Latest / Deep Values: Value Investing Deep Dives / [Q3] Baidu Deep Value Analysis
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Deep Dive. Our mission today is to tackle
- 0:03what is probably one of the most frustrating, but also maybe
- 0:06rewarding puzzles in global tech investing.
- 0:10Baidu Ticker BIDU. Exactly.
- 0:12We've gone through a whole stack of sources here, everything
- 0:15from, you know, deep forensic accounting dies to these broader
- 0:18market analysis, and we're going to put Baidu under a microscope.
- 0:22A very specific microscope. A Warren Buffett microscope.
- 0:25We're looking at this through his key tenets.
- 0:27Is there a durable competitive advantage?
- 0:30Is capital being allocated rationally?
- 0:32And most importantly, is there a huge margin of safety?
- 0:36And the core conflict here is just, I mean, it's glaring.
- 0:38It's why we felt this deep dive was so necessary for you.
- 0:41It is Baidu trades right now as if the business is, well, a one
- 0:45way path to collapse. You see these historically
- 0:48depressed valuation multiples and yet it's underlying tech,
- 0:52especially in AI and autonomy driving, places it at the
- 0:55absolute global forefront. It's a real paradox.
- 0:58Which forces us and you, to ask a really critical question.
- 1:03Is Baidu's current price a classic rare opportunity?
- 1:07You know, a deep value stock with a safety net made of cash.
- 1:10Or is it a trap? Or is it a classic value trap
- 1:13where the old business is just eroding faster than any of the
- 1:15new stuff can possibly grow? So today we're going to unpack
- 1:18the structural changes to its competitive Moat.
- 1:21We'll dive right into the messy, controversial accounting from
- 1:24Q32025 and figure out what this company's true intrinsic value
- 1:29really is. But before all that, we have to
- 1:32start with the one risk. It just colors this entire
- 1:35analysis. We can't ignore it the.
- 1:36Vie structure. That's right, the variable
- 1:39interest entity. You just can't analyze the stock
- 1:41without understanding what that means.
- 1:43O for anyone who hasn't heard that term break it down, what
- 1:46does BIE actually mean for me as a shareholder?
- 1:49Simply put, it means you don't directly own the assets in
- 1:52China. You own shares in a shell
- 1:55company, usually set up in the Cayman Islands, and that shell
- 1:58company has a series of contracts that give it control
- 2:01over the actual Chinese business.
- 2:02So it's a legal workaround it. Is it's a way to get around
- 2:06foreign ownership rules in China, but it comes with this
- 2:09huge fundamental regulatory risk.
- 2:12If Beijing ever decides to challenge those contracts, well,
- 2:16your ownership could basically become worthless.
- 2:18And that risk is just always baked into the price.
- 2:21Always. It's why a lot of investors just
- 2:23put it in the too hard pile and walk away.
- 2:25OK, great context. So let's start with that all
- 2:27important Moat. For two decades, Baidu was a
- 2:30monopoly. It was the gateway to the
- 2:32Chinese Internet. Absolutely a true monopoly.
- 2:35It was like a toll booth on the busiest Hwy. you can imagine.
- 2:38But now that highway has a lot of detours, the.
- 2:41Castle walls are crumbling. You can see it.
- 2:43The Chinese Internet has fractured into these walled
- 2:46gardens, self-contained ecosystems like WeChat and do
- 2:50in. And if you're searching for
- 2:51something you intend to buy, the high intent, lucrative
- 2:54commercial queries that actually drive ad revenue, you are
- 2:57increasingly not starting on Baidu.
- 2:59That is the core leak in the Moat.
- 3:01And we have hard data on this. I mean, platforms like
- 3:03Shahongshu, it's known as the Little Red Book.
- 3:06They were processing something like 600 million searches a day
- 3:09in 2024. Wait, wait, Xia Hongshu, the
- 3:13lifestyle and fashion app, you're telling me a huge chunk
- 3:16of valuable commercial searches, people looking for product
- 3:21reviews, travel ideas is now happening on the Chinese
- 3:24equivalent of Instagram? That's exactly what's happening.
- 3:27And that 600 million daily searches number, that is just
- 3:30staggering. It's staggering.
