Latest / WonkyFolk / Vol 18 - Jed and Andy Want Freedom from Dysfunction
Transcript
- 0:01Hey, Andy.
- 0:02Hey, Jed.
- 0:03How are you?
- 0:04Yeah, it's been a little while.
- 0:05This summer's been so crazy busy.
- 0:06I hope, all's treating you well.
- 0:09Yeah, we've had a really great summer, of all kinds of ventures
- 0:13before the kids left for college.
- 0:14So I've been, been all over the place and doing a bunch of different stuff.
- 0:18So I'm sorry, I haven't had a chance to see you and check in.
- 0:21Hey, no problem.
- 0:22I did the drop off at college as well, with, for our second.
- 0:27no, that routine, but there's just been so much stuff going on this summer that,
- 0:32I've been wanting to talk with you and see what you're thinking about things.
- 0:35So heck I just want to dive straight in and see what what
- 0:39you're thinking about stuff.
- 0:40You ready to go?
- 0:41Yeah, man.
- 0:42a lot has been happening in the educational world and the
- 0:44larger, larger political world.
- 0:47I think the last time we talked, the party line was that like Joe Biden was
- 0:51running circles around his 25 year old.
- 0:55staffers and then, that's right.
- 0:59during the Republican convention, I really had some questions for you.
- 1:01In fact, we were swapping texts on those things and we haven't really
- 1:04had a chance to talk about it.
- 1:05But in the interim, we had no answers because, yeah, then we get
- 1:09to the democratic inexplicable.
- 1:13but let's you mind if we start with the Democrats and then maybe
- 1:17go back and just re, re touch.
- 1:22Democrats is fresher.
- 1:23it's more recent.
- 1:24yeah, and in some ways less predictable because it was obviously
- 1:27not the convention people thought it would be, a little bit ago.
- 1:30Yeah, I think I'd love to, hear your thoughts.
- 1:34I saw your piece that you wrote about walls and, and I,
- 1:38I wrote about walls as well.
- 1:42there are a variety of things that I've been talking about.
- 1:44I thought it was noteworthy.
- 1:45I think the Wall Street Journal did a, article yesterday or two days ago
- 1:51where they were speculating on who might be appointed To all of the different
- 1:55posts if Harris were to win and they must have done every single cabinet
- 2:00position Except education secretary and it I just think it's reflective
- 2:05of what's going on in the democratic world Generally, they just are trying
- 2:09to erase education Conflict or policy work of any kind from the landscape.
- 2:15Just keep it down.
- 2:16low on the profile low on the on the roster of priorities here.
- 2:21Do you see things any differently now?
- 2:23Look, it's a party splitter, right?
- 2:25And, so they, the one, one of the areas, a couple of areas of dem vulnerability
- 2:33going into the fall, all type education, ends up being a piece, not the whole
- 2:38thing, but a piece of the issue there.
- 2:39So that's, they're concerned about their performance among black voters.
- 2:42Obviously there's a lot more excitement now than there was.
- 2:45Yeah.
- 2:46Not too, long ago, but that's still a problem.
- 2:48Particularly, young black men, they are, struggling among moderates
- 2:54and, centrist to some extent, and.
- 2:57Education, it's a party splitter, among those populations.
- 3:02And so I think they're figuring the, cause it, cause the, obviously cause
- 3:05of the union, the union positions, on a number of reform issues, whether it's,
- 3:10choice, accountability, all of it.
- 3:12So I think, yeah, it's if, you don't talk about it, you'll probably do
- 3:15less damage between now and November.
- 3:17This is not the time for a big inner party fight.
- 3:20that seems like the strategy.
- 3:22Yeah.
- 3:23And there are all sorts of things that are happening
- 3:25perhaps above the charter school.
- 3:27Pay grade, as they're making their calculations about what to do.
- 3:31I think for the Shapiro possible selection as vice president, the his stand on school
- 3:40choice was obviously a very big problem and, the NEA and others were actively
- 3:46working to make sure that he would not be chosen for, education reasons.
- 3:51But then there were the other, there was the stuff around Gaza and Israel.
- 3:54and then apparently there was something around.
- 3:57just a chemistry between him and Harris that factored in.
- 4:01But I got to say in the end, I really wasn't surprised.
- 4:04That's the basic thing is the chemistry.
- 4:05Look, he's an ambitious guy and like her first hire wouldn't need
- 4:09to be an education secretary.
- 4:10Wouldn't need to be a food taster.
- 4:13and so yeah, so that I, it, seemed.
- 4:18and they probably could have worked around that.
- 4:20There's plenty of presidents and vice presidents who didn't have
- 4:22necessarily great chemistry, but we're able to work together.
- 4:25The issue was on top of all that other, on top of all that other stuff,
- 4:30Why run the risk of drama?
- 4:32I just think they wanted something drama free and walls, I think, was a
- 4:37solid candidate that helped in the kind of helps in the rust belt projects who
- 4:44they want into, rural voters and I, at least as it relates to education issues.
- 4:51I think he's just remarkably unremarkable.
- 4:55He's, he is.
- 4:56Yeah.
- 4:57and to go back to Shapiro for a sec, Shapiro is quite remarkable in that he's
- 5:00been running for buck orthodoxy at times.
- 5:02And I think that's for the, I think it's less the choice thing.
- 5:06we had in 2004, we had a democratic vice presidential
- 5:09nominee who was very pro voucher.
- 5:12and, that can be, That can be finessed.
- 5:15I think the thing with Shapiro is they didn't, they feel like he's not,
- 5:19they can't necessarily control him.
- 5:21and if you're somebody like me, you think that's good because he's going to
- 5:23actually do creative innovative policy.
- 5:25But if you're the teacher's unions, that's just a huge liability.
- 5:29And so they wanted somebody a lot more predictable.
- 5:32And I think one of the things that came through with walls, including
- 5:36all the reactions to him from Minnesotans that we gathered is
- 5:38he's, he seems pretty predictable.
- 5:40Yeah, and I think, hearing from Joe Nathan, hearing from Amber and the
- 5:45others that you interviewed, it seems as though, obviously, an educator himself,
- 5:51cares a lot about public education, has a lot of alignment with the teacher
- 5:54unions, but for our charter folk in Minnesota, They haven't found him to
- 5:59be one that's actively going against them or really causing problems is,
- 6:03perhaps, a low key supporter, as long as things don't get very controversial.
