Latest / Markets to Menus by ArrowStream / Midterms, Menus, and 2027
Transcript
- speaker-0: What we've seen is that the consumer remains resilient. They're continuing speaker-1: spend. speaker-0: more so than we had thought. Numbers aren't going gangbusters, and that's part of the reason why we're consuming. speaker-1: Concerned about twenty twenty seven. All of the that speaker-0: The sales increase. speaker-1: we're seeing over the last few months has come from price increases again, which is as you know, is completely unsustainable, right? But there might be speaker-0: Consumers are holding in, they're still spending. speaker-2: Welcome back to Markets to Menus. I'm your host, David Maloney. We've got a big episode as John Goodwin, Aerostream senior commodity analyst, as always, joins me to unpack the markets, including the latest on the Strait of Her Moods, one election that is already impacting the commodity markets, and tightening chicken supplies. Then, Michael Hainland, senior restaurant analyst at Bloomberg, sits down with us to discuss the outlook for the consumer. And the food service industry heading into 2027. This episode is sponsored by Aerostream Commodity One, matching over four decades of expertise with Deep Learning AI to deliver the best commodity intelligence forecasts and contract management opportunities in the food supply chain. Here we go. As we talked about a big week just this week alone, folks, midterms. We get October's jobs data, lots of quarterly earnings happening this week. And then, by the way, we have Iran U. S, right? This conflict. But the markets still softened last week. All right. Aero Stream Commodity Index was down 1.7% from the prior week to a four month low, still up a half percentage point year on year. Grains were lower across the board. Soybean meal declined for four consecutive weeks. Soy oil has been down three of the last four weeks and is near an eight month low. In dairy, September milk output was 2.7% better than last year. So, in other words, strong milk supplies continue. And by the way, the milk cow herd expanded substantially in September to its biggest level since 1993. Markets were mostly lower last week, including weakness in the cheese blocks, which we've been looking for, and we anticipate more of that in the near term. Whey and nonfat dry milk, as we have discussed in prior episodes, due to their protein content, still historically high. In pork, output up 0.2% last week, week on week, up a half percent year on year, year to date, down a tenth of a percentage point. Markets were lower across the board. Check this out. 12% decline last week alone in bellies, not to be outdone. 20% decline last week in the pork. Trim markets. Give you perspective, folks. Belly markets have not traded at these levels for a sustained period of time. And we're talking about how low they are right now for a sustained period of time since 2015. In chicken, bird slaughter last week, down 0.4% week on week, down 2.9% year on year. Prior week was down 3.4% year on year. And we're going to talk about these tightening chicken supplies further in a moment. The markets were mixed, almost all of them lower, except for tenders and leg quarters, which were higher. And check this out, folks. In October, there was a record premium in the boneless, skinless thigh market to the boneless, skinless breasts. And we talked about that in prior episodes. How the dark meter, the back half of the bird, has been holding more value this year. And beef output was. Even with the prior week last week, down 1.8% from the same week last year. Year to date, down 4.9%. That's due to cattle's year-to-day cattle slaughter being lower by 7.1%. The choice box beef cutout, or think index of choice box beef prices and the select cutout, same for select, as well as domestic trim markets, all lower. All of the beef primals were lower. Except for ribs, which is not abnormal for this time of the year. The international trend markets ticked higher. And this despite the Trump suspension of the tariffs on low quota countries. Energy, crude oil was higher, highest weekly close we've seen since March last week. Gasoline actually has been softer as of late, but still up $1.23 year on year. And diesel prices. Have been firm and trading near record highs and up over $2.60 a gallon year on year. So, John, near record diesel prices, which reminds us all that the Strait of Hermuz remains a choke point in the Middle East, right? What's going on there? speaker-3: Yeah, so just a lot of uncertainty. Crude's obviously been able to rally it quite a bit over the past couple of weeks just based off rumors and reports alone, with the midterms behind us now. The market's, I guess, not really sure. it's been rallying on the idea that the US Iran war will pick back up once the midterms are over and done with. But there's also the chance that Iran's just been waiting until after the midterms to return to the negotiating table and all these reports that we've been seeing about moves to pick up the strikes again have just been posturing in preparation for Iran to return to said negotiating table. So a lot of uncertainty, a lot of risk, because if we do if it is the former, if we