Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / California's Prior Authorization Remodel: SB 306 and the New Role of DHCS
Transcript
- 0:03Hello and welcome to California's Prior Authorization
- 0:06Remodel, SB 306, and the new role of DHCS. I'm
- 0:11delighted to introduce our speaker today, Henry
- 0:13Norwood. Henry Norwood is of council at Kauffman
- 0:16-Dulwich LLP, where he represents clients at
- 0:18Clients across a range of practice areas and
- 0:21industries nationwide, concentrating in health
- 0:23care and managed care law, insurance coverage,
- 0:26ERISA, general liability, commercial litigation,
- 0:29professional liability, employment law, and cyber
- 0:31litigation. Admitted to practice in California,
- 0:34Florida, Maine, and Massachusetts, he defends
- 0:37private businesses, insurance carriers, and individuals
- 0:39in managed care, health, and compliance matters,
- 0:42including hospital and nursing home liability
- 0:44defense, commercial health disputes, and HIPAA
- 0:47and other health care organizational issues.
- 0:50A noted author, Mr. Norwood, has published more
- 0:52than 50 articles and book chapters on health
- 0:54care law, cybersecurity, and insurance matters.
- 0:57Now over to you. Thank you so much. Good afternoon,
- 1:01everybody. Hope you're having a really great
- 1:03day so far. I'm Henry Norwood, and I'm going
- 1:06to be speaking with you today about recent developments
- 1:09in California pertaining to prior authorization
- 1:12requirements under health insurance plans, and
- 1:15what really amounts to a remodel of California's
- 1:18legal framework surrounding prior authorizations.
- 1:22But before we dive in, and I know we had a bit
- 1:25of a bio, I just wanted to go over a little bit
- 1:27more about me. in the state of Maine now, but
- 1:31I started out my practice in Florida, where I
- 1:34earned my JD in practice law for about 10 years
- 1:37or so. Since then, I've worked for a national
- 1:40firm working primarily on California and Florida
- 1:43matters. I'm licensed to practice in the states
- 1:46of California, Florida, Maine, Massachusetts,
- 1:50and my work focuses primarily on healthcare law,
- 1:53both on the litigation and the compliance side
- 1:56of things. As we went over in my earlier bio.
- 2:02But if we could go to the next slide, here's
- 2:04just a brief road map to give you an idea of
- 2:07what we'll be covering today. We're going to
- 2:11start with the. Just a discussion of the basics
- 2:14of prior authorizations, including a basic definitional
- 2:17understanding and understanding of the entities
- 2:20who oversee insurance in the state of California,
- 2:23which is going to come back later on as well.
- 2:25The timing requirements that are imposed by California
- 2:28law for prior authorization determinations and.
- 2:32the health care services that are most commonly
- 2:34subject to prior authorization requirements.
- 2:37Next, we'll go over current prior authorization
- 2:40prohibitions that are imposed under California
- 2:42and federal law before the remodel takes full
- 2:46effect. We're going to cover insurance denials
- 2:49of prior authorization requests and what next
- 2:52steps insureds or their medical providers can
- 2:56or sometimes have to take if they want to dispute
- 2:59the prior authorization denial. We'll then dive
- 3:02into Senate Bill 306, which is the bill that
- 3:05really kickstarted the whole prior authorization
- 3:08remodel in California, including a deep dive
- 3:11into the bill's provisions, its requirements,
- 3:14and then also the timeline under which each of
- 3:17its sections are going to take effect, because
- 3:19it's really starting to take effect right now.
- 3:21Actually, it was passed last year, but its provisions
- 3:24are starting to go into effect this year, and
- 3:26they'll be continuing over the next two years
- 3:28as well. And we're going to conclude our discussion
- 3:30today by talking about the potential impact on
- 3:34health insurance litigation, including the impact
- 3:37on providers, insurers, and patient insurers
- 3:41as well that I think Senate Bill 306 may end
- 3:44up having. And by the end of the presentation,
- 3:47I'm really hopeful that you all have a good grasp
- 3:50on the basics of prior authorizations, how they're
- 3:53currently addressed under California law, what
- 3:56happens if a prior authorization request is denied,
- 3:59and how things are going to be changing over
- 4:01the next few years with prior authorizations
- 4:04in California with Senate Bill 306. So let's
- 4:12dive in. We begin with the basics of prior authorizations.
- 4:18So a prior authorization, also known as a PA,
- 4:22is the process by which health insurance companies
- 4:26review planned medical services before the date
- 4:30that they are supposed to be rendered. So here's
- 4:32kind of just an example of how it works. Assume
- 4:35that we have John Smith who's suffering from
- 4:38severe anxiety and depression. He goes to his
- 4:41primary care physician. They discuss it and the
- 4:44physician recommends that John Smith undergo
- 4:46wilderness therapy at a residential care facility.
- 4:50So his doctor, his PCP wants John Smith to be
- 4:54immersed in the wilderness for a matter of time
- 4:57within a residential facility. John Smith intends
- 5:00to pay for this therapy using his health insurance.
- 5:03So as you can probably imagine, John Smith's
- 5:06health insurer may have some questions before
- 5:08they agree to pay for this open ended care. They'll
- 5:11want to know what led the PCP to believe that
- 5:14wilderness. Would alleviate John Smith's depression
- 5:17and anxiety. How long is he going to be at this
- 5:20facility? Is there a less intensive treatment
- 5:23or less expensive treatment? A shorter timeframe,
- 5:26perhaps at the facility that could adequately
- 5:29treat John Smith's anxiety and depression. Does
- 5:32this need to occur at a residential treatment
- 5:34facility or is it something where he could come
- 5:35and go? And we know that all of these questions
- 5:39are actually going to come up because there's
- 5:41a surprisingly large body of case law dealing
- 5:44with wilderness therapy specifically because
- 5:47insurers are reluctant to pay for this particular
- 5:49type of service and they question its effectiveness.
- 5:52So it's a good example for our purposes in understanding
- 5:55what prior authorizations are and how they work.
- 5:59So we have all these questions that the insurer
- 6:02wants to ask. And there's really two different
- 6:03timeframes when these questions could possibly
- 6:06be raised. First, the insurer could ask the questions
- 6:10after John Smith has already started receiving
- 6:13his therapy and the therapy provider starts submitting
- 6:17claims for payment to the insurer. So John Smith,
- 6:19he's at the facility already. He started receiving
- 6:21his care maybe for a few days and his provider
- 6:24submitting these. claims or bills to the insurer
- 6:27for payment. And that's the first time that the
- 6:29insurer learns that John Smith's even there.