- 6:08Did you pick up anything different in your discussions?
- 6:11No, we could talk about that.
- 6:12I do think so, over the years I've done some work in Minnesota, I spent
- 6:15a little time around the Capitol with some of the political leaders there.
- 6:19One thing that, really has always struck me is there's generally
- 6:23a pragmatism and let's figure out, what's good for Minnesota?
- 6:28What should we do here?
- 6:29It's not that there's not disagreement in ideology.
- 6:32but like on the charter school thing, Walls, he's definitely
- 6:36no fan of charter schools.
- 6:37And anyone who's trying to tell you that is spinning you.
- 6:39But on the other hand, he's there, they're there, they're educating kids.
- 6:43So he brings I think just like a degree of seriousness.
- 6:46Like what do we do about this?
- 6:49that you don't see in some of these other sort of ideological, just a,
- 6:52degree of like practicality because it's people's kids are in these schools.
- 6:55They're trying to live their lives.
- 6:56How do you not be like hyper disruptive?
- 7:00and that's what we heard, but you didn't hear anybody who's Oh,
- 7:04he's just like a great friend.
- 7:05He's a great reformer.
- 7:06And so I think one of the takeaways for this is
- 7:12I, wrote a piece of this a while ago and throw in the show notes that,
- 7:15Joe, saying Joe Biden's a centrist.
- 7:17And of course, I got an ear full of shit from the usual
- 7:19suspects are like, no, he's woke.
- 7:20It's all lefty and everything.
- 7:21It's no, he's find, where the median sort of set of politics with the
- 7:26democratic party is any point in time.
- 7:28And you're going to find Joe Biden, like when he got into Politics.
- 7:31He was like opposed to busing.
- 7:32And then, the last few years he's been, in a totally different place
- 7:36on a number of race issues and guts because the Democratic Party's evolved.
- 7:41I think Harris is the same way.
- 7:42And I think walls is the same way.
- 7:43And what they have in common is that surprise their politicians.
- 7:47and that's what they're going to do.
- 7:48And so the reform community has to figure out, okay, because you were saying going
- 7:52to the fall, no one's really talking about education yet because there's no pressure.
- 7:56And so the reform has to figure out how do you create pressure to force those
- 8:00hard Conversations and force those issues.
- 8:04that's, I think otherwise you're going to get, and the sort of parallel I'd use is
- 8:09last night in her speech, when she talked about the war in Gaza, like essentially
- 8:14Harris had something for everybody.
- 8:16She said, Israel should be able to defend itself.
- 8:20Hamas is terrible.
- 8:22The people in Gaza should be able to live a life of dignity and security
- 8:26and not put up with many of the things that they've been putting up with.
- 8:29Which essentially is by the way, this position, most people agree with, except
- 8:32the hardcore ideologues on all sides.
- 8:34But it was a something for everybody policy cause they wanted to go away
- 8:40until the second week in November.
- 8:43and I think we're seeing the same thing.
- 8:44We're seeing the same thing on education.
- 8:46How significant do you think it is that Harris becomes the candidate without
- 8:49having run the gauntlet of the primary process, which is usually the place
- 8:54where NEA and AFT invite the candidates to come and speak and really kowtow
- 9:00specifically to their extreme agenda.
- 9:03The fact that there wasn't that, Harris, she had to do it in 2019,
- 9:08but it's now, four years later.
- 9:10That's distant history.
- 9:11It seems to me as though the lack of the primary process and that key leverage
- 9:15point for the unions allows Harris and Walls to perhaps stake out something a
- 9:20little bit more moderate and neutral.
- 9:22But am I reading it differently than you?
- 9:24It allows them to whether they will is going to be a different story.
- 9:29and they're already, getting wrapped in that whole process.
- 9:34I think, the thing with Harris, she has been tested in a primary in 2020.
- 9:39It didn't go well.
- 9:41like her challenge itself.
- 9:43is she's a very good inside player.
- 9:47She's been very successful in California, democratic politics,
- 9:50obviously, as sort of her rise shows.
- 9:52And more about this.
- 9:53I want to hear your take on this.
- 9:55She hasn't really, you people say, she hasn't earned a vote outside of
- 9:59California and that's like half true.
- 10:01she was on the ticket in 2020.
- 10:02So people across the country, voted for it and that ticket got more votes, but,
- 10:09But there is something to the idea.
- 10:11She's basically been more of an inside player.
- 10:13She's California politics are not Republican Democrats or
- 10:16intra democratic politics.
- 10:18and so what is that going to look like?
- 10:20And I think if I'm the unions, I like that because she's proven pretty well at
- 10:24operating in a space that they control pretty effect, pretty effectively.
- 10:29she hasn't had to govern and persuade across the middle.
- 10:34And you saw that a little bit of, I think the democratic
- 10:36convention went extremely well.
- 10:39We can talk about that.
- 10:40But the one thing I thought was interesting is there was not as much
- 10:44pitching to persuadables and moderates and like, how do we really like peel
- 10:49off some Nikki Haley voters and all of this than you would have thought.
- 10:53there was a lot of stuff that was aimed pretty squarely at the base.
- 10:56And I think the base is pretty squarely in her corner.
- 10:59That's not where, that's not where she risks losing votes and what looks
- 11:03like it's gonna be a tight election.
- 11:05Yeah.
- 11:05I thought it was striking that In the Democratic Party platform,
- 11:10education literally doesn't make the table of contents.
- 11:13The Republican convention, document, it was near the top and they were expansive
- 11:20in all the things that they want to get done, whether or not we agree with those
- 11:23things or whatever, they have a theory.
- 11:25They feel like they're on offense.
- 11:27And in order to get to the education stuff, you had to click
- 11:30into one of their subcommit.
- 11:32It was like something about reducing costs.
- 11:35It was reducing costs.
- 11:36Education is in there and you reduce like the higher ed costs,
- 11:41And then that provides the segue to talk about the rest of education.
- 11:44Don't you find it striking that, the democratic party would be so,
- 11:51quiet, so under the radar about, things that wants to do in education.
- 11:57Yeah.
- 11:57especially because if I'm remembering right, the 2021.
- 12:02They obviously didn't go hardcore to choice, but it did talk about
- 12:06ending, making sure there's quality options across every zip code.
- 12:10I think a reasonable person then says, then maybe we should not
- 12:13have zip code based education, but, but it's even a walk back.
