Latest / Bloomberg Law / Mother on Trial for Son's Actions & Musk Pay Voided
Transcript
- 0:03Speaker 1: This is Bloomberg Law with June Brusso from Bloomberg Radio.
- 0:09Speaker 2: Jennifer Cumbley didn't pull the sugar a day, but she
- 0:12Speaker 2: is responsible for those deaths. Jennifer Crumbley is on trial
- 0:16Speaker 2: for the murders of four students in a shooting rampage
- 0:19Speaker 2: at a Michigan high school in November of twenty twenty one.
- 0:23Speaker 2: It was her fifteen year old son who pulled the trigger,
- 0:26Speaker 2: but prosecutors are trying to hold her responsible for what
- 0:29Speaker 2: they say as wilful negligence of her son's deteriorating mental
- 0:34Speaker 2: health and warning signs that he was contemplating violence. Here
- 0:38Speaker 2: is prosecutor Mark Quist.
- 0:40Speaker 1: This case is about.
- 0:42Speaker 2: It's about Jennifer Crumbley's willful disregard of the danger that
- 0:45Speaker 2: she knew of. But her defense attorney, Shannon Smith, says
- 0:49Speaker 2: Crumbly had no reason to believe her son Ethan was
- 0:52Speaker 2: a threat. The evidence the trial is going to show
- 0:55Speaker 2: you that Jennifer Crumley did the best she good as
- 1:00Speaker 2: a mother to a child who grew up into a
- 1:05Speaker 2: teenager and had no way to know what was going
- 1:11Speaker 2: to happen. Ethan Crumbley was sentenced to life in prison
- 1:15Speaker 2: in December after he pleaded guilty to murder, terrorism and
- 1:18Speaker 2: other crimes. Joining me is criminal defense attorney Richard Kaplan
- 1:22Speaker 2: of Caplin Marino. Parents have been charged for the criminal
- 1:25Speaker 2: acts of their children before. What makes this case novel?
- 1:29Speaker 1: Well, I just think it's the premise that you're charging
- 1:33Speaker 1: someone for a failure to ask. I mean, it's just
- 1:35Speaker 1: kind of rare in a criminal case that in action
- 1:40Speaker 1: is the basis of the crime. We just don't see
- 1:43Speaker 1: that very much. So, you know, what we have is,
- 1:45Speaker 1: you know, basically a circumstantial evidence case saying, hey, in hindsight,
- 1:50Speaker 1: we're looking back and say you should have known. And
- 1:52Speaker 1: I think it's kind of a slippery slope when you
- 1:54Speaker 1: start doing that, because you're holding people to a standard
- 1:58Speaker 1: and that really is hindsight. And so that that's kind
- 2:01Speaker 1: of in my mind where it gets dangerous. Now we
- 2:04Speaker 1: can look at all the factors here, and there are
- 2:06Speaker 1: quite a few, you know, I find so much of
- 2:08Speaker 1: what's going on in this case cuts both ways.
- 2:11Speaker 2: How do you mean it cuts both ways? Because the
- 2:13Speaker 2: prosecution has introduced a lot of evidence so far the
- 2:18Speaker 2: trial's not over yet, that the mother failed to heed
- 2:22Speaker 2: or do anything about these troubling warning signs that her
- 2:27Speaker 2: son had mental health issues.
- 2:30Speaker 1: Well, I was given that some thought, and you know,
- 2:33Speaker 1: there's such an issue in society today with mental health
- 2:37Speaker 1: and you know how vigilant we have to be, but
- 2:40Speaker 1: there's a strong segment of the society that just doesn't
- 2:43Speaker 1: understand mental health awareness. You know, they don't believe that
- 2:47Speaker 1: going to get therapy is something that they normally do.
- 2:53Speaker 1: And so you're now holding these people to a standard
- 2:56Speaker 1: that you know, in certain more rural areas, you know,
- 2:59Speaker 1: people just don't address it that way. And I think
- 3:01Speaker 1: at one point for the father had said, you know,
- 3:03Speaker 1: the son, you just got it tough en up. And
- 3:05Speaker 1: that's a lot of people believe that. And so again
- 3:09Speaker 1: that in and of itself kind of cuts both ways.
- 3:11Speaker 1: If she's ignorant on mental health, she's not really aware
- 3:15Speaker 1: of what can be done to help. You know, you're
- 3:18Speaker 1: criminalizing someone who's maybe just be ignorant.
- 3:21Speaker 2: But the prosecution seems to be piling up evidence. I
- 3:25Speaker 2: mean it's almost heartbreaking in a way. Sort of the
- 3:28Speaker 2: son's cries for help, including a text where he said
- 3:32Speaker 2: he was having hallucinations. Basically he was scared because demons
- 3:37Speaker 2: were throwing bowls. Can you text back? He asked his mother,
- 3:42Speaker 2: and his mother didn't.
- 3:43Speaker 1: Text back again. She's going to testify, my understanding, and
- 3:48Speaker 1: I don't know what her explanation is going to be,
- 3:50Speaker 1: you know, whether she was caught up at work at
- 3:52Speaker 1: the moment, whether she didn't know what to appropriately text back.
- 3:57Speaker 1: I mean, we've all got that text of some sort
- 4:01Speaker 1: or another where you look at it and you think,
- 4:03Speaker 1: I got to think about this. You know, this is
- 4:05Speaker 1: kind of strange. Texting is different than having a conversation.
- 4:08Speaker 1: You know, I think we can all acknowledge that, and
- 4:11Speaker 1: it may have been kind of like she didn't know
- 4:13Speaker 1: what to do. I think we're going to hear from her,
- 4:14Speaker 1: so that'll be very interesting.
- 4:16Speaker 2: Yeah, her attorney said she's going to take the stand,
- 4:20Speaker 2: and that's always risky here. There's a lot for the
- 4:24Speaker 2: prosecution to cross her on, and plus she has to
- 4:27Speaker 2: hold it together to a certain extent. And she was
- 4:31Speaker 2: sobbing audibly in the courtroom when the school surveillance video
- 4:35Speaker 2: was shown.