do return to war, pick up strikes again, we're in a much tighter situation domestically than we were back in March when the war first started. crude oil stocks, gasoline stocks all have been setting, I think twelve year seasonal lows. for multiple weeks at this point. Distillet stocks have been setting all time, I think all time seasonal lows for multiple weeks now. So needless to say, all three are in really tight positions and not really going to slow down the buying if we do start striking again. speaker-2: Yeah. So speaking of risks, we've been talking a lot about risks in the chicken markets. Last week, folks, Pilgrim's Pride, which is our nation's second largest chicken producer, reported their Q3 2026 fiscal earnings. Their operating income was down 60% from the same quarter last year. And that really highlights how challenging it's been for these chicken producers over the last several months with these. Low chicken prices to give you some perspective on some of these low chicken prices. October average for boneless, skinless chicken breast, second lowest for any October since 2020. Wings, second lowest for any October and over a decade, not to be outdone. Chicken tenders, lowest for any October and over a decade. And we are seeing that producers are closely managing supplies, as they would say. Give you perspective. August output, and this is really indicative of the months leading up to for most of this year. August output was up 3.3% year on year. Folks, that's a really big number. I mentioned earlier those weekly numbers are tracking 3% below chicken supplies, 3% below. Those numbers are estimates, and I have more confidence in the monthly numbers. We give you perspective September chicken output down 1.2% year on year. It was the strongest decline, year over year decline for any comparable same production day months in over three years. Okay. So obviously these producers are curtailing supplies or slowing supplies or slowing growth at a minimum, right? And you accompany this with record consumption and no F, fans, or buts as we get in this winter, the risk in these markets is to the upside. So speaking of upside john, or actually the opposite of that, we got a surprise election result in agricultural superpower Brazil almost two weeks ago, which significantly impacted their currency. What's going on there? speaker-3: Yeah, Brazilian Real's value in dollars really took a hit after the runoff election. So after the first round of the presidential elections, it seemed like Bolsonaro was doing a lot better than everyone expected, which gave the Real a boost. But then fast forward a month and the Real took a huge hit. I mean and wiped out all those gains and then some as a result of Lula da Silva's victory. And that's pretty important. Two reasons. we have a lot of commodities that we import from Brazil. They're the world's largest exporter of coffee, sugar, beef, pork, chicken, bunch of others, soybeans, second biggest exporter of corn. And for commodities we heavily import from Brazil, like coffee and sugar, a weaker real tends to incentivize export selling down south. So it helps supplies here in the US, bearish for prices here in the US. On top of that, for commodities that we compete with Brazil in terms of exports like corn and soybeans, Real makes Brazilian exports more competitive on the international market. So again, bearish for prices here at stateside, the more competitive Brazilian corn and soybeans are, the less export selling we're seeing here in the US. So no matter how you slice it, it's it's put some pressure on a number of different commodity sectors here in the US over the past few weeks. And it's definitely something So watch going into twenty twenty seven. speaker-2: All right, Mike, welcome to the show. Tell us a little bit about yourself. speaker-0: Yeah, I'm the senior restaurant and food service analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence. I've been in the markets for 27 years, first as a prop trader and running prop trading desk. speaker-1: And more recently, you know, the last 15 plus years speaker-0: Fifty years. speaker-1: as an equity analyst, most of those as a restaurant analyst. I've also called it covered other. speaker-0: areas of consumer, but primarily restaurants. I cover nineteen as well as go. I liken it to speaker-1: and publicly traded restaurant companies as well as so in US foods and the peanut gallery for publicly traded restaurant chains. I'm writing about how we think they can improve their sales and margins and who has the best opportunities there. And given our two cents in terms of, you know, which names are good and which names may be looking at some tougher times coming up. speaker-2: So I was just thinking that it was a couple of years ago that you and I met, but it wasn't. So it happens when we're getting older, buddy, right? I think that was 2018 that you and I first met at a conference out in Sun Valley, Idaho. yeah. So speaker-1: Great conference. speaker-2: yeah, great conference. And the reason I bring that up is it occurred to me when you were talking, I don't know how you got into covering restaurants. speaker-0: Luck. It was luck. When I left the trading business, I wore