Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Child Emotional Abuse (2017 Rerun)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners, It's just me today. I thought I would respond
- 0:03to some patron emails. This first emails from patron Terra slash Slade Terror goes
- 0:11by Tara and Slade. But first, let's introduce the podcast. This is
- 0:15the Psychology and Seattle Podcast. I'm your host, doctor Kirkanda. I'm a
- 0:19therapist and a professor. Again. Email from patron Tara. She writes,
- 0:24can you talk about emotional child abuse? Why do parents abuse their children emotionally?
- 0:29What are the immediate and long term effects? Okay, these are good
- 0:33questions, and I don't think I've ever specifically talked about it. So let's
- 0:38get into this for a little while. They'll do a little mini deep dive
- 0:40on this. First off, what is emotional child abuse? Well, sometimes
- 0:45it's also referred to as psychological abuse, and in the literature there are many
- 0:51inconsistent definitions. And for example, here's one definition maltreatment which results in impaired
- 1:00psychological growth and development. So let's break this down. Maltreatment by you know,
- 1:06a parent or guardian, which results in impaired psychological growth and development.
- 1:12Impaired psychological growth and development. I think that would be very difficult to determine,
- 1:19and according to this definition, every parent has emotionally abused their child,
- 1:26because every child has, you know, both positive and negative effects as a
- 1:33result of the parenting that they went through. No parent is perfect. Every
- 1:37parent, you know, makes mistakes routinely, and so the or every parent
- 1:46or the way that every parent and every child come together as a relationship creates
- 1:52a lot of different complications that children will emerge from childhood with with issues,
- 1:57you know, And so this definition I think is too broad. There are
- 2:02other kinds of markers that define what emotional abuse is, such as people who
- 2:12are being controlling of you that isn't physical or sexual controlling, it's emotional controlling.
- 2:20Just being hostile can be considered emotional abuse. Name calling, intimidating behavior,
- 2:27threats of violence or harm, playing, buying games such as gaslighting,
- 2:31general neglect, and etc. So let's get into perhaps how the law defines
- 2:39emotional abuse. So in Washington, the law actually defines quite extensively what is
- 2:47child abuse or neglect, and it's mostly about physical abuse and a little bit
- 2:53about sexual abuse, and even less so about what we would call emotional abuse.
- 3:00I'm going to read the relevant parts of the law in Washington State that
- 3:04pertain to this. So here we go. Child abuse or neglect means the
- 3:08injury, sexual abuse, or sexual exploitation of a child by any person under
- 3:14circumstances which indicate that the child's health, welfare or safety is harmed, or
- 3:20the negligent treatment or maltreatment of a child by a person responsible for or providing
- 3:25care of the child to the child. So that's just the general So let's
- 3:29get into the specific things around around emotional abuse. So far down on the
- 3:36list we have Negligent treatment or maltreatment may include the cumulative effects of a pattern
- 3:43of conduct, behavior, or an action by a parent or guardian in providing
- 3:46for the physical, emotional, or developmental needs of the child such that it
- 3:51shows a serious disregard of the consequences to the child and creates a clear and
- 3:55present danger to the child's health, welfare, or safety. So most of
- 4:00this applies to situations like you, as a parent, are not feeding your
- 4:08child, or housing your child, or taking your child to the hospital when
- 4:13needed or you know, that's usually what this law is referring to. But
- 4:19in this definition, there is a little bit that pertains to emotional abuse,
- 4:26which is serious disregard of the consequences to the child. That creates a clear
- 4:34and present danger to the child's welfare. You know what exactly is welfare?
- 4:40Right, So if you, as a parent, are you have a pattern
- 4:45of putting the child down, name calling, scaring the child, then that
- 4:51is that could be considered emotional abuse. And I've seen CPS react to emotional
- 4:58abuse, as you know, similarly to the way they would address physical abuse.
- 5:02But this is also a problem because the law and society doesn't really care
- 5:11as much about emotional abuse as it does about physical and sexual abuse, and
- 5:14so the opportunities or the chances or the interpretations of these kinds of behaviors are
- 5:21different than if you actually struck a child. It's sort of interesting. You
- 5:26could do just tons and tons of damage to a child emotionally and not have
- 5:32anybody react to you, you know, not have the law or the police
- 5:38or CPS get involved. But you strike a child once across the face,
- 5:43which could be damaging for sure. But according to people who go through things
- 5:47like this, they would say, you know, the worst part of the
- 5:51abuse that I went through with my parents had nothing to do with you know,
- 5:56when my parent actually struck me or spanked me or hit me. That
- 6:00was nothing compared to the ongoing fear and horribleness that came out of their mouth.