- 4:36Speaker 1: It's always a risk when your client takes a stand,
- 4:38Speaker 1: and you know this kind of case, does a jury
- 4:43Speaker 1: like her, does she come across as genuinely feeling terrible,
- 4:48Speaker 1: feeling bad seeing all this in hindsight, these warning signs,
- 4:53Speaker 1: and in a sense feeling guilty in the sense that
- 4:56Speaker 1: she should have done more. But you know, again there's
- 4:59Speaker 1: an ignorance to all this, and the jury believes that
- 5:02Speaker 1: she's being honest. You know that she just didn't see
- 5:05Speaker 1: it the way you see it. Now in hindsight, they
- 5:08Speaker 1: may acquit her. I think she really just needs to
- 5:11Speaker 1: be real. I mean, if they think there's crocodile tears,
- 5:13Speaker 1: then she's done again. If the jury likes her, she
- 5:17Speaker 1: got a chance.
- 5:19Speaker 2: The prosecution has built this case where they sort of
- 5:22Speaker 2: present different avenues for the jury defined culpability of the
- 5:26Speaker 2: mother and also the father when he's tried in March.
- 5:29Speaker 2: First there's what we were talking about, the parents ignoring
- 5:32Speaker 2: signs of his mental distress. And then they also have
- 5:35Speaker 2: evidence where their parents were directly confronted with facts that
- 5:39Speaker 2: sort of forecast the shooting. For example, there was a
- 5:43Speaker 2: school meeting and this is just hours before the shooting,
- 5:48Speaker 2: and the parents were called in to discuss Ethan's disturbing drawings,
- 5:52Speaker 2: which depicted a gun, the figure of a shooting victim,
- 5:56Speaker 2: and the words blood everywhere. And so they've had school
- 5:59Speaker 2: of officials testify about that and say, A, the parents
- 6:03Speaker 2: didn't say anything, but B they didn't take him out
- 6:07Speaker 2: of school.
- 6:08Speaker 1: Yes, and again we get that the school did not insist.
- 6:11Speaker 1: You kind of run into that again where I say
- 6:13Speaker 1: things cut both ways. I mean, the prosecution is putting
- 6:16Speaker 1: on their case and look, these are good points, and
- 6:18Speaker 1: I think they're building a strong circumstantial evidence case. But
- 6:22Speaker 1: at the same time, the school saw this and you know,
- 6:26Speaker 1: they gave them the option and instead of saying no,
- 6:28Speaker 1: he's out here until we figure out more. And so
- 6:32Speaker 1: you know, I think to some degree you're going to
- 6:34Speaker 1: see her lawyers kind of say, hey, the school didn't
- 6:37Speaker 1: know better. The school sees them every day. There could
- 6:41Speaker 1: have been some warning signs that went on at the
- 6:43Speaker 1: school too, and they failed to act in the same way. Again,
- 6:47Speaker 1: it's that kind of hindsight. Is twenty twenty and you
- 6:50Speaker 1: know the defense is set. You can't hold somebody responsible
- 6:54Speaker 1: for the unforseeable. I mean, no one imagines the unimaginable
- 6:58Speaker 1: that this is going to happen. You know, like I said,
- 7:01Speaker 1: everything cuts two ways.
- 7:02Speaker 2: In this The prosecutors are also presenting evidence of affirmative acts.
- 7:07Speaker 2: The parents took just four days before the shootings. The
- 7:11Speaker 2: father bought Ethan this semi automatic handgun used in the shootings,
- 7:16Speaker 2: and his mother took him for target practice. That strikes
- 7:20Speaker 2: me as the most incriminating evidence the prosecution has here.
- 7:24Speaker 1: Again, it's not a good fast for the mom or
- 7:26Speaker 1: for the dad that they went and did this, especially
- 7:29Speaker 1: with the warning signs. But the other side of it
- 7:32Speaker 1: is they purchased the gun legally. I think in that
- 7:37Speaker 1: area of Michigan, it's not uncommon that, you know, teenagers
- 7:41Speaker 1: learned to shoot with their families. They took him to
- 7:44Speaker 1: a shooting range, which is kind of a supervised area
- 7:47Speaker 1: to learn to shoot, so there was some responsibility. Now
- 7:50Speaker 1: again that cuts both ways. You understanding the dangers of
- 7:53Speaker 1: a gun, you're doing it the right way, you know,
- 7:55Speaker 1: so it cuts a little bit of both ways. Apparently,
- 7:57Speaker 1: I think they also purchased the lock box the gun,
- 8:00Speaker 1: So again that's the two way. You know, you're recognizing
- 8:03Speaker 1: the dangers of a weapon, and that's why you have
- 8:05Speaker 1: a block box. But then of course key knows the
- 8:08Speaker 1: code to the box, so it's tough. But I think
- 8:10Speaker 1: you know, it's four days before and with all the
- 8:13Speaker 1: warning signs. I think that's probably the strongest evidence against
- 8:17Speaker 1: her is, you know, taking him to the range.
- 8:19Speaker 2: The parents fled after the shooting, and the prosecution is
- 8:23Speaker 2: presenting that as consciousness of guilt. Will the defense says
- 8:28Speaker 2: they were going to come back for the arraignment. How
- 8:30Speaker 2: important is that because in a lot of cases, judges
- 8:34Speaker 2: will even instruct the jury that they can consider flight
- 8:38Speaker 2: as evidence of consciousness of guilt.
- 8:41Speaker 1: And that's certainly I think the instruction they may try
- 8:44Speaker 1: to get, or certainly the inference the prosecution wants to
- 8:47Speaker 1: make is playing is a consciousness of guilt. But then again,
- 8:49Speaker 1: you know, there's also a fear factor that they didn't
- 8:52Speaker 1: want to stay at their home where they thought, you know,
- 8:54Speaker 1: maybe one of these other parents are going to come
- 8:56Speaker 1: by and do something. I mean, we don't know what
- 8:58Speaker 1: she's going to say.