- 12:19It's even a walk back from that.
- 12:21Yeah, it was.
- 12:21look, they want the issue.
- 12:22They want the issue to go away.
- 12:25we can get to the Republicans.
- 12:26Their platform is no great shakes either, even by the standards of these things.
- 12:30It was pretty vacuous and like thematic with your you'll search in
- 12:34vain for any real policy on education.
- 12:38but yeah, it's a good example.
- 12:39They want this.
- 12:40They want this problem to go away, at least through.
- 12:45at least through November.
- 12:47And what do you think?
- 12:48And for reformers, I will say we're going to be back in the same spot where
- 12:52everybody like, everybody was like Cardona people who, hasn't necessarily had a great
- 12:57run as secretary, but people are relieved.
- 12:59They weren't relieved.
- 13:00Cause oh my God, we got this great.
- 13:02Person is going to be transformative.
- 13:03It was like, like the thing you heard ever, I could have
- 13:05been worse, which is true.
- 13:07and we're going to end performance.
- 13:08We'll be right back in that same spot.
- 13:11if Harris wins in November.
- 13:13Yeah.
- 13:14It'll be interesting to see whether or not they just, whether Harris just
- 13:18appoints Cardona again, we want no, no attention on education issues.
- 13:21We want no drama, just.
- 13:24going would not surprise me at all.
- 13:26But I, I think it's interesting.
- 13:30That's a good, that's a good thing, Jed.
- 13:31I don't know if you saw Tim Daly's piece.
- 13:33At what point are people going to be willing to say we've now had basically
- 13:37eight years of a leadership vacuum over there, and we can't afford 12.
- 13:43That's a, kid's entire travel through, through the public education system.
- 13:48And I was struck.
- 13:48So Tim writes this piece and all these people are willing to talk
- 13:52anonymously about how exasperated they are, how bad it's been, but
- 13:55hardly anybody will go on the record.
- 13:57And it's like, that, that's, not a good look for this community.
- 14:01Like at some point, like, when are people going to say, Hey, you know what?
- 14:04Like you can hold two things to your head at the same time.
- 14:07I'm not trying to be coy.
- 14:08Like I'm somehow like an independent analyst on this.
- 14:10I want Kamala Harris to win in November.
- 14:13I don't think Donald Trump should be president, but I can hold that
- 14:16in my head and also say, this has not been a great run on education.
- 14:19I'm going to be voting for, despite.
- 14:22What it looks like.
- 14:23Same thing as Biden and I voted for Biden 2020 the same way.
- 14:26And this community is struggling with that.
- 14:30And I think it's a problem and it leads to like bad policy, no pressure for change.
- 14:37and, we're getting, what we get.
- 14:40I think we see a democratic party though, that.
- 14:42Is moderating generally and maybe something just for electoral strategy
- 14:48and we end up sagging back to something different But it's noteworthy to me that
- 14:51you see in california Newsome say bring me, you know some anti crime legislation
- 14:57anti, theft mom stuff And we see them harris basically embrace an immigration
- 15:05bill that you know, not so long ago would have been considered completely
- 15:08anathema You In the democratic race.
- 15:11So it seems to be like all over the place with four years ago, if you were saying
- 15:15this country is the greatest country on earth, like literally, let's let's let's
- 15:19let's not put too fond of a point on this.
- 15:21Like they're like, there were workshops across the education sector saying
- 15:25if you said that you were hopelessly unreconstructed, if not just outright
- 15:29racist, for saying that this is the greatest country on the face of the
- 15:34earth, the greatest Republican history.
- 15:36and people were chanting that.
- 15:38Yeah.
- 15:38Last night.
- 15:39So it's not just moderating.
- 15:41It's just a complete makeover.
- 15:44which look, I'm, good with.
- 15:46I've been saying like the Democrats need to be more normal
- 15:49and they'll win more elections.
- 15:51but like it is, noteworthy just how much
- 15:57again, like it says something about the community that you
- 15:59and I operate in, like where,
- 16:03how quickly everybody can, just different tune starts playing, everybody changes
- 16:08the dance and that, that should cause at least some questioning about, the
- 16:12degree and deepness of people's political commitments around some of this stuff.
- 16:16the contrast, though, is that in all of these other places where you see
- 16:20them re anchoring, repositioning.
- 16:23There's nothing happening in education.
- 16:25There's just absolute silence.
- 16:27And I wonder, yeah.
- 16:29Science 1 0 1, though, you know this, like the, folks who think America's
- 16:34nothing but a litany of sins.
- 16:36They're out there and they're loud, but they're not really organized.
- 16:38The teacher's unions are quite organized and in politics, organized always
- 16:42beats diffused, and the few times it doesn't organize comes roaring
- 16:47back and wins on the second track.
- 16:49. Yeah.
- 16:50is it, is this a different way of saying the other.
- 16:54Issues are ones where there's not a constituency strong enough to resist
- 16:58them re anchoring, but education is, that what you're basically,
- 17:02is that a re learning element?
- 17:04one of the things, you can have your pick of special interest groups, like
- 17:09if you're telling me like, if you have to be ruled by somebody like the N.
- 17:13E.
- 17:13A.
- 17:13Or the N.
- 17:13R.
- 17:14A.
- 17:14Like it's a reasonable thing to say, I'll take the N.
- 17:16E.
- 17:16A.
- 17:16But like they're both fundamentally interest groups.
- 17:19And what happens is people ascribe these virtues and to these interest groups
- 17:24that and they're all that this interest groups do the same kind of stuff.
- 17:28They influence the process the same way.
- 17:32and so there's a reason like the republicans act the way they act on guns.
- 17:37Because the NRA is organized, they are there, and frankly a bunch of like even
- 17:40harder core, pro gun groups, on the NEA's, excuse me, on the NRA's right flank.
- 17:46and it's the same thing with, with the teachers unions, and it's worth noting
- 17:50inside the teachers unions, the pressure on the leadership there is not to
- 17:54moderate, it's to be more extreme, right?
- 17:57That's what they're getting, internally, and that's how it's
- 18:00impacting their leadership.
- 18:01And so So it's just, it's, the same reason we don't suddenly expect the
- 18:06oil companies to like completely change their tune on environmental issues.
- 18:11We don't expect wall street to change its tune on financial regulation.