a lot of hats, right? speaker-1: I I was a trader, I trained guys, I did hiring, PNL, risk management, I mean you named it, but I loved investing speaker-0: I really loved trading. I really loved speaker-1: and speaker-0: what I felt was a hole in my skill set was funding and my younger brother who had but speaker-1: Mental research. speaker-0: had quit a couple of years before I change was working at speaker-1: look to make the change. I was working at an equity research shop named Sudotti and he was doing well and he got me a job there. And the DOR Marie Conway, she was great. She was like, We do really well in consumer. We really like you. We want you to speaker-0: Think of speaker-1: an area in consumer where you think we speaker-0: w that you'd like to cover. To me it was restaurants. my mom's a phenomenal Italian cook. We live to eat. I love restaurants and as a trader speaker-1: And they were volatile. So to me they were exciting. Unfortunately at the time your restaurant analyst restaurant restaurant small cap restaurant names to go around. So I started with health and wellness. speaker-0: And then then a year later. speaker-1: Our restaurant analyst left and Marie Conway decided to give me all of the restaurant names. So I think it was speaker-0: Just fake. speaker-2: Yeah. Cool. And your Italian mother, I'm sure, is power out. speaker-0: For sure. I give her a lot of credit. I come from speaker-1: along line of O C D Italians, not really OCD, but like my mom growing up, she'd be clean in the house all day long. You know what I mean? And yeah, my uncle super neat and clean and organized. And I out speaker-0: Credit a lot. speaker-1: of that to my success in the business. Right. I have a lot of pride in my work and I'll work on a model until it's right. Right. Like good enough is not in my vocabulary. So speaker-2: Yeah. Well, great. Well, you've been a leading voice in this industry now for quite a while and always have enjoyed it, whether it's your written work, your TV or radio, right? Thanks, man. Yeah, my pleasure. So Mike and I were talking offline and I changed up the whole question outline thing on him, but he's a pro, so I'm not worried about it, right? But what I really want to start is the consumer. And folks, the idea of this this part of this podcast is to dive into what Mike thought process on the consumer and the restaurant industry. And we're even going to talk a little bit about distribution as he covers a little bit of distribution for 2027. So the consumer seems challenged. We've got elevated fuel prices. We've got interest rates rising now, right? The restaurant industry, there's been a lot of talk about challenges with the consumer, including some very big names. What's going on there, Mike? speaker-0: They've been surprisingly resilient. Coming into the year, there were some easier comparisons, right? the administration threw a lot. speaker-1: of sand in the gears in the economy last year. Well yeah, whether it be the tax announcements. speaker-0: Government shutdown, whatever it was. And so we were kind of bullish coming into the year, bullish speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: I think, than most. We kinda changed course. speaker-1: When the war broke out and then again when the war ex speaker-0: Accelerated, right? Because that caused oil prices to spike, other soft commodity prices to spike, cause interest to higher, speaker-1: Which goes from interest rates high speaker-0: right? And but what we've seen is that the consumer remains resilient. They're continuing to speaker-1: Band. speaker-0: more so than we had thought. Numbers aren't going gangbusters, and that's part of the reason why we're speaker-1: concerned about twenty twenty seven. All of the sales increase speaker-0: Increase. speaker-1: that we're seeing over the last few months has come from price increases again, which is, as you know, is completely unsustainable, right? But speaker-0: Consumers are holding in, they're still spending right now. Unfortunately, they're dipping into savings in a lot of cases to pay for it, but they're still spending. speaker-2: And you're always good in your reports showing some charts and metrics around how those consumers are doing. Is there anything that stands out to you right now? speaker-0: There's nothing that's flashing red in terms of the economic indicators that we watch. Two that are like heavily weighted to a proprietary model that we created. One of them speaker-1: real income that continues to decline because of the CPI and the higher energy costs largely has been impacting that. And we also continue to see auto loans. speaker-0: Delinquencies to kinda tick a little bit higher. It's not hockey stick at a fast rate, but it's those are two that are pretty heavily speaker-1: Higher thinking it's not going up inching higher. So our model that we're keeping a close eye on. But next speaker-0: year, a lot of what we do for our companies, as well as when we're looking at the economy, is looking at base effects, right? And it's looking at how results were the year. speaker-1: prior and how that's impacting the following speaker-0: gonna impact the speaker-1: years growth and inflation and all that