- 6:32This is a less favorable way to handle matters
- 6:35for a number of different reasons. It's not great
- 6:38for the patient because they've already started
- 6:40receiving the services before the insurer has
- 6:43had a chance to question the proposed care or
- 6:45whether they've even really agreed to pay for
- 6:47it. So if the insurer ultimately denies the claims
- 6:52as not covered, Maybe they say that they're not
- 6:56reasonable in amount, that wilderness therapy
- 6:58is a common one, is that wilderness therapy is
- 7:01investigational, that it's not really proven
- 7:04by the science. The insurer may ultimately deny
- 7:08those claims. And as a result, John Smith is
- 7:13left. Having to pay for this care and it's possible
- 7:17that if John Smith had known on the front end
- 7:19before he started receiving care that he was
- 7:21going to have to pay for it out of pocket. He
- 7:23may never have gone through with the pair with
- 7:25the care. He may have discussed alternative options
- 7:27with his PCP. From the providers perspective.
- 7:33It's not really ideal for them either because
- 7:36they've already rendered partial or complete
- 7:38sometimes services to the patient. So if the
- 7:41insurer ends up denying coverage and the patient
- 7:44isn't able to pay, the provider could end up
- 7:47being out financially. And lastly, it's not ideal
- 7:50for the insurer either because if the insurer
- 7:53ultimately decides that coverage should be denied,
- 7:56They risk doing so while the insured is in the
- 7:59middle of receiving their care, which may place
- 8:01the insured in a worse position than they had
- 8:04been prior to starting their care, which is it's
- 8:08not a great position, obviously, for a number
- 8:10of reasons, litigation being one of them if the
- 8:14insured ends up suing the insurer. And so this
- 8:18is why the second alternative timeframe is really
- 8:21more preferable. Under the second scenario, the
- 8:24insured So the insurer could ask their questions
- 8:28before John Smith has already started receiving
- 8:31therapy and before the therapy provider starts
- 8:34submitting claims for payment to the insurer.
- 8:37But how is the insurer supposed to know that
- 8:39John Smith intends to seek wilderness therapy?
- 8:41Well, by requiring John Smith or his provider
- 8:45to contact them. let them know about the care
- 8:48that he intends to seek and the basis for seeking
- 8:50that care before it all starts. This is done
- 8:53through a prior authorization requirement in
- 8:56the insurance health insurance plan, which requires
- 8:59the insurer's authorization for certain health
- 9:03services before the insured starts receiving
- 9:07the care. Oftentimes, a prior authorization requirement
- 9:12in a health insurance policy will read something
- 9:14like, you know, prior authorization except for
- 9:18emergency services or where prior authorization
- 9:21is not otherwise required by the plan, the insured
- 9:26or their provider shall obtain prior authorization
- 9:29for covered services in accordance with the following.
- 9:32And they may list the full list of services for
- 9:36which prior authorization is required right there
- 9:38on the plan, or they may refer the insured to
- 9:42their website or their patient or insured portal
- 9:45where a full list of those services that are
- 9:48covered by prior authorization requirements will
- 9:50be. And so just to sort of wrap up our hypothetical
- 9:54here, John Smith's PCP recommends the wilderness
- 9:57therapy, right? Either John Smith or the PCP
- 10:01will contact the health insurer to let them know
- 10:04about the intended care. So we're assuming that
- 10:07there's a prior authorization requirement here
- 10:09for wilderness therapy. They will discuss the
- 10:12reasons for the recommendation, the length of
- 10:14the stay, the description of the treatment. The
- 10:17insurer may follow up with certain requests for
- 10:20information or documents. And then the insurer
- 10:23will either authorize the care or deny the care
- 10:27all before it actually starts. Prior authorizations
- 10:31are normally used Buy health insurers to try
- 10:35to make sure that the services requested are
- 10:38medically necessary, both in type and in quantity.
- 10:42In theory, these prior authorization requirements
- 10:46should curbed patients receiving unnecessary
- 10:49care and insurers from paying unnecessary amounts,
- 10:54though insured patients and their providers generally
- 10:58view them as simply hurdles to patients receiving
- 11:01care that they really do need. As mentioned,
- 11:07prior authorization requirements, they're normally
- 11:09found in the insured's health insurance policy.
- 11:13or on the insurer's online portal. If an insured
- 11:18does not comply with a prior authorization requirement,
- 11:22the insurer will often deny their claim for payment
- 11:24once it's submitted and after the services have
- 11:27already been received. So moving on, there are
- 11:36Broadly speaking, three different regulatory
- 11:39entities to know in California who oversee the
- 11:43health insurance policies. And this is going
- 11:46to become relevant later on once we look closer
- 11:49into Senate Bill 306. So first, the Department
- 11:54of Health Care Services, or DHCS, they established
- 11:58the rules for California's Medi -Cal fee for
- 12:01service system. Department of Managed Healthcare
- 12:06or DMHC regulates most California health plans,
- 12:12HMOs, and then certain Medi -Cal managed care
- 12:15plans as well. The California Department of Insurance
- 12:20or CDI regulates traditional PPO insurance plans
- 12:25and combined life and health insurance plans.
- 12:29And again, as we get into Senate Bill 306, We'll
- 12:33see how the bill incorporates oversight entities
- 12:36into the overall remodel in California. But moving
- 12:41on to current California state and federal timing
- 12:46requirements. So California state law and federal
- 12:49law impose certain timeline requirements by which
- 12:53health insurers have to provide a decision on
- 12:56a prior authorization request submitted by an
- 12:59insured. The primary regulation is CMS -0057
- 13:05-F and under it insurers have to respond to standard
- 13:10non -urgent requests for prior authorizations
- 13:13within seven calendar days of receiving the request.