- 3:32It shows Baidu keeps the, you know, the long tail
- 3:35informational searches, but it's losing the money searches.
- 3:38The transactions have moved. And what's the other surprising
- 3:40competitor the sources pointed to?
- 3:42Oh, this one's a throwback Microsoft Bing.
- 3:45Bing, really? I thought that was a relic.
- 3:47You'd think so, but in certain professional segments,
- 3:49especially on desktop, it grabbed a huge chunk of the
- 3:52market in 2024-2025. Some estimates put it at 40 to
- 3:5650% in specific user groups. How?
- 3:59What's the driver there? It's all about distribution and
- 4:02frankly, quality. Bing is the default on Windows
- 4:06and the Edge browser, so it has this instant pipeline to white
- 4:09collar professionals to academics.
- 4:11And the users actually prefer it.
- 4:13They do. It's cleaner, the English
- 4:15language results are far superior, and crucially, it
- 4:20doesn't have all the aggressive, low quality medical advertising
- 4:24that Baidu became infamous for. So the core business, the old
- 4:28cash cow, has gone from a monopoly to what?
- 4:31A competitive oligopoly? That's the perfect description.
- 4:34It's a mature toll bridge, but now it's facing declining
- 4:37traffic and it can't charge as much.
- 4:39Which explains the cheap stock price and it forces Baidu's
- 4:42hand. Exactly, which is why they made
- 4:45this radical, massive pivot to AI.
- 4:48And that brings us to the next section, the new Moat.
- 4:51They knew they couldn't just defend the Oldcastle.
- 4:53They had build a new. One they had build a new one, so
- 4:55they went AI 1st and they built a full stack system.
- 4:58They designed their own chips, the Kunlun chips.
- 5:00They built the paddle paddle framework and of course they're
- 5:02big foundation model Ernie. It's incredibly capital
- 5:05intensive, but it gives them total control.
- 5:07And you see this pivot so clearly in the financials, the
- 5:10non online marketing revenue, which is mostly their AI cloud
- 5:13business, it was growing consistently of between what 21
- 5:17and 34% year over year in mid 2025.
- 5:20And they're not just selling generic cloud space, they're
- 5:22focused on model as service or Moss.
- 5:26Right, and this is where the new Moat starts to form.
- 5:28It's all about switching costs. If the old Moat was user habit,
- 5:33the new Moat is deep technical integration.
- 5:35Explain that. Well, once a company build its
- 5:38custom applications on top of the Ernie model and the Paddle
- 5:40Paddle framework, migrating to a competitor becomes a nightmare.
- 5:44It's monstrously expensive and complex.
- 5:48Stickiness is real. You can measure it.
- 5:50Subscription based revenue for their AI accelerator
- 5:52infrastructure grew 128% year over year in Q32025.
- 5:58These aren't just experiments. Customers are signing on for the
- 6:01long haul. OK.
- 6:02But hold on, you're describing this perfect sticky Moat, but
- 6:05the entire AI space has been just ravaged by these insane
- 6:08price wars. You have Alibaba Byte dance
- 6:11slashing their prices by like 99%.
- 6:14Race to the bottom. Exactly, So if the price of AI
- 6:17effectively becomes 0, how do Baidu's margins survive?
- 6:20Isn't that something Buffett would just run away from?
- 6:23That is the single biggest challenge to the entire thesis
- 6:26and Baidu's counter argument is their full stack approach.
- 6:30By controlling the whole vertical chip framework model,
- 6:35they believe they can become the low cost producer.
- 6:37So they can make it cheaper than anyone else.
- 6:39They can optimize everything to work together.
- 6:42So they argued, the total cost of ownership is lower for the
- 6:44enterprise. Even if the sticker price per
- 6:46token isn't the absolute rock bottom, it's a plausible
- 6:50defense. But that price war risk is very
- 6:53real. And then there's the other piece
- 6:54of this growth story, the embedded option that the market
- 6:57just seems to value at 0 Apollo Go.
- 7:00The autonomous ride hailing business and this was things get
- 7:03really interesting because the market can ignore it until it
- 7:06becomes commercially viable. And it just.