- 18:15Like it's just when it happens in our sector, everybody treats it as somehow
- 18:18like very different and unusual, and maybe those things don't apply.
- 18:22It's the same thing.
- 18:23It's special interest politics.
- 18:24And Reformers could do worse than say, okay, we're trying to change a
- 18:27publicly governed system with heavy, heavy special interest involvement.
- 18:33How has that worked or not worked in other sectors?
- 18:35What do you do instead of thinking that somehow this
- 18:38issue we work on is a unicorn?
- 18:40so question, I, accept all that.
- 18:42I think it's the right analysis.
- 18:43Now, here's the next question.
- 18:45Okay, they can't pivot.
- 18:46They can't move on education issues.
- 18:48But then look what is happening in urban education right now.
- 18:52it's just so striking.
- 18:53Brandon Johnson, the mayor of Chicago, spent his whole life working in education
- 18:58and for the union, when he welcomes people to Chicago, he can't even mention what's
- 19:02going on within Chicago public schools.
- 19:04He's trying to force out, Martinez right now.
- 19:07The implosion in CPS is just, Tragic.
- 19:11There was the same thing happening in Milwaukee, a few months earlier
- 19:15at the Republican convention.
- 19:16I don't know if you're following what's going on in St.
- 19:18Louis.
- 19:19This is an abject tragedy.
- 19:21I just, I don't think long term the Dem policymakers can stay on not changing.
- 19:30When this is what's happening within major urban school districts across the country.
- 19:34Am I right or wrong here?
- 19:36I don't know.
- 19:37I feel like the one thing that people like under value is the dem the dem
- 19:41leadership They have an enormous ally and supporter, in their ability to kick
- 19:47this down the road and that's called the republicans and so you always think
- 19:52there's going to be a reckoning on this because it is it's untenable as you're
- 19:56saying from any sort of moral standpoint value standpoint Like at all connecting
- 20:02like rhetoric with action, and especially, post pandemic, it's just unacceptable.
- 20:10Except then the Republicans go off and do their stuff.
- 20:15And and you have to go back to, George Bush had a sort of compelling,
- 20:21effective and coherent education policy, and the Republicans are doing
- 20:25really well on education, and they were doing well in a positive way.
- 20:29Now they're doing okay on it, but it's mostly Because of parental frustration.
- 20:34you have some Republican governors who are reasonably popular on it, but in
- 20:39general, so nationally, it's more like people are still frustrated and so forth.
- 20:42And so they're doing well because people are just fed up and not doing well.
- 20:46Cause like people are really excited about some sort of positive affirmative agenda
- 20:49and there's obviously, cause they're less.
- 20:52hindered on some of this stuff by the, politics, there is an agenda out
- 20:56there for them, that they could take in terms of like transparency, choice,
- 21:02accountability, empowering parents.
- 21:03Like it's a bunch of really popular stuff, but it's hard for them.
- 21:08it's hard for them to walk back from crazy.
- 21:10And it's particularly hard when Donald Trump's at the top of your ticket.
- 21:14Yeah, I don't know if you see it.
- 21:17I don't know if you see it differently, but that's where
- 21:19it's like it's a two party.
- 21:21It's a two party dynamic.
- 21:22And so you're
- 21:25until one party, the Democrats really got their act together for a while in
- 21:28education when, when there was pressure and when the pressure is not there.
- 21:33and there's a vacuum, you get what we see now.
- 21:36Yeah, I blame it on the Republicans.
- 21:38I guess to some extent, I primarily blame it on us.
- 21:42Yeah.
- 21:42I don't think we have a theory.
- 21:44I don't think we have an idea about what's supposed to happen
- 21:47in places like Chicago and St.
- 21:49Louis.
- 21:51the, new lead of the Missouri Association, Noah Devine, I think
- 21:54this guy is doing an incredible job, but he's early in his tenure.
- 21:57And, he, emails me and we call, we talk about, what's the playbook
- 22:02or what it's supposed to, what's the charter school world supposed
- 22:04to do when something like St.
- 22:06Louis happens?
- 22:06I'm sure we have 10, 15 examples of like things that would help
- 22:09me in my moment right now.
- 22:11And.
- 22:12He was just shocked to learn.
- 22:13We don't really have any examples.
- 22:15We don't have any North Star in these places, and my sense is that
- 22:19if we had an agenda, if we had a North Star, if we were pushing for it
- 22:23proactively, and then these implosions happen, they may have ignored us.
- 22:31Before, but in the moment of the implosion, they're not going to ignore
- 22:35it anymore, but we don't have it.
- 22:37No.
- 22:37And the question is, who's the us there?
- 22:39Like I, I was struck.
- 22:42Donald Trump was terrible.
- 22:44and he didn't do much on charters and the extent he proposed policies.
- 22:47They weren't particularly good ideas in my view.
- 22:49But, He at least talked about choice and so forth and said
- 22:54he was going to do some stuff.
- 22:55And that caused a number of people to simply abandon choice and walk away.
- 23:00Cause if Trump and DeVos were for it, then they didn't want to be for it.
- 23:04And my view is if your political commitments on this stuff are that easily
- 23:09rattled, Reverse then they're not real.
- 23:11That's not a real political commitment to begin with.
- 23:13Yeah.
- 23:15and so I think the question I agree with you.
- 23:17I'm just pushing on this.
- 23:18I think we have to define who is this idea of us?
- 23:20'cause I think what charters have discovered or should have discovered is
- 23:24they have a lot of really fickle friends.
- 23:27Who are not going to be there at all when there's any kind of headwind.
- 23:31I guess us, in this context, is wonky folk.
- 23:35Both the charter school people and the ed reformers.
- 23:37What is our theory here?
- 23:38And I don't think we have one.
- 23:40and we really pay the price in moments like this.
- 23:43I will just, I know we've been talking about this, Dem convention piece.
- 23:47and may, whatever.
- 23:48I think sometimes I am the more pessimistic one.
- 23:52or I'm, talking about half empty rather than half full, and I got
- 23:56to, moderate my own language.
- 23:57My mom, gives me a hard time from time, from, time to time.
- 24:02I'm a little bit more sanguine in, in, in what may happen with
- 24:07the Democratic Party right now.
- 24:08I just feel like having not refreshed, They're anchoring to any a stuff.
- 24:13I think Bowman losing is actually pretty important.
- 24:17He was, one of the most anti charter legislators that's out there.
- 24:22I just think, the time is ripe.