- 13:17For urgent or expedited requests insurers have
- 13:19to respond within 72 hours. For Medi -Cal managed
- 13:25care members specifically under certain certain
- 13:30scenarios, determinations have to be made by
- 13:33the insurer within 24 hours. Once a prior authorization
- 13:38request is approved and the services are provided,
- 13:41health insurers are prohibited from then going
- 13:44in and rescinding their approval, which, of course,
- 13:46makes sense. They can't approve care, have it
- 13:49be rendered, and then basically go back on their
- 13:51word. Health insurers are also prohibited from
- 13:56intentionally delaying prior authorization responses.
- 14:00And a number of ways that this normally comes
- 14:01up is that the health insurer will submit a number
- 14:05of different document requests, requests for
- 14:07information. For anybody who's involved in litigation,
- 14:12it's essentially unduly burdensome, irrelevant
- 14:15discovery requests essentially that the health
- 14:18insurer is imposing on either the insured patient
- 14:22or the provider. And the law specifically prohibits
- 14:27health insurers from doing that. And moving on
- 14:32to the next slide. So to sort of have an understanding
- 14:36of the scope of prior authorization. So across
- 14:39the country, there are certain services that
- 14:42are most commonly subject to prior authorization
- 14:45requirements by insurers. There's not a ton of
- 14:48variability here from state to state when it
- 14:50comes to the highest percentage services that
- 14:53are subject prior authorizations. And that holds
- 14:57true in California as well. So the services that
- 15:00are most commonly subject to prior authorizations
- 15:04requirements are genetic testing services, specialty
- 15:08drugs, elective inpatient surgical services,
- 15:13elective inpatient medical services, high -cost
- 15:16non -specialty prescription drugs, high -tech
- 15:19imaging, post -acute care facility services,
- 15:23cardiology services, durable medical equipment
- 15:27or DME. and then orthopedic services. And just
- 15:32a note, wherever we see here anything regarding
- 15:36prior authorizations on prescription drugs, there
- 15:39are certain There's really a specific law in
- 15:42California that was recently passed having to
- 15:45do with prescription drug prior authorizations.
- 15:48We should have time to get to it. It's in the
- 15:50slide materials, but I'm hopeful that we'll be
- 15:52able to get to it just that, you know, there
- 15:54is a separate law that does impact prescription
- 15:56drug prior authorizations. But we're going to
- 15:59see when we get into our discussion of Senate
- 16:02Bill 306, why it matters to California lawmakers,
- 16:06what services are often subject to prior authorization
- 16:10requirements and also which services are frequently
- 16:14approved after a prior authorization request
- 16:17is submitted. And so getting into our next section,
- 16:26let's move on to a discussion of some of the
- 16:29current prohibitions on prior authorizations
- 16:32under California law. So, health insurers are
- 16:50not allowed to impose prior authorization requirements
- 16:53on every type of service or in every circumstance.
- 16:58And that's the case under the existing law right
- 17:00now, before we even get to Senate Bill 306. There
- 17:04are a few circumstances where health insurers
- 17:08are prohibited specifically from imposing a prior
- 17:11authorization requirement. The first one is emergency
- 17:15medical services. Health insurers cannot impose
- 17:20prior authorization requirements for emergency
- 17:23medical services. And this prohibition, it makes
- 17:25perfect sense. It's kind of common sense, I think.
- 17:29If a person's experiencing a medical emergency,
- 17:32they're rushed to the hospital, it's not realistic
- 17:36that the patient could contact their health insurer
- 17:39and request that they conduct an urgent prior
- 17:41authorization review. Just a matter of public
- 17:43policy, obviously. We don't want patients having
- 17:46to do that. So obviously it's potentially dangerous.
- 17:50It could result in death or substantial injury
- 17:53to the patient insured. And so for the same reasons,
- 18:01it's not reasonable to expect that health care
- 18:04providers. could call in the prior authorization
- 18:07request for the patient prior to initiating that
- 18:10emergency care. So for emergency services, health
- 18:14insurers are prohibited from imposing prior authorization
- 18:18requirements. And if you remember from that sample
- 18:22language that we talked about earlier, I gave
- 18:25you a sample prior authorization language that's
- 18:27often in health insurance policies, it specifically
- 18:30carved out emergency services, and that's because
- 18:32of this exception. Next is ongoing treatment
- 18:37and continuity of care. This one's a little bit
- 18:39more, not so much common sense, but health insurers
- 18:43normally can't impose prior authorization requirements
- 18:47for a treatment plan that was started when the
- 18:51patient was insured by a different plan, but
- 18:53then switches to the current insurer while the
- 18:56treatment's ongoing. So generally, This prohibition
- 19:00applies when the treatment was subjected to a
- 19:03prior authorization by the first insurer that
- 19:06was ultimately granted or when the initial insurer
- 19:10otherwise agreed to cover the treatment. And
- 19:13so I want to give an example there, because I
- 19:15know that that does get a little bit complicated,
- 19:17just following the track with the different insurers.
- 19:21So assume we have a patient who's insured by
- 19:24insurer A, and the patient initiates chemotherapy
- 19:28treatment for cancer with insurer A. But while
- 19:33the treatment is ongoing, it could be multi years
- 19:35of treatment, while the treatment is ongoing,
- 19:37they switch their insurance or they want to switch
- 19:40to insurer B. And so now they're insured by Insurer
- 19:45B. Insurer B cannot then impose a prior authorization
- 19:50requirement once the patient is already covered
- 19:54by Insurer B's plan. And I wanna make that distinction
- 19:57because what this rule is saying, it doesn't
- 20:00prohibit Insurer B from turning the patient away
- 20:05and saying, we're not gonna enroll you in our
- 20:07health. or health insurance policy. That's not
- 20:09what this rule says. There may be other rules
- 20:12that say that, for example, the Affordable Care
- 20:14Act's pre -existing condition rules. But what
- 20:19this rule is saying that when you have a patient
- 20:21who's enrolled in one plan and they're receiving
- 20:25care, ongoing treatment under that plan, they
- 20:27switch and they want to go to a different plan.
