Latest / 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories / The Devil Is Good Looking Too

Transcript

The Devil Is Good Looking Too · 10 Minute Murder | Bingeable True Crime Stories

• 0:13
  Discretion is advised. This is ten minuted murderer. Often the life stories of
• 0:37
  serial killers begin with tragic, dysfunctional upbringings, but the beginning of Shawn Michael
• 0:43
  Great's childhood was perfectly normal. Born in nineteen seventy six in Marion, Ohio,
• 0:49
  he did struggle in school was held back a grade, but he was
• 0:53
  also sporty. He was a social kid who got along well with others.
• 0:57
  Then, as Sean grew older, things began to change. When Shawn was
• 1:03
  six years old, his parents got a divorce, and five years later,
• 1:07
  his mother, Teresa, abandoned her two children. She left them behind in
• 1:11
  Ohio with their father and moved to Kentucky to live with her new boyfriend.
• 1:17
  Sewn spent his teenage years resenting Theresa for this decision, and he indulged in
• 1:22
  elaborate fantasies about killing his mother and making her pay for what she had done.
• 1:27
  While Shawn and his brother were living with their father, Seawan began attending
• 1:33
  River Valley High School. At first, he continued using sports as an outlet
• 1:38
  for his feelings and became one of the school's best baseball players until he broke
• 1:44
  his arm. When the fracture was X rayed, doctors discovered a tumor,
• 1:48
  which required immediate surgery. After that, Shawn never played baseball again. From
• 1:55
  that point, Shawn's mental health took a turn. One of his high school
• 1:59
  girls friends remembered that he went through severe depressive episodes where he would lay on
• 2:05
  the couch for days. Once the episode was over, he'd continue with his
• 2:08
  life like nothing ever happened. Despite this, Sewn never had a hard time
• 2:14
  getting a date. His school friend Amy Smith, said Sean was charming,
• 2:20
  he was always smiling, and he had those big blue eyes. All the
• 2:23
  girls liked Sean. Sean might have been considered a heart throb, but he
• 2:29
  wasn't a good boyfriend. As his relationships progressed, he became more and more
• 2:35
  jealous and controlling, and after a while, he'd eventually become violent. When
• 2:40
  he was eighteen years old, he was arrested for the first time after he
• 2:45
  grabbed a girlfriend by her neck during an argument. His next arrest came the
• 2:50
  following year, shortly after he graduated from high school, when he was caught
• 2:53
  breaking into a house. He was charged with a felony burglary and sent to
• 3:00
  four years in prison, but He ended up being released early. That time
• 3:05
  behind bars did not change Shawn. If anything, his violent behavior towards women
• 3:10
  only escalated after he was released in nineteen ninety seven. Two years later,
• 3:15
  Shawn's girlfriend reported him to the police, saying that he had choked her almost
• 3:20
  to the point of unconsciousness. The girl was seventeen years old and she was
• 3:24
  a few months pregnant with Shawn's child. Shawn's adult life continued the same way.
• 3:30
  He was a ladies man, but he was a menace to the women
• 3:34
  he dated, often terrorizing his girlfriends and threatening them whenever they stood up to
• 3:38
  him. If there was one thing that Sean hated more than anything else,
• 3:43
  it was a woman who told him no. He briefly got married and became
• 3:47
  a father once again, but only a few months after the wedding, his
• 3:51
  wife had enough and she filed for divorce. On September thirteenth, twenty sixteen,
• 3:58
  a nine to one one call came through in Ashland, Ohio. A
• 4:01
  female caller claimed that she had been kidnapped two days ago, and since then
• 4:06
  her captiir had kept her tied to a bed, repeatedly raping her to protect
• 4:13
  the victim's identity. Her name was never released to the public and she was
• 4:16
  only known by the moniker Jane Doe. And Jane Doe was certain that she
• 4:20
  knew the identity of the kidnapper. In fact, he was somebody whom she'd
• 4:25
  been friends with for several months. She told the police that his name was
• 4:29
  Sean Michael Great and she had been held captive in the abandoned house that he
• 4:33
  was living in. The police rushed to that address that Jane was calling from,
• 4:40
  and they were able to save her and apprehend her captor. After her
• 4:44
  rescue, she revealed more details about her ordeal. She'd met Sean in the
• 4:48
  summer of twenty sixteen at the local community center and viewed him as an older
• 4:55
  brother type. The two of them often met up for lunch together or to
• 4:59
  go on walk where they would talk about the Bible. Jane had been aware
• 5:02
  that Sean was romantically interested in her, but she dodged his advances and even
• 5:09
  refused his attempts to get her cell phone number. Then, on the eleventh
• 5:14
  of September, Sean invited Jane Doe to come over to a house in Ashland,
• 5:17
  where she began to read the Bible sewn left to go to the kitchen,
• 5:23
  and when he came back, Jane didn't recognize the man she'd come to
• 5:26
  view as a friend. His friendly demeanor had vanished, and he grabbed the
• 5:30
  Bible, saying quote, you're not going anywhere. When Jane continued resisting Sean's
• 5:35
  sexual advances, he physically overpowered her and tied her to the bed. Throughout
• 5:42
  the following days, Sean regularly retied Jane Doe into different weird positions. On
• 5:48
  one occasion, he told her that he'd positioned the ropes so that if she
• 5:51
  struggled, she would be strangled to death. When Sean fell asleep, Jane
• 5:57
  was able to free herself from the restraints managed to place that nine to one
• 6:00
  one call that saved her life. When the police arrived at the abandoned house
• 6:05