- 7:08Did and in mid 2025 it hit that milestone.
- 7:11Apollo Go achieved unit level profitability in the city of
- 7:15Wuhan. And just to be clear, that means
- 7:17the revenue from a single ride covered the direct operational
- 7:20cost of that ride? Exactly in that city, that is a
- 7:23global watershed moment for autonomous driving.
- 7:25And the scale is just exploding. They did 3.1 million driverless
- 7:31rides in Q32025. That's up 212% year over year.
- 7:36How are they doing this so fast? Two things, cost and automation.
- 7:40They've crashed the cost of the hardware.
- 7:42Their new 6 Gen. robo taxi, the RT-6, cost only about $28,500 to
- 7:47build. It's incredibly cheap.
- 7:49It is, and even more important, they're pulling the expensive
- 7:52safety drivers out of the cars and moving to a model where 1
- 7:55remote officer can monitor up to 10 vehicles at once.
- 7:58That completely changes the economics.
- 7:59It's a total game changer. You go from a super expensive
- 8:02taxi service to a high margin software driven business.
- 8:05If they can scale that Wuhan model, the cash flow potential
- 8:08is just undeniable. All right, let's pivot to the
- 8:11really crucial part, the financial forensics, because if
- 8:13the business is changing this fast, search going down, AI
- 8:16going up, the numbers have to be messy.
- 8:17And Q 3/20/25 was a nightmare. It was the income statement
- 8:21showed exactly what we were talking about.
- 8:22The high margin online marketing revenue dropped 18%.
- 8:25The growing CapEx, heavy AI revenues pulled overall margins
- 8:29down with it. But the real shocker was the
- 8:31bottom line. Baidu reported a GAP operating
- 8:34loss of 15.1 billion RMB and that was almost entirely driven
- 8:41by one single line item. A massive non cash impairment
- 8:45charge of 16.2 billion RMB on long lived assets.
- 8:49What on earth were they writing? Down.
- 8:51This write down is basically a confession.
- 8:53This is where the forensic accounting comes in.
- 8:55A year before, Baidu had quietly changed its accounting,
- 8:58extending the useful life of its servers from five years to 6.
- 9:02Which would boost their net income by spreading out the
- 9:04depreciation cost. Precisely.
- 9:06They were under depreciating their assets.
- 9:08This huge impairment is the catch up.
- 9:10It's them admitting that those old servers became obsolete way
- 9:13faster than six years thanks to the crazy pace of AI chip
- 9:17development. So it's an admission of past
- 9:19capital allocation errors. That's what it is, and it's
- 9:21critical context for the next number, which is maybe the most
- 9:24important quantitative truth of all.
- 9:25Return on invested capital. ROIC.
- 9:28So what is the company actually earning on the capital it
- 9:30invests? On a GAAP basis, Baidu ROIC is
- 9:34somewhere between 2.7 and 3.8%. Now compare that to their cost
- 9:39of capital, which is estimated around 10 to 12%.
- 9:42Wow, that is a massive gap for the listener.
- 9:45What does that mean in simple terms?
- 9:47It means for every dollar Baidu is investing in its business
- 9:50right now, it is getting back far less than what it costs to
- 9:54finance that dollar. They are actively destroying
- 9:57shareholder value on a GAAP basis.
- 9:59That one metric explains everything.
- 10:01It's why the stock is so cheap. If you're destroying capital,
- 10:04you don't deserve a premium. But, and this is a huge but,
- 10:07here is the saving grace. The anchor.
- 10:10The balance sheet fortress. This is the entire margin of
- 10:12safety argument, right? Here it is.
- 10:14As of late 2025, Baidu is sitting on Cash, Cash
- 10:17equivalents and short term investments of $20.6 billion.
- 10:20An incredible number. And even after you subtract all
- 10:23their debt, their net cash position is still somewhere
- 10:26between 12 and $13 billion. That is the ultimate insurance
- 10:29policy. It means they can survive the AI
- 10:32price wars, they can fund their massive CapEx, and they can keep
- 10:35buying back shares without ever risking going bust.
- 10:38The cash provides A tangible floor or under the stock price.
- 10:41OK, let's move to the last piece, management and risk.