- 20:30The second plan can't impose a prior authorization
- 20:34requirement on that existing care, that continuity
- 20:38of care. And so that's the second restriction
- 20:45where health insurers are not allowed to impose
- 20:47prior authorization requirements. The last one,
- 20:51health insurers cannot impose prior authorization
- 20:54requirements on care that's necessary to stabilize
- 20:57a patient. And this one's very similar to the
- 21:01emergency services prohibition. It should be
- 21:05noted that once the patient reaches the point
- 21:08of stabilization, once their condition has stabilized,
- 21:11the insurer can then go in and impose a prior
- 21:14authorization requirement on post stabilization
- 21:17care. So if a patient goes to a provider with,
- 21:22let's say they've got a big gash and they're
- 21:25bleeding profusely, their insurer cannot impose
- 21:30or enforce a prior authorization requirement
- 21:33for the treatment to get that patient stable,
- 21:36to stop the bleeding, close up the wound. But
- 21:39once that patient is stable, any post stabilization
- 21:43care, maybe it's infection prevention or removing
- 21:47sutures, that all can be placed under a prior
- 21:50authorization requirement. So the stabilization
- 21:53care, You can't impose a prior authorization
- 21:55requirement, but any post stabilization you can.
- 22:02This is a separate requirement, but health insurers
- 22:05are required to post and otherwise make available
- 22:09to their insureds a full list of the services
- 22:12that are subject to prior authorization requirements
- 22:14under the health plans. The lists are normally
- 22:18found on the insurer's portal. Sometimes they
- 22:20can be included in the health plan. If a service
- 22:24is supposed to be subject to a prior authorization
- 22:27requirement, but it's not publicly posted or
- 22:30otherwise available to insureds, if it's not
- 22:32in that list of services, courts may ultimately
- 22:35find that the insurer has waived any prior authorization
- 22:38requirement for that specific service. And so
- 22:41the patient or the insured doesn't have to give
- 22:44prior authorization or get prior authorization
- 22:47for the service that's not included in the list.
- 22:57And moving on, this is a slide that a topic that
- 23:00I mentioned earlier with prescription medication.
- 23:03So California has some relatively new prior authorization
- 23:09requirements. Oh, sorry. I think I'm on the wrong
- 23:17slide here. One moment. There we go. Step therapy.
- 23:21Perfect. So. California has some relatively new
- 23:25prior authorization requirements that have to
- 23:27do with prior authorizations for prescription
- 23:31medications and also what's called step therapy
- 23:34specifically. So step therapy it's a related
- 23:38concept to prior authorizations in that it is
- 23:41a means by an insurer to control the care that's
- 23:45being received by a patient but it is it's quite
- 23:48a bit different too so step therapy is a requirement
- 23:52imposed by health insurers that requires an insured
- 23:55who has been prescribed a medication to first
- 23:58attempt a lower cost comparable medication and
- 24:02for that medication to be unsuccessful before
- 24:05the insurer will cover the more expensive medication
- 24:09that was prescribed. It's commonly referred to
- 24:13as fail first protocols, which is not a great
- 24:16nickname for it, but it's essentially saying,
- 24:19you know, The insurer tells the insured, you
- 24:23need to try this less expensive medication and
- 24:25it needs to fail first before we will cover the
- 24:29more expensive medication. Diabetes medications
- 24:33like Ozempic in particular, they're really common
- 24:36prescription medications that are subject to
- 24:38step therapy requirements. So if A patient is
- 24:42prescribed Ozempic by their physician to treat
- 24:45diabetes. Their insurer may impose step therapy
- 24:48requirements that require the patient to first
- 24:51try a less expensive alternative medication and
- 24:56for that medication to be unsuccessful in treating
- 24:58the patient before the insurer will cover the
- 25:01Ozempic. Insurance can request exemptions from
- 25:07step therapy requirements, allowing them to go
- 25:09straight to the more expensive medication. And
- 25:12this is really where it's the exemption request.
- 25:15This is really where prior authorizations and
- 25:18step therapy kind of collide here for purposes
- 25:21of this new regulation. So the rule that we're
- 25:24talking about, it's California Health and Safety
- 25:26Code. 1367 .241. It was passed into law in 2025.
- 25:32The rule has a number of different provisions
- 25:36that impact prior authorizations and step therapy
- 25:39requirements for prescription medication specifically.
- 25:42That's what we're dealing with. The rule provides
- 25:45a single uniform prior authorization form to
- 25:48use for prescription drug benefits and it allows
- 25:50electronic prior authorization requests. for
- 25:54prescription drugs. The law also imposes its
- 25:57own timing requirements. For example, insurers
- 25:59have to respond to prior authorization and step
- 26:02therapy exemption requests within 72 hours for
- 26:05non -urgent requests and then within 24 hours
- 26:08for urgent requests. And then under subsection
- 26:12B1A, if an insurer fails to satisfy these timing
- 26:17standards that we just talked about, the prior
- 26:19authorization request or the step therapy exemption
- 26:22request is automatically granted. Just to sort
- 26:28of recap that real quick, California Health and
- 26:30Safety Code 1367241, it applies to prescription
- 26:34medication benefits and it imposes certain requirements
- 26:37on insurers for prior authorizations and step
- 26:40therapy exemption requests. So just so that you
- 26:43know that that's out there if you do deal with
- 26:45prior authorization requests a lot in your work.
- 26:51Okay, now let's move on and let's talk about
- 26:53prior authorization denials. So when a prior
- 27:00authorization for health services has been submitted
- 27:03by a patient or their provider and the insurer
- 27:06declines to authorize the care, what recourse
- 27:10does the patient have other than just accepting
- 27:12that their insurer won't cover the cost? If a
- 27:23health insurer denies a submitted prior authorization
- 27:27request, or on the other hand, if the insurer
- 27:30denies coverage for care altogether because the
- 27:33patient failed to comply with a PA requirement,
- 27:37the insurer is required to provide the patient
- 27:39with written notice of the denial detailing the
- 27:43basis for that denial. Most health plans have
- 27:47one to two levels of mandatory internal appeals.
- 27:51uh, to the insurer that have to be complied with
- 27:54to permit the insured to file a lawsuit or seek
- 27:57other recourse. Um, and I am speaking a bit generally
- 28:00there because, uh, you know, oftentimes lawyers
- 28:04find ways to get around these requirements. They
- 28:06may bring up common law causes of action like
- 28:09promissory estoppel, um, unjust enrichment in
- 28:12certain circumstances that they try to use to
- 28:15get around the, the, the. appeal requirement
- 28:18but generally speaking if you're suing for plan
- 28:21benefits you need to comply with this appeal
- 28:25process. The health insurance plan will detail
- 28:28how many levels of appeal an insured has to submit
- 28:32before they gain the right to file suit and what
- 28:35the requirements of those appellate levels are.