stuff. So speaker-0: All right. speaker-1: we've had some really strong numbers throughout this year, economic numbers. We had incredible growth speaker-0: Incredible DPS growth. speaker-1: in the S P in the second quarter, a lot of it fueled by the AI boom, which is kind of unwinding right now. speaker-0: In the second quarter, we're gonna have to speaker-1: That fifty two percent earnings growth. It's an speaker-0: Right? that's speaker-1: uncompable number. When we have some really strong, especially February and April, there's a few months that were very strong economically here in twenty twenty six that we're gonna have here. And it's concerning for the economic numbers that we're gonna get next year. speaker-2: Okay. So on a scale of one to ten today, and we'll dive into twenty seven a little bit more in a minute, but ten being the best, how would you rate the consumer? speaker-0: Man, I haven't done this before, David. So it's tough. I mean, where they are right now, maybe like a six. Okay. So not coming from very strong footing, that could get a lot there. So higher income consumers are have speaker-1: And we're concerned that worse from there, right? speaker-0: assets, right? So through this inflationary period, they own assets that are speaker-1: appreciating and have appreciated, right? So they can withstand the higher inflation. The low income consumers continue speaker-0: To be strapped and the middle income so speaker-1: Consumers as well. speaker-0: there were some economic data points that supported their spending a little bit this year. speaker-1: Low income consumer hiring was up and down then was speaker-0: Some of the data around them was speaker-1: maybe not as bad as some people thought it might have been coming into the year. speaker-0: But again, all of these economic improvements just add up to a harder speaker-1: comparison to lab next year. Uh-huh. speaker-2: So is it the same story for restaurants? it seems to me that there seems to be a widening spread between the winners and the losers. What do you see in the industry right now? speaker-1: Yeah, we've seen it. speaker-0: For a couple years, and we don't expect it to stop because people are more discerning with their dollars. Even we're hearing at higher-end restaurants where people are making sure they're not wasting their money on a bad experience, right? So when they have a good experience, they go back to that place, right? So when it's time to go out to eat on a Friday night, if when people are being more discerning, they're gonna go to a place that they have historically had a great experience, they get a lot of value, speaker-1: Pay for the money. speaker-0: right? And they're gonna go there because They don't want to leave that place spending a hundred and fifty dollars for a family of three and being like, that was speaker-1: Totally not worth it. Right. speaker-0: So you continue to see this divergence between that are winning chains that are losing. And it's been really interesting that the casual dining last almost two years have outperformed quick service by so much. Right. speaker-1: Right. speaker-0: But starting with chilies and getting back to the roots and what made it such a in the first place and nailing doing a great job with the market. speaker-1: And really some great branding the operations and then doing marketing and then now you see speaker-0: Chains like Cheesecake Factory kinda. speaker-1: lean more they've always but you see them lean more in speaker-0: Always had great operations into the marketing and talking about the value on the plate there. And these chains are doing a good job of getting in younger, speaker-1: Getting in some young speaker-0: more affluent customers, right? Whereas the quick service names are struggling. They continue to have large exposure to low, middle, well. And speaker-1: Middle income consumers who are aren't doing as well. speaker-0: it's a struggle. speaker-1: value in it anymore, right? Chicken selling a ten ninety nine. Right now it's a ten ninety nine fried chicken sandwich. speaker-0: That's significantly larger than QSR. speaker-1: Our chicken sandwiches and it comes with and and that speaker-0: unlimited chips and a drink and it's a better deal than you're gonna get at some of these quick service players and continues to be for the speaker-1: It can be a struggle with quick service chains. speaker-2: Yeah, it seems like the value equation has become cloudy, right? It seemed that before there was a sharp separation and not anymore, right? And it's interesting. What's surprised you so far in two thousand twenty six as far as the restaurant industry? speaker-0: That's a good speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: I don't know. I think we were pretty on point coming into this year. What surprised me is what I mentioned is that the consumer has continued to spend despite speaker-1: paying four dollars in change for a gallon of gas. speaker-0: Right. speaker-1: We really haven't seen that eat into restaurants spending as much as we would have thought. speaker-0: And historically gas prices and oil prices don't have a mess. speaker-1: Masiv impact. speaker-0: But they do when they spike. I mean, yeah, we