- 6:08And so you know, it's it's it's a problem because it's really hard
- 6:16to define that, right. I mean, every parent will lose their cool
- 6:20sometimes and parents, you know they so you can't make name calling illegal,
- 6:28right because or at least most would agree we shouldn't make that illegal, because
- 6:32you know, that's different, you know. Anyway, My point is is
- 6:35that when it comes to law, it's it's just hard to figure out what
- 6:40to do with this, Okay. Well, to me, I in terms
- 6:44of how I define abuse, the word abuse and emotional abuse is that it
- 6:53has to it has to result in three different possible things. One is that
- 6:59does a victim feel afraid or unsafe or harmed or damaged in some way?
- 7:05So that's important is to me, it doesn't depend on the behavior of the
- 7:11abuser. It depends on the on the reaction of the victim. And that
- 7:16gets that gets a little funny because sometimes some people misinterpret things. But really
- 7:21I'm not concerned about the law because that's not my job. But what I'm
- 7:25concerned about is how to help people after the fact, or how to help
- 7:30people in the midst of these kinds of relationships. For example, if if
- 7:35a parent, if I look at a parent child interaction and to me it
- 7:40looks totally fine, but the child walks away traumatized, then I care about
- 7:46that, right, and so I'm gonna I'm gonna try to change that dynamic
- 7:50so that the child doesn't walk away feeling traumatized. Now, should that situation
- 7:55be prosecuted, I don't know. That's not my job. That's that's for
- 7:59prosecutors to decide in lawyers. But to me, it doesn't matter what the
- 8:03behavior is. It matters more the reaction of the child. The harm is
- 8:09there, harm is the child? Is the child harmed in some way?
- 8:15And another thing to really think about is is there a later trauma reaction.
- 8:22This is important because a lot of people in the middle of being abused will
- 8:26not notice that they're being harmed. They'll just say like, eh, and
- 8:31no big deal because they have defense mechanisms that protect them from their difficult feelings.
- 8:37But if a month later, or even five years later or fifty years
- 8:43later, there's still a traumatic reaction, then according to me, that person
- 8:48went through abuse, and if it didn't involve physical or sexual exploitation or harm
- 8:54or contact, then I would probably categorize it as emotional or psychological abuse.
- 9:01For example, someone can yell at me and call me names and be hostile
- 9:05with me and try to scare me, But if I don't feel afraid,
- 9:09then that's just someone trying to scare me, right if I'm not. If
- 9:13someone could be extremely abusive to me emotionally, but if it doesn't get under
- 9:18my skin, then I don't categorize that as abuse. I might categorize the
- 9:22person as trying to be abusive or exhibiting abusive behavior. But did abuse occur,
- 9:28I would say no, because I wasn't harmed by it. On the
- 9:33other hand, someone could just look at me funny, and if I have
- 9:37a relationship with that person or that person gives me a certain kind of vibe,
- 9:41then I would call that emotional abuse. The whole Harvey Weinstein thing because
- 9:46he was known to be a bully and scary, and he had so much
- 9:52power. There were times when all he had to do was just say a
- 9:56couple words or have have a vibe about him, and people felt abused.
- 10:05When you look at what had Nina Hedley Hedley Hetty, the woman who plays
- 10:13Circe Lanister in Game of Thrones. When you hear her account, she was
- 10:16never Harvey Weinstein, never touched her or or only briefly touched her back or
- 10:22something as they were in the elevator. She never entered his hotel room.
- 10:26But she felt abused. She cried afterwards. She's she's probably mildly traumatized by
- 10:33it. And it was all verbal, and it was all kind of implied,
- 10:39and it was all subtle vibe that Harvey Weinstein was giving off. And
- 10:46that to me, is much more powerful than overt, easily recognizable emotional abuse.
- 10:56And if you've ever been through a situation like that, you know what
- 10:58I'm talking. And I'm guessing everyone it's been through a situation like that,
- 11:01whether or not you recognize it as such. But there are people who know
- 11:07how to scare you, and they know how to make you feel afraid through
- 11:13extremely subtle means, And that is, to me, quintessential emotional abuse.
