lot of the insurance carriers, as you talked about earlier, don't even offer a small group coverage anymore, which is why a lot of them shifted to the exchange.
- I have leverage because I have 250,000 people.
- I have a billion dollar contract with Anthem.
- I have a $500 million contract with CVS.
- If I have a problem, I can call the CEOs of these companies on my phone.
- My mom couldn't even get a broker on the phone when she was a small business owner.
- So if we really want to maximize what we're already doing and that you're already paying for as a taxpayer.
- I think we should do that to, to lever this playing field.
- And it's something that the governor and I are, are working on trying to get done.
- Energy costs is complicated and the last thing that any politician should say is, this is hard.
- Feel bad for us.
- Right? The truth is we spent 30 plus years not investing in our energy infrastructure.
- And what is happening is we are getting our lunch eaten by other states that have done this.
- Right.
- And the simple problem in Connecticut is we don't have enough supply coming into our state.
- Um, everyone wants to move to renewables like solar, water, wind.
- That takes time.
- I think we should move to those things, but I also get in trouble with definitely people in my party by saying that we need a bridge to get us there.
- And to me, natural gas is that bridge to get us there.
- We gotta bring in more gas to this state that is the short term solution to lowering costs.
- If we can do that while simultaneously developing those renewables, we can get more supply into our grid and lower the cost of energy here in our state.
- We don't have 5, 10, 15 years to do that because people are getting killed by these costs right now.
- So I think we have to be realistic about this to have a two track approach of what can we do right now to lower these costs and what can we do in 15 years to have it be cleaner energy? But we can't just do the 15 year thing, which is kind of what we have been doing.
- Right.
- We're just focusing on the future and saying to people, hang in there.
- Nobody wants to hear hanging in there anymore because they just can't afford it.
- Yeah, agreed.
- And, and according to the economic update report, you mentioned regional energy transmission projects that could eventually ease some of these electricity prices.
- Is that relief meaningful for small businesses in the near term, or is that more of a long-term story at this point? Well, I, I think it is probably longer term, but I think there are examples of short term too, right? So 40% of our power in the state comes from Millstone, which is a nuclear energy plant in southeastern Connecticut.
- Um, millstone also exports power to other states that don't pay for it as part of what's called the power purchasing agreement.
- So everyone hates the public benefits charge.
- That's on your Eversource bill.
- Part of that charge is to pay for this power purchase agreement with Millstone.
- I'm not the governor, but if I was, I would say to those other states, Hey, there's no such thing as a free lunch anymore, buddy.
- You gotta start paying less for some of the power that we're generating, right? And if you're not gonna pay us, then we're gonna turn off the hose.
- Right? That's not a hard thing to do.
- That's uncomfortable.
- Um, but I think we have to get uncomfortable.
- The status quo is not working.
- We can't just do the same thing over and over again.
- And, uh, you know, no offense to Massachusetts or New Hampshire, but I don't want to pay for some dude's electrical bill up there.
- Uh, if I'm paying for it here in Connecticut, he should be paying for the energy that we are generating here in Connecticut.
- Just like we're paying for the water that comes down through the pipelines from Canada, through New Hampshire, through Maine.
- So I just think, um, short term, could we renegotiate that? Get some stuff? Yeah, I think we could.
- But longer term, developing those things, it'll take time.
- But I think if we're doing both, it's a good thing to do.
- Is there any optimism in 2026 for that negotiation to actually come to fruition? Or is this more still sort of an idea that needs to be fully vetted out? I.
- Well, I would civically say yes in the sense that 2026 is an election year, so there's a motivation by politicians to, uh, to try to figure this out.
- But I, I think, um, the, the big solutions to this, the real ones that aren't just BS for a campaign bumper sticker or a commercial are gonna take some time and they're hard.
- I think voters reward elected officials who tell them the truth and tell them it's hard and don't just say, I've solved every problem, or This is easy.
- Or they distract them by saying, let's just do this and let's just get rid of the public benefits charge.
- Yeah, of course I would love to do that, but we can't just do that tomorrow.
- It's gotta be something that we do thoughtfully over time.
- And I just think that people more and more reward people for kind.