- 28:38Exhausting this appeals processed that's required
- 28:41under health plans. It's often referred to as
- 28:43exhaustion of administrative remedies and it's
- 28:46a prerequisite to filing a lawsuit for plan benefits.
- 28:51Now, there is an exception to the exhaustion
- 28:53requirement. It's known as the futility exception.
- 28:57So what the futility exception says is. It can
- 29:02excuse and insured from exhausting administrative
- 29:05remedies if doing so. would be doomed to fail
- 29:09right so if the insured complying with this one
- 29:13or two step levels of appeals would be pointless
- 29:16and they'd be doomed the insurer would still
- 29:19just deny it anyway. Now to establish that futility
- 29:24argument the insured has to establish by what's
- 29:27referred to as a clear showing that complying
- 29:30with their plan's mandatory appeals would be
- 29:32futile. Over the years, courts that have looked
- 29:36at this exception, they found various circumstances
- 29:39may rise to the level of permitting waiver of
- 29:42the appeal requirements. It is a higher burden
- 29:44to meet, but it has been met before, in particular,
- 29:48when the insurer just completely ignores the
- 29:51insurance request for information about the appeal
- 29:53process. or where the insured request documents
- 29:57that are actually relevant, they're not pointless
- 30:00requests, they're relevant documents they're
- 30:02requesting that they need for their appeal and
- 30:05the insurer just ignores them. It also arises
- 30:09where the insured is able to show that this particular
- 30:15insurer has a history of denying the same claims
- 30:18that the insured is using on the same basis and
- 30:23that the insurer is relying on the same external
- 30:26guidance to support their denial. So it's a little
- 30:31bit specific, but for example, going back to
- 30:34the wilderness therapy example, Oftentimes, insurers
- 30:37will deny wilderness therapy as investigational
- 30:40or not medically necessary based on external
- 30:43guidance or guidelines from third parties who
- 30:47have studied wilderness therapy and its effects.
- 30:50Now, if those guidelines have been found unreasonable
- 30:54or out of date in some litigation, then and a
- 30:58particular insurer has a history of relying on
- 31:01those guidelines over and over again to deny
- 31:04wilderness therapy. An insured who is seeking
- 31:08prior authorization for wilderness therapy could
- 31:12point to that to a judge and say look judge even
- 31:14though I didn't comply with the two -step appeal
- 31:17process doing so would have been futile because
- 31:19this particular insurer has a long history of
- 31:22denying wilderness therapy relying on this particular
- 31:26you know outdated external guidance. Peer -to
- 31:33-peer review is another form of an administrative
- 31:39remedy that's available to and it's often required
- 31:42of insureds. This refers to a consultation between
- 31:45the insurer's reviewing physician and the provider
- 31:49who's providing the care for the insured. Really
- 31:54it's intended for the Kind of the doctors in
- 31:58the room to get together and discuss each side's
- 32:00position and their justifications for either
- 32:03recommending or denying the health services that
- 32:06are at issue and kind of the goal or the thought
- 32:10behind this is that they're. These 2 experts
- 32:13will get together and there's either going to
- 32:15be a meeting of the minds and 1 of them will
- 32:18decide. Well, okay, maybe it should be covered
- 32:20or the other one will decide. Well, okay, maybe
- 32:22it shouldn't have been covered or at a minimum
- 32:24that there will be an understanding that the
- 32:27other parties aside that the other the other
- 32:30side's position is reasonable, even if they don't
- 32:33necessarily agree with it. I don't think that
- 32:36necessarily happens a whole lot, but I think
- 32:39that's the goal behind it. And then lastly, external
- 32:41review of the prior authorization denial is often
- 32:48permitted by either DMHC or CDI. And moving on,
- 32:57this is just a minor point to be aware of. As
- 33:00I was preparing the presentation, I thought it's
- 33:02a good point to be aware of, particularly for
- 33:04anybody who's starting out in this area. Generally
- 33:07speaking, only an insured Or their authorized
- 33:10beneficiaries, like a spouse or a child who's
- 33:14covered under the primary insurance plan can
- 33:16receive information regarding the plan and the
- 33:19insurer will not speak to others outside of that
- 33:23group, such as providers, for example. So if
- 33:26the insured wants to appeal. a prior authorization
- 33:30denial and would prefer that their provider handle
- 33:33that appeal as often happens. The insured has
- 33:37to designate the provider as authorized to speak
- 33:40on their behalf and insurers often have specific
- 33:44mandatory ways of designating them. Typically
- 33:47it's done through a designation of authorized
- 33:50representative form which authorizes a third
- 33:53party to communicate with the insurer on behalf
- 33:56of the insured. Um, during the claims process
- 34:00and appeals, so. The designation, it typically
- 34:04will not act to transfer the insured's right
- 34:09to benefits payment or to sue under the plan
- 34:12that has to be done through an assignment of
- 34:14benefits or an AOB. Which is entirely separate,
- 34:17but the designations often made on a it's a pre
- 34:21approved form often that's created by the insurer
- 34:25and sometimes it'll be given to the member. by
- 34:28the healthcare provider or the insurance company
- 34:32along with an ALB. So I think this really builds
- 34:43our foundation to now start discussing Senate
- 34:46Bill 306, the law that will remodel the prior
- 34:51authorization landscape in California quite significantly,
- 34:54Kimley, I think. So Senate Bill 306 is titled
- 35:00Healthcare Coverage Prior Authorizations, and
- 35:03it is now codified as Health and Safety Code
- 35:061367 .025. The section goes beyond simply restricting
- 35:16the ability of health insurers to impose prior
- 35:19authorization requirements under certain circumstances.
- 35:22Instead, it vests really significant power in
- 35:26the California Department of Health Care Services,
- 35:29DHCS, like we discussed earlier, to determine
- 35:32which services should be exempt from prior authorization
- 35:37requirements, which provides DHCS much greater
- 35:41power than it previously had, and it removes
- 35:44some of that power from health insurers. So what's
- 35:47happening here is the legislature has decided
- 35:49that insurers in California are imposing prior
- 35:54authorization requirements too much, too broadly
- 35:56across too many different services. And it's
- 35:59really, it's a drain on the healthcare system.
- 36:02It's making things too cumbersome for patients.