- 24:26They haven't really committed anything.
- 24:29And in that moment of vacuum.
- 24:33To assert ourselves in ways that shows how our policy agenda and our north
- 24:37star actually Fits perfectly within the pantheon of democratic values.
- 24:43Now is our moment.
- 24:44We should be getting ourselves ready I agree.
- 24:47I agree with that but that takes political pressure takes sustained political
- 24:52pressure and it takes a willingness to have real hard conversations with your
- 24:58allies and I worry I agree Like people think that will just happen organically.
- 25:04there's just a lot of vibes rather than that's a process.
- 25:08This is about power and you have to, it has to be rested away.
- 25:13and that's that's a long process.
- 25:16And I do feel like people are still very much in a sort of do no harm mode
- 25:20where it's okay, we'll have, a lot of big donors, support charters, maybe
- 25:24they can head off like the worst stuff.
- 25:26And, the, That making sure that like a call for more transparency doesn't
- 25:31become a bunch of, regulations intended to curtail the growth of charters.
- 25:35that's not a great place, to be.
- 25:40yeah, I'm always optimistic that, there's going to be, politics ebbs
- 25:44and flows and, ideas coming in waves.
- 25:48And there's,
- 25:51a trough they call punctuate equilibrium is always, I'm always optimistic
- 25:54over time, but I think people undervalue how much this stuff just
- 25:58does not just happen out of thin air.
- 26:01So is there anything you want to go back to as it relates
- 26:03to the Republican convention?
- 26:04We, we've spoken a lot about Dems here.
- 26:07Yeah.
- 26:07And, were there any observations you wanted to share there?
- 26:11Yeah.
- 26:12look, I don't know, like it struck me, I think, and again, I think the Dems had
- 26:17a, I think the Dems had better convention in some ways than the Republicans did.
- 26:20The Republicans didn't like super damage themselves, but I don't
- 26:22think they accomplished much.
- 26:23Whereas the Dems, I don't think that this a really close election.
- 26:27I think the polls, as of when we're recording, even, accounting for
- 26:31the volatility, that's it's tight.
- 26:34the Dems, put themselves in a position to create a permission structure
- 26:38to lower back a lot of, persuadable voters, but they haven't done it yet.
- 26:42Now they gotta do that this fall.
- 26:44The Republican convention, I feel like it was just an enormous
- 26:48missed opportunity for them.
- 26:49It seemed coming out of the assassination attempt and everything, Trump had
- 26:53to basically do two big things, pick a compelling vice president.
- 26:58And, give a normal acceptance speech on the last night of
- 27:05the convention and lay out the framework for the case for the fall.
- 27:07And he failed at both of those just miserably.
- 27:10So I was actually one of those people.
- 27:11I was like, he could probably close the deal this week.
- 27:14And then attention just turns to, okay, like how bad is the
- 27:17damage going to be down ballot?
- 27:20in the Senate, in the House, everything else, but instead
- 27:22he picked the vice president.
- 27:24You can argue like, vice presidents don't matter that much.
- 27:26And the advance on the van stuff may be overstated, but the fact is every
- 27:30day you're explaining, something crazy that your, vice president said.
- 27:36You're not communicating your message.
- 27:37You're not.
- 27:37And so the Republicans have a, they have a JD Vance problem there because
- 27:41clearly nobody vetted this stuff.
- 27:43Not that it would necessarily be disqualifying, but just like nobody,
- 27:46like I said, you got to have an answer.
- 27:48When somebody asks you about this stuff about childless, people and
- 27:52stuff, you got to have an answer.
- 27:53And they were just totally caught.
- 27:56so just complete political malpractice.
- 27:58And then, the acceptance speech was just bonkers.
- 28:02If trump, could just be a little bit normal and say something like, Hey,
- 28:05you know what, like our politics and our rhetoric have gotten out of hand.
- 28:09we saw evidence of that this week and I deserve, some responsibility
- 28:13for that as well as, there's responsibility to go around.
- 28:16We need to off.
- 28:16He had just been like remotely normal, but he cannot do that.
- 28:20he's so defective.
- 28:22That he could, he couldn't even, let alone if he believes any of that,
- 28:25he couldn't, utter the words that they're putting in front of him.
- 28:29it's, which to me is precisely why he should not be,
- 28:35and so I feel like for them,
- 28:38the racist still status quo, it's close and a chance they had
- 28:41to maybe, to maybe make a move.
- 28:45they, blew.
- 28:49it wasn't terrible.
- 28:50Like they didn't again, no, like terrible damage, but I don't think, I don't think
- 28:56they helped themselves in a way that they had an opportunity to, and then
- 29:00the race reset and I still don't think.
- 29:02And you're seeing this, they don't have a good response to Kamala Harris yet.
- 29:06And, they better figure it out because the election's coming.
- 29:09And she, I think this idea that she was just going to be a terrible candidate.
- 29:13this, a lot of stuff can still happen, but so far she's doing, she's,
- 29:17politically she's doing quite Well, in terms of the Republican convention,
- 29:22in terms of just milestones that have now shifted, it seems pretty clear now
- 29:27the litmus test is universal vouchers.
- 29:31Universal is in there now, and it was the second highest priority.
- 29:36The other one was some cockamamie throwaway.
- 29:40Universal vouchers is the new it is the new litmus test and we saw in Tennessee,
- 29:47the governor took out several that would not support universal vouchers.
- 29:52And now he's gearing up to take another run at the Tennessee vouchers.
- 29:56and of course Abbott did the same thing in Texas.
- 30:00I think we're going to see even more universal voucher pressure happen.
- 30:03I do think that, should they prevail and should there be
- 30:08a democratic administration, which is not willing to allow.
- 30:12federal funds to flow to voucher funded schools.
- 30:16The disconnect between red and blue policymakers is going to get even
- 30:20more pronounced, especially when red state politicians find that
- 30:24their universal programs are very difficult to afford at the state level.
- 30:29I just see us careening further forward in that dysfunctional direction.
- 30:33Yeah, this will be an issue to watch.
- 30:34The two things I'm paying attention to there a little bit.
- 30:37One, inside the Republican Party, there's an interesting dynamic where you're right,
- 30:41that is becoming the price of admission.
- 30:43But because of their constitutional structures and so forth, this is
- 30:46not an option really in every state.