  where Sean kept Jane prisoner, they immediately noticed an unmistakable stench. The entire
• 6:12
  house was full of piles of trash, surrounded by swarming flies and maggots,
• 6:16
  But the smell wasn't coming from the trash. It was coming from the two
• 6:20
  decomposing bodies that Sean had hidden under piles of dirty laundry. Those bodies belonged
• 6:27
  to two young women, Elizabeth Griffin and Stacy Stanley. Both of them had
• 6:31
  been strangled to death, and Sean hadn't bothered to dispose of their bodies.
• 6:36
  He'd just hidden them pretty badly and then gone on a hunt for his next
• 6:42
  victims. Seawan was then indicted for two counts of aggravated murder for Elizabeth and
• 6:47
  Stacy's death, as well as the sexual assault and abduction of Jane Doe,
• 6:54
  and lesser counts of tampering with evidence and breaking and entering. The defense filed
• 6:58
  a not guilty plea by reason of insanity. Meanwhile, the prosecution announced that
• 7:02
  they would be pushing for the death penalty. By his twenty eighteen trial,
• 7:09
  Shawn hadn't just confessed to the charges he was facing, He'd also claimed to
• 7:13
  have killed three other women. After Seawn revealed details about the additional murders to
• 7:18
  local news stations, the defense and prosecution joined forces to request a gag order
• 7:25
  that would prevent him from talking to the media throughout the trial. Shawn showed
• 7:30
  absolutely no remorse. The following month, he was found guilty of both murders
• 7:34
  and sentenced to death. In March twenty nineteen, Shawn pleaded guilty to murdering
• 7:41
  two other women, Rebecca Lacey in twenty fifteen and Candace Cuttingham in twenty sixteen.
• 7:47
  He had dated Candace for several months and even lived with her for a
• 7:50
  while, and throughout their relationship he admitted to fantasizing about murdering her. Rebecca
• 7:57
  Lacey was also someone that Shawn knew personally, although he wasn't as close with
• 8:01
  her as he was with Candace, and all of his victims were killed in
• 8:05
  the same fashion. Strangled to death. Seawn gave investigators directions to Candace's body,
• 8:11
  which was found behind a burnt house in Madison Township. Rebecca's body had
• 8:16
  been found in twenty fifteen in a patch of woodland in Ashland County. Before
• 8:22
  Shawn's confession, Rebecca's death was believed to be an accidental overdose. Now police
• 8:28
  knew that Sean had killed her over a petty dispute. She allegedly had stolen
• 8:33
  four dollars from him and paid for it with her life. In September that
• 8:39
  same year, Seawn pleaded guilty to a fifth murder, a woman whose unidentified
• 8:45
  body had been found in Marion County in two thousand and six. Shawn's confession
• 8:48
  eventually led to the woman being identified as Dana Lowry, a twenty three year
• 8:54
  old mother of two. Shortly after his original trial, Shawn's attorney appealed him
• 9:00
  death sentence, but in twenty twenty the Ohio Supreme Court dismissed this appeal and
• 9:05
  upheld the sentence. As of October twenty twenty three, his execution is scheduled
• 9:11
  for the nineteenth of March twenty twenty five. At Shawn's second trial, the
• 9:18
  family friend of one of his victims addressed him directly, saying, quote,
• 9:22
  you will die with a needle in your arm, with no more notoriety than
• 9:26
  a junkie who overdoses in an alley. You will die, you will burn,
• 9:31
  and you will be completely forgotten. Shawn's mother, Teresa, was approached
• 9:35
  by the media countless times after her son's arrest. Finally, she agreed to
• 9:41
  give one interview with The Daily Mail. She shared that she believed time behind
• 9:46
  bars had changed Sean into someone she didn't recognize, but she also believed that
• 9:50
  he had spent his life using his charming nature to get what he wanted.
• 9:56
  Quote. Yes, he's good looking, she said, but the devil good
• 10:00
  looking too. That's ten Minute Murder for today brief and binge able true crime.
• 10:18
  I'm Joe, I'm the host, and I really appreciate you taking the
• 10:22
  time out of your day to listen to this episode. If you're brand new,
• 10:26
  I'm super excited that you're here. Hope you enjoyed the episode, and
• 10:28
  if you did, be sure to subscribe before you go. It more easily
• 10:33
  lets you catch up on the back episodes and find ten Minute Murder wherever you
• 10:37
  like to listen to podcasts. Connect with me on social media to see the
• 10:41
  pictures of what we talk about here on the podcast, and it's never gross
• 10:45
  or graphic stuff. Ratings and reviews help the show grow, so please do
• 10:48
  that. And finally, this is the first episode I'm doing in the month
• 10:52
  of November. Halloween just happened, and I need to ask a question,
• 10:58
  do we not do Halloween anymore? I bought a bucket of candy and was
• 11:03
  all ready for the trick or treaters. I don't We're not doing it anymore.
• 11:07
  I guess there were like three kids, and at one point I made
• 11:11
  the executive decision to just not get my hopes up anymore, turned off the
• 11:15
  porch light, and I enjoyed the kit Kats and Snickers bars myself. I
• 11:18
  don't know, maybe I'm missing something somewhere. There might have been a news
• 11:24
  release that it was happening on a different day and I just wasn't paying attention
• 11:26
  to it. But three tricker treaters for an entire bucket of candy that I
• 11:31
  had, and I do the good stuff too. I wanted to be the
• 11:33
  house that has the full size bars, the ones when like I was a
• 11:37
  kid, I'd go back and say, Hey, go to this house.
• 11:39
  They've got the full size stuff over there. They're not messing around. I
• 11:41
  wanted to be that house. But three trick or treaters. Anyway, that's
• 11:46
  your episode for today. Thank you so much for listening to ten minute Murder.