- 8:59Speaker 2: So now the defense is arguing several things You've mentioned
- 9:03Speaker 2: some of them, and she's also trying to pin the
- 9:06Speaker 2: blame on her husband. That's very convenient because he's not
- 9:09Speaker 2: in the courtroom and can't answer back, and also on
- 9:13Speaker 2: the school which you refer to, for failing to notify
- 9:16Speaker 2: her about her son's problematic behavior. How effective might that be.
- 9:21Speaker 1: On this one. There's a lot of factors. There's mom,
- 9:24Speaker 1: there's dad, there's the school, and any one of them
- 9:27Speaker 1: could have and should have done something. I think we
- 9:29Speaker 1: all agree in hindsight that's, of course. But you know
- 9:33Speaker 1: her side is, Look, husband didn't do anything. He's the
- 9:35Speaker 1: one who bought the gun. You know, school didn't do anything.
- 9:38Speaker 1: They see him every day, and there was problematic behavior,
- 9:41Speaker 1: and so now it's kind of like, hey, you're piling
- 9:43Speaker 1: on on me, and you know, I was just trying
- 9:45Speaker 1: to do the best I can at being the good mother.
- 9:48Speaker 1: And again when the unimaginable happens, you can't say, oh,
- 9:51Speaker 1: I should have known that was going to happen.
- 9:53Speaker 2: Do you think this case could set a precedent or
- 9:56Speaker 2: is it just relegated to the facts of this case.
- 10:00Speaker 1: These facts are fairly extreme. I think. You know, certainly
- 10:04Speaker 1: the prosecution's trying to send a message here, not only
- 10:08Speaker 1: to their local area, but it's the national news that
- 10:12Speaker 1: you know, parents can be held responsible. It gets to
- 10:15Speaker 1: the ages. You know, he was at sixteen seventeen, I
- 10:18Speaker 1: mean it's it's a much younger child, for example, then
- 10:21Speaker 1: you have a higher duty to keep the weapon safe
- 10:24Speaker 1: versus you know, a teenager. And again, in that environment,
- 10:27Speaker 1: probably many teenagers shoot with their families. I mean, I
- 10:30Speaker 1: think they would like to set a precedent that parents,
- 10:32Speaker 1: you better wake up and you know, keep an eye
- 10:34Speaker 1: on your kids, because yes, if your kid does something
- 10:37Speaker 1: like this, you can be held responsible.
- 10:39Speaker 2: Which side would you rather be on? Would you rather
- 10:41Speaker 2: be the prosecutor or the defense attorney in this case?
- 10:44Speaker 1: I've been a defense attorney for thirty five years. That's
- 10:47Speaker 1: what I know. And again, this is one right. You know,
- 10:49Speaker 1: in California, we have a jury instructure that says, in
- 10:52Speaker 1: a circumstantial evidence case, if there's two reasonable versions of
- 10:58Speaker 1: the evidence, you must go with the one that points
- 11:00Speaker 1: they're not guilty. Now Michigan doesn't have that particular instruction,
- 11:04Speaker 1: but that's kind of you know. What you want to
- 11:06Speaker 1: argue is, look, there's an innocent story here and then
- 11:09Speaker 1: there's a guilty story here. But if both have reasonableness
- 11:13Speaker 1: within them, then you have to go with not guilty.
- 11:16Speaker 2: We'll see how the defense presents its case. The prosecution
- 11:19Speaker 2: is expected to rest its case by Friday. Thanks for
- 11:23Speaker 2: joining me, Richard. That's Richard Kaplan of Kaplan Marino coming
- 11:27Speaker 2: up next on the Bloomberg Launch show. The judge called
- 11:30Speaker 2: Elon Musk's fifty five billion dollar pay package and unfathomable sum, historically,
- 11:36Speaker 2: unprecedented and incredible, and then she voided it, I'm June Grosso,
- 11:41Speaker 2: and this is Bloomberg. Elon Musk's fifty five billion dollar
- 11:45Speaker 2: pay package, the largest in US corporate history, is no more.
- 11:51Speaker 2: A Delaware judge has voided it after asking the question,
- 11:55Speaker 2: was the richest person in the world overpaid? And then
- 11:58Speaker 2: two hundred pages Lela answering yes he was, with a
- 12:03Speaker 2: lot of legal reasoning in between. In her opinion, Chance
- 12:07Speaker 2: Recort Chief Judge Kathleen McCormick compared the pay package to
- 12:11Speaker 2: a flawed car design, where Musk launched a self driving process,
- 12:16Speaker 2: recalibrating the speed and direction along the way as he
- 12:19Speaker 2: saw fit, and when that process arrived at an unfair price,
- 12:24Speaker 2: she granted the investor's requests for a recall. Joining me
- 12:28Speaker 2: is an expert in business law, Eric Talley, a professor
- 12:31Speaker 2: at Columbia Law School, so she didn't hold back on
- 12:34Speaker 2: her thoughts about his pay package, calling it an unfathomable
- 12:38Speaker 2: sum historically unprecedented and incredible. How much was about the
- 12:43Speaker 2: size of the package and how much about the process
- 12:47Speaker 2: that Musk and the board used to get there.
- 12:50Speaker 3: Well, I don't think this conversation gets started unless we're
- 12:53Speaker 3: talking about the size of the pay package, right, That's
- 12:56Speaker 3: what puts so much at stake here. But you're correct,
- 12:59Speaker 3: the opinion actually circulates around the process by which that
- 13:03Speaker 3: pay package was approved, eventually circling around to talk about
- 13:06Speaker 3: the size as well, kind of for reasons that are
- 13:09Speaker 3: necessary for you know, doctrinal purposes. And it's a long opinion.