- 30:49And so what is it gonna, what's the effect going to be Governors who
- 30:55can't actually do a lot of this stuff.
- 30:56They're not going to have a record on it because their state doesn't allow it.
- 30:59And you saw a little bit of that with, in the Republican primary,
- 31:03when Nikki Haley and Ron DeSantis got into it about who was better.
- 31:07And, DeSantis was like hitting her on, the stuff she didn't do.
- 31:11And she's Hey, look at my state, look at, here's the apparatus I
- 31:14have to operate in, usually, which it was a political conversation.
- 31:19So DeSantis wasn't having any of that, but like she was making a good point.
- 31:22Hey, can I, I can only do so much.
- 31:24We have a constitution.
- 31:26and that's going to affect other governors.
- 31:28And so how that plays out enter.
- 31:30And my concern is, does that then lead to people want to
- 31:33distinguish themselves other ways?
- 31:34So you end up on some of these really divisive social issues instead.
- 31:39so that's a dynamic I'd pay attention to.
- 31:40And then a second one is, look, the Dem lineup in the Senate is tough.
- 31:47You never, everyone's full of certitude in politics, as a couple,
- 31:50again, the last time we were together, Everybody said there's
- 31:52no way Biden was going to drop out.
- 31:55there's all these, all these things.
- 31:59and so people should know better.
- 32:01so but the Senate's a tough lineup for the Democrats.
- 32:04If you look at this, they really need to, draw to an inside straight.
- 32:09So Bill Cassidy from Louisiana may well become, the chair of the,
- 32:13Senate, the Committee that Handles Education, the HELP Committee.
- 32:16He has a choice bill in now that hasn't gotten a lot of attention,
- 32:21that I would pay attention to.
- 32:22And I think he, you would see more choice activity.
- 32:26He's not an ideologue.
- 32:28and he's really good on a bunch of education.
- 32:29He's terrific on child mental health, for instance.
- 32:32yeah.
- 32:33he's a doctor.
- 32:36so I would keep an eye out for something on choice for him.
- 32:39And to your situation you're talking about, you could see this
- 32:42emerging as actually a negotiation point where we're, how, much
- 32:46flexibility do you give these states?
- 32:47What does it, what does it look like?
- 32:49And so forth.
- 32:49So I think that's going to be, that's going to be an issue worth watching.
- 32:55how that, I think you're onto something and how that dynamic plays out.
- 32:59Yeah, I think that's gonna be foundational.
- 33:00And I don't think there's been that much policy substance related to Vance.
- 33:05I would glob onto except I found it interesting.
- 33:09I saw an interview where he was talking about the child tax credit
- 33:15and how, and he's a big supporter of it, which is noteworthy and
- 33:21new for at least some Republicans.
- 33:23But he was very clear in the interview.
- 33:27It's not right that this tax value would only come to low income families
- 33:34and absolutely everybody should get it.
- 33:37And it just seems like a positioning that's very consistent with the,
- 33:41these universal vouchers, which is, Hey, let's go up with a dollar amount
- 33:45and give the same to everybody.
- 33:46And that's going to get us the.
- 33:48Result we want in the end.
- 33:50Yeah, look, I'm not a big JD Vance fan.
- 33:53and some of the, stuff he said is being caricatured and so forth,
- 33:56and he does have a view on like the tax code helping families, and you
- 34:03can argue whether it's a good idea.
- 34:04He is had some ideas on like basically picking winners and losers at, on, on tax.
- 34:09Policy based on family structure, which I think you can argue the
- 34:13tax code shouldn't be doing that.
- 34:15But like he's pretty consistent on it.
- 34:17And you're seeing that you're seeing that here.
- 34:20And I think what's interesting is the Republican Party is in evolution.
- 34:25it's, there's a MAGA party.
- 34:28there's the, establishment Republicans.
- 34:31there's a shaking out going on.
- 34:32It's very fast.
- 34:33fluid.
- 34:33And so you saw so as discordant as it was like, again, to see like the
- 34:38Democrats, all chanting, you, it sounded like the Democratic convention sounded
- 34:42like a Republican convention at points.
- 34:44The Republican convention, you had this weird thing, you had these
- 34:47delegates on the floor holding these like anti immigrant signs and so forth.
- 34:51And yet both the, People on the ticket, the both the presidential
- 34:54candidate and the vice presidential candidate are married to immigrants.
- 34:59and Vance's personal life is very, illustrative of the United
- 35:05States and how we're changing and how the country's evolving and
- 35:08becoming more inclusive and better.
- 35:10And so I feel like, there's more to, there's, there, there's, there,
- 35:13I don't know what side's gonna win.
- 35:16I can't handicap.
- 35:17that.
- 35:19but it does seem like there's an evolution going on and things are gonna,
- 35:24things are gonna look different one way or another when the dust settles.
- 35:28someday we need to get to a political circumstance such that
- 35:31we can actually talk about issues.
- 35:33And at least from my standpoint, if we look at this over a multi decade,
- 35:38landscape, We're in declining population.
- 35:42We're in declining enrollment, and the countries that succeed are
- 35:46the ones that are going to be able to attract the young people that
- 35:50their economies need to succeed.
- 35:52And yes, some of those young people will be coming from a
- 35:54variety of different contexts.
- 35:56Some of them will be more affluent countries and all that kind of
- 35:58stuff, but a significant portion of them are not going to be.
- 36:01And the question is going to be, not only can countries.
- 36:05Be smart enough to recognize that they should be letting these young
- 36:08families in, but they can also do a great job of educating their kids.
- 36:13Once they arrive, this is an imperative for the country right now.
- 36:17That's nowhere discussed.
- 36:20Position, George Bush was like, we have to like, have a well regulated
- 36:26orderly border, but once people are here under whatever circumstance,
- 36:29their kids ought to be in school and now that's being revisited, right?
- 36:33People want to, change that.
- 36:34To me, that's just common.
- 36:36You should have kids in school.
- 36:38And frankly, look, I'm, very pro immigrant.
- 36:41given my family background, how could I not be?
- 36:43But, if like immigrants historically, maybe this will be the time they'll
- 36:47be different, but historically they always make us better.
- 36:49They make us stronger.
- 36:50They make us more dynamic.
- 36:53And we, we, we periodically forget that.
- 36:56I remember Trump in 2016, one of his attack lines on Hillary was
- 36:59if, Hillary Clinton wins, there'll be a taco truck on every corner.