- 36:05And so they've kind of appointed DHCS and given
- 36:09them the power to really rein that in here. The
- 36:13law was passed in 2025, but it's gonna be rolled
- 36:17out in multiple stages over the next several
- 36:19years. And the first stage of the rollout is
- 36:29the data collection stage. This stage really
- 36:33began this year in 2026. Under the provisions
- 36:38that go into effect this year, DHCS is required
- 36:42to request data from California health insurers
- 36:47regarding each insurer's use of prior authorization
- 36:50requirements and how frequently PA requests are
- 36:53approved and how frequently they're denied. These
- 36:57requests were required to have been made by July
- 37:0031st, 2026, so about a month and a half ago.
- 37:05And insurers are required to respond by December
- 37:0731st of this year. So this stage of the process
- 37:11is found in subsections A through B of the new
- 37:15law. And so that process is underway as we speak.
- 37:20And so then we move on to stage two, which I
- 37:24labeled the identification stage. And if we could
- 37:32go to the next slide for that one, thank you.
- 37:36So here, this stage is going to take place by
- 37:38the end of 2027. So using the data that DHCS
- 37:43obtains by the end of this year under stage one,
- 37:47DHCS has the authority to prohibit insurers from
- 37:51imposing prior authorization requirements on
- 37:54specific health services that are covered by
- 37:56a health plan. So to accomplish this DHCS is
- 38:02directed under the law to identify all services
- 38:05that are subject to PA requirements and that
- 38:08are approved. So the prior authorization requirements
- 38:11are approved by the insurer at a rate of 90 %
- 38:15or greater. These services that are identified
- 38:19as approved at this rate, 90 % or greater, are
- 38:22just automatically deemed exempt from prior authorization
- 38:26requirements. So I think of this sort of as it's
- 38:30the initial action by DHCS that targets what
- 38:34I see as the low hanging fruit here. Healthcare
- 38:36services that are often subject to PA requirements,
- 38:40but that are approved at large, the majority
- 38:43of the time, 90%. So these services are going
- 38:47to automatically be exempt from prior authorizations
- 38:50going forward. This should be the less contentious
- 38:54effort to remove prior authorization requirements
- 38:57from services because health insurers approve
- 39:00these authorization requests nearly all the time
- 39:03anyway. That's why I sort of think of it as the
- 39:06initial action that's just targeting that low
- 39:08-hanging fruit. It shouldn't be too much of an
- 39:10issue. But that's just the first step. After
- 39:17that, DHCS is able to determine which other services
- 39:24to deem exempt from prior authorization requirements.
- 39:27So with the low -hanging fruit sort of out of
- 39:29the way, DHCS is going to go further and target
- 39:32other services that are subject to PA requirements.
- 39:36And in order to do this, this sort of second...
- 39:38Secondary action, DHCS is allowed to consider
- 39:43the following factors in determining whether
- 39:46to remove prior authorization requirements from
- 39:48services. Number one is whether the health service
- 39:52is frequently used contrary to clinical guidelines.
- 39:55Number two, whether the health service has significant
- 39:58potential for fraud, waste, and abuse. Three
- 40:01is whether significant costs would be saved by
- 40:04eliminating prior authorization requirements.
- 40:07Number four is whether significant improvements
- 40:09in health care quality outcomes and timely access
- 40:12would occur if PA requirements are removed. And
- 40:16then number five is just additional factors that
- 40:21DHCS determines. And these five requirements
- 40:24are found under subsection C of the law. And
- 40:27if you sort of just look at these factors, you
- 40:29can see that the first two, whether the service
- 40:33is frequently used contrary to clinical guidelines
- 40:35and whether the service has a significant potential
- 40:39for fraud, waste and abuse. Those are really
- 40:42more insurer side types of considerations where
- 40:46that's often what the insurer is looking at when
- 40:49they're considering whether to impose a PA requirement,
- 40:52right? Because that's what they're concerned
- 40:53about. They want these PA requirements for services
- 40:57that they think are often fraudulently. use that
- 41:00they promote waste and they're often used outside
- 41:04of their clinical guidelines. While factors three
- 41:07and four, those factors really go on the provider
- 41:12side or even the insured side in saying, look,
- 41:15these PA requirements are a waste of time. They're
- 41:18a drain on the system. There's no need for them.
- 41:21And then five, of course, we just have whatever
- 41:23else DHCS wants to look at in considering. So
- 41:30those are the five factors, and I think those
- 41:32are the first four factors I think will be the
- 41:35factors that are most commonly considered by
- 41:38DHCS, but then they have no restriction on looking
- 41:42at other factors as well. And then moving on
- 41:46to the next slide, this takes us to stage three.
- 41:49Enforcement. So, DHCS has to demand that insurers
- 41:59no longer place prior authorization requirements
- 42:02on the services designated by DHCS in the prior
- 42:06stage, starting no later than January 1st, 2028.
- 42:10So, we're starting this year, 2026. Then we move
- 42:13into identification 2027 and enforcement 2028.
- 42:17That's the full rollout period. So, this Demand
- 42:23that ensures stop imposing these requirements
- 42:25on the exempt services. Includes those prior
- 42:30authorization services that are approved at the
- 42:3290 plus percent rate or the low hanging fruit
- 42:35as I keep saying in addition to the additional
- 42:38health services that are simply designated as
- 42:41exempt by considering the previous factors that
- 42:45we talked about. Insurers who fail to comply
- 42:48with this requirement are subject to an enforcement
- 42:50action by DHCS. The law does place certain limitations
- 42:56on DHCS ability to prohibit PA requirements,
- 43:01which are found in subsection D1 through 5 of
- 43:05the new law. Specifically, DHCS cannot restrict
- 43:13insurers Use of prior authorization requirements
- 43:17for these services that are listed here. So we
- 43:20start with outpatient prescription drugs in tier
- 43:23three or four of the healthcare services plan.