- 13:13Speaker 3: It's a logically ordered and rather meticulous opinion, and one
- 13:18Speaker 3: can certainly understand why Chancellor McCormick decided that she wanted
- 13:22Speaker 3: to spend so much time and quite literally so much
- 13:25Speaker 3: ink on this because the attention that this case has
- 13:28Speaker 3: gotten and will get over the next weeks to months,
- 13:32Speaker 3: I think is considerable. And the question really is, like,
- 13:36Speaker 3: we're to situate a case that looks like such a
- 13:40Speaker 3: kind of bizarre black Swan case kind of within our
- 13:43Speaker 3: established pantheon of cases involving executive compensation and chansder McCormick
- 13:48Speaker 3: does a lot of work in the opinion to try
- 13:51Speaker 3: to do that to sort of say, Okay, here is
- 13:53Speaker 3: the law as it has been developed in Delaware around
- 13:56Speaker 3: these types of compensation contracts. And even though this was
- 13:59Speaker 3: a really big one, it doesn't mean it has different
- 14:01Speaker 3: rules that apply to it. And I'm going to go
- 14:03Speaker 3: ahead and go down that same template of rules, which
- 14:07Speaker 3: is not terribly surprising. But when the decisions at every
- 14:11Speaker 3: juncture have such large valuation swings, it can certainly be
- 14:15Speaker 3: fraught with drama. And we definitely have seen drama since
- 14:18Speaker 3: this case was decided and the opinion was released.
- 14:21Speaker 2: So explain her analysis of the process of getting to
- 14:27Speaker 2: the pay package and the board members being beholden to musk.
- 14:31Speaker 2: You know, there's no meaningful negotiation.
- 14:34Speaker 3: There are a couple of moving parts here, but weirdly enough,
- 14:37Speaker 3: there aren't that many moving parts here. The case itself
- 14:40Speaker 3: circulates within a fairly well known strand of Delaware cases
- 14:46Speaker 3: that deal with what happens when you have someone who's
- 14:49Speaker 3: getting into some sort of a deal. It could be
- 14:52Speaker 3: a compensation agreement, it could be something else that has
- 14:54Speaker 3: a material financial conflict of interest, right, and when you
- 14:58Speaker 3: are asking the company that you're a fiduciary of to
- 15:02Speaker 3: then pay you more. You know, that's one version of
- 15:05Speaker 3: a conflict of interest. Now, Delaware law, which Chancellor McCormick
- 15:09Speaker 3: is as expert, if not more expert than anyone else
- 15:12Speaker 3: in has different approaches depending on the type of person
- 15:16Speaker 3: who's the defendant. And probably the most intense scrutiny that
- 15:21Speaker 3: you can get is if you are someone who controls
- 15:23Speaker 3: the company that's making this decision, in this case, the
- 15:26Speaker 3: compensation decision for controllers, you're under a much much more
- 15:32Speaker 3: powerful microscope in terms of the facts of the case
- 15:35Speaker 3: and you know how they are evaluated by the judge
- 15:38Speaker 3: then you would be if you were maybe just some
- 15:40Speaker 3: random outside director who didn't have a big stake in
- 15:43Speaker 3: the company. So the first juncture that Chancellor McCormick had
- 15:47Speaker 3: to decide, and it's been in front of the Delaware
- 15:50Speaker 3: chancefer record three previous times, and each previous time her
- 15:54Speaker 3: predecessors have avoided having to say whether mister Musk is
- 15:57Speaker 3: a controller of Tesla. He finally gets to the point
- 16:01Speaker 3: to say, yes, he is a controller. I'm going to
- 16:05Speaker 3: have to make that decision myself. Even though we've been
- 16:07Speaker 3: able to skirt that decision in the past, it kind
- 16:10Speaker 3: of has to be made right now. And notwithstanding the
- 16:12Speaker 3: fact that mister Musk has only about twenty one to
- 16:15Speaker 3: twenty two percent ownership of Tesla, which is what he
- 16:19Speaker 3: had at the time, he still is someone that, for
- 16:22Speaker 3: purposes of this decision, was a controller. He still had
- 16:27Speaker 3: sort of outsized influence over the decision making apparatus inside
- 16:33Speaker 3: the board. And that's a pretty critical juncture. I think
- 16:36Speaker 3: a lot of people were sort of, you know, not
- 16:39Speaker 3: terribly surprised that Elon Musk would be held by a
- 16:43Speaker 3: court to kind of control what happens at Tesla. I
- 16:46Speaker 3: think you pull any random person off the street, they'll
- 16:48Speaker 3: probably say the same thing. But we had never actually
- 16:51Speaker 3: had a judicial opinion that said that. And when you're
- 16:54Speaker 3: under fifty percent ownership, it could cut either way. And
- 16:58Speaker 3: so that was in many ways like a big unanswered
- 17:01Speaker 3: question that had gone kind of frustratingly unanswered for a
- 17:05Speaker 3: long time.
- 17:06Speaker 2: It would probably be really surprising to the average person,
- 17:09Speaker 2: and that it was so hard for the Delaware courts
- 17:12Speaker 2: to say that out loud. So where does that leave
- 17:15Speaker 2: the judge in this analysis?
- 17:16Speaker 3: Then, once he's deemed to be a controller then absent
- 17:20Speaker 3: some way to fix it, he's under what is known
- 17:23Speaker 3: as the entire fairness standard of review, So that is
- 17:27Speaker 3: legal ease for you better be able to show that
- 17:31Speaker 3: both the process and the substance of this compensation package
- 17:35Speaker 3: didn't give the shaft to the company that it was
- 17:38Speaker 3: fair to the company. And that can be hard to
- 17:40Speaker 3: do because when you bear the burden of proving that unclear,
- 17:45Speaker 3: situations kind of get resolved against you, and so proving
- 17:49Speaker 3: entire fairness is something that defendants usually try to avoid,
- 17:53Speaker 3: and then that gives rise to kind of the last
- 17:55Speaker 3: big moving piece and the liability part of this is
- 17:59Speaker 3: is there any way that you can avoid having to
- 18:02Speaker 3: show the entire fairness of this particular package and maybe
- 18:06Speaker 3: push that burden back on the plaintiffs. And the answer
- 18:09Speaker 3: is yes, but only if you've somehow been able to
- 18:12Speaker 3: figure out how to get approval from totally disinterested board
- 18:16Speaker 3: members who say, yeah, we're not dominated or controlled by you,
- 18:20Speaker 3: but we think that this is fair, or by stockholders
- 18:24Speaker 3: who were willing to vote, not affiliated stockholders who are
- 18:27Speaker 3: willing to vote to approve it. And Tesla tried to
- 18:29Speaker 3: do both of those things. They did have a compensation committee,
- 18:33Speaker 3: but the compensation committee largely consisted of people that Chancellor
- 18:36Speaker 3: McCormick found to be basically completely beholden to mister Musk
- 18:40Speaker 3: and not really credible negotiators against him. And then when
- 18:44Speaker 3: they went out for a stockholder vote, they told the stockholders, oh,
- 18:48Speaker 3: there was this very very independent and rigorous process that
- 18:52Speaker 3: we went through and structuring this, when in fact she
- 18:54Speaker 3: found that that wasn't what they went through at all.