saw oil almost double, right? Gasoline prices skyrocketed. So that was the biggest surprise that people kind of absorbed it and could Being said, traffic continues to decline, right? same source sales. speaker-1: Dining was up what was it up? A couple of percent in September. Same s couple of percent in September. Traffic speaker-0: In September But price was up four and speaker-1: was down too, right? And yeah. It's just not a sustainable situation in the long term. But we've seen a lot of that. especially from QSR. And that's the big problem, QSR. You mentioned it. They really lost speaker-0: That value equation lost that price gap. speaker-1: to casual dining, which safe speaker-0: Made them kinda the same speaker-1: haven when restaurant sales were weak. speaker-2: Yeah. And I think, at least from my perspective, it's become incredibly difficult to provide that value equation in this labor inflation environment. But I'm also reminded how gritty and how creative the restaurant industry is, right? For sure. And I'm pretty confident the industry will figure this out. So as we look to two thousand twenty seven for the restaurant industry, you talked about Some concerns. What are those concerns? speaker-0: be repeating a lot of the stuff we talked about. It's like number one, it's the economy's gonna slow, right? So people start to hear that or see it. speaker-1: T V on the news or when they're reading online and reading their news online and things. speaker-0: Things that nature could force them maybe a little bit, right? Because economic speaker-1: Or motivate to maybe pull back a little, right? speaker-0: Cause decline in the stock market, right? Which we could see there's some issues here. We're seeing credit spreads credit, right? speaker-1: We're seeing widen here for private right. There's really concerns now about the AI, right? Decline in is speaker-0: my bubble bursting. Right. So if we see stock market prices speaker-1: in crypto, right? You might see the high income consumer moves remain strong start to pull back, right? speaker-0: And it's less so for the restaurant industry, but speaker-1: In terms of consumer spending, the high income consumers make up a disproportionate amount of that spending compared to the percentage of the population here in the United States. And so speaker-0: They start pulling back. speaker-1: spending economic gets worse and it kind of feeds on itself, right? So low speaker-0: income consumers continue to struggle. We got middle income consumers dipping into their savings, continue to on their lifestyles, pricing increases, fueling same source sales while traffic declines year speaker-1: Mind you. speaker-0: after year. Like all of these things are not speaker-1: sustainable. And so we think they can come to a head here in the first half twenty seven. speaker-2: Is there something that could change? I'm with you. I struggle to see this economy, higher interest rates, higher fuel prices. Is there something that could change, maybe that would surprise us for twenty seven with the economy? speaker-0: I would love to see the end of the Iran and Ukraine wars, right? I mean Yeah. The reacceleration of those wars really caused this last gas price spike and interest rate spike and I'm pretty anti war A and B that's what would speaker-1: help this economy and no doubt about it. speaker-0: Right, we would see when we thought the Iran war speaker-1: Yeah. speaker-0: basically all of the oil price appreciation speaker-1: from sixty to a hundred and change. speaker-0: went away. It went dipped right back to the sixties, which probably shouldn't have happened because supplies had been pretty it happened, right? So the lowest which is very speaker-1: drawn down significantly, but right now we're since maybe nineteen eighty two, very concerning for oil prices and what that can do to the economy. So speaker-0: Yeah, I think the end of these wars would speaker-1: be a nice benefit for the consumer, man. middle income consumers, you know, they live on fixed budgets. speaker-0: Especially low and they don't live like us. David's budget and when gasoline prices go from three to that impacts their budget and how much they spend speaker-1: Before, right? Restaurants. speaker-2: So summary, what's your best case scenario maybe for restaurants in twenty seven in some sort of metric? And what do you think likely scenario is? speaker-0: Man, that's tough. It's tough for me to say, but we expect a pretty significant We'll see. best case scenario is you have a much more mild winter and get some gain in maybe first speaker-1: war ends and we can gains here in the first quarter and maybe the speaker-0: half. That's not necessarily our base case. People see the first quarter of twenty six hours, surprisingly, speaker-1: Spent in the first twenty six at restaurants so speaker-0: even though the weather was so bad. So it's not like a really easy it's supposed to be a more mild winter because they'll need so we'll see what happens. It should be more speaker-1: Right. Z comp I think more pattern. So mild, so that should help restaurants, but that's not our base case. speaker-0: But for the reasons we outlined. speaker-2: Yeah, and folks, I would