- 37:03And it was interesting because a lot of people are like, is
- 37:05that, wait, are you for her?
- 37:09Cause that sounds great.
- 37:12And like you just, it, the communities flourish.
- 37:15That's what makes America such an interesting tapestry.
- 37:18And I think the party that can get to that sooner, we'll also
- 37:23saying, look, any country has to have an orderly regulated border.
- 37:27You're not a country.
- 37:28And I think like the can get there.
- 37:30And I think Harris took some strides, at least rhetorically trying to get there.
- 37:35that, that couldn't have gone, she was talking about being tougher on the border.
- 37:39This is, a few months ago, Biden was apologizing for using
- 37:42the word illegal immigrant.
- 37:44That tells you how much things, how much, how fast things are changing.
- 37:47Yeah, the foundational difference between now and then, from my standpoint, is
- 37:52that back then we thought that we were on a trajectory for global population
- 37:56exceeding 20 billion, and we're just going to have too many people altogether.
- 38:00And now we're in this recognition where, wait a second, the dem
- 38:05demographic pyramids are such that.
- 38:08We have aging societies and not enough young people.
- 38:11And so it just completely changes the imperative for a country.
- 38:15And yet our discussion is still locked into jingoism and cultural issues.
- 38:21And it's just at some point.
- 38:23Here's the weird thing.
- 38:24That's the rhetoric.
- 38:26But then you look at more and more how people are living their lives.
- 38:29You look at the rate of, interracial and cross ethnic marriages and all of this,
- 38:34like people, if you believe in revealed preferences, Which I do people are moving.
- 38:40There's all this rhetoric in this, but things are moving, in a different
- 38:45direction and not always in ways.
- 38:47People predict, right?
- 38:50everybody thought that the increasing number of Hispanic Americans was
- 38:55going to, it would be inevitable that there'd just be a wave for Democrats.
- 38:58And as it turns out, Reagan was more right that like their, Republicans,
- 39:03they just didn't know it yet.
- 39:04It was what he used to say.
- 39:05And that's what's, that's what's happening.
- 39:07And it's, it's scrambling our politics.
- 39:09And yeah, I don't know.
- 39:11I just think, I'm more optimist.
- 39:14I think you get these loud voices and so forth.
- 39:17But I think most people appreciate this is good.
- 39:20And frankly, in our little corner of the world at the public schools,
- 39:23they ought to be on the front lines of being pro immigration because
- 39:27we're losing kids because people are moving out of a lot of these places.
- 39:31They are sending their kids to other options and that
- 39:33accelerated after the pandemic.
- 39:35And to your point, there's fewer we've got this demographic thing.
- 39:38So they should be they should be out in front This is their this
- 39:41is like their your customer base.
- 39:44and they should be out in front on that Yeah, let's strike you together.
- 39:46I mean if harris wins, we will have the not just the first, first man in the in
- 39:54the in as a part of this, but we will have a first couple that is interracial.
- 39:59and if you look at the, the Olympic sport, the U.
- 40:03S.
- 40:03team, it was like every single winner, was running into the crowd to embrace
- 40:08people of different races that were either their spouses or their moms or whatever.
- 40:14That's my point.
- 40:14This is how, people like pollsters don't even ask some of these questions
- 40:18that they used to ask about things like interracial issues because it's a waste
- 40:23of a poll question because it always comes back overwhelmingly because it's
- 40:26just not, people are more likely to be concerned that their, son or daughter,
- 40:32much more likely now to be concerned their son or daughter is in an interpolitical
- 40:35relationship, that they're on a Republican dating a Democrat or Democrat dating a
- 40:38Republican than they are worried about the sort of stuff that used to hang people up.
- 40:41Yeah.
- 40:43so yeah, I would say one thing on Harris is why we're on it.
- 40:47because it ties into our family issues, what we do.
- 40:50So you remember a couple of months ago she was, before she was nominee, she
- 40:53went on the Drew Barrymore show and okay, Drew Barrymore did this really weird,
- 40:59cringy, kind of kids would say cringy, thing where she was like, you're our
- 41:02mama and we need a national mama law.
- 41:06Yeah, it was very weird.
- 41:08and Drew Barrymore, her whole posture was strange.
- 41:10As someone said, it was as if Kamala Harris had Coke and Drew Barrymore
- 41:13knew, it was just very, it was a very weird interaction was weird.
- 41:18And, but what was really disappointing about it to me was, and it was the
- 41:23example of other terrible advance work that has plagued Harris.
- 41:28what, what was interesting about it to me though, is just before that
- 41:32they had a fascinating exchange.
- 41:35Where Harris was talking about having a blended family and what that's and
- 41:40how, being, being a, a step mom and that sort of and it was one of these answers.
- 41:46You were like, it took me back.
- 41:47I was like the last time you had a vice president talking about this, that was
- 41:49probably quail and the Murphy Brown stuff.
- 41:51And he was coming at it from a different direction.
- 41:54It was like, one of these things, it was like how we live now.
- 41:57And these are issues that culture warriors are going to get so Spun up about, but
- 42:00like average Americans like, Oh yeah, you have to navigate those issues.
- 42:03And this is, it was a very empathetic human kind of answer and it just got
- 42:08drowned out by the mommal awareness of Drew Barrymore in the next, moment.
- 42:13That's the part that went viral.
- 42:15And I thought it was too bad to your point that this is like a
- 42:19fairly, typical kind of situation.
- 42:23you've got a blended family, you've had a divorce.
- 42:26It's and I just wish we could talk about that.
- 42:28And Trump.
- 42:30Could talk about that too.
- 42:31His wife is an immigrant.
- 42:32He has a buddy.
- 42:34If he had, more of an empathy gene or was willing to show it in public or whatever,
- 42:39he could talk about these things too.
- 42:40And I think it'd be good.
- 42:41Not that we need to be parented from the White House, but just to talk about
- 42:45how things are changing and like to talk about that in more normal, and more
- 42:52normal terms, I think would be, yeah.
- 42:54Would be healthy for us in terms of our little issue, education would help
- 42:58then tie into, okay, what are the kinds of conversations we need to be having
- 43:01about what do families need actually?
- 43:04and what should we be doing, in the education sector, the public sector,
- 43:08the, independent charter sector, the private sector to accommodate
- 43:13that, that would be a very healthy.
- 43:15Conversation, but instead we get culture wars and mama.