- 18:57Speaker 3: So those are kind of the main moving pieces in
- 18:59Speaker 3: the opinion. Over two hundred pages sort of takes you
- 19:02Speaker 3: through the decision tree that sort of gets us to
- 19:05Speaker 3: the point where mister Musk is gonna have to carry
- 19:09Speaker 3: a burden to show that a fifty six billion dollar
- 19:12Speaker 3: pay package is entirely fair, and she finds that he
- 19:15Speaker 3: failed to do that, and that's why the end of
- 19:18Speaker 3: the day, she finds that this was a breach of
- 19:20Speaker 3: fiduciary duties and ultimately his pay package is voided. It's
- 19:24Speaker 3: forth it.
- 19:25Speaker 2: So what were the facts that she really considered in
- 19:29Speaker 2: coming to this decision that Elon Musk was overpaid?
- 19:34Speaker 3: So once we get to this question of asking, hey,
- 19:36Speaker 3: is this a fair deal, they're two big ingredients to
- 19:39Speaker 3: keep in mind. First of all, the way that this
- 19:41Speaker 3: ended up getting set up. He's the guy that had
- 19:44Speaker 3: to prove it was fair. It wasn't. The other side
- 19:46Speaker 3: had to prove it was unfair. And then the second
- 19:48Speaker 3: thing is what goes into that assessment. It's sort of
- 19:51Speaker 3: a combination of what was the process that gave rise
- 19:54Speaker 3: to this pay package. Did it look like and kind
- 19:56Speaker 3: of walk like and smell like and sound like an
- 19:59Speaker 3: arm length to negotiation, or was there something a little
- 20:02Speaker 3: bit more sort of a you know, fade a complete
- 20:05Speaker 3: about it. And then the second part of it is just,
- 20:08Speaker 3: you know, compare the size of this package to what
- 20:11Speaker 3: would be sort of substantively what you'd expect to come
- 20:15Speaker 3: out of it. And on that process part, you know,
- 20:18Speaker 3: a bunch of the stuff that we've been talking about
- 20:19Speaker 3: the fact that Musk is very very close to many
- 20:23Speaker 3: of the of the board members, one of whom, even
- 20:26Speaker 3: when asked about his relationship with mister Musk, broke down
- 20:30Speaker 3: in tears and deposition because of his gratitude towards mister Musk,
- 20:33Speaker 3: which is, you know, touching on one level, but on
- 20:35Speaker 3: another level, that's not necessarily the type of person you
- 20:39Speaker 3: want guarding the gate of executive compensation. Against this charismatic,
- 20:43Speaker 3: and so the process stuff just didn't seem to be
- 20:46Speaker 3: there much at all. And then when it came to
- 20:49Speaker 3: trying to compare how fair his compensation package was to others,
- 20:54Speaker 3: this is literally a compensation package that has no comparison.
- 20:57Speaker 3: It's bigger than anything we've ever seen. It's, you know,
- 21:00Speaker 3: multitudes larger than the median ceo pay package. Other kind
- 21:04Speaker 3: of so called superstar CEOs like Jeff Bezos or Mark Zuckerberg,
- 21:09Speaker 3: they don't even take a salary. They just basically benefit
- 21:12Speaker 3: only to the extent that the stock goes up in value.
- 21:15Speaker 3: So when it came down to brass tacks, mister Musk's
- 21:18Speaker 3: case kind of got backed into this corner of having
- 21:21Speaker 3: to show that, you know, these numbers are fair, and
- 21:24Speaker 3: they made a good effort of it. They tried to say, well,
- 21:26Speaker 3: look at the time it was entered into in twenty eighteen,
- 21:30Speaker 3: you know, this was a highly incentivized contract and a
- 21:33Speaker 3: bunch of these hurdles they may never you know, get triggered.
- 21:36Speaker 3: And it was really really a highly speculative thing that
- 21:39Speaker 3: was going to pay off big but only if kind
- 21:41Speaker 3: of outsized promises came true. And the Chancellor wasn't buying that.
- 21:46Speaker 3: In fact, of the twelve different layers of this contract,
- 21:51Speaker 3: three of the first hurdles were almost certain to occur,
- 21:54Speaker 3: and they knew that at the time that they signed
- 21:56Speaker 3: the deal. So at the end of the day, she said,
- 21:59Speaker 3: there's just none enough here for me to conclude that
- 22:01Speaker 3: you have shown that a compensation package of this magnitude
- 22:07Speaker 3: is on his price terms fair, particularly compared to what
- 22:11Speaker 3: other people are now. And that was the end of
- 22:13Speaker 3: the show. I mean, it took two hundred pages to
- 22:15Speaker 3: get there, but that was the end of the show.
- 22:17Speaker 2: So he will probably appeal to the Delaware Supreme Court.
- 22:20Speaker 3: What are his chances on appeal, Well, you know, they're
- 22:24Speaker 3: not zero, and I think that there are a couple
- 22:26Speaker 3: of things that he can probably take up. I mean,
- 22:28Speaker 3: he's going to probably try to attack every one of
- 22:30Speaker 3: these junctures of her opinion, and you know, you can
- 22:34Speaker 3: sort of tell from the opinion that Chancellor McCormick is
- 22:36Speaker 3: aware of it, and that's why she's pretty meticulous at
- 22:38Speaker 3: each juncture. It's conceivable that he'll, you know, sort of
- 22:42Speaker 3: go after this question of whether he was a controller
- 22:45Speaker 3: or not. I don't really like his odds on that
- 22:48Speaker 3: that much, because this is a highly fact intensive inquiry
- 22:52Speaker 3: and most of this opinion is development of findings a fact.