tell you the last two years Mike's nailed it. So he's worth it. Yeah. So as we think about the food supply chain as a whole, distribution, we were talking offline. You said there it's distribution's become more attractive for investors lately. What's going on there? speaker-0: Yeah, so as I mentioned, I cover Cisco and US Foods. US Foods is a really company. They have a pretty big percentage of their healthcare account. speaker-1: business it goes to accounts, government education accounts, right? Which are not likely speaker-0: Impacted typically speaker-1: by economic downturns, right? So more defensive name. It's a very well run company and speaker-0: We're starting to see that bit up now and I think it's because it's a speaker-1: net safer play than restaurants. So you're starting to see some of these food service distribution teams outperform. speaker-0: Cisco, a smaller percentage of their business goes to the government education, healthcare accounts, but they made a huge acquisition. So they're top speaker-1: Position of restaurant depot and so line growth and margin expansion good here once deal speaker-0: That speaker-1: closes. So and speaker-0: I think investors are looking at that. speaker-1: saying we're gonna be looking at strong top and bottom line growth for this name. A s per percentage of their business is speaker-0: smaller but still a is pretty speaker-1: insulated versus economic downturns and this might be speaker-0: A pretty good place to play. So we're we're seeing some buying into staples. speaker-1: Consumer names which investors consider these food service distribution companies. speaker-2: And one might think that these elevated fuel prices, obviously they're operating a lot of trucks, would hurt them, but my understanding a lot of those times that's a pass through, right? Through fuel surcharges. speaker-0: Yes, sir. They have a lot of fixed cost, fixed percentage, fixed speaker-1: And speaker-0: price contracts, right? So when their costs go up, whether it be for fuel or for inputs, they're automatic price pass. Protect when inflation speaker-1: The food input our contracts allow for pass throughs monthly, right? So it's them. So when speaker-0: rises, their margins decline, but their profit dollar speaker-1: Don't take a hit. speaker-2: Interesting. So as we wind down, like we were talking about the winners and the losers, it seems to be a wider basis in the restaurant industry. If you were to tell an operator today, like, hey, starting next week, these are the things you need to start thinking about. Like this is what's working. What would you tell them? speaker-0: I mentioned it earlier, but what's working is providing your customers a really good experience, giving them good value for the money. And then with the chains that we cover, it's about speaker-1: And then it's marketing. speaker-0: right. And it's in that order, right? Like you have to get your operations nailed perfect before you speaker-1: And per start marketing and getting more people in the door. speaker-0: Right, because if you don't get the operations right, people come and they have a bad experience. speaker-1: And then now they're not coming back. Right. So speaker-0: About nailing the operations, making sure you're giving people good value for the money. And what's value? Value is what you get for what you pay, right? So if I have Texas Roadhouse, they drive in traffic speaker-1: Keep tracking traffic. speaker-0: year after year after year. Why? Like the services are phenomenal, right? Like they seat you with speaker-1: Phenomenal. Form rolls. speaker-0: their appetizer comes like almost immediately after you order. speaker-1: Right. speaker-0: The servers do a phenomenal job, right? And you get a lot of food for what you pay, right? So people. keep going back, right? They have a good experience to say, I'm not gonna risk this new place. I'm gonna keep going back to Texas Roadhouse because every time I go, they nail it. So it's not rocket science, but it's hard to do. Yeah. I speaker-1: Man, it's you know, speaker-0: mean, especially to your point like about the labor market. speaker-1: and how much turnover we've seen in the industry over the last few years. And if you don't have the the general manager and the teams in place, it's not easy to accomplish, right? But it's basic blocking and tackling, man. speaker-2: Yeah. Well, bringing you back to your college football days, right, Mike? For sure. Yeah. All right. Well, Mike, I want to thank you for being on the show. speaker-0: Thanks for having me, David. speaker-2: That's a wrap on another great episode of Markets to Menus. Thanks for listening. And also thanks to John Goodwin for joining me to break down the markets and to Michael Halen for the food service outlook heading into 2027. If you found this episode helpful, please subscribe, leave us a review, and share it with your network. A reminder that Markets to Menus is sponsored by Aerostream Commodity One, matching over four decades of expertise with deep learning AI to deliver the best commodity intelligence forecast. And contract management opportunities in the food supply chain. I'm David Maloney. We'll see you next time on Markets the Menu.