- Giving it to 'em straight and thinking outside the box than they do just looking for short term solutions.
- So I wish that I could tell your listeners that we're gonna solve this in 2026.
- I think that that's probably unlikely.
- I think what needs to happen though is that we start the process of solving it.
- Yeah, I think the general audience needs to understand that these conversations are difficult, but they need to be had, and I think you should be applauded, um, for your honesty and your transparency.
- And just like you mentioned, you have to have straight conversations with your constituents and you have to be willing to have those difficult conversations.
- All right.
- Two closing questions for you.
- Where do you see the biggest opportunities for state policy to help small businesses manage rising costs in areas like healthcare, real estate, and workforce development? Well, healthcare, we just talked about.
- So I'll, I'll skip that one.
- We'll, we'll go to, uh, workforce.
- I am a big believer that college is great, um, but it's not for everybody.
- And I think we do a disservice to a lot of people by prioritizing higher education over things like trades, the technical schools.
- Um, you know, when I go to a tech school in Connecticut, every kid is amped and psyched to be there.
- If you go to a K through 12 school, you know, there's kids like sleeping on the desk, there's kids like doing stuff, right? It's not a knock on them, it's just that it's not for everyone.
- Um, last year we had 10,000 applications for the tech school system, and we could only take 2000 kids, which means that we turned down 8,000 kids who made a choice to say, you know what, I don't want to go read.
- The Scarlet letter and learn advanced, you know, math that I'm never gonna use.
- I wanna learn how to wealth, right? Um, I think we have to find a way to, uh, in include more of those people that have that goal.
- There's also 11,000 kids that graduate high school in Connecticut every year that do not go on to college.
- I think we should send every one of those kids a letter that says, Hey, congratulations, you just graduated from high school.
- It's a big deal.
- If you don't have a plan for what you're gonna do now and you're not gonna join the military, come be a firefighter in Connecticut.
- Here's a link to a class.
- You can do that.
- Go be a cop.
- Learn to be an electrician.
- All these tools that we can just hand to people, again, not just create a program and expect that maybe they're gonna find their way to the free community college program that we set up.
- No, life doesn't work like that.
- You gotta go to people.
- And I think if we can do that and build the next generation of the workforce at the same time that we re-skill and retrain the existing labor market workforce, that is not.
- Able to find, uh, meaningful employment, we can really, really make a big deal on that.
- Um, real estate is, is a tough one in the sense that, you know, there was a big housing bill that the legislature and the governor passed last year.
- Very, very controversial.
- Um, I think there's more scary rhetoric about it than it actually is a scary bill.
- The truth of the matter is we don't have enough housing to meet the housing needs of the state.
- And a lot of people get scared and spooked by the term affordable housing.
- But in a town like Guilford where I live, that really means that our cops and firefighters and teachers, or me, when I got outta college, can afford to live somewhere and not be living in your parents' basement.
- Right.
- And I think if we don't get that right, um, we're not going to be friendly for businesses.
- EB just said that they make submarines in southeastern Connecticut.
- They're gonna hire 7,000 people this year.
- That's insane.
- Right? That's awesome.
- But it's also insane in the sense that there is not anywhere near the housing stock for us to meet those needs.
- And so we need to get this right.
- We need to look at zoning, uh, we need to work with towns to rezone places.
- We need to help towns clean up brownfield.
- So, you know, I go to all these communities in Connecticut where there's these giant abandoned factories, right? There's tons of PFAS, there's tons of stuff below those buildings.
- But if we get rid of that chemical, we, we, we treat that, we clean that up.
- There's so much potential for us to develop land.
- Everyone worries that we're gonna build these giant housing projects.
- It's not about that.
- It's about finding existing land that is not fitting a purpose anymore and rezoning it to meet the needs of 2025, not 1925.
- And I think if we do all these things together, um, you know, you said Louis, like you're bullish on Connecticut, like.
- I'm super bullish on Connecticut and I want my kids to inherit a better state than the one that I inherited.
- And I think if we start really solving these problems and not just kicking the can, I think Connecticut is gonna have a really, really great next 10 years, 20 years, and we need to as someone who's the product of the technical school system, I'm so impressed by how far the educational system has come and really how well positioned they are to essentially be the funnel for the next skilled labor workforce coming through our great state.