- 22:56Speaker 3: Usually the trial court judges get a lot of difference
- 22:59Speaker 3: on that, and I expect that she's going to get
- 23:00Speaker 3: difference on it as well. Moreover, I think, you know,
- 23:03Speaker 3: like I said, like almost any layperson would think, yeah,
- 23:06Speaker 3: of course, mister Musk controls what happens at Tesla as
- 23:09Speaker 3: well as many other companies. So I don't think that
- 23:11Speaker 3: that is going to be as successful if he takes
- 23:14Speaker 3: it to the Delaware Supreme Court, which I'm sure he'll try.
- 23:17Speaker 1: Yep.
- 23:17Speaker 3: Maybe some of the other things may be a little
- 23:19Speaker 3: bit more successful. Possibly they can put some dents in
- 23:23Speaker 3: the conclusion that the pay package was unfair, that it
- 23:26Speaker 3: was so highly incentivized that you know, maybe this is
- 23:29Speaker 3: just hindsight bias. The fact that Tesla actually met all
- 23:32Speaker 3: these hurdles kind of looks obvious when you look backwards
- 23:35Speaker 3: in time, but it couldn't have been obvious looking forward
- 23:37Speaker 3: in time, and so there might be a little bit
- 23:39Speaker 3: that they can do there. I think where Musk's team
- 23:42Speaker 3: might have the most leverage here is to say, okay, well,
- 23:46Speaker 3: look if you're invalidating my contract saying I get nothing.
- 23:50Speaker 3: It's not the same as saying I didn't create value
- 23:53Speaker 3: for this company. It's just saying that the contract, you're
- 23:55Speaker 3: going to rescind it, and you can't use the contract.
- 23:58Speaker 3: But as a general matter, there's area of law called
- 24:01Speaker 3: restitution that basically says, you know, if you create something
- 24:05Speaker 3: of value for someone else and they know you're expecting
- 24:07Speaker 3: compensation for it, and there's no other mechanism to do it,
- 24:10Speaker 3: like in this case the contract got canceled, you can
- 24:13Speaker 3: you know, allege or even file a lawsuit saying I
- 24:16Speaker 3: want to claim restitution. And so that may be one
- 24:19Speaker 3: of the things that also goes up to the Supreme
- 24:21Speaker 3: Court saying, you know, should he get the chance to
- 24:23Speaker 3: try to prove what the fair value of what he
- 24:26Speaker 3: did do PROTESTA was if this contract was unfair, is
- 24:29Speaker 3: there a smaller number that would be fair? And then
- 24:31Speaker 3: he could at least get that chance. For McCormick actually
- 24:34Speaker 3: even takes on that question and opinion. At the very
- 24:37Speaker 3: end of the opinion, she says, look, in principle, I
- 24:39Speaker 3: could revert back to, like what's the fair value of
- 24:42Speaker 3: what he should have gotten? But the defenders never even
- 24:45Speaker 3: tried to present evidence about that. They were all in
- 24:48Speaker 3: on there's no liability, no liability, no liability, And therefore
- 24:52Speaker 3: they never really even made a case on what the
- 24:54Speaker 3: fair versus the unfair component of his compensation package was.
- 24:58Speaker 3: And you can kind of understand why they didn't, right Like,
- 25:01Speaker 3: if you're starting to do that as the defendant, it's
- 25:03Speaker 3: almost like you've given up on trying to show that,
- 25:06Speaker 3: you know, the whole thing was fair, and so they
- 25:09Speaker 3: shied away, probably for understandable reasons. And they might say, hey,
- 25:12Speaker 3: you know, Della or a Supreme court, you should at
- 25:14Speaker 3: least give us a chance to make that claim and
- 25:18Speaker 3: remand this for a more sort of fulsome analysis of
- 25:22Speaker 3: not only the recision part of the contract, but he
- 25:25Speaker 3: should get restitution for the benefits that he's conferred. And
- 25:28Speaker 3: that's a possibility. It would be changing the nature of
- 25:31Speaker 3: the remedy, and therefore the Supreme Court would have to
- 25:34Speaker 3: say that the trial court, the Chance McCormick, just she
- 25:37Speaker 3: fashioned her remedy in an incomplete way. There's a pretty
- 25:41Speaker 3: kerdel to do that as well, but at least it's
- 25:44Speaker 3: a possibility. There's one other angle here, June, which is
- 25:48Speaker 3: restitution is itself a lawsuit that you can file. So
- 25:52Speaker 3: there's also an outside chance that, independent of filing an appeal,
- 25:57Speaker 3: Elon Musk might turn around and sue for revolution. It
- 26:02Speaker 3: would probably land in front of Chancellor McCormick. And then
- 26:05Speaker 3: you know, the directors and the other you know, folks
- 26:08Speaker 3: in charge of Tesla that had been sitting on the
- 26:10Speaker 3: same side of the table with him during this litigation
- 26:13Speaker 3: are now adverse parties. And one could imagine that that
- 26:16Speaker 3: might be a strategy as well, one that the board
- 26:19Speaker 3: might decide later on that they're going to settle that
- 26:22Speaker 3: and settle it for I don't know, stock options valued
- 26:25Speaker 3: at say forty eight billion dollars or something like that.
- 26:28Speaker 3: You know, that decision itself might attract the lawsuits.
- 26:31Speaker 2: A Delaware judge has ruled that Elon Musk is not
- 26:35Speaker 2: entitled to the landmark compensation package awarded by Tesla's board
- 26:40Speaker 2: of directors, potentially worth more than fifty five billion dollars.