- 43:19Yeah.
- 43:20can't wrap up without Taking advantage of this opportunity given, we're
- 43:25talking about society evolving and then our politics and our policies
- 43:30are like vestiges of the past that hold us, in a dysfunctional fixity.
- 43:36I can't help but mention, Milliken versus Bradley.
- 43:40And I know I obsess on this and you're going to give me a hard
- 43:43time about it, but I just, thank goodness for Tim and Darrell.
- 43:47They actually wrote something.
- 43:50the 74 did put something out.
- 43:52there was a Detroit newspaper that did two articles about it.
- 43:56And then nothing else.
- 43:58We just say for people who don't always listen, aren't Darrell Bradford,
- 44:02who's president of 50 cam, which is education advocacy organization.
- 44:05He's very pro choice and getting rid of barriers to people
- 44:09being able to go to school.
- 44:10And Tim Deroche, who runs an organization called available to
- 44:12all, which is about school boundaries and school district boundaries.
- 44:16And then Milliken versus Bradley is the decision that was made 50 years ago.
- 44:21the last week of July that basically said that integration efforts cannot
- 44:26happen, cannot be required to involve, suburban and just contributed to
- 44:32white flight and a lot of stuff.
- 44:33And just cracked public education across these lines of division that are still
- 44:39there to this very day I find it just disheartening that supreme court case
- 44:46Didn't get greater attention every time brown versus board of education
- 44:49happens Everybody talks about it and no one talks about The next case that
- 44:54came along, 20 years later, or I guess it was whatever that is, what is that?
- 45:00Yeah.
- 45:0120 years, 20 years later.
- 45:02And, we don't do math on this.
- 45:05Exactly.
- 45:05It's 20 years later and it basically unwound or, defanged, brown versus white.
- 45:12And I thought that, Darrell and Tim did a great job because they, were able to say,
- 45:16look, the idea that would have happened had the Supreme Court case not been
- 45:20decided that way is that forced busing.
- 45:23Across all these lines would have been required and anybody
- 45:26that's supporting Forrest Buzzi.
- 45:28But the idea that we have these lines that prevent people from being able to get to
- 45:33the schools that they want to go to, I just find it surprising that our world
- 45:39is not more deeply anchored on the need to get rid of these scourges in society.
- 45:44the politics are strange, right?
- 45:46Because this is one of these ones where now, because of the political
- 45:49arrangements, it's the people on the left who generally want to talk about how do
- 45:53we dismantle structural barriers, right?
- 45:56the opportunity, which I think is important.
- 45:58And how do we, empower people, but on this particular issue, these
- 46:03boundaries, which, whether it's, leftover from busing, it's crazy.
- 46:07There's still stuff in federal policy, just on transportation
- 46:09leftover from busing that makes it harder to do transportation
- 46:13in, equitable and efficient ways.
- 46:16these, leftover massive resistance, like all this stuff is now it's got a political
- 46:21utility if you don't want choice.
- 46:23And We don't talk about it.
- 46:25Yeah.
- 46:25I think these, cases, there's a number of like really important education cases that
- 46:30we do not talk about enough that are, and Brown is this incredibly important case.
- 46:35I don't mean to take anything away from that, but it's not the only sort
- 46:38of seminal, education case of the 20th century, the very early part of the
- 46:4221st, that helps create the contours of the, debate we have, and so I do think
- 46:48we should talk about that, stuff more.
- 46:50Now we talked earlier just how do we get this issue higher on our issues higher
- 46:54on the radar screen with the Democratic Party and I just feel as though our lack
- 46:58of policy imagination, Brandon Johnson is a part of an effort to erase all forms
- 47:04of school choice and basically require people to go back to their neighborhoods.
- 47:09That is exactly the same impulse that has resulted in so much
- 47:14unfairness in our society.
- 47:16And we don't have the policy proposals that directly, challenge him.
- 47:21And with that being the case, we let him drive the narrative.
- 47:26Yeah, look, to end on a happy note, I think the opening there is the theme
- 47:30of the Democratic Party convention they kept coming back to is freedom.
- 47:33Yeah.
- 47:35And you can argue it's a pretty easy hole to poke.
- 47:39you don't have to be, much of an analystist to point out like it's
- 47:42if you're, if your theme is freedom and you're not doing something more
- 47:45robust on school choice than what's on offer, then there's a disconnect.
- 47:48That's like an obvious point, but I do think it starts to create an opening.
- 47:53and as the parties redefine themselves to, your point on wanting to see
- 47:57more, I think that is a thread to pull on what does freedom actually
- 48:00look like in an educational context.
- 48:03for families.
- 48:04And right around when we're recording, it's, it's Jack Coons.
- 48:08His birthday is 95, and he was dean of the law school at Berkeley.
- 48:13Litigated Serrano.
- 48:15He's a deeply wonderful person, deeply Catholic, and he believed that not all
- 48:20Having parents having freedom like this just did violence to the idea of family.
- 48:26and that's a, those are conversations.
- 48:29So I think this freedom thread, that is a, thread to pull on and it's a more positive
- 48:34thread on a range of issues, in terms of trying to expand access to opportunity.
- 48:41this conversation has been an example of why I've been missing you over the summer.
- 48:45I miss you too, Jed.
- 48:46Look, I, you and I have been talking about it separately.
- 48:49a new cadence for things.
- 48:51I've got, some additional, content coming out at Charterfolk in the
- 48:54first three weeks of the month.
- 48:56And we're really going to try and anchor ourselves to a Walkie Folk
- 48:59post, coming out, every fourth, week.
- 49:03so I really look forward to that.
- 49:05Yeah, we're going to do this more.
- 49:06We'll get back on a more regular cadence and I'll give you the plug
- 49:09that you won't give yourself the wonky folk or the, chart folk stuff.
- 49:11It's just been great.
- 49:12And the email is terrific and I would encourage people to sign up and
- 49:18subscribe, if they can, it's a great way to Keep up on what's going on, but
- 49:23also you highlight so many interesting leaders, either you highlighting them or
- 49:26letting them talk in their own, voice.
- 49:28And that's, I think, that's great.
- 49:32No one else is, really doing that right now.
- 49:34And I think it's a really valuable thing you're up to.
- 49:36I appreciate you saying it.
- 49:37Hey, good.
- 49:39See you soon.
- 49:40See you next month.
- 49:41Take care.