- So a lot of great work happening there, and I'll be watching to see how far along we continue to come.
- All right.
- Last question.
- If you had to leave small business owners with one risk to watch and one opportunity to season 2026, what would they be? Well, the easy answer to that with the risk is just the economy, right? What, what happens in the markets, does their.
- You know, do we see a recession? Do the jobs numbers sort of continue to, to struggle a little bit? Um, my opportunity is this.
- Um, you know, I, uh, I, I try very hard, as I said, to try to restore people's faith in government.
- And that's not an easy project to undertake these days because they see things on the news and they're just disgusted by politics.
- And not a day goes by where somebody doesn't ask me like, how can you stand to do this, uh, for a job? And the honest answer is, 'cause I think I can make things better.
- And I think that Connecticut can get better, and I want to be a part of that for a short period of time.
- I'm not gonna be 80 years old and be the comptroller, I promise you that.
- Uh, but for this limited period of time that I have this really big gift of, of serving the state, I, I want to do it well, but I can't do it unless we hear from people.
- Um, and I think the message that I would have to the business owners about what's an opportunity is.
- Get to know your local business, uh, you know, community, but, but also get to know your mayor, your state rep, your whatever, uh, and, and try to get them to understand your needs and try to have them help you with it.
- And if they aren't helping you with it, run against them.
- Right? This is what democracy is all about.
- People need to use their voice and if their voice is not being heard, they can change the system.
- And so for as much as it's a dispiriting time, it's very frustrating.
- Um, you gotta make sure people are hearing your perspective and government will be better off if they do hear that perspective.
- So don't assume that, uh, just because you read an article in the paper about a bill, that that bill is gonna die because of common sense.
- That's not how politics works, right? So always use your voice, get in touch with people, and I go back to the Genius Bar.
- You can go on my website right now and find my cell phone number and text me or shoot me any email and if I can ever do anything to help you guys.
- Or any of your clients or any of the businesses that are gonna listen to this, just reach out and help us, help you make this state better.
- Thank you, Sean.
- You know, a wise old man once told me, if you don't ask, you don't get.
- And that is so true, especially in today's times.
- So to close this out, I wanted to thank you for joining us on the Small Business Intelligence Podcast.
- We know you're really, really busy, so we appreciate you taking the time to share your insights.
- Especially on Connecticut's economic outlook.
- Your leadership in promoting fiscal responsibility and long-term sustainability is critical to strengthening our small business ecosystem here in the great state of Connecticut.
- So thank you again for being part of the discussion.
- We're grateful for your leadership, and we look forward to continuing the dialogue.
- Well, it's great to be on guys, and I look forward to coming back and, uh, listen to your last episode.
- There was some Super Bowl talk, lot of, lot of bullish talk on the Patriots, uh, as, as a, as a New York sports fan.
- Just wanna say, uh, how'd that work out for you? But, uh, best of luck next year well played Sean.
- There is a bright spot in the Patriot's future and I'm here for all of it.
- So, uh, Joe, any last thoughts for you as a fellow New Yorker? I.
- Uh, well the only thing I was gonna say is, uh, you know, I used to be a, a Patriots fan until Bob Kraft Welch on the deal to bring him to Hartford, and ever since then I've been a Patriots hater, so yeah, I'm true blue to Connecticut.
- There you go.
- All right guys, thanks for having me up.
- Thanks Ryan.
- Alright, take care.
- Be sure to sign up for Comp Controller Scanlon's monthly economic update report via his website@osc.ct.gov.
- If you wish to understand more about how the economy and businesses work, read this report.
- It's well worth the investment of time keeping abreast of the economic changes taking place in your state.
- The New England region and beyond is a competitive advantage for entrepreneurs.
- In times like this, information produces the knowledge that business executives, particularly small business owners, need to develop forward looking strategic intelligence that will enhance the value of your business.
- You can follow Community Investment Corporation on social media and direct questions or comments to us about this podcast via our website@ciclending.com.
- And that'll be it.
- That sound good, Louis? Yep.
- Perfect.