- 26:44Speaker 2: The shareholder lawsuit argued that the compensation package should be
- 26:48Speaker 2: voided because it was dictated by Musk and was the
- 26:51Speaker 2: product of sham negotiations with directors who were not independent
- 26:56Speaker 2: of him. We've discussed before that Musk has been press
- 27:00Speaker 2: shuring Tesla's board to arrange another massive stock award for him,
- 27:04Speaker 2: and now you have questions about the board's independent So
- 27:09Speaker 2: what happens do they negotiate a new pay package for him?
- 27:12Speaker 3: I mean, I think they have to at this stage,
- 27:14Speaker 3: they have to figure out, Okay, what's our package is
- 27:16Speaker 3: going to look like? Now going forward with the caveat
- 27:20Speaker 3: in mind that we're sitting on this two hundred page
- 27:22Speaker 3: opinion that said here's a model of how not to
- 27:25Speaker 3: do a pay package. Right, So so at this point
- 27:28Speaker 3: they're under even more scrutiny and more constraints than they
- 27:31Speaker 3: would have been before this opinion, and just a repeat
- 27:35Speaker 3: of the twenty eighteen executive compensation package is almost certain
- 27:40Speaker 3: to draw attention. So, you know, I think when they're
- 27:42Speaker 3: trying to figure out what is this next compensation package
- 27:45Speaker 3: going to look like? I think they want to be
- 27:48Speaker 3: sure that they have truly independent board members. There's been
- 27:51Speaker 3: some turnover on the board and I think, you know,
- 27:54Speaker 3: they may want to make sure that they've got that
- 27:56Speaker 3: in place, and that they also then also go out
- 27:59Speaker 3: to the stockholders to vote to approve that transaction that's
- 28:03Speaker 3: going to give them a lot more protection should this
- 28:07Speaker 3: new package ever get litigated. And you know, I think
- 28:10Speaker 3: on some level, the hindsight lesson here is that you know,
- 28:14Speaker 3: these burdens matter, and using the right kind of processes
- 28:17Speaker 3: can give you a lot of protection if you're a
- 28:20Speaker 3: potential defended in these cases, it seems like the processes
- 28:24Speaker 3: were treated, at least in the twenty eighteen pay package
- 28:27Speaker 3: in a little bit more of a cavalier way than
- 28:31Speaker 3: they would confront the same problem in twenty twenty four.
- 28:34Speaker 2: Do you think that this is a warning to other
- 28:38Speaker 2: companies and CEOs about how they negotiate their pay packages.
- 28:44Speaker 3: I think on some level it is. Pay packages have
- 28:46Speaker 3: always been a little bit strange because you know, the
- 28:49Speaker 3: companies and the boards and the executives have to set
- 28:52Speaker 3: the compensation of boards and executives, and so how do
- 28:55Speaker 3: you even do that in a way that runs, you know,
- 28:58Speaker 3: on the on the permissive side of of self interest.
- 29:01Speaker 3: I think, you know, every once in a while we
- 29:03Speaker 3: get a big compensation case in Delaware. This is about
- 29:06Speaker 3: as big as they get. The other thing that's going
- 29:09Speaker 3: to be kind of interesting here is for both compensation
- 29:12Speaker 3: cases and not what role did musks sort of charismatics
- 29:17Speaker 3: the chancell uses the term superstar ceo status have in
- 29:23Speaker 3: affecting the outcome of this case. And I think on
- 29:25Speaker 3: one level it clearly did that he was deemed to
- 29:29Speaker 3: be a controller of the company in large part because
- 29:33Speaker 3: he is such a sort of an iconic and charismatic
- 29:36Speaker 3: person that a bunch of stockholders and a bunch of
- 29:38Speaker 3: directors are just kind of like want to please him.
- 29:42Speaker 3: And that's the type of the situation that is more
- 29:46Speaker 3: likely to give rise, certainly after this case, to a
- 29:48Speaker 3: finding that, yeah, this is a controller and therefore under
- 29:52Speaker 3: this heightened degree of scrutiny under Delaware laws.
- 29:56Speaker 1: I don't know.
- 29:57Speaker 3: I guess you could be a little bit cynical about
- 29:59Speaker 3: it and say this is like charisma tax on CEOs
- 30:02Speaker 3: who you know, have that added element that might cause
- 30:05Speaker 3: them to be, you know, particularly persuasive when they want
- 30:09Speaker 3: shareholders on the board to do something for them, as
- 30:11Speaker 3: opposed to the more sort of workaday, boring CEOs who
- 30:15Speaker 3: don't end up getting leveled.
- 30:16Speaker 2: The Charismatacks Delaware, as you know, the corporate home to
- 30:20Speaker 2: almost seventy percent of the fortune five hundred companies. Shortly
- 30:25Speaker 2: after the judge voided his pay package, Musk posted, never
- 30:29Speaker 2: incorporate your company in the state of Delaware. Do you
- 30:33Speaker 2: think this will have any ramifications for Delaware as a
- 30:36Speaker 2: corporate home.
- 30:38Speaker 3: Yeah, we'll see. If you're asking whether w'ere I'm betting
- 30:40Speaker 3: my money, June, I would not be rushing the exits
- 30:43Speaker 3: on Delaware for a whole bunch of different reasons. It's conceivable,
- 30:46Speaker 3: by the way, that Tesla itself might decide to reincorporate
- 30:51Speaker 3: in Nevada or maybe Texas. Nevada is kind of well
- 30:54Speaker 3: known as a place where the protective cloak for you know,
- 30:59Speaker 3: C directors is a little bit thicker than it is
- 31:03Speaker 3: in Delaware, though it's plenty of thick already in Delaware.
- 31:05Speaker 3: It didn't survive this on slot. So it's conceivable that
- 31:09Speaker 3: that Tesla itself might incorporate a decision that could attract
- 31:12Speaker 3: a lawsuit of its own. Are they reincorporating for selfish
- 31:16Speaker 3: reasons or for the good of the company. But Delaware
- 31:19Speaker 3: is not just kind of popular as you noted it is.
- 31:23Speaker 3: It is the place of incorporation for over two thirds
- 31:27Speaker 3: of the Fortune five hundred most companies incorporated in Delaware.