- 11:24Just as another kind of stark example, one time I was I was walking
- 11:28out of a convenience store downtown and this all of a sudden, there was
- 11:35a man standing right in front of me, this big guy, and he
- 11:37punched me as hard as he could in the shoulder, like as hard.
- 11:43I mean, just imagine a big guy punching you in the shoulder as hard
- 11:48as he could and as squarely as he could, just like really just connected,
- 11:54you know. And I remember I was just I was just like huh
- 11:58like and and it hurt physically, right, and naturally it was painful,
- 12:03but it was so weird and so sudden. And I have a certain I
- 12:07have a brain mechanism that kicks in in situations like that where it's just like,
- 12:11remain calm, figure out how to de escalate the situation and get to
- 12:16safety. And so I was totally calm, and I just looked at him
- 12:20and I did a real quick assessment, and I was like, Oh,
- 12:22this guy, he doesn't know me, and he probably is suffering from some
- 12:28mental issue right now and has decided punching me as the answer. And he
- 12:35doesn't appear to be wanting to punch me again. Is that happened? Like
- 12:37in a split second, as I'm sort of looking at him, I gave
- 12:41him a mental pat down, as Mac likes to say, ocular pat down.
- 12:48And so I just calmly said okay, and then walked away. And
- 12:54then later I thought about, like what was going on. I still don't
- 12:58really know what's going on. I'm guessing the guy had some sort of mental
- 13:01issue that made it, you know, made me a target of that.
- 13:05Now, that was physical harm, right, It's very obvious that the guy
- 13:13without any reason harmed me and inflicted pain on me. Was it abusive?
- 13:18No, because I was I didn't feel afraid, I wasn't traumatized by it,
- 13:22and my heart rate probably never rose because it was just it was just
- 13:26so weird. You know, I just thought, oh, that guy something,
- 13:30he's suffering from something, and I feel pain in my arm. You
- 13:33know, it'd be the same as if I'm getting my flu shot and I
- 13:37feel a little bit of pain in my arm. Is that just because I
- 13:39feel pain doesn't mean that I'm experiencing abuse? Right? So I felt pain
- 13:45and I walked away. Now, if someone watched it, would they say
- 13:46that was abusive behavior? They'd say, yeah, that's why would that guy
- 13:50punch that innocent person? It was abusive behavior. But was their harm?
- 13:54No? It was their pain, yeah, But you know it was just
- 13:58just transient pain. Didn't really bother me too much. So again to me
- 14:03just my definition, and it's a very squishy one because you have to ask
- 14:09the person to tell you honestly, have they been emotionally harmed by it?
- 14:16Are they afraid? Were they made to feel afraid? And even if they
- 14:20say no, you have to ask them six months later, two years later,
- 14:26did that event cause any long lasting trauma effects? For example, just
- 14:33using sexual abuse as an example, it if there was a five year old
- 14:39and you had a parent who exposed that child to pornography over the span of
- 14:45a few months or something. You know that there's magazines around, there's internet
- 14:48porn or whatever. And if you ask the child after viewing your father's pornography,
- 14:54are you harmed by it? Were you made to feel afraid? The
- 14:58child would say no, it's fine, you know whatever. But when that
- 15:03child is twenty five, thirty five, that's when you also ask has there
- 15:11been any noticeable pattern in your sexuality and in your relationships that could be attributed
- 15:18to the events of when you were five when in which your father exposed you
- 15:24to all that pornography. Well, I'm here to tell you that there's a
- 15:28lot of people that will say, uh, yeah, now, is there
- 15:31a scientifically proven connection between those between the exposure to pornography and a and a
- 15:39much later pattern in your sexuality and relationships. No, there's no, there's
- 15:43no way to demonstrate that. But in my world, you don't need things
- 15:48to be scientifically proven. You can you can take general guesses and proceed according
- 15:54to those hypotheses. So so that's so that's my definition of abuse. So,
- 16:02for example, you could go to a ten year old and say,
- 16:06are you being harmed by the way your parents are treating you emotionally? And
- 16:11the kid could be like, no, it's fine. You know, it's
- 16:14not a big deal. And I'll be like, are you sure. You're
- 16:17like, yeah, you know. It's bothersome sometimes, but it's fine.
- 16:21I don't. It doesn't really bother me. I've learned to deal with it.