- 10:44We have to talk about the Jockey CEO, Robin Lie.
- 10:47He controls 59% of the voting power.
- 10:50His vision is the company's strategy.
- 10:52And you have to give him credit. He was a visionary for funding
- 10:56that huge, risky pivot into AI. He had guts, but his capital
- 11:00allocation track record is mixed to be charitable.
- 11:04Mix is a good word. You have the expensive failure
- 11:06of 91 Wireless years ago. The YY Live acquisition has been
- 11:10a real challenge. On the plus side though, they
- 11:12have ramped up share buybacks $2.3 billion by late 2025.
- 11:16That's a smart move. But a true Buffett style
- 11:18analysis would say given how cheap the stock is and how much
- 11:21cash they have, those buybacks should be way, way more
- 11:24aggressive. Absolutely.
- 11:25Finally, we have to come back to the existential risk,
- 11:27geopolitics and chips. US export controls on advanced
- 11:31GPUs from NVIDIA are a fundamental threat to Chinese
- 11:34AI. So how is Baidu defending
- 11:36against that? Vertical integration.
- 11:37They are developing and deploying their own chip, the
- 11:40Kunlun. The homegrown solution.
- 11:42It's their key strategic defense.
- 11:44They've deployed over 30,000 of them.
- 11:47And look, they might not have the raw power of the absolute
- 11:50best NVIDIA chip. But they're sanction proof.
- 11:52They're sanction proof, and they are optimized for Baidu's
- 11:56software stack. This actually makes Baidu a
- 11:59resilient, unique choice for domestic Chinese clients who are
- 12:03terrified of getting cut off by future US regulations.
- 12:07OK, let's bring it all home with the valuation conclusion.
- 12:10We ran conservative analysis focused on owner earnings, the
- 12:13real cash you can pull out of the business.
- 12:15Right. And using a conservative DCF and
- 12:18some of the parts model, we get an intrinsic value range of
- 12:21about $47.5 billion on the low end.
- 12:24That's a zero growth case up to maybe $55 billion.
- 12:27If you do, you assume they successfully monetize AI.
- 12:29And here's the key take away for you Baidu's market cap today is
- 12:33hovering between 45 and $48 billion.
- 12:36Meaning the market is pricing this company as if it will never
- 12:39grow again. It's valuing it like it's a
- 12:41Garbutt, assuming total failure. And this is where that margin of
- 12:44safety just becomes impossible to ignore.
- 12:46Nearly half of the entire market cap is just sitting there in net
- 12:49cash. So if you strip out the cash,
- 12:51the market is assigning an operating value of only about 20
- 12:54to $25 billion to the entire business.
- 12:56Just think about that. That 20 billion covers the
- 12:59declining but still profitable search business, the fast
- 13:02growing AI cloud business with its sticky Moat, and the scaling
- 13:06Apollo robo taxi unit. The market is pricing the entire
- 13:10future of AI and autonomous driving as if they are
- 13:13completely free options worth nothing.
- 13:16So. To be clear, Baidu is not a
- 13:17classic Buffett compounder like Coca-Cola.
- 13:20It's not predictable. The core business is leaking.
- 13:23And the new businesses are risky and capital intensive, but the
- 13:26valuation implies total failure when the company is actually
- 13:29generating cash and scaling some truly groundbreaking tack.
- 13:32The downside seems clearly protected by that fortress
- 13:35balance sheet. The upside, though, hinges
- 13:37completely on management navigating this AI price war and
- 13:40actually monetizing Apollo. Which leaves us with one final
- 13:43provocative thought for you to choose, Given those inherent
- 13:48existential risks of the VIE structure and the geopolitical
- 13:52friction over chips, does Baidu's incredible statistical
- 13:56cheapness. A high tech business trading for
- 13:58one time sales with a massive cash floor.
- 14:00Does that still put it in Buffett's too hard pile?
- 14:03Or is the margin of safety from that cash cushion just too
- 14:06compelling to ignore? It's the ultimate trade off
- 14:08between deep value security and geopolitical uncertainty.
- 14:11That was your deep dive into Baidu.
- 14:13We'll see you next time.