- 31:31Speaker 3: There's reason for it is that this is like kind
- 31:33Speaker 3: of the one state court system that has a completely
- 31:38Speaker 3: separate set of courts that are experts in business law,
- 31:41Speaker 3: that are well known experts in business law, that have
- 31:44Speaker 3: consistent jurisprudence. It isn't like you're playing judicial roulette like
- 31:48Speaker 3: you would with a state court judge in another area.
- 31:51Speaker 3: And that's large part because Delaware has maintained this specific
- 31:55Speaker 3: set of judges that have expertise mainly in corporate law
- 31:59Speaker 3: and business law sorts of settings. That's generally not going
- 32:02Speaker 3: to be the case. You go out into a random
- 32:03Speaker 3: California civil court in which the judge is, you know,
- 32:07Speaker 3: balancing all kinds of different things, You're not going to
- 32:09Speaker 3: have the same sort of consistency. And so I think
- 32:12Speaker 3: that's a hard thing to compete on, and to do it,
- 32:15Speaker 3: you actually have to have the right personnel in place.
- 32:19Speaker 3: And I'd also add to it that most lawyers out there,
- 32:23Speaker 3: including just about every student I've ever taught, in corporate law,
- 32:26Speaker 3: they'll get a little bit of New York corporate law,
- 32:28Speaker 3: they'll get a little bit of California corporate law, but
- 32:30Speaker 3: they will get a lot of Delaware corporate law. So
- 32:33Speaker 3: most of the practicing corporate lawyers, and I would have
- 32:35Speaker 3: venture to say bankers out there, they're highly familiar with
- 32:39Speaker 3: the landmarks and Delaware corporate law. And once you're asking
- 32:43Speaker 3: people to, you know, hand over a lot of money
- 32:45Speaker 3: to you, and you don't really know how to that
- 32:47Speaker 3: law works or how it will work because it's not
- 32:49Speaker 3: as developed or Texas law. That's asking those investors to
- 32:53Speaker 3: take a little bit of a Roulette wheel spin and
- 32:56Speaker 3: that may be not the best way to raise money.
- 32:58Speaker 3: So maybe maybe we're going to see some action on
- 33:01Speaker 3: the incorporation market, but I'm not so sure that when
- 33:05Speaker 3: mister Musk looks behind him to see the parade of
- 33:08Speaker 3: other companies reincorporating out of Delaware, that line is going
- 33:11Speaker 3: to be all that long.
- 33:13Speaker 2: What is it that Nevada the law offers more protections
- 33:17Speaker 2: against investor suits? Is that what the attraction is?
- 33:21Speaker 3: Correct? One of the things that Nevada kind of advertises
- 33:24Speaker 3: itself as doing is as as creating more protections for
- 33:29Speaker 3: corporate fiduciars like officers and directors, CEOs and things like that,
- 33:33Speaker 3: and actually allowing the waiver of many of those types
- 33:37Speaker 3: of liabilities in a way that are not generally allowed
- 33:41Speaker 3: in other states, including Delaware. So the idea and you know,
- 33:45Speaker 3: and Nevada has for years kind of advertised come incorporated
- 33:49Speaker 3: Nevada and you'll never get sued type of type of advertisements.
- 33:53Speaker 3: And so so that that can look attractive to a
- 33:56Speaker 3: corporate fiduciary, particularly one licking his wounds at a big
- 34:00Speaker 3: you know, multi billion dollar out you know, swing in
- 34:03Speaker 3: an outcome. But I'll also say that if you are
- 34:07Speaker 3: someone who's trying to raise money from investors and saying, yeah,
- 34:11Speaker 3: you should just give me a lot of your money,
- 34:12Speaker 3: because I'm going to incorporate in a state in which
- 34:14Speaker 3: you never consume me for say, pilfering that money or
- 34:18Speaker 3: misusing that money, it may be harder to raise that
- 34:21Speaker 3: capital to begin with. So there's this kind of interesting
- 34:23Speaker 3: trade off that the most lax area or the most
- 34:28Speaker 3: lax jurisdiction for liability may not necessarily attract the investment
- 34:34Speaker 3: dollars because the people that are basically sort of forking
- 34:37Speaker 3: over their harder and cash, you want to make sure
- 34:40Speaker 3: that you're also going to be held to account on
- 34:43Speaker 3: real standards as opposed to you know, vaporware that disappears
- 34:46Speaker 3: as soon as you have a complaint.
- 34:48Speaker 2: And Eric, one last question on the Musk case. Was
- 34:52Speaker 2: there any sort of middle ground the judge could have taken?
- 34:56Speaker 3: You know, in some ways, the litigation strategy kind of
- 34:59Speaker 3: forced this thing to be, you know, either a massive
- 35:02Speaker 3: win for the plaintiffs or a massive win for the defendants.
- 35:05Speaker 3: It was really hard to conjure up a solomonic middle
- 35:08Speaker 3: ground outcome the way that the case was sort of
- 35:11Speaker 3: presented to Chancellor McCormick. And so now, you know, I
- 35:13Speaker 3: can see that mister maccatt maybe even the plants attorneys
- 35:16Speaker 3: are going to sort of realize, Okay, look, there's going
- 35:18Speaker 3: to be a lot more fighting downstream. Maybe we can
- 35:20Speaker 3: figure out some solomonic way to take this opinion and
- 35:24Speaker 3: turn it into an outcome that everyone can live with.
- 35:26Speaker 3: But that's going to take some doing from both sides
- 35:29Speaker 3: if that's going to happen.
- 35:30Speaker 2: Well, this decision was certainly a long time coming, but
- 35:34Speaker 2: well worth talking about. Thanks so much. Eric. That's Professor
- 35:37Speaker 2: Eric Talley of Columbia Law School, And that's it for
- 35:40Speaker 2: this edition of the Bloomberg Law Podcast. Remember you can
- 35:43Speaker 2: always get the latest legal news by subscribing and listening
- 35:46Speaker 2: to the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify and at bloomberg
- 35:50Speaker 2: dot com, slash podcast, slash Law. I'm June Grosso and
- 35:54Speaker 2: this is Bloomberg