- 16:25It's fine. But when they're thirty five and they come into therapy and
- 16:30we determine that their issues of trust, their attachment disruptions, their PTSD reactions
- 16:38even are manifesting, then we would look back and say you were emotionally abused
- 16:45when you were at ten, even though at the time you didn't really identify
- 16:48it as such. So that's what emotional abuse is to me. So what
- 16:53are some examples of typical emotional abuse. Well, one that I deal with
- 16:56a lot is explosive of anger from a parent that is unpredictable. This often
- 17:03results in trauma, which again meets my criteria for emotional abuse. So we're
- 17:08talking about a parent who was likely mistreated by an explosively angry parent themselves,
- 17:15and they when they're upset. You know, when you're a parent, there's
- 17:21a lot of opportunities to lose your temper. There's a lot of opportunities to
- 17:25get angry. Right, the kid runs out into the street, the kid
- 17:32spills milk, the kid you know, gets angry and throws something at your
- 17:37head. The kid doesn't go to bed on time, the kid breaks your
- 17:45laptop. There's just I don't know. Those are just examples off top my
- 17:48head. There's probably better examples I could think of, But at any rate,
- 17:52or loud noises, right, your kid is just making a bunch of
- 17:56loud noises, your kid pushes your kid down the stairs or something. You
- 18:02know, there's a lot of opportunities for you to feel some anger, and
- 18:07even often explosive anger where you just like this explosive anger just overcomes you.
- 18:14You know, you're just ah, well, if you had been traumatized yourself
- 18:18and or were given a really bad example from your parents about how to deal
- 18:22with that, then then you're you're much more likely to be very explosive with
- 18:26that. And children can be very much traumatized by that because kids are you
- 18:33know, their kids are mischievous at times, but a lot of times they're
- 18:37just sort of unregulated because their children they just don't really know what to do
- 18:41with themselves, and they're trying to process a lot of different things, and
- 18:47then they're trying their best just put it that way, Then all of a
- 18:48sudden, their parents just completely comes out of nowhere and scares the Jesus out
- 18:53of them, and that gets into their neurons when you are terrified. Every
- 19:00time you're terrified, your brain tries to encode that to protect you from later
- 19:04experiences. And so if you rinse and repeat that situation, you develop a
- 19:12pathway in the brain that is PTSD for the child. Anyway, another sign
- 19:18I suppose is feeling like you're walking on egg shells with your parent. This
- 19:23is a very frequent report from emotionally abused children. Is they feel like they're
- 19:30always walking on egg shells. They don't know when their parents going to explode.
- 19:33Other kinds of emotional abuse are frequent and harsh criticism that results in harm,
- 19:38right, And that's important because if you have a parent who is critical
- 19:44but it doesn't really harm the child, either in the moment or later on,
- 19:48then it's not really emotional abuse. But often it is. Often it
- 19:52is taken as harm shaming a child that results in harm or overreacting, you
- 19:59know, just having just having overreactions. So basically you could kind of,
- 20:04in my definition, you could sort of categorize these into two different things.
- 20:08One is to terrify a child to scare them, and then the other one
- 20:15is to make them feel bad about themselves and make to shame them. Okay,
- 20:22So, for example, I've had a number of clients who were emotionally
- 20:29abused by their parents, one or both of their parents as children, and
- 20:33then as adults, say thirty thirty five, forty years old, they come
- 20:37into therapy and they have they have all the classic PTSD symptoms even though they
- 20:44were never physically or sexually abused, They were never physically harmed, but because
- 20:49of the terror that they went through due to the vibe they got from their
- 20:53parents and the explosive anger, but without being violent. As adults, they
- 21:02have PTSD and they have low self esteem, and they'd associate at times,
- 21:07and they don't trust people very much, and they have immature parts of themselves,
- 21:12and they have trouble with relationships sometimes and they can be explosively angry themselves.