- 43:26The tiers are defined under this section of the
- 43:30law that's cited here. Number two, a drug or
- 43:35medical device prescribed or recommended for
- 43:38a use that's different from the use. for which
- 43:40the drug or medical device has been cleared or
- 43:42approved by the FDA. So that's sort of going
- 43:45outside of the clinical guidance factor that
- 43:48we talked about earlier. Number three, a covered
- 43:50healthcare service that's experimental or investigational,
- 43:54excluding services for which there is medical
- 43:56or scientific evidence. That's one that we're
- 43:59gonna come back to later when we talk about implications
- 44:01going forward. Number four. a covered health
- 44:05service that's prescribed or recommended for
- 44:07use that's a novel application of an existing
- 44:10therapy or technology, unless there's medical
- 44:13or scientific evidence for that use. And then
- 44:15five, a covered health service requested or prescribed
- 44:19by an out -of -network provider. So if the health
- 44:22service requested by the insured or their provider
- 44:25falls into one of these categories, DHCS is prohibited
- 44:31or sorry, DHDS may not prohibit the insurer's
- 44:35use of prior authorization requirements for those
- 44:38specific categories. And moving on, there's also
- 44:47exceptions that allow health insurers to impose
- 44:51prior authorization requirements on services
- 44:55rendered by certain providers. So here, the focus
- 44:59is taken off of the service that's being rendered
- 45:03to the patient, instead is put on the provider
- 45:06who's rendering this service. And I think this
- 45:09is where it gets really interesting, especially
- 45:11when we start talking about future implications
- 45:13later. So even if... a health care service has
- 45:18been deemed exempt by DHCS, exempt from PA requirements,
- 45:22it can still be subject to a PA requirement if
- 45:25the service is to be rendered by certain providers.
- 45:29So who are these providers? Subsection F of the
- 45:33new law tells us, these are providers who the
- 45:36health insurer can establish has engaged in either
- 45:39one fraudulent billing or two, repeated rendering
- 45:44of services outside of acceptable standards of
- 45:47care. So if the insurer can establish either
- 45:50one of these about a specific provider, they
- 45:54are still allowed to impose prior authorization
- 45:56requirements, despite the service being included
- 45:59under the PA exemption by DHCS. The insurer has
- 46:08to satisfy the clear and convincing standard
- 46:12to establish that a provider is engaged in one
- 46:14of these two problematic practices to allow the
- 46:19insurer to impose a PA requirement for an exempt
- 46:21service. So it is a slightly higher standard
- 46:25that they need to prove here. And on the slide
- 46:29here, it was mentioned above as well, but out
- 46:32of network services do not fall within the scope
- 46:35of this new law. We're just talking about in
- 46:37network services here. And so that's the new
- 46:46law, or at least that's its major highlights.
- 46:49Now let's talk about what the potential impact
- 46:52or implications on healthcare litigation that
- 46:56this new law may have going forward. So what
- 47:03I think kind of the teeth of this law, which
- 47:07is to demand health insurers stop imposing prior
- 47:11authorization requirements on exempt services.
- 47:14That's not going to go into effect until the
- 47:15beginning of 2028. That's the final step of this
- 47:18whole process. The law, in my view, it really
- 47:23provides DHCS broad authority to try to rein
- 47:26in prior authorizations that the California legislature
- 47:30thinks are out of control. And really, PA requirements
- 47:35have been one of the more effective, if not certainly
- 47:39one of the most used insurer practices used to
- 47:42contain unnecessary, ineffective, sometimes fraudulent
- 47:47health care services from the insurer's perspective.
- 47:51So I think that this law will certainly be effective
- 47:54at decreasing the use of prior authorization
- 47:57requirements in California. I do think that we're
- 47:59going to see far less of them being applied.
- 48:03But I do also think that insurers may seek to
- 48:06deny services that they consider unnecessary
- 48:09using other means other than PA requirements.
- 48:13Services are commonly denied as experimental
- 48:16or investigational. Even currently before this
- 48:21law goes into effect, if there's some dispute
- 48:24in the medical community over application of
- 48:26that service to the insurance condition. So denials
- 48:30on this basis may increase. as DHCS deems various
- 48:35services exempt from PA requirements. So the
- 48:38PA requirements won't be available to the insurers
- 48:41anymore. It won't sort of buy them that little
- 48:44bit of extra time to review the situation. So
- 48:47we may see more denials on the experimental or
- 48:50investigational side of things. And I mean, in
- 48:53fact, subsection D3, which we talked about in
- 48:56the previous slide, it specifically carves out
- 48:59experimental or investigational services from
- 49:02the purview of DHCS's exemption powers. So I
- 49:06can see insurers really trying to target that
- 49:08exception that they're already using with even
- 49:12greater frequency in the future in an effort
- 49:15to try to control services and ensure unnecessary
- 49:18or overly expensive care isn't being provided.
- 49:25We talked about the the denial process in a couple
- 49:29of slides. And what an insured can do following
- 49:36a claim denial or a prior authorization denial.
- 49:43And we said that the most common avenue of relief
- 49:47that's available to appeal the insurer's denial
- 49:49is to go through the health plans. one or two
- 49:54step level appeal process. So if insurers start
- 49:57denying claims as investigational or experimental
- 50:00with greater frequency, this may cause patients
- 50:03to put a pause on ongoing care that they have
- 50:06going on while they appeal the determination.
- 50:09And in some circumstances, this will buy the
- 50:12insurers more time to review the care that the
- 50:14patient is undergoing as the patient goes through
- 50:16the appeal process. So we may see more initial
- 50:19denials. But when the patient or the provider
- 50:22appeals them, we may also see more reversals
- 50:27of the initial denials, of the initial claim
- 50:30denials on the insurer side, just because they
- 50:33needed more time to actually look at the situation,
- 50:36since they no longer have prior authorizations
- 50:38available to them. And then also insurers may...
- 50:48They may also review providers claim practices
- 50:52more carefully to determine whether P .A. requirements
- 50:56can be imposed on services that are rendered
- 50:59by that specific provider under subsection F
- 51:03of the law, which we just talked about in your
- 51:06call. Subsection F allows insurers to impose
- 51:10PA requirements on exempt services if the provider
- 51:14can be shown to engage in fraudulent billing
- 51:16or repeated rendering of services outside the
- 51:20acceptable standard of care. So this could end
- 51:23up, I think, being a major source of disputes
- 51:25between the providers and the insurers here.