- 21:18So it's a very common thing. Okay, So, patron Tara,
- 21:23you ask why do parents do this? Well, there are many reasons and
- 21:27it's hard to reduce to a simple statement. But in my experience, parents
- 21:32who are emotionally abusive were emotionally abused themselves as children. And I know that's
- 21:37just such a typical thing for a therapist to say, but it's been That's
- 21:42been the case one hundred percent of the time in my clinical experience. Are
- 21:47there cases where that wouldn't be true, I'm guessing sure. But people want
- 21:53to do good in life, they want to treat other people well, particularly
- 21:56their children, and so if they end up being emotionally abusive, there must
- 22:02be there must have been something that happened to them, some experience, some
- 22:06ongoing horribleness that happened to someone that would make them go against their human nature
- 22:14in terms of being good to other people. So but often they are they
- 22:18have been mistreated, and that results in a number of things. One is
- 22:22that you end up having a difficult time regulating your own emotions because you weren't
- 22:27given that space to develop those skills. Also, you just have a really
- 22:33bad model for what parenting looks like. And all of us do what our
- 22:38parents did and or we try to improve on it a little bit. And
- 22:42if your parents were very explosively angry, then in your head, it's sort
- 22:48of normal to be explosively angry, right. Other things is you internalize that
- 22:52relationship and then have to defend against it through projective identification and by re enacting
- 22:59those relationships. And if if you want more information on that, listen to
- 23:00my episodes on projective identification and psychodynamic theory. Also, stressors can increase the
- 23:07likelihood. Like I said, any parent is capable of emotional abuse, and
- 23:11every parent probably is emotionally abusive, at least in minor ways. You know,
- 23:17money problems can stress you out, family conflict, trouble with your child's
- 23:22entering the next phase of lice life, like becoming a teenager, or moving
- 23:26out of the house, being marginalized as a family by the rest of society.
- 23:32All these things can increase your stress, which can increase the likelihood of
- 23:34any sort of bad parenting. All right, patron terras slash slade, you
- 23:41asked for the effects. Well, there's a lot of psychopathology that is associated
- 23:47with childhood mistreatment. Depression, anxiety, PTSD, dissociation, bipolar psychosis,
- 23:53borderline personality, narcissistic personality, psychopathy, etc. So a lot of the
- 24:00main DSM labels have been associated with childhood mistreatment, including emotional abuse. Also,
- 24:07you can find that there's a lot of attachment problems with people because if
- 24:14your parent is hurting you, your parents, your parent is your main attachment
- 24:18figure, and so you learn that those people whom you are attracted to are
- 24:26also terrifying and scary. That is a and it becomes basically encoded into your
- 24:33brain. Is a that will create behavior problems later, That will create relationship
- 24:37problems later on, because as you become close to, say a spouse,
- 24:42you will become very sensitive to them because you're worried they're going to hurt you
- 24:47in the way that your parents did. And little hurts will become exaggerated because
- 24:51of the open wounds that you have as a result of being emotionally abused by
- 24:53your parents. Also, other effects that I've mentioned already is basically you just
- 25:00you become sort of numb to being mistreated. At times, people can become
- 25:07almost in denial. Like I'll talk with people as adults and they'll be telling
- 25:14me a story and I'll react to it. I'll be like, wow,
- 25:17you know, it sounds like your spouse is really treating you badly, or
- 25:21it sounds like that friend or that boss is being very intimidating, and the
- 25:26client will say something like, oh, yeah, I guess you're right.
- 25:30And because to them that's just the way people treat people, they're they've normalized
- 25:36it, you know, it's like, well, isn't that what everyone does?
- 25:40Isn't that what life is like? And me on the outside, I'm
- 25:44saying, no, you don't have to put up with that crap. That's
- 25:47not fair to you, and you have every right to take action against that.
- 25:52And so that's another effect. Also, all the defense mechanisms can be
- 25:56involved because of the mistreatment, projective identification or recreating the dynamic with other people.
- 26:04So you were emotionally abused as a child, and so you grow up
- 26:10and you might become emotionally abusive and or attract emotionally abusive people into your life.
- 26:18So those are just some of the effects of emotional abuse. Really,
- 26:22the list could go on and on. Every In some ways, all psychological
- 26:26problems can be at least in part traced back to mistreatment as a child,
- 26:36including emotional abuse, and so you could say that nearly all problems can be
- 26:44caught. Nearly all psychological problems can be caused by emotional abuse as a child.
- 26:49Even things like psychosis is associated with mistreatment as a child. So addiction
- 26:56because you need substances to calm your nerves in order to cope with life,
- 27:00that kind of thing anyway, all right, So that was that, And
- 27:06I think I'm just gonna call that episode emotional child abuse because I talked for
- 27:11long enough to justify this being a standalone episode. So let's just do that.
- 27:15Thanks for joining me. Please take care of yourself because you deserve it,
- 27:18and you deserve not to be abused, and you deserve to recover from
- 27:22abuse. You really, really do