- 51:28And there's just a lot of unresolved questions
- 51:30here about how this whole process is going to
- 51:33work, such as would a provider's fraudulent billing
- 51:37or substandard services outside the acceptable
- 51:40care. Would it be provable by the provider's
- 51:43conduct with other insurers? Are insurers going
- 51:46to start looking into how physicians are billing
- 51:50their services or providing their services that
- 51:52they're billing to other insurers, not just that
- 51:55specific insurer? Could DHCS authorization to
- 52:01impose PA requirements, right? So let's say they're
- 52:04able to establish That this particular provider
- 52:09does engage in fraudulent billing or services
- 52:11outside the acceptable standard of care. Could
- 52:14they then use that regarding a certain provider
- 52:16under subsection F to serve it as a pretense
- 52:19to deny the prior authorization altogether. And
- 52:24I also find it a bit curious and. If this exception
- 52:29could potentially lead to what's referred to
- 52:31as the corporate exclusion issue. That we see
- 52:34in other contacts and so what corporate exclusions
- 52:38are it's they they occur when there's a large
- 52:42player. In the healthcare chain of services,
- 52:45for example, like a large retail pharmacy, and
- 52:49they categorically refuse to work with a certain
- 52:52provider, which can potentially cause that provider
- 52:55a lot of harm. Sometimes they lose patients as
- 52:57a result. So in the pharmacy context, for example,
- 53:01you have large retail pharmacies and they sometimes
- 53:03put a ban. on their pharmacists from filling
- 53:06prescriptions that were written by certain physicians
- 53:09for various reasons. Oftentimes it's because
- 53:12of the physician's past, you know, allegedly
- 53:15fraudulent behavior or for other reasons. This
- 53:19is called a corporate exclusion and oftentimes
- 53:22physicians will file lawsuits against the pharmacy
- 53:25seeking legal or equitable relief. to remove
- 53:28those exclusions and sometimes seeking damages
- 53:31as well. And I'm just really curious if this
- 53:34new law, if it leads to insurers trying to use
- 53:38subsection F frequently, it may lead to insurers
- 53:42essentially keeping a list of providers that
- 53:45they know have some history of conduct that falls
- 53:48under subsection F, right? The fraudulent billing
- 53:50or services outside the standard of care. and
- 53:54insurers may routinely just attempt to impose
- 53:56PA requirements on these excluded providers whenever
- 54:00they come up. It's possible this might lead to
- 54:02litigation similar to the corporate exclusion
- 54:05litigation that exists in other contexts. And
- 54:07I think there's just a whole lot of unanswered
- 54:10questions regarding that whole provision of this
- 54:14new law under subsection F. There are fewer prior
- 54:20authorization requirements imposed in the coming
- 54:22years. I do think litigation is going to remain
- 54:24prevalent as litigants continue to dispute claim
- 54:28denials outside the scope of Section 1367 .025.
- 54:37And just really briefly on the next slide here,
- 54:40Assembly Bill 539, this is, it applies to prior
- 54:45authorization requirements. It's separate from
- 54:48what we've been talking about, but I thought
- 54:49it would be good just to erase it because this
- 54:52is an assembly bill. It's not the law yet, but
- 54:54it's working its way through the California legislature
- 54:56and it's likely to be enacted this year, if not
- 54:59sometime next year. But if it is enacted, the
- 55:02law would require approved PA request to last
- 55:06one year from the date that the request was made,
- 55:10unless there's a shorter date specifically requested
- 55:12by the provider. So it kind of gives prior authorization
- 55:16approvals a shelf life of at least or of one
- 55:20year unless the doctor asks for less. It's just
- 55:23something to keep an eye on if your work does
- 55:25involve dealing with prior authorizations again
- 55:27I expect that to become the law very soon. And
- 55:35so just to give a recap of what we went over
- 55:38today we started out with a discussion of learning
- 55:42the basics of prior authorizations, including
- 55:44basic definitions, timing requirements, services
- 55:47that are commonly subject to PA requirements.
- 55:50We discussed the current prior authorization
- 55:53prohibitions before the new law goes into effect.
- 55:57We went over what recourse insureds have for
- 56:00prior authorization denials. And then we went
- 56:03through the requirements of Senate Bill 306 itself
- 56:07and how it's going to be rolled out By dhcs over
- 56:12the next three years again it went into it was
- 56:15passed last year. This year we're going through
- 56:18the kind of the data collection stage of the
- 56:21process next year in twenty twenty seven it'll
- 56:24be the identification of okay what are those
- 56:28prior authorizations that are being approved
- 56:30at that ninety percent that we can just automatically
- 56:32exempt and then beyond that what additional.
- 56:35services, are we going to subject to prior authorizations
- 56:38even if they don't meet the 90 % acceptance threshold?
- 56:42And then moving into 2028 is when the DHCS will
- 56:49start issuing demand letters to all the insurers
- 56:51saying you cannot impose prior authorizations
- 56:53on this list of services. And then we just concluded
- 56:58with a discussion of possible implications of
- 57:00Senate Bill 306. things that may be coming down
- 57:04the pipe, particularly 2028 moving forward implications
- 57:09from this law. So I hope you now have a good
- 57:12understanding of prior authorizations, how they
- 57:16currently work in California and how the California
- 57:18legislature is seeking to remodel the prior authorization
- 57:23legal framework. So with that being said, does
- 57:30anybody have any questions? Looks like we actually
- 57:35have one question here from Stephanie. Will the
- 57:38approved percentage of services be calculated
- 57:41utilizing post -appeal decisions as well or only
- 57:44initial approvals? Does this include medications
- 57:46too or only services? Okay, so I think two questions
- 57:51there. My understanding I think the second question
- 57:54was whether or not this would include prescription
- 57:56services or prescription medications. My understanding
- 58:00is that it will. And the first question, could
- 58:03I have that again just to make sure I'm answering
- 58:05it? All right, so will the approved percentage
- 58:09of services be calculated utilizing post -appeal
- 58:13decisions as well or only initial approvals?
- 58:16Yes, my understanding is that it will include
- 58:18post -appeal decisions as well. that is going
- 58:21to include both of them is my understanding.
- 58:28Well, if you'd like to contact me, I've put my
- 58:31information on the screen here. If you'd like
- 58:33to talk more about prior authorizations or anything
- 58:36else for that matter, I'm more than happy to
- 58:38chat with anybody. Send me an email, give me
- 58:39a call. But that concludes today's presentation.
- 58:43I just want to thank you all for joining me.
- 58:45Hope you have a great rest of your day and I
- 58:47